@&Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 179.$ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 *)APOLLWNI/OU *SOLEU\S H)\ *TARSEU/S, W(S *)ALE/CANDROS E)N *DIADOXAI=S, MAQHTH\S *KLEA/NQOUS. OU(=TOS PRO/TERON ME\N DO/LIXON H)/SKEI, E)/PEITA A)KOU/SAS *ZH/NWNOS H)\ *KLEA/NQOUS, W(S *DIOKLH=S KAI\ OI( PLEI/OUS, E)/TI TE ZW=NTOS A)PE/STH AU)TOU= KAI\ OU)X O( TUXW\N E)GE/NETO KATA\ FILOSOFI/AN: A)NH\R EU)FUH\S KAI\ O)CU/TATOS E)N PANTI\ ME/REI OU(/TWS W(/STE KAI\ E)N TOI=S PLEI/STOIS DIHNE/XQH PRO\S *ZH/NWNA, A)LLA\ KAI\ PRO\S *KLEA/NQHN, W(=| KAI\ POLLA/KIS E)/LEGE MO/NHS TH=S TW=N DOGMA/TWN DIDASKALI/AS XRH/|ZEIN, TA\S DE\ A)PODEI/CEIS AU)TO\S EU(RH/SEIN. METENO/EI ME/N-TOI O(PO/TE PRO\S AU)TO\N A)POTEI/NOITO, W(/STE SUNEXE\S PROFE/RESQAI TAU=TA: @E)GW\ DE\ TA)/LLA MAKA/RIOS PE/FUK' A)NH\R @PLH\N EI)S *KLEA/NQHN: TOU=TO D' OU)K EU)DAIMONW=. OU(/TW D' E)PI/DOCOS E)N TOI=S DIALEKTIKOI=S E)GE/NETO, W(/STE DOKEI=N TOU\S PLEI/OUS O(/TI EI) PARA\ QEOI=S H)=N [H(] DIALEKTIKH/, OU)K A)\N H)=N A)/LLH H)\ H( *XRUSI/PPEIOS: PLEONA/SAS DE\ TOI=S PRA/GMASI TH\N LE/CIN OU) KATW/RQWSE. PONIKW/TATO/S TE PAR' O(NTINOU=N GE/GONEN, W(S DH=LOS E)K TW=N SUGGRAMMA/-TWN AU)TOU=: TO\N A)RIQMO\N GA\R U(PE\R PE/NTE KAI\ E(PTAKO/SIA/ E)STIN. E)PLH/-QUNE DE\ AU)TA\ POLLA/KIS U(PE\R TOU= AU)TOU= DO/GMATOS E)PIXEIRW=N KAI\ PA=N TO\ U(POPESO\N GRA/FWN KAI\ DIORQOU/MENOS PLEONA/KIS PLEI/STH| TE TW=N MARTURIW=N PARAQE/SEI XRW/MENOS: W(/STE KAI\ E)PEIDH/ POTE E)/N TINI TW=N SUGGRAMMA/TWN PAR' O)LI/GON TH\N *EU)RIPI/DOU *MH/DEIAN O(/LHN PARETI/QETO KAI/ TIS META\ XEI=RAS EI)=XE TO\ BIBLI/ON, PRO\S TO\N PUQO/MENON TI/ A)/RA E)/XOI, E)/FH "1*XRUSI/PPOU *MH/DEIAN"2. KAI\ *)APOLLO/DWROS DE\ O( *)AQHNAI=OS E)N TH=| SUNAGWGH=| TW=N DOGMA/TWN, BOULO/MENOS PARISTA/NEIN, O(/TI TA\ *)EPIKOU/ROU OI)KEI/A| DUNA/MEI GEGRAMME/NA KAI\ A)PARA/QETA O)/NTA MURI/W| PLEI/W E)STI\ TW=N *XRUSI/PPOU BIBLI/WN, FHSI\N OU(/TWS AU)TH=| TH=| LE/CEI: "1EI) GA/R TIS A)FE/LOI TW=N *XRUSI/PPOU BIBLI/WN O(/S' A)LLO/TRIA PARATE/QEITAI, KENO\S AU)TW=| O( @1 XA/RTHS KATALELEI/YETAI."2 KAI\ TAU=TA ME\N *)APOLLO/DWROS. H( DE\ PARE-DREU/OUSA PRESBU=TIS AU)TW=|, W(/S FHSI *DIOKLH=S, E)/LEGEN W(S PENTAKOSI/OUS GRA/FEI STI/XOUS H(MERHSI/OUS. *(EKA/TWN DE/ FHSIN E)LQEI=N AU)TO\N E)PI\ FILO-SOFI/AN TH=S OU)SI/AS AU)TOU= TH=S PATRW/|AS EI)S TO\ BASILIKO\N A)NALHFQEI/SHS. *)=HN DE\ KAI\ TO\ SWMA/TION EU)TELH/S, W(S DH=LON E)K TOU= A)NDRIA/NTOS TOU= E)N *KERAMEIKW=|, O(\S SXEDO/N TI U(POKE/KRUPTAI TW=| PLHSI/ON I(PPEI=. O(/QEN AU)TO\N O( *KARNEA/DHS *KRU/YIPPON E)/LEGEN [1&secuntur apophthegmata]1. &`183.$ *TE/LOS DE\ *)ARKESILA/W| KAI\ *LAKU/DH|, KAQA/ FHSI *SWTI/WN E)N TW=| O)GDO/W| PARAGENO/MENOS E)N *)AKADHMI/A| SUNEFILOSO/FHSE: DI' H(\N AI)TI/AN KAI\ <20KATA\ TH=S SUNHQEI/AS>20 KAI\ <20U(PE\R AU)TH=S>20 E)PEXEI/RHSE: <20KAI\ PERI\ MEGEQW=N KAI\ PLHQW=N TH=| TW=N *)AKADHMAI+KW=N SUSTA/SEI XRH-SA/MENOS.>20 @*TOU=TON E)N TW=| W)|DEI/W| SXOLA/ZONTA/ FHSIN *(/ERMIPPOS E)PI\ QUSI/AN U(PO\ TW=N MAQHTW=N KLHQH=NAI: E)/NQA PROSENEGKA/MENON GLUKU\N A)/KRATON KAI\ I)LIGGIA/SANTA PEMPTAI=ON A)PELQEI=N E)C A)NQRW/PWN, TRI/A KAI\ E(BDOMH/-KONTA BIW/SANTA E)/TH, KATA\ TH\N TRI/THN KAI\ TETTARAKOSTH\N KAI\ E(KATOSTH\N *)OLUMPIA/DA, KAQA/ FHSIN *)APOLLO/DWROS E)N *XRONIKOI=S [1&sequitur Lae%28rtii &epigramma$]1. E)/NIOI DE/ FASI GE/LWTI SUSXEQE/NTA AU)TO\N TELEUTH=SAI: O)/NOU GA\R TA\ SU=KA AU)TW=| FAGO/NTOS, EI)PO/NTA TH=| GRAI\+ DIDO/NAI A)/KRATON E)PIR)-R(OFH=SAI TW=| O)/NW|, U(PERKAGXA/SANTA TELEUTH=SAI. @*DOKEI= DE\ U(PERO/PTHS TIS GEGONE/NAI. TOSAU=TA GOU=N SUGGRA/YAS OU)DENI\ TW=N BASILE/WN PROSPEFW/NHKEN: H)RKEI=TO/ TE GRAI+DI/W| MO/NW|, KAQA\ KAI\ *DHMH/TRIOS E)N *(OMWNU/MOIS FHSI/. *PTOLEMAI/OU TE PRO\S *KLEA/NQHN E)PISTEI/LANTOS H)\ AU)TO\N E)LQEI=N H)\ PE/MYAI TINA/, *SFAI=ROS ME\N A)PH=LQE, *XRU/SIPPOS DE\ PERIEI=DE. METAPEMYA/MENOS DE\ TOU\S TH=S A)DELFH=S UI(EI=S, *)ARISTOKRE/ONTA KAI\ *FILOKRA/THN, SUNEKRO/THSE. KAI\ PRW=TOS E)QA/R)R(HSE SXOLH\N E)/XEIN U(/PAIQRON E)N *LUKEI/W|, KAQA/PER O( PROEIRHME/NOS *DHMH/TRIOS I(STOREI=. @&Lucian. Macrob. 20$ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 E(\N KAI\ O)GDOH/KONTA [1&scil.$ E)/TH E)/ZHSEN]1. @&10Strabo XIV p. 671.$10 GEGO/NASI D' A)/NDRES E)NQE/NDE [1&10scil. Solis$10]1 TW=N O)NOMASTW=N <20*XRU/SIPPO/S>20 TE O( *STWI+KO\S FILO/SOFOS, PATRO\S W)\N *TARSE/WS E)KEI=QEN METOIKH/SANTOS &10etc. @1 &10@Galenus Protrept. 7 p. 8, 22 Kaibel.$10 TI/S GA\R [2A)/N]2 H)=N *STAGI/RWN LO/GOS, EI) MH\ DI' *)ARISTOTE/LHN, TI/S D' A)\N *SO/LWN, EI) MH\ DI' *)/ARATO/N TE KAI\ *XRU/SIPPON. @&10Ind. Stoic. Herc. col. XXXVIII.$10 KAI\ TA)=LL' O(MOI/WS E)/[1PR]1AT%5TEN, A)LLA\ KAI\ E)PI\ T[1H\N]1 %5 SXOLH\N AI)EI\ TH\N A[1U)]1TH\N %5 W(/RAN E)CH/|EI KAI\ O(MOI/%5WS A)PELU/ETO, W(/STE MH%5[1DE/NA]1 DIAYEU/DESQAI TW=N %5 [1GN]1WRI/MWN&10 etc. [1Ad <21Chrysippum>21 haec &10pertinere probabile est]1. &10@Col. XXXIX, 3.$10 GEGRAM[1ME/]1NA PER[1I\ DIK]1AI%5OSU/NHS.&10 6$10 TH=| D[1E\ KAQ' H(]1%5ME/RAN [1D]1IAI/T[1H| !!!!! %5 W/TATOS [1KAI\ !!!!!!!! %5 TATOS E)%5GE/NETO. @&10Ind. Stoic. Herc. col. XL$10 PE]1RI\ TH\[1N FULAKH\N]1 TH=S SKH%5NH=S E)KAR-TE/[1R]1EI, ME/NOUSA %5 KATA\ T[1H\N]1 E)C A)RXH=S TOU= %5 BI/OU TA/[1CIN. *OU)/]1TE GA\R A)MI/%5-DOS O(PO/TE SXOI/H XREI/AN %5 OU)QE/NA [1E)/]1PAS[1XEN]1 AU(TW=|%5 [1U(]1POQEI=[1N]1AI: [1PRO/]1S TE TA)%5NAGKAI=A A)NI[1STA/]1MENOS %5 [1KAQ]1A/PER U(GIA[1I/NWN&10 etc. &10@Pausanias I 17, 2.$10 *)EN DE\ TW=| GUMNASI/W| TH=S A)GORA=S A)PE/XONTI OU) POLU/, *PTOLEMAI/OU DE\ A)PO\ TOU= KATASKEUASAME/NOU KALOUME/NW|, LI/QOU TE/ EI)SIN *(ERMAI= QE/AS A)/CIOI__KAI\ O(/ TE *LI/BUS *)IO/BAS E)NTAU=QA KEI=TAI KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS O( *SOLEU/S.>20 @&10Plut. de Stoic. repugn. cp. 2 p. 1033e.$10 *)ARISTOKRE/WN GOU=N, O( *XRUSI/PPOU MAQHTH\S KAI\ OI)KEI=OS EI)KO/NA XALKH=N A)NASTHLW/SAS E)NE/GRAYE TO/DE TO\ E)LEGEI=ON. @TO/NDE NE/ON *XRU/SIPPON *)ARISTOKRE/WN A)NE/QHKE @TW=N *)AKADHMIAKW=N STRAGGALI/DWN KOPI/DA. @&10Quintilianus instit. orat. XII 7, 9. at si res familiaris amplius &10aliquid ad usus necessarios exiget, secundum omnium sapientium leges &10patietur sibi gratiam referri, cum et Socrati collatum sit ad victum et &10Zenon, Cleanthes, <21Chrysippus>21 mercedes a discipulis acceptaverint. &10@Ind. Stoic. Herc. col. XLI.$10 LE/GET[1AI]1 D' EI)=NAI TAU=TA: W(S OU)DEI\S A)\N %5 E)KEI=NON OU)/TE TAXE/WS ME%5T' A)/LLWN EI)=DEN H)\ TW=N A)%5KROATW=N KAI\ ZHLWTW=N%5 KAI\ SE!!!! @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 183.$10 OU(/TW D' H)=N FRONHMATI/AS [1O( *XRU/SIPPOS]1 W(/ST' E)ROME/NOU TINO/S: "1TI/NI SUSTH/SW TO\N UI(O/N"2 EI)PEI=N: "1E)MOI/: EI) GA\R U(PELA/M-BANON EI)=NAI/ TINA E)MOU= BELTI/ONA, PAR' AU)TW=| A)\N E)GW\ E)FILOSO/FOUN."2 O(/QEN FASI\N E)P' AU)TOU= LEXQH=NAI. [1K&10 495]1 @$10OI)=OS PE/PNUTAI, TOI\ DE\ SKIAI\ A)I/+SSOUSI: KAI\: @EI) MH\ GA\R H)=N *XRU/SIPPOS, OU)K A)\N H)=N STOA/. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 183. $10 E)N ME/NTOI TAI=S OI)NW/SESIN H(SU/XAZE PARA-FERO/MENOS TOI=S SKE/LESIN, W(/ST' EI)PEI=N TH\N DOU/LHN: "1*XRUSI/PPOU MO/NA TA\ SKE/LH MEQU/EI"2. @1 @&10 Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 182.$10 PA/LIN DE\ E)PEI/ TIS ZHTW=N KATAMO/NAS AU)TW=| DIELE/GETO EU)STAQW=S, E)PEI\ DE\ QEWRW=N PROSIO/NTA O)/XLON H)/RXETO FILONIKEI=N E)/FH [1&10Eur. Or. 253. 54]1 @$10OI)/MOI, KASI/GNHT', O)/MMA SO\N TARA/SSETAI: @TAXU\S DE\ METE/QOU LU/SSAN A)RTI/WS FRONW=N. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 182.$10 PRO\S DE\ TO\N KATECANISTA/MENON *KLEA/NQOUS DIALEKTIKO\N KAI\ PROTEI/NONTA AU)TW=| SOFI/SMATA: "1PE/PAUSO, EI)=PE, PARE/LKWN TO\N PRESBU/TERON A)PO\ TW=N PRAGMATIKWTE/RWN, H(MI=N DE\ TOI=S NE/OIS TAU=TA PROTI/QEI."2 @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 182.$10 OU(=TOS O)NEIDISQEI\S U(PO/ TINOS O(/TI OU)XI\ PARA\ *)ARI/STWNI META\ POLLW=N SXOLA/ZOI: "1EI) TOI=S POLLOI=S, EI)=PE, PROSEI=XON, OU)K A)\N E)FILOSO/FHSA"2 @&10Dio Chrysost. Or. XXXIII %14 53 [1v. i p. 312, 16 Arn.]1 [1Tarsi]1$10 TW=N GA\R E)NQA/DE DEINW=N TINA LE/GOUSIN EI)/S TINA PO/LIN [2E)LQEI=N]2 AU)TO\ TOU=TO E)/RGON PEPOIHME/NON, W(/STE EU)QU\S EI)DE/NAI TO\N TRO/PON E(KA/STOU KAI\ DIHGEI=SQAI TA\ PROSO/NTA, KAI\ MHDENO\S O(/LWS A)POTUGXA/NEIN__O(/TI OU(=TOS ME\N A)NDREI=OS, OU(=TOS, DE\ DEILO/S, OU(=TOS DE\ A)LAZW/N, OU(=TOS DE\ U(BRISTH\S H)\ KI/NAIDOS H)\ MOIXO/S. W(S OU)=N QAUMASTO\S H)=N E)PIDEIKNU/MENOS KAI\ OU)DAMH=| DIHMA/RTANE, PROSA/GOUSIN AU)TW=| SKLHRO/N TINA TO\ SW=MA KAI\ SU/NOFRUN A)/NQRWPON, AU)XMW=NTA KAI\ FAU/LWS DIAKEI/MENON KAI\ E)N TAI=S XERSI\ TU/LOUS E)/XONTA, FAIO/N TI KAI\ TRAXU\ PERIBEBLH-ME/NON I(MA/TION, DASU\N E(/WS TW=N SFURW=N KAI\ FAU/LWS KEKARME/NON: KAI\ TOU=TON H)CI/OUN EI)PEI=N O(/STIS H)=N. O( DE\ W(S POLU\N XRO/NON E(W/RA, TELEUTAI=ON O)KNW=N MOI DOKEI= TO\ PARISTA/MENON LE/GEIN OU)K E)/FH CUNIE/NAI, KAI\ BADI/ZEIN AU)TO\N E)KE/LEUSEN. H)/DH DE\ A)POXWRW=N PTA/RNUTAI: KA)KEI=NOS EU)QU\S A)NEBO/HSEN W(S EI)/H KI/NAIDOS. @&10Seneca de constantia sapientis 17, 2 <21Chrysippus>21 ait quendam &10indignatum, quod illum aliquis vervecem marinum dixerat. &10@Ind. Stoic. Herc. col. XLVI, 1.$10 !A NOSW=N: *(/ULLOS *SOLEU/S, O(\N KAI\ *SFAI/RW| PROESXOLAKE/NAI FHSI\N *)ARISTOKRE/WN <20E)N TAI=S *XRUSI/P[1POU]1 TAFAI=S>20. *DIAFA/N[1H]1S %5 !!!!NI/THS. @&10Col. XLVII, 3.$10 *)APELLH=S %5 [1O( O(R]1MH/SAS [1E)P' *)A]1RI[1S]1TO/BOU%5[1LO]1N DIENE-G!!!!S, *(HRA%5KLEI/DHS *SF[1AI/RW|]1 *)ARKE%5SI/LA|]1 *)ARISTO[1BOU/LW|]1 %5 [1PR]1W=TON [1E)SXOLAKW/S]1, *)A[1RIS]1%5TOK[1R]1E/WN. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 189.$10 *)EPEI\ DE\ E)NDOCO/TATA TA\ BIBLI/A E)STI\N AU)TW=| [1&10scil. Chrysippo$10]1, E)/DOCE/ MOI KAI\ TH\N PRO\S EI)=DOS A)NAGRAFH\N AU)TW=N E)NTAU=QA KATAXWRI/SAI: KAI\ E)/STI TA/DE. {3*LOGIKOU= *TO/POU [2TOU= PERI\ TH\N *DIA/RQRWSIN TW=N LOGIKW=N *)ENNOIW=N]2.}3 @QE/SEIS LOGIKAI/ @TW=N TOU= FILOSO/FOU SKEMMA/TWN @O(/RWN DIALEKTIKW=N PRO\S *MHTRO/DWRON A# B# G# D# E# #2# @1 PERI\ TW=N KATA\ TH\N DIALEKTIKH\N O)NOMA/TWN PRO\S *ZH/NWNA A# TE/XNH DIALEKTIKH\ PRO\S *)ARISTAGO/RAN A# SUNHMME/NWN PIQANW=N PRO\S *DIOSKOURI/DHN A# B# G# D#. {3*LOGIKOU= *TO/POU TOU= PERI\ TA\ *PRA/GMATA.}3 @<20*SU/NTACIS PRW/TH>20: PERI\ A)CIWMA/TWN A# PERI\ TW=N OU)X A(PLW=N A)CIWMA/TWN A# PERI\ TOU= SUMPEPLEGME/NOU PRO\S *)AQHNA/DHN A# B# PERI\ A)POFATIKW=N PRO\S *)ARISTAGO/RAN A# B# G# PERI\ TW=N KATAGOREUTIKW=N PRO\S *)AQHNO/DWRON A# PERI\ TW=N KATA\ STE/RHSIN LEGOME/NWN PRO\S *QE/ARON A# PERI\ TW=N A)ORI/STWN A)CIWMA/TWN PRO\S *DI/WNA A# B# G# PERI\ TH=S DIAFORA=S TW=N A)ORI/STWN A# B# G# D# PERI\ TW=N KATA\ XRO/NOUS LEGOME/NWN A# B# PERI\ SUNTELIKW=N A)CIWMA/TWN A# B#. @<20*SU/NTACIS DEUTE/RA>20: PERI\ A)LHQOU=S DIEZEUGME/NOU PRO\S *GORGIPPI/DHN A# PERI\ A)LHQOU=S SUNHMME/NOU PRO\S *GORGIPPI/DHN A# B# G# D# AI(/RESIS PRO\S *GORGIPPI/DHN A# PRO\S TO\ PERI\ A)KOLOU/QWN A# PERI\ TOU= DIA\ TRIW=N PA/LIN PRO\S *GORGIPPI/DHN A# PERI\ DUNATW=N PRO\S *KLEI=TON A# B# G# D# PRO\S TO\ PERI\ SHMASIW=N *FI/LWNOS A# PERI\ TOU= TI/NA E)STI\ TA\ YEUDH= A#. @<20*SU/NTACIS TRI/TH>20: PERI\ PROSTAGMA/TWN A# B# PERI\ E)RWTH/SEWS A# B# PERI\ PEU/SEWS A# B# G# D# E)PITOMH\ PERI\ E)RWTH/SEWS KAI\ PEU/SEWS A# E)PITOMH\ PERI\ A)POKRI/SEWS A# PERI\ ZHTH/SEWS B# PERI\ A)POKRI/SEWS D#. @<20*SU/NTACIS TETA/RTH>20: PERI\ TW=N KATHGORHMA/TWN PRO\S *MHTRO/DWRON A# B# G# D# E# #2# Z# H# Q# I# PERI\ O)RQW=N KAI\ U(PTI/WN PRO\S *FI/LARXON A# PERI\ TW=N SUNAMMA/TWN PRO\S *)APOLLWNI/DHN A# PRO\S *PA/SULON PERI\ KATHGORHMA/TWN A# B# G# D#. @1 @<20*SU/NTACIS PE/MPTH>20: PERI\ TW=N PE/NTE PTW/SEWN A# PERI\ TW=N KATA\ TO\ U(POKEI/MENON W(RISME/NWN E)KFORW=N A# PERI\ PAREMFA/SEWS PRO\S *STHSAGO/RAN A# B# PERI\ TW=N PROSHGORIKW=N A# B#. {3*LOGIKOU= *TO/POU PERI\ TA\S *LE/CEIS KAI\ TO\N KAT' AU)TA\S *LO/GON.}3 @<20*SU/NTACIS PRW/TH>20: PERI\ TW=N E(NIKW=N KAI\ PLHQUNTIKW=N E)KFORW=N A# B# G# D# E# #2# PERI\ LE/CEWN PRO\S *SWSIGE/NHN KAI\ *)ALE/CANDRON A# B# G# D# E# PERI\ TH=S KATA\ TA\S LE/CEIS A)NWMALI/AS PRO\S *DI/WNA A# B# G# D# PERI\ TW=N PRO\S TA\S FWNA\S SWREITW=N LO/GWN A# B# G# PERI\ SOLOIKISMW=N A# PERI\ SOLOIKIZO/NTWN LO/GWN PRO\S *DIONU/SION A# LO/GOI PARA\ TA\S SUNHQEI/AS A# LE/CIS PRO\S *DIONU/SION A#. @<20*SU/NTACIS DEUTE/RA>20: PERI\ TW=N STOIXEI/WN TOU= LO/GOU KAI\ TW=N LEGOME/NWN A# B# G# D# E# PERI\ TH=S SUNTA/CEWS TW=N LEGOME/NWN A# B# G# D# PERI\ TH=S SUNTA/CEWS KAI\ STOIXEI/WN TW=N LEGOME/NWN PRO\S *FI/LIPPON A# B# G# PERI\ TW=N STOIXEI/WN TOU= LO/GOU PRO\S *NIKI/AN A# PERI\ TOU= PRO\S E(/TERA LEGOME/NOU A#. @<20*SU/NTACIS TRI/TH>20: PRO\S TOU\S MH\ DIAIROUME/NOUS A# B# PERI\ A)MFIBOLIW=N PRO\S *)APOLLA=N A# B# G# D# PERI\ TW=N TROPIKW=N A)MFIBOLIW=N A# PERI\ SUNHMME/NHS TROPIKH=S A)MFIBOLI/AS A# B# PRO\S TO\ PERI\ A)MFIBOLIW=N *PANQOI/DOU A# B# PERI\ TH=S EI)S TA\S A)MFIBOLI/AS EI)SAGWGH=S A# B# G# D# E# E)PITOMH\ TW=N PRO\S *)EPIKRA/THN A)MFIBOLIW=N A# SUNHMME/NA PRO\S TH\N EI)SAGWGH\N TH\N EI)S TA\S A)MFIBOLI/AS A# B#. {3*LOGIKOU= *TO/POU PRO\S TOU\S *LO/GOUS KAI\ TOU\S *TRO/POUS.}3 @<20*SU/NTACIS PRW/TH>20: TE/XNH LO/GWN KAI\ TRO/PWN PRO\S *DIOSKOURI/DHN A# B# G# D# E# PERI\ TW=N LO/GWN A# B# G# PERI\ TRO/PWN SUSTA/SEWS PRO\S *STHSAGO/RAN A# B# [1SUSTA/SEWN&10 D$10]1 SU/GKRISIS TW=N TROPIKW=N A)CIWMA/TWN A# PERI\ A)NTISTREFO/NTWN LO/GWN KAI\ SUNHMME/NWN A# PRO\S *)AGA/QWNA H)\ PERI\ TW=N E(CH=S PROBLHMA/TWN A# PERI\ TOU= TI/NA SULLOGISTIKA/ TINOS MET' A)/LLOU TE KAI\ MET' A)/LLWN A# [1TI-@@NO/S TE MET' A)/LLOU KAI\ MEGA/LWN&10 D$10]1 @1 PERI\ TW=N E)PIFORW=N PRO\S *)ARISTAGO/RAN A# PERI\ TOU= TA/TTESQAI TO\N AU)TO\N LO/GON E)N PLEI/OSI TRO/POIS A# PRO\S TA\ A)NTEIRHME/NA TW=| TO\N AU)TO\N LO/GON E)N SULLOGISTIKW=| KAI\ A)SULLO-@@GI/STW| TETA/XQAI TRO/PW| A# B# PRO\S TA\ A)NTEIRHME/NA TAI=S TW=N SULLOGISMW=N A)NALU/SESI A# B# G# PRO\S TO\ PERI\ TRO/PWN *FI/LWNOS PRO\S *TIMO/STRATON A# LOGIKA\ SUNHMME/NA PRO\S *TIMOKRA/THN KAI\ *FILOMAQH= EI)S TA\ PERI\ LO/GWN @@KAI\ TRO/PWN A#. @<20*SU/NTACIS DEUTE/RA>20: PERI\ TW=N PERAINO/NTWN LO/GWN PRO\S *ZH/NWNA A# PERI\ TW=N PRW/TWN KAI\ A)NAPODEI/KTWN SULLOGISMW=N PRO\S *ZH/NWNA A# PERI\ TH=S A)NALU/SEWS TW=N SULLOGISMW=N A# [1&10cum antecedente permutat DF$10]1 PERI\ TW=N PARELKO/NTWN LO/GWN PRO\S *PA/SULON A# B# PERI\ TW=N EI)S TOU\S SULLOGISMOU\S QEWRHMA/TWN A# PERI\ SULLOGISMW=N EI)SAGWGIKW=N PRO\S *ZH/NWNA A# TW=N PRO\S EI)SAGWGH\N TRO/PWN PRO\S *ZH/NWNA A# B# G# PERI\ TW=N KATA\ YEUDH= SXH/MATA SULLOGISMW=N A# B# G# D# E# LO/GOI SULLOGISTIKOI\ KATA\ A)NA/LUSIN E)N TOI=S A)NAPODEI/KTOIS A# TROPIKA\ ZHTH/MATA PRO\S *ZH/NWNA KAI\ *FILOMAQH= A# [1TOU=TO DOKEI= YEUDE-@@PI/GRAFON]1. @<20*SU/NTACIS TRI/TH>20: PERI\ TW=N METAPIPTO/NTWN LO/GWN PRO\S *)AQHNA/DHN A# [1YEUDEPI/GRAFON]1 LO/GOI METAPI/PTONTES PRO\S TH\N MESO/THTA A# B# G# [1YEUDEPI/GRAFA]1 PRO\S TOU\S *)AMEINI/OU DIAZEUKTIKOU/S A#. @<20*SU/NTACIS TETA/RTH>20: PERI\ U(POQE/SEWN PRO\S *MELE/AGRON A# B# G# LO/GOI U(POQETIKOI\ EI)S TOU\S NO/MOUS PRO\S *MELE/AGRON PA/LIN A# LO/GOI U(POQETIKOI\ PRO\S EI)SAGWGH/N A# B# LO/GOI U(POQETIKOI\ QEWRHMA/TWN A# B# LU/SIS TW=N *(HDU/LOU U(POQETIKW=N A# B# LU/SIS TW=N *)ALECA/NDROU U(POQETIKW=N A# B# G# [1YEUDEPI/GRAFA]1 PERI\ E)KQE/SEWN PRO\S *LAODA/MANTA A#. @<20*SU/NTACIS PE/MPTH>20: PERI\ TH=S EI)S TO\N YEUDO/MENON EI)SAGWGH=S PRO\S TO\N *)ARISTOKRE/ONTA A# LO/GOI YEUDO/MENOI PRO\S EI)SAGWGH\N A# PERI\ TOU= YEUDOME/NOU PRO\S *)ARISTOKRE/ONTA A# B# G# D# E# #2#. @<20*SU/NTACIS E(/KTH>20: PRO\S TOU\S NOMI/ZONTAS KAI\ YEUDH= KAI\ A)LHQH= EI)=NAI A# PRO\S TOU\S DIA\ TH=S TOMH=S DIALU/ONTAS TO\N YEUDO/MENON LO/GON PRO\S *)ARISTO-@@KRE/ONTA A# B# A)PODEI/CEIS PRO\S TO\ MH\ DEI=N TE/MNEIN TA\ A)O/RISTA A# @1 PRO\S TA\ A)NTEIRHME/NA TOI=S KATA\ TH=S TOMH=S TW=N A)ORI/STWN PRO\S *PA/SULON A# B# G# LU/SIS KATA\ TOU\S A)RXAI/OUS PRO\S *DIOSKOURI/DHN A# PERI\ TH=S TOU= YEUDOME/NOU LU/SEWS PRO\S *)ARISTOKRE/ONTA A# B# G# LU/SIS TW=N *(HDU/LOU U(POQETIKW=N PRO\S *)ARISTOKRE/ONTA KAI\ *)APOLLA=N A#. @<20*SU/NTACIS E(BDO/MH>20: PRO\S TOU\S FA/SKONTAS TA\ LH/MMATA E)/XEIN YEUDH= TO\N YEUDO/MENON LO/GON A# PERI\ A)POFA/SKONTOS PRO\S TO\N *)ARISTOKRE/ONTA A# B# LO/GOI A)POFA/SKONTES PRO\S GUMNASI/AN A# PERI\ TOU= PARA\ MIKRO\N LO/GOU PRO\S *STHSAGO/RAN A# B# PERI\ TW=N EI)S TA\S U(POLH/YEIS LO/GWN KAI\ H(SUXAZO/NTWN PRO\S *)ONH/TORA A# B# PERI\ TOU= E)GKEKALUMME/NOU PRO\S *)ARISTO/BOULON A# B# PERI\ TOU= DIALELHQO/TOS PRO\S *)AQHNA/DHN A#. @<20*SU/NTACIS O)GDO/H>20: PERI\ TOU= OU)/TIDOS PRO\S *MENEKRA/THN A# B# G# D# E# #2# Z# H# [1Q# &10D$10]1 PERI\ TW=N E)C A)ORI/STOU KAI\ W(RISME/NOU LO/GWN PRO\S *PA/SULON A# B# PERI\ OU)/TIDOS LO/GOU PRO\S *)EPIKRA/THN A#. @<20*SU/NTACIS E)NA/TH>20: PERI\ TW=N SOFISMA/TWN PRO\S *(HRAKLEI/DHN KAI\ *PO/LLIN A# B# PERI\ TW=N A)PO/RWN DIALEKTIKW=N PRO\S *DIOSKOURI/DHN E# PRO\S TO\ *)ARKESILA/OU MEQO/DION PRO\S *SFAI=RON A#. @<20*SU/NTACIS DEKA/TH>20: KATA\ TH=S SUNHQEI/AS PRO\S *MHTRO/DWRON A# B# G# D# E# #2# PERI\ TH=S SUNHQEI/AS PRO\S *GORGIPPI/DHN A# B# G# D# E# #2# Z#. {3*LOGIKOU= *TO/POU TA\ TW=N PROEIRHME/NWN TETTA/RWN DIAFORW=N E)KTO\S O)/NTA KAI\ PERIE/XONTA [2TA\S]2 SPORA/DHN KAI\ OU) SWMATIKA\S ZHTH/SEIS LOGIKA\S PERI\ TW=N KATALEGOME/NWN.}3 *ZHTHMA/TWN E)NNE/A KAI\ TRIA/KONTA. _*(OMOU= TA\ PA/NTA TOU= LOGIKOU= TIA#. {3*)HQIKOU= LO/GOU TOU= PERI\ TH\N *DIA/RQRWSIN TW=N H)QIKW=N *)ENNOIW=N.}3 @<20*SU/NTACIS PRW/TH>20: U(POGRAFH\ TOU= LO/GOU TOU= [2H)QIKOU=]2 PRO\S *QEO/PORON A# QE/SEIS H)QIKAI/ A# PIQANA\ LH/MMATA EI)S TA\ DO/GMATA PRO\S *FILOMAQH= A# B# G# O(/RWN TW=N TOU= A)STEI/OU PRO\S *MHTRO/DWRON A# B# O(/RWN TW=N TOU= FAU/LOU PRO\S *MHTRO/DWRON A# B# O(/RWN TW=N A)NA\ ME/SON PRO\S *MHTRO/DWRON A# B# O(/RWN TW=N PRO\S *MHTRO/DWRON TW=N KATA\ GE/NOS A# B# G# D# E# #2# Z# O(/RWN TW=N KATA\ TA\S A)/LLAS TE/XNAS PRO\S *MHTRO/DWRON A# B#. @1 @<20*SU/NTACIS DEUTE/RA>20: PERI\ TW=N O(MOI/WN PRO\S *)ARISTOKLE/A A# B# G# PERI\ TW=N O(/RWN PRO\S *MHTRO/DWRON A# B# G# D# E# #2# Z#. @<20*SU/NTACIS TRI/TH>20: PERI\ TW=N OU)K O)RQW=S TOI=S O(/ROIS A)NTILEGOME/NWN PRO\S *LAODA/MANTA A# B# G# D# E# #2# Z# PIQANA\ EI)S TOU\S O(/ROUS PRO\S *DIOSKOURI/DHN A# B# PERI\ EI)DW=N KAI\ GENW=N PRO\S *GORGIPPI/DHN A# B# PERI\ TW=N DIAIRE/SEWN A# PERI\ TW=N E)NANTI/WN PRO\S *DIONU/SION B# PIQANA\ PRO\S TA\S DIAIRE/SEIS KAI\ TA\ GE/NH KAI\ TA\ EI)/DH KAI\ [2TA\]2 PERI\ @@TW=N E)NANTI/WN A#. @<20*SU/NTACIS TETA/RTH>20: PERI\ TW=N E)TUMOLOGIKW=N PRO\S *DIOKLE/A A# B# G# D# E# #2# Z# E)TUMOLOGIKW=N PRO\S *DIOKLE/A A# B# G# D#. @<20*SU/NTACIS PE/MPTH>20: PERI\ PAROIMIW=N PRO\S *ZHNO/DOTON A# B# PERI\ POIHMA/TWN PRO\S *FILOMAQH= A# PERI\ TOU= PW=S DEI= TW=N POIHMA/TWN A)KOU/EIN A# B# PRO\S TOU\S KRITIKOU\S PRO\S *DIO/DWRON A#. {3*)HQIKOU= *TO/POU PERI\ TO\N KOINO\N LO/GON KAI\ TA\S E)K TOU/TOU SUNISTAME/NAS TE/XNAS KAI\ A)RETA/S.}3 @<20*SU/NTACIS PRW/TH>20: PRO\S TA\S A)NAZWGRAFH/SEIS PRO\S *TIMW/NAKTA A# PERI\ TOU= PW=S E(/KASTA LE/GOMEN KAI\ DIANOOU/MEQA A# PERI\ TW=N E)NNOIW=N PRO\S *LAODA/MANTA A# B# PERI\ U(POLH/YEWS PRO\S *PUQW/NAKTA A# B# G# A)PODEI/CEIS PRO\S TO\ MH\ DOCA/SEIN TO\N SOFO/N A# PERI\ KATALH/YEWS KAI\ E)PISTH/MHS KAI\ A)GNOI/AS A# B# G# D# PERI\ LO/GOU A# B# PERI\ TH=S XRH/SEWS TOU= LO/GOU PRO\S *LEPTI/NAN. @<20*SU/NTACIS DEUTE/RA>20: PERI\ TOU= E)GKRI/NEIN TOU\S A)RXAI/OUS TH\N DIALEKTIKH\N SU\N TAI=S A)PODEI/CESI @@PRO\S *ZH/NWNA A# B# PERI\ TH=S DIALEKTIKH=S PRO\S *)ARISTOKRE/ONTA A# B# G# D# PERI\ TW=N A)NTILEGOME/NWN TOI=S DIALEKTIKOI=S A# B# G# PERI\ TH=S R(HTORIKH=S PRO\S *DIOSKOURI/DHN A# B# G# D#. @<20*SU/NTACIS TRI/TH>20: PERI\ E(/CEWS PRO\S *KLE/WNA A# B# G# PERI\ TE/XNHS KAI\ A)TEXNI/AS PRO\S *)ARISTOKRE/ONTA A# B# G# D# PERI\ TH=S DIAFORA=S TW=N A)RETW=N PRO\S *DIO/DWRON A# B# G# D# PERI\ TOU= POIA\S EI)=NAI TA\S A)RETA/S A# PERI\ A)RETW=N PRO\S *PO/LLIN A# B#. @1 {3*)HQIKOU= *TO/POU PERI\ *)AGAQW=N KAI\ *KAKW=N.}3 @<20*SU/NTACIS PRW/TH>20: PERI\ TOU= KALOU= KAI\ TH=S H(DONH=S PRO\S *)ARISTOKRE/ONTA A# B# G# D# E# #2# Z# H# Q# I# A)PODEI/CEIS PRO\S TO\ MH\ EI)=NAI TH\N H(DONH\N TE/LOS A# B# G# D# A)PODEI/CEIS PRO\S TO\ MH\ EI)=NAI TH\N H(DONH\N A)GAQO/N A# B# G# D# PERI\ TW=N LEGOME/NWN U(PE\R TH=S %2%2%2%2%2%2 @&10Valerius Maximus VIII 7, 10. Citerioris aetatis metas, sed non &10parvi tamen spatii Chrysippi vivacitas flexit%10 nam octogesimo anno coep-&10tum undequadragesimum$10 *LOGIKW=N&10 exactissimae subtilitatis volumen reliquit. &10cuius studium in tradendis ingenii sui monumentis tantum operae laboris-&10que sustinuit, ut ad ea quae scripsit penitus cognoscenda longa vita sit &10opus. &10@Numenius apud Eusebium praep. evang. XIV p. 728a.$10 TA\ DE\ TW=N *STWI+KW=N E)STASI/ASTAI, A)RCA/MENA A)PO\ TW=N A)RXO/NTWN KAI\ MHDE/PW TELEUTW=NTA KAI\ NU=N. E)LE/GXOUSI DE\ A)GAPW/NTWS U(PO\ DUSMENOU=S E)LE/GXOU, OI( ME/N TINES AU)-TW=N E)MMEMENHKO/TES E)/TI, OI( D' H)/DH METAQE/MENOI. EI)/CASIN OU)=N OI( PRW=TOI O)LI-GARXIKWTE/ROIS, OI(\ DH\ DIASTA/NTES U(PH=RCAN EI)S TOU\S METE/PEITA POLLH=S ME\N TOI=S PROTE/ROIS, POLLH=S DE\ TH=S A)LLH/LOIS E)PITIMH/SEWS AI)/TIOI, EI)SE/TI E(TE/RWN E(/TEROI *STWI+KW/TEROI: KAI\ MA=LLON O(/SOI PLE/ON E)PI\ TO\ TEXNIKO\N W)/FQHSAN MIKROLO/GOI: AU)TOI\ GA\R OU(=TOI TOU\S E(TE/ROUS U(PERBALLO/MENOI TH=| TE POLUPRAGMOSU/NH| TOI=S TE SKARIFHQMOI=S E)PETI/MWN QA=TTON. @&10Origenes contra Celsum II. 12 Vol. I p. 141, 7 [1p. 297 Delarue$10]1. A)LLA\ KAI\ O( <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 POLLAXOU= TW=N SUGGRAMMA/TWN AU)TOU= FAI/NETAI KA-QAPTO/MENOS *KLEA/NQOUS, KAINOTOMW=N PARA\ TA\ E)KEI/NW| DEDOGME/NA, GENOME/NW| AU)TOU= DIDASKA/LW| E)/TI NE/OU KAI\ A)RXA\S E)/XONTOS FILOSOFI/AS ..... OU)K O)LI/GON DE\ XRO/NON KAI\ O( *XRU/SIPPOS PARA\ TW=| *KLEA/NQEI PEPOIH=SQAI TA\S DIATRIBA/S [1&10scil.$10 LE/GETAI]1. @&10Origenes contra Celsum I. 39 Vol. I p. 91, 20 [1p. 357 Delarue]1. $10O( DE\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 POLLAXOU= E)KQE/MENOS TA\ KINH/SANTA AU)TO\N A)NAPE/MPEI H(MA=S E)F' OU(\S A)\N EU(/ROIMEN KREI=TTON AU)TOU= E)ROU=NTAS. @&10Origenes contra Celsum V. 57 Vol. II p. 60, 5 [1p. 621 Delarue]1. $10*PARA/DOCA DE\ PRA/GMATA TOI=S A)NQRW/POIS E)PIFAI/NESQAI/ POTE KAI\ TW=N *(ELLH/NWN I(STO/RHSAN OU) MO/NON OI( U(PONOHQE/NTES A)\N W(S MUQOPOIOU=NTES, A)LLA\ KAI\ OI( OI(=ON POLU\ E)PIDEICA/MENOI GNHSI/WS FILOSOFEI=N KAI\ FILALH/QWS E)KTI/QESQAI TA\ EI)S AU)TOU\S FQA/SANTA. *TOIAU=TA DE\ A)NE/GNWMEN PARA\ TW=| <20*SOLEI= *XRUSI/PPW|>20 &10etc. &10@Galenus de differentia puls. 10. ed. Bas. III 30. K. VIII. 631 &10[1impugnans sectam Archigenis]1.$10 POLU\ DE\ TOU=T' E)/STI PARA\ TW=| PROPA/PPW| TH=S AI(RE/SEWS AU)TW=N <20*XRUSI/PPW|>20: NOMOQETEI= ME\N GA\R O)NO/MATA PLEI=ON H)\ *SO/LWN *)AQHNAI/OIS I(STA=| TOI=S A)/COSI NOMI/SMATA, SUGXEI= D' AU)TO\S PRW=TOS AU)TA/. @&10paulo post%10$10 NUNI\ DE\ TO\ DEINO/TATON OU)/TE GENNHQEI\S *)AQH/NHSIN OU)/TE TRA- @1FEI/S, A)LLA\ XQE\S KAI\ PRW/HN H(/KWN E)K *KILIKI/AS, PRI\N A)KRIBW=S AU)TO\N E)KMAQEI=N H(NTINAOU=N *(ELLA/DA FWNH/N, *)AQHNAI/OIS U(PE\R O)NOMA/TWN E)PIXEIREI= NOMOQETEI=N __O(/SA ME\N OU)=N <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 EI)S TH\N TW=N *)AQHNAI/WN E)CUBRI/ZEI DIA/LEKTON TA/X' A)/N POTE KAI\ AU)=QIS H(MI=N DIELQEI=N GE/NOITO. @&10Phot. lexicon s. v.$10 ME/NTOI: TO\ DE\ ME/NTON BA/RBARON, W(=| KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 XRH=TAI. @&10Quintilianus instit. orat. X 1, 84. minus indulsere eloquentiae &10<21Stoici>21 veteres, sed cum honesta suaserunt, tum in colligendo probando-&10que quae instituerant plurimum valuerunt, rebus tamen acuti magis quam, &10id quod sane non adfectaverunt, oratione magnifici. &10@id. XII 2, 25. <21Stoici>21 sicut copiam nitoremque eloquentiae fere prae-&10ceptoribus suis defuisse concedant necesse est, ita nullos aut probare acrius &10aut concludere subtilius contendunt. &10@Cicero de oratore I 11, 50. Etenim videmus, iisdem de rebus &10ieiune quosdam et exiliter, ut eum, quem acutissimum ferunt, <21Chrysippum>21, &10disputavisse, neque ob eam rem philosophiae non satisfecisse, quod non &10habuerit hanc dicendi ex arte aliena facultatem. &10@Frontonis epist. [1ac. M. Antoninum de eloquentia]1 p. 146 Naber. &10Ubi illud acumen tuum? ubi subtilitas? Evigila et attende, quid cupiat &10ipse <21Chrysippus>21. Num contentus est docere, rem ostendere, definire, ex-&10plorare? non est contentus%10 verum auget in quantum potest, exaggerat, &10praemunit, iterat, differt, recurrit, interrogat, describit, dividit, personas &10fingit, orationem suam alii accommodat%10$10 TAU=TA D' E)STI\N AU)/CEIN, DIASKEUA/ZEIN, E)CERGA/ZESQAI, PA/LIN LE/GEIN, E)PANAFE/REIN, PARA/PTEIN, PROSWPOPOIEI=N. @&10Dionysius Halicarn. de compos. verb. p. 30 Re.$10 *KAI\ TI/ DEI= TOU/-TOUS QAUMA/ZEIN, O(/POUGE KAI\ OI( TH\N FILOSOFI/AN E)PAGGELLO/MENOI KAI\ TA\S DIA-LEKTIKA\S E)KFE/RONTES TE/XNAS OU(/TWS EI)SI\N A)/QLIOI PERI\ TH\N SU/NQESIN TW=N O)NO-MA/TWN, W(/ST' AI)DEI=SQAI KAI\ LE/GEIN; A)PO/XRH DE\ TEKMHRI/W| XRH/SASQAI TW=| LO/GW| <20*XRUSI/PPOU TOU= *STWI+KOU=>20: PERAITE/RW GA\R OU)K A)\N PROBAI/HN. TOU/TOU GA\R OU)/T' A)/MEINON OU)DEI\S TA\S DIALEKTIKA\S TE/XNAS H)KRI/BWSEN, OU)/TE XEI/RONI A(RMONI/A| SUNTAXQE/NTAS E)CH/NEGKE LO/GOUS TW=N O)NO/MATOS KAI\ DO/CHS A)CIWQE/NTWN. KAI/TOI SPOUDA/ZEIN GE/ TINES PROSEPOIH/QHSAN AU)TW=N KAI\ PERI\ TOU=TO TO\ ME/ROS, W(S A)NAGKAI=ON O)\N TW=| LO/GW|, KAI\ TE/XNAS TINA\S E)PE/GRAYAN <20U(PE\R TH=S SUNTA/CEWS TW=N TOU= LO/GOU MORI/WN>20. A)LLA\ POLLOI\ H)\ MA=LLON PA/NTES A)PO\ TH=S A)LHQEI/AS A)PEPLANH/QHSAN KAI\ OU)D' O)/NAR EI)=DON TI/ POT' E)STI\ TO\ POIOU=N H(DEI=AN KAI\ KALH\N TH\N SU/NQESIN. @&10Arrianus Epict. dissert. I 17, 15.$10 A)LLA\ NH\ *DI/A OU) PARAKOLOUQW= TW=| BOULH/MATI TH=S FU/SEWS. TI/S OU)=N E)CHGEI=TAI AU)TO/; LE/GOUSIN O(/TI <20*XRU/SIP-POS>20. E)/RXOMAI KAI\ E)PIZHTW= TI/ LE/GEI OU(=TOS O( E)CHGHTH\S TH=S FU/SEWS. A)/RXOMAI MH\ NOEI=N TI/ LE/GEI, ZHTW= TO\N E)CHGOU/MENON: "1I)/DE E)PI/SKEYAI, PW=S TOU=TO LE/GETAI, KAQA/PER EI) R(WMAI+STI/."2 POI/A OU)=N E)NQA/DE O)FRU\S TOU= E)CHGOUME/NOU; @&10Plut. de Stoic. repugn. cp. 9 p. 1035b.$10 *)ALLA\ TOU=TO/N GE TO\N LO/-GON, O(\N E)/SXATO/N FHSI DEI=N TA/TTESQAI [2TO\N]2 PERI\ QEW=N, E)/QEI PROTA/TTEI KAI\ PROEKTI/QHSI <20PANTO\S H)QIKOU= ZHTH/MATOS>20: OU)/TE GA\R PERI\ *TELW=N, OU)/TE PERI\ *DIKAIOSU/NHS, OU)/TE PERI\ *)AGAQW=N KAI\ *KAKW=N, OU)/TE PERI\ *GA/MOU KAI\ *PAIDO-TROFI/AS OU)/TE PERI\ *NO/MOU KAI\ *POLITEI/AS FAI/NETAI TO\ PARA/PAN FQEGGO/MENOS, @1 EI) MH/, KAQA/PER OI( TA\ YHFI/SMATA TAI=S PO/LESIN EI)SFE/RONTES PROGRA/FOUSIN *)AGAQH\N *TU/XHN, OU(/TW KAI\ AU)TO\S PROGRA/YEIE TO\N *DI/A, TH\N *EI(MARME/NHN, TH\N *PRO/NOIAN, TO\ SUNE/XESQAI MIA=| DUNA/MEI TO\N KO/SMON, E(/NA O)/NTA KAI\ PEPERAS-ME/NON. @&10Plut. de Stoic. repugn. cp. 24 p. 1046a.$10 TI/ OU)=N SU\ [1&10scil. Chry-&10sippe$10]1, FH/SAI TIS A)/N, AU)TO\S A)NDRA/SI TOIOU/TOIS KAI\ TOSOU/TOIS OU)DE/POTE PAU/SH| MAXO/MENOS OU)D' E)LE/GXWN, W(S NOMI/ZEIS, E)N TOI=S KURIWTA/TOIS KAI\ MEGI/STOIS DIA-MARTA/NONTAS; OU) GA\R DH/POU PERI\ ME\N DIALEKTIKH=S E)SPOUDASME/NWS E)/GRAYAN, PERI\ D' A)RXH=S KAI\ TE/LOUS KAI\ QEW=N KAI\ DIKAIOSU/NHS E)K PARE/RGOU KAI\ PAI/-ZONTES, E)N OI(=S TUFLO\N AU)TW=N A)POKALEI=S TO\N LO/GON KAI\ MAXO/MENON AU(TW=| KAI\ MURI/AS A)/LLAS A(MARTI/AS E)/XONTA. @&10Plut. de Stoic. repugn. cp. 10 p. 1036b.$10 O(/TI D' AU)TO\S [1&10scil. Chry-&10sippus$10]1 OU)K E)N O)LI/GOIS A)LLA\ POLLAXOU= TOU\S E)NANTI/OUS OI(=S DOKIMA/ZEI LO/GOUS KATESKEU/AKEN E)R)R(WME/NWS KAI\ META\ SPOUDH=S KAI\ FILOTIMI/AS TOSAU/THS, W(/STE MH\ PANTO\S EI)=NAI KATAMAQEI=N TO\ A)RE/SKON [2AU)TW=|]2, AU)TOI\ DH/POU LE/GOUSI [1&10scil. &10Stoici$10]1, TH\N DEINO/THTA QAUMA/ZONTES TA)NDRO\S KAI\ TO\N *KARNEA/DHN OU)DE\N OI)-O/MENOI LE/GEIN I)/DION, A)LL' E)C W(=N E)PEXEI/RHSE <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 EI)S TOU)NANTI/ON O(R-MW/MENON E)PITI/QESQAI TOI=S LO/GOIS AU)TOU= KAI\ POLLA/KIS PARAFQE/GGESQAI [1*Z& 407$]1 "1DAIMO/NIE, FQI/SEI SE TO\ SO\N ME/NOS"2 W(S MEGA/LAS A)FORMA\S KAQ' E(AUTOU= DI-DO/NTA TOI=S KINEI=N TA\ DO/GMATA KAI\ DIABA/LLEIN BOULOME/NOIS. @&10Plut. de comm. not. cp. 1 p. 1050b [1Stoicus aliquis dicit]1%10$10 W(S OU)K A)PO\ TU/XHS A)LL' E)K PRONOI/AS QEW=N NOMI/ZOI MET' *)ARKESI/LAON KAI\ PRO\ *KARNEA/DOU GEGONE/NAI *XRU/SIPPON. __<20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 OU)=N E)N ME/SW| GENO/ME-NOS <20TAI=S PRO\S *)ARKESI/LAON A)NTIGRAFAI=S>20 KAI\ TH\N *KARNEA/DOU DEINO/THTA E)NE/FRACE, POLLA\ ME\N TH=| AI)SQH/SEI KATALIPW\N W(/SPER EI)S POLIORKI/AN BOHQH/-MATA, TO\N DE\ PERI\ TA\S PROLH/YEIS KAI\ TA\S E)NNOI/AS TA/RAXON A)FELW\N PANTA/-PASI KAI\ DIORQW/SAS E(KA/STHN KAI\ QE/MENOS EI)S TO\ OI)KEI=ON: W(/STE KAI\ TOU\S AU)=QIS E)KKROU/EIN TA\ PRA/GMATA KAI\ PARABIA/ZESQAI BOULOME/NOUS MHDE\N PERAI/NEIN A)LL' E)LE/GXESQAI KAKOURGOU=NTAS KAI\ SOFIZOME/NOUS. @&10Cicero de finibus I 2, 6. <21Quid enim est a Chrysippo prae-&10termissum in Stoicis>21? Legimus tamen Diogenem, Antipatrum, Mnesar-&10chum, Panaetium, multos alios in primisque familiarem nostrum Posidonium. @1 &10@Ae%28tii Placita I. Prooem. 2 [1D G p. 273, 11$10]1. <20*OI( ME\N OU)=N *STWI+KOI\>20 E)/FASAN TH\N ME\N <20SOFI/AN EI)=NAI QEI/WN TE KAI\ A)NQRWPI/NWN E)PISTH/MHN>20, TH\N DE\ FILOSOFI/AN A)/SKHSIN E)PITHDEI/OU TE/XNHS: E)PITH/DEION DE\ EI)=NAI MI/AN KAI\ A)NWTA/TW TH\N A)RETH/N, A)RETA\S DE\ TA\S GENIKWTA/TAS TREI=S, FUSI-KH\N H)QIKH\N LOGIKH/N: DI' H(\N AI)TI/AN KAI\ TRIMERH/S E)STIN H( FILOSOFI/A, H(=S TO\ ME\N FUSIKO/N, TO\ DE\ H)QIKO/N, TO\ DE\ LOGIKO/N: KAI\ FUSIKO\N ME\N O(/TAN PERI\ KO/SMOU ZHTW=MEN KAI\ TW=N E)N KO/SMW|, H)QIKO\N DE\ TO\ KATHSXOLHME/NON PERI\ TO\N A)NQRW/PINON BI/ON, LOGIKO\N DE\ TO\ PERI\ TO\N LO/GON, O(\ KAI\ DIALEKTIKO\N KALOU=SIN. @&10Sextus adv. math. IX 13.$10 TH\N FILOSOFI/AN FASI\N E)PITH/DEUSIN EI)=NAI SOFI/AS, <20TH\N DE\ SOFI/AN E)PISTH/MHN QEI/WN TE KAI\ A)NQRWPI/NWN PRAGMA/TWN.>20 @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 39.$ *TRIMERH= FASIN EI)=NAI TO\N KATA\ FILO-SOFI/AN LO/GON: EI)=NAI GA\R AU)TOU= TO\ ME/N TI FUSIKO/N, TO\ DE\ H)QIKO/N, TO\ DE\ LOGIKO/N. *OU(/TW DE\ PRW=TOS DIEI=LE *ZH/NWN__KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS E)N TW=| PRW/TW| PERI\ LO/GOU>20 KAI\ <20E)N TH=| PRW/TH| TW=N FUSIKW=N>20. __ TAU=TA DE\ TA\ ME/RH O( ME\N *)APOLLO/DWROS TO/POUS KALEI=, O( <20DE\ *XRU/SIP-POS>20 KAI\ *EU)/DROMOS EI)/DH. A)/LLOI GE/NH. @&10Sextus adv. math. VII 16.$10 OI( EI)PO/NTES TH=S FILOSOFI/AS TO\ ME/N TI EI)=NAI FUSIKO/N, TO\ DE\ H)QIKO/N, TO\ DE\ LOGIKO/N: __R(HTO/TATA DE\ OI( PERI\ *CENOKRA/THN KAI\ OI( A)PO\ TOU= PERIPA/TOU, E)/TI DE\ <20OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 E)/XONTAI TH=SDE TH=S DIAIRE/SEWS. E)NQE/NDE PIQANW=S O(MOIOU=SI TH\N FILOSOFI/AN PAGKA/RPW| A)LWH=|, I(/NA TH=| ME\N U(YHLO/THTI TW=N FUTW=N EI)KA/ZHTAI TO\ FUSIKO/N, TW=| DE\ NOSTI/MW| TW=N KARPW=N TO\ H)QIKO/N, TH=| DE\ O)XURO/THTI TW=N TEIXW=N TO\ LOGIKO/N. OI( DE\ W)W=| FASIN AU)TH\N EI)=NAI PARAPLH/SION: E)W/|KEI GA\R TH=| ME\N LEKI/QW|, H(/N TINES NEOTTO\N U(PA/RXEIN LE/GOUSI, TA\ H)QIKA/, TW=| DE\ LEUKW=|, O(\ DH\ TROFH/ E)STI TH=S LEKI/QOU, TA\ FUSIKA/, TW=| DE\ E)/CWQEN O)STRAKW/DEI TA\ LOGIKA/ [1O( DE\ <20*POSEIDW/NIOS>20, E)PEI\ TA\ ME\N ME/RH TH=S FILOSOFI/AS A)XW/RISTA/ E)STIN A)LLH/LWN, TA\ DE\ FUTA\ TW=N KARPW=N E(/TERA QEWREI=TAI KAI\ TA\ TEI/XH TW=N FUTW=N KEXW/RISTAI, ZW/|W| MA=LLON EI)KA/ZEIN @1 H)CI/OU TH\N FILOSOFI/AN, AI(/MATI ME\N KAI\ SARCI\ TO\ FUSIKO/N, O)STE/OIS DE\ KAI\ NEU/-ROIS TO\ LOGIKO/N, YUXH=| DE\ TO\ H)QIKO/N]1. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 40.$10 EI)KA/ZOUSI DE\ ZW/|W| TH\N FILOSOFI/AN, O)STOI=S ME\N KAI\ NEU/ROIS TO\ LOGIKO\N PROSOMOIOU=NTES, TOI=S DE\ SARKWDESTE/ROIS TO\ H)QI-KO/N, TH=| DE\ YUXH=| TO\ FUSIKO/N: H)\ PA/LIN W)W=|: TA\ ME\N GA\R E)KTO\S EI)=NAI TO\ LOGI-KO/N, TA\ DE\ META\ TAU=TA TO\ H)QIKO/N, TA\ D' E)SWTA/TW TO\ FUSIKO/N: H)\ A)GRW=| PAM-FO/RW|: OU(= TO\N ME\N PERIBEBLHME/NON FRAGMO\N TO\ LOGIKO/N, TO\N DE\ KARPO\N TO\ H)QIKO/N, TH\N DE\ GH=N H)\ TA\ DE/NDRA TO\ FUSIKO/N: H)\ PO/LEI KALW=S TETEIXISME/NH| KAI\ KATA\ LO/GON DIOIKOUME/NH|. @&10Philo de agricultura %14 14 Vol. II p. 97, 24 Wendl.$10 *TO\N GOU=N KATA\ FILOSOFI/AN LO/GON TRI/DUMON O)/NTA <20TOU\S PALAIOU\S>20 A)GRW=| FASIN A)PEI-KA/SAI, TO\ ME\N FUSIKO\N AU)TOU= DE/NDROIS KAI\ FUTOI=S PARABA/LLONTAS, TO\ DE\ H)QIKO\N KARPOI=S, W(=N E(/NEKA KAI\ TA\ FUTA/, TO\ D' AU)= LOGIKO\N FRAGMW=| KAI\ PERI-BO/LW|__ [1&10quod ceteris partibus praesidio est]1 %14 16.$10 TA\S GA\R DIPLA=S KAI\ A)MFIBO/LOUS O(/TAN E)CAPLOI= LE/CEIS KAI\ TA\S DIA\ TW=N SOFISMA/TWN PIQANO/-THTAS E)PILU/H| KAI\ TH\N EU)PARA/GWGON A)PA/THN__A)NAIRH=|, DIA\ LO/GWN E)MFAN-TIKWTA/TWN KAI\ A)PODEI/CEWN A)NENDOIA/STWN, W(/SPER KHRO\N LELEIASME/NON TO\N NOU=N A)PERGA/ZETAI, E(/TOIMON DE/XESQAI TOU/S TE FUSIOLOGI/AS KAI\ TOU\S H)QOPOII/+AS__ XARAKTH=RAS. @&10Origenes comment. in Matthaeum Vol. III p. 778 Delarue.$10 KAI\ O(/RA EI) DUNA/MEQA TH\N ME\N KATA\ TH\N QEI/AN GRAFH\N FUSIOLOGI/AN TO\N A)MPELW=NA EI)PEI=N: TO\N DE\ A)KO/LOUQON TH=| A)LHQEI= FUSIOLOGI/A| BI/ON E)N A)RETH=| KAI\ KALLI/STOIS H)/QESI KARPOFOROU=NTA LE/GEIN EI)=NAI TO\N TOU= A)MPELW=NOS KARPO/N: TO\N DE\ LOGI-KO\N TO/PON [1KAI\ PA=N TO\ GRA/MMA TH=S GRAFH=S]1 TO\N FRAGMO\N EI)=NAI TOU= A)MPE-LW=NOS PERIKEI/MENON E)/CWQEN &10etc. &10@Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 40.$10 KAI\ OU)QE\N ME/ROS [1&10ex tribus philosophiae &10partibus$10]1 TOU= E(TE/RON PROKEKRI/SQAI, KAQ' A(/ TINES AU)TW=N FASIN, A)LLA\ MEMI=XQAI AU)TA/. KAI\ TH\N PARA/DOSIN MIKTH\N E)POI/OUN. @&Plut. de Stoic. repugn. c. 9 p. 1035a.$8 *(O *XRU/SIPPOS OI)/ETAI DEI=N TW=N LOGIKW=N PRW=TON A)KROA=SQAI TOU\S NE/OUS, DEU/TERON DE\ TW=N H)QI-KW=N, META\ DE\ TAU=TA TW=N FUSIKW=N, W(SAU/TWS DE\ TOU/TOIS TO\N PERI\ QEW=N LO/GON E)/SXATON PARALAMBA/NEIN. *POLLA/KIS DE\ TOU/TWN U(P' AU)TOU= LEGO-ME/NWN, A)RKE/SEI PARAQE/SQAI <20TA\ E)N TW=| TETA/RTW| PERI\ *BI/WN>20 E)/XONTA KATA\ LE/CIN OU(/TW: "1<20*PRW=TON ME\N OU)=N DOKEI= MOI, KATA\ TA\ O)RQW=S U(PO\ TW=N A)RXAI/WN EI)RHME/NA, TRI/A GE/NH TW=N TOU= FILOSO/FOU QEWRHMA/TWN EI)=NAI: TA\ ME\N LOGIKA/, TA\ DE\ H)QIKA/, TA\ DE\ FUSIKA/: EI)=TA TOU/TWN DEI=N TA/TTESQAI PRW=TA ME\N TA\ LOGIKA/, DEU/TERA DE\ TA\ H)QIKA/, TRI/TA DE\ TA\ FUSIKA/: TW=N DE\ FUSIKW=N E)/SXATOS @1 EI)=NAI O( PERI\ TW=N QEW=N LO/GOS, DIO\ KAI\ TELETA\S H)GO/REUSAN TA\S TOU/TOU PARADO/SEIS.>20"2 @&Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 40.$ A)/LLOI DE\ PRW=TON ME\N TO\ LOGIKO\N TA/T-TOUSI: DEU/TERON DE\ TO\ FUSIKO/N: KAI\ TRI/TON TO\ H)QIKO/N. W(=N E)STI *ZH/NWN E)N TW=| PERI\ LO/GOU KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 &etc. @&10Sextus adv. math. VII 22.$10 <20OI( DE\ A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 KAI\ AU)TOI\ A)/RXEIN ME/N FASI TA\ LOGIKA/, DEUTEREU/EIN DE\ TA\ H)QIKA/: TELEUTAI=A DE\ TETA/XQAI TA\ FUSIKA/. PRW=TON GA\R DEI=N KATHSFALI/SQAI TO\N NOU=N EI)S DUSE/KKROUSTON TW=N PARADIDOME/NWN FULAKH/N: O)XURWTIKO\N DE\ EI)=NAI TH=S DIANOI/AS TO\N DIA-LEKTIKO\N TO/PON: DEU/TERON DE\ U(POGRA/FEIN TH\N H)QIKH\N QEWRI/AN PRO\S BELTI/WSIN TW=N H)QW=N: A)KI/NDUNOS GA\R H( PARADOXH\ TAU/THS E)PI\ PROU+POKEIME/NH| TH=| LOGIKH=| DUNA/MEI: TELEUTAI/AN DE\ E)PA/GEIN TH\N FUSIKH\N QEWRI/AN: QEIOTE/RA GA/R E)STI KAI\ BAQUTE/RAS DEI=TAI TH=S E)PISTA/SEWS. @1 @&Cicero de finibus IV 4, 9.&3 Quid? ea quae dialecticinunc tra-&3dunt et docent, nonne ab illis instituta sunt [1scil. a veteribus]1? de qui-&3bus etsi a <21Chrysippo>21 maxime est elaboratum, tamen a Zenone minus &3multo quam ab antiquis. Ab hoc autem quaedam non melius, quam &3veteres, quaedam omnino relicta. Cumque duae sint artes, quibus per-&3fecte ratio et oratio compleatur, una inveniendi, altera disserendi, hanc &3posteriorem et Stoici et Peripatetici, priorem autem illi egregie tradide-&3runt, hi omnino ne attigerunt quidem. @&10Galenus de libris propriis 11. Vol. XIX p. 40 K.$10 A)LLH/LOIS ME\N LE/GW DIAFE/RESQAI TOU\S FILOSO/FOUS E)N TH=| LOGIKH=| QEWRI/A|, TOU\S *PERIPATHTI-KOU/S TE KAI\ *STWI+KOU\S KAI\ *PLATWNIKOU/S: E(AUTW=N DE\ PA/LIN I)DI/A| TOU\S KAQ' E(KA/STHN AU)TW=N: MIKRA\ ME\N DH/ PW/S E)STIN H( PARA\ TOI=S *PERIPATHTIKOI=S DIA-FWNI/A, <20MEGA/LH DE\ PARA\ TOI=S *STWI+KOI=S>20 KAI\ *PLATWNIKOI=S. @&Galenus de differentia pulsuum II 4. Vol. VIII 578.$ OU)DE\ GA\R EU(=RON TOU)/NOMA PARA/ TINI TW=N *(ELLH/NWN: W(/STE OU)DE\ KAQ' OU(= TE/-TAKTAI PRA/GMATOS U(P' *)ARXIGE/NOUS E)PI/STAMAI, KAI\ TAU=TA MHDE\ GRA/YAN-TOS AU)TOU= <20BIBLI/ON PERI\ TH=S I)DI/AS DIALE/KTOU, KAQA/PER *XRU/-SIPPOS U(PE\R W(=N E)/QETO KATA\ TH\N DIALEKTIKH\N O)NOMA/TWN.>20 @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 41.$10 TO\ DE\ LOGIKO\N ME/ROS FASI\N E)/NIOI EI)S DU/O DIAIREI=SQAI E)PISTH/MAS, EI)S R(HTORIKH\N KAI\ EI)S DIALEKTIKH/N. __&10`42.$10 TH/N TE R(HTORIKH\N E)PISTH/MHN OU)=SAN TOU= EU)= LE/GEIN PERI\ TW=N E)N DIECO/DW| LO/GWN KAI\ TH\N DIALEKTIKH\N TOU= O)RQW=S DIALE/GESQAI PERI\ TW=N E)N E)RWTH/SEI KAI\ A)POKRI/SEI LO/GWN: O(/QEN KAI\ OU(/TWS AU)TH\N O(RI/ZONTAI: E)PISTH/MHN A)LHQW=N KAI\ YEUDW=N KAI\ OU)DETE/RWN. @1 @&10Ammonius in Aristot. Anal. pr. p. 8, 20 Wal.$10 <20OI( ME\N *STWI+KOI\>20 TH\N LOGIKH\N OU) MO/NON O)/RGANON OU)K A)CIOU=SI KALEI=SQAI FILOSOFI/AS, A)LL' OU)DE\ MO/RION TO\ TUXO/N, A)LLA\ ME/ROS. @&10idem p. 9, 1$10 OI( ME\N OU)=N *STWI+KOI/ FASIN O(/TI AU)TH\ H( FILOSOFI/A TH\N LOGIKH\N A)POGENNA=| KAI\ TAU/TH| ME/ROS A)\N EI)/H AU)TH=S. KAI\ A)/LLOUS DE\ POLLOU\S TOIOU/TOUS LE/GOUSI LO/GOUS SAQROU/S, DI' W(=N, W(S OI)/ONTAI, <20KATASKEUA/ZOUSIN O(/TI ME/ROS E)STI\N H( LOGIKH\ TH=S FILOSOFI/AS>20. DIO\ TOU\S ME\N POLLOU\S E)ATE/ON, E)KEI=NON DE\ LEKTE/ON O(\N OI)/ONTAI KATASKEUASTIKW/TATON KAI\ DRIMU/TATON EI)=NAI. SULLOGI/ZONTAI GA\R OU(/TWS: <20E)A/N TIS TE/XNH KE/XRHTAI/ TINI O(\ MHDE-MIA=S A)/LLHS TE/XNHS ME/ROS E)STI\N H)\ MO/RION, TOU=TO PA/NTWS TAU/THS TH=S TE/XNHS H)\ ME/ROS E)STI\N H)\ MO/RION:>20 OI(=ON TH=| XEIROURGIKH=|, FASI/N, KE/XRH-TAI H( I)ATRIKH/, KAI\ E)PEIDH\ OU)DEMI/A A)/LLH TE/XNH KE/XRHTAI TH=| XEIROURGIKH=| W(S ME/REI H)\ MORI/W|, H( XEIROURGIKH\ TH=S I)ATRIKH=S OU)K E)/STIN O)/RGANON. <20H( DE\ FILO-SOFI/A>20, FHSI/N, <20KE/XRHTAI TH=| LOGIKH=|, H(/TIS OU)DEMIA=S A)/LLHS TE/XNHS [2ME/ROS E)STI\N H)\ MO/RION: H( LOGIKH\ A)/RA OU)K E)/STIN O)/RGANON]2 TH=S FILOSOFI/AS A)LL' H)\ ME/ROS H)\ MO/RION>20. EI) DE/ TIS LE/GEI O(/TI KAI\ A)/LLAI TE/XNAI KE/XRHNTAI TH=| LOGIKH=|, W(S H( I)ATRIKH\ KE/XRHTAI SULLOGISMOI=S KAI\ [2AI(]2 A)/LLAI PA=SAI TE/XNAI KE/XRHNTAI SULLOGISMOI=S, E)ROU=MEN O(/TI KE/XRHNTAI ME\N KA)-KEI=NAI, A)LL' OU)K EI)SI\N TW=N MEQO/DWN E)PISTH/MONES KAI\ OU) PROHGOUME/NWS PERI\ TOU=TO SPOUDA/ZOUSIN: OI(=ON O( I)ATRO\S OU) PROHGOUME/NWS PERI\ TH\N SULLOGISTIKH\N ME/QODON SPOUDA/ZEI, OU)DE\ EI)/POIS ME/ROS H)\ MO/RION I)ATRIKH=S EI)=NAI AU)TH/N, A)LL' O(/SON E)STI\N AU)TW=| XRH/SIMON PRO\S A)PO/DEICIN TW=N I)ATRIKW=N QEWRHMA/TWN, TOSOU=-TON PARALAMBA/NEI PARA\ TOU= DIALEKTIKOU= W(S O)/RGANON: O( DE\ FILO/SOFOS E)PI-STH/MWN E)STI\N W(S E)/NI MA/LISTA TH=S TOIAU/THS MEQO/DOU. TAU/TH| ME\N OU)=N <20OI( *STWI+KOI/>20, W(S OI)/ONTAI, KATASKEUA/ZOUSIN O(/TI OU)K O)/RGANO/N E)STIN H( LOGIKH/. LOIPO\N DE\ O(/TI [2ME/ROS, OU)]2 MO/RION. LE/GOUSIN O(/TI TW=N TRIW=N MORI/WN TOU= PRAKTIKOU= U(/LH ME/N E)STIN TA\ A)NQRW/PINA, TE/LOS DE\ H( TOU= A)NQRWPI/NOU BI/OU EU)DAIMONI/A, H(\N O( POLITIKO\S SPOUDA/ZEI PERIPOIEI=N: PA/LIN DE\ TW=N TOU= QEWRH-TIKOU= MORI/WN U(/LH ME/N E)STI TA\ QEI=A PRA/GMATA, TE/LOS DE\ H( QEWRHTIKH\ EU)DAI-MONI/A: H( DE\ LOGIKH\ PRAGMATEI/A OU)/TE U(/LHN TH\N AU)TH\N E)/XEI OU)/TE TE/LOS: U(/LH ME\N GA\R AU)TH=S E)STIN OI( LO/GOI, TE/LOS DE\ H( GNW=SIS TW=N A)PODEIKTIKW=N MEQO/DWN: KAI\ TA\ A)/LLA GA\R PA/NTA EI)S TOU=TO SUNTELEI=, EI)S TO\ E)PISTHMONIKW=S A)PODEIKNU/-NAI. W(/STE U(P' OU)DE/TERON ME/ROS FILOSOFI/AS DU/NATAI TETA/XQAI: EI) GA\R KAI\ PERI\ A)NQRWPI/NWN KAI\ QEI/WN PRAGMA/TWN H( LOGIKH\ PRAGMATEU/ETAI [1KEXRH/MEQA GA\R AU)TH=| H)\ PERI\ A)NQRWPI/NWN H)\ QEI/WN PRAGMA/TWN DIALEGO/MENOI]1, A)LL' OU) PERI\ A)NQRW/PINA MO/NA E)/XEI W(S TA\ TOU= PRAKTIKOU= MO/RIA, OU)DE\ PERI\ QEI=A MO/NA W(S TA\ TOU= QEWRHTIKOU=: W(/STE OU) MO/RION A)LLA\ TRI/TON ME/ROS E)STI\N FILOSOFI/AS. @&10Alexander Aphrod. in Aristot. Analyt. pr. p. 1, 9 Wal.$10 OI( ME\N OU)=N ME/ROS AU)TH\N LE/GONTES H)NE/XQHSAN E)PI\ TOU=TO, DIO/TI W(/SPER PERI\ TA\ A)/LLA, A(\ O(MOLOGEI=TAI PRO\S A(PA/NTWN ME/RH FILOSOFI/AS EI)=NAI, H( FILOSOFI/A KATAGI/NETAI E)/RGON POIOUME/NH TH/N TE EU(/RESIN AU)TW=N KAI\ TH\N TA/CIN TE KAI\ TH\N SU/STASIN, OU(/TW DH\ KAI\ PERI\ TH\N PRAGMATEI/AN TH/NDE: OU)=SA DE\ TAU/THS E)/RGON OU)DETE/ROU @1 TW=N LOIPW=N TH=S FILOSOFI/AS MERW=N MO/RIO/N E)STIN, OU)/TE TOU= QEWRHTIKOU= OU)/TE TOU= PRAKTIKOU=. A)/LLO GA\R TO/ TE U(POKEI/MENON TAU/TH| KA)KEI/NWN E(KATE/RA| KAI\ DIAFE/ROUSA H( PRO/QESIS KAQ' E(KA/STHN AU)TW=N: OI(=S DE\ DIAFE/RONTA E)KEI=NA A)L-LH/LWN A)NTIDIAIREI=TAI A)LLH/LOIS, TOU/TOIS KAI\ H( ME/QODOS AU(/TH E(KATE/RAS E)KEI/NWN DIAFE/ROUSA EU)LO/GWS A)NTIDIAIREI=TAI AU)TOI=S: KAI\ GA\R TW=| U(POKEIME/NW| DIAFE/ROUSA E)KEI/NWN: A)CIW/MATA GA\R KAI\ PROTA/SEIS TA\ U(POKEI/MENA TAU/TH|: KAI\ TW=| TE/LEI KAI\ ሌTH=| PROQE/SEI: H( GA\R TAU/THS PRO/QESIS TO\ DIA\ TH=S POIA=S SUNQE/SEWS TW=N PRO-TA/SEWN E)K TW=N TIQEME/NWN TE KAI\ SUGXWROUME/NWN E)C A)NA/GKHS TI SUNAGO/MENON DEIKNU/NAI: O(\ OU)DETE/RAS E)KEI/NWN TE/LOS. @&Plut. de Stoic. repugn. cp. 9 p. 1035e.$8 *EI) DE/ TIS E)REI=, GEGRA-FE/NAI TO\N *XRU/SIPPON <20E)N TW=| PERI\ *LO/GOU *XRH/SEWS>20, W(S "1<20*OU) KAQA/PAC A)FEKTE/ON E)STI\ TW=N A)/LLWN TW=| TH\N LOGIKH\N A)NALAMBA/NONTI PRW/-THN, A)LLA\ KA)KEI/NWN METALHPTE/ON KATA\ TO\ DIDO/MENON>20"2 A)LHQH= ME\N E)REI= &etc. &@Arrianus Epictet. dissert. I 17, 10.$ E)KEI=NO A)PARKEI= O(/ TI [1TA\ LOGIKA/]1 TW=N A)/LLWN E)STI\ DIAKRITIKA\ KAI\ E)PISKEPTIKA\ KAI\ W(S A)/N TIS EI)/POI METRHTIKA\ KAI\ STATIKA/. TI/S LE/GEI TAU=TA; MO/NOS <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 KAI\ *ZH/NWN KAI\ *KLEA/NQHS; @1 @&10Diocles Magnes apud Diog. Lae%28rt. VII, 49.$10 <20A)RE/SKEI TOI=S *STWI+-KOI=S TO\N PERI\ FANTASI/AS KAI\ AI)SQH/SEWS PROTA/TTEIN LO/GON>20, KAQO/TI TO\ KRITH/RION, W(=| H( A)LH/QEIA TW=N PRAGMA/TWN GINW/SKETAI, KATA\ GE/NOS FANTASI/A E)STI/, KAI\ KAQO/TI O( PERI\ SUGKATAQE/SEWS KAI\ O( PERI\ KATALH/YEWS KAI\ NOH/SEWS LO/GOS, PROA/GWN TW=N A)/LLWN, OU)K A)/NEU FANTASI/AS SUNI/STATAI: PROHGEI=TAI GA\R H( FANTASI/A, EI)=Q' H( DIA/NOIA E)KLALHTIKH\ U(PA/RXOUSA, O(\ PA/SXEI U(PO\ TH=S FAN-TASI/AS, TOU=TO E)KFE/REI LO/GW|. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 46.$10 <20TH\N DE\ FANTASI/AN EI)=NAI TU/PWSIN E)N YUXH=|>20, TOU= O)NO/MATOS OI)KEI/WS METENHNEGME/NOU A)PO\ TW=N TU/PWN [2TW=N]2 E)N TW=| KHRW=| U(PO\ TOU= DAKTULI/OU GINOME/NWN. TH=S DE\ FANTASI/AS TH\N ME\N KATALHPTI-KH\N TH\N DE\ A)KATA/LHPTON: KATALHPTIKH\N ME/N, H(\N KRITH/RION EI)=NAI TW=N PRAGMA/-TWN FASI/, TH\N GINOME/NHN A)PO\ U(PA/RXONTOS KAT' AU)TO\ TO\ U(PA/RXON E)NAPESFRA-GISME/NHN KAI\ E)NAPOMEMAGME/NHN: A)KATA/LHPTON DE\ TH\N MH\ A)PO\ U(PA/RXONTOS: H)\ A)PO\ U(PA/RXONTOS ME/N, MH\ KAT' AU)TO\ DE\ TO\ U(PA/RXON: TH\N MH\ TRANH= MHDE\ E)/KTUPON. @&Ae%28tii plac. IV. 12, 1 [1DDG p. 401, 14]1.$ *TI/NI DIAFE/REI FAN-TASI/A FANTASTO\N FANTASTIKO\N FA/NTASMA. &Gal. hist. philos. 93. cf. &Nemesius p. 171_73 ed. Matth.$ @<20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 DIAFE/REIN A)LLH/LWN FHSI\ TE/TTARA TAU=TA. <20FANTASI/A>20 ME\N OU)=N E)STI PA/QOS E)N TH=| YUXH=| GIGNO/MENON, E)NDEIKNU/MENON E)N AU(TW=| KAI\ TO\ PEPOIHKO/S: OI(=ON E)PEIDA\N DI' O)/YEWS QEWRW=MEN TO\ LEUKO/N, E)/STI PA/QOS TO\ E)GGEGENHME/NON DIA\ TH=S O(RA/SEWS E)N TH=| YUXH=|. KAI\ [2KATA\]2 TOU=TO TO\ PA/QOS EI)PEI=N E)/XOMEN, O(/TI U(PO/KEITAI LEUKO\N KINOU=N H(MA=S: O(MOI/WS KAI\ DIA\ TH=S A(FH=S KAI\ TH=S O)SFRH/SEWS. _*EI)/RHTAI DE\ H( FAN-TASI/A A)PO\ TOU= FWTO/S: KAQA/PER GA\R TO\ FW=S AU(TO\ DEI/KNUSI KAI\ TA\ @1 A)/LLA TA\ E)N AU)TW=| PERIEXO/MENA, KAI\ H( FANTASI/A DEI/KNUSIN E(AUTH\N KAI\ TO\ PEPOIHKO\S AU)TH/N. @<20*FANTASTO\N>20 DE\ TO\ POIOU=N TH\N FANTASI/AN: OI(=ON TO\ LEUKO\N KAI\ TO\ YUXRO\N KAI\ PA=N O(/,TI A)\N DU/NHTAI KINEI=N TH\N YUXH/N, TOU=T' E)/STI FANTASTO/N. @<20*FANTASTIKO\N>20 DE/ E)STI DIA/KENOS E(LKUSMO/S, PA/QOS E)N TH=| YUXH=| A)P' OU)DENO\S FANTASTOU= GINO/MENON KAQA/PER E)PI\ TOU= SKIAMAXOU=NTOS KAI\ KENOI=S E)PIFE/RONTOS TA\S XEI=RAS: TH=| GA\R FANTASI/A| U(PO/KEITAI/ TI FAN-TASTO/N, TW=| DE\ FANTASTIKW=| OU)DE/N. @<20*FA/NTASMA>20 DE/ E)STIN E)F' O(\ E(LKO/MEQA KATA\ TO\N FANTASTIKO\N DIA/-KENON E(LKUSMO/N: TAU=TA DE\ GI/NETAI E)PI\ TW=N MELAGXOLW/NTWN KAI\ MEMH-NO/TWN: O( GOU=N TRAGIKO\S *)ORE/STHS O(/TAN LE/GH| [1&Eur. Or. 255sq.$]1: @W)= MH=TER, I(KETEU/W SE, MH\ 'PI/SEIE/ MOI @TA\S AI(MATWPOU\S KAI\ DRAKONTW/DEIS KO/RAS: @AU(=TAI GA/R, AU(=TAI PLHSI/ON QRW/SKOUSI/ MOU, LE/GEI ME\N AU)TA\ W(S MEMHNW/S, O(RA=| DE\ OU)DE/N, A)LLA\ DOKEI= MO/NON: DIO\ KAI/ FHSIN AU)TW=| *)HLE/KTRA: @ME/N', W)= TALAI/PWR', A)TRE/MA SOI=S E)N DEMNI/OIS, @O(RA=|S GA\R OU)DE\N W(=N DOKEI=S SA/F' EI)DE/NAI, W(S KAI\ PAR' *(OMH/RW| *QEOKLU/MENOS [1&Od.$ U& 350]1. &@Diocles Magnes apud Diog. Lae%28rt. VII, 50.$ DIAFE/REI DE\ FAN-TASI/A KAI\ FA/NTASMA. FA/NTASMA ME\N GA/R E)STI DO/KHSIS DIANOI/AS, OI(/A GI/NETAI KATA\ TOU\S U(/PNOUS, FANTASI/A DE/ E)STI TU/PWSIS E)N YUXH=|, TOUTE/STIN A)LLOI/WSIS, W(S O( <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 E)N TH=| B# PERI\ YUXH=S U(FI/STATAI. OU)DE\ GA\R DEKTE/ON TH\N TU/PWSIN OI(ONEI\ TU/PON SFRAGISTH=ROS, E)PEI\ A)NE/NDEKTO/N E)STI POLLOU\S TU/POUS KATA\ TO\ AU)TO\ PERI\ TO\ AU)TO\ GI/NESQAI. @&Sextus Emp. adv. math. VII 227.$ A)POLEIPOME/NHS D' E)/TI TH=S STWI+KH=S DO/CHS PARAKEIME/NWS KAI\ PERI\ TAU/THS LE/GWMEN. KRITH/RION TOI/NUN FASI\N A)LHQEI/AS EI)=NAI OI( A)/NDRES OU(=TOI TH\N KATALHPTIKH\N FAN-TASI/AN. TAU/THN D' EI)SO/MEQA, PRO/TERON GNO/NTES TI/ POTE/ E)STI KAT' AU)-TOU\S H( FANTASI/A KAI\ TI/NES E)P' EI)/DOUS TAU/THS DIAFORAI/. FANTASI/A OU)=N E)STI\ KAT' AU)TOU\S TU/PWSIS E)N YUXH=|. PERI\ H(=S EU)QU\S KAI\ DIE/STHSAN: *KLEA/NQHS ME\N GA\R H)/KOUSE TH\N TU/PWSIN KATA\ EI)SOXH/N TE KAI\ E)COXH/N, W(/SPER KAI\ DIA\ TW=N DAKTULI/WN GINOME/NHN TOU= KHROU= TU/PWSIN. <20*XRU/-SIPPOS>20 DE\ A)/TOPON H(GEI=TO TO\ TOIOU=TO. PRW=TON ME\N GA/R, FHSI, TH=S DIANOI/AS DEH/SEI U(F' E(/N POTE TRI/GWNO/N TI KAI\ TETRA/GWNON FANTASIOU-ME/NHS TO\ AU)TO\ SW=MA KATA\ TO\N AU)TO\N XRO/NON DIAFE/RONTA E)/XEIN PERI\ @1 AU(TW=| SXH/MATA A(/MA TE TRI/GWNON KAI\ TETRA/GWNON GI/NESQAI H)\ KAI\ PERI-FERE/S, O(/PER E)STI\N A)/TOPON: EI)=TA POLLW=N A(/MA FANTASIW=N U(FISTAME/NWN E)N H(MI=N PAMPLHQEI=S KAI\ TOU\S SXHMATISMOU\S E(/CEIN TH\N YUXH/N, O(\ TOU= PROTE/ROU XEI=RO/N E)STIN. AU)TO\S OU)=N TH\N TU/PWSIN EI)RH=SQAI U(PO\ TOU= *ZH/NWNOS U(PENO/EI A)NTI\ TH=S E(TEROIW/SEWS, W(/ST' EI)=NAI TOIOU=TON TO\N LO/GON "1FANTASI/A E)STI\N E(TEROI/WSIS YUXH=S"2 MHKE/TI A)TO/POU O)/NTOS [2TOU=]2 TO\ AU)TO\ SW=MA U(F' E(/NA KAI\ TO\N AU)TO\N XRO/NON, POLLW=N PERI\ H(MA=S SUNISTA-ME/NWN FANTASIW=N, PAMPLHQEI=S A)NADE/XESQAI E(TEROIW/SEIS: W(/SPER GA\R O( A)H\R, O(/TAN A(/MA POLLOI\ FWNW=SIN, A)MUQH/TOUS U(PO\ E(\N KAI\ DIAFEROU/SAS A)NADEXO/MENOS PLHGA\S EU)QU\S POLLA\S I)/SXEI KAI\ TA\S E(TEROIW/SEIS, OU(/TW KAI\ TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N POIKI/LWS FANTASIOU/MENON A)NA/LOGO/N TI TOU/TW| PEI/SETAI. @&ibid. 372.$ EI) GA\R TU/PWSI/S E)STIN E)N YUXH=| H( FANTASI/A, H)/TOI KAT' E)COXH\N KAI\ EI)SOXH\N TU/PWSI/S E)STIN, W(S OI( PERI\ TO\N *KLEA/NQHN NOMI/-ZOUSIN, H)\ KATA\ YILH\N E(TEROI/WSIN GI/NETAI, KAQA/PER <20OI( PERI\ TO\N *XRU/-SIPPON>20 E)DO/CASAN. KAI\ EI) ME\N KAT' E)COXH\N KAI\ EI)SOXH\N U(FI/STATAI TAU=TA A)KOLOUQH/SEI TA\ A)/TOPA A(/PER FASI\N OI( PERI\ TO\N *XRU/SIPPON. EI) GA\R KHROU= TRO/PON TUPOU=TAI H( YUXH\ FANTASTIKW=S PA/SXOUSA, A)EI\ TO\ E)/SXATON KI/NHMA E)PISKOTH/SEI TH=| PROTE/RA| FANTASI/A|, W(/SPER KAI\ O( TH=S DEUTE/RAS SFRAGI=DOS TU/POS E)CALEIPTIKO/S E)STI TOU= PROTE/ROU. A)LL' EI) TOU=TO, <20A)NAIREI=TAI ME\N MNH/MH QHSAURISMO\S OU)=SA FANTASIW=N>20, A)NAIREI=TAI DE\ PA=SA <20TE/XNH: SU/STHMA GA\R H)=N KAI\ A)/QROISMA KATA-LH/YEWN>20, PLEI/ONAS DE\ FANTASI/AS KAI\ DIAFO/ROUS OU) DUNATO\N U(POSTH=-NAI PERI\ TO\ H(GEMONIKO/N, A)/LLOTE A)/LLWN NOOUME/NWN TW=N PERI\ AU)TO\ TU/PWN. OU) TOI/NUN H( KURI/WS NOOUME/NH TU/PWSI/S E)STI FANTASI/A. A)/L-LWS TE EI) O)/YIS E)STI\ TW=N A)DH/LWN TA\ FAINO/MENA, QEWROU=MEN DE\ TA\ POLU\ PAXUMERE/STERA TOU= PNEU/MATOS TW=N FAINOME/NWN SW/MATA MHD' O(NTINOU=N PERI\ AU(TOI=S TU/PON DUNA/MENA THREI=N, EU)/LOGO/N E)STI MHDE\ TO\ PNEU=MA E(/NA MO/NON TINA\ A)PO\ FANTASI/AS TU/PON FULA/TTEIN. @&10Philo de mundi opificio %14 166 Vol. I p. 58, 9 Wendl.$10 [1AI( AI)SQH/-SEIS]1 TA\ FANE/NTA E)KTO\S EI)/SW KOMI/ZOUSAI DIAGGE/LLOUSI KAI\ E)PIDEI/KNUNTAI, TOU\S TU/POUS E(KA/STWN E)NSFRAGIZO/MENAI KAI\ TO\ O(/MOION E)NERGAZO/MENAI PA/QOS. *KHRW=| GA\R E)OIKW\S [1&10scil.$10 O( NOU=S]1 DE/XETAI TA\S DIA\ TW=N AI)SQH/SEWN FANTASI/AS, AI(=S TA\ SW/MATA KATALAMBA/NEI &10etc. &10@Alexander Aphrod. de anima p. 72, 5 Bruns.$10 XRH\ DE\ TOU= TU/POU KOINO/TERON E)PI\ TH=S FANTASI/AS A)KOU/EIN. *KURI/WS ME\N GA\R TU/POS TO\ KAT' EI)-SOXH/N TE KAI\ E)COXH/N, H)\ TO\ TOU= TUPOU=NTOS E)N TW=| TUPOUME/NW| SXH=MA GINO/ME-NON, W(S O(RW=MEN TA\ E)PI\ TW=N SFRAGI/DWN E)/XONTA. OU)X OU(/TWS DE\ TA\ A)PO\ TW=N AI)SQHTW=N E)GKATALEI/MMATA E)N H(MI=N GI/NETAI. OU)DE\ GA\R TH\N A)RXH\N KATA\ SXH=- @1MA/ TI H( TW=N AI)SQHTW=N A)NTI/LHYIS. POI=ON GA\R SXH=MA TO\ LEUKO\N H)\ O(/LWS TO\ XRW=MA; H)\ POI=ON SXH=MA H( O)SMH/; A)LLA\ DI' A)PORI/AN KURI/OU TINO\S O)NO/MATOS TO\ I)/XNOS KAI\ E)GKATA/LEIMMA TO\ U(POME/NON A)PO\ TW=N AI)SQHTW=N E)N H(MI=N TU/PON KA-LOU=MEN METAFE/RONTES TOU)/NOMA. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de anima p. 68, 11 Bruns.$10 DIO\ KAI\ O(RI/ZONTAI TH\N FANTASI/AN TU/PWSIN E)N YUXH=| <20KAI\ TU/PWSIN E)N H(GEMONIKW=|>20. [1&10cf. ibid. 16. &10@Diocles Magnes apud Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 50.$10 NOEI=TAI DE\ [H(] FANTASI/A H( A)PO\ U(PA/RXONTOS KATA\ TO\ U(PA/RXON E)NAPOMEMAGME/NH KAI\ E)NAPOTETUPWME/NH KAI\ E)NAPESFRAGISME/NH, OI(/A OU)K A)\N GE/NOITO A)PO\ MH\ U(PA/RXONTOS. @&10Diocles Magnes apud Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 51.$10 TW=N DE\ FANTASIW=N KAT' AU)TOU\S AI( ME/N EI)SIN AI)SQHTIKAI/, AI( D' OU)/: AI)SQHTIKAI\ ME\N AI( DI' AI)SQHTH-RI/OU H)\ AI)SQHTHRI/WN LAMBANO/MENAI, OU)K AI)SQHTIKAI\ DE\ AI( DIA\ TH=S DIANOI/AS, KAQA/PER TW=N A)SWMA/TWN KAI\ TW=N A)/LLWN TW=N LO/GW| LAMBANOME/NWN. TW=N DE\ AI)SQHTIKW=N [2AI( ME\N]2 A)PO\ U(PARXO/NTWN META\ EI)/CEWS KAI\ SUGKATAQE/SEWS GI/-NONTAI: EI)SI\ DE\ TW=N FANTASIW=N KAI\ E)MFA/SEIS, AI( W(S A)\N A)PO\ U(PARXO/NTWN GINO/MENAI. E)/TI TW=N FANTASIW=N AI( ME/N EI)SI LOGIKAI/, AI( DE\ A)/LOGOI: LOGIKAI\ ME\N AI( TW=N LOGIKW=N ZW/|WN, A)/LOGOI DE\ AI( TW=N A)LO/GWN. AI( ME\N OU)=N LOGIKAI\ NOH/SEIS EI)SI/N, AI( D' A)/LOGOI OU) TETUXH/KASIN O)NO/MATOS: KAI\ AI( ME/N EI)SI TEXNI-KAI/, AI( DE\ A)/TEXNOI: A)/LLWS GOU=N QEWREI=TAI U(PO\ TEXNI/TOU EI)KW\N KAI\ A)/LLWS U(PO\ A)TE/XNOU. @&Cicero de divin. II. 61, 126.&3 praesertim cum <21Chrysippus>21, &3Academicos refellens, permulto clariora et certiora esse dicat, quae vigi-&3lantibus videantur, quam quae somniantibus. @&10Sextus adv. math. VII 162.$10 KAI\ FANTASI/AN R(HTE/ON EI)=NAI PA/QOS TI PERI\ TO\ ZW=|ON E(AUTOU= TE KAI\ TOU= E(TE/ROU PARASTATIKO/N. OI(=ON PROSBLE/YANTE/S TINI, <20FHSI\N O( *)ANTI/O-XOS>20, DIATIQE/MEQA/ PWS TH\N O)/YIN, KAI\ OU)X OU(/TWS AU)TH\N DIAKEIME/NHN I)/SXOMEN W(S PRI\N TOU= BLE/YAI DIAKEIME/NHN EI)/XOMEN. *KATA\ ME/NTOI TH\N TOIAU/THN A)LLOI/W-SIN DUOI=N A)NTILAMBANO/MEQA, E(NO\S ME\N AU)TH=S TH=S A)LLOIW/SEWS, TOUTE/STI TH=S FANTASI/AS, DEUTE/ROU DE\ TOU= TH\N A)LLOI/WSIN E)MPOIH/SANTOS, TOUTE/STI TOU= O(RA-TOU=: KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N A)/LLWN AI)SQH/SEWN PARAPLH/SION. <20W(/SPER OU)=N TO\ FW=S E(AUTO/>20 TE <20DEI/KNUSI KAI\ PA/NTA TA\ E)N AU)TW=|, OU(/TW KAI\ H( FANTASI/A>20, A)RXHGO\S OU)=SA TH=S PERI\ TO\ ZW=|ON EI)DH/SEWS, FWTO\S DI/KHN E(AUTH/N TE E)MFANI/ZEIN O)FEI/LEI KAI\ TOU= POIH/SANTOS AU)TH\N E)NARGOU=S E)NDEIKTIKH\ KAQESTA/NAI. @1 @&10Sextus adv. math. VII 241.$10 H( FANTASI/A GI/NETAI H)/TOI TW=N E)KTO\S H)\ TW=N E)N H(MI=N PAQW=N, O(\ DH\ KURIW/TERON <20DIA/KENOS E(LKUSMO\S>20 PAR' AU)TOI=S [1&10scil. Stoicis$10]1 KALEI=TAI. @&10Sextus adv. math. VII 242.$10 TW=N DE\ FANTASIW=N POLLAI\ ME\N KAI\ A)/LLAI EI)SI\ DIAFORAI/, A)PARKE/SOUSI DE\ AI( LEXQHSO/MENAI. TOU/TWN GA\R AI( ME/N EI)SI PIQANAI/, AI( DE\ A)PI/QANOI, AI( DE\ PIQANAI\ A(/MA KAI\ A)PI/QANOI, AI( DE\ OU)/TE PIQANAI\ OU)/TE A)PI/QANOI. <20PIQANAI\>20 ME\N OU)=N EI)SIN AI( LEI=ON KI/NHMA PERI\ YU-XH\N E)RGAZO/MENAI, W(/SPER NU=N TO\ H(ME/RAN EI)=NAI KAI\ TO\ E)ME\ DIALE/GESQAI [1&10Sex-&10tum audi$10]1_<20A)PI/QANOI DE\>20 AI( MH\ TOIAU=TAI A)LL' A)POSTRE/FOUSAI H(MA=S TH=S SUGKATAQE/SEWS OI(=ON "1EI) H(ME/RA E)STI/N, OU)K E)/STIN H(/LIOS U(PE\R GH=S"2 "1EI) SKO/TOS E)STI/N, H(ME/RA E)STI/N"2. _<20PIQANAI\ DE\ KAI\ A)PI/QANOI>20 KAQESTA=SIN AI( KATA\ TH\N PRO/S TI SXE/SIN O(TE\ ME\N TOI=AI GINO/MENAI O(TE\ DE\ TOI=AI, OI(=ON AI( TW=N A)PO/-RWN LO/GWN, <20OU)/TE DE\ PIQANAI\ OU)/TE A)PI/QANOI>20 KAQA/PER AI( TW=N TOIOU/TWN PRAGMA/TWN "1A)/RTIOI/ EI)SIN OI( A)STE/RES"2 "1PERISSOI/ EI)SIN OI( A)STE/RES"2. _*TW=N DE\ PIQANW=N H)\ A)PIQA/NWN FANTASIW=N AI( ME/N EI)SIN A)LHQEI=S, AI( DE\ YEUDEI=S, AI( DE\ A)LHQEI=S KAI\ YEUDEI=S, AI( DE\ OU)/TE A)LHQEI=S OU)/TE YEUDEI=S. <20A)LHQEI=S>20 ME\N OU)=N EI)SIN W(=N E)/STIN A)LHQH= KATHGORI/AN POIH/SASQAI, W(S TOU= "1H(ME/RA E)STI/N"2 E)PI\ TOU= PARO/NTOS H)\ TOU= "1FW=S E)STI"2, <20YEUDEI=S>20 DE\ W(=N E)/STI YEUDH= KA-THGORI/AN POIH/SASQAI, W(S TOU= KEKLA/SQAI TH\N KATA\ BUQOU= KW/PHN H)\ MU/-OURON EI)=NAI TH\N STOA/N, <20A)LHQEI=S DE\ KAI\ YEUDEI=S>20 O(POI/A PROSE/PIPTEN *)ORE/STH| KATA\ MANI/AN A)PO\ TH=S *)HLE/KTRAS [1KAQO\ ME\N GA\R W(S A)PO\ U(PA/R-XONTO/S TINOS PROSE/PIPTEN, H)=N A)LHQH/S, U(PH=RXE GA\R *)HLE/KTRA: KAQO\ D' W(S A)PO\ *)ERINU/OS, YEUDH/S: OU)K H)=N GA\R *)ERINU/S]1, KAI\ PA/LIN EI)/TIS A)PO\ *DI/WNOS ZW=NTOS KATA\ TOU\S U(/PNOUS W(S A)PO\ PARESTW=TOS O)NEIROPOLEI=TAI YEUDH= KAI\ DIA/KENON E(LKUSMO/N. <20OU)/TE DE\ YEUDEI=S OU)/TE A)LHQEI=S>20 EI)SIN AI( GENIKAI/: W(=N GA\R TA\ EI)/DH TOI=A H)\ TOI=A, TOU/TWN TA\ GE/NH OU)/TE TOI=A OU)/TE TOI=A, OI(=ON TW=N A)NQRW/PWN OI( ME/N EI)SIN *(/ELLHNES OI( DE\ BA/RBAROI, A)LL' O( GENIKO\S A)/NQRW-POS OU)/TE *(/ELLHN E)STI/N, E)PEI\ PA/NTES A)\N OI( E)P' EI)/DOUS H)=SAN *(/ELLHNES, OU)/TE BA/RBAROS DIA\ TH\N AU)TH\N AI)TI/AN. _TW=N DE\ <20A)LHQW=N>20 AI( ME/N EI)SI KATALHP-TIKAI/, AI( DE\ OU)/, OU) KATALHPTIKAI\ ME\N AI( PROSPI/PTOUSAI/ TISI KATA\ PA/QOS: MURI/OI GA\R FRENITI/ZONTES KAI\ MELAGXOLW=NTES A)LHQH= ME\N E(/LKOUSI FANTASI/AN, OU) KATALHPTIKH\N DE/, A)LL' E)/CWQEN KAI\ E)K TU/XHS OU(/TW SUMPESOU=SAN, O(/QEN OU)DE\ DIABEBAIOU=NTAI PERI\ AU)TH=S POLLA/KIS, OU)DE\ SUGKATATI/QENTAI AU)TH=|. <20KA-TALHPTIKH\>20 DE/ E)STIN H( A)PO\ U(PA/RXONTOS KAI\ KAT' AU)TO\ TO\ U(PA/RXON E)NAPO-MEMAGME/NH KAI\ E)NAPESFRAGISME/NH, O(POI/A OU)K A)\N GE/NOITO A)PO\ MH\ U(PA/RXONTOS. A)/KRWS GA\R POIOU/MENOI A)NTILHPTIKH\N EI)=NAI TW=N U(POKEIME/NWN TH/NDE TH\N FAN-TASI/AN KAI\ PA/NTA TEXNIKW=S TA\ PERI\ AU)TOI=S I)DIW/MATA A)NAMEMAGME/NHN, E(/KASTON TOU/TWN FASI\N E)/XEIN SUMBEBHKO/S. W(=N PRW=TON ME\N <20TO\ A)PO\ U(PA/RXONTOS GI/NESQAI>20_DEU/TERON DE\ TO\ KAI\ A)PO\ U(PA/RXONTOS EI)=NAI <20KAI\ KAT' AU)TO\ TO\ U(PA/RXON>20: E)/NIAI GA\R PA/LIN A)PO\ U(PA/RXONTOS ME/N EI)SIN, OU)K AU)TO\ DE\ TO\ U(PA/R-XON I)NDA/LLONTAI, W(S E)PI\ TOU= MEMHNO/TOS *)ORE/STOU MIKRW=| PRO/TERON E)DEI/KNUMEN. _OU) MH\N A)LLA\ KAI\ <20E)NAPOMEMAGME/NHN>20 KAI\ <20E)NAPESFRAGISME/NHN>20 TUG-XA/NEIN, I(/NA PA/NTA TEXNIKW=S TA\ I)DIW/MATA TW=N FANTASTW=N A)NAMA/TTHTAI. OU(/TW KAI\ OI( KATA/LHYIN POIOU/MENOI TW=N U(POKEIME/NWN PA=SIN O)FEI/LOUSI TOI=S I)DIW/MASIN AU)TW=N E)PIBA/LLEIN. TO\ DE\ "1<20OI(/A OU)K A)\N GE/NOITO A)PO\ MH\ U(PA/RXONTOS>20"2 PROSE/QESAN, E)PEI\ OU)X W(/SPER OI( A)PO\ TH=S @1 *STOA=S <20A)DU/NATON U(PEILH/FASI KATA\ PA/NTA A)PARA/LLAKTO/N TINA EU(RE-QH/SESQAI>20, OU(/TW KAI\ OI( A)PO\ TH=S *)AKADHMI/AS. E)KEI=NOI ME\N GA/R FASIN O(/TI O( E)/XWN TH\N KATALHPTIKH\N FANTASI/AN TEXNIKW=S PROSBA/LLEI TH=| U(POU/SH| TW=N PRAG-MA/TWN DIAFORA=|, E)PEI/PER KAI\ EI)=XE/ TI TOIOU=TON I)DI/WMA H( TOIAU/TH FANTASI/A PARA\ TA\S A)/LLAS FANTASI/AS KAQA/PER OI( KERA/STAI PARA\ TOU\S A)/LLOUS O)/FEIS: OI( DE\ A)PO\ TH=S *)AKADHMI/AS TOU)NANTI/ON FASI\ DU/NASQAI TH=| KATALHPTIKH=| FAN-TASI/A| A)PARA/LLAKTON EU(REQH/SESQAI YEU=DOS. @&10Cicero Acad. Pr. II 47. Nam cum dicatis, inquiunt [1scil. novi &10Academici contra Stoicos disputantes]1, visa quaedam mitti a deo, velut &10ea quae in somnis videantur, quaeque oraculis, auspiciis, extis declarentur &10__haec enim aiunt probari Stoicis, quos contra disputant__quaerunt, &10<21quonam modo, falsa visa quae sint, ea deus efficere possit pro-&10babilia>21 etc. @&10Sextus adv. math. VII 405 [1Carneades]1. $10EI) OU)=N KATALHPTIKAI/ TI-NE/S EI)SI FANTASI/AI PARO/SON E)PA/GONTAI H(MA=S EI)S SUGKATA/QESIN KAI\ EI)S TO\ TH\N A)KO/LOUQON AU)TAI=S PRA=CIN SUNA/PTEIN &10etc. &10@Sextus adv. math. VII 424 [1Carneades$10]1. I(/NA GE MH\N AI)SQHTIKH\ GE/NHTAI FANTASI/A KAT' AU)TOU/S [1&10scil. Stoicos$10]1, OI(=ON O(RATIKH\, DEI= PE/NTE SUN-DRAMEI=N, TO/ TE <20AI)SQHTH/RION>20 KAI\ TO\ <20AI)SQHTO\N>20 KAI\ TO\N <20TO/PON>20 KAI\ TO\ <20PW=S>20 KAI\ TH\N <20DIA/NOIAN>20, W(S E)A\N TW=N A)/LLWN PARO/NTWN E(\N MO/NON A)PH=|, KA-QA/PER DIA/NOIA PARA\ FU/SIN E)/XOUSA, OU) SWQH/SETAI, FASI/N, H( A)NTI/LHYIS. @&10Sextus adv. math. VII 426.$10 ZHTOU/NTWN H(MW=N TI/S E)STIN H( KATA-LHPTIKH\ FANTASI/A, O(RIZO/MENOI/ FASIN "1H( A)PO\ U(PA/RXONTOS &10etc. etc.$10"2 EI)=TA PA/-LIN [1E)PEI\ PA=N TO\ O(RIKW=S DIDASKO/MENON E)K GINWSKOME/NWN DIDA/SKETAI]1 PROS-ANAKRINO/NTWN H(MW=N TI/ POT' E)/STI KAI\ TO\ U(PA/RXON, A)NASTRE/YANTE/S FASIN <20O(/TI U(PA/RXON E)STI\N O(\ KINEI= KATALHPTIKH\N FANTASI/AN>20. @&10Alexander de anima p. 71, 10. Bruns.$10 TA\S DH\ A)LHQEI=S TW=N FAN-TASIW=N KAI\ SFODRA\S EI)W/QAMEN LE/GEIN KAI\ KATALHPTIKA/S, TW=| KATA/LHYIN EI)=NAI TH\N TAI=S TOIAU/TAIS FANTASI/AIS SUGKATA/QESIN, A)KATA/LHPTON DE\ FANTASI/AN KA-LOU=MEN TH/N TE YEUDH= KAI\ TW=N A)LHQW=N TA\S A)MUDRA/S. @&10Diocles Magnes apud Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 52.$10 AI)/SQHSIS DE\ LE/GETAI KATA\ TOU\S *STWI+KOU\S TO/ TE A)F' H(GEMONIKOU= PNEU=MA [KAI\] E)PI\ TA\S AI)SQH/SEIS DIH=KON KAI\ H( DI' AU)TW=N KATA/LHYIS KAI\ H( PERI\ TA\ AI)SQHTH/RIA KATASKEUH/, KAQ' H(/N TINES PHROI\ GI/NONTAI. KAI\ H( E)NE/RGEIA DE\ AI)/SQHSIS KALEI=TAI. @&10Ae%28t. Plac. IV 8, 12.$10 <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 PA=SAN AI)/SQHSIN EI)=NAI SUGKA-TA/QESIN KAI\ KATA/LHYIN. @&10Cicero Acad. Pr. II 108. Alterum est, quod negatis actionem &10ullius rei posse in eo esse, qui nullam rem adsensu suo comprobet. Pri-&10mum enim videri oportere, in quo sit etiam adsensus. <21Dicunt enim @1 &10Stoici sensus ipsos adsensus esse>21; quos quoniam adpetitio conse-&10quatur, actionem sequi; tolli autem omnia, si visa tollantur. &10@Porphyrius de anima apud Stobaeum ed. II 349, 23 W.$10 <20TW=N A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 TH\N AI)/SQHSIN OU)K E)N TH=| FANTASI/A| I(STA/NTWN MO/NON, A)LLA\ TH\N OU)SI/AN A)NARTW/NTWN A)PO\ TH=S SUGKATAQE/SEWS: AI)SQHTIKH=| GA\R FANTASI/A| SUGKATA/QESI/S E)STIN H( AI)/SQHSIS, TH=S SUGKATAQE/SEWS KAQ' O(RMH\N OU)/SHS. @&10Galenus in Hippocr. de medic. officina Vol. XVIII B p. 654 K.$10 KAI\ MH\N KAI\ TOIAU/THN E)CH/GHSIN E)/GRAYA/N TINES: OU) TO\ AU)TO\ SHMAI/NESQAI/ FASIN E)K TOU= FA/NAI "1KAI\ I)DEI=N KAI\ QIGEI=N KAI\ A)KOU=SAI E)/STI"2 TW=| "1KAI\ TH=| O)/YEI KAI\ TH=| A)KOH=| KAI\ TH=| A(FH=| E)/STIN AI)SQA/NESQAI"2. <20I)DEI=N ME\N GA\R E)/STI KAI\ QI-GEI=N KAI\ A)KOU/EIN MH\ KATALHPTIKW=S, AI)SQA/NESQAI DE\ OU)KE/TI MH\ KATALHPTIKW=S>20. E)/STI DE\ H( TOIAU/TH TH=S AI)SQH/SEWS E)CH/GHSIS <20TOU= *SIMI/OU TOU= *STWI+KOU=>20, DIO\ KAI\ [2O(]2 TOU= *KOI/+NTOU MAQHTH\S *)IFIKIANO\S AU)TH\N PROS-H/KATO, TH\N *STWI+KH\N A)SPAZO/MENOS FILOSOFI/AN. A)LL' O(\ LE/GOUSI/N E)STI TOIOU=-TON. TO\ ME\N E(/TERON ME/ROS TH=S R(H/SEWS PERI\ TOU= GE/NOUS MO/NOU DIDA/SKEI TW=N PRAGMA/TWN, E)C W(=N AI( SHMEIW/SEIS H(MW=N GI/GNONTAI: TO\ DE\ DEU/TERON PERI\ TOU= KAT' AU)TO\ DIHKRIBWME/NOU TE KAI\ PISTOU=, W(S EI) KAI\ OU(/TWS E)GE/GRAPTO: "1PROSH=KE POIEI=SQAI TA\S DIAGNW/SEIS A)PO\ TW=N O(MOI/WN TE KAI\ A)NOMOI/WN TOI=S KATA\ FU/-SIN E)N TW=| TOU= KA/MNONTOS SW/MATI FAINOME/NWN. TAU=TA DE/ E)STI TA\ AI)SQHTA\ KAI\ TOU/TWN OU)X O(/SA PAREI=DEN H)\ PARH/KOUSEN H)\ O(/LWS PARH/|SQETO KATA/ TINA TW=N AI)SQH/SEWN, A)LL' A(\ KALW=S KAI\ KATALHPTIKW=S TW=N AI)SQH/SEWN E(KA/STH| H)/|SQETO KAI\ TH=| GNW/MH|"2. SUGKEXRH=SQAI GA/R FHSI TH=| TOU= AI)SQE/SQAI FWNH=| TO\N *(IP-POKRA/THN KATA\ TH=S GNW/MHS. @&10Sextus adv. math. VIII 185.$10 <20OI( DE\ A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 KAI\ TOU= *PERIPA/TOU ME/SHN O(DO\N TE/MNONTES E)/NIA ME\N U(POKEI=SQAI TW=N AI)SQHTW=N E)/LECAN W(S A)LHQH=, E)/NIA DE\ MH\ U(PA/RXEIN, YEUDOME/NHS PERI\ AU)TW=N TH=S AI)SQH/SEWS. @&10Cicero Acad. Pr. II 101. Neque nos [1scil. Academici]1 contra &10sensus aliter dicimus ac <21Stoici>21, qui multa falsa esse dicunt longeque &10aliter se habere ac sensibus videantur. &10@Ae%28t. Plac. IV 9, 4.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 TA\S ME\N AI)SQH/SEIS A)LHQEI=S, TW=N DE\ FANTASIW=N TA\S ME\N A)LHQEI=S, TA\S DE\ YEUDEI=S. @&10Galenus de dignoscendis pulsibus I 5. Vol. VIII p. 793.$10 PRW=TA GA/R E)STIN AI)SQHTA\ E)N TOI=S H(METE/ROIS SW/MASI TA\ PAQH/MATA, DEU/TERA DE\ TA\ TOU/TWN POIHTIKA\ E)KTO\S U(POKEI/MENA. @&10Sextus adv. math. IX 352.$10 TOIOU/TWN DE\ H)PORHME/NWN KATA\ TO\N TO/PON EI)W/QASIN <20OI( DOGMATIKOI/>20_LE/GEIN O(/TI TO\ ME\N E)KTO\S U(POKEI/MENON KAI\ AI)SQHTO\N OU)/TE O(/LON E)STI\N OU)/TE ME/ROS, H(MEI=S DE/ E)SMEN OI( E)KEI/NOU TO/ TE O(/LON KAI\ TO\ ME/ROS E)PIKATHGOROU=NTES. H)=N GA\R TO\ O(/LON TW=N PRO/S TI: W(S GA\R PRO\S TA\ ME/RH E)NOEI=TO TO\ O(/LON: KAI\ PA/LIN TA\ ME/RH TW=N PRO/S TI: W(S GA\R PRO\S TO\ O(/LON NOEI=TAI TA\ ME/RH: TA\ DE\ PRO/S TI E)N SUMMNHMONEU/SEI E)STI\N H(METE/RA|, H( DE\ H(METE/RA SUMMNHMO/NEUSI/S E)STIN E)N H(MI=N. TO\ OU)=N O(/LON KAI\ TO\ ME/ROS E)STI\N E)N H(MI=N. <20TO\ DE\ E)KTO\S U(POKEI/MENON AI)SQHTO\N OU)/TE O(/LON E)STI\N OU)/TE ME/ROS>20, A)LLA\ PRA=GMA OU(= H(MEI=S E)PIKATHGOROU=MEN TH\N H(MW=N AU)TW=N SUMMNH-MO/NEUSIN. @1 @&Ae%28ti Plac. IV 9, 13$. <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 TO\ ME\N GENIKO\N H(DU\ NOH-TO/N, TO\ DE\ EI)DIKO\N KAI\ PROSPI=PTON H)/DH AI)SQHTO/N. @&10Ae%28tii Plac. IV 11.$10 *PW=S GI/NETAI H( AI)/SQHSIS KAI\ H( E)/NNOIA KAI\ O( KATA\ E)NDIA/QESIN LO/GOS. &10Gal. 92.$10 @<20*OI( *STWI+KOI/>20 FASIN: O(/TAN GENNHQH=| O( A)/NQRWPOS, E)/XEI TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N ME/ROS TH=S YUXH=S W(/SPER XA/RTHN EU)/ERGON EI)S A)POGRAFH/N: EI)S TOU=TO MI/AN E(KA/-STHN <20TW=N E)NNOIW=N>20 E)NAPOGRA/FETAI. _*PRW=TOS DE\ [O(] TH=S A)NAGRAFH=S TRO/-POS O( DIA\ TW=N AI)SQH/SEWN. AI)SQANO/MENOI GA/R TINOS OI(=ON LEUKOU=, A)PELQO/N-TOS AU)TOU= MNH/MHN E)/XOUSIN: O(/TAN DE\ O(MOEIDEI=S POLLAI\ MNH=MAI GE/NWNTAI, TO/TE FAME\N E)/XEIN <20E)MPEIRI/AN>20: E)MPEIRI/A GA/R E)STI TO\ TW=N O(MOEIDW=N FANTASIW=N PLH=QOS. _<20*TW=N DE\ E)NNOIW=N>20 AI( ME\N FUSIKW=S GI/NONTAI KATA\ TOU\S EI)RHME/-NOUS TRO/POUS KAI\ A)NEPITEXNH/TWS, AI( DE\ H)/DH DI' H(METE/RAS DIDASKALI/AS KAI\ E)PIMELEI/AS: AU(=TAI ME\N OU)=N E)/NNOIAI KALOU=NTAI MO/NON, E)KEI=NAI DE\ KAI\ <20PRO-LH/YEIS>20. _<20*(O DE\ LO/GOS, KAQ' O(\N PROSAGOREUO/MEQA LOGIKOI\ E)K TW=N PROLH/YEWN SUMPLHROU=SQAI LE/GETAI>20 KATA\ TH\N PRW/THN E(BDOMA/DA. E)/STI D' E)NNO/HMA FA/NTASMA DIANOI/AS LOGIKOU= ZW/|OU: TO\ GA\R FA/NTASMA E)PEIDA\N LO-GIKH=| PROSPI/PTH| YUXH=|, TO/TE E)NNO/HMA KALEI=TAI, EI)LHFO\S TOU)/NOMA PARA\ TOU= NOU=. _*DIO/PER TOI=S A)LO/GOIS ZW/|OIS O(/SA PROSPI/PTEI, FANTA/SMATA MO/NON E)STI/N: O(/SA DE\ H(MI=N KAI\ TOI=S QEOI=S, TAU=TA KAI\ FANTA/SMATA KATA\ GE/NOS KAI\ E)NNOH/-MATA KAT' EI)=DOS: W(/SPER TA\ DHNA/RIA KAI\ OI( STATH=RES AU)TA\ ME\N KAQ' AU(TA\ U(PA/RXEI DHNA/RIA [2KAI\]2 STATH=RES: E)A\N DE\ EI)S PLOI/WN DOQH=| MI/SQWSIN, THNI-KAU=TA PRO\S TW=| DHNA/RIA EI)=NAI KAI\ NAU=LA LE/GETAI. @&10Diocles Magnes apud Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 52.$10 H( <20DE\ KATA/LHYIS GI/-NETAI>20 KAT' AU)TOU\S AI)SQH/SEI ME\N LEUKW=N KAI\ MELA/NWN KAI\ TRAXE/WN KAI\ LEI/WN, <20LO/GW| DE\ TW=N DI' A)PODEI/CEWS SUNAGOME/NWN>20, W(/SPER TOU= QEOU\S EI)=NAI KAI\ PRONOEI=N TOU/TOUS. @&10Sextus adv. math. VIII 409.$10 OI( DE\ [1&10scil. Stoici$10]1 KAI\ DI' U(PODEIG-MA/TWN PEIRW=NTAI TO\ A)CIOU/MENON PARAMUQEI=SQAI [1&10scil.$10 O(/TI TA\ A)SW/MATA OU) POIEI= TI OU)DE\ FANTASIOI= H(MA=S, A)LL' H(MEI=S E)SMEN OI( E)P' E)KEI/NOIS FANTASIOU/-MENOI &10cf. %14 406$10]1. W(/SPER GA/R, FASI/N, O( PAIDOTRI/BHS KAI\ O( O(PLOMA/XOS E)/SQ' O(/TE ME\N LABO/MENOS TW=N XEIRW=N TOU= PAIDO\S R(UQMI/ZEI KAI\ DIDA/SKEI TINA\S KI-NEI=SQAI KINH/SEIS, E)/SQ' O(/TE DE\ A)/PWQEN E(STW\S KAI/ PWS KINOU/MENOS E)N R(UQMW=| PARE/XEI E(AUTO\N E)KEI/NW| PRO\S MI/MHSIN, OU(/TW KAI\ TW=N FANTASTW=N E)/NIA ME\N OI(ONEI\ YAU/ONTA KAI\ QIGGA/NONTA TOU= H(GEMONIKOU= POIEI=TAI TH\N E)N TOU/TW| TU/- @1PWSIN, O(POI=O/N E)STI TO\ LEUKO\N KAI\ ME/LAN KAI\ KOINW=S TO\ SW=MA, E)/NIA DE\ TOI-AU/THN E)/XEI FU/SIN, TOU= H(GEMONIKOU= E)P' AU)TOI=S FANTASIOUME/NOU KAI\ OU)X U(P' AU)TW=N, O(POI=A/ E)STI TA\ A)SW/MATA LEKTA/. @&10Philo de provid. II %14 58 [1p. 85 Aucher]1. quid tamen, quaeso, &10sit unquam species, nisi universalis alicuius comprehensio? Et intellectui &10quid occurrat universale aliud, quod deus prius non fecerit, menti inserens &10fecunditatem, quae optime est apta ad admovendum sibi singula, occur-&10rentibus signis vel antea conceptis pro naturis inquirendis. &10@Diocles Magnes apud. Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 52.$10 TW=N_NOOUME/NWN TA\ ME\N KATA\ PERI/PTWSIN E)NOH/QH, TA\ DE\ KAQ' O(MOIO/THTA, TA\ DE\ KAT' A)NALOGI/AN, TA\ DE\ KATA\ META/QESIN, TA\ DE\ KATA\ SU/NQESIN, TA\ DE\ KAT' E)NANTI/WSIN, <20KATA\ PERI/PTWSIN>20 ME\N OU)=N E)NOH/QH TA\ AI)SQHTA/, <20KAQ' O(MOIO/THTA>20 DE\ [TA\] A)PO/ TINOS PARAKEIME/NOU, W(S *SWKRA/THS A)PO\ TH=S EI)KO/NOS, <20KAT' A)NALOGI/AN>20 DE\ AU)CHTIKW=S ME/N, W(S O( *TITUO\S KAI\ *KU/KLWY, MEIWTIKW=S DE/, W(S O( *PUGMAI=OS. KAI\ TO\ KE/NTRON DE\ TH=S GH=S KAT' A)NALOGI/AN E)NOH/QH A)PO\ TW=N MIKROTE/RWN SFAI-RW=N. <20KATA\ META/QESIN>20 DE\ OI(=ON O)FQALMOI\ E)PI\ TOU= STH/QOUS: <20KATA\ SU/N-QESIN>20 DE\ E)NOH/QH *(IPPOKE/NTAUROS: KAI\ KAT' <20E)NANTI/WSIN>20 QA/NATOS. @NOEI=TAI DE\ KAI\ <20KATA\ META/BASI/N>20 TINA, W(S TA\ LEKTA\ KAI\ O( TO/POS. <20FU-SIKW=S>20 DE\ NOEI=TAI DI/KAIO/N TI KAI\ A)GAQO/N: KAI\ <20KATA\ STE/RHSIN>20, OI(=ON A)/XEIR. @&10Sextus adv. math. VIII 56.$10 PA=SA GA\R NO/HSIS A)PO\ AI)SQH/SEWS GI/-NETAI H)\ OU) XWRI\S AI)SQH/SEWS, KAI\ H)\ <20A)PO\ PERIPTW/SEWS H)\ OU)K A)/NEU PE-RIPTW/SEWS>20. O(/QEN OU)DE\ TA\S LEGOME/NAS YEUDEI=S FANTASI/AS, OI(=ON TA\S KAQ' U(/PNOUS H)\ TA\S KATA\ MANI/AN, EU(RH/SOMEN A)PHRTHME/NAS TW=N DIA\ TH=S AI)SQH/SEWS KATA\ PERI/PTWSIN H(MI=N E)GNWSME/NWN. _KAI\ KAQO/LOU <20OU)DE/N E)STIN EU(REI=N KAT' E)PI/NOIAN O(\ MH\ E)/XEI TIS AU(TW=| KATA\ PERI/PTWSIN E)GNWSME/NON>20. TOU=TO GA\R H)\ KAQ' O(MOIO/THTA TW=N E)N PERIPTW/SEI PEFHNO/TWN LHFQH/SETAI H)\ KATA\ PARAU/CHSIN H)\ KATA\ MEI/WSIN H)\ KAT' E)PISU/NQESIN [1&10sequuntur exempla]1 &10cf. id. IX 393_395. &10@Galenus defin. medicae 126 Vol. XIX p. 381 K.$10 E)PI/NOIA/ E)STIN E)NA-POKEIME/NH NO/HSIS: NO/HSIS DE\ LOGIKH\ FANTASI/A. @&10Sextus adv. math. VII 151.$10 TRI/A GA\R EI)=NAI/ FASIN E)KEI=NOI [1&10Stoici &10ab Arcesilao impugnati i. e. Zeno et Cleanthes$10]1 TA\ SUZUGOU=NTA A)LLH/LOIS, E)PISTH/MHN KAI\ DO/CAN KAI\ TH\N E)N MEQORI/A| TOU/TWN TETAGME/NHN KATA/LHYIN, W(=N E)PISTH/MHN ME\N EI)=NAI TH\N A)SFALH= KAI\ BEBAI/AN KAI\ A)META/QETON U(PO\ LO/GOU KA-TA/LHYIN, DO/CAN DE\ TH\N A)SQENH= KAI\ YEUDH= SUGKATA/QESIN, KATA/LHYIN DE\ TH\N METACU\ TOU/TWN, H(/TIS E)STI\ KATALHPTIKH=S FANTASI/AS SUGKATA/QESIS: KATALHPTIKH\ DE\ FANTASI/A KATA\ TOU/TOUS E)TU/GXANEN H( A)LHQH\S KAI\ TOIAU/TH OI(/A OU)K A)\N GE/NOITO YEUDH/S. W(=N <20TH\N ME\N E)PISTH/MHN E)N MO/NOIS U(FI/STASQAI LE/GOUSI TOI=S @1 SOFOI=S, TH\N DE\ DO/CAN E)N MO/NOIS TOI=S FAU/LOIS, TH\N DE\ KATA/LHYIN KOINH\N A)MFOTE/RWN EI)=NAI KAI\ TAU/THN KRITH/RION A)LHQEI/AS KAQE-STA/NAI>20. @&10Sextus adv. math. VIII 396.$10 E)PEI\ KAI\ <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 MA/LISTA DO-KOU=SIN E)CHKRIBWKE/NAI TOU\S A)PODEIKTIKOU\S TRO/POUS, FE/RE KAI\ PRO\S TOU/TOUS O)LI/GA DIECE/LQWMEN. _&10`397.$10 E)/STI ME\N OU)=N H( <20KATA/LHYIS>20, W(S E)/STI PAR' AU)TW=N A)KOU/EIN, <20KATALHPTIKH=S FANTASI/AS SUGKATA/QESIS>20, H(/TIS DIPLOU=N E)/OIKEN EI)=NAI PRA=GMA, KAI\ TO\ ME/N TI E)/XEIN A)KOU/SION, TO\ DE\ E(KOU/SION KAI\ E)PI\ TH=| H(METE/RA| KRI/SEI KEI/MENON. TO\ ME\N GA\R FANTASIWQH=NAI A)BOU/LHTON H)=N: KAI\ OU)K E)PI\ TW=| PA/SXONTI E)/KEITO A)LL' E)PI\ TW=| FANTASIOU=NTI TO\ OU(TWSI\ DIATEQH=NAI, OI(=ON LEUKANTIKW=S LEUKOU= U(POPESO/NTOS XRW/MATOS H)\ GLUKANTIKW=S GLUKE/OS TH=| GEU/SEI PROSAXQE/NTOS: TO\ DE\ SUGKATAQE/SQAI TOU/TW| TW=| KINH/MATI E)/KEITO E)PI\ TW=| PARADEXOME/NW| TH\N FANTASI/AN. @&10Cicero Acad. Pr. II 119. Quamcumque vero sententiam proba-&10verit [1scil. sapiens]1, eam sic animo comprensam habebit ut ea, quae sen-&10sibus, nec magis adprobabit nunc lucere, quam, quoniam <21Stoicus>21 est, &10hunc mundum esse sapientem, habere mentem, quae et se et ipsum fa-&10bricata sit et omnia moderetur, moveat, regat. Erit ei persuasum etiam &10solem, lunam, stellas omnes, terram, mare deos essse, quod quaedam ani-&10malis intelligentia per omnia ea permanet et transeat; fore tamen ali-&10quando, ut omnis hic mundus ardore deflagret. &10@Galenus defin. medicae 7. Vol. XIX p. 350.$10 E)PISTH/MH E)STI\ KATA/LHYIS A)SFALH\S KAI\ A)META/PTWTOS U(PO\ LO/GOU. DUNATO\N DE\ KAI\ OU(/TWS O(RI/SASQAI: E)PISTH/MH E)STI\N E(/CIS A)META/PTWTOS E)K FANTASIW=N DO/CAN A)ME/MPTWS U(PO\ LO/GOU PAREXOME/NH,&10 8.$10 TE/XNH E)STI\ SU/STHMA E)K KATALH/YEWN SUGGEGUMNASME/NWN PRO/S TI TE/LOS EU)/XRHSTON TW=N E)N TW=| BI/W|. H)\ OU(/TWS: TE/XNH E)STI\ SU/STHMA E)K KATA-LH/YEWN SUGGEGUMNASME/NON E)F' E(\N TE/LOS TH\N A)NAFORA\N E)XO/NTWN. @&10Scholia in Dionys. Thrac. p. 649 Bekker Anecd. Gr. II.$10 *OI( DE\ <20*STWI+KOI\>20 LE/GOUSI: TE/XNH E)STI\ SU/STHMA E)K KATALH/YEWN E)MPEIRI/A| SUGGEGUM-NASME/NWN PRO/S TI TE/LOS EU)/XRHSTON TW=N E)N TW=| BI/W|. @&10Philo de congressu erud. gratia %14 141 Vol. III p. 101, 5 Wendl.$10 <20*TE/XNHS>20 ME\N GA\R O(/ROS OU(=TOS: SU/STHMA E)K KATALH/YEWN SUGGEGUMNASME/NWN, PRO/S TI TE/LOS EU)/XRHSTON [1TOU= EU)XRH/STOU DIA\ TA\S KAKOTEXNI/AS U(GIW=S PROSTI-QEME/NOU]1. <20*)EPISTH/MHS>20 DE/: KATA/LHYIS A)SFALH\S KAI\ BE/BAIOS, A)META/PTWTOS U(PO\ LO/GOU. MOUSIKH\N ME\N OU)=N KAI\ GRAMMATIKH\N KAI\ TA\S SUGGENEI=S KALOU=MEN TE/XNAS__FILOSOFI/AN DE\ KAI\ TA\S A)/LLAS A)RETA\S E)PISTH/MAS KAI\ TOU\S E)/XON-TAS AU)TA\S E)PISTH/MONAS. FRO/NIMOI GA/R EI)SI KAI\ SW/FRONES KAI\ FILO/SOFOI, W(=N OU)DE\ EI(=S E)N TOI=S TH=S DIAPEPONHME/NHS E)PISTH/MHS SFA/LLETAI DO/GMASI, KAQA/PER OI( PROEIRHME/NOI E)N TOI=S TW=N ME/SWN TEXNW=N QEWRH/MASIN. @&10Sextus Pyrrh. Hypot. III 188.$10 PA/LIN <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 PERI\ YUXH\N A)GAQA/ FASIN EI)=NAI TE/XNAS TINA\S TA\S A)RETA/S: TE/XNHN DE\ EI)=NAI/ FASI SU/STHMA E)K KATALH/YEWN SUGGEGUMNASME/NWN, TA\S DE\ KATALH/YEIS GI/GNESQAI PERI\ TO\ H(GE-MONIKO/N. *PW=S OU)=N E)N TW=| H(GEMONIKW=|, PNEU/MATI KAT' AU)TOU\S U(PA/RXONTI, E)NA-PO/QESIS GI/GNETAI KATALH/YEWN KAI\ A)QROISMO\S TOSOU/TWN W(S GENE/SQAI TE/XNHN, @1 OU)X OI(=O/N TE E)NNOH=SAI, TH=S E)PIGIGNOME/NHS TUPW/SEWS A)EI\ TH\N PRO\ AU)TH=S A)PA-LEIYOU/SHS, E)PEI\ XUTO/N TE/ E)STI TO\ PNEU=MA KAI\ E)C O(/LOU KINEI=SQAI LE/GETAI KAQ' E(KA/STHN TU/PWSIN. @&10Sextus adv. math. XI 182.$10 TE/XNH GA/R E)STI SU/STHMA E)K KATALH/YEWN, KAI\ KATA/LHYI/S E)STI KATALHPTIKH=S FANTASI/AS SUGKATA/QESIS. @&10ibid. 183.$10 PRO\S TOU/TOIS H( KATALHPTIKH\ FANTASI/A KRI/NETAI KATA\ <20TOU\S *STWI+KOU/S>20, O(/TI KATALHPTIKH/ E)STI TW=| A)PO\ U(PA/RXONTOS GENE/SQAI KAI\ KAT' AU)TO\ TO\ U(PA/RXON E)NAPOMEMAGME/NWS KAI\ E)NAPESFRAGISME/NWS: TO/ Q' U(PA/RXON DOKI-MA/ZETAI, O(/TI U(PA/RXON E)STI/N, E)K TOU= KATALHPTIKH\N KINEI=N FANTASI/AN. @&10Ps. Galeni prognostica ex mathem. scientia 1 Vol. XIX p. 529 K.$10 *PERI\ ME\N <20TOU= U(PARKTH\N EI)=NAI TH\N MAQHMATIKH\N E)PISTH/MHN>20 H)/RKEI KAI\ H( <20TW=N *STWI+KW=N>20 FILOSO/FWN, A)NDRW=N KAI\ LO/GOUS DIEKPEPONHME/NWN KAI\ TO\N BI/ON O(POI=O/S E)STI PARASTHSA/NTWN DO/CA. @&10Philo de congressu erud. gratia %14 146 Vol. III p. 102, 15 Wendl.$10 *KAI/TOIG' OU)DE\ TOU=TO/ TIS A)GNOEI=, O(/TI PA/SAIS TAI=S KATA\ ME/ROS [1&10scil.$10 E)PISTH/MAIS]1 TA\S A)RXA\S KAI\ TA\ SPE/RMATA, E)C W(=N A)NABLASTEI=N E)/DOCE TA\ QEWRH/MATA, FILO-SOFI/A DEDW/RHTAI. *)ISO/PLEURA GA\R KAI\ SKALHNA/, KU/KLOUS TE KAI\ POLUGW/NIA KAI\ TA\ A)/LLA SXH/MATA <20GEWMETRI/A>20 PROSECEU=RE: SHMEI/OU DE\ KAI\ GRAMMH=S KAI\ E)PIFANEI/AS KAI\ STEREOU= FU/SIN, A(\ DH\ R(I/ZAI KAI\ QEME/LIOI TW=N LEXQE/NTWN EI)SI/N, OU)KE/TI GEWMETRI/A. *PO/QEN GA\R AU)TH=| LE/GEIN O(RIZOME/NH|, O(/TI SHMEI=ON ME/N E)STIN, OU(= ME/ROS OU)DE/N, GRAMMH\ DE\ MH=KOS A)PLATE/S, E)PIFA/NEIA DE\ O(\ MH=KOS KAI\ PLA/-TOS MO/NON E)/XEI, STEREO\N DE\ O(\ TA\S TREI=S E)/XEI DIASTA/SEIS, MH=KOS, PLA/TOS, BA/QOS; *TAU=TA GA\R A)NA/KEITAI FILOSOFI/A|, KAI\ H( PERI\ O(/RWN PRAGMATEI/A PA=SA TW=| FI-LOSO/FW|. _*TO/ GE MH\N GRA/FEIN KAI\ A)NAGIGNW/SKEIN <20GRAMMATIKH=S>20 TH=S A)TE-LESTE/RAS E)PA/GGELMA, H(\N PARATRE/PONTE/S TINES GRAMMATISTIKH\N KALOU=SIN: TH=S DE\ TELEIOTE/RAS A)NA/PTUCIS TW=N PARA\ POIHTAI=S TE KAI\ SUGGRAFEU=SIN. *)EPEIDA\N OU)=N PERI\ TW=N TOU= LO/GOU DIECE/RXWNTAI MERW=N, TO/TE OU) TA\ FILOSOFI/AS EU(RH/-MATA PARASPW=NTAI/ TE KAI\ PARERGOLABOU=SI; TAU/THS GA\R I)/DION E)CETA/ZEIN, TI/ ㈐SU/NDESMOS, TI/ O)/NOMA, TI/ R(H=MA, TI/ KOINO\N O)/NOMA, TI/ I)/DION, TI/ E)LLIPE\S E)N LO/GW|, TI/ PLH=RES, TI/ A)POFANTO/N, TI/ E)RW/THMA, TI/ PU/SMA, TI/ PERIEKTIKO/N, TI/ EU)KTIKO/N, TI/ A)RATIKO/N. TA\S GA\R PERI\ AU)TOTELW=N KAI\ A)CIWMA/TWN KAI\ KATHGORHMA/TWN PRAGMATEI/AS H(/D' E)STI\N H( SUNQEI=SA: H(MI/FWNON DE\ H)\ FWNH=EN H)\ PANTELW=S A)/FWNON STOIXEI=ON I)DEI=N KAI\ PW=S E(/KASTON TOU/TWN EI)/WQE LE/GESQAI, KAI\ PA=SA H( PERI\ FWNH=S KAI\ STOIXEI/WN KAI\ TW=N TOU= LO/GOU MERW=N I)DE/A, OU) FILOSOFI/A| PEPO/NHTAI KAI\ KATH/NUSTAI; @&Plutarchus quomodo adol. poe%28t. aud. debeat p. 34b.$ *TH\N D' E)PI\ PLE/ON TW=N LEGOME/NWN XRH=SIN U(PE/DEICEN O)RQW=S O( <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20, O(/TI DEI= META/GEIN KAI\ DIABIBA/ZEIN E)PI\ TA\ O(MOEIDH= TO\ XRH/SIMON. O(/ TE GA\R *(HSIO/DOS EI)PW/N [1&Op. et D. 348$]1 @"3OU)D' A)\N BOU=S A)PO/LOIT', EI) MH\ GEI/TWN KAKO\S EI)/H"3 KAI\ PERI\ KUNO\S TAU)TO\ KAI\ PERI\ O)/NOU LE/GEI KAI\ PERI\ PA/NTWN O(MOI/WS TW=N A)POLE/SQAI DUNAME/NWN. *KAI\ PA/LIN TOU= *EU)RIPI/DOU LE/GONTOS [1&inc. @1 &fab. fr. 950 N$]1 @"3TI/S D' E)STI\ DOU=LOS TOU= QANEI=N A)/FRONTIS W)/N"3; U(PAKOUSTE/ON O(/TI KAI\ PERI\ PO/NOU KAI\ NO/SOU TAU)TO\N EI)/RHKEN. @&Plutarchus quomodo adol. poe%28t. aud. debeat p. 31E.$ DEI= DE\ MHDE\ TW=N O)NOMA/TWN A)MELW=S A)KOU/EIN, A)LLA\ TH\N ME\N *KLEA/NQOUS PAIDIA\N PARAITEI=SQAI: KATEIRWNEU/ETAI GA\R E)/STIN O(/TE PROSPOIOU/MENOS E)CHGEI=SQAI TO\ @"3*ZEU= PA/TER *)/IDHQEN MEDE/WN"3 [1*G& 320$]1 KAI\ TO\ @"3*ZEU= A)/NA *DWDWNAI=E"3 [1*P& 233$]1 KELEU/WN A)NAGIGNW/SKEIN U(F' E(/N, W(S TO\N E)K TH=S GH=S A)NAQUMIW/MENON A)E/RA DIA\ TH\N A)NA/DOSIN A)NADWDWNAI=ON O)/NTA. KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 DE\ POLLAXOU= GLI/SXROS E)STI/N, OU) PAI/ZWN A)LL' EU(RHSILOGW=N A)PIQA/NWS, KAI\ PARABIAZO/MENOS "3EU)RUO/PA *KRONI/DHN"3 EI)=NAI TO\N DEINO\N E)N TW=| DIALE/GESQAI KAI\ DIABEBHKO/TA TH=| DUNA/MEI TOU= LO/GOU. @&10Clemens Al. Strom. VI 14 p. 801 Pott.$10 E)/STIN DE\ H( ME\N <20ZH/THSIS>20 O(RMH\ E)PI\ TO\ KATALABEI=N DIA/ TINWN SHMEI/WN A)NEURI/SKOUSA TO\ U(POKEI/MENON: H( <20EU(/RESIS>20 DE\ PE/RAS KAI\ A)NA/PAUSIS ZHTH/SEWS E)N KATALH/YEI GENOME/NHS. @&10Cicero Acad. Pr. II 26. &10Quid quod, si ista vera sunt, ratio omnis tollitur, quasi quae-&10dam lux lumenque vitae! __nam <21quaerendi>21 initium ratio attulit, quae &10perfecit virtutem, cum esset ipsa ratio confirmata <21quaerendo. quaestio>21 &10autem est adpetitio cognitionis, <21quaestionisque finis inventio>21. at &10nemo invenit falsa, nec ea quae incerta permanent, inventa esse possunt, &10sed cum ea, quae quasi involuta fuerunt, aperta sunt, tum inventa dicun-&10tur. sic et <21initium quaerendi et exitus>21 percipiendi et comprendendi &10[2facultate]2 tenetur. &10@Plutarchus apud Olympiodorum in Plat. Phaedon. p. 125, 7 ed. &10Finckh.$10 *(/OTI A)/PORON O)/NTWS <20EI) OI(=O/NTE ZHTEI=N KAI\ EU(RI/SKEIN>20, W(S E)N *ME/-NWNI [1&10p. 80 E$10]1 PROBE/BLHTAI: OU)/TE GA\R A(\ I)/SMEN: MA/TAION GA/R: OU)/TE A(\ MH\ I)/SMEN: KA)\N GA\R PERIPE/SWMEN AU)TOI=S, A)GNOOU=MEN, W(S TOI=S TUXOU=SIN. __ <20OI( DE\ A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S TA\S FUSIKA\S E)NNOI/AS>20 AI)TIW=NTAI: EI) ME\N DH\ DU-NA/MEI, TO\ AU)TO\ E)ROU=MEN: EI) DE\ E)NERGEI/A|, DIA\ TI/ ZHTOU=MEN A(\ I)/SMEN; EI) DE\ A)PO\ TOU/TWN A)/LLA A)GNOOU/MENA, PW=S A(/PER OU)K I)/SMEN. @1 @&Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 54.$ KRITH/RION DE\ TH=S A)LHQEI/AS FASI\ TUGXA/NEIN TH\N KATALHPTIKH\N FANTASI/AN, TOUTE/STI TH\N A)PO\ U(PA/RXONTOS, KAQA/ FHSI <20*XRU/SIPPOS E)N TH=| B# TW=N *FUSIKW=N>20 KAI\ *)ANTI/PATROS KAI\ *)APOLLO/DWROS. O( ME\N GA\R *BO/HQOS KRITH/RIA PLEI/ONA A)POLEI/PEI, NOU=N KAI\ AI)/SQHSIN KAI\ O)/RECIN KAI\ E)PISTH/MHN: O( DE\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 DIAFERO/-MENOS PRO\S AU(TO\N <20E)N TW=| PRW/TW| PERI\ LO/GOU>20 KRITHRIA/ FHSIN EI)=NAI AI)/SQHSIN KAI\ PRO/LHYIN. @&10Augustinus de civ. dei VIII 7. qui posuerunt iudicium veritatis &10in sensibus corporis eorumque__regulis__omnia quae discuntur me-&10tienda esse censuerunt, ut Epicurei et quicumque alii tales, ut etiam ipsi &10<21Stoici, qui cum vehementer amaverint sollertiam disputandi, &10quam dialecticam nominant, a corporis sensibus eam ducendam &10putarunt, hinc asseverantes animum concipere notiones, quas &10appellant>21$10 <20E)NNOI/AS>20,&10 earum <21rerum scilicet quas definiendo expli-&10cant; hinc propagari atque conecti totam discendi docendique &10rationem>21. &10@Sextus adv. math. VII 35.$10 PA/RESTI ME/NTOI KAI\ TO\ LOGIKO\N TOU=TO [1&10scil.$10 KRITH/RION]1 U(PODIAIREI=SQAI, LE/GONTAS TO\ ME/N TI EI)=NAI <20KRITH/RION>20 W(S U(F' OU(=, TO\ DE\ W(S DI' OU(=, TO\ DE\ W(S PROSBOLH\ KAI\ SXE/SIS. U(F' OU(= ME\N W(S A)/N-QRWPOS, DI' <20OU(=>20 DE\ W(S AI)/SQHSIS, TO\ DE\ TRI/TON W(S H( <20PROSBOLH\ TH=S FAN-TASI/AS>20.&10 37.$10 KAI\ E)/OIKE TW=| ME\N ZUGOSTA/TH| H)\ TE/KTONI O( A)/NQRWPOS, U(F' OU(= GI/NETAI H( KRI/SIS, TW=| DE\ ZUGW=| KAI\ KANO/NI H( AI)/SQHSIS KAI\ H( DIA/NOIA, DI' H(=S GI/NETAI TA\ TH=S KRI/SEWS, TH=| DE\ SXE/SEI TW=N PROEIRHME/NWN O)RGA/NWN H( PROS-BOLH\ TH=S FANTASI/AS, KAQ' H(\N O( A)/NQRWPOS E)PIBA/LLETAI KRI/NEIN. @&10Origenes contra Celsum VII 37 Vol. II p. 187, 22 Ko+. [1p. 720 Del.]1 &10dicit Celsum$10 DOGMATI/ZEIN PARAPLHSI/WS TOI=S A)NAIROU=SI NOHTA\S OU)SI/AS <20*STWI+-KOI=S PERI\ TOU= AI)SQH/SESIN KATALAMBA/NESQAI TA\ KATALAMBANO/MENA KAI\ PA=SAN KATA/LHYIN H)RTH=SQAI TW=N AI)SQH/SEWN>20. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 10 p. 1036c.$ *)EPI\ DE\ <20TOI=S KATA\ *SUNHQEI/AS>20 E)KDOQEI=SIN OU(/TW KOMW=SIN KAI\ MEGALHGOROU=SIN, W(/STE TOU\S PA/NTWN O(MOU= TW=N *)AKADHMAI+KW=N LO/GOUS EI)S TAU)TO\ SUMFO-RHQE/NTAS, OU)K A)CI/OUS EI)=NAI PARABALEI=N OI(=S *XRU/SIPPOS E)/GRAYEN EI)S DIABOLH\N TW=N AI)SQH/SEWN__E)KEI=NO D' A)LHQE/S, O(/TI <20BOULHQEI\S AU)=QIS SUNEIPEI=N TH=| *SUNHQEI/A|>20 KAI\ TAI=S AI)SQH/SESIN, E)NDEE/STEROS GE/GONEN E(AUTOU=, KAI\ TO\ SU/NTAGMA TOU= SUNTA/GMATOS MALAKW/TERON. _ _&p. 1036e.$ *(HDE/WS A)\N OU)=N PUQOI/MHN TW=N *STWI+KW=N, EI) TA\ *MEGARIKA\ @1 E)RWTH/MATA DUNAMIKW/TERA NOMI/ZOUSIN EI)=NAI TW=N U(PO\ *XRUSI/PPOU <20KATA\ TH=S *SUNHQEI/AS E)N E(\C BIBLI/OIS>20 GEGRAMME/NWN; &p. 1037a.$ AU)TO\S DE\ TOSAU=TA BIBLI/A GRA/FWN <20KATA\ TH=S *SUNHQEI/AS>20, OI(=S, EI)/TI A)NEU=RES, PROSE/QHKAS, U(PERBALE/SQAI FILOTIMOU/MENOS TO\N *)ARKESI/LAON__ OU)DE\ GA\R YILOI=S XRH=TAI TOI=S KATA\ TH=S SUNHQEI/AS E)PIXEIRH/MASI, A)LL' W(/SPER E)N DI/KH| META\ PA/QOUS TINO\S SUNEPIPA/SXWN, MWROLOGEI=N TE POL-LA/KIS LE/GEI KAI\ KENOKOPEI=N. @&Cicero Acad. Pr. II 87.&3 res iam universas profundam, de qui-&3bus volumina impleta sunt non a nostris solum, sed etiam a <21Chry-&3sippo>21__de quo queri solent Stoici, dum studiose omnia conquisierit &3contra sensus et perspicuitatem contraque omnem consuetudinem contra-&3que rationem, ipsum sibi respondentem inferiorem fuisse%10 itaque ab eo &3armatum esse Carneadem. @&idem Acad. Pr. II 75.&3 Atqui habebam molestos vobis, sed minutos, &3Stilponem, Diodorum, Alexinum, quorum sunt contorta et aculeata quae-&3dam$ SOFI/SMATA_&3sic enim appellantur fallaces conclusiunculae. Sed &3quid eos colligam, cum habeam <21Chrysippum>21, qui fulcire putatur por-&3ticum Stoicorum? Quam multa ille contra sensus, quam multa contra &3omnia, quae in consuetudine probantur. At dissolvit idem. Mihi quidem &3non videtur%10 sed dissolverit sane. Certe tam multa non collegisset, quae &3nos fallerent probabilitate magna, nisi videret iis resisti non facile posse. @&10Cicero Acad. Pr. II 67. Sed illud primum, sapientem, si assen-&10surus esset, etiam opinaturum, falsum esse et <21Stoici>21 dicunt et eorum ad-&10stipulator Antiochus%10 <21posse enim eum falsa a veris et quae non &10possint percipi ab iis quae possint distinguere>21. @&10Cicero Acad. Pr. II 26. &10Argumenti conclusio, quae est Graece$10 A)PO/DEICIS,&10 ita definitur%10 &10<21ratio, quae ex rebus perceptis ad id, quod non percipiebatur, &10adducit>21. 27. quodsi omnia visa eius modi essent, qualia isti dicunt, ut &10ea vel falsa esse possent, neque ea posset ulla ratio discernere, quo modo &10quemquam aut conclusisse aliquid aut invenisse diceremus aut quae esset &10conclusi argumenti fides? &10@Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 36 p. 1077c.$10 A)KOU=SAI TOI/NUN E)/STIN AU)TW=N KAI\ GRA/MMASIN E)NTUXEI=N POLLOI=S PRO\S TOU\S *)AKADHMAI+KOU\S DIAFERO-ME/NWN KAI\ BOW/NTWN, W(S PA/NTA PRA/GMATA SUGXE/OUSI TAI=S <20A)PARALLACI/AIS>20, E)PI\ DUEI=N OU)SIW=N E(/NA POIO\N EI)=NAI BIAZO/MENOI: KAI/TOI TOU=TO ME\N OU)K E)/STIN O(/STIS A)NQRW/PWN OU) DIANOEI=TAI KAI\ TOU)NANTI/ON OI)/ETAI QAUMASTO\N EI)=NAI KAI\ PARA/DOCON, EI) MH/TE FA/TTA FA/TTH| MH/TE MELI/TTH| ME/LITTA MH/TE PURW=| PURO\S H)\ SU/KW| TO\ TOU= LO/GOU SU=KON E)N TW=| PANTI\ XRO/NW| GE/GONEN A)PARA/LLAKTON. @&10Cicero Acad. Pr. II 85. <21Stoicum>21 est quidem nec admodum cre- @1&10dibile "1<21nullum esse pilum omnibus rebus talem, qualis sit pilus &10alius, nullum granum>21"2. &10@Cicero Acad. Pr. II 54. cur id potius contenditis, quod rerum na-&10tura non patitur, ut non [2in]2 suo quidque genere sit tale, quale est, nec &10sit in duobus aut pluribus nulla re differens ulla communitas? ibid. 56 &10quod dilucide docetur a politioribus physicis, singularum rerum singulas &10proprietates esse. &10@Cicero Acad. Pr. II 37 &10nunc de adsensione atque adprobatione, quam Graeci$10 SUGKATA/-QESIN&10 vocant, pauca dicemus. __nam cum vim, quae esset in sensibus, &10explicabamus, simul illud aperiebatur, <21comprendi multa et percipi &10sensibus>21, quod fieri sine <21adsensione>21 non potest. deinde cum inter in-&10animem et animal hoc maxime intersit, <21quod animal agit aliquid>21 [1nihil &10enim agens ne cogitari quidem potest quale sit]1, aut ei sensus adimendus &10est aut ea, quae est in nostra potestate sita, reddenda <21assensio>21. _38 &10sed haec etiam sequuntur, nec <21memoriam>21 sine <21adsensione>21 posse con-&10stare nec notitias rerum nec artes; idque quod maximum est, ut sit ali-&10quid in nostra potestate, in eo, qui rei nulli adsentietur, non erit. Ubi &10igitur virtus, si nihil situm est in ipsis nobis? &10@Cicero Acad. Pr. II 24 &10Atque etiam illud perspicuum est, constitui necesse esse initium, &10quod sapientia, cum quid agere incipiat sequatur, idque initium esse na-&10turae accommodatum. Nam aliter adpetitio [1eam enim volumus esse$10 O(R-MH/N]1, &10qua ad agendum impellimur et id adpetimus, quod est visum, mo-&10veri non potest. <21illud autem, quod movet, prius oportet videri &10eique credi; quod fieri non potest, si id, quod visum erit, dis-&10cerni non poterit a falso>21. quomodo autem moveri animus ad adpe-&10tendum potest, si id, quod videtur, non percipitur accommodatumne na-&10turae sit an alienum? &10@Itemque si, quid officii sui sit, non occurrit animo, nihil unquam &10omnino aget, ad nullam rem unquam impelletur, numquam movebitur. &10Quodsi aliquid aliquando acturus est, necesse est id ei verum, quod oc-&10currit videri. &10@Cicero Acad. Pr. II 23. <21Maxime vero virtu-&10tum cognitio confirmat percipi et comprehendi multa posse>21. in &10quibus solis inesse etiam scientiam dicimus, quam nos non comprehensio-&10nem modo rerum, sed eam stabilem quoque et immutabilem esse cense-&10mus, itemque sapientiam, artem vivendi, quae ipsa ex sese habeat con-&10stantiam. Ea autem constantia si nihil habeat percepti et cogniti, quaero &10unde nata sit aut quo modo. &10@Sextus adv. math. VII 440.$10 A)LL' EI)W/QASIN A)NQUPOFE/RONTES OI( DOG-MATIKOI\ ZHTEI=N PW=S POTE KAI\ O( SKEPTIKO\S TO\ MHDE\N EI)=NAI KRITH/RION A)POFAI/-NETAI: H)/TOI GA\R A)KRI/TWS TOU=TO LE/GEI H)\ META\ KRITHRI/OU: KAI\ EI) ME\N A)KRI/TWS, @1 A)/PISTOS GENH/SETAI, EI) DE\ META\ KRITHRI/OU, PERITRAPH/SETAI KAI\ LE/GWN MHDE\N EI)=NAI KRITH/RION O(MOLOGH/SEI EI)S TH\N TOU/TOU PARA/STASIN KRITH/RION PARALAM-BA/NEIN. @PA/LIN TE H(MW=N SUNERWTW/NTWN "1EI) E)/STI KRITH/RION, H)/TOI KE/KRITAI H)\ A)/K-RITO/N E)STI"2 KAI\ DUOI=N QA/TERON SUNAGO/NTWN H)/TOI TH\N EI)S A)/PEIRON E)/KPTWSIN H)\ TO\ A)TO/PWS E(AUTOU= TI KRITH/RION EI)=NAI LE/GESQAI, A)NTIPARECA/GONTE/S FASI <20MH\ A)/TOPON U(PA/RXEIN TO\ E(AUTOU= TI KRITH/RION A)POLEI/PEIN>20. KAI\ GA\R E(AU-TOU= TO\ EU)QU\ KAI\ A)/LLWN E)STI\ DOKIMASTIKO/N, KAI\ O( ZUGO\S TH=S TE TW=N A)/LLWN I)SO/THTOS KAI\ TH=S I)DI/AS STAQMHTIKO\S U(PH=RXEN, <20KAI\ TO\ FW=S OU) MO/NON TW=N A)/LLWN A)LLA\ KAI\ E(AUTOU= E)KKALUPTIKO\N FAI/NETAI>20, DIO/PER KAI\ TO\ KRITH/-RION DU/NATAI KAI\ A)/LLWN KAI\ E(AUTOU= KRITH/RION KAQESTA/NAI. @&10Sextus adv. math. XI 162.$10 O(/QEN KAI\ KATAFRONEI=N A)NAGKAI=ON TW=N EI)S A)NENERGHSI/AN AU)TO\N [1&10scil.$10 TO\N SKEPTIKO/N]1 PERIKLEI/ESQAI NOMIZO/NTWN H)\ EI)S A)PE/M-FASIN: KAI\ EI)S A)NENERGHSI/AN ME\N O(/TI TOU= BI/OU PANTO\S E)N AI(RE/SESI KAI\ FUGAI=S O)/NTOS O( MH/TE AI(ROU/MENO/S TI MH/TE FEU/GWN DUNA/MEI TO\N BI/ON A)RNEI=TAI KAI/ TINOS FUTOU= TRO/PON E)PEI=XEN, EI)S A)PE/MFASIN DE\ O(/TI U(PO\ TURA/NNW| POTE\ GENO/MENOS KAI\ TW=N A)R)R(H/TWN TI POIEI=N A)NAGKAZO/MENOS H)\ OU)X U(POMENEI= TO\ PROSTATTO/ME-NON A)LL' E(KOU/SION E(LEI=TAI QA/NATON, H)\ FEU/GWN TA\S BASA/NOUS POIH/SEI TO\ KE-LEUO/MENON, OU(/TW TE OU)KE/TI "1A)FUGH\S KAI\ A)NAI/RETOS"2 E)/STAI KATA\ TO\N *TI/MWNA, A)LLA\ TO\ ME\N E(LEI=TAI, TOU= D' A)POSTH/SETAI: O(/PER H)=N TW=N META\ PEI/SMATOS KA-TEILHFO/TWN TO\ FEUKTO/N TI EI)=NAI KAI\ AI(RETO/N. TAU=TA DH\ LE/GONTES OU) SU-NIA=SIN&10 etc. &10@Galenus adv. Iulianum 5. Vol. XVIII A p. 268 K.$10 EI) MH/ TIS TH\N DIAFWNI/AN I(KANO\N OI)/ETAI MA/RTURA EI)=NAI TH=S A)GNOI/AS TOU= DO/GMATOS, E)CAI/FNHS A)PORHTIKO/S TIS A)NTI\ <20*STWI+KOU=>20 GEGONW/S. EI) GA\R DH\ TOU/TW| PE/PEISAI TW=| LO/GW|, FA/SKONTI MHDE\N TW=N DIAPEFWNHME/NWN PA=SI TOI=S FILOSO/FOIS EI)S GNW=SIN A)N-QRWPI/NHN A)FIKE/SQAI DU/NASQAI &10etc. &10@Clemens Al. Stromat. VIII 5 [1II p. 923 Pott.$10]1. <20*PRO\S TOU\S *PUR)-R(WNEI/OUS>20. *EI) [2ME/N]2 FHSIN H( E)POXH\ BE/BAION EI)=NAI MHDE/N, DH=LON O(/TI A)F' E(AUTH=S A)RCAME/NH PRW=TON A)KURW/SEI E(AUTH/N. H)\ TOI/NUN DI/DWSIN A)LHQE/S TI EI)=NAI KAI\ OU) PERI\ PA/NTWN E)FEKTE/ON, H)\ E)NI/STATAI MHDE\N EI)=NAI A)LHQE\S LE/GOUSA KAI\ DH=LON O(/TI OU)D' AU)TH\ PRO/TERON A)LHQEU/SEI. H)/TOI GA\R AU)TH\ A)LHQEU/EI H)\ OU)K A)LHQEU/EI. A)LL' EI) ME\N A)LHQEU/EI, DI/DWSIN A)/KOUSA/ TI EI)=NAI A)LHQE/S. EI) DE\ MH\ A)LHQEU/EI, A)LHQH= A)POLEI/PEI A(/PER A)NELEI=N E)BOU/LETO. E)N W(=| GA\R YEUDH\S DEI/KNUTAI H( A)NAIROU=SA E)POXH/, E)N TOU/TW| TA\ A)NAIROU/MENA A)LHQH= DEI/KNUTAI, W(S O( O)/NEIROS O( LE/GWN YEUDEI=S EI)=NAI PA/NTAS TOU\S O)NEI/ROUS. AU(TH=S GA\R A)NAI-RETIKH\ OU)=SA TW=N A)/LLWN GI/NETAI KURWTIKH/. KAI\ O(/LWS EI) E)/STIN A)LHQH/S, A)F' E(AUTH=S POIH/SETAI TH\N A)RXH/N, OU)K A)/LLOU TINO\S OU)=SA E)POXH/, A)LL' E(AUTH=S PRW=-TON. E)/PEITA EI) KATALAMBA/NEI TIS O(/TI A)/NQRWPO/S E)STIN H)\ O(/TI E)PE/XEI, DH=LO/S E)STI MH\ E)PE/XWN. PW=S D' A)\N KAI\ TH\N A)RXH\N EI)S TH\N A)MFISBH/THSIN A)FI/KETO PERI\ @1 PA/NTWN E)PE/XWN: PW=S D' A)\N KAI\ A)PEKRI/NETO PRO\S TO\ E)RWTHQE/N; PERI\ GA\R AU)TOU= TOU/TOU DH=LO/S E)STIN OU)K E)PE/XWN: KAI\ MH\N KAI\ A)POFAI/NETAI O(/TI E)PE/XEI. O(\ KAI\ EI) DEI= PEIQO/MENON AU)TOI=S PERI\ PA/NTWN E)PE/XEIN, PERI\ AU)TH=S PRO/TERON TH=S E)POXH=S E)FE/COMEN, EI)/TE PEISTE/ON AU)TH=| EI)/TE KAI\ MH/. E)/TI EI) TOU=TO AU)TO/ E)STI TO\ A)LHQE\S TO\ MH\ EI)DE/NAI TO\ A)LHQE/S, OU)DE\ TH\N A)RXH\N A)LHQE/S TI PAR' E)KEI/NOU DI/DOTAI. EI) DE\ KAI\ TOU=TO A)MFISBHTH/SIMON E)REI=, TO\ A)GNOEI=N TA)-LHQE/S, E)N AU)TW=| TOU/TW| DI/DWSIN EI)=NAI TO\ A)LHQE\S GNW/RIMON, E)N W(=| TH\N PERI\ AU)TOU= E)POXH\N FAI/NETAI MH\ BEBAIW=N. EI) DE\ AI(/RESI/S E)STI PRO/SKLISIS DOGMA/-TWN H)/, W(/S TINES, PRO/SKLISIS DO/GMASI POLLOI=S A)KOLOUQI/AN PRO\S A)/LLHLA KAI\ TA\ FAINO/MENA PERIE/XOUSI, PRO\S TO\ EU)= ZH=N SUNTEI/NOUSA: KAI\ TO\ ME\N DO/GMA E)STI\ KATA/LHYI/S TIS LOGIKH/: KATA/LHYIS DE\ E(/CIS KAI\ SUGKATA/QESIS TH=S DIANOI/AS [2OU)K A)\N EI)/H AI(/RESIS H( TW=N E)FEKTIKW=N. KAI/TOI]2 OU) MO/NON OI( E)FEKTIKOI/, A)LLA\ KAI\ PA=S DOGMATIKO\S E)/N TISIN E)PE/XEIN EI)/WQEN, H)/TOI PARA\ GNW/MHS A)SQE/NEIAN H)\ PARA\ PRAGMA/TWN A)SA/FEIAN H)\ PARA\ TH\N TW=N LO/GWN I)SOSQE/NEIAN. @1 @&Diocles Magnes apud Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 62.$ DIALEKTIKH\ DE/ E)STIN, W(/S FHSI *POSEIDW/NIOS, E)PISTH/MH A)LHQW=N KAI\ YEUDW=N KAI\ OU)DE-TE/RWN: TUGXA/NEI DE\ AU(/TH, W(S O( <20*XRU/SIPPO/S>20 FHSI, PERI\ SHMAI/NONTA KAI\ SHMAINO/MENA. @&10Sextus adv. math. XI 187.$10 KAI\ AU)TOI\ DE\ [1&10scil. Stoici$10]1 <20TH\N DIALEK-TIKH\N>20 E)/FASAN E)PISTH/MHN A)LHQW=N TE KAI\ YEUDW=N KAI\ OU)DETE/RWN. @&10Alexander in Aristot. Top. p. 3 Ald. p. 1, 8 Wal.$10 H(MA=S DE\ KALW=S E)/XEI PROEIDE/NAI O(/TI TO\ TH=S DIALEKTIKH=S O)/NOMA OU)K E)PI\ TO\ AU)TO\ SHMAINO/MENON PA/NTES OI( FILO/SOFOI FE/ROUSIN, A)LL' <20OI( ME\N A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S O(RIZO/MENOI TH\N DIALEKTIKH\N E)PISTH/MHN TOU= EU)= LE/GEIN>20, TO\ DE\ EU)= LE/GEIN E)N TW=| TA\ A)LHQH= KAI\ TA\ PROSH/KONTA LE/GEIN EI)=NAI TIQE/MENOI, TOU=TO DE\ I)/DION H(GOU/MENOI TOU= FI-LOSO/FOU KATA\ TH=S TELEIOTA/THS FILOSOFI/AS FE/ROUSIN AU)TO/: KAI\ DIA\ TOU=TO <20MO/-NOS O( SOFO\S KAT' AU)TOU\S DIALEKTIKO/S>20. @&10Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. I 10 Sudhaus.$10 A)/%5CIO/N TE E)PISTH=SAI %5 MH/POTE OU)K A)P[1I/]1QA[1NA]1 %5 LE/GH[1IT]1IS W(/SP[1ER T]1H\N %5 DIALEKTIKH\N TE/%5XNHN U(PA/RXEIN, OU)[1M]1H\[1N]1 %5 A)PERGA/ZESQAI/ TI KA%5Q' E(AUTH\N, EI) MH\ TOI=[1S]1 %5 H)QI-KOI=S KAI\ F[1U]1SIKO[1I=S]1 %5 SUNDEQEI/H LO/G[1OI]1S, O(\[1N]1 %5 TRO/PON KAI\ TW=[1N]1 <20*STW- %5IKW=N>20 E)/NIOI DI[1E/]1LABON: %5 OU(/TW KAI\ TH\N R(HTO%5RIKH\N &10etc. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 24 p. 1045f.$8 <20*)EN TW=| TRI/TW| PERI\ TH=S *DIALEKTIKH=S>20 U(PEIPW\N O(/TI "1<20*PLA/TWN E)SPOU/DASE PERI\ TH\N *DIALEKTIKH\N KAI\ *)ARISTOTE/LHS KAI\ [2OI(]2 A)PO\ TOU/TWN A)/XRI *POLE/MWNOS KAI\ *STRA/TWNOS, MA/LISTA DE\ *SWKRA/THS>20"2 KAI\ E)PIFW-NH/SAS O(/TI "1<20KAI\ SUNECAMARTA/NEIN A)/N TIS E)QELH/SEIE TOU/TOIS TO-SOU/TOIS KAI\ TOIOU/TOIS OU)=SIN>20"2 E)PIFE/REI KATA\ LE/CIN: "1<20*EI) ME\N GA\R E)K PARE/RGOU PERI\ AU)TW=N EI)RH/KESAN, TA/X' A)/N TIS DIE/SURE TO\N TO/PON TOU=TON: OU(/TW D' AU)TW=N E)PIMELW=S EI)RHKO/TWN W(S E)N TAI=S MEGI/STAIS DUNA/MESI KAI\ A)NAGKAIOTA/TAIS AU)TH=S OU)/SHS, OU) PIQANO\N E)PI\ TOSOU=TON DIAMARTA/NEIN AU)TOU\S E)N TOI=S O(/LOIS O)/N-TAS OI(/OUS U(PONOOU=MEN>20."2 @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 10 p. 1035f.$8 *TO\ PRO\S TA\ E)NANTI/A DIALE/GESQAI KAQO/LOU ME\N OU)/ FHSIN A)PODOKIMA/ZEIN, XRH=SQAI DE\ @1 TOU/TW| PARAINEI= MET' EU)LABEI/AS, W(/SPER E)N TOI=S DIKASTHRI/OIS, MH\ META\ SUNHGORI/AS, A)LLA\ DIALU/ONTAS AU)TW=N TO\ PIQANO\N "1<20*TOI=S ME\N GA\R E)POXH\N A)/GOUSI PERI\ PA/NTWN, E)PIBA/LLEI, FHSI/, TOU=TO POIEI=N, KAI\ SUNERGO/N E)STI PRO\S O(\ BOU/LONTAI: TOI=S D' E)PISTH/MHN E)NER-GAZOME/NOIS, KAQ' H(\N O(MOLOGOUME/NWS BIWSO/MEQA, TA\ E)NANTI/A, STOIXEIOU=N KAI\ KATASTOIXI/ZEIN TOU\S EI)SAGOME/NOUS A)P' A)RXH=S ME/XRI TE/LOUS: E)F' W(=N KAIRO/S E)STI MNHSQH=NAI KAI\ TW=N E)NANTI/WN LO/GWN, DIALU/ONTAS AU)TW=N TO\ PIQANO/N, KAQA/PER KAI\ E)N TOI=S DIKASTHRI/OIS>20"2. *TAUTI\ GA\R AU)TAI=S LE/CESIN EI)/RHKEN. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 10 p. 1037b.$8 *)EN ME\N TAI=S <20*FUSIKAI=S *QE/SESI>20 TAU=TA GE/GRAFEN: "1<20*)/ESTAI DE\ KAI\ KATALAMBA/NON-TA/S TI, PRO\S TA\ E)NANTI/A E)PIXEIREI=N, TH\N E)NOU=SAN SUNHGORI/AN POIOUME/NOUS: POTE\ D' OU)DE/TERON KATALAMBA/NONTAS EI)S E(KA/TE-RON TA\ O)/NTA LE/GEIN>20."2 @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 10 p. 1037b.$8 <20*)EN DE\ TW=| PERI\ TH=S TOU= *LO/GOU *XRH/SEWS>20 EI)PW/N, W(S OU) DEI= TH=| TOU= LO/GOU DUNA/MEI PRO\S TA\ MH\ E)PIBA/LLONTA XRH=SQAI, KAQA/PER OU)DE\ O(/PLOIS, TAU=T' E)PEI/RHKE: "1<20*PRO\S ME\N GA\R TH\N TW=N A)LHQW=N EU(/RESIN DEI= XRH=SQAI AU)TH=|, KAI\ PRO\S TH\N TOU/TWN SUGGE/NEIAN, EI)S TA)NANTI/A D' OU)/, POL-LW=N POIOU/NTWN TOU=TO>20."2 POLLOU\S [DE\] LE/GWN I)/SWS TOU\S E)PE/XONTAS. @&10Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 46.$10 AU)TH\N DE\ <20TH\N DIALEKTIKH\N>20 A)NAGKAI/AN EI)=NAI KAI\ A)RETH\N E)N EI)/DEI PERIE/XOUSAN A)RETA/S: TH/N TE <20A)PROPTWSI/AN>20 E)PISTH/MHN TOU= PO/TE DEI= SUGKATATI/QESQAI KAI\ MH/: TH/N TE A)NEIKAIO/THTA I)SXURO\N LO/GON PRO\S TO\ EI)KO/S, W(/STE MH\ E)NDIDO/NAI AU)TW=|: TH/N TE <20A)NELEGCI/AN>20 I)SXU\N E)N LO/GW|, W(/STE MH\ A)PA/GESQAI U(P' AU)TOU= EI)S TO\ A)NTIKEI/MENON: TH/N TE <20A)MATAIO/THTA>20 E(/CIN A)NAFE/ROUSAN TA\S FANTASI/AS E)PI\ TO\N O)RQO\N LO/GON. AU)TH/N TE TH\N <20E)PI-STH/MHN>20 FASI\N H)\ KATA/LHYIN A)SFALH= H)\ E(/CIN E)N FANTASIW=N PROSDE/CEI A)ME-TA/PTWTON U(PO\ LO/GOU. OU)K A)/NEU DE\ TH=S DIALEKTIKH=S QEWRI/AS TO\N SOFO\N A)/P-TWTON E)/SESQAI E)N LO/GW|: TO/ TE GA\R A)LHQE\S KAI\ TO\ YEU=DOS DIAGINW/SKESQAI U(P' AU)TH=S KAI\ TO\ PIQANO\N TO/ TE A)MFIBO/LWS LEGO/MENON DIEUKRINEI=SQAI: XWRI/S TE AU)TH=S OU)K EI)=NAI O(DW=| E)RWTA=N KAI\ A)POKRI/NESQAI. DIATEI/NEIN DE\ TH\N E)N TAI=S A)POFA/NSESI PROPE/TEIAN KAI\ E)PI\ TA\ GINO/MENA, W(/STE EI)S A)KOSMI/AN KAI\ EI)KAIO/-THTA TRE/PESQAI TOU\S A)GUMNA/STOUS E)/XONTAS TA\S FANTASI/AS. OU)K A)/LLWS TE O)CU\N KAI\ A)GXI/NOUN KAI\ TO\ O(/LON DEINO\N E)N LO/GOIS FANH/SESQAI TO\N SOFO/N: TOU= GA\R AU)TOU= EI)=NAI O)RQW=S DIALE/GESQAI KAI\ DIALOGI/ZESQAI KAI\ TOU= AU)TOU= PRO/S TE TA\ PROKEI/MENA DIALEXQH=NAI KAI\ PRO\S TO\ E)RWTW/MENON A)POKRI/NASQAI, A(/PER E)MPEI/ROU DIALEKTIKH=S A)NDRO\S EI)=NAI. @1 @&Papyrus 1020 [1Hercul. Vol. Coll. alt. X 112_177. Hermes &XXV p. 473 sq.]1. [Col. IV n %6 Ox Nd$] O(/[1T]1I TH\N [1A)]1PROPTWSI/[1AN]1 %5 TIMW=M[1E]1N KAI\ TH\N [1A)NEI]1%5KAIO/T[1H]1TA, PRO\S DE\ %5 TA\S E)NANTI/AS DI[1A]1BE%5-BLH/MEQA O)RQW=[1S]1. E)S%5TI\ D' H( M[1E\]1N A)PROPTW%5SI/A DIA/QE[1S]1IS A)SUNKA%5-TA/QETOS PRO\ KATALH/%5YEWS, SUNKATAQETI%5KH\N KATA\ NER!!!!!AI %5 FAN-TASI/A| KATA[1L]1H%5PTW=I, I)SXU/OUSA T' E)N %5 FANTASI/AIS KAI\ A)/NEI%5KTON PAREXO[1M]1E/N[1H]1 %5 TAI=S MH\ KATALH%5PTIKAI=S. *DEI= GA\R %5 TO\N A)PRO/PTW-TON %5 A)[1N]1E/L[1K]1USTO/N TE EI)=%5NAI U(PO\ FANTASI/AS %5 A)KATALH/PTOU KAI\ %5 I)SXU/EIN E)N TAI=S FAN%5TASI/AIS, W(/STE MH\ E(/L%5KESQAI A)PO\ FANTA%5SI[1W=?N?]1 A)KATALH/PTWN %5 KAI\ KRATEI=N TW=N %5 SUNKATAQE/SEWN W(/S%5TE MHEL!ESU!H MH\ %5 A)[1KO]1L?OUQ[1EI=N]1 FAN[1TASI/AIS. @[&Frgm. In %6 Ox La$] PRO/[1TERON]1 TOU\[1S T]1OIOU/%5[1T]1OUS, [1OU)]1DE/N [1E)]1STI PRO\[1S %5 TO\]1 MH\ [1U(PARK]1TOU\S EI)=NA[1I %5 TOU\]1S [1A)STEI/O]1US, A)DUNA/%5TOU [1ME\N OU)K]1 OI)=M[1AI TUGXA/NON]1%5TOS AU)[1TO]1U=, DUSKATAPO%5NH/TO[1U D' A)/KR]1WS KAQA/PER %5 KA[1I\ DUSAPO]1SEI/STOU: OU(/%5TW [1D' EI)/RHTAI]1 O(/TI TH=S [1A)RE%5TH=S I(DRW=TA QEOI\]1 %5 P[1ROPA/]1RO[1IQ]1EN [1E)/Q]1HKAN. %5 [1*TW=I]1 DE\ MH\ [1D]1OCA/ZEIN %5 TO\[1N SO]1FO\[1N PLEI/W]1 A)KO%5LO[1U?QE]1I=?N [1FAME]1N TOI%5AU=T?[1A: PR]1W=[1TO]1N ME\N TO\ %5 MH\ DOKE[1I=N]1 AU)[1T]1W=| MH%5DE/N: H( GA\R DO/K?H[1SI/]1S E)S%5[1TIN DO/]1C[1A A)]1KA-TA/L[1HP]1%5T[1OS: KAI\]1 TO\ MHD' OI)/ES%5QAI [1AU)]1TO\N MHDE/N: KAI\ %5 [1GA\R H(]1 OI)/H-[1SI/]1S E)STIN AU)TH\ %5 [1D]1O/CA A)DIA!!TOS MA=L[1L]1ON [1D]1O/KHSIS MI!!!!!%5 [1L]1E/[1G]1ETAI DE\ T! @[&Frgm. IIn %6 Ox Lb$] [1MH/TE]1 %5 [1E)]1C[1E]1LE/GXESQ[1AI SPOU]1%5D[1AI/]1WN EI)=N[1AI !! M?H/]1%5TE METAPE[1ISQH=NAI]1, %5 KATA\ TAU)TA\ D' OU)?[1DE\]1 %5 E)[1C]1ALLA/TTEIN A[1U(]1T[1O/]1N, %5 OU)DEI\S OU)/TE PA[1R]1AKOU/SE%5TAI OU)/TE PARANO[1H/SEI:]1 DE[1I= %5 GA\R]1 MH\ PARAD[1E/XESQAI AU)%5TO\]1N YEUDH=!!!!!!!! %5 !!TA!!N?IA?N, E)/TI [1D' A)]1%5KO-LOU/QWS TOU/TO[1IS OU)/]1%5T' AU)TO\S PARA[1RI]1QM?[1EI=]1 %5 O[1U)/Q']1 U(P' A)/LLOU[S] PAR[1A]1R?I%5QMEI=TAI: KAI\ PRO\S TO[1U/]1%5TOIS OU)/?T?E PARORAI= OU)/TE %5 [1PAR]1A?KOU/EI OU)/T?E [1KAT' A)/L]1%5LO T?W=?N A?I)SQ?[1H]1THR[1I/WN !! %5 !!E[1IK]1AT!!!S1!TA!!!! %5 [1DEI= GA\]1R TO\N PARORW=?[1N]1%5TA, [1KA]1TA\ TH\N O)/YIN [1LAM]1%5B[1A/N]1ONTA FA?N- @1TA[1SI/AN]1 %5 YEUDH=, TAU/THN PA[1RA]1%5D[1E/X]1ES[1QAI]1 K!!!O!!!%5Q!!IKA !!! A)]1NE%5CAPA/THT[1ON]1 OU)DENO\S %5 #7N!!#7!!!!ONK!!! @&[Frgm. IIIn %6 Ox Lc$] TA/[1C]1IN !!!!!!IN!E %5 #7IN!!!!!!!!!!IL?EI %5 GA\R !!!!!!!!!!!!! %5 AU)TOI=S KATA\ TA\ PL#7!! %5 !EIS KA[1I\]1 POLLA\S [1TW=N]1 TEXNW=?N? OU)X E(/COUSIN %5 KAI\ EI)SAXQH/SONTAI EI)S %5 TAU/TAS: PARORA=N D[1E\]1 AU)%5TOU\S H)\ [1A)]1TE/XNOUS EI)=NAI %5 OU) [1R(]1HTE/ON L!!TA\S EI)%5R?[1HME/]1NAS, OI( TA\S !!!!%5T!!!!!!!!!EKEI!!!! %5 OU)[1DE\]1N!!! A)]1LLA!!!!%5NA!!T!!!!!!O !O!!!%5PR?O?SUSI!!!!!!!!! %5 &desunt duo versus$ %5!!!!NI!!!!!!!!!!%5 A!!OUS1!!!!!!!!!! %5 N!!AU!!!!!!!! [1H(]1 %5 ME\?N GA\R M[1ETAPTWTIKH/ E)S]1%5TIN D[1O/]1CA!!!!!!!!!%5TIKAI!!S1!!!!!!!! %5 A)DU/?[1NATON]1 OU)DE/!!!!%5 !U!!!!!!!OS1!!!!! %5 &totus versus deest$ %5 !!Y!!!!! @[&Ox Ld, deest in n$] DE!!!!! A)]1KOLO?[1UQE]1I= MH%5DE\N A)GNO?EI=N TO\N SO%5FO/N: A)[1F' W(=]1N KAI\ [1TOIAU=]1TA %5 PARAPL[1H/S]1IA E)/STAI: ME%5TA\ D?E\ T[1W=N PRO[1EIR]1HM[1E/]1%5NWN TA\ [1ME\N]1 O)/NTA FAU=%5LA OU)K E)/[1ST]1A[1I]1 PERI\ TO\N FR[1O/]1-NIMON, T[1A\]1 DE\ A)NAME/SON, %5 DIA\ TO\ MH\ GI/NE[1S]1QAI TAU=%5TA E)N TOI=S LOGI-KOI=S A)/%5NEU A(MARTHMA/TWN. %5 H( ME\N GA\R U(PO/N[1O]1IA? KAI\ %5 H( A)/?G?[1N]1O?I[1A]1 KA[1I\]1 H( A)[1PIS]1TI/A %5 KAI\ TA\ PARA[1PLH/S]1IA FAU=%5[1L]1A/ E)STI[1N, H(]1 D' [1A)TEX]1NI/A [1KAI\ H(]1 PARO/[1RA]1SIS KAI\ PA%5RARI/Q[1MH]1SI[1S TW=N]1 A)NA%5ME/SON !!!A!!!!T !!AI%5!!EIA PARAREIQM[1H=]1SAI %5 !!EX!!AI T!!!!!!PAI!!!%5!!!!E!!!I !!!!!TA!!!!%5!A!!!WSQ!!AI TOU= YEU/%5[1DOUS]1 !!A!!!!!!!!!! %5 KA[1I\ PAN]1TO\S F[1AU/]1LOU: DIA\ [1TOU=]1%5TO KAI\ LE!PA!!SI! TOI=S %5 TO?IOU/T?[1OI]1S !!!!!TATOIS %5 !!!!!!!ON!!!!!!OIS1!!! %5 !!!!!!!AU!!!!DIAFORA! %5 @[&Col. In %6 Ox Ma$] NA: TOU/TOIS DE\ W([1S F]1A[1SI\N]1 %5 A)KOL[1O]1UQEI= KAI\ TO\ TOU\S %5 [1S]1OFO[1U\S]1 A)NECA[1P]1ATH/%5TOUS EI)=NAI KAI\ A)NAMAR%5TH/TOUS KAT' *)ARI[1ST]1OTE/LHN [1K]1AI\ PA/NTA PRA/[1T]1TEIN %5 EU)=: DIO\ KAI\ PERI\ [1TA\S S]1UN%5-[1KA]1TAQE/?SEIS O(/P?WS GI/NON%5TAI MH\ A)/LLWS, A)LLA\ ME%5TA\ KATALH/YEWS PLEI/%5W GE/GONEN E)[1P]1I[1ST]1RO%5FH/. PRW=TON ME\N GA/R E)S%5TIN [1H(]1 FILOSOFI/A, EI)/TE E)[1PI]1%5TH/DE?U[1SI]1S LO/GOU O)R[1QO/]1%5THT[1OS [1EI)/T']1 E)PISTH/M?[1H]1, %5 H( [1AU)TH\ TH=|]1 PERI\ LO/GON %5 P[1RAGM]1ATEI/AI: K[1AI\ GA\R]1 %5 E)N[1TO\]1S O)/?NTES TW=N? [1TOU=]1 %5 LO/-GOU MORI/WN KAI\ TH=S %5 [1SU]1N[1TA/CEWS AU)]1TW=N XR[1H]1%5[1S]1O/M?[1E]1QA E)MP[1E]1I/-[1RWS AU)]1%5TW=|: LO/[1G]1ON DE\ [1LE/]1GW TO\N %5 KA[1TA\ FU/S]1IN P?[1A=S]1I [1TOI=S]1 %5 LOGIKOI=S U(PA/RXONTA: %5 E[1I) D']1 H( D?IA?L?EK?T[1IKH/]1 E)S[1TIN]1 %5 E)PIST[1H/]1M[1H]1 TOU= O)[1R]1QW=[1S %5 DI]1ALE/G?E?S[1Q]1AI KAQ' H([1MA=S%1 @[&Col. IIn %6 Ox Mb$] [1A)]1POK[1R]1I/SEI [1PI]1QAN[1O\]1N %5 TOU=TON DEINO\N EI)=-NAI: %5 [1K]1AI\ TO\N E)N E)[1R]1WT[1H/]1SEI %5 [1K]1AI\ A)POK[1R]1I/SEI DEINO\N %5 M[1H/]1TE P[1ERI]1GI/NESQAI %5 DUNATO\N EI)=NAI MH/TE %5 D?IA?FEU/[1G]1EIN, TO\N D' OI(=ON %5 O)/NTA @1 E)CAPATA=SQAI %5 KAI\ PERIGENE/SQA[1I EI)=N]1AI %5 KAI\ DIAFEU/GEIN: I#7 I(KA%5NO\N ME\N DEI= AU)TO\N %5 EI)=NAI E)N TW=I DIALE/%5GESQAI, TO\N D' I(KANO\N %5 E)N TW=| D[1I]1A-LE/GESQAI %5 E)PAK[1TE/ON EI)=]1NAI KA[1I\]1 %5 EU)ERWTHTIKO\N KAI\ [1EU)]1%5APOKRITIKO/N, OU)/[1T]1E %5 T?OU/TW[1N]1 E)SOME/NWN %5 KATA\ TO\N E)[1CAP]1A[1TW/]1%5M[1E]1NON OU)/[1T' A)\N AU)TOU=]1 %5 YEUDE/SI KAI\ PRO[1PETE/%5SI LO/GOIS O)RQW=S A)POKRI]1%5NOME/NOU, EI)/ TINA TRI%5BH\N ME\N E)N LO/GWI %5 PROSH=K?EN AU)TO\N [1E)/XEIN]1, %5 H( D' E(/WS TW=N E)LAXI/S%5TWN Q?EWRHTI[1KH\!]1N__ @[&Col. IIIn %6 Ox Mc$] KATA\ TO\N E)CAP[1A]1%5TW/MENON, OU)/TE [1A)/L]1L?OU %5 A)/N, O(/?S?ON DE\ I(KANO\N %5 E)N TW=I DIAL[1E/]1GE?S?Q?A?[1I A)N%5T]1I LE/GONTOS, DUNATOU= %5 O)/NTOS PERIGE[1NE/S]1QAI %5 OU)/TE T[1H]1RH=SAI A[1U(T]1O\N %5 A)PERIGE/NHTON. KAI\ %5 GA\R A)LHQE\S LE/GWN %5 AU)TW=N A)NTEREI= KAI\ %5 YEUDE\S? LE/[1G]1OUSIN AU)%5-TOI=S E)PIP?O?R?E?U/?SONTA[1I]1: [1T]1UG?X?A/NOUSI DE\ KAI\ %5 A)NECE/[1L]1EKTOI O)/NTES %5 OI( A)[1G]1AQOI\ KAI\ KATAL[1H]1%5PTIKOI\ O)/NTES A)[1CI]1W%5MA/TWN AU)TA/[1RK]1WS %5 PROS-ELE/GXON?[1TES TE T]1O\N A)FAIROU/MENON LO/%5GON KAI\ I)SXU/ON[1TES]1 %5 [1PR]1O\S TOU\[1S E)]1N[1ANTI/]1OUS: %5 DEI=? G?A\R AU)TOU\S KAI\ A)%5KINH/TOUS EI)=NAI [1U(]1P' E)%5LE/GXO?[1U]1 KAI\ SUNK[1A]1T?[1A]1 %5 SUNKATATI/QESQAI %5 PEFRAGME/NWS PRO\S %5 TOU\S E)[1NANTI/]1OUS__ @&10Sextus adv. math. VII 38.$10 TH\N DE\ A)LH/QEIAN OI)/ONTAI/ TINES KAI\ MA/-LISTA <20OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 DIAFE/REIN TA)LHQOU=S KATA\ TREI=S TRO/POUS, OU)SI/A| TE KAI\ SUSTA/SEI KAI\ DUNA/MEI: <20OU)SI/A|>20 ME\N PARO/SON H( <20ME\N A)LH/QEIA SW=MA/ E)STI, TO\ DE\ A)LHQE\S A)SW/MATON>20 U(PH=RXEN. KAI\ EI)KO/TWS, FASI/N, TOUTI\ ME\N GA\R A)CI/WMA/ E)STI: TO\ DE\ A)CI/WMA LEKTO/N: TO\ DE\ LEKTO\N A)SW/MATON. A)NA/PALIN DE\ H( <20A)LH/QEIA SW=MA/ E)STI PARO/SON E)PISTH/MH PA/NTWN A)LHQW=N A)POFAN-TIKH\ DOKEI= TUGXA/NEIN>20, PA=SA DE\ E)PISTH/MH PW=S E)/XON E)STI\N H(GEMONIKO/N, W(/SPER KAI\ H( PW=S E)/XOUSA XEI\R PUGMH\ NOEI=TAI: TO\ DE\ H(GEMONIKO\N SW=MA KATA\ TOU/TOUS U(PH=RXEN: TOI/NUN KAI\ H( A)LH/QEIA KATA\ GE/NOS E)/STAI SWMATIKH/. _ <20SUSTA/SEI>20 DE\ KAQO/SON TO\ ME\N A)LHQE\S W(S MONOEIDE/S TI KAI\ A(PLOU=N TH\N FU/SIN NENO/HTAI__H( DE\ A)LH/QEIA W(S A)\N E)PISTH/MH KAQESTHKUI=A TOU)NANTI/ON SU-STHMATIKH/ TE KAI\ PLEIO/NWN A)/QROISMA TUGXA/NEIN U(PEI/LHPTAI. __&10`42.$10 <20DU-NA/MEI>20 DE\ TAU=TA A)LLH/LWN KEXW/RISTAI, E)PEI\ TO\ ME\N A)LHQE\S OU) PA/NTWS E)PISTH/-MHS EI)/XETO [1KAI\ GA\R O( FAU=LOS KAI\ O( NH/PIOS KAI\ O( MEMHNW\S LE/GEI ME\N POTE/ TI A)LHQE/S, OU)K E)/XEI DE\ E)PISTH/MHN A)LHQOU=S]1 H( DE\ A)LH/QEIA KAT' E)PISTH/MHN QEWREI=TAI. O(/QEN KAI\ O( E)/XWN TAU/THN SOFO/S E)STIN [1E)PISTH/MHN GA\R EI)=XEN A)LH-QW=N]1 KAI\ OU)/POTE YEU/DETAI, KA)\N YEU=DOS LE/GH|, DIA\ TO\ MH\ A)PO\ KAKH=S, A)LL' A)PO\ A)STEI/AS AU)TO\ DIAQE/SEWS PROFE/RESQAI. _&10`44.$10 W(=DE KAI\ O( SOFO/S, TOUTE/-STIN O( TH\N TOU= A)LHQOU=S E)PISTH/MHN E)/XWN, E)REI= ME/N POTE YEU=DOS, YEU/SETAI DE\ OU)DE/POTE DIA\ TO\ MH\ E)/XEIN TH\N GNW/MHN YEU/DEI SUGKATATIQEME/NHN. _&10`45.$10 TO\ YEU=DOS LE/GEIN TOU= YEU/DESQAI KATA\ POLU\ DIENH/NOXEN, H(=| TO\ ME\N A)PO\ A)STEI/AS GI/NETAI GNW/MHS, TO\ DE\ YEU/DESQAI A)PO\ PONHRA=S. @&10Alexander in Aristot. Metaphys. p. 258, 4 Bon. 301, 17 Hayd.$10 TO\ @1 DH\ MH\ H(GEI=SQAI MA=LLON A)/LLO A)/LLOU DIAYEU/DESQAI, O(\ DOKEI= <20TOI=S A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20, YEU=DO/S TE KAI\ PARA\ TA\ FAINO/MENA. @&Cicero Orator 32, 115.&3 Ergo eum censeo, qui eloquentiae &3laude ducatur, non esse earum rerum [1scil. logicae]1 omnino rudem, sed &3vel illa antiqua vel hac <21Chrysippi>21 disciplina institutus, noverit primum &3vim, naturam, genera verborum, et simplicium et copulatorum%10 deinde &3quot modis quidque dicatur%10 qua ratione verum falsumne sit iudicetur%10 &3quid efficiatur e quoque, quid cuique consequens sit, quidque contrarium%10 &3quumque ambigue multa dicantur, quomodo quidque eorum dividi ex-&3planarique oporteat. @&10Galenus in Hippocr. de med. officina Vol. XVIII B p. 649 K.$10 TW=N AI)SQH/SEWN A(PA/SAIS TH\N GNW/MHN E)FECH=S E)/TACEN, O(/PER E)STI\ TH\N DIA/NOIAN, H(/N TE KAI\ NOU=N KAI\ FRE/NA KAI\ LO/GON KOINW=S OI( A)/NQRWPOI KALOU=SIN. <20E)PEI\ DE\ KAI\ TW=N KATA\ FWNH\N E)STI/ TIS LO/GOS, A)FORI/ZONTES OU)=N TOU=TON TO\N PROEIRHME/NON LO/GON OI( FILO/SOFOI KALOU=SIN E)NDIA/QETON>20, W(=| LO/GW| TA/ TE A)KO/LOUQA KAI\ TA\ MAXO/MENA GIGNW/SKOMEN, OI(=S E)MPERIE/XETAI KAI\ DIAI/RESIS KAI\ SU/NQESIS KAI\ A)NA/LUSIS KAI\ A)PO/DEICIS. @&10Sextus adv. math. VIII 275.$10 FASI\N O(/TI A)/NQRWPOS OU)XI\ TW=| PROFO-RIKW=| LO/GW| DIAFE/REI TW=N A)LO/GWN ZW/|WN [1KAI\ GA\R KO/RAKES KAI\ YITTAKOI\ KAI\ KI/TTAI E)NA/RQROUS PROFE/RONTAI FWNA/S]1 A)LLA\ TW=| E)NDIAQE/TW|, OU)DE\ TH=| A(PLH=| MO/NON FANTASI/A|__A)LLA\ TH=| METABATIKH=| KAI\ SUNQETIKH=|. DIO/PER A)KOLOU-QI/AS E)/NNOIAN E)/XWN EU)QU\S KAI\ SHMEI/OU NO/HSIN LAMBA/NEI DIA\ TH\N A)KOLOUQI/AN. @&10Diocles Magnes apud Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 55.$10 TH=S DE\ DIALEKTIKH=S QEWRI/AS SUMFW/NWS DOKEI= TOI=S PLEI/STOIS A)PO\ TOU= PERI\ TH=S FWNH=S E)NA/RXE-SQAI TO/POU. @&10Scholia Hesiod. Theog. v. 266.$10 *)=IRIS DE\ O( PROFORIKO\S LO/GOS A)PO\ TOU= EI)/RW TO\ LE/GW. @&10Origenes contra Celsum II 72 Vol. I p. 194, 13 Ko+. [1p. 441 De-&10larue$10]1. OU)DE/PW DE\ LE/GW O(/TI OU) PA/NTWS E)STI\N A)H\R PEPLHGME/NOS H)\ PLHGH\ A)E/ROS H)\ O(/TI POTE\ LE/GETAI <20E)N TOI=S PERI\ FWNH=S>20 H( A)NAGRAFOME/NH FWNH\ TOU= QEOU=. @&10Scholia Arati v. 1.$10 OI( GA\R <20*STWI+KOI\>20 U(POTI/QENTAI, MA=LLON DE\ PA/N-TES OI( O(/RON FWNH=S GRA/YANTES PEPLHGME/NON TAU/THN A)E/RA KALOU=SIN. @&Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 55.$ KAI\ SW=MA D' E)STI\N H( FWNH/, KATA\ TOU\S *STWI+KOU/S, W(/S FHSIN *)ARXE/DHMO/S TE E)N TH=| PERI\ FWNH=S KAI\ *DIO- @1GE/NHS KAI\ *)ANTI/PATROS KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS E)N TH=| DEUTE/RA| TW=N FUSI-KW=N>20. PA=N GA\R TO\ POIOU=N SW=MA/ E)STIN: POIEI= DE\ H( FWNH\ PROSIOU=SA TOI=S A)KOUO/USIN A)PO\ TW=N FWNOU/NTWN. @&10Gellius Noct. Att. V 15. Sed vocem <21Stoici>21 corpus esse conten-&10dunt eamque esse dicunt ictum ae%28ra. &10@Servius ad Verg. Aeneid. II 488. Ferit clamor%10 secundum philo-&10sophos physicos, qui dicunt, vocem corpus esse. &10@Varro de lingua lat. VI 56.&3 Loqui ab loco dictum, quod &3qui primo dicitur iam fari, vocabula et reliqua verba dicit, ante quam &3suo quisque loco ea dicere potest. Hunc <21Chrysippus>21 negat loqui, sed &3ut loqui%10 quare ut imago hominis non sit homo, sic in corvis, cornici-&3bus, pueris primitus incipientibus fari, verba non esse verba, quod non &3loquantur. @&10Galenus in Hippocr. de humoribus lib. I. Vol. XVI p. 204 K.$10 OU) TAU)TO\N DE/ E)STI FWNH\ KAI\ DIA/LEKTOS KAI\ AU)DH/, A)LL' H( ME\N FWNH\ E)/RGON E)STI\ TW=N FWNHTIKW=N O)RGA/NWN, H( DIA/LEKTOS DE\ TW=N DIALEKTIKW=N, W(=N TO\ ME\N PRW=-TO/N E)STIN H( GLW=TTA, E)/PEITA DE\ H( R(I\S KAI\ TA\ XEI/LH KAI\ OI( O)DO/NTES. FWNH-TIKA\ DE\ O)/RGANA/ E)STI LA/RUGC KAI\ OI( KINOU=NTES AU)TO\N MU/ES KAI\ NEU=RA, O(/SA TH\N E)C E)GKEFA/LOU PARAKOMI/ZEI TOU/TOIS DU/NAMIN. AU)DH\N DE\ OU)/TE PA=N TO\ TH=S A)KOH=S I)/DION AI)SQHTO\N OI( PALAIOI\ E)KA/LOUN, OU)/TE E)KEI=NO MO/NON, O(\ DIA\ STO/MA-TOS E)KPE/MPETAI, E)N W(=| PERIE/XETAI KAI\ TO\ KLA/EIN KAI\ TO\ SURI/TTEIN KAI\ OI)MW/ZEIN KAI\ BH/TTEIN KAI\ O(/SA TOIAU=TA, MO/NHN DE\ TH\N A)NQRW/POU FWNH/N, KAQ' H(\N DIA-LEGO/MEQA PRO\S A)LLH/LOUS, AU)DH\N W)NO/MAZON. @&10Idem in Hippocr. Epidem. III Comment. III Vol. XVII 1 p. 757 K. iis-&10dem verbis utitur inde ab$10 AU)DH\N DE\ OU)/TE_W)NO/MAZON. &10Pergit%10$10 OU(/TW GOU=N KAI\ O( POIHTH/S, H(NI/KA E)POI/HSE TOI=S I)DI/OIS I(/PPOIS DIALEGO/MENON TO\N *)AXILLE/A, THNIKAU=TA/ FHSI TO\N E(/TERON AU)TW=N A)MEI/YASQAI LO/GOIS XRHSA/MENON A)NQRWPI/NH| DIALE/KTW|. *AU)DH/ENTA, GA/R FHSIN, E)/QHKE QEA\ LEUKW/LENOS *(/HRH [1*T&10 407$10]1. OU)X W(S A)/FWNON O)/NTA PRO/TERON OU)D' W(S OU)K E)/XONTA TH\N KOINH\N TW=N I(/PPWN FW-NH/N, A)LL' W(S OU)K O)NOMAZOME/NHN AU)DH\N E)KEI/NHN. OU(/TWS OU)=N KAI\ "1QEO\N AU)-DH/ESSAN"2 EI)/RHKE TH\N A)NQRWPI/NH| DIALE/KTW| XRWME/NHN, O(/TI KAI\ AU)TH\N A)NQRW-POEIDH= FASIN EI)=NAI, MH\ PA/NTWN TW=N QEW=N TOIOU/TWN U(PARXO/NTWN. E)NARGW=S GOU=N H(/LIOS KAI\ SELH/NH KAI\ TA\ LOIPA\ TW=N A)/STRWN A)POKEXW/RHKE PA/MPOLU TH=S TW=N A)NQRW/PWN I)DE/AS. @&10Philo quaest. et solut. in Genesin IV 117 [1p. 336 Aucher]1. [1in-&10tellectum, sensus, corpus comparat cum vocalibus, semivocalibus, conso-&10nantibus]1. &10@Origenes contra Celsum I, 24 [1p. 341 Delarue]1 Vol. I p. 74, 10 Ko+.$10 E)MPI/PTEI EI)S TO\ PROKEI/MENON LO/GOS BAQU\S KAI\ A)PO/R)R(HTOS, O( PERI\ FU/SEWS O)NO-MA/TWN, PO/TERON, W(S OI)/ETAI *)ARISTOTE/LHS, QE/SEI E)STI\ TA\ O)NO/MATA H)\, <20W(S NOMI/-ZOUSIN OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S, FU/SEI>20, MIMOUME/NWN TW=N PRW/TWN FWNW=N TA\ PRA/GMATA, KAQ' W(=N TA\ O)NO/MATA, KAQO\ KAI\ STOIXEI=A/ TINA TH=S E)TUMOLOGI/AS EI)SA/GOUSIN. @&Diocles Magnes apud Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 57.$ TOU= DE\ LO/GOU @1 E)STI\ ME/RH PE/NTE, W(/S FHSI *DIOGE/NHS__KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20: O)/NOMA, PROSHGORI/A, R(H=MA, SU/NDESMOS, A)/RQRON. @&Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. plac. VIII 3 [1`232. 673 M.]1.$ TO\ AI)SQHTO\N TOUTI\ PU=R A)QRO/ON A)/QROISMA NOMI/ZEI SMIKRW=N EI)=NAI SWMA/-TWN, TO\ SXH=MA PA/NTWN E)XO/NTWN PURAMI/DOS. E)KEI/NWN OU)=N E(/KASTON STOIXEI=ON EI)=NAI/ FHSI TOU= PURO/S [1&sc. Plato$]1, W(S EI) KAI\ TOU= TW=N PURW=N SWROU= STOIXEI=ON E)/LEGEN EI)=NAI/ TIS E(/KASTON TW=N PURW=N. <20KATA\ DE\ TO\N AU)TO\N LO/GON KAI\ TA\ TH=S FWNH=S STOIXEI=A GENNA=N PRW=TON ME\N TA\S SULLABA/S, EI)=TA E)C AU)TW=N GENNA=SQAI TO/ TE O)/NOMA KAI\ TO\ R(H=MA KAI\ TH\N PRO/QESIN A)/RQRON TE KAI\ SU/NDESMON, A(\ PA/LIN O( *XRU/SIPPOS O)NOMA/ZEI TOU= LO/GOU STOIXEI=A>20. @&10Galenus de differentia pulsuum III 4 Vol. VIII p. 662.$ A)LLA\ KAI\ TO\ BLI/TURI, FASI\, KAI\ TO\ SKINDAYO\S A)/SHMA PANTELW=S E)STI. __TI/ LHREI=S, A)/NQRWPE, E(KW/N; KAI\ GA\R TO\ BLI/TURI KROU=MA/ TI DHLOI= KAI\ TO\ SKINDAYO\S OU)K OI)KE/TOU MO/NON, A)LLA\ KAI\ O)RGA/NOU TINO/S E)STIN O)/NOMA. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 8 Z. ed. Bas.$10 *OI)KEIOTE/RWS DE\ O( *)ARISTOTE/LHS <20SUNW/NUMA>20 KE/KLHKE TA\ SU\N TW=| O)NO/MATI KAI\ TO\N O(RISMO\N E)/XONTA TO\N AU)TO\N H)/PER <20OI( *STWI+KOI\ TA\ POLLA\ A(/MA E)/XONTA O)NO/MATA>20, W(S *PA/RIS KAI\ *)ALE/CANDROS O( AU)TO/S, KAI\ A(PLW=S TA\ POLUW/NUMA LEGO/MENA. @&Varro de lingua lat. IX 1&3 898989 nesciunt docere quam discere &3quae ignorant, in quo fuit Crates, nobilis grammaticus, qui fretus <21Chry-&3sippo>21, homine acutissimo, qui reliquit <20$PERI\ A)NWMALI/AS&>20 III libros, &contra analogiam atque Aristarchum est nixus, sed ita, ut scripta indi-&cant eius, ut neutrius videatur pervidisse voluntatem, quod et <21Chry-&sippus, de inaequabilitate cum scribit sermonis, propositum &habet ostendere similes res dissimilibus verbis et dissimiles &similibus esse vocabulis notatas>21, id quod est verum etc. @&Gellius N. A. XI 12.&3 <21Chrysippus>21 ait, omne verbum am-&3biguum natura esse, quoniam ex eodem duo vel plura accipi possunt, &3Diodorus autem, cui Crono cognomentum fuit "1nullum"2, inquit, "1verbum &3est ambiguum, nec quisquam ambiguum dicit aut sentit, nec aliud dici &3videri debet, quam quod se dicere sentit is, qui dicit& etc."2 @&Galenus de sophismatis ex elocutione 4. Vol. XIV p. 595 K.$ *EI)/RHTAI DE/ TINA KAI\ TOI=S *STWI+KOI=S PERI\ TOU/TWN, [2A(\ KATA\]2 ME/ROS DI/-KAION E)PELQOU=SIN I)DEI=N, EI)/ TIS E)/CW PI/PTEI TRO/POS TW=N EI)RHME/NWN. EI)/H GA\R [2A)/N]2 E)PAGWG[2IK]2H/ TIS AU(/TH PI/STIS: KAI\ DI/KAION A)/LLWS, MHDEMI/AN @1 DO/CAN A)NDRW=N EU)DOKI/MWN PA/RERGON TI/QESQAI. *TO\N ME\N OU)=N TH=S A)M-FIBOLI/AS O(/RON, EI) KAI\ PRO\S POLLA\ TW=N H(METE/RWN MA/XESQAI DOKEI=, TO/ GE NU=N E)ATE/ON: E(TE/RAS GA\R KAI\ U(PE\R TOU/TWN SKOPEI=N PRAGMATEI/AS E)STI/: <20TA\S DE\ DIAFORA\S TW=N LEGOME/NWN A)MFIBOLIW=N>20 AU)TA\S LHPTE/ON. *EI)SI/ GE PRO\S TW=N XARIESTE/RWN LEGO/MENAI TO\N A)RIQMO\N O)KTW/: <20MI/A ME\N>20 H(\N KOINH\N O)NOMA/ZOUSI TOU= TE EI)RHME/NOU KAI\ TOU= DIAI-RETOU=, OI(/A E)STI\N H( AU)LHTRI\S PESOU=SA: KOINH\ GA\R AU(/TH TOU= TE AU)LH-TRI\S O)NO/MATOS KAI\ TOU= EI)RHME/NOU. <20DEUTE/RA>20 DE\ PARA\ TH\N E)N TOI=S A(PLOI=S [2O(MWNUMI/AN]2, OI(=ON "3A)NDREI=OS"3. H)\ GA\R XITW\N H)\ A)/NQRWPOS. TRI/TH DE\ PARA\ TH\N E)N TOI=S SUNQE/TOIS O(MWNUMI/AN, OI(=ON "1A)/NQRWPO/S E)STIN"2. A)MFI/BOLOS GA\R O( LO/GOS, EI)/TE TH\N OU)SI/AN EI)/TE TH\N PTW=SIN EI)=NAI SHMAI/NEI. <20TETA/RTH DE/>20 E)STI PARA\ TH\N E)/LLEIYIN, W(S "1O(/ E)STI/ SOU"2: KAI\ GA\R E)LLEI/PEI TO\ DIA\ ME/SON, OI(=ON DESPO/TOU H)\ PATRO/S. <20PE/MPTH>20 DE\ PARA\ TO\N PLEONASMO/N, W(/SPER H( TOIAU/TH "1A)PHGO/REUSEN AU)TW=| MH\ PLEI=N"2. TO\ GA\R "1MH\"2 PROSKEI/MENON A)MFI/DOCON POIEI= TO\ PA=N EI)/TE TO\ PLEI=N A)PHGO/REUSEN EI)/TE TO\ MH\ PLEI=N. <20E(/KTHN>20 FASI\N EI)=NAI TH\N MH\ DIASAFOU=SAN TI/ META\ TI/NOS A)/SHMON MO/RION TE/TAKTAI, W(S E)N TW=| [1&Il.$ *Y& 382$]1 "1KAI\ NU/ KEN H)\ PARE/LASSEN"2. TO\ GA\R STOIXEI=ON %2%2 A)\N MH\ %2%2 GE/NOITO DIAZEUKTIKO/N. <20E(BDO/MH>20 DE/ E)STIN H( MH\ DHLOU=SA TI/ META\ TI/NOS TE/TAKTAI SHMANTIKO\N MO/RION. W(S E)N TW=| "1PENTH/KONT' A)NDRW=N E(KATO\N LI/PE DI=OS *)AXILLEU/S"2. <20O)GDO/H>20 H( MH\ DHLOU=SA TI/ E)PI\ TI/ A)NAFE/RETAI, W(S E)N TW=| "1*DI/WN *QE/WN E)STI/N"2. A)/DHLON GA/R E)STIN EI)/TE E)PI\ TH\N A)M-FOTE/RWN U(/PARCIN A)NAFE/RETAI, EI)/TE E)PI\ TOIOU=TON, OI(=ON "1O( *DI/WN *QE/WN E)STI/N"2 H)\ PA/LIN. _*OI( ME\N DH\ TRO/POI PRO\S TW=N XARIESTE/RWN OU(=TOI KATHRI/QMHNTAI_TO\ D' A)ME/QODO/N TE KAI\ A)/TEXNON PRO/DHLON [1&quod plu-&ribus ostendit Galenus]1. &@Varro de lingua lat. VI 1.&3 In hoc dicam de vocabulis tem-&3porum et earum rerum quae in agendo fiunt aut dicuntur cum tempore &3aliquo ut "1sedetur"2, "1ambulatur"2, "1loquantur"2; atque si quae erunt ex &3diverso genera adiuncta, potius cognationi verborum quam auditori co-&3lumnianti geremus morem. Huius rei auctor satis mihi <21Chrysippus &3et Antipater ...... qui omnes verba ex verbis ita declinari &3scribunt, ut verba litteras alia assumant, alia mittant, alia &3commutent>21 &etc. &@Varro de lingua lat. X 59.&3 Nam nonnunquam alterum ex &3altero videtur, ut <21Chrysippus>21 scribit, quem admodum pater ex filio et @1 &3filius ex patre, neque minus in fornicibus propter sinistram dextra stat, &3quam propter dextram sinistra. Quapropter et ex rectis casibus obliqui &3et ex obliquis recti et ex singularibus multitudinis et ex multitudinis &3singulares nonnunquam recuperari possunt. @&Scholia in Hom. Iliad.$ *D& 295.$ A)LA/STWR KAI\ O( A(MARTWLO\S H)\ KATA\ <20*XRU/SIPPON>20 O( FONEU\S DIA\ TO\ A)/CIOS EI)=NAI A)LA=SQAI O(/ E)STI PLANA=SQAI. @&Lexicon apud Bekk. Anecd. Gr. I 374.$ A)LA/STWR: O( A(MAR-TWLO/S. H)\ O( FONIKO\S DAI/MWN: KAI\ KATA\ ME\N <20*XRU/SIPPON>20 TO\N FILO/SO-FON A)PO\ TH=S E)LA/SEWS, O( A)/CIOS E)LAU/NESQAI DIA\ FO/NON: KATA\ DE\ *)APOL-LO/DWRON A)PO\ TOU= A)LITEI=N &etc. &@Etymologicum Magn. s. v.$ A)LA/STWR__KATA\ ME\N *XRU/-SIPPON TO\N FILO/SOFON E)PI\ TOU= A(MARTWLOU= KAI\ FONE/WS, A)PO\ TH=S E)LA/SEWS, O( A)/CIOS TOU= E)LAU/NESQAI DIA\ FO/NON. @&Etymologicum Orion. s. v.$ A)GKW/N: __*XRU/SIPPOS DE\ E)GKW/N, A)PO\ TOU= E)GKEI=SQAI TW=| E(TE/RW| O)STE/W| TO\ E(/TERON. @&Etymologicum Magn. s. v.$ DIDA/SKW &p. 272, 18.$ *(HRWDIANO\S DE\ LE/GEI O(/TI <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 FHSI\ PARA\ TO\ A)SKEI=N TO\ SHMAI=NON TO\ DI-DA/SKEIN: TI\ A)SKW=, DIA/SKW: KAI\ E)PENQE/SEI TOU= D DIDA/SKW. @&Etymologicum Magn. s. v.$ PALAISTH/ &p. 647, 34.$ *LE/GETAI SPIQAMH\ PARA\ TO\ A)POSPASMO\N POIEI=N, DIA\ TO\N A)POSPASMO\N TO\N A)PO\ TOU= MEGA/LOU DAKTU/LOU, TOU= A)NTI/XEIROS, PRO\S TO\ TOU= MIKROU= A)/KRON. W(S DE\ *XRU/SIPPOS DIA\ TO\ SPA=SQAI TH\N O(/LHN XEI=RA. @&Etymologicum Gud. s. v.$ BA/NAUSOS__*XRU/SIPPOS DE\ A)PO\ TOU= TEXNI/TAS [1&leg.$ TOI=S TEXNI/TAIS]1 TH\N PRO\S TO\N BI/ON E)GGI/NESQAI KAI\ PORI/ZESQAI .... [1&excidit substantivum]1. &@Varro de lingua lat. VI 11.&3 Aevum ab aetate omnium an-&3norum; hinc aeviteruum, quod factum est aeteruum: <21quod Graeci>21$ <20AI)W=NA>20, &3<21id ait Chrysippus esse>21$ <20A)EI\ O)/N>20. @&10Ammonius in Aristot. de interpr. p. 42, 30 Busse.$10 <20PERI\ TH=S KAT' EU)QEI=AN GINOME/NHS TW=N O)NOMA/TWN PROFORA=S EI)/WQE PARA\ TOI=S PALAIOI=S ZHTEI=SQAI, PO/TERON PTW=SIN AU)TH\N PROSH/KEI KALEI=N>20 H)\ OU)-DAMW=S, A)LLA\ TAU/THN ME\N O)/NOMA, W(S KAT' AU)TH\N E(KA/STOU TW=N PRAGMA/TWN O)NOMAZOME/NOU, TA\S DE\ A)/LLAS PTW/SEIS O)NO/MATOS A)PO\ TOU= METASXHMATISMOU= TH=S EU)QEI/AS GINOME/NAS. TH=S ME\N OU)=N DEUTE/RAS PROI/+STATAI DO/CHS O( *)ARISTOTE/LHS __TH=S DE\ PROTE/RAS <20OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 KAI\ W(S TOU/TOIS A)KOLOUQOU=NTES OI( TH\N GRAMMATIKH\N METIO/NTES TE/XNHN. LEGO/NTWN DE\ PRO\S AU)TOU\S TW=N *PERIPATH-TIKW=N__"1TH\N EU)QEI=AN KATA\ TI/NA LO/GON PTW=SIN O)NOMA/ZEIN DI/KAION, W(S A)PO\ TI/NOS PESOU=SAN;"2 __A)POKRI/NONTAI <20OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 W(S A)PO\ TOU= NOH/MA-TOS TOU= E)N TH=| YUXH=| KAI\ AU(/TH PE/PTWKEN: O(\ GA\R E)N E(AUTOI=S E)/XOMEN TOU= *SWKRA/- @1TOUS NO/HMA DHLW=SAI BOULO/MENOI TO\ "1*SWKRA/THS"2 O)/NOMA PROFERO/MEQA: KAQA/-PER OU)=N TO\ A)/NWQEN A)FEQE\N GRAFEI=ON KAI\ O)RQO\N PAGE\N PEPTWKE/NAI TE LE/-GETAI KAI\ TH\N PTW=SIN O)RQH\N E)SXHKE/NAI, TO\N AU)TO\N TRO/PON KAI\ TH\N EU)QEI=AN PEPTWKE/NAI ME\N A)CIOU=MEN A)PO\ TH=S E)NNOI/AS, O)RQH\N DE\ EI)=NAI DIA\ TO\ A)RXE/TUPON TH=S KATA\ TH\N E)KFW/NHSIN PROFORA=S. @&10Scholia in Dionys. Thrac. Bekker Anecd. Gr. II p. 891.$10 *TO\N E)NE-STW=TA <20OI( *STWI+KOI\ E)NESTW=TA PARATATIKO\N O(RI/ZONTAI>20 O(/TI PARATEI/NETAI KAI\ EI)S ME/LLONTA: O( GA\R LE/GWN "1POIW="2 KAI\ O(/TI E)POI/HSE/ TI E)MFAI/NEI KAI\ O(/TI POIH/SEI. @&10Sextus adv. math. VIII 11.$ H)=N DE\ KAI\ A)/LLH TIS PARA\ TOU/TOIS [1&10scil. apud dogmaticos$10]1 DIA/STASIS, KAQ' H(\N OI( ME\N PERI\ TW=| SHMAINOME/NW| TO\ A)LHQE/S TE KAI\ YEU=DOS U(PESTH/SANTO, OI( DE\ PERI\ TH=| FWNH=|, OI( DE\ PERI\ TH=| KINH/SEI TH=S DIANOI/AS. KAI\ DH\ TH=S ME\N PRW/THS DO/CHS PROESTH/KASIN OI( A)PO\ <20TH=S *STO-A=S>20, TRI/A FA/MENOI SUZUGEI=N A)LLH/LOIS, TO/ TE SHMAINO/MENON KAI\ TO\ SHMAI=NON KAI\ TO\ TUGXA/NON, W(=N <20SHMAI=NON>20 ME\N EI)=NAI TH\N FWNH/N, OI(=ON TH\N "1*DI/WN"2, <20SHMAI-NO/MENON>20 DE\ AU)TO\ TO\ PRA=GMA TO\ U(P' AU)TH=S DHLOU/MENON KAI\ OU(= H(MEI=S ME\N A)N-TILAMBANO/MEQA TH=| H(METE/RA| PARUFISTAME/NOU DIANOI/A|, OI( DE\ BA/RBAROI OU)K E)PAI/+-OUSI KAI/PER TH=S FWNH=S A)KOU/ONTES, <20TUGXA/NON>20 DE\ TO\ E)KTO\S U(POKEI/MENON, W(/SPER AU)TO\S O( *DI/WN. TOU/TWN DE\ DU/O ME\N EI)=NAI SW/MATA, KAQA/PER TH\N FWNH\N KAI\ TO\ TUGXA/NON, <20E(\N DE\ A)SW/MATON, W(/SPER TO\ SHMAINO/MENON PRA=GMA, KAI\ LEKTO/N>20, O(/PER A)LHQE/S TE GI/NETAI H)\ YEU=DOS. KAI\ TOU=TO OU) KOINW=S PA=N, A)LLA\ TO\ ME\N E)LLIPE\S TO\ DE\ AU)TOTELE/S. KAI\ TOU= AU)TOTELOU=S TO\ KALOU/MENON A)CI/WMA, O(/PER KAI\ U(POGRA/FONTE/S FASIN "1A)CI/WMA/ E)STIN O(/ E)STIN A)LHQE\S H)\ YEU=DOS"2. @&10Sextus adv. math. VIII 80.$10 PA=N TE LEKTO\N LE/GESQAI DEI=, O(/QEN KAI\ TAU/THS E)/TUXE TH=S PROSHGORI/AS. __LE/GEIN GA/R E)STI, KAQW\S AU)TOI/ FASIN <20OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20, TO\ TH\N TOU= NOOUME/NOU PRA/GMATOS SHMANTIKH\N PROFE/-RESQAI FWNH/N &10etc. @&10Ammonius in Aristot. de interpret. p. 17, 24.$10 O( *)ARISTOTE/LHS DI-DA/SKEI DIA\ TOU/TWN, TI/NA E)STI\ TA\ PROHGOUME/NWS KAI\ PROSEXW=S U(P' AU)TW=N SH-MAINO/MENA [1&10scil.$10 U(PO\ TW=N FWNW=N]1, KAI\ O(/TI TA\ NOH/MATA, DIA\ DE\ TOU/TWN ME/-SWN TA\ PRA/GMATA, KAI\ OU)DE\N E(/TERON DEI= PARA\ TAU=TA E)PINOEI=N <20ME/SON TOU= TE NOH/MATOS KAI\ TOU= PRA/GMATOS, O(/PER OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S U(POTIQE/-MENOI LEKTO\N H)CI/OUN O)NOMA/ZEIN>20. @&10Scholia in Hom. Iliad. B. 349.$10 YEU=DOS%10 A)NTI\ TOU= YEUDH/S. TAU=TA DE\ PARA\ TOI=S <20*STWI+KOI=S>20 LEKTA\ KALEI=TAI TA\ PRO\S TH\N SHMASI/AN DI' A)/LLWN FERO/MENA. @&10Sextus adv. math. XI 224.$10 TO\ ME\N OU)=N SW=MA OU) DIDA/SKETAI, KAI\ MA/LISTA <20KATA\ TOU\S A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20: LEKTA\ GA/R E)STI TA\ DIDASKO/MENA, SW=MA D' OU)K E)/STI TA\ LEKTA/. @1 @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 11 p. 1037d.$ *AU)TOI/ GE MH\N LE/GOUSI, TOU\S A)PAGOREU/ONTAS A)/LLO ME\N LE/GEIN, A)/LLO D' A)PAGO-REU/EIN, A)/LLO DE\ PROSTA/SSEIN: O( GA\R LE/GWN, *MH\ KLE/YH|S, LE/GEI ME\N AU)TO\ TOU=TO, *MH\ KLE/YH|S, A)PAGOREU/EI DE\ [2KLE/PTEIN, PROSTA/SSEI DE\]2 MH\ KLE/PTEIN. @&Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 98$ *G &ed. Bas.$ A)LL' E)PEIDH\ SAFHNEI/AS E)/TUXEN H( TOU= *)ARISTOTE/LOUS LE/CIS, I)/DWMEN KAI\ O(/SA TW=| TO/PW| PROSECERGA/ZONTAI OI( KLEINO/TEROI TW=N E)CHGHTW=N. *TW=N GA\R <20*STWI+KW=N>20 ME/GA FRONOU/NTWN E)PI\ TH=| TW=N LOGIKW=N E)CERGASI/A|, E)/N TE TOI=S A)/LLOIS KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N E)NANTI/WN, SPOUDA/ZOUSI DEIKNU/NAI, O(/TI PA/NTWN TA\S A)FOR-MA\S O( *)ARISTOTE/LHS PARE/SXEN E)N E(NI\ BIBLI/W|, O(\ PERI\ A)NTIKEIME/NWN E)PE/-GRAYEN, E)N W(=| KAI\ A)PORIW=N E)STI PLH=QOS A)MH/XANON, W(=N O)LI/GHN E)KEI=NOI MOI=RAN PARE/QENTO: KAI\ TA\ ME\N A)/LLA E)N EI)SAGWGH=| PAREMBALEI=N OU)K EU)/LOGON. O(/SA DE\ SUMFW/NWS OI( <20*STWI+KOI\>20 TW=| *)ARISTOTE/LEI DIETA/CANTO, TAU=TA R(HTE/ON. <20*(/OROU TOI/NUN PALAIOU= PERI\ TW=N E)NANTI/WN KATA-BEBLHME/NOU>20, OU(= KAI\ E)/MPROSQEN E)MNHMONEU/SAMEN, <20O(/TI O(/SA E)STI\N E)N TW=| AU)TW=| GE/NEI PLEI=STON A)LLH/LWN DIAFE/REI>20, H)QE/THKE TO\N O(/RON O( *)ARISTOTE/LHS E)N TW=| PERI\ TW=N A)NTIKEIME/NWN, POLUEIDW=S BASANI/SAS AU)-TO/N. __*XRHSAME/NOU DE\ O(/MWS TW=| O(/RW| TOU/TW| E)N TW=| PERI\ TOU= POSOU= LO/GW| META\ TOU= E)PISHMH/NASQAI O(/TI PALAIO\S O( O(/ROS, <20OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S PARALABO/NTES AU)TO\N E)XRH/SANTO>20, TO\ ME\N SAQRO\N AU)TOU= PARADEI-KNU/ONTES, PEIRW/MENOI DE\ O(/MWS LU/EIN TA\ DOKOU=NTA A)/TOPA. __TOU/-TOIS OU)=N OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S E)XRH/SANTO PA=SIN KAI\ [2E)N]2 TOI=S A)/LLOIS DIORISMOI=S TOI=S PERI\ TW=N E)NANTI/WN *)ARISTOTE/LEI KATA\ PO/DAS H)KOLOU/-QHSAN, E)KEI/NOU TA\S A)FORMA\S AU)TOI=S DEDWKO/TOS E)N TW=| PERI\ TW=N A)NTI-KEIME/NWN SUGGRA/MMATI A(\S E)CEIRGA/SANTO E)N TOI=S AU(TW=N BIBLI/OIS. @&Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 98 E. ed. Bas.$ KAI\ GA\R KAI\ TA\S E(/CEIS E)NANTI/AS U(PE/LABON, W(S E)KEI=NOS [1&scil. Aristoteles$]1, OI(=ON FRO/-NHSIN A)FROSU/NHN, KAI\ TA\ KATHGORH/MATA, W(/SPER TO\ FRONEI=N KAI\ A)FRAI/- @1NEIN, KAI\ TA\S MESO/THTAS, OI(=ON TO\ FRONI/MWS H)\ A)FRO/NWS. TOU\S ME/NTOI POIOU\S KAI\ PW=S E)/XONTAS OU)KE/TI U(PE/LABON E)NANTI/OUS, A)LL' E)NANTI/WS E)/XEIN, KAI\ [2OU)]2 TOU=TON TOU/TW| A)LL' A)ME/SWS TO\N FRO/NIMON TW=| A)/FRONI LE/GOUSIN. E)A\N DE/ POTE KAI\ LE/GWMEN TOU=TON TOU/TW| E)NANTI/ON EI)=NAI, E)PI\ TA\ A)/MESA [2BLE/PONTES]2 POIOU/MEQA TH\N SHMASI/AN, W(/S FASI. <20KURIW/TATA ME\N OU)=N E)PI\ TW=N E(/CEWN>20 KAI\ <20TW=N SXE/SEWN KAI\ TW=N E)NERGEIW=N KAI\ TW=N TOU/TOIS PARAPLHSI/WN H( E)NANTI/WSIS QEW-REI=TAI. DEU/TERON DE\ W(S E)NANTI/A LE/GETAI TA\ KATHGORH/MATA KAI\ TA\ KATHGOROU/MENA/ PWS E)KEI/NOIS>20. PROSA/GEI DE\ A(MW=S GE/ PWS PRO\S TA\ E)NANTI/A KAI\ TO\ FRONI/MWS KAI\ A)FRO/NWS. <20O(/LWS DE\ E)N TOI=S PRA/GMASI TA\ E)NANTI/A QEWREI=TAI>20, KAI\ H( FRO/NHSIS TH=| A)FROSU/NH| A)ME/SWS OU(/TWS E)NANTI/A LE/GETAI, OU)X H(/DE TH=|DE: TOIAU/THS DE\ OU)/SHS TH=S *STWI+KH=S DIDASKALI/AS, I)/DWMEN PW=S AU)TH\N A)PO\ TH=S *)ARISTOTE/LOUS PARADO/SEWS PARESPA/SANTO. @&Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 98$ *Z. &ed. Bas.$ O)/NTOS DE\ DU-NATOU= TO\ AU)TO\ KAI\ KAT' A)SU/NQETON FWNH\N EI)PEI=N, OI(=ON FRO/NHSIN A)FRO-SU/NHN, KAI\ DI' O(/ROU, OI(=ON E)PISTH/MHN A)GAQW=N KAI\ KAKW=N KAI\ OU)DE-TE/RWN KAI\ TH\N A)FROSU/NHN A)/GNOIAN TW=N AU)TW=N, ZHTOU=SI PO/TERO/N E)STI TA\ KATA\ TA\ A(PLA= MO/NON H)\ [2KAI\ TA\]2 KATA\ TOU\S O(/ROUS [2E)NANTI/A]2: KAI\ O(/ GE <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 E)FI/STHSI, MH/POTE TA\ PROSHGORIKA\ KAI\ A(PLA= MO/NON E)STI\N E)NANTI/A, TA\ DE\ OU)K E)/STI. POLLA\ GA\R E)N TOU/TOIS SUMPERILAM-BA/NOMEN KAI\ META\ A)/RQRWN KAI\ META\ SUNDE/SMWN KAI\ A)/LLWN DE\ MORI/WN E)CHGHTIKW=N [2PROFE/ROMEN]2 W(=N E(/KASTON EI)S TO\N TW=N E)NANTI/WN LO/GON A)LLOTRI/WS A)\N PARALAMBA/NOITO: DIO\ TH\N ME\N FRO/NHSIN TH=| A)FROSU/NH| FHSI\N EI)=NAI E)NANTI/ON, TO\N DE\ O(/RON TW=| O(/RW| OU)KE/TI O(MOEIDW=S E)NANTI/ON EI)=NAI/ FHSIN "1<20E)P' E)KEI=NA DE\ POIOU/MENOI TH\N A)NAFORA\N KAI\ TOU\S O(/ROUS KATA\ SUZUGI/AN A)NTITIQE/ASI>20."2 @&Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 102$ *Z. &ed. Bas.$ *KAI\ OI( <20A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 DE\ DII+SXURI/ZONTAI, O(/TI OU)DE\N TW=N KATA\ A)PO/FASIN LEGOME/-NWN OU)DENI/ E)STIN E)NANTI/ON: H)=N GA\R A)\N TH=| A)RETH=| E)NANTI/A H( OU)K A)RETH/, KAI\ TH=| KAKI/A| E)NANTI/A H( OU) KAKI/A, U(PO\ ME\N TH\N OU)K A)RETH\N KAI\ TH=S KAKI/AS PIPTOU/SHS KAI\ A)/LLWN POLLW=N [1KAI\ GA\R LI/QOU KAI\ I(/PPOU KAI\ PA/NTWN TW=N PARA\ TH\N A)RETH/N]1 U(PO\ DE\ TH\N OU) KAKI/AN KAI\ TH=S A)RETH=S KAI\ TW=N A)/LLWN PA/NTWN. E)/STAI OU)=N E(NI\ PA/NTA E)NANTI/A, KAI\ TA\ AU)TA\ TH=| A)RETH=| KAI\ TH=| KAKI/A| E)NANTI/A, EI) MH\ H( A)RETH\ TH=| KAKI/A| E)NANTI/A, A)LL' H( OU) KAKI/A: <20SUMBH/SETAI KAI\ SPOUDAI/OIS ME/SA E)NANTI/A EI)=NAI KAI\ FAU/LOIS, A)/TOPON DE\ TOU=TO>20, KAI\ MA/LISTA EI) KAI\ TA\ AU)TA\ KAI\ @1 MH/. *KAI\ TO\ DUOI=N E)NANTI/WN U(F' O(\ ME\N PA/NTA TA\ U(POPI/PTONTA POIO/-THTAS EI)=NAI, W(S U(PO\ TH\N A)RETH\N KAI\ TH\N KAKI/AN, U(F' O(\ DE\ KAI\ POIO/-THTAS KAI\ POIA/, W(S U(PO\ TH\N OU)K A)RETH\N KAI\ TH\N OU) KAKI/AN [1U(PO\ TAU/-TAS GA\R KAI\ POIO/THTES KAI\ POIA\ KAI\ E)NE/RGEIAI KAI\ PA=N O(TIOU=N E)STI]1 KAI\ TOU=TO/ E)STIN A)PEMFAI=NON. OU(/TWS ME\N OU)=N KAI\ PARA\ TOI=S <20*STWI+-KOI=S>20 DIW/RISTAI TA/ TE E)NANTI/A KAI\ TA\ A)POFATIKW=S A)NTIKEI/MENA. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 102$10 *D &10ed. Bas.$10 OI( GOU=N <20*STWI+KOI\>20 MO/NA TA\ A)POFATIKA\ TOI=S KATAFATIKOI=S A)NTIKEI=SQAI NOMI/ZOUSIN. @&10Bekkeri Anecd. gr. p. 484.$10 MHDE\ TO\ PRO\S TW=N *STWI+KW=N LEGO/MENON PARALEI/PWMEN, PAR' OI(=S E)STI/ TIS DIAFORA\ E)N TOI=S KATA\ FU/SIN DIEZEUGME/NOIS MAXOME/NOU KAI\ A)NTIKEIME/NOU: KAI\ H)=N MAXO/MENON TO\ MH\ DUNA/MENON KATA\ TO\ AU)TO\ PARALHFQH=NAI, U(PE\R OU(= KAI\ E)N TOI=S PROKEIME/NOIS EI)/RHTAI: "1H(ME/RA E)STI\N H)\ NU\C E)STI/N"2 H)\ "1FQE/GGOMAI H)\ SIGW="2 KAI\ E)/TI TA\ TOU/TOIS O(/MOIA. <20A)NTIKEI/-MENON DE\ TO\ PLEONA/ZON A)POFA/SEI>20 &10etc. @&Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 100 B. ed. Bas.$ E)/STI DE/ TIS STE/RHSIS KAI\ A)/LLH PARA\ TH\N FUSIKH/N, LE/GW DE\ PAR' H(\N E)PI\ TW=N PEFU-KO/TWN E)LE/GOMEN KAI\ O(/TE E)PEFU/KESAN, H(\N <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 H)QIKH\N KALEI=: A)XI/TWN GA\R KAI\ A)NUPO/DHTOS KAI\ A)NA/RISTOS SHMAI/NEI ME\N KAI\ YILH\N A)NAI/RESIN, SHMAI/NEI DE\ KAI\ PARE/MFASI/N TINA, O(/TE KAI\ KATA\ STE/RHSIN GI/NETAI. OU)/TE GA\R A)XI/TWNA TO\N BOU=N E)ROU=MEN, OU)/TE H(MA=S O(/TAN LOUW/-MEQA A)NUPODE/TOUS, KAI\ A)NARI/STOUS OU)/TE TOU\S O)/RNIQAS OU)/TE H(MA=S A(/MA TW=| H(ME/RAN GENE/SQAI, A)LLA\ DEI= SUNEMFAI/NESQAI TO\ EI)QISME/NON KAI\ O(/TE EI)/QISTAI TH\N STE/RHSIN. O)/NTOS GA\R E)/QOUS A)RISTA=N KATA/ TINA W(/RAN TETAGME/NHN O( U(PO\ TO\ E)/QOS W)/N, O(/TAN MH\ E)N TW=| XRO/NW| TW=| TETAGME/NW| A)RISTH/SH|, OU) FU/SEWS E)/MFASIN, A)LL' E)/QOUS KATA\ TH\N STE/RHSIN A)NAIREI=. EI)SI\N OU)=N A)E/XEIAI AI( ME\N TW=N FU/SEI, AI( DE\ TW=N KAT' E)/QOS, KAI\ A)NAI-RE/SEIS E)N OI(=S E(/KASTA KAI\ PE/FUKE KAI\ EI)/QISTAI. POLLA/KIS DE\ OU)K E)/QOUS A)LLA\ KAQH/KONTOS A)PO/PTWSIN E)MFAI/NEI H( STE/RHSIS, W(S E)PI\ TOU= A)/KLHTON DEIPNEI=N, O(/TAN PAREMFAI/NWMEN, O(/TI OU) KAQHKO/NTWS A)PH/NTHSEN OU)/TE KATA\ TO\ E)PIBA/LLON TOI=S E)/QESIN. E)/STI KAI\ A)/LLWS H( STE/RHSIS TW=N O(MW-NU/MWS LEGOME/NWN: KAI\ GA\R O(/TAN TI GE/NOS O(/LON MH\ H)=| PEFUKO/S TI E)/XEIN, E)STERH=SQAI LE/GOMEN E)KEI/NOU, O(\ MH\ PE/FUKEN E)/XEIN: OU(/TWS TA\ FUTA\ E)STERH=SQAI LE/GOMEN AI)SQH/SEWS TW=| MH\ PEFUKE/NAI E)/XEIN AI)/SQHSIN. KAI\ O(/TAN DE\ TA\ E)N TW=| GE/NEI TA\ ME\N H)=| PEFUKO/TA E)/XEIN, TA\ DE\ MH\ PEFUKO/TA, E)STERH=SQAI LE/GETAI TA\ MH\ PEFUKO/TA, W(/SPER E)N TW=| GE/NEI TW=N ZW/|WN O( A)SPA/LAC O)/YEWS. KAI\ MA=LLO/N GE TOU=TO LE/GOMEN H)\ E)PI\ TOU= PRO\S BI/AN A)FH|RH=SQAI. KURI/WS DE\ STE/RHSIS LE/GETAI E)PI\ TW=N PEFUKO/TWN ME\N E)/XEIN, MH\ E)XO/NTWN DE\ TO/TE O(/TE PEFU/KASI KAI\ O(/TE EI)W/QASI KAI\ E)NESTH/SANTO E)/XEIN, O(\ DH\ KAI\ A)NTI/QETON TH=| E(/CEI QEW- @1REI=TAI: KAI\ H( E)N TOU/TOIS A)NTI/QESIS KE/KLHTAI H( KATA\ E(/CIN KAI\ STE/RHSIN. __KAI\ TOU=TO DE\ I)STE/ON O(/TI E)NI/OTE ME\N OU) STERHTIKA\ O)NO/MATA STE/-RHSIN DHLOI=, W(S H( PENI/A TH\N STE/RHSIN TW=N XRHMA/TWN KAI\ O( TUFLO\S STE/RHSIN O)/YEWS. E)NI/OTE DE\ STERHTIKA\ O)NO/MATA OU) STE/RHSIN DHLOI=: TO\ GA\R A)QA/NATON, STERHTIKO\N E)/XON TO\ SXH=MA TH=S LE/CEWS, OU) SHMAI/NEI STE/RHSIN: OU) GA\R E)PI\ PEFUKO/TOS A)POQNH/SKEIN, EI)=TA MH\ A)POQNH/SKONTOS, XRW/MEQA TW=| O)NO/MATI. POLLH\ DE\ TARAXH/ E)STI KATA\ TA\S FWNA\S TA\S STERHTIKA/S. DIA\ GA\R TOU= KAI\ PROSAGOME/NWN AU)TW=N, W(/SPER A)/OI-KOS KAI\ A)NE/STIOS, <20SUMBAI/NEI POTE\ ME\N TAI=S A)POFA/SESI, POTE\ DE\ TOI=S E)NANTI/OIS SUMFU/RESQAI AU)TA\S>20 [1&sequuntur exempla$]1. POLLH=S D' OU)/SHS TH=S A)NWMALI/AS <20*XRU/SIPPOS ME\N E)N TOI=S PERI\ TW=N STE-RHTIKW=N>20 LEGOME/NOIS E)PECH=LQEN AU)TH/N, *)ARISTOTE/LEI DE\ OU) TOU=TO PROU)/-KEITO &etc. &@Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 101 E. ed. Bas.$ E(/CEWS DE\ KAI\ STERH/SEWS OU) DUNATO\N EI)S A)/LLHLA METABOLH\N GI/NESQAI. TUFLO/THS ME\N GA\R E)C O)/YEWS GI/NETAI, OU)KE/TI ME/NTOI KAI\ A)NA/PALIN. O(/QEN KAI\ O( <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 E)ZH/THSEN, EI) TUFLOU\S R(HTE/ON TOU\S U(POXUQE/NTAS, DUNA-ME/NOUS DE\ E)K PARAKENTH/SEWS A)NABLE/YAI, KAI\ E)F' W(=N TA\ BLE/FARA KE/KLEI-STAI. TH=S GA\R DUNA/MEWS OU)/SHS E)OIKE/NAI TW=| KATAMEMUKO/TI TOU\S O)FQAL-MOU\S H)\ TW=| KWLUOME/NW| O(RA=N DIA/ TI PARAPE/TASMA, OU(= A)FAIREQE/NTOS OU)DE\N KWLU/ETAI O(RA=N. DIO\ OU)DE\ A)PO\ STERH/SEWS EI)S E(/CIN GI/NETAI H( TOIAU/TH METABOLH/. LAMBA/NEI DE\ NU=N STE/RHSIN TH\N KATA\ PH/RWSIN. @&Simplicius in Aristot categ. f. 100 B. ed. Bas. [1Jamblichum &se exscribere significat ipse S.]1.$ KAI\ GA\R KAI\ TO\N <20*XRU/SIPPON>20 *)ARI-STOTE/LEI E(PO/MENON STERHTIKA\ LE/GEIN TAU=TA, O(/SA A)NAIREI= PAREMFAI/NONTA TH\N TOU= E)/XEIN FU/SIN, OU)X A(PLW=S, A)LL' O(/TAN E)MFAI/NH| TO\ PEFUKO\S KAI\ O(/TE PE/FUKEN_KAI\ A)NTI/KEITAI TH=| A)PO\ TOU= E)/XEIN LEGOME/NH| E(/CEI H( STE/-RHSIS, KAI\ OU) MO/NON POIOTH/TWN AI( STERH/SEIS, A)LLA\ KAI\ E)NERGEIW=N, W(S H( TUFLO/THS TH=S TOU= O(RA=N E)NERGEI/AS KAI\ H( XWLO/THS TH=S TOU= BADI/ZEIN. @&Papyrus Letronnii$ PERI\ A)POFATIKW=N [1&ed. Brunet Notices &et extraits de manuscrits de la bibliotheque imperiale. Tome XVIII &Paris 1865, Th. Bergk Opusc. II p. 114]1. &@I.$ [1E)ST]1IN O(/PER OU(/TW LE/GOI %5 [1A)/N TI]1S: "1*OU)K OI)=D' O(/PWS XRH\ [1TO\N S]1AFW=S KATEIDO/TA %5 [1TH=S *(H]1RAKLEI/AS FRONTI/%19%5[1DOS K]1ATHGOREI=N."2 *NAI\ @1 %5 [1OU) A)L]1HQE\S O)\N E)/LEGEN O( %5 [1POIHT]1H/S: "1*OU)K OI)=D' O(/PWS %5 [1XRH\ TO\N]1 SAFW=S KATEIDO/%5[1TA T]1H=S *(HRAKLEI/AS %5 [1FRONT]1I/DOS KATHGOREI=N."2 _%5[1*EI) OU)/TE]1 YEUDW=S OU)/%5[1TE A)LHQW=S]1 OU(/TW LE/GOI %5 [1TIS A)\N: "1TOI/ ME]1 CE/NON OU)DE\ %5 [1A)DAH/MO]1NA *MOUSA=N %5 [1E)PAI/DEUS]1AN KLUTAI\ %5 [1*QH=BAI"2 OU)K A)L]1HQE\S O)\N E)LE/%5[1XQH O(/PER LEX]1QEI/H A)\N OU(/TW %5 "1[1OU)/TOI ME]1 CE/NON OU)%5[1DE\ A)DA-H/M]1ONA *MOUSA=N E)%5[1PAI/DEUS]1AN KLUTAI\ *QH=BAI."2 %5 [1NAI/: OU)/]1TE YEUDW=S %5 [1OU)/T' A)LHQW=S]1 OU(/TW LE/GOI %5 [1TIS A)/N: "1TOI/]1 ME CE/NON %5 [1OU)DE\ A)DAH/M]1ONA *MOU%5[1SA=N E)PAI/DEU]1SAN KLUTAI\ [1*QH=BAI."2 NAI\ O]1U): A)LHQE\S E)%5[1LE/XQH O(/PER]1 LEXQEI/H A)\N &II.$ OU(/TWS: "1OU)/TOI ME CE/NON OU)DE\ %5 A)DAH/MONA *MOUSA=N E)PAI/%5DEUSAN KLUTAI\ *QH=BAI."2 &`3.$ *EI) A)LHQW=S TIS TW=N POIH%5TW=N OU(/TWS A)PEFAI/NETO %5 @"1*OU)/ MOI *SARDANA/PALLOS A)RE/SKEI TH\N DIA/NOIAN"2 A)NTI/KEITAI A)CI/WMA KATAFATIKO\N TW=|: @"1*OU)/ MOI_DIA/NOIAN"2 NAI\ OU) A)NTI/KEITAI A)CI/WMA KATAFATIKO\N TW=|: @"1*OU)/ MOI_DIA/NOIAN."2 NAI\ OU) A)LHQW=S TIS TW=N POIHTW=N OU(/TWS A)PEFAI/NETO: @"1*OU)/ MOI_DIA/NOIAN."2 &`4.$ *EI) A)PEFH/NATO/ TIS: [1&trag. fr. adesp. 83 Nauck$]1 @"1*OU)K H)=N A)/R' OU)QE\N PH=M' E)LEUQE/RAN DA/KNON @*YUXH\N O(MOI/WS A)NDRO\S W(S A)TIMI/A."2 A)NTI/KEITAI A)CI/WMA KATAFATIKO\N TW=|: @"1*OU)K H)=N__A)TIMI/A."2 NAI\ OU) A)PEFH/NATO/ TIS: @"1*OU)K H)=N__A)TIMI/A."2 &`5.$ [1*EI) A)LHQW=S]1 OU(/TWS A)PE/FASKEN *EU)RIPI/DHS: [1&Iphig. Aul. 28$]1 @"1*OU)K A)/GAMAI TAU=T' A)NDRO\S A)RISTE/WS."2 A)NTI/KEITAI A)CI/WMA KATAFATIKO\N TW=|: @"1*OU)K_A)RISTE/WS."2 NAI\ OU) A)NTI/KEITAI A)CI/WMA KATAFATIKO\N TW=| @"1*OU)K_A)RISTE/WS."2 NAI\ OU) A)PE/FASKEN OU(/TWS *EU)RIPI/DHS: @"1*OU)K_A)RISTE/WS."2 &`6.$ *EI) *)ANDROMA/XH *EU)RIPI/DOU PRO\S *(ERMIO/NHN TOU=TON A)PEFH/NATO TO\N TRO/PON: [1&Androm. 205$]1 @"1*OU)K E)C E)MW=N SE FARMA/KWN STUGEI= PO/SIS"2 A)NTI/KEITAI A)CI/WMA KATAFATIKO\N TW=|: @"1*OU)K E)C_PO/SIS"2 @1 NAI\ OU) A)NTI/KEITAI A)CI/WMA KATAFATIKO\N TW=|: @"1*OU)K E)C_PO/SIS"2 NAI\ OU) *)ANDROMA/XH *EU)RIPI/DOU PRO\S *(ERMIO/NHN A)PEFH/NATO TOU=TON TO\N TRO/PON: @"1*OU)K E)C_PO/SIS"2 &`7.$ *EI) A)LHQE/S E)STIN, O(/PER OU(/TW LEXQEI/H A)/N: [1&Eur. Stheneb. fr. 662 N.$]1 @"1*OU)K E)/STIN O(/STIS PA/NT' A)NH\R EU)DAIMONEI=."2 A)NTI/KEITAI A)CI/WMA KATAFATIKO\N TW=|: @"1*OU)K E)/STIN_EU)DAIMONEI=."2 NAI\ OU) A)NTI/KEITAI A)CI/WMA KATAFATIKO\N TW=|: @"1*OU)K E)/STIN_EU)DAIMONEI=."2 &V.$ NAI\ OU) A)LHQE/S E)STIN O(/PER OU(/TW LEXQEI/H A)/N: @"1*OU)K E)/STIN_EU)DAIMONEI=."2 &`8.$ *EI) A)LHQE\S O)\N E)/LEGEN *EU)RIPI/DHS: [1&inc. fab. fr. 896 N.$]1 @"1*OU)K E)N GUNAICI\ TOU\S NEANI/AS XREW/N, @A)LL' E)N SIDH/RW| KA)N O(/PLOIS TIMA\S E)/XEIN."2 A)NTI/KEITAI A)CI/WMA KATAFATIKO\N TW=|: @"1*OU)K E)N_TIMA\S E)/XEIN."2 NAI\ OU) A)NTI/KEITAI A)CI/WMA KATAFATIKO\N TW=|: @"1*OU)K E)N_TIMA\S E)/XEIN."2 NAI\ OU) A)LHQE\S O)\N E)/LEGEN *EU)RIPI/DHS: @"1*OU)K E)N_TIMA\S E)/XEIN."2 &`9.$ *EI) POIHTH/S TIS OU(/TWS A)PEFH/NATO: [1&lyr. fr. adesp. 5 Bgk.]1 &VI.$ "1*OU) MOI E)/T' EU)KELA/DWN U(/MNWN ME/LEI OU)D' E)/TI MOLPH=S."2 FA/SIS E)STI\N O(/PER OU(/TW LEXQEI/H A)/N: @"1MOI E)/T'__MOLPH=S."2 NAI\ OU) FA/SIS E)STI\N O(/PER OU(/TW LEXQEI/H A)/N: @"1MOI E)/T'_MOLPH=S."2 NAI\ OU) POIHTH/S TIS OU(/TWS A)PEFH/NATO: @"1OU)/ MOI E)/T'_MOLPH=S."2 *EI) POIHTH/S TIS OU(/TWS A)PEFH/NATO: @"1*OU)/ MOI E)/T'_MOLPH=S."2 A)NTI/KEITAI TW=|: @"1*OU)/ MOI E)/T'_MOLPH=S."2 A)CI/WMA KATAFATIKO/N. *NAI\ OU) A)NTI/KEITAI TW=|: @"1*OU)/ MOI E)/T'_MOLPH=S."2 A)CI/WMA KATAFATIKO/N. *NAI\ OU) POIHTH/S TIS OU(/TWS A)PEFH/NATO: @"1*OU)/ MOI E)/T'_MOLPH=S."2 &`10.$ *EI) *KU/KLWY O( TOU= *TIMOQE/OU PRO/S TINA OU(/TWS A)PEFH/NATO: @1 &VII. [1Timoth. fr. 4$]1 @"1*OU)/TOI TO/N G' U(PERAMPE/XONT' OU)RANO\N EI)SANABH/SEI."2 A)NTI/KEITAI E(NI\ KATAFATIKW=| A)CIW/MATI DU/O A)POFATIKA\ A)CIW/MATA. NAI\ OU) A)NTI/KEITAI E(NI\ KATAFATIKW=| A)CIW/MATI DU/O A)POFATIKA\ A)CIW/MATA. NAI\ OU) *KU/KLWY O( TOU= *TIMOQE/OU PRO/S TINA OU(/TWS A)PEFH/NATO: @"1*OU)/TOI TO/N_EI)SANABH/SEI."2 &`11.$ *EI) OU(/TWS A)PEFH/NATO/ TIS: [1&trag. fr. adesp. 78 N.$]1 @"1*OU)K OI)=DA: TA)LHQE\S GA\R A)SFALE\S FRA/SAI."2 A)POFAI/NOIT' A)/N TIS: @"1[OU)K] OI)=DA_FRA/SAI."2 NAI\ OU) A)POFAI/NOIT' A)/N TIS: @"1[K] OI)=DA_FRA/SAI."2 NAI\ OU) OU(/TWS A)PEFAI/NETO/ TIS: @"1OU)K OI)=DA_FRA/SAI."2 &`12.$ *EI) OU(/TWS A)POFAI/NOIT' A)/N TIS: [1&Thesp. fr. 2 N.]1 &VIII.$ "1[K] E)CAQRH/SAS OI)=D': I)DW\N DE/ SOI LE/GW."2 *QE/SPIS O( POIHTH\S OU(/TWS A)PE/FASKEN: @"1OU)K E)CAQRH/SAS OI)=D': I)DW\N DE/ SOI LE/GW."2 NAI\ OU) OU(/TWS A)POFAI/NOIT' A)/N TIS: @"1[K] E)CAQRH/SAS OI)=D': I)DW\N DE/ SOI LE/GW."2 NAI\ OU) *QE/SPIS O( POIHTH\S OU(/TWS A)PE/FASKEN: @"1OU)K E)CAQRH/SAS OI)=D': I)DW\N DE/ SOI LE/GW."2 &`13.$ *EI) *SAPFW\ OU(/TWS A)PEFH/NATO: [1&fr. 69 Bgk.$]1 @"1OU)D' I)/AN DOKI/MOIMI PROSIDOI=SAN FA/OS A(LI/W @E)/SSESQAI SOFI/AN PARQE/NON EI)S OU)DE/NA PW XRO/NON @TOIAU/TAN."2 A)NTI/KEITAI A)CI/WMA KATAFATIKO\N TW=|: @"1OU)D' I)/AN___TOIAU/TAN."2 NAI\ OU) A)NTI/KEITAI A)CI/WMA KATAFATIKO\N TW=|: &IX.$ "1OU)D' I)/AN___TOIAU/TAN."2 NAI\ OU) *SAPFW\ OU(/TWS A)PEFAI/NETO: @"1OU)D' I)/AN___TOIAU/TAN."2 &`14.$ *EI) OU) A)NTI/KEITAI A)CI/WMA KATAFATIKO\N TW=|: [1&Ibyc. fr. 27 Bgk.$]1 @"1OU)K E)/STIN A)POFQIME/NOIS ZWA=S E)/TI FA/RMAKON EU(REI=N."2 OU)K [O(] *)/IBUKOS O( POIHTH\S OU(/TWS A)[1PE]1FAI/NET[1O]1: @"1OU)K E)/STIN___EU(REI=N."2 NAI\ OU) A)NTI/KEITAI A)CI/WMA KATAFATIKO\N TW=|: @"1OU)K E)/STIN___EU(REI=N."2 @1 NAI\ OU) *)/IBUKOS O( POIHTH\S OU(/TWS A)PEFAI/NETO: @"1OU)K E)/STIN___EU(REI=N."2 &`15.$ *EI) OU) EI)SI\N A)MFI/BOLOI DIA/LEKTOI, OU) *EU)RIPI/DHS OU(/TWS A)POFHNA/-MENOS: [1&Eur. Dictys fr. 344 N.$]1 @"1OU)K A)\N GE/NOITO XRHSTO\S E)K KAKOU= PATRO/S."2 [A)PE/FASKEN: @"1A)\N GE/NOITO_PATRO/S."2 NAI\ OU) EI)SI\N A)MFI/BOLOI DIA/LEKTOI: NAI\ OU) *EU)RIPI/DHS, OU(/TWS A)PO-FHNA/MENOS: @"1OU)K A)\N GE/NOITO_PATRO/S."2 A)PE/FASKEN: @"1A)\N GE/NOITO_PATRO/S."2 ______________ &`16.$ *EI) H)\ YEU=DOS H)\ A)LHQE/S E)STIN, O(\ E)LE/XQH U(P' *EU)RIPI/DOU TO\N TRO/PON TOU=TON: [1&Eur. Hel. 1261$]1 @"1OU)X W(=DE NAU/TAS O)LOME/NOUS TUMBEU/OMEN."2 &X.$ A)NTI/]KEITAI A)CI/WMA KATAFATIKO\N TW=|: @"1OU)X W(=DE__TUMBEU/OMEN."2 NAI\ OU) A)NTI/KEITAI A)CI/WMA KATAFATIKO\N TW=|: @"1OU)X W(=DE__TUMBEU/OMEN."2 NAI\ OU)/TE YEU=DOS OU)/TE A)LHQE/S E)STIN [1O(\ E)LE/XQH]1 U(P' *EU)RIPI/DOU TO\N TRO/PON TOU=TON: @"1OU)X W(=DE__TUMBEU/OMEN."2 &`17.$ [1*EI)]1 A)LHQW=S *EU)RIPI/DHS [1E)/L]1EGEN: [1&Eur. Phoenix fr. 814 N.$]1 @"1OU)K E)/STI [1TOU= QR]1E/YANTOS H(/DION PE/DON."2 A)NTI/KEITAI A)CI/WMA KATAFATIKO\N TW=|: @"1OU)K E)/STI__PE/DON."2 NAI\ OU) A)NTI/KEITAI A)CI/WMA KATAFATIKO\N TW=|: @"1OU)K E)/STI__PE/DON."2 NAI\ OU) A)LHQW=S *EU)RIPI/DHS E)/LEGEN: @"1OU)K E)/STI__PE/DON."2 &`18.$ *EI) *EU)RIPI/DHS OU(/TWS A)PEFAI/NETO: [1&Eur. Suppl. 270$]1 @"1OU)K E)/STIN OU)QE\N DIA\ TE/LOUS EU)DAIMONEI=N."2 A)NTI/KEITAI A)CI/WMA KATAFATIKO\N TW=|: @"1OU)K E)/STIN_EU)DAIMONEI=N."2 NAI\ OU) A)NTI/KEITAI A)CI/WMA KATAFATIKO\N TW=|: @"1OU)K E)/STIN_EU)DAIMONEI=N."2 @1 NAI\ OU) *EU)RIPI/DHS OU(/TWS A)PEFAI/NETO: @"1OU)K E)/STIN_EU)DAIMONEI=N."2 &`19.$ *EI) OU(/TWS A)PEFAI/NETO/ TIS TW=N POIHTW=N: [1&trag. fr. adesp. 79 N.$]1 @"1OU)K A)CIW= MIK[1R]1W=N SE: MEGA/LA D' OU)K E)/XW."2 E)/STIN TIS O(\S OU(/TWS A)POFAI/NOIT' A)/N: @"1A)CIW= MIK[1R]1W=N_E)/XW."2 NAI\ OU) E)/STIN TIS O(\S OU(/TWS A)POFAI/NOIT' A)/N: @"1[K] A)CIW= MIK[1R]1W=N_E)/XW."2 NAI\ OU) A)PEFAI/NETO/ TIS TW=N POIHTW=N OU(/TWS: @"1OU)K A)CIW=__E)/XW."2 &`20.$ *EI) *)AGAME/MNWN OU(/TWS A)PE/FASKEN: [1&Cypriorum fr. 13 K.$]1 @"1OU)K E)FA/MHN *)AXILH=I XOLW/SEIN A)/LKIMON H)=TOR @W(=DE MA/L' E)KPA/GLWS, E)PEIDH\ MA/LA MOI FI/LOS H)/HN."2 A)CI/WMA/ E)STIN: @"1[K] E)FA/MHN *)AXILH=I__H)/HN."2 NAI\ OU)K A)CI/WMA/ E)STIN: @"1[K] E)FA/MHN *)AXILH=I__H)/HN."2 NAI\ OU) *)AGAME/MNWN OU(/TWS A)PE/FASKEN: @"1OU)K E)FA/MHN___H)/HN."2 &`21.$ *EI) *)ALKMA\N O( POIHTH\S OU(/TWS A)PEFAI/NETO: [1&Alcm. fr. 25$]1 @"1OU)K H)=S A)NH\R A)/GROIKOS OU)DE\ SKAIO/S."2 KATAFA/SKOI A)/N TIS: @"1[K] H)=S A)NH\R_SKAIO/S."2 NAI\ OU) KATAFA/SKOI A)/N TIS: @"1[K] H)=S A)NH\R_SKAIO/S."2 NAI\ OU)K *)ALKMA\N O( POIHTH\S OU(/TWS A)PEFAI/NETO: @"1OU)K H)=S__SKAIO/S."2 &`22.$ *EI) OU(/TWS A)POFAI/NOIT' A)/N TIS: [1&Anacr. fr. 15$]1 @"1[OU)] DHU)=T' E)/MPEDO/S EI)MI, @OU)D' A)STOI=SI PROSHNH/S,"2 OU) *)ANAKRE/WN OU(/TWS A)PEFH/NATO: @OU) DHU)=T'_PROSHNH/S: NAI\ OU) OU(/TWS A)POFAI/NOIT' A)/N TIS: @"1DHU)=T'__PROSHNH/S."2 NAI\ OU) *)ANAKRE/WN OU(/TWS A)PEFH/NATO: @"1OU) DHU)=T'__PROSHNH/S."2 &`23.$ *EI) *SAPFW\ OU(/TWS A)POFAINOME/NH: [1&Sappho fr. 36$]1 @"1OU)K OI)=D' O(/TTI QE/W: DU/O MOI TA\ NOH/MATA."2 @1 A)PE/FASKEN: @"1OI)=D' O(/TTI__NOH/MATA."2 EI)SI\N A)MFI/BOLOI DIA/LEKTOI. NAI\ OU) EI)SI\N A)MFI/BOLOI DIA/LEKTOI. NAI\ OU) *SAPFW\ OU(/TWS A)POFAINOME/NH: @"1OU)K OI)=D' O(/TTI__NOH/MATA."2 A)PE/FASKEN: @"1OI)=D' O(/TTI__NOH/MATA."2 *EI) *SAPFW\ OU(/TWS A)PE/FASKEN: @"1OU)K OI)=D'__NOH/MATA."2 E)/STIN TI KATAFATIKO\N A)CI/WMA A)NTIKEI/MENON TW=|: @"1OU)K OI)=D'__NOH/MATA."2 NAI\ OU) E)/STIN TI KATAFATIKO\N A)CI/WMA A)NTIKEI/MENON TW=|: @"1OU)K OI)=D'__NOH/MATA."2 NAI\ OU) *SAPFW\ OU(/TWS A)PE/FASKEN: @"1OU)K OI)=D'__NOH/MATA."2 &`24.$ *EI) POIHTH/S TIS OU(/TWS A)PEFAI/NETO: [1&lyr. fr. adesp. 106 Bgk.$]1 @"1OU)K EI)=DON A)NEMWKE/A KO/RAN."2 E)/STIN TI KATAFATIKO\N A)CI/WMA A)NTIKEI/MENON TW=|: @"1OU)K EI)=DON_KO/RAN."2 NAI\ OU) E)/STIN TI KATAFATIKO\N A)CI/WMA A)NTIKEI/MENON TW=|: @"1OU)"2 %17 @&tredecim versus desiderantur$ %5A KO/[1RAN!!!!!! %5 KATAFAT[1IKW=| DU/O A)CIW/]1%5MATA A)P[1OFATIKA\ A)N]1%5TI/-KEITAI !!!!!!!!%5DE/XETAI !!!!!!!!%5SIN KA)KEI=NA !!!!! %5 A)POFAIN!!!! !!!! %5 K EI)=DON A)NEMWKE/A KO/%5RAN A)POF!!!!!!!! %5 NEMWKE/A KO/RAN!!!! %5 TWN OU EID!!!! %5 @&10Diocles Magnes apud. Diog Lae%28rt. VII 63.$10 FASI\ DE\ [TO\] <20LEKTO\N>20 EI)=NAI TO\ KATA\ FANTASI/AN LOGIKH\N U(FISTA/MENON. TW=N DE\ LEKTW=N TA\ ME\N LE/-GOUSIN EI)=NAI <20AU)TOTELH=>20 OI( *STWI+KOI/, TA\ DE\ <20E)LLIPH=: E)LLIPH=>20 ME\N OU)=N E)STI TA\ A)NAPA/RTISTON E)/XONTA TH\N E)KFORA/N, OI(=ON "1GRA/FEI"2. E)PIZHTOU=MEN GA/R "1TI/S;"2 <20AU)TOTELH=>20 D' E)STI\ TA\ A)PHRTISME/NHN E)/XONTA TH\N E)KFORA/N, OI(=ON: "1GRA/FEI *SWKRA/THS"2. @&10Philo de agricultura %14 139. Vol. II p. 122, 18 Wendl.$10 O(/TI TW=N O)/NTWN TA\ ME/N E)STI <20SW/MATA>20, TA\ D' A)SW/MATA: KAI\ [2TW=N SWMA/TWN]2 TA\ ME\N A)/YUXA, TA\ DE\ YUXH\N E)/XONTA: KAI\ TA\ ME\N LOGIKA\, TA\ D' A)/LOGA: KAI\ TA\ ME\N QNHTA/, TA\ DE\ QEI=A: KAI\ TW=N QNHTW=N TO\ ME\N A)/R)R(EN, TO\ DE\ QH=LU, TA\ A)NQRW/-POU TMH/MATA. *KAI\ PA/LIN TW=N <20A)SWMA/TWN>20 TA\ ME\N <20TE/LEIA>20, TA\ D' A)TELH=: KAI\ TW=N <20TELEI/WN>20 TA\ ME\N E)RWTH/MATA KAI\ PU/SMATA, A)RATIKA/ TE AU)= KAI\ O(RKI- @1KA\ KAI\ O(/SAI A)/LLAI TW=N KAT' EI)=DOS E)N TAI=S PERI\ TOU/TWN STOIXEIW/SESIN A)NA-GRA/FONTAI DIAFORAI/. @*TA\ DE\ PA/LIN A(\ DIALEKTIKOI=S E)/QOS E)STI\N O)NOMA/ZEIN <20A)CIW/MATA>20: KAI\ TOU/-TWN TA\ ME\N A(PLA=, TA\ D' OU)X A(PLA=: KAI\ TW=N OU)X A(PLW=N TA\ ME\N SUNHMME/NA, TA\ DE\ PARASUNHMME/NA TO\ MA=LLON H)\ H(=TTON: KAI\ PROSE/TI DE\ DIEZEUGME/NA KAI\ A)/LLA TOIOUTO/TROPA: E)/TI D' A)LHQH= TE KAI\ YEUDH= KAI\ A)/DHLA, DUNATA/ TE KAI\ A)DU/NATA: [KAI\ TA\ ME\N FQARTA\ KAI\ A)/FQARTA,] KAI\ A)NAGKAI=A KAI\ OU)K A)NAG-KAI=A, KAI\ EU)/PORA/ TE KAI\ A)/PORA, KAI\ O(/SA SUGGENH= TOU/TOIS. @*PA/LIN DE\ TW=N <20A)TELW=N>20 AI( EI)S TA\ LEGO/MENA KATHGORH/MATA KAI\ SUMBE-BHKO/TA KAI\ O(/SA TOU/TWN E)LA/TTW DIAIRE/SEIS PROSEXEI=S. @&10Diocles Magnes apud, Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 63.$10 E)N ME\N OU)=N TOI=S E)L-LIPE/SI LEKTOI=S TE/TAKTAI TA\ <20KATHGORH/MATA>20: _&10`64.$10 E)/STI DE\ TO\ <20KATHGO/-RHMA>20 TO\ KATA/ TINOS A)GOREUO/MENON: H)\ PRA=GMA SUNTAKTO\N PERI/ TINOS H)\ TINW=N, W(S OI( PERI\ *)APOLLO/DWRO/N FASIN, H)\ LEKTO\N E)LLIPE\S SUNTAKTO\N O)RQH=| PTW/SEI PRO\S A)CIW/MATOS GE/NESIN. TW=N DE\ KATHGORHMA/TWN TA\ ME/N E)STI <20SUMBA/MATA>20 %2%2%2%2 OI(=ON TO\ "1DIA\ PE/TRAS PLEI=N"2. KAI\ TA\ ME/N E)STI TW=N KATHGORHMA/TWN O)RQA/, A(\ D' U(/PTIA, A(\ D' OU)DE/TERA. <20O)RQA\>20 ME\N OU)=N E)STI TA\ SUNTASSO/MENA MIA=| TW=N PLAGI/WN PTW/SEWN PRO\S KATHGORH/MATOS GE/NESIN, OI(=ON "1A)KOU/EI"2 "1O(RA=|"2 "1DIALE/GETAI"2. <20U(/PTIA>20 DE/ E)STI TA\ SUNTASSO/MENA TW=| PAQHTIKW=| MORI/W|, OI(=ON "1A)KOU/OMAI"2 "1O(RW=MAI"2. <20OU)DE/TERA>20 D' E)STI\ TA\ MHDETE/RWS E)/XONTA, OI(=ON "1FRO-NEI="2 "1PERIPATEI="2 <20A)NTIPEPONQO/TA>20 DE/ E)STIN E)N TOI=S U(PTI/OIS, A(\ U(/PTIA O)/NTA E)NERGH/MATA/ [DE/] E)STIN, OI(=ON "1KEI/RETAI"2. E)MPERIE/XEI GA\R E(AUTO\N O( KEI-RO/MENOS. <20PLA/GIAI DE\ PTW/SEIS>20 EI)SI\ GENIKH\ KAI\ DOTIKH\ KAI\ AI)TIATIKH/. @&10Porphyrius apud Ammonium in Aristot de interpr. p. 44, 19 &10Busse.$10 [1E)N OI(=S KAI\ PROSISTOREI= [1&10scil. Porphyrius$10]1 TH\N <20TW=N *STWI+KW=N>20 DIA/-TACIN PERI\ TW=N KATHGOROUME/NWN O(/RWN E)N TAI=S PROTA/SESIN OU)=SAN TOIAU/THN.]1 "1*TO\ KATHGOROU/MENON H)/TOI <20O)NO/MATOS>20 KATHGOREI=TAI H)\ <20PTW/SEWS>20, KAI\ TOU/TWN E(KA/TERON H)/TOI <20TE/LEIO/N>20 E)STIN W(S KATHGOROU/MENON KAI\ META\ TOU= U(POKEIME/NOU AU)/TARKES PRO\S GE/NESIN A)POFA/NSEWS, H)\ <20E)LLIPE\S>20 KAI\ PROSQH/KHS TINO\S DEO/-MENON PRO\S TO\ TE/LEION POIH=SAI KATHGOROU/MENON. A)\N ME\N OU)=N O)NO/MATO/S TI KATHGORHQE\N A)PO/FANSIN POIH=|, <20KATHGO/RHMA KAI\ SU/MBAMA>20 PAR' AU)TOI=S O)NOMA/ZETAI [1SHMAI/NEI GA\R A)/MFW TAU)TO\N]1, W(S TO\ "1PERIPATEI="2, OI(=ON "1*SWKRA/-THS PERIPATEI="2. A)\N DE\ PTW/SEWS, <20PARASU/MBAMA>20, W(SANEI\ PARAKEI/MENON TW=| SUMBA/MATI KAI\ O)\N OI(=ON PARAKATHGO/RHMA. W(S E)/XEI TO\ "1METAME/LEI"2, OI(=ON "1*SW-KRA/TEI METAME/LEI"2. TO\ ME\N GA\R "1METAMELEI=TAI"2 SU/MBAMA EI)=NAI, TO\ DE\ "1META-ME/LEI"2 PARASU/MBAMA OU) DUNA/MENON O)NO/MATI SUNTAXQE\N A)PO/FANSIN E)RGA/SASQAI, OI(=ON "1*SWKRA/THS METAME/LEI"2 [1OU)DEMI/A GA\R TOU=TO A)PO/FANSIS]1 A)LL' OU)/TE KLI/SIN E)PIDE/CASQAI DUNA/MENON, W(S TO\ "1PERIPATW=, PERIPATEI=S, PERIPATEI="2 OU)/TE SUM-METASXHMATISQH=NAI TOI=S A)RIQMOI=S: W(/SPER GA\R LE/GOMEN "1TOU/TW| METAME/LEI"2 OU(/-TWS KAI\ "1TOU/TOIS METAME/LEI"2. KAI\ PA/LIN A)\N ME\N TO\ TOU= O)NO/MATOS KATHGO-ROU/MENON DE/HTAI PROSQH/KHS PTW/SEWS O)NO/MATO/S TINOS PRO\S TO\ POIH=SAI A)PO/- @1FANSIN, <20E)/LATTON H)\ KATHGO/RHMA>20 LE/GETAI, W(S E)/XEI TO\ "1FILEI="2 KAI\ TO\ "1EU)NOEI="2, OI(=ON "1*PLA/TWN FILEI="2: TOU/TW| GA\R PROSTEQE\N TO\ TINA/, OI(=ON *DI/WNA, POIEI= W(RISME/NHN A)PO/FANSIN TH\N "1*PLA/TWN *DI/WNA FILEI="2. A)\N DE\ TO\ TH=S PTW/SEWS KATHGOROU/MENON H)=| TO\ DEO/MENON E(TE/RA| SUNTAXQH=NAI PLAGI/A| PTW/SEI PRO\S TO\ POIH=SAI A)PO/FANSIN, <20E)/LATTON H)\ PARASU/MBAMA>20 LE/GETAI, W(S E)/XEI TO\ ME/LEI, OI(=ON "1*SWKRA/TEI *)ALKIBIA/DOU ME/LEI"2. TAU=TA DE\ PA/NTA KALOU=SI "1R(H/MATA"2. KAI\ TOIAU/TH ME\N H( TW=N *STWI+KW=N PERI\ TOU/TWN PARA/DOSIS. @&10Eadem fere Stephanus in Aristot. de interpret. p. 10, 22 sq. p. 11, 8 sq. &10Hayd. [1Comment. graec. XVIII, 3]1, Cf. etiam Apollon.$10 PERI\ SUNT. &10III 32$10 METAME/LEI GA\R *SWKRA/TEI KAI\ E)/TI ME/LEI, TH=S O)RQH=S OU) SUNOU/SHS, DIO\ KAI\ PA-RASUMBA/MATA AU)TA\ E)KA/LESAN OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S, TW=N A)/LLWN R(HMA/TWN KATA\ TA\S SUMBAINOU/SAS DIAQE/SEIS PAR' AU)TOI=S SUMBAMA/TWN PROSAGOREUOME/NWN H)\ KAI\ E)/TI KATHGORHMA/TWN: KAI\ TO\ ME\N A)PARTI/ZON TH\N DIA/NOIAN PARASU/MBAMA, LE/GW TO\ "1ME/LEI *SWKRA/TEI"2, TO\ DE\ E)LLEI=PON H(=TTON H)\ PARASU/MBAMA, LE/GW DH\ TO\ "1ME/LEI"2.&10 Idem I, 8$10 PA=N A)PARE/MFATON O)/NOMA/ E)STI R(HMATIKO/N, EI)/ GE KAI\ OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S AU)TO\ ME\N KALOU=SI R(H=MA, TO\ DE\ "1PERIPATEI="2 H)\ "1GRA/FEI"2 KATHGO/RHMA H)\ SU/MBAMA. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 84$10 *D &10ed. Bas.$10 *PARATHREI=N DE\ DEI= KAI\ <20PO/TE O)RQO/N>20 E)STI KAI\ <20PO/TE U(/PTION>20 TO\ E)NE/RGHMA H)\ PA/QOS. AU)TI/KA TO\ ME\N LUPEI=N O)RQO\N TOI=S POLLOI=S DOKEI=, TO\ DE\ LUPEI=SQAI U(/PTION. OU) MH\N A)EI\ TOU=TO SUMBAI/NEI, W(/SPER E)PI\ TOU= TU/PTONTOS KAI\ TUPTOME/NOU: E)NDE/XETAI GA\R MH\ A)EI\ SUNEI=NAI TO\N LUPOU=NTA, OI(=ON TO\N A)POQANO/NTA UI(O/N, EI) E)P' AU)TW=| TIS LU-POI=TO: E)NDE/XETAI DE\ KAI\ MH\ LUPEI=SQAI, EI) MH\ A)/RA H( FANTASI/A, POIHTIKO\N OU)=SA KAI\ AU)TH\ AI)/TION, E)PIME/NEI. E)/STI D' O(/TAN KAI\ PAUSAME/NOU TOU= POIOU=N-TOS PA/SXEI TO\ PA/SXON, E)PIMENOU/SHS TH=S DIAQE/SEWS, W(S E)PI\ TOU= U(PO\ PURO\S QERMAINOME/NOU KAI\ META\ TH\N A)NAXW/RHSIN TOU= PURO\S E)/TI PA/SXONTOS TO\ QER-MAI/NESQAI: DITTO\N GA\R TO\ PA/SXEIN, TO\ ME\N TW=| POIEI=N SUNHRTHME/NON, TO\ DE\ KATA\ TH\N DIA/QESIN QEWROU/MENON. I)/SWS DE\ KAI\ E)NTAU=QA E)/NDON SUNE/ZEUKTAI TO\ POIOU=N, H)/TOI H( FANTASI/A H)\ TO\ E)/CWQEN E)GGENO/MENON PU=R. TOI=S OU)=N PRA/GMASIN A)LL' OU) TAI=S LE/CESIN E)N TH=| TOU/TWN E)PIKRI/SEI A)KOLOUQEI=N KALO/N. POLLH\ DE\ H( TW=N TOIOU/TWN E)CERGASI/A PARA\ TOI=S <20*STWI+KOI=S: W(=N E)F' H(MW=N KAI\ H( DI-DASKALI/A KAI\ TA\ PLEI=STA TW=N SUGGRAMMA/TWN E)PILE/LOIPEN>20. @&10Diocles Magnes apud Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 66.$10 DIAFE/REI DE\ A)CI/WMA KAI\ E)RW/THMA KAI\ PU/SMA [2KAI\]2 PROSTAKTIKO\N KAI\ O(RKIKO\N KAI\ A)RATIKO\N KAI\ U(POQETIKO\N KAI\ PROSAGOREUTIKO\N KAI\ PRA=GMA O(/MOION A)CIW/MATI. <20A)CI/WMA>20 ME\N @1 GA/R E)STIN O(\ LE/GONTES A)POFAINO/MEQA, O(/PER H)\ A)LHQE/S E)STIN H)\ YEU=DOS. <20E)RW/-THMA>20 DE/ E)STI PRA=GMA AU)TOTELE\S ME/N, W(S KAI\ TO\ A)CI/WMA, AI)THTIKO\N DE\ A)PO-KRI/SEWS, OI(=ON "1A)=RA/ GE H(ME/RA E)STI/;"2 TOU=TO DE\ OU)/TE A)LHQE/S E)STIN OU)/TE YEU=DOS: W(/STE TO\ ME\N "1H(ME/RA E)STI/N"2 A)CI/WMA/ E)STI, TO\ DE\ "1A)=RA/ GE H(ME/RA E)STI/N;"2 E)RW/THMA. <20PU/SMA>20 DE/ E)STI PRA=GMA PRO\S O(\ SUMBOLIKW=S OU)K E)/STIN A)POKRI/NESQAI, W(S E)PI\ TOU= E)RWTH/MATOS, "1NAI/"2, A)LLA\ [2DEI=]2 EI)PEI=N "1OI)KEI= E)N TW=|DE TW=| TO/PW|"2. <20PROS-TAKTIKO\N>20 DE/ E)STI PRA=GMA, O(\ LE/GONTES PROSTA/SSOMEN, OI(=ON: [1&10fr. trag. adesp. &10`144$10 *N]1 @"1SU\ ME\N BA/DIZE TA\S E)P' *)INA/XOU R(OA/S"2. O(RKIKO\N %2%2%2%2 [2<20PROSAGOREUTIKO\N>20]2 DE/ E)STI PRA=GMA, O(\ EI) LE/GOI TIS, PROS-AGOREU/OI A)/N, OI(=ON @"1*)ATREI/DH KU/DISTE, A)/NAC A)NDRW=N *)AGAME/MNON"2. <20O(/MOION DE/ E)STIN A)CIW/MATI>20, O(\ TH\N E)KFORA\N E)/XON A)CIWMATIKH\N PARA/ TINOS MORI/OU PLEONASMO\N H)\ PA/QOS E)/CW PI/PTEI TOU= GE/NOUS TW=N A)CIWMA/TWN, OI(=ON: @"1KALO/S G' O( PARQENW/N"2. @"1W(S *PRIAMI/DH|SIN E)MFERH\S O( BOUKO/LOS"2 [1&10frg. trag. adesp. 109$10]1 E)/STI DE\ KAI\ <20E)PAPORHTIKO/N>20 TI PRA=GMA DIENHNOXO\S A)CIW/MATOS, O(\ EI) LE/GOI TIS, A)POROI/H A)\N: [1&10Menandri fr. 281, 9 Kock$10]1 @"1A)=R' E)/STI SUGGENE/S TI LU/PH KAI\ BI/OS;"2 OU)/TE DE\ A)LHQH= E)STIN OU)/TE YEUDH= TA\ E)RWTH/MATA KAI\ TA\ PU/SMATA KAI\ TA\ TOU/-TOIS PARAPLH/SIA, TW=N A)CIWMA/TWN H)\ A)LHQW=N H)\ YEUDW=N O)/NTWN. @&10Sextus adv. math. VIII 70.$10 AU)TI/KA GA\R_H)CI/OUN <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 KOINW=S E)N LEKTW=| TO\ A)LHQE\S EI)=NAI KAI\ TO\ YEU=DOS. <20LEKTO\N DE\ U(PA/RXEIN FASI\ TO\ KATA\ LOGIKH\N FANTASI/AN U(FISTA/MENON>20: LOGIKH\N DE\ EI)=NAI FAN-TASI/AN KAQ' H(\N TO\ FANTASQE\N E)/STI LO/GW| PARASTH=SAI. TW=N DE\ LEKTW=N TA\ ME\N E)LLIPH= KALOU=SI TA\ DE\ AU)TOTELH=. W(=N TA\ ME\N E)LLIPH= PAREI/SQW NU=N, TW=N DE\ AU)TOTELW=N PLEI/OUS EI)=NAI/ FASI [2DIAFORA/S]2. KAI\ GA\R <20PROSTAKTIKA\>20 KA-LOU=SI/ TINA, A(/PER PROSTA/SSONTES LE/GOMEN, OI(=ON "1DEU=R' I)/QI NU/MFA FI/LH"2 [1&10Il.$10 *G&10 30$10]1 KAI\ <20A)POFANTIKA/>20, A(/PER A)POFAINO/MENOI/ FAMEN, OI(=ON "1O( *DI/WN PE-RIPATEI="2, KAI\ <20PU/SMATA>20, A(/PER LE/GONTES PUNQANO/MEQA, OI(=ON "1POU= OI)KEI= *DI/WN;"2 O)NOMA/ZETAI DE/ TINA PAR' AU)TOI=S KAI\ <20A)RATIKA/>20, A(/PER LE/GONTES A)RW/-MEQA "1W(=DE/ SF' E)GKE/FALOS XAMA/DIS R(E/OI W(S O(/DE OI)=NOS"2 [1&10Il.$10 *G&10 300$10]1 KAI\ <20EU)K-TIKA/>20, A(/PER LE/GONTES EU)XO/MEQA "1*ZEU= PA/TER, *)/IDHQEN MEDE/WN, KU/DISTE ME/GISTE, DO\S NI/KHN *AI)/ANTI KAI\ A)GLAO\N EU)=XOS A)RE/SQAI"2 [1&10Il.$10 *H&10 202$10]1. PROSAGOREU/OUSI DE/ TINA TW=N AU)TOTELW=N KAI\ <20A)CIW/MATA>20, A(/PER LE/GONTES H)\ A)LHQEU/OMEN H)\ YEU-DO/MEQA. E)/STI DE/ TINA KAI\ <20PLEI/ONA H)\ A)CIW/MATA>20, OI(=ON TO\ ME\N TOIOU=TO "1*PRIAMI/DH|SIN E)MFERH\S O( BOUKO/LOS"2 A)CI/WMA/ E)STIN: H)\ GA\R A)LHQEU/OMEN LE/GON-TES AU)TO\ H)\ YEUDO/MEQA: TO\ DE\ OU(/TWS E)/XON "1W(S *PRIAMI/DH|SIN E)MFERH\S O( BOU-KO/LOS"2 PLE/ON TI A)CIW/MATO/S E)STI KAI\ OU)K A)CI/WMA. PLH\N I(KANH=S OU)/SHS E)N TOI=S LEKTOI=S DIAFORA=S, I(/NA TI, FASI/N, A)LHQE\S H)=| H)\ YEU=DOS, DEI= AU)TO\ PRO\ PANTO\S LEKTO\N EI)=NAI, EI)=TA KAI\ AU)TOTELE/S, KAI\ OU) KOINW=S O(POI=ON DH/POTE OU)=N A)LL' A)CI/WMA: MO/NON GA\R TOU=TO, W(S PROEI=PON, LE/GONTES H)/TOI A)LHQEU/OMEN H)\ YEUDO/MEQA. @&10Ammonius in Aristot. de interpret. p. 2, 26 Busse.$10 KALOU=SI DE\ <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 TO\N ME\N A)POFANTIKO\N LO/GON A)CI/WMA, TO\N DE\ EU)KTIKO\N A)RATIKO/N, TO\N DE\ KLHTIKO\N PROSAGOREUTIKO/N, PROSTIQE/NTES TOU/TOIS E(/TERA PE/NTE LO/GWN EI)/DH @1 SAFW=S U(PO/ TINA TW=N A)PHRIQMHME/NWN A)NAFERO/MENA: LE/GOUSI GA\R TO\ ME/N TI EI)=NAI <20O)MOTIKO\N>20 OI(=ON: @I)/STW NU=N TO/DE GAI=A, TO\ DE\ <20E)KQETIKO\N>20 OI(=ON "1E)/STW EU)QEI=A GRAMMH\ H(/DE"2, TO\ DE\ <20U(POQETIKO\N>20 OI(=ON "1U(POKEI/SQW TH\N GH=N KE/NTRON EI)=NAI TH=S TOU= H(LI/OU SFAI/RAS"2 TO\ DE\ <20O(/MOION A)CIW/MATI>20 OI(=ON @W(S W(RAI/+ZETAI H( TU/XH EI)S TOU\S BI/OUS [1&10Menander fr. 855$]1 A(/PER A(/PANTA DEKTIKA\ O)/NTA YEU/DOUS TE KAI\ A)LHQEI/AS U(PA/GOINTO A)\N TW=| A)PO-FANTIKW=|. __PE/MPTON DE/ TI PRO\S TOU/TOIS EI)=NAI/ FASI TO\ <20E)PAPORHTI-KO\N>20 OI(=ON: @*DA=OS PA/RESTI: TI/ POT' E)PAGGELW=N A)/RA; O(/PER E)NARGW=S TAU)TO\N O)\N TUGXA/NEI TW=| E)RWTHMATIKW=|, PLH\N O(/TI PROTI/QHSI TH\N PRO/FASIN TH=S E)RWTH/SEWS. @&10Ammonius in Aristot. Analyt. pr. p. 2, 3 Wal.$10 W(/STE OU) PERI\ PANTO\S LO/GOU E)KEI= DIALAMBA/NEI, OU)/TE PERI\ TOU= EU)KTIKOU= OU)/TE PERI\ TOU= PROS-TAKTIKOU= OU)/TE A)/LLOU TINO\S H)/TOI TW=N PE/NTE KATA\ TOU\S *PERIPATHTIKOU\S H)\ TW=N DE/KA KATA\ <20TOU\S *STWI+KOU\S>20 PLH\N TOU= A)POFANTIKOU=.&10 Cf. p. 26, 31. &10@Scholia Hesiod. Theog. v. 463.$10 TW=| E)RWTH/MATI SUMBOLIKW=S E(/PETAI H( A)PO/KRISIS, TW=| <20PU/SMATI>20 DE\ DIECODIKW=S. @&10Alexander in Aristot. Topica p. 539, 17.$10 KAI\ GA\R E)N E)KEI/NW| EI)=PE [1&10scil. Aristoteles in Top. lib. I$10]1 MH\ EI)=NAI DIALEKTIKA\S E)RWTH/SEIS TA\S TI/ E)STI TO\ PROKEI/MENON E)CETAZOU/SAS, A(\ <20PU/SMATA>20 E)/QOS LE/GEIN <20TOI=S NEWTE/ROIS>20. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 103 A. ed. Bas.$10 XWRI\S DE\ TOU/TWN, FASI/, PA/LAI LE/LUTAI TAU=TA E)N TAI=S E)CHGH/SESI TOU= O(/ROU TOU= A)CIW/MATOS TOU= A)FO-RIZOME/NOU TO\ A)CI/WMA O(/ E)STIN A)LHQE\S H)\ YEU=DOS: OU) GA\R TO\ <20O)MOTIKO\N>20 OI(=O/N TE A)LHQE\S EI)=NAI H)\ YEUDE/S, A)LL' EU)ORKEI=N ME\N H)\ E)PIORKEI=N E)N TOI=S O(/RKOIS EI)KO/S: A)LHQEU/EIN DE\ H)\ YEU/DESQAI E)N AU)TOI=S OU)X OI(=O/N TE, KA)\N PERI\ A)LHQW=N O)MO/SH| TIS H)\ YEUDW=N. KAI\ TO\ <20QAUMASTIKO\N>20 DE\ PLEONA/ZON TW=| QAU/MATI PARA\ TO\ A)CI/WMA KAI\ TO\ <20YEKTIKO\N>20 TW=| MWMI/MW| [1&10sic!$10]1 OU)/TE A)LHQE/S E)STIN OU)/TE YEUDE/S, A)LLA\ O(/MOIA A)LHQE/SIN H)\ YEUDE/SIN: A)LL' AU(=TAI ME\N A)PO\ TH=S <20*STWI+KH=S>20 A)KRI-BEI/AS E)/STWSAN AI( LU/SEIS. @&Diocles Magnes apud Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 65.$8 <20A)CI/WMA>20 DE/ E)STIN O(/ E)STIN A)LHQE\S H)\ YEU=DOS: H)\ PRA=GMA AU)TOTELE\S A)POFANTO\N O(/SON E)F' E(AUTW=| W(S O( <20*XRU/SIPPO/S>20 FHSIN <20E)N TOI=S DIALEKTIKOI=S O(/ROIS @1 "1A)CI/WMA/ E)STI TO\ A)POFANTO\N H)\ KATAFANTO\N O(/SON E)F' E(AUTW=| OI(=ON "3H(ME/RA E)STI/"3 "3*DI/WN PERIPATEI="3>20."2 W)NO/MASTAI DE\ TO\ A)CI/WMA A)PO\ TOU= A)CIOU=SQAI H)\ A)QETEI=SQAI. O( GA\R LE/GWN "1H(ME/RA E)STI/N"2 A)CIOU=N DOKEI= TO\ H(ME/RAN EI)=NAI. OU)/SHS ME\N OU)=N H(ME/RAS A)LHQE\S GI/NETAI TO\ PRO-KEI/MENON A)CI/WMA, MH\ OU)/SHS DE\ YEU=DOS. @&10Gellius Noct. Att. XVI 8, 1. Cum in disciplinas dialecticas in-&10duci atque imbui vellemus, necessus fuit adire atque cognoscere quas vo-&10cant dialectici$10 EI)SAGWGA/S.&10 Tum quia in primo$10 PERI\ A)CIWMA/TWN&10 discendum. &10__4. redimus igitur necessario ad graecos libros. Ex quibus accepimus$10 A)CI/WMA&10 esse his verbis%10$10 LEKTO\N AU)TOTELE\S A)PO/FANTON O(/SON E)F' AU(TW=|. __ &10`8. et omnino quicquid ita dicitur plena atque perfecta verborum sententia, &10ut id necesse sit aut verum aut falsum esse, id a dialecticis$10 A)CI/WMA&10 ap-&10pellatum est. __ &10@Sextus adv. math. VIII 10.$10 <20OI( DE\ A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 LE/GOUSI ME\N TW=N TE AI)SQHTW=N TINA KAI\ TW=N NOHTW=N A)LHQH=, OU)K E)C EU)QEI/AS DE\ TA\ AI)S-QHTA/, A)LLA\ KAT' A)NAFORA\N TH\N W(S E)PI\ TA\ PARAKEI/MENA TOU/TOIS NOHTA/: A)LH-QE\S GA/R E)STI KAT' AU)TOU\S TO\ U(PA/RXON KAI\ A)NTIKEI/MENO/N TINI, KAI\ YEU=DOS TO\ MH\ U(PA/RXON KAI\ [MH\] A)NTIKEI/MENO/N TINI: O(/PER A)SW/MATON A)CI/WMA KAQESTW\S NOHTO\N EI)=NAI. @&10Cicero Acad. Pr. II 95. Fundamentum dialecticae est, quidquid &10enuntietur [1id autem appellant$10 A)CI/WMA&10_]1 aut verum esse aut falsum. &10Quid igitur? haec vera an falsa sunt%10 "3si te mentiri dicis idque verum &10dicis, mentiris [verum dicis]"3. Haec scilicet inexplicabilia esse dicitis. _ &10Si ista explicari non possunt nec eorum ullum iudicium invenitur, ut re-&10spondere possitis, verane an falsa sint, ubi est illa definitio, effatum esse &10id, quod aut verum aut falsum sit? @&Stobaeus Florileg. 28, 18 H. [1`28, 15 M.]1$ *XRUSI/PPOU. <20*XRU/-SIPPOS>20 DIAFE/REIN E)/FH TO\ A)LHQORKEI=N TOU= EU)ORKEI=N: KAI\ TO\ E)PIORKEI=N TOU= YEUDORKEI=N. *TO\N ME\N GA\R O)MNU/NTA KAQ' O(\N O)MNU/EI KAIRO\N PA/NTWS H)\ A)LHQORKEI=N H)\ YEUDORKEI=N. TO\ GA\R O)MNU/MENON U(P' AU)TOU= H)\ A)LHQE\S EI)=NAI H)\ YEU=DOS, E)PEIDH\ A)CI/WMA TUGXA/NEI O)/N. TO\N DE\ O)MNU/NTA MH\ PA/N-TWS KAQ' O(\N O)MNU/EI XRO/NON H)\ EU)ORKEI=N H)\ E)PIORKEI=N, O(/TE MH\ PA/RESTIN O( XRO/NOS, EI)S O(\N H( A)NAFORA\ TW=N O(/RKWN E)GI/GNETO. *(\ON TRO/PON GA\R LE/GESQAI/ TINA EU)SUNQETEI=N H)\ A)SUNQETEI=N, OU)X O(/TE SUNTI/QETAI, A)LL' O(/TE OI( XRO/NOI E)NI/STANTAI TW=N KATA\ TA\S O(MOLOGI/AS: OU(/TW KAI\ EU)ORKEI=N TIS KAI\ E)PIORKEI=N R(HQH/SETAI, O(/TAN OI( KAIROI\ PARASTW=SI, KAQ' OU(\S W(MOLO/GHSEN E)PITELE/SEIN TA\ KATA\ TOU\S O(/RKOUS. @&10Simplicius in Aristot categ. f. 103 B ed Bas.$10 PERI\ DE\ TW=N EI)S TO\N ME/LLONTA XRO/NON A)NTIFA/SEWN OI( ME\N <20*STWI+KOI\>20 TA\ AU)TA\ DOKIMA/ZOUSIN, A(/PER KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N A)/LLWN. W(S GA\R TA\ PERI\ TW=N PARO/NTWN KAI\ PARELHLUQO/- @1TWN A)NTIKEI/MENA, OU(/TWS KAI\ TA\ ME/LLONTA AU)TA/ TE/ FASI KAI\ TA\ MO/RIA AU)TW=N. H)\ GA\R TO\ E)/STAI A)LHQE/S E)STIN H)\ TO\ OU)K E)/STAI, EI) DEI= H)/TOI YEUDH= H)\ A)LHQH= EI)=NAI. W(RI/SQAI GA\R KAT' AU)TA\ TA\ ME/LLONTA. KAI\ EI) ME\N E)/STAI NAUMAXI/A AU)/RION, A)LHQE\S EI)PEI=N O(/TI E)/STAI: EI) DE\ MH\ E)/STAI, YEU=DOS TO\ EI)PEI=N O(/TI E)/STAI. H)/TOI E)/STAI H)\ OU)K E)/STAI, H)/TOI A)/RA A)LHQE\S H)\ YEU=DOS QA/TERON. @&10Sextus adv. math. VIII 79.$10 TA\ NU=N DE\ E)KEI=NO R(HTE/ON O(/TI <20TO\ AU)-TOTELE\S A)CI/WMA SU/NQETON EI)=NAI QE/LOUSIN>20, OI(=ON TO\ "1H(ME/RA E)STI/"2 SU/G-KEITAI E)/K TE TOU= "1H(ME/RA"2 KAI\ TOU= "1E)/STIN"2. @&10Proclus in euclid. p. 193 Friedlein.$10 KAI\ OI(/ GE <20A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 A(/PANTA LO/GON A(PLOU=N A)POFANTIKO\N A)CI/WMA PROSAGOREU/EIN EI)W/QASIN, KAI\ O(/TAN DIALEKTIKA\S H(MI=N GRA/FWSI TE/XNAS "1PERI\ A)CIWMA/TWN"2, TOU=TO DIA\ TW=N E)PIGRAM-MA/TWN DHLOU=N E)QE/LOUSIN. @&10Diocles Magnes apud Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 75.$10 <20PIQANO\N DE/ E)STIN>20 A)CI/WMA TO\ A)/GON EI)S SUGKATA/QESIN, OI(=ON "1EI)/ TI/S TI E)/TEKEN, E)KEI/NH E)KEI/NOU MH/-THR E)STI/"2. YEU=DOS DE\ TOU=TO: OU) GA\R H( O)/RNIS W)OU= E)STI MH/THR. E)/TI TA\ ME/N E)STI <20DUNATA/>20, TA\ DE\ <20A)DU/NATA>20, KAI\ TA\ ME\N <20A)NAGKAI=A>20, TA\ D' <20OU)K A)NAG-KAI=A. DUNATO\N>20 ME\N TO\ E)PIDEKTIKO\N TOU= A)LHQE\S EI)=NAI, TW=N E)KTO\S MH\ E)NAN-TIOUME/NWN PRO\S TO\ A)LHQE\S EI)=NAI, OI(=ON "1ZH=| *DIOKLH=S"2. <20A)DU/NATON>20 DE\ O(\ MH/ E)STIN E)PIDEKTIKO\N TOU= A)LHQE\S EI)=NAI, OI(=ON "1H( GH= I(/PTATAI"2. <20A)NAGKAI=ON>20 DE/ E)STIN, O(/PER A)LHQE\S O)\N OU)K E)/STIN E)PIDEKTIKO\N TOU= YEU=DOS EI)=NAI, H)\ E)PIDEKTIKO\N ME/N E)STI, TA\ D' E)KTO\S AU)TW=| E)NANTIOU=TAI PRO\S TO\ YEU=DOS EI)=NAI, OI(=ON "1H( A)RETH\ W)FELEI="2. <20OU)K A)NAGKAI=ON>20 DE/ E)STIN O(\ KAI\ A)LHQE/S E)STIN KAI\ YEU=DOS OI(=O/N TE EI)=NAI, TW=N E)KTO\S MHDE\N E)NANTIOUME/NWN, OI(=ON TO\ "1PERIPATEI= *DI/WN"2. <20EU)/LOGON>20 DE/ E)STIN A)CI/WMA TO\ PLEI/ONAS A)FORMA\S E)/XON EI)S TO\ A)LHQE\S EI)=NAI, OI(=ON "1BIW/-SOMAI AU)/RION"2. KAI\ A)/LLAI DE/ EI)SI DIAFORAI\ A)CIWMA/TWN KAI\ <20METAPTW/SEIS>20 AU)TW=N E)C A)LHQW=N EI)S YEU/DH KAI\ <20A)NTISTROFAI/>20, PERI\ W(=N E)N TW=| PLA/TEI LE/GOMEN. @&10Boe%28thius ad Aristot. de interpr. p. 374. Stoici vero possibile quidem &10posuerunt, quod susceptibile esset verae praedicationis, nihil his prohiben-&10tibus, quae cum extra sint cum ipso tamen fieri contingunt; impossibile &10autem, quod nullam unquam suscipiat veritatem, aliis extra eventum ip-&10sius prohibentibus; necessarium, quod cum verum sit falsam praedicationem &10nulla ratione suscipiat. &10@Idem p. 429. illud autem ignorandum non est, quod Stoicis univer-&10salius videatur esse possibile a necessario; dividunt enim enuntiationes &10hoc modo%10 "1enuntiationum, inquiunt, aliae sunt possibiles, aliae impossi-&10biles; possibilium aliae sunt necessariae, aliae non necessariae; rursus non &10necessariarum aliae possibiles etc."2 stulte atque improvide idem possibile &10et genus non necessarii et speciem constituentes. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. c. 46 p. 1055d.$ *(O <20DE\ TW=N DUNATW=N LO/GOS>20 PRO\S TO\N TH=S EI(MARME/NHS LO/GON AU)TW=| PW=S OU) MAXO/-MENO/S E)STIN; EI) GA\R OU)K E)/STI DUNATO\N O(/PER H)/ E)STIN A)LHQE\S H)\ E)/STAI, KATA\ *DIO/DWRON, "1<20A)LLA\ PA=N TO\ E)PIDEKTIKO\N TOU= GENE/SQAI, KA)\N MH\ ME/LLH| GENH/SESQAI DUNATO/N E)STIN"2>20 E)/STAI DUNATA\ POLLA\ TW=N MH\ KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN. [2*)\H A)/RA TH\N]2 A)NI/KHTON KAI\ A)NEKBI/ASTON KAI\ @1 PERIGENHTIKH\N A(PA/NTWN H( EI(MARME/NH DU/NAMIN A)PO/LLUSIN H)\ TAU/THS OI(/AN A)CIOI= *XRU/SIPPOS OU)/SHS, TO\ E)PIDEKTIKO\N TOU= GENE/SQAI POLLA/KIS EI)S TO\ A)DU/NATON E)MPESEI=TAI &etc. @&Alexander Aphrod. comm. in Aristot. Analyt. pr. p. 177, 25 &Wallies.$ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 DE\ LE/GWN MHDE\N KWLU/EIN KAI\ DUNATW=| A)DU/NATON E(/PESQAI PRO\S ME\N TH\N U(P' *)ARISTOTE/LOUS EI)RHME/NHN DEI=CIN OU)DE\N LE/GEI, PEIRA=TAI DE\ DIA\ PARADEIGMA/TWN TINW=N OU)X U(GIW=S SUGKEIME/NWN DEIK-NU/NAI TOU=TO MH\ OU(/TWS E)/XON. FHSI\ GA\R E)N TW=| SUNHMME/NW| TW=| "1EI) TE/QNHKE *DI/WN, TE/QNHKEN OU(=TOS"2 DEIKNUME/NOU TOU= *DI/WNOS A)LHQEI= O)/NTI TO\ ME\N H(GOU/MENON [2TO\]2 "1TE/QNHKE *DI/WN"2 DUNATO\N EI)=NAI TW=| DU/NASQAI/ POTE A)LHQE\S GENE/SQAI TO\ TEQNHKE/NAI *DI/WNA, TO\ DE\ "1TE/QNHKEN OU(=TOS"2 A)DU/NATON: A)POQANO/NTOS GA\R *DI/WNOS FQEI/RESQAI TO\ A)CI/WMA TO\ "1OU(=TOS TE/QNHKE"2 MHKE/T' O)/NTOS TOU= TH\N DEI=CIN A)NADEXOME/NOU: E)PI\ GA\R ZW=NTOS KAI\ KATA\ ZW=NTOS H( DEI=CIS. EI) OU)=N MH/[2TE]2 TEQNEW=TOS AU)TOU= E)/TI TO\ "1OU(=TOS"2 OI(=O/NTE, MH/TE PA/LIN U(FI/STATAI O( *DI/WN, W(S DU/NASQAI E)P' AU)-TOU= R(HQH=NAI TO\ "1TE/QNHKEN OU(=TOS"2, A)DU/NATON TO\ "1TE/QNHKEN OU(=TOS"2. H)=N GA\R A)\N OU)K A)DU/NATON, EI) U(/STERO/N POTE E)DU/NATO META\ TO\N QA/NATON TO\N *DI/WNOS, E)F' OU(= TO\ PRO/TERON E)N TW=| SUNHMME/NW|, O(/TE E)/ZH O( *DI/WN, KATHGOREI=TO TO\ "1TE/QNHKEN OU(=TOS"2, KATHGORHQH=NAI PA/LIN TO\ "1OU(=TOS"2. E)PEI\ DE\ MH\ OI(=O/NTE TOU=TO, A)DU/NATON A)\N EI)/H TO\ "1TE/QNHKEN OU(=TOS"2. O(/MOION TOU/TW| PARATI/QETAI KAI\ TO\ "1EI) NU/C E)STIN, OU)K E)/STIN AU(/TH H(ME/RA"2 DEIKNUME/NHS TH=S H(ME/RAS: KAI\ GA\R E)N TOU/TW| TW=| SUNHMME/NW| ሔA)LHQEI= O)/NTI, W(S OI)/ETAI, DUNATW=| O)/NTI TW=| H(GOUME/NW| A)DU/NATON TO\ E(PO/-MENON"2. @&10Proclus in Plat. Parmen. Vol. IV p. 103 ed. Cousin.$10 EI) DE/ TIS TOSOU/TWN EI)S E)CE/TASIN PROKEIME/NWN EI)S TH\N <20*STWI+KH\N>20 TERQREI/AN A)PA/GOI TO\N LO/GON, ZHTW=N EI) DUNATW=| A)DU/NATON A)KOLOUQEI= TO\ "1EI) TE/QNHKE *DI/WN"2 EI)S ME/-SON FE/RWN: EI) OU)=N TIS KAI\ TW=N TOIOU/TWN A)PO/RWN E)QE/LOI POIEI=SQAI MNH/MHN, I(KANW=S U(PO\ TW=N *PERIPATHTIKW=N E)CHTASME/NWN, R(A/|DION A)PANTA/N. @&Diocles Magnes apud Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 68.$ TW=N A)CIWMA/TWN TA\ ME/N E)STIN A(PLA=, TA\ D' OU)X A(PLA=, W(/S FASIN OI( PERI\ <20*XRU/SIPPON>20 KAI\ *)ARXE/DHMON KAI\ *)AQHNO/DWRON KAI\ *)ANTI/PATRON KAI\ *KRI/NIN: <20A(PLA=>20 ME\N OU)=N E)STI TA\ SUNESTW=TA E)C A)CIW/MATOS MH\ DIAFOROUME/NOU [H)\ E)C @1 A)CIWMA/TWN], OI(=ON TO\ "1H(ME/RA E)STI/N"2. <20OU)X A(PLA=>20 DE/ E)STI TA\ SUNESTW=TA E)C A)CIW/MATOS DIAFOROUME/NOU H)\ E)C A)CIWMA/TWN, E)C A)CIW/MATOS ME\N DIA-FOROUME/NOU, OI(=ON "1EI) H(ME/RA E)STI/N, [2H(ME/RA E)STI/N]2"2. E)C A)CIWMA/TWN DE/, OI(=ON "1EI) H(ME/RA E)STI/, FW=S E)STI/"2. @&10Diocles Magnes apud Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 69.$10 E)N DE\ TOI=S A(PLOI=S A)CIW/MASI/N E)STI TO\ A)POFATIKO\N KAI\ TO\ A)RNHTIKO\N KAI\ TO\ STERHTIKO\N KAI\ TO\ KATHGORIKO\N KAI\ TO\ KATAGOREUTIKO\N KAI\ TO\ A)O/RISTON. __[2KAI\ <20A)POFATI-KO\N>20 ME\N]2 OI(=ON "1OU)XI\ H(ME/RA E)STI/N"2. EI)=DOS DE\ TOU/TOU TO\ <20U(PERAPOFATIKO/N>20. U(PERAPOFATIKO\N DE/ E)STIN A)POFATIKO\N A)POFATIKOU=, OI(=ON "1OU)XI\ H(ME/RA [2OU)K]2 E)/STI"2. TI/QHSI DE\ TO\ "1H(ME/RA E)STI/N"2. <20A)RNHTIKO\N>20 DE/ E)STI TO\ SUNESTO\S E)C A)RNHTIKOU= MORI/OU KAI\ KATHGORH/MATOS, OI(=ON "1OU)DEI\S PERIPATEI="2. <20STERHTIKO\N>20 DE/ E)STI TO\ SUNESTO\S E)K STERHTIKOU= MORI/OU KAI\ A)CIW/MATOS KATA\ DU/NAMIN, OI(=ON "1A)FILA/NQRWPO/S E)STIN OU(=TOS"2. <20KATHGORIKO\N>20 DE/ E)STI TO\ SUNESTO\S E)K PTW/-SEWS O)RQH=S KAI\ KATHGORH/MATOS, OI(=ON "1*DI/WN PERIPATEI="2. <20KATAGOREUTIKO\N>20 DE/ E)STI TO\ SUNESTO\S E)K PTW/SEWS O)RQH=S DEIKTIKH=S KAI\ KATHGORH/MATOS, OI(=ON "1OU(=TOS PERIPATEI="2. <20A)O/RISTON>20 DE/ E)STI TO\ SUNESTO\S E)C A)ORI/STOU MORI/OU H)\ A)ORI/STWN MORI/WN [2KAI\ KATHGORH/MATOS]2, OI(=ON "1TI\S PERIPATEI="2, "1E)KEI=NOS KI-NEI=TAI"2. @&10[Apuleius]$10 PERI\ E(RMHNEI/AS&10 266 [1p. 2, 9 Goldb.]1. aliae dedi-&10cativae sunt [1scil. propositiones]1 quae dedicant aliquid de quopiam, ut &10"1virtus bonum est"2__aliae abdicativae, quae abdicant aliquid de quo-&10piam, ut "1voluptas non est bonum"2__at Stoici hanc quoque dedica-&10tivam putant, cum inquiunt: "1evenit cuidam voluptati bonum non esse; &10ergo dedicat, quid evenerit ei, id est, quid sit. idcirco dedicativa, in-&10quiunt, est, quia et in quo negavit esse, dedicat id, quod non videtur &10esse"2. Solum autem abdicativum vocant, cui negativa particula praeponi-&10tur. &10@Sectus adv. math. VIII 93.$10 TW=N A)CIWMA/TWN PRW/THN SXEDO\N KAI\ KURIWTA/THN E)KFE/ROUSI DIAFORA\N OI( DIALEKTIKOI/, KAQ' H(\N TA\ ME/N E)STIN AU)TW=N A(PLA=, TA\ D' OU)X A(PLA=. KAI\ A(PLA= ME\N O(/SA MH/T' E)C E(NO\S A)CIW/MATOS DI\S LAMBANOME/NOU SUNE/STHKEN, MH/T' E)C A)CIWMA/TWN DIAFERO/NTWN DIA\ TINO\S H)\ TINW=N SUNDE/SMWN. __&10`94$10 A(PLA= LE/GETAI A)CIW/MATA, E)PEI\ OU)K E)C A)CIWMA/TWN SUNE/STHKEN A)LL' E)C A)/LLWN TINW=N. __&10`95$10 OU)X A(PLA= DE\ E)TU/GXANE TA\ OI(=ON DIPLA=, KAI\ O(/SA D' E)C A)CIW/MATOS DI\S LAMBANOME/NOU H)\ E)C A)CIWMA/TWN DIAFERO/NTWN SUNE/STHKE DIA\ SUNDE/SMOU TE H)\ SUNDE/SMWN, OI(=ON "1EI) H(ME/RA E)STI/N, H(ME/RA E)STIN: EI) NU/C E)STI, SKO/TOS E)STI/N: KAI\ [EI)] H(ME/RA E)STI\ KAI\ FW=S E)STIN: H)/TOI H(ME/RA E)STI\N H)\ NU/C E)STIN"2. @&10`96$10 TW=N DE\ A(PLW=N TINA\ ME\N W(RISME/NA E)STI/N, TINA\ DE\ A)O/RISTA, TINA\ DE\ ME/SA: <20W(RISME/NA>20 ME\N TA\ KATA\ DEI=CIN E)KFERO/MENA, OI(=ON "1OU(=TOS PERIPATEI=, OU(=TOS KA/QHTAI"2. DEI/KNUMI GA/R TINA TW=N E)PI\ ME/ROUS A)NQRW/PWN. <20A)O/RISTA>20 @1 DE/ E)STI KAT' AU)TOU\S E)N OI(=S A)O/RISTO/N TI KURIEU/EI MO/RION, OI(=ON "1TI\S KA/QHTAI"2, <20ME/SA>20 DE\ TA\ OU(/TWS E)/XONTA "1A)/NQRWPOS KA/QHTAI"2 H)\ "1*SWKRA/THS PERIPATEI="2. TO\ ME\N OU)=N "1TI\S PERIPATEI="2 A)O/RISTO/N E)STIN, E)PEI\ OU)K A)FW/RIKE/ TINA TW=N E)PI\ ME/ROUS PERIPATOU/NTWN: KOINW=S GA\R E)F' E(KA/STOU AU)TW=N E)KFE/RESQAI DU/NATAI: TO\ DE\ "1OU(=TOS KA/QHTAI"2 W(RISME/NON E)STI/N, E)PEI/PER A)FW/RIKE TO\ DEIKNU/MENON PRO/SWPON. TO\ DE\ "1*SWKRA/THS KA/QHTAI"2 ME/SON U(PH=RXEN, E)PEI/PER OU)/TE A)O/RI-STO/N E)STIN, A)FW/RIKE GA\R TO\ EI)=DOS, OU)/TE W(RISME/NON, OU) GA\R META\ DEI/CEWS E)K-FE/RETAI, A)LL' E)/OIKE ME/SON A)MFOTE/RWN U(PA/RXEIN, TOU= TE A)ORI/STOU KAI\ TOU= W(RIS-ME/NOU: <20GI/NESQAI DE/ FASI TO\ A)O/RISTON A)LHQE/S_O(/TAN TO\ W(RISME/NON A)LHQE\S EU(RI/SKHTAI>20. __ @&10`100$10 KAI\ DH\ <20TO\ W(RISME/NON TOU=TO A)CI/WMA>20, TO\ "1OU(=TOS KA/QHTAI"2 H)\ "1OU(=TOS PERIPATEI="2, TO/TE <20FASI\N A)LHQE\S U(PA/RXEIN O(/TAN TW=| U(PO\ TH\N DEI=-CIN PI/PTONTI SUMBEBH/KH| TO\ KATHGO/RHMA>20, OI(=ON TO\ KAQH=SQAI H)\ TO\ PERIPATEI=N. @&10Alexander Aphrod. apud Simplicium in Aristot. phys. p. 1299, &10`36 Diels.$10 E)K DH\ TOU/TWN TW=N LO/GWN, FHSI\N O( *)ALE/CANDROS, DUNATO\N O(RMW/-MENON DEIKNU/NAI TA\ <20PARA\ TOI=S *STWI+KOI=S>20 A)CIW/MATA, A(\ <20METAPI/PTONTA/>20 TINES LE/GOUSIN A)PERIGRA/FWS, MH\ O)/NTA TOIAU=TA: E)/STI DE\ TAU=TA TOIAU=TA: "1EI) ZH=| *DI/WN, ZH/SETAI *DI/WN"2 TOU=TO GA\R EI) KAI\ A)LHQE/S E)STI NU=N, A)RXO/MENON A)PO\ A)LHQOU=S TOU= "1ZH=| *DI/WN"2 KAI\ LH=GON EI)S A)LHQE\S TO\ "1ZH/SETAI"2, A)LL' E)/STAI POTE/, O(/TE TH=S PROSLH/YEWS A)LHQOU=S OU)/SHS TH=S "1A)LLA\ MH\N ZH=| *DI/WN"2 META-PESEI=TAI TO\ SUNHMME/NON EI)S YEU=DOS TW=| E)/SESQAI/ POTE, O(/TE A)LHQOU=S O)/NTOS E)/TI TOU= "1ZH=| *DI/WN"2 OU)K E)/STAI A)LHQE\S TO\ "1KAI\ ZH/SETAI"2, OU(= MH\ O)/NTOS A)LHQOU=S TO\ O(/LON SUNHMME/NON GI/NOITO A)\N YEU=DOS METAPI=PTON: OU) GA\R A)EI/, O(/TE TO\ "1ZH=|"2 A)LHQE/S, KAI\ TO\ "1ZH/SETAI"2, E)PEI\ OU(/TWS A)QA/NATOS A)\N EI)/H O( *DI/WN. OU) MH\N E)/STAI O(RI/SANTAS EI)PEI=N, PO/TE OU)K A)LHQE\S E)/STAI ZW=NTOS AU)TOU= TO\ "1ZH/SETAI"2. DIO\ KAI\ <20E)N A)PERIGRA/FW| KAI\ A)ORI/STW| XRO/NW| LE/GOUSI GI/NESQAI TH\N TW=N TOIOU/TWN A)CIWMA/TWN META/PTWSIN>20. @&Dionysius Halicarn. de compos. verb. p. 31. Re.$ *)/EGWG' OU)=N O(/TE DIE/GNWN SUNTA/TTESQAI TAU/THN TH\N U(PO/QESIN, E)ZH/TOUN EI)/ TI TOI=S PRO/TERON EI)/RHTAI PERI\ AU)TH=S, KAI\ MA/LISTA <20TOI=S A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 FILOSO/FOIS EI)DW\S TOU\S A)/NDRAS OU) MIKRA\N FRONTI/DA TOU= LEKTIKOU= TO/-POU PEPOIHME/NOUS. DEI= GA\R AU)TOI=S TA)LHQH= MARTUREI=N. OU)DAMH= D' OU)DE\N U(P' OU)DENO\S EU(RW\N TW=N O)NO/MATOS H)CIWME/NWN OU)/TE MEI=ZON OU)/T' E)/LATTON SUNAXQE\N EI)S H(\N E)GW\ PROH/|RHMAI PRAGMATEI/AN, A(\S DE\ <20*XRU/-SIPPOS>20 KATALE/LOIPE SUNTA/CEIS DITTA/S, E)PIGRAFH\N E)XOU/SAS "1<20*PERI\ TH=S SUNTA/CEWS TW=N TOU= LO/GOU MERW=N"2>20 OU) R(HTORIKH\N QEWRI/AN E)XOU/SAS, A)LLA\ DIALEKTIKH/N, W(S I)/SASIN OI( TA\S BI/BLOUS A)NEGNWKO/TES, <20U(PE\R A)CIW-MA/TWN SUNTA/CEWS, A)LHQW=N TE KAI\ YEUDW=N KAI\ DUNATW=N KAI\ A)DUNA/TWN, E)NDEXOME/NWN TE KAI\ METAPIPTO/NTWN KAI\ A)MFIBO/- @1LWN KAI\ A)/LLWN TINW=N TOIOUTOTRO/PWN>20, OU)DEMI/AN OU)/TE XREI/AN OU)/T' W)FE/LEIAN TOI=S POLITIKOI=S LO/GOIS SUMBALLOME/NWN, EI)S GOU=N H(DONH\N H)\ KA/LLOS E(RMHNEI/AS, W(=N DEI= STOXA/ZESQAI TH\N SU/NQESIN: TAU/THS ME\N TH=S PRAGMATEI/AS A)PE/STHN. @&Diocles Magnes apud Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 71.$ TW=N D' OU)X A(PLW=N A)CIWMA/TWN <20SUNHMME/NON>20 ME/N E)STIN, W(S O( <20*XRU/SIPPOS E)N TAI=S DIALEKTIKAI=S>20 FHSI KAI\ <20*DIOGE/NHS E)N TH=| DIALEKTIKH=| TE/XNH|>20, TO\ SUNESTO\S DIA\ TOU= "1EI)"2 SUNAPTIKOU= SUNDE/SMOU: E)PAGGE/LLETAI DE\ O( SU/NDESMOS OU(=TOS A)KOLOUQEI=N TO\ DEU/TERON TW=| PRW/TW|, OI(=ON "1EI) H(ME/RA E)STI/, FW=S E)STI"2. [1&Deinde definitur$ TO\ PARASUNHMME/NON, W(S O( *KRI/NIS FHSI\N E)N TH=| DIALEKTIKH=| TE/XNH|]1.& 72.$ <20SUMPEPLEGME/NON>20 DE/ E)STIN A)CI/WMA O(\ U(PO/ TINWN SUMPLEKTIKW=N SUNDE/SMWN SUMPE/PLEKTAI, OI(=ON "1KAI\ H(ME/RA E)STI\ KAI\ FW=S E)STI"2. <20DIEZEUGME/NON>20 DE/ E)STIN, O(\ U(PO\ TOU= ψ"1H)/TOI"2 DIAZEUKTIKOU= SUNDE/SMOU DIE/ZEUKTAI, OI(=ON, "1H)/TOI H(ME/RA E)STI\N H)\ NU/C E)STIN"2. E)PAGGE/LLETAI DE\ O( SU/NDESMOS OU(=TOS TO\ E(/TERON TW=N A)CIW-MA/TWN YEU=DOS EI)=NAI. <20AI)TIW=DES>20 DE/ E)STIN A)CI/WMA TO\ SUNTASSO/MENON DIA\ TOU= "1DIO/TI"2, OI(=ON "1DIO/TI H(ME/RA E)STI/, FW=S E)STI/N"2. OI(ONEI\ GA\R AI)/-TIO/N E)STI TO\ PRW=TON TOU= DEUTE/ROU. <20DIASAFOU=N DE\ TO\ MA=LLON>20 A)CI/WMA/ E)STI TO\ SUNTATTO/MENON U(PO\ TOU= DIASAFOU=NTOS TO\ MA=LLON SUN-DE/SMOU KAI\ TOU= [2"1H)\"2]2 ME/SOU TW=N A)CIWMA/TWN TASSOME/NOU, OI(=ON "1MA=L-LON H(ME/RA E)STI\N H)\ NU/C E)STIN"2. <20DIASAFOU=N DE\ TO\ H(=TTON>20 A)CI/WMA/ E)STI TO\ E)NANTI/ON TW=| PROKEIME/NW|, OI(=ON "1H(=TTON NU/C E)STIN H)\ H(ME/RA E)STI/N"2. @&Galenus introductio dialectica 4 p. 10, 13 Kalbfl.$ EI) DE\ E)F' E(TE/RWN LE/GOITO [2H(]2 FWNH\, [2A(\]2 MH/TE A)KOLOUQI/AN E)/XEI PRO\S A)/LLHLA MH/TE MA/XHN A)POFATIKH/N, <20SUMPEPLEGME/NON>20 KALE/SOMEN TO\ TOIOU=TON A)CI/WMA, KAQA/PER E)PI\ TOU= "1*DI/WN PERIPATEI= KAI\ *QE/WN DIALE/GETAI"2. TAUTI\ GA\R OU)/TE MA/XHN OU)/TE A)KOLOUQI/AN E)/XONTA KATA\ SUMPLOKH\N E(RMH- @1NEU/ETAI. DIO\ KA)PEIDA\N A)POFA/SKWMEN AU)TA/, TO\N LO/GON E)KEI=NON H)/TOI GE <20A)POFATIKH\N SUMPLOKH\N>20 H)\ A)POFATIKO\N EI)=NAI SUMPEPLEGME/NON FH/-SOMEN: OU)DE\N GA\R PRO\S TO\ PARO\N DIAFE/REI SUMPEPLEGME/NON LE/GEIN A)POFATIKO\N H)\ SUMPLOKH/N. __A)LL' <20OI( PERI\ *XRU/SIPPON>20, KA)N-TAU=QA TH=| LE/CEI MA=LLON H)\ TOI=S PRA/GMASI PROSE/XONTES TO\N NOU=N, <20A(/PANTA TA\ DIA\ TW=N SUMPLEKTIKW=N KALOUME/NWN SUNDE/SMWN SUNISTA/-MENA KA)\N E)K MAXOME/NWN H)\ A)KOLOU/QWN, SUMPEPLEGME/NA KA-LOU=SIN>20, E)N OI(=S ME\N E)/GKEITAI/ TIS A)KRI/BEIA DIDASKALI/AS, A)MELW=S XRW/-MENOI TOI=S O)NO/MASIN, E)N OI(=S DE\ OU)DE\N DIAFE/RON AI( FWNAI\ SHMAI/NOUSIN, AU)TOI\ NOMOQETOU=NTES I)/DIA SHMAINO/MENA &etc. @&10Dexippus in Aristot. categ. p. 22, 18 Busse.$10 FAME\N DH\ O(/TI OI( MO/NHN <20SUMPLOKH\N TH\N META\ SUMPLEKTIKOU= SUNDE/SMOU PROFORA\N LE/-GONTES TOI=S *STWI+KOI=S E)PAKOLOUQOU=SIN>20, W(=N A)RXAIO/TEROS *)ARISTOTE/LHS KAI\ TH=| TW=N PRESBUTE/RWN SUNHQEI/A| XRW/MENOS, OI(/TINES TH\N TW=N PLEIO/NWN ME-RW=N TOU= LO/GOU SU/NODON SUMPLOKH\N W)NO/MAZON. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 29 p. 1047c.$ *)ALLA\ MH\N AU)TO\S [1&sc. Chrysippus$]1 TA\S DIA\ DE/KA A)CIWMA/TWN <20SUMPLOKA\S>20 PLH/QEI FHSI\N U(PERBA/LLEIN E(KATO\N MURIA/DAS, OU)/TE DI' AU(TOU= ZHTH/SAS E)PIMELW=S OU)/TE DIA\ TW=N E)MPEI/RWN TO\ A)LHQE\S I(STORH/SAS &etc.$ __<20*XRU/SIPPON>20 DE\ PA/NTES E)LE/GXOUSIN OI( A)RIQMHTIKOI/. W(=N KAI\ *(/IPPARXO/S E)STIN, A)PODEIKNU/WN TO\ DIA/PTWMA TOU= LOGISMOU= PAMME/GEQES AU)TW=| GEGONO/S: EI)/GE TO\ ME\N KATAFATIKO\N POIEI= SUMPEPLEGME/NWN A)CIWMA/TWN MURIA/DAS DE/KA, KAI\ PRO\S TAU/TAIS TRISXI/LIA TESSARA/KONTA E)NNE/A, TO\ D' A)POFATIKO\N E)NNA-KO/SIA PENTH/KONTA DU/O PRO\S TRIA/KONTA KAI\ MIA=| MURIA/SI. @&10Sextus adv. math. VIII 124.$10 E)NE/STAI DE\ A)PO\ TOU/TWN KAI\ E)PI\ TA\ <20SUMPEPLEGME/NA>20 KAI\ E)PI\ TA\ DIEZEUGME/NA KOINW=S TE E)PI\ TA\ LOIPA\ EI)/DH TW=N OU)X A(PLW=N A)CIWMA/TWN DIABAI/NEIN. _O(/TAN LE/GWSIN <20U(GIE\S EI)=NAI SUMPE-PLEGME/NON TO\ PA/NT' E)/XON E)N AU(TW=| A)LHQH=>20, OI(=ON TO\ "1H(ME/RA E)STI\ KAI\ FW=S E)STIN"2, <20YEU=DOS DE\ TO\ E)/XON YEU=DOS>20. &10Haec impugnat Sextus, deinde per-&10git 128.$10 A)LL' W(/SPER E)N TW=| BI/W|, FASI/, TO\ KATA\ ME\N TA\ PLEI=STA ME/RH U(GIE\S I(MA/TION, KAT' O)LI/GON DE\ DIER)R(WGO\S OU)K A)PO\ TW=N PLEI/STWN KAI\ U(GIW=N MERW=N U(GIE\S EI)=NAI LE/GOMEN, A)LL' A)PO\ TOU= O)LI/GOU KAI\ DIER)R(WGO/TOS DIER)R(WGO/S, OU(/TW KAI\ TO\ SUMPEPLEGME/NON, KA)\N E(\N MO/NON E)/XH| YEU=DOS, PLEI/ONA DE\ A)LHQH=, LEX-QH/SETAI TO\ O(/LON A)PO\ TOU= E(NO\S YEU=DOS. @&Galenus de simplic. medicam. II 16. Vol. XI p. 499 K.$ TH\N U(POQETIKH\N PRO/TASIN, H(\N <20OI( PERI\ TO\N *XRU/SIPPON>20 A)CI/WMA SUNHM-ME/NON O)NOMA/ZOUSIN. @&10Gellius Noct. Att. XVI 8, 9. Sed quod Graeci$10 <20SUNHMME/NON. A)CI/WMA>20 &10dicunt__id_tale est%10 "1si Plato ambulat, Plato movetur"2, &10"1si dies est, sol super terras est."2 @1 &10@Item quod illi$10 <20SUMPEPLEGME/NON>20,&10 nos vel "1coniunctum"2 vel "1copu-&10latum"2 dicimus, quod est eiusdemmodi%10 "1P. Scipio, Pauli filius, et bis con-&10sul fuit et triumphavit et censura functus est et collega in censura &10L. Mummi fuit"2. <21In omni autem coniuncto si unum est menda-&10cium, etiamsi cetera vera sunt, totum esse mendacium dicitur.>21 @&10Sextus adv. math. VIII 88.$10 OU) PA/NU DE/ GE DU/NANTAI PARASTH=SAI TO\ A)NTIKEI/MENON H(MI=N <20OI( *STWI+KOI/>20. _FASI\ GA\R: "1<20A)NTIKEI/MENA/ E)STIN W(=N TO\ E(/TERON TOU= E(TE/ROU A)POFA/SEI PLEONA/ZEI>20, OI(=ON: H(ME/RA E)STI/N_OU)X H(ME/RA E)STI/N. TOU= GA\R "3H(ME/RA E)STI/N"3 A)CIW/MATOS TO\ "3OU)X H(ME/RA E)STI/N"3 A)PO-FA/SEI PLEONA/ZEI TH=| "3OU)XI/"3, KAI\ DIA\ TOU=T' A)NTIKEI/MENO/N E)STIN E)KEI/NW|"2 A)LL' EI) TOU=T' E)/STI TO\ A)NTIKEI/MENON, E)/STAI KAI\ TA\ TOIAU=TA A)NTIKEI/MENA TO/ TE "3H(ME/RA E)STI/N [2KAI\ FW=S E)STI/N"3 KAI\ TO\ "3H(ME/RA E)STI/N]2 KAI\ OU)XI\ FW=S E)STIN."3 TOU= GA\R "1H(ME/RA [2E)STI/N KAI\ FW=S]2 E)STIN"2 A)CIW/MATOS A)POFA/SEI PLEONA/ZEI TO\ [2"1H(ME/RA E)STI/N KAI\]2 OU)XI\ FW=S E)STIN"2. <20OU)XI\ DE/ GE KAT' AU)TOU\S TAU=TA A)NTIKEI/-MENA/ E)STIN>20: OU)K A)/RA A)NTIKEI/MENA/ E)STIN [2W(=N]2 TO\ E(/TERON TOU= E(TE/ROU A)PO-FA/SEI PLEONA/ZEI. <20NAI/ FASIN, A)LLA\ SU\N TOU/TW| A)NTIKEI/MENA/ E)STI, SU\N TW=| TH\N A)PO/FASIN PROTETA/XQAI TOU= E(TE/ROU>20: TO/TE GA\R KURIEU/EI TOU= O(/LOU A)CIW/MATOS: E)PI\ DE\ TOU= "1H(ME/RA E)STI\N KAI\ OU)XI\ FW=S E)STI/N"2 ME/ROS OU)=SA TOU= PANTO/S, OU) KURIEU/EI PRO\S TO\ A)POFATIKO\N POIH=SAI TO\ PA=N. @&10Diocles Magnes apud Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 73.$10 E)/TI TW=N A)CIWMA/TWN KATA/ TE A)LH/QEIAN KAI\ YEU=DOS <20A)NTIKEI/MENA>20 A)LLH/LOIS E)STI/N, W(=N TO\ E(/TERON TOU= E(TE/ROU E)STI\N A)POFATIKO/N, OI(=ON TO\ "1H(ME/RA E)STI/N"2 KAI\ TO\ "1OU)XI\ H(ME/RA E)STI/N"2. <20SUNHMME/NON OU)=N A)LHQE/S E)STIN>20, OU(= TO\ A)NTIKEI/MENON TOU= LH/GON-TOS MA/XETAI TW=| H(GOUME/NW|, OI(=ON "1EI) H(ME/RA E)STI/, FW=S E)STI"2. TOU=TO A)LHQE/S E)STI: TO\ GA\R "1OU)XI\ FW=S [2E)STI]2"2, A)NTIKEI/MENON TW=| LH/GONTI, MA/XETAI TW=| "1H(ME/RA E)STI/"2. <20SUNHMME/NON DE\ YEU=DO/S E)STIN>20 OU(= TO\ A)NTIKEI/MENON TOU= LH/GONTOS OU) MA/XETAI TW=| H(GOUME/NW|, OI(=ON "1EI) H(ME/RA E)STI/, *DI/WN PERIPATEI="2. TO\ GA\R "1OU)XI\ *DI/WN PERIPATEI="2 OU) MA/XETAI TW=| "1H(ME/RA E)STI/"2. [1&10sequitur$10 PARASU-NHMME/NON, &10quod inter Crinidis fragmenta posui.$10]1 <20AI)TIW=DES DE\ A)LHQE\S ME/N E)STIN>20, O(\ A)RXO/MENON A)PO\ A)LHQOU=S EI)S A)KO/LOUQON LH/GEI, OU) MH\N E)/XEI TW=| LH/-GONTI TO\ A)RXO/MENON A)KO/LOUQON, OI(=ON "1DIO/TI H(ME/RA E)STI/, FW=S E)STI"2. TW=| ME\N GA\R "1H(ME/RA E)STI/N"2 A)KOLOUQEI= TO\ "1FW=S E)STI"2, TW=| DE\ "1FW=S E)STIN"2 OU)X E(/PETAI TO\ "1H(ME/RA E)STI/N"2. <20AI)TIW=DES DE\ YEU=DO/S E)STIN>20 O(\ H)/TOI A)PO\ YEU/DOUS A)/R-XETAI H)\ MH\ EI)S A)KO/LOUQON LH/GEI H)\ E)/XEI TW=| LH/GONTI TO\ A)RXO/MENON A)KO/LOUQON, OI(=ON "1DIO/TI NU/C E)STI, *DI/WN PERIPATEI="2. @&10Sextus adv. math. VIII 108.$10 KAI\ DH\ <20OU)X A(PLA=>20 ME/N E)STIN A)CIW/-MATA_A(/PER E)C A)CIW/MATOS DIAFOROUME/NOU H)\ A)CIWMA/TWN DIAFERO/NTWN SUNE/-STHKE KAI\ E)N OI(=S SU/NDESMOS H)\ SU/NDESMOI E)PIKRATOU=SIN: LAMBANE/SQW DE\ E)K TOU/TWN E)PI\ TOU= PARO/NTOS TO\ KALOU/MENON <20SUNHMME/NON>20. TOU=TO TOI/NUN SUN-E/STHKEN E)C A)CIW/MATOS DIAFOROUME/NOU H)\ E)C A)CIWMA/TWN DIAFERO/NTWN DIA\ TOU= "1EI)"2 H)\ "1EI)/PER"2 SUNDE/SMOU: OI(=ON E)K DIAFOROUME/NOU ME\N A)CIW/MATOS KAI\ TOU= "1EI)"2 SUNDE/SMOU SUNE/STHKE TO\ TOIOU=TON SUNHMME/NON "1EI) H(ME/RA E)STI/N, H(ME/RA @1 E)STI/N"2. E)K DIAFERO/NTWN DE\ A)CIWMA/TWN KAI\ DIA\ TOU= "1EI)/PER"2 SUNDE/SMOU TO\ OU(/TWS E)/XON "1EI)/PER H(ME/RA E)STI/, FW=S E)STIN"2. TW=N DE\ E)N TW=| SUNHMME/NW| A)CIW-MA/TWN TO\ META\ TO\N "1EI)"2 H)\ TO\N "1EI)/PER"2 SU/NDESMON TETAGME/NON <20H(GOU/MENO/N>20 TE KAI\ PRW=TON KALEI=TAI, TO\ DE\ LOIPO\N <20LH=GO/N>20 TE KAI\ DEU/TERON, KAI\ E)A\N A)NA-STRO/FWS E)KFE/RHTAI TO\ O(/LON SUNHMME/NON, OI(=ON OU(/TWS "1FW=S E)STIN, EI)/PER H(ME/RA ؈E)STI/N"2: KAI\ GA\R E)N TOU/TW| LH=GON ME\N KALEI=TAI TO\ "1FW=S E)STIN"2 KAI/PER PRW=-TON E)CENEXQE/N, H(GOU/MENON DE\ TO\ "1H(ME/RA E)STI/N"2, KAI/PER DEU/TERON LEGO/MENON, DIA\ TO\ META\ TO\N "1EI)/PER"2 SU/NDESMON TETA/XQAI. H( ME\N OU)=N SU/STASIS TOU= SU-NHMME/NOU, W(S E)N SUNTO/MW| EI)PEI=N, E)STI\ TOIAU/TH, <20E)PAGGE/LLESQAI DE\ DOKEI= TO\ TOIOU=TON A)CI/WMA A)KOLOUQEI=N TW=| E)N AU)TW=| PRW/TW| TO\ E)N AU)TW=| DEU/-TERON>20, KAI\ O)/NTOS <20TOU=>20 H(GOUME/NOU E)/SESQAI TO\ LH=GON. O(/QEN <20SW|ZOME/NHS ME\N TH=S TOIAU/THS E)PAGGELI/AS KAI\ A)KOLOUQOU=NTOS TW=| H(GOUME/NW| TOU= LH/GONTOS A)LHQE\S GI/NETAI KAI\ TO\ SUNHMME/NON, MH\ SW|ZOME/NHS DE\ YEU=DOS>20. @&10Galenus introductio dialectica cp. 3 p. 8, 11 Kalbfl.$10 E)PEIDA\N DIO/TI MH\ E)/STI TO/DE, EI)=NAI TO/DE NOW=MEN, OI(=ON [2O(/TI]2 NU\C OU)K E)/STIN, H(ME/RAN EI)=NAI__DIEZEUGME/NON A)CI/WMA/ TISI TW=N NEWTE/RWN FILOSO/FWN [1&10scil. Stoicis$10]1 O)NOMA/ZETAI, KAQA/PER GE KAI\ SUNHMME/NON TO\ E(/TERON EI)=DOS TW=N PROTA/SEWN TW=N U(POQETIKW=N A(\S KATA\ SUNE/XEIAN E)LE/GOMEN GI/GNESQAI [1&10cf. supra%10$10 E)PEIDA\N U(PA/R-XON TI PISTEU/HTAI DI' E(/TERON U(PA/RXEIN H)\ KATA\ SUNE/XEIAN]1, OI)KEIOTE/RA DE/ E)STI LE/CIS TO\ [TA\] "1DIEZEUGME/NON"2 TOI=S A)CIW/MASIN [1A(\S DHLONO/TI DIAIRETIKA\S PRO-TA/SEIS E)/FAMEN O)NOMA/ZESQAI]1 [2TOI=S]2 DIA\ TOU= "1H)/TOI"2 SUNDE/SMOU [1DIAFE/REI DE\ OU)DE\N "1H)\"2 DIA\ MIA=S SULLABH=S LE/GEIN H)\ DIA\ DUOI=N "1H)/TOI"2]1: "1SUNHMME/NON"2 DE\ [2TOI=S]2 DIA\ TOU= "1EI)"2 [2H)\ "1E)PEI\"2]2, EI)/PER E(\N KAI\ OU(=TOI SHMAI/NOUSIN: W(S O)NO-MA/ZESQAI TO\N ME\N TOIOU=TON LO/GON "1EI) H(ME/RA E)STI/N, O( H(/LIOS U(PE\R GH=S E)STIN"2 SUNHMME/NON A)CI/WMA KATA/ GE TOU\S NEWTE/ROUS FILOSO/FOUS. __<20TOU\S DE/ GE TOIOU/TOUS "1H)/TOI G' H(ME/RA E)STI\N H)\ NU/C E)STI"2 DIEZEUGME/NON ME\N A)CI/WMA PARA\ TOI=S NEWTE/ROIS FILOSO/FOIS>20&10 etc.& &@ibid. 14 p. 32, 13 Kalbfl.$ KALOU=SI DE\ TA\S ME\N KATA\ SUNE/XEIAN [1&scil.$ PROTA/SEIS]1 <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 SUNHMME/NA A)CIW/MATA, TA\S DE\ KATA\ DIAI/-RESIN DIEZEUGME/NA, KAI\ SUMFWNEI=TAI/ GE AU)TOI=S DU/O ME\N GI/GNESQAI SULLOGISMOU\S KATA\ TO\ SUNHMME/NON A)CI/WMA, DU/O DE\ KATA\ TO\ DIEZEUGME/-NON. __TRI/TON OU)=N A)NAPO/DEIKTON <20TW=N PERI\ TO\N *XRU/SIPPON>20 H(GOUME/NWN E)C A)POFATIKOU= SUMPEPLEGME/NOU KAI\ QATE/ROU TW=N E)N AU)TW=| TO\ A)NTIKEI/MENON TOU= LOIPOU= PERAI/NONTA &etc.&10 &10@Epimerismi Homer. Cramer. Anecd. Ox. I p. 188.$10 O( "1H)\"2 SU/NDESMOS YILOU/MENOS KAI\ O)CUNO/MENOS SHMAI/NEI TRI/A: H)\ DIAZEUKTIKO/S E)STIN H)\ U(PODIA-ZEUKTIKO\S H)\ DIASAFHTIKO/S__TI/ DIAFE/ROUSIN A)LLH/LWN; O(/TI O( ME\N DIA-ZEUKTIKO\S TO\ E(/TERON MO/NON TW=N U(POKEIME/NWN AI(REI=TAI, TO\ DE\ E(/TERON A)NAIREI=: "1H)\ H(ME/RA E)STI\N H)\ NU/C"2 [1TO\ E(/TERON MO/NON: OU) GA\R DU/NATAI A)MFO/TERA]1__ O( DE\ PARADIAZEUKTIKO\S KAI\ A)MFO/TERA DU/NATAI PARALAMBA/NEIN, E)PEIDA\N OU(/TW LE/GWMEN "1E)RE/SSWN H)\ E)PISPA=TAI TH\N KW/PHN H)\ A)PWQEI=TAI"2 [1A)MFO/TERA GA\R @1 POIEI=]1__E)/STI DE\ KAI\ DIASAFHTIKO/S, O( E)LEGKTIKO\S KALOU/MENOS PARA\ TOI=S *STWI+KOI=S, OU(/TWS LU/SEIS "1BOU/LOM' E)GW\ LAO\N SO/ON E)/MMENAI H)\ A)POLE/SQAI"2. E)/STI GA\R H)/PER A)POLE/SQAI. E)N H)/QEI DE\ LE/GETAI U(PO\ TOU= *)AGAME/MNONOS. @&10Gellius Noct. Att. XVI 8, 12. Est item aliud, quod Graeci$10 <20DIE-ZEUGME/NON A)CI/WMA>20, &10nos "1disiunctum"2 dicimus. Id huiuscemodi est%10 "1aut &10malum est voluptas aut bonum aut neque bonum neque malum est"2. &10Omnia autem, quae disiunguntur, pugnantia esse inter sese oportet, eorum-&10que opposita, quae$10 A)NTIKEI/MENA &10Graeci dicunt, ea quoque ipsa inter se ad-&10versa esse. <21Ex omnibus, quae disiunguntur, unum esse verum &10debet, falsa cetera.>21 Quod si aut nihil omnium verum, aut omnia &10plurave quam unum vera erunt, aut quae disiuncta sunt non pugnabunt, &10aut quae opposita eorum sunt contraria inter sese non erunt, tunc id dis-&10iunctum mendacium est et appellatur$10 <20PARADIEZEUGME/NON>20; &10sicuti hoc est, &10in quo quae opposita non sunt contraria: "1aut curris aut ambulas aut &10stas"2. __possis enim simul eodemque tempore neque ambulare neque &10stare neque currere. &10@Cicero Acad. Pr. II 97. cum ab Edicuro__non impetrent, ut &10verum esse concedat, quod ita effabimur%10 "1aut vivet cras Hermarchus aut &10non vivet"2, <21cum dialectici sic statuant, omne quod ita disiunctum &10sit, quasi "3aut etiam aut non"3 non modo verum esse, sed etiam &10necessarium.>21 [1paulo post%10]1 dialectici__id est Antiochus et <21Stoici.>21 &10@Galenus introductio dialectica 5 p. 12, 3 Kalbfl.$10 [2E)N]2 E)NI/OIS D' A)CIW/MASIN E)GXWREI= ME\N EI)=NAI KAI\ PLEI/W KAI\ PA/NTA, MH\ MO/NON E(/N, A)NAGKAI=ON D' E)STI\ TO\ E(\N U(PA/RXEIN: O)NOMA/ZOUSI D' E)/NIOI TA\ TOIAU=TA "1<20PARADIEZEUG-ME/NA"2>20, TW=N DIEZEUGME/NWN E(\N MO/NON E)XO/NTWN A)LHQE/S, A)/N T' E)K DUOI=N A)CIW-MA/TWN A(PLW=N A)/N T' E)K PLEIO/NWN SUGKE/HTAI. @&10Sextus adv. math. VIII 244.$10 BRAXE/A D' I)/SWS DEH/SEI KAI\ PERI\ TOU= A)RE/SKONTOS AU)TOI=S PROLABEI=N, KAQ' O(\ A)CI/WMA QE/LOUSIN EI)=NAI TO\ SHMEI=ON, KAI\ DIA\ TOU=TO NOHTO/N. U(POGRA/FONTES TOI/NUN FASI\ <20SHMEI=ON EI)=NAI A)CI/WMA E)N U(GIEI= SUNHMME/NW| KAQHGOU/MENON, E)KKALUPTIKO\N TOU= LH/GONTOS>20. KRI/SEIS DE\ TOU= U(GIOU=S SUNHMME/NOU POLLA\S ME\N KAI\ A)/LLAS EI)=NAI/ FASIN, MI/AN D' E)C A(PASW=N U(PA/RXEIN__TH\N A)PODOQHSOME/NHN. PA=N GA\R SUNHMME/NON H)\ A)PO\ A)LHQOU=S A)RXO/MENON EI)S A)LHQE\S LH/GEI, H)\ A)PO\ YEU/DOUS A)RXO/MENON E)PI\ YEU=DOS LH/GEI, H)\ A)P' A)LHQOU=S E)PI\ YEU=DOS, H)\ A)PO\ YEU/DOUS E)P' A)LHQE/S. A)PO\ ME\N OU)=N A)LHQOU=S A)RXO/MENON E)P' A)LHQE\S LH/GEI TO\ "1[2EI)]2 EI)SI\ QEOI/, PRONOI/A| QEW=N DIOIKEI=TAI O( KO/SMOS"2, A)PO\ YEU/DOUS DE\ E)PI\ YEU=DOS TO\ "1EI) PE/TATAI H( GH=, PTE/RUGAS E)/XEI H( GH="2, A)PO\ YEU/DOUS DE\ E)P' A)LHQE\S TO/ "1EI) PE/TATAI H( GH=, E)/STIN H( GH="2, A)PO\ DE\ A)LHQOU=S E)PI\ YEU=DOS TO\ "1EI) KINEI=TAI OU(=TOS, PERIPATEI= OU(=TOS"2 MH\ PERIPATOU=NTOS ME\N AU)TOU=, KINOUME/NOU DE/. TESSA/RWN OU)=N OU)SW=N TOU= SUNHMME/NOU SUZUGIW=N, __<20KATA\ ME\N TOU\S PRW/TOUS TREI=S TRO/-POUS FASI\N A)LHQE\S TOU=TO GI/NESQAI_KAQ' E(/NA DE\ MO/NON GI/NE- @1SQAI YEU=DOS, O(/TAN A)P' A)LHQOU=S A)RXO/MENON LH/GH| E)PI\ YEU=DOS>20. TOU/-TWN DE\ OU(/TWS E)XO/NTWN A)NAZHTHTE/ON, FASI/, TO\ SHMEI=ON OU)K E)N TW=| MOXQHRW=| TOU/TW| SUNHMME/NW| A)LL' E)N TW=| U(GIEI=: EI)/RHTAI GA\R A)CI/WMA TO\ E)N U(GIEI= SUNHM-ME/NW| KAQHGOU/MENON. A)LL' E)PEI\ OU)X E(\N H)=N U(GIE\S SUNHMME/NON, TRI/A DE/, KA-QA/PER TO\ A)P' A)LHQOU=S A)RXO/MENON KAI\ E)P' A)LHQE\S LH=GON KAI\ TO\ A)PO\ YEU/DOUS E)PI\ YEU=DOS KAI\ TO\ A)PO\ YEU/DOUS E)P' A)LHQE/S, SKEPTE/ON PO/TERO/N POTE E)N PA=SI ZHTHTE/ON TOI=S U(GIE/SI SUNHMME/NOIS TO\ SHMEI=ON H)\ E)N TISI\N H)\ E)N TINI/. OU)KOU=N EI) TO\ SHMEI=ON A)LHQE\S EI)=NAI DEI= KAI\ A)LHQOU=S PARASTATIKO/N, OU)/TE E)N TW=| A)PO\ YEU/DOUS A)RXOME/NW| KAI\ E)PI\ YEU=DOS LH/GONTI OU)/TE E)N TW=| A)PO\ YEU/DOUS E)P' A)LHQE\S U(POKEI/SETAI. LEI/PETAI OU)=N [2E)N]2 E)KEI/NW| MO/NON AU)TO\ TUGXA/NEIN TW=| A)PO\ TOU= A)LHQOU=S TE A)RXOME/NW| KAI\ E)P' A)LHQE\S LH/GONTI, W(S A)\N KAI\ AU)TOU= U(PA/R-XONTOS KAI\ TOU= SHMEIWTOU= SUNUPA/RXEIN O)FEI/LONTOS AU)TW=|. TOI/NUN O(/TAN LE/-GHTAI <20TO\ SHMEI=ON>20 A)CI/WMA EI)=NAI E)N U(GIEI= SUNHMME/NW| KAQHGOU/MENON, <20DEH/SEI E)N MO/NW| A)KOU/EIN AU)TO\ KAQHGOU/MENON SUNHMME/NW| TW=| A)P' A)LHQOU=S TE A)RXOME/NW| KAI\ E)P' A)LHQE\S LH/GONTI>20. _KAI\ MH\N OU)K EI)/TI H(GEI=TAI A)CI/WMA E)N U(GIEI= SUNHMME/NW| A)P' A)LHQOU=S TE A)RXOME/NW| KAI\ E)P' A)LHQE\S LH/-GONTI, TOU=TO/ E)STI SHMEI=ON: [1&10sequitur exemplum$10]1 DEI= A)/RA TO\ SHMEI=ON__ KAI\ E)KKALUPTIKH\N E)/XEIN FU/SIN TOU= LH/GONTOS, OI(=O/N E)STI TO\ E)N TOI=S TOIOU/TOIS SUNHMME/NOIS "1EI) GA/LA E)/XEI E)N MASTOI=S H(/DE, KEKU/HKEN H(/DE"2 KAI\ "1EI) BROGXEI=ON E)/PTUKEN OU(=TOS, E(/LKOS E)/XEI E)N PNEU/MONI OU(=TOS"2. TOUTI\ GA\R TO\ SUNHMME/NON U(GIE/S E)STIN, A)RXO/MENON ME\N A)P' A)LHQOU=S__LH=GON D' E)P' A)LHQE/S__ <20META\ TOU= E)KKALUPTIKO\N EI)=NAI TO\ PRW=TON TOU= DEUTE/ROU>20: E)KEI/NW| GA\R PROSBA/LLONTES KATA/LHYIN TOU/TOU POIOU/MEQA. ݈@*)/ETI, FASI/, <20TO\ SHMEI=ON PARO\N PARO/NTOS EI)=NAI DEI= SHMEI=ON>20. E)/NIOI GA\R E)CAPATW/MENOI KAI\ PARO\N PARW|XHME/NOU QE/LOUSIN EI)=NAI SHMEI=ON, W(S E)PI\ TOU= "1EI) OU)LH\N E)/XEI OU(=TOS, E(/LKOS E)/SXHKEN OU(=TOS"2. EI) ME\N GA\R OU)LH\N E)/XEI, PARO/N E)STI, FAI/NETAI GA/R, TO\ DE\ E(/LKOS E)SXHKE/NAI PARW|XHME/NON, OU)KE/TI GA/R E)STIN E(/LKOS: KAI\ PARO\N ME/LLONTOS, W(S TO\ PERIEXO/MENON TW=| TOIOU/TW| SUNHMME/NW| "1EI) KARDI/AN TE/TRWTAI OU(=TOS, A)POQANEI=TAI OU(=TOS"2. TO\ ME\N GA\R TRAU=MA TH=S KAR-DI/AS EI)=NAI/ FASIN H)/DH, TO\N DE\ QA/NATON ME/LLEIN: A)GNOOU=SI DH\ OI( TA\ TOIAU=TA LE/GONTES O(/TI A)/LL' E)STI TA\ PARW|XHME/NA KAI\ TA\ ME/LLONTA, TO\ ME/NTOI SHMEI=ON KAI\ TO\ SHMEIWTO\N KA)N TOU/TOIS PARO\N PARO/NTOS E)STI/N. E)/N TE GA\R TW=| PROTE/RW| _TO\ ME\N E(/LKOS GE/GONEN H)/DH KAI\ PARW/|XHKEN, TO\ DE\ E(/LKOS E)SXHKE/NAI TOU=TON A)CI/WMA KAQESTHKO\S E)NE/STHKEN, PERI\ GEGONO/TOS TINO\S LEGO/MENON: E)/N TE TW=| "1EI) KARDI/AN TE/TRWTAI OU(=TOS, A)POQANEI=TAI OU(=TOS"2, O( ME\N QA/NATOS ME/LLEI, TO\ DE\ A)POQANEI=SQAI TOU=TON A)CI/WMA E)NE/STHKEN, PERI\ ME/LLONTOS LEGO/MENON, PARO\ KAI\ NU=N E)STIN A)LHQE/S. W(/STE KAI\ A)CI/WMA/ E)STI TO\ SHMEI=ON, KAI\ E)N U(GIEI= SUNHMME/NW| KAQHGEI=TAI, TW=| A)RXOME/NW| A)PO\ A)LHQOU=S KAI\ LH/GONTI E)P' A)LHQE/S, E)KKALUPTI-KO/N TE/ E)STI TOU= LH/GONTOS, KAI\ DIA\ PANTO\S PARO\N PARO/NTOS E)STI\ SHMEI=ON. @*TOU/TWN D' U(PODEDEIGME/NWN <20KATA\ TA\S AU)TW=N E)KEI/NWN TEXNOLO-GI/AS>20 &10etc. &10@Sextus adv. math. VIII 117.$10 TW=N ME\N AI)SQHTO\N U(POLAMBANO/NTWN TOU=TO [1&10scil.$10 TO\ SHMEI=ON]1 EI)=NAI, TW=N DE\ NOHTO/N. *)EPI/KOUROS ME\N GA\R KAI\ OI( PROESTW=TES AU)TOU= TH=S AI(RE/SEWS E)/LECAN AI)SQHTO\N EI)=NAI TO\ SHMEI=ON, <20OI( DE\ A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 NOHTO/N. @1 @&10Sextus adv. math. VIII 275.$10 <20OI( DE\ DOGMATIKOI\>20 PRO\S E(/KASTON ME\N TW=N OU(/TWS E)PIKEXEIRHME/NWN [1&10argumenta scil. quibus sceptici probabant &10nullum esse$10 SHMEI=ON]1 PEFI/MWNTAI, TOU)NANTI/ON DE\ KATASKEUA/ZONTE/S FASIN O(/TI A)/NQRWPOS OU)XI\ TW=| PROFORIKW=| LO/GW| DIAFE/REI TW=N A)LO/GWN ZW/|WN [1<20KAI\ GA\R KO/RAKES KAI\ YITTAKOI\ KAI\ KI/TTAI E)NA/RQROUS PROFE/RONTAI FWNA/S>20]1 A)LLA\ TW=| E)NDIAQE/TW|, OU)DE\ TH=| A(PLH=| MO/NON FANTASI/A| [1E)FANTASIOU=TO GA\R KA)-KEI=NA]1 A)LLA\ TH=| METABATIKH=| KAI\ SUNQETIKH=|. DIO/PER <20A)KOLOUQI/AS E)/NNOIAN E)/XWN>20 EU)QU\S KAI\ <20SHMEI/OU NO/HSIN LAMBA/NEI>20 DIA\ TH\N A)KOLOUQI/AN: KAI\ GA\R AU)TO\ TO\ SHMEI=O/N E)STI TOIOU=TON "1EI) TO/DE, TO/DE"2. E(/PETAI A)/RA TH=| FU/SEI KAI\ KATASKEUH=| TA)NQRW/POU TO\ KAI\ SHMEI=ON U(PA/RXEIN. _<20SUNWMOLO/GHTAI/>20 TE H( <20A)PO/DEICIS TW=| GE/NEI SHMEI=ON EI)=NAI>20. DHLWTIKH\ GA/R E)STI TOU= SUMPERA/S-MATOS, KAI\ E)/STAI H( DIA\ TW=N LHMMA/TWN AU)TH=S SUMPLOKH\ SHMEI=ON TOU= U(PA/R-XEIN TO\ SUMPE/RASMA. OI(=ON E)PI\ TH=S TOIAU/THS "1EI) E)/STI KI/NHSIS, E)/STI KENO/N: E)/STI DE\ KI/NHSIS: E)/STIN A)/RA KENO/N"2 TO\ TOIOU=TON SUMPEPLEGME/NON "1EI) E)/STI KI/-NHSIS, E)/STI KENO/N [2KAI\ E)/STI KI/NHSIS]2"2, DIA\ TW=N LHMMA/TWN SUMPEPLEGME/NON, EU)QU\S KAI\ SHMEI=O/N E)STI TOU= SUMPERA/SMATOS TOU= "1E)/STI KENO/N"2. H)/TOI OU)=N A)PO-DEIKTIKOI/ EI)SI LO/GOI, FASI/N, OI( KATA\ TOU= SHMEI/OU KOMISQE/NTES U(PO\ TW=N A)PO-RHTIKW=N H)\ OU)K A)PODEIKTIKOI/. KAI\ EI) ME\N OU)/K EI)SIN A)PODEIKTIKOI/, A)/PISTOI KAQESTA=SIN, O(/POU GE KAI\ A)PODEIKTIKOI\ TUGXA/NONTES MO/LIS A)\N E)PISTEU/QHSAN: EI) DE\ A)PODEIKTIKOI/, DH=LON O(/TI E)/STI TI SHMEI=ON: H( GA\R A)PO/DEICIS SHMEI=ON H)=N KATA\ TO\ GE/NOS. _EI)/PER DE\ OU)DE\N OU)DENO/S E)STI SHMEI=ON, H)/TOI SHMAI/NOUSI/ TI AI( KATA\ TOU= SHMEI/OU E)KFERO/MENAI FWNAI\ H)\ OU)DE\N SHMAI/NOUSIN. KAI\ EI) ME\N OU)DE\N, OU)DE\ TH\N TOU= SHMEI/OU U(/PARCIN A)NELOU=SIN: PW=S GA\R OI(=O/N TE TA\S MHDE\N SHMAINOU/SAS PISTEU/ESQAI PERI\ TOU= MHDE\N EI)=NAI SHMEI=ON; EI) DE\ SHMAI/NOUSI, MA/TAIOI KAQESTA=SIN OI( A)PO\ TH=S SKE/YEWS, LO/GW| ME\N E)KBA/LLONTES TO\ SHMEI=ON, E)/RGW| DE\ TOU=TO PARALAMBA/NONTES. _KAI\ MH\N EI) MHDE/N E)STI QEW/RHMA TE/XNHS I)/DION, OU) DIOI/SEI TH=S A)TEXNI/AS H( TE/XNH: EI) D' E)/STI QEW/RHMA TE/XNHS I)/DION, H)/TOI FAINO/MENO/N E)STIN H)\ A)/DHLON: A)LLA\ FAINO/MENON ME\N OU)K A)\N EI)/H: TA\ GA\R FAINO/MENA PA=SIN O(MOI/WS KAI\ A)DIDA/KTWS FAI/NETAI. EI) DE\ A)/DHLON TUGXA/NEI, DIA\ SHMEI/OU QEWRHQH/SETAI. EI) DE\ E)/STI TI DIA\ SHMEI/OU QEWROU/MENON, E)/STAI TI KAI\ SHMEI=ON. *TINE\S DE\ KAI\ OU(/TW SUNERWTW=SIN "1EI) E)/STI TI SHMEI=ON, E)/STI SHMEI=ON: EI) MH\ E)/STI SHMEI=ON, E)/STI SHMEI=ON. H)/TOI D' OU)DE/N E)STI SHMEI=ON H)\ E)/STIN: E)/STIN A)/RA"2. @&Sextus adv. math. XI 8.$ TO\N GA\R O(/RON FASI\N <20OI( TEXNO-GRA/FOI>20 YILH=| TH=| SUNTA/CEI DIAFE/REIN TOU= KAQOLIKOU=, DUNA/MEI TO\N AU)-TO\N O)/NTA. KAI\ EI)KO/TWS: O( GA\R EI)PW\N "1A)/NQRWPO/S E)STI ZW=|ON LOGIKO\N QNHTO/N"2 TW=| EI)PO/NTI "1EI)/ TI/ E)STIN A)/NQRWPOS, E)KEI=NO ZW=|O/N E)STI LOGIKO\N QNHTO/N"2 TH=| ME\N DUNA/MEI TO\ AU)TO\ LE/GEI, TH=| DE\ FWNH=| DIA/FORON. KAI\ O(/TI TOU=TO, SUMFANE\S E)K TOU= MH\ MO/NON <20TO\ KAQOLIKO\N>20 TW=N E)PI\ ME/ROUS EI)=NAI PERILHPTIKO/N, A)LLA\ KAI\ <20TO\N O(/RON>20 E)PI\ PA/NTA TA\ EI)/DH TOU= A)PO- @1DIDOME/NOU PRA/GMATOS DIH/KEIN, OI(=ON TO\N ME\N TOU= A)NQRW/POU E)PI\ PA/N-TAS TOU\S KAT' EI)=DOS A)NQRW/POUS, TO\N DE\ TOU= I(/PPOU E)PI\ PA/NTAS TOU\S I(/PPOUS. E(NO/S TE U(POTAXQE/NTOS YEU/DOUS E(KA/TERON GI/NETAI MOXQHRO/N, TO/ TE KAQOLIKO\N KAI\ O( O(/ROS. A)LLA\ GA\R W(S TAU=TA FWNAI=S E)CHLLAGME/NA KATA\ DU/NAMI/N E)STI TA\ AU)TA/, W(=DE KAI\ H( <20TE/LEIOS, FASI/, DIAI/RESIS>20, DU/NAMIN E)/XOUSA KAQOLIKH/N, SUNTA/CEI TOU= KAQOLIKOU= DIENH/NOXEN. O( GA\R TRO/PW| TW=|DE DIAIROU/MENOS "1TW=N A)NQRW/PWN OI( ME/N EI)SIN *(/ELLHNES OI( DE\ BA/RBAROI"2 I)/SON TI LE/GEI TW=| "1EI)/ TINE/S EI)SIN A)/NQRWPOI, E)KEI=NOI H)\ *(/ELLHNE/S EI)SIN H)\ BA/RBAROI"2. E)A\N GA/R TIS A)/NQRWPOS EU(RI/SKHTAI MH/TE *(/ELLHN MH/TE BA/RBAROS, A)NA/GKH MOXQHRA\N ME\N EI)=NAI TH\N DIAI/RESIN, YEU=DOS DE\ GI/NESQAI TO\ KAQOLIKO/N. DIO/PER KAI\ TO\ OU(/TW LEGO/MENON "1TW=N O)/NTWN TA\ ME/N E)STIN A)GAQA/, TA\ DE\ KAKA/, TA\ DE\ TOU/TWN METACU/"2 DUNA/MEI <20KATA\ TO\N *XRU/SIPPON>20 TOIOU=TO/N E)STI KAQOLIKO/N "1EI)/ TINA/ E)STIN O)/NTA, E)KEI=NA H)/TOI A)GAQA/ E)STIN H)\ KAKA/ E)STIN H)\ A)DIA/FORA"2. @&10Simplicius in Arist. categ. f. 16 B. ed. Bas.$10 KAI\ TOU= ME\N O)NO/-MATOS TO\ SUNH|RHME/NON H)/, W(S <20OI( *STWI+KOI/>20 FASI, TO\ KEFALAIW=DES DHLOU=NTOS, <20TOU= DE\ O(RISMOU=>20 TO\ DIAKEKRIME/NON &10etc.& &@Scholia Vaticana in Dionys. Thrac. p. 107, 5 Hilgaro [1Gram. &Gr. III]1.$ <20O( DE\ *XRU/SIPPOS>20 LE/GEI O(/TI O(/ROS E)STI\N H( TOU= I)DI/OU A)PO/-DOSIS, TOUTE/STIN O( TO\ I)/DION A)PODIDOU/S. O( DE\ <20*)ANTI/PATROS>20 O( *STWI+-KO\S LE/GEI: O(/ROS E)STI\ LO/GOS KAT' A)NA/GKHN E)KFERO/MENOS, TOUTE/STI KAT' A)NTISTROFH/N: KAI\ GA\R O( O(/ROS A)NTISTRE/FEIN QE/LEI. @&Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 60.$ O(/ROS DE/ E)STIN, W(/S FHSIN <20*)ANTI/PATROS>20 E)N TW=| PRW/TW| PERI\ O(/RWN LO/GOS KAT' A)NA/LUSIN A)PARTIZO/NTWS E)KFERO/MENOS H)\ W(S <20*XRU/SIPPOS E)N TW=| PERI\ O(/RWN>20 I)DI/OU A)PO/DOSIS. @&10Galenus defin. medicae 1. Vol. XIX p. 349 K.$10 <20O(/ROS>20 E)STI\ LO/GOS KAT' A)NA/LUSIN A)PARTIZO/NTWS E)KFERO/MENOS. @&10Ibid.$10 <20U(POGRAFH/>20 E)STI LO/GOS TUPWDW=S EI)SA/GWN EI)S TH\N DHLOUME/NHN TOU= PRA/GMATOS GNW=SIN. @&10Alexander in Aristot. Top. p. 24 Ald. p. 42, 20.$10 OU)K A)/RA AU)/-TARKES TO\ H)=N [1&10scil.$10 E)N TW=| TI/ H)=N EI)=NAI]1, W(/S TINES H(GOU=NTAI, W(=N DOKEI= PRW=-TOS ME\N *)ANTISQE/NHS EI)=NAI, EI)=TA DE\ KAI\ <20TW=N A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S TINE/S>20, A)LLA\ EU)LO/GWS TO\ EI)=NAI PRO/SKEITAI.&10 &10@Idem paulo post%10$10 OI( DE\ LE/GONTES O(/RON EI)=NAI LO/GON KATA\ A)NA/LUSIN A)PAR-TIZO/NTWS E)KFERO/MENON [1A)NA/LUSIN ME\N LE/GONTES TH\N E)CA/PLWSIN TOU= O(RISTOU= KAI\ KEFALAIWDW=S, A)PARTIZO/NTWS DE\ TO\ MH/TE U(PERBA/LLEIN MH/TE E)NDEI=N]1 OU)DE\N A)\N LE/GOIEN TO\N O(/RON DIAFE/REIN TH=S TOU= I)DI/OU A)PODO/SEWS &10etc. &10@Galenus de differentia pulsuum IV 2. Vol. VIII p. 708 K.$10 A)R-CW/MEQ' OU)=N AU)=QIS A)PO\ TW=N <20E)NNOHMATIKW=N O(/RWN>20, OU(\S OU)DE\N E)/FAMEN E(R- @1MHNEU/EIN PLE/ON W(=N A(/PANTES A)/NQRWPOI GIGNW/SKOUSIN. __OU(\S OI( DEINOI\ PERI\ TA\S PROSHGORI/AS OU)D' O(/ROUS A)CIOU=SIN, A)LL' <20U(POGRAFA/S>20 TE KAI\ <20U(PO-TUPW/SEIS O)NOMA/ZEIN>20. @&Galenus adv. Lycum 3. Vol. XVIII A. p. 209 K.$ OU(/TWS OU)=N A)PAI/DEUTON E)RWTA=| LO/GON O( *LU/KOS, W(/STE OU)K AI)SQA/NETAI TA\S TE/XNAS A(PA/SAS A)NAIRW=N. <20E)N GA/R TOI TH=| GNW/SEI TW=N DIAFORW=N E(KA/STOU TW=N O)/NTWN AI( TE/XNAI SUNI/STANTAI>20. KAI\ TOU=TO E)PI\ PLEI=STON ME\N KA)N TW=| *FILH/BW| DIH=LQEN O( *PLA/TWN EU)QU\S E)N A)RXH=| TOU= SUGGRA/MMATOS: E)FU/LACE D' AU)TOU= TH\N GNW/MHN *)ARISTOTE/LHS KAI\ *QEO/FRASTOS, <20*XRU/-SIPPO/S>20 TE KAI\ *MNHSI/QEOS KAI\ OU)DEI\S O(/STIS OU) DIH=LQEN E)N TW=| PERI\ TE/XNHS GRA/MMATI TO\N AU)TO\N LO/GON. @&Galenus de libris propriis 11. Vol. XIX p. 43 K.$ E)/TI DE\ PAI=S W)/N, H(NI/KA PRW=TON O( PATH/R ME TW=| TH\N LOGIKH\N QEWRI/AN *XRUSI/P-POU KAI\ TW=N E)NDO/CWN *STWI+KW=N DIDA/CONTI PARE/DWKEN, E)POIHSA/MHN E)MAUTW=| <20TW=N *XRUSI/PPOU SULLOGISTIKW=N BIBLI/WN>20 U(POMNH/MATA. @&Galenus de libris propriis 16. Vol. XIX p. 47 K.$ PERI\ TH=S KATA\ *XRU/-SIPPON LOGIKH=S QEWRI/AS G#. TH=S *XRUSI/PPOU SULLOGISTIKH=S PRW/THS U(POMNH/MATA G#. DEUTE/RAS E(/N. PERI\ TH=S LOGIKH=S DUNA/MEWS KAI\ QEW-RI/AS Z#. PERI\ TH=S XREI/AS TW=N EI)S TOU\S SULLOGISMOU\S QEWRHMA/TWN E(/N. __PERI\ TH=S XREI/AS TW=N EI)S TOU\S SULLOGISMOU\S QEWRHMA/TWN B#. @&Lucianus Icaromen. 24 [1Iupiter loquitur%10$]1 TOIGAROU=N YUXRO-TE/ROUS A)/N MOU TOU\S BWMOU\S I)/DOIS TW=N *PLA/TWNOS *NO/MWN H)\ TW=N <20*XRU-SI/PPOU>20 SULLOGISMW=N. @&Galenus de Hiprocr. et Plat. plac II. 3[1`91]1 p. 178 Mu+.$ KAI\ TAU/TH| DIH/NEGKEN E)PISTHMONIKO\N DEI/CEWS LH=MMA R(HTORIKOU= TE KAI\ GUMNASTIKOU= KAI\ SOFISTIKOU=, U(PE\R W(=N OU)D' AU)TW=N OU)DEMI/AN E)DI/DACAN H(MA=S OU)/TE ME/QODON OU)/TE GUMNASI/AN <20OI(/GE PERI\ TO\N *ZH/NWNA KAI\ TO\N *XRU/SIPPON>20. O(/QEN A)NAME/MIKTAI FU/RDHN <20E)N TOI=S BIBLI/OIS AU)-TW=N>20 E)FECH=S A(/PANTA TA\ LH/MMATA. KAI\ POLLA/KIS H(GEI=TAI ME/N, EI) OU(/TWS E)/XEI, R(HTORIKO\N E)PIXEI/RHMA, TOU/TW| D' E(/PETAI GUMNASTIKO/N TE KAI\ DIA- @1LEKTIKO/N, EI)=Q' E(CH=S E)PISTHMONIKO/N, EI)=Q' OU(/TWS EI) E)/TUXE SOFISTIKO/N, OU)K EI)DO/TWN, W(S TA\ ME\N E)PISTHMONIKA\ LH/MMATA PRO\S TH\N OU)SI/AN A)NA-FE/RETAI TOU= ZHTOUME/NOU &etc. @&10Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 45.$10 EI)=NAI DE\ TO\N <20LO/GON>20 AU)TO\N SU/STHMA E)K LHMMA/TWN KAI\ E)PIFORA=S: TO\N DE\ <20SULLOGISMO\N>20 LO/GON SULLOGISTIKO\N E)K TOU/TWN: TH\N DE\ A)PO/DEICIN LO/GON DIA\ TW=N MA=LLON KATALAMBANOME/NWN TO\ H(=T-TON KATALAMBANO/MENON PERAI/NONTA. @[&10Ammonius] in Aristot. Analyt. pr. [1Comm. graec. IV 6]1 p. 68, 4 &10Wal.$10 TI/NA TA\ O)NO/MATA OI(=S <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 KE/XRHNTAI; OU(=TOI TOI/NUN TA\ PRA/G-MATA TUGXA/NONTA KALOU=SI: TE/LOS GA\R TO\ TUXEI=N TOU/TWN: TA\ NOH/MATA E)KFORIKA/. TAU=TA GA\R E)KFE/ROMEN DIA\ TW=N FWNW=N, TA\S FWNA\S LEKTA/. TO\ SUNHMME/NON H)\ DIEZEUGME/NON <20TROPIKO\N>20 DIA\ TO\ TRO/PON POIEI=SQAI A)P' A)/LLHS PROTA/SEWS EI)S A)/LLHN: TO\ H(GOU/MENON O(MOI/WS H(MI=N <20H(GOU/MENON>20, TO\ E(PO/MENON <20LH=GON>20, TH\N PRO/SLHYIN O(MOI/WS H(MI=N <20PRO/SLHYIN>20. __O(\ D' H(MEI=S LE/GOMEN SUMPE/RASMA, E)KEI=NOI <20E)PIFORA\N>20 KALOU=SI. TOU\S D' U(POQETIKOU\S SULLOGISMOU\S <20A)NAPODEI/K-TOUS KALOU=SI>20 KAI\ <20QE/MATA>20. @&10Ammonius in Aristot. Analyt. pr. p. 26, 36$10 <20OI( DE\ *STWI+KOI\>20 A)CIW/MATA AU)TA\S [1&10scil.$10 TA\S PROTA/SEIS]1 E)KA/LOUN KAI\ <20LH/MMATA>20 PARA\ TO\ LAM-BA/NEIN KAI\ A)CIOU=N AU)TA\S A)LHQEI=S EI)=NAI, W(S TA\ PARA\ TOI=S GEWME/TRAIS A)CIW/MATA. @&10Diocles Magnes apud Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 77.$10 TW=N DE\ LO/GWN OI( ME/N EI)SIN <20A)PE/RANTOI, OI( DE\ PERANTIKOI/: A)PE/RANTOI>20 ME\N W(=N TO\ A)NTIKEI/MENON TH=S E)PIFORA=S OU) MA/XETAI TH=| DIA\ TW=N LHMMA/TWN SUMPLOKH=|, OI(=ON OI( TOIOU=TOI "1EI) H(ME/RA E)STI/, FW=S E)STI: H(ME/RA DE/ E)STI: PERIPATEI= A)/RA *DI/WN"2. TW=N DE\ <20PERANTIKW=N>20 LO/GWN OI( ME\N O(MWNU/MWS TW=| GE/NEI LE/GONTAI PERANTIKOI/, OI( DE\ <20SULLOGISTIKOI/>20. SULLOGISTIKOI\ ME\N OU)=N EI)SIN OI( H)/TOI A)NAPO/DEIKTOI O)/NTES H)\ A)NAGO/MENOI E)PI\ TOU\S A)NAPODEI/KTOUS KATA/ TI TW=N QEMA/TWN H)\ TINA/, OI(=ON OI( TOIOU=TOI "1EI) PE-RIPATEI= *DI/WN, [2KINEI=TAI *DI/WN: A)LLA\ MH\N PERIPATEI= *DI/WN:]2 KINEI=TAI A)/RA *DI/WN"2. <20PERANTIKOI\ DE/ EI)SIN EI)DIKW=S>20 OI( SUNA/GONTES MH\ SULLOGISTIKW=S, OI(=ON OI( TOIOU=TOI "1YEU=DO/S E)STI TO\ H(ME/RA E)STI\ KAI\ NU/C E)STI: H(ME/RA DE/ E)STIN: OU)K A)/RA NU/C E)STIN"2. <20A)SULLO/GISTOI>20 D' EI)SI\N OI( PARAKEI/MENOI ME\N PIQANW=S TOI=S SULLOGISTIKOI=S, OU) SUNA/GONTES DE/, OI(=ON "1EI) I(/PPOS E)STI\ *DI/WN, ZW=|O/N E)STI *DI/WN [2A)LLA\ MH\N I(/PPOS OU)K E)/STI *DI/WN]2: OU)K A)/RA ZW=|O/N E)STI *DI/WN"2. E)/TI TW=N LO/GWN OI( ME\N <20A)LHQEI=S>20 EI)SIN, OI( DE\ <20YEUDEI=S. A)LHQEI=S>20 ME\N OU)=N EI)SI LO/GOI OI( DI' A)LHQW=N SUNA/GONTES, OI(=ON "1EI) H( A)RETH\ W)FELEI=, H( KAKI/A BLA/PTEI: [2A)LLA\ MH\N W)FELEI= H( A)RETH/: H( KAKI/A A)/RA BLA/PTEI]2."2 <20YEUDEI=S>20 DE/ EI)SIN OI( @1 TW=N LHMMA/TWN E)/XONTE/S TI YEU=DOS H)\ A)PE/RANTOI O)/NTES, OI(=ON "1EI) H(ME/RA E)STI/, FW=S E)STIN: H(ME/RA DE/ E)STI: ZH=| A)/RA *DI/WN"2. KAI\ <20DUNATOI\>20 D' EI)SI\ LO/GOI KAI\ <20A)DU/NATOI>20 KAI\ <20A)NAGKAI=OI>20 KAI\ <20OU)K A)NAGKAI=OI>20. @&10Sextus adv. math. VIII 411.$10 OI)/ONTAI TOI/NUN [1&10scil. Stoici$10]1 TREI=S TINAS A)LLH/LOIS SUZUGEI=N LO/GOUS, TO/N TE SUNAKTIKO\N KAI\ TO\N A)LHQH= KAI\ TO\N A)PODEIKTIKO/N: W(=N TO\N ME\N A)PODEIKTIKO\N PA/NTWS A)LHQH= TE KAI\ SUNAKTIKO/N, TO\N DE\ A)LHQH= PA/NTWS SUNAKTIKO\N ME\N U(PA/RXEIN, OU)K E)C A)NA/GKHS DE\ KAI\ A)PO-DEIKTIKO/N, TO\N DE\ SUNAKTIKO\N OU)/TE PA/NTWS A)LHQH= OU)/TE PA/NTWS A)PODEIKTIKO/N. _KAI\ O( ME\N TOIOU=TOS H(ME/RAS OU)/SHS "1EI) NU/C E)STI, SKO/TOS E)STI/N: A)LLA\ MH\N NU/C E)STIN: SKO/TOS A)/RA E)STI\N"2 SUNA/GEI ME\N DIA\ TO\ E)N U(GIEI= H)RWTH=SQAI SXH/-MATI, OU)K E)/STI DE\ A)LHQH/S, TO\ DEU/TERON LH=MMA E)/XWN YEU=DOS, TH\N PRO/SLHYIN, TO\ "1A)LLA\ MH\N NU/C E)STIN"2. O( DE\ OU(/TWS E)/XWN H(ME/RAS OU)/SHS "1EI) H(ME/RA E)STI/, FW=S E)STIN: A)LLA\ MH\N H(ME/RA E)STI/N: FW=S A)/RA E)STI/N"2 SUNAKTIKO\S A(/MA H)=N KAI\ A)LHQH\S TW=| KAI\ E)N U(GIEI= H)RWTH=SQAI SXH/MATI KAI\ DI' A)LHQW=N A)LHQE\S SUNA/GEIN. @*KRI/NESQAI DE/ FASI <20TO\N SUNAKTIKO\N>20 LO/GON O(/TI SUNAKTIKO/S E)STIN, O(/TAN TH=| DIA\ TW=N LHMMA/TWN AU)TOU= SUMPLOKH=| E(/PHTAI TO\ SUMPE/RASMA: OI(=ON TO\N TOIOU=TON LO/GON H(ME/RAS OU)/SHS "1EI) NU/C E)STI, SKO/TOS E)STI/N: A)LLA\ MH\N NU/C E)STIN: SKO/TOS A)/RA E)STI/N"2 KAI/PER MH\ O)/NTA A)LHQH= DIA\ TO\ E)PI\ YEU=DOS A)/GEIN, SUNAK-TIKO\N EI)=NAI FAME/N: SUMPLE/CANTES GA\R OU(/TW TA\ LH/MMATA "1NU/C E)STI KAI\ EI) NU/C E)STI, SKO/TOS E)STI/"2, POIOU=MEN SUNHMME/NON [SULLOGISMO/N], A)RXO/MENON ME\N A)PO\ TH=S TOIAU/THS SUMPLOKH=S, LH=GON DE\ EI)S TO\ SUMPE/RASMA, TOIOU=TON "1[2EI)]2 NU/C E)STI KAI\ EI) NU/C E)STI, SKO/TOS E)STI/, [2SKO/TOS E)STI/N]2"2. TOU=TO GA\R TO\ SUNHMME/NON A)LHQE/S E)STI, DIA\ TO\ MHDE/POTE A)RXO/MENON A)PO\ TOU= A)LHQOU=S LH/GEIN E)PI\ YEU=-DOS: H(ME/RAS ME\N GA\R OU)/SHS A)/RXETAI A)PO\ YEU/DOUS__KAI\ LH/CEI E)PI\ YEU=-DOS_KAI\ OU(/TWS E)/STAI A)LHQE/S: NUKTO\S DE\ A)/RCETAI/ TE A)P' A)LHQOU=S KAI\ LH/CEI E)P' A)LHQE/S, KAI\ E)/STAI PAR' AU)TO\ TOU=TO A)LHQE/S. OU)KOU=N O( ME\N SUNAKTIKO\S TO/TE E)STIN U(GIH/S, O(/TAN SUMPLECA/NTWN H(MW=N TA\ LH/MMATA KAI\ SUNHMME/NON POIHSA/NTWN TO\ A)RXO/MENON ME\N A)PO\ TH=S DIA\ TW=N LHMMA/TWN SUMPLOKH=S, LH=GON D' EI)S TO\ SUMPE/RASMA, EU(RI/SKHTAI TOU=TO AU)TO\ SUNHMME/NON A)LHQE/S. _O( D' <20A)LHQH\S LO/GOS>20 KRI/NETAI O(/TI E)/STIN A)LHQH\S OU)K E)K TOU= MO/NON TO\ SUNHMME/NON TO\ A)RXO/MENON A)PO\ TH=S DIA\ TW=N LHMMA/TWN SUMPLOKH=S KAI\ LH=GON EI)S TO\ SUM-PE/RASMA EI)=NAI A)LHQE/S, A)LLA\ KAI\ E)K TOU= TO\ DIA\ TW=N LHMMA/TWN SUMPEPLEGME/-NON U(PA/RXEIN U(GIE/S: W(S A)\N TO\ E(/TERON TOU/TWN EU(RI/SKHTAI YEU=DOS, KAI\ TO\N LO/GON E)C A)NA/GKHS GI/NESQAI YEUDH=. __W(/STE GI/NETAI A)LHQH\S O( LO/GOS OU)/TE O(/TAN TO\ SUMPEPLEGME/NON MO/NON H)=| A)LHQE\S OU)/TE O(/TAN TO\ SUNHMME/NON, A)LL' O(/TAN A)MFO/TERA A)LHQH=. _O( <20DE\ A)PODEIKTIKO\S>20 TOU= A)LHQOU=S DIAFE/REI, O(/TI O( ME\N A)LHQH\S DU/NATAI E)NARGH= E)/XEIN PA/NTA, FHMI\ DE\ TA/ TE LH/MMATA KAI\ TH\N E)PIFORA/N, O( DE\ A)PODEIKTIKO\S PLE/ON TI E)/XEIN BOU/LETAI, LE/GW DE\ TO\ TH\N E)PI-FORA\N A)/DHLON OU)=SAN <20E)KKALU/PTESQAI>20 U(PO\ TW=N LHMMA/TWN. O(/QEN O( ME\N TOI-OU=TOS__E)NARGH= E)/XWN TA\ LH/MMATA KAI\ TH\N E)PIFORA\N A)LHQH/S E)STI KAI\ OU)K A)PODEIKTIKO/S: O( DE\ TOIOU=TOS "1EI) GA/LA E)/XEI E)N MASTOI=S H(/DE, KEKU/HKEN H(/DE: A)LLA\ MH\N GA/LA E)/XEI E)N MASTOI=S H(/DE: KEKU/HKEN A)/RA H(/DE"2 SU\N TW=| A)LH-QH\S EI)=NAI E)/TI KAI\ A)PODEIKTIKO/S E)STIN: A)/DHLON GA\R E)/XWN TO\ SUMPE/RASMA_ TOU=TO DIA\ TW=N LHMMA/TWN E)KKALU/PTEI. @1 @[&10Apuleius$10] PERI\ E(RMHNEI/AS&10 277 [1p. 15, 11 Goldb.]1. Est et altera &10probatio communis omnium etiam indemonstrabilium, quae dicitur "1im-&10possibile"2 appellaturque a Stoicis "1prima constitutio"2 vel "1primum expo-&10situm"2. quod sic definiunt%10 "1Si ex duobus tertium quid colligitur, alterum &10eorum cum contrario illationis colligit contrarium reliqui"2. __quae &10res inventa est adversus eos, qui concessis acceptionibus id, quod ex illis &10colligitur, impudenter recusant. __nec frustra constituerunt dialectici &10eum modum verum esse, cuius adversum illationis cum alterutra acceptione &10tollit reliquam. At Stoici quidem tantum negativa particula praeposita &10putant illationem recusari etc. &10@Sextus adv. math. VIII 429.$10 PERI\ ME\N OU)=N <20TW=N PERAINO/NTWN>20 POLLH=S KAI\ A)KRIBOU=S OU)/SHS ZHTH/SEWS OU)K A)NA/GKH NU=N DIECELQEI=N, PERI\ DE\ <20TW=N A)PERA/NTWN LO/GWN>20 E)PI\ POSO\N U(PODEIKTE/ON. TOI/NUN FASI\ TETRAXW=S GI/GNESQAI TO\N A)PE/RANTON LO/GON, H)/TOI KATA\ DIA/RTHSIN H)\ KATA\ PAROLKH/N, H)\ KATA\ TO\ E)N MOXQHRW=| H)RWTH=SQAI SXH/MATI H)\ KATA\ E)/LLEIYIN. _A)LLA\ <20KATA\ DIA/RTHSIN>20 ME\N O(/TAN MHDEMI/AN E)/XH| KOINWNI/AN KAI\ SUNA/RTHSIN TA\ LH/MMATA PRO\S A)/LLHLA/ TE KAI\ PRO\S TH\N E)PIFORA/N, OI(=ON E)PI\ TOU= TOIOU/TOU LO/GOU "1EI) H(ME/RA E)STI/, FW=S E)STIN: A)LLA\ MH\N PUROI\ E)N A)GORA=| PWLOU=NTAI: FW=S A)/RA E)STI/N"2. __<20KATA\ DE\ PAROLKH\N A)PE/RANTOS GI/NETAI>20 O( LO/GOS O(/TAN E)/CWQE/N TI KAI\ PERISSW=S PARALAMBA/NHTAI TOI=S LH/MMASI, KAQA/PER E)PI\ TOU= OU(/TWS E)/XONTOS "1EI) H(ME/RA E)STI/, FW=S E)STIN: A)LLA\ MH\N H(ME/RA E)STI/N: A)LLA\ KAI\ H( A)RETH\ W)FELEI=: FW=S A)/RA E)STI/N"2. __<20DIA\ DE\ TO\ E)N MOXQHRW=|>20 H)RWTH=SQAI <20SXH/MATI>20 A)PE/RANTOS GI/NETAI LO/GOS O(/TAN E)/N TINI TW=N PARA\ TA\ U(GIH= SXH/MATA QEWROUME/NWN E)RWTHQH=| SXH/-MATI: OI(=ON O)/NTOS U(GIOU=S SXH/MATOS TOU= TOIOU/TOU "1EI) TO\ PRW=TON, TO\ DEU/TERON: TO\ DE/ GE PRW=TON, TO\ A)/RA DEU/TERON"2, O)/NTOS DE\ KAI\ TOU= "1EI) TO\ PRW=TON TO\ DEU/TERON: OU)XI\ DE/ GE TO\ PRW=TON, OU)K A)/RA TO\ DEU/TERON"2, FAME\N TO\N E)N TOI-OU/TW| SXH/MATI E)RWTHQE/NTA "1EI) TO\ PRW=TON TO\ DEU/TERON: OU)XI\ DE/ GE TO\ PRW=TON: OU)K A)/RA TO\ DEU/TERON"2 A)PE/RANTON EI)=NAI, OU)X O(/TI A)DU/NATO/N E)STIN E)N TW=| TOI-OU/TW| SXH/MATI LO/GON SUNERWTA=SQAI DI' A)LHQW=N A)LHQE\S SUNA/GONTA [1DU/NATAI GA/R, OI(=ON O( TOIOU=TOS "1EI) TA\ TRI/A TE/SSARA/ E)STIN, TA\ E(\C O)KTW/ E)STIN: OU)XI\ DE/ GE TA\ TRI/A TE/SSARA/ E)STIN: OU)K A)/RA TA\ E(\C O)KTW/ E)STIN"2]1, TW=| DE\ DU/NASQAI/ TINAS LO/GOUS E)N AU)TW=| TA/TTESQAI MOXQHROU/S, KAQA/PER KAI\ TO\N TOIOU=TON: "1EI) H(ME/RA E)STI/, FW=S E)STIN: A)LLA\ MH\N OU)/K E)STIN H(ME/RA OU)K A)/RA E)STI\ FW=S"2. _KAT' <20E)/L-LEIYIN>20 DE\ A)PE/RANTOS E)GI/NETO O( LO/GOS, O(/TAN E)LLEI/PH| TI TW=N SUNAKTIKW=N LHM-MA/TWN. OI(=ON "1H)/TOI KAKO/N E)STIN O( PLOU=TOS H)\ A)GAQO/N E)STIN O( PLOU=TOS: OU)XI\ DE/ GE KAKO/N E)STIN O( PLOU=TOS: A)GAQO\N A)/RA E)STI\N O( PLOU=TOS"2. E)LLEI/PEI GA\R E)N TW=| DIEZEUGME/NW| TO\ A)DIA/FORON EI)=NAI TO\N PLOU=TON, W(/STE TH\N U(GIH= SUNERW/-THSIN TOIAU/THN MA=LLON U(PA/RXEIN "1H)/TOI A)GAQO/N E)STIN O( PLOU=TOS H)\ KAKO/N E)STIN H)\ A)DIA/FORON: OU)/TE [2DE/ G']2 A)GAQO/N E)STIN O( PLOU=TOS OU)/TE KAKO/N: A)DIA/FORON A)/RA E)STI/N"2. @&Diocles Magnes apud Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 79.$ EI)SI\ DE\ KAI\ <20A)NAPO/DEIKTOI/>20 TINES, TW=| MH\ XRH/|ZEIN A)PODEI/CEWS, A)/LLOI ME\N PAR' A)/LLOIS, PARA\ DE\ <20TW=| *XRUSI/PPW|>20 PE/NTE, DI' W(=N PA=S LO/GOS PLE/KETAI, @1 OI(/TINES LAMBA/NONTAI E)PI\ TW=N PERANTIKW=N KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N SULLOGISTIKW=N KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N TROPIKW=N. <20PRW=TOS>20 DE/ E)STIN A)NAPO/DEIKTOS, E)N W(=| PA=S LO/GOS SUNTA/SSETAI E)K SUNHMME/NOU KAI\ TOU= H(GOUME/NOU, A)F' OU(= A)/RXE-TAI TO\ SUNHMME/NON, KAI\ TO\ LH=GON E)PIFE/REI, OI(=ON "1EI) TO\ PRW=TON, TO\ DEU/TERON: A)LLA\ MH\N TO\ PRW=TON: TO\ A)/RA DEU/TERON"2. <20DEU/TEROS>20 D' E)STI\N A)NAPO/DEIKTOS O( DIA\ SUNHMME/NOU KAI\ TOU= A)NTIKEIME/NOU TOU= LH/-GONTOS TO\ A)NTIKEI/MENON TOU= H(GOUME/NOU E)/XWN SUMPE/RASMA, OI(=ON "1EI) H(ME/RA E)STI/, FW=S E)STIN: A)LLA\ MH\N NU/C E)STIN: OU)K A)/RA H(ME/RA E)STI/N"2. H( GA\R PRO/SLHYIS GI/NETAI E)K TOU= A)NTIKEIME/NOU TW=| LH/GONTI KAI\ H( E)PI-FORA\ E)K TOU= A)NTIKEIME/NOU TW=| H(GOUME/NW|. <20TRI/TOS>20 D' E)STI\N A)NAPO/DEI-KTOS O( DI' A)POFATIKOU= SUMPLOKH=S KAI\ E(NO\S TW=N E)N TH=| SUMPLOKH=| E)PI-FE/RWN TO\ A)NTIKEI/MENON TOU= LOIPOU=, OI(=ON "1OU)XI\ TE/QNHKE *PLA/TWN KAI\ ZH=| *PLA/TWN: A)LLA\ MH\N TE/QNHKE *PLA/TWN: OU)K A)/RA ZH=| *PLA/TWN"2. <20TE/-TARTOS>20 DE/ E)STIN A)NAPO/DEIKTOS O( DIA\ DIEZEUGME/NOU KAI\ E(NO\S TW=N E)N TW=| DIEZEUGME/NW| TO\ A)NTIKEI/MENON TOU= LOIPOU= E)/XWN SUMPE/RASMA, OI(=ON "1H)/TOI TO\ PRW=TON H)\ TO\ DEU/TERON: A)LLA\ MH\N TO\ PRW=TON: OU)K A)/RA TO\ DEU/TERON"2. <20PE/MPTOS>20 DE/ E)STIN A)NAPO/DEIKTOS, E)N W(=| PA=S LO/GOS SUN-TA/SSETAI E)K DIEZEUGME/NOU KAI\ E(NO\S TW=N E)N TW=| DIEZEUGME/NW| A)NTIKEI-ME/NOU KAI\ E)PIFE/REI TO\ LOIPO/N, OI(=ON "1H)/TOI H(ME/RA E)STI\N H)\ NU/C E)STIN: OU)XI\ DE\ NU/C E)STIN: H(ME/RA A)/RA E)STI/N"2. @&Sextus adv. math. VIII 223.$ EU)QE/WS GA/R, I(/NA MIKRO\N A)/NWQEN PROLA/BWMEN, A)NAPO/DEIKTOI LE/GONTAI DIXW=S, OI(/ TE MH\ A)PODE-DEIGME/NOI KAI\ OI( MH\ XREI/AN E)/XONTES A)PODEI/CEWS TW=| AU)TO/QEN EI)=NAI PERIFANE\S E)P' AU)TW=N TO\ O(/TI SUNA/GOUSIN. E)PEDEI/CAMEN DE\ POLLA/KIS W(S KATA\ TO\ DEU/TERON SHMAINO/MENON TAU/THS H)CI/WNTAI TH=S PROSHGORI/AS OI( <20KAT' A)RXH\N TH=S PRW/THS PERI\ SULLOGISMW=N EI)SAGWGH=S PARA\ TW=| *XRUSI/PPW| TETAGME/NOI>20. NUNI\ DE\ E)F' O(MOLO/GW| TOU/TW| GNWSTE/ON <20O(/TI PRW=TOS ME/N E)STIN A)NAPO/DEIKTOS>20 O( E)K SUNHMME/NOU KAI\ TOU= H(GOUME/NOU, TO\ LH=GON E)N E)KEI/NW| TW=| SUNHMME/NW| E)/XWN SUMPE/RASMA. TOUTE/STIN O(/TAN LO/GOS DU/O E)/XH| LH/MMATA, W(=N TO\ ME\N E(/TERO/N E)STI SUN-HMME/NON TO\ DE\ E(/TERON H(GOU/MENON E)N TW=| SUNHMME/NW|, E)/XH| DE\ KAI\ E)PI-FORA\N TO\ LH=GON E)N TW=| AU)TW=| SUNHMME/NW|, TO/TE O( TOIOU=TOS LO/GOS PRW=-TOS A)NAPO/DEIKTOS KALEI=TAI, OI(=ON O( OU(/TWS E)/XWN "1EI) H(ME/RA E)/STI, FW=S E)/STIN: A)LLA\ MH\N H(ME/RA E)/STIN: FW=S A)/RA E)/STIN"2. OU(=TOS GA\R TO\ ME\N E(/TERON TW=N LHMMA/TWN E)/XEI SUNHMME/NON, TO\ "1EI) H(ME/RA E)/STI, FW=S E)/STIN"2, TO\ DE\ LOIPO\N TO\ H(GOU/MENON E)N TW=| SUNHMME/NW| "1A)LLA\ MH\N H(ME/RA E)/STIN"2, TO\ [2DE\]2 "1FW=S A)/RA E)/STIN"2 TRI/TON TH\N E)PIFORA\N TO\ LH=GON TOU= SUNHM- @1ME/NOU. _<20DEU/TEROS D' E)STI\N A)NAPO/DEIKTOS>20 O( E)K SUNHMME/NOU KAI\ TOU= A)NTIKEIME/NOU TW=| LH/GONTI E)N E)KEI/NW| TW=| SUNHMME/NW|, TO\ A)NTIKEI/MENON TW=| H(GOUME/NW| E)/XWN SUMPE/RASMA. TOUTE/STIN O(/TAN LO/GOS PA/LIN E)K DUOI=N SUNESTW\S LHMMA/TWN, W(=N TO\ ME\N E(/TERO/N E)STI SUNHMME/NON, TO\ DE\ E(/TERON A)NTIKEI/MENON TW=| LH/GONTI E)N TW=| SUNHMME/NW|, E)/XH| DE\ KAI\ E)PIFORA\N TO\ A)NTIKEI/MENON TW=| H(GOUME/NW|, TO/TE O( TOIOU=TOS GI/NETAI DEU/TEROS A)NAPO/-DEIKTOS, W(S TO\ "1EI) H(ME/RA E)/STI, FW=S E)/STIN: OU)XI\ DE/ GE FW=S E)/STIN: OU)K A)/RA E)/STIN H(ME/RA"2. TO/ TE GA\R "1EI) E)/STIN H(ME/RA, FW=S E)/STIN"2 TO\ E(/TERON LH=MMA TOU= LO/GOU SUNHMME/NON E)STI/, TO/ TE "1OU)XI\ DE/ GE FW=S E)/STIN"2 LOIPO\N LH=MMA TOU= LO/GOU KAQESTW/S, A)NTIKEI/MENO/N E)STI TW=| LH/GONTI E)N TW=| SUNHMME/NW|: H(/ TE E)PIFORA\ H( "1OU)K A)/RA H(ME/RA E)/STIN"2 TO\ A)NTIKEI/MENON H)=N TOU= H(GOUME/NOU. _<20TRI/TOS DE/ E)STI LO/GOS A)NAPO/DEIKTOS>20 O( E)C A)POFATIKOU= SUMPLOKH=S KAI\ E(NO\S TW=N E)N TH=| SUMPLOKH=|, TO\ A)NTIKEI/MENON TOU= LOIPOU= TW=N E)N TH=| SUMPLOKH=| E)/XWN SUMPE/RASMA, OI(=ON "1OU)XI\ KAI\ H(ME/RA E)/STI KAI\ NU\C E)/STIN: H(ME/RA DE\ E)/STIN: OU)K A)/RA E)/STI NU/C"2. TO\ ME\N GA\R "1OU)XI\ KAI\ H(ME/RA E)/STI KAI\ NU\C E)/STIN"2 A)POFATIKO\N H)=N SUM-PEPLEGME/NOU TOU= "1KAI\ H(ME/RA E)/STI KAI\ NU\C E)/STI"2, TO\ DE\ "1H(ME/RA E)/STI"2 TO\ E(/TERON E)TU/GXANE TW=N E)N TH=| SUMPLOKH=|, TO\ DE\ "1OU)K A)/RA E)/STI NU/C"2 TO\ A)NTIKEI/MENON H)=N TW=| LOIPW=| TW=N E)N TH=| SUMPLOKH=|. _*OI( ME\N OU)=N LO/GOI TOIOU=TOI/ TINE/S EI)SI, <20TRO/POI>20 DE\ AU)TW=N KAI\ W(SPEREI\ <20SXH/MATA>20 E)N OI(=S H)RW/THNTAI OI( OU(/TWS E)/XONTES, TOU= ME\N PRW/TOU A)NAPODEI/KTOU: "1EI) TO\ PRW=TON, TO\ DEU/TERON: TO\ DE/ GE PRW=TON: TO\ A)/RA DEU/TERON"2. TOU= DE\ DEUTE/ROU "1EI) TO\ PRW=TON, TO\ DEU/TERON: OU)XI\ DE/ GE TO\ DEU/TERON: OU)K A)/RA TO\ PRW=TON"2, TOU= DE\ TRI/TOU "1OU)XI\ KAI\ TO\ PRW=TON KAI\ TO\ DEU/-TERON: TO\ DE/ GE PRW=TON: OU)K A)/RA TO\ DEU/TERON"2. _*)/ETI XRH\ GINW/SKEIN O(/TI TW=N A)NAPODEI/KTWN OI( ME/N EI)SIN A(PLOI= OI( DE\ OU)X A(PLOI=: W(=N <20A(PLOI=>20 ME/N EI)SIN OI( AU)TO/QEN SAFE\S E)/XONTES TO\ O(/TI SUNA/GOUSIN__O(POI=OI/ EI)SIN OI( E)KKEI/MENOI. __<20OU)X A(PLOI=>20 DE/ EI)SIN OI( E)K TW=N A(PLW=N PEPLEGME/NOI KAI\ E)/TI XREI/AN E)/XONTES TH=S EI)S E)KEI/NOUS A)NALU/SEWS, I(/NA GNWSQW=SIN O(/TI KAI\ AU)TOI\ SUNA/GOUSIN. TOU/TWN DE\ TW=N OU)X A(PLW=N OI( ME\N E)C O(MOGENW=N EI)SI SUNESTW=TES, OI( DE\ E)C A)NOMOGENW=N, KAI\ <20E)C O(MO-GENW=N>20 ME\N W(/SPER OI( E)K DUOI=N PRW/TWN A)NAPODEI/KTWN PEPLEGME/NOI H)\ E)K DUOI=N DEUTE/RWN, <20E)C A)NOMOGENW=N>20 DE\ W(/SPER OI( E)K PRW/TOU A)NAPO-DEI/KTOU SUNESTW=TES H)\ E)K DEUTE/ROU KAI\ TRI/TOU, KAI\ KOINW=S OI( TOU/TOIS PARAPLH/SIOI. @&10Diocles Magnes apud Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 81.$10 E)P' A)LHQEI= DE\ A)LHQE\S E(/PETAI, <20KATA\ TOU\S *STWI+KOU/S>20, W(S TW=| "1H(ME/RA E)STI/"2 TO\ "1FW=S E)STI"2 KAI\ YEU/DEI YEU=DOS, W(S TW=| "1NU/C E)STI"2 YEU/DEI TO\ "1SKO/TOS E)STI/"2, KAI\ YEU/DEI A)LH- @1QE/S, W(S TW=| "1I(/PTASQAI TH\N GH=N"2 TO\ "1EI)=NAI TH\N GH=N"2. <20A)LHQEI= ME/NTOI YEU=DOS OU)K A)KOLOUQEI=>20: TW=| GA\R "1EI)=NAI TH\N GH=N"2 TO\ "1PE/TESQAI TH\N GH=N"2 OU)K A)KOLOUQEI=. @&Galenus introductio dialectica 7 p. 16, 18 Kalbfl.$ KATA\ ME\N DH\ TOU\S TOIOU/TOUS SULLOGISMOU\S AI( PROTA/SEIS H(GEMONIKAI\ TW=N PROSLH/YEWN: OU)/TE GA\R E)N TW=| DIEZEUGME/NW| [2PLEI/OUS H)\ DU/O GI/GNONTAI PROSLH/YEIS OU)/T' E)N TW=| SUN-HMME/NW|]2, <20KATA\ DE\ TH\N E)LLIPH= MA/XHN>20 E(\N MO/NON OI(=O/N TE PROSLAMBA/-NEIN: O(/PER <20OI( PERI\ *XRU/SIPPON>20 OU)X H(GEMONIKA\ MO/NON A)LLA\ KAI\ TRO-PIKA\ [2TA\]2 TOIAU=TA TW=N A)CIWMA/TWN O)NOMA/ZOUSIN, W(S A)\N E)P' AU)TOI=S O(/LOU TOU= SULLOGISMOU= PHGNUME/NOU KAQA/PER E)PI\ TRO/PIDI NEW/S. KAI\ ME/NTOI KAI\ TW=N E)K TOU= *PERIPA/TOU TINE/S. W(/SPER KAI\ *BO/HQOS OU) MO/-NON A)NAPODEI/KTOUS O)NOMA/ZOUSI TOU\S E)K TW=N H(GEMONIKW=N LHMMA/TWN SULLOGISMOU/S, A)LLA\ KAI\ PRW/TOUS: <20O(/SOI DE\>20 E)K <20KATHGORIKW=N PRO-TA/SEW/N EI)SIN A)NAPO/DEIKTOI SULLOGISMOI/, TOU/TOUS OU)K E)/TI PRW/TOUS O)NOMA/ZEIN SUGXWROU=SI>20: KAI/TOI KAQ' E(/TERO/N GE TRO/PON OI( TOIOU=TOI PRO/TEROI TW=N U(POQETIKW=N EI)SIN, EI)/PER GE KAI\ AI( PROTA/SEIS AU)TW=N, E)C W(=N SU/GKEINTAI, PRO/TERAI BEBAI/WS EI)SI/N: OU)DEI\S GA\R A)MFIS-BHTH/SEI TO\ MH\ OU) PRO/TERON EI)=NAI TO\ A(PLOU=N TOU= SUNQE/TOU. @&Galenus introductio dialectica 6 p. 15, 8 Kalbfl.$ O)NOMA/ZOUSI DE\ TRO/PON OI( DIALEKTIKOI\ TA\ TW=N LO/GWN SXH/MATA, OI(=ON E)PI\ ME\N TOU= [2E)K SUNHM]2ME/NOU KAI\ TOU= H(GOUME/NOU TO\ LH=GON PERAI/NONTOS, O(\N O( <20*XRU/SIPPOS O)NOMA/ZEI PRW=TON A)NAPO/DEIKTON>20, O( TOIOU=TOS TRO/POS E)STI/N "1EI) TO\ , TO\ : TO\ DE\ : TO\ A)/RA "2. E)PI\ DE\ TOU= E)K SUNHMME/-NOU [2KAI\ TOU=]2 A)NTIKEIME/NOU TW=| EI)S O(\ LH/GEI TO\ TOU= H(GOUME/NOU A)NTI-KEI/MENON E)PIFE/RONTOS, <20O(\N KAI\ AU)TO\N O( *XRU/SIPPOS DEU/TERON A)N-APO/DEIKTON O)NOMA/ZEI>20, TOIOU=TO/S E)STIN "1EI) TO\ , TO\ : OU)XI\ DE\ TO\ DEU/TERON, OU)K A)/RA TO\ PRW=TON"2, W(/SPER GE <20KA)PI\ TOU= TRI/TOU KATA\ TOU=TON>20, O(\S E)C A)POFATIKOU= SUMPEPLEGME/NOU KAI\ E(NO\S TW=N E)N AU)TW=| TO\ A)NTIKEI/MENON TOU= LOIPOU= PARE/XEI, TOIOU=TOS O( TRO/POS E)STI/N "1OU)XI\ TO\ KAI\ TO\ : [2TO\ DE\ : OU)K A)/RA TO\ ]2. O(MOI/WS DE\ <20KA)PI\ TOU= TE-TA/RTOU KATA\ TO\N AU)TO/N>20, O(\S E)K DIEZEUGME/NOU KAI\ E(NO\S TW=N E)N AU)TW=| TOU= LOIPOU= TO\ A)NTIKEI/MENON E)PIFE/REI, TOIOU=TO/S TIS O( TRO/POS E)STI/N "1H)/TOI TO\ H)\ TO\ : TO\ DE\ : OU)K A)/RA TO\ "2. *KAI\ TOI/NUN KA)PI\ TOU= @1 PE/MPTOU, O(\S [2E)K]2 DIEZEUGME/NOU KAI\ TOU= A)NTIKEIME/NOU E(NO\S TW=N E)N AU)TW=| TO\ LOIPO\N E)PIFE/REI, TOIOU=TO/S [DE/] E)STIN O( TRO/POS "1H)/TOI TO\ H)\ TO\ : [2OU)XI\ DE\ TO\ , TO\ A)/RA ]2"2. @&Galenus introductio dialectica 5 p. 13, 10 Kalbfl.$ E)PI\ DE\ TH=S KATA\ SUNE/XEIAN U(POQETIKH=S PROTA/SEWS, H(\N <20OI( PERI\ TO\N *XRU/-SIPPON>20 O)NOMA/ZOUSI SUNHMME/NON A)CI/WMA, PROSLABO/NTES ME\N TO\ H(GOU/-MENON E(/COMEN TO\ LH=GON SUMPE/RASMA, PROSLABO/NTES DE\ TO\ TOU= LH/GONTOS A)NTIKEI/MENON E(/COMEN SUMPE/RASMA TO\ TOU= H(GOUME/NOU A)NTIKEI/MENON, OU) MH\N OU)/TE TO\ LH=GON PROSLABO/NTES OU)/TE TO\ A)NTIKEI/MENON TOU= H(GOUME/NOU SUMPE/RASMA E(/COMEN. @&Galenus introductio dialectica 19 p. 48, 23 Kalbfl.$ DIA\ TOU=TO OU)=N OU)DE\ TOU\S U(PO\ <20*XRUSI/PPOU>20 SUNTEQE/NTAS <20E)N TAI=S TRISI\ *SUL-LOGISTIKAI=S>20 A)XRH/STOUS E)PIDEIKTE/ON MOI NU=N E)STIN A)XRH/STOUS O)/NTAS: E(TE/RWQI GA\R E)/DEICA TOU=TO, KAQA/PER KAI\ [2PERI\]2 TW=N <20PERANTIKW=N>20 U(P' AU)TOU= KLHQE/NTWN: E)DEI/XQH[2SAN]2 GA\R KAI\ TOU/TWN E)/NIOI ME\N OU)K I)/DIO/N TI GE/NOS O)/NTES SULLOGISMW=N, A)LLA\ [2DIA\]2 PEPONQUI/AS LE/CEWS E(RMHNEU-O/MENOI, POTE\ ME\N KAT' A)KOLOUQI/AS U(PE/RQESIN %2%2%2%2: OI( DE\ <20U(POSUL-LOGISTIKOI\>20 KLHQE/NTES E)N I)SODUNAMOU/SAIS LE/CESI TOI=S SULLOGISTIKOI=S LEGO/MENOI: TE/LOS DE\ PERITTOI\ PRO\S TOU/TOIS OU(\S <20A)MEQO/DOUS>20 O)NOMA/ZOUSIN, OI(=S OU)DENO\S O)/NTOS O(/LWS MEQODIKOU= LO/GOU SULLOGISTE/ON. @&Galenus de Hippocr. et Plat. plac. II 3 [1`92]1 p. 182 Mu+.$ NUNI\ DE\ <20PW=S ME\N OI( DIA\ DU/O TROPIKW=N H)\ TRIW=N A)NALU/ONTAI SULLOGISMOI\ KAI\ PW=S OI( A)DIAFO/RWS PERAI/NONTES H)/ TINES A)/LLOI TOIOU=TOI, TW=| PRW/TW| KAI\ DEUTE/RW| QE/MATI PROSXRW/MENOI>20, POLLOI=S E)/STI SUNTUXEI=N A)KRIBW=S H)SKHME/NOIS, W(/SPER A)ME/LEI KAI\ E)P' A)/LLOIS, O(/SOIS DIA\ TOU= TRI/TOU QE/MATOS H)\ TETA/RTOU SULLOGISMOU\S A)NA-LU/OUSI. [1KAI/TOI TOU/TWN TOU\S PLEI/STOUS E)/NESTIN E(TE/RWS A)NALU/EIN SUN-TOMW/TERON, W(S <20*)ANTI/PATROS>20 E)/GRAYEN, PRO\S TW=| KAI\ PERIERGI/AN EI)=NAI OU) MIKRA\N A)XRH/STOU PRA/GMATOS A(/PASAN TH\N TW=N TOIOU/TWN SULLOGIS-MW=N SUMPLOKH/N, W(S AU)TO\S O( <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 E)/RGW| MARTUREI=, MHDAMO/QI TW=N E(AUTOU= SUGGRAMMA/TWN EI)S A)PO/DEICIN DO/GMATOS E)KEI/NWN DEHQEI\S TW=N SULLOGISMW=N. O(/PWS DE\ XRH\ GNWRI/ZEIN TE KAI\ DIAKRI/NEIN E)PISTH-MONIKA\ LH/MMATA DIALEKTIKW=N TE KAI\ R(HTORIKW=N KAI\ SOFISTIKW=N OU)KE/TI @1 E)/GRAYAN A)CIO/LOGON OU)DE\N OI( PERI\ TO\N *XRU/SIPPON, OU)DE\ FAI/NONTAI XRW/MENOI. @&<21ibidem>21 [1`93]1 p. 184 Mu+.$ PRO\S ME/NTOI TOU\S *STWI+KOU\S A)NAGKAI=O/N E)STI MAKRO\N A)NU/ESQAI LO/GON, A)NQRW/POUS E)N ME\N TOI=S A)XRH/STOIS TH=S LOGIKH=S QEWRI/AS I(KANW=S GEGUMNASME/NOUS, E)N DE\ TOI=S XRHSI/MOIS A)GUMNA-STOTA/TOUS TE A(/MA KAI\ MOXQHRAI=S O(DOI=S E)PIXEIRHMA/TWN E)NTEQRAMME/NOUS. __PERI\ DE\ TOU= PROTEQE/NTOS A)EI\ ZHTOU=SI, PRI\N O(/PWS XRH\ ZHTEI=N KATASTH/SASQAI_ @&Sextus adv. math. VIII 443.$ TO\ ME\N GA\R LE/GEIN MH\ A)RE/SKEIN TW=| <20*XRUSI/PPW|>20 MONOLHMMA/TOUS EI)=NAI LO/GOUS, O(\ TA/XA TINE\S E)ROU=SI PRO\S TH\N TOIAU/THN E)/NSTASIN, TELE/WS LHRW=DES. OU)/TE GA\R TAI=S *XRUSI/P-POU FWNAI=S W(S PUQOXRH/STOIS PARAGGE/LMASIN A)NA/GKH PEI/QESQAI, OU)/TE MARTURI/A| PROSE/XEIN A)NDRW=N E)STI\N EI)S OI)KEI/AN A)PO/R)R(HSIN E)K MA/RTUROS TOU= TO\ E)NANTI/ON LE/GONTOS: <20*)ANTI/PATROS>20 GA/R, TW=N E)N TH=| STWI+KH=| AI(RE/SEI E)PIFANESTA/TWN A)NDRW=N, E)/FH DU/NASQAI KAI\ MONOLHMMA/TOUS LO/GOUS SUNI/STASQAI. @&Plutarchus de comm. not. 2 p. 1059e.$ *TO\ GA/R, W)= A)/RISTE, <20SUMPEPLEGME/NON>20 TI DI' A)NTIKEIME/NWN MH\ FA/NAI YEU=DOS EU)PO/RWS EI)=NAI: <20LO/GOUS DE\ PA/LIN AU)= FA/NAI TINA\S A)LHQH= TA\ LH/MMATA KAI\ TA\S A)GWGA\S U(GIEI=S E)/XONTAS, E)/TI KAI\ TA\ A)NTIKEI/MENA TW=N SUMPERASMA/TWN E)/XEIN A)LHQH=>20, POI/AN E)/NNOIAN A)PODEI/CEWS H)\ TI/NA PI/STEWS OU)K A)NATRE/PEI PRO/LHYIN; @&10Dexippus in Aristot. categ. p. 25, 22 Busse.$10 A)LLA\ DH\ PW=S A)PAN-TH/SOMEN TOI=S E)RISTIKOI=S, OI(\ TA\ MH\ U(PA/RXONTA TW=| KATHGOROUME/NW| LAMBA/NONTES W(S LEGO/MENA KAT' AU)TOU= POIOU=SI PRO\S TW=| U(POKEIME/NW| TO\N TH=S A)POFA/SEWS SULLOGISMO/N; OI(=ON O( A)/NQRWPOS TOU= *SWKRA/TOUS KAQ' U(POKEIME/NOU KATHGO-REI=TAI, KATA\ DE\ TOU= A)NQRW/POU LE/GETAI TO\ MH\ EI)=NAI *SWKRA/THN: OU)KOU=N KAI\ KATA\ *SWKRA/TOUS R(HQEI/H A)\N TO\ MH\ EI)=NAI *SWKRA/THN. *PA/LIN GA\R KAI\ PRO\S TOU/TOUS U(POLOGIZO/MEQA, <20OU)X W(S OI( *STWI+KOI\ LE/GOUSI, TH\N TW=N A)POFA-TIKW=N U(PECAI/RESIN>20, A)LL' W(S *)ARISTOTE/LHS DIDA/SKEI, TH\N TW=N KAT' OU)SI/AN U(PARXO/NTWN LH=YIN, H(\N E)KEI=NOI OU) PARASWSA/MENOI PARALOGI/ZONTAI, TA\ MH\ U(PA/R-XONTA W(S KAQ' U(POKEIME/NOU LEGO/MENA OU)SI/AN PROSLAMBA/NONTES. @&10Alexander in Aristot. Analyt. pr. p. 390, 16 Wal.$10 W(/STE A)NA/-PALIN KAT' AU)TO\N [1&10scil. Aristotelem$10]1 H)\ W(S <20OI( NEW/TEROI>20 A)CIOU=SIN OI( U(PO-QETIKOI\ LO/GOI PERANTIKOI\ ME/N, OU) SULLOGISMOI\ DE/, __SULLOGISMOI\ D' OI( KATHGORIKOI/. @&10Alexander in Aristot. Analyt. pr. p. 373, 28 Wal.$10 *)ARISTOTE/LHS ME\N OU)=N OU(/TWS PERI\ TW=N KATA\ TA\S LE/CEIS METALH/YEWN FE/RETAI: OI( DE\ NEW/- @1TEROI, TAI=S LE/CESIN E)PAKOLOUQOU=NTES OU)KE/TI DE\ TOI=S SHMAINOME/NOIS, OU) TAU)TO/N FASI GI/NESQAI E)N TAI=S EI)S TA\S I)SODUNAMOU/SAS LE/CEIS METALH/YESI TW=N O(/RWN: TAU)TO\N GA\R SHMAI/NONTOS TOU= "1EI) TO\ *A TO\ *B"2 TW=| A)KOLOUQEI=N TW=| *A TO\ *B, <20SULLOGISTIKO\N>20 ME\N LO/GON FASI\N EI)=NAI TOIAU/THS LHFQEI/SHS TH=S LE/CEWS "1EI) TO\ *A TO\ *B, TO\ DE\ *A, TO\ A)/RA *B"2, <20OU)KE/TI DE\ SULLOGISTIKO\N A)LLA\ PE-RANTIKO\N TO\>20 "1A)KOLOUQEI= TW=| *A TO\ *B, TO\ DE\ *A, TO\ A)/RA *B"2. @&10Alexander in Aristot. Analyt. pr. p. 262, 28.$10 <20DI' U(POQE/SEWS DE\ A)/LLHS>20, W(S EI)=PEN [1&10scil. Aristoteles$10]1, EI)=EN A)\N KAI\ OU(\S <20OI( NEW/TEROI>20 SUL-LOGISMOU\S MO/NOUS BOU/LONTAI LE/GEIN: OU(=TOI D' EI)SI\N OI( <20DIA\ TROPIKOU=>20, W(/S <20FASI, KAI\ TH=S PROSLH/YEWS GINO/MENOI, TOU= TROPIKOU= H)\ SUNHMME/NOU O)/NTOS H)\ DIEZEUGME/NOU H)\ SUMPEPLEGME/NOU>20, OU(\S OI( A)RXAI=OI LE/GOUSI MIK-TOU\S E)C U(POQETIKH=S PROTA/SEWS KAI\ DEIKTIKH=S, TOU=T' E)/STI KATHGORIKH=S.&10 cf. &10ibid. p. 263, 12. _p. 264, 7.$10 O( D' AU)TO\S LO/GOS KAI\ E)PI\ TOU= DIAIRETIKOU= "1H)/TOI TO/DE H)\ TO/DE"2, O(\ KAI\ AU)TO\ E)K TROPIKOU= KAI\ TH=S PROSLH/YEWS LE/GOUSIN. _&10p. 265, 3.$10 A(\ ME\N GA\R LE/GOUSI TROPIKA/, E)N PA=SI DI' U(POQE/SEWS KAI\ O(MO-LOGI/AS W(S FANERA\ PARALAMBA/NETAI: E)PI\ TO\ PLEI=STON DE\ DEI=TAI DEI/CEWS TA\ <20ME-TALAMBANO/MENA KAI\ PROSLAMBANO/MENA>20, EI) O(/LWS EI)=EN XREIW/DEIS OI( TOI-OU=TOI LO/GOI: W(S O(/POU MH\ DEI=TAI DEI/CEWS TO\ METALAMBANO/MENON, OU)DE\ SULLO-GISMO/S E)STI TO\ GIGNO/MENON, PA/NTWN GE FANERW=N O)/NTWN. @&10Alexander in Aristot. Anal. pr. p. 278, 6 Wal.$10 E)/STI DE\ H( TOI-AU/TH SU/NQESIS KATA\ TO\ TRI/TON <20U(PO\ TW=N NEWTE/RWN>20 KALOU/MENON QE/MA GINO-ME/NH. __&10`11.$10 <20TOU= DE/ GE TRI/TOU KALOUME/NOU QE/MATOS H( PERIOXH\ KAI\ AU)TOU= E)/XEI W(=DE "1O(/TAN E)K DUEI=N TRI/TON TI SUNA/GHTAI, E(NO\S DE\ AU)TW=N E)/CWQEN LHFQH=| SULLOGISTIKA/, E)K TOU= LOIPOU= KAI\ E)K TW=N E)/CW-QEN TOU= E(TE/ROU SULLOGISTIKW=N TO\ AU)TO\ SUNAXQH/SETAI>20. @&10Simplicius in Arist. de caelo p. 236, 33 Heibg.$10 H( DE\ TOIAU/TH A)NA/LUSIS TOU= LO/GOU H( TO\ SUMPE/RASMA LAMBA/NOUSA KAI\ PROSLAMBA/NOUSA A)/L-LHN PRO/TASIN KATA\ TO\ TRI/TON LEGO/MENON PARA\ <20TOI=S *STWI+KOI=S>20 QE/MA PERAI/-NETAI, OU(= LO/GOS KATA\ TOU\S PALAIOU\S TOIOU=TOS: E)A\N E)K DUEI=N TRI/TON TI SUNA/-GHTAI, TO\ DE\ SUNAGO/MENON MET' A)/LLOU TINO\S E)/CWQEN SUNA/GH| TI, KAI\ E)K TW=N PRW/TWN DUEI=N KAI\ TOU= E)/CWQEN PROSLHFQE/NTOS SUNAXQH/SETAI TO\ AU)TO/. @&10Alexander in Aristot. analyt. pr. p. 283, 7 Wal.$10 OI(=ON EI) LA/BOI-MEN TO\ *A KATA\ TOU= *B, TO\ *B KATA\ TOU= *G, TO\ *G KATA\ TOU= *D, TO\ *D KATA\ TOU= *E, TO\ *A A)/RA KATA\ TOU= *E. __E)N TH=| TOIAU/TH| TW=N PROTA/SEWN SUNEXEI/A| TO/ TE SUNQETIKO/N E)STI QEW/RHMA, PERI\ OU(= PROEIRH/KAMEN, KAI\ <20OI( KALOU/MENOI U(PO\ TW=N NEWTE/RWN E)PIBA/LLONTE/S TE KAI\ E)PIBALLO/MENOI>20. __OI( DE\ E)PIBA/LLONTE/S TE KAI\ E)PIBALLO/MENOI KALOU/MENOI EI)=EN A)\N E)N TAI=S SUNEXW=S LAM-BANOME/NAIS PROTA/SESI XWRI\S TW=N SUMPERASMA/TWN. <20E)PIBALLO/MENOI>20 ME\N GA/R EI)SIN, W(=N PAREI=TAI TO\ SUMPE/RASMA, <20E)PIBA/LLONTES>20 DE/, W(=N H( DEIKTIKH\ PRO/-TASIS PAREI=TAI: TA\ GA\R SUMPERA/SMATA TA\ PARALEIPO/MENA TW=N E)PIBALLOME/NWN SULLOGISMW=N, OI(/ EI)SI PRW=TOI TH=| TA/CEI, PROTA/SEIS EI)SI\ DEIKTIKAI\ TW=N E)PIBAL-LO/NTWN, OI(/ EI)SI DEU/TEROI TH=| TA/CEI, OI(=ON TO\ *A KATA\ PANTO\S TOU= *B, TO\ *B KATA\ PANTO\S TOU= *G, TO\ *G KATA\ PANTO\S TOU= *D, TO\ *A KATA\ PANTO\S TOU= *D. E)PI-BALLO/MENOS GA/R E)STIN O( PRW=TOS, OU(= PAREI=TAI TO\ SUMPE/RASMA, O(/ E)STIN "1*A KATA\ PANTO\S TOU= *G"2. <20E)PIBA/LLWN>20 DE\ O( E)/K TE TOU= PAREIME/NOU TOU= "1TO\ *A @1 KATA\ TOU= *G"2 KAI\ E)K TOU= "1TO\ *G KATA\ TOU= *D"2 DEIKNU/MENOS, OU(= E)STI SUMPE/-RASMA "1TO\ A)/RA *A KATA\ TOU= *D"2. E)PI\ ME\N OU)=N TW=N EI)RHME/NWN KAI\ O( E)PI-BA/LLWN KAI\ O( E)PIBALLO/MENOS E)N PRW/TW| SXH/MATI: DU/NATAI DE\ KATA\ TH\N O(DO\N TAU/THN KAI\ E)K DEUTE/ROU SXH/MATOS E)PIBA/LLEIN SULLOGISMO\S E)K PRW/TOU SXH/MA-TOS SULLOGISMW=|: A)\N GA\R "1TO\ *A KATA\ PANTO\S TOU= *B, TO\ *B KATA\ PANTO\S TOU= *G, TO\ *A KAT' OU)DENO\S TOU= *D, [2TO\ *G KAT' OU)DENO\S TOU= *D]2"2 GI/NETAI O( <20ME\N E)PIBALLO/MENOS E)N PRW/TW| SXH/MATI>20, OU(= SUMPE/RASMA "1TO\ *A [2KATA\ PAN-TO\S TOU=]2 *G, O( <20DE\ E)PIBA/LLWN AU)TW=| E)N DEUTE/RW| SXH/MATI>20, O( E)/XWN PRO-TA/SEIS "1TO\ *A KATA\ PANTO\S TOU= *G"2, O(\ PAREI=TAI O)\N SUMPE/RASMA TOU= PRW/TOU, PRO/TASIS DE\ TOU/TOU, KAI\ "1TO\ *A KAT' OU)DENO\S TOU= *D"2, E)/XWN SUMPE/RASMA "1TO\ *G KAT' OU)DENO\S TOU= *D"2. _DU/NATAI DE\ KAI\ A)NA/PALIN O( <20E)PIBALLO/MENOS>20 EI)=NAI <20E)N DEUTE/RW| SXH/MATI, O( DE\ E)PIBA/LLWN E)N TW=| PRW/TW|>20 [1&10sequitur &10exemplum$10]1. TH=| AU)TH=| MEQO/DW| KAI\ E)K TOU= TRI/TOU SXH/MATOS E)/STI KAI\ E)PIBA/L-LONTA KAI\ E)PIBALLO/MENON LABEI=N KAI\ PRO\S TW=N E)N PRW/TW| TINA\ SXH/MATI KAI\ PRO\S TW=N E)N DEUTE/RW|: A)LLA\ KAI\ TOU\S E)K TW=N AU)TW=N SXHMA/TWN PRO\S A)LLH/LOUS, TOU\S ME\N E)N PRW/TW| PRO\S A)LLH/LOUS, TOU\S DE\ E)N DEUTE/RW| PRO\S A)LLH/LOUS, KAI\ TOU\S E)N TRI/TW| O(MOI/WS: A)LLA\ KAI\ TREI=S SULLOGISMOU\S E)/STIN OU(/TWS LABEI=N E)K TW=N TRIW=N SXHMA/TWN E)PIBA/LLONTA/S TE KAI\ E)PIBALLOME/NOUS KATA\ TO\ PARADE-DOME/NON <20SUNQETIKO\N QEW/RHMA>20, O(\ OI( ME\N PERI\ *)ARISTOTE/LH TH=| XREI/A| PARA-METRH/SANTES PARE/DOSAN E)F' O(/SON AU(/TH A)PH/|TEI, <20OI( DE\ A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 PAR' E)KEI/NWN LABO/NTES KAI\ DIELO/NTES E)POI/HSAN E)C AU)TOU= <20TO\ KALOU/MENON PAR' AU)TOI=S DEU/TERON QE/MA KAI\ TRI/TON KAI\ TE/TARTON>20, A)MELH/SANTES ME\N TOU= XRHSI/MOU, PA=N DE\ TO\ O(PWSOU=N DUNA/MENON LE/GESQAI E)N TH=| TOIAU/TH| QEWRI/A|, KA)\N A)/XRHSTON H)=|, E)PECELQO/NTES TE KAI\ ZHLW/SANTES. @&10Alexander in Aristot. analyt. pr. p. 263, 26.$10 DIAFE/REIN DE\ DOKEI= KATA\ TOU\S A)RXAI/OUS TO\ METALAMBANO/MENON TOU= PROSLAMBANOME/NOU: E)F' W(=N ME\N GA\R E)N TOI=S EI)LHMME/NOIS E)/GKEITAI/ TE KAI\ E)/STI TO\ LAMBANO/MENON, OU) MH\N OU(/TWS OU)DE\ TOIOU=TON OI(=ON LAMBA/NETAI, E)PI\ TOU/TWN TO\ LAMBANO/MENON METALAM-BANO/MENO/N E)STIN: OU) GA\R E)/CWQEN PROSTI/QETAI, A)LLA\ KEI/MENON A)/LLWS METALAM-BA/NETAI EI)S A)/LLO: E)N GA\R TW=| "1EI) H(ME/RA E)STI/, FW=S E)STI"2 TO\ "1H(ME/RA E)STI/N"2, O(\ <20PROSLAMBANO/MENON OI( NEW/TEROI LE/GOUSIN>20, E)/GKEITAI ME\N, OU) MH\N TOI-OU=TON O(POI=ON LAMBA/NETAI: TI/QETAI ME\N GA\R E)N TW=| SUNHMME/NW| E)N U(POQE/SEI TE KAI\ A)KOLOUQI/A|, LAMBA/NETAI DE\ W(S U(PA/RXON. __PROSLAMBANO/MENON DE\ LE/GOUSIN, E)F' W(=N TOI=S KEIME/NOIS E)/CWQE/N TI PROSTI/QETAI &10etc. &10@Alexander in Aristot. Analyt. pr. p. 164, 27 Wal.$10 O(/QEN DH=LON, O(/TI KAI\ TAU=TA, PERI\ W(=N AU)TO\S ME\N OU)K EI)/RHKE [1&10scil. Aristoteles$10]1, LE/GOUSI DE\ <20OI( NEW/TEROI>20, A)XRH/STWN O)/NTWN PRO\S A)PO/DEICIN, DI' A)XRHSTI/AN OU) DI' A)/GNOIAN PARE/LIPEN, OI(=OI/ EI)SIN <20OI( DIAFOROU/MENOI LO/GOI H)\ A)DIAFO/RWS PERAI/NON-TES H)\ H( A)/PEIROS U(/LH LEGOME/NH>20 KAI\ KAQO/LOU <20TO\ QE/MA TO\ DEU/TERON KA-LOU/MENON>20 PARA\ TOI=S NEWTE/ROIS. @1 @&10Alexander in Aristot. Analyt. pr. p. 21, 28 Wal.$10 KAQO/LOU GA/R, EI)/ TI EI)/H SUNAGO/MENON ME/N, OU) MH\N E)K TW=N KEIME/NWN, A)LL' E(TE/RAS PROTA/-SEWS PROSLH/YEI, TO\ TOIOU=TON A)NAGKAI=ON ME\N R(HQH/SETAI, OU) MH\N SULLOGISMO\S H)/DH TOU=TO: O(POI=OI/ EI)SI KAI\ <20OI( A)MEQO/DWS PERAI/NONTES LO/GOI PARA\ TOI=S *STWI+KOI=S>20, OI(=ON EI) LE/GOI TIS "1TO\ PRW=TON TOU= DEUTE/ROU MEI=ZON, TO\ DE\ DEU/-TERON TOU= TRI/TOU, TO\ A)/RA PRW=TON TOU= TRI/TOU MEI=ZON"2. TOU=TO GA\R A)NAGKAI/WS ME\N E(/PETAI, OU) MH\N KAI\ SULLOGISTIKW=S, EI) MH\ PROSLHFQEI/H TIS E)/CWQEN PRO/-TASIS H( LE/GOUSA "1TO\ TOU= MEI/ZONOS MEI=ZON KAI\ TOU= E)LA/TTONOS E)KEI/NOU MEI=ZO/N E)STIN"2. &10p. 22, 17$10 KAI\ O(/LWS TOIOU=TON TO\ EI)=DO/S E)STI TW=N LO/GWN, <20OU(\S OI( NEW/-TEROI LE/GOUSIN A)MEQO/DWS PERAI/NONTAS>20, OI(=O/N E)STI KAI\ TO\ "1H(ME/RA E)STI/N: A)LLA\ KAI\ SU\ LE/GEIS O(/TI H(ME/RA E)STI/N: A)LHQEU/EIS A)/RA"2. @&10Alexander in Aristot. anal. pr. [1p. 24&14b&10 18]1 p. 18, 12 Wal.$10 PA/NU DE\ KALW=S TO\ DEI=N E(/TERON TW=N TEQE/NTWN EI)=NAI TO\ SUMPE/RASMA PROSE/QHKEN [1&10scil. Aristoteles$10]1. __TO\ GA\R XREIW=DES TOU= SULLOGISMOU= OU) PARE/XETAI TO\ "1EI) H(ME/RA E)STI/N, FW=S E)STIN: A)LLA\ MH\N H(ME/RA E)STI/N: FW=S A)/RA E)STI/"2 KAI\ O(/LWS <20OI( LEGO/MENOI U(PO\ TW=N NEWTE/RWN A)DIAFO/RWS PERAI/NONTES>20. TOIOU=TOI DE\ KAI\ <20OI( DIFOROU/MENOI>20, OI(=O/S E)STIN "1EI) H(ME/RA E)STI/N, H(ME/RA E)STI/N: A)LLA\ MH\N H(ME/RA E)STI/N: H(ME/RA A)/RA E)STI/N"2. &10p. 19, 3.$10 O( <20GA\R E)C A)NTIFA/SEWS DIAIRETIKO\S SULLOGISMO\S>20 OU)X W(S TAU)TO\N TW=| METALAMBANOME/NW| H)/, W(S OI( <20NEW/TEROI/>20 FASI, PROSLAMBANOME/NW| TO\ SUMPE/RASMA E)PIFE/REI: O( GA\R LE/GWN "1H)/TOI H(ME/RA E)/STIN H)\ OU)K E)/STIN H(ME/RA"2 EI)=TA PROSLAMBA/NWN TO\ E(/TERON TW=N E)N TW=| DIAIRETIKW=|, H)\ TO\ A)POFATIKO\N TO\ "1A)LLA\ MH\N OU)K E)/STIN H(ME/RA"2 H)\ TO\ KATA-FATIKO\N TO\ "1H(ME/RA E)STI/N"2, E)/XEI ME\N SUNAGO/MENON H)\ TO\ "1OU)K A)/RA H(ME/RA E)STI/N"2 H)\ TO\ "1H(ME/RA A)/RA E)STI/N"2, O(\ DOKEI= TAU)TO\N EI)=NAI TW=| PROSEILHMME/NW|, H)/TOI TW=| @1 "1A)LLA\ MH\N OU)K E)/STIN H(ME/RA"2 H)\ TW=| "1A)LLA\ MH\N H(ME/RA E)STI/N"2: OU) MH\N W(S TAU)TO\N O)\N AU)TW=| E)PIFE/RETAI, A)LL' W(S A)NTIKEI/MENON TW=| E(TE/RW| TW=N E)N TW=| DIAIRETIKW=|. _ &10ibid. 20.$10 O(\ A)NAGKAI=ON KAI\ <20TOI=S A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 LE/GEIN, <20EI)/ GE E)N TOI=S DIAIRETIKOI=S KAI\ DIAZEUKTIKOI=S SULLOGISMOI=S FASI TH=| PROSLH/YEI QATE/ROU TW=N E)N TW=| DIEZEUGME/NW| TO\ A)NTIKEI/MENON E(/PESQAI TOU= LOI-POU= TH=S SULLOGISTIKH=S SUMPLOKH=S>20. &10p. 20,10.$10 A)LLA\ MH\N OU)DE\ <20OI( DI-FOROU/MENOI LO/GOI LEGO/MENOI U(P' AU)TW=N>20 SULLOGISTIKOI/, OI(=O/S E)STIN O( "1EI) H(ME/RA E)STI/N, H(ME/RA E)STI/N: A)LLA\ MH\N H(ME/RA E)STI/N: H(ME/RA A)/RA E)STI/N"2. OU)/TE GA\R TH\N XREI/AN TH\N TOU= SULLOGISMOU= PARE/XETAI, E)/TI TE, <20EI) H( TOU= E(POME/NOU PRO/SLHYIS E)N TOI=S SUNEXE/SIN A)SULLO/GISTOS>20, E)N DE\ TOI=S TOIOU/TOIS SU-NEXE/SI TAU)TO\N TO\ H(GOU/MENON TW=| E(POME/NW|, H( PRO/SLHYIS OU) MA=LLON TOU= H(GOU-ME/NOU H)\ TOU= E(POME/NOU GI/NETAI &10etc. &10@[Apuleius$10] PERI\ E(RMHNEI/AS&10 272 [1p. 9, 12 Goldb.]1 supervacanei &10sunt moduli Stoicorum non idem differenter peragentes%10 "1aut dies est aut &10nox; atqui dies est; [2igitur dies est]2"2. item idem geminantes%10 "1si dies &10est, dies est; [2atqui dies est]2; dies igitur est"2. @&10Alexander in Aristot. Top. p. 8 Ald. p. 10, 5.$10 OU)DE\ SULLOGISMO\S OU)=N E)/TI EI)/H A)\N O( MH\ TH\N XREI/AN SW/|ZWN TH\N TOU= SULLOGISMOU=. TOIOU=TOS DE\ O( SULLOGISMO\S E)N W(=| TO\ AU)TO\ TO\ SUMPE/RASMA/ TINI TW=N KEIME/NWN: OI(=OI/ EI)SI <20KA-TA\ TOU\S A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S OI( DIFOROU/MENOI/ TE KAI\ OI( A)DIAFO/RWS PERAI/-NEIN U(P' AU)TW=N LEGO/MENOI>20: DIFOROU/MENOI ME\N GA/R EI)SI KAT' AU)TOU\S OI( TOIOU=TOI "1EI) H(ME/RA E)STI/N, H(ME/RA E)STI/N: A)LLA\ MH\N H(ME/RA E)STI/N: H(ME/RA A)/RA E)STI/N"2. A)DIAFO/RWS DE\ PERAI/NONTES E)N OI(=S TO\ SUMPE/RASMA TAU)TO/N E)STIN E(NI\ TW=N LHMMA/TWN, W(S E)PI\ TW=N TOIOU/TWN "1H)/TOI H(ME/RA E)STI\N H)\ NU/C E)STIN: A)LLA\ MH\N H(ME/RA E)STI/N: H(ME/RA A)/RA E)STI/N"2. @&10Alexander in Aristot. Analyt. pr. p. 84, 5 Wal.$10 [1EI) TO\ *M TW=| ME\N *N PANTI\ U(PA/RXEI, TW=| DE\ *C MH\ PANTI/]1 SUNAXQH/SETAI TO\ *N OU) PANTI\ TW=| *C. TOIOU=TO/S E)STIN O( <20U(POSULLOGISTIKO\S U(PO\ TW=N NEWTE/RWN LEGO/-MENOS>20 O( LAMBA/NWN ME\N TO\ I)SODUNAMOU=N TH=| PROTA/SEI TH=| SULLOGISTIKH=|, TAU)TO\N DE\ KAI\ E)K TAU/THS SUNA/GWN: TW=| GA\R "1TINI\ MH\ U(PA/RXEIN"2 TO\ "1MH\ PANTI\ U(PA/RXEIN"2 I)SODUNAMOU=N METEI/LHPTAI. A)LL' E)KEI=NOI ME\N OU)=N LE/GOUSI TOU\S TOIOU/TOUS SULLOGISMOU/S, EI)S TH\N FWNH\N KAI\ TH\N LE/CIN BLE/PONTES: A)LL' *)ARISTOTE/LHS PRO\S TA\ SHMAINO/MENA O(RW=N, E)F' W(=N O(MOI/WS SHMAI/NETAI, OU) PRO\S TA\S FWNA/S, TO\N AU)TO/N FHSI SUNA/GESQAI SULLOGISMO\N KAI\ E)N TH=| TOIAU/TH| TH=S LE/CEWS E)N TW=| SUMPERA/SMATI METALH/YEI, A)\N H)=| SULLOGISTIKH\ O(/LWS SUMPLOKH/. @&10Alexander in Aristot. Anal. pr. p. 20,2 Wal.$10 E)N GOU=N TOI=S MH\ E)C A)NTIKEIME/NWN DIAIRETIKOI=S, W(S E)N TOI=S E)C E)NANTI/WN, OU)DETE/RW| TW=N KEIME/NWN TAU)TO\N TO\ SUMPE/RASMA OU)DE\ TH=| LE/CEI, O(/TI MH\ SUMPI/PTEI E)PI\ TOU/TWN TO\ A)N-TIKEI/MENON TW=| E(TE/RW| TW=| LOIPW=| TAU)TO\N EI)=NAI: E)N GA\R TW=| "1H)/TOI H(ME/RA E)STI/N H)\ NU/C E)STIN, A)LLA\ MH\N OU)K E)/STIN H(ME/RA, NU\C A)/RA E)STI/N"2 _TO\ "1NU/C E)STIN"2 OU)DETE/RW| TAU)TO\N TW=N EI)LHMME/NWN, OU)/TE TW=| TROPIKW=| <20U(P' AU)TW=N>20 [1&10scil. a &10Stoicis$10]1 LEGOME/NW| [1H)=N GA\R E)KEI=NO "1H)/TOI H(ME/RA E)STI/N H)\ NU/C E)STIN"2 TO\ O(/LON @1 TOU=TO]1 OU)/TE TH=| PROSLH/YEI: H( GA\R PRO/SLHYI/S E)STIN "1A)LLA\ MH\N OU)K E)/STIN H(ME/RA"2: W(=N A)MFOTE/RWN E(/TERO/N E)STI TO\ "1NU/C E)STIN"2. @&10Sextus adv. math. VIII 310.$10 TOU/TWN DH\ OU(/TWS E)XO/NTWN H( <20A)PO/-DEICIS>20 PRO\ PANTO\S O)FEI/LEI LO/GOS EI)=NAI, DEU/TERON SUNAKTIKO/S, TRI/TON KAI\ A)LHQH/S, TE/TARTON KAI\ A)/DHLON E)/XWN SUMPE/RASMA, PE/MPTON KAI\ E)KKALUPTO/MENON TOU=TO E)K TH=S DUNA/MEWS TW=N LHMMA/TWN. &10`314.$10 SUNDRAMO/NTWN OU)=N PA/NTWN TOU/TWN, TOU= TE SUNAKTIKO\N EI)=NAI TO\N LO/GON KAI\ A)LHQH= KAI\ A)DH/LOU PARASTATIKO/N, U(FI/STATAI H( A)PO/DEICIS: E)/NQEN KAI\ OU(/TWS AU)TH\N U(POGRA/FOUSIN "1<20A)PO/DEICI/S E)STI LO/GOS DI' O(MOLOGOUME/NWN LHMMA/TWN KATA\ SUNAGWGH\N E)PIFORA\N E)KKALU/PTWN A)/DHLON>20"2. @&10Sextus adv. math. VIII 367.$10 A)LL' OU) DEI=, FASI/, PA/NTWN A)PO/DEI-CIN AI)TEI=N, TINA\ DE\ KAI\ E)C U(POQE/SEWS LAMBA/NEIN, E)PEI\ OU) DUNH/SETAI PROBAI/-NEIN H(MI=N O( LO/GOS, E)A\N MH\ DOQH=| TI PISTO\N E)C AU(TOU= TUGXA/NEIN. @&10`369.$10 OU)X H( A)PO/DEICIS MO/NON E)C U(POQE/SEWS PROKO/PTEIN A)CIOU=TAI TOI=S DOGMATIKOI=S, A)LLA\ KAI\ O(/LH SXEDO\N FILOSOFI/A. @&10`375.$10 NH\ *DI/A, A)LL' EI)W/QASIN U(POTUGXA/NONTES LE/GEIN O(/TI <20PI/STIS E)STI\ TOU= E)R)R(W=SQAI TH\N U(PO/QESIN TO\ A)LHQE\S EU(RI/SKESQAI E)KEI=NO TO\ TOI=S E)C U(POQE/SEWS LHFQEI=SIN E)PIFERO/MENON>20: EI) GA\R TO\ TOU/TOIS A)KOLOUQOU=N E)STI\N U(GIE/S, KA)KEI=NA OI(=S A)KOLOUQEI= A)LHQH= KAI\ A)NAMFI/LEKTA KAQE/STHKEN. @&10Sextus adv. math. VIII 463.$10 OI)/ONTAI GA\R <20OI( DOGMATIKOI\>20 TW=N FILOSO/FWN LO/GON TO\N A)CIOU=NTA MH\ EI)=NAI A)PO/DEICIN AU)TO\N U(F' AU(TOU= PERI-TRE/PESQAI, KAI\ DI' W(=N A)NAIREI= TAU/THN, DIA\ TOU/TWN AU)TH\N O(RI/ZEIN. O(/QEN KAI\ A)NTIKAQISTA/MENOI TOI=S SKEPTIKOI=S FASI/N: "1O( LE/GWN MHDE\N EI)=NAI A)PO/DEICIN H)/TOI YILH=| KAI\ A)NAPODEI/KTW| XRW/MENOS FA/SEI LE/GEI MHQE\N U(PA/RXEIN A)PO/DEICIN, H)\ LO/GW| TO\ TOIOU=TON A)PODEIKNU/S: KAI\ EI) ME\N YILH=| FA/SEI PROSXRW/MENOS, OU)QEI\S AU)TW=| PISTEU/SEI TW=N TH\N A)PO/DEICIN PARADEXOME/NWN, YILH=| FA/SEI XRWME/NW|, A)LLA\ DIA\ TH=S A)NTIKEIME/NHS E)PISXEQH/SETAI FA/SEWS, EI)PO/NTOS TINO\S EI)=NAI A)PO/DEICIN: EI) DE\ A)PODEIKNU\S TO\ MH\ EI)=NAI A)PO/DEICIN [1TOU=TO GA/R FASIN]1, AU)TO/QEN W(MO-LO/GHSE TO\ EI)=NAI A)PO/DEICIN: O( GA\R DEIKNU\S LO/GOS TO\ MH\ EI)=NAI A)PO/DEICIN E)/STIN A)PO/DEICIS TOU= EI)=NAI A)PO/DEICIN: KAI\ KAQO/LOU O( KATA\ TH=S A)PODEI/CEWS LO/GOS H)/TOI A)PO/DEICI/S E)STIN, H)\ OU)K E)/STIN A)PO/DEICIS: KAI\ EI) ME\N OU)K E)/STIN A)PO/DEICIS, A)/PISTO/S E)STIN, EI) DE\ E)/STIN A)PO/DEICIS, A)PO/DEICIS E)/STIN"2. E)/NIOI DE\ KAI\ OU(/TW SUNERWTW=SIN: "1EI) E)/STIN A)PO/DEICIS, A)PO/DEICIS E)/STIN: EI) MH\ E)/STIN A)PO/DEICIS, A)PO/DEICIS E)/STIN: H)/TOI DE\ E)/STIN H)\ OU)K E)/STIN A)PO/DEICIS: A)PO/DEICIS A)/RA E)/STIN"2. @&10Galenus in Hippocr. prognost. i. Vol. XVIII B p. 26 K.$10 A)NALO-GISMO\S D' E)STI\ LO/GOS E)K TOU= FAINOME/NOU O(RMW/MENOS KAI\ TOU= A)DH/LOU KATA/-LHYIN POIOU/MENOS: E)PILOGISMO\S DE\ O( KOINO\S KAI\ SUMFWNOU/MENOS PARA\ PA/N-TWN LO/GOS. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 10 p. 1036c.$8 *(/WST' AU)TO\N E(AUTW=| MA/XESQAI__FULA/TTESQAI ME\N E(TE/ROIS PARAINOU=NTA TOU\S EI)S TA)NANTI/A LO/GOUS, W(S PERISPW=NTAS TH\N KATA/LHYIN, AU)TO\N DE\ TW=N BEBAI- @1OU/NTWN TH\N KATA/LHYIN LO/GWN FILOTIMO/TERON SUNTIQE/NTA TOU\S A)NAIROU=N-TAS. *KAI/TOI O(/TI TOU=TO AU)TO\S FOBEI=TAI, SAFW=S U(PODEI/KNUSIN <20E)N TW=| TETA/RTW| PERI\ *BI/WN>20 TAU=TA GRA/FWN "1<20*OU)X W(S E)/TUXE DE\ OU)DE\ TOU\S E)NANTI/OUS U(PODEKTE/ON LO/GOUS, OU)DE\ PROS[2ETE/A]2 TA\ E)NANTI/A PIQANA/, A)LL' EU)LABOUME/NOUS, MH\ KAI\ PERISPASQE/NTES U(P' AU)TW=N TA\S KATALH/YEIS A)FW=SIN, OU)/TE TW=N LU/SEWN I(KANW=S A)\N A)KOU=SAI DUNA/MENOI, KATALAMBA/NONTE/S TE EU)APOSEI/STWS: E)PEI\ KAI\ OI( TH\N SUNH/QEIAN KATALAMBA/NONTES KAI\ TA\ AI)SQHTA\ KAI\ TA\ A)/LLA E)K TW=N AI)SQH/SEWN, R(A|DI/WS PROI/+ENTAI TAU=TA, KAI\ U(PO\ TW=N *MEGA-RIKW=N E)RWTHMA/TWN PERISPW/MENOI, KAI\ U(P' A)/LLWN PLEIO/NWN KAI\ DUNAMIKWTE/RWN E)RWTHMA/TWN>20."2 @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 10 p. 1036f.$8 *)=H TOU=TO [1&quanti$8 TA\ *MEGARIKA\ E)RWTH/MATA& aestimanda sint$8]1 PAR' AU)TOU= *XRUSI/P-POU DEI= PUNQA/NESQAI; SKO/PEI GA\R OI(=A PERI\ TOU= *MEGARIKOU= LO/GOU GE/-GRAFEN <20E)N TW=| PERI\ *LO/GOU *XRH/SEWS>20 OU(/TWS: "1<20*OI(=O/N TI SUMBE/BHKE KAI\ E)PI\ TOU= *STI/LPWNOS LO/GOU KAI\ *MENEDH/MOU: SFO/DRA GA\R E)PI\ SOFI/A| GENOME/NWN AU)TW=N E)NDO/CWN, NU=N EI)S O)/NEIDOS AU)TW=N O( LO/GOS PERITE/TRAPTAI, W(S TW=N ME\N PAXUTE/RWN, TW=N D' E)KFA-NW=S SOFIZOME/NWN>20."2 @&10Galenus de animi peccatis dignoscendis 3. Vol. V p. 72. K.$10 A)NAG-KAI=ON D' E)STI\ TO\N E)CAI/FNHS PROSELQO/NTA KRI/SEI LO/GOU A)DUNATEI=N DIAGNW=NAI/ TE KAI\ DIAKRI=NAI TOU\S YEUDEI=S A)PO\ TW=N A)LHQW=N. E)NARGE\S DE\ TOU/TOU TEKMH/-RIO/N E)STI, <20TA\ KALOU/MENA SOFI/SMATA>20, LO/GOI TINE\S O)/NTES YEUDEI=S EI)S O(MOIO/-THTA TW=N A)LHQW=N PEPANOURGEUME/NOI: TO\ ME\N OU)=N YEU=DOS AU)TW=N PRO/DHLON FAI/NETAI DIA\ TOU= SUMPERA/SMATOS OU)K O)/NTOS A)LHQOU=S: E)PEIDH\ D' OI( YEUDEI=S LO/GOI PA/NTWS H)/TOI TW=N LHMMA/TWN E)/XOUSI/ TI YEU=DOS H)\ TO\ SUMPE/RASMA KAKW=S E)PIFERO/MENON, OU) FAI/NETAI DE\ PROXEI/RWS TAU=TA KATA\ TA\ SOFI/SMATA, DIA\ TOU=TO DU/SOPTA TOI=S A)GUMNA/STOIS PERI\ LO/GOUS. @&10Anonymi scholia in status Walz. Rh. Gr. VII 1 p. 383.$10 O(/POU GE KAI\ <20PARA\ TOI=S *STWI+KOI=S KALEI=TAI/ TIS DIA/LLHLOS LO/GOS, O(/S E)STIN A)NA-PO/DEIKTOS>20: OI(=ON POU= *QE/WN OI)KEI=, E)/NQA *DI/WN, KAI\ POU= *DI/WN, E)/NQA *QE/WN: O( DE\ TOIOU=TOS LO/GOS, O( DIA/LLHLO/S FHMI TH\N A)PO/DEICIN E)/XEIN, A)NAPO/DEIKTO/S TE/ E)STI KAI\ PE/RAS AU)TOU= OU)DE\N GI/GNETAI, O(/TAN TA\ SHMEI=A TOU= PRA/GMATOS DI' A)LLH/LWN SUGKATASKEUA/ZHTAI. @&10Diocles Magnes apud Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 82.$10 KAI\ <20A)/POROI>20 DE/ TINE/S EI)SI LO/GOI, E)GKEKALUMME/NOI KAI\ DIALELHQO/TES KAI\ SWREI=TAI KAI\ KERATI/DES KAI\ OU)/TIDES. E)/STI DE\ <20E)GKEKALUMME/NOS>20 OI(=ON O( TOIOU=TOS "1OU)XI\ TA\ ME\N DU/O O)LI/GA @1 E)STI/N, OU)XI\ DE\ KAI\ TA\ TRI/A, OU)XI\ DE\ KAI\ TAU=TA ME/N, OU)XI\ DE\ KAI\ TA\ TE/SSARA, KAI\ OU(/TW ME/XRI TW=N DE/KA: TA\ DE\ DU/O O)LI/GA E)STI/N: KAI\ TA\ DE/KA A)/RA"2. <20OU)/TIS>20 DE/ E)STI LO/GOS SUNAKTIKO\S [KAI\] E)C A)ORI/STOU KAI\ W(RISME/NOU SUNESTW/S, PRO/S-LHYIN DE\ KAI\ E)PIFORA\N E)/XWN, OI(=ON: "1EI) TI/S E)STIN E)NTAU=QA, OU)K E)/STIN E)KEI=NOS E)N *(RO/DW|: [2A)LLA\ MH\N E)/STI TIS E)NTAU=QA: OU)K A)/RA TIS E)/STIN E)N *(RO/DW|]2"2. @&Sextus Pyrrh. Hyp. II 253.$ KAI\ EI)/GE <20OI( PERI\ TO\N *XRU/-SIPPON>20 DOGMATIKOI\ E)N TH=| SUNERWTH/SEI <20TOU= SWRI/TOU>20 PROI+O/NTOS TOU= LO/GOU FASI\ DEI=N I(/STASQAI KAI\ E)PE/XEIN, I(/NA MH\ E)KPE/SWSIN EI)S A)TOPI/AN, POLU\ DH/POU MA=LLON A)\N H(MI=N A(RMO/ZON EI)/H SKEPTIKOI=S OU)=SIN, U(POPTEU/-OUSIN A)TOPI/AN, MH\ PROPI/PTEIN KATA\ TA\S SUNERWTH/SEIS TW=N LHMMA/TWN, A)LL' E)PE/XEIN KAQ' E(/KASTON E(/WS TH=S O(/LHS SUNERWTH/SEWS TOU= LO/GOU. @&Sextus adv. math. VII 416.$ E)PI\ GA\R <20TOU= SWRI/TOU>20 TH=S E)SXA/THS KATALHPTIKH=S FANTASI/AS TH=| PRW/TH| A)KATALH/PTW| PARAKEIME/NHS KAI\ DUSDIORI/STOU SXEDO\N U(PARXOU/SHS, FASI\N <20OI( PERI\ TO\N *XRU/SIP-PON>20 O(/TI E)F' W(=N ME\N FANTASIW=N O)LI/GH TIS OU(/TWS E)/STI DIAFORA/, STH/-SETAI O( SOFO\S KAI\ H(SUXA/SEI, E)F' W(=N DE\ PLEI/WN PROSPI/PTEI, E)PI\ TOU/-TWN SUGKATAQH/SETAI TH=| E(TE/RA| W(S A)LHQEI=. @&Cicero Acad. Pr. II 93.&3 Placet enim <21Chrysippo>21 cum gra-&3datim interrogetur, verbi causa "1tria pauca sint anne multa,"2 aliquanto &3prius quam ad multa perveniat quiescere, id est quod ab iis dicitur $10H(SUXA/ZEIN.&3 "1Per me vel stertas licet, inquit Carneades, non modo &3quiescas."2 @&Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 26E. ed. Bas.$ *)/ACION DE\ ZH-TEI=N KATA\ TOU\S U(PO/STASIN DIDO/NTAS TOI=S EI)/DESI KAI\ GE/NESIN EI) R(HQH/-SETAI "1TA/DE"2 EI)=NAI. *KAI\ GA\R KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 A)POREI= PERI\ TH=S I)DE/AS EI) TO/DE TI R(HQH/SETAI. SUMPARALHPTE/ON DE\ KAI\ TH\N SUNH/QEIAN TW=N *STWI+KW=N PERI\ TW=N GENIKW=N POIW=N, PW=S AI( PTW/SEIS KAT' AU)TOU\S PRO-FE/RONTAI KAI\ PW=S <20OU)/ TINA TA\ KOINA\ PAR' AU)TOI=S LE/GETAI>20 KAI\ O(/PWS PARA\ TH\N A)/GNOIAN TOU= MH\ PA=SAN OU)SI/AN TO/DE TI SHMAI/NEIN KAI\ <20TO\ PARA\ TO\N OU)/TINA SO/FISMA>20 GI/NETAI, PARA\ TO\ SXH=MA TH=S LE/CEWS, OI(=ON <20EI)/ TIS E)STI\N E)N *)AQH/NAIS, OU)K E)/STIN E)N *MEGA/ROIS>20. O( GA\R A)/NQRWPOS OU)/ TIS E)STI/N. OU) GA\R E)STI/ TIS O( KOINO/S, W(S TINA\ DE\ AU)TO\N E)LA/BOMEN E)N TW=| LO/GW|, KAI\ PARA\ TOU=TO TO\ O)/NOMA TOU=TO E)/SXEN O( LO/GOS, "1OU)/ TIS"2 KLHQEI/S. TO\ AU)TO\ KAI\ E)PI\ TOU=DE TOU= SOFI/SMATO/S E)STIN: O(\ <20E)GW\ EI)MI/, SU\ OU)K EI)=. A)/NQRWPOS D' EI)MI\ E)GW/. A)/NQRWPOS A)/RA @1 SU\ OU)K EI)=>20. *KAI\ GA\R E)PI\ TOU/TOU TOU= SOFI/SMATOS TO\ ME\N "1E)GW\"2 KAI\ "1SU\"2 E)PI\ TW=N A)TO/MWN LE/GETAI: O( DE\ A)/NQRWPOS E)P' OU)DENI\ TW=N E)N ME/REI. GE/GONEN OU)=N H( PARAGWGH\ DIO/TI TW=| OU)/ TINI W(S "1TINI\"2 E)XRH/SATO. @&Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 186.$ *(O DH\ FILO/SOFOS KAI\ TOIOU/TOUS TINA\S H)RW/TA LO/GOUS. *(O LE/GWN TOI=S A)MUH/TOIS TA\ MUSTH/RIA A)SEBEI=: O( DE/ GE I(EROFA/NTHS TOI=S A)MUH/TOIS LE/GEI [2TA\ MUSTH/RIA]2: A)SEBEI= A)/RA O( I(ERO-FA/NTHS. A)/LLO: *(\O OU)K E)/STIN E)N TH=| PO/LEI, OU)D' E)N TH=| OI)KI/A|: OU)K E)/STI DE\ FRE/AR E)N TH=| PO/LEI: OU)D' A)/RA E)N TH=| OI)KI/A|. A)/LLO: *)/ESTI TIS KEFALH/. E)KEI/NHN DE\ OU)K E)/XEIS: E)/STI DE\ GE/ TIS KEFALH/ [2H(\N OU)K E)/XEIS]2: OU)K A)/RA E)/XEIS KEFALH/N. A)/LLO: <20*EI)/ TIS E)/STIN E)N *MEGA/ROIS, OU)K E)/STIN E)N *)AQH/NAIS: A)/NQRWPOS DE/ E)STIN E)N *MEGA/ROIS: OU)K A)/RA E)STI\N A)/NQRWPOS E)N *)AQH/NAIS>20. *KAI\ PA/LIN: *EI)/ TI LALEI=S, TOU=TO DIA\ TOU= STO/MATO/S SOU DIE/RXETAI: A(/MACAN DE\ LALEI=S: A(/MACA A)/RA DIA\ TOU= STO/-MATO/S SOU DIE/RXETAI. KAI/: *EI)/ TI OU)K A)PE/BALES, TOU=TO E)/XEIS: KE/RATA DE\ OU)K A)PE/BALES: KE/RATA A)/RA E)/XEIS. OI( DE\ *EU)BOULI/DOU TOU=TO/ FASIN. @&Arrianus Epictet. dissert. II 17, 34.$ A)LL' E)GW\ QE/LW GNW=NAI TI/ LE/GEI <20*XRU/SIPPOS E)N TOI=S PERI\ TOU= *YEUDOME/NOU>20. @&Hieronymus ep. 69 ad Oceanum.&3 statimque recordatus <21Chry-&3sippei>21 sophismatis%10 Si mentiris, idque vere dicis, mentiris. @&Cicero Acad. Pr. II 96.&3 Quomodo igitur hoc conclusum esse &3iudicas? "1Si dicis nunc lucere et verum dicis [2lucet; dicis autem lucere &3et verum dicis]2 lucet igitur."2 Probatis certe genus et rectissime conclu-&3sum dicitis. Itaque in docendo eum primum concludendi modum tra-&3ditis. Aut quidquid igitur eodem modo concluditur, probabitis, aut ars &3ista nulla est. Vide ergo hanc conclusionem probaturusne sis%10 "1Si dicis &3te mentiri, verumque dicis, mentiris. Dicis autem te mentiri verumque &3dicis%10 mentiris igitur."2 Qui potes hanc non probare, quum probaveris &3eiusdem generis superiorem? Haec <21Chrysippea>21 sunt, ne ab ipso qui-&3dem dissoluta. Quid enim faceret huic conclusioni%10 "3Si lucet, lucet; &3lucet autem; lucet igitur."3 Cederet scilicet. Ipsa enim ratio conexi, &3cum concesseris superius, cogit inferius concedere. Quid ergo haec ab &3illa conclusione differt? @&Arrianus Epictet. dissert. II 19, 1 sq.$ *(O KURIEU/WN LO/GOS A)PO\ TOIOU/TWN TINW=N A)FORMW=N H)RWTH=SQAI FAI/NETAI. *KOINH=S GA\R OU)/SHS @1 MA/XHS TOI=S TRISI\ TOU/TOIS PRO\S A)/LLHLA, TW=| "1*PA=N PARELHLUQO\S A)LHQE\S A)NAGKAI=ON EI)=NAI"2 KAI\ TW=| "1*DUNATW=| A)DU/NATON MH\ A)KOLOUQEI=N"2 KAI\ TW=| "1*DUNATO\N EI)=NAI O(\ OU)/T' E)/STIN A)LHQE\S OU)/T' E)/STAI"2: SUNIDW\N TH\N MA/XHN TAU/THN O( *DIO/DWROS, TH=| TW=N PRW/TWN DUOI=N PIQANO/THTI SUNEXRH/SATO PRO\S PARA/STASIN TOU= "1*MHDE\N EI)=NAI DUNATO\N O(\ OU)/T' E)/STIN A)LHQE\S OU)/T' E)/STAI."2 *LOIPO\N O( ME/N TIS TAU=TA THRH/SEI TW=N DUOI=N, O(/TI E)/STI TE/ TI DUNATO/N, O(\ OU)/T' E)/STIN A)LHQE\S OU)/T' E)/STAI: KAI\ DUNATW=| A)DU/NATON OU)K A)KOLOUQEI=: OU) PA=N DE\ PARELHLUQO\S A)LHQE\S A)NAGKAI=O/N E)STI: KAQA/PER OI( PERI\ <20*KLEA/NQHN>20 FE/RESQAI DOKOU=SIN, OI(=S E)PIPOLU\ SUNHGO/RHSEN <20*)ANTI/PATROS. *OI( DE\>20 [1&scil. <21Chrysippus>21$]1 <20TA)/LLA DU/O: O(/TI DUNA-TO/N T' E)STI\N O(\ OU)/T' E)/STIN A)LHQE\S OU)/T' E)/STAI KAI\ PA=N PARE-LHLUQO\S A)LHQE\S A)NAGKAI=O/N E)STIN: DUNATW=| D' A)DU/NATON A)KO-LOUQEI=>20. *TA\ TRI/A D' E)KEI=NA THRH=SAI A)MH/XANON, DIA\ TO\ KOINH\N EI)=NAI AU)TW=N TH\N MA/XHN. @&ibid. %14 9.$ *GE/GRAFE DE\ KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 QAUMASTW=S <20E)N TW=| PRW/TW| PERI\ *DUNATW=N>20: KAI\ *KLEA/NQHS D' I)DI/A| GE/GRAFE PERI\ TOU/TOU KAI\ <20*)ARXE/DHMOS>20: GE/GRAFE DE\ KAI\ <20*)ANTI/PATROS>20, OU) MO/NON D' E)N TOI=S PERI\ *DUNATW=N, A)LLA\ KAI\ KAT' I)DI/AN E)N TOI=S PERI\ TOU= *KURIEU/ONTOS. @&Cicero ad famil. IX 4.$ *PERI\ DUNATW=N&3 me scito$ KATA\ *DIO/-DWRON KRI/NEIN.&3 Quapropter si venturus es, scito necesse esse te venire%10 &3sin autem non es,$ TW=N A)DUNA/TWN&3 est, te venire. Nunc vide, utra te $KRI/SIS&3 magis delectet,$ *XRUSIPPEI/A&3 ne, an haec, quam noster Diodotus &3non concoquebat. Sed de his etiam rebus, otiosi quum erimus, loque-&3mur%10 hoc etiam$ KATA\ *XRU/SIPPON DUNATO\N&3 est. @&Cicero Acad. Pr. II 143.&3 In hoc ipso, quod in elementis dia &3lectici docent, quo modo iudicare oporteat, verum falsumne sit, si quid &3ita conexum est, ut hoc%10 "1si dies est, lucet"2, quanta contentio est! aliter &3Diodoro, aliter Philoni, <21Chrysippo>21 aliter placet. Quid? cum Cleanthe, &3doctore suo, quam multis rebus <21Chrysippus>21 dissidet! quid? duo vel &3principes dialecticorum, Antipater et Archedemus, opiniosissimi homines, &3nonne multis in rebus dissentiunt? @&10Syrianus Schol. in Hermog. Vol. II p. 42, 1 Rabe.$10 <20TO\N A)/PO-RON E)N KATHGORI/A|, O(\N KAI\ KROKODEILI/THN OI( *STWI+KOI/ FASIN>20, OI(=ON: *EU)/AQLOS SUNE/QETO *PRWTAGO/RA| TW=| SOFISTH=| DW/SEIN MISQO\N, EI) TH\N PRW/THN DI/KHN LE/GWN NIKH/SEIE. MAQW\N KAI\ MH\ BOULO/MENOS LE/GEIN U(PO\ TOU= *PRWTAGO/-ROU TO\N MISQO\N A)PAITEI=TAI: O( DE\ A)NTILE/GEI: EI)/TE GA\R NIKH/SEIEN, OU) DI/KAIOS DOU=NAI KATA\ TH\N SU/NTACIN, EI)/TE H(TTHQEI/H, W(S MHDE/PW MAQW\N OU)K A)/CIOS A)PAITEI=SQAI. @&Lucianus vitarum auctio 22.$ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20: E)/STI SOI PAI-DI/ON; _<20*)WNHTH/S>20: TI/ MH/N; _<20*XRUS1>20. TOU=TO H)/N PWS KROKO/DEILOS @1 A(RPA/SH| PLHSI/ON TOU= POTAMOU= PLAZO/MENON EU(RW/N, KW)=|TA/ SOI A)PODW/SEIN U(PISXNH=TAI AU)TO/, H)\N EI)/PH|S TA)LHQE\S O(/TI DE/DOKTAI AU)TW=| PERI\ TH=S A)PO-DO/SEWS TOU= BRE/FOUS, TI/ FH/SEIS AU)TO\N E)GNWKE/NAI; ____<20*XRUS1>20. *KAI\ A)/LLA GA/R SE DIDA/COMAI QAUMASIW/TERA_TO\N <20QERI/ZONTA>20 KAI\ TO\N <20KURI/TTONTA>20 KAI\ E)PI\ PA=SI <20TH\N *)HLE/KTRAN>20 KAI\ <20TO\N E)GKEKA-LUMME/NON>20. __*)HLE/KTRAN ME\N E)KEI/NHN_H(\ TA\ AU)TA\ OI)=DE/ TE A(/MA KAI\ OU)K OI)=DEN: PARESTW=TOS GA\R AU)TH=| TOU= *)ORE/STOU E)/TI A)GNW=TOS, OI)=DE ME\N *)ORE/STHN, O(/TI A)DELFO\S AU)TH=S, O(/TI DE\ OU(=TOS *)ORE/STHS A)GNOEI=. TO\N D' AU)= E)GKEKALUMME/NON KAI\ PA/NU QAUMASTO\N A)KOU/SH| LO/GON. A)PO/KRINAI GA/R MOI, TO\N PATE/RA OI)=SQA TO\N SEAUTOU=; _*)WN. NAI/. _<20*XRUS1>20. TI/ OU)=N; H)/N SOI PARASTH/SAS TINA\ E)GKEKALUMME/NON E)/RWMAI "1TOU=TON OI)=SQA"2; TI/ FH/SEIS; _*)WN. DHLADH\ A)GNOEI=N. _<20*XRUS1>20. A)LLA\ MH\N AU)TO\S OU(=TOS H)=N O( PATH\R O( SO/S, W(/STE EI) TOU=TON A)GNOEI=S, DH=LOS EI)= TO\N PATE/RA TO\N SO\N A)GNOW=N. @1 @&Cicero de finib. IV 7.&3 [1de rhetorica arte locutus%10]1 Totum &3genus hoc Zeno et qui ab eo sunt__aut non potuerunt [2tueri]2 aut &3noluerunt__certe reliquerunt. Quamquam scripsit <21artem rhetoricam>21 &3Cleanthes, <21Chrysippus>21 etiam; sed sic ut siquis obmutescere concupierit, &3nihil aliud legere debeat. @&10Quintilianus instit. orat. III. 1, 15. Theophrastus quoque Ari-&10stotelis discipulus de rhetorice diligenter scripsit atque hinc vel studiosius &10philosophi quam rhetores praecipueque <21Stoicorum>21 ac Peripateticorum &10principes. &10@Quintilianus instit. orat. I 17, 2. quod [1scil. rhetoricen artem &10esse]1 non oratores tantum vindicarunt__sed cum iis philosophi <21Stoici>21 &10et Peripatetici plerique consentiunt. &10@Cicero de oratore III 65. stoicos autem, quos minime improbo, &10dimitto tamen__atque hanc iis habeo gratiam, quod soli ex omnibus &10<21eloquentiam virtutem ac sapientiam esse dixerunt>21. &10@Quintilianus instit. orat. II 15, 34.&3 huic eius substantiae &3maxime conveniet finitio "1<21rhetoricen esse bene dicendi scientiam>21."2 &3nam et orationis omnes virtutes semel complectitur et protinus etiam &3mores oratoris, cum bene dicere non possit nisi bonus. idem valet <21Chry-&3sippi>21 finis ille, ductus a <21Cleanthe, "1scientia recte dicendi>21."2 Sunt &3plures eiusdem, sed ad alias quaestiones magis pertinent. @&10Anonymi Proleg. in Hermog. status Walz. rh. gr. VII p. 8.$10 OI( ME\N GA\R AU)TH\N [1&10scil.$10 TH\N R(HTORIKH/N]1 E)KA/LESAN E)PISTH/MHN A)PO\ TOU= MEI/ZONOS, O(RIZO/MENOI <20E)PISTH/MHN TOU= EU)= LE/GEIN>20, OI( <20*STWI+KOI/>20. @&10Sextus adv. math. II 6.$10 *CENOKRA/THS DE\ O( *PLA/TWNOS A)KOUSTH\S KAI\ <20OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S FILO/SOFOI>20 E)/LEGON R(HTORIKH\N U(PA/RXEIN <20E)PISTH/-MHN TOU= EU)= LE/GEIN>20, A)/LLWS ME\N *CENOKRA/TOUS TH\N E)PISTH/MHN LAMBA/NONTOS_ A)/LLWS DE\ <20TW=N *STWI+KW=N>20, A)NTI\ TOU= BEBAI/AS E)/XEIN KATALH/YEIS, E)N SOFW=| MO/NW| FUOME/NHN. TO\ DE\ LE/GEIN A)MFO/TEROI PARALAMBA/NOUSIN W(S DIAFE/RON TOU= DIA-LE/GESQAI, E)PEIDH/PER TO\ ME\N E)N SUNTOMI/A| KEI/MENON KA)N TW=| LAMBA/NEIN KAI\ DI-DO/NAI LO/GON DIALEKTIKH=S E)STI\N E)/RGON, TO\ DE\ LE/GEIN E)N MH/KEI KAI\ DIECO/DW| QEWROU/MENON R(HTORIKH=S E)TU/GXANEN I)/DION. @1 @&10Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 42.$10 KAI\ TH\N R(HTORIKH\N AU)TH\N ME\N EI)=NAI LE/-GOUSI TRIMERH=: TO\ ME\N GA\R AU)TH=S EI)=NAI SUMBOULEUTIKO/N, TO\ DE\ DIKANIKO/N, TO\ DE\ E)GKWMIASTIKO/N: EI)=NAI D' AU)TH=S TH\N DIAI/RESIN EI)/S TE TH\N EU(/RESIN KAI\ EI)S TH\N FRA/SIN KAI\ EI)S TH\N TA/CIN KAI\ EI)S TH\N U(PO/KRISIN, TOU= DE\ R(HTORIKOU= LO/GOU EI)/S TE TO\ PROOI/MION KAI\ EI)S TH\N DIH/GHSIN KAI\ TA\ PRO\S TOU\S A)NTIDI/KOUS KAI\ TO\N E)PI/LOGON. @&Anonymus art. rhetor. [1Rhet. graec. Vol. I ed. Spengel]1 &p. 454, 1.$ E)/RGON DE\ E)PILO/GOU *PLA/TWN ME\N E)N *FAI/DRW| FHSI/N, E)N KEFALAI/W| E(/KASTA LE/GONTA U(POMNH=SAI E)PI\ TELEUTH=S TOU\S A)KOU/ONTAS PERI\ TW=N EI)RHME/NWN [1&Plat. Phaedr. p. 267d$]1. E)/XETAI DE\ TH=S AU)TH=S DO/CHS KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20: KAI\ GA\R AU)TO\S MONOMERH= FHSI\ TO\N E)PI/LOGON. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 28 p. 1047a.$8 <20*TH\N R(HTO-RIKH\N>20 O(RI/ZETAI TE/XNHN PERI\ KO/SMON EU(RHME/NOU LO/GOU KAI\ TA/CIN: E)/TI D' E)N TW=| PRW/TW| KAI\ TAU=TA GE/GRAFEN: "1<20*OU) MO/NON DE\ TOU= E)LEUQERI/OU KAI\ A)FELOU=S KO/SMOU DEI=N OI)/OMAI E)PISTRE/FESQAI KA)PI\ TW=N LO/-GWN A)LLA\ KAI\ TW=N OI)KEI/WN U(POKRI/SEWN KATA\ TA\S E)PIBALLOU/SAS TA/SEIS TH=S FWNH=S, KAI\ SXHMATISMOU\S TOU= TE PROSW/POU KAI\ TW=N XEIRW=N>20."2 *OU(/TW DE/ TIS FILO/TIMOS E)NTAU=QA KAI\ PERITTO\S GENO/MENOS &etc. &@Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 28 p. 1047b.$8 PA/LIN E)N TW=| AU)TW=| BIBLI/W| PERI\ TH=S TW=N FWNHE/NTWN SUGKROU/SEWS U(PEIPW/N, "1<20*OU) MO/-NON, FHSI/, TAU=TA PARETE/ON TOU= BELTI/ONOS E)XOME/NOUS, A)LLA\ KAI\ POIA\S A)SAFEI/AS KAI\ E)LLEI/YEIS KAI/, NH\ *DI/A, SOLOIKISMOU/S, E)F' OI(=S A)/LLOI A)\N AI)SXUNQEI/HSAN OU)K O)LI/GOI>20."2 ቁ$70{1*X*R[1*U*S*I*P*P*O*U]1 *L*O*G*I*K*W?[1*N]1 *Z*H*T[1*H]1*M[1*A*T*W*N]1 <*A>.}1$8 E)SOME/NOU TW=N KAI\ !!!!!NOS PLHQUNT?IK?!TOU!!!!!!#7N !ESTWMHTW!!TWP?LHQ?UNTI-KW KAI\ TW=N? E)RWT[1H/]1S1!! O(MOI/-!!METW!!!OMEN!!!#7E!! G!I PERI\ T!! TOUTO? E)N!!TW! EI)=NAI TI!!!!!!TON?!!!!LOI @1 LEGOUS?!!!!!TO PRO!!!!!!! KONEN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!TO?TE!!!!!!!!!NTW=P?A R]1ELHLU[1QO/TI?]1N!!!!!!TO!! TWNOU!!!!!A?IP!!!!!! T!TH!!!!!!!!EN!!!!!! A)[1L]1LA MO/NON TA?!!!!!!! !!!WNPROHGE!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!KEI!!TON !!QA!!!IKEINOS1!!!!!! PO?RI/ZESQAI O(/PEROH!!!!!! FAI/NET]1A[1I]1. KA)NTAU=Q' !!!!!! TO!!!!!!!!IRHTWN A)[1PI/-QA[1NON FAI/NES]1QAI, OU)/T!! [1DI-XW=[1S]1 PRO!!!!!WT!!!!!!!! T!!!OS1!!MENA!!!!ERON TI KATA\ TW=[1N]1 !OSU[1M]1BE!!!! !!TWN E)N TW= $70*A*I*D*I*K!!*I*S*Q$8AI EI!PAN!!!!!APRO!!!! !!NA M[1H\ E)NEK]1TE/ON [1EI)=-N]1AI E)PI\ TAU=TA W(/SQ' E(/N[1A PERI\ PA/NTWN POIH/SASQAI LO/GON !!PE!DES1!TI [1U(P]1A/R-XEI !!!!MA!!!!!!PAR!! TIS1!!!NOU PARE!!!!!!! K?AI\ PA[1RE]1LH[1LUQO/TWN PARE-LHLUQ[1O/T]1A E)ST[1I\N ME/XRI EI)S A)/PEIRON. KAI\ E)/S[1TI ME\]1N [1PA-RELHLUQO/TA TOI?A[1U=T]1A KAI\ KA-TA[1TO\N]1 AU)TO\N E)S[1OME/]1N[1WN E)SO/MENA E)/[1S]1TAI [1ME/X]1RI EI)?S? [1A)/-PEIRON ! KAI\ [1PARELH]1LUQO/-TWN E)ST[1I/!!!!!!!!GE !EN!WEN. TO\!!!EISQA[1I!! U(]1PTIO!! U(PT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! KAI\ T!!! ME/[1XRI]1 EI)S A)/[1PEIRON T!EI!!!TAU?TWN E)NT!!!! @1 NON!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! @[1&`4 versus desunt$8]1 !!WN O)RQ[1W=N]1 !!XEI!!!!! N!!THOIS O!SI!!!!!!!!! #6T!N!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! T]1W=| M[1E\]1N E)N TW=| !!!!E!I U(P[1A/R-XEIN !! U(/PTIO[1N D' OU)]1DE/N !!! !!!!EI=SQAI [1S]1UN!!!!!!!! !!N U(PA/RXEIN !!!!N!K!! !!OU!!!!!!!!!!!THTWN TOIOU/[1T]1WN! A)[1LLA/]1 GE TA\ PRO/-TER[1ON L]1EGO/MENA PAREI/[1SQW TA/T' E)KEI/NOU KAI\ !!!!!TA !!#7NO!!!!ON!!!NE!!!!! !!A!!!!ERBWME!!E!!EON !!N!!!!N A)/PEIRA?!!!TW !!!!!OS ETER!!!!ESQAI TA !!!!S E)/XONTA O!!!!!!!! RELHLUQO/TA KAI\ !!!!!!! !!!ROST! [1U(]1P?AR!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!![1D]1UOI=N TO\!!!! !!!!!!!!! [1D]1UOI=N E)!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!M]1E/XR?I EI)S A)/PEI-RON]1 !!!!!! O(MOI/WN E)S[1TI/ !!!!!!!!!!TWN!!!TA!! !A!!!!!!!!TAI E)PIZ[1HT!! !A!!!!!!!!OUTWN!!!!! T!H!!!!!!!!!!KISE!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!AT!!!!! #6TER!!ATE!!!!!ERTW=[1N! TOI-OU/TWN EK!!TOUQ!A!P?ER!! TW=N SUNB[1E]1BHKO/T[1WN!!!!! DO/CE[1I]1 KAI\ [1T]1O\ P[1LHQUNTI]1KO\N !!KAT' AU)T[1O\N]1 A!!!!!!NAI !!!!! A)PO\ TOU/TWN D[1E\]1 KAI\ PRO\S E)KEI=NA E)/STAI PI?QANW=S PROSELQEI=N LE/GONTA [1O]1U) D[1H=TA PLHQUNTIKA\ ME\N PL[1HQUN- @1TIK]1W=N EI)=NAI, TRO/PON TIN[1A\ !!!!!TW=N PRO\S TA\ E(NIKA\ !!!MENWN, PARELHLUQO/TA DE\ PARELHLUQO/TWN MH\ EI)=NAI KAI\ U(/PTIA U([1PTI/]1WN. MHD' E)-PI\]1 TOU/TWN [1ME\N]1 TH\N A)[1P]1EIRI/-AN]1 G?I/NESQAI, E)P' E)KEI/NWN [1D']1 A)/R[1A MH/, KAI\ [1E)/M]1PALIN. KA)\N EI) A)/[1RA TIS]1 TOIOU/TOUS E[1I)/]1P?OI LO/GOUS K[1ATA\]1 TW=N E(TE/R[1WN K%32 KAT]1A\ [1TAU=T]1A DIABAI/NO[1I A)PO/ TINOS [1TW=N]1 TOIOU/TWN [1EI)S]1 SUN-G?E?N?H= !!! TO/PON, H([1M]1E\N [1A)GWGH\ T[1OU= LO/GOU U(GIH\S]1 TW=[1I]1 EI)/[1D]1EI, A?U)-T[1H\]1 DE\ H( [1DI]1A/B?ASI/S E)STIN TW=N @TAN!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!DWNP!!!!! !!!!!!!! [1K]1ATA\ KL!!!QHN !!!!!!!![1K]1EIME/N[1OU DE\]1 TOU !!!!!!!!!PRO\S E)/LE[1G]1XO[1N !!!H!!![1G]1ENOME/NWN !!!!!!!!!ME\N E)K TH=S KA-TA\!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! #6E!!!O!!!!!!!NUP!!!E O)/NTWN !!!!!!!!!![1PARE-]1LH[1LUQOT!!!!!!!!!!!! T!#7I/TA!!!!!#7TA K[1AI\ PAREL]1H-L[1U]1QO/TWN PAR?ELHLU?Q?O/?[1T]1A E)?[1S-TI ME/XRI EI)S A)/PEIRON. OU) PA/NU DE\ TOU=TO. OU)/T' A)/[1RA K]1A[1THGORH/-MATA OU)/T' [1A)CI]1W/[1MA]1TA/ E)STIN PA-RELH[1LUQO/TA. *EI) E)/]1ST?IN U(/[1PTI]1A KATHGORH/M[1A]1TA, KAI\ U(PTI/WN U(/PT[1IA/]1 E)STIN KATHGORH/MATA ME/XRI EI)S [1A)/]1PEIRON. OU) PA/NU DE\ TOU=TO. OU)D' A)/RA TO\ P?[1RW=TON]1. *E[1I) PLHQUNTIKA/ E)STIN KATHGORH/-MATA, KAI\ PLHQUNTIKW=N PLH-QUNTIKA/ E)STI ME/XRI EI)S A)/PEI- @1RON. OU) PA/NU DE\ TOU=TO. O[1U)D' A)/RA TO\ PRW=]1TON. *)EPI\ GA\R TW=N TOIOU/-TWN!! ME!!!!!AIME!!!T?!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!ABE!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!! KAI\ PRO\S EU!!!!AS1!!!!EM!!!!! PLH!!SE!!!!ON E)/STAI !!!!!!!!!!T]1U?G?XA/NEI !!!!!!!!! E(?T?E/?RA[1N]1 AU) !!!!!!!!!!!!LEG!!!! ME!!!!TOIOUTOIS1!!! D!!!!!IALOGISMO!! EP!!!!!AUT!OUD!! !!!!!!EPITOUDE!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!TEI!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!AN!! !!SQAI!!!!!!!!HMWN! !WN!!!!!!!!!HTWN!! !QHSEIS1!!!!!! KAI\ !!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!H!!!!!!! AIS1!!!!!!!!!!OUN!!!!! #6AN!!!!!!!!!!QH!!!!!!! TH!!!!!!!!!!NHS1!!!!!#7I NOM!!!!!!!!!DEAN!!UTE PTW!!!!!!!!!APO!#7#7#7S AI!!!!!!!! [1F]1ANTAS[1I/]1AI G?I/?-NON[1TAI A)LHQ]1EI=S KAI\ YEU-DEI=S [1KAI\ KA]1TA[1LH]1PTIKAI\ KAI\ A)KAT[1A/LHP]1TOI: KAI\ E)PI\ TH=S DIANOI/AS T[1O\]1 PARAPLH/SION U(-PA/RXEI !!! G]1A\?R E)PI\ PA/NTWN !DIK!!!!!UTWISTE!! [1FAN-T]1ASI/AS AU)TW=N LANBA/NEIN OU)/TE KATALANBA/NEIN DU/NA-#6TAI PA/NTA, YEUDEI=S TE GI/NON-TAI KAT' AU)TH\N FANTASI/AI KAI\ A)KATA/[1LHP]1TOI, OU)QE\N [1H(=T]1TON KAI\ KATA[1LHPTI]1KW=N GINOME/- @1NWN. [1P]1A[1RAPLH/]1SION DE\ TOU/-TWN KAI\ TOU=TO [1S]1UNTE/TEUXEN TO\ PARA!#7#7!!!!! A)/]1LLA G[1EI/-NESQAI A)!!!!!! O(R]1ATA\ KAI\ A)KOUSTA\ [1KAI\ O(M]1OI/WS E)PI\ T[1W=N LOIPW=N A[1I)SQH/SE]1WN. K[1AI\ KATA\ TO\ O(/LON A)!!!!! KAI\ KA[1TA\ TH\N DIA/NO[1IAN !!!ATA !!LEG!!!!!!!! E)PI\ T[1W=N LOIPW=N !!!!!!!MH\ K[1ATA-E!!!WI!!!!!!!!!!!! SE!!!!!!!#7WS KA!!!!!! A!!AN PAR!!!SOT!!!!!! DI[1AFO]1RW=N !!!MEN!!!!!! QE!!!!!!!!!!!K!!!!!! TI!!!!!!!!!!!OU!!!!!! MO?N FAN!!!!!!!XE!!!!!! DADH!S1!!!!!!!XE!!!!!! OU/TOIS. O[1U) MO/]1NON D[1E\ P]1ARA\ T?[1A\S FU/SEIS GI/NONT?AI TO[1IAU=TAI DI]1-AFORAI/, A)LLA\ KAI\ P[1A]1R[1A\]1 TE/X[1N]1AS KAI\ TRIBA\S A)/LLWN PRO\S A)/LLA #6POLLA[1X]1W=S. *)/ETI DE\ TO\ O(/MOION TO[1I=S]1 AI)SQHT[1HRI/OI]1S KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N TEXNW=N SUNTE/TEUXEN. O[1U)/]1TE GA\R OU)QE\N AU)TAI=S E)STIN FWRA-TO\N OU)/T' E[1I)S PA/NTA [1T]1O\N O(M?[1O-GENH= TO/PON DIATEI/NEIN D?[1U/-#6NA[1NTAI]1. *KAI\ TAU=TA P?A/NTA [1DI-ATEI/NEIN U(PONOHTE/ON [1O]1U) MO/-NON EI)S TOU\S FRONI/MOUS A)N-QRW/POUS A)LLA\ KAI\ [1E]1I)S TOU\S NE/-#6OUS. *)EPIST!!!AI!!!!!AIN!! TON E)PI\ TW=N !W!!!!!!P!!! TI/ TO\ GINO/MENO/N E)STIN OU(= DE[1IKNU/]1NTES DU/O LE/GWSIN [1A)/N]1 O(/[1T]1I "1OU)K [1E)STIN]1 OU(=TOS OU(=-TOS"2 !!OT MS1!!!!! DIASA- @1FH=[1SA]1I OU)K A)\N DU/N[1AI]1NT[1O QAR)[1R(]1H/SANT[1ES !!!!!! !! O]1U)DE\ MA!!!!UET!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!BAN!!! TIN!!!STENE!!PAI?DON!!! [1PE]1RI\ T!!!!!!!!!MOS1!!! TW!!!!!!!!!!ADIA!!! !E!!!!!!!!!WAIRA!! AUT!!!!!!!!!O!!!!! DEN!!!!!!!!!H!QAI!! DIE!!!! PR]1O\S TAU=TA TA\ MET!!!!!!IMOUTA!!! NAIS DH\ TO\ R(HS1!!!!!!! TWN O(/TI TAU)TO/N E)ST[1I TO\ "1TOU=-TON [1TOU=TO]1N EI)=NAI"2 [1TW=? "1EI)=NAI TOU=[1TON TOU=TON"2]1 OI(=ON O(/TI T[1AU)TO/N E)STI [1TO\ "1*DI/W]1NA *QE/W[1NA EI)=N]1A?I?"2 TW=| "1*DI/WNA *QE/WNA EI)=NAI"2 [1E)A/NQ']1 OU(/-TWS E)A/NQ' W(RISME/NWS E)KFE/-#6RWMEN. *EI)=[1Q']1 O(/TI A)NTI/KEITAI TW=| "1*DI/WNA *QE/WNA EI)=NAI"2 TO\ "1MH\ EI)=-NAI *DI/WNA *QE/WNA"2 KA)\N W(RIS-ME/NWS E)KFE/RWMEN. *)EPI\ GO[1U=]1N TOU/TWN KAI\ TW=N O(MOI/WN OU) MO/NON TI/ [1TO\ L]1EGO/MENON E)S-TI\N [1X]1ALEPO\N SUNBALEI=N, A)LLA\ KAI\ MH/POTE LANQA/NO-#6MEN TA\? [1Y]1EUDH= LE/GONTES: O(MO-EIDW=S A)\N TOU/TWN DIATEI[1NO/N-TWN KAI\ EI)S TOU\S SOFOU/S: *OU)/[1TE GA\R PIQAN[1O\]1N MHQE\N TOIO?U=?T?O A)POFAI/[1NES]1QAI A)\N, OU)/T' A)\N A)POF[1AI]1NO/M[1E]1NO[1N MH\]1 DIAPO-[1R]1H[1QH=]1NAI. *TA\ PARAPLH/SIA D' E)STI\N E)PILE/GEIN MAT!!! !!#7WN KAI\ E)PAKAW!!!!! !!!O!!WN PARAL[1L]1A[1G]1A\S KAI\ !!!!!Q' O(/TAN KA!!!!!!!! @1 !!!!!!DIALEG!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!KA!A!!!!!!!!! T]1O\ PARABE!!!!!!!!!!!!! @[1&sequuntur etiam 5 versus$8]1 @TOU @TE !!! O]1U)/T' AR!PE!!!!!!MH !!!!!!!!! TOIOU=T[1ON U(]1PA/RXEI !!!!!!!!!!!!QE!!!!!!TE EN!!!!!!!!!!KTA/ [1E)S]1T?IN KAI\ DEIS1!! K]1AI\ TAU=TA !!!OUTO NEI!!!QUN!!!!XE!!!!!! !!!!!!EI)?S PR!!ADE!!!!!! !!!!!!!TUGXA/NEI !!!!!! #6K]1A[1I\]1 TO\ ME\N [1P]1LHQ[1UNTI]1KO\N !! O?X!!!!!!!!L!!!!!!!! OUTO!!!!!!TERO!!ANA LWNS1!!!!! E)]1KFEROM!DHS A)=RA PLHQUNT[1I]1K?O/N [1E)STI]1 DI-A\ TOU/TWN, KAQA/PER KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N PARAPLHSI/WN TOU/TWN [1PA-RE/CEI [1H(MI=N]1 E)PI/STASIN. H)\ KATA\ ME\N TOU\S A[1U)TO]1U\S DEIKN?[1U]1ME/NOU[1S E)/STAI TOI[1OU=T]1O? PLHQU[1NTI]1K?O/N, OI(=?ON "1H(ME/TEROS"2, A)/LLWN DE\ KAI\ A)/LLWN [1DEIK]1N?[1UM]1E/NWN OU)/: H)\ MH/ POTE TO\ Z[1H]1TOU/MENO/N E)STIN TOI-OU=TO: E(NIKOU= GA\R O)/NTOS TOU= "1TOU/-TOUS TU/PTWN"2 E)/STIN T[1I T]1OIOU=TO PL?H?Q?UNT[1IKO\N !!!!!!!!!! !!! TOIOU/TWI !!!!!!!!!! SION "1TOU/TOUS TU/PTWN"2 [1TW=N D']1 A)/L-LWN D[1EIKNU]1ME/N?W?[1N !!!OISTOU !!!!POIK!L!!!!!!!!!!!!! A)\]1N M[1H\]1 KAQ' E(/TERO/N TINA!!!!! XQW=M?[1E]1N LO/GON KAI\ DIA!!!!! !ES1!! P]1LHQUNT[1IKA/]1, EI) KAI\ T[1O\N! TR]1O/P[1O]1N E)PI\ TO\ M!!!EK!!!!! @1 META!!!ARA!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!EKE!!NLEG!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!SION KATA !!!!!!!!!!!!TOSON TOU= !!!!!!!!!!!TWN OU)DE\ TAU=-TA]1 !!!!!!!!!T?AS MEN !!!!!!!!!!!!!TIST!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!N !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!NE!ME Q!!!!!!!!!!!!TA!PANTA TO!!!!! PLHQUN]1TIKO\N O)\N E)KEI=-NO!!!!!!!!!!!!EQ?ANTA T!!!!!!!!NPAI!EN E)PI\ TOU= "1TO[1U/TOUS TU/P]1TWN"2 KAI\ "1TOU=TON TU/[1PT!!!!!EWS1!!!TIKWN GARTINW?[1N P]1ROHGOUME/NWN E)KFERI!!!!ETAI!A!TA\ TOI-AU=TA "1S[1FE/TER]1OS"2 KA[1I\]1 "1H(ME/TEROS"2 KA]1I\ !!!!!! W(]1SAU/TW[1S]1 E)PI\ TW=N O(]1MOI/WN [1KAI\]1 MA/LISTA TOIOU/-TW[1N O]1I(=?ON [1"1E)MOI\]1 U(PA/RXWN"2 KAI\ "1E)M[1OI\]1 U(PA/RXONT[1A]1"2 KAI\ "1H(MI=N U(PA/RXWN"2 !!!ER#7!HS E)STIN E)N!EN!QW!!TO!!AIDRAUMO?I? E!T!A!!!!TOUT!! K]1AI\ W(SAU/-TWS E)PI\ !!!!!!!!!!!! E)A\N E)GW\ !OSA!!!!OU!!!SIAI!!EIS RO!!!TA\ O(/MOIA !!!! O(/TI DEI= !!!!N KAI\ !!!PI]1QANON A)-POL[1A]1B?EI=N KAI\ D?!!!AMIN A)N-QRWP[1!]1S A)N!!TA!!!!!!EME !!!!!OI!!!NOU!!!!!U#7!!! !!!TESQAIS1!!!EDHS ME/ROS @[1&versus inutiles omitto$8]1 @ESI TAU-!!!!!!!!!!!H!D!!!!!!H !!!!!!!!!NA!A KAI\ PO/S[1O]1N !!!!!INON!!!! KAI\ E)K PO/SWN @1 [1GR]1A/FETAI !!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!AME!!!!!!!!!!!!!MAI !!LON!!!!!!!!!KO DIASTA !!!!!!!MEN!N!ECEI DE\ KAI\ !!!!!!!ASIN!!IATINAN?!! !!! M?[1ET]1A\ [1TO\ T]1O?U=TON FRONH=SAI E)FRO/NH?SA"2 KAI\ "1META\ TO\ TOU=TON PERIPATH=SAI E)KA/QI[1S]1A"2. *OU) GA\R#505 !!AUT!!#7A?I? E)/STIN TA\ W([1M]1OIW-ME/NA O[1I(=O]1N "1[1M]1ETA\ [1DE\]1 TOU=TO E)FRO/-#6NHSA H)\ A)NE/STHN"2. *)/ONTWN DE\ KAI\ TOIOU/TWN L?EKTW=N E)/STAI E)PI-ZHTEI=N KATA\ TI/ E)/SONTAI AI( DIA-FORAI\ AU)TW=N. *(/OMOIA D' E)STI\N TA\ PRA/GMATA KAI\ E)PI\ TI!!OI!!NA TO\]1 TOU=TON FRONH=SAI E)FRO/NH-SA"2 "1U(/STERON TOU= TOUTONI\ FRONH=-SAI E)FRO/NHSA"2 UTWN!N AKOLOU-QENTOS KAI\ TO\ TOU=TON FRONH=-!!!!!N!SAIS1!!!!YEUDE/S E)STIN TA\ D' OU)K [1A)KOLOU]1QOU=NTOS TO !!OU!!!!!!TOIOUTOS HMA !!!EMON META\ TOU=TON!!!! !!! KAI\ U(/STERON TOU/TOU !!RO !!!!!!!! Y?E?UDE/S E)STIN TO\ !!!!!!!!TA!!!! TOU=TO FRO N!!OS KAI\ PO!!!!!!A!DE !!!!!!METALH!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!NOM!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!QAI!!!!!!!!!! E!!KA!!!!!DA!!!OTOS1!!! OF!INAI!!!!ERI!!!TEIN!!!! A!!KATA!!!!!!!!!MENO!!AT<6U>6 TWS T!!!!!!!!!!!UDIWN!N !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!TOI=S S[1HMAI-NOMENOIS1!!!!!!!!!!!!!! TOUTO!!!!!!!!!!! KAI\ !!! NO!EI!!!!!TE!!NAIDHN AU- @1TON TOIO[1U=]1T[1O]1 DUNATO\N A)PO[1S]1H-MAIN!N!O!!!!!! K]1AI\ LE/GOU-SIN ME\N TA\ PRA/GMATA [1K]1AI\ SH-MAI/[1NOU]1SIN OU)/TE D[1E\ O)M]1NU/OUSIN OU)/TE PR?OSTA/TTOU[1SIN]1 OU)/T' [1A)R]1W=?N-TAI [1OU)/T' E)]1RWTW=S[1IN OU)/T]1E P?UNQA/-#6NON[1T]1A?I?. [1K]1AI\ E(/WS TI/NOS DEI= TAU=-Q' U(PA[1K]1OU/E[1I]1N PARE/X[1E]1I E)PI/STA-SIN KATA\ TO\N PAR?A\ MIKRO\N LO/GON !OI!!!TON!!!!EI PE-RI\ TH=S A)POKRI/SE[1WS]1 !HSEIN, [1PI-#6QANO\N DE\ M[1HDE\]1 TOU=TO U(PA/[1RXE]1IN. KAI\ O(MOI/W[1S PE]1RI\ TOU\S A)LHQEU/-O]1N!!!!!!!ONOMWS LEGO/N-TWN A!!!OU KAI\ A)LH[1Q]1H KAI\ [1Y]1EU=-DO/S [1E)STIN H(]1 E)FIF[1ORA/]1 KAI\ !!! !!!!!!!!!SINOMO!!!OSIN!!! MENO!!!!!!!OUTI!!!!!!!!! TOS1!!!!!!!!!SIN KAI\ !!!!!! AUT!!!!!! O(/TI !! KAI\ STA!!! #6ANA!!!!!NT!!!W!!!!!!!!! !!! O)]1MNU/EI?N A)LL!!!!!!!!! 챰!!!!!!: S]1UNKA!!!!!!!! O!!!!NTA\ PRA/G[1MATA]1 !!!! TA!!MES1!!AUTO!!!!!!!! OU!!!EC!!!TA!!!!!!!!!! #6E)/STAI !!TA!!ANM!!!!!!!!!!! TA[1U/]1TAIS H)\ TOIAU/TA[1IS]1 E)PI[1FORAI=S KAI!!!!!!ONADI!!!!!!!!! SIN!!!!OMN!!!!!!!!!PERI[1EI-LHMME/NA A)C!!!!!!!!TEIN !!!!MEN TON AU!!!! A)]1PI/?-Q?A[1NON]1 DE\ KAI\ TOU=TO. [1A)LHQ]1EU/EIN [1K]1A[1I\]1 YEU/DESQAI AU)TOU\S OU)? R(HTE/?-ON, OU) TOU=TO U(FORWME/NOU?[1S]1 A)L-LW? TRO/PW, EI) O(? AU)TO\S A(/MA A)-LHQEU/SEI KAI\ YEU/[1S]1ETAI, A)LL' O(/- @1TI TOU= SHMAINOME/NOU TEL?E/-#6WS A)POPLAN[1W=N]1TAI. *K[1AI\]1 TO\N PROHGOU/MENON LO/GON PROS-E]1LE/?G[1XEI]1 KAI\ TO\N [1YEU/SESQAI #6AU)TOU\S A(/MA KAI\ A)[1LH]1QEU/SEIN TUGXA/NEIN D' E)N PA=SIN TOI=S TOIOU/TOIS O(TE\ ME\N A(PLW=S LE-GO/MENA O(TE\ DE\ PLE/ONO/S TI-NOS SUNPARENFAINOME/NOU. LE/?GW D' OU) TO\? ME\N LEGO/MEN[1ON AU)TW=N KATA\ DOCA?[1SM?]1O\N [1H)\? DIA/-NOI[1AN]1, TO\? DE\ KATA\ L[1E/CIN]1 !!NOU TO!!!ALLOI!!!!!!!! OU)/T' EI)S O!!!!!#7HNTATE!!! KAI\ !!! !!!!!!!! A)LL[1A\]1 TA\ O(/MOIA TA\!! ON!OP!!!!!!!EI!!!!!! !!!!!!!!#7T!!N!!!!!!! !!!!!!!#7OMENO!!!!!! !!!!NT!THS DIET!!!!!!! LE/G[1W]1 ME/X[1RI !!!!!!KAT!!!! !EIN LOI!!EN!!!!!!!!!! !!!!OA!!!!!AM!!!!!! !!!! KAI\ !ARON SUN!GE!!! A)/LLWN !EN EI)PA/TW LE/GEIN TOI-AU=TA KA[1TA\ F]1ORA\S H(ME[1TE/]1RAS, E)/S-TIN Q' O(/TE [1TA]1U/TAS [1U(]1PE[1CE]1LO/ME-NOS KAI\ TO\ O(/LON !#7T!PWTI [1ST]1REFO/[1M]1ENOI W(/STE MH\ A)N?-APHRTI?SME/NWS MHD' A)MFI-BO/LOUS TA\S LE/CEIS LE/GEIN, XRH-SI/MOU SFO/DR' O)/NTOS PARASESH-MA/NQAI TO\N TO/PON TOU=TON, O(/PWS A)NA[1ST]1RE/F[1W]1MEN EI)S AU)-TO\N]1 SUNE[1XE/S]1TERON. *)EPI\ DE\ TW=N TOIOU/TWN "1PERIPA/TEI, E)PEI\ H(-ME/RA E)STIN"2 MH/P[1OTE]1 DIXW=S LE/GOMEN, W(/STE KA[1TA\ QA/]1TERON ME\N TW=N LEKTW=N PROSTA/T- @1TEIN TO\ O(/LON TOU=TO, TO\ "1PERIPA-TEI=N, E)PEI\ D' H(ME/RA E)[1STI]1N"2 KA-TA\ [1TO\]1 LO[1I]1PO\?N D' O(\? KAI\ MA=LLON E)NFAI/NETAI KAI\ [1W(=? MA=L]1LON XRW/MEQA, TO\ PERIPA[1TEI=N PROS-TA/TTETAI, TO\ DE\ LO[1IPO\]1N E)/C[1W-QEN E)PI[1GI/N]1ETAI !!!!!!KA-!!MATI!MENO!!!!!!!! !!!PR!!!NUTO!!!!#7NUMEN !!!AP!!!OS1!!!U!!!!RA !!REST!!!!!!!!OP[1E]1RILAN-[1BAN]1OM!!!!!!!!!!ON!! !IS1!!A!!!!!!!!!!!!! !WQEN A!!!!PA!!!!NLA[1NBA-N]1OME/NOU!DO!!!!!!!E! TAI KA[1I\ TOI]1O[1U/]1TWN "1O[1U(=TOS]1 PE-[1RI]1PA/TE[1I, EI) D]1E\ M[1H\]1 KA/Q[1OU"2. *PA/N-TA ME\[1N G]1A\[1R]1 U(P?[1O\]1 TH\N [1P]1RO/S-TACI?N PI/PTEI, KATHGO/RHS[1IN D[1E\ METALLA!IN OU)Q[1AMH=]1 E)/S-TIN. OU)QE\N GA\R E)MFA[1I/NEI]1 TOI-OU=TO PRA=GMA "1OU(=TOS [1PE]1RIPA-T[1E]1I=: EI) DE\ MH\ KA/QHT?AI"2. [1H(M]1I=N G' H( XREI/A TOIAU/TH DIA!!OU !!XOUS LO/GON "1PERIPA/TEI, E)-A\N DE\ TOU=T[1O M]1H\ E)KPOI[1H=| K]1A-QOU"2 KAI\ OI(=ON "1MA/LISTA [1M]1E\N? PE-RIPA/TEI, E)A\N DE\ TOU=TO [1M]1H\ E)K?-POIH=|, KA/QOU"2. *DU/NATAI [1D']1 EI)S TO\ KAI\ E)PI\ [1P]1LE/ON E)KT[1EI/NES-]1QAI KAI\ NH\ *DI/A[N] KATHK!#7!!! T#7!!!THPW TOUTWN!!E! !!!!EN [1"1PERI]1P?A/T?EI, EI) D[1E\ MH\ 챲KAQEU/DE[1I]1"2 KAI\ "1MA/[1LIS]1TA [1POI/]1EI TOU=TO, EI) DE\ [1M]1H\ TOU=?[1TO POI/EI, EI) DE\ MH\ TOU=T[1O"2 KAI\]1 OU(/TWS E[1I)S]1 A)/PEI-R?O?N OUN!!!!!! O]1U(/TWS !!!!!! !!SN!!!!!!AX!!!!!!!!!!! TOU=[1T]1ON P?E[1RIPATEI=N, EI) DE\ MH\, KAQH=SQ[1AI OUD]1EN FA @1 !!!NAI!!!!!!!!!TET!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!ES1!!!!U! KATALH[1PTIK]1W=S !!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!ESTI!!!EIE!!! !!!!!!N!!!AM!!!T!!!!! #6!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! A)]1LL' E)PI\ M!N!!!!!!ATO!TOUONO!! KATAME!IOUTO!!!W!!!!! TIH!!!!INED!!!!!!E PRO[1S-TA/[1TT]1E[1SQ]1AI MH\ P?[1OIEI=]1N. *TO\ DE\ TOIOU=TO D[1I]1XW=S R(HQH/S[1E]1TAI "1H)\ PERIPA/TE?[1I H)\]1 KA/Q]1OU]1"2 W(=N TO\ M[1E/N E)S?T?I TOI[1OU=TON]1 W!!!!AT!! MENWN [1T]1OU/TWNT!ENI!!!! MEN OU) PROSTA/TTESQAI, T[1O\ DE\ TOIOU=TO "1TOU=TO, EI) DE\ MH\ [1TOU=-TO"2. *PO/T[1E]1RON OU)=N TAU=TA LE/[1GW-MEN H)\ R(HTE/ON KA)NTAU=QA EI)=-NA[1I D]1H\ TO\ PRO[1S]1TATTO/MENON, O(\N TRO/PON E)[1S]1TI\ TOIOU=TO A)CI/-WMA "1PERIPATEI= *DI/WN, EI) DE\ MH\ KA/QHTAI"2 KAI\ KATHGO/RH-M]1A PIQ[1A]1NO\N EI)=NAI TOIOU=TO "1PERIPATEI=N, EI) DE\ MH\ KAQH=S-QAI"2, EI) DE\ TOU=TO KAI\ PROSTA/T-TESQ]1AI T[1OI]1OU=TO PIQANO/N [1E)S-TIN]1. *META\ DE\ TAU=TA KAI\ [1E(TE/-RA E)STI\N E)PI/STASIS TO[1I]1AU/-TH, MH/POTE KAI\ OI( OU(/TWS PROS-TA/TTONTES "1O(\ E)/TUXE TOU/TWN LABE/"2 KAI\ "1O(POIONO[1U=N TOU/]1TWN LABE/"2 OU)Q[1E\]1N PROSTA/TTOUSIN. OU)/TE GA\R KATHGO/RHMA/ TI E)/S-TIN EU(REI=N TO\ [1PROST]1ATTO/M?[1E-NON OU)/T' A)/LLO TOIOU=TON OU)-QE/N. *(OMOI/WS DE\ KAI\ A)\N OU(/TWS IPHT!!!!TONT!!!!!ON!!! *D!!!!!!!OUT!ISMEL!N!! !!!!USODOUM!!!!!!!!! @1 !!!!!TW!!!!GEI!! KAI\ !! !!!!ONOS OU)X W(!!!!!OU !!! A)LL' E)/CWQE/N P?W[1S E)PIGI-NO/MEN]1ON !!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! TA, K[1AI\]1 A)/L[1L]1WN !D!!!!!!!! N!WN! OU(/TWS DE\ W!!!!!! E! E)PI/STASI/N PWS LE/GETAI TO[1I=XO/]1S T' E)CALHLEIMME/NOS K[1AI\ K]1EKONIAME/NOS KAI\ KI/WN PEPITTWME/NOS KAI\ Q?U/RA KAI\ A)SPI\S LELEUKWME/NH? KAI\ TOU/-TOIS SU/NEGGUS A)/NQRWPOS A)LH-LEIMME/NOS KAI\ H)SBOLWME/NOS KAI\ PA/LIN I(MA/TION [1E)R)]1R(UP?AS-ME/NON KAI\ [1R(U]1PARO\N KAI\ A)/N-Q[1RWPOS]1 R(UPARO/S. *DEI= DE\ DI-ANE/XEIN KATA\ TO\N TO/PON TOU=-T[1ON!! A)/]1NWQEN E)C!!!!TON KA[1I\ S1!!!!!TINW=N ME\N PERI !!!ON SUNKATAT[1A/T]1TESQAI !!! AU)TO\N LOG!!!!WSME-!!!!!! U(POTE!!!!TINW=N !! A)/LLA[1S PA]1RALL[1AGA\S !!! !!!!!!!!! O(/SA G!!! KAI\ !!!!!!!! E)PI\ POLLW=N KAI\ !!!! A)CIW/]1MATA KAI\ KATH?-GORH/MATA !!!!!!!!!! @[1&quinque versus inutiles omitto$8]1 LIN KATAMA!!ME!DEON! OUG!AR!!!!!NEUW!KAR SON KA[1THGORH]1MA/TWN !!! PANDEIS TA\ POLLA\ ME\N A)-PODE/XETAI/ PWS, TA\ DE\ KAI\ E!E!!!PW! DIX[1W=]1S L[1EGO/]1MEN[1A !!!! KAI\ TOIAU=TA/ TINA !!!!! !! PERI\]1 D' E)K[1EI/]1NWN A)RKEI= TA\ EI)RHME/NA. @1 @&10Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 134.$10 DIAFE/REIN DE/ FASIN <20A)RXA\S>20 KAI\ <20STOI-XEI=A>20: TA\S ME\N GA\R EI)=NAI A)GENH/TOUS [2KAI\]2 A)FQA/RTOUS, TA\ DE\ STOIXEI=A KATA\ TH\N E)KPU/RWSIN FQEI/RESQAI. A)LLA\ KAI\ A)SWMA/TOUS EI)=NAI TA\S A)RXA\S KAI\ A)MO/R-FOUS, TA\ DE\ MEMORFW=SQAI.&10 Cf. n. 408. @&Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 139.$ DOKEI= D' AU)TOI=S A)RXA\S EI)=NAI TW=N O(/LWN DU/O, TO\ POIOU=N KAI\ TO\ PA/SXON. TO\ ME\N OU)=N PA/SXON EI)=NAI TH\N A)/POION OU)SI/AN, TH\N U(/LHN: TO\ DE\ POIOU=N TO\N E)N AU)TH=| LO/GON, TO\N QEO/N. TOU=TON GA\R A)I/+DION O)/NTA DIA\ PA/SHS AU)TH=S DHMIOURGEI=N E(/KASTA. TI/QHSI DE\ TO\ DO/GMA TOU=TO *ZH/NWN ME\N O( *KITIEU\S E)N TW=| PERI\ OU)SI/AS, *KLEA/NQHS DE\ E)N TW=| PERI\ TW=N A)TO/MWN, <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 DE\ E)N <20TH=| PRW/TH| TW=N FU-SIKW=N>20 PRO\S TW=| TE/LEI__ @&10Sextus adv. math. IX 11.$10 OU) MH\N A)LLA\ KAI\ <20OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 DU/O LE/GONTES A)RXA/S, QEO\N KAI\ A)/POION U(/LHN, TO\N ME\N QEO\N POIEI=N U(PEILH/FASI, TH\N DE\ U(/LHN PA/SXEIN TE KAI\ TRE/PESQAI. @&10Philo de mundi opificio %14 8 Vol. I p. 2, 18 Wendl.$10 E)/GNW DH\ O(/TI A)NAGKAIO/TATO/N E)STIN, E)N TOI=S OU)=SI TO\ ME\N EI)=NAI DRASTH/RION AI)/TION, TO\ DE\ PAQHTO/N, KAI\ O(/TI TO\ ME\N DRASTH/RION O( TW=N O(/LWN NOU=S E)STIN EI(LIKRINE/STATOS KAI\ A)KRAIFNE/STATOS__TO\ DE\ PAQHTO\N A)/YUXON KAI\ A)KI/NHTON E)C E(AUTOU=, KINHQE\N DE\ KAI\ SXHMATISQE\N KAI\ YUXWQE\N U(PO\ TOU= NOU= METE/BALEN EI)S TO\ TE-LEIO/TATON E)/RGON, TO/NDE TO\N KO/SMON. @&10Seneca ep. 65, 2. dicunt, ut scis, <21Stoici>21 nostri%10 <21duo esse in &10rerum natura>21, ex quibus omnia fiant, <21causam et materiam>21, materia &10iacet iners, res ad omnia parata, cessatura, si nemo moveat, causa autem, &10id est ratio, materiam format et quocumque vult versat, ex illa varia &10opera producit. Esse ergo debet, unde fiat aliquid, deinde a quo fiat; &10hoc causa est, illud materia. &10@Origenes de principiis [1interpr. Rufino]1 II cp. 1 p. 78. ed. De-&10larue contra eos disputat, qui dum deum mundi opificem et providentem &10autumant, materiam$10 [1TH\N A)/POION U(/LHN&10]1 ingenitam esse affirment. &10@Theodoretus graec. affect. cur. 58, 10.$10 *KAI\ TH\N U(/LHN DE\__ @1 KAI\ O( TW=N *STWI+KW=N O(RMAQO\S TREPTH\N KAI\ A)LLOIWTH\N KAI\ R(EUSTH\N E)/FASAN EI)=NAI. &10ibid. 19.$10 *)ARISTOTE/LHS DE\ AU)TH\N SWMATIKH\N KE/KLHKEN, OI( *STWI+KOI\ DE\ SW=MA. @&10Alexander Aphrod. in Aristotelis Metaphys. p. 133, 33 Bon. 178, &10`15 Hayd.$10 A)LL' EI) KAI\ E)/STI TI KAQ' AU(TO\ AI)/TION PARA\ TH\N U(/LHN, KAI\ A)/LLO TI/ FHSI DEI=N E)PISKE/YASQAI, PO/TERON TOU=TO/ E)STI KEXWRISME/NON U(/LHS KAI\ AU)TO\ KAQ' AU(TO\ U(FESTW\S H)\ E)N TH=| U(/LH|, O(POI=O/N E)STI TO\ E)/NULON EI)=DOS KAI\ W(S <20TOI=S A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 E)/DOCEN O( QEO\S KAI\ TO\ POIHTIKO\N AI)/TION E)N TH=| U(/LH| EI)=NAI. @&10Proclus in Plat. Timaeum p. 81 E Schn.$10 A)POROU=SI DE/ TINES, O(/PWS O( *PLA/TWN E)/LABEN W(S W(MOLOGHME/NON TO\ DHMIOURGO\N EI)=NAI TOU= PANTO\S EI)S PARA/DEIGMA BLE/PONTA: MH\ GA\R EI)=NAI DHMIOURGO\N EI)S TO\ KATA\ TAU)TA\ E)/XON O(RW=NTA. POLLOI\ GA\R KAI\ TOU/TOU PROESTA=SI TOU= LO/GOU TW=N PALAIW=N, OI( ME\N *)EPIKOU/REIOI KAI\ PA/NTH TOU= PANTO\S AI)/TION OU)K EI)=NAI FA/SKONTES, OI( DE\ <20A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 EI)=NAI ME/N, <20A)XW/RISTON DE\ U(FESTA/NAI TH=S U(/LHS>20.&10 Cf. p. 299 C.$10 PERI\ DE\ A(PA/NTWN TW=N KATEUQUNO/NTWN TH\N GE/NESIN QEW=N LE/GWMEN, W(S OU)/TE <20TH\N OU)SI/AN E)/XOUSI TH=| U(/LH| SUMMEMIGME/NHN>20, KAQA/PER FASI\N OI( <20A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 &10etc. &10@Syrianus in Aristot. Metaphys. [1Aristot. Acad. V. 841&14a$10]1. A)/LLWN DE\ KAI\ POIHTIKH\N ME\N AI)TI/AN A)POLEIPO/NTWN, A)XW/RISTON DE\ TAU/THN TH=S U(/LHS, KAQA/PER OI( <20*STWI+KOI\>20 ME\N U(/STERON, A)/LLOI DE/ TINES PRO\ AU)TOU= [1&10sc. Aristotele &10@Sextus adv. math. X 312.$10 E)C A)POI/OU ME\N OU)=N KAI\ E(NO\S SW/MATOS TH\N TW=N O(/LWN U(PESTH/SANTO GE/NESIN OI( <20*STWI+KOI/>20: A)RXH\ GA\R TW=N O)/NTWN KAT' AU)TOU/S E)STIN H( A)/POIOS U(/LH KAI\ DI' O(/LWN TREPTH/, METABALLOU/SHS TE TAU/THS GI/GNETAI TA\ TE/SSARA STOIXEI=A, PU=R KAI\ A)H/R, U(/DWR KAI\ GH=. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de mixtione p. 224, 32 Bruns.$10 AI)TIA/SAITO D' A)/N TIS EU)LO/GWS AU)TW=N, E)NTAU=QA TOU= LO/GOU GENO/MENOS, KAI\ TO\ DU/O A)RXA\S TW=N PA/NTWN LE/GONTAS EI)=NAI, U(/LHN TE KAI\ QEO/N, W(=N TO\N ME\N POIOU=NTA EI)=NAI, TH\N DE\ PA/SXOUSAN, <20MEMI=XQAI TH=| U(/LH| LE/GEIN TO\N QEO/N, DIA\ PA/SHS AU)TH=S DIH/KONTA KAI\ SXHMATI/ZONTA KAI\ MORFOU=NTA KAI\ KOSMOPOIOU=NTA TOU/TW| TW=| TRO/PW|>20: EI) GA\R QEO\S KAT' AU)TOU\S SW=MA, PNEU=MA W)\N NOERO/N TE KAI\ A)I/+DION, KAI\ H( U(/LH DE\ SW=MA, PRW=TON ME\N E)/STAI PA/LIN DIH=KON SW=MA DIA\ SW/MATOS, E)/PEITA TO\ PNEU=MA TOU=TO H)/TOI TI TW=N TESSA/RWN TW=N A(PLW=N E)/STAI SWMA/TWN, A(\ KAI\ STOIXEI=A/ FASIN, H)\ E)K TOU/TWN SU/GKRIMA, W(/S POU KAI\ AU)TOI\ LE/GOUSIN [1KAI\ GA\R <20A)E/ROS KAI\ PURO\S U(FI/STANTAI TH\N OU)SI/AN E)/XEIN TO\ PNEU=MA>20]1 H)\ [2EI)]2 A)/LLO TI EI)/H, E)/STAI TO\ QEI=ON AU)TOI=S SW=MA PE/MPTH TIS OU)SI/A, XWRI\S A)PODEI/CEW/S TINOS KAI\ PARAMUQI/AS LEGOME/NH TOI=S PRO\S TO\N META\ TW=N OI)KEI/WN [2A)PODEI/CEWN]2 TIQE/MENON TOU=TO A)NTILE/GOUSIN W(S LE/GONTA PARA/DOCA. @&10Sextus adv. math. IX 75.$10 H( TOI/NUN TW=N O)/NTWN OU)SI/A, FASIN, A)KI/NHTOS OU)=SA E)C AU(TH=S KAI\ A)SXHMA/TISTOS, U(PO/ TINOS AI)TI/AS O)FEI/LEI KINEI=-SQAI/ TE KAI\ SXHMATI/ZESQAI: KAI\ DIA\ TOU=TO, W(S XALKOU/RGHMA PERIKALLE\S QEA-SA/MENOI POQOU=MEN MAQEI=N TO\N TEXNI/THN A(/TE KAQ' AU(TH\N TH=S U(/LHS A)KINH/TOU KAQESTW/SHS, OU(/TW KAI\ TH\N TW=N O(/LWN U(/LHN QEWROU=NTES KINOUME/NHN KAI\ E)N MORFH=| TE KAI\ DIAKOSMH/SEI TUGXA/NOUSAN, EU)LO/GWS A)\N SKEPTOI/MEQA TO\ KINOU=N @1 AU)TH\N KAI\ POLUEIDW=S MORFOU=N AI)/TION. TOU=TO DE\ OU)K A)/LLO TI PIQANO/N E)STIN EI)=NAI H)\ DU/NAMI/N TINA DI' AU)TH=S PEFOITHKUI=AN, KAQA/PER [2E)N]2 H(MI=N YUXH\ PE-FOI/THKEN. @AU(/TH OU)=N H( DU/NAMIS H)/TOI AU)TOKI/NHTO/S E)STIN H)\ U(PO\ A)/LLHS KINEI=TAI DUNA/-MEWS: KAI\ EI) ME\N U(F' E(TE/RAS KINEI=TAI, TH\N E(TE/RAN %2%2%2%2 A)DU/NATON EI)=NAI KI-NEI=SQAI MH\ U(P' A)/LLHS KINOUME/NHN, O(/PER A)/TOPON: E)/STI TIS A)/RA KAQ' E(AUTH\N AU)TOKI/NHTOS DU/NAMIS, H(/TIS A)\N EI)/H QEI/A KAI\ A)I/+DIOS. @H)\ GA\R E)C AI)W=NOS KINH/SETAI H)\ A)PO/ TINOS XRO/NOU: A)LL' A)PO/ TINOS XRO/NOU ME\N OU) KINH/SETAI: OU) GA\R E)/STAI TIS AI)TI/A TOU= A)PO/ TINOS AU)TH\N XRO/NOU KI-NEI=SQAI. A)I/+DIOS TOI/NUN E)STI\N H( KINOU=SA TH\N U(/LHN DU/NAMIS KAI\ TETAGME/NWS AU)TH\N EI)S GENE/SEIS KAI\ METABOLA\S A)/GOUSA: W(/STE QEO\S A)\N EI)/H AU(/TH. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. Phys. p. 25, 15.$10 KAI\ TW=N PEPERASME/NAS [1&10scil.$10 LEGO/NTWN A)RXA/S]1 OI( ME\N DU/O W(S *PARMENI/DHS__H)\ W(S <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 QEO\N KAI\ U(/LHN, OU)X W(S STOIXEI=ON DHLONO/TI TO\N QEO\N LE/GONTES, A)LL' W(S TO\ ME\N POIOU=N, TO\ DE\ PA/SXON. @&10Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 48 p. 1085b.$10 KAI\ MH\N OU(=TOI TO\N QEO\N A)RXH\N O)/NTA SW=MA NOERO\N KAI\ NOU=N E)N U(/LH| POIOU=NTES, OU) KAQARO\N OU)D' A(PLOU=N OU)D' A)SU/NQETON A)LL' E)C E(TE/ROU KAI\ DI' E(TE/ROU A)POFAI/NOUSIN: H( D' U(/LH KAQ' AU(TH\N A)/LOGOS OU)=SA KAI\ A)/POIOS TO\ A(PLOU=N E)/XEI KAI\ TO\ A)RXOEIDE/S. O( QEO\S DE/, EI)/PER OU)K E)/STIN A)SW/MATOS OU)D' A)/U+LOS, W(S A)RXH=S METE/SXHKE TH=S U(/LHS: EI) ME\N GA\R E(\N KAI\ TAU)TO\N H( U(/LH KAI\ O( LO/GOS, OU)K EU)= TH\N U(/LHN A)/LO-GON A)PODEDW/KASIN: EI) D' E(/TERA, [KAI\] A)MFOTE/RWN TAMI/AS A)/N TIS O( QEO\S EI)/H KAI\ OU)X A(PLOU=N A)LLA\ SU/NQETON PRA=GMA, TW=| NOERW=| TO\ SWMATIKO\N E)K TH=S U(/LHS PROSEILHFW/S. @&10Plotinus Ennead. VI lib. I 27 [1Vol. II p. 258 Mue.$10]1. E)XRH=N DE\ KAI\ A)/LLWS, THROU=NTAS TH\N A)RXH\N TW=N PA/NTWN E)N TW=| TIMI/W|, MH\ TO\ A)/MORFON MHDE\ TO\ PAQHTO\N MHDE\ TO\ ZWH=S A)/MOIRON KAI\ A)NO/HTON KAI\ SKOTEINO\N KAI\ TO\ A)O/RISTON TI/QESQAI A)RXH\N <20KAI\ TOU/TW| A)NAFE/REIN KAI\ TH\N OU)SI/AN>20. O( GA\R QEO\S AU)TOI=S EU)PREPEI/AS E(/NEKEN E)PEISA/GETAI, PARA/ TE TH=S U(/LHS E)/XWN TO\ EI)=NAI KAI\ SU/NQETOS KAI\ U(/STEROS, MA=LLON DE\ U(/LH PW\S E)/XOUSA: E)/PEITA EI) U(POKEI/MENON, A)NA/GKH A)/LLO EI)=NAI, O(\ POIOU=N EI)S AU)TH/N, E)/CW O)\N AU)TH=S, PARE/XEI AU)TH\N U(PO-KEI=SQAI TOI=S PAR' AU)TOU= PEMPOME/NOIS EI)S AU)TH/N: EI) D' E)N TH=| U(/LH| KAI\ AU)TO\S EI)/H U(POKEI/MENOS KAI\ AU)TO\S SU\N AU)TH=| GENO/MENOS, OU)KE/TI U(POKEI/MENON TH\N U(/LHN PARE/CETAI, OU)DE\ META\ TH=S U(/LHS AU)TO\S U(POKEI/MENON: TI/NI GA\R U(POKEI/MENA E)/STAI, OU)KE/TI O)/NTOS TOU= PARE/CONTOS U(POKEI/MENA AU)TA/, A(PA/NTWN KATANALWQE/NTWN EI)S TO\ LEGO/MENON U(POKEI/MENON; PRO/S TI GA\R TO\ U(POKEI/MENON, OU) PRO\S TO\ E)N AU)TW=|, A)LLA\ PRO\S TO\ POIOU=N EI)S AU)TO\ KEI/MENON. KAI\ TO\ U(POKEI/MENON U(PO/KEITAI PRO\S TO\ OU)X U(POKEI/MENON. EI) [2DE\]2 TOU=TO, PRO\S TO\ E)/CW, W(/STE PARALELEIMME/NON A)\N EI)/H TOU=TO: <20EI) DE\ OU)DE\N DE/ONTAI A)/LLOU E)/CWQEN, AU)TO\ DE\ PA/NTA DU/NA-TAI GI/GNESQAI SXHMATIZO/MENON, W(/SPER O( TH=| O)RXH/SEI PA/NTA AU(TO\N POIW=N>20, OU)KE/T' A)\N U(POKEI/MENON EI)/H, A)LL' AU)TO\ TA\ PA/NTA. __&10p. 259, 14 $10SUMBAI/NEI AU)TOI=S, <20AI)TIWME/NOIS TOU\S E)K MH\ OU)SIW=N OU)SI/AS POIOU=NTAS>20, AU)TOU\S POIEI=N E)C OU)SI/AS MH\ OU)SI/AN. O( GA\R KO/SMOS KAQ' O(/SON KO/SMOS OU)K OU)SI/A. __PW=S DE\ H( U(/LH O(TE\ ME\N SW/MATA GI/GNETAI, A)/LLO DE\ AU)TH=S YUXH/; @&10Plotinus Ennead. VI. lib. I 26.$10 O(/LWS DE\ TO\ PROTA/TTEIN A(PA/NTWN TH\N U(/LHN, O(\ DUNA/MEI E)STI/N, A)LLA\ MH\ E)NE/RGEIAN PRO\ DUNA/MEWS TA/TTEIN PAN- @1TA/PASIN A)TOPW/TATON__A)LLA\ DEI= H)\ PRO\ AU)TOU= EI)=NAI TO\ E)NERGEI/A|, KAI\ OU)KE/TI TOU=TO A)RXH\ H)/, EI) A(/MA LE/GOIEN, E)N TU/XAIS QH/SONTAI TA\S A)RXA/S: E)/PEITA EI) A(/MA, DIA\ TI/ OU)K E)KEI=NO PROTA/TTOUSI; KAI\ DIA\ TI/ TOU=TO MA=LLON O)/N, H( U(/LH, A)LL' OU)K E)KEI=NO; EI) DE\ U(/STERON E)KEI=NO, PW=S; OU) GA\R DH\ H( U(/LH TO\ EI)=DOS GENNA=|, H( A)/POIOS TO\ POIO/N, OU)D' E)K TOU= DUNA/MEI E)NE/RGEIA: E)NUPH=RXE GA\R A)\N TO\ E)NERGEI/A| KAI\ OU)X A(PLOU=N E)/TI. KAI\ O( QEO\S DEU/TEROS AU)TOI=S TH=S U(/LHS: KAI\ GA\R SW=MA E)C U(/LHS O)\N KAI\ EI)/DOUS. KAI\ PO/QEN AU)TW=| TO\ EI)=DOS; EI) DE\ KAI\ A)/NEU TOU= U(/LHN E)/XEIN [2E)/STIN]2, A)RXOEIDH\S W)\N KAI\ LO/GOS, A)SW/MATOS A)\N EI)/H O( QEO\S KAI\ TO\ POIH-TIKO\N A)SW/MATON. EI) DE\ KAI\ A)/NEU TH=S U(/LHS E)STI\ TH\N OU)SI/AN SU/NQETOS, A(/TE SW=MA W)/N, A)/LLHN U(/LHN TH\N TOU= QEOU= EI)SA/COUSIN. E)/PEITA PW=S A)RXH\ H( U(/LH, SW=MA OU)=SA; OU) GA\R E)/STI SW=MA MH\ OU) POLLA\ EI)=NAI: KAI\ PA=N SW=MA E)C U(/LHS KAI\ POIO/THTOS. EI) DE\ A)/LLWS TOU=TO [TO\] SW=MA, O(MWNU/MWS LE/GOUSI SW=MA TH\N U(/LHN. EI) DE\ KOINO\N E)PI\ SW/MATOS TO\ TRIXH=| DIASTATO/N, MAQHMATIKO\N LE/GOUSIN. EI) DE\ META\ A)NTITUPI/AS TO\ TRIXH=|, OU)X E(\N LE/GOUSIN. __E)/PEITA PO/QEN H( E(/NWSIS; OU) GA\R DH\ AU)TO\ E(/N, A)LLA\ METOXH=| E(NO/THTOS. @&Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 150.$ OU)SI/AN DE/ FASI TW=N O)/NTWN A(PA/N-TWN TH\N PRW/THN U(/LHN, W(S KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS E)N TH=| PRW/TH| TW=N FU-SIKW=N>20 KAI\ *ZH/NWN. U(/LH DE/ E)STIN E)C H(=S O(TIDHPOTOU=N GI/NETAI. KALEI=TAI DE\ DIXW=S OU)SI/A TE KAI\ U(/LH, H(/ TE TW=N PA/NTWN KAI\ H( TW=N E)PI\ ME/ROUS. H( ME\N OU)=N TW=N O(/LWN OU)/TE PLEI/WN OU)/TE E)LA/TTWN GI/NETAI, H( DE\ TW=N E)PI\ ME/ROUS KAI\ PLEI/WN KAI\ E)LA/TTWN. @&Chalcidius in Tim. c. 290.&3 Plerique tamen silvam separant ab &3essentia, ut Zeno et <21Chrysippus>21. @&Stobaeus Eclog. I p. 133, 6 W. [1Arii Did. frg. Phys. 20 Diels$]1. <20*XRUSI/PPOU *STWI+KOU=>20. *TOI=S KATA\ POIO/THTA U(FISTAME/NHN PRW/THN U(/LHN: TAU/THN DE\ A)I/+DION, OU)/TE AU)/CHSIN OU)/TE MEI/WSIN U(POME/NOUSAN, DIAI/RESIN DE\ KAI\ SU/GXUSIN E)PIDEXOME/NHN KATA\ ME/RH, W(/STE FQORA\S GI/GNESQAI [E)K] TW=N MERW=N EI)/S TINA OU) KATA\ DIAI/RESIN [2MO/NON]2, A)LLA\ KAT' A)NALOGI/AN TH=| SUGXU/SEI TINW=N GIGNOME/NWN E)/K TINWN. @&10Origenes de oratione Vol. II p. 368, 1 Koe. [1p. 246. ed. Delarue$10]1. *TOI=S DE\ E)PAKOLOUQHTIKH\N AU)TH\N EI)=NAI NOMI/ZOUSI [1&10scil.$10 TH\N TW=N A)SWMA/TWN OU)SI/AN]1 PROHGOUME/NHN DE\ TH\N TW=N SWMA/TWN O(/ROI AU)TH=S OU(=TOI/ EI)SIN: <20OU)SI/A E)STI\N H( PRW/TH TW=N O)/NTWN U(/LH KAI\ E)C H(=S TA\ O)/NTA: H( TW=N SWMA/TWN U(/LH KAI\ E)C H(=S TA\ SW/MATA: H( TW=N O)NOMAZOME/NWN KAI\ E)C H(=S TA\ O)NO-MAZO/MENA: H)\ TO\ PRW=TON U(PO/STATON A)/POION: H)\ TO\ PROU+FISTA/MENON TOI=S OU)=SIN: H)\ TO\ PA/SAS DEXO/MENON TA\S METABOLA/S TE KAI\ A)LLOIW/SEIS, AU)TO\ DE\ A)NALLOI/WTON KATA\ TO\N I)/DION LO/GON: H)\ TO\ U(POME/NON PA=SAN A)LLOI/WSIN KAI\ METABOLH/N>20. KATA\ TOU/TOUS DE\ H( OU)SI/A E)STI\N A)/POIO/S TE KAI\ A)SXHMA/TISTOS KATA\ TO\N I)/DION LO/GON, A)LL' OU)DE\ ME/GEQOS A)POTETAGME/NON E)/XOUSA, PA/SH| DE\ E)/KKEITAI POIO/THTI KAQA/PER E(/TOIMO/N TI XWRI/ON: POIO/THTAS DE\ DIATAK- @1TIKW=S LE/GOUSI TA\S E)NERGEI/AS KAI\ TA\S POIH/SEIS KOINW=S, E)N AI(=S EI)=NAI TA\S KINH/-SEIS KAI\ TA\S SXE/SEIS SUMBE/BHKEN. *OU)DE\ TINO\S GA\R TOU/TWN KATA\ TO\N I)/DION LO/GON METE/XEIN FASI\ TH\N OU)SI/AN, A)EI\ DE\ TINO\S AU)TW=N A)XW/RISTON EI)=NAI, PAQH-TH\N DE\ OU)DE\N H(=TTON KAI\ E)PIDEKTH\N PASW=N TW=N TOU= POIOU=NTOS E)NERGEIW=N W(S A)\N E)KEI=NO POIH=| KAI\ METABA/LLH|: O( GA\R SUNW\N AU)TH=| TO/NOS KAI\ DI' O(/LWN KE-XWRHKW\S PA/SHS TE POIO/THTOS KAI\ TW=N PERI\ AU)TH\N AI)/TIOS H)=N OI)KONOMIW=N. *DI' O(/LWN TE METABLHTH\N KAI\ DI' O(/LWN DIAIRETH\N LE/GOUSIN EI)=NAI KAI\ PA=SAN OU)SI/AN PA/SH| SUGXEI=SQAI DU/NASQAI, H(NWME/NHN ME/NTOI. @&10Plotinus Ennead. VI lib. I 28 [1Vol. II p. 259, 33 Mu+.$10]1. AI)/TION DE\ H( AI)/SQHSIS AU)TOI=S H(GEMW\N GENOME/NH KAI\ PISTH\ EI)S A)RXW=N KAI\ TW=N A)/LLWN QE/SIN. TA\ GA\R SW/MATA NOMI/SANTES EI)=NAI TA\ O)/NTA, EI)=TA AU)TW=N TH\N METABOLH\N EI)S A)/LLHLA FOBHQE/NTES, TO\ ME/NON U(P' AU)TA/, TOU=TO W)|H/QHSAN TO\ O)\N EI)=NAI, W(/SPER A)\N EI)/ TIS MA=LLON TO\N TO/PON H)\ TA\ SW/MATA NOMI/SEIEN EI)=NAI TO\ O)/N, O(/TI OU) FQEI/RETAI O( TO/POS NOMI/SAS. __&10p. 260, 14$10 PA/NTWN TE QAUMASTO/TATON TO\ TH=| AI)SQH/SEI PISTOUME/NOUS E(/KASTA, TO\ MH\ TH=| AI)SQH/SEI A(LWTO\N TI/QESQAI O)/N. <20OU)DE\ GA\R O)RQW=S TO\ A)NTITUPE\S AU)TH=| DIDO/ASI>20: POIO/THS GA\R TOU=TO. @&10Plotinus Ennead. II lib. IV, 1 [1Vol. I p. 104 Mu+.$10]1. KAI\ OI( ME\N SW/MATA MO/NON TA\ O)/NTA EI)=NAI QE/MENOI KAI\ TH\N OU)SI/AN E)N TOU/TOIS, MI/AN TE TH\N U(/LHN LE/GOUSI KAI\ TOI=S STOIXEI/OIS U(POBEBLH=SQAI, KAI\ AU)TH\N EI)=NAI TH\N OU)-SI/AN: TA\ D' A)/LLA PA/NTA OI(=ON PA/QH TAU/THS, KAI\ PW\S E)/XOUSAN AU)TH\N KAI\ TA\ STOIXEI=A EI)=NAI. KAI\ DH\ KAI\ TOLMW=SI KAI\ ME/XRI QEW=N AU)TH\N A)/GEIN: KAI\ <20TE/-LOS DH\ KAI\ AU)TO\N [AU)TW=N] TO\N QEO\N U(/LHN TAU/THN PW\S E)/XOUSAN EI)=NAI>20. DIDO/ASI DE\ KAI\ SW=MA AU)TH=|, <20A)/POION AU)TO\ SW=MA LE/GONTES>20: KAI\ ME/GEQOS DE/. @&10Chalcidius ad Timaeum cp. 280. Qui tamen providentiae opus &10silvae quoque constitutionem esse pronuntiaverunt, censent eam una qua-&10dam ab exordio usque ad finem continuatione porrectam, nec tamen om-&10nes eodem modo. aliter enim Pythagoras et item aliter Plato diversoque &10Aristoteles modo et cum aliquanta differentia <21Stoici>21. Sed hi quidem om-&10nes informem eam et sine ulla qualitate constituunt. &10@Galenus methodi med. II 7. Vol. X p. 155 K.$10 TH\N GA\R MIKRO-LOGI/AN TW=N O)NOMA/TWN, H(\N E)KOMYEU/SANTO/ TINES TW=N FILOSO/FWN_PARAITOU=-MAI LE/GEIN TA\ NU=N. __LE/GW DE\ MIKROLOGI/AN, E)N H(=| <20DIAIROU=NTAI KATA\ GE/NH TO/ TE O)\N KAI\ TO\ U(FESTO/S>20. @&10Galenus de qualitatibus incorporeis 5. Vol. XIX p. 476 K.$10 PRO\S [2D']2 OI(=S E)/FHN A)TO/POIS OU)D' H(NWME/NHN E)/TI XRH\ LE/GEIN U(PA/RXEIN TH\N OU)SI/AN. ___H(/N TE LE/GOUSIN OI( <20*STWI+KOI\>20 PRW/THN U(/LHN KAI\ PRW/THN OU)SI/AN, E)C H(=S FASI TO/N TE KO/SMON KAI\ TW=N E)N AU)TW=| PRAGMA/TWN E(/KASTON PEPOIHKE/NAI TO\N *DI/A, EI) KAQA/PER AI( POIO/THTES SW=MA H)=N, PW=S OU)K H)=N KAI\ AU)TH\ POIO/THS H)\ EI)=XE/ GE POIO/THTA; EI)/ TE TA\S A)/LLAS POIO/THTAS OU)K EI)=XE, A)LLA\ DH\ PA/NTWS U(PH=RXE BA/ROS, O(/PER FASI\N EI)=NAI SW/MATOS [2I)/DION]2, PW=S A(PLH=N E)/TI FASI\ TH\N PRW/THN OU)SI/AN, A)LL' OU)XI\ SU/GKRIMA; EI) DE\ PEPERASME/NHN EI)=NAI/ FASI KAI\ PE/-RASI KEXRHME/NHN, KAI\ SXH=MA DH=LON W(S E)KE/KTHTO, A)/TOPON GA/R E)STIN I)DI/OIS @1 PERAINO/MENON SW=MA PE/RASI MH\ META\ SXH/MATOS PA/NTWS U(PA/RXEIN, EI) KAI\ MH\ SUNNOOI=TO TOU=T' AU)TW=| KAQ' U(PO/QESIN: W(/STE EI) PERI\ U(/LHN H)=N TAU=Q' A(/PER E)/FHN PA/NTA, TAU=TA D' E)STI/, KAQA/PER AU)TOI/ FASI, SW/MATA, OU)/TE A)/POIOS H)=N DHLADH\ OU)/TE A(PLH=. __TAU/TH| DE\ OU)DE\N A)MIGE\S H)=N KAT' AU)TOU/S. @&10Galenus de qualitatibus incorporeis 6. Vol. XIX p. 478 K.$10 O( ME\N OU)=N I)ATRO\S SUNTIQEI\S E)K POLLW=N FARMA/KWN E(/TERON FA/RMAKON, I)DI/AN POIO/-THTA PA/NTWN E)XO/NTWN, POIO\N E(/TERON E)K TH=S MI/CEWS POIEI=, TO\N *DI/A D' OU)/ FASI MI=CAI TH=| PRW/TH| OU)SI/A| KAI\ SXHMATO/THTA, OU)DE\ MHKO/THTA OU)DE\ TW=N A)/LLWN TI SUMBEBHKO/TWN. EI) DE\ MI/GNUSIN, O)/NTA KAI\ AU)TA\ DH=LON W(S A)I/+DIA, TAU=TA/ [E)STIN], PW=S E)/TI LE/GOUSI MO/NHN TH\N PRW/THN U(/LHN A)I/+DION TH\N A)/POION, OU)XI\ DE\ KAI\ TA\S A)/LLAS POIO/THTAS KAI\ PA/NTA TA\ SUMBAI/NONTA. OU)DE\ GA\R POIHTH\N EI)=NAI/ FASI, KAQA/PER TINA\ XEIROTE/XNHN, TO\N *DI/A, A)LL' O(/LON DI' O(/LHS TH=S U(/LHS DIELHLUQO/TA PA/NTWN DHMIOURGO\N GEGONE/NAI. TH/N TE PHLIKO/THTA TOU= QEI/OU PURO\S KAI\ TA\ E)PI\ ME/ROUS TH=| PHLIKO/THTI SUMBEBHKO/TA, TO/ TE MH=KOS KAI\ PLA/-TOS KAI\ BA/QOS, KAI\ PRO\S TOU/TOIS TO\ LOGIKO\N AU)TOU= KAI\ TH\N MAKARIO/THTA, EI) ME\N OU)SI/AS EI)=NAI FH/SOUSI KAI\ SWMATIKA\S AU)TA\S E)ROU=SIN, E)K SWMA/TWN DH=LON W(S H)=N O( *ZEU\S SUNESTHKW\S KAI\ OU)X A(PLOU=N H)=N, A)LLA\ KAI\ SU/GKRIMA. EI) DE\ A)NOUSI/OUS AU)TA\S__FU/SEIS E)ROU=SI, TO\ LEGO/MENON U(F' H(MW=N KRATU/NETAI TO\ MH\ SWMATIKH\N E)/XEIN FU/SIN TA\ SUMBEBHKO/TA MHDE\ TA\S POIO/THTAS. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. I 9, 2.$10 *OI( A)PO\ *QA/LEW KAI\ *PUQAGO/ROU KAI\ <20OI( *STWI+-KOI\>20 TREPTH\N KAI\ A)LLOIWTH\N KAI\ METABLHTH\N KAI\ R(EUSTH\N O(/LHN DI' O(/LHS TH\N U(/LHN. [1&10Stob.$10 LE/GW DE\ TOU\S ME/XRI TW=N *STWI+KW=N KATABEBHKO/TAS SU\N *(HRA-KLEI/TW| &10etc.]1 &10@Ae%28tius Plac. I, 9, 7.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 SW=MA TH\N U(/LHN A)POFAI/NONTAI. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. phys. p. 227, 23.$10 A)LL' E)PEIDH/ TINES KAI\ OU)DE\ OI( TUXO/NTES E)N FILOSOFI/A| TO\ <20A)/POION SW=MA TH\N PRWTI/STHN U(/LHN EI)=NAI/ FASI>20 KAI\ KATA\ *)ARISTOTE/LHN KAI\ KATA\ *PLA/TWNA, W(/SPER TW=N ME\N PA-LAIW=N OI( <20*STWI+KOI/>20, TW=N DE\ NE/WN *PERIKLH=S O( *LUDO/S, KALW=S A)\N E)/XOI TAU/THN E)PISKE/YASQAI TH\N DO/CAN. @&10Galenus de qualitatibus incorporeis 5. Vol. XIX p. 477 K. [1de &10materia Stoicorum locutus$10]1 A)DIANO/HTO/N TE KAI\ TO\ MH/TE BARU\ TOU=Q' U(PA/R-XEIN MH/TE KOU=FON, OU)X H(=TTON [2D']2 A)/TOPON EI) LE/GOI TIS A(/MA TOU=T' E)/XEIN A)M-FO/TERA KAI\ KATA\ TA\ AU)TA\ KAI\ MH\ PRO\S A)/LLO KAI\ A)/LLO KRINO/MENON: TO/ TE MH\ [2POIA\N]2 E)KEI/NHS E)XOU/SHS OU)SI/AN, TW=N E)C AU)TH=S, W(/S FASI, GEGONO/TWN PRW=TON TETTA/RWN E(/KASTON E)/XEIN POIO/THTA. __EI) DE\ MHD' AU)TO\ EI)=XE TOU/TWN MHDE\ E(\N KAQ' U(PO/QESIN TO\ AI)QE/RION DH\ E)KEI=NO PU=R, U(F' OU(= FASI TA/ TE STOIXEI=A KAI\ TO\N KO/SMON GEGONE/NAI, PW=S TAU=T' E)/XEI TA\ GENNH/MATA KAI\ POIH/MATA KAI\ PLA/SMATA. @&10Asclepius in Aristot. Metaph. p. 377, 29 Hayd.$10 KAI\ PA/LIN OI( ME\N MI/AN OU)SI/AN EI)=NAI EI)RH/KASIN, OI(=ON TH\N AI)SQHTH/N, W(/SPER OI( FUSIKOI\ KAI\ <20OI( *STWI+KOI/>20. @1 @&10Alexander Aphrod. comm. in Aristot. Topica IV p. 155 Ald. &10p. 301, 19 Wal.$10 OU(/TW DEIKNU/OIS A)\N O(/TI MH\ KALW=S <20TO\ TI\ OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S GE/NOS TOU= O)/NTOS TI/QENTAI>20: EI) GA\R TI/, DH=LON O(/TI KAI\ O)/N: EI) DE\ O)/N, TO\N TOU= O)/NTOS A)NADE/XOITO A)\N LO/GON: A)LL' E)KEI=NOI NOMOQETH/SANTES AU(TOI=S <20TO\ O)\N KATA\ SWMA/TWN MO/NWN LE/GESQAI>20, DIAFEU/GOIEN A)\N TO\ H)PORHME/NON: <20DIA\ TOU=TO GA\R TO\ TI\ GENIKW/TERON AU)TOU= FASIN EI)=NAI, KATHGOROU/MENON OU) KATA\ SWMA/TWN MO/NON, A)LLA\ KAI\ KATA\ A)SWMA/TWN>20. @&10Sextus adv. math. I 17.$10 KAI\ MH\N EI) DIDA/SKETAI/ TI, H)/TOI DIA\ TW=N OU)TINW=N DIDAXQH/SETAI H)\ DIA\ TW=N TINW=N: A)LLA\ DIA\ ME\N TW=N OU)TINW=N OU)X OI(=O/N TE DIDAXQH=NAI: A)NUPO/STATA GA/R E)STI TH=| DIANOI/A| TAU=TA <20KATA\ TOU\S A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20. @&10Sextus adv. math. X 218.$10 W(/SQ' OU(=TOI ME\N SW=MA POIOU=SI TO\N XRO/NON, <20OI( DE\ A)PO\ TH=S STOA=S FILO/SOFOI>20 A)SW/MATON AU)TO\N W)|H/QHSAN U(PA/R-XEIN: TW=N GA\R TINW=N FASI\ TA\ ME\N EI)=NAI SW/MATA TA\ DE\ A)SW/MATA, TW=N DE\ A)SW-MA/TWN TE/SSARA EI)/DH KATARIQMOU=NTAI W(S LEKTO\N KAI\ KENO\N KAI\ TO/PON KAI\ XRO/NON. E)C OU(= DH=LON GI/GNETAI O(/TI PRO\S TW=| A)SW/MATON U(POLAMBA/NEIN TO\N XRO/NON, E)/TI KAI\ KAQ' AU(TO/ TI NOOU/MENON PRA=GMA DOCA/ZOUSI TOU=TON. @&10Seneca ep. 58, 12. illud genus "1quod est"2 [1scil.$10 TO\ O)/N&10]1 generale &10supra se nihil habet. initium rerum est, omnia sub illo sunt. <21Stoici>21 vo-&10lunt superponere huic etiamnunc aliud genus magis principale. _ &10@ibid. 15. Primum genus Stoicis quibusdam videtur "1quid"2%10 quare &10videatur subiiciam. in rerum, inquiunt, natura quaedam sunt, quaedam &10non sunt. et haec autem, quae non sunt, rerum natura complectitur, quae &10animo succurrunt, tamquam Centauri, Gigantes et quicquid aliud falso co-&10gitatione formatum habere aliquam imaginem coepit, quamvis non habeat &10substantiam"2. @&10Anonymi Proleg. in Aristot. Categ. p. 34&14b&10 Brandis [1Schol. in Ar.$10]1. TRI/A DE\ TA\ KAQOLIKW/TATA O(MW/NUMA, E(/N, O)/N, TI/: KATA\ PA/NTWN GA\R TW=N O)/NTWN FE/RETAI TAU=TA, KATA\ ME\N *PLA/TWNA TO\ E(/N, KAT' *)ARISTOTE/LH TO\ O)/N, KATA\ DE\ TOU\S *STWI+KOU\S TO\ TI/. @&10Philo Leg. Alleg. III %14 175 Vol. I p. 151, 28.$10 TO\ GA\R MA/NNA E(R-MHNEU/ETAI "1TI/"2: TOU=TO/ E)STI TO\ GENIKW/TATON TW=N O)/NTWN. @&10Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 30 p. 1074d.$10 OU)DE\N OU)=N E)/TI DEI= LE/GEIN TO\N XRO/NON, TO\ KATHGO/RHMA, TO\ A)CI/WMA, TO\ SUNHMME/NON, TO\ SUMPEPLEGME/NON: OI(=S XRW=NTAI ME\N MA/LISTA TW=N FILOSO/FWN, O)/NTA D' OU) LE/GOUSIN EI)=NAI. @1 @&Stobaeus Eclogae I p. 138, 23 W.$ <20*XRUSI/PPOU>20. *XRU/SIP-POS AI)/TION EI)=NAI LE/GEI DI' O(/. *KAI\ TO\ ME\N AI)/TION O)\N KAI\ SW=MA [2OU(= DE\ AI)/TION MH/TE O)/N, MH/TE SW=MA]2 KAI\ AI)/TION ME\N O(/TI, OU(= DE\ AI)/TION DIA/ TI. *AI)TI/AN D' EI)=NAI LO/GON AI)TI/OU, H)\ LO/GON TO\N PERI\ TOU= AI)TI/OU W(S AI)TI/OU. @&10Sextus adv. math. IX 196.$10 EI)/PER TOI/NUN, FASI/N, E)/STI SPE/RMA, E)/STI KAI\ AI)/TION, E)PEI/PER TO\ SPE/RMA AI)/TIO/N E)STI TW=N E)C AU)TOU= FUOME/NWN TE KAI\ GENNWME/NWN: E)/STI DE/ GE SPE/RMA, W(S E)K TW=N SPEIROME/NWN KAI\ ZW|OGONOUME/NWN DEI/KNUTAI: E)/STIN A)/RA AI)/TION. KAI\ PA/LIN EI) E)/STI TI FU/SIS, E)/STI TI AI)/TION: TW=N GA\R FUOME/NWN H)\ E)KPEFUKO/TWN AI)/TIO/N E)STIN H( FU/SIS. U(PA/RXEI DE\ AU(/TH, W(S A)PO\ TW=N A)POTELESMA/TWN SUMFANE/S. __TOI/NUN EI) E)/STI FU/SIS, E)/STI TI AI)/-TION: A)LLA\ MH\N TO\ PRW=TON: A)/RA TO\ DEU/TERON. KAI\ A)/LLWS EI) E)/STI TI YUXH/, E)/STIN AI)/TION: AU(/TH GA\R KAI\ TOU= ZH=N KAI\ TOU= QNH/|SKEIN AI)TI/A GI/NETAI, TOU= ME\N ZH=N PAROU=SA, TOU= DE\ QNH/|SKEIN XWRIZOME/NH TW=N SWMA/TWN: E)/STI DE/ GE YUXH/, FASI/N, EI)/GE KAI\ O( LE/GWN MH\ EI)=NAI YUXH\N AU)TH=| PROSXRW/MENOS TOU=TO A)POFAI/-NETAI: E)/STIN A)/RA AI)/TION. PRO\S TOU/TOIS EI) E)/STI QEO/S, E)/STIN AI)/TION: OU(=TOS GA\R H)=N O( TA\ O(/LA DIOIKW=N: E)/STI DE/ GE KATA\ TA\S KOINA\S E)NNOI/AS TW=N A)NQRW/PWN QEO/S: E)/STIN A)/RA AI)/TION: KAI/TOI KA)\N MH\ QEO\S U(PA/RXH|, E)/STIN AI)/TION: TO\ GA\R MH\ EI)=NAI QEOU\S DIA/ TINA AI)TI/AN GI/NETAI: KAI\ TW=| OU)=N U(PA/RXEIN QEO\N KAI\ TW=| MH\ U(PA/RXEIN E)P' I)/SHS A)KOLOUQEI= TO\ EI)=NAI/ TI AI)/TION. @POLLW=N GE MH\N GENNWME/NWN KAI\ FQEIROME/NWN, AU)COME/NWN TE KAI\ MEIOU-ME/NWN, KINOUME/NWN TE KAI\ A)KINHTIZO/NTWN, E)C A)NA/GKHS O(MOLOGEI=N DEI= TO\ EI)=NAI/ TINA TOU/TWN AI)/TIA, TA\ ME\N GENE/SEWS TA\ DE\ FQORA=S, KAI\ TA\ ME\N AU)CH/SEWS TA\ DE\ MEIW/SEWS KAI\ H)/DH KINH/SEWS H)\ A)KINHSI/AS: SU\N TW=| KA)\N MH\ U(PA/RXH| TAU=TA TA\ A)POTELE/SMATA, FAI/NHTAI DE\ MO/NON, PA/LIN EI)SA/GESQAI TH\N U(/PARCIN TW=N AI)-TI/WN: TOU= GA\R FAI/NESQAI ME\N H(MI=N AU)TA\ W(S U(POKEI/MENA, MH\ U(POKEI=SQAI DE/, AI)/TIO/N TI KAQE/STHKEN. KAI\ MH\N EI) MHDE/N E)STIN AI)/TION, PA/NTA E)K PANTO\S DEH/-SEI GI/NESQAI KAI\ E)N PANTI\ TO/PW|, E)/TI KAI\ KATA\ PA/NTA KAIRO/N: O(/PER A)/TOPON. EU)QE/WS GA\R EI) MHDE/N E)STIN AI)/TION, OU)DE\N TO\ KWLU=ON E)C A)NQRW/POU I(/PPON SUN-I/STASQAI: [AI)/TION A)/RA TI E)/STAI]. MHDENO\S DE\ O)/NTOS TOU= KWLU/ONTOS SUSTH/SE-TAI/ POTE E)C A)NQRW/POU I(/PPOS, KAI\ OU(/TWS, EI) TU/XOI, E)C I(/PPOU FUTO/N: KATA\ TAU)TA\ DE\ OU)K A)DU/NATON E)/STAI XIO/NA ME\N E)N *AI)GU/PTW| PH/GNUSQAI, A)BROXI/AN DE\ E)N *PO/NTW| SUMBAI/NEIN, KAI\ TA\ ME\N TOU= QE/ROUS E)N XEIMW=NI GI/GNESQAI, TA\ DE\ TOU= XEIMW=NOS E)N QE/REI SUNI/STASQAI: O(/QEN EI)/PER W(=| E(/PETAI/ TI A)DU/NATON, KAI\ AU)TO\ E)/STAI A)DU/NATON, TW=| DE\ MH\ EI)=NAI AI)/TION E(/PETAI POLLA\ TW=N A)DUNA/TWN, R(HTE/ON KAI\ TO\ MH\ EI)=NAI AI)/TION TW=N A)DUNA/TWN U(PA/RXEIN. O(/ TE LE/GWN MH\ EI)=-NAI AI)/TION H)/TOI XWRI\S AI)TI/AS TOU=TO LE/GEI H)\ META/ TINOS AI)TI/AS. KAI\ EI) ME\N XWRI/S TINOS AI)TI/AS, A)/PISTO/S E)STIN, META\ TOU= A)KOLOUQEI=N AU)TW=| TO\ MH\ MA=LLON TOU=TO A)CIOU=N H)\ TO\ A)NTIKEI/MENON TOU/TW|, AI)TI/AS EU)LO/GOU MH\ PROU+POKEIME/NHS, DI' H(/N FHSIN A)NU/PARKTON EI)=NAI TO\ AI)/TION: EI) DE\ META/ TINOS AI)TI/AS, PERITRE/- @1PETAI, KA)N TW=| LE/GEIN MH\ EI)=NAI/ TI AI)/TION TI/QHSI TO\ EI)=NAI/ TI AI)/TION: O(/QEN KAI\ A)PO\ TH=S AU)TH=S DUNA/MEWS E)RWTA=N E)/CESTI KAI\ TO\N E)PI\ TOU= SHMEI/OU KAI\ TH=S A)PODEI/CEWS DIA\ TW=N E)/MPROSQEN A)PODOQE/NTA LO/GON, O(\S E(/CEI TH\N SU/NTACIN TOI-AU/THN: "1EI) E)/STI TI AI)/TION, E)/STIN AI)/TION: A)LLA\ KAI\ EI) MH\ E)/STI TI AI)/TIO/N, E)/STIN AI)/TION: H)/TOI DE\ E)/STIN H)\ OU)K E)/STIN: E)/STIN A)/RA"2. TW=| TE GA\R EI)=NAI AI)/TION A)KO-LOUQEI= TO\ EI)=NAI/ TI AI)/TION, MH\ DIAFE/RONTOS PARA\ TO\ H(GOU/MENON TOU= LH/GONTOS, TW=| TE MHDE\N EI)=NAI AI)/TION A)KOLOUQEI= PA/LIN TO\ EI)=NAI/ TI AI)/TION, E)PEI/PER O( LE/-GWN MHDE\N EI)=NAI AI)/TION U(PO/ TINOS AI)TI/AS KINHQEI\S LE/GEI MHDE\N EI)=NAI AI)/TION. W(/STE KAI\ TO\ DIEZEUGME/NON PRO\S TOI=S DUSI\ SUNHMME/NOIS A)LHQE\S GI/NESQAI E)C A)NTIKEIME/NWN DIEZEUGME/NON, KAI\ TH\N E)PIFORA\N TOI=S TOIOU/TOIS LH/MMASI SUNEISA/-GESQAI, KAQW\S A)NW/TERON PAREMUQHSA/MEQA. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. 11, 7.$10 *OI( *STWI+KOI\ TO\ PRW=TON AI)/TION W(RI/SANTO KI-NHTO/N. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. Phys. p. 420,6 Diels.$10 O(/TI TISI\ DOKEI= MH\ EI)=NAI/ TI KINOU=N A)KI/NHTON, A)LLA\ PA=N TO\ KINOU=N KINEI=SQAI__KAI\ DH=LON O(/TI TAU/THS EI)SI\ TH=S DO/CHS TW=N TE PALAIW=N FUSIOLO/GWN O(/SOI SWMATIKH\N H)\ MI/AN H)\ PLEI/OUS U(PE/QENTO TH\N A)RXH\N, KAI\ TW=N NE/WN OI( <20*STWI+KOI/>20. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. I 11, 5.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 PA/NTA TA\ AI)/TIA SWMATIKA/: PNEU/MATA GA/R. @&10Sextus adv. math. IX 211.$10 EI)/GE <20*STWI+KOI\>20 ME\N PA=N AI)/TION SW=MA/ FASI SW/MATI A)SWMA/TOU TINO\S AI)/TION GI/NESQAI, OI(=ON SW=MA ME\N TO\ SMILI/ON, SW/MATI DE\ TH=| SARKI/, A)SWMA/TOU DE\ TOU= TE/MNESQAI KATHGORH/MATOS, KAI\ PA/LIN SW=MA ME\N TO\ PU=R, SW/MATI DE\ TW=| CU/LW|, A)SWMA/TOU DE\ TOU= KAI/ESQAI KATHGO-RH/MATOS. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 77 B. ed. Bas.$10 OU)DE\ E)/DEI A)PO\ TW=N E)SXA/TWN A)/RXESQAI POIH/SEWN, LE/GW DH\ TW=N KATA\ PLHGH\N KAI\ W)=SIN, OU)DE\ TOI=S <20*STWI+KOI=S>20 SUGXWREI=N PERI\ OU(= DIATELOU=MEN AU)TOI=S DIAFERO/MENOI, W(S TO\ POIOU=N PELA/SEI TINI\ POIEI= KAI\ A(/YEI. BE/LTION GA\R LE/GEIN W(S OU) PA/NTA PELA/SEI KAI\ A(/YEI POIEI=. @&10Proclus in Plat. Parmen. Vol. V p. 74 ed. Cousin.$10 *TO\ DEU/TERON TOI/NUN O( TH=S SFRAGI=DOS TU/POS <20*STWI+KW=N>20 U(POQE/SESI PROSH/KEI TAI=S SWMATI-KW=S LEGOU/SAIS TA\ POIOU=NTA POIEI=N KAI\ TA\ PA/SXONTA PA/SXEIN: W)QISMOU= GA\R DEDE/HTAI KAI\ A)NTITUPI/AS KAI\ E)PEREI/SEWS KAI\ OU)K A)/LLWS GE/GONEN. @&10Clemens Alexandrinus Stromat. VIII 9 [1Vol. II p. 929 Pott.$10]1. AI)/-TION DE\ KURI/WS LE/GETAI TO\ PAREKTIKO/N TINOS E)NERGHTIKW=S. E)PEI\ KAI\ TO\N SI/-DHRON TMHTIKO/N FAMEN EI)=NAI OU) MO/NON E)N TW=| TE/MNEIN, A)LLA\ KAI\ E)N TW=| MH\ TE/MNEIN: OU(/TWS OU)=N KAI\ TO\ PAREKTIKO\N A)/MFW SHMAI/NEI, KAI\ TO\ H)/DH E)NERGOU=N, KAI\ TO\ MHDE/PW ME/N, DUNA/MEI DE\ KEXRHME/NON TOU= E)NERGH=SAI. @&10Clemens Alexandrinus Stromat. VIII 9 [1Vol. II p. 929 Pott.$10]1. OI( ME\N OU)=N SWMA/TWN, OI( D' A)SWMA/TWN FASI\N EI)=NAI TA\ AI)/TIA [1&10scil. Stoici et &10Peripatetici$10]1. OI( DE\ TO\ ME\N SW=MA KURI/WS AI)TIO/N FASI, TO\ DE\ A)SW/MATON KA-TAXRHSTIKW=S KAI\ OI(=ON AI)TIWDW=S [1&10scil Stoici$10]1: A)/LLOI D' E)/MPALIN A)NASTRE/FOUSI, TA\ ME\N A)SW/MATA KURI/WS AI)/TIA LE/GONTES, KATAXRHSTIKW=S DE\ TA\ SW/MATA. @&10Clemens Alexandrinus Stromat. VIII 9 [1Vol. II p. 929 Pott.$10]1. *TW=N AI)TI/WN TA\ ME\N PROKATARKTIKA/, TA\ DE\ SUNEKTIKA/, TA\ DE\ SUNERGA/, TA\ DE\ W(=N OU)K A)/NEU. PROKATARKTIKA\ ME\N TA\ PRW/TWS A)FORMH\N PAREXO/MENA EI)S TO\ @1 GI/GNESQAI/ TI, KAQA/PER TO\ KA/LLOS TOI=S A)KOLA/STOIS TOU= E)/RWTOS: O)FQE\N GA\R AU)TOI=S TH\N E)RWTIKH\N DIA/QESIN E)MPOIEI= ME/N, OU) MH\N KATHNAGKASME/NWS: SUNEK-TIKA\ DE\ A(/PER SUNWNU/MWS KAI\ AU)TOTELH= KALEI=TAI, E)PEIDH/PER AU)TA/RKWS DI' AU(-TW=N POIHTIKA/ E)STI TOU= A)POTELE/SMATOS. @E(CH=S DE\ PA/NTA TA\ AI)/TIA E)PI\ TOU= MANQA/NONTOS DEIKTE/ON. O( ME\N PATH\R AI)TIO/N E)STI PROKATARKTIKO\N TH=S MAQH/SEWS, O( DIDA/SKALOS DE\ SUNEKTIKO/N, H( DE\ TOU= MANQA/NONTOS FU/SIS SUNERGO\N AI)/TION, O( DE\ XRO/NOS TW=N W(=N OU)K A)/NEU LO/-GON E)PE/XEI. @&10Seneca epist. 65, 4. Stoicis placet unam causam esse id &10quod facit. &10@ibid. 11. Haec quae ab Aristotele et Platone ponitur turba causa-&10rum aut nimium multa aut nimium pauca comprehendit. nam si, quo-&10cumque remoto quid effici non potest, id causam iudicant esse faciendi, &10pauca dixerunt%10 ponant inter causas tempus%10 nihil sine tempore fieri potest. &10ponant locum%10 si non fuerit, ubi fiat aliquid, ne fiet quidem. ponant mo-&10tum%10 nil sine hoc nec fit nec perit, nulla sine motu ars, nulla mutatio est. &10Sed nos nunc primam et generalem quaerimus causam. haec simplex esse &10debet, nam et materia simplex est, quaerimus quae sit causa, ratio scilicet &10faciens, id est deus. &10@Clemens Alexandrinus Stromat. VIII 9 [1Vol. II p. 930 Pott.$10]1. TO\ DE\ AU)TO\ A)/RA AI)/TION KAI\ POIHTIKO\N KAI\ DI' O(/. KAI\ EI) ME\N TI/ E)STIN AI)/TION KAI\ POIHTIKO/N, TOU=TO PA/NTWS E)STI\ KAI\ DI' O(/, EI) DE/ TI E)STI\ DI' O(/, OU) PA/NTWS TOU=TO KAI\ AI)/TION. POLLA\ GOU=N E)F' E(\N A)POTE/LESMA SUNTRE/XEI, DI' A(\ GI/NETAI TO\ TE/LOS, A)LL' OU)K E)/STI PA/NTA AI)/TIA: OU) GA\R A)\N E)TEKNOKTO/NHSEN *MH/DEIA, EI) MH\ W)RGI/SQH: OU)D' A)\N W)RGI/SQH, EI) MH\ E)ZH/LWSEN: OU)DE\ TOU=TO, EI) MH\ H)RA/SQH: OU)DE\ TOU=TO, EI) MH\ *)IA/SWN E)/PLEUSEN EI)S *KOLXOU/S: OU)DE\ TOU=TO, EI) MH\ *)ARGW\ KATESKEUA/SQH: OU)DE\ TOU=TO, EI) MH\ TA\ CU/LA E)K TOU= *PHLI/OU E)TMH/QH: E)N TOU/TOIS GA\R A(/PASIN TOU= "1DI' O(\"2 TUGXA/NONTOS, OU) PA/NTA TH=S TEKNOKTONI/AS AI)/TIA TUG-XA/NEI, MO/NH DE\ H( *MH/DEIA. @&10Clemens Alexandrinus Stromat. VIII 9 [1Vol. II p. 932 Pott.$10]1. E)/TI ZHTEI=TAI, EI) POLLA\ KATA\ SU/NODON E(NO\S AI)/TIA GI/NETAI: [2KAI\ TINE\S ME\N LE/-GOUSIN O(/TI GI/NETAI]2: POLLOI\ GA\R A)/NQRWPOI SUNE/LKONTES AI)/TIOI/ EI)SI TOU= KA-QE/LKESQAI TH\N NAU=N, [2OU)K AU)TO\S E(/KASTOS AI)/TIOS W)\N]2 A)LLA\ SU\N TOI=S A)/LLOIS, EI) DH/ TI KAI\ TO\ SUNAI/TION AI)/TION. A)/LLOI DE/ FASIN, EI) POLLA\ AI)/TIA, KAT' I)DI/AN E(/KASTON E(NO\S AI)/TION GI/NETAI: TOU= GOU=N EU)DAIMONEI=N E(NO\S O)/NTOS AI)/TIAI TUGXA/-NOUSIN AI( A)RETAI\ POLLAI\ OU)=SAI: KAI\ TOU= QERMAI/NESQAI KAI\ TOU= A)LGEI=N O(MOI/WS POLLA\ TA\ AI)/TIA. MH/ TI OU)=N AI( POLLAI\ A)RETAI\ MI/A E)STI\ KATA\ DU/NAMIN, KAI\ TA\ QERMAI/NONTA KAI\ TA\ A)LGU/NONTA. KAI\ TO\ PLH=QOS DE\ TW=N A)RETW=N KATA\ GE/-NOS E(\N TUGXA/NON E(NO\S AI)/TION GI/NETAI TOU= EU)DAIMONEI=N. TW=| O)/NTI DE\ PROKA-TARKTIKA\ ME\N AI)/TIA E(NO\S GI/NETAI PLEI/ONA KATA\ GE/NOS KAI\ KAT' EI)=DOS: KAI\ KATA\ GE/NOS ME\N TOU= NOSEI=N O(PWSOU=N, OI(=ON YU/CIS, E)/KLUSIS, KO/POS, A)PEYI/A, ME/QH: KAT' EI)=DOS DE\ TOU= PURETOU=. TA\ DE\ SUNEKTIKA\ AI)/TIA KATA\ GE/NOS MO/NON, OU)-KE/TI DE\ KAI\ KAT' EI)=DOS. TOU= GA\R EU)WDIA/ZESQAI KATA\ GE/NOS E(NO\S O)/NTOS POLLA\ TA\ AI)/TIA KAT' EI)=DOS: OI(=ON LIBANWTO/S, R(O/DON, KRO/KOS, STU/RAC, SMU/RNA, MU/RON: @1 [2TOU= DE\ EU)WDIA/ZESQAI TOU= KAT' EI)=DOS OU)KE/TI POLLA/]2: TO\ GA\R R(O/DON OU)K A)\N OU(/TWS EU)W=DES EI)/H W(S H( SMU/RNA. @&10Clemens Alexandrinus Stromat. VIII 9 [1Vol. II p. 932 Pott.$10]1. A)LLH/LWN OU)K E)/STI TINA\ AI)/TIA, A)LLH/LOIS DE\ AI)/TIA: H( GA\R SPLHNIKH\ DIA/QESIS PROU+POKEIME/NH OU) PURETOU= AI)/TIOS, A)LLA\ TOU= GI/NESQAI TO\N PURETO/N, KAI\ O( PU-RETO\S PROU+POKEI/MENOS OU) SPLHNO/S, A)LLA\ TOU= AU)/CESQAI TH\N DIA/QESIN. OU(/TWS KAI\ AI( A)RETAI\ A)LLH/LAIS AI)/TIAI, TW=| MH\ XWRI/ZESQAI DIA\ TH\N A)NTAKOLOUQI/AN: KAI\ OI( E)PI\ TH=S YALI/DOS LI/QOI A)LLH/LOIS EI)SI\N AI)/TIOI TOU= ME/NEIN KATHGORH/MA-TOS, A)LLH/LWN DE\ OU)K EI)SI\N AI)/TIOI: KAI\ O( DIDA/SKALOS DE\ KAI\ O( MANQA/NWN A)L-LH/LOIS EI)SI\N AI)/TIOI TOU= PROKO/PTEIN KATHGORH/MATOS. LE/GETAI DE\ A)LLH/LOIS AI)/TIA POTE\ ME\N TW=N AU)TW=N, W(S O( E)/MPOROS KAI\ O( KA/PHLOS A)LLH/LOIS EI)SI\N AI)/TIOI TOU= KERDAI/NEIN: POTE\ DE\ A)/LLOU KAI\ A)/LLOU, KAQA/PER H( MA/XAIRA KAI\ H( SA/RC: H( ME\N GA\R TH=| SARKI\ TOU= TE/MNESQAI, H( SA\RC DE\ TH=| MAXAI/RA| TOU= TE/MNEIN&10 etc. &10@Clemens Alexandrinus Stromat. VIII 9 [1Vol. II p. 933 Pott.$10]1. TO\ DE\ AU)TO\ TW=N E)NANTI/WN AI)/TION GI/NETAI, POTE\ ME\N PARA\ TO\ ME/GEQOS TOU= AI)-TI/OU KAI\ TH\N DU/NAMIN, POTE\ DE\ PARA\ TH\N E)PITHDEIO/THTA TOU= PA/SXONTOS: PARA\ ME\N TH\N POIA\N DU/NAMIN, [2OI(=ON]2 H( AU)TH\ XORDH\ PARA\ TH\N E)PI/TASIN H)\ TH\N A)/NESIN O)CU\N H)\ BARU\N A)PODI/DWSI TO\N FQO/GGON: PARA\ DE\ TH\N E)PITHDEIO/THTA TW=N PASXO/NTWN, [2OI(=ON]2 TO\ ME/LI GLUKA/ZEI ME\N TOU\S U(GIAI/NONTAS, PIKRA/ZEI DE\ TOU\S PURE/SSONTAS: KAI\ EI(=S KAI\ O( AU)TO\S OI)=NOS TOU\S ME\N EI)S O)RGH/N, TOU\S DE\ EI)S DIA/XUSIN A)/GEI: KAI\ O( AU)TO\S H(/LIOS TH/KEI ME\N TO\N KHRO/N, CHRAI/NEI DE\ TO\N PHLO/N. @&10Clemens Alexandrinus Stromat. VIII 9 [1Vol. II p. 933 Pott.$10]1. KAI\ TA\ ME\N PROKATARKTIKA/, TA\ DE\ SUNEKTIKA/, TA\ DE\ SUNAI/TIA, TA\ DE\ SUNERGA/. __TW=N ME\N OU)=N PROKATARKTIKW=N AI)ROME/NWN ME/NEI TO\ A)POTE/LESMA: SUNEK-TIKO\N DE/ E)STIN AI)/TION, OU(= PARO/NTOS ME/NEI TO\ A)POTE/LESMA KAI\ AI)ROME/NOU AI)/-RETAI. TO\ DE\ SUNEKTIKO\N SUNWNU/MWS KAI\ AU)TOTELE\S KALOU=SIN, E)PEIDH\ AU)TA/R-KWS DI' AU(TOU= POIHTIKO/N E)STI TOU= A)POTELE/SMATOS. EI) DE\ TO\ AI)/TION AU)TOTE-LOU=S E)NERGEI/AS E)STI\ DHLWTIKO/N, TO\ [2DE\]2 SUNERGO\N U(PHRESI/AN SHMAI/NEI KAI\ TH\N SU\N E(TE/RW| LEITOURGI/AN, EI) ME\N OU)=N MHDE\N PARE/XETAI, OU)DE\ SUNERGO\N LEX-QH/SETAI: EI) DE\ PARE/XETAI, TOU/TOU PA/NTWS GI/NETAI AI)/TION, OU(= KAI\ PARE/XETAI, TOUTE/STIN TOU= DI' AU)TO\ GINOME/NOU: E)/STIN OU)=N SUNERGO/N, OU(= PARO/NTOS E)GI/NETO TO\ A)POTE/LESMA: PRODH/LWS ME\N OU)=N PARO/NTOS [2PRODH/LOU]2, A)DH/LWS DE\ A)DH/LOU: KAI\ TO\ SUNAI/TION DE\ E)K TOU= GE/NOUS E)STI\ TW=N AI)TI/WN, KAQA/PER O( SUSTRATIW/-THS STRATIW/THS KAI\ O( SUNE/FHBOS E)/FHBOS. TO\ ME\N OU)=N SUNERGO\N AI)/TION TW=| SUNEKTIKW=| PRO\S TH\N E)PI/TASIN BOHQEI= TOU= U(P' AU)TOU= GINOME/NOU: TO\ DE\ SUNAI/-TION OU)K E)PI\ TH=S AU)TH=S E)STIN E)NNOI/AS: DU/NATAI GA\R SUNAI/TION U(PA/RXEIN, KA)\N MH\ SUNEKTIKO\N AI)/TION H)=| TI. NOEI=TAI GA\R SU\N E(TE/RW| TO\ SUNAI/TION OU)D' AU)TW=| DUNAME/NW| KAT' I)DI/AN POIH=SAI TO\ A)POTE/LESMA, AI)/TION O)\N SU\N AI)TI/W|. DIAFE/REI DE\ TOU= SUNAITI/OU TO\ SUNERGO\N E)N TW=| TO\ ME\N SUNAI/TION [2MEQ' E(TE/ROU AI)TI/OU]2 KAT' I)DI/AN MH\ POIOU=NTOS TO\ A)POTE/LESMA PARE/XEIN, TO\ DE\ SUNERGO\N E)N TW=| KAT' I)DI/AN MH\ POIEI=N, E(TE/RW| DE\ PROSERXO/MENON TW=| KAT' I)DI/AN POIOU=NTI SUN-ERGEI= AU)TW=| PRO\S TO\ SFODRO/TERON GI/NESQAI TO\ A)POTE/LESMA. MA/LISTA DE\ TO\ @1 E)K PROKATARKTIKOU= SUNERGO\N GEGONE/NAI, [2E)PI\ TOU=TO]2 TH\N TOU= AI)TI/OU DIATEI/-NEIN DU/NAMIN PARI/STHSIN. @&10Clemens Alexandrinus Stromat. I p. 376. 77 Pott. distinguit$10 TO\ SUNERGO/N, TO\ SUNAI/TION, TO\ SUNEKTIKO\N AI)/TION. @O(\ DE\ MEQ' E(TE/ROU POIEI=, A)TELE\S O)\N KAQ' AU(TO\ E)NERGEI=N, SUNERGO\N FAME\N KAI\ SUNAI/TION [A)PO\ TOU= SUNAITI/OU AI)/TION U(PA/RXEIN] A)PO\ TOU= E(TE/RW| SUNELQO\N AI)/TION GI/GNESQAI W)NOMASME/NON: KAQ' E(AUTO\ DE\ MH\ DU/NASQAI TO\ A)POTE/LESMA __PARE/XEIN.&10 &10@paulo post%10$10 A)LLA\ TW=N SUNERGW=N TA\ ME\N PLEI/ONA TA\ DE\ E)LA/TTONA PROS-FE/RETAI DU/NAMIN. @&10Clemens Alexandrinus Stromat. I p. 367 Pott.$10 OI)=DA POLLOU\S __KAI\ TO\ MH\ KWLU=ON AI)/TION EI)=NAI LE/GONTAS. __FAME\N DH\ PRO\S AU)-TOU\S TO\ AI)/TION E)N TW=| POIEI=N KAI\ E)NERGEI=N KAI\ DRA=N NOEI=SQAI: TO\ DE\ MH\ KW-LU=ON KATA/ GE TOU=TO A)NENE/RGHTON EI)=NAI. E)/TI TO\ ME\N AI)/TION PRO\S TH=| E)NERGEI/A| E)STI/, KAQA/PER O( ME\N NAUPHGO\S PRO\S TW=| GI/GNESQAI TO\ SKA/FOS, O( DE\ OI)KODO/-MOS PRO\S TW=| KTI/ZESQAI TH\N OI)KI/AN: TO\ DE\ MH\ KWLU=ON KEXW/RISTAI TOU= GIGNO-ME/NOU&10 etc. &10@Galenus defin. med. 154_160 Vol. XIX p. 392 K. definit$10 AI)/TIA PROKATARKTIKA/, PROHGOU/MENA, SUNEKTIKA/, AU)TOTELH=, SUNAI/TIA, SUNERGA/. @&10Galenus adv. Iulianum 6 vol. XVIII A p. 279 K.$10 EI)/RHTAI DE\ KAI\ PERI\ TW=N SUNEKTIKW=N AI)TI/WN E(TE/RWQI DEIKNU/NTWN H(MW=N O(/TI TO/ TE O)/NOMA KAI\ TO\ PRA=GMA AU)TO/, KAQ' OU(= TOU)/NOMA, <20TH=S *STWI+KH=S AI(RE/SEW/S>20 E)STI KAI\ W(S OU)K O)RQW=S U(PEILH/FASIN OU)/T' O)NOMA/ZOUSIN OI( NEW/TEROI TW=N I)ATRW=N A(/PAN TOU=TO TO\ GE/NOS, O(/TI TE KAI\ H(MEI=S E(PO/MENOI POLLA/KIS AU)TOI=S, O(/PWS MH\ DO/CW-MEN E)RI/ZEIN U(PE\R TOU= O)NO/MATOS, E)/NIA ME\N TW=N AI)TIW=N OU(/TW KALEI=SQAI SUG-XWROU=MEN, OU) MA\ *DI/A O(/SA TW=N A(PLW=S O)/NTWN E)STI/N, A)LLA\ TW=N E)N TW=| GI/GNE-SQAI TO\ EI)=NAI KEKTHME/NWN.&10 &10@ibid. p. 298.$10 KAI\ MH\N OU)D' A)/LLHN TINA\ E)/NNOIAN EI)PEI=N E)/XEI TOU= SUNE/-XONTOS AI)TI/OU PARA\ TO\ GI/NESQAI/ TI PRO\S AU)TOU= KAI\ PAU/ESQAI SU\N AU)TW=|, PLH\N EI) KA)NTAU=QA PA/LIN E)CAI/FNHS E(AUTO\N EI)=NAI/ FHSI <20*STWI+KO/N>20, W(S E)N A)/LLOIS E)POI/HSEN. A)LLA\ TOU=TO/ GE PRA/CAS OU) NO/SOU MO/NON, A)LLA\ KAI\ TH=S U(GEI/AS AU)TH=S AI)/TION A)POFANEI=TAI/ TI EI)=NAI KAI\ QERMO\N KAI\ YUXRO\N A)NAGKASQH/SETAI/ TI LE/GEIN EI)=NAI NO/SHMA KAI\ CHRO\N KAI\ U(GRO/N, A(/PER OU) BOU/LETAI. MH\ TOI/NUN LHREI/TW MA/TAIA MHD' E)MPLH/KTWN TRO/PON A)/LLOT' A)/LLA FANTAZE/SQW, POTE\ ME\N E)PAINW=N *STWI+KOU/S, POTE\ D' A)NAIRW=N AU)TW=N TA\ DO/GMATA. @&10Galenus synopsis librorum de pulsibus 9. Vol. IX p. 458 K.$10 ME-MNH=SQAI ME/NTOI XRH\ PRO\ PA/NTWN O(/PWS E)/FAMEN O)NOMA/ZEIN TO\ OI(=ON SUNEKTIKO\N AI)/TION, O(/TI MH\ KURI/WS A)LLA\ KATAXRW/MENOI TH=| PROSHGORI/A|: TO\ ME\N GA\R KURI/WS LEGO/MENON AI)/TION SUNEKTIKO\N OU)/T' W)NO/MASE/ TIS A)/LLOS PRO\ <20TW=N *STWI+KW=N OU)/T'>20 EI)=NAI SUNEXW/RHSE: TA\ DE\ KAI\ PRO\ H(MW=N OI(=ON SUNEKTIKA\ LEGO/MENA GENE/-SEW/S TINOS, OU)X U(PA/RCEWS AI)/TIA. @1 @&10Arius Didymus epit. phys. fr. 19 Diels [1DG p. 457, 17. Sto-&10baeus ecl. I p. 143, 24 W.]1.$10 SW=MA/ E)STI TO\ TRIXH=| DIASTATO/N, PLA/TEI, BA/QEI, MH/KEI: TAU=TA DE\ PLEONAXW=S LE/GESQAI. O(TE\ ME\N GA\R MH=KOS [EI)=NAI] LE/GESQAI TO\ ME/GISTON DIA/STHMA TOU= SW/MATOS, O(TE\ DE\ MO/NON TO\ KA/TWQEN A)/NW: KAI\ PLA/-TOS O(TE\ [2ME\N]2 TO\ DEU/TERON DIA/STHMA, O(TE\ DE\ TO\ E)K DECIA=S KAI\ E)C EU)WNU/MOU: KAI\ BA/QOS O(TE\ ME\N TO\ EI)S E(AUTO\ DIA/STHMA, O(TE\ DE\ TO\ PRO/SW KAI\ O)PI/SW: KATA\ ME\N TO\N PRO/TERON LO/GON OU)/TE TW=N SFAIRW=N OU)/TE TW=N TETRAGW/NWN KAI\ TW=N O(MOI/WN OU)DE\N TW=N DIASTHMA/TWN TOU/TWN E)XO/NTWN, KATA\ DE\ TO\N DEU/TERON PANTO\S SW/MATOS TA\S TREI=S E)/XONTOS DIASTA/SEIS DIA\ TO\ KATA\ PA=SAN QE/SIN U(PO\ TO\N LO/GON TOU=TON PI/PTEIN AU)TO/. @&10Philo de mundi opificio %14 36 Vol. I p. 11, 9 Wendl.$10 TO\ GA\R SW=MA FU/SEI STEREO\N O(/TIPER KAI\ TRIXH= DIASTATO/N: STEREOU= DE\ KAI\ SW/MATOS E)/NNOIA TI/S E(TE/RA, PLH\N TO\ PA/NTH DIESTHKO/S. @&10Clemens Alexandrinus Stromat II p. 436 Pott.$10 DII+SXURI/ZONTAI TOU=T' EI)=NAI MO/NON O(/PER E)/XEI PROSBOLH\N KAI\ E)PAFH/N TINA, TAU)TO\N SW=MA KAI\ OU)SI/AN O(RIZO/MENOI, [2A)/LLOI DE\]2 PRO\S AU)TOU\S A)MFISBHTOU=NTES MA/LA EU)LABW=S A)/NWQEN E)C A)ORA/TOU POQE\N A)MU/NONTAI, NOHTA\ A)/TTA KAI\ A)SW/MATA EI)/DH BIAZO/-MENOI TH\N A)LHQINH\N OU)SI/AN EI)=NAI. @&10Ae%28tius I 10, 5.$10 <20*OI( A)PO\ *ZH/NWNOS *STWI+KOI\>20 E)NNOH/MATA H(ME/TERA TA\S I)DE/AS E)/FASAN. @&10Syrianus in Aristot. Metaph. [1Aristot. Acad. Bor. Vol. V]1 p. 892&14a&10. $10TW=N KAQ' E(/KASTA, A(\ EI)/TE R(E/OI KATA\ PA=N__EI)/TE GI/GNOITO ME\N A)EI\ KAI\ FQEI/ROITO, DIAME/NOI DE\ KATA\ TO\ E(AUTW=N O(/LON DIA\ TH\N EI)DHTIKH\N AI)TI/AN__ EI)/TE KAI\ O)/NTA TIS AU)TA\ KALOI/H, W(S *)ARISTOTE/LHS EI)/WQEN, EI)/TE KAI\ MO/NA EI)=NAI LE/GOI, <20W(S OI( *STWI+KOI/>20 FASIN. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 17 A ed. bas.$10 OI( DE\ A)NAIROU=SI ME\N TH\N TW=N KOINW=N FU/SIN, E)N DE\ TOI=S KAQ' E(/KASTA AU)TA\ MO/NOIS U(FESTA/NAI NOMI/ZOUSIN, AU)TA\ KAQ' AU(TA\ MHDAMOU= QEWROU=NTES. @&10Sextus adv. math. VIII 263.$10 TO\ A)SW/MATON KAT' AU)TOU\S [1&10scil. &10Stoicos$10]1 OU)/TE POIEI=N TI PE/FUKEN OU)/TE PA/SXEIN. @&Syrianus in Aristot. Metaphys. [1Aristot. Acad. V 892&14b&, 14$]1. W(S A)/RA TA\ EI)/DH PARA\ TOI=S QEI/OIS TOU/TOIS A)NDRA/SIN OU)/TE PRO\S TH\N XRH=SIN TH=S TW=N O)NOMA/TWN SUNHQEI/AS PARH/GETO, W(S <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 KAI\ *)ARXE/DHMOS KAI\ OI( PLEI/OUS TW=N *STWI+KW=N U(/STERON W)|H/QHSAN [1POLLAI=S GA\R DIAFORAI=S DIE/STHKE TA\ KAQ' AU(TA\ EI)/DH TW=N E)N TH=| SUNHQEI/A| LEGO-ME/NWN]1 OU)/TE& etc. &@Proclus in Euclidem 35, 25 p. 395 Friedlein.$ [1*TA\ PARALLH-LO/GRAMMA TA\ E)PI\ TH=S AU)TH=S BA/SEWS KAI\ E)N TAI=S AU)TAI=S PARALLH/LOIS @1 I)/SA A)LLH/LOIS E)STIN]1. *TA\ D' OU)=N TOIAU=TA TW=N QEWRHMA/TWN, W(S FHSI\N O( *GEMI=NOS, A)PEI/KAZEN O( <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 TAI=S I)DE/AIS. W(S GA\R E)KEI=NAI TW=N A)PEI/RWN E)N PE/RASIN W(RISME/NOIS TH\N GE/NESIN PERILAMBA/NOUSIN, OU(/TWS KAI\ E)N TOU/TOIS TW=N A)PEI/RWN E)N W(RISME/NOIS TO/POIS H( PERI/LHYIS GI/NE-TAI. KAI\ DIA\ TO\N O(/RON TOU=TON H( I)SO/THS A)NAFAI/NETAI. TO\ GA\R U(/YOS TW=N PARALLH/LWN TO\ AU)TO\ ME/NON A)PEI/RWN NOOUME/NWN E)PI\ TH=S AU)TH=S BA/SEWS PARALLHLOGRA/MMWN PA/NTA I)/SA A)LLH/LOIS A)POFAI/NEI. @&10Plutarchus praec. conjugalia cp. 34%10$10 *TW=N SWMA/TWN <20OI( FILO/SO-FOI>20 [1&10scil. Stoici$10]1 TA\ ME\N E)K DIESTW/TWN LE/GOUSIN EI)=NAI KAQA/PER STO/LON KAI\ STRATO/PEDON, TA\ D' E)K SUNAPTOME/NWN W(S OI)KI/AN KAI\ NAU=N, TA\ D' H(NWME/NA KAI\ SUMFUA= KAQA/PER E)STI\ TW=N ZW/WN E(/KASTON. ___DEI= DE\ W(/SPER <20OI( FUSIKOI\>20 TW=N U(GRW=N LE/GOUSI DI' O(/LWN GENE/SQAI TH\N KRA=SIN, OU(/TW&10 etc. @&Plutarchus de defectu oraculorum cp. 29.$ OU) GA\R E)NTAU=QA ME\N E(\N SUNI/STATAI SW=MA POLLA/KIS E)K DIESTW/TWN SWMA/TWN, OI(=ON E)K-KLHSI/A KAI\ STRA/TEUMA KAI\ XORO/S: W(=N E(KA/STW| KAI\ ZH=N KAI\ FRONEI=N KAI\ MANQA/NEIN SUMBE/BHKEN, W(S OI)/ETAI <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20: E)N DE\ TW=| PANTI\ DE/KA KO/SMOUS__E(NI\ XRH=SQAI LO/GW|__A)DU/NATO/N E)STIN. @&10Achilles Isagoge 14 p. 134 in Petav. Uranol.$10 [1*TI/ ME\N A)STH/R, TI/ DE\ A)/STRON;]1 SW/MATA H(NWME/NA LE/GESQAI O(/SA U(PO\ MIA=S E(/CEWS KRATEI=TAI, OI(=ON LI/QOS, CU/LON: E)/STI DE\ E(/CIS PNEU=MA SW/MATOS SUNEKTIKO/N. SUNHMME/NA DE\ O(/SA OU)X U(PO\ MIA=S E(/CEWS DE/DETAI, W(S PLOI=ON KAI\ OI)KI/A: TO\ ME\N GA\R E)K POL-LW=N SANI/DWN, H( DE\ E)K POLLW=N LI/QWN SU/GKEITAI. DIESTW=TA DE\ W(S XORO/S. TW=N DE\ TOIOU/TWN DITTAI\ AI( DIAFORAI/. TA\ ME\N GA\R E)C W(RISME/NWN SWMA/TWN KAI\ A)RIQMW=| LHPTW=N W(S XORO/S, TA\ DE\ E)C A)ORI/STWN W(S O)/XLOS. EI)/H OU)=N [2A)\N]2 O( ME\N A)STH\R SW=MA H(NWME/NON, TO\ DE\ A)/STRON E)K DIESTW/TWN KAI\ W(RISME/NWN: A)RIQMO\S GA\R A)STE/RWN E)F' E(KA/STOU DEI/KNUTAI. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 16$10 *D&10 ed. Bas.$10 *OI( DE/ GE <20*STWI+-KOI\>20 EI)S E)LA/TTONA SUSTE/LLEIN A)CIOU=SI TO\N TW=N PRW/TWN GENW=N A)RIQMO/N. KAI\ TINA\ E)N TOI=S E)LA/TTOSIN U(PHLLAGME/NA PARALAMBA/NOUSI. POIOU=NTAI GA\R TH\N TOMH\N EI)S TE/SSARA: EI)S <20U(POKEI/MENA>20 KAI\ <20POIA\>20 KAI\ <20PW=S E)/XONTA>20 KAI\ <20PRO\S TI/ PWS E)/XONTA>20. KAI\ DH=LON O(/TI PLEI=STA PARALEI/POUSIN. TO/ TE GA\R POSO\N A)/NTIKRUS, KAI\ TA\ E)N XRO/NW| KAI\ E)N TO/PW|. EI) GA\R TO\ PW=S E)/XON NOMI/ZOUSIN AU)TOI=S TA\ TOIAU=TA PERILAMBA/NEIN, O(/TI TO\ PE/RUSIN O)\N H)\ TO\ E)N *LUKEI/W| H)\ TO\ KAQH=SQAI H)\ TO\ U(PODEDE/SQAI DIA/KEITAI/ PWS KATA/ TI TOU/TWN, PRW=TON ME\N POLLH=S OU)/SHS TH=S E)N TOU/TOIS DIAFORA=S A)DIA/RQRWTOS H( TOU= PW=S E)/XEIN KOI-NO/THS E)KFE/RETAI KAT' AU)TH=S. E)/PEITA TO\ KOINO\N TOU=TO PW=S E)/XEIN KAI\ TW=| U(PO-KEIME/NW| A(RMO/SEI KAI\ TW=| POSW=| MA/LISTA. KAI\ TAU=TA GA\R DIA/KEITAI/ PWS. @&10Dexippus in Aristot. categ. p. 5, 18 Busse [1de Aristotelis cate-&10goriis locutus%10$10]1 SXEDO\N GA\R KATANENO/HKA, W(S OU)/TE PLEI/OUS A)NTILOGI/AI EI)S @1 E(TE/RAN U(PO/QESIN GEGO/NASIN OU)/TE MEI/ZOUS A)GW=NES KEKI/NHNTAI OU) MO/NON <20TOI=S *STWI+KOI=S>20 KAI\ *PLATWNIKOI=S, SALEU/EIN E)PIXEIROU=SI TAU/TAS TA\S *)ARISTOTE/LOUS KATHGORI/AS&10 etc. &10@Plotinus Ennead. VI lib. I 25 [1Vol. II p. 256 Mu+.$10]1. PRO\S DE\ TOU\S TE/TTARA TIQE/NTAS [1&10scil.$10 GE/NH TOU= O)/NTOS]1 KAI\ TETRAXW=S DIAIROU=NTAS EI)S <20U(POKEI/MENA>20 KAI\ <20POIA\>20 KAI\ <20PW\S E)/XONTA>20 KAI\ <20PRO/S TI PW\S E)/XONTA>20 KAI\ KOINO/N TI E)P' AU)TW=N TIQE/NTAS KAI\ E(NI\ GE/NEI PERILAMBA/NONTAS TA\ PA/NTA, O(/TI ME\N KOINO/N TI KAI\ E)PI\ PA/NTWN E(\N GE/NOS LAMBA/NOUSI, POLLA\ A)/N TIS LE/GOI. KAI\ GA\R W(S A)SU/NETON AU)TOI=S KAI\ A)/LOGON TO\ "1TI\"2 <20TOU=TO>20 KAI\ OU)K E)FARMO/T-TON <20A)SWMA/TOIS KAI\ SW/MASI>20. KAI\ DIAFORA\S OU) KATALELOI/PASIN, AI(=S TO\ "1TI\"2 DIAIRH/SOUSI&10 etc. &10@Simplicius in Aristot. Phys. p. 94, 11 Diels.$10 DIO\ POLLAXW=S E)/FH TO\ O)/N [1&10scil. Aristoteles]1.$10 PLH\N O(/TI TA\ A)/LLA E)PI\ TH=| OU)SI/A| SUMBE/BHKE, KAQ' H(\N KAI\ XARAKTHRI/ZETAI TO\ U(POKEI/MENON, DIO\ OI( ME\N <20A)NH/|ROUN TA\ A)/LLA>20, KAQA/PER <20OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 E)POI/OUN PARA\ TA\ E)NARGH=, O( DE\ O(MOI/WS TH=| OU)SI/A| KAI\ TA)=LL' EI)PW\N EI)=NAI MA=LLON A(MARTA/NEI. @&10Plotinus Ennead. VI lib. I 25 [1Vol. II p. 256 Mu+.$10]1. AU)TH\N DE\ TH\N DIAI/RESIN E)PISKEPTE/ON: U(POKEI/MENA ME\N GA\R PRW=TA TA/CANTES KAI\ TH\N U(/LHN E)NTAU=QA TW=N A)/LLWN PROTA/CANTES, TH\N PRW/THN AU)TOI=S DOKOU=SAN A)RXH\N SUN-TA/TTOUSI TOI=S META\ TH\N A)RXH\N AU)TW=N__E)PEI\ KAI\ AU)TOI\ FH/SOUSI PARA\ TH=S U(/LHS, OI)=MAI, TOI=S A)/LLOIS TO\ EI)=NAI U(PA/RXEIN. E)/PEITA TO\ U(POKEI/MENON E(\N A)RIQMOU=NTES OU) TA\ O)/NTA E)CARIQMOU=NTAI, A)LL' A)RXA\S TW=N O)/NTWN ZHTOU=SI. DIA-FE/REI DE\ A)RXA\S LE/GEIN KAI\ AU)TA/. EI) DE\ O)\N ME\N MO/NON TH\N U(/LHN FH/SOUSI, TA\ D' A)/LLA PA/QH TH=S U(/LHS, OU)K E)XRH=N TOU= O)/NTOS KAI\ TW=N A)/LLWN E(/N TI GE/NOS PROTA/TTEIN: MA=LLON D' A)\N BE/LTION AU)TOI=S E)LE/GETO, EI) TO\ ME\N OU)SI/AN [2E)/FASAN]2, TA\ D' A)/LLA PA/QH, KAI\ DIH|ROU=NTO TAU=TA. TOU= DE\ KAI\ LE/GEIN "1TA\ ME\N U(POKEI/-MENA, TA\ DE\ TA\ A)/LLA"2, E(NO\S O)/NTOS TOU= U(POKEIME/NOU KAI\ DIAFORA\N OU)K E)/XON-TOS, A)LL' H)\ TW=| MEMERI/SQAI W(/SPER O)/GKON EI)S ME/RH [1KAI/TOI OU)DE\ MEMERI/SQAI TW=| SUNEXH= LE/GEIN TH\N OU)SI/AN]1 BE/LTION LE/GEIN H)=N "1TO\ ME\N U(POKEI/MENON."2 @&10Dexippus in Aristot. categ. p. 23, 25 Busse.$10 PRO\S TOU=TO TO\ A)PO/RHMA E)KEI=NO XRH\ PROSEIPEI=N, W(S E)/STI TO\ U(POKEI/MENON DITTO\N KAI\ KATA\ <20TOU\S A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 KAI\ KATA\ TOU\S PRESBUTE/ROUS: E(\N ME\N TO\ LEGO/MENON PRW=TON U(POKEI/MENON W(S H( A)/POIOS U(/LH, H(\N DUNA/MEI SW=MA *)ARISTOTE/LHS FHSI/, DEU/TERON DE\ U(POKEI/MENON TO\ POIO/N, O(\ KOINW=S H)\ I)DI/WS U(FI/STATAI: U(POKEI/MENON GA\R KAI\ O( XALKO\S KAI\ O( *SWKRA/THS TOI=S E)GGINOME/NOIS H)\ KATHGOROUME/NOIS KAT' AU)TW=N. TO\ GA\R U(POKEI/MENON KATA\ [2TO\]2 PRO/S TI LE/GESQAI E)DO/KEI [1TINI\ GA\R U(POKEI/MENON]1, H)/TOI DE\ A(PLW=S TW=N GINOME/NWN E)N AU)TW=| KAI\ KATHGOROUME/NWN AU)TOU= H)\ I)DI/WS: A(PLW=S ME\N GA\R U(POKEI/MENON PA=SI TOI=S GINOME/NOIS KAI\ KATH-GOROUME/NOIS H( PRW/TH| U(/LH, TISI\ DE\ U(POKEI/MENON GIGNOME/NOIS E)P' AU)TOU= KAI\ KATHGOROUME/NOIS O( XALKO\S KAI\ O( *SWKRA/THS. DU/O TOI/NUN U(POKEIME/NWN O)/NTWN POLLA\ TW=N E)GGINOME/NWN, W(S PRO\S TO\ PRW=TON U(POKEI/MENON E)N U(POKEIME/NW| O)/NTA, W(S PRO\S TO\ DEU/TERON OU)K H)=N E)N U(POKEIME/NW| A)LLA\ ME/RH AU)TOU=. @&10Plotinus Ennead. IV lib. VII 9 [1Vol. II p. 114 Mu+.$10]1. O(/TI DE\ KAI\ TA\ SW/MATA A)SWMA/TOIS DUNA/MESI DU/NATAI A(\ DU/NATAI, E)K TW=NDE DH=LON. O(MOLOGH/SOUSI GA\R E(/TERON POIO/THTA KAI\ POSO/THTA EI)=NAI KAI\ PA=N SW=MA POSO\N EI)=NAI KAI\ E)/TI OU) PA=N SW=MA POIO\N EI)=NAI, W(/SPER TH\N U(/LHN. TAU=TA DE\ O(MOLO- @1GOU=NTES TH\N POIO/THTA O(MOLOGH/SOUSIN, E(/TERON OU)=SAN POSOU=, E(/TERON SW/MATOS EI)=NAI. PW=S GA\R MH\ POSO\N OU)=SA SW=MA E)/STAI, EI)/PER PA=N SW=MA POSO/N; __ TO\ DE\ U(/LHN ME\N TH\N AU)TH\N EI)=NAI, SW=MA W(/S FASIN OU)=SAN, DIA/FORA DE\ POIEI=N POIO/THTAS PROSLABOU=SAN, PW=S OU) DH=LON POIEI=, TA\ PROSGENO/MENA LO/GOUS A)U/+LOUS KAI\ A)SWMA/TOUS EI)=NAI; @&10Plotinus Ennead. VI lib. I 29 [1Vol. II p. 260 Mu+.$10]1. TA\ DE\ POIA\ AU)TOI=S E(/TERA ME\N DEI= EI)=NAI TW=N U(POKEIME/NWN KAI\ LE/GOUSIN: OU) GA\R A)\N AU)TA\ DEU/TERA KATHRI/QMOUN. __EI) DE\ TA\ POIA\ U(/LHN POIA\N LE/GOIEN, PRW=TON ME\N OI( LO/GOI AU)TOI=S E)/NULOI, A)LL' OU)K E)N U(/LH| GENO/MENOI SU/NQETO/N TI POIH/SOUSIN, A)LLA\ PRO\ TOU= SUNQE/TOU, O(\ POIOU=SIN, E)C U(/LHS KAI\ EI)/DOUS E)/SONTAI: OU)K A)/RA AU)TOI\ EI)/DH OU)DE\ LO/GOI. EI) DE\ LE/GOIEN MHDE\N EI)=NAI TOU\S LO/GOUS H)\ U(/LHN PW\S E)/XOUSAN, TA\ POIA\ DH=LON O(/TI PW\S E)/XONTA E)ROU=SI, KAI\ E)N TW=| TETA/RTW| GE/NEI TAKTE/ON. EI) DE\ H(/DE H( SXE/SIS A)/LLH, TI/S H( DIAFORA/; H)\ DH=LON O(/TI TO\ PW\S E)/XEIN E)NTAU=QA U(PO/STASIS MA=LLON; @&10Galenus de qualitatibus incorporeis 1 Vol. XIX p. 463 K.$10 H)=N DE\ O( PERI\ TW=N POIOTH/TWN LO/GOS KAI\ TW=N SUMBEBHKO/TWN A(PA/NTWN, A(/ FASIN EI)=NAI <20*STWI+KW=N>20 PAI=DES SW/MATA. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 57 E. ed. Bas.$10 *OI( DE\ <20*STWI+KOI\>20 TO\ KOINO\N TH=S POIO/THTOS TO\ E)PI\ TW=N SWMA/TWN LE/GOUSI <20DIAFORA\N EI)=NAI OU)SI/AS, OU)K A)PODIALHPTH\N KAQ' E(AUTH/N, A)LL' EI)S E(\N NO/HMA KAI\ I)DIO/THTA A)POLH/GOUSAN>20, OU)/TE XRO/NW| OU)/TE I)SXU/I+ EI)DOPOIOUME/NHN, A)LLA\ TH=| E)C AU)TH=S TOIOUTO/THTI, KAQ' H(\N POIOU= U(FI/STATAI GE/NESIS. E)N DE\ TOU/TOIS EI) MH\ OI(=O/N TE, KATA\ TO\N E)KEI/NWN LO/GON, KOINO\N EI)=NAI SU/MPTWMA SWMA/TWN KAI\ A)SWMA/TWN, OU)KE/TI E)/STAI GE/NOS H( POIO/THS &10etc. &10@Alexander Aphrod. in Aristot. Topica IV p. 181 Ald. p. 360, 9 &10Wal.$10 A)NAIROI=TO A)\N TO\ TH\N POIO/THTA EI)=NAI PNEU=MA/ PWS E)/XON H)\ U(/LHN PWS E)/XOUSAN. _A)LLA\ KAI\ O( TH\N PUGMH\N LE/GWN EI)=NAI XEI=RA/ PWS E)/XOUSAN A(MAR-TA/NEI. OU) GA\R H( PUGMH\ XEI/R, A)LL' E)N U(POKEIME/NW| TH=| XEIRI\ H( PUGMH/. @&10Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 50 p. 1085e.$10 E)/TI TH\N ME\N OU)SI/AN KAI\ TH\N U(/LHN U(FESTA/NAI TAI=S POIO/THSI LE/GOUSI, W(S SXEDO\N OU(/TW TO\N O(/RON A)PODIDO/NAI: TA\S DE\ POIO/THTAS AU)= PA/LIN OU)SI/AS KAI\ SW/MATA POIOU=SI: TAU=TA DE\ POLLH\N E)/XEI TARAXH/N. EI) ME\N GA\R I)DI/AN OU)SI/AN OI( POIO/THTES E)/XOUSI KAQ' H(\N SW/MATA LE/GONTAI KAI/ EI)SIN, OU)X E(TE/RAS OU)SI/AS DEO/NTAI: TH\N GA\R AU(TW=N E)/XOUSIN. EI) DE\ TOU=TO MO/NON AU)TAI=S U(FE/STHKE TO\ KOINO/N, O(/PER OU)SI/AN OU(=TOI KAI\ U(/LHN KALOU=SI, DH=LON O(/TI SW/MATOS METE/XOUSI, SW/MATA D' OU)/K EI)SIN [2OU)D' OU)SI/AI]2: TO\ GA\R U(FESTW\S KAI\ DEXO/MENON DIAFE/REIN A)NA/GKH TW=N A(\ DE/XETAI KAI\ OI(=S U(FE/STHKEN. OI( DE\ TO\ H(/MISU BLE/POUSI: TH\N GA\R U(/LHN A)/POION O)NOMA/ZOUSI, TA\S DE\ POIO/THTAS OU)KE/TI BOU/LONTAI KALEI=N A)U/+LOUS.&10 p. 1086a$10 O(\N DE/ <20TINES AU)TW=N>20 PROBA/LLONTAI LO/GON, W(S A)/POION TH\N OU)SI/AN O)NOMA/ZONTES, OU)X O(/TI PA/SHS E)STE/RHTAI POIO/THTOS A)LL' O(/TI PA/SAS E)/XEI TA\S POIO/THTAS, MA/LISTA PARA\ TH\N E)/NNOIA/N E)STIN. @1 @&10Galenus de qualitatibus incorporeis 10. Vol. XIX p. 483 K.$10 EI)/ TE KAI\ TW=N SUMBEBHKO/TWN E(/KASTON SW=MA/ E)STI, TI/ BOULO/MENOI TO\ SW=MA MO/NON FASI\N E)P' A)/PEIRON TE/MNESQAI, OU)XI\ DE\ KAI\ TO\ SXH=MA FE/RE KAI\ TH\N GLUKU/THTA KAI\ TW=N A)/LLWN E(/KASTON, OU) TW=| KATA\ SUMPLOKH\N TRO/PW|, FHMI/, OU)DE\ KAT' A)NAFORA\N E)PI\ TO\ SUNH/QWS KALOU/MENON SW=MA, A)LL' A)P' EU)QEI/AS; DIA\ TI/ DE\ MO/NOU, KAQA/PER E)/FHN, TOU= SW/MATOS TOU=TON O(/RON EI)=NAI/ FASIN, TO\ TRIXH=| DIA-STATO\N META\ A)NTITUPI/AS, OU)XI\ DE\ KAI\ XRO/AN KAI\ XULO\N KAI\ XUMO\N KAI\ TW=N LOIPW=N SUMBEBHKO/TWN E(/KASTON OU(/TWS O(RI/ZONTAI; EI) DE\ SW/MA[2TA]2 PA/NTA TAU=T' EI)=NAI/ FASI [1<20KA)\N GA\R E)P' EI)/DOUS DIAFE/RH|>20, KOINW=S GE KAI\ PA/NTA SW/MATA EI)=NAI/ FASIN]1__TW=N SUMBEBHKO/TWN E(/KASTON O(RIZO/MENOI LEGE/TWSAN OU)SI/AN SWMATIKH\N TRIXH=| DIASTATH\N META\ A)NTITUPI/AS. @&10Galenus de qualitatibus incorporeis 3. 4 Vol. XIX p. 471 K.$10 E)PITEI/NETAI DE\ TO\ A)/PORON TOU= LO/GOU, EI) KAI\ TO\ MH=KOS TOU= SW/MATOS SW=MA/ E)STI KAI\ TO\ PLA/TOS KAI\ TO\ BA/QOS. A(/MA GA\R A)/PEIROI, FHMI/, SWMA/TWN A)PEI-RI/AI GENH/SONTAI E)N BRAXEI= KATA\ PERIGRAFH\N PRO\S AI)/SQHSIN TO/PW|. TO/ TE TW=N POLLW=N TOU/TWN, MA=LLON DE\ A)PEI/RWN SWMA/TWN PLH=QOS A)=RA/ GE OU)=N A)I/+DION; KAI\ PW=S E)/TI FH/SOUSIN A)/POION TH\N PRW/THN OU)SI/AN; E)C H(=S FASI TO/N TE KO/SMON KAI\ TW=N E)PI\ ME/ROUS EI)DW=N E(/KASTON GEGONE/NAI. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 69$10 *G.&10 ed. Bas.$10 A)LL' OU)DE\ H( TW=N <20*STWI+KW=N>20 DO/CA, LEGO/NTWN SW/MATA EI)=NAI TA\ SXH/MATA, W(/SPER KAI\ TA\ A)/LLA POIA/, SUMFWNEI= TH=| *)ARISTOTE/LOUS DO/CH|. @&10Galenus de qualitatibus incorporeis 2 Vol. XIX p. 467 K. [1post-&10quam probare studuit$10 MH=KOS, PLA/TOS, BA/QOS, BA/ROS, SXH=MA &10non esse cor-&10pora$10]1 O( D' O(/MOIOS E)PI\ TW=N LOIPW=N SUMBEBHKO/TWN LO/GOS, XRWMA/TWN TE KAI\ XUMW=N KAI\ TW=N PRO\S O)/SFRHSIN KAI\ TW=N PRO\S A)KOH/N, FWNW=N, LO/GWN, SURIG-MW=N, MUGMW=N, POPPUSMW=N, STENAGMW=N, R(WXMW=N, R(OGXASMW=N, BO/MBWN, H)/XWN, YO/FWN: EI) DE\ LE/GOI TIS TAU=TA/ TE KAI\ TA\ TOIAU=TA PA/NTA U(PA/RXEIN A)E/RA PEPLHGME/NON PWS, KALO\N E)PEIPEI=N AU)TW=| TO\ *MENA/NDREION @"1TAU=TA/ S' A)POLW/LEKEN, W)= PONHRE/"2 TO\ MH\ DI/XA SW/MATOS NOEI=SQAI/ TI TOIOU=TO. __OU)/KOUN OU)DE\ PLHGH\ TOU= A)E/ROS A)H/R E)STIN &10etc. &10@Galenus de qualitatibus incorporeis 6 Vol. XIX p. 480 K.$10 KA)-KEI=NA LOIPO\N TOI=S FILONI/KOIS A)NDRA/SIN OU)K A)/TOPA; KAI\ GA\R TA\S KINH/SEIS, AI(\ PROSGI/GNONTAI TOI=S SW/MASIN KAI\ PA/LIN A)POGI/GNONTAI, SW/MAT' EI)=NAI/ FASIN. __A)LL' EI) ME\N TW=| KATA\ A)NAFORA\N TRO/PW| TH=S KLH/SEWS OU(/TWS E)KA/LOUN, OU)D' A)\N OU)D' AU)TO\S E)XALE/PAINON AU)TOI=S. _EI) DE\ PRW/TWS KAI\ KURI/WS, A(MAR-TA/NOUSIN. @&10Galenus de qualitatibus incorporeis 4. Vol. XIX p. 473 K.$10 [2PW=S D' EI)]2 KAI\ TO\ FW=S E)STI SW=MA KAI\ H( LEUKO/THS KAI\ H( QERMO/THS, PA=N DE\ SW=MA POSO/N E)STI KAI\ PHLI/KON KAI\ SUNAUCHTIKH\N FU/SIN E)/XEI, TO\ KATAUGASQE\N KAI\ @1 QERMANQE\N U(/DWR U(PO\ H(LI/OU [2OU)]2 PLEI=O/N TE KAI\ MEI=ZON GI/GNETAI KAI\ DIA\ TOU=TO MEI/ZONOS DEI=TAI TO/POU. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. IV 20,2.$10 <20*OI( DE\ *STWI+KOI\>20 SW=MA TH\N <20FWNH/N>20: PA=N GA\R TO\ DRW=N H)\ KAI\ POIOU=N SW=MA: H( DE\ FWNH\ POIEI= KAI\ DRA=|: A)KOU/OMEN GA\R AU)TH=S KAI\ AI)SQANO/MEQA PROSPIPTOU/SHS TH=| A)KOH=| KAI\ E)KTUPOU/SHS KAQA/PER DAKTULI/OU EI)S KHRO/N. E)/TI PA=N TO\ KINOU=N KAI\ E)NOXLOU=N SW=MA/ E)STI: KINEI= DE\ H(MA=S H( EU)MOUSI/A, E)NOXLEI= DE\ H( A)MOUSI/A. E)/TI PA=N TO\ KINOU/MENON SW=MA/ E)STI: KINEI=TAI DE\ H( FWNH\ KAI\ PROSPI/PTEI EI)S TOU\S LEI/OUS TO/POUS KAI\ A)NTANAKLA=TAI KAQA/PER E)PI\ TH=S SFAI/RAS TH=S BALLOME/NHS EI)S TOI=XON: E)N GOU=N TAI=S KAT' *AI)/GUPTON PURAMI/SIN E)/NDON MI/A FWNH\ R(HGNUME/NH TE/TTARAS H)\ KAI\ PE/NTE H)/XOUS A)PERGA/ZETAI. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. categorias f. 54 B. ed. Bas.$10 OI( DE\ TINA\S ME\N A)NH/|ROUN POIO/THTAS, TINA\S DE\ KATELI/MPANON. TW=N DE\ U(PO/STASIN AU)TAI=S DIDO/NTWN, OI( ME\N PA/SAS H(GOU=NTO A)SWMA/TOUS, W(/SPER OI( A)RXAI=OI: OI( DE\ TW=N ME\N A)SWMA/TWN A)SWMA/TOUS, TW=N DE\ SWMA/TWN SWMATIKA\S W(/SPER <20OI( *STWI+KOI/>20. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 56$10 *D &10ed. Bas.$10 *OI( DE\ <20*STWI+KOI\>20 TW=N ME\N SWMA/TWN SWMATIKA/S, TW=N DE\ A)SWMA/TWN A)SWMA/TOUS EI)=NAI LE/GOUSI TA\S POIO/THTAS. SFA/LLONTAI DE\ A)PO\ TOU= H(GEI=SQAI TA\ AI)/TIA TOI=S A)POTELOU-ME/NOIS A)F' E(AUTW=N O(MOOU/SIA EI)=NAI KAI\ A)PO\ TOU= KOINO\N LO/GON TH=S AI)TI/AS E)PI/ TE TW=N SWMA/TWN KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N A)SWMA/TWN U(POTI/QESQAI. <20PW=S DE\ KAI\ PNEU-MATIKH\ H( OU)SI/A E)/STAI TW=N SWMATIKW=N POIOTH/TWN>20, AU)TOU= TOU= PNEU/-MATOS SUNQE/TOU O)/NTOS KAI\ E)K PLEIO/NWN SUNESTHKO/TOS, MERISTOU= TE U(PA/RXONTOS KAI\ E)PI/KTHTON E)/XONTOS TH\N E(/NWSIN, W(/STE OU) KAT' OU)SI/AN E)/XEIN TO\ SUNHNW=SQAI OU)DE\ PRW/TWS A)F' E(AUTOU=; PW=S OU)=N A)\N TOI=S A)/LLOIS TOU=TO PARE/XOI TO\ SUN-E/XESQAI; @&10Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 55 A ed. Bas.$10 *KAI\ EI) O( *)ARISTO-TE/LHS ME\N KAI\ TA\ E(KTA\ KAI\ TA\S E)NERGEI/AS PERI\ H(MA=S A)POLEI/PEI, OI( DE\ E)C *)AKADHMI/AS A)MFO/TERA E)KTO/S, OI( DE\ <20*STWI+KOI\>20 TA\ ME\N E(KTA\ PERI\ H(MA=S, TA\ DE\ E)NERGH/MATA KAI\ TA\ POIH/MATA E)KTO/S, SUGXE/ANTES TA\S DU/O DO/CAS, SUMFW/NWS E(AUTW=| O( *)ARISTOTE/LHS SUNH=YE TH=| POIO/THTI TO\ POIO/N, W(S O)/NTA A)MFO/TERA PERI\ H(MA=S. TW=N DE\ <20*STWI+KW=N>20 TINES, TRIXW=S TO\ POIO\N A)FORIZO/MENOI, TA\ ME\N DU/O SHMAINO/MENA E)PIPLE/ON TH=S POIO/THTOS LE/GOUSI: TO\ DE\ E(\N H)/TOI E(NO\S ME/ROS SUN-APARTI/ZEIN AU)TH=| FASI. LE/GOUSI GA\R POIO\N <20KAQ' E(\N ME\N SHMAINO/MENON PA=N TO\ KATA\ DIAFORA/N>20, EI)/TE KINOU/MENON EI)/H EI)/TE E)XO/MENON: KAI\ EI)/TE DUS-ANALU/TWS EI)/TE EU)ANALU/TWS E)/XEI. KATA\ TOU=TO DE\ OU) MO/NON O( FRO/NIMOS KAI\ O( PU\C PROTEI/NWN, A)LLA\ KAI\ O( TRE/XWN POIOI/. <20KAQ' E(/TERON DE\>20 KAQ' O(\ OU)KE/TI TA\S KINH/SEIS PERIELA/MBANON, A)LLA\ MO/NON TA\S SXE/SEIS: O(\ DH\ KAI\ W(RI/ZONTO TO\ <20I)SXO/MENON KATA\ DIAFORA/N>20, OI(=O/S E)STIN O( FRO/NIMOS KAI\ O( PROBEBLHME/NOS. KAI\ TOU/TWN DE\ TW=N E)MMO/NWS I)SXOME/NWN KATA\ DIAFORA\N OI( ME\N A)PHRTISME/NWS KATA\ TH\N E)KFORA\N AU)TW=N KAI\ TH\N E)PI/NOIAN EI)SI\ TOIOU=TOI, OI( DE\ OU)K A)PHRTISME/NWS. KAI\ TOU/TOUS ME\N PARH|TOU=NTO: <20TOU\S DE\ A)PARTI/ZONTAS KAI\ E)MMO/NOUS O)/NTAS KATA\ DIAFORA\N POIOU\S E)TI/QENTO>20. A)PARTI/ZEIN DE\ KATA\ TH\N E)KFORA\N E)/LEGON TOU\S TH=| POIO/THTI SUNECISOUME/NOUS, W(S TO\N GRAM-MATIKO\N KAI\ TO\N FRO/NIMON. OU)/TE GA\R PLEONA/ZEI OU)/TE E)LLEI/PEI TOU/TWN E(KA/TEROS PARA\ TH\N POIO/THTA: O(MOI/WS DE\ KAI\ O( FI/LOYOS KAI\ O( FI/LOINOS. OI( ME/NTOI PERI\ TA\S E)NERGEI/AS TOIOU=TOI, W(/SPER O( O)YOFA/GOS KAI\ O( OI)NO/FLUC, E)/XONTES ME/RH @1 TOIAU=TA, DI' W(=N A)POLAU/OUSIN, OU(/TWS LE/GONTAI. DIO\ KAI\ EI) ME/N TIS O)YOFA/GOS, KAI\ FI/LOYOS PA/NTWS: EI) DE\ FI/LOYOS, OU) PA/NTWS O)YOFA/GOS. E)PILEIPO/NTWN GA\R TW=N MERW=N DI' W(=N O)YOFAGEI=, TH=S ME\N O)YOFAGI/AS A)POLE/LUTAI, TH\N DE\ FI/LOYON E(/CIN OU)K A)NH/|RHKE. TRIXW=S OU)=N TOU= POIOU= LEGOME/NOU, H( POIO/THS KATA\ TO\ TELEUTAI=ON POIO\N SUNAPARTI/ZEI PRO\S TO\ POIO/N. DIO\ KAI\ O(/TAN <20O(RI/-ZWNTAI TH\N POIO/THTA SXE/SIN POIOU=>20, OU(/TWS A)KOUSTE/ON TOU= O(/ROU, W(S TOU= TRI/TOU POIOU= PARALAMBANOME/NOU. MONAXW=S ME\N GA\R H( POIO/THS LE/GETAI KAT' AU)TOU\S TOU\S <20*STWI+KOU/S>20, TRIXW=S DE\ O( POIO/S. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 55 E ed. Bas.$10 *KAI\ <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 DE\ KATA\ TA\S AU(TW=N U(POQE/SEIS TH\N AU)TH\N A)\N A)PORI/AN PROSAGA/GOIEN TW=| LE/-GONTI LO/GW|, KATA\ POIO/THTA PA/NTA TA\ POIA\ LE/GESQAI. TA\S GA\R POIO/THTAS E(KTA\ LE/GONTES OU(=TOI, <20E)PI\ TW=N H(NWME/NWN MO/NWN E(KTA\ A)POLEI/POUSIN>20: E)PI\ DE\ TW=N KATA\ SUNAFH/N, OI(=ON NEW/S, KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N KATA\ DIA/STASIN, OI(=ON STRATOU=, MHDE\N EI)=NAI E(KTO/N, MHDE\ EU(RI/SKESQAI PNEUMATIKO/N TI E(\N E)P' AU)TW=N MHDE\ E(/NA LO/GON E)/XON, W(/STE E)PI/ TINA U(PO/STASIN E)LQEI=N MIA=S E(/CEWS. TO\ DE\ POIO\N KAI\ E)N TOI=S E)K SUNAPTOME/NWN QEWREI=TAI KAI\ E)N TOI=S E)K DIESTW/TWN. W(S GA\R EI(=S GRAMMATIKO\S E)K POIA=S A)NALH/YEWS KAI\ SUGGUMNASI/AS E)MMO/NWS E)/XEI KATA\ DIAFORA/N, OU(/TWS KAI\ O( XORO\S E)K POIA=S MELE/THS E)MMO/NWS E)/XEI KATA\ DIA-FORA/N. DIO\ POIA\ ME\N U(PA/RXEI DIA\ TH\N KATA/TACIN KAI\ TH\N PRO\S E(\N E)/RGON SUNE/RGEIAN: DI/XA DE\ POIO/THTO/S E)STI POIA/. E(/CIS GA\R E)N TOU/TOIS OU)K E)/STIN: OU)DE\ GA\R O(/LWS E)N DIESTW/SAIS OU)SI/AIS KAI\ MHDEMI/AN E)XOU/SAIS SUMFUH= PRO\S A)LLH/LAS E(/NWSI/N E)STI POIO/THS H)\ E(/CIS. EI) DE\ POIOU= O)/NTOS OU)K E)/STI POIO/THS, OU) SUNAPARTI/ZEIN TAU=TA A)LLH/LOIS FAI=EN A)/N, OU)DE\ DUNATO/N E)STI DIA\ TOU= POIOU= TH\N POIO/THTA A)PODI/DOSQAI. PRO\S DE\ TAU=TA DUNATO\N ME\N LE/GEIN, W(S A)SW/MATON O)\N TO\ EI)=DOS E(\N KAI\ TO\ AU)TO\ DIATEI/NEI E)PI\ TOI=S POLLOI=S, PANTAXOU= TO\ AU)TO\ U(PA/RXON O(/LON. EI) DE\ TOU=TO, E)/STAI KAI\ POIO/THS MI/A DIH/KOUSA DIA\ TW=N DIESTH-KO/TWN KAI\ SUNAPTOME/NWN POIW=N. EI) ME/NTOI TOIAU/THN TIS TH\N U(PO/QESIN W(S A)PECENWME/NHN TH\S <20*STWI+KH=S AI(RE/SEWS MH\>20 PROSDE/XOITO, E)/STIN I)SXURW=S A)PO-MA/XESQAI&10 etc. &10@Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 70 E ed. Bas.$10 KAI\ OI( <20*STWI+KOI\>20 DE\ POIO/THTAS POIOTH/TWN POIOU=SIN, E(AUTW=N POIOU=NTES E(KTA\S E(/CEIS. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 61 B ed. bas.$10 *)/ACION DE\ KAI\ TH\N <20TW=N *STWI+KW=N>20 SUNH/QEIAN PA/NTWN PERI\ TA\ O)NO/MATA TAU=TA KATAMAQEI=N. DO-KOU=SI GA\R OU(=TOI TISI\N A)NA/PALIN TW=| *)ARISTOTE/LEI TH\N DIA/QESIN TH=S E(/CEWS MONI-MWTE/RAN H(GEI=SQAI. TO\ DE\ A)FORMH\N ME\N E)/XEI TH=S TOIAU/THS U(PONOI/AS, OU) ME/N-TOI KATA\ TO\ MONIMW/TERON H)\ MH\ PARA\ TOI=S <20*STWI+KOI=S>20 H( TOU/TWN EI)/LHPTAI DIAFORA/, A)LLA\ KAT' A)/LLAS DIAQE/SEIS. KAI\ GA\R TA\S ME\N E(/CEIS E)PITEI/NESQAI/ FASI DU/NASQAI KAI\ A)NI/ESQAI: TA\S DE\ DIAQE/SEIS A)NEPITA/TOUS EI)=NAI KAI\ A)NA-NE/TOUS. DIO\ KAI\ TH\N EU)QU/THTA TH=S R(A/BDOU, KA)\N EU)META/BOLOS H)=|, DUNAME/NH KA/MPTESQAI, DIA/QESIN EI)=NAI/ FASI. MH\ GA\R A)NEQH=NAI H)\ E)PITAQH=NAI TH\N EU)-QU/THTA MHDE\ E)/XEIN TO\ MA=LLON H)\ H(=TTON, DIO/PER EI)=NAI DIA/QESIN. OU(TWSI\ DE\ KAI\ TA\S A)RETA\S DIAQE/SEIS EI)=NAI, OU) KATA\ TO\ MO/NIMON I)DI/WMA, A)LLA\ KATA\ TO\ A)NEPI/TATON KAI\ A)NEPI/DEKTON TOU= MA=LLON: TA\S DE\ TE/XNAS KAI/TOI DUSKINH/TOUS OU)/SAS [H)\] MH\ EI)=NAI DIAQE/SEIS. KAI\ E)OI/KASI TH\N ME\N E(/CIN E)N TW=| PLA/TEI TOU= EI)/DOUS QEWREI=N: TH\N DE\ DIA/QESIN E)N TW=| TE/LEI TOU= EI)/DOUS KAI\ E)N TW=| MA/LISTA, @1 EI)/TE KINOI=TO KAI\ METABA/LLOI, W(S TO\ EU)QU\ TH=S R(A/BDOU, EI)/TE KAI\ MH/. MA=LLON D' E)XRH=N E)KEI=NO E)PISTH=SAI, MH\ H( PARA\ <20TOI=S *STWI+KOI=S>20 SXE/SIS H( AU)TH/ E)STI TH=| PARA\ *)ARISTOTE/LEI DIAQE/SEI, KATA\ TO\ EU)ANA/LUTON KAI\ DUSANA/LUTON DII+STA-ME/NH PRO\S TH\N E(/CIN: A)LL' OU)DE\ OU(/TWS SUMFWNOU=SIN. O( ME\N GA\R *)ARISTOTE/LHS TH\N A)BE/BAION U(GEI/AN DIA/QESIN EI)=NAI/ FHSIN: OI( DE\ A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S TH\N U(GEI/AN, O(/PWS A)\N E)/XH|, OU) SUGXWROU=SI SXE/SIN EI)=NAI: FE/REIN GA\R TO\ TH=S E(/CEWS I)DI/WMA. TA\S ME\N GA\R SXE/SEIS TAI=S E)PIKTH/TOIS KATASTA/SESI XARAKTHRI/ZESQAI, TA\S DE\ E(/CEIS TAI=S E)C E(AUTW=N E)NERGEI/AIS. O(/QEN OU)DE\ XRO/NOU MH/KEI H)\ I)SXU/I+ EI)DOPOI-OU=NTAI AI( E(/CEIS KAT' AU)TOU/S, I)DIO/THTI DE/ TINI KAI\ XARAKTH=RI. KAI\ W(/SPER TA\ E)R)R(IZWME/NA MA=LLON KAI\ H(=TTON E)R)R(I/ZWTAI, E(\N DE\ E)/XEI TO\ KOINO\N I)DI/WMA, TO\ A)NTE/XESQAI TH=S GH=S, OU(/TW KAI\ H( E(/CIS E)PI\ TW=N DUSKINH/TWN KAI\ EU)KINH/TWN H( AU)TH\ QEWREI=TAI. O(/LWS GA\R TW=| GE/NEI POLLA\ POIA\ O)/NTA, E)KLELUME/NON E)KEI=NO TO\ I)DI/WMA E)/XEI KAQO\ EI)DOPOIEI=TAI, W(S O( AU)STHRO\S OI)=NOS KAI\ A)MU/GDALA PIKRA\ KAI\ MOLOTTIKO\S KU/WN KAI\ MELITAI=OS, OI(=S PA=SI ME/TESTI ME\N O( GENIKO\S XARAKTH/R, E)PI\ BRAXU\ DE\ KAI\ A)NEIME/NWS, KAI\ O(/SON E)P' AU)TOI=S TOI=S E)N TH=| E(/CEI LO/GOIS E)PI-ME/NEI E)PI\ MIA=S KATASTA/SEWS AU(/TH, TO\ DE\ EU)KI/NHTON POLLA/KIS E)C A)/LLHS AI)TI/AS E)/XEI. DIO/PER OI( <20*STWI+KOI\>20 DIATEI/NOUSI TA\S E(/CEIS KOINO/TERON KAI\ E)PI\ TA\S EU)-KINH/TOUS A(\S LE/GEI O( *)ARISTOTE/LHS DIAQE/SEIS, KAI\ TAU/TAS H(GOU=NTAI POLU\ DIENH-NOXE/NAI TH=S SXE/SEWS. H( GA\R TOU= A)NALAMBA/NONTOS TH\N U(GI/EIAN E(/CIS KAQI/SEWS KAI\ PROBOLH=S KAI\ TW=N TOIOU/TWN SXE/SEWN PA/NTH DIE/STHKEN. AI( ME\N GA\R A)/R)-R(IZOI KAI\ A)PAGEI=S EI)SIN: TA\S DE\ OU(/TWS U(FESTHKE/NAI FASI/N, W(/STE A)FEQEI/SAS DIAME/NEIN O(/SON E)F' E(AUTAI=S DU/NASQAI, TO\ E)/MMONON E)C E(AUTW=N KAI\ TOU= OI)KEI/OU LO/GOU PAREXOME/NAS. DIA\ TAU=TA OU)DE\ H( O(PWSOU=N DUSANA/LUTOS SXE/SIS LE/GETAI E(/CIS PAR' AU)TOI=S. EI) GA\R E)/CWQEN E)/XEI TO\ DUSANA/LUTON, W(/SPER O( DAKTU/LIOS E)N DAKTULH/QRA| W)/N, OU)K A)\N EI)/H E)N E(/CEI TH=S TOIAU/THS KATASTA/SEWS, A)LL' EI) A)F' E(AUTOU= TH\N E)NE/RGEIAN PARE/XOITO TOU= EI)=NAI TOIO/NDE, TO/TE A)\N EI)/H E)N E(/CEI, W(/SPER O( PHLO\S EI)S O)/STRAKON METABALW/N. AU)TO\S GA\R A)F' E(AUTOU= TOIO/SDE GE/-GONEN. A)LLA\ TAU=TA ME\N OU(/TWS I(STOREI/SQW. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de anima p. 17, 15 Bruns.$10 A)LL' OU)DE\ KATA\ TOU\S LE/GONTAS PA=N SW=MA H)\ U(/LHN H)\ E)C U(/LHS EI)=NAI [1W(S TOI=S <20A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 DOKEI=]1 EI)/H A)\N TO\ EI)=DOS SW=MA. @&10p. 17, 21.$10 EI) GA\R OU(/TWS LE/GOIEN TO\ EI)=DOS E)C U(/LHS TE KAI\ EI)/DOUS, OU)X W(S E)C A)/LLOU TINO\S EI)/DOUS, A)LL' W(S AU)TOU= SU\N U(/LH| TO\ EI)=NAI E)/XONTOS, OU)D' A)\N H( U(/LH KAT' AU)TOU\S A)/POIOS EI)/H KATA\ TO\N AU(TH=S LO/GON &10etc. &10@p. 18, 7.$10 E)/TI DE\ PW=S OU)K A)/TOPON TO\ TH\N U(/LHN LE/GEIN E)N TW=| TO\ EI)=DOS KAI\ TH\N POIO/THTA LAMBA/NEIN KAI\ U(/LHN TINA PROSLAMBA/NEIN; O(\ A)NAGKAI=O/N E)STI LE/GEIN TOI=S TO\ EI)=DO/S TE KAI\ TH\N POIO/THTA SW=MA E)/NULON LE/GOUSIN. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. de anima p. 217, 36 Hayd.$10 EI)/ GE KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N SUNQE/TWN TO\ A)TOMWQE\N U(PA/RXEI EI)=DOS, <20KAQ' O(\ I)DI/WS PARA\ TOI=S E)K TH=S *STOA=S LE/GETAI POIO/N>20, O(\ KAI\ A)QRO/WS E)PIGI/NETAI KAI\ AU)= A)POGI/NE-TAI KAI\ TO\ AU)TO\ E)N PANTI\ TW=| TOU= SUNQE/TOU BI/W| DIAME/NEI, KAI/TOI TW=N MORI/WN A)/LLWN A)/LLOTE GINOME/NWN TE KAI\ FQEIROME/NWN. @1 @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 36 p. 1077d.$ E)KEI=NA D' O)/NTWS PARA\ TH\N E)/NNOIA/N E)STIN, A(\ LE/GOUSIN OU(=TOI KAI\ PLA/TTOUSIN "1E)PI\ MIA=S OU)SI/AS DU/O I)DI/WS GENE/SQAI POIOU\S KAI\ TH\N AU)TH\N OU)SI/AN E(/NA POIO\N I)DI/WS E)/XOUSAN E)PIO/NTOS E(TE/ROU DE/XESQAI KAI\ DIAFULA/TTEIN O(MOI/WS A)MFOTE/ROUS."2 @&Philo de incorrupt. mund. 236, 6 B.$8 <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 GOU=N O( DOKIMW/TATOS TW=N PAR' AU)TOI=S <20E)N TOI=S PERI\ *AU)CANOME/NOU>20 TERATEU/ETAI/ TI TOIOU=TON: PROKATASKEUA/SAS O(/TI DU/O I)DI/WS POIOU\S E)PI\ TH=S AU)TH=S OU)-SI/AS A)MH/XANON SUSTH=NAI, FHSI/N: @"1<20*)/ESTW QEWRI/AS E(/NEKA TO\N ME/N TINA O(LO/KLHRON, TO\N DE\ XWRI\S E)PINOEI=SQAI TOU= E(TE/ROU PODO/S, KALEI=SQAI DE\ TO\N ME\N O(LO/KLHRON *DI/WNA, TO\N DE\ A)TELH= *QE/WNA, KA)/PEITA A)POTE/MNESQAI *DI/WNOS TO\N E(/TERON TOI=N PODOI=N>20."2 @*ZHTOUME/NOU DH\ PO/TEROS E)/FQARTAI, TO\N *QE/WNA FA/SKEIN OI)KEIO/TERON EI)=NAI. TOU=TO DE\ PARADOCOLOGOU=NTOS MA=LLO/N E)STIN H)\ A)LHQEU/ONTOS. PW=S GA\R O( ME\N OU)DE\N A)KRWTHRIASQEI\S ME/ROS, O( *QE/WN, A)NH/RPASTAI, O( D' A)PO-KOPEI\S TO\N PO/DA *DI/WN OU)XI\ DIE/FQARTAI; @"1<20*DEO/NTWS, FHSI/N, A)NADEDRA/MHKE GA\R O( E)KTMHQEI\S TO\N PO/DA *DI/WN E)PI\ TH\N A)TELH= TOU= *QE/WNOS OU)SI/AN, KAI\ DU/O I)DI/WS POIOI\ PERI\ TO\ AU)TO\ U(POKEI/MENON OU) DU/NANTAI EI)=NAI. TOIGAR-OU=N TO\N ME\N *DI/WNA ME/NEIN A)NAGKAI=ON, TO\N DE\ *QE/WNA DIE-FQA/RQAI>20."2 @&10Syrianus in Aristot. Metaphys. Acad. [1Aristot. V 852&14a&10 3$10]1. KAI\ <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 DE\ TOU\S KOINW=S POIOU\S PRO\ TW=N I)DI/WS POIW=N A)POTI/QENTAI. @&10Dexippus in Aristot. categ. p. 34, 19 Busse.$10 EI) DE/ TIS EI)S TO\ PW\S E)/XON SUNTA/TTOI TA\S PLEI/STAS KATHGORI/AS, W(/SPER <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 POIOU=SIN, E)PIDEIKTE/ON AU)TOI=S, O(/TI PLEI=STA PARALEI/POUSI TW=N O)/NTWN, TA/ TE E)N TO/PW| KAI\ TA\ E)N XRO/NW| KAI\ KAT' A)RIQMO\N POSA\ KAI\ KATA\ PHLI/KON KAI\ TO\ U(PODEDE/SQAI KAI\ A)/LLA TOIAU=TA: OU)DE\N GA\R O(/,TI TW=N TOIOU/TWN PERIE/XETAI E)N TW=| PW\S E)/XONTI. @&10Plotinus Ennead. VI lib. I, 30 [1Vol. II p. 261 Mu+.$10]1. E)N DE\ TOI=S PW\S E)/XOUSIN A)/TOPON ME\N I)/SWS TA\ PW\S E)/XONTA TRI/TA TI/QESQAI H)\ O(PWSOU=N TA/CEWS E)/XEI, E)PEIDH\ PERI\ TH\N U(/LHN PW\S E)/XONTA PA/NTA. A)LLA\ DIAFORA\N TW=N PW\S E)XO/NTWN FH/SOUSIN EI)=NAI KAI\ <20A)/LLWS PW\S E)/XEIN TH\N U(/LHN W(DI\ KAI\ @1 OU(/TWS, A)/LLWS DE\ E)N TOI=S PW\S E)/XOUSI>20: KAI\ E)/TI <20TA\ ME\N POIA\ PERI\ TH\N U(/LHN PW\S E)/XONTA, TA\ I)DI/WS DE\ PW\S E)/XONTA PERI\ TA\ POIA/>20. A)LLA\ TW=N POIW=N AU)TW=N OU)DE\N H)\ U(/LHS PW\S E)XOU/SHS O)/NTWN, PA/LIN TA\ PW\S E)/XONTA E)PI\ TH\N U(/LHN AU)TOI=S A)NATRE/XEI KAI\ PERI\ TH\N U(/LHN E)/STAI. PW=S DE\ E(\N TO\ PW\S E)/XON, POLLH=S DIAFORA=S E)N AU)TOI=S OU)/SHS; PW=S GA\R TO\ TRI/PHXU KAI\ TO\ LEUKO\N EI)S E(/N, TOU= ME\N POSOU=, TOU= DE\ POIOU= O)/NTOS; PW=S DE\ TO\ "1PO/TE"2 KAI\ TO\ "1POU="2; PW=S DE\ O(/LWS PW\S E)/XONTA TO\ XQE\S KAI\ TO\ PE/RUSI KAI\ TO\ E)N *LUKEI/W| KAI\ [2E)N]2 *)AKADHMI/A|; KAI\ O(/LWS PW=S [DE\] O( XRO/NOS PW\S E)/XWN; OU)/TE GA\R AU)TO\S OU)/TE TA\ E)N AU)TW=| [TW=| XRO/NW|] OU)/TE O( TO/POS OU)/TE TA\ E)N TW=| TO/PW|. TO\ DE\ POIEI=N PW=S PW\S E)/XON; __I)/SWS D' A)\N MO/NON A(RMO/SEI[2E]2 E)PI\ TOU= KEI=SQAI TO\ PW\S E)/XON KAI\ E)PI\ TOU= E)/XEIN. E)PI\ DE\ TOU= E)/XEIN OU) PW\S E)/XON A)LLA\ E)/XON. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 94 E ed. Bas.$10 TW=N DE\ A)PO\ TH=S <20*STOA=S>20 A)CIOU/NTWN EI)S TO\ "1PW=S E)/XEIN"2 A)NAFE/REIN TO\ "1E)/XEIN"2 O( *BOHQO\S E)NANTIOU=TAI &10etc. &10@Plotinus Ennead. VI lib. I 3o.$10 TO\ DE\ "1PRO/S TI"2 EI) ME\N MH\ U(F' E(\N TOI=S A)/LLOIS E)TI/QESAN, E(/TEROS LO/GOS H)=N A)\N ZHTOU/NTWN, EI)/ TINA DIDO/ASIN U(PO/STASIN TAI=S TOIAU/TAIS SXE/SESI, POLLAXOU= OU) DIDO/NTWN: EI) D' E)N GE/NEI TW=| AU)TW=|, E)PIGENO/MENON PRA=GMA TOI=S H)/DH OU)=SIN, A)/TOPON SUNTA/TTEIN TO\ E)PIGIGNO/-MENON EI)S TAU)TO\N GE/NOS TOI=S PRO/TERON OU)=SI. DEI= GA\R PRO/TERON E(\N KAI\ DU/O EI)=NAI, I(/NA KAI\ H(/MISU KAI\ DIPLA/SION. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. categor. f. 42 E ed. Bas.$10 *OI( DE\ <20*STWI+KOI\>20 A)NQ' E(NO\S GE/NOUS DU/O KATA\ TO\N TO/PON TOU=TON A)RIQMOU=NTAI, TA\ ME\N E)N TOI=S PRO/S TI TIQE/NTES, TA\ DE\ E)N TOI=S PRO/S TI/ PWS E)/XOUSI. KAI\ TA\ ME\N PRO/S TI A)NTIDIAIROU=SI TOI=S KAQ' AU(TA/: TA\ DE\ PRO/S TI/ PWS E)/XONTA TOI=S KATA\ DIAFORA/N, PRO/S TI ME\N LE/GONTES TO\ GLUKU\ KAI\ PIKRO\N KAI\ TA\ TOIAU=TA KAI\ O(/SA TOIW=SDE DIATI/QHSI: PRO/S TI DE/ PWS E)/XONTA OI(=ON DECIO/N, PATE/RA KAI\ TA\ TOIAU=TA. KATA\ DIAFORA\N DE/ FASI TA\ KATA/ TI EI)=DOS XARAKTHRIZO/MENA. W(/SPER OU)=N A)/LLH TW=N KAQ' AU(TA\ E)/NNOIA KAI\ A)/LLH TW=N KATA\ DIAFORA/N, OU(/TWS A)/LLA ME\N TA\ PRO/S TI E)STI/N, A)/LLA DE\ TA\ PRO/S TI/ PWS E)/XONTA. A)NTESTRAMME/NH DE/ E)STI TW=N SUZU-GIW=N H( A)KOLOUQI/A. TOI=S ME\N GA\R KAQ' AU(TA\ SUNUPA/RXEI TA\ KATA\ DIAFORA/N. KAI\ GA\R TA\ KAQ' AU(TA\ O)/NTA DIAFORA\S E)/XEI TINA/S, W(/SPER TO\ LEUKO\N KAI\ ME/LAN. OU) ME/NTOI TOI=S KATA\ DIAFORA\N TA\ KAQ' AU(TA\ SUNUPA/RXEI. TO\ GA\R GLUKU\ KAI\ PIKRO\N DIAFORA\S ME\N E)/XEI, KAQ' A(\S XARAKTHRI/ZETAI, OU) ME/NTOI KAQ' AU(TA/ E)STI TOIAU=TA, A)LLA\ PRO/S TI. TA\ DE\ PRO/S TI/ PWS E)/XONTA, A(/PER A)NTI/KEITAI TOI=S KATA\ DIAFORA/N, PA/NTWS KAI\ PRO/S TI E)STI/N. O( GA\R DECIO\S KAI\ PATH\R META\ TOU= PW=S E)/XEIN KAI\ PRO/S TI EI)SI/N. TO\ GLUKU\ KAI\ PIKRO\N PRO/S TI O)/NTA KATA\ DIAFORA/N E)STI: TA\ DE\ PRO/S TI/ PWS E)/XONTA E)NANTI/A TOI=S KATA\ DIAFORA\N U(PA/RXEI. KAI\ GA\R TA\ ME\N PRO/S TI/ PWS E)/XONTA A)DU/NATON KAQ' AU(TA\ EI)=NAI H)\ KATA\ DIAFORA/N. E)K GA\R TH=S PRO\S E(/TERON SXE/SEWS H)/RTHTAI MO/NHS. TA\ ME/NTOI PRO/S TI KAQ' AU(TA\ ME\N OU)K E)/STI [1OU) GA/R E)STIN A)PO/LUTA]1 KATA\ DIAFORA\N DE\ PA/NTWS E)/STAI: META\ GA/R TINOS XARAKTH=ROS QEWREI=TAI. _EI) DE\ DEI= SAFE/STERON METALABEI=N TA\ LEGO/MENA, PRO/S TI ME\N LE/GOUSIN O(/SA KAT' OI)KEI=ON XARAKTH=RA DIAKEI/MENA/ PWS A)PONEU/EI PRO\S E(/TERON, PRO/S TI DE/ PWS E)/XONTA O(/SA PE/FUKE SUMBAI/NEIN TINI\ KAI\ MH\ SUMBAI/NEIN A)/NEU TH=S PERI\ AU)TA\ METABOLH=S KAI\ A)LLOI-W/SEWS META\ TOU= PRO\S TO\ E)KTO\S A)POBLE/PEIN, W(/STE O(/TAN ME\N KATA\ DIAFORA/N TI DIAKEI/MENON PRO\S E(/TERON NEU/SH|, PRO/S TI MO/NON TOU=TO E)/STAI, W(S H( E(/CIS KAI\ @1 H( E)PISTH/MH KAI\ H( AI)/SQHSIS. O(/TAN DE\ MH\ KATA\ TH\N E)NOU=SAN DIAFORA/N, KATA\ YILH\N DE\ TH\N PRO\S E(/TERON SXE/SIN QEWRH=TAI, PRO/S TI/ PWS E)/XON E)/STAI. O( GA\R UI(O\S KAI\ O( DECIO\S E)/CWQE/N TINWN PROSDE/ONTAI PRO\S TH\N U(PO/STASIN. DIO\ KAI\ MHDEMIA=S GINOME/NHS PERI\ AU)TA\ METABOLH=S, GE/NOIT' A)\N OU)KE/TI PATH\R TOU= UI(OU= A)POQANO/NTOS, O( DE\ DECIO\S TOU= PARAKEIME/NOU METASTA/NTOS. TO\ DE\ GLUKU\ KAI\ PIKRO\N OU)K A)\N A)LLOI=A GE/NOITO, EI) MH\ SUMMETABA/LLOI KAI\ H( PERI\ AU)TA\ DU/NA-MIS. EI) TOI/NUN KAI\ MHDE\N AU)TA\ PAQO/NTA METABA/LLOI KATA\ TH\N TOU= A)/LLOU PRO\S AU)TA\ SXE/SIN, DHLONO/TI E)N TH=| SXE/SEI MO/NH| TO\ EI)=NAI E)/XEI KAI\ OU) KATA/ TINA DIAFORA/N, TA\ PRO/S TI/ PWS E)/XONTA.&10 &10@ibid. cf. 43 A.$10 E(/PETAI DE\ AU)TOI=S KA)KEI=NO A)/TOPON TO\ SU/NQETA POIEI=N TA\ GE/NH E)K PROTE/RWN TINW=N KAI\ DEUTE/RWN, W(S TO\ PRO/S TI E)K POIOU= KAI\ PRO/S TI: A)LLA\ KAI\ PERI\ TH=S A)KOLOUQI/AS, OU)/TE W(S OI( <20*STWI+KOI\>20 LE/GOUSI TW=| ME\N PRO/S TI/ PWS E)/XONTI TO\ PRO/S TI E(/PETAI, TW=| DE\ PRO/S TI OU)KE/TI TO\ PRO/S TI/ PWS E)/XON: OU)/Q' W(S O( *BOHQO\S A)MUNO/MENOS AU)TOU/S&10 etc. &10@ibid. f. 44B.$10 KAI\ OU) KALW=S OI( <20*STWI+KOI\>20 NOMI/ZOUSI PA/SHS TH=S KATA\ DIAFORA\N I)DIO/THTOS A)PHLLA/XQAI TA\ PRO/S TI/ PWS E)/XONTA, DIO/TI PE/FUKE SUM-BAI/NEIN KAI\ A)POSUMBAI/NEIN MHDEMIA=S METABOLH=S PERI\ AU)TA\ GENOME/NHS. YEU=DOS GA\R TOU=TO LE/GETAI&10 etc. &10@Sextus adv. math. VIII 453.$10 KAI\ O(/TI TW=| O)/NTI E)PINOI/A| MO/NON SW/|ZETAI TA\ PRO/S TI/ PWS E)/XONTA, U(/PARCIS DE\ OU)K E)/STIN AU)TOI=S, PA/RESTI DI-DA/SKEIN E)K TH=S <20TW=N DOGMATIKW=N>20 A)NQOMOLOGH/SEWS. U(POGRA/FONTES GA\R TO\ PRO/S TI SUMFW/NWS FASI/ "1PRO/S TI E)STI\ TO\ PRO\S E(TE/RW| NOOU/MENON."2 @&10Galenus de constitutione artis medicae 8 Vol. I p. 251 K.$10 E)PEIDH\ TO\ STOIXEI=ON A)LLOIWTO/N E)STI DI' O(/LOU, PO/SA TA\ PA/NT' E)STI\ STOIXEI=A, DIE/L-QWMEN E(CH=S, A)RXH\N KA)NTAU=QA TW=N LO/GWN TW=N E)NARGW=S TI FAINOME/NWN POIH-SA/MENOI. TOI=S A)LLOIOU=SIN O(TIOU=N A)NAGKAI=ON, [KAI\] A(YAME/NOIS PRW=TON, W(=N A)LLOIOU=SI, POIH/SASQAI TH\N METABOLH/N, W(/SPER H( AI)/SQHSIS DIDA/SKEI, KAI\ AU)TH\ TW=N PRAGMA/TWN H( FU/SIS E)NDEI/KNUTAI. __KAI\ MH/N, EI) A(YA/MENON A)LLOIOI= TO\ METABA/LLON, A)NAGKAI=ON AU)TW=| KATA/ TINAS TW=N A(PTW=N POIO/THTAS E)NERGH=SAI. TI/ OU)=N TO\ KWLU=ON E)STI\N E)PISKE/YASQAI PA/SAS AU)TA/S; O)CU\ ME\N OU)=N TE/MNEI TO\ PLHSIA/ZON, A)LL' OU)K A)LLOIOI= TH\N OU)SI/AN AU)TOU=, KAQA/PER OU)DE\ TO\ BA/ROS, A)LLA\ QLA=| ME\N KAI\ TOU=TO, DI' O(/LOU D' OU)K E)RGA/ZETAI TH=S PASXOU/SHS OU)SI/AS TH\N METABOLH/N. OU) MH\N OU)DE\ SKLHRO/THS OU(/TW A)LLOIW=SAI DU/NATAI TO\ PLHSIA/ZON, W(S EI)S E(/TERON EI)=DOS METASTH=SAI. QERMO/THS ME/NTOI KAI\ YUXRO/THS O(/LHN A)LLOI-W=SAI DU/NATAI TH\N PLHSIA/ZOUSAN OU)SI/AN. W(SAU/TWS DE\ U(GRO/THS KAI\ CHRO/THS, EI) KAI\ MH\ DIA\ TA/XOUS O(MOI/WS TAI=S EI)RHME/NAIS, A)LL' E)N XRO/NW| GE KAI\ AU(=TAI METAL-LA/TTOUSI TA\ U(POKEI/MENA. A)=R' OU)=N KAI\ E(TE/RAN TINA\ E)/XOMEN A)LLOIOU=N DUNAME/NHN H)\ TO\ SU/MPAN PLH=QOS E)N TAU/TAIS E)STI/; KAI\ MO/NAS O)NOMA/ZESQAI/ TE KAI\ NOMI/-ZESQAI PROSH/KEI TA\S EI)RHME/NAS POIO/THTAS DRASTIKA/S, KAI\ MA/LIST' E)N AU)TAI=S TH\N PRW/THN A)NTI/QESIN, KAI\ KAT' AU)TH\N MA=LLON TH\N QERMO/THTA: DRASTIKWTA/TH GA\R AU(/TH TW=N POIOTH/TWN E)STI/N. E(CH=S D' AU)TH=S YUXRO/THS, EI)=Q' U(GRO/THS KAI\ CHRO/THS. A)/LLH DE\ OU)DEMI/A POIO/THS A)LLOIOI= TA\ PLHSIA/ZONTA DI' O(/LWN AU)TW=N. __<20O(/SA TOI/NUN SW/MATA PRW=TON TA\S TOIAU/TAS E)/XEI POIO/THTAS, @1 E)KEI=NA STOIXEI=A TW=N A)/LLWN A(PA/NTWN E)STI\>20 KAI\ TH=S SARKO/S. E)/STI DE\ TAU=TA GH= KAI\ U(/DWR KAI\ A)H\R KAI\ PU=R, A(/PER A(/PANTES OI( MH\ FEU/GONTES A)PO/DEICIN FILO/SOFOI STOIXEI=A TW=N GENNWME/NWN TE KAI\ FQEIROME/NWN E)/FASAN EI)=NAI. KAI\ METABA/LLEIN EI)S A)/LLHLA/ FASIN AU)TA\ KAI\ EI)=NAI/ TI KOINO\N A(/PASIN U(POKEI/MENON. @&10Galenus de natur. facult. I 3 ed. Bas. I 88. K. II 7.$10 EI)SI\ D' OU)K O)LI/GOI TINE\S A)/NDRES OU)DE\ A)/DOCOI, FILO/SOFOI/ TE KAI\ I)ATROI/, OI( TW=| ME\N QERMW=| KAI\ TW=| YUXRW=| TO\ DRA=N A)NAFE/RONTES, U(POBA/LLONTES D' AU)TOI=S PAQHTIKA\ TO/ TE CHRO\N KAI\ TO\ U(GRO/N. *KAI\ PRW=TO/S G' *)ARISTOTE/LHS TA\S TW=N KATA\ ME/ROS A(PA/NTWN AI)TI/AS EI)S TAU/TAS A)NA/GEIN PEIRA=TAI TA\S A)RXA/S, H)KOLOU/QHSE D' U(/STE-RON AU)TW=| KAI\ O( <20A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 XORO/S. *KAI/TOI TOU/TOIS ME\N W(S A)\N KAI\ <20AU)TW=N TW=N STOIXEI/WN TH\N EI)S A)/LLHLA METABOLH\N XU/SESI/ TE/ TISI KAI\ PILH/SESIN A)NAFE/ROUSIN>20 EU)/LOGON H)=N A)RXA\S DRASTIKA\S POIH/SASQAI TO\ QERMO\N KAI\ TO\ YUXRO/N, *)ARISTOTE/LEI D' OU)X OU(/TWS&10 etc. &10@Plutarchum de primo frigido cp. 2 p. 946a,$10 H( DE\ YUXRO/THS OU)K E)LA/TTONA TH=S QERMO/THTOS E)GGIGNOME/NH TOI=S SW/MASI PA/QH KAI\ METABOLA\S E)NERGA/ZESQAI PE/FUKE: KAI\ GA\R PH/GNUTAI POLLA\ TW=| YUXRW=| KAI\ SUGKRI/NETAI KAI\ PUKNOU=TAI: KAI\ TO\ STA/SIMON AU)TW=| KAI\ DUSKI/NHTON OU)K A)RGO/N E)STIN, A)LL' E)MBRIQE\S KAI\ BE/BAION, <20U(PO\ R(W/MHS SUNEREISTIKO\N KAI\ SUNEKTIKO\N E)XOU/SHS TO/NON>20. O(/QEN H( ME\N STE/RHSIS E)/KLEIYIS GI/NETAI KAI\ U(POXW/RHSIS TH=S A)NTIKEIME/NHS DUNA/MEWS, YU/XETAI DE\ POLLA/, POLLH=S AU)TOI=S QERMO/THTOS E)NUPARXOU/SHS: E)/NIA DE\ KAI\ MA=LLON H( YUXRO/THS, A)\N LA/BH| QERMO/-TERA, PH/GNUSI KAI\ SUNA/GEI, KAQA/PER TO\N BAPTO/MENON SI/DHRON: <20OI( DE\ *STWI+-KOI\>20 KAI\ TO\ PNEU=MA LE/GOUSIN E)N TOI=S SW/MASI TW=N BREFW=N TH=| PERIYU/CEI STO-MOU=SQAI KAI\ METABA/LLON E)K FU/SEWS GI/GNESQAI YUXH/N. A)LLA\ TOU=TO ME\N A)MFISBHTH/SIMON&10 etc. &10@Galenus de elementis sec. Hippocr. I 6. Vol. I p. 469 K.$10 O(/TI TE GA\R A(PLOU/STERO/N E)STI PURO\S H( A)/KRA QERMO/THS, O(/TI TE TAU/THS E)GGINOME/NHS TH=| U(/LH| PU=R A)POTELEI=TAI, TOI=S FILOSO/FOIS W(MOLO/GHTAI PA=SIN, OI(=S *)AQH/NAIOS E(/PESQAI SPOUDA/ZEI. KAI\ ME\N DH\ KAI\ W(S A)RXH\ TH=S TOU= PURO\S GENE/SEWS U(/LH TI/S E)STIN H( A(/PASIN U(POBEBLHME/NH TOI=S STOIXEI/OIS H( A)/POIOS H(/ T' E)GGINOME/NH TAU/TH| QERMO/THS H( A)/KRA, KAI\ TOU=Q' O(MOI/WS W(MOLO/GHTAI: KAI\ W(S H( ME\N U(/LH DIA\ PANTO\S TOU= AI)W=NOS E)STI/N, A)GE/NHTO/S TE KAI\ A)/FQARTOS OU)=SA, TO\ DE\ GINO/-MENO/N TE KAI\ A)POGINO/MENON AU)TH=S H( POIO/THS E)STI/N: KAI\ W(S O(MOGENE\S EI)=NAI XRH\ TO\ STOIXEI=ON, OU(=PER A)\N H)=| STOIXEI=ON. E)N TOU/TW| GA\R DH\ KAI\ DIH/NEGKE STOIXEI=ON A)RXH=S, E)N TW=| TA\S ME\N A)RXA\S OU)K E)C A)NA/GKHS O(MOGENEI=S EI)=NAI TOI=S PRA/GMASIN, W(=N U(PA/RXOUSIN A)RXAI/, TA\ DE\ STOIXEI=A PA/NTWS O(MOGENH=. @&10Galenus in Hippocr. de nat. hom. lib. I Vol. XV p. 3dK.$10 OU) MH\N STOIXEI=A/ GE TAU=T' E)/STIN [1&10scil.$10 H( A)GE/NHTOS U(/LH&10 et quattuor primae quali-&10tates$10 YUXRO/THS, QERMO/THS, CHRO/THS, U(GRO/THS]1 OU)/TE TW=N A)/LLWN OU)/T' A)NQRW/POU FU/SEWS, A)LL' A)RXAI/. SUNEKE/XUTO OU)=N TOU=TO PARA\ TOI=S A)RXAI/OIS, OU)D' EI)S E)/N-NOIAN A)FIGME/NOIS TH=S DIAFORA=S A)RXH=S TE KAI\ STOIXEI/OU, DIA\ TO\ DU/NASQAI XRH=SQAI TH=| TOU= STOIXEI/OU PROSHGORI/A| KA)PI\ TW=N A)RXW=N. A)LLA\ [DE\] DU/O PRA/GMATA/ E)STI FANERW=S A)LLH/LWN DIAFE/RONTA, TO\ ME\N E(/TERON E)LA/XISTON MO/RION @1 TOU= O(/LOU, TO\ DE\ E(/TERON, EI)S O(\ DIE/LH| TIS KAT' E)PI/NOIAN AU)TO\ TOU=TO [2TO\]2 E)LA/-XISTON. AU)TO\ ME\N GA\R TO\ PU=R OU)X OI(=O/N TE DIELEI=N EI)S DU/O SW/MATA KAI\ DEI=CAI KEKRAME/NON E)C E)KEI/NWN, W(/SPER OU)DE\ TH\N GH=N H)\ TO\ U(/DWR H)\ TO\N A)E/RA: NOH=SAI ME/NTOI DUNATO/N, E(TE/RAN ME\N EI)=NAI TOU= METABA/LLONTOS TH\N OU)SI/AN, E(TE/RAN DE\ TH\N METABOLH\N AU)TOU=. OU) GA\R TAU)TO/ E)STI TO\ METABA/LLON SW=MA TH=| KAT' AU)TO\ METABOLH=|. TO\ ME\N GA\R METABA/LLON E)STI\ TO\ U(POKEI/MENON, H( METABOLH\ DE\ AU)-TOU= KATA\ TH\N TW=N POIOTH/TWN A)MOIBH\N GI/NETAI. @&10Galenus de nat. facult. II 4. Vol. II p. 88 K.$10 TO\ QERMO\N KAI\ TO\ YUXRO\N KAI\ TO\ CHRO\N KAI\ TO\ U(GRO\N EI)S A)/LLHLA DRW=NTA KAI\ PA/SXONTA: KAI\ TOU/TWN AU)TW=N DRASTIKW/TATON ME\N TO\ QERMO/N, DEU/TERON DE\ TH=| DUNA/MEI TO\ YUXRO/N, __TRE/FESQAI DE\ DI' O(/LWN AU)TW=N TA\ TREFO/MENA KAI\ KERA/NNUSQAI DI' O(/LWN TA\ KERANNU/MENA KAI\ A)LLOIOU=SQAI DI' O(/LWN TA\ A)LLOIOU/MENA, __ KAI\ TH\N PE/YIN A)LLOI/WSI/N TINA U(PA/RXEIN KAI\ METABOLH\N TOU= TRE/FONTOS EI)S TH\N OI)KEI/AN TOU= TREFOME/NOU POIO/THTA, TH\N D' E)CAIMA/TWSIN A)LLOI/WSIN EI)=NAI, KAI\ TH\N QRE/YIN W(SAU/TWS, KAI\ TH\N AU)/CHSIN E)K TH=S PA/NTH| DIATA/SEWS TOU= SW/MATOS KAI\ QRE/YEWS GI/NESQAI: TH\N D' A)LLOI/WSIN U(PO\ TOU= QERMOU= MA/LISTA SUNTELEI=SQAI, KAI\ DIA\ TOU=TO KAI\ TH\N QRE/YIN KAI\ TH\N PE/YIN KAI\ TH\N TW=N XUMW=N A(PA/NTWN GE/NESIN: H)/DH DE\ KAI\ TOI=S PERITTW/MASI TA\S POIO/THTAS U(PO\ TH=S E)MFU/TOU QERMASI/AS E)GGI/NESQAI. __&10p. 92$10 A)LL' O(/TI ME\N TH=S *)ARISTO-TE/LOUS FUSIOLOGI/AS OU)DE\N *)ERASISTRA/TW| ME/TESTIN, O( <20KATA/LOGOS TW=N PRO-EIRHME/NWN>20 E)NDEI/KNUTAI <20DOGMA/TWN>20: A(\ PRW=TON ME\N *(IPPOKRA/TOUS H)=N, DEU-TE/ROU D' *)ARISTOTE/LOUS, TRI/TWN DE\ <20TW=N *STWI+KW=N>20, E(NO\S MO/NOU METATIQEME/NOU, TOU= TA\S POIO/THTAS EI)=NAI SW/MATA. @&Galenus methodi med. I 2. Vol. X 15 K.$ EI) DE\ <20TOU\S A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 FILOSO/FOUS EI)S TO\ SUNE/DRION EI)S-AGAGO/NTES E)PITRE/YAIMEN KAI\ TOU/TOIS TH\N YH=FON, E)C W(=N AU)TOI\ TI/QENTAI DOGMA/TWN, E)K TOU/TWN *(IPPOKRA/THN STEFANW/SOUSI. TO\ GA\R QERMO\N KAI\ TO\ YUXRO\N KAI\ TO\ CHRO\N KAI\ TO\ U(GRO\N *(IPPOKRA/THS ME\N PRW=TOS EI)S-HGH/SATO, MET' AU)TO\N D' *)ARISTOTE/LHS A)PE/DEICEN: E(/TOIMA D' H)/DH PARALA-BO/NTES OU)K E)FILONI/KHSAN <20OI( PERI\ TO\N *XRU/SIPPON>20, A)LL' E)K TOU/TWN TA\ SU/MPANTA KEKRA=SQAI LE/GOUSI, KAI\ TAU=T' EI)S A)/LLHLA PA/SXEIN KAI\ DRA=N, KAI\ TEXNIKH\N EI)=NAI TH\N FU/SIN, A(/PANTA/ TE TA)/LLA TA\ PERI\ FU/SEWS *(IPPOKRA/TOUS DO/GMATA PROSI/ENTAI: PLH\N PERI\ MIKROU= TINO/S E)STIN AU)-TOI=S H( DIAFORA\ PRO\S *)ARISTOTE/LH. LE/GONTOS GA\R *(IPPOKRA/TOUS O)RQW=S W(S SU/MPNOUN KAI\ SU/R)R(OUN E)STI\N A(/PAN TO\ SW=MA KAI\ PA/NTA SUMPAQH= TA\ TW=N ZW/|WN MO/RIA, PROSI/ENTAI ME\N A)MFO/TEROI TOUTI/, DIAFE/RONTAI DE\ E)N TW=| TA\S ME\N POIO/THTAS MO/NAS TO\N *)ARISTOTE/LH DI' A)LLH/LWN I)E/NAI KAI\ KERA/NNUSQAI PA/NTH, <20TOU\S D' A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 OU) TAU/TAS MO/NAS, A)LLA\ KAI\ TA\S OU)SI/AS AU)TA\S U(POLAMBA/NEIN. @1 @&Galenus de elementis I 9 ed. Bas. I 56. K. I 487.$ *)ARISTO-TE/LEI D' E)/N TE TOI=S PERI\ OU)RANOU= KAI\ TOI=S PERI\ GENE/SEWS KAI\ FQORA=S O( PERI\ TW=N STOIXEI/WN LO/GOS E)CEI/RGASTAI, W(/SPER <20E)N TOI=S PERI\ OU)SI/AS LO/GOIS *XRUSI/PPW|>20. @&Stobaeus Eclog. I p. 129, 1 W.$ <20*XRUSI/PPOU>20. PERI\ DE\ TW=N E)K TH=S OU)SI/AS STOIXEI/WN TOIAU=TA/ TINA A)POFAI/NETAI, TW=| TH=S AI(RE/SEWS H(GEMO/NI *ZH/NWNI KATAKOLOUQW=N, TE/TTARA LE/GWN EI)=NAI STOIXEI=A [2PU=R, A)E/RA, U(/DWR, GH=N, E)C W(=N SUNI/STASQAI PA/NTA KAI\ ZW=A]2 KAI\ FUTA\ KAI\ TO\N O(/LON KO/SMON KAI\ TA\ E)N AU)TW=| PERIEXO/MENA KAI\ EI)S TAU=TA DIALU/-ESQAI. TO\ DE\ [2PU=R KAI\]2 KAT' E)COXH\N STOIXEI=ON LE/GESQAI DIA\ TO\ E)C AU)TOU= PRW/TOU TA\ LOIPA\ SUNI/STASQAI KATA\ METABOLH\N KAI\ EI)S AU)TO\ E)/SXATON PA/NTA XEO/MENA DIALU/ESQAI, TOU=TO DE\ MH\ E)PIDE/XESQAI TH\N EI)S A)/LLO XU/SIN H)\ A)NA/LUSIN: [SUNI/STASQAI DE\ E)C AU)TOU= TA\ LOIPA\ KAI\ XE-O/MENA EI)S TOU=TO E)/SXATON TELEUTA=N: PARO\ KAI\ STOIXEI=ON LE/GESQAI, O(\ PRW=TON E(/STHKEN OU(/TWS, W(/STE SU/STASIN DIDO/NAI A)F' AU(TOU= KAI\ AU)TO\ TW=N LOIPW=N XU/SIN KAI\ DIA/LUSIN DE/XESQAI EI)S AU(TO/]. KATA\ ME\N TO\N LO/GON TOU=TON AU)TOTELW=S LEGOME/NOU TOU= PURO\S STOIXEI/OU: OU) MET' A)/L-LOU GA/R: KATA\ DE\ TO\N PRO/TERON KAI\ MET' A)/LLWN SUSTATIKO\N EI)=NAI, PRW/THS ME\N GIGNOME/NHS TH=S E)K PURO\S KATA\ SU/STASIN EI)S A)E/RA META-BOLH=S, DEUTE/RAS D' A)PO\ TOU/TOU EI)S U(/DWR, TRI/THS D' E)/TI MA=LLON KATA\ TO\ A)NA/LOGON SUNISTAME/NOU TOU= U(/DATOS EI)S GH=N. PA/LIN D' A)PO\ TAU/THS DIALUOME/NHS KAI\ DIAXEOME/NHS PRW/TH ME\N GI/GNETAI XU/SIS EI)S U(/DWR, DEU-TE/RA D' E)C U(/DATOS EI)S A)E/RA, TRI/TH DE\ KAI\ E)SXA/TH EI)S PU=R. *LE/GESQAI [2DE\]2 PU=R TO\ PURW=DES PA=N KAI\ A)E/RA TO\ A)ERW=DES KAI\ O(MOI/WS TA\ LOIPA/. *TRIXW=S DH\ LEGOME/NOU KATA\ *XRU/SIPPON TOU= STOIXEI/OU, KAQ' E(/NA ME\N TRO/PON TOU= PURO/S, DIA\ TO\ E)C AU)TOU= TA\ LOIPA\ SUNI/STASQAI KATA\ META-BOLH\N KAI\ EI)S AU)TO\ LAMBA/NEIN TH\N A)NA/LUSIN: KAQ' E(/TERON DE/, KAQO\ LE/GETAI TA\ TE/SSARA STOIXEI=A, PU=R, A)H\R, U(/DWR, GH= [1E)PEI\ DIA\ TOU/TWN TINO\S H)\ TINW=N H)\ KAI\ PA/NTWN TA\ LOIPA\ SUNE/STHKE, DIA\ ME\N TW=N TET-TA/RWN, W(S TA\ ZW=|A KAI\ TA\ E)PI\ GH=S PA/NTA SUGKRI/MATA, DIA\ DUOI=N DE/, W(S H( SELH/NH DIA\ PURO\S KAI\ A)E/ROS SUNE/STHKE, DI' E(NO\S DE\ W(S O( H(/LIOS, DIA\ PURO\S GA\R MO/NOU, O( GA\R H(/LIOS PU=R E)STIN EI)LIKRINE/S]1, KATA\ TRI/TON LO/GON LE/GETAI STOIXEI=ON %2%2 EI)=NAI O(\ PRW=TON SUNE/STHKEN OU(/TWS, W(/STE GE/NESIN DIDO/NAI A)F' AU(TOU= O(DW=| ME/XRI TE/LOUS KAI\ E)C E)KEI/NOU TH\N A)NA/LUSIN DE/XESQAI EI)S E(AUTO\ TH=| O(MOI/A| O(DW=|. *GEGONE/NAI D' E)/FHSE KAI\ @1 TOIAU/TAS A)PODO/SEIS PERI\ STOIXEI/OU, W(S E)/STI TO/ TE DI' AU(TOU= EU)KINH-TO/TATON KAI\ H( A)RXH\ [2KAI\ O( SPERMATIKO\S]2 LO/GOS KAI\ H( A)I/+DIOS DU/NAMIS FU/SIN E)/XOUSA TOIAU/THN, W(/STE AU(TH/N TE KINEI=N KA/TW PRO\S [GH=N] TH\N TROPH\N KAI\ A)PO\ TH=S TROPH=S A)/NW PA/NTH| KU/KLW|, EI)S AU(TH/N TE PA/NTA KATANALI/SKOUSA KAI\ A)F' AU(TH=S PA/LIN A)POKAQISTA=SA TETAGME/NWS KAI\ O(DW=|. @[&10Iustinus] de resurrect. 6.$10 *FASI\ TOI/NUN OI( TOU= KO/SMOU FUSIKOI\ SOFOI\ LEGO/MENOI TO\ PA=N U(PA/RXEIN OI( ME\N U(/LHN KAI\ QEO\N W(S *PLA/TWN__ OI( DE\ TA\ TE/SSARA, PU=R, U(/DWR, A)E/RA, GH=N, W(/SPER <20OI( *STWI+KOI/>20. __*KAI\ O( ME\N *PLA/TWN FHSI\N U(PO\ TOU= QEOU= TA\ PA/NTA E)K TH=S U(/LHS GEGONE/NAI__ <20OI( DE\ *STWI+KOI\>20 E)K TW=N TESSA/RWN DIH/KONTOS DI' AU)TW=N TOU= QEOU=.&10 &10@ibidem paulo post%10$10 *)ALLA\ MH\N KATA\ TOU\S *STWI+KOU/S, E)K TH=S TW=N TESSA/-RWN STOIXEI/WN KRA/SEWS GINOME/NOU TOU= SW/MATOS, KAI\ DIALUOME/NOU TOU/TOU EI)S TA\ TE/SSARA, PARAMENO/NTWN TOU/TWN A)FQA/RTWN, DUNATO/N E)STI PA/LIN TA\ TE/SSARA STOIXEI=A, TH\N AU)TH\N MI=CIN KAI\ KRA=SIN LABO/NTA A)PO\ TOU= DIH/KONTOS DI' AU)TW=N QEOU=, POIH=SAI O(\ PRO/TERON PEPOIH/KEI SW=MA. @&10Galenus de venae sectione therapeutici 3. Vol. XI p. 256 K.$10 AI( D' A)RXAI\ TH=S GENE/SEWS A(/PASI TOI=S OU)=SIN, U(/LHN E)/XOUSI, TA\ TE/TTARA STOI-XEI=A, KERA/NNUSQAI/ TE PEFUKO/TA DI' O(/LWN A)LLH/LWN KAI\ DRA=N EI)S A)/LLHLA. @&10Galenus introductio s. medicus 9. Vol. XIV p. 698 K.$10 KATA\ DE\ TO\N *)AQH/NAION STOIXEI=A A)NQRW/POU OU) TA\ TE/SSARA PRW=TA SW/MATA, PU=R KAI\ A)H\R KAI\ U(/DWR KAI\ GH=, A)LL' AI( POIO/THTES AU)TW=N, TO\ QERMO\N KAI\ TO\ YUXRO\N KAI\ TO\ CHRO\N KAI\ TO\ U(GRO/N, W(=N DU/O ME\N TA\ POIHTIKA\ AI)/TIA U(POTI/QETAI, TO\ QERMO\N KAI\ TO\ YUXRO/N, DU/O DE\ TA\ U(LIKA/, TO\ CHRO\N KAI\ TO\ U(GRO/N, KAI\ PE/M-PTON PAREISA/GEI <20KATA\ TOU\S *STWI+KOU\S>20 TO\ DIH=KON DIA\ PA/NTWN PNEU=MA, U(F' OU(= TA\ PA/NTA SUNE/XESQAI KAI\ DIOIKEI=SQAI. @&10Origenes contra Celsum IV 56. Vol. I p. 329, 12 Ko+. [1p. 547]1 &10Delarue$10]1. PROSFEU/CETAI DE\ *)ARISTOTE/LEI KAI\ TOI=S A)PO\ TOU= *PERIPA/TOU, A)/U+LON FA/SKOUSIN EI)=NAI TO\N AI)QE/RA KAI\ PE/MPTHS PARA\ TA\ TE/SSARA STOIXEI=A AU)TO\N EI)=NAI FU/SEWS: PRO\S O(\N LO/GON OU)K A)GENNW=S KAI\ OI( A)PO\ *PLA/TWNOS KAI\ <20OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 E)/STHSAN. @&10Nemesius de nat. hom. cp. 5 p. 126.$10 LE/GOUSI DE\ <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 TW=N STOIXEI/WN TA\ ME\N EI)=NAI DRASTIKA/, TA\ DE\ PAQHTIKA/: DRASTIKA\ ME\N A)E/RA KAI\ PU=R, PAQHTIKA\ DE\ GH=N KAI\ U(/DWR. @&10Ae%28tius I 15, 11$10 [1PERI\ XRWMA/TWN&10]1 DG. p. 314, 11.$10 OI( ME\N A)/LLOI TA\ STOIXEI=A KEXRW=SQAI FUSIKW=S. @&10Galenus de constitutione artis medicae 7. Vol. I p. 245 K.$10 *)/ESTI ME\N DH\ TO\ PROKEI/MENON_AU)TO\ TOU=TO E)CEUREI=N, O(POI=A TA\ PRO\S TH\N FU/SIN @1 E)STI\ [TA\] PRW=TA/ TE KAI\ A(PLOU/STATA MO/RIA. MH\ TOI/NUN E)PI\ PA/NTWN, A)LL' E)F' E(NO\S_O( LO/GOS H(MI=N GIGNE/SQW, TH=S SARKO\S E)PISKEPTOME/NHS, PRW=TON ME\N <20EI) E(/N TI TH\N I)DE/AN E)STI\ TO\>20 GENNH=SAN AU)TH\N <20STOIXEI=ON>20 [1OU)DE\N GA\R XEI=RON OU(/TWS O)NOMA/SAI TO\ PRW=TO/N TE KAI\ A(PLOU/STATON E)N AU)TH=| MO/RION]1: EI)=Q' E(CH=S, EI)/PER MH\ FAI/NOITO TOIOU=TON, <20EI) POLLA/>20, KA)/PEITA <20PO/SA>20 GE KAI\ <20TI/NA>20 KAI\ <20O(/STIS O( TRO/POS>20 AU)TOI=S E)STI <20TH=S SUNQE/SEWS>20. @E)PEI\ TOI/NUN H( SA\RC O)DUNA=TAI TEMNOME/NH TE KAI\ QERMAINOME/NH SFODRW=S, A)DU/NATON E(\N EI)=NAI TW=| EI)/DEI TO\ STOIXEI=ON, OI(=ON *)EPI/KOUROS U(PE/QETO TH\N A)/TO-MON. O(/TI GA\R [OU)X] E(\N TW=| EI)/DEI TO\ STOIXEI=O/N E)STI [2TO\]2 TOIOU=TON, E)NQE/NDE DH=LON. OU)DEMI/A TW=N A)TO/MWN AU)TH\ KAQ' AU(TH\N OU)/TE QERMH\ TH\N FU/SIN E)STI\N OU)/TE YUXRA/, OU) MH\N OU)DE\ LEUKH/ TI/S E)STIN E)C AU)TW=N H)\ ME/LAINA. __O(/LWS GA\R OU)DEMI/A POIO/THS E)STI\N AU)TH=| TH=| A)TO/MW|, W(S OI( PATE/RES AU)TW=N BOU/LONTAI. TW=N GA\R DH\ TOIOU/TWN POIOTH/TWN PA=SAI DI' O(/LWN FAI/NONTAI DIELHLUQE/NAI TW=N SWMA/TWN, W(S H(/ GE KATA\ TO\ SXH=MA POIO/THS U(PA/RXEI PA/SAIS AU)TAI=S, U(PA/RXEI DE\ KAI\ A)NTITUPI/A KAI\ BA/ROS. A)LL' EI)/TE POIO/THTA XRH\ KALEI=N, EI)/TE A)/LLO TI TA\ TOIAU=TA, PRO/S GE TO\ PROKEI/MENON OU)DE\N DIAFE/REI. PA/SAIS GA\R AU)TAI=S U(PA/RXEI TA\ EI)RHME/NA, KAI\ OU) DIAFE/ROUSIN A)LLH/LWN EI)/DEI, KAQA/PER AI( O(MOIOME/REIAI TOI=S E)KEI/NAS U(POTIQEME/NOIS, H)\ TA\ TE/TTARA STOIXEI=A TOI=S U(POTIQEME/NOIS TAU=TA. FHSI\N OU)=N *(IPPOKRA/THS: "1E)GW\ DE/ FHMI, EI) E(\N H)=N A)/NQRWPOS, OU)DE/POT' A)\N H)/LGEEN"2 O)RQO/TATA LE/GWN. TO\ GA\R E(\N A)META/BLHTON EI)S E(/TERON, OU)K E)/XON GE EI)S O(\ METABA/LOI. TO\ DE\ A)META/BLHTON A)NALLOI/WTON KAI\ A)PAQE/S, TO\ DE\ A)PAQE\S A)NW/DUNON. GI/GNETAI TOI/NUN E)K TW=N EI)RHME/NWN PROTA/SEWN SUMPE/RASMA, TO\ E(\N A)PAQE\S U(PA/RXEIN. E)F' W(=| PA/LIN E(/TEROS E)RWTHQH/SETAI LO/GOS TOIO/SDE: "1EI) E(\N H)=N TW=| EI)/DEI TO\ STOIXEI=ON, OU)DE\N E)N TOI=S PA=SIN OU)DE/POTE O)DUNH/SETAI: A)LLA\ MH\N O)DUNA=TAI. OU)K A)/RA E(/N E)STI TO\ STOIXEI=ON."2 E)PEI\ D' U(PE/KEITO PERI\ SARKO\S POIEI=SQAI TO\N LO/GON, E)P' E)KEI/NHS E)CETAZE/SQW. "1EI) E(\N H)=N TW=| EI)/DEI TO\ TH=S SARKO\S STOIXEI=ON, OU)DE/POTE H( SA\RC O)DUNH/SETAI: A)LLA\ MH\N O)DUNA=TAI: OU)K A)/RA E(/N E)STI TW=| EI)/DEI TO\ TH=S SARKO\S STOIXEI=ON."2 O( D' AU)TO\S LO/GOS KAI\ KAQ' E(/TE-RON E)RWTHQH/SETAI TRO/PON: "1EI) A)PAQE/S E)STI TO\ TH=S SARKO\S STOIXEI=ON, OU)K O)DUNHQH/SETAI: A)LLA\ MH\N O)DUNA=TAI: OU)K A)/RA E)STI\N A)PAQE/S."2 @EI) DE\ KAI\ PLEI/W LE/GOI TIS EI)=NAI TA\ STOIXEI=A, MH\ ME/NTOI GE A)LLOIOU/MENA, KAI\ E)P' E)KEI/NWN O( AU)TO\S LO/GOS E)RWTHQH/SETAI KATA\ TO\N AU)TO\N TRO/PON. "1EI) A)PAQH= TH=S SARKO/S E)STI TA\ STOIXEI=A, OU)K A)LGH/SEI: A)LLA\ MH\N A)LGEI=: OU)K A)/RA E)STI\N A)PAQH= TA\ TH=S SARKO\S STOIXEI=A."2 O( ME\N OU)=N PRO/TEROS LO/GOS A)NATRE/PEI TH/N TE TW=N A)TO/MWN KAI\ TH\N TW=N A)NA/RMWN KAI\ TH\N TW=N E)LAXI/STWN U(PO/QESIN, KATA\ DE\ TO\N DEU/TERON H(/ TE TW=N O(MOIOMERW=N A)NAIREI=TAI DO/CA KAI\ H( *)EMPEDO-KLE/OUS. KAI\ GA\R OU(=TOS E)K TW=N TESSA/RWN STOIXEI/WN BOU/LETAI SUNI/STASQAI TA\ SW/MATA, MH\ METABALLO/NTWN EI)S A)/LLHLA. @PROSE/XE NU=N H)/DH TW=| LO/GW|, O(\S QA=TTON E)LPI/DOS E)CEU=RE TO\ ME/GISTON ME/ROS W(=N E)ZH/TEIS. OU)K A)PAQH= GA\R A)PE/DEICEN EI)=NAI DEI=N TA\ STOIXEI=A TH=S SARKO/S. OU)/KOUN E)/TI KAQE/COUSI TO\ PROKEI/MENON KATA\ TO\N LO/GON, E)N TH=| SUNQE/SEI TW=N A)PAQW=N E)KEI/NWN SWMA/TWN, A(\ DH\ STOIXEI=A TH=S TW=N O)/NTWN A(PA/NTWN FU/SEWS U(POTI/QENTAI, TA\S O)DU/NAS GENNA=SQAI FA/SKONTES. A)PAQE\S GA\R O)DUNW/MENON OU)/Q' H( DIA/NOIA PARADE/XETAI, KAI\ POLU\ DH\ MA=LLON OU)DE\N TW=N AI)SQHTW=N MAR-TUREI=. TOU\S GOU=N DAKTU/LOUS EI) SUMPLE/CAIS A)LLH/LOIS, EI)=T' AU)=QIS A)POXWRI/ZOIS, @1 OU)/Q' H( SU/NODOS OU)/Q' O( DIAXWRISMO\S O)DU/NHN E)RGA/SETAI. TO\ ME\N GA\R O)DU-NA=SQAI SU\N TW=| PA/SXEIN E)STI/N: PA/SXEI DE\ OU)DE\N TO\ YAU=ON, E)PEIDH/PER E)N DUOI=N TOU/TOIN E)STI\ TO\ PA/SXEIN, A)LLOIW/SEI TE TH=| DI' O(/LWN KAI\ LU/SEI TH=S SUNEXEI/AS. O(PO/T' OU)=N OU)D' E)N TOI=S PAQHTIKOI=S E)NARGW=S SW/MASIN OU)/Q' H( SU/NODOS OU)/Q' H( A)/FODOS O)DU/NHN E)RGA/ZETAI, SXOLH=| GE A)\N E)N TOI=S A)PAQE/SIN E)RGA/SAITO. __ XRH\ TOI/NUN TO\ ME/LLON O)DUNH/SESQAI PAQHTO\N EI)=NAI KAI\ AI)SQHTO/N. @<20OU) MH\N E)C AI)SQHTIKW=N GE TW=N PRW/TWN A)NAGKAI=ON EI)=NAI TO\ AI)SQHTIKO/N, A)LL' A)RKEI= TO\ PAQHTIKO\N MO/NON. AI)SQHTIKO\N GA\R DU/NATAI GENE/SQAI POTE/, METABA/LLON TE KAI\ A)LLOIOU/MENON>20. E)PEI\ D' A)PEI/ROUS E)GXWREI= TO\ PLH=QOS GENE/SQAI TA\S E)K TW=N STOIXEI/WN A)LLOIW/SEIS TE KAI\ KRA/SEIS, A)/PEIROI TW=N KATA\ ME/ROS SWMA/TWN AI( I)DIO/THTES SUSTH/SONTAI, KAQ' A(\S OU)DE\N A)/TOPON A)NAI/SQHTA GENE/SQAI POLLA/, KAI\ TW=N AI)SQANOME/NWN TO\ ME\N MA=LLON AI)SQA/NESQAI, TO\ D' H(=TTON. @&10Cicero de natura deorum III 35. Sed omnia vestri, Balbe, so-&10lent ad igneam vim referre, Heraclitum, ut opinor, sequentes__; vos &10autem ita dicitis, omnem vim esse igneam, itaque et animantis, cum calor &10defecerit, tum interire, et in omni natura rerum id vivere, id vigere, quod &10caleat. _36. Ita voltis, opinor, nihil esse animal intrinsecus in natura at-&10que mundo praeter ignem. __Quodsi ignis ex sese ipse animal est nulla se &10alia admiscente natura, quoniam is, cum inest in corporibus nostris, efficit, &10ut sentiamus, non potest ipse esse sine sensu. __Ita fit, ut ne ignem &10quidem efficere possitis aeternum. 37. Quid enim? non eisdem vobis placet &10omnem ignem pastus indigere nec permanere ullo modo posse, nisi alatur? &10ali autem solem, lunam, reliqua astra aquis, alia dulcibus, alia marinis? &10@Philo de visione angeli p. 616 Aucher. Cherubim exponitur &10typus vel incendium. __Incendium vero propterea, quia consumunt &10privationem ab ordine sive informitatem materiae, in ordinem eam redu-&10centes et consequenter informem in formam et inornatum in ornatum. Quo-&10niam non corruptibilis ignis erant virtutes, sed salutaris, per quem omnia &10artificiose facta sunt. Quare, ut mihi videtur, etiam nonnulli philosopho-&10rum ignem artificialem asseruere in viam cadere ad semina in generationem &10producenda. Siquidem extensum illud lucis volumen corporis conceditur &10oculis, evidens autem in invisibilibus natura, qua creatur formaturque &10materia, mentis velocissime videntibus oculis. &10@Augustinus de civ. dei VIII 5. Nam quidam eorum a rebus &10non vivis res vivas fieri posse crediderunt, sicut Epicurei; <21quidam>21 vero &10a vivente quidem et viventia et non viventia, sed tamen a corpore cor-&10pora. Nam <21Stoici>21 ignem, id est corpus, unum ex his quattuor elementis, &10quibus visibilis mundus hic constat, et viventem et sapientem et ipsius &10mundi fabricatorem atque omnium, quae in eo sunt, eumque omnino ignem &10deum esse putaverunt. &10@Galenus de differentia pulsuum III 6. Vol. VIII p. 672 K.$10 OU) MH\N OI( TW=| LO/GW| DIASKEYA/MENOI/ TI <20PERI\ TOU= A)E/ROS>20 I)ATROI/ TE KAI\ FILO/SOFOI KENO\N EI)=NAI PANTA/PASIN U(POLAMBA/NOUSIN AU)TO/N, A)LL' OI( ME/N TINES, W(=N TH=S DO/CHS KAI\ H(MEI=S METE/XOMEN, <20E(\N U(PA/RXEIN SW=MA SUNEXE\S E(AUTW=| PA/NTH|, MHDAMO/QI KENOU= PARAPLOKH\N E)/XON>20, OI( DE/ TINES E)N KENW=| POLLA\ SW/MATA, @1 TA\ SMIKRA/, TA\ PRW=TA, PROSFERO/MENA PROSKROU/ONTA/ TE KAI\ A)POPALLO/MENA, MH\ ME/NTOI PERIPLEKO/MENA/ TE KAI\ SUGKRINO/MENA. @&10ibid. 673.$10 OU)DE\N GA/R E)STIN E)N KO/SMW| TOIOU=TON [1&10scil.$10 KENO/N]1, A)LL' OU)DE\ KAT' E)PIKRA/TEIAN. OU)DENO\S GA\R U(PA/RXONTOS O(/LWS E)N KO/SMW| KENOU=, PW=S A)\N EI)/H TI KAT' E)PIKRA/TEIAN KENO/N; @&10ibid. 674. [1pneumatici aiunt%10$10]1 OU) GA\R EI)=NAI TOIAU/THN [1&10scil.$10 KENH\N XW/-RAN]1 OU)DEMI/AN E)N KO/SMW| NOMI/ZOUSIN, A)LL' H(NW=SQAI TH\N O(/LHN OU)SI/AN E(AUTH=|. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. IV 19, 4.$10 <20*OI( DE\ *STWI+KOI/>20 FASI TO\N A)E/RA MH\ SUGKEI=SQAI E)K QRAUSMA/TWN, A)LLA\ SUNEXH= DI' O(/LOU, MHDE\N KENO\N E)/XONTA: E)PEIDA\N DE\ PLHGH=| PNEU/MATI, KUMATOU=TAI KATA\ KU/KLOUS O)RQOU\S EI)S A)/PEIRON, E(/WS PLHRW/SH| TO\N PERIKEI/MENON A)E/RA, W(S E)PI\ TH=S KOLUMBH/QRAS TH=S PLHGEI/SHS LI/QW|. KAI\ AU(/TH ME\N KUKLIKW=S KINEI=TAI, O( D' A)H\R SFAIRIKW=S. @&10Galenus de simplic. medicam. I 24. Vol. XI p. 423.$10 <20TO\N A)E/RA>20 TOI/NUN OU)K E)/STIN O(/STIS OU)K EI)=PE <20LEPTOMERH=, TW=| KATAQRAU/ESQAI DHLO-NO/TI R(A|DI/WS EI)S LEPTA\ MO/RIA KAI\ DIA\ PUKNOTA/TWN SWMA/TWN E(TOI/-MWS DIE/RXESQAI>20. *)\H EI)/PER E)C A)/LLOU TINO\S E)PIFE/ROUSIN AU)TW=| TO\ LEPTOMERE\S O)/NOMA, DIDASKO/NTWN H(MA=S SAFW=S. OU) GA\R DH\ E)C O)/GKWN GE LEPTW=N, W(S OI( TH=S E(TE/RAS AI(RE/SEWS EI)/POIEN A)\N H(GEMO/NES, E)ROU=MEN KAI\ H(MEI=S SUGKEI=SQAI TO\N A)E/RA. SUNEXH\S GA/R E)STIN KAI\ EI(=S O(/LOS, OU)DAMO/QI KENO\N E)N E(AUTW=| PERIE/XWN OU)DE/N. E)N DE\ TOIAU/TH| FU/SEI SW/MATOS H( LEPTOME/REIA TW=| TA/XEI TH=S EI)S MIKRA\ DIAIRE/SEWS E)PINOEI=TAI MO/NW|. A)LL' EI)/PER DIA\ TOU=TO LEPTOMERH\S O( A)H/R, OU)X A(/PAN PU=R E)/STAI LEPTOMERE/S. E)/STI ME\N GA\R DH/POU KAI\ XALKO\S KAI\ SI/DHROS KAI\ LI/QOS KAI\ CU/LON KAI\ PA=N O(/PER [2A)\N]2 A)NQRAKWQH=| PU=R, OU) MH\N LEPTOME-RE/STERON NU=N H)\ PRO/SQEN. AI( ME/NTOI FLO/GES, E(/TERO/N TI GE/NOS PURO/S, O)/NTWS EI)SI\ LEPTOMEREI=S&10 etc. &10@Galenus de simplic. medic. IV 2. Vol. XI p. 626 K.$10 A)LL' A)H\R ME\N E)KPURWQEI\S FLO\C GI/GNETAI, GH= DE\ A)/NQRAC, TO\ D' U(/DWR DE/XETAI ME\N I)SXU-RA\N QERMASI/AN, A)LL' OU)/TE FLO\C OU)/T' A)/NQRAC GI/NETAI, DIA\ TH\N SU/MFUTON U(GRO/-THTA. FLO\C ME\N GA\R KAI\ A)/NQRAC EI)/DH PURO/S&10 etc. &10@Galenus de simplic. medicam. I 14. Vol. XI p. 405 K.$10 LE/GW DE\ A)RAIA\N [1OU)SI/AN]1, H(=S TA\ MO/RIA DIALAMBA/NETAI XW/RAIS KENAI=S, E)PISTAME/NWN H(MW=N DHLONO/TI KAI\ MEMNHME/NWN A)EI/, PW=S LE/GETAI XW/RA KENH\ PRO\S TW=N H(NW=SQAI FASKO/NTWN TH\N OU)SI/AN, O(/TI MH\ KAQA/PER *)EPIKOU/RW| KAI\ *)ASKLHPIA/DH| DOKEI=, A)LL' E)/STIN A)E/ROS PLH/RHS E)N A(/PASI TOI=S A)RAIOI=S SW/MASIN H( KENH\ XW/RA. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 43 p. 1053f.$ *TO\N A)E/RA FU/SEI ZOFERO\N EI)=NAI LE/GEI, KAI\ TOU/TW| TEKMHRI/W| XRH=TAI TOU= KAI\ YUXRO\N EI)=NAI PRW/TWS: "1A)NTIKEI=SQAI GA\R AU)TOU= TO\ ME\N ZOFERO\N PRO\S TH\N LAM-PRO/THTA, TO\ DE\ YUXRO\N PRO\S TH\N QERMO/THTA TOU= PURO/S."2 *TAU=TA KI-NW=N <20E)N TW=| PRW/TW| TW=N *FUSIKW=N ZHTHMA/TWN>20 PA/LIN E)N TOI=S &10etc. &10@idem de primo frigido cp. 17 p. 952c.$8 E)PEI\ DE\ KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 OI)O/MENOS TO\N A)E/RA PRW/TWS YUXRO\N EI)=NAI, DIO/TI KAI\ SKOTEINO/N, E)MNH/SQH MO/NON TW=N PLE/ON A)FESTA/NAI TO\ U(/DWR TOU= AI)QE/ROS H)\ TO\N A)E/RA LEGO/N-TWN, KAI\ PRO\S AU)TOU/S TI BOULO/MENOS EI)PEI=N "1<20*OU(/TW ME\N A)/N"2, E)/FH, "1KAI\ TH\N GH=N YUXRA\N EI)=NAI PRW/TWS LE/GOIMEN, O(/TI TOU= AI)QE/ROS A)FE/STHKE PLEI=STON>20"2, W(S A)DO/KIMO/N TINA PANTELW=S TOU=TON KAI\ A)/TOPON @1 A)POR)R(I/YAS TO\N LO/GON, E)GW/ MOI DOKW= MHDE\ TH\N GH=N A)/MOIRON EI)KO/TWN KAI\ PIQANW=N A)POFAI/NEIN, POIHSA/MENOS A)RXH\N W(=| MA/LISTA <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 U(PE\R TOU= A)E/ROS KE/XRHTAI: TI/ DE\ TOU=TO/ E)STI; TO\ SKOTEINO\N O)/NTA PRW/TWS [2EI)=NAI KAI\ YUXRO\N PRW/TWS]2. @&idem de primo frigido cp. 9 p. 948d.$ E)PEI\ TO\ PU=R QERMO\N A(/MA KAI\ LAMPRO/N E)STI, DEI= TH\N A)NTIKEIME/NHN TW=| PURI\ FU/SIN YUXRA/N TE EI)=NAI KAI\ SKOTEINH/N: A)NTI/KEITAI GA\R W(S TW=| LAMPRW=| TO\ ZOFERO/N, OU(/TW TW=| QERMW=| TO\ YUXRO/N: E)/STI GA\R W(S O)/YEWS TO\ SKOTEINO/N, OU(/TW TO\ YU-XRO\N A(FH=S SUGXUTIKO/N: H( DE\ QERMO/THS DIAXEI= TH\N AI)/SQHSIN TOU= A(PTO-ME/NOU, KAQA/PER H( LAMPRO/THS TOU= O(RW=NTOS. TO\ A)/RA PRW/TWS SKOTEINO\N E)N TH=| FU/SEI PRW/TWS KAI\ YUXRO/N E)STIN. _O(/TI DE\ A)H\R TO\ PRW/TWS SKOTEINO/N E)STIN, OU)DE\ TOU\S POIHTA\S LE/LHQEN: A)E/RA GA\R TO\ SKO/TOS KA-LOU=SIN: @*)AH\R GA\R PARA\ NHUSI\ BAQU\S H)=N, OU)DE\ SELH/NH @OU)RANO/QEN PROU)/FAINEN. [1I& 143$]1 KAI\ PA/LIN: @*)HE/RA E(SSA/MENOI PA=SAN FOITW=SIN E)P' AI)=AN [1&Hes. Op. et D. 255$]1 KAI\ PA/LIN @*AU)TI/KA D' H)E/RA ME\N SKE/DASEN KAI\ A)PW=SEN O(MI/XLHN, @H)E/LIOS D' E)PE/LAMYE: MA/XH D' E)PI\ PA=SI FAA/NQH [1&P 649$]1 KAI\ GA\R "1KNE/FAS"2 TO\N A)FW/TISTON A)E/RA KALOU=SIN, KENO\N W(S E)/OIKE FA/OUS O)/NTA: KAI\ "1NE/FOS"2 O( SUMPESW\N KAI\ PUKNWQEI\S A)H\R A)POFA/SEI FWTO\S KE/KLHTAI: KALEI=TAI DE\ KAI\ A)XLU\S KAI\ O(MI/XLH, KAI\ O(/SA TOU= FW-TO\S OU) PARE/XEI TH=| AI)SQH/SEI DI/OYIN, A)E/ROS EI)SI\ DIAFORAI/: KAI\ TO\ A)EIDE\S AU)TOU= KAI\ A)/XRWSTON *)AI/+DHS KAI\ *)AXE/RWN E)PI/KLHSIN E)/SXEN. W(/SPER OU)=N AU)GH=S E)PILIPOU/SHS SKOTEINO\S A)H/R, OU(/TW QERMOU= METASTA/NTOS TO\ A)PO-LEIPO/MENON A)H\R YUXRO/S, A)/LLO DE\ OU)DE/N E)STI: DIO\ KAI\ TA/RTAROS OU(/TWS U(PO\ YUXRO/THTOS KE/KLHTAI: DHLOI= DE\ KAI\ *(HSI/ODOS EI)PW/N: @_TA/RTARON H)ERO/ENTA: [1&Hesiod. Theog. 119$]1 KAI\ TO\ R(IGOU=NTA PA/LLESQAI KAI\ TRE/MEIN TARTARI/ZEIN. TAU=TA ME\N OU)=N TOIOU=TON E)/XEI LO/GON. @&cp. 10.$ *)EPEI\ DE\ H( FQORA\ METABOLH/ TI/S E)STI TW=N FQEIROME/NWN EI)S TOU)NANTI/ON E(KA/STW|, SKOPW=MEN EI) KALW=S EI)/RHTAI TO\ "1*PURO\S QA/NA-TOS A)E/ROS GE/NESIS."2 *QNH/SKEI GA\R KAI\ PU=R, W(/SPER ZW=|ON, H)\ BI/A| SBEN-NU/MENON H)\ DI' AU(TOU= MARAINO/MENON. H( ME\N OU)=N SBE/SIS E)MFANESTE/RAN POIEI= TH\N EI)S A)E/RA METABOLH\N AU)TOU=: KAI\ GA\R O( KAPNO\S A)E/ROS E)STI\N EI)=DOS, KAI\ H( KATA\ *PI/NDARON, @*)AE/RA KNISA=NTI LAKTI/ZOISA KAPNW=| LIGNU\S KAI\ A)NAQUMI/ASIS. OU) MH\N A)LLA\ KAI\ FQINOU/SHS A)TROFI/A| FLO- @1GO\S I)DEI=N E)/STIN, W(/SPER E)PI\ TW=N LU/XNWN, TO\ A)/KRON EI)S A)E/RA KAI\ GNO-FW/DH KAI\ ZOFERO\N A)POXEO/MENON. I(KANW=S DE\ KAI\ O( TW=N META\ LOUTRO\N H)\ PURI/AN PERIXEAME/NWN YUXRO\N A)NIW\N A)TMO\S E)NDEI/KNUTAI TH\N EI)S A)E/RA TOU= QERMOU= FQEIROME/NOU METABOLH/N, W(S FU/SEI PRO\S TO\ PU=R A)NTIKEI/-MENON: W(=| TO\ PRW/TWS TO\N A)E/RA SKOTEINO\N EI)=NAI KAI\ YUXRO\N H)KOLOU/QEI. @&cp. 11.$ *KAI\ MH\N A(PA/NTWN GE TW=N GINOME/NWN U(PO\ YUXRO/THTOS E)N TOI=S SW/MASI SFODRO/TATON KAI\ BIAIO/TATON H( PH=CIS OU)=SA, PA/QOS ME/N E)STIN U(/DATOS, E)/RGON DE\ A)E/ROS: AU)TO\ ME\N GA\R KAQ' E(AUTO\ TO\ U(/DWR EU)-DIA/XUTON KAI\ A)PAGE\S KAI\ A)SU/STATO/N E)STIN, E)NTEI/NETAI DE\ KAI\ SUNA/GETAI TW=| A)E/RI SFIGGO/MENON U(PO\ YUXRO/THTOS: DIO\ KAI\ LE/LEKTAI, @*EI) DE\ NO/TOS BORE/HN PROKALE/SSETAI, AU)TI/KA NI/YEI: *TOU= GA\R NO/TOU KAQA/PER U(/LHN TH\N U(GRO/THTA PARASKEUA/SANTOS O( BO/-REIOS A)H\R U(POLABW\N E)/PHCE. KAI\ DH=LO/N E)STI MA/LISTA PERI\ TA\S XIO/NAS, A)E/RA GA\R MEQEI=SAI KAI\ PROANAPNEU/SASAI LEPTO\N KAI\ YUXRO\N OU(/TW R(E/OUSIN: *)ARISTOTE/LHS DE\ KAI\ TA\S A)KO/NAS TOU= MOLI/BDOU TH/KESQAI/ FHSI KAI\ R(EI=N U(PO\ KRU/OUS KAI\ XEIMW=NOS, U(/DATOS MO/NOU PLHSIA/ZONTOS AU)-TAI=S: O( DE\ A)H/R, W(S E)/OIKE, SUNELAU/NWN TA\ SW/MATA TH=| YUXRO/THTI KATA-QRAU/EI KAI\ R(H/GNUSIN. @&10Galenus de simpl. medicam. temp. II 20 ed. Bas. II 25 K. II 510.$10 KAI\ DH=LON W(S E)NTEU=QEN AU)TOU\S DIADE/XETAI ME/GISTON ZH/THMA, TO\ KAI\ TOI=S E)N-DOCOTA/TOIS FILOSO/FOIS H)MFISBHTHME/NON, *)ARISTOTE/LOUS ME\N KAI\ TW=N A)P' AU)TOU= QERMO\N U(POLAMBANO/NTWN EI)=NAI TO\N A)E/RA, TW=N D' <20A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 YUXRO/N. @&10Alexander de anima libri mantissa p. 124, 9 Bruns [1in capite$10 O(/TI AI( POIO/THTES OU) SW/MATA&10 adversus Stoicos scripto$10]1 E)/TI EI) SW=MA AI( POI-O/THTES KAI\ TO\ FW=S POIO/THS KAI\, <20W(S DOKEI= AU)TOI=S>20, SW=MA.&10 &10@p. 132, 30 [1in capite$10 PRO\S TOU\S DIA\ TH=S TOU= A)E/ROS SUNENTA/SEWS TO\ O(RA=N POIOU=NTAS,&10 adversus Chrysippum conscripto$10]1 E)/TI EI) TO\ FW=S SW=MA O)\N KAI\ DI' U(/DATOS KAI\ DIA\ TW=N A)/LLWN KEXWRHKE/NAI LE/GOUSIN, DH=LON W(S, A)\N FANH=| TO\ FW=S MH\ O)\N SW=MA, KENO\S O( LO/GOS A)\N EI)/H. EI) GA/R, DIO/TI SW=MA, <20E)PE/REISIS AU)TW=| GI/NETAI>20, A)\N MH\ SW=MA H)=|, DH=LON O(/TI OU)K E)PEREISQH/SETAI. E)/TI PW=S OU) SUGKRI/NETAI TH=| TOU= U(/DATOS YUXRO/THTI TO\ FW=S TOU=TO KAI\ PAU/ETAI TOU= FW=S EI)=NAI, <20EI)/PER DIAKRI/SEI FW=S E)STIN>20. E)/TI KAI\ E)N TOI=S PA/GOIS E)XRH=N H(=TTON FW=S GI/NESQAI, KAQA/PER KAI\ A)LE/AN. TO\ GA\R MH\ SUGKRI/NESQAI TO\ PNEU=MA U(/DA-TOS SUGKRINOME/NOU KAI\ KRUSTA/LLOU GINOME/NOU PARA/LOGON, EI)/ GE/ E)STIN A)H\R <20DIAKRINO/MENOS TO\ FW=S>20. @&10p. 138, 2 [1extremo capite$10 PRO\S TOU\S DIA\ TH=S A)POR)R(OI/AS TH=S A)P' A)MFOI=N TO\ O(RA=N LE/GONTAS]1 E)/TI KAI\ KATA\ TOU/TOUS SW=MA E)/STAI TO\ FW=S [1&10sequitur caput%10$10 O(/TI MH\ SW=MA TO\ FW=S]1. *EI) SW=MA TO\ FW=S, H)/TOI PU=R E)STI H)\ <20PURO\S A)POR)-R(OH/, H(\N AU)GH/N TE LE/GOUSIN KAI\ TRI/TON TI PURO\S EI)=DOS>20. @&10p. 139, 1.$10 E)/TI EI) SW=MA TO\ SKO/TOS, O( A)H/R, E)N W(=| GI/NETAI TO\ FW=S, H)/TOI DI' O(/LOU SW=MA W)\N DE/CETAI TO\ FW=S, KAI\ OU(/TW SW=MA DIA\ SW/MATOS XWRH/SEI, H)\ @1 E(/CEI PO/ROUS, DI' W(=N DI/EISIN TO\ FW=S. OU(=TOI DH\ H)/TOI, O(/TAN MH\ H)=| FW=S, E)/SON-TAI/ TINOS A)/LLOU SW/MATOS PLH/REIS, O(\ TI/ POTE E)ROU=SIN EI)=NAI, H)\ POU= MEQI/STASQAI; DEH/SEI GA\R AU)TO\ LEPTO/TERON A)E/ROS EI)=NAI, A)LLA\ KAI\ TOU= FWTO\S AU)TOU=, EI)/ GE KAI\ TOU/TW| U(POXWREI= KAI\ MEQI/STATAI: TI/ D' A)\N EI)/H SW=MA <20KAT' AU)TOU\S>20 TOU= FWTO\S LEPTO/TERON; __EI) DE\ OI( TOU= A)E/ROS PO/ROI KENOI\ ME/NOUSIN O)/NTOS SKO/TOUS, PRW=TON ME\N E)/STAI KENO/N TI E)NERGEI/A| E)N TW=| KO/SMW| KAT' AU)TOU/S, <20O(/PER OU) QE/LOUSIN>20, E)/TI KAI\ MANO/TEROS O( A)H\R E)/STAI TH=S NUKTO/S, A(/TE E)/XWN E)N AU(TW=| KENA/ [1DOKEI= DE\ PUKNO/TEROS GI/NESQAI TO/TE]1, E)/TI <20TO\ FW=S OU)K E)/STAI DIAKRITIKO\N KAI\ LEPTUNTIKO\N TOU= A)E/ROS, W(S LE/GOUSIN>20, A)LLA\ TOU)-NANTI/ON. @&10Galenus in Hippocr. Epidem. VI comment. IV Vol. XVII B. &10p. 161 K.$10 *LAMPRO\N GA\R FAI/NETAI TO\ KAQARO\N U(/DWR OU)K AU)GH=S TINOS E)/CWQEN E)MPIPTOU/SHS EI)S AU)TO\ LAMPRA=S, A)LLA\ KATA\ TH\N A)LLOI/WSIN, H(\N E)K TOU= PROS-PI/PTONTOS E)/XEI FWTO/S, W(/SPER GE KAI\ AU)TO\S O( A)H/R. OU)DE\ GA\R OU)D' OU(=TO/S E)STI KATA\ TH\N AU(TOU= FU/SIN LAMPRO/S: PA/NTWS [2GA\R]2 A)\N H)=N KAI\ NU/KTWR TOIOU=TOS. A)LLA\ <20TOI=S A)/NW PE/RASIN AU)TOU= PROSPIPTOU/SHS TH=S H(LIAKH=S AU)GH=S O(/LOS A)LLOIOU=TAI/ TE KAI\ METABA/LLETAI SUNEXH\S W)\N E(AUTW=|>20. TO\ DE\ KENA\S EI)=NAI/ TINAS XW/RAS H)\ KATA\ TO\ U(/DWR H)\ KATA\ TO\N A)E/RA, TH=| ME\N *)EPIKOU/-ROU TE KAI\ *)ASKLHPIA/DOU DO/CH| PERI\ TW=N STOIXEI/WN A)KO/LOUQO/N E)STIN: TH=| D' *)ARISTOTE/LOUS TE KAI\ [2TW=N]2 <20*STWI+KW=N>20 E)NANTI/ON, OU)DAMO/QI KENO\N OU)DE\N E)N TW=| KO/SMW| PEPEISME/NWN U(PA/RXEIN, A)LL' E)KPEPLHRW=SQAI PA/NTA SW/MASIN. OU)DE\ GA\R KATA\ TH\N KI/SSHRIN AI( METACU\ TW=N GEWDW=N SWMA/TWN XW=RAI PANTA/PASIN AU)TOI=S EI)=NAI DOKOU=SI KENAI/. PERIE/XESQAI GOU=N E)N AU)TAI=S TO\N A)E/RA FASI/. KATA\ ME/NTOI TO\ U(/DWR OU)K EI)=NAI/ TINA POROPOII/+AN TOIAU/THN O(POI/A KATA\ TH\N KI/SSHRI/N E)STIN, A)LLA\ SUNEXE\S E(AUTW=| PANTOI/WS U(PA/RXEIN AU)TO/.&10 &10@Plutarchus de facie in orbe lunae cp. 18 p. 930f.$10 AU)TO\N DE\ TO\N A)E/RA LE/GOUSIN OU)K A)POR)R(OI/AIS TISI\N OU)DE\ A)KTI=SI MEMIGME/NAIS, A)LLA\ TROPH=| KAI\ META-BOLH=| KATA\ NU/CIN H)\ YAU=SIN E)CHLIOU=SQAI. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 42 p. 1053e.$ *TO\N A)E/RA POTE\ ME\N A)NWFERH= KAI\ KOU=FON EI)=NAI/ FHSI___*)EN ME\N OU)=N <20TW=| DEUTE/RW| PERI\ *KINH/SEWS>20 "1TO/ TE PU=R, A)BARE\S O)/N, A)NWFERE\S EI)=NAI LE/GEI, KAI\ TOU/TW| PARAPLHSI/WS TO\N A)E/RA, TOU= ME\N U(/DATOS TH=| GH=| MA=L-LON PROSNEMOME/NOU, TOU= D' A)E/ROS TW=| PURI/."2 @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 42 p. 1053e.$ <20*)EN DE\ TAI=S *FUSIKAI=S *TE/XNAIS>20 E)PI\ TH\N E(TE/RAN R(E/PEI DO/CAN, W(S "1MH/TE BA/ROS E)C AU(TOU=, MH/TE KOUFO/THTA TOU= A)E/ROS E)/XONTOS."2 @&10Scholia Pind. Olymp. I 1 p. 22B.$10 TH=| TW=N FILOSO/FWN E(PO/MENOS GNW/MH|, OI(\ FUSIKW/TERON KINHQE/NTES E)K TOU= U(/DATOS E)/FASAN KAI\ TA\ A)/LLA TRI/A STOIXEI=A SUNI/STASQAI: TO\ ME\N GA\R AU)TOU=, TO\ LEPTOMERE/S, A)E/RA LE/GOUSI GI/NESQAI, TO\ DE\ PAXU/TERON EI)S E(AUTO\ SUNISTA/MENON GH=N, A)POTELEI=N DE\ A)POLEPTUNO/MENON TO\N DIA/PURON AI)QE/RA PU=R. @&10Philo de incorrupt. mund. 225, 5 B.$10 *XA/OS D' O( ME\N *)ARISTOTE/LHS TO/PON OI)/ETAI EI)=NAI, O(/TI TO\ DECO/MENON A)NA/GKH PROU+POKEI=SQAI SW/MATI, TW=N DE\ *STWI+KW=N E)/NIOI TO\ U(/DWR, PARA\ TH\N XU/SIN TOU)/NOMA PEPOIH=SQAI NOMI/ZONTES. @1 @&10Galenus de simplic. medicam. IX 1 Vol. XII p. 165 K.$10 E(\N ME\N DH\ TOU=TO SHMAINO/MENO/N E)STI TOU= TH=S GH=S O)NO/MATOS A(/PASI SU/NHQES, E(/TERON DE\ MO/NON TOI=S FILOSO/FOIS, E)PEIDA\N LE/GWSI TW=N SWMA/TWN STOIXEI=A GH=N KAI\ U(/DWR KAI\ A)E/RA KAI\ PU=R. <20TO\ GA\R CHRO\N E)SXA/TWS SW=MA KAI\ YUXRO\N O)NOMA/ZOUSI GH=N>20. KATA\ TOU/TOUS OU)=N OU)DE\N ME\N TW=N SUNQE/TWN TOU/TWN SWMA/TWN E)STI\N H( STOIXEIW/DHS GH=, PLEI=STON ME/NTOI TH=S GH=S E)/XEIN AU)TA/ FASIN, OI(=ON TO/N TE A)DA/MANTA KAI\ TA\S PE/TRAS, KAI\ O(/SW| G' A)\N W)=SI SKLHRO/TERA TO\ SW=MA, TOSOU/TW| MA=LLON AU)TA\ EI)=NAI/ FASI GEWDE/STERA. __KATA\ ME\N OU)=N TO\ PARA\ TOI=S FILOSO/FOIS SHMAINO/MENON AI( TH=S GH=S DIAFORAI\ TRISI\N O(RISQH/SON-TAI GE/NESIN. <20E)/STI GA\R TO\ ME/N TI LI/QOS AU)TH=S, TO\ DE\ METALLEUTO/N TI SW=MA, TO\ DE\ TRI/TON H( GEWRGOUME/NH GH=>20, DIAFWNI/AS GEGONUI/AS PAR' AU)TOI=S PERI\ TW=N XEOME/NWN METALLEUTW=N SWMA/TWN, OI(=ON XALKOU= KAI\ KASSITE/ROU KAI\ MOLU/BDOU. TAU=TA GA\R E)/NIOI/ FASIN OU) GH=S, A)LL' U(/DATOS E)/XEIN TO\ PLE/ON. __E)KEI=NO MO/NON E)/TI PROSQEI/S, W(S H( PROEIRHME/NH TOMH\ TW=N GEWDW=N SW-MA/TWN EI)/S TE LI/QOUS KAI\ TA\ METALLEUO/MENA KAI\ TH\N GEWRGOUME/NHN GH=N A)/NEU TW=N FUSIKW=N I)DI/WS O)NOMAZOME/NWN SWMA/TWN EI)/RHTAI. TOU/TWN DE\ PROSIO/NTWN KAI\ <20TA\ CU/LA PA/NTA KAI\ KARPW=N MO/RIA POLLA/, KAQA/PER KAI\ ZW/|WN, O)NOMASQH/SETAI GEW/DH TH\N OU)SI/AN EI)=NAI>20. KARPW=N ME\N MO/RIA PURH=NES E)LAIW=N KAI\ GI/GARTA STAFULW=N KAI\ KARU/WN LE/MMATA KAI\ KW/NWN, E(/TERA/ TE POLLA\ TOIAU=TA, TW=N ZW/|WN DE\ TA/ T' O)STE/A KAI\ TA\ KE/RATA KAI\ OI( O)DO/NTES. @&10Galenus$10 PERI\ PLH/QOUS&10 3 Vol. VII p. 525 K.$10 POIEI=N D' EI)S E(AUTO\ LE/GEIN O(TIOU=N H)\ E)NERGEI=N EI)S E(AUTO\ PARA\ TH\N E)/NNOIA/N E)STIN: OU(/TWS OU)=N KAI\ SUNE/XEIN E(AUTO/. KAI\ GA\R OI( MA/LISTA EI)SHGHSA/MENOI TH\N SUNEKTIKH\N DU/-NAMIN, W(S <20OI( *STWI+KOI/>20, TO\ ME\N SUNE/XON E(/TERON POIOU=SI, TO\ SUNEXO/MENON DE\ A)/LLO: <20TH\N ME\N GA\R PNEUMATIKH\N OU)SI/AN TO\ SUNE/XON, TH\N DE\ U(LIKH\N TO\ SUNEXO/MENON: O(/QEN A)E/RA ME\N KAI\ PU=R SUNE/XEIN FASI/, GH=N DE\ KAI\ U(/DWR SUNE/XESQAI>20. @&10Galenus$10 PERI\ PLH/QOUS&10 3 Vol. VII p. 526 K.$10 O(/PWS TOI/NUN A)NAG-KAI=O/N E)STIN EI)S A)/TOPON TO\N LO/GON A)XQH=NAI, QEME/NWN H(MW=N A(/PAN TO\ O)\N DEI=-SQAI SUNEKTIKH=S AI)TI/AS, H)/DH SOI DI/EIMI. TH\N SUNEKTIKH\N AI)TI/AN, H(/TIS POT' E)STI/N [1OU) GA\R O(MOLOGOU=SIN AU)TH\N OI( *(HROFI/LEIOI GIGNW/SKEIN]1, A)=RA/ GE E)K TW=N O)/NTWN TI\ KAI\ AU)TOI\ U(POLAMBA/NOUSIN H)\ TW=N OU)K O)/NTWN; EI) ME\N GA\R TW=N OU)K O)/NTWN TI, QAUMA/ZW TH\N SOFI/AN TW=N A)NDRW=N, EI) KAI\ TW=N O)/NTWN E(/KASTON DEI=-SQAI/ FASI TW=N OU)K O)/NTWN TINO/S: EI) DE\ TW=N O)/NTWN TI/QENTAI TH\N SUNEKTIKH\N AI)TI/AN, A)NAMNHSQH/TWSAN, W(S <20A(/PAN TO\ O)\N E)/FASAN AI)TI/AS DEI=SQAI SUN-EKTIKH=S EI)S TO\ EI)=NAI>20. SUMBH/SETAI GA\R OU(/TWS KAI\ AU)TH\N TH\N AI)TI/AN AI)-TI/AS E(TE/RAS, I(/NA U(PA/RXH|, DEHQH=NAI, KA)KEI/NHN AU)=QIS A)/LLHS KAI\ TOU=TO EI)S A)/PEIRON. EI) DE\ <20TW=N O)/NTWN TA\ ME\N E(TE/ROU TINO\S AI)TI/OU DEI=SQAI PRO\S TO\ EI)=NAI, TA\ DE\ E)C AU(TW=N E)/XEIN TO\ EI)=NAI>20 FH/SOUSI, PRW=TON ME\N I)/STWSAN OU)KE/TI DIAFULA/TTONTES TO\ E)C A)RXH=S A)CI/WMA. __DEU/TERON DE\ MAKROTA/TOU XRH/|ZONTES LO/GOU DIA\ TI/ TA\ ME\N DEI=TAI, TA\ DE\ OU) DEI=TAI, H)\ KAI\ O(POI=A E)K TOU/-TWN AU)TW=N E)STIN E(KA/TERA. OU)DE\ GA\R OU)D' OI( POLLOI\ TW=N *(HROFILEI/WN OU)D' @1 <20OI( NEW/TEROI *STWI+KOI\>20 LE/GOUSI/ TINA A)PO/DEICIN TOU= <20TO\ ME\N PNEU=MA KAI\ TO\ PU=R SUNE/XEIN E(AUTO/ TE KAI\ TA\ A)/LLA, TO\ DE\ U(/DWR KAI\ TH\N GH=N E(TE/ROU DEI=SQAI TOU= SUNE/CONTOS>20. O(/SON ME\N GA\R E)PI\ TH=| PROXEI/RW| FAN-TASI/A| TO\ ME\N SKLHRO\N KAI\ A)NTI/TUPON KAI\ PUKNO\N E(AUTO\ SUNE/XEIN [2A)\N]2 LE/GOITO, TO\ D' A)RAIO/N TE KAI\ MALAKO\N KAI\ U(PEI=KON E(TE/ROU DEI=SQAI TOU= SUNE/CONTOS. OU) MO/NON DE\ OU)DEMI/AN A)PO/DEICIN EI)PO/NTES OI( A)/NDRES A)CIOU=SI PISTEU/ESQAI TH\N U(PO/QESIN AU)TW=N, A)LLA\ KAI\ PRO\S E(AUTH\N U(POTIQE/MENOI MAXOME/NHN OU)K E)/TI AI)SQA/NONTAI. TA\ GA\R A(PA/NTWN LEPTOMERE/STERA KAI\ MALAKW/TERA KAI\ EI)KTIKW/-TERA, TO\ PU=R KAI\ [2TO\N]2 A)E/RA, TAU=T' AI)/TIA TH=| GH=| TH=S SKLHRO/THTO/S TE KAI\ A)NTITUPI/AS EI)=NAI/ FASIN, W(S E)NDEXO/MENON E(/TERON E(TE/RW| TINI\ METADOU=NAI DUNA/-MEWS H)\ FU/SEWS H)\ E)NERGEI/AS H)\ POIO/THTOS, H(=S OU) METEI/LHFEN AU)TO/. KAI\ GA\R AU)= KAI\ FAI/NETAI SAFW=S OU) MO/NON OU)DE\N U(PO\ TOU= PURO\S SUNEXO/MENON, A)LLA\ KAI\ DIALUO/MENA PA/NTA. PRO\S ME\N DH\ TH\N <20TW=N *STWI+KW=N>20 U(PO/QESIN E(TE/RWQI LE/LEKTAI DIA\ PLEIO/NWN. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de mixtione p. 223, 25 Bruns.$10 TOU/TOU D' OU(/TWS E)/XONTOS, PW=S A)\N E)/TI A)LHQE\S EI)/H, <20TO\ PA=N H(NW=SQAI/ TE KAI\ SUN-E/XESQAI, PNEU/MATO/S TINOS DIA\ PANTO\S DIH/KONTOS AU)TOU=>20; E)/PEITA D' EU)/LOGON ME\N H)=N, O(MOI/AN TH\N U(PO\ TOU= PNEU/MATOS SUNOXH\N GINOME/NHN E)N PA=SIN EI)=NAI TOI=S SW/MASIN: OU)X OU(/TWS D' E)/XEI. TW=N GA\R SWMA/TWN TA\ ME/N E)STI SUN-EXH=, TA\ DE\ DIWRISME/NA. DIO\ EU)LOGW/TERON, E(/KASTON AU)TW=N U(PO\ TOU= OI)KEI/OU EI)/DOUS SUNE/XESQAI/ TE KAI\ H(NW=SQAI LE/GEIN PRO\S E(AUTO/, KAQ' O(/ E)STIN AU)TW=N E(KA/STW| TO\ EI)=NAI, TH\N [2DE\]2 SUMPA/QEIAN AU)TW=N SW/|ZESQAI TH\N PRO\S A)/LLHLA DIA/ TE TH\N TH=S U(/LHS KOINWNI/AN KAI\ TH\N TOU= PERIKEIME/NOU QEI/OU SW/MATOS AU)TW=| FU/SIN H)\ TW=| DIA\ TOU= PNEU/MATOS DESMW=|. <20TI/S GA\R KAI\ O( TO/NOS TOU= PNEU/MATOS, U(F' OU(= SUNDOU/MENA TH/N TE SUNE/XEIAN E)/XEI TH\N PRO\S TA\ OI)KEI=A ME/RH KAI\ SUNH=PTAI TOI=S PARAKEIME/NOIS>20; BIAZO/MENON ME\N GA\R U(PO/ TINOS TO\ PNEU=MA, DIA\ TH\N PRO\S TOU=TO EU)FUI/+AN, TW=| MHDEMI/AN A)NTI/BASIN E)/XEIN TW=| KINOU=NTI DI' EU)PA/QEIAN DU/NASQAI, U(PO\ TH=S A)QRO/AS KINH/SEWS I)SXU/N TINA LAMBA/NEI: EU)PAQE\S DE\ O)\N KATA\ TH\N OI)KEI/AN FU/SIN, U(GRO/N E)STI KAI\ EU)-DIAI/RETON, W(S KAI\ TW=N A)/LLWN, E)N OI(=S A)\N H)=| TOU=TO MEMIGME/NON, KATA\ TOU=TO MA/LISTA/ [TE KAI\] R(A/|STHN GI/NESQAI TH\N DIAI/RESIN. _KAI\ GA\R EI) <20TOU= MH\ DIAPI/PTEIN, A)LLA\ SUMME/NEIN TA\ SW/MATA AI)/TION TO\ SUNE/XON AU)TA\ PNEU=MA>20, TA\ DIAPI/PTONTA TW=N SWMA/TWN DH=LON W(S OU)K A)\N E)/XOI TO\ PNEU=MA TO\ SUNDE/ON. PW=S D' A)\N TH\N A)RXH\N H( DIAI/RESIS SW/|ZOITO TW=N SWMA/TWN, EI)/ GE H( ME\N DIAI/RESIS XWRISMO/S E)STI TW=N H(NWME/NWN, ME/NEI DE\ KAT' AU)TOU\S [TW=N] H(NWME/NA O(MOI/WS A)LLH/LOIS PA/NTA, KA)\N DIAIREQH=|. PW=S D' OU)K A)\N A)PEMFAI/NOI TO\ TA\ PARAKEI/MENA A)LLH/LOIS KAI\ R(A|DI/WS A)LLH/LWN XWRI/ZESQAI DUNA/MENA U(P[2O\ T]2AU)TOU= KAI\ O(MOI/WS A)LLH/LOIS H(NW=SQAI LE/GEIN TOI=S SUNEXE/SI TE OU)=SI KAI\ XWRI\S DIAIRE/SEWS MH\ DUNAME/NOIS [TINO\S] A)LLH/LWN XWRISQH=NAI/ POTE. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de mixtione p. 224, 14 Bruns.$10 PRO\S DE\ TOU/-TOIS EI) <20TO\ PNEU=MA GEGONO\S E)K PURO/S TE KAI\ A)E/ROS DIA\ PA/NTWN PE- @1FOI/THKE TW=N SWMA/TWN [2TW=|]2 PA=SIN AU)TOI=S KEKRA=SQAI KAI\ E(KA/STW| AU)TW=N E)K TOU/TOU H)RTH=SQAI TO\ EI)=NAI>20, PW=S A)\N E)/TI A(PLOU=N TI EI)/H SW=MA; PW=S D' A)/N, EI) U(/STERON TO\ E)/K TINWN SUGKEI/MENON TW=N A(PLW=N, TO\ PU=R A)\N KAI\ O( A)H\R EI)/H, E)C W(=N MIGNUME/NWN TO\ PNEU=MA GI/NETAI, OU(= XWRI\S A)DU/NATON EI)=NAI/ TI SW=MA; EI) GA\R E)C E)KEI/NWN ME\N H( GE/NESIS TW=| PNEU/MATI, A)DU/NATON DE\ E)KEI/NWN EI)=NAI/ TI XWRI\S PNEU/MATOS, OU)/T' A)\N E)KEI/NWN TI EI)/H PRO\ TH=S TOU= PNEU/MATOS GENE/SEWS, OU)/T' A)\N TO\ PNEU=MA GI/NOITO, OU)K O)/NTWN E)C W(=N H( GE/NESIS AU)TW=|. PW=S D' A)/N TIS E)N TW=| YUXRW=| E)NERGEI/A| TI QERMO\N EI)=NAI LE/GOI; TI/S DE\ <20KAI\ H( EI)S TO\ E)NANTI/ON A(/MA KI/NHSIS AU)TOU=, KAQ' H(\N SUNE/XEI TA\ E)N OI(=S A)\N H)=|, O)/N, W(/S FASI, PNEU=MA KINOU/MENON A(/MA E)C AU(TOU= TE KAI\ EI)S AU(TO/>20, KAI\ KATA\ TI/ EI)=DOS KINH/SEWS GI/NETAI; @&10Plotinus Ennead. IV lib. VII, 3 [1Vol. II p. 106, 20 Mu+.]1.$10 LUQH/-SETAI/ TE KAI\ TO/DE TO\ CU/MPAN, EI)/ TIS AU)TO\ PISTEU/SEIE SW/MATOS SUNE/RCEI, DI-DOU\S AU)TW=| YUXH=S TA/CIN ME/XRI TW=N O)NOMA/TWN, A)E/RI KAI\ PNEU/MATI SKEDASTO-TA/TW|.&10 &10@ibid. 4.$10 MARTUROU=SI DE\ KAI\ AU)TOI\ U(PO\ TH=S A)LHQEI/AS A)GO/MENOI, W(S DEI= TI PRO\ TW=N SWMA/TWN EI)=NAI KREI=TTON AU)TW=N YUXH=S EI)=DOS, <20E)/NNOUN TO\ PNEU=MA KAI\ PU=R NOERO\N TIQE/MENOI>20, W(/SPER A)/NEU PURO\S KAI\ PNEU/MATOS OU) DUNA-ME/NHS TH=S KREI/TTONOS MOI/RAS E)N TOI=S OU)=SIN EI)=NAI, TO/PON DE\ ZHTOU/SHS EI)S TO\ I(DRUQH=NAI__EI) DE\ <20MHDE\N PARA\ TO\ PNEU=MA TH\N ZWH\N KAI\ TH\N YUXH\N TI/QENTAI>20, TI/ TO\ POLUQRU/LLHTON AU)TOI=S "1PW\S E)/XON"2, EI)S O(\ KATA-FEU/GOUSIN A)NAGKAZO/MENOI TI/QESQAI A)/LLHN PARA\ TA\ SW/MATA FU/SIN DRASTH/RION; EI) OU)=N OU) PA=N ME\N PNEU=MA YUXH/N [1O(/TI MURI/A PNEU/MATA A)/YUXA]1, TO\ DE\ PW\S E)/XON PNEU=MA FH/SOUSI, TO\ "1PW\S E)/XON"2 TOU=TO KAI\ TAU/THN TH\N SXE/SIN H)\ TW=N O)/NTWN TI FH/SOUSIN H)\ MHDE/N: A)LL' EI) ME\N MHDE/N, PNEU=MA A)\N EI)/H MO/NON, TO\ DE\ "1PW\S E)/XON"2 O)/NOMA: KAI\ OU(/TW SUMBH/SETAI AU)TOI=S, OU)DE\ A)/LLO OU)DE\N EI)=NAI LE/GEIN H)\ TH\N U(/LHN: KAI\ YUXH\N KAI\ QEO\N KAI\ %2%2%2 O)NO/MATA PA/NTA, E)KEI=NO DE\ MO/NON [2O)/N]2. @&10Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 49 p. 1085c.$10 TA/ GE MH\N TE/SSARA SW/MATA, GH=N KAI\ U(/DWR A)E/RA TE KAI\ PU=R, PRW=TA STOIXEI=A PROSAGOREU/ONTES, OU)K OI)=D' O(/PWS TA\ ME\N A(PLA= KAI\ KAQARA/, TA\ DE\ SU/NQETA KAI\ MEMIGME/NA POIOU=SI. <20GH=N ME\N GA/R FASI KAI\ U(/DWR OU)/Q' E(AUTA\ SUNE/XEIN OU)/Q' E(/TERA, PNEUMATIKH=S DE\ METOXH=| KAI\ PURW/DOUS DUNA/MEWS TH\N E(NO/-THTA DIAFULA/TTEIN: A)E/RA DE\ KAI\ PU=R AU(TW=N T' EI)=NAI DI' EU)TONI/AN E(KTIKA/, KAI\ TOI=S DUSI\N E)KEI/NOIS E)GKEKRAME/NA TO/NON PARE/XEIN KAI\ TO\ MO/NIMON KAI\ OU)SIW=DES>20. &10Ex his Plutarchus concludit%10$10 A)LL' OU)K E)/STI GH= KAQ' E(AUTH\N OU)D' U(/DWR: A)LLA\ TH\N U(/LHN O( A)H\R W(=DE ME\N SUNAGAGW\N KAI\ PUKNW/SAS GH=N E)POI/HSEN, W(=DE DE\ PA/LIN DIALUQEI=SAN KAI\ MALAXQEI=SAN U(/DWR. OU)DE/TERON OU)=N TOU/TWN STOIXEI=ON, OI(=S E(/TERON A)MFOTE/ROIS OU)SI/AN KAI\ GE/NESIN PARE/SXHKEN. @&10Scholia Hesiod. Theogon. v. 120.$10 TA\ TRI/A STOIXEI=A EI)PW\N TO\ TE/TARTON LE/GEI, TO\ PU=R, O(/PER DAIMONI/WS E)/RWTA/ FHSI: SUNARMO/ZEIN GA\R KAI\ E(NOU=N PE/FUKEN. @1 @&10Galenus de tremore, palpitatione, convulsione 6 Vol. VII p. 616K.$10 OU)K O)/GKOUS KAI\ PO/ROUS H(MW=N STOIXEI=A TIQEME/NWN TOU= SW/MATOS_A)LLA\ TO\ ME\N O(/LON SW=MA SU/MPNOUN TE KAI\ SU/R)R(OUN H(GOUME/NWN, TO\ QERMO\N D' OU)K E)PI/KTHTON OU)D' U(/STERON TOU= ZW/|OU TH=S GENE/SEWS, A)LL' AU)TO\ PRW=TO/N TE KAI\ A)R-XE/GONON KAI\ E)/MFUTON. KAI\ H(/ GE FU/SIS KAI\ H( YUXH\ OU)DE\N A)/LLO H)\ TOU=T' E)/STIN, W(/ST' OU)SI/AN AU)TOKI/NHTO/N TE KAI\ A)EIKI/NHTON AU)TO\ NOW=N OU)K A)\N A(MA/R-TOIS. __A(/TE GA\R A)EIKI/NHTON O)\N TO\ E)/MFUTON QERMO/N, <20OU)/T' EI)/SW MO/NON OU)/T' E)/CW KINEI=TAI, DIADE/XETAI D' A)EI\ TH\N E(TE/RAN AU)TOU= KI/NHSIN H( E(TE/RA.>20 TAXU\ GA\R A)\N H( ME\N E)/SW MONH\ KATE/PAUSEN EI)S A)KINHSI/AN, H( DE\ E)KTO\S E)SKE/DASE/ TE KAI\ TAU/TH| DIE/FQEIREN AU)TO/. <20ME/TRIA DE\ SBENNU/MENON KAI\ ME/TRIA A)NAPTO/MENON, W(S *(HRA/KLEITOS E)/LEGEN, A)EIKI/NHTON OU(/TW ME/NEI>20. A)NA/PTETAI ME\N OU)=N TH=| KA/TW SUNNEU/SEI, TH=S TROFH=S O)REGO/MENON: AI)-RO/MENON DE\ KAI\ PA/NTH SKIDNA/MENON SBE/NNUTAI. A)LLA\ TH\N ME\N A)/NW TE KAI\ E)/CW FORA\N KAI\ W(S A)/N TIS EI)/POI E)CA/PLWSIN A)PO\ TH=S I)DI/AS A)RXH=S, DIO/TI FU/SEI QERMO/N E)STI, KE/KTHTAI: TH\N D' EI)/SW TE KAI\ KA/TW, TOUTE/STIN E)PI\ TH\N I)DI/AN A)RXH\N O(DO/N, O(/TI YUXROU= TI METE/XEI: MIKTO\N GA\R E)K QERMOU= KAI\ YUXROU= GE/-GONE: KATA\ ME\N TO\N PRW=TON LO/GON TOU= QERMOU=, [2H(=|]2 TOU=T' E)/STIN AU)TOKI/NHTON AU)TOU= KAI\ TOU/TOU MA/LISTA DEI=TAI PRO\S TA\S E)NERGEI/AS: MEGA/LHN D' O(/MWS AU)TW=| XREI/AN KAI\ TO\ YUXRO\N PARE/XEI. PE/FUKE GA\R TO\ ME\N QERMO\N EI)S U(/YOS AI)/RE-SQAI KAI\ SUMPROSA/GEIN AU(TW=| TH\N TROFH/N. EI) DE\ MH\ TO\ YUXRO\N E)MPODW\N E)GE/NETO, KAI\ E)PI\ MH/KISTON PROH=KE. GI/NETAI D' E)MPODW\N TO\ YUXRO\N TH=| TOIAU/TH| TOU= QERMOU= KINH/SEI, W(S MH\ A)PO/LOITO E)KTEINO/MENON. KI/NDUNOS GA\R U(PO\ KOU-FO/THTOS KAI\ TH=S PRO\S TO\ A)/NW O(RMH=S A)POSTH=NAI TW=N SWMA/TWN AU)TO/. A)LLA\ TO\ YUXRO\N E)PE/XEI TE KAI\ KWLU/EI KAI\ TH=S A)/GAN TAU/THS KINH/SEWS A)FAIREI= TO\ SFODRO/N. @&10Clemens Al. Stromat. V 8 p. 674$10 SFI\GC DE\ OU)X H( TW=N O(/LWN SU/NESIS KAI\ H( TOU= KO/SMOU KATA\ TO\N POIHTH\N *)/ARATON PERIFORA/. A)LLA\ TA/XA ME\N O( <20DIH/KWN PNEUMATIKO\S TO/NOS KAI\ SUNE/XWN TO\N KO/SMON>20 EI)/H A)/N. A)/MEINON DE\ E)KDE/XESQAI TO\N AI)QE/RA PA/NTA SUNE/XONTA KAI\ SFI/GGONTA: KAQA\ KAI\ O( *)EMPEDOKLH=S FHSI/N: [1&10v. 130_33 St.]1 &10@Alexander Aphrod. de anima libri mant. p. 131, 5 Bruns.$10 TO\ DE\ O(/LON A)PORI/AS E)/XEI POLLA\S H( <20PERI\ TH=S TONIKH=S KINH/SEWS DO/CA>20. PRW=-TON ME\N GA\R O(MOEIDE/S TI O)\N AU)TO\ E(AUTO\ KINH/SEI, O(\ A)DU/NATON DEI/KNUTAI PRO-XEIRIZOME/NOIS TA\S KAQE/KASTA KINH/SEIS. E)/PEITA EI)/PER <20E(/N TI SUNE/XEI TO/N TE SU/NOLON KO/SMON A(/MA TOI=S E)N AU)TW=|, KAI\ KAQ' E(/KASTON TW=N E)PI\ ME/ROUS SWMA/TWN E)STI/ TI O(\ SUNE/XEI>20, PW=S OU)K A)NAGKAI=ON TAU)TO\N A(/MA TA\S E)NANTI/AS KINEI=SQAI KINH/SEIS. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 43 p. 1053f.$ PA/LIN E)N <20TOI=S PERI\ *(/ECEWN>20 "1OU)DE\N A)/LLO TA\S E(/CEIS PLH\N A)E/RAS EI)=NAI/ FHSIN: U(PO\ TOU/TWN GA\R SUNE/XETAI TA\ SW/MATA: KAI\ TOU= POIO\N E(/KASTON EI)=NAI TW=N E(/CEI SUNEXOME/NWN O( SUNE/XWN AI)/TIOS A)H/R E)STIN, O(\N SKLHRO/THTA ME\N E)N SIDH/RW|, PUKNO/THTA D' E)N LI/QW|, LEUKO/THTA D' E)N A)RGU/RW| KALOU=SI."2 @&p. 1054a.$ *KAI/TOI <20PANTAXOU=>20 "1TH\N U(/LHN A)RGO\N E)C E(AUTH=S KAI\ A)KI/NHTON U(POKEI=SQAI TAI=S POIO/THSIN A)POFAI/NOUSI, TA\S DE\ POIO/THTAS @1 PNEU/MATA OU)/SAS KAI\ TO/NOUS A)ERW/DEIS, OI(=S A)\N E)GGE/NWNTAI ME/RESI TH=S U(/LHS, EI)DOPOIEI=N E(/KASTA KAI\ SXHMATI/ZEIN."2 @&10Galenus de musculorum motu I cp. 7 et 8 [1K. vol. IV p. 400$10]1 DIO/TI ME\N GA\R E)NERGOU=SIN OI( MU/ES DIA\ TOU=T' AU)TOU\S KINEI=SQAI LE/GOMEN: DIO/TI D' OU)/Q' O(/LON TO\ KW=LON OU(= ME/ROS EI)SI/N, OU)/T' AU)TOI\ KATA\ MO/NAS FAI/NONTAI KINOU/MENOI, DIA\ TOU=T' AU)TOU\S PA/LIN OU) TOLMW=MEN O(MO-LOGEI=N KINEI=SQAI. TI/NA OU)=N A)/N TIS LU/SIN E)FEU/ROI TH=S A)PORI/AS; PO/TERON H(\N <20OI( TA\S TONIKA\S KALOUME/NAS U(POQE/MENOI KINH/SEIS>20, H)/ TINA E(TE/RAN BEL-TIO/NA__; &10cp. 8.$10 KAI\ DH\ POIOU=MEN OU(/TWS KAI\ PRW=TON <20ME\N W(/SPER E)KEI=NOI DIDA/SKOUSIN>20 O( LO/GOS PROI/+TW. *NOH/SWMEN E(/LKESQAI/ TI SW=MA TW=N A)YU/XWN, OI(=ON CU/LON H)\ LI/QON U(PO/ TOU, AU)=QIS D' AU)= NOH/SWMEN U(F' E(TE/ROU TINO\S E)PI\ TA)NANTI/A TAU)TO\ TOU=TO PA/LIN A)NTISPA=SQAI, KRATEI=N ME/NTOI TH=| R(W/MH| TH\N PRO-TE/RAN O(LKH\N KAI\ DIA\ TOU=Q' E(/PESQAI ME\N E)KEI/NH| TO\ SW=MA, POLU\ D' H(=TTON H)\ EI) PRO\S MHDENO\S A)NQEI/LKETO. TRI/THN DH\ KATA/STASIN TW=| TOIOU/TW| SW/MATI PROS-FE/RWMEN O(/TAN I)SOSQENW=S EI)S TA)NANTI/A TEI/NHTAI. OU)KOU=N H( ME\N PRW/TH KA-TA/STASIS E)KI/NHSEN AU)TO\ MI/AN KI/NHSIN O(/SHN H( TOU= KINOU=NTOS DU/NAMIS H)DU/NATO KAI\ EI)S TOSAU/THN H)NA/GKASE PROELQEI=N DIA/STASIN EI)S O(/SHN OI(=O/N T' H)=N A)/GEIN TO\ KINOU=N, H( DE\ DEUTE/RA TOSOU=TON E)LA/TTONA TH=S PRO/SQEN TH\N DIA/STASIN A)PE/-DEICEN, O(/SON QA/TERON TW=N KINOU/NTWN EI)S TOU)NANTI/ON A)PE/SPASE TO\ KINOU/MENON. H( DE\ TRI/TH KATA/STASIS, O(/SON H( E(TE/RA TW=N KINH/SEWN EI(=LKE PRO/SW TOSOU=TON A)NTISPW/SHS EI)S TOU)PI/SW TH=S E(TE/RAS, E)N TAU)TW=| TO/PW| TO\ SW=MA ME/NEIN H)NA/G-KASEN, OU)X W(S TO\ PANTELW=S A)KI/NHTON: ME/NEI GA\R KAI\ TOU=T' E)N TAU)TW=| DIA\ PANTO\S A)LL' OU)X O(MOI/WS E)KEI/NW|: TO\ ME\N GA\R O(/TI MHD' O(/LWS KINEI=TAI, TO\ DE\ O(/TI DITTW=S, W(/SPER KAI\ O( PRO\S R(OU=N POTAMW=N NH/XWN E)NANTI/WS. KAI\ GA\R OU(=-TOS E)A\N I)SOSQENH\S H)=| TH=| TOU= R(OU= SFODRO/THTI KATA\ TO\N AU)TO\N A)EI\ DIAME/NEI TO/PON, OU)X W(S MHD' O(/LWS KINOU/MENOS, A)LL' O(/TI PRO/SW TOSOU=TON U(PO\ TH=S OI)-KEI/AS DIAFE/RETAI KINH/SEWS O(/SON U(PO\ TH=S E)/CWQEN O)PI/SW FE/RETAI. OU)DE\N DE\ XEI=RON OU(/TW A)SAFE\S PRA=GMA DIA\ PLEIO/NWN E)CETA/ZESQAI PARADEIGMA/TWN. E)/STW TIS U(YHLO\S O)/RNIS E)N TAU)TW=| TO/PW| FAINO/MENOS ME/NEIN. PO/TERON A)KI/NHTON EI)=NAI TOU=TON LEKTE/ON, W(/SPER EI) KAI\ KREMA/MENOS A)/NWQEN E)/TUXEN, H)\ KINEI=SQAI TH\N E)PI\ TA\ A)/NW KI/NHSIN EI)S TOSOU=TON EI)S O(/SON H)/GAGEN AU)TO\N KA/TW TO\ TOU= SW/MA-TOS BA/ROS; E)MOI\ ME\N TOU=TO A)LHQE/STERON EI)=NAI DOKEI=. STERH/SAS GOU=N AU)TO\N TH=S YUXH=S H)\ TOU= TW=N MUW=N TO/NOU TAXE/WS E)PI\ TH\N GH=N O)/YEI KATAFERO/MENON: W(=| DH=LON O(/TI TH\N SU/MFUTON TW=| TOU= SW/MATOS BA/REI KA/TW R(OPH\N EI)S I)/SON A)N-TESH/KOU TH=| KATA\ TO\N TH=S YUXH=S TO/NON A)/NW FORA=|. PO/TERON OU)=N <20E)N TAI=S TOIAU/TAIS A(PA/SAIS KATASTA/SESI POTE\ ME\N KA/TW POTE\ DE\ A)/NW TO\ SW=MA FE/RETAI TA)NANTI/A PA/SXON E)N ME/REI, DIA\ DE\ TO\ TAXEI/AS TE KAI\ O)CUR)R(O/POUS GI/NESQAI TA\S METABOLA\S KAI\ KATA\ BRAXUTA/TWN DIA-STHMA/TWN FE/RESQAI TA\S KINH/SEIS E)N TAU)TW=| FAI/NETAI TO/PW| ME/NEIN>20 H)\ O)/NTWS E(/NA DIA\ PANTO\S TOU= XRO/NOU KATE/XEI TO/PON, OU) TOU= PARO/NTOS KAIROU= DIELQEI=N: E)N GA\R TOI=S FUSIKOI=S PERI\ KINH/SEWS LO/GOIS TA\ TOIAU=TA E)REUNA=SQAI DIKAIO/TERON: A)LL' A)RKEI= PRO\S TA\ PARO/NTA TOU=TO E)CEURH=SQAI TO\ GI/GNESQAI/ TI KAI\ TOIOU=TON EI)=DOS E)NERGEI/AS O(\ KALEI=N ME\N EI)/TE TONIKO\N EI)/T' A)/LLWS W(S A)\N E)QE/LH|S OU) DIOI/SEI. @&10Nemesius de nat. hom. cp. 2 p. 42.$10 EI) DE\ LE/GOIEN, KAQA/PER <20OI( *STWI+KOI/>20, TONIKH/N TINA EI)=NAI KI/NHSIN PERI\ TA\ SW/MATA EI)S TO\ EI)/SW A(/MA KI- @1NOUME/NHN KAI\ EI)S TO\ E)/CW: KAI\ <20TH\N ME\N EI)S TO\ E)/CW MEGEQW=N KAI\ POIO-TH/TWN A)POTELESTIKH\N EI)=NAI, TH\N DE\ EI)S TO\ EI)/SW E(NW/SEWS KAI\ OU)-SI/AS>20, E)RWTHTE/ON AU)TOU\S__[1&10sequitur refutatio platonica, paulo infra%10$10]1 EI) DE\ LE/GOIEN O(/TI TA\ SW/MATA TRIXH= DIASTATA/ E)STI KAI\ H( YUXH\ DE\ DIO/LOU DIH/KOUSA TOU= SW/MATOS TRIXH= DIASTATH/ E)STI KAI\ DIA\ TOU=TO PA/NTWS KAI\ SW=MA, E)ROU=MEN &10etc. &10@Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 68E. ed. Bas.$10 *OI( DE\ <20*STWI+KOI\>20 DU/NAMIN H)\ MA=LLON KI/NHSIN TH\N MANWTIKH\N KAI\ PUKNWTIKH\N TI/QENTAI, TH\N ME\N E)PI\ TA\ E)/SW, TH\N DE\ E)PI\ TA\ E)/CW: KAI\ TH\N ME\N TOU= EI)=NAI, TH\N DE\ TOU= POIO\N EI)=NAI NOMI/ZOUSIN AI)TI/AN. @&10Philo de sacrif. Abel et Cain %14 68 Vol. I p. 230, 5 Wendl. &10de$10 LO/GW|&10 locutus%10$10 OU) METABATIKW=S KINOU/MENOS, W(S TO\N ME\N E)PILAMBA/NEIN, TO\N DE\ A)POLEI/PEIN TO/PON, A)LLA\ <20TONIKH=| XRW/MENOS TH=| KINH/SEI>20. @&10Sextus adv. math. IX 149$10 W(SAU/TWS DE\ KAI\ A)/YUXO/N E)STIN [1&10scil.$10 TO\ QEI=ON]1. EI) GA\R U(PO\ YUXH=S SUNE/XETAI, PA/NTWS A)PO\ TW=N ME/SWN E)PI\ TA\ PE/RATA KAI\ A)PO\ TW=N PERA/TWN E)PI\ TA\ ME/SA FEROME/NOU [2PNEU/MATOS]2 SUNE/XETAI. @&10Cleomedes Circul. doctr. I cp. 8 p. 58 Bake.$10 TA\ STEREA\ TW=N SWMA/TWN OI(=A/ TE/ E)STI POLLAXW=S SXHMATI/ZESQAI, E)PI\ DE\ PNEUMATIKH=S H)\ PURW/DOUS OU)SI/AS, O(PO/TE KAQ' AU(TA\S EI)=EN, OU)DE\N E)GXWREI= TOIOU=TON GI/NESQAI. <20*)EPI\ TO\ OI)KEI=ON OU)=N TH=| FU/SEI AU)TW=N PARAGI/NONTAI SXH=MA TETONWME/NAI KAI\ TO\ I)/SON A)PO\ TOU= MESAITA/TOU PA/NTH A)POTEINO/MENAI>20, MALAKH=S AU)TW=N TH=S OU)SI/AS OU)/SHS KAI\ MHDENO\S O)/NTOS STEREOU=, O(\ A)/LLWS SXHMATI/ZOI A)\N AU)TA/S. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 68E. ed. Bas.$10 *TO\ TOI/NUN SXH=MA OI( <20*STWI+KOI\>20 TH\N TA/SIN PARE/XESQAI LE/GOUSIN, W(/SPER KAI\ TH\N METACU\ TW=N SHMEI/WN DIA/STASIN. DIO\ KAI\ <20EU)QEI=AN O(RI/ZONTAI GRAMMH\N TH\N EI)S A)/KRON TETAME/NHN>20. @&10Galenus de dignoscendis pulsibus IV 2 Vol. VIII p. 923K.$10 TO\ ME/N GE TOU= TO/NOU DIAMFISBHTEI=TAI. TH\N A)RXH\N GA\R OI(=O/S TI/S E)STIN O( TO/NOS E)N TOI=S TW=N ZW/|WN SW/MASI OU)X W(MOLO/GHTAI PRO\S TW=N EI)S E)LA/XISTA H)\ EI)S A)/TOMA H)\ EI)S A)/NARMA TH\N O(/LHN OU)SI/AN KATAQRAUO/NTWN. MO/NOIS GA\R O(MOLO-GEI=TAI TOI=S H(NW=SQAI FA/SKOUSIN AU)TH/N. @&10Philo Leg. Alleg. II %14 22 Vol. I p. 95, 8 Wendl.$10 O( NOU=S__ POLLA\S E)/XEI DUNA/MEIS, E(KTIKH/N, FUTIKH/N, YUXIKH/N, LOGIKH/N, DIANOHTIKH/N, A)/L-LAS MURI/AS KATA/ TE EI)/DH KAI\ GE/NH. *(H ME\N E(/CIS KOINH\ KAI\ TW=N A)YU/XWN E)STI/, LI/QWN KAI\ CU/LWN, H(=S METE/XEI KAI\ TA\ E)N H(MI=N E)OIKO/TA LI/QOIS O)STE/A. *(H DE\ FU/SIS DIATEI/NEI KAI\ E)PI\ TA\ FUTA/. KAI\ E)N H(MI=N DE/ E)STIN E)OIKO/TA FU-TOI=S, O)/NUXE/S TE KAI\ TRI/XES: <20E)STI\ DE\ H( FU/SIS E(/CIS H)/DH KINOUME/NH>20. *YUXH\ DE/ E)STI FU/SIS PROSEILHFUI=A FANTASI/AN KAI\ O(RMH/N. AU(/TH KOINH\ KAI\ TW=N A)LO/GWN E)STI/N. *)/EXEI DE\ KAI\ O( H(ME/TEROS NOU=S A)NALOGOU=N TI A)LO/GOU YUXH=|: PA/LIN H( DIANOHTIKH\ DU/NAMIS I)DI/A TOU= NOU= E)STI, KAI\ H( LOGIKH\ KOINH\ ME\N TA/XA KAI\ TW=N QEIOTE/RWN FU/SEWN, I)DI/A DE/, W(S E)N QNHTOI=S, A)NQRW/POU. AU(/TH DE\ DITTH/. H( ME\N KAQ' H(\N LOGIKOI/ E)SMEN, NOU= METE/XONTES: H( DE\ KAQ' H(\N DIA-LEGO/MEQA.&10 &10@Philo Quod deus sit immut. %14 35 Vol. II p. 64, 1 Wendl.$10 *TW=N GA\R SWMA/TWN TA\ ME\N E)NEDH/SATO E(/CEI, TA\ DE\ FU/SEI, TA\ DE\ YUXH=|, TA\ DE\ KAI\ LOGIKH=| @1 YUXH=|. *LI/QWN ME\N OU)=N KAI\ CU/LWN, A(\ DH\ TH=S SUMFUI/+AS A)PE/SPASTAI, <20DESMO\N KRATAIO/TATON E(/CIN EI)RGA/ZETO. H( DE/ E)STI PNEU=MA A)NASTRE/FON E)F' E(AUTO/>20. *)/ARXETAI ME\N GA\R A)PO\ TW=N ME/SWN E)PI\ TA\ PE/RATA TEI/NESQAI, YAU=SAN DE\ A)/KRAS E)PIFANEI/AS A)NAKA/MPTEI PA/LIN, A)/XRIS A)\N E)PI\ TO\N AU)TO\N A)FI/KHTAI TO/PON, A)F' OU(= TO\ PRW=TON W(RMH/QH. *(/ECEWS O( SUNEXH\S OU(=TOS DI/AULOS A)/FQAR-TOS, O(\N OI( DROMEI=S A)POMIMOU/MENOI TAI=S TRIETHRI/SIN E)N TOI=S A)NQRW/PWN A(PA/N-TWN KOINOI=S QEA/TROIS W(S ME/GA DH\ KAI\ LAMPRO\N KAI\ PERIMA/XHTON E)/RGON E)PI-DEI/KNUNTAI. *TH\N DE\ <20FU/SIN>20 A)PE/NEIME TOI=S FUTOI=S, KERASA/MENOS AU)TH\N E)K PLEI/STWN DUNA/MEWN, QREPTIKH=S TE KAI\ METABLHTIKH=S KAI\ AU)CHTIKH=S. &10%14 41.$10 <20*YUXH\N>20 DE\ FU/SEWS TRISI\ DIALLA/TTOUSAN O( POIW=N E)POI/EI AI)SQH/SEI, FANTASI/A|, O(RMH=|. *TA\ ME\N GA\R FUTA\ A)O/RMHTA, A)FA/NTASTA, AI)SQH/SEWS A)ME/TOXA, TW=N DE\ ZW/|WN E(/KASTON A)QRO/WN ME-TE/XEI TW=N EI)RHME/NWN. <20*AI)/SQHSIS ME\N OU)=N, W(S AU)TO/ POU DHLOI= TOU)/-NOMA, EI)/SQESI/S TIS OU)=SA>20, TA\ FANE/NTA E)PEISFE/REI TW=| NW=|. *TOU/TW| GA\R E)PEIDH\ ME/GISTO/N E)STI TAMIEI=ON KAI\ PANDEXE/S, PA/NQ' O(/SA DI' O(RA/SEWS KAI\ A)KOH=S KAI\ TW=N A)/LLWN AI)SQHTIKW=N O)RGA/NWN E)NTI/QETAI KAI\ E)NAPOQHSAURI/ZETAI. <20*FAN-TASI/A DE/ E)STI TU/PWSIS E)N YUXH=|>20: A(\ GA\R EI)SH/GAGEN E(KA/STH TW=N AI)SQH/SEWN, W(/SPER DAKTU/LIO/S TIS H)\ SFRAGI\S E)NAPEMA/CATO TO\N OI)KEI=ON XARAKTH=RA. *KHRW=| DE\ E)OIKW\S O( NOU=S, TO\ E)KMAGEI=ON DECA/MENOS A)/KRWS PAR' E(AUTW=| FULA/TTEI, ME/XRIS A)\N H( A)NTI/PALOS MNH/MHS TO\N TU/PON LEA/NASA LH/QH A)MUDRO\N E)RGA/SHTAI H)\ PAN-TELW=S A)FANI/SH|. *TO\ DE\ FANE\N KAI\ TUPW=SAN TO/TE ME\N OI)KEI/WS, TO/TE DE\ W(S E(TE/RWS DIE/QHKE TH\N YUXH/N. *TOU=TO D' AU)TH=S TO\ PA/QOS <20O(RMH\ KALEI=TAI, H(\N O(RIZO/MENOI PRW/THN E)/FASAN EI)=NAI YUXH=S KI/NHSIN>20. *TOSOU/TOIS ME\N DH\ ZW=|A PROU)/XEI FUTW=N. I)/DWMEN DE\ TI/NI TW=N A)/LLWN ZW/|WN U(PERBE/BLHKEN A)/NQRW-POS. *)ECAI/RETON OU(=TOS TOI/NUN GE/RAS E)/LAXE DIA/NOIAN, H(=| TA\S A(PA/NTWN FU/SEIS, SWMA/TWN TE O(MOU= KAI\ PRAGMA/TWN EI)/WQE KATALAMBA/NEIN. *KAQA/PER GA\R E)N ME\N TW=| SW/MATI TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N O)/YIS E)STI/N, E)N DE\ TW=| PANTI\ H( TOU= FWTO\S FU/SIS, TO\N AU)TO\N TRO/PON KAI\ TW=N E)N H(MI=N TO\ KRATISTEU=ON O( NOU=S. *YUXH=S GA\R O)/YIS OU(=TOS, OI)KEI/AIS PERILAMPO/MENOS AU)GAI=S, DI' W(=N O( POLU\S KAI\ BAQU\S ZO/-FOS, O(\N KATE/XEEN A)/GNOIA TW=N PRAGMA/TWN, A)NASKI/DNATAI. @&10Critolaus apud Philonem$10 PERI\ A)FQARSI/AS KO/SMOU&10 p. 248, 2.$10 TI/ DH/POT' OU)XI\ KAI\ TH\N TOU= KO/SMOU FU/SIN LEKTE/ON EI)=NAI MAKRAI/WNA "1TH\N TA/CIN TW=N A)TA/KTWN, TH\N A(RMONI/AN TW=N A)NARMO/STWN, TH\N SUMFWNI/AN TW=N A)SUMFW/-NWN, TH\N E(/NWSIN TW=N DIESTHKO/TWN, TH\N CU/LWN ME\N KAI\ LI/QWN E(/CIN, SPARTW=N TE KAI\ DE/NDRWN FU/SIN, YUXH\N DE\ ZW/WN A(PA/NTWN, A)NQRW/PWN DE\ NOU=N KAI\ LO/GON, A)RETH\N DE\ SPOUDAI/WN TELEIOTA/THN;"2 @&10Plutarchus de virtute morali cp. 12 p. 451b.$10 KAQO/LOU DE\ TW=N O)/NTWN AU)TOI/ TE/ FASI [1&10scil. Stoici antiquiores$10]1 KAI\ DH=LO/N E)STIN, O(/TI TA\ ME\N E(/CEI DIOIKEI=TAI, TA\ DE\ FU/SEI, TA\ D' A)LO/GW| YUXH=|, TA\ DE\ KAI\ LO/GON E)XOU/SH| KAI\ DIA/NOIAN. @&10Dexippus in Aristot. categ. p. 50, 31 Busse.$10 QAUMA/ZW DE\ <20TW=N *STWI+KW=N>20 XWRIZO/NTWN TA\S E(/CEIS A)PO\ TW=N E(KTW=N. A)SW/MATA GA\R MH\ PARADE-XO/MENOI KAQ' E(AUTA/, O(/TAN E)RESXELEI=N DE/ON H)=|, E)PI\ TA\S TOIAU/TAS DIALH/YEIS E)/RXONTAI. @1 @&10Galenus de nat. facult. II 3. Vol. II p. 82K.$10 H( GA\R DIAPLA/T-TOUSA TA\ MO/RIA FU/SIS E)KEI/NH KAI\ KATA\ BRAXU\ PROSAU/COUSA PA/NTWS DH/POU KAI\ DI' O(/LWN AU)TW=N E)KTE/TATAI: KAI\ GA\R O(/LA DI' O(/LWN, OU)K E)/CWQEN MO/NON, AU)TA\ DIAPLA/TTEI TE KAI\ TRE/FEI KAI\ PROSAU/CEI. __OU)DE\N GA/R E)STIN A)/YAU-STON AU)TH=| ME/ROS OU)D' A)NECE/RGASTON OU)D' A)KO/SMHTON. @&10Galenus in Hippocr. de nat. hom. lib. I Vol. XV p. 32K.$10 E)/NIOI ME\N GA\R TA\S TE/TTARAS POIO/THTAS MO/NAS KERA/NNUSQAI DI' O(/LWN A)LLH/LAIS, E)/NIOI DE\ TA\S OU)SI/AS A)PEFH/NANTO, *PERIPATHTIKOI\ ME\N TH=S PROTE/RAS DO/CHS PROSTA/NTES, <20*STWI+KOI\>20 DE\ TH=S DEUTE/RAS. @&10Galenus de elementis sec. Hippocr. I 9. Vol. I p. 489K.$10 KAI\ ME\N DH\ KAI\ O(/PWS DI' O(/LWN KERA/NNUTAI TA\ KERANNU/MENA, PO/TERON TW=N POIOTH/TWN MO/NON, W(S *)ARISTOTE/LHS U(PE/LABEN, H)\ KAI\ TW=N SWMATIKW=N OU)SIW=N DI' A)LLH/LWN I)OUSW=N, OU)K A)NAGKAI=ON E)PI/STASQAI TOI=S I)ATROI=S. @&10Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 37 p. 1077e.$10 PARA\ TH\N E)/NNOIA/N E)STI SW=MA SW/MATOS EI)=NAI TO/PON KAI\ SW=MA XWREI=N DIA\ SW/MATOS, KENO\N MHDE-TE/ROU PERIE/XONTOS, A)LLA\ TOU= PLH/ROUS EI)S TO\ PLH=RES E)NDUOME/NOU KAI\ DEXOME/NOU TO\ E)PIMIGNU/MENON TOU= DIA/STASIN OU)K E)/XONTOS OU)DE\ XW/RAN E)N AU(TW=| DIA\ TH\N SUNE/XEIAN: OI( D' OU)X E(\N EI)S E(\N OU)DE\ DU/O OU)DE\ TRI/A [2H)\]2 KAI\ DE/KA SUNWQOU=N-TES, A)LLA\ PA/NTA ME/RH TOU= KO/SMOU KATAKERMATISQE/NTOS E)MBA/LLONTES EI)S E(\N O(/,TI A)\N TU/XWSI, KAI\ TOU)LA/XISTON AI)SQHTO\N OU) FA/SKONTES E)PILEI/YEIN E)PIO\N TW=| MEGI/STW|, NEANIEU/ONTAI &10etc. &10@p. 1078 b.$10 A)NA/GKH GA/R, EI)S A)/LLHLA XWROU/NTWN TW=| KERA/NNUSQAI, MH\ QA/TERON ME\N PERIE/XEIN, PERIE/XESQAI DE\ QA/TERON, KAI\ TO\ ME\N DE/XESQAI, TO\ D' E)NUPA/RXEIN: OU(/TW GA\R OU) KRA=SIS, A(FH\ DE\ KAI\ YAU=SIS E)/STAI TW=N E)PIFANEIW=N, TH=S ME\N E)NTO\S U(PODUOME/NHS, TH=S D' E)KTO\S PERIEXOU/SHS, TW=N D' A)/LLWN MERW=N A)MI/KTWN KAI\ KAQARW=N E)NDIAFEROME/NWN: A)LL' A)NA/GKH, GIGNOME/NHS W(/SPER A)CIOU=SI шTH=S A)NAKRA/SEWS, E)N A)LLH/LOIS TA\ MIGNU/MENA GI/GNESQAI KAI\ TAU)TO\N O(MOU= TW=| E)NUPA/RXEIN PERIE/XESQAI KAI\ TW=| DE/XESQAI PERIE/XEIN QA/TERON. KAI\ MHDE/TERON AU)TW=N AU)= PA/LIN DUNATO\N EI)=NAI, SUMBAI/NEI [2D']2 A)MFO/TERA, TH=S KRA/SEWS DI' A)LLH/LWN DIIE/NAI KAI\ MHDE\N E)/TI LEI/PESQAI MHDENO\S MO/RION A)LLA\ [2PA=N]2 PANTO\S A)NAPI/MPLASQAI BIAZOME/NHS. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de mixtione p. 219, 16 Bruns.$10 [1TO\ SW=MA TO\ TRIXH=| TE KAI\ PA/NTH| DIESTHKO/S, E)A\N A)/LLW| O(MOI/WS AU)TW=| DIESTW=TI SUNTEQH=|, E)C A)NA/GKHS SUNAU/CEI TOU=TO]1. EI) DH\ TOU=TO ME\N OI)KEI=ON TOI=S SW/MASIN KAI\ I)/DION AU)TW=N, OI( DE\ LE/GONTES SW=MA/ TI DIA\ SW/MATOS XWREI=N [2TW=|]2 <20KAI\ E)/LATTO/N POTE KAI\ I)/SON TO\ E)C A)MFOI=N POIEI=N>20 A)NAIROU=SI TOU=TO, A)NAIROI=EN A)\N TH\N TOU= SW/MATOS FU/SIN. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. Phys. p. 530, 9 Diels.$10 TO\ DE\ SW=MA DIA\ SW/MATOS XWREI=N OI( ME\N A)RXAI=OI W(S E)NARGE\S A)/TOPON E)LA/MBANON, <20OI( DE\ A)PO\ @1 TH=S *STOA=S>20 U(/STERON PROSH/KANTO W(S A)KOLOUQOU=N TAI=S SFW=N AU)TW=N U(POQE/-SESIN, A(\S E)NO/MIZON PANTI\ TRO/PW| DEI=N KUROU=N: SW/MATA GA\R PA/NTA LE/GEIN DO-KOU=NTES, KAI\ TA\S POIO/THTAS KAI\ TH\N YUXH/N, KAI\ DIA\ PANTO\S O(RW=NTES TOU= SW/-MATOS KAI\ TH\N YUXH\N XWROU=SAN KAI\ TA\S POIO/THTAS, E)N TAI=S KRA/SESI SUN-EXW/ROUN SW=MA DIA\ SW/MATOS XWREI=N.&10 22.$10 OU)DE\ GA\R AI)TIW=NTAI KENA\ OI( DI' A)LLH/LWN LE/GONTES XWREI=N. @&Themistius paraphr. in Arist. Phys. IV 1 p. 256 Sp.$ A)LL' OU(/TW TO\ PA/NTWN A)TOPW/TATON A)PANTH/SETAI: SW=MA GA\R DIA\ SW/MATOS XWRH/SEI DI' O(/LOU KAI\ DU/O SW/MATA TO\N AU)TO\N E)FE/CEI TO/PON. EI) GA\R KAI\ O( TO/POS SW=MA KAI\ TO\ GENO/MENON E)N AU)TW=| SW=MA KAI\ I)/SA TOI=S DIA-STH/MASIN A)/MFW, TO\ SW=MA E)/STAI E)N I)/SW| E(TE/RW| SW/MATI, TOU=TO DE\ <20*XRU-SI/PPW|>20 ME\N KAI\ TOI=S A)PO\ *ZH/NWNOS [2E)N]2 DO/GMASI/N E)STIN, OI( DE\ PA-LAIOI/ &etc. &@Hippolytus Philos. 21 [1DDG p. 571, 23]1 Stoici Chrysippus &et Zeno%10$ SW/MATA DE\ PA/NTA U(PE/QENTO KAI\ SW=MA DIA\ SW/MATOS ME\N XW-REI=N, A)LLA\ A)NA/STASIN EI)=NAI KAI\ PEPLHRW=SQAI PA/NTA KAI\ MHDE\N EI)=NAI KENO/N. TAU=TA KAI\ OI( *STWI+KOI/. @&Alexander Aphrod. de mixtione p. 216, 1 Bruns.$ METE/LQWMEN DE\ E)PI\ TOU\S KOINW=S H(NW=SQAI TH\N U(/LHN LE/GONTAS KAI\ MI/AN PA=SI TOI=S GINOME/NOIS KAI\ TH\N AU)TH\N U(POQE/[2N]2TAS__TW=N DH\ H(NW=SQAI TH\N U(/LHN LEGO/NTWN DOKOU=SI MA/LISTA/ TE KAI\ PERI\ KRA/SEWS <20OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 PERI\ KRA/SEWS DIALAMBA/NEIN. OU)/SHS DE\ KAI\ E)N TOU/TOIS POLU-FWNI/AS [1A)/LLOI GA\R A)/LLWS AU)TW=N TA\S KRA/SEIS GI/NESQAI LE/GOUSIN]1 H( MA/LISTA DOKOU=SA DO/CA EU)DOKIMEI=N PAR' AU)TOI=S PERI\ KRA/SEW/S E)STIN H( U(PO\ <20*XRUSI/PPOU>20 LEGOME/NH. TW=N GA\R MET' AU)TO\N OI( ME\N *XRUSI/PPW| SUMFE/RONTAI, OI( DE/ TINES AU)TW=N, TH=S *)ARISTOTE/LOUS DO/CHS U(/STERON A)KOU=SAI DUNHQE/NTES, POLLA\ TW=N EI)RHME/NWN U(P' E)KEI/NOU PERI\ KRA/SEWS KAI\ AU)TOI\ LE/GOUSIN, W(=N EI(=S E)STI KAI\ <20*SWSIGE/NHS>20, E(TAI=ROS <20*)ANTIPA/-TROU>20, OI(=S OU) DUNA/MENOI PA/NTH SUMFE/RESQAI DIA\ TH\N E)N TOI=S A)/LLOIS DIAFWNI/AN E)N POLLOI=S AU(TOI=S LE/GONTES EU(RI/SKONTAI MAXO/MENA. @&Stobaeus Eclogae I p. 153, 24 W.$ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 DE\ TOIOU=TO/N TI DIEBEBAIOU=TO: EI)=NAI TO\ O)\N PNEU=MA KINOU=N E(AUTO\ PRO\S E(AUTO\ KAI\ E)C AU(TOU=, H)\ PNEU=MA E(AUTO\ KINOU=N PRO/SW KAI\ O)PI/SW: PNEU=MA DE\ EI)/LHPTAI DIA\ TO\ LE/GESQAI AU)TO\ A)E/RA EI)=NAI KINOU/MENON: A)NA/LOGON DE\ GI/NESQAI KA)PI\ TOU= AI)QE/ROS, W(/STE KAI\ EI)S KOINO\N LO/GON PESEI=N AU)TA/. *(H TOIAU/TH DE\ KI/NHSIS KATA\ MO/NOUS GI/NETAI TOU\S NOMI/ZONTAS TH\N OU)SI/AN PA=SAN META-BOLH\N E)PIDE/XESQAI KAI\ SU/GXUSIN KAI\ SU/STASIN KAI\ SU/MMICIN KAI\ SU/M- @1FUSIN KAI\ TA\ TOU/TOIS PARAPLH/SIA. *DIAFE/REIN GA\R A)RE/SKEI <20TOI=S A)PO\ TH=S *STWI+KH=S AI(RE/SEWS>20 PARA/QESIN, MI=CIN, KRA=SIN, SU/GXUSIN. <20*PARA/-QESIN>20 ME\N GA\R EI)=NAI SWMA/TWN SUNAFH\N KATA\ TA\S E)PIFANEI/AS, W(S E)PI\ TW=N SWRW=N O(RW=MEN, E)N OI(=S PUROI/ TE KAI\ KRIQAI\ KAI\ FAKOI\ KAI\ EI)/ TINA TOU/TOIS A)/LLA PARAPLH/SIA PERIE/XETAI KAI\ TW=N E)PI\ TW=N AI)GIALW=N YH/FWN KAI\ A)/MMWN. <20*MI=CIN>20 D' EI)=NAI DU/O H)\ KAI\ PLEIO/NWN SWMA/TWN A)NTIPARE/KTASIN DI' O(/LWN, U(POMENOUSW=N TW=N SUMFUW=N PERI\ AU)TA\ POIO-TH/TWN, W(S E)PI\ TOU= PURO\S E)/XEI KAI\ TOU= PEPURAKTWME/NOU SIDH/ROU, E)PI\ TOU/TWN GA\R [2DI']2 O(/LWN GI/GNESQAI TW=N SWMA/TWN TH\N A)NTIPARE/KTASIN. *(OMOI/WS DE\ KA)PI\ TW=N E)N H(MI=N YUXW=N E)/XEIN: DI' O(/LWN GA\R TW=N SWMA/-TWN H(MW=N A)NTIPAREKTEI/NOUSIN, A)RE/SKEI GA\R AU)TOI=S SW=MA DIA\ SW/MATOS A)NTIPARH/KEIN. <20*KRA=SIN>20 DE\ EI)=NAI LE/GOUSI DU/O H)\ KAI\ PLEIO/NWN SWMA/-TWN U(GRW=N DI' O(/LWN A)NTIPARE/KTASIN TW=N PERI\ AU)TA\ POIOTH/TWN U(POME-NOUSW=N: [*TH\N ME\N MI=CIN KAI\ E)PI\ CHRW=N GI/GNESQAI SWMA/TWN, OI(=ON PURO\S KAI\ SIDH/ROU, YUXH=S TE KAI\ TOU= PERIE/XONTOS AU)TH\N SW/MATOS: TH\N DE\ KRA=SIN E)PI\ MO/NWN FASI\ GI/NESQAI TW=N U(GRW=N] SUNEKFAI/NESQAI GA\R E)K TH=S KRA/SEWS TH\N E(KA/STOU TW=N SUGKRAQE/NTWN U(GRW=N POIO/THTA, OI(=ON OI)/NOU, ME/LITOS, U(/DATOS, O)/COUS, TW=N PARAPLHSI/WN. *(/OTI D' E)PI\ TOIOU/TWN KRA/SEWN DIAME/NOUSIN AI( POIO/THTES TW=N SUGKRAQE/NTWN, PRO/-DHLON E)K TOU= POLLA/KIS E)C E)PIMHXANH/SEWS A)POXWRI/ZESQAI TAU=TA A)P' A)LLH/LWN. *)EA\N GOU=N SPO/GGON H)LAIWME/NON KAQH=| TIS EI)S OI)=NON U(/DATI KEKRAME/NON, A)POXWRI/SEI TO\ U(/DWR TOU= OI)/NOU, A)NADRAMO/NTOS TOU= U(/DATOS EI)S TO\N SPO/GGON. *TH\N DE\ <20SU/GXUSIN>20 DU/O [2H)\]2 KAI\ PLEIO/NWN POIOTH/-TWN PERI\ TA\ SW/MATA METABOLH\N EI)S E(TE/RAS DIAFEROU/SHS TOU/TWN POIO/-THTOS GE/NESIN, W(S E)PI\ TH=S SUNQE/SEWS E)/XEI TW=N MU/RWN KAI\ TW=N I)ATRI-KW=N FARMA/KWN @&10Philo de confusione linguarum %14 184 Vol. II p. 264, 23 Wendl.$10 A)LL' H( ME\N MI=CIS E)N CHRAI=S, H( DE\ KRA=SIS E)N U(GRAI=S OU)SI/AIS DOKIMA/ZETAI. <20*MI=CIS>20 ME\N OU)=N SWMA/TWN DIAFERO/NTWN E)STI\N OU)K E)N KO/SMW| PARA/QESIS, W(/SPER A)\N EI)/TIS SWRO\N POIH/SEIE KRIQA\S KAI\ PUROU\S KAI\ O)RO/BOUS KAI\ A)/LL' A)/TTA EI)/DH TW=N SPARTW=N EI)S TAU)TO\ EI)SENEGKW/N. <20*KRA=SIS>20 D' OU) PARA/QESIS, A)LLA\ TW=N A)NOMOI/WN MERW=N EI)S A)/LLHLA EI)SDUOME/NWN DI' O(/LWN A)NTIPARE/KTASIS, E)/TI DUNA-ME/NWN E)PITEXNH/SEI TINI\ DIAKRI/NESQAI TW=N POIOTH/TWN, W(S E)PI\ OI)/NOU KAI\ U(/DATO/S FASI GI/NESQAI: SUNELQOU/SAS ME\N GA\R TA\S OU)SI/AS A)POTELEI=N KRA=SIN: TO\ DE\ KRAQE\N OU)DE\N H(=TTON A)NAPLHROU=SQAI PA/LIN EI)S TA\S E)C W(=N A)PETELE/SQH POIO/THTAS. *SPO/GGW| GA\R H)LAIWME/NW| TO\ ME\N U(/DWR A)NALAMBA/NESQAI, TO\N DE\ OI)=NON U(POLEI/-PESQAI. *MH/POTE E)PEIDH/PER E)C U(/DATOS H( SPOGGIA=S GE/NESI/S E)STI TO\ ME\N OI)-KEI=ON U(/DWR PE/FUKEN A)NALAMBA/NESQAI PRO\S AU)TH=S E)K TOU= KRA/MATOS, TO\ D' A)LLO/TRION U(POLEI/PESQAI O( OI)=NOS. <20*SU/GXUSIS>20 DE/ E)STI FQORA\ TW=N E)C A)RXH=S @1 POIOTH/TWN, PA=SI TOI=S ME/RESIN A)NTIPAREKTEINOME/NWN, EI)S DIAFEROU/SHS MIA=S GE/-NESIN, W(S E)PI\ TH=S E)N I)ATRIKH=| TETRAFARMA/KOU SUNTE/TEUXE. *KHRO\S GA\R KAI\ STE/AR KAI\ PI/TTA R(HTI/NH TE OI)=MAI SUNELQO/NTA TAU/THN A)POTELEI=: SUNDEQEI/SHS DE\ A)MH/XANON E)/TI TA\S E)C W(=N SUNETE/QH DIAKRIQH=NAI DUNA/MEIS, A)LL' E(KA/STH ME\N AU)TW=N H)FA/NISTAI, PASW=N DE\ FQORA\ MI/AN E)CAI/RETON A)/LLHN E)GE/NNHSE DU/NAMIN. @&Alexander Aphrod. de mixtione p. 216, 14 Bruns.$ E)/STI DE\ H( <20*XRUSI/PPOU>20 DO/CA PERI\ KRA/SEWS H(/DE: H(NW=SQAI ME\N U(POTI/QETAI TH\N SU/MPASAN OU)SI/AN, PNEU/MATO/S TINOS DIA\ PA/SHS AU)TH=S DIH/KONTOS, U(F' OU(= SUNE/XETAI/ TE KAI\ SUMME/NEI KAI\ SUMPAQE/S E)STIN AU(TW=| TO\ PA=N: TW=N DE\ MIGNUME/NWN E)N AU)TH=| SWMA/TWN, <20TA\S ME\N PARAQE/SEI>20 MI/CEIS GI/NE-SQAI LE/GEI DU/O TINW=N H)\ KAI\ PLEIO/NWN OU)SIW=N EI)S TAU)TO\N SUNTEQEI-ME/NWN KAI\ PARATIQEME/NWN A)LLH/LAIS, W(/S FHSIN, KAQ' A(RMH/N, SW|ZOU/SHS E(KA/STHS AU)TW=N E)N TH=| TOIAU/TH| PARAQE/SEI KATA\ TH\N PERIGRAFH\N TH\N OI)KEI/AN OU)SI/AN TE KAI\ POIO/THTA, W(S E)PI\ KUA/MWN, FE/RE EI)PEI=N, KAI\ PU-RW=N E)N TH=| PAR' A)LLH/LOUS QE/SEI GI/NETAI. <20TA\S DE/ TINAS SUGXU/SEI>20, DI' O(/LWN TW=N TE OU)SIW=N AU)TW=N KAI\ TW=N E)N AU)TAI=S POIOTH/TWN SUMFQEI-وROME/NWN A)LLH/LAIS, W(S GI/NESQAI/ FHSIN E)PI\ TW=N I)ATRIKW=N FARMA/KWN, KATA\ SU/MFQARSIN TW=N MIGNUME/NWN A)/LLOU TINO\S E)C AU)TW=N GENNWME/NOU SW/MATOS. <20TA\S DE/ TINAS>20 GI/NESQAI MI/CEIS LE/GEI, DI' O(/LWN TINW=N OU)SIW=N TE KAI\ TW=N TOU/TWN POIOTH/TWN A)NTIPAREKTEINOME/NWN A)LLH/LAIS META\ TOU= TA\S E)C A)RXH=S OU)SI/AS TE KAI\ POIO/THTAS SW/|ZEIN E)N TH=| MI/CEI TH=| TOIA=|DE: H(/N TINA TW=N MI/CEWN KRA=SIN I)DI/WS EI)=NAI LE/GEI. TH\N GA\R DU/O H)\ KAI\ PLEIO/NWN TINW=N SWMA/TWN O(/LWN DI' O(/LWN A)NTIPARE/KTASIN A)LLH/LOIS OU(/-TWS W(S SW/|ZEIN E(/KASTON AU)TW=N E)N TH=| MI/CEI TH=| TOIAU/TH| TH/N TE OI)KEI/AN OU)SI/AN KAI\ TA\S E)N AU)TH=| POIO/THTAS LE/GEI KRA=SIN EI)=NAI MO/NHN TW=N MI/CEWN: EI)=NAI GA\R I)/DION TW=N KEKRAME/NWN TO\ DU/NASQAI XWRI/ZESQAI PA/LIN A)P' A)LLH/LWN, O(\ MO/NWS GI/NESQAI TW=| SW/|ZEIN E)N TH=| MI/CEI TA\ KE-KRAME/NA TA\S AU(TW=N FU/SEIS. _*TO\ DE\ TAU/TAS TA\S DIAFORA\S EI)=NAI TH=S MI/CEWS, PEIRA=TAI PISTOU=SQAI DIA\ TW=N KOINW=N E)NNOIW=N, MA/LISTA DE\ KRI-TH/RIA TH=S A)LHQEI/AS FHSI\N H(MA=S PARA\ TH=S FU/SEWS LABEI=N TAU/TAS. A)/L-LHN GOU=N FANTASI/AN E)/XEIN H(MA=S TW=N KAQ' A(RMH\N SUGKEIME/NWN KAI\ A)/LLHN TW=N SUGKEXUME/NWN TE KAI\ SUNEFQARME/NWN KAI\ A)/LLHN TW=N KE-KRAME/NWN TE KAI\ A)LLH/LOIS DI' O(/LWN A)NTIPAREKTEINOME/NWN OU(/TWS W(S SW/|ZEIN E(/KASTON AU)TW=N TH\N OI)KEI/AN FU/SIN: H(\N DIAFORA\N FANTASIW=N OU)K A)\N EI)/XOMEN, EI) PA/NTA TA\ O(PWSOU=N MIGNU/MENA PARE/KEITO A)LLH/LOIS KAQ' A(RMH/N. TH\N DE\ TOIAU/THN A)NTIPARE/KTASIN TW=N KIRNAME/NWN U(PO- @1LAMBA/NEI GI/NESQAI XWROU/NTWN DI' A)LLH/LWN TW=N KIRNAME/NWN SWMA/TWN, W(S MHDE\N MO/RION E)N AU)TOI=S EI)=NAI MH\ METE/XON PA/NTWN TW=N E)N TW=| TOI-OU/TW| MI/GMATI: OU)KE/TI GA\R A)/N, EI) MH\ TOU=TO EI)/H, KRA=SIN A)LLA\ PARA/QESIN TO\ GINO/MENON EI)=NAI. _*TOU= DE\ TOU=TO OI)/ESQAI GI/NESQAI PI/STEIS FE/-ROUSIN OI( PROI+STA/MENOI TH=SDE TH=S DO/CHS TO/ TE POLLA\ TW=N SWMA/TWN SW/|ZEIN TA\S E(AUTW=N POIO/THTAS E)PI/ T' E)LATTO/NWN E)NARGW=N O)/GKWN KAI\ E)PI\ MEIZO/NWN O)/NTA: W(S O(RA=N E)/STIN E)PI\ TOU= LIBANWTOU=, O(\S E)N TW=| QU-MIA=SQAI LEPTUNO/MENOS E)PI\ PLEI=STON TH\N AU(TOU= FULA/SSEI POIO/THTA: E)/TI TE POLLA\ EI)=NAI, A(\ KAQ' E(AUTA\ MH\ OI(=A/ TE O)/NTA E)PI/ TI E)LQEI=N ME/GEQOS U(P' A)/LLWN BOHQOU/MENA E)P' AU)TO\ PRO/EISI: TO\N GOU=N XRUSO\N U(PO/ TINWN MIGNUME/NWN FARMA/KWN E)PI\ PLEI=STON XEI=SQAI/ TE KAI\ LEPTU/NESQAI, E)F' O(/SON KAQ' AU(TO\N E)LAUNO/MENOS OU)K E)DU/NATO. *KAI\ H(MEI=S DE/, A(\ KAQ' AU(TOU\S O)/NTES OU)K E)/SMEN OI(=OI/ TE E)NERGEI=N, SU\N A)/LLOIS E)NERGOU=MEN. TOU/S TE GA\R POTAMOU\S DIABAI/NOMEN A)LLH/LWN E)FAPTO/MENOI, OU(\S OU)X OI(=OI/ TE E)SME\N DIABAI/NEIN KAQ' AU(TOU/S, KAI\ BA/RH TINA\ FE/ROMEN MET' A)/LLWN, W(=N TO\ E)PIBA/LLON H(MI=N ME/ROS, MO/NOI GENO/MENOI, FE/REIN OU) DUNA/MEQA. KAI\ A)/MPELOI DE\ KAQ' AU(TA\S I(/STASQAI MH\ DUNA/MENAI, A)NI/STANTAI A)LLH/LAIS E)MPLEKO/MENAI: W(=N OU(/TWS E)XO/NTWN OU)DE/N FASI QAUMASTO\N TO\ KAI\ SW/-MATA/ TINA BOHQOU/MENA U(P' A)LLH/LWN OU(/TWS A)LLH/LOIS E(NOU=SQAI DI' O(/LWN, W(S AU)TA\ SW|ZO/MENA META\ TW=N OI)KEI/WN POIOTH/TWN A)NTIPAREKTEI/NESQAI A)LLH/LOIS DI' O(/LWN O(/LA, KA)\N H)=| TINA E)LA/TTW TO\N O)/GKON KAI\ MH\ DUNA/-MENA KAQ' AU(TA\ E)PI\ TOSOU=TON XEI=SQAI/ TE KAI\ SW/|ZEIN TA\S OI)KEI/AS POI-O/THTAS: OU(/TW GA\R KAI\ TO\N KU/AQON TOU= OI)/NOU KIRNA=SQAI TW=| U(/DATI TW=| POLLW=|, BOHQOU/MENON U(P' AU)TOU= EI)S TH\N E)PI\ TOSOU=TON E)/KTASIN. _*TOU= DE\ TOU=Q' OU(/TWS E)/XEIN W(S E)NARGE/SI XRW=NTAI MARTURI/OIS TW=| TE TH\N YUXH/N, I)DI/AN U(PO/STASIN E)/XOUSAN, W(/SPER KAI\ TO\ DEXO/MENON AU)TH\N SW=MA, DI' O(/LOU TOU= SW/MATOS DIH/KEIN, E)N TH=| MI/CEI TH=| PRO\S AU)TO\ SW/|ZOUSAN TH\N OI)KEI/AN OU)SI/AN: OU)DE\N GA\R YUXH=S A)/MOIRON TOU= TH\N YUXH\N E)/XONTOS SW/MA-TOS. O(MOI/WS DE\ E)/XEIN KAI\ TH\N TW=N FUTW=N FU/SIN, A)LLA\ KAI\ TH\N E(/CIN E)N TOI=S SUNEXOME/NOIS U(PO\ TH=S E(/CEWS. *)ALLA\ KAI\ TO\ PU=R O(/LON DI' O(/LOU XWREI=N TOU= SIDH/ROU LE/GOUSIN, SW/|ZONTOS AU)TW=N E(KATE/ROU TH\N OI)KEI/AN OU)SI/AN. KAI\ TW=N STOIXEI/WN DE/ FASI TW=N TESSA/RWN TA\ DU/O, TO/ TE PU=R KAI\ TO\N A)E/RA, LEPTOMERH= TE KAI\ KOU=FA KAI\ EU)/TONA O)/NTA DIA\ TW=N DU/O, GH=S TE KAI\ U(/DATOS, PAXUMERW=N KAI\ BARE/WN KAI\ A)TO/NWN O)/NTWN, DIAPE-FOITHKE/NAI O(/LA DI' O(/LWN, SW/|ZONTA TH\N OI)KEI/AN FU/SIN KAI\ SUNE/XEIAN AU)TA/ TE KAI\ E)KEI=NA. DHLHTH/RIA/ TE TA\ FQEI/RONTA KAI\ TA\S O)SMA/S, O(/SAI TOIAU=TAI, H(GOU=NTAI KIRNA=SQAI TOI=S U(P' AU)TW=N PA/SXOUSIN O(/LA DI' O(/LWN PARATIQE/MENA. *KAI\ TO\ FW=S DE\ TW=| A)E/RI O( <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 KIRNA=SQAI LE/GEI. *KAI\ AU(/TH ME\N H( PERI\ KRA/SEWS DO/CA <20*XRUSI/PPOU>20 TE KAI\ TW=N KAT' AU)TO\N FILOSOFOU/NTWN. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de mixtione p. 221, 16 Bruns.$10 EI) DE\ TA\ SUG- @1KEXUME/NA TE KAI\ SUNEFQARME/NA OU)X OI(=O/N TE AU)TA\ SW/|ZESQAI, OU)D' A)\N E(/CEIS SW/|ZOINTO AU)TW=N, EI)/ GE E(\N ME/N TI TO\ GEGONO\S E)K TW=N SUGKEXUME/NWN TE KAI\ SUNEFQARME/NWN, A)NA/GKH DE\ TO\ E(\N SW=MA U(PO\ MIA=S, W(/S FASIN, E(/CEWS SUN-E/XESQAI. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de mixtione p. 226, 34 Bruns.$10 *TAU=TA ME\N EI)PEI=N PROH/XQHN DIA\ TOU\S A)NTILE/GONTAS ME\N *)ARISTOTE/LEI PERI\ TOU= PE/MPTOU SW/MATOS KAI\ TOI=S MO/NOIS KAT' A)CI/AN TW=N QEI/WN EI)RHME/NOIS E)NI/STASQAI PEIRW-ME/NOUS DIA\ FILOTIMI/AN, TH=S DE\ A)TOPI/AS TW=N U(F' AU(TW=N LEGOME/NWN MHDE\ TH\N A)RXH\N SUNIE/NTAS, OI(=S KAI\ TA\ KURIW/TATA KAI\ ME/GISTA TW=N KATA\ FILOSOFI/AN DOGMA/TWN H)/RTHTAI KAI\ TH\N KATASKEUH\N A)PO\ TOU= QAUMASTOU= DO/GMATOS E)/XEI TOU= SW=MA XWREI=N DIA\ SW/MATOS. *(/O TE GA\R PERI\ KRA/SEWS AU)TOI=S LO/GOS OU)K E)N A)/LLW| TINI/. A)LLA\ KAI\ TA\ PERI\ YUXH=S U(P' AU)TW=N LEGO/MENA E)NTEU=QEN H)/RTH-TAI. H(/ TE POLUQRU/LHTOS AU)TOI=S EI(MARME/NH KAI\ H( TW=N PA/NTWN PRO/NOIA DE\ [2E)NTEU=QEN]2 TH\N PI/STIN LAMBA/NOUSIN. E)/TI TE O( PERI\ A)RXW=N TE KAI\ QEOU= [2LO/GOS]2 KAI\ H( TOU= PANTO\S E(/NWSI/S TE KAI\ SUMPA/QEIA PRO\S AU(TO/. PA/NTA GA\R AU)TOI=S TAU=T' E)STI\N O( DIA\ TH=S U(/LHS DIH/KWN QEO/S. TOU=TO DE/, TO\ SW=MA XWREI=N DIA\ SW/MATOS, E)C OU(= SXEDO\N A(PA/SHS TH=S FUSIOLOGI/AS A)NH/RTHTAI AU)TOI=S TA\ PEI/SMATA PARA/ TE TA\S KOINA\S PROLH/YEIS LEGOME/NOU KAI\ PARA\ TA\S A(PA/NTWN DO/CAS TW=N FILOSO/FWN, TH\N PI/STIN KAT' AU)TOU\S LAMBA/NEI W(S A)\N A)PO\ E)NARGOU=S TOU= TO\N SI/DHRON O(/TAN H)=| PEPURWME/NOS [ME\N] MH\ AU)TO\N E)CA/PTESQAI/ TE KAI\ PUROU=SQAI LE/GEIN O(MOI/WS TOI=S, OI(=S U(/LH| TO\ PU=R [2XRH=TAI]2, A)LLA\ DIA\ PANTO\S AU)TOU= XWREI=N TO\ PU=R U(POLAMBA/NEIN META\ TH=S U(/LHS E)KEI/NHS, E)F' H(=S O)\N GEIT-NIA=SAN TW=| SIDH/RW| E)QERMHNE/ TE KAI\ E)CH=YEN AU)TO/N. @&10Alexander Aphrod. Quaest. II 12 p. 57, 9 Bruns.$10 O(/TI OU) DEI/-KNUTAI DIA\ TOU= SUSTE/LLESQAI TA\ SW/MATA EI)S E(AUTA\ TO\ SW=MA DIA\ SW/MATOS XWREI=N &10impugnat Stoicorum$10 KRA=SIN DI' O(/LOU. &10Cf. inprimis p. 57, 22$10 EI) ME\N OU)=N E)N TH=| TW=N SWMA/TWN XWRH/SEI DI' A)LLH/LWN E)GI/NETO FQORA/ TIS KAI\ [H(] METABOLH\ EI)S PAXUMERE/STERA SW/MATA, I)/SWS A)\N E)DU/NATO O(\N TE/WS TO\ E(/TERON KATEI=XEN TO/PON, TOU=TON U(/STERON KATE/XEIN TO\ E)K TH=S A)MFOTE/RWN MI/CEWS GINO/-MENON, EI) DE\ TA\ AU)TA\ ME/NEI [1E(KA/TERON GA\R AU)TW=N DOKEI= SW/|ZEIN TH\N E(AUTOU= FU/SIN]1 PW=S A)\N E)NDE/XOITO TOU=TO GI/NESQAI. E)/TI E)/NIA MIGNU/MENA, OU) MO/NON OU) PAXU/TERON A)LLA\ KAI\ LEPTO/TERON AU)TO\ H)\ PRO/SQEN H)=N POIEI=, W(/STE E)/DEI AU)TO\ E)PI\ MEI/ZONOS GIGNO/MENON O)/GKOU KAI\ TO/PON KATE/XEIN PLEI/ONA. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de anima libri mant. p. 139, 30 Bruns.$10 *TO\ SW=MA DIA\ SW/MATOS DIH/KEIN, EI) ME\N W(S E)XO/NTWN KENA\ TW=N SWMA/TWN__ A)/LLOS O( LO/GOS__EI) DE\ MH\ DIA\ KENW=N [1OU)DE\ GA\R EI)=NAI/ FASIN KENO\N E)N TW=| KO/SMW| OI(=S TOU=TO A)RE/SKEI]1 A)LLA\ MESTO/N TI O)\N AU(TOU= SW=MA A)/LLO DECA/MENON AU(TOU= SW=MA KA)KEI=NO MESTO\N O)\N O(MOI/WS E)N AU(TW=| OU)DE\N HU)CH/QH, A)LL' E)/MEINEN E)N TW=| AU)TW=| TO/PW|, TI/ DH/ POTE TO/DE ME\N TO\ SW=MA DE/CETAI E)N AU(TW=| A)/LLO SW=MA, TO/DE DE\ OU)/ &10etc. &10@`140, 10.$10 E)/TI EI) <20O(/LA O(/LOIS PAREKTEI/NETAI KAI\ TA\ BRAXU/TATA TOI=S ݈MEGI/STOIS ME/XRI TH=S E)SXA/THS E)PIFANEI/AS>20, O(\N KATE/XEI TO\ E(\N TO/PON, TO\ SUNAMFO/TERON KAQE/CEI. @&10`140, 20.$10 EI) DE\ W(=N O( TO/POS I)/SOS, KAI\ AU)TA\ I)/SA, TA/ TE E)C W(=N TO\ SUN- @1AMFO/TERON I)/SA A)LLH/LOIS E)/STAI, KAI\ TO\ SUNAMFO/TERON E(KATE/RW| AU)TW=N: KAI\ O( KU/AQOS A)/RA TOU= OI)/NOU EI)S PE/LAGOS E)KXUQEI\S I)/SOS E)/STAI TW=| PELA/GEI, KAI\ TO\ PE/LAGOS META\ TOU= KUA/QOU TW=| KUA/QW| MO/NW|. <20TO\ GA\R LE/GEIN O(/TI TH=| DU-NA/MEI OU)K I)/SON>20, OU)DE\N PRO\S TO\N LO/GON. A)RKEI= GA\R EI)S TH\N TOU= PROKEI-ME/NOU DEI=CIN TO\ KATA\ TO\ POSO\N I)/SA AU)TA\ PEFUKE/NAI. E)/TI TE OU)DE\N MA=LLON TO\ PU=R DIA\ TOU= SIDH/ROU DI/EISIN H)\ O( SI/DHROS DIA\ TOU= PURO/S: KAI\ GA\R KAI\ H( YUXH\ DIA\ TOU= SW/MATOS KAI\ H( FU/SIS DIA\ TW=N FUTW=N KAI\ H( E(/CIS DIA\ TW=N A)/LLWN SWMA/TWN, KAI\ A)NA/PALIN TAU=TA DI' E)KEI/NWN. OU)DE\N GA\R TO\ LEPTO/TERO/N TI EI)=NAI KAI\ PAXU/TERON EI)S TOU=TO SUNTELEI=, EI)/GE A)MFO/TERA O(MOI/WS E)STI\ PLH/RH. __E)/TI TI/S AI)TI/A, DI' H(\N E)K TINW=N ME\N MIGNUME/NWN O( O)/GKOS GI/NETAI MEI/-ZWN, E)K TINW=N DE\ O( AU)TO\S ME/NEI; TO\ GA\R LE/GEIN TO\N SI/DHRON PAXU/TERON GEGO-NE/NAI TH=| MI/CEI TOU= PURO\S PARA/LOGON. @&10Plotinus Ennead. II lib. VII 1 [1Vol. I p. 127 Mu+.$10]1. OI( D' AU)= [1&10scil.$10 OI( TH\N DI' O(/LWN KRA=SIN EI)SA/GONTES]1 TE/MNESQAI ME\N KAI\ MH\ EI)S TOMA\S A)NA-LI/SKESQAI LE/GEIN A)\N DU/NAINTO, KAI\ DI' O(/LWN TH=S KRA/SEWS GIGNOME/NHS: E)PEI\ KAI\ TOU\S I(DRW=TAS OU) TOU= SW/MATOS TOMA\S POIEI=N OU)D' AU)= KATATETRH=SQAI FH/-SOUSI. KAI\ GA\R EI)/ TIS LE/GOI MHDE\N KWLU/EIN TH\N FU/SIN OU(/TW PEPOIHKE/NAI TOU= DII+E/NAI TOU\S I(DRW=TAS XA/RIN, A)LL' E)PI\ TW=N TEXNHTW=N, O(/TAN LEPTA\ H)=| KAI\ SUNEXH=, O(RA=SQAI TO\ U(GRO\N DI' O(/LOU DEU=ON[TA] AU)TA\ KAI\ DIAR)R(EI=N E)PI\ QA/TERA TO\ U(GRO/N. A)LLA\ SWMA/TWN O)/NTWN PW=S OI(=O/N TE TOU=TO GI/GNESQAI, W(S DII+E/NAI MH\ TE/MNONTA, E)PINOH=SAI OU) R(A/|DION: TE/MNONTA DE\ KATA\ PA=N A)NAIRH/SEI A)/LLHLA DHLONO/TI. <20TA\S DE\ AU)/CAS O(/TAN LE/GWSI MH\ GI/GNESQAI POLLAXOU=>20, DI-DO/ASI TOI=S E(TE/ROIS A)E/RWN E)CO/DOUS AI)TIA=SQAI. PRO/S TE TH\N TW=N TO/PWN AU)/CHSIN XALEPW=S ME/N, O(/MWS DE\ TI/ KWLU/EI LE/GEIN, SUNEISFEROME/NOU E(KATE/ROU SW/MATOS KAI\ TO\ ME/GEQOS META\ TW=N A)/LLWN POIOTH/TWN, E)C A)NA/GKHS TH\N AU)/CHN GI/GNESQAI: MH\ GA\R MHDE\ TOU=TO A)PO/LLUSQAI, W(/SPER OU)DE\ TA\S A)/LLAS POIO/THTAS: KAI\ W(/SPER E)KEI= POIO/THTOS A)/LLO EI)=DOS MIKTO\N E)C A)MFOI=N, OU(/TW KAI\ ME/GEQOS A)/LLO [OU(=] DH\ TO\ MI=GMA POIEI=, TO\ E)C A)MFOI=N ME/GEQOS. __TO\ DE\ E)/LATTON DIA\ PANTO\S TOU= MEI/ZONOS KAI\ [2DIA\]2 MEGI/STOU TO\ MIKRO/TATON [KAI\] E)F' W(=N FANERO\N O(/TI KI/RNATAI [1E)PI\ GA\R TW=N A)DH/LWN E)/CESTI LE/GEIN, MH\ EI)S PA=N FQA/NEIN]1 A)LL' E)F' W(=N GE FANERW=S SUMBAI/NEI, <20LE/GOIEN A)\N E)KTA/SEIS TW=N O)/GKWN>20, OU) SFO/DRA PIQANA\ LE/GONTES, EI)S TOSOU=TON TO\N SMIKRO/TATON O)/GKON E)KTEI/NONTES. OU)DE\ GA\R METABA/LLONTES TO\ SW=MA ME/GEQOS AU)TW=| PLE/ON DIDO/ASIN, W(/SPER EI) E)C U(/DATOS A)H\R GI/GNOITO. TOU=TO DE\ AU)TO\ E)F' AU(TOU= ZHTHTE/ON, TI/ SUMBAI/NEI O(/TAN O(/SPER H)=N O)/GKOS U(/DATOS A)H\R GI/GNHTAI [2KAI\]2 PW=S TO\ MEI=ZON E)N TW=| GENOME/NW|. @&Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 151.$ *KAI\ TA\S KRA/SEIS DE\ DIO/LOU GI/NE-SQAI, KAQA/ FHSIN O( <20*XRU/SIPPOS E)N TH=| TRI/TH| TW=N FUSIKW=N>20, KAI\ MH\ KATA\ PERIGRAFH\N KAI\ PARA/QESIN: KAI\ GA\R EI)S PE/LAGOS O)LI/GOS OI)=NOS BLHQEI\S E)PI\ POSO\N A)NTIPAREKTAQH/SETAI, EI)=TA SUMFQARH/SETAI. @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 37 p. 1078e.$ *KAI\ TAU=TA PROS-DE/XETAI *XRU/SIPPOS EU)QU\S <20E)N TW=| PRW/TW| TW=N *FUSIKW=N *ZHTHMA/-TWN "1OU)DE\N A)PE/XEIN FA/MENOS, OI)/NOU STALAGMO\N E(/NA KERA/SAI @1 TH\N QA/LATTAN>20,"2 KAI\ I(/NA DH\ MH\ TOU=TO QAUMA/ZWMEN, "1<20EI)S O(/LON, FHSI/, TO\N KO/SMON DIATENEI=N TH=| KRA/SEI TO\N STALAGMO/N>20."2 @&Alexander Aphrod. de mixtione p. 213, 2 Bruns.$ PW=S D' A)\N PARADE/CAITO/ TIS TO\ <20E)N TH=| TOIAU/TH| KRA/SEI TW=N SWMA/TWN E(/KASTON TW=N KIRNAME/NWN FULA/TTEIN DU/NASQAI TH\N OI)KEI/AN E)PIFA/NEIAN>20, W(S O(MOU= ME\N MHDE\ TO\ TUXO\N AU)TOU= MO/RION EI)=NAI KAQ' AU(TO\ KEXWRISME/-NON QATE/ROU, O(MOU= DE\ FULA/TTEIN E(/KASTON AU)TW=N TH\N E)PIFA/NEIAN TH\N E(AUTOU=, H(\N EI)=XE KAI\ PRO\ TH=S KRA/SEWS; TOU=TO GA\R U(PERAI/REI KAI\ TA\S E)N TOI=S MU/QOIS PARADOCOLOGI/AS, O(\ TI/QHSI <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20, W(S O)\N E)N TOU/TW| TO\ DU/NASQAI TA\ KEKRAME/NA XWRI/ZESQAI PA/LIN. @&Stobaeus Eclogae I 142, 2 W.$ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 E)/FASKE TA\ SW/-MATA EI)S A)/PEIRON TE/MNESQAI KAI\ TA\ TOI=S SW/MASI PROSEOIKO/TA, OI(=ON E)PIFA/NEIAN, GRAMMH/N, TO/PON, KENO/N, XRO/NON: EI)S A)/PEIRO/N TE TOU/TWN TEMNOME/NWN OU)/TE SW=MA E)C A)PEI/RWN SWMA/TWN SUNE/STHKEN OU)/T' E)PIFA/-NEIA OU)/TE GRAMMH\ OU)/TE TO/POS [2OU)/TE KENO\N OU)/TE XRO/NOS]2 @&Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 150.$ KAI\ PAQHTH\ DE/ E)STIN [1&scil.$ H( OU)SI/A]1 W(S O( AU)TO/S FHSIN [1&scil. Apollodorus$ E)N TH=| FUSIKH=|]1. EI) GA\R H)=N A)/TRE-PTOS, OU)K A)\N TA\ GINO/MENA E)C AU)TH=S E)GI/NETO. E)/NQEN KA)K[2OLOUQ]2EI=N W(S H(/ TE TOMH\ EI)S A)/PEIRO/N E)STIN [1H(\N A)/PEIRON, [2OU)K EI)S A)/PEIRO/N]2 FHSIN O( *XRU/SIPPOS: OU) GA/R E)STI/ TI A)/PEIRON, EI)S O(\ GI/NETAI H( TOMH/. A)LL' A)KA-TA/LHKTO/S E)STI]1 KAI\ TA\S KRA/SEIS DE\ DIO/LOU GI/NESQAI &etc. &@Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 38 p. 1076b.$ *LE/GEI GA\R O( <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 "1E)RWTWME/NOUS H(MA=S, EI)/ TINA E)/XOMEN ME/RH KAI\ PO/SA KAI\ E)K TI/NWN SUGKEI/MENA MERW=N KAI\ PO/SWN, DIASTOLH=| XRH/SESQAI, TO\ ME\N O(LOSXERE\S TIQE/NTAS, W(S E)K KEFALH=S KAI\ QW/RAKOS KAI\ SKELW=N SUGKEI/-MEQA: TOU=TO GA\R H)=N PA=N TO\ ZHTOU/MENON KAI\ A)POROU/MENON: E)A\N D' E)PI\ TA\ E)/SXATA ME/RH TO\ E)RWTA=N PROA/GWSIN, OU)DE/N, FHSI/, TW=N TOIOU/TWN E)STI\N U(POLHPTE/ON, A)LLA\ R(HTE/ON, OU)/T' E)/K TINWN SUNESTA/NAI, KAI\ O(MOI/WS, OU)/T' E)C O(PO/SWN, EI)/T' A)PEI/RWN, EI)/TE PEPERASME/NWN. @1 @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 38 p. 1079a.$ GENO/MENOI DE\ *STWI+KOI\ DOCA/ZOUSIN, W(S OU)K E)/STIN E)K PLEIO/NWN MORI/WN O( A)/NQRWPOS H)\ O( DA/KTULOS, OU)D' O( KO/SMOS H)\ O( A)/NQRWPOS [1E)P' A)/PEIRON GA\R H( TOMH\ PROA/GEI TA\ SW/MATA: TW=N D' A)PEI/RWN OU)DE/N E)STI PLE/ON OU)D' E)/LATTON]1 OU)D' O(/LWS U(PERBA/LLEI PLH=QOS, H)\ PAU/SETAI TA\ ME/RH TOU= U(POLEIPOME/NOU MERIZO/MENA KAI\ PARE/XONTA PLH=QOS E)C AU(TW=N O(TIOU=N. @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 38 p. 1078e.$ *KAI\ MH\N PARA\ TH\N E)/NNOIAN MH/T' A)/KRON E)N TH=| FU/SEI TW=N SWMA/TWN MH/TE PRW=TON MH/T' E)/SXATON [2ME/ROS EI)=NAI]2 MHDE/N, EI)S O(\ LH/GEI TO\ ME/GEQOS TOU= SW/MATOS, A)LL' A)EI/ [2TI]2 TOU= LHFQE/NTOS E)PE/KEINA FAINO/MENON EI)S A)/PEIRON KAI\ A)O/RI-STON E)MBA/LLEIN TO\ U(POKEI/MENON. &p. 1079a$ OI( SW=MA MHDE\N EI)S E)/SXATON ME/ROS PERAI/NONTES A)LLA\ PA/NTA PLH/QEI MERW=N E)P' A)/PEIRON E)CA/GONTES. @&10Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 40 p. 1080d.$10 KAI\ MH\N TO\ MHDENO\S A(/PTESQAI MHDE\N PARA\ TH\N E)/NNOIA/N E)STIN: OU)X H(=TTON DE\ TOU=TO, A(/PTESQAI ME\N A)LLH/LWN TA\ SW/MATA, MHDENI\ D' A(/PTESQAI: TOU=TO D' A)NA/GKH PROSDE/XESQAI TOI=S MH\ A)POLEI/POUSIN E)LA/XISTA ME/RH SW/MATOS, A)LL' A)EI/ TI TOU= DOKOU=NTOS A(/PTESQAI PRO/TERON LAMBA/NOUSI KAI\ MHDE/POTE TOU= PROA/GEIN E)PE/KEINA PAUOME/NOIS. @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 40 p. 1080e.$ *(\O GOU=N AU)TOI\ MA/LISTA PROFE/ROUSI TOI=S TW=N A)MERW=N PROISTAME/NOIS TOU=TO/ E)STI "1TO\ MH/TE O(/LOIS O(/LWN A(FH\N EI)=NAI, MH/TE ME/RESI MERW=N: TO\ ME\N GA\R OU)X A(FH\N A)LLA\ KRA=SIN POIEI=N, TO\ D' OU)K EI)=NAI DUNATO/N, ME/RH TW=N A)MERW=N OU)K E)XO/NTWN."2 *PW=S OU)=N OU)K AU)TOI\ TOU/TW| PERIPI/PTOUSI, MHDE\N ME/ROS E)/SXATON MHDE\ PRW=TON A)POLEI/PONTES; O(/TI, NH\ *DI/A "1YAU/EIN KATA\ PE/RAS TA\ SW/MATA [2OU)X]2 O(/LA O(/LWN, OU)[2DE\]2 KATA\ ME/ROS"2 LE/GOUSI: TO\ DE\ PE/-RAS SW=MA OU)K E)/STIN. @&10Proclus in Euclid. def. I p. 89 Friedlein.$10 O(/TI DE\ OU) DEI= NOMI/ZEIN KAT' E)PI/NOIAN YILH\N U(FESTA/NAI TA\ TOIAU=TA PE/RATA, LE/GW TW=N SWMA/TWN, W(/SPER <20OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 U(PE/LABON, A)LL' EI)=NAI/ TINAS FU/SEIS E)N TOI=S OU)=SI TOIA/SDE KAI\ LO/GOUS AU)TW=N PROESTA/NAI DHMIOURGIKOU/S, A)NAMNHSQEI/HMEN A)\N EI)S TO\N O(/LON KO/SMON A)POBLE/YANTES &10etc. @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 39 p. 1079d.$ *)EPI\ DE\ TOU/TOIS E)PINEANIEUO/MENOS FHSI\ "1TH=S PURAMI/DOS E)K TRIGW/NWN SUNISTAME/NHS. TA\S PLEURA\S [2TA\S]2 KATA\ TH\N SUNAFH\N E)GKEKLIME/NAS A)NI/SOUS ME\N EI)=NAI, MH\ U(PERE/XEIN DE/, H(=| MEI/ZONE/S EI)SI."2 &p. 1079e.$ *)/ETI TOI/NUN O(/RA TI/NA TRO/PON A)PH/NTHSE *DHMOKRI/TW|, DIAPOROU=NTI FUSIKW=S KAI\ E)PITUXW=S, EI) KW=NOS TE/MNOITO PARA\ TH\N BA/SIN E)PIPE/DW|, TI/ XRH\ DIANOEI=SQAI TA\S TW=N @1 TMHMA/TWN E)PIFANEI/AS, I)/SAS H)\ A)NI/SOUS GINOME/NAS: A)/NISOI ME\N GA\R OU)=SAI TO\N KW=NON A)NW/MALON PARE/COUSI, POLLA\S A)POXARA/CEIS LAMBA/NONTA BAQMOEIDEI=S KAI\ TRAXU/THTAS: I)/SWN D' OU)SW=N, I)/SA TMH/MATA E)/STAI, KAI\ FANEI=TAI TO\ TOU= KULI/NDROU PEPONQW\S O( KW=NOS, E)C I)/SWN SUGKEI/MENOS KAI\ OU)K A)NI/SWN KU/KLWN, O(/PER E)STI\N A)TOPW/TATON. *)ENTAU=QA DH\ TO\N *DHMO/KRITON A)POFAI/NWN A)GNOOU=NTA "1TA\S ME\N E)PIFANEI/AS, FHSI/, MH/T' I)/SAS EI)=NAI MH/T' A)NI/SOUS: A)/NISA DE\ TA\ SW/MATA, TW=| MH/T' I)/SAS EI)=NAI MH/T' A)NI/SOUS TA\S E)PIFANEI/AS."2 @&10Syrianus in Aristot. Metaphys. [1Aristot. Acad. V 91ia 28]1.$10 O(/TAN DE\ LE/GWSI [1&10scil. Pythagorei$10]1 MONA/DA EI)=NAI EI)DW=N EI)=DOS TH\N A)RXHGIKH\N AU)TW=N AI)TI/AN E)NDEI/KNUNTAI TH\N PA/NTWN E)N E(AUTH=| TA\ EI)/DH TW=N A)RIQMW=N PROEILH-FUI=AN, H(\N KAI\ OI( <20A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 E(\N PLH=QOS OU)K W)/KNOUN KALEI=N. @&10Sextus adv. math. X 123.$10 TA/CEI DE\ A)PO\ TH=S PRW/THS STA/SEWS POIW/MEQA TH\N E)PIXEI/RHSIN, KAQ' H(\N PA/NTA EI)S A)/PEIRON TE/MNETAI. KAI\ DH\ OI( PROESTW=TES AU)TH=S FASI\ TO\ KINOU/MENON SW=MA U(F' E(/NA KAI\ TO\N AU)TO\N XRO/NON A)/QROUN MERISTO\N A)NU/EIN DIA/STHMA, KAI\ OU) TO\ PRW=TON TOU= DIASTH/MATOS PRW=-TON E)PILAMBA/NEIN TW=| PRW/TW| AU(TOU= ME/REI KAI\ TO\ DEU/TERON TH=| TA/CEI DEU/TERON, A)LL' U(F' E(\N TO\ O(/LON MERISTO\N DIA/STHMA KAI\ A)QRO/WS DIE/RXESQAI. @&Stobaeus Eclogae I p. 165, 15.$ <20*XRUSI/PPOU>20. *KI/NHSIN DE/ FHSIN EI)=NAI O( *XRU/SIPPOS METABOLH\N KATA\ TO/PON H)\ O(/LW| H)\ ME/REI, H)\ METALLAGH\N E)K TO/POU H)\ KAQ' O(/LON H)\ KATA\ ME/ROS. *KAI\ A)/LLWS: KI/NHSIN METALLAGH\N KATA\ TO/PON H)\ SXH=MA: FORA\N DE\ METE/WRON KI/NHSIN O)CEI=AN, MONH\N DE\ TO\ ME\N OI(=ON A)KINHSI/AN SW/MATOS, TO\ D' OI(=ON SW/MATOS SXE/SIN KATA\ TAU)TA\ KAI\ W(SAU/TWS NU=N TE KAI\ PRO/TERON. *POLLAXW=S DE\ LE/GE-SQAI TH\N KI/NHSIN KAI\ TH\N MONH/N, DIO\ KAI\ POLLOU\S KAQ' E(/KASTON SH-MAINO/MENON A)PODI/DOSQAI O(/ROUS. *TA\S DE\ PRW/TAS KINH/SEIS EI)=NAI DU/O, TH/N TE EU)QEI=AN KAI\ TH\N KAMPU/LHN: DIA\ TOU/TWN DE\ POLLAXW=S MIGNU-ME/NWN GI/NESQAI POLLA\S KINH/SEIS KAI\ DIAFEROU/SAS. @&Sextus adv. math. X 52.$ KAI/ FASIN O(/TI KI/NHSI/S E)STI META/BASIS A)PO\ TO/POU EI)S TO/PON H)/TOI O(/LOU TOU= SW/MATOS H)\ TW=N TOU= O(/LOU MERW=N. @&10Sextus adv. math. X 45.$10 KAI\ EI)=NAI ME\N [1&10scil.$10 KI/NHSIN]1_OI( PLEI/OUS TW=N FUSIKW=N__OI(=S KAI\ OI( A)PO\ TOU= PERIPA/TOU, E)/TI DE\ KAI\ <20OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 SUNAPEGRA/YANTO. @1 @&10Galenus methodi med. I 6 Vol. X p. 46K.$10 E)PEI\ D' E)CA/LLACIN EI)=-PON EI)=NAI TOU= PROU+PA/RXONTOS TH\N KI/NHSIN, E)CALLA/TTETAI DE\ DIXW=S TO\ PROU+-PA/RXON H)\ KATA\ POIO/THTA H)\ KATA\ TO/PON, H( ME\N OU)=N KATA\ TO/PON E)CALLAGH\ AU)TOU= FORA\ O)NOMA/ZETAI, H( DE\ KATA\ POIO/THTA METABOLH\ A)LLOI/WSIS: W(/STE EI)=NAI FORA\N ME\N E)CA/LLACIN H)\ U(PA/LLACIN H)\ A)LLAGH\N H)\ METABOLH\N TOU= PROU+PA/RXON-TOS TO/POU__<20A)LLOI/WSIN DE\ H)\ METABOLH\N KATA\ TO\ POIO\N H)\ A)LLA-GH\N TH=S PROU+PARXOU/SHS POIO/THTOS>20 &10etc. @&Galenus de nat. facult. I 2 Vol. II p. 4K.$ EI) ME\N GA\R OU)K I)/SASIN, O(/SA PERI\ TH=S KAQ' O(/LHN TH\N OU)SI/AN A)LLOIW/SEWS *)ARISTOTE/LEI TE KAI\ META\ TOU=TON <20*XRUSI/PPW|>20 GE/GRAPTAI, PARAKALE/SAI XRH\ TOI=S E)KEI/NWN AU)TOU\S O(MILH=SAI GRA/MMASIN. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. phys. p. 1320,19 Diels.$10 OI( DE\ <20A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 KATA\ PA=SAN KI/NHSIN E)/LEGON U(PEI=NAI TH\N TOPIKH\N H)\ KATA\ MEGA/LA DIA-STH/MATA H)\ KATA\ LO/GW| QEWRHTA\ U(FISTAME/NHN. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 78A.$10 *PLWTI=NOS KAI\ OI( A)/LLOI OI( A)PO\ TH=S TW=N <20*STWI+KW=N>20 SUNHQEI/AS EI)S TH\N *)ARISTOTE/LOUS AI(/RESIN METAFE/RONTES TO\ <20KOINO\N TOU= POIEI=N KAI\ TOU= PA/SXEIN EI)=NAI TA\S KINH/SEIS>20. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 78B. ed. Bas.$10 KAI\ TH=S KINH/SEWS, FHSI\N *)IA/MBLIXOS, OU) KALW=S OI( <20*STWI+KOI\>20 E)PILAMBA/NONTAI LE/GONTES TO\ A)TELE\S E)PI\ TH=S KINH/SEWS EI)RH=SQAI, OU)X O(/TI OU)K E)/STIN E)NE/RGEIA [1E)/STI GA\R PA/NTWS, FASI/N, E)NE/RGEIA]1 A)LL' E)/XEI TO\ PA/LIN KAI\ PA/LIN, OU)X I(/NA A)FI/KHTAI EI)S E)NE/RGEIAN [1E)/STI GA\R H)/DH]1 A)LL' I(/NA E)RGA/SHTAI/ POU E(/TERON, O(/ E)STI MET' AU)TH/N. TAU=TA ME\N OU)=N OI( <20*STWI+KOI\>20 LE/GOUSI. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 78B. ed.$10 *KAI\ GA\R O(/TAN OI( <20*STWI+KOI\>20 DIAFORA\S GENW=N LE/GWSI <20TO\ E)C AU(TW=N KINEI=SQAI>20 W(S H( MA/XAIRA TO\ TE/MNEIN E)K TH=S OI)KEI/AS E)/XEI KATASKEUH=S [1KATA\ GA\R TO\ SXH=MA KAI\ TO\ EI)=DOS H( POI/HSIS E)PITELEI=TAI]1 TO\ DE\ <20DI' E(AUTOU=>20 E)NERGEI=N TH\N KI/NHSIN, W(S AI( FU/SEIS KAI\ AI( I)ATRIKAI\ DUNA/MEIS TH\N POI/HSIN A)PERGA/ZONTAI [1KATABLHQE\N GA\R TO\ SPE/RMA A)NAPLHROI= TOU\S OI)KEI/OUS LO/GOUS KAI\ E)PISPA=TAI TH\N PARAKEIME/NHN U(/LHN KAI\ DIAMORFOI= TOU\S E)N AU)TW=| LO/GOUS]1 A)LLA\ MH\N KAI\ TO\ <20A)F' E(AUTOU=>20 POIEI=N, O(/ E)STI KOINW=S ME\N A)PO\ I)DI/AS O(RMH=S POIEI=N, E(/TERON DE\ A)PO\ LOGIKH=S O(RMH=S, O(\ KAI\ PLA/TTEIN KALEI=TAI: TOU/TOU DE\ E)/TI EI)DIKW/TERON TO\ KAT' A)RETH\N E)NERGEI=N. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 210B. ed. Bas.$10 OI( ME/NTOI <20*STWI+-KOI\>20 DIAFE/REIN A)LLH/LWN H(GOU=NTAI TO\ ME/NEIN, TO\ H)REMEI=N, TO\ H(SUXA/ZEIN, TO\ A)KINHTEI=N, TO\ A)KINHTI/ZEIN: ME/NEIN GA\R A)\N R(HQH=NAI [2OU)]2 PRO\S E(/NA XRO/NON, A)LLA\ PRO\S TO\N E)NESTW=TA KAI\ ME/LLONTA: ME/NEIN GA\R LE/GOMEN TO\ KATE/XON TO\N AU)TO\N TO/PON KAI\ KAQE/CON. TO\ GA\R KATESXHKO\S MEMENHKE/NAI LE/GOMEN. XRW/-MEQA DE/, FASI, KAI\ E)PI\ TOU= MH\ KINEI=SQAI TW=| ME/NEIN, W(/STE KATAXRHSTIKW=S EI)PEI=N A)/N TINA KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N A)SWMA/TWN TO\ ME/NEIN A)NTI\ TOU= MH\ KINEI=SQAI. KOINO\N ME\N OU)=N PA/NTWN SWMA/TWN TO\ ME/NEIN, TO\ DE\ H)REMEI=N KAI\ H(SUXA/ZEIN, FHSI/, MH/POTE ZW/|WN EI)SI\ SUMPTW/MATA: LI/QOS GA\R OU)K H)REMEI=. ZW/|WN DE\ KAI\ TO\ H(SUXA/ZEIN. TO\ A)KINHTEI=N KAI\ A)KINHTI/ZEIN E)PI\ TW=N SWMA/TWN LE/GETAI, A(\ PE/FUKE MH\ KINEI=SQAI, A)NTI\ TOU= MH\ KINEI=SQAI DE\ LE/GETAI. @1 @&10Sextus adv. math. X 7.$10 EI)/PER OU)=N E)/STIN A)/NW KAI\ KA/TW KAI\ EI)S TA\ DECIA\ KAI\ TA\ A)RISTERA\ KAI\ PRO/SW KAI\ O)PI/SW, E)/STI TIS TO/POS: ME/RH GA/R EI)SIN AI( E(\C AU(=TAI PARATA/SEIS TOU= TO/POU, KAI\ A)DU/NATO/N E)STI/ TINOS TW=N MERW=N U(PARXO/NTWN MH\ OU)XI\ KA)KEI=NO U(PA/RXEIN OU(= E)STI\ TA\ ME/RH. E)/STI DE/ GE E)N TH=| FU/SEI TW=N PRAGMA/TWN A)/NW KAI\ KA/TW KAI\ EI)S DECIA\ KAI\ A)RISTERA\ KAI\ PRO/SW KAI\ O)PI/SW: E)/STIN A)/RA TO/POS. OU) MH\N A)LL' EI) O(/POU H)=N *SWKRA/THS, NU=N E)STI\N A)/LLOS, OI(=ON *PLA/TWN A)POQANO/NTOS *SWKRA/TOUS, E)/STIN A)/RA TO/POS. W(S GA\R TOU= E)N TW=| A)MFOREI= U(GROU= E)KKENWQE/NTOS KAI\ A)/LLOU E)PEGXUQE/NTOS LE/GOMEN U(PA/R-XEIN TO\N A)MFORE/A TO/PON O)/NTA KAI\ TOU= PROTE/ROU KAI\ TOU= U(/STERON E)PEMBLH-QE/NTOS U(GROU=, OU(/TWS EI) O(\N TO/PON KATEI=XE *SWKRA/THS O(/T' E)/ZH, TOU=TON E(/TEROS NU=N KATE/XEI, E)/STI TIS TO/POS. KAI\ A)/LLWS EI) E)/STI TI SW=MA, KAI\ TO/POS E)STI/N: [2SW=MA GA/R E)STI TO\ KATE/XON TO/PON]2: A)LLA\ MH\N TO\ PRW=TON: TO\ A)/RA DEU/TERON. PRO\S TOU/TOIS EI) O(/POU TO\ KOU=FON FU/SEI FE/RETAI, E)KEI= TO\ BARU\ FU/SEI OU) FE/-RETAI, E)/STIN I)/DIOS TOU= KOU/FOU KAI\ TOU= BARE/OS TO/POS: A)LLA\ MH\N TO\ PRW=TON: TO\ A)/RA DEU/TERON. TO\ GE/ TOI PU=R, FU/SEI KOU=FON KAQESTW/S, A)NW/FORO/N E)STI, KAI\ TO\ U(/DWR, FU/SEI BARU\ TUGXA/NON, KA/TW BRI/QEI, KAI\ OU)/TE TO\ PU=R KA/TW FE/RETAI OU)/TE TO\ U(/DWR A)/NW A)/TTEI. E)/STIN A)/RA I)/DIOS TOU= FU/SEI KOU/FOU KAI\ TOU= FU/SEI BARE/OS TO/POS. W(/SPER TE EI) TO\ E)C OU(= GI/GNETAI E)/STI, KAI\ TO\ U(F' OU(= TI GI/GNETAI KAI\ TO\ DI' O(/, OU(/TWS U(PA/RXOI A)\N KAI\ TO\ E)N W(=| TI GI/GNETAI: E)/STI DE\ TO\ E)C OU(= TI GI/GNETAI, OI(=ON U(/LH, KAI\ TO\ U(F' OU(=, OI(=ON TO\ AI)/TION, KAI\ TO\ DI' O(/, KAQA/PER TO\ TE/LOS: E)/STIN A)/RA KAI\ TO\ E)N W(=| TI GI/GNETAI, TOUTE/STIN O( TO/-POS. OI(/ TE PALAIOI\ KAI\ TA\ O(/LA DIAKOSMH/SANTES A)RXH\N TW=N PA/NTWN U(PE/QENTO TO/PON, KA)NTEU=QEN O(RMHQEI\S O( *(HSI/ODOS A)NEFW/NHSEN: [1&10Theog. 116sq.$10]1 @H)/TOI ME\N PRW/TISTA XA/OS GE/NET', AU)TA\R E)/PEITA @GAI=' EU)RU/STERNOS, PA/NTWN E(/DOS A)SFALE\S AI)EI/, XA/OS LE/GWN TO\N XWRHTIKO\N TW=N O(/LWN TO/PON: MH\ U(POKEIME/NOU GA\R TOU/TOU OU)/TE GH= OU)/TE U(/DWR OU)/TE TA\ LOIPA\ TW=N STOIXEI/WN, OU)X O( SU/MPAS KO/SMOS E)DU/-NATO SUSTH=NAI. KA)\N KAT' E)PI/NOIAN DE\ A(/PANTA A)NE/LWMEN, O( TO/POS OU)K A)NAI-REQH/SETAI E)N W(=| H)=N TA\ PA/NTA, A)LL' U(POME/NEI, TA\S TREI=S E)/XWN DIASTA/SEIS, MH=-KOS BA/QOS PLA/TOS, XWRI\S A)NTITUPI/AS: TOU=TO GA\R I)/DION H)=N SW/MATOS. @&10Galenus de qualitatibus incorporeis 1 Vol. XIX 464K.$10 O(/TI DE\ KOINO/N E)STI TOU=TO [DH=LON] [1LE/GW DE\ TO\ TRIXH=| DIASTATO/N]1 SW/MATO/S TE KAI\ KENOU= KAI\ TO/POU, <20*STWI+KOU\S>20 ME\N O(MOLOGEI=N A)NAGKAI=ON, A(/TE KENO\N A)POLIPO/N-TAS E)N TH=| TW=N O)/NTWN PRAGMA/TWN FU/SEI, KA)\N E)N TW=| KO/SMW| TOU=Q' U(PA/RXEIN MH\ LE/GWSI. @&Stobaeus Eclogae I p. 161, 8 W.$ <20*XRUSI/PPOU>20. *TO/PON D' EI)=NAI O( *XRU/SIPPOS A)PEFAI/NETO TO\ KATEXO/MENON DI' O(/LOU U(PO\ O)/NTOS H)\ TO\ OI(=O/N [2TE]2 KATE/XESQAI U(PO\ O)/NTOS KAI\ DI' O(/LOU KATEXO/MENON EI)/TE U(PO\ TINO\S [2EI)/TE]2 U(PO\ TINW=N. *)EA\N DE\ TOU= OI(/OU TE KATE/XESQAI U(PO\ O)/NTOS @1 TI\ ME\N KATE/XHTAI, TI\ DE\ MH/, TO\ O(/LON [2OU)/TE]2 KENO\N E)/SESQAI OU)/TE TO/PON, E(/TERON DE/ TI OU)K W)NOMASME/NON: TO\ ME\N GA\R KENO\N TOI=S KENOI=S A)GGEI/OIS LE/GESQAI PARAPLHSI/WS, TO\N DE\ TO/PON TOI=S PLH/RESI: XW/RAN DE\ PO/TERON TO\ MEI=ZON OI(=O/NTE KATE/XESQAI U(PO\ O)/NTOS KAI\ OI(=ON MEI=ZON A)GGEI=ON SW/MA-TOS H)\ TO\ XWROU=N MEI=ZON SW=MA; *TO\ ME\N OU)=N KENO\N A)/PEIRON EI)=NAI LE/-GESQAI: TO\ GA\R E)KTO\S TOU= KO/SMOU TOIOU=T' EI)=NAI, TO\N DE\ TO/PON PEPE-RASME/NON DIA\ TO\ MHDE\N SW=MA A)/PEIRON EI)=NAI. *KAQA/PER DE\ TO\ SWMATIKO\N PEPERASME/NON EI)=NAI, OU(/TWS TO\ A)SW/MATON A)/PEIRON, O(/ TE GA\R XRO/NOS A)/PEIROS KAI\ TO\ KENO/N. *(/WSPER GA\R TO\ MHDE\N OU)DE/N E)STI PE/RAS, OU(/TWS OU)DE\ TOU= MHDENO/S, OI(=O/N E)STI TO\ KENO/N. *KATA\ GA\R TH\N AU(TOU= U(PO/-STASIN A)/PEIRO/N E)STI: PERATOU=TAI D' AU)= TOU=TO E)KPLHROU/MENON: TOU= DE\ PLHROU=NTOS A)RQE/NTOS OU)K E)/STIN AU)TOU= NOH=SAI PE/RAS [1&Diels Arii Di-&dymi Epit. phys. frgm. 25$]1. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. I 20,1.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 .... DIAFE/REIN KENO/N, TO/PON, XW/RAN: KAI\ TO\ ME\N KENO\N EI)=NAI E)RHMI/AN SW/MATOS, TO\N DE\ TO/PON TO\ E)XO/MENON U(PO\ SW/MATOS, TH\N DE\ XW/RAN TO\ E)K ME/ROUS E)XO/MENON, W(/SPER E)PI\ TH=S TOU= OI)/NOU PIQA/KNHS. @&10Sextus adv. math. X 3.$10 KAI\ OI( <20*STWI+KOI\>20 DE\ KENO\N ME\N EI)=NAI/ FASI TO\ OI(=O/NTE U(PO\ O)/NTOS KATE/XESQAI, MH\ KATEXO/MENON DE/, H)\ DIA/STHMA E)/RHMON SW/MATOS H)\ DIA/STHMA A)KAQEKTOU/MENON U(PO\ SW/MATOS, TO/PON DE\ TO\N U(PO\ O)/NTOS KATEXO/MENON KAI\ E)CISAZO/MENON TW=| KATE/XONTI AU)TO/N, NU=N O)\N KALOU=NTES TO\ SW=MA, KAQW\S KAI\ E)K TH=S METALH/YEWS TW=N O)NOMA/TWN E)STI\ SUMFANE/S. XW/RAN DE/ FASIN EI)=NAI DIA/STHMA KATA\ ME/N TI KATEXO/MENON U(PO\ SW/MATOS KATA\ DE/ TI A)KAQEKTOU/MENON. @&10idem adv. math. X 4.$10 E)/NIOI DE\ [1&10scil. Chrysippus cf. 503$10]1 XW/RAN E)/LE-CAN U(PA/RXEIN TO\N TOU= MEI/ZONOS SW/MATOS TO/PON, W(S TAU/TH| DIAFE/REIN TOU= TO/POU TH\N XW/RAN TW=| E)KEI=NON ME\N MH\ E)MFAI/NEIN ME/GEQOS TOU= E)MPERIEXOME/NOU SW/MATOS [1KA)\N GA\R E)LA/XISTON PERIE/XH| SW=MA, OU)DE\N H(=TTON TO/POS PROSAGOREU/ETAI]1, TH\N D' A)CIO/LOGON E)MFAI/NEIN ME/GEQOS TOU= E)N AU)TH=| SW/MATOS. @&Themistius paraphr. ad Arist. Phys. IV 4 p. 268 Sp.$ LEI/PETAI TOI/NUN H(MI=N O(/TI MHDE\ TO\ DIA/STHMA O( TO/POS E)STI\N A)PODEI=CAI. DIA/STHMA DE\ TO\ METACU\ NOOU/MENON TW=N PERA/TWN TOU= PERIE/XONTOS, OI(=ON TO\ ME-TACU\ TH=S KOI/LHS E)PIFANEI/AS TOU= KA/DOU. PALAIA\ ME\N OU)=N H( DO/CA KAI\ TOI=S TO\ KENO\N TIQEME/NOIS PROSH/KOUSA, H)KOLOU/QHSEN DE\ O(/MWS AU)TH=| KAI\ O( PERI\ <20*XRU/SIPPON>20 XORO\S KAI\ *)EPI/KOUROS U(/STERON. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 91$10 *D&10 ed. Bas.$10 O( *)IA/MBLIXOS ZHTEI= PRW=TON, PO/TERON AU)TA\ TA\ PRA/GMATA E)N TO/PW| O)/NTA A)FORI/ZEI TO\N TO/PON PERI\ AU)TA\ H)\ SU\N AU)TOI=S, H)\ O( TO/POS A)FORI/ZEI TA\ PRA/GMATA, W(S A)\N AU)TO\S AU)TA\ SUMPERAI/NWN, KAI\ FHSI\N O(/TI "1EI) ME/N, W(S OI( <20*STWI+KOI\>20 LE/GOUSI, PARUFI/STATAI @1 TOI=S SW/MASIN O( TO/POS, KAI\ TO\N O(/RON A)P' AU)TW=N PROSLAMBA/NEI TO\N ME/XRI TO-SOU=DE KAQ' O(/SON SUMPLHROU=TAI U(PO\ TW=N SWMA/TWN. EI) ME/NTOI &10etc."2 &10@Simplicius in Aristot. Phys. p. 571, 22.$10 H)\ GA\R TO\ EI)=DOS TOU= E)N TO/PW| H)\ TH\N U(/LHN AU)TOU= H)\ TO\ DIA/STHMA TO\ METACU\ TW=N E)SXA/TWN TOU= PERI-E/XONTOS TO\N TO/PON A)NA/GKH EI)=NAI [1O(/ TINES KAI\ TW=N PROTE/RWN W(S OI( PERI\ *DH-MO/KRITON KAI\ TW=N U(STE/RWN W(S OI( PERI\ *)EPI/KOURON KAI\ <20OI( *STWI+KOI/>20, TINE\S DE\ KAI\ KATA\ *PLA/TWNA TOU=TO TO\N TO/PON EI)=NAI E)NO/MISAN]1 H)\ TA\ E)/SXATA TOU= PERIE/XONTOS. __TO\ DE\ DIA/STHMA TOU=TO OI( ME\N PERI\ *DHMO/KRITON KAI\ *)EPI/-KOURON KENO\N EI)=NAI LE/GOUSIN OU(/TWS W(/STE POTE\ ME\N PLHROU=SQAI SW/MATOS POTE\ DE\ KAI\ KENO\N A)POLEI/PESQAI, OI( DE\ *PLATWNIKOI\ KAI\ <20OI( *STWI+KOI\ EI)=NAI ME\N A)/LLO PARA\ TA\ SW/MATA/ FASIN>20, A)EI\ DE\ SW=MA E)/XEIN, W(S MHDE/POTE KENO\N A)POLEI/PESQAI. @&Stobaeus Eclogae I. p. 106, 5 W. [1Arii Did. fr. 26 Diels$]1. <20*XRUSI/PPOU>20: *(O DE\ *XRU/SIPPOS XRO/NON EI)=NAI KINH/SEWS DIA/STHMA, KAQ' O(/ POTE LE/GETAI ME/TRON TA/XOUS TE KAI\ BRADU/THTOS: H)\ TO\ PARAKOLOUQOU=N DIA/STHMA TH=| TOU= KO/SMOU KINH/SEI, KAI\ KATA\ ME\N TO\N XRO/NON KINEI=SQAI/ TE E(/KASTA KAI\ EI)=NAI: EI) MH\ A)/RA DITTO\S LE/GETAI O( XRO/NOS, KAQA/PER H(/ TE GH= KAI\ H( QA/LATTA KAI\ TO\ KENO/N, TA/ TE O(/LA KAI\ TA\ ME/RH TA\ AU)TW=N. *(/WSPER DE\ TO\ KENO\N PA=N A)/PEIRON EI)=NAI PA/NTH|, KAI\ TO\N XRO/NON PA/NTA A)/PEIRON EI)=NAI E)F' E(KA/TERA: KAI\ GA\R TO\N PARELHLUQO/TA KAI\ TO\N ME/L-LONTA A)/PEIRON EI)=NAI. *)EMFANE/STATA DE\ TOU=TO LE/GEI, O(/TI OU)DEI\S O(/LWS E)NI/STATAI XRO/NOS. *)EPEI\ GA\R EI)S A)/PEIRON H( TOMH\ TW=N SUNEXO/NTWN E)STI/, KATA\ TH\N DIAI/RESIN TAU/THN KAI\ PA=S XRO/NOS EI)S A)/PEIRON E)/XEI TH\N TO-MH/N: W(/STE MHQE/NA KAT' A)PARTISMO\N E)NESTA/NAI XRO/NON, A)LLA\ KATA\ PLA/-TOS LE/GESQAI. *MO/NON D' U(PA/RXEIN FHSI\ TO\N E)NESTW=TA, TO\N DE\ PARW|-XHME/NON KAI\ TO\N ME/LLONTA U(FESTA/NAI ME/N, U(PA/RXEIN DE\ OU)DAMW=S FHSIN, W(S KAI\ KATHGORH/MATA U(PA/RXEIN LE/GETAI MO/NA TA\ SUMBEBHKO/TA, OI(=ON TO\ PERIPATEI=N U(PA/RXEI MOI O(/TE PERIPATW=, O(/TE DE\ KATAKE/KLIMAI H)\ KA/QHMAI OU)X U(PA/RXEI .......... @&10Simplicius in Aristot. categ. p. 88Z. ed. Bas.$10 TW=N DE\ <20*STWI+KW=N *ZH/NWN>20 ME\N PA/SHS A(PLW=S KINH/SEWS DIA/STHMA TO\N XRO/NON EI)=PE: <20*XRU/SIP- @1POS>20 DE\ DIA/STHMA TH=S TOU= KO/SMOU KINH/SEWS: OU) GA\R DU/O O(/ROUS EI)S TAU)TO\N SUNA/PTEI, A)LL' E(/NA O(RISMO\N POIEI=TAI KAI\ I)DIA/ZONTA TOU=TON PARA\ TA\S TW=N A)/L-LWN A)POFA/SEIS. @&10Philo de mundi opificio %14 26 Vol. I p. 8, 7 Wendl.$10 XRO/NOS GA\R OU)K H)=N PRO\ KO/SMOU A)LL' H)\ SU\N AU)TW=| GE/GONEN H)\ MET' AU)TO/N. *)EPEI\ GA\R DIA/-STHMA TH=S TOU= KO/SMOU KINH/SEW/S E)STIN O( XRO/NOS, PROTE/RA [2DE\]2 TOU= KINOUME/-NOU KI/NHSIS OU)K A)\N GE/NOITO, A)LL' A)NAGKAI=ON AU)TH\N H)\ U(/STERON H)\ A(/MA SUN-I/STASQAI, A)NAGKAI=ON A)/RA KAI\ TO\N XRO/NON H)\ I)SH/LIKA KO/SMOU GEGONE/NAI H)\ NEW/TERON E)KEI/NOU. @&10Philo quod deus sit immut. %14 31 Vol. II p. 63, 3 Endl.$10 DH-MIOURGO\S DE\ KAI\ XRO/NOU QEO/S: KAI\ GA\R TOU= PATRO\S AU)TOU= PATH/R: PATH\R DE\ XRO/NOU KO/SMOS, TH\N KI/NHSIN AU)TOU= GE/NESIN A)POFH/NAS E)KEI/NOU. @&10Sextus adv. math. X 170.$10 KAI\ DH\ TINE/S FASI XRO/NON EI)=NAI DIA/-STHMA TH=S TOU= KO/SMOU KINH/SEWS. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. I 22, 7.$10 *OI( PLEI/OUS <20TW=N *STWI+KW=N>20 [1XRO/NOU OU)SI/AN]1 AU)TH\N TH\N KI/NHSIN. @&10Plutarchus quaest. Plat. 8, 4 p. 1007a.$10 R(HTE/ON OU)=N TOU\S U(PO\ TOU/TWN TARATTOME/NOUS DI' A)/GNOIAN OI)/ESQAI TO\N XRO/NON "1ME/TRON EI)=NAI KINH/SEWS KAI\ A)RIQMO\N KATA\ TO\ PRO/TERON KAI\ U(/STERON"2 W(S *)ARISTOTE/LHS EI)=PEN, H)\ "1TO\ E)N KINH/SEI POSO/N"2 W(S *SPEU/SIPPOS, H)\ "1DIA/STHMA KINH/SEWS"2 A)/LLO D' OU)DE/N, W(S E)/NIOI TW=N *STWI+KW=N A)PO\ SUMBEBHKO/TOS O(RIZO/MENOI, TH\N D' OU)SI/AN AU)TOU= KAI\ TH\N DU/NAMIN OU) SUNORW=NTES. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. phys. p. 700, 16 Diels.$10 A)/DHLON OU)=N KAI\ TO\ TI/ E)STIN [1&10scil.$10 O( XRO/NOS]1, EI)/PER OI( ME\N TH\N TOU= O(/LOU KI/NHSIN KAI\ PERI-FORA\N TO\N XRO/NON EI)=NAI/ FASIN, __OI( DE\ TH\N SFAI=RAN AU)TH\N TOU= OU)RA-NOU=, W(S TOU\S *PUQAGOREI/OUS I(STOROU=SI LE/GEIN OI( PARAKOU/SANTES I)/SWS TOU= *)ARXU/TOU LE/GONTOS KAQO/LOU TO\N XRO/NON DIA/STHMA TH=S TOU= PANTO\S FU/SEWS, H)\ W(/S <20TINES TW=N *STWI+KW=N>20 E)/LEGON: OI( DE\ TH\N KI/NHSIN A(PLW=S. @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 41 p. 1081f.$ *)EN DE\ <20TW=| TRI/TW|>20 KAI\ <20TETA/RTW|>20 KAI\ <20PE/MPTW| PERI\ TW=N *MERW=N>20 TI/QHSI "1TOU= E)NESTHKO/-TOS XRO/NOU TO\ ME\N ME/LLON EI)=NAI, TO\ DE\ PARELHLUQO/S."2 @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 41 p. 1081f.$ *XRU/SIPPOS DE\ BOULO/MENOS FILOTEXNEI=N PERI\ TH\N DIAI/RESIN, <20E)N ME\N TW=| PERI\ TOU= *KENOU=>20 KAI\ A)/LLOIS TISI\ "1TO\ ME\N PARW|XHME/NON TOU= XRO/NOU KAI\ TO\ ME/LLON OU)X U(PA/RXEIN A)LL' U(FESTHKE/NAI FHSI/, MO/NON DE\ U(PA/RXEIN TO\ E)NESTHKO/S."2 @&10Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 41 p. 1081c.$10 PARA\ TH\N E)/NNOIA/N E)STI XRO/NON EI)=NAI ME/LLONTA KAI\ PARW|XHME/NON, E)NESTW=TA DE\ MH\ EI)=NAI XRO/NON, A)LLA\ TO\ ME\N A)/RTI KAI\ TO\ PRW/|HN U(FESTA/NAI, TO\ DE\ NU=N O(/LWS MHDE\N EI)=NAI. KAI\ MH\N TOU=TO SUMBAI/NEI TOI=S *STWI+KOI=S E)LA/XISTON XRO/NON MH\ A)POLEI/POUSI MHDE\ TO\ NU=N A)MERE\S EI)=NAI BOULOME/NOIS, A)LL' O(/,TI A)/N TIS W(S E)NESTW\S OI)/H-TAI LABW\N DIANOEI=SQAI, TOU/TOU TO\ ME\N ME/LLON, TO\ DE\ PARW|XHME/NON EI)=NAI FA/SKOUSIN. @&10Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 140 [1postquam de inani incorporeo locutus @1 &10est$10]1 EI)=NAI DE\ KAI\ TAU=TA A)SW/MATA O(/MOIA, E)/TI DE\ KAI\ TO\N XRO/NON A)SW/MATON, DIA/STHMA O)/NTA TH=S TOU= KO/SMOU KINH/SEWS. TOU/TOU DE\ TO\N ME\N PARW|XHKO/TA KAI\ TO\N ME/LLONTA A)PEI/ROUS, TO\N DE\ E)NESTW=TA PEPERASME/NON. @&10Proclus in Platonis Timaeum p. 271d.$10 E)/TI DE\ KA)KEI=NO LHPTE/ON A)PO\ TW=N PROEIRHME/NWN, O(/TI POLLOU= DEI= TOIOU=TON U(PONOH=SAI TO\N XRO/NON O( *PLA/TWN OI(=ON <20OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 U(PE/LABON H)\ TW=N E)K TOU= *PERIPA/TOU POL-LOI/, OI( ME\N KAT' E)PI/NOIAN YILH\N AU)TO\N SUNISTA/NTES A)MENHNO\N KAI\ E)/GGISTA TOU= MH\ O)/NTOS: E(\N GA\R H)=N TW=N PAR' AU)TOI=S A)SWMA/TWN O( XRO/NOS, A(\ DH\ KATA-PEFRO/NHTAI PAR' AU)TOI=S W(S A)DRANH= KAI\ OU)K O)/NTA KAI\ E)N E)PINOI/AIS U(FISTA/-MENA YILAI=S: OI( DE\ SUMBEBHKO\S TH=S KINH/SEWS LE/GONTES. @1 @&10Ae%28tius Plac. II 1, 7.$10 <20*OI( STWI+KOI\>20 DIAFE/REIN TO\ PA=N KAI\ TO\ O(/LON: PA=N ME\N GA\R EI)=NAI TO\ SU\N TW=| KENW=| TW=| A)PEI/RW|, O(/LON DE\ XWRI\S TOU= KENOU= TO\N KO/SMON. @&10Achilles isagoge 5 p. 129 Petav. Uranol.$10 TO\ DE\ PA=N TOU= O(/LOU PARA\ TOI=S <20*STWI+KOI=S>20 DIAFE/REI. O(/LON ME\N GA\R LE/GOUSI TO\N KO/SMON: PA=N DE\ META\ TOU= KENOU=. @&10Sextus adv. math. IX 332.$10 KAI\ DH\ <20OI( ME\N A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S FILO/SOFOI>20 DIAFE/REIN U(POLAMBA/NOUSI TO\ O(/LON KAI\ TO\ PA=N: O(/LON ME\N GA\R EI)=NAI LE/GOUSI TO\N KO/SMON, PA=N DE\ TO\ SU\N TW=| KO/SMW| E)/CWQEN KENO/N, KAI\ DIA\ TOU=TO TO\ ME\N O(/LON PEPERASME/NON EI)=NAI, PEPE/RASTAI GA\R O( KO/SMOS, TO\ DE\ PA=N A)/PEIRON, TOIOU=TON GA\R TO\ E)KTO\S TOU= KO/SMOU KENO/N. @[&10`336.$10 OI( DE\ *STWI+KOI\ OU)/TE E(/TERON TOU= O(/LOU TO\ ME/ROS OU)/TE TO\ AU)TO/ FASIN U(PA/RXEIN: H( GA\R XEI\R OU)/TE H( AU)TH\ TW=| A)NQRW/PW| E)STI/N, OU) GA/R E)STIN A)/NQRW-POS, OU)/TE E(TE/RA PARA\ TO\N A)/NQRWPON: SU\N AU)TH=| GA\R O( A)/NQRWPOS NOEI=TAI A)/NQRWPOS.] @&10Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 30 p. 1073d.$10 KAQO/LOU ME\N A)/TO-PON KAI\ PARA\ TH\N E)/NNOIA/N E)STIN EI)=NAI ME/N TI, MH\ O)\N D' EI)=NAI: KAI\ [2A)/LLA D']2 EI)=NAI ME/N, OU)K O)/NTA DE\ EI)=NAI LEGO/NTWN, A)TOPW/TATO/N E)STI TO\ E)PI\ TOU= PANTO\S LEGO/MENON. KENO\N GA\R A)/PEIRON E)/CWQEN TW=| KO/SMW| PERIQE/NTES <20OU)/TE SW=MA TO\ PA=N OU)/T' A)SW/MATON EI)=NAI LE/GOUSIN>20. E(/PETAI DE\ TOU/TW| TO\ MH\ O)\N EI)=NAI TO\ PA=N: O)/NTA GA\R MO/NA TA\ SW/MATA KALOU=SIN, E)PEIDH\ O)/NTOS TO\ POIEI=N TI KAI\ PA/SXEIN, TO\ DE\ PA=N OU)K O)/N E)STIN: W(/STE OU)/TE TI POIH/SEI OU)/TE TI PEI/SETAI TO\ PA=N. &10p. 1074a.$10 W(/ST' A)NA/GKH LE/GEIN AU)TOI=S O(/PER LE/GOUSI <20MH/TE ME/NON EI)=-NAI TO\ PA=N MH/TE KINOU/MENON>20 &10ibid. 6.$10 <20TO\ PA=N O(MOLOGOU=NTES MH/T' E)/MYUXON EI)=NAI MH/T' A)/YUXON>20 &10ibid.$10 OU(=TOI DE\ TE/LEION OU)/ FASIN EI)=NAI TO\ PA=N: W(RISME/NON GA/R TI TO\ TE/LEION, TO\ DE\ PA=N U(P' A)PEIRI/AS A)O/RISTON: OU)KOU=N E)/STI TI KAT' AU)TOU/S, O(\ MH/T' A)TELE\S MH/TE TE/LEIO/N E)STIN. A)LLA\ MH\N <20OU)/TE ME/-ROS E)STI\ TO\ PA=N>20: OU)DE\N GA\R AU)TOU= MEI=ZON: <20OU)/Q' O(/LON, W(S AU)TOI\ LE/-GOUSI>20. TETAGME/NOU GA\R TO\ O(/LON KATHGOREI=SQAI, TO\ DE\ PA=N DI' A)PEIRI/AN KAI\ @1 A)O/RISTON EI)=NAI KAI\ A)/TAKTON. AI)/TION TOI/NUN OU)/TE TOU= PANTO\S E(/TERO/N E)STI, TW=| MHDE\N EI)=NAI PARA\ TO\ PA=N E(/TERON, OU)/T' A)/LLOU TO\ PA=N A)LL' OU)D' E(AUTOU=. POI-EI=N GA\R OU) PE/FUKE, TW=| DE\ POIEI=N TO\ AI)/TION NOEI=TAI. @&10Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 137.$10 LE/GOUSI DE\ KO/SMON TRIXW=S: AU)TO/N TE TO\N QEO\N TO\N E)K TH=S A(PA/SHS OU)SI/AS I)DI/WS POIO/N, O(\S DH\ A)/FQARTO/S E)STI KAI\ A)GE/NHTOS, DHMIOURGO\S W)\N TH=S DIAKOSMH/SEWS, KATA\ XRO/NWN POIA\S PERIO/DOUS A)NALI/SKWN EI)S E(AUTO\N TH\N A(/PASAN OU)SI/AN KAI\ PA/LIN E)C AU(TOU= GENNW=N. &10`138.$10 KAI\ AU)TH\N DE\ TH\N DIAKO/SMHSIN [TW=N A)STE/RWN] KO/SMON EI)=NAI LE/GOUSI: KAI\ TRI/TON TO\ SUNESTHKO\S E)C A)MFOI=N. @&Stobaeus Eclogae I. p. 184, 8 W.$ <20*XRUSI/PPOU>20. *KO/SMON D' EI)=NAI/ FHSIN O( *XRU/SIPPOS SU/STHMA E)C OU)RANOU= KAI\ GH=S KAI\ TW=N E)N TOU/TOIS FU/SEWN: H)\ TO\ E)K QEW=N KAI\ A)NQRW/PWN SU/STHMA KAI\ E)K TW=N E(/NEKA TOU/TWN GEGONO/TWN. *LE/GETAI D' E(TE/RWS KO/SMOS O( QEO/S, KAQ' O(\N H( DIAKO/SMHSIS GI/NETAI KAI\ TELEIOU=TAI. *TOU= DE\ KATA\ TH\N DIAKO/SMHSIN LEGOME/NOU KO/SMOU TO\ ME\N EI)=NAI PERIFERO/MENON PERI\ TO\ ME/SON, TO\ D' U(POME/NON: PERIFERO/MENON ME\N TO\N AI)QE/RA, U(POME/NON DE\ TH\N GH=N KAI\ TA\ E)P' AU)TH=S U(GRA\ KAI\ TO\N A)E/RA. *TO\ GA\R TH=S PA/SHS OU)SI/AS PUKNO/-TATON U(PE/REISMA PA/NTWN EI)=NAI KATA\ FU/SIN, O(/NPER TRO/PON E)N ZW/W| TA\ O)STE/A, TOU=TO DE\ KALEI=SQAI GH=N. *PERI\ DE\ TAU/THN TO\ U(/DWR PERIKEXU/-SQAI SFAIRIKW=S, O(MALWTE/RAN TH\N I)SXU\N DIEILHXO/S. *TH=S GA\R GH=S E)CO-XA/S TINAS E)XOU/SHS A)NWMA/LOUS DIA\ TOU= U(/DATOS EI)S U(/YOS A)NHKOU/SAS, TAU/TAS DH\ NH/SOUS KALEI=SQAI: TOU/TWN DE\ TA\S E)PI\ PLEI=ON DIHKOU/SAS H)PEI/ROUS PROSHGOREU=SQAI U(P' A)GNOI/AS TOU= PERIE/XESQAI KAI\ TAU/TAS PELA/GESI MEGA/LOIS. *)APO\ DE\ TOU= U(/DATOS TO\N A)E/RA E)CH=FQAI KAQA/PER E)CATMISQE/NTA, KAI\ PERIKEXU/SQAI SFAIRIKW=S: E)K DE\ TOU/TOU TO\N AI)QE/RA A)RAIO/TATON O)/NTA KAI\ EI)LIKRINE/STATON. *TO\N ME\N OU)=N KATA\ TH\N DIAKO/-SMHSIN LEGO/MENON KO/SMON EI)S TAU/TAS DIAKEKRI/SQAI TA\S FU/SEIS: TO\ DE\ PERIFERO/MENON AU)TW=| E)GKUKLI/WS AI)QE/RA EI)=NAI, E)N W(=| TA\ A)/STRA KAQI/DRU-TAI, TA/ TE A)PLANH= KAI\ TA\ PLANW/MENA, QEI=A TH\N FU/SIN O)/NTA KAI\ E)/M-YUXA KAI\ DIOIKOU/MENA KATA\ TH\N PRO/NOIAN. *TW=N ME\N OU)=N A)PLANW=N A)STE/RWN A)KATA/LHPTON EI)=NAI TO\ PLH=QOS, TA\ DE\ PLANW/MENA E(PTA\ TO\N A)RIQMO\N EI)=NAI, PA/NTA DE\ TA\ PLANW/MENA TAPEINO/TERA TW=N A)PLANW=N. *TETA/XQAI DE\ TA\ ME\N A)PLANH= E)PI\ MIA=S E)PIFANEI/AS, W(S KAI\ O(RA=TAI. TA\ @1 DE\ PLANW/MENA E)P' A)/LLHS KAI\ A)/LLHS SFAI/RAS: PERIE/XESQAI DE\ PA/SAS TA\S TW=N PLANWME/NWN U(PO\ TH=S TW=N A)PLANW=N SFAI/RAS. *TW=N DE\ PLA-NWME/NWN U(YHLOTA/THN EI)=NAI META\ TH\N [2TW=N]2 A)PLANW=N TH\N TOU= *KRO/NOU, META\ DE\ TAU/THN TH\N TOU= *DIO/S, EI)=TA TH\N TOU= *)/AREOS, E)FECH=S DE\ TH\N TOU= *(ERMOU= KAI\ MET' AU)TH\N TH\N TH=S *)AFRODI/THS, EI)=TA TH\N TOU= H(LI/OU, E)PI\ PA=SI DE\ TH\N TH=S SELH/NHS, PLHSIA/ZOUSAN TW=| A)E/RI. *DIO\ KAI\ A)ERW-DESTE/RAN FAI/NESQAI KAI\ MA/LISTA DIATEI/NEIN TH\N A)P' AU)TH=S DU/NAMIN EI)S TA\ PERI/GEIA. *(UPO\ DE\ TH\N SELH/NHN TH\N TOU= U(P' AU)TOU= FEROME/NOU A)E/ROS, EI)=TA TH\N [2TOU=]2 U(/DATOS, TELEUTAI/AN DE\ TH\N TH=S GH=S, PERI\ TO\ ME/SON SHMEI=ON TOU= KO/SMOU KEIME/NHS, O(\ DH\ TOU= PANTO/S E)STI KA/TW, A)/NW DE\ TO\ A)P' AU)TOU= EI)S TO\ KU/KLW| PA/NTH| [1&Diels Arii Didymi Epit. phys. &frgm. 31]1. @&10Arius Didymus apud Eusebium praep. evang. XV 15 p. 817, 6.$10 *(/OLON DE\ TO\N KO/SMON SU\N TOI=S E(AUTOU= ME/RESI PROSAGOREU/OUSI QEO/N: TOU=TON DE\ E(/NA MO/NON EI)=NAI/ FASI KAI\ PEPERASME/NON KAI\ ZW=|ON KAI\ A)I/+DION KAI\ QEO/N. E)N GA\R TOU/TW| PA/NTA PERIE/XESQAI TA\ SW/MATA, KENO\N DE\ MHDE\N U(PA/RXEIN E)N AU)TW=|. TO\ GA\R E)K PA/SHS TH=S OU)SI/AS POIO\N PROSAGOREU/ESQAI [2QEO/N, OU)]2 TO\ KATA\ TH\N DIAKO/SMHSIN TH\N TOIAU/THN DIA/TACIN E)/XON. DIO\ KATA\ ME\N TH\N PRO-TE/RAN A)PO/DOSIN A)I/+DION TO\N KO/SMON EI)=NAI/ FASI, KATA\ DE\ TH\N DIAKO/SMHSIN GE-NHTO\N KAI\ METABLHTO\N KATA\ PERIO/DOUS A)PEI/ROUS GEGONUI/AS TE KAI\ E)SOME/NAS. KAI\ TO\ ME\N E)K TH=S PA/SHS OU)SI/AS POIO\N KO/SMON A)I/+DION EI)=NAI KAI\ QEO/N. LE/GE-SQAI DE\ KO/SMON [2KAI\]2 SU/STHMA E)C OU)RANOU= KAI\ A)E/ROS KAI\ GH=S KAI\ QALA/TTHS KAI\ TW=N E)N AU)TOI=S FU/SEWN: LE/GESQAI DE\ KO/SMON KAI\ TO\ OI)KHTH/RION QEW=N KAI\ A)NQRW/PWN [2KAI\ TO\ E)K QEW=N KAI\ A)NQRW/PWN]2 KAI\ TW=N E(/NEKA TOU/TWN GENOME/NWN SU/STHMA. O(\N GA\R TRO/PON PO/LIS LE/GETAI DIXW=S TO/ TE OI)KHTH/RION KAI\ TO\ E)K TW=N E)NOIKOU/NTWN SU\N TOI=S POLI/TAIS SU/STHMA, OU(/TW KAI\ O( KO/SMOS OI(ONEI\ PO/LIS E)STI\N E)K QEW=N KAI\ A)NQRW/PWN SUNESTW=SA, TW=N ME\N QEW=N TH\N H(GEMONI/AN E)XO/N-TWN, TW=N D' A)NQRW/PWN U(POTETAGME/NWN. KOINWNI/AN D' U(PA/RXEIN PRO\S A)LLH/-LOUS DIA\ TO\ LO/GOU METE/XEIN, O(/S E)STI FU/SEI NO/MOS: TA\ D' A)/LLA PA/NTA GEGO-NE/NAI TOU/TWN E(/NEKA. OI(=S A)KOLOU/QWS NOMISTE/ON PRONOEI=N TW=N A)NQRW/PWN TO\N TA\ O(/LA DIOIKOU=NTA QEO/N, EU)ERGETIKO\N O)/NTA KAI\ XRHSTO\N KAI\ FILA/NQRWPON DI/-KAIO/N TE KAI\ PA/SAS E)/XONTA TA\S A)RETA/S. DIO\ DH\ KAI\ *ZEU\S LE/GETAI O( KO/SMOS, E)PEIDH\ TOU= ZH=N AI)/TIOS H(MI=N E)STI. KAQ' O(/SON DE\ EI)ROME/NW| LO/GW| PA/NTA DIOIKEI= A)PARABA/TWS E)C A)I+DI/OU, PROSONOMA/ZESQAI EI(MARME/NHN: *)ADRA/STEIAN DE\ O(/TI OU)DE\N E)/STIN AU)TO\N A)PODIDRA/SKEIN: PRO/NOIAN D' O(/TI PRO\S TO\ XRH/SIMON OI)KONOMEI= E(/KASTA [1&10frgm. 29 Arii Did. epit. p. 464, 9 Diels]1. &10@Cleomedes Circul. doctr. I cp 1 p. 1 Bake.$10 *TOU= KO/SMOU POLLA-XW=S LEGOME/NOU O( NU=N H(MI=N LO/GOS E)NESTHKW\S PERI\ TOU= KATA\ TH\N DIAKO/SMHSI/N E)STIN: O(\N O(RI/ZONTAI OU(/TW. *KO/SMOS E)STI\ SU/STHMA E)C OU)RANOU= KAI\ GH=S KAI\ TW=N E)N TOU/TOIS FU/SEWN. *OU(=TOS DE\ PA/NTA ME\N TA\ SW/MATA E)MPERIE/XEI, OU)DE-NO\S A(PLW=S E)KTO\S AU)TOU= U(PA/RXONTOS, W(S E)N E(TE/ROIS DEI/KNUTAI. @1 @&10Ae%28tius Plac. I 5, 1 g. 32 E. XV 33.$10 <20*OI( ME\N OU)=N A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 E(/NA KO/SMON A)PEFH/NANTO, O(\N DH\ TO\ PA=N E)/FASAN EI)=NAI KAI\ TO\ SWMA-TIKO/N. @&Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 143.$ O(/TI TE EI(=S E)STI [1&scil.$ O( KO/SMOS]1 *ZH/NWN TE/ FHSIN E)N TW=| PERI\ TOU= O(/LOU KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20. @&10Philo de migrat. Abrah. %14 180 Vol. II p. 303, 18 Wendl. [1Moses$10]1. E(/NA KAI\ GENHTO\N A)POFHNA/MENOS TO\N KO/SMON EI)=NAI. GENOME/NOU GA\R KAI\ E(NO\S U(PA/RXONTOS EU)/LOGON TA/S GE STOIXEIW/DEIS OU)SI/AS U(POBEBLH=SQAI TOI=S A)POTELOU-ME/NOIS TA\S AU)TA\S A(/PASI KATA\ ME/RH, KAQA/PER E)PI\ SWMA/TWN SUMBE/BHKE TW=N H(NWME/NWN A)LLHLOUXEI=N [1&10In antecedentibus Chaldaeorum disciplina enarratur%10$10 TA\ E)PI/GEIA TOI=S METEW/ROIS KAI\ TA\ OU)RA/NIA TOI=S E)PI\ GH=S A(RMOZO/MENOI KAI\ W(/SPER DIA\ MOUSIKH=S LO/GWN TH\N E)MMELESTA/THN SUMFWNI/AN TOU= PANTO\S E)PIDEIKNU/MENOI TH=| TW=N MERW=N PRO\S A)/LLHLA KOINWNI/A| KAI\ SUMPAQEI/A|, TO/POIS ME\N DIEZEUGME/-NWN, SUGGENEI/A| DE\ OU) DIW|KISME/NWN: OU(=TOI TO\N FAINO/MENON TOU=TON KO/SMON E)N TOI=S OU)=SIN U(PETO/PHSAN EI)=NAI MO/NON, H)\ QEO\N O)/NTA AU)TO\N H)\ E)N AU(TW=| QEO\N PERIE/XONTA, TH\N TW=N O(/LWN YUXH/N, EI(MARME/NHN TE KAI\ A)NA/GKHN QEOPLASTH/SAN-TES &10etc.]1. &10@Proclus in Platonis Timaeum p. 138E,$10 [1O( *PLA/TWN A)PE/FHNE]1 O(/TI EI(=S O( KO/SMOS A)PO\ TH=S TOU= PARADEI/GMATOS MONW/SEWS. KAI\ E)/TI TOU\S U(LI-KOU\S PARH|TH/SATO TRO/POUS TH=S E)PIXEIRH/SEWS. OU)/TE GA\R A)PO\ TH=S U(/LHS O(/TI MI/A, W(S *)ARISTOTE/LHS, A)PE/DEICEN, H)\ A)PO\ TOU= W(RI/SQAI TOU\S KATA\ FU/SIN TO/POUS, OU)/TE A)PO\ TOU= H(NW=SQAI TH\N OU)SI/AN, TOUTE/STI TH\N U(/LHN SW=MA OU)=SAN, W(S OI( <20A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20. @&10Cleomedes Circul. doctr. I cp. 1 p. 1 Bake.$10 *OU) MH\N A)/PEIRO/S GE, A)LLA\ PEPERASME/NOS E)STI/N [1O( KO/SMOS]1, W(S TOU=TO DH=LON E)K TOU= U(PO\ FU/SEWS AU)TO\N DIOIKEI=SQAI. *)APEI/ROU ME\N GA\R OU)DENO\S FU/SIN EI)=NAI DUNATO/N: DEI= GA\R KATAKRATEI=N TH\N FU/SIN OU(=TINO/S E)STIN. *(/OTI DE\ FU/SIN E)/XEI TH\N DIOIKOU=SAN AU)TO/N, GNW/RIMON, PRW=TON ME\N E)K TH=S TA/CEWS TW=N E)N AU)TW=| MERW=N: E)/PEITA E)K TH=S TW=N GINOME/NWN TA/CEWS: TRI/TON E)K TH=S SUMPAQEI/AS TW=N E)N AU)TW=| MERW=N PRO\S A)/LLHLA: TE/TARTON E)K TOU= E(/KASTA PRO/S TI PEPOIH=SQAI: KAI\ LOIPO\N E)K TOU= PA/NTA MEGALWFELESTA/TAS PARE/XESQAI TA\S XREI/AS: A(/PER I)/DIA KAI\ TW=N E)PI\ ME/ROUS FU/SEW/N E)STIN: W(/STE FU/SIN E)/XWN TH\N DIOIKOU=SAN, AU)TO\S ME\N PEPE/RA-STAI A)NAGKAI/WS. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. de caelo p. 1286 Karsten. p. 284, 28 Heibg.$10 OI( DE\ <20A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 E)/CW TOU= OU)RANOU= KENO\N EI)=NAI BOULO/MENOI DIA\ TOIAU/-THS AU)TO\ KATASKEUA/ZOUSIN U(POQE/SEWS. E)/STW, FASI/N, E)N TW=| E)SXA/TW| TH=S A)PLA-NOU=S E(STW=TA/ TINA E)KTEI/NEIN PRO\S TO\ A)/NW TH\N XEI=RA: KAI\ EI) ME\N E)KTEI/NEI, LAMBA/NOUSIN O(/TI E)/STI TI E)KTO\S TOU= OU)RANOU= EI)S O(\ E)CE/TEINEN, EI) DE\ MH\ DU/NAITO @1 E)KTEI=NAI, E)/STAI TI KAI\ OU(/TWS E)KTO\S TO\ KWLU=SAN TH\N TH=S XEIRO\S E)/KTASIN. KA)\N PRO\S TW=| PE/RATI PA/LIN E)KEI/NOU STA\S E)KTEI/NH|, O(MOI/A H( E)RW/THSIS: EI)=NAI GA\R DEIXQH/SETAI KA)KEI/NOU TI E)KTO\S O)/N. @&idem p. 129a. p. 285. 28 Heibg. [1ex Alexandro Aphrod.]1.$ E)/STW GA/R, EI) DUNATO/N, E)KTO\S TOU= KO/SMOU KENO/N: TOU=TO DE\ H)/TOI PEPERASME/NON E)STI\N H)\ A)/PEIRON. __EI) DE\ A)/PEIRON EI)/H, W(/SPER <20*XRUSI/PPW|>20 DOKEI=, KENO\N DE\ TOU=TO/ FASI DIA/STHMA, O(\ OI(=O/NTE O)\N SW=MA DE/CASQAI MH\ DE/-DEKTAI, TW=N DE\ PRO/S TI A)NAGKAI=ON, EI) QA/TERON E)/STI, KAI\ QA/TERON EI)=NAI, EI) E)/STI TO\ OI(=O/N TE DE/CASQAI, EI)/H A)\N KAI\ TO\ DEXQH=NAI DUNA/MENON H)\ E)NDE/XETAI EI)=NAI: SW=MA DE\ OU)/TE AU)TOI\ LE/GOUSIN OU)/TE E)/STIN A)/PEIRON, O(\ OI(=O/N TE/ E)STI DEXQH=NAI U(PO\ TOU= A)PEI/ROU KENOU=: OU)D' A)/RA TO\ OI(=O/N TE DE/CASQAI E)/STIN AU)TO/. @&10Alexander Aphrod. Quaest. III 12 p. 101, 10 Bruns.$10 O( LO/GOS [2O(]2 DEIKNU/NAI QE/LWN A)/PEIRON TO\ O)\N DIA\ TOU= TO\N U(POTEQE/NTA EI)=NAI E)N TW=| TOU= KO/SMOU PE/RATI H)/TOI E)KTENEI=N E)PE/KEINA TOU= KO/SMOU TH\N XEI=RA H)\ DI' O(TIDH\ KWLUQH/SESQAI, A)MFOTE/RWS DE\ E)/SESQAI/ TI E)KTO\S TOU= KO/SMOU: H)\ GA\R TO\ KWLU=ON E)KTO/S E)STIN, H)\ E)N W(=| E)/STAI TO\ E)KTEINO/MENON, TH\N PIQANO/THTA E)/XEI PARA\ TH=S FANTASI/AS TE KAI\ AI)SQH/SEWS, W(/SPER KAI\ O( LE/GWN PA=N TO\ PEPERASME/NON PARA/ TI PERAI/NEIN. @&10ibid. p. 106, 10.$10 OI( DE\ TO\ KENO\N EI)=NAI TIQE/MENOI OU)DE\N A)/LLO H)\ TREI=S DIASTA/SEIS E)N U(PA/RCEI LAMBA/NOUSIN EI)=NAI XWRI\S U(/LHS, O(\ LE/GONTES EI)=NAI DEKTI-KO\N SWMA/TWN, OU)DE\N A)LL' H)\ DIA/STHMA DIASTH/MATO/S FASIN EI)=NAI DEKTIKO/N. @&10Cleomedes Circul. doctr. I cp. 1 p. 2sq.$10 *(/OTI DE\ E)/STI KENO\N DIA\ BRAXE/WN U(POMNH/SOMEN [1&10Dein plura argumenta profert, quorum maxime no-&10tandum hoc p. 4%10$10]1 *EI) DE\ KAI\ EI)S PU=R A)NALU/ETAI H( PA=SA OU)SI/A, W(S TOI=S XARIESTA/TOIS TW=N FUSIKW=N DOKEI=, A)NA/GKH PLE/ON H)\ MURIOPLASI/ONA TO/PON AU)-TH\N KATALAMBA/NEIN, W(/SPER KAI\ TA\ EI)S A)TMO\N A)NAQUMIW/MENA TW=N STEREW=N SW-MA/TWN. *(O TOI/NUN E)N TH=| E)KPURW/SEI U(PO\ TH=S OU)SI/AS E)KXEOME/NHS KATALAMBA-NO/MENOS TO/POS, NU=N KENO/S E)STIN, OU)DENO/S GE SW/MATOS AU)TO\N PEPLHRWKO/TOS. @&10Cleomedes. Circul. doctr. I cp. 1 p. 9sq. Bake probare studet:$10 O(/TI TO\ E)KTO\S TOU= KO/SMOU KENO\N A)PO\ PANTO\S ME/ROUS AU)TOU= EI)S A)/PEIRON DIH/-KEIN A)NAGKAI=O/N E)STIN. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 44 p. 1054b.$ *(/OTI TOU= KO/SMOU KENO\N E)KTO\S A)/PEIRO/N E)STI, TO\ D' A)/PEIRON OU)/T' A)RXH\N OU)/TE ME/SON OU)/TE TELEUTH\N E)/XEI, <20POLLA/KIS>20 [1&<21in libris physicis>21$]1 <20U(P' AU)TOU=>20 LE/-GETAI. *KAI\ TOU/TW| MA/LISTA TH\N LEGOME/NHN U(P' *)EPIKOU/ROU TH=S A)TO/MOU KA/TW FORA\N E)C AU(TH=S <20A)NAIROU=SIN>20, OU)K OU)/SHS E)N A)PEI/RW| DIAFORA=S, KAQ' H(\N TO\ ME\N A)/NW, TO\ DE\ KA/TW NOEI=TAI GINO/MENON. @&10Cleomedes Circul. doctr. I cp. 1 p. 7 Bake.$10 *LE/GETAI KA)KEI=NO U(P' AU)TW=N [1&10scil. a Peripateticis$10]1 W(S EI) H)=N E)/CW TOU= KO/SMOU KENO/N, XEOME/NH DI' AU)TOU= H( OU)SI/A, E)P' A)/PEIRON DIESKEDA/SQH A)\N KAI\ DIESKORPI/SQH. *)ALLA/, FH/- @1SOMEN, W(S MHDE\ TOU=TO DU/NATAI PAQEI=N: E(/CIN GA\R E)/XEI TH\N SUNE/XOUSAN AU)TH\N KAI\ SUNTHROU=SAN. *KAI\ TO\ ME\N PERIE/XON AU)TH\N KENO\N OU)DE\N POIEI=. AU)TH\ D' U(PERBALLOU/SH| DUNA/MEI XRWME/NH SUNTHREI= E(AUTH/N, SUSTELLOME/NH TE KAI\ PA/LIN XEOME/NH E)N AU)TW=| KATA\ TA\S FUSIKA\S AU(TH=S METABOLA/S, A)/LLOTE ME\N EI)S PU=R XEOME/NH, A)/LLOTE DE\ KAI\ E)PI\ KOSMOGONI/AN O(RMW=SA. @&10Cleomedes Circul. doctr. I cp. 1 p. 5 Bake.$10 *)ANAGKAI=ON TOI/NUN EI)=NAI/ TINA U(PO/STASIN KENOU=. *)/ESTI DE\ A(PLOUSTA/TH H( AU)TOU= E)PI/NOIA, A)SW-MA/TOU TE KAI\ A)NAFOU=S O)/NTOS, KAI\ OU)/TE SXH=MA E)/XONTOS OU)/TE SXHMATIZOME/NOU, KAI\ OU)/TE TI PA/SXONTOS OU)/TE POIOU=NTOS, A(PLW=S DE\ SW=MA DE/XESQAI OI(/OU TE O)/NTOS. @&10Galenus de animi peccatis dignoscendis 7. Vol. V p. 101K.$10 O( DE\ *STWI+KO\S OU)K E)/NDON TI KENO\N EI)=NAI, E)/CWQEN TOU= KO/SMOU U(PA/RXEIN AU)TO/. __OU) GA\R E(/NA O(MOLOGEI= KO/SMON EI)=NAI TO/NDE [1&10scil. Epicureus$10]1, KAQA/PER O( *STWI+KO\S OI)/ETAI, KATA/ GE TOU=TO TOI=S *PERIPATHTIKOI=S O(MO/DOCOS. @&Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 140.$ E)/CWQEN DE\ AU)TOU= [1&scil.$ TOU= KO/SMOU]1 PERIKEXUME/NON EI)=NAI TO\ KENO\N A)/PEIRON, O(/PER A)SW/MATON EI)=NAI. A)SW/MA-TON DE\ TO\ OI(=O/NTE KATE/XESQAI U(PO\ SWMA/TWN OU) KATEXO/MENON. E)N DE\ TW=| KO/SMW| MHDE\N EI)=NAI KENO/N, A)LL' H(NW=SQAI AU)TO/N: TOU=TO GA\R A)NAGKA/ZEIN TH\N TW=N OU)RANI/WN PRO\S TA\ E)PI/GEIA SU/MPNOIAN KAI\ SUNTONI/AN. FHSI\ DE\ PERI\ TOU= KENOU= <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 ME\N E)N TW=| <20PERI\ TOU= *KENOU=>20 KAI\ <20E)N TH=| PRW/TH|>20 TW=N <20*FUSIKW=N *TEXNW=N>20 &etc. @&10Galenus$10 PERI\ T. T. YUXH=S H)QW=N&10 ed. Bas. I p. 346K. 785.$10 DUOI=N OU)SW=N AI(RE/SEWN E)N FILOSOFI/A| KATA\ TH\N PRW/THN TOMH/N, E)/NIOI ME\N GA\R [1&10scil. &10Stoici$10]1 H(NW=SQAI TH\N KATA\ TO\N KO/SMON OU)SI/AN A(/PASAN, E)/NIOI DE\ DIH|RH=SQAI/ FASI KENOU= PARAPLOKH=| &10etc. &10@Galenus comm. 4 in Hippocr. epid. 6 ed. Bas. V 497K. XVII B. 162.$10 TO\ DE\ KENA\S EI)=NAI/ TINAS XW/RAS H)\ KATA\ TO\ U(/DWR H)\ KATA\ TO\N A)E/RA, TH=| ME\N *)EPI-KOU/ROU TE KAI\ *)ASKLHPIA/DOU DO/CH| PERI\ TW=N STOIXEI/WN A)KO/LOUQO/N E)STIN: TH=| D' *)ARISTOTE/LOUS TE KAI\ [2TW=N]2 <20*STWI+KW=N>20 E)NANTI/ON, OU)DAMO/QI KENO\N OU)DE\N E)N TW=| KO/SMW| PEPEISME/NWN U(PA/RXEIN, A)LL' E)KPEPLHRW=SQAI PA/NTA SW/MASIN. OU)DE\ GA\R KATA\ TH\N KI/SSHRIN AI( METACU\ TW=N GEWDW=N SWMA/TWN XW=RAI PANTA/PASIN AU)TOI=S EI)=NAI DOKOU=SI KENAI/: PERIE/XESQAI GOU=N E)N AU)TAI=S TO\N A)E/RA FASI/. KATA\ ME/NTOI TO\ U(/DWR OU)K EI)=NAI/ TINA POROPOII/+AN TOIAU/THN O(POI/A KATA\ TH\N KI/SSHRI/N E)STIN, A)LLA\ SUNEXE\S E(AUTW=| PANTELW=S U(PA/RXEIN AU)TO/. @&10Cleomedes Circul doctr. I cp. 1 p. 5 Bake.$10 *TOIOU=TON DE\ U(PA/R-XON TO\ KENO/N, E)N ME\N TW=| KO/SMW| OU)DE\ O(/LWS E)/STI. *DH=LON DE\ E)K TW=N FAINO-ME/NWN. *EI) GA\R MH\ DI' O(/LOU SUMFUH\S U(PH=RXEN H( TW=N O(/LWN OU)SI/A, OU)/T' A)\N U(PO\ FU/SEWS OI(=O/NT' H)=N SUNE/XESQAI KAI\ DIOIKEI=SQAI TO\N KO/SMON, OU)/TE TW=N ME-RW=N AU)TOU= SUMPA/QEIA/ TIS A)\N H)=N PRO\S A)/LLHLA: OU)/TE MH\ U(F' E(NO\S TO/NOU SUNEXOME/NOU AU)TOU= KAI\ TOU= PNEU/MATOS MH\ DI' O(/LOU O)/NTOS SUMFUOU=S, OI(=O/NT' A)\N H)=N H(MI=N O(RA=N H)\ A)KOU/EIN. *METACU\ GA\R O)/NTWN KENWMA/TWN E)NEPODI/ZONTO A)\N U(P' AU)TW=N AI( AI)SQH/SEIS. @1 @&10Ae%28tius Plac. II 2, 1.$10 <20*OI( ME\N *STWI+KOI\>20 SFAIROEIDH= TO\N KO/SMON. @&10Philo quaest. et solut. in Exodum II 90 [1p. 528 Aucher]1. Vides &10quod terra et aqua, quippe quae in medio sunt totius ae%28ris ignisque, caelo &10circumlato, firmatae sunt non aliunde unquam, sed sese invicem tenendo &10mutuis vinculis secundum ligantem eos divinum sermonem sapientissimo &10artificio perfectissimaque harmonia? &10@Cicero de nat. deor. II 115. ita stabilis est mundus atque ita &10cohaeret ad permanendum, ut nihil ne excogitari quidem possit aptius. &10Omnes enim partes eius undique medium locum capessentes nituntur aequa-&10liter. Maxime autem corpora inter se iuncta permanent, cum quasi quo-&10dam vinculo circumdato colligantur; quod facit ea natura, quae per omnem &10mundum, omnia mente et ratione conficiens, funditur et ad medium rapit &10et convertit extrema. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 44 p. 1054e.$8 *TAU=TA D' OU)K A)\N E)FOBEI=TO& [1mundum deletum iri, partibus in medium infiniti spatii &confluentibus$8]1 MH\ FU/SEI TA\ SW/MATA FE/RESQAI PANTAXO/QEN E)PI\ TO\ ME/SON H(GOU/MENOS, OU) TH=S OU)SI/AS, A)LLA\ TH=S PERIEXOU/SHS TH\N OU)SI/AN XW/RAS: PERI\ OU(= KAI\ <20POLLA/KIS>20 EI)/RHKEN W(S "1A)DUNA/TOU KAI\ PARA\ FU/SIN O)/NTOS: OU) GA\R U(PA/RXEIN E)N TW=| KENW=| DIAFORA/N, H(\ TA\ SW/MATA DEURI\ MA=LLON H)\ DEURI\ PROSA/GETAI: TH\N DE\ TOU= KO/SMOU TOU/TOU SU/NTACIN AI)TI/AN EI)=NAI TH=S KINH/SEWS, E)PI\ TO\ KE/NTRON KAI\ TO\ ME/SON AU)TOU= NEUO/NTWN KAI\ FEROME/NWN PANTAXO/QEN."2 *)ARKEI= D' EI)S TOU=TO PARAQE/SQAI LE/CIN E)K <20TOU= DEUTE/ROU PERI\ *KINH/SEWS>20. *(UPEIPW\N GA\R O(/TI "1TE/LEON ME\N O( KO/SMOS SW=MA/ E)STIN, OU) TE/LEA DE\ TA\ TOU= KO/SMOU ME/RH, TW=| PRO\S TO\ O(/LON PWS E)/XEIN, KAI\ MH\ KAQ' AU(TA\ EI)=NAI,"2 KAI\ PERI\ TH=S KINH/SEWS AU)TOU= DIELQW\N W(S "1E)PI\ TH\N SUMMONH\N KAI\ TH\N SUNOXH\N TH\N E(AUTOU= KINEI=SQAI DIA\ TW=N MERW=N PA/NTWN PEFUKO/TOS, OU)K E)PI\ TH\N DIA/LUSIN KAI\ TH\N QRU/YIN,"2 TAU=T' EI)/RHKEN: "1<20*OU(/TW DE\ TOU= O(/LOU TEINOME/NOU EI)S TAU)TO\ KAI\ KINOUME/NOU, KAI\ TW=N MORI/WN TAU/THN TH\N KI/NHSIN E)XO/NTWN E)K TH=S TOU= SW/MATOS FU/-SEWS, PIQANO\N PA=SI TOI=S SW/MASIN EI)=NAI TH\N PRW/THN KATA\ FU/-SIN KI/NHSIN PRO\S TO\ TOU= KO/SMOU ME/SON, TW=| ME\N KO/SMW| OU(TWSI\ KINOUME/NW| PRO\S AU(TO/N, TOI=S DE\ ME/RESIN W(S A)\N ME/RESIN OU)=SIN>20."2 @&p. 1055bc.$8 *KAI/TOI TOI=S PROEIRHME/NOIS TAUTI\ SUNA/PTEIS, W(/SPER AU)-TO\S SEAUTO\N E)CELE/GCAI FILOTIMOU/MENOS: "1<20*(\ON TRO/PON DE\ KINEI=TAI E(/KASTON TW=N MORI/WN, SUMFUE\S O)\N TW=| LOIPW=|, EU)/LOGON OU(/TW KAI\ KAQ' AU(TO\ KINEI=SQAI, KAI\ EI) LO/GOU XA/RIN NOH/SAIMEN AU)TO\ @1 KAI\ U(POQOI/MEQA EI)=NAI E)N KENW=| TINI TOU= KO/SMOU TOU/TOU: W(S GA\R A)\N SUNEXO/MENON PA/NTOQEN E)KINEI=TO E)PI\ TO\ ME/SON, ME/NEI E)N TH=| KINH/SEI TAU/TH|, KA)\N LO/GOU XA/RIN E)CAI/FNHS PERI\ AU)TO\ GE/NHTAI KENO/N>20."2 @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 44 p. 1054c.$8 *)ALL' E)/N GE <20TW=| TETA/RTW| PERI\ *DUNATW=N>20 ME/SON TINA\ TO/PON KAI\ ME/SHN XW/RAN U(POQE/-MENOS, E)NTAU=QA/ FHSIN I(DRU=SQAI TO\N KO/SMON: E)/STI D' H( LE/CIS AU(/TH: "1<20*DIO\ KAI\ E)PI\ TOU= KO/SMOU EI) R(HTE/ON AU)TO\N FQARTO\N EI)=NAI, LO/GOU OI)/-OMAI DEI=SQAI. *OU) MH\N A)LLA\ KAI\ MA=LLON E)MOI\ FAI/NETAI OU(/TWS E)/XEIN. *OI(ONEI\ D' EI)S TH\N W(/SPER, A)FQARSI/AN POLU/ TI AU)TW=| SUN-ERGEI= KAI\ H( TH=S XW/RAS KATA/LHYIS, OI(=ON DIA\ TO\ E)N ME/SW| EI)=NAI: E)PEI\ EI) A)LLAXH=| NOHQEI/H W)/N, KAI\ PANTELW=S A)\N AU)TW=| SUNA/PTOI H( FQORA/."2 *KAI\ META\ MIKRO\N AU)=QIS: "1*OU(/TW GA/R PWS KAI\ H( OU)SI/A SUNTE/TEUXEN A)I+DI/WS TO\N ME/SON KATEILHFUI=A TO/PON, EU)QU\S TOI-A/DE TIS OU)=SA, W(/STE %2 KAQ' E(/TERON TRO/PON, A)LLA\ %2 KAI\ DIA\ TH\N SUNTUXI/AN MH\ E)PIDE/XESQAI AU)TH\N FQORA/N, [2KAI\]2 KATA\ TOU=T' AU)TO\ EI)=NAI A)I/+DION>20."2 &p. 1054d.$8 DH=LO/S E)STI DEDIW\S MH/, TW=N MERW=N TH=S OU)SI/AS E)PI\ TO\ ME/SON FEROME/NWN, DIA/LUSIS KAI\ FQORA\ TOU= KO/SMOU GE/NOITO. @&idem de defectu oraculorum cp. 28.$ DIO\ KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPON>20 E)/STI QAUMA/ZEIN, MA=LLON DE\ O(/LWS DIAPOREI=N O(/ TI DH\ PAQW\N TO\N KO/SMON E)N ME/SW| FHSI\N I(DRU=SQAI, KAI\ TH\N OU)SI/AN AU)TOU=, TO\N ME/SON TO/PON A)I+DI/WS KATEILHFUI=AN, OU)X H(/KISTA TOU=TON SUNEI/RGESQAI PRO\S TH\N DIAMONH\N KAI\ OI(ONEI\ A)FQARSI/AN. TAUTI\ GA\R <20E)N TW=| TETA/RTW| PERI\ *DUNATW=N>20 LE/GEI, ME/SON TE TOU= A)PEI/ROU TO/PON OU)K O)RQW=S O)NEIRW/TTWN, A)TOPW/TERO/N TE TH=S DIAMONH=S TOU= KO/SMOU TW=| A)NUPA/RKTW| ME/SW| TH\N AI)TI/AN U(POQEI\S KAI\ TAU=TA <20POLLA/KIS EI)RHKW\S E)N E(TE/ROIS "1O(/TI TAI=S EI)S TO\ AU(-TH=S ME/SON H( OU)SI/A KAI\ TAI=S A)PO\ TOU= AU(TH=S ME/SOU DIOIKEI=TAI KAI\ SUNE/XETAI KINH/SESI>20."2 @&10Alexander Aphrod. apud Simplicium in Aristot. phys. p. 671, 4.$10 [1LE/GEI DE\ O( *)ALE/CANDROS O(/TI]1 DUNATO\N TOU/TW| TW=| E)PIXEIRH/MATI KAI\ PRO\S <20TOU\S *STWI+KOU\S>20 XRH/SASQAI A)/PEIRON KENO\N LE/GONTAS E)KTO\S PERIE/XEIN TO\N KO/SMON. DIA\ TI\ GA\R A)PEI/ROU O)/NTOS TOU= KENOU= E)NTAU=QA OU(= E)STI ME/NEI O( KO/SMOS KAI\ OU) FE/RETAI; H)\ EI) FE/RETAI, TI/ MA=LLON E)NTAU=QA H)\ A)LLAXOU=; TO\ GA\R KENO\N A)DIA/-FORON KAI\ O(MOI/WS U(PEI=KON PANTAXH=|: EI) DE\ LE/GOUSIN, O(/TI <20TH=S E(/CEWS TH=S AU)TH=S AU)TO\N SUNEXOU/SHS ME/NEI>20, PRO\S ME\N TO\ MH\ SKEDA/NNUSQAI AU)TOU= TA\ MO/RIA KAI\ DIASPA=SQAI KAI\ A)/LLO A)LLAXOU= FE/RESQAI SUNERGOI/H A)/N TI I)/SWS H( E(/CIS: PRO\S DE\ TO\ O(/LON META\ TH=S SUNEXOU/SHS E(/CEWS ME/NEIN, A)LLA\ MH\ FE/RESQAI, OU)DE\N E)/TI H( E(/CIS POIH/SEI."2 @&Themistius paraphr. in Aristot. Phys. IV 8 p. 294 Sp.$ TOU=TO @1 KAI\ PRO\S TOU\S PERI\ <20*XRU/SIPPON>20 R(HTE/ON, DIA\ TI/ O( KO/SMOS OU)K EI)S A)/PEIRON OI)SQH/SETAI FERO/MENOS E)PI\ PA=N TOU= KENOU= ME/ROS O(MOI/WS, H)\ DIA\ TI/ E)NTAU=QA ME\N BOU/LONTAI STHRI/ZEIN AU)TO/N; PRO\S ME\N GA\R TO\ MH\ DIA-SPA=SQAI A)RKEI/TW H( SUNE/XOUSA E(/CIS, PRO\S DE\ TO\ O(/LON META\ TH=S SUNE-XOU/SHS E(/CEWS E)NTAU=QA ME/NEIN, TI/ A)\N POIOI=. @&10Achilles Isagoge 9 p. 131 in Petav. Uranol.$10 *DO/GMA E)STI\ TW=N <20*STWI+KW=N>20 KAI\ MAQHMATIKW=N, ME/NEIN TO\N KO/SMON. TO\ ME/NTOI DO/GMA DIA\ TOI-OU/TWN KATASKEUA/ZETAI. EI) O( KO/SMOS KENW=| E)N A)PEI/RW| U(PA/RXWN KA/TW E)FE/RETO, OU)K A)\N O)/MBROI KATELA/MBANON TH\N GH=N: KATALAMBA/NOUSI DE/: OU)K A)/RA FE/RETAI O( KO/SMOS, A)LLA\ E(/STHKE. _KAI\ PA/LIN OI( A)/NEMOI A)/LLOI ME\N A)PO\ TH=S GH=S EI)S A)E/RA, A)/LLOI DE\ E)PI\ TA\ KA/TW EI)SI\ KATABALLO/MENOI: EI) DE\ OU) %2%2%2%2 OU)K A)/RA FE/RETAI O( KO/SMOS. _FASI\ DE\ ME/NEIN TO\N KO/SMON E)N A)PEI/RW| KENW=| DIA\ TH\N E)PI\ TO\ ME/SON FORA/N: E)PEI\ PA/NTA AU)TOU= TA\ ME/RH E)PI\ TO\ ME/SON NE/NEUKE. ME/RH DE/ E)STIN AU)TOU= GH=, U(/DWR, A)H/R, PU=R, A(\ PA/NTA NEU/EI E)PI\ TO\ ME/SON: DIA\ TOU=TO OU)=N OU)DAMOU= R(E/PEI O( KO/SMOS. @&Achilles Isagoge 4 [1in Petavii Uranologio p. 126]1.$ *KALW=S A)\N E)/XOI PEI/QESQAI TW=| <20*XRUSI/PPW|>20 FH/SANTI E)K TW=N TESSA/RWN STOI-XEI/WN TH\N SU/STASIN TW=N O(/LWN GEGONE/NAI, AI)/TION DE\ TH=S MONH=S TOU/TWN TO\ I)SOBARE/S. DU/O GA\R U(POKEIME/NWN BARE/WN, GH=S KAI\ U(/DATOS, DU/O DE\ KOU/FWN, PURO\S KAI\ A)E/ROS, TH\N TOU/TWN SU/GKRASIN AI)TI/AN EI)=NAI TH=S TOU= PANTO\S TA/CEWS. W(/SPER GA\R EI) H)=N O( KO/SMOS BARU\S KA/TW A)\N E)FE/RETO, OU(/TWS, EI) KAI\ KOU=FOS, A)/NW. ME/NEI DE\ TW=| I)/SON E)/XEIN TO\ BARU\ TW=| KOU/FW|. TO\N DE\ AI)QE/RA KAI\ OU)RANO\N [1EI)/TE O( AU)TO/S, EI)/TE DIA/FOROS]1 E)/CWQEN EI)=NAI, SFAIRIKO\N SXH=MA E)/XONTA. META\ DE\ TOU=TON E)NTO\S AU)TOU= TO\N A)E/RA EI)=-NAI, KAI\ AU)TO\N SFAIRIKW=S PERIKEI/MENON E)/CWQEN TH=| GH=|. E)NDOTE/RW DE\ AU)TOU= TRI/THN EI)=NAI SFAI=RAN, TH\N TOU= U(/DATOS, PERI\ AU)TH\N TH\N GH=N ME-TACU\ TOU= A)E/ROS KAI\ TH=S GH=S. E)N DE\ TW=| MESAITA/TW| TH\N GH=N EI)=NAI, KE/NTROU TA/CIN KAI\ ME/GEQOS E)PE/XOUSAN, W(S E)N SFAI/RA|: KAI\ TA\S ME\N A)/L-LAS TREI=S SFAI/RAS H)\ TE/SSARAS PERIDINEI=SQAI: TH\N DE\ TH=S GH=S MO/NHN E(STA/NAI. @&ibidem paulo post%10$ TESSA/RWN OU)=N O)/NTWN TW=N STOIXEI/WN, SUMBE/-BHKE TO\ PU=R KAI\ TO\N A)E/RA, KOUFO/TATA O)/NTA, E)PI\ TH\N A)/NW FORA\N E)/XEIN TH\N O(RMH\N KAI\ PERIDINEI=SQAI [1&sequuntur excmpla]1 p. 127.$ O(/TI DE\ H( GH= KAI\ TO\ U(/DWR BARE/A KAI\ KATWFERH=, OU) DEI= LO/GOU, TH=S PEI/RAS DI-DASKOU/SHS. @&ibidem paulo post%10$ O(/TI DE\ KAI\ E(/STHKEN H( GH=, PARADEI/GMATI XRW=N-TAI TOU/TW|. EI)/ TIS [1FASI\N]1 EI)S FU/SKAN KE/GXRON BA/LOI H)\ KO/KKON FAKOU=, KAI\ FUSH/SEIE KAI\ E)MPLH/SEIEN AU)TH\N A)E/ROS, SUMBH/SETAI METEWRISQE/NTA TO\N KO/KKON E)N ME/SW| TH=S KU/STEWS STH=NAI. KAI\ TH\N GH=N DE/, PANTAXO/QEN U(PO\ TOU= A)E/ROS W)QOUME/NHN I)SOR)R(O/PWS, E)N TW=| ME/SW| EI)=NAI KAI\ E(STA/NAI. H)\ PA/LIN W(/SPER EI)/ TIS LABW\N SW=MA DH/SEIE PANTAXO/QEN SXOINI/OIS KAI\ @1 DOI/H TISI\N I)SOR)R(O/PWS E(/LKEIN E)P' A)KRIBEI/AS: SUMBH/SETAI GA\R PANTAXO/QEN E)PI/SHS PERIELKO/MENON STH=NAI KAI\ A)TREMH=SAI. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 36B. ed. Bas.$10 A)LL' OI( ME\N OU)DE\ EI)=NAI FU/SEI TO\ A)/NW KAI\ TO\ KA/TW NOMI/ZOUSIN, A)LLA\ KATA\ TH\N PRO\S H(MA=S SXE/SIN QEWREI=SQAI__OI( DE\ [1&10scil. Stoici$10]1 TO\ A)/NW KAI\ TO\ KA/TW OU) KATA\ SXE/SIN, A)LLA\ KATA\ TH\N TOU= PANTO\S DIA/STASIN LAMBA/NOUSI, TH/N TE A)PO\ TOU= ME/SOU PRO\S TA\ PE/RATA KAI\ TH\N A)PO\ TW=N PERA/TWN PRO\S TO\ ME/SON: FU/SEI GA\R DIA/-FORA TAU=TA. @&10Cleomedes Circul. doctr. I cp. 1 p. 11 Bake.$10 [1TO\ KENO\N%19A)SW/MA-TON O)\N OU)/TE A)/NW TI A)\N E)/XOI OU)/TE KA/TW OU)/TE E)/MPROSQEN OU)/TE O)/PISQEN, OU)/TE E)K DECIW=N OU)/TE E)C EU)WNU/MWN, OU)/TE ME/SON]1 &10p. 12.$10 *AU)TO\S DE\ O( KO/SMOS, SW=MA W)/N, E)/XEI TI KAI\ A)/NW KAI\ KA/TW KAI\ TA\S LOIPA\S SXE/SEIS A)NAGKAI/WS. *)EMPRO/S-QIA ME\N OU)=N TA\ PRO\S TH=| DU/SEI FASI\N EI)=NAI AU)TOU=, E)PEIDH\ W(S E)PI\ DU/SIN E)/XEI TH\N O(RMH/N. O)PI/SQIA DE\ TA\ PRO\S TH=| A)NATOLH=|: A)PO\ TOU/TWN GA\R E)PI\ TA\ E)/M-PROSQEN PRO/EISIN. *(/OQEN DECIA\ ME\N AU)TOU= TA\ PRO\S A)/RKTON, EU)W/NUMA DE\ TA\ PRO\S MESHMBRI/AN GENH/SETAI. *KAI\ AU(=TAI ME\N AI( SXE/SEIS AU)TOU= OU)DE\N E)/XOUSIN A)SAFE/S. *AI( DE\ LOIPAI\ SXE/SEIS POLLH\N PARE/SXON TARAXH\N TOI=S PALAIOTE/ROIS TW=N FUSIKW=N KAI\ PLEI=STA GE/GONE KATA\ TO\N TO/PON DIAPTW/MATA, OU) DUNHQE/N-TWN E)PISTH=SAI, O(/TI E)N TW=| KO/SMW|, SFAIRIKW=| TO\ SXH=MA O)/NTI, KA/TW ME\N A)PO\ PANTO\S AU)TOU= TO\ MESAI/TATON EI)=NAI A)NAGKAI=ON: A)/NW DE\ TO\ A)PO\ PANTO\S TOU= ME/SOU E)PI\ TA\ PE/RATA KAI\ TH\N E)PIFA/NEIAN AU)TH\N TH=S SFAI/RAS DIH=KON, SUM-PIPTOUSW=N TW=N DU/O SXE/SEWN E)N TAU)TW=| KAI\ TOU= AU)TOU= ME/SOU TE KAI\ KA/TW U(PA/RXONTOS. @&10Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 155.$10 A)RE/SKEI DE\ AU)TOI=S KAI\ TH\N DIAKO/SMHSIN W(=DE E)/XEIN: ME/SHN TH\N GH=N KE/NTROU LO/GON E)PE/XOUSAN, MEQ' H(\N TO\ U(/DWR SFAI-ROEIDE/S, E)/XON TO\ AU)TO\ KE/NTRON TH=| GH=|, W(/STE TH\N GH=N E)N U(/DATI EI)=NAI: META\ TO\ U(/DWR DE\ A)E/RA E)SFAIRWME/NON. @&10Servius ad Aeneid. I 381. secundum physicos qui dicant ter-&10ram inferiorem esse, quia omne quod continet supra illud est quod con-&10tinetur. &10@Philo de confusione linguarum %14 5 Vol. II p. 230, 21 Wendl. &10Commemorantur$10 OI( ZHTHTIKOI\ TW=N FILOSO/FWN, OI(\ TOU= PANTO\S KE/NTRON EI)=NAI TH\N GH=N W(MOLO/GHSAN. @&10Philo quaest. et solut. in Exodum II 81 [1p. 523 Aucher]1. Unum &10est caelum et nemini alii simile secundum figuram viresque. Namque &10quattuor elementa cognationem habent inter se tam substantia quam cir-&10cumactione; substantia, cum mutuo commutantur; circumactione vero, quo-&10niam rectum motum continent%10 de centro superius ignis et ae%28r, subque &10centro aqua et terra; caelum vero non directe, sed circuitu circumfertur, &10figuram habens undique aequalem perfectissimam. &10@ibidem II 88 [1p. 527 Aucher]1. Quamvis terra ab aqua distincta &10sit et aqua ab ae%28re ae%28rque ab igne et ignis ab istis singulis, nihilo minus @1 &10tamen omnia sunt concinnata ad unam formam determinatam. Quae enim &10ex tot et tantis perfectum fuit materia, una convenit esse, maxime quod &10et elementorum mutua inter se commutatio communionem eorum evidenter &10arguit. &10@Philo quaest. et solut. in Genesin II 85 [1p. 526 Aucher]1. Sub-&10niger est ae%28r, nullam habens luminis in se speciem, ideoque ab alio lumine &10illuminatur. &10@Scholia Hesiod. Theogon. 119.$10 LE/GEI DE\ TO\N A)E/RA TO\N TH\N GH=N PERIE/XONTA KAI\ TO\ PERI\ AU)TH/N. EI)=NAI DE\ EI)KO/S, TOU=TON E)C E)LA/SSONOS U(GROU= EI)S PLEI/ONA O)/GKON DIAXEO/MENON KAI\ A)TMIZO/MENON TETARA/XQAI, ME/XRI A)\N LA/BH| TO\N H(/LION. TO/TE GA\R TW=| H(LI/W| SUMPAREKTEI/NETAI, W(/SPER TW=| PURAKTWQE/NTI SIDH/RW| TO\ PU=R. A)/LLWS. *TA/RTARA TO\N A)E/RA A)PO\ TOU= TARA/TTESQAI, E)PEIDH/, W(/S FASIN, E(/WS W(=DE EI)=PE TA\ D# STOIXEI=A. @&10Scholia Hesiod. Theogon. v. 116.$10 OI( DE\ EI)RH=SQAI/ FASI XA/OS PARA\ TO\ XEI=SQAI, O(/ E)STI XE/ESQAI: OI( DE/ FASIN A)PO\ TOU= XADEI=N, O(/ E)STI XWREI=N: "1*(/HRH D' OU)K E)/XADE XO/LON."2 H( OU)=N EI)S TA\ STOIXEI=A DIA/KRISIS KAI\ DIAXW/RHSIS XA/OS. OI( DE\ TO\ U(/DWR LE/GOUSIN, E)K TOU= OU)RANI/OU U(/DATOS A)NADIDO/MENON, W(/SPER A)H\R SKOTEINO/S, A)/LLOI DE\ TO\N A)E/RA, H)/GOUN TO\N KEXUME/NON E)N TW=| METACU\ GH=S KAI\ OU)RANOU=. @&10Scholia Hesiod. Theogon. v. 115.$10 TRI/A PRW=TON E)GE/NONTO: *XA/OS, *GH=, *)/ERWS OU)RA/NIOS, O(\S KAI\ QEO/S: O( GA\R E)C *)AFRODI/THS NEW/TERO/S E)STI. E)K DE\ TOU= U(/DATOS E)GE/NONTO TA\ STOIXEI=A: GH= KATA\ SUNI/ZHSIN, A)H\R KATA\ A)NA/DOSIN, TO\ DE\ LEPTOMERE\S TOU= A)E/ROS GE/GONE PU=R, H( DE\ QA/LASSA KATA\ E)KMU/ZHSIN, TA\ DE\ O)/RH KATA\ E)COSTRAKISMO\N TH=S GH=S. @&10Philo quaest. et solut. in Genesin IV 5 [1p. 248 Aucher]1. Mani-&10festatur et aliquid huiusmodi a praesenti scriptura, quod homines per &10aquam lavati mundantur, aqua vero ipsa per divinum pedem. Symbolice &10autem pes ultimum et infimum corporis est; ultima vero divinorum sorti-&10tus est ae%28r, animans creaturas congregatas. Nam si ae%28r non tangat move-&10atque aquam, emoritur ista; vivifica autem magis comperitur non aliunde &10nisi ae%28re in eam intermixto. &10@Philo quaest. et solut. in Genesin I 64 [1p. 44 Aucher]1. Per &10ordinem autem universus mundus et huius partes factae sunt. Quoniam &10et mundi conditor, cum indomitam inordinatamque et patibilem essentiam &10ordinare coepit, sectione usus est et divisione. Nam gravia et deorsum &10prona ex natura, terram et aquam in medio universi posuit, ae%28ra vero et &10ignem sursum, ob levitatem sublevatos. &10@Philo de provid. II %14 62 [1p. 87 Aucher]1. Perpende, quod dicis &10a gravioribus sursum agi leviora, quoniam non omne__corpus pondere &10gaudet, ita ut quaedam omnino non gravia dici apud physicum expediat, &10velut opposita gravibus; magnam enim vim habet contrariorum compositio, &10ex quibus mundus est factus. __Sufficiet_dicere, quod ae%28r et ignis, &10naturaliter habentes motum in sursum absque gravitate, nec a terra neque &10ab aqua sursum premuntur. &10@Dio Chrysost. Or. XXXVI %14 42sq. mundi gubernationem de scri-&10bit sub imagine currus quattuor equis vecti i. e. quattuor elementis. <21Pri- @1&10mum>21 ecum dicit %14 43$10 DIAFE/REIN KA/LLEI TE KAI\ MEGE/QEI KAI\ TAXUTH=TI, A(/TE E)/CWQEN PERITRE/XONTA TO\ MH/KISTON TOU= DRO/MOU, AU)TOU= *ZHNO\S I(ERO/N: PTHNO\N DE\ EI)=NAI: TH\N DE\ XRO/AN LAMPRO/N, AU)GH=S TH=S KAQARWTA/THS: TO\N DE\ H(/LION E)N AU)TW=| KAI\ TH\N SELH/NHN SHMEI=A PROFANH= O(RA=SQAI. &10%14 44$10 KAI\ TA)/LLA A)/STRA_ CU/MPANTA E)KEI/NOU PEFUKO/TA ME/RH TA\ ME\N PERIFE/RESQAI SU\N AU)TW=|, MI/AN TAU/-THN E)/XONTA KI/NHSIN, TA\ DE\ A)/LLOUS QEI=N DRO/MOUS. &10<21Alter>21 est %14 45$10 A(PTO/ME-NOS AU)TOU= KAI\ PLHSIW/TATOS *(/HRAS E)PW/NUMOS, EU)H/NIOS KAI\ MALAKO/S, POLU\ DE\ H(/TTWN KATA/ TE R(W/MHN KAI\ TA/XOS. XROIA\N DE\ TH=| ME\N AU(TOU= FU/SEI ME/LAS, FAIDRU/NETAI DE\ A)EI\ TO\ KATALAMPO/MENON *(HLI/W|: TO\ DE\ SKIASQE\N E)N TH=| PERI-FORA=| TH\N AU(TOU= METALAMBA/NEI TH=S XRO/AS I)DE/AN. &10<21Tertius>21 est %14 46$10 *POSEI-DW=NOS I(ERO/S, TOU= DEUTE/ROU BRADU/TEROS. &10<21Quartus>21 autem$10 STEREO/S TE KAI\ A)KI/-NHTOS, OU)X O(/PWS PTERWTO/S, E)PW/NUMOS *(ESTI/AS. &10Hunc dicit %14 47$10 SUNEREI/DEIN PANTAXO/QEN AU(TW=| TOI=S ME/RESI, KAI\ TW\ DU/O TW\ PLHSI/ON O(MOI/WS PRO\S AU)TO\N E)GKLI/NEIN, A)TEXNW=S E)PIPI/PTONTE KAI\ W)QOUME/NW: TO\N DE\ E)CWTA/TW PRW=TON A)EI\ PERI\ TO\N E(STW=TA W(S NU/SSAN FE/RESQAI. @&10Plutarchus de facie lunae cp. 5 p. 922d. [1Lucius Pharnaci &10Stoico dicit, de ae%28re locutus$10]1 PRO\S PA=SAN ME\N GA/R E)STI POIO/THTA KAI\ DU/NA-MIN EU)KE/RASTOS U(PO\ MANO/THTOS, MA/LISTA DE\ FWTO\S A)\N E)PIYAU/SH| MO/NON, <20W(/S FATE>20, KAI\ QI/GH|, DI' O(/LOU TREPO/MENOS E)KFWTI/ZETAI. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. I 12, 4.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 DU/O ME\N E)K TW=N TESSA/RWN STOIXEI/WN KOU=FA, PU=R KAI\ A)E/RA: DU/O DE\ BARE/A, U(/DWR KAI\ GH=N. KOU=FON GA\R U(PA/RXEI FU/SEI O(\ NEU/EI A)PO\ TOU= I)DI/OU ME/SOU, BARU\ DE\ TO\ EI)S ME/SON. KAI\ TO\ ME\N PERI/GEION FW=S KAT' EU)QEI=AN, TO\ D' AI)QE/RION PERIFERW=S KINEI=TAI. @&10Cleomedes Circul. doctr. I cp. 11 p. 75 Bake.$10 *OU) XRH\ DE\ A)PO-REI=N E)NTAU=QA PW=S H( GH=, STIGMIAI/A OU)=SA PRO\S TO\ ME/GEQOS TOU= KO/SMOU, A)NA-PE/MPEI TROFH\N TW=| TE OU)RANW=| KAI\ TOI=S E)MPERIEXOME/NOIS E)N AU)TW=| A)/STROIS, TOSOU/-TOIS KAI\ TO\ PLH=QOS KAI\ TO\ ME/GEQOS OU)=SI. *TW=| ME\N GA\R O)/GKW| BRAXEI=A/ E)STIN H( GH=, TH=| DE\ DUNA/MEI MEGI/STH, SXEDO\N AU)TH\ TO\ PLEI=STON TH=S OU)SI/AS U(PA/RXOUSA. *EI) GOU=N E)PINOH/SAIMEN AU)TH\N H)\ EI)S KAPNO\N H)\ EI)S A)E/RA PA=SAN A)NALUOME/NHN, KATA\ POLU\ A)\N MEI/ZWN GE/NOITO TH=S TOU= KO/SMOU PERIOXH=S. *KAI\ OU) MO/NON GE EI) KAPNO\S H)\ A)H\R H)\ PU=R GE/NOITO, A)LLA\ KAI\ EI)S KONIORTO\N A)NALUQEI=SA. *PA/RESTI GOU=N O(RA=N O(/TI KAI\ TA\ EI)S KAPNO\N A)NALUO/MENA TW=N CU/LWN SXEDO\N E)P' A)/PEIRON XEI=TAI, KAI\ O( E)KQUMIW/MENOS LIBANWTO/S, KAI\ O(PO/SA E(/TERA TW=N STEREW=N SWMA/-TWN EI)S A)TMO\N A)NALU/ETAI. *KAI\ EI) TO\N OU)RANO\N DE\ SU\N TW=| A)E/RI KAI\ TOI=S A)/STROIS E)PINOH/SAIMEN SUNAGO/MENON EI)S TO\ TH=S GH=S PU/KNWMA, EI)S E)LA/TTONA O)/GKON AU)TH=S SUSTALEI/H A)/N. *(/WSTE TW=| ME\N O)/GKW| H( GH= STIGMIAI/A W(S PRO\S TO\N KO/SMON OU)=SA, A)FA/TW| DE\ TH=| DUNA/MEI KEXRHME/NH KAI\ SXEDO\N E)P' A)/PEIRON XEI=SQAI FU/SIN E)/XOUSA, OU)K E)/STIN A)DU/NATOS A)NAPE/MPEIN TROFH\N TW=| OU)RANW=| KAI\ TOI=S E)N TW=| OU)RANW=|. *OU)D' A)\N E)CANALWQEI/H TOU/TOU E(/NEKA, E)N ME/REI KAI\ AU)TH\ A)NTILAMBA/NOUSA/ TINA E)/K TE A)E/ROS KAI\ E)C OU)RANOU=. *(ODO\S GA\R A)/NW KA/TW, FHSI\N O( *(HRA/KLEITOS, DI' O(/LHS [2TH=S]2 OU)SI/AS TRE/PESQAI KAI\ METABA/LLEIN PEFUKUI/AS, EI)S PA=N [2DE\]2 TW=| DHMIOURGW=| U(PEIKOU/SHS EI)S TH\N TW=N O(/LWN DIOI/-KHSIN KAI\ DIAMONH/N. @1 @&10Scholia Hesiod. Theog. v. 397.$10 "1H)=LQE D' A)/RA PRW/TH *STU\C A)/FQI-TOS *OU)/LUMPO/NDE."2 PRW=TON GA\R E)XWRI/SQH TO\ U(/DWR TH\N GH=N E)PIKALU/PTON KAI\ PRO\S TO\N A)E/RA A)NE/DRAMEN: U(PO\ TOU/TW| GA\R KEI=TAI TO\ U(/DWR. @&10Clemens Al. Stromat. V 14 p. 701 Pott.$10 GENHTO\N DE\ KAI\ OI( <20*STWI+KOI\>20 TI/QENTAI TO\N KO/SMON. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. II 4, 1.$10 *PUQAGO/RAS KAI\ *PLA/TWN KAI\ <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 GENHTO\N U(PO\ QEOU= TO\N KO/SMON. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. Phys. p. 1121, 12 Diels.$10 GENHTO\N DE\ KAI\ FQARTO\N TO\N E(/NA KO/SMON POIOU=SIN O(/SOI A)EI\ ME/N FASIN EI)=NAI KO/SMON, OU) MH\N TO\N AU)TO\N A)EI\ A)LLA\ A)/LLOTE A)/LLON GINO/MENON KATA/ TINAS XRO/NWN PERIO/DOUS, W(S *)ANACIME/NHS TE KAI\ *(HRA/KLEITOS KAI\ *DIOGE/NHS KAI\ U(/STERON OI( <20A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20. KAI\ DH=LON O(/TI KAI\ PERI\ KINH/SEWS OU(=TOI TH\N AU)TH\N E)/XOUSI DO/CAN: O(/TE GA\R KO/SMOS H)=N, TO/TE KI/NHSIN A)NAGKAI=ON EI)=NAI. @&10Philo de provid. I %14 9 [1p. 5 Auch.]1. Porro mundi partes, ut &10essent, accepisse initium fatemur. Atqui partes, si initium ut essent ha-&10buerunt, omnino necesse est totum quoque ut esset initium habuisse. Et &10si pars corruptioni obnoxia est, corruptioni obnoxium et totum sit oportet. &10@Philo de provid. I %14 10 [1p. 6 Aucher]1. Nonne apud omnes in &10confesso est, quod pars mundi est talis homo, quo homine humanitas ex-&10stitit? nusquam enim humanitas erit, nisi prius homo aliquis. Atqui homo &10ille initium habet generationis et est pars humanitatis; neque enim datur &10humanitas sine aliquo homine, et sublato ipso homine quodam, simul tol-&10litur etiam humanitas. Si ergo homo quidam humanae generationis ini-&10tium sumpsit, omnino necesse est et humanitatem subiacere creationi. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 41 p. 1053a.$8 E)/MYUXON H(GEI=-TAI TO\N H(/LION, PU/RINON O)/NTA KAI\ GEGENHME/NON E)K TH=S A)NAQUMIA/SEWS EI)S PU=R METABALOU/SHS. *LE/GEI GA\R <20E)N TW=| PRW/TW| PERI\ *FU/SEWS "1*(H DE\ PURO\S METABOLH/ E)STI TOIAU/TH: DI' A)E/ROS EI)S U(/DWR TRE/PETAI: KA)K TOU/TOU GH=S U(FISTAME/NHS A)H\R A)NAQUMIA=TAI: LEPTUNOME/NOU DE\ TOU= A)E/ROS, O( AI)QH\R PERIXEI=TAI KU/KLW|: OI( D' A)STE/RES E)K QA-LA/SSHS META\ TOU= H(LI/OU A)NA/PTONTAI>20."2 @&Diogenes Laert. VII 135.$ E(/N TE EI)=NAI QEO\N KAI\ NOU=N KAI\ EI(MARME/NHN KAI\ *DI/A: POLLAI=S TE E(TE/RAIS O)NOMASI/AIS PROSONOMA/ZESQAI. &`136.$ KAT' A)RXA\S ME\N OU)=N KAQ' AU(TO\N O)/NTA TRE/PEIN TH\N PA=SAN OU)SI/AN @1 DI' A)E/ROS EI)S U(/DWR: KAI\ W(/SPER E)N TH=| GONH=| TO\ SPE/RMA PERIE/XETAI, OU(/TW KAI\ TOU=TON SPERMATIKO\N LO/GON O)/NTA TOU= KO/SMOU TOIO/NDE U(POLIPE/SQAI E)N TW=| U(GRW=|, EU)ERGO\N AU(TW=| POIOU=NTA TH\N U(/LHN PRO\S TH\N TW=N E(CH=S GE/NESIN, EI)=TA A)POGENNA=N PRW=TON TA\ TE/SSARA STOIXEI=A, PU=R, U(/DWR, A)E/RA, GH=N. E)/STI DE\ <20STOI-XEI=ON>20 E)C OU(= PRW/TOU GI/NETAI TA\ GINO/MENA KAI\ EI)S O(\ E)/SXATON A)NALU/E-TAI.& 137.$ TA\ DH\ TE/TTARA STOIXEI=A EI)=NAI O(MOU= TH\N A)/POION OU)SI/AN, TH\N U(/LHN. EI)=NAI DE\ TO\ ME\N PU=R TO\ QERMO/N, TO\ DE\ U(/DWR TO\ U(GRO/N, TO/N TE A)E/RA TO\ YUXRO\N KAI\ TH\N GH=N TO\ CHRO/N. OU) MH\N A)LLA\ KAI\ E)N TW=| A)E/RI EI)=NAI TO\ AU)TO\ ME/ROS. A)NWTA/TW ME\N OU)=N EI)=NAI TO\ PU=R, O(\ DH\ AI)QE/RA KALEI=SQAI, E)N W(=| PRW/THN TH\N TW=N A)PLANW=N SFAI=RAN GENNA=SQAI, EI)=TA TH\N TW=N PLANWME/NWN: MEQ' H(\N TO\N A)E/RA, EI)=TA TO\ U(/DWR, U(POSTA/QMHN DE\ PA/NTWN TH\N GH=N, ME/SHN A(PA/NTWN OU)=SAN. @&Auctores horum placitorum afferuntur%10$ <20*ZH/NWN>20 E)N TW=| PERI\ TOU= O(/LOU, <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 E)N TH=| PRW/TH| TW=N FUSIKW=N, <20*)ARXE/DHMOS>20 E)N TW=| PERI\ STOIXEI/WN. @&Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 142.$ *GI/NESQAI DE\ TO\N KO/SMON, O(/TAN E)K PURO\S H( OU)SI/A TRAPH=| DI' A)E/ROS EI)S U(GRO/THTA, EI)=TA TO\ PAXUMERE\S AU)-TOU= SUSTA\N A)POTELESQH=| GH=, TO\ DE\ LEPTOMERE\S E)CARAIWQH=|, KAI\ TOU=T' E)PI\ PLE/ON LEPTUNQE\N PU=R A)POGENNH/SH|. EI)=TA KATA\ MI=CIN E)K TOU/TWN FUTA/ TE KAI\ ZW=|A KAI\ TA\ A)/LLA GE/NH. *PERI\ DH\ OU)=N TH=S GENE/SEWS KAI\ [TH=S] FQORA=S TOU= KO/SMOU FHSI\ *ZH/NWN ME\N E)N TW=| PERI\ O(/LOU, <20*XRU/-SIPPOS>20 DE\ E)N TH=| <20PRW/TH| TW=N FUSIKW=N>20 &etc.$ @&10Ae%28tius Plac. II 6, 1.$10 <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 A)PO\ GH=S A)/RCASQAI TH\N GE/NESIN TOU= KO/SMOU KAQA/PER A)PO\ KE/NTROU: A)RXH\ DE\ SFAI/RAS TO\ KE/NTRON. @&10Achilles Isagoge 7 p. 131 in Petav. Uranol.$10 *OI( <20*STWI+KOI\>20 FA-SI\N E)K TH=S GH=S TH\N E)/CWQEN GI/NESQAI PRW=TON PERIFORA/N. E)PEI\ GA\R H( GH= KE/NTROU TA/CIN E)PE/XEI, W(/SPER A)PO\ KE/NTROU KU/KLOS GI/NETAI, OU(/TW KAI\ A)PO\ TH=S GH=S EI)KO\S E)/CW PERIFE/REIAN GEGONE/NAI. @&10Philo quaest. et solut. in Exodum I 1 [1p. 445 Aucher]1. Tem-&10pus autem mundi conditi, siquis opportuno examinis consilio utens inqui-&10rere velit veritatem, vernum tempus est; hoc enim tempore omnia uni-&10versim florescunt ac germinantur et suos terra perfectos generat fructus. &10Nihil autem imperfectum erat, ut dixi, in prima procreatione universorum. &10Nam opera data constitutum erat, ut gens ista optime conversaretur in &10mundo, sortita propriam partem meliorem pro honore pietatis, magnam &10hanc urbem, mundum inquam, et urbanitatem. @1 &10@Ae%28tius Plac. II 4, 7.$10 OI( *STWI+KOI\ FQARTO\N TO\N KO/SMON, KAT' E)KPU/-RWSIN DE/. @&10Commenta Lucani Lib. VII 1 p. 220 Us. Quam lex aeterna%10 &10potest secundum Platonem intellegi qui natum quidem tradit esse mun-&10dum, sed non interiturum. diverse <21Stoici>21 et Epicurei, qui et natum esse &10et periturum adfirmant. &10@Commenta Lucani Lib. VIII 459 p. 274 Us. quod <21Stoici>21 di-&10cunt%10 utique si non fuit, potest et non esse. initium enim habere non &10potest, quod non habet finem. &10@Laetantius instit. div. II 10. Aristoteles autem labore se ac &10molestia liberavit, dicens semper mundum fuisse%10 itaque et humanum ge-&10nus et cetera quae in eo sunt initium non habere, sed fuisse semper ac &10semper fore. Sed cum videamus singula quaeque animalia quae ante non &10fuerant incipere esse et esse desinere%10 necesse est totum genus aliquando &10esse coepisse et aliquando desiturum esse quia coeperit. Omnia enim tri-&10bus temporibus contineri necesse est, praeterito, praesenti, futuro. Prae-&10teriti est origo, praesentis substantia, futuri dissolutio. Quae omnia in &10singulis hominibus apparent%10 et incipimus enim cum nascimur, et sumus &10cum vivimus, et desinimus cum interimus. Unde etiam tres Parcas esse &10voluerunt%10 unam quae vitam hominis ordiatur, alteram quae contexat, ter-&10tiam quae rumpat ac finiat. In toto autem genere hominum quia solum &10praesens tempus apparet, ex eo tamen et praeteritum, id est origo colli-&10gitur et futurum, id est dissolutio. Nam quoniam est, apparet aliquando &10coepisse [1esse enim nulla res sine exordio potest]1 et quia coepit, apparet &10quandoque desiturum. nec enim potest id totum esse immortale, quod ex &10mortalibus constat. Nam sicut universi per singulos interimus, fieri po-&10test ut aliquo casu omnes simul, vel sterilitate terrarum, quae accidere &10particulatim solet; vel pestilentia ubique diffusa, quae singulas urbes at-&10que regiones plerumque populatur; vel incendio in orbem misso, quale &10iam fuisse sub Phae%28tonte dicitur; vel diluvio aquarum quale sub Deucalione &10traditur, cum praeter unum hominem genus omne deletum est. Quod &10[diluvium] si casu accidit, profecto potuit accidere, ut et unus ille qui &10superfuit interiret%10 si autem divinae providentiae nutu, quod negari non &10potest, ad reparandos homines reservatus est, apparet in dei potestate &10esse vel vitam vel interitum generis humani. Quodsi potest occidere in &10totum, quia per partes occidit, apparet aliquando esse ortum, et ut fragi-&10litas initium sic declarat et terminum. Quae si vera sunt, non potuit &10defendere Aristoteles, quominus habuerit et mundus ipse principium. Quod &10si Aristoteli Plato et Epicurus extorquent, et Platoni et Aristoteli, qui &10semper fore mundum putaverunt, licet sint eloquentes, ingratis tamen idem &10Epicurus eripiet, quia sequitur, ut habeat et finem. &10@Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 141.$10 A)RE/SKEI DE\ AU)TOI=S KAI\ FQARTO\N EI)=NAI @1 TO\N KO/SMON, A(/TE GENNHTO/N, TW=| LO/GW| TW=N DI' AI)SQH/SEWS NOOUME/NWN. OU(= TE TA\ ME/RH FQARTA/ E)STI, KAI\ TO\ O(/LON: TA\ DE\ ME/RH TOU= KO/SMOU FQARTA/: EI)S A)/LLHLA GA\R METABA/LLEI: FQARTO\S A)/RA O( KO/SMOS. KAI\ EI)/ TI E)PIDEKTIKO/N E)STI TH=S E)PI\ TO\ XEI=RON METABOLH=S, FQARTO/N E)STI: KAI\ O( KO/SMOS DE/: E)CAUXMOU=TAI GA\R KAI\ E)CUDATOU=TAI: [2FQARTO\S A)/RA O( KO/SMOS]2. @&10Clemens Al. Stromat. V 14 p. 711 Pott.$10 *SAFE/STATA *(HRA/KLEITOS O( *)EFE/SIOS TAU/THS E)STI\ TH=S DO/CHS: TO\N ME/N TINA KO/SMON A)I/+DION EI)=NAI DOKI-MA/SAS, TO\N DE/ TINA FQEIRO/MENON TO\N KATA\ TH\N DIAKO/SMHSIN EI)DW\S OU)X E(/TERON O)/NTA E)KEI/NOU PW=S E)/XONTOS: A)LL' O(/TI ME\N A)I/+DION TO\N E)C A(PA/SHS TH=S OU)SI/AS I)DI/WS POIO\N KO/SMON H)/|DEI, FANERO\N POIEI= LE/GWN OU(/TWS: [1&10sequitur Heracliti &10frgm. 20 Byw.$10]1 O(/TI DE\ KAI\ GENHTO\N KAI\ FQARTO\N AU)TO\N EI)=NAI E)DOGMA/TIZEN ·MHNU/EI TA\ E)PIFERO/MENA [1&10sq. Heracl. frgm. 21 Byw.$10]1 DUNA/MEI GA\R LE/GEI O(/TI PU=R U(PO\ TOU= DIOIKOU=NTOS LO/GOU KAI\ QEOU= TA\ SU/MPANTA DI' A)E/ROS TRE/PETAI EI)S U(GRO\N TO\ W(S SPE/RMA TH=S DIAKOSMH/SEWS: O(\ KALEI= QA/LASSAN: E)K DE\ TOU/TOU AU)=QIS GI/GNETAI GH= KAI\ OU)RANO\S KAI\ TA\ E)MPERIEXO/MENA. *(/OPWS DE\ PA/LIN A)NA-LAMBA/NETAI KAI\ E)KPUROU=TAI SAFW=S DIA\ TOU/TWN DHLOI= [1&10sq. Heracl. frgm. 23 &10Byw.$10]1. O(MOI/WS KAI\ PERI\ TW=N A)/LLWN STOIXEI/WN TA\ AU)TA/. *PARAPLH/SIA TOU/TW| KAI\ <20OI( E)LLOGIMW/TATOI TW=N *STWI+KW=N>20 DOGMATI/ZOUSI PERI/ TE E)KPURW/SEWS DIALAMBA/NONTES KAI\ KO/SMOU DIOIKH/SEWS KAI\ TOU= I)DI/WS POIOU= KO/SMOU TE KAI\ A)NQRW/POU KAI\ TH=S TW=N H(METE/RWN YUXW=N E)PIDIAMONH=S. @&10Philo de provid. I %14 13 [1p. 7 Aucher]1. Corruptio particularum &10alicuius partis et iterum corruptio minimae partis huius particulae, si ex &10ipsa natura atque essentia corporis oriatur, praesignat corruptionem quo-&10que futuram corporis totius. Quid enim est corruptio in aliquam corpo-&10ris partem primum obrepens, nisi differentia quaedam parti vel particulae &10inducta, qua fit ut differant ab iis corporibus, ex quibus sunt sublatae? &10Siquidem quod unius eiusdemque erat naturae, dissolutionem subiit cor-&10ruptionis, expectantibus aliis quoque corporibus parem sortiri dissolutionem &10ac corruptionem; ita ut universa corpora mors in unum finem concludat. &10@`14. Qui ergo naturali usus ratione videt condicionem animantium &10animaliumque ratione praeditorum et universim omnium rerum, quae in &10mundo sunt ac fuere, quod nempe in fluxu sint, nonne universum quoque &10mundum ad norman partium suarum habiturum esse corruptionem fatebitur? &10@Philo de provid. I %14 15 [1p. 8 Aucher]1. Terrae itaque et ae%28ris &10natura examinata atque perpensa nullam in istis invenias differentiam a &10ceteris mundi partibus, nisi quod unius eiusdemque naturae est totum in &10genere%10 et tamen utriusque terminus generatio est ac corruptio. Cum &10enim ista subiecta sunt mutationi, variationi et conversionibus, finem etiam &10habent, et permutationem naturae suae ab igne. Ita ut, consumpta longo &10opere ac deficiente tota naturali fertilitate, germinationem non ulterius &10terra prae se ferat; quae sane semper ita habere voluisset, sed non potuit, &10ab igne impedita, ne germina producat, vel corruptione aquarum caenosa &10reddita, et aliter etiam aliis variationibus permutata. Quomodo illam ita-&10que immortalem dicere praesumant, qui sapientiae vestigiis institerunt? &10@%14 18. agam__de terra atque ae%28re, non minus ipsam ae%28ris @1 &10naturalem affectionem considerans, quam animadvertens ipsum nunc varias &10passiones experiri et rursum in sanitatem redire%10 unde etiam medicorum &10iudicio per commutationes eius oriri morbos statuitur, quoniam languescere &10per hunc dixere corpora in mundo existentia naturali eius participatione. &10Qui ergo obnoxius est morbo, tempestati ac corruptioni, quidni ipsa quo-&10que vita non demum privetur? &10@%14 19. Si quis autem ae%28rem putat immortalem esse, ita ut perpe-&10tuum istum permansurum dicat, quomodo, quaeso, in corpore immortali &10mortales mori soleant? qui nempe vitali ae%28re perpetuo saturari illumque &10sugere consuevere. &10@Cicero de nat. deor. II 118. Sunt autem stellae natura flam-&10meae; quocirca terrae, maris, aquarum vaporibus aluntur iis, qui a sole &10ex agris tepefactis et ex aquis excitantur; quibus altae renovataeque stellae &10atque omnis aether refundunt eadem et rursum trahunt indidem, nihil ut &10fere intereat aut admodum paululum, quod astrorum ignis et aetheris &10flamma consumit. Ex quo eventurum nostri putant__ut ad extremum &10omnis mundus ignesceret, cum umore consumpto neque terra ali posset &10nec remearet ae%28r, cuius ortus aqua omni exhausta esse non posset; ita &10relinqui nihil praeter ignem, a quo rursum animante ac deo renovatio &10mundi fieret atque idem ornatus oreretur. &10@Alexander in Aristot. Meteorol. f. 90a ed. Ven$10 *(/OQEN TOU\S E)PI\ MIKRO\N BLE/PONTAS FHSI\ KAI\ A)PO\ TW=N MIKRW=N PERI\ TW=N O(/LWN PEIRWME/NOUS LE/GEIN TH=S TOIAU/THS KATA\ TH\N GH=N METABOLH=S, KAQ' H(\N TA\ ME\N E(LW/DH TE KAI\ U(GRA\ OI)KH/SIMA/ TE KAI\ SU/MMETRA GI/NETAI DIA\ CHRO/THTA, TA\ DE\ PRO/TERON SUM-ME/TRWS E)/XONTA A)OI/KHTA DIA\ TH\N TH=S CHRO/THTOS E)PI/TASIN, AI)TI/AN LE/GEIN EI)=NAI TH\N TOU= O(/LOU METABOLH/N TE KAI\ FQORA/N. H(GOU=NTAI GA\R SHMEI/OIS TOU/TOIS XRW/MENOI E)KPU/RWSIN GI/NESQAI TOU= O(/LOU, W(S *(HRA/KLEITOS ME\N PRO\ AU)TOU= KAI\ OI( TH=S E)KEI/NOU DO/CHS, OI( DE\ <20A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 MET' AU)TO/N. KAI\ E)K TOU/TOU LE/GOUSIN, W(S O)/NTOS GENHTOU= TE KAI\ FQARTOU= TOU= PANTO/S, W(S TOU= TH=S GH=S TA\ ME\N CHRAI/NESQAI TA\ DE\ PA/LIN E)CUGRAI/NESQAI AI)TI/AN XRH\ TH\N TOU= KO/SMOU GE/NESIN H(GEI=SQAI. A)/TOPON DE\ DIA\ BRAXEI/AS METABOLA\S KINEI=N TO\ PA=N KAI\ GE-NHTO/N TE KAI\ FQARTO\N POIEI=N. TO\ GA\R TH=S GH=S ME/GEQOS OU)DE/N E)STIN W(S PRO\S O(/LON TO\N OU)RANO\N PARABALLO/MENON: KE/NTROU GOU=N FASIN AU)TH\N LO/GON E)/XEIN W(S PRO\S TO\ PA=N. @&10Minucius Fel. Octav. cp. 34, 2. Quis enim sapientium dubitat, &10quis ignorat, omnia quae orta sunt occidere, quae facta sunt interire? &10Caelum quoque cum omnibus, quae caelo continentur, ita ut coepit, si de-&10sierit fontium dulcis aqua maria nutrire, in vim ignis abiturum, <21Stoicis>21 &10constans opinio est, quod consumpto umore mundus hic omnis ignescat. @&Stobaeus Eclogae I p. 171, 2 W.$ *ZH/NWNI KAI\ *KLEA/NQEI KAI\ <20*XRUSI/PPW|>20 A)RE/SKEI TH\N OU)SI/AN METABA/LLEIN OI(=ON EI)S SPE/RMA TO\ PU=R, KAI\ PA/LIN E)K TOU/TOU TOIAU/THN A)POTELEI=SQAI TH\N DIAKO/SMHSIN, OI(/A PRO/-TERON H)=N [1&Diels Arii Didymi Epit. phys. frgm. 36$]1. @1 @&Plura habet Eusebius Pr. Ev. XV 18, 1_3 i.e. Arius Did. [1fr. 36 &DDG p. 468, 8$]1. *(/OPWS OI( *STWI+KOI\ PERI\ TH=S TOU= PANTO\S E)KPURW/SEWS DOCA/ZOUSIN. *)ARE/SKEI DE\ TOI=S PRESBUTA/TOIS TW=N A)PO\ TH=S AI(RE/SEWS TAU/-THS E)CAIQEROU=SQAI PA/NTA KATA\ PERIO/DOUS TINA\S TA\S MEGI/STAS EI)S PU=R AI)QERW=DES A)NALUOME/NWN PA/NTWN. *KAI\ E(CH=S E)PA/GEI: @*)EK TOU/TWN DE\ DH=LON, O(/TI <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 E)PI\ TH=S OU)SI/AS OU) TAU/THN PAREI/LHFE TH\N SU/GXUSIN [1A)DU/NATON GA/R]1, A)LLA\ TH\N A)NTI\ TH=S METABO-LH=S LEGOME/NHN: OU) GA\R E)PI\ TH=S TOU= KO/SMOU KATA\ PERIO/DOUS TA\S MEGI/-STAS GINOME/NHS FQORA=S KURI/WS PARALAMBA/NOUSI TH\N FQORA\N OI( TH\N EI)S PU=R A)NA/LUSIN TW=N O(/LWN DOGMATI/ZONTES, H(\N DH\ KALOU=SIN E)KPU/RW-SIN: A)LL' A)NTI\ TH=S KATA\ FU/SIN METABOLH=S XRW=NTAI TH=| PROSHGORI/A| TH=S FQORA=S. A)RE/SKEI GA\R TOI=S *STWI+KOI=S FILOSO/FOIS TH\N O(/LHN OU)SI/AN EI)S PU=R METABA/LLEIN OI(=ON EI)S SPE/RMA, KAI\ PA/LIN E)K TOU/TOU AU)TH\N A)POTE-LEI=SQAI TH\N DIAKO/SMHSIN, OI(/A TO\ PRO/TERON H)=N. KAI\ TOU=TO TO\ DO/GMA TW=N A)PO\ TH=S AI(RE/SEWS OI( PRW=TOI KAI\ PRESBU/TATOI PROSH/KANTO, *ZH/NWN TE KAI\ *KLEA/NQHS KAI\ *XRU/SIPPOS. TO\N ME\N GA\R TOU/TOU MAQHTH\N KAI\ DIA/DOXON TH=S SXOLH=S *ZH/NWNA/ FASIN E)PISXEI=N PERI\ TH=S E)KPURW/SEWS TW=N O(/LWN. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. II 4, 13.$10 OI( FA/MENOI DE\ TH\N DIAKO/SMHSIN AI)W/NION U(PA/RXEIN PERIODEUTIKOU\S EI)=NAI/ FASI XRO/NOUS, KAQ' OU(\S KATA\ TAU)TA\ KAI\ W(S-AU/TWS GI/GNESQAI PA/NTA KAI\ TH\N AU)TH\N DIASW/|ZESQAI TOU= KO/SMOU DIA/TACI/N TE KAI\ DIAKO/SMHSIN. @[2<20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20]2 MH/TE AU)/CESQAI MH/TE MEIOU=SQAI TO\N KO/SMON, TOI=S DE\ ME/-RESIN O(TE\ ME\N PAREKTEI/NESQAI PRO\S PLE/ONA TO/PON, O(TE\ DE\ SUSTE/LLESQAI. @&10Hippolytus Philos. 21 [1DDG p. 571, 20]1 Stoici, Chrysippus et &10Zeno%10$10 PROSDE/XONTAI DE\ E)KPU/RWSIN E)/SESQAI KAI\ <20KA/QARSIN TOU= KO/SMOU TOU/TOU>20 OI( ME\N PANTO/S, OI( DE\ ME/ROUS: KAI\ KATA\ ME/ROS DE\ AU)TO\N KAQAI/RESQAI LE/GOUSIN: KAI\ SXEDO\N TH\N FQORA\N KAI\ TH\N E(TE/ROU E)C AU)TH=S GE/NESIN <20KA/QARSIN O)NOMA/ZOUSIN>20. @&10Arius Didymus epit. phys. fr. 37 Diels [1DG. p. 469, 12. Euseb. &10praep. evang. XV 19, 1$10]1 E)PI\ TOSOU=TON DE\ PROELQW\N O( KOINO\S LO/GOS KAI\ [2H(]2 KOINH\ FU/SIS MEI/ZWN KAI\ PLEI/WN GENOME/NH, TE/LOS A)NACHRA/NASA PA/NTA KAI\ EI)S ׄE(AUTH\N A)NALABOU=SA E)N TH=| PA/SH| OU)SI/A| GI/NETAI, E)PANELQOU=SA EI)S TO\N PRW=TON R(HQE/NTA LO/GON KAI\ EI)S TH\N A)NA/STASIN E)KEI/NHN TH\N POIOU=SAN E)NIAUTO\N TO\N ME/GISTON, KAQ' O(\N A)P' AU)TH=S MO/NHS EI)S AU)TH\N PA/LIN GI/NETAI H( A)POKATA/STASIS. E)PANELQOU=SA DE\ DIA\ TA/CIN, A)F' OI(/AS DIAKOSMEI=N W(SAU/TWS H)/RCATO, KATA\ LO/GON PA/LIN TH\N AU)TH\N DIECAGWGH\N POIEI=TAI, TW=N TOIOU/TWN PERIO/DWN E)C A)I+DI/OU GI-NOME/NWN A)KATAPAU/STWS. OU)/TE GA\R TH=S OU)SI/AS A)RXH\N KA)NA/PAUSIN OI(=O/N TE GI/NESQAI OU)/TE TOU= DIOIKOU=NTOS AU)TH/N. OU)SI/AN TE GA\R TOI=S GINOME/NOIS U(FE- @1STA/NAI DEI=, PEFUKUI=AN A)NADE/XESQAI TA\S METABOLA\S PA/SAS, KAI\ TO\ DHMIOURGH=SAN E)C AU)TH=S, OI(/A [GA\R] E)F' H(MW=N TI/S E)STI FU/SIS DHMIOURGOU=SA TOIOU/TOU TINO\S KAT' A)NA/GKHN O)/NTOS KAI\ E)N TW=| KO/SMW| A)GENH/TOU. GENE/SEWS GA\R A)RXH\N OU)X OI(=O/N TE EI)=NAI E)PI\ TH=S FU/SEWS TAU/THS. O(\N TRO/PON D' A)GE/NHTO/S E)STI, KAI\ A)NAI-REQH=NAI A)DU/NATO/N E)STIN AU)TH\N OU)/TE AU)TH=S E)C AU(TH=S OU)/TE E)/CWQE/N TINOS A)N-AIRH/SONTOS AU)TH/N. @&10Origenes contra Celsum VIII 72 Vol. II p. 288, 21 Ko+. [1p. 795 &10Del.$10]1. <20OI( ME\N OU)=N A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 E)PIKRATH/SANTOS W(S OI(=O/N TE TOU= I)SXU-ROTE/ROU TW=N A)/LLWN STOIXEI/OU TH\N E)KPU/RWSIN E)/SESQAI PA/NTWN EI)S PU=R META-BALLO/NTWN. @&10Dio Chrysost. Or. XL %14 37 [1Vol. I p. 56, 5 Arn.$10]1. H( ME\N GA\R LEGOME/NH PARA\ TOI=S SOFOI=S <20E)PIKRA/THSIS AI)QE/ROS>20, E)N W(=| TO\ BASILEU=ON KAI\ TO\ KURIW/TATON TH=S YUXIKH=S DUNA/MEWS, O(\N OU)K A)POTRE/PONTAI PU=R O)NOMA/ZEIN POLLA/KIS, O(/RW| TE KAI\ PRA/|WS GIGNOME/NH E)/N TISI XRO/NOIS TETAGME/NOIS, META\ PA/SHS FILI/AS KAI\ O(MONOI/AS E)/OIKE SUMBAI/NEIN. H( DE\ TW=N A)/LLWN PLEONECI/A KAI\ DIAFORA\ PARANO/MWS GIGNOME/NH TO\N E)/SXATON E)/XEI KI/NDUNON O)LE/QROU, PERI\ TW=N O(/LWN OU)/POTE E)SO/MENON DIA\ TO\ PA=SAN EI)RH/NHN KAI\ DIKAIOSU/NHN E)N AU)TOI=S U(PA/RXEIN KAI\ PANTAXOU= PA/NTA DOULEU/EIN KAI\ CUNAKOLOUQEI=N EU)GNW/MONI NO/MW| PEIQO/MENA KAI\ EI)/KONTA. @&10Dio Chrysostomus Or. XXXVI %14 51 [1V. II p. 14, 13 Arn.]1. post-&10quam gubernationem mundi sub imagine currus descripsit quattuor equis &10i. e. elementis vecti, etiam$10 E)KPU/RWSIN &10quomodo fiat enarrat%10$10 E)N A)LLH/LOIS METABALLOME/NWN KAI\ DIALLATTO/NTWN TA\ EI)/DH, ME/XRIS A)\N EI)S MI/AN A(/PANTA SUN-E/LQH| FU/SIN, H(TTHQE/NTA TOU= KREI/TTONOS. __OI(=ON EI)/ TIS QAUMATOPOIO\S E)K KHROU= PLA/SAS I(/PPOUS, E)/PEITA A)FAIRW=N KAI\ PERICU/WN A)F' E(KA/STOU PROSTIQEI/H A)/LLOTE A)/LLW|, TE/LOS DE\ A(/PANTAS EI)S E(/NA TW=N TETTA/RWN A)NALW/SAS MI/AN MORFH\N E)C A(PA/SHS TH=S U(/LHS E)RGA/ZOITO. EI)=NAI/ GE MH\N TO\ TOIOU=TO MH\ KAQA/PER A)YU/-XWN PLASMA/TWN E)/CWQEN TOU= DHMIOURGOU= PRAGMATEUOME/NOU KAI\ MEQISTA/NTOS TH\N U(/LHN, AU)TW=N DE\ E)KEI/NWN GI/GNESQAI TO\ PA/QOS, W(/SPER E)N A)GW=NI MEGA/LW| TE KAI\ A)LHQINW=| PERI\ NI/KHS E)RIZO/NTWN. &10Postremo autem Iovis ecum %14 53 $10A(/TE PA/NTWN A)LKIMW/TATON KAI\ FU/SEI DIA/PURON, TAXU\ A)NALW/SANTA TOU\S A)/LLOUS, <20KAQA/PER OI)=MAI TW=| O)/NTI KHRI/NOUS>20, E)N OU) POLLW=| TINI XRO/NW|, DOKOU=NTI DE\ H(MI=N A)PEI/RW|__KAI\ TH\N OU)SI/AN PA/NTWN PA=SAN EI)S AU(TO\N A)NALA-BO/NTA POLU\ KREI/TTW KAI\ LAMPRO/TERON O)FQH=NAI TOU= PRO/TERON__TO/PON TE W(S PLEI=STON KATALABEI=N KAI\ MEI/ZONOS XW/RAS DEHQH=NAI TO/TE__&10%14 54$10 EI)=NAI_AU)TO\N H)/DH THNIKA/DE A(PLW=S TH\N TOU= H(NIO/XOU KAI\ DESPO/TOU YUXH/N, MA=LLON DE\ AU)TO\ TO\ FRONOU=N KAI\ TO\ H(GOU/MENON AU)TH=S. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. Phys. p. 480, 27 Diels.$10 E)/LEGE GA\R *(HRA/-KLEITOS E)K PURO\S PEPERASME/NOU PA/NTA EI)=NAI KAI\ EI)S TOU=TO PA/NTA A)NALU/ESQAI. EI)=EN D' A)\N KAI\ <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 TAU/THS TH=S DO/CHS. H( GA\R E)KPU/RWSIS TOIOU=TO/N TI AI)NI/TTETAI, KAI\ PA=N SW=MA PEPERASME/NON EI)=NAI LE/GOUSIN. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. 39 p. 1052c.$8 <20*)EN DE\ TW=| PRW/-TW| PERI\ *PRONOI/AS>20 TO\N *DI/A FHSI\N AU)/CESQAI, ME/XRIS A)\N EI)S AU(TO\N A(/PANTA KATANALW/SH|. "1<20*)EPEI\ GA\R O( QA/NATOS ME/N E)STI XWRISMO\S @1 YUXH=S A)PO\ TOU= SW/MATOS, H( DE\ TOU= KO/SMOU YUXH\ OU) XWRI/ZETAI ME/N, AU)/CETAI DE\ SUNEXW=S, ME/XRIS A)\N EI)S AU(TH\N KATANALW/SH| TH\N U(/LHN, OU) R(HTE/ON A)POQNH/SKEIN TO\N KO/SMON>20."2 @&p. 1052d.$8 SAFW=S GA\R AU)TO\S E)N TW=| AU)TW=| GE/GRAFEN: "1<20*AU)TA/RKHS D' EI)=NAI LE/GETAI MO/NOS O( KO/SMOS, DIA\ TO\ MO/NOS E)N AU(TW=| PA/NTA E)/XEIN W(=N DEI=TAI: KAI\ TRE/FETAI E)C AU(TOU= KAI\ AU)/CETAI, TW=N A)/L-LWN MORI/WN EI)S A)/LLHLA KATALLATTOME/NWN>20."2 @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. c. 41 p. 1053b.$8 *KAI\ MH\N O(/TAN E)KPU/RWSIS GE/NHTAI, DIO/LOU ZH=N KAI\ ZW=|ON EI)=NAI/ FHSI [2TO\N KO/SMON]2, SBEN-NU/MENON D' AU)=QIS KAI\ PAXUNO/MENON, EI)S U(/DWR KAI\ GH=N KAI\ TO\ SWMATOEIDE\S TRE/PESQAI. *LE/GEI D' <20E)N TW=| PRW/TW| PERI\ *PRONOI/AS: *DIO/LOU ME\N GA\R W)\N O( KO/SMOS PURW/DHS, EU)QU\S KAI\ YUXH/ E)STIN E(AUTOU= KAI\ H(GEMONIKO/N: O(/TE DE/, METABALW\N EI)S TO\ U(GRO\N KAI\ TH\N E)NAPO-LEIFQEI=SAN YUXH/N, TRO/PON TINA\ EI)S SW=MA KAI\ YUXH\N METE/BA-LEN, W(/STE SUNESTA/NAI E)K TOU/TWN, A)/LLON TINA\ E)/SXE LO/GON>20."2 [1TH=| DE\ SBE/SEI PA/LIN KAI\ TH\N YUXH\N A)NI/ESQAI KAI\ A)NUGRAI/NESQAI, METABA/LLOU-SAN EI)S TO\ SWMATOEIDE/S]1. @&10Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 17 p. 1067a.$10 O(/TAN E)KPURW/SWSI TO\N KO/SMON OU(=TOI, <20KAKO\N ME\N OU)D' O(TIOU=N A)POLEI/PETAI>20, TO\ D' O(/LON FRO/NIMO/N E)STI THNIKAU=TA KAI\ SOFO/N. @&10Porphyrius in Aristot. categ. p. 119, 34 Busse.$10 A)LLA\ MH\N KAI\ EI)/ TIS FQEI/REIEN TA\ ZW=|A, W(/SPER FASI\N <20OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 E)N TH=| E)KPURW/SEI GI/NESQAI, AI)/SQHSIS ME\N OU)K E)/STIN ZW/|OU MH\ O)/NTOS, AI)SQHTO\N ME/NTOI E)/STAI: TO\ GA\R PU=R E)/STAI. @&10Commenta Lucani Lib. VII 813 p. 252 Us. Uret cum terris%10$10 E)KPU/RWSIS &10quam secuturam$10 KATAKLUSMOU\S &10adserunt <21Stoici>21. &10@Ae%28tius Plac. II 9, 2.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 EI)=NAI KENO/N, EI)S O(\ KATA\ TH\N E)KPU/RWSIN A)NALU/ETAI O( KO/SMOS A)/PEIRON O)/N. @&10Achilles Isagoge 8 p. 131 Petav. Uranol.$10 *OI( DE\ <20*STWI+KOI\>20 E)K-PU/RWSIN LE/GONTES KO/SMOU KATA/ TINAS W(RISME/NOUS XRO/NOUS EI)=NAI, KENO\N ME/N, OU) MH\N A)/PEIRO/N FASIN: A)LLA\ TOSOU=TON O(/SON XWRH=SAI LUQE\N TO\ PA=N. @&Philo de incorr. mundi p. 254, 7 [1p. 28, 23 Cumont]1.$ META-BA/LLEIN DE\ [1&sc.$ TO\N KO/SMON]1 H)\ EI)S FLO/GA H)\ EI)S AU)GH\N A)NAGKAI=ON: EI)S ME\N FLO/GA W(S W)/|ETO *KLEA/NQHS, EI)S D' AU)GH\N <20W(S O( *XRU/SIPPOS>20. @&ibidem p. 250, 9 [1p. 26, 9 Cumont$]1. A)LL' A)MH/XANON TOU=TO/ GE: [1&sc. mundum deleri$ A)NAIRE/SEI PANTELEI= TH=S POIO/THTOS]1 ME/NEI GA\R KATA\ TOU\S TA)NANTI/A AI(ROUME/NOUS H( TH=S DIAKOSMH/SEWS POIO/THS E)P' E)LA/TTONOS OU)SI/AS TH=S TOU= *DIO\S STALEI=SA KATA\ TH\N E)KPU/RWSIN. @1 @&10Stoicus quidam apud Philonem$10 PERI\ A)FQARSI/AS KO/SMOU&10 p. 252, 5.$10 PURO\S TRITTO\N EI)=DOS: TO\ ME\N A)/NQRAC, TO\ DE\ FLO/C, TO\ DE\ AU)GH/. A)/NQRAC ME\N OU)=N E)STI PU=R E)N OU)SI/A| GEW/DEI, O(\ TRO/PON E(/CEWS PNEUMATIKH=S PEFW/LEUKE KAI\ E)LLOXA=| DI' O(/LHS A)/XRI PERA/TWN TETAME/NON. FLO\C DE/ E)STIN O(/PER E)K TROFH=S AI)/-RETAI METEWRIZO/MENON, AU)GH\ DE\ TO\ A)POSTELLO/MENON E)K FLOGO/S, SUNERGO\N O)FQAL-MOI=S EI)S TH\N TW=N O(RATW=N A)NTI/LHYIN. @&10Philo de incorrupt. mund. 235, 13 B. [1p. 15, 4 Cummont$10]1. KAI\ MH\N OI(/ GE TA\S E)KPURW/SEIS KAI\ TA\S PALIGGENESI/AS EI)SHGOU/MENOI TOU= KO/SMOU NOMI/ZOUSI KAI\ O(MOLOGOU=SI TOU\S A)STE/RAS QEOU\S EI)=NAI, OU(\S TW=| LO/GW| DIAFQEI/REIN OU)K E)RUQRIW=SIN. E)/DEI GA\R H)\ MU/DROUS DIAPU/ROUS A)POFH/NASQAI, KAQA/PER E)/NIOI ...... H)\ QEI/AS H)\ DAIMONI/AS FU/SEIS NOMI/ZONTAS TH\N A(RMO/TTOUSAN QEOI=S A)FQARSI/AN PROSOMOLOGH=SAI. NUNI\ DE\ TOSOU=TON DO/CHS A)LHQOU=S DIH/MARTON, W(/STE LELH/QASIN AU(TOU\S KAI\ TH=| PRONOI/A|_YUXH\ D' E)STI\ TOU= KO/SMOU_ FQORA\N E)PIFE/RONTES, E)C W(=N A)NAKO/LOUQA FILOSOFOU=SIN @&10Iustinus Apol. I 20.$10 *OI( LEGO/MENOI DE\ <20*STWI+KOI\>20 FILO/SOFOI KAI\ AU)TO\N TO\N QEO\N EI)S PU=R A)NALU/ESQAI DOGMATI/ZOUSI KAI\ AU)= PA/LIN KATA\ META-BOLH\N TO\N KO/SMON GENE/SQAI LE/GOUSIN. @&10ibid.$10 TW=| GA\R LE/GEIN H(MA=S U(PO\ QEOU= PA/NTA KEKOSMH=SQAI KAI\ GEGENH=SQAI, *PLA/TWNOS DO/COMEN LE/GEIN DO/GMA: TW=| DE\ E)KPU/RWSIN GENE/SQAI <20*STWI+KW=N>20. @&10idem II 7.$10 OU(/TW GA\R H(MEI=S TH\N E)KPU/RWSIN FAME\N GENH/SESQAI, A)LL' OU)X W(S OI( *STWI+KOI\ KATA\ TO\N TH=S EI)S A)/LLHLA PA/NTWN METABOLH=S LO/GON. @&10Athanasius Or. IV c. Arianos c. 13 p. 626.$10 *TOU=TO DE\ I)/SWS A)PO\ TW=N *STWI+KW=N U(PE/LABE DIABEBAIOUME/NWN SUSTE/LLESQAI KAI\ PA/LIN E)KTEI/NESQAI TO\N QEO\N META\ TH=S KTI/SEWS KAI\ A)PEI/RWS PAU/ESQAI. @&10Philo de anim. sacrif. idon. Vol. II Mang. p. 242.$10 *(H DE\ EI)S ME/LH TOU= ZW/|OU DIANOMH\ DHLOI=, H)/TOI W(S E(\N TA\ PA/NTA H)\ O(/TI E)C E(NO/S TE KAI\ EI)S E(/N: O(/PER OI( ME\N KO/RON KAI\ XRHSMOSU/NHN E)KA/LESAN, OI( D' E)KPU/RWSIN KAI\ DIAKO/SMHSIN: E)KPU/RWSIN ME\N KATA\ TH\N TOU= QEOU= DUNASTEI/AN TW=N A)/LLWN E)PI-KRATH/SANTOS, DIAKO/SMHSIN DE\ KATA\ TH\N TW=N TETTA/RWN STOIXEI/WN I)SONOMI/AN, H(\N A)NTIDIDO/ASIN A)LLH/LOIS. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. de caelo p. 132b Karsten p. 294, 4 Heibg.$10 KAI\ *(HRA/KLEITOS DE\ POTE\ ME\N E)KPUROU=SQAI LE/GEI TO\N KO/SMON, POTE\ DE\ E)K TOU= PURO\S SUNI/STASQAI PA/LIN AU)TO\N KATA/ TINAS XRO/NWN PERIO/DOUS, E)N OI(=S FHSI/: "1ME/TRA A(PTO/MENOS KAI\ ME/TRA SBENNU/MENOS."2 TAU/THS DE\ TH=S DO/CHS U(/STERON E)GE/NONTO KAI\ <20OI( *STWI+KOI/>20. @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 35 p. 1077b$]1. *)ALLA\ TOU= [TE] KO/SMOU PA/LIN TO\ [PU=R, O(\] SPE/RMA <20LE/GOUSIN>20 EI)=NAI [2MEI=ZON]2 KAI\ META\ TH\N E)KPU/RWSIN, [2O(/TE]2 EI)S SPE/RMA METE/BALE, TO\N KO/SMON, E)K BRAXUTE/- @1ROU SW/MATOS KAI\ O)/GKOU XU/SIN E)/XONTA POLLH/N, KAI\ TOU= KENOU= PROS-EPILAMBA/NONTA XW/RAN A)/PLETON E)PINEMOME/NHN TH=| AU)CH/SEI, GENNWME/NOU D' AU)=QIS U(POXWREI=N TO\ ME/GEQOS KAI\ SUNOLISQAI/NEIN, DUOME/NHS KAI\ SUNAGOME/NHS PERI\ TH\N GE/NESIN EI)S E(AUTH\N TH=S U(/LHS. @&Philo de incorrupt. mund. p. 255, 8 [1p. 29, 13 Cumont]1.$ FE/RE D' OU)=N, <20W(/S FHSIN O( *XRU/SIPPOS>20, TO\ A)NASTOIXEIW=SAN TH\N DIAKO/SMHSIN EI)S AU(TO\ PU=R TOU= ME/LLONTOS A)POTELEI=SQAI KO/SMOU SPE/RMA EI)=NAI KAI\ W(=N E)P' AU)TW=| PEFILOSO/FHKE MHDE\N E)YEU=SQAI, PRW=TON ME\N O(/TI KAI\ E)K SPE/RMATOS H( GE/NESIS KAI\ EI)S SPE/RMA H( A)NA/LUSIS, E)/PEITA D' O(/TI FUSIO-LOGEI=TAI O( KO/SMOS KAI\ FU/SIS LOGIKH/, OU) MO/NON E)/MYUXOS W)\N A)LLA\ KAI\ NOERO\S PRO\S DE\ KAI\ FRO/NIMOS, E)K TOU/TWN TOU)NANTI/ON OU(= BOU/LETAI KATASKEUA/ZETAI TO\ MHDE/POTE FQARH/SESQAI. @&10Stoicus apud Philonem de incorr. mundi p. 257, 12 B. [1p. 31, 9 &10Cumont$10]1 E)PI\ DE\ TOU= PANTO\S GENH/SETAI TOU)NANTI/ON. TO\ ME\N GA\R SPE/RMA KAI\ MEI=ZON E)/STAI KAI\ PLEI/ONA TO/PON E)FE/CEI, TO\ D' A)POTE/LESMA BRAXU/TERON KAI\ E)N E)LA/TTONI FANEI=TAI TO/PW|, KAI\ O( KO/SMOS E)K SPE/RMATOS SUNISTA/MENOS OU)K E)K TOU= KAT' O)LI/GON E)PI-DW/SEI PRO\S AU)/CHSIN, A)LL' E)/MPALIN E)C O)/GKOU MEI/ZONOS EI)S E)LA/TTONA SUNAIREQH/-SETAI. TO\ DE\ LEGO/MENON R(A/|DION SUNIDEI=N: A(/PAN SW=MA A)NALUO/MENON EI)S PU=R DIALU/ETAI/ TE KAI\ XEI=TAI, SBENNUME/NHS DE\ TH=S E)N AU)TW=| FLOGO\S STE/LLETAI KAI\ SUNA/GETAI: PI/STEWN DE\ TOI=S OU(/TWS E)MFANE/SI PRO\S MARTURI/AN W(S A)DHLOUME/NOIS OU)DEMI/A XREI/A. KAI\ MH\N O( KO/SMOS O( PURWQEI\S GENH/SETAI MEI/ZWN, A(/TE SUM-PA/SHS TH=S OU)SI/AS EI)S TO\N LEPTO/TATON A)NALUQEI/SHS AI)QE/RA: O(/ MOI DOKOU=SI KAI\ <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 PROI+DO/MENOI KENO\N A)/PEIRON E)KTO\S TOU= KO/SMOU TW=| LO/GW| KATA-LIPEI=N, I(/N' E)PEIDH\ XU/SIN A)PE/RANTO/N TINA E)/MELLE LH/YESQAI MH\ A)PORH=| TOU= DE-COME/NOU XWRI/OU TH\N A)NA/XUSIN. O(/TE ME\N OU)=N EI)S TOSOU=TON E)PIDE/DWKE KAI\ SUNHU/CHTAI W(S MONONOUXI\ TH=| A)ORI/STW| TOU= KENOU= FU/SEI TW=| TH=S E)LA/SEWS A)PEI-ROMEGE/QEI SUNDRAMEI=N, SPE/RMATOS E)/XEI KAI\ TOU=TO LO/GON, O(/TE DE\ KATA\ TH\N PA-LIGGENESI/AN E)K TELEI/WN TW=N MERW=N TH=S SUMPA/SHS OU)SI/AS .........., STELLO-ME/NOU ME\N KATA\ TH\N SBE/SIN TOU= PURO\S EI)S PAXU\N A)E/RA, STELLOME/NOU DE\ A)E/ROS EI)S U(/DWR KAI\ SUNI/ZONTOS, PAXUNOME/NOU D' E)/TI MA=LLON U(/DATOS KATA\ TH\N EI)S GH=N, TO\ PUKNO/TATON TW=N STOIXEI/WN, METABOLH/N. E)/STI DE\ TAU=TA PARA\ TA\S KOINA\S E)NNOI/AS TW=N DUNAME/NWN A)KOLOUQI/AN PRA/GMATOS E)KLOGI/ZESQAI. @&10Philo de incorrupt. mund. p. 222, 2 B. [1p. 4, 3 Cumont$10]1. *DH-MO/KRITOS ME\N OU)=N KAI\ *)EPI/KOUROS KAI\ O( POLU\S O(/MILOS <20TW=N A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S FILOSO/FWN>20 GE/NESIN KAI\ FQORA\N A)POLEI/POUSI TOU= KO/SMOU, PLH\N OU)X O(MOI/WS: OI( ME\N GA\R POLLOU\S KO/SMOUS U(POGRA/FOUSIN &10etc.$10 __<20OI( DE\ *STWI+KOI\>20 KO/SMON ME\N E(/NA, GENE/SEWS DE\ AU)TOU= QEO\N AI)/TION, FQORA=S DE\ MHKE/TI QEO/N, A)LLA\ TH\N U(PA/RXOUSAN E)N TOI=S OU)=SI PURO\S A)KAMA/TOU DU/NAMIN, XRO/NWN MAKRAI=S PERIO/DOIS A)NALU/OUSAN TA\ PA/NTA EI)S E(AUTH/N, E)C H(=S PA/LIN AU)= A)NAGE/NNHSIN KO/SMOU SUNI/STASQAI PROMHQEI/A| TOU= TEXNI/TOU. DU/NATAI DE\ KATA\ TOU/TOUS O( ME/N TIS KO/SMOS A)I/DIOS, O( DE/ TIS FQARTO\S LE/GESQAI, FQARTO\S ME\N O( KATA\ TH\N @1 DIAKO/SMHSIN, A)I/DIOS DE\ O( KATA\ TH\N E)KPU/RWSIN PALIGGENESI/AIS KAI\ PERIO/DOIS A)QANATIZO/MENOS OU)DE/POTE LHGOU/SAIS. @&10Philo de incorrupt. mund. p. 220,9 B.$10 KATA\ DE\ TRI/TON, W(S DOKEI= <20TOI=S *STWI+KOI=S>20 "1DIH/KOUSA A)/XRI TH=S E)KPURW/SEWS OU)SI/A TIS H)\ DIAKEKOSMHME/NH H)\ A)DIAKO/SMHTOS,"2 OU(= TH=S KINH/SEW/S FASIN EI)=NAI TO\N XRO/NON DIA/STHMA. @&10Dio Chrysost. Or. XXXVI %14 55 [1II p. 15, 8 Arn.$10]1. LEIFQEI\S DH\ MO/NOS O( NOU=S KAI\ TO/PON A)MH/XANON E)MPLH/SAS AU(TOU= A(/T' E)P' I)/SHS PANTAXH=| KEXUME/NOS, OU)DENO\S E)N AU)TW=| PUKNOU= LEIFQE/NTOS, A)LLA\ PA/SHS E)PIKRATOU/SHS MANO/THTOS, O(/TE KA/LLISTOS GI/GNETAI, TH\N KAQARWTA/THN LABW\N AU)GH=S A)KHRA/TOU FU/SIN, EU)QU\S E)PO/QHSE TO\N E)C A)RXH=S BI/ON. E)/RWTA DE\ LABW/N__W(/RMHSEN E)PI\ TO\ GENNA=N KAI\ DIANE/MEIN E(/KASTA KAI\ DHMIOURGEI=N TO\N O)/NTA NU=N KO/SMON E)C A)RXH=S POLU\ KREI/TTW KAI\ LAMPRO/TERON A(/TE NEW/TERON. A)STRA/YAS DE\ O(/LOS OU)K A)/TAKTON OU)DE\ R(UPARA\N A)STRAPH/N__A)LLA\ KAQARA\N KAI\ A)MIGH= PAN-TO\S SKOTEINOU=, METE/BALE R(A|DI/WS A(/MA TH=| NOH/SEI. MNHSQEI\S DE\ *)AFRODI/THS KAI\ GENE/SEWS E)PRA/U+NE KAI\ A)NH=KEN AU(TO/N, KAI\ POLU\ TOU= FWTO\S A)POSBE/SAS EI)S A)E/RA PURW/DH TRE/PETAI PURO\S H)PI/OU. MIXQEI\S DE\ TO/TE *(/HRA| KAI\ METALABW\N TOU= TELEIOTA/TOU LE/XOUS, A)NAPAUSA/MENOS A)FI/HSI TH\N PA=SAN AU)= TOU= PANTO\S GONH/N. <20TOU=TON U(MNOU=SI PAI=DES SOFW=N E)N A)R)R(H/TOIS TELETAI=S *(/HRAS KAI\ *DIO\S EU)DAI/MONA GA/MON>20. U(GRA\N DE\ POIH/SAS TH\N O(/LHN OU)SI/AN, E(\N SPE/RMA TOU= PANTO/S, AU)TO\S E)N TOU/TW| DIAQE/WN, KAQA/PER E)N GONH=| PNEU=MA TO\ PLA/TTON KAI\ DHMIOURGOU=N, TO/TE DH\ MA/LISTA PROSEOIKW\S TH=| TW=N A)/LLWN SUSTA/SEI ZW/|WN, KAQ' O(/SON E)K YUXH=S KAI\ SW/MATOS SUNESTA/NAI LE/GOIT' A)\N OU)K A)/PO TRO/-POU, TA\ LOIPA\ H)/DH R(A|DI/WS PLA/TTEI KAI\ TUPOI=, LEI/AN KAI\ MALAKH\N AU(TW=| PERIXE/AS TH\N OU)SI/AN KAI\ PA=SAN EI)/KOUSAN EU)PETW=S. E)RGASA/MENOS DE\ KAI\ TELEW/SAS A)PE/-DEICEN E)C A)RXH=S TO\N O)/NTA KO/SMON EU)EIDH= KAI\ KALO\N A)MHXA/NWS, POLU\ DH\ LAMPRO/TERON H)\ OI(=OS O(RA=TAI NU=N &10etc. @&Lactantius div. instit. VII 23. Melius <21Chrysippus>21 quem &Cicero ait fulcire porticum Stoicorum, qui in libris quos <21de provi-&dentia>21 scripsit, cum de innovatione mundi loqueretur, haec intulit%10$8 <20TOU/TOU D' OU(/TWS E)/XONTOS, DH=LON W(S OU)DE\N A)DU/NATON, KAI\ H(MA=S META\ TO\ TELEUTH=SAI PA/LIN PERIO/DWN TINW=N EI)LHMME/NWN XRO/-NOU EI)S O(\ NU=N E)SMEN KATASTH/SESQAI SXH=MA>20. @&Alexander Aphrod. comm. in Aristot. Analyt. pr. p. 180, 31 &Wallies.$ A)LHQE\S DE\ DU/NATAI/ POTE GENE/SQAI KAT' AU)TOU\S META\ TO\N QA/-NATON TO\N *DI/WNOS TO/ "1TOU/TOU KEXW/RISTAI H( YUXH\ KAI\ TO\ SW=MA"2 DEIKNU-ME/NOU *DI/WNOS: A)RE/SKEI GA\R AU)TOI=S TO\ META\ TH\N E)KPU/RWSIN PA/LIN PA/NTA TAU)TA\ E)N TW=| KO/SMW| GI/NESQAI KAT' A)RIQMO/N, W(S KAI\ TO\N I)DI/WS POIO\N PA/LIN TO\N AU)TO\N TW=| PRO/SQEN EI)=NAI/ TE KAI\ GI/NESQAI E)N E)KEI/NW| TW=| KO/SMW|, W(S <20E)N TOI=S PERI\ KO/SMOU *XRU/SIPPOS>20 LE/GEI. @&p. 181, 13.$ EI) DE\ LE/GOIEN__MHKE/TI TH\N AU)TH\N YUXH/N TE KAI\ @1 SW=MA KAT' A)RIQMO\N EI)=NAI TA\ SUNTIQE/MENA, OU)DE\N TOU=TO PRO\S TO\N LO/-GON E)STI/N. @&ibid. 25%10$ *KAI\ LE/GOUSI DE\ KAI\ TOI=S I)DI/WS POIOI=S TOI=S U(/STERON GI-NOME/NOIS PRO\S TOU\S PRO/SQEN PARALLAGA\S MO/NON GI/NESQAI KATA/ TINA TW=N E)/CWQEN SUMBEBHKO/TWN, OI(=AI PARALLAGAI\ KAI\ E)PI\ TOU= AU)TOU= ME/NON-TO/S TE KAI\ ZW=NTOS *DI/WNOS OU)K A)LLA/SSOUSIN AU)TO/N: OU) GA\R A)/LLOS GI/-NETAI, EI) PRO/TERON E)/XWN E)PI\ TH=S O)/YEWS FAKOU\S U(/STERON MHKE/T' E)/XOI: TOIAU/TAS DE/ FASI TA\S E)N TOI=S I)DI/WS POIOI=S TOI=S E)N A)/LLW| KO/SMW| PARA\ TOU\S E)N A)/LLW| GI/NESQAI. @&10Nemesius de nat. hom. cp. 38 p. 277.$10 <20OI( DE\ *STWI+KOI/>20 FASIN A)POKAQISTAME/NOUS TOU\S PLA/NHTAS EI)S TO\ AU)TO\ SHMEI=ON KATA/ TE MH=KOS KAI\ PLA/TOS, E)/NQA TH\N A)RXH\N E(/KASTOS H)=N, O(/TE TO\ PRW=TON O( KO/SMOS SUNE/STH, E)N R(HTAI=S XRO/NWN PERIO/DOIS E)KPU/RWSIN KAI\ FQORA\N TW=N O)/NTWN A)PERGA/ZESQAI: KAI\ PA/LIN E)C U(PARXH=S EI)S TO\ AU)TO\ TO\N KO/SMON A)POKAQI/STASQAI: TW=N A)STE/RWN O(MOI/WS PA/LIN FEROME/NWN, E(/KASTON E)N TH=| PROTE/RA| PERIO/DW| GINO/MENON A)PARAL-LA/KTWS A)POTELEI=SQAI. E)/SESQAI GA\R PA/LIN *SWKRA/TH KAI\ *PLA/TWNA KAI\ E(/KASTON TW=N A)NQRW/PWN SU\N TOI=S AU)TOI=S KAI\ FI/LOIS KAI\ POLI/TAIS: KAI\ TA\ AU)TA\ PEI/SESQAI KAI\ TA\ AU)TA\ METAXEIRIEI=SQAI, KAI\ PA=SAN PO/LIN KAI\ KW/MHN KAI\ A)GRO\N O(MOI/WS A)POKA-QI/STASQAI: GI/NESQAI DE\ TH\N A)POKATA/STASIN TOU= PANTO\S OU)X A(/PAC, A)LLA\ POL-LA/KIS: MA=LLON DE\ EI)S A)/PEIRON KAI\ A)TELEU/THTON TA\ AU)TA\ A)POKAQI/STASQAI. TOU\S DE\ QEOU\S TOU\S MH\ U(POKEIME/NOUS TH=| FQORA=|, TAU/TH| PARAKOLOUQH/SANTAS MIA=| PERIO/DW|, GINW/SKEIN E)K TAU/THS PA/NTA TA\ ME/LLONTA E)/SESQAI E)N TAI=S E(CH=S PERI-O/DOIS. OU)DE\N GA\R CE/NON E)/SESQAI PARA\ TA\ GENO/MENA PRO/TERON, A)LLA\ PA/NTA W(SAU/TWS A)PARALLA/KTWS A)/XRI KAI\ TW=N E)LAXI/STWN. @&10Origenes contra Celsum IV 68 Vol. I p. 338, 3 Ko+. [1p. 555 &10Delarue$10]1. <20TW=N DE\ *STWI+KW=N>20 OI( PLEI/OUS OU) MO/NON TH\N TW=N QNHTW=N PERI/O-DON TOIAU/THN EI)=NAI/ FASIN A)LLA\ KAI\ TH\N TW=N A)QANA/TWN KAI\ TW=N KAT' AU)TOU\S QEW=N: META\ GA\R TH\N TOU= PANTO\S E)KPU/RWSIN, A)PEIRA/KIS GENOME/NHN KAI\ A)PEI-RA/KIS E)SOME/NHN, H( AU)TH\ TA/CIS A)P' A)RXH=S ME/XRI TE/LOUS PA/NTWN GE/GONE/ TE KAI\ E)/STAI. *PEIRW/MENOI ME/NTOI QERAPEU/EIN PWS TA\S A)PEMFA/SEIS <20OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 OU)K OI)=D' O(/PWS A)PARALLA/KTOUS FASI\N E)/SESQAI KATA\ PERI/ODON TOI=S A)PO\ TW=N PROTE/RWN PERIO/DWN PA/NTAS: I(/NA MH\ *SWKRA/THS PA/LIN GE/NHTAI, A)LL' A)PARA/LLAKTO/S TIS TW=| *SWKRA/TEI, GAMH/SWN A)PARA/LLAKTO/N TINA *CANQI/PPH|, KAI\ KATHGORHQHSO/MENOS U(PO\ A)PARALLA/KTWN *)ANU/TW| KAI\ *MELH/TW|. *OU)K OI)=DA DE\ PW=S O( ME\N KO/SMOS A)EI\ O( AU)TO/S E)STI KAI\ OU)K A)PARA/LLAKTOS E(/TEROS E(TE/RW|: TA\ D' E)N AU)TW=| OU) TA\ AU)TA/, A)LL' A)PARA/LLAKTA. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. Phys. p. 886, 11 Diels.$10 TOU=TO DE\ ZH/THMA @1 TH=| TW=N <20*STWI+KW=N>20 E)STI MA=LLON A(RMO/TTON PALIGGENESI/A|: LE/GONTES GA\R E)KEI=NOI TO\N AU)TO\N E)ME\ PA/LIN GI/NESQAI E)N TH=| PALIGGENESI/A|, ZHTOU=SIN EI)KO/TWS PO/TERON EI(=S EI)MI TW=| A)RIQMW=| O( NU=N KAI\ TO/TE, DIA\ TO\ TH=| OU)SI/A| EI)=NAI O( AU)TO/S, H)\ TH=| KATATA/CEI TH=| EI)S A)/LLHN KAI\ A)/LLHN KOSMOPOII/+AN DIAFOROU=MAI. @&10Origenes contra Celsum IV 12 Vol. I p. 282, 9 Ko+. [1p. 508 &10Delarue]1.$10 O(/TI A)RXAIO/TATOI A)/NDRES GENO/MENOI *MWUSH=S KAI/ TINES TW=N PROFH-TW=N OU) PAR' E(TE/RWN EI)LH/FASI TA\ PERI\ TH=S TOU= KO/SMOU E)KPURW/SEWS, A)LL' [1EI) XRH\ E)PISTH/SANTA TOI=S XRO/NOIS EI)PEI=N]1 MA=LLON TOU/TWN E(/TEROI PARAKOU/SANTES KAI\ MH\ A)KRIBW/SANTES TA\ U(PO\ TOU/TWN LEGO/MENA A)NE/PLASAN KATA\ PERIO/DOUS TAUTO/THTAS KAI\ A)PARALLA/KTOUS TOI=S I)DI/WS POIOI=S KAI\ TOI=S SUMBEBHKO/SIN AU)-TOI=S [2KO/SMOUS]2: H(MEI=S DE\ OU)/TE TO\N KATAKLUSMO\N OU)/TE TH\N E)KPU/RWSIN KU/KLOIS KAI\ A)STE/RWN PERIO/DOIS A)NATI/QEMEN. @&10Origenes de principiis [1interpr. Rufino]1 II cp. 3 p. 81 ed. Dela-&10rue. Iam vero qui indissimiles sibi mundos ac per omnia pares aliquando &10evenire confirmant, nescio quibus id possint asserere documentis. [1Hanc &10sententiam cum liberi arbitrii doctrina pugnare Origenes contendit]1. Non &10enim cursu aliquo in eosdem se circulos post multa saecula revolvente &10aguntur animae, ut hoc aut illud vel agant vel capiant etc. &10@Clemens Al. Stromat. V 1 p. 649 Pott.$10 OI)=DEN GA\R KAI\ OU(=TOS [1&10scil. Heraclitus$10]1 TH\N DIA\ PURO\S KA/QARSIN__H(\N U(/STERON E)KPU/RWSIN E)KA/LESAN <20OI( *STWI+KOI/. KAQ' O(\N KAI\ TO\N I)DI/WS POIO\N A)NASTH/SESQAI DOGMATI/ZOUSI>20. @&10Hieronymus ep. 96. Nec quisquam &10hominum crebrius moritur, quod Origenes ausus est scribere, <21Stoicorum>21 &10impiissimum dogma divinarum cupiens scripturarum auctoritate firmare. &10@Plutarchus de defectu oraculorum cp. 29.$10 *KAI\ MH\N TA/ GE A)/LLA <20TW=N *STWI+KW=N>20 TI/S A)\N FOBHQEI/H, PUNQANOME/NWN "1PW=S EI(MARME/NH MI/A ME/NEI KAI\ PRO/NOIA, KAI\ OU) POLLOI\ *DI/ES KAI\ *ZH=NES E)/SONTAI PLEIO/NWN O)/NTWN KO/SMWN;"2 PRW=TON ME\N GA\R EI) TO\ POLLOU\S EI)=NAI *DI/AS KAI\ *ZH=NAS A)/TOPO/N E)STI, POLLW=| DH/POUQEN E)/STAI TA\ E)KEI/NWN A)TOPW/TERA: <20KAI\ GA\R *(HLI/OUS KAI\ *SELH/NAS KAI\ *)APO/LLWNAS KAI\ *)ARTE/MIDAS KAI\ *POSEIDW=NAS E)N A)PEI/ROIS KO/-SMWN PERIO/DOIS A)PEI/ROUS POIOU=SIN>20. @&Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 142, 143.$ O(/TI DE\ KAI\ ZW=|ON O( KO/SMOS KAI\ LOGIKO\N KAI\ E)/MYUXON KAI\ NOERO\N KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPO/S>20 FHSIN <20E)N PRW/TW| PERI\ *PRONOI/AS>20 KAI\ *)APOLLO/DWRO/S FHSIN E)N TH=| FUSIKH=| KAI\ *POSEIDW/NIOS: ZW=|ON ME\N OU(/TWS O)/NTA, OU)SI/AN E)/MYUXON AI)SQHTIKH/N. TO\ GA\R ZW=|ON TOU= MH\ ZW/|OU KREI=TTON: OU)DE\N DE\ TOU= KO/SMOU KREI=TTON. ZW=|ON A)/RA O( KO/SMOS. E)/MYUXON DE/, W(S DH=LON E)K TH=S H(METE/RAS YUXH=S E)KEI=QEN OU)/SHS A)POSPA/SMATOS. @1 @&Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 138.$ TO\N DH\ KO/SMON OI)KEI=SQAI KATA\ NOU=N KAI\ PRO/NOIAN, KAQA/ FHSI <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 E)N TOI=S <20PERI\ PRONOI/AS>20 KAI\ *POSEIDW/NIOS E)N TH=| IG# PERI\ QEW=N, EI)S A(/PAN AU)TOU= ME/ROS DIH/KON-TOS TOU= NOU=, KAQA/PER E)F' H(MW=N TH=S YUXH=S: A)LL' H)/DH DI' W(=N ME\N MA=L-LON DI' W(=N DE\ H(=TTON. DI' W(=N ME\N GA\R W(S E(/CIS KEXW/RHKEN, W(S DIA\ TW=N O)STW=N KAI\ TW=N NEU/RWN, DI' W(=N DE\ W(S NOU=S, W(S DIA\ TOU= H(GEMONIKOU=. OU(/TW DH\ KAI\ TO\N O(/LON KO/SMON, ZW=|ON O)/NTA KAI\ E)/MYUXON KAI\ LOGIKO/N, E)/XEIN H(GEMONIKO\N ME\N TO\N AI)QE/RA___O(\N KAI\ PRW=TON QEO\N LE/-GOUSIN, %% AI)SQHTIKW=S W(/SPER KEXWRHKE/NAI DIA\ TW=N E)N A)E/RI KAI\ DIA\ TW=N ZW/|WN A(PA/NTWN KAI\ FUTW=N: DIA\ DE\ TH=S GH=S AU)TH=S KAQ' E(/CIN. @&10Philo quaest. et solut. in Genesin IV 188 [1p. 397 Aucher]1. &10Itidem universum caelum et <21mundus>21 [1scil. non mixtam tristitiae aeternam &10habet laetitiam]1, quoniam <21animal est et rationale et animans vir-&10tute praeditus et natura philosophus>21; atque eandem ob causam &10tristitia et timore carens plenusque gaudii. Immo dicitur, quod et ipse &10pater et creator universorum perpetuo in vita sua exsultat et ludit, gau-&10dens condecenti divinum iocum iucunditate, nec opus habens ullius nec &10ullo modo indigens, sed ipse in se ipso laetificatus atque in suis virtuti-&10bus mundisque a se conditis. @&Philodemus de pietate c. 14 [1DDG p. 548b, 13$]1. TA\ PARA-PLH/SIA DE\ <20KA)N TOI=S PERI\ *FU/SEWS>20 GRA/FEI, MEQ' W(=N EI)/PAMEN%1 KAI\ TOI=S *(HRAKLEI/TOU SUNOIKEIW=N. KAI\ DH\%1 <20KA)N TW=| PRW/TW|>20 TH\N NU/KTA QEA/N FHSIN EI)=NAI PRWTI/STHN. <20E)N DE\ TW=| TRI/TW|>20 TO\N KO/SMON E(/NA TW=N FRONI/MWN, SUNPOLEITEUO/MENON QEOI=S KAI\ A)NQRW/POIS, KAI\ TO\N PO/LEMON KAI\ TO\N *DI/A TO\N AU)TO\N EI)=NAI, KAQA/PER KAI\ TO\N *(HRA/KLEITON LE/GEIN: <20E)N DE\ TW=| PE/MPTW|>20 KAI\ LO/GOUS E)RWTA=| PERI\ TOU= TO\N KO/SMON ZW=|ON EI)=NAI KAI\ LOGIKO\N KAI\ FRONOU=N KAI\ QEO/N. @&Philo de incorrupt. mund. 246, 10 B.$ E)PEI\ KAI\ OI( FQEI/RONTES AU)-TO\N LOGIKO\N EI)=NAI U(PONOOU=SIN. @&10Seneca cp. 92, 30. Quid est autem, cur non existimas in eo &10divini aliquid existere, qui dei pars est? totum hoc, quo continemur, et &10unum est et deus%10 et socii sumus eius et membra. &10@[Galenus$10] EI) ZW=|ON TO\ KATA\ GASTRO/S&10 1 Vol. XIX p. 160 K.$10 I)/DWMEN OU)=N EI) ZW=|O/N E)STIN O( KO/SMOS KAI/, EI)/ GE TH\N A)RXH\N [2MH\]2 E)GE/NETO, EI)=T' AU)= PA/LIN TH\N O(LO/KLHRON E)PE/SXE FU/SIN. KO/SMOS TOI/NUN E)STI\N SU/STHMA E)C OU)RA-NOU= KAI\ GH=S KAI\ TW=N METACU\ FU/SEWN. %2%2%2%2%2 KAI\ U(/DATOS KAI\ A)E/ROS KAI\ TO\ DIH=KON E)/XON DIA\ PA/NTWN AU)TW=N A)RXHGO\N KAI\ PRWTO/GONON PNEU=MA, O(/PER KA-LOU=SI PAI=DES FILOSO/FWN H)\ YUXH\N H)\ MONA/DA [H)\ A)/TOMON] H)\ PU=R H)\ O(MWNU/MWS @1 TW=| GE/NEI PNEU=MA TO\ PRW=TON. TAU=TA DE\ H)=N ME\N KAI\ PRO\ TOU= AU)TO\N TAU/THN E)/XEIN TH\N E)PWNUMI/AN: A)LLA\ TO/TE ME\N A)/KRITA H)=N [2KAI\]2 A)DIA/LLAKTA KAI/, W(/S FASI/ TINES, U(/LHN EI)=XE TOU)/NOMA, KO/SMON DE\ NU=N, DIA\ TO\ POIEI=N E)MMELW=S KAI\ EU)TA/KTWS KAI\ W(S A)\N E)N R(UQMW=| KAI\ KO/SMW| POIEI=SQAI TH\N KI/NHSIN. __E)C O(/LWN ME\N OU)=N O( KO/SMOS O(/LOS H(/RMOSTAI KAI\ E)K TELEI/WN TE/LEIOS KAI\ E)C AU)TO-TELW=N A)NENDEH/S: KAI\ H)=N KAI\ E)/STAI KINOU/MENON ZW=|ON. A)LLA\ TO/TE ME\N [2E)N]2-ESPARME/NHN KAI\ TH\N TOU= PANTO\S E)/XOUSAN LO/GON DU/NAMIN E)KE/KTHTO, DIAKRIQEI\S DE\ KAI\ TOU= SKO/TOUS PROELQW\N TH\N OI)KEI/AN TW=N SPERMA/TWN A)RETH\N E)/DEICEN, E)/NQA ME\N GH= FAINO/MENOS, E)/NQA D' U(/DWR, O(/POU DE\ PU=R %2%2%2%2 SU\N A)E/RI E)K-TEINO/MENOS PANTAXOU= TW=| TH=S AU)CH/SEWS TRO/PW| [2E)N]2 TH=| TW=N STOIXEI/WN FU/SEI, FWTI/ZWN TO\ O(/LON OI(=ON O)FQALMOI=S H(LI/W| KAI\ SELH/NH|, KAI\ TH=| TOU/TWN DIAUGEI= KAI\ LAMPRA=| STILPNO/THTI KINH/SEI PA/SH| O(DHGO\S GENO/MENOS. SUNEKE/KRATO GA\R AU)TW=| KAI\ OU(=TOS E)C A)RXH=S E)/TI GINOME/NW| KAI\ TH\N PRW/THN SUNISTAME/NW| FU/SIN. ZW=|O/N TE GA\R PRW=TON KAI\ E)/MPNOUN TE KAI\ E)/NNOUN O(/DE O( KO/SMOS KAI\ TO/TE H)=N KAI\ NU=N FAI/NETAI. W(/SPER OU)=N OU)K A)/N TIS TOLMH/SAS EI)/POI MH\ ZW=|ON AU)TO/N, H(NI/KA E)KUI/+SKETO [1A)PEDEI/CAMEN GA\R W(S E)C O(/LWN O(/LOS KAI\ W(S E)K TELEI/WN TE/LEIOS: PW=S GA\R A)\N O(LOTELH= PAREI/XETO MH\ W)\N O(/LOS;]1 OU(/TW KAI\ TO\ KATA\ GASTRO\S MH\ ZW=|ON [2OU)K]2 EI)/POI TIS A)/N. O(\N GA\R TRO/PON O( XALKOURGO\S H)\ O( SIDHREU\S H)\ O( A)NDRIANTOURGO\S H)\ O( NAUPHGO\S H)/ TIS TW=N O(MOI/WN OU)K A)\N LE/GOITO TE/LEIO/N TI TW=N E)C AU)TOU= KAI\ O(LO/KLHRON PARESXHKE/NAI E)LLEI/PONTO/S TINOS___TO\ D' A)NELLIPE\S KAI\ TOI=S A(/PASIN A)PHRTISME/NON_TE/LEIO/N E)STIN, TO\N AU)TO\N TRO/-PON KAI\ O( KO/SMOS__OU)K A)/N POTE TO\N TE/LEION E)PE/SXE LO/GON, EI) MH\ TO/TE, O(/TE PRW=TON TOU= EI)=NAI METELA/MBANEN, TH\N TOU= PANTO\S A)NEDE/CATO OU)SI/AN. @&10VH&14`2&10 VIII 27, 5.$10 H)\ TI/ MA=LLON A)N%5QRW/PWN XA/RIN H)\ TW=N [1A)%5-LO/GWN ZW/IWN E)/STIN E[1I)%5PEI=N GEGENNHKE/NAI %5 TO!!TW @&10`19.$10 TOIOU=%5TOS D' W)\N OU)K E)PAISQA%5NO/MENOS NOHQH/SE%5TAI: TH\N GA\R I)SXU\N OU) %5 TH\N PURO\S OU)DE\ TH\N A)%5E/ROS]1 @&10in fine col.$10 A)L%5LA\ DH\ KAI\ PAR' H(MI=N %5 TW=N ME\N FU/SEI TW=N %5 DE\ PRO-AIR[1E/S]1EI GINOME/%5NWN E)PIBLE/Y[1AI PRO/%5XEIRON O(/TI TW=N [1PRO%5AIRETIKW=N OU)D[1ENI\ %5 PROSE/OIKEN O( KO/SMOS &10etc. &10@VH&14`2&10 VIII 29.$10 TOU= KO/SMOU N!!AL!! %5 TI PARAKOPO!!!!!!! %5 MH/TE GINWSKOME/NOU %5 MHQ' O(/LWS O)/NTOS MH/TE %5 XA/RITOS E)PIDEKTIKOU= %5 DIA\ TH\N A)YUXI/AN TH\N %5 E)NARGE/STATA QEWROU%5ME/NHN. @&Cicero de natura deorum II 14, 38.&3 Bene igitur idem <21Chry-&3sippus>21, qui similitudines adiungens omnia in perfectis et maturis docet &3esse meliora, ut in equo quam in eculeo, in cane quam in catulo, in &3viro quam in puero; item quod in omni mundo optimum sit, id in per-&3fecto aliquo atque absoluto esse debere.& 39.&3 Est autem mundo nihil &3perfectius, nihil virtute melius%10 igitur mundi est propria virtus. Nec @1 &3vero hominis natura perfecta est%10 et efficitur tamen in homine virtus%10 &3quanto igitur in mundo facilius! Est ergo in eo virtus%10 sapiens est igi-&3tur et propterea deus. @&Arius Didymus epit. phys. fr. 29 Diels [1DG p. 465$]1. TISI\ DE\ TW=N A)PO\ TH=S AI(RE/SEWS E)/DOCE GH=N TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N EI)=NAI TOU= KO/SMOU. <20*XRUSI/PPW|>20 DE\ TO\N AI)QE/RA TO\N KAQARW/TATON KAI\ EI)LIKRINE/STATON A(/TE PA/NTWN EU)KINHTO/TATON O)/NTA KAI\ TH\N O(/LHN PERIA/GONTA TOU= KO/SMOU FORA/N. @&10Philo quaest. et solut. in Genesin IV 215 [1p. 416 Aucher]1. In &10homine mens similis est caelo, quoniam rationales sunt partes utriusque, &10una mundi, altera animae. @&Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 139.$ <20*XRU/SIPPOS DE\ E)N TW=| PRW/TW| PERI\ PRONOI/AS>20 KAI\ *POSEIDW/NIOS E)N TW=| PERI\ QEW=N TO\N OU)RANO/N FASI TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N TOU= KO/SMOU, *KLEA/NQHS DE\ TO\N H(/LION. O( ME/NTOI <20*XRU/-SIPPOS>20 DIAFORW/TERON PA/LIN TO\ KAQARW/TATON TOU= AI)QE/ROS E)N TAU)TW=|. @&10Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 34 p. 1076f.$10 A)LLA\ MH\N TO/N GE KO/SMON EI)=NAI PO/LIN KAI\ POLI/TAS TOU\S A)STE/RAS, EI) DE\ TOU=TO, KAI\ FULE/TAS KAI\ A)/RXONTAS DHLONO/TI KAI\ BOULEUTH\N TO\N H(/LION KAI\ TO\N E(/SPERON PRU/TANIN H)\ A)STUNO/MON, OU)K OI)=D' [2EI)]2 MH\ TOU\S E)LE/GXONTAS TA\ TOIAU=TA TW=N LEGO/NTWN KAI\ A)POFAINOME/NWN A)PODEI/KNUSIN A)TOPWTE/ROUS. @1 @&10Plutarchus de facie in orbe lunae cp. 6 p. 923e.$10 GH=N DE\ FATE\ U(MEI=S [1&10scil. <21Stoici>21$10]1 A)/NEU BA/SEWS KAI\ R(I/ZHS DIAME/NEIN. PA/NU ME\N OU)=N, EI)=PEN O( *FARNA/KHS, TO\N OI)KEI=ON KAI\ KATA\ FU/SIN TO/PON E)/XOUSAN, O(/SPER AU)TH=|, TO\N ME/SON: OU(=TOS GA/R E)STI PERI\ O(\N A)NTEREI/DEI PA/NTA TA\ BA/RH R(E/PONTA, KAI\ FE/RE-TAI KAI\ SUNNEU/EI PANTAXO/QEN: H( DE\ A)/NW XW/RA PA=SA KA)/N TI DE/CHTAI GEW=DES U(PO\ BI/AS A)NAR)R(IFE/N, EU)QU\S E)KQLI/BEI DEU=RO, MA=LLON DE\ A)FI/HSIN H(=| PE/FUKEN OI)KEI/A| R(OPH=| KATAFERO/MENON. @&10cp. 8 in.$10 E(TE/ROUS FASI\ GELOIA/ZEIN A)/NW TH\N *SELH/NHN, GH=N OU)=SAN, E)NI-DRU/ONTAS OU)X O(/POU TO\ ME/SON E)STI/. KAI/TOI GE EI) PA=N SW=MA E)MBRIQE\S EI)S TO\ AU)TO\ SUNNEU/EI, KAI\ PRO\S TO\ AU(TOU= ME/SON A)NTEREI/DEI PA=SI TOI=S MORI/OIS, OU)X W(S ME/SON OU)=SA TOU= PANTO\S H( GH= MA=LLON H)\ W(S O(/LON OI)KEIW/SETAI ME/RH AU)TH=S O)/NTA TA\ BA/RH: KAI\ TEKMH/RION E)/STAI [2TO\ PA/QOS]2 TW=N R(EPO/NTWN, OU) TH=| [2GH=|]2 TH=S MESO/THTOS PRO\S TO\N KO/SMON, A)LLA\ PRO\S TH\N GH=N KOINWNI/AS TINO\S KAI\ SUMFUI/AS TOI=S A)POSPWME/NOIS AU)TH=S, EI)=TA PA/LIN KATAFEROME/NOIS. @&10cp. 9.$10 O(RA=TE O(/TI GELOI=O/N E)STIN EI) GH=N OU) FH/SOMEN EI)=NAI TH\N *SELH/NHN, O(/TI TH=S KA/TW XW/RAS A)FE/STHKEN &10etc. &10@Ae%28tius Plac. III 9, 3.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 TH\N GH=N MI/AN KAI\ PEPE-RASME/NHN. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. III 10, 1.$10 *QALH=S KAI\ <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 KAI\ OI( A)P' AU)-TW=N SFAIROEIDH= TH\N GH=N. @&10Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 156.$10 <20ZW=NAI/>20 TE <20E)PI\ TH=S GH=S>20 EI)SI <20PE/NTE>20: PRW/TH BO/REIOS [KAI\] U(PE\R TO\N A)RKTIKO\N KU/KLON, A)OI/KHTOS DIA\ YU=XOS. DEU-TE/RA EU)/KRATOS: TRI/TH A)OI/KHTOS U(PO\ KAU/MATOS, H( DIAKEKAUME/NH KALOUME/NH: TETA/RTH H( A)NTEU/KRATOS: PE/MPTH NO/TIOS, A)OI/KHTOS DIA\ YU=XOS. @&10Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 144.$10 TW=N DE\ A)/STRWN TA\ ME\N <20A)PLANH=>20 SUM-PERIFE/RESQAI TW=| O(/LW| OU)RANW=|, TA\ DE\ <20PLANW/MENA>20 KAT' I)DI/AS KINH/SEIS KINEI=- @1SQAI. TO\N DE\ <20H(/LION>20 LOCH\N TH\N POREI/AN POIEI=SQAI DIA\ TOU= ZW|DIAKOU= KU/KLOU: O(MOI/WS KAI\ TH\N <20SELH/NHN>20 E(LIKOEIDH=. EI)=NAI DE\ TO\N ME\N <20H(/LION>20 EI)LIKRINE\S PU=R [1&10Posidonius$10]1 KAI\ MEI/ZONA TH=S GH=S [1&10Posidonius$10]1 A)LLA\ KAI\ SFAIROEIDH= [1&10Posi-&10donius$10]1 A)NALO/GWS TW=| KO/SMW|. PU=R ME\N OU)=N EI)=NAI, O(/TI TA\ PURO\S PA/NTA POIEI=: MEI/ZW DE\ TH=S GH=S TW=| PA=SAN U(P' AU)TOU= FWTI/ZESQAI, A)LLA\ KAI\ TO\N OU)RANO/N. KAI\ TO\ TH\N GH=N DE\ KWNOEIDH= SKIA\N A)POTELEI=N TO\ MEI/ZONA EI)=NAI SHMAI/NEI: PA/N-TOQEN DE\ BLE/PESQAI DIA\ TO\ ME/GEQOS. GEWDESTE/RAN DE\ TH\N <20SELH/NHN>20, A(/TE KAI\ PROSGEIOTE/RAN OU)=SAN. <20TRE/FESQAI>20 DE\ TA\ E)/MPURA TAU=TA KAI\ TA\ A)/LLA A)/STRA, TO\N ME\N H(/LION E)K TH=S MEGA/LHS QALA/TTHS NOERO\N O)/NTA A)/NAMMA: TH\N DE\ SELH/NHN E)K POTI/MWN U(DA/TWN, A)EROMIGH= TUGXA/NOUSAN KAI\ PRO/SGEION OU)=SAN, [1&10Posidonius$10]1 TA\ D' A)/LLA A)PO\ TH=S GH=S. DOKEI= DE\ AU)TOI=S <20SFAIROEIDH= EI)=NAI>20 KAI\ <20TA\ A)/STRA KAI\ TH\N GH=N>20, A)KI/NHTON OU)=SAN. TH\N DE\ <20SELH/NHN>20 OU)K I)/DION E)/XEIN FW=S, A)LLA\ PAR' H(LI/OU LAMBA/NEIN E)PILAMPOME/NHN. <20E)KLEI/PEIN>20 DE\ TO\N <20ME\N H(/LION>20 E)PIPROSQOU/SHS AU)TW=| SELH/NHS KATA\ TO\ PRO\S H(MA=S ME/ROS [1&10Zeno$10 E)N TW=| PERI\ TOU= O(/LOU]1. FAI/NETAI GA\R U(PERXOME/NH TAI=S SUNO/DOIS KAI\ A)PO-KRU/PTOUSA AU)TO\N KAI\ PA/LIN PARALLA/TTOUSA. GNWRI/ZETAI DE\ TOU=TO DIA\ LEKA/NHS U(/DWR E)XOU/SHS. @&10Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII. 155.$10 <20KU/KLOUS>20 DE\ EI)=NAI <20E)N TW=| OU)RANW=| PE/NTE>20, W(=N PRW=TON A)RKTIKO\N A)EI\ FAINO/MENON, DEU/TERON TROPIKO\N QERINO/N, TRI/-TON I)SHMERINO/N, TE/TARTON XEIMERINO\N TROPIKO/N, PE/MPTON A)NTARKTIKO\N A)FANH=. LE/GONTAI DE\ PARA/LLHLOI. KAQO/TI OU) SUNNEU/OUSIN EI)S A)LLH/LOUS: GRA/FONTAI ME/N-TOI PERI\ TO\ AU)TO\ KE/NTRON. O( DE\ ZW|DIAKO\S LOCO/S E)STIN W(S E)PIW\N TOU\S PA-RALLH/LOUS. @&Stobaeus I p. 214, 1 W.$ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 TO\N H(/LION EI)=NAI TO\ A)QROISQE\N E)/CAMMA NOERO\N E)K TOU= TH=S QALA/SSHS A)NAQUMIA/MATOS, SFAI-ROEIDH= DE\ EI)=NAI TW=| SXH/MATI [1&Diels Arii Didymi epitom. phys. fragm. 33]1. @&10Achilles Isagoge 14 p. 139 in Petav. Uranol.$10 SXH=MA DE\ AU)TOU= [1&10scil.$10 TOU= H(LI/OU]1 OI( ME\N DISKOEIDE/S, *(HRA/KLEITOS DE\ SKAFOEIDE/S. *STWI+KOI\ DE\ SFAIROEIDE\S EI)=NAI LE/GOUSI. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. II 22, 3.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 SFAIROEIDH= [1TO\N H(/LION]1 W(S TO\N KO/SMON KAI\ TA\ A)/STRA. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. II 20,4.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 A)/NAMMA NOERO\N E)K QALA/TTHS TO\N H(/LION. &10Cf. ibid 16 Hecataeum [1Milesium]1. &10@Scholia in Dionys. Thrac. p. 668 Bekker Anecd. Gr. II.$10 *)/ETI DEI= TO\N O(/RON KAI\ TOI=S MH\ PA/NU LOGI/OIS DHLOU=N, TI/NOS E)STI\N O( O(/ROS, OU)X W(/SPER OI( <20*STWI+KOI\>20 O(RIZO/MENOI TO\N H(/LION LE/GOUSIN O(/TI H(/LIO/S E)STIN A)/NAMMA NOERO\N QALASSI/WN U(DA/TWN. @&10Servius ad Verg. Georg. I 249. Redit a nobis%10 i. e. ad illos. &10et hoc secundum <21Stoicos>21 qui dicunt Solem vicissim per utrumque hemis-&10phaerium ire et alternis noctem facere. &10@Ae%28tius Plac. II 23, 5.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 KATA\ TO\ DIA/STHMA TH=S U(PO-KEIME/NHS TROFH=S DIE/RXESQAI TO\N H(/LION: W)KEANO\S DE/ E)STIN H)\ GH=S, H(=S TH\N A)NA-QUMI/ASIN E)PINE/METAI. @1 @&10Servius ad Verg. Anneid. I 607. "1pasci"2 autem aquis marinis &10sidera, id est ignes caelestes, physici docent. __quidam radios solis &10pasci asserunt humore terreno. &10@Commenta Lucani lib. VII 15 p. 220. Us. Non pabula flammis%10 &10ut <21Stoici>21 colligunt, ex nubibus flagrantia solis accenditur. &10@Alexander Aphrod. in Aristot. Meteorol. f. 92b ed. Ven.$10 DIO\ KAI\ GELOI=OI PA/NTES O(/SOI TW=N PRO/TERON U(PE/LABON TO\N H(/LION TRE/FESQAI TW=| U(GRW=|. KAI\ DIA\ TOU=T' E)/NIOI KAI/ FASI POIEI=SQAI TA\S TROPA\S AU)TO/N. OU) GA\R A)EI\ TOU\S AU)TOU\S DU/NASQAI TO/POUS PARASKEUA/ZEIN AU)TW=| TROFH/N. A)NAGKAI=ON D' EI)=NAI TOU=TO SUMBAI/NEIN PERI\ AU)TO\N H)\ FQEI/RESQAI. KAI\ GA\R TO\ FANERO\N PU=R, E(/WS A)\N E)/XH| TROFH/N, ME/XRI TOU/TOU ZH=N. TO\ D' U(GRO\N TW=| PURI\ TROFH\N EI)=NAI MO/NON, W(/SPER A)FIKNOU/MENON ME/XRI PRO\S TO\N H(/LION TO\ A)NAGO/MENON TOU= U(GROU=, H)\ TH\N A)/NODON TOIAU/THN OU)=SAN, OI(/ANPER TH=| GINOME/NH| FLOGI/. DI' H(=S TO\ EI)KO\S LABO/N-TES OU(/TW KAI\ PERI\ TOU= H(LI/OU U(PE/LABON. @&10Scholia Hesiod. Theog. v. 276.$10 "1*SQEINW/ T' *EU)RUA/LH TE."2 TO\ DUNATO\N KAI\ KATA/MHKES PE/LAGO/S FHSI, *ME/DOUSAN DE\ TH\N LEPTOTA/THN OU)SI/AN. <20*PERSE/A DE\ TO\N H(/LION KALEI=>20 TO\N PRO\S E(AUTO\N E(/LKONTA TH\N I)KMA/DA W(S A)POTE/MNONTA AU)TH/N, PARA\ TO\ PERISSW=S SEU/EIN TOUTE/STIN O(RMA=N: KAI/ FHSIN O(/TI O( H(/LIOS KINOU/MENOS TH=| OU)RANI/W| FORA=| TH\N ME\N *SQEINW\ KAI\ TH\N *EU)RUA/LHN H)/GOUN TO\ DUNATO\N KAI\ KATA/MHKES PE/LAGOS TH=S QALA/SSHS OU)K A)NAIREI= H)/GOUN OU)K A)NIMA=TAI, TH\N DE\ *ME/DOUSAN W(S QNHTH\N A)NAIREI= H)/GOUN TO\ BASILIKW/TA-TON KAI\ LEPTO/[2TATO]2N TH=| KINH/SEI TH=| E(AUTOU= A)NIMA=TAI. O(RMA=| DE\ A)PO\ TH=S KEFALH=S AU)TOU= O( *PH/GASOS. A)NIMWME/NOU GA\R TOU= H(LI/OU KAI\ TOU= A)E/ROS TO\ KEFALAIW=DES KAI\ A)TMW=DES, SUMBAI/NEI TO\ BARU/TATON A)NAFERO/MENON KATAPHGA/-ZEIN KAI\ XE/ESQAI. @&10Plutarchus de Iside et Osiride cp. 41 p. 367e.$10 <20OI( DE\ *STWI+-KOI\>20 TO\N ME\N H(/LION E)K QALA/TTHS A)NA/PTESQAI KAI\ TRE/FESQAI/ FASI, TH=| DE\ SELH/NH| TA\ KRHNAI=A KAI\ LIMNAI=A NA/MATA GLUKEI=AN A)NAPE/MPEIN KAI\ MALAKH\N A)NAQU-MI/ASIN. @&10Philo de confus. linguarum %14 156 Vol. II p. 259, 2.$10 O(/TI O( AI)QH/R, I(ERO\N PU=R, FLO/C E)STIN A)/SBESTOS, W(S KAI\ AU)TO\ DHLOI= TOU)/NOMA, PARA\ TO\ AI)/-QEIN, O(\ DH\ KAI/EIN E)STI\ KATA\ GLW=TTAN, EI)RHME/NON. *MA/RTUS DE\ MI/A MOI=RA TH=S OU)RANI/OU PURA=S, H(/LIOS, O(\S TOSOU=TON GH=S A)FESTW/S, A)/XRI MUXW=N TA\S A)KTI=NAS E)PIPE/MPWN, AU)TH/N TE KAI\ TO\N A)P' AU)TH=S A)NATEI/NONTA ME/XRI TH=S OU)RANI/OU SFAI/RAS A)E/RA FU/SEI YUXRO\N O)/NTA, TH=| ME\N A)LEAI/NEI TH=| DE\ KATAFLE/GEI. *TA\ ME\N GA\R O(/SA H)\ MAKRA\N A)FE/STHKEN AU)TOU= TH=S FORA=S H)\ E)GKA/RSIA PARABE/BLH-TAI A)LEAI/NEI MO/NON, TA\ D' E)GGU\S H)\ E)P' EU)QEI/AS O)/NTA KAI\ PROSANAKAI/EI BI/A|. @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 45 p. 1084c.$8 *KAI\ MH\ DUSXE-RAINE/TWSAN E)PI\ TAU=T' A)GO/MENOI TW=| KATA\ MIKRO\N LO/GW|, <20*XRUSI/PPOU>20 MNH-MONEU/ONTES, <20E)N TW=| PRW/TW| TW=N *FUSIKW=N *ZHTHMA/TWN>20 OU(/TW PROS-A/GONTOS: "1<20*OU)X H( ME\N NU\C SW=MA/ E)STIN, H( DE\ E)SPE/RA KAI\ O( O)/RQROS KAI\ TO\ ME/SON TH=S NUKTO\S SW/MATA OU)K E)/STIN: OU)DE\ H( ME\N H(ME/RA SW=MA/ E)STIN, OU)XI\ DE\ KAI\ H( NOUMHNI/A SW=MA, KAI\ H( DEKA/TH KAI\ @1 PENTEKAIDEKA/TH KAI\ H( TRIAKA/S, KAI\ O( MH\N SW=MA/ E)STI, KAI\ TO\ QE/ROS KAI\ TO\ FQINO/PWRON KAI\ O( E)NIAUTO/S>20."2 @&10Ae%28tius Plac. II 26, 1.$10 <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 MEI/ZONA TH=S GH=S A)POFAI/NON-TAI [1TH\N SEL.]1 W(S KAI\ TO\N H(/LION. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. II 27, 1.$10 <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 SFAIROEIDH= EI)=NAI [1TH\N SEL.]1 W(S TO\N H(/LION. SXHMATI/ZESQAI D' AU)TH\N POLLAXW=S, KAI\ GA\R PANSE/LHNON GIGNO-ME/NHN KAI\ DIXO/TOMON KAI\ A)MFI/KURTON KAI\ MHNOEIDH=. @&10Plutarchus de facie lunae cp. 15 p. 928c.$10 LE/GOUSI DE\ [1&10scil. Stoici$10]1 TOU= AI)QE/ROS TO\ ME\N AU)GOEIDE\S KAI\ LEPTO\N U(PO\ MANO/THTOS OU)RANO\N GEGONE/NAI, TO\ DE\ PUKNWQE\N KAI\ SUNEILHQE\N A)/STRA: TOU/TWN DE\ TO\ NWQRO/TATON EI)=NAI TH\N SELH/NHN KAI\ QOLERW/TATON. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. II 30, 5.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 DIA\ TO\ A)EROMIGE\S TH=S OU)SI/AS MH\ EI)=NAI AU)TH=S [1&10sc.$10 TH=S SELH/NHS]1 A)KH/RATON TO\ SU/GKRIMA. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. II 28, 3.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 A)MAUROFANE\S [1&10sc.$10 TO\ FW=S TH=S SEL.]1, A)EROEIDE\S GA/R. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. II 25, 5.$10 *POSEIDW/NIOS DE\ KAI\ <20OI( PLEI=STOI TW=N *STWI+KW=N>20 MIKTH\N E)K PURO\S KAI\ A)E/ROS [1TH\N SELH/NHN]1. @&10Plutarchus de facie in orbe lunae cp. 21 p. 933f.$10 O( *FARNA/KHS [1&10Stoicus Plutarchi$10]1 EI)=PEN, O(/TI TOU=TO KAI\ MA/LISTA TH\N *SELH/NHN DEI/KNUSIN A)/STRON H)\ PU=R OU)=SAN: OU) GA/R E)STI PANTELW=S A)/DHLOS E)N TAI=S E)KLEI/YESIN, A)LLA\ DIAFAI/NEI TINA\ XRO/AN A)NQRAKW/DH KAI\ BLOSURA\N H(/TIS I)/DIO/S E)STIN AU)TH=S. @&10Plutarchus de facie in orbe lunae cp. 5 p. 921f.$10 *)ALLA\ MH\ DO/-CWMEN, E)/FH, KOMIDH= PROPHLAKI/ZEIN TO\N *FARNA/KHN, OU(/TW <20TH\N *STWIKH\N DO/CAN>20 A)PROSAU/DHTON U(PERBAI/NONTES, EI)PE\ DH/ TI PRO\S TO\N A)/NDRA <20PA/NTWS A)E/ROS MI=GMA KAI\ MALAKOU= PURO\S U(POTIQE/MENON TH\N *SELH/NHN, EI)=TA OI(=ON E)N GALH/NH| FRI/KHS U(POTREXOU/SHS FA/SKONTA TOU= A)E/ROS DIAMELAI/-NONTOS E)/MFASIN GI/NESQAI MORFOEIDH= [2PROSW/POU>20]2. @&10paullo infra vituperat Stoicos%10$10 O(MOU= ME\N *)/ARTEMIN KAI\ *)AQHNA=N A)NAKA-LOU=NTAS, O(MOU= DE\ SU/MMIGMA KAI\ FU/RAMA POIOU=NTAS A)E/ROS ZOFEROU= KAI\ PURO\S A)NQRAKW/DOUS, OU)K E)/XOUSAN E)/CAYIN OU)DE\ AU)GH\N OI)KEI/AN, A)LLA\ DUSKRINE/S TI SW=MA TUFO/MENON A)EI\ KAI\ PURI/KAUSTON: W(/SPER TW=N KERAUNW=N TOU\S A)LAMPEI=S KAI\ YOLO/ENTAS U(PO\ TW=N POIHTW=N PROSAGOREUOME/NOUS. @&10p. 922c.$10 KAI\ GA\R *)EMPEDOKLEI= DUSKOLAI/NOUSI PA/GON A)E/ROS XALAZW/DH POIOU=NTI TH\N *SELH/NHN U(PO\ TH=S TOU= PURO\S SFAI/RAS PERIEXO/MENON: AU)TOI\ DE\ TH\N *SELH/NHN SFAI=RAN OU)=SAN PURO/S, A)E/RA FASI\N A)/LLON A)/LLH| DIESPASME/NON PERIE/XEIN, KAI\ TAU=TA MH/TE R(H/CEIS E)/XOUSAN E)N E(AUTH=| MH/TE BA/QH KAI\ KOILO/TH-TAS, A(/PER OI( GEW/DH POIOU=NTES A)POLEI/POUSIN, A)LLA\ E)PIPOLH=S DHLONO/TI TH=| KUR-TO/THTI E)PIKEI/MENON. @1 @&10Philo de somniis lib. I %14 145.$10 *LE/GETAI GOU=N, O(/TI SELH/NH PI/LHMA ME\N A)/KRATON AI)QE/ROS OU)/K E)STIN, W(S E(/KASTOS TW=N A)/LLWN A)STE/RWN, KRA=MA DE\ E)/K TE AI)QERW/DOUS OU)SI/AS KAI\ A)ERW/DOUS: KAI\ TO/ GE E)MFAINO/MENON AU)TH=| ME/LAN, O(\ KALOU=SI/ TINES PRO/SWPON, OU)DE\N A)/LLO EI)=NAI H)\ TO\N A)NAMEMIGME/NON A)E/RA, O(\S KATA\ FU/SIN ME/LAS W)\N A)/XRIS OU)RANOU= TEI/NETAI. @&10Plutarchus de facie lunae cp. 23 p. 936b.$10 A)LL' E)KEI=NO MA=LLON E)LE/GXEIN DOKEI= TH\N LEGOME/NHN A)NA/KLASIN A)PO\ TH=S SELH/NHS, O(/TI TOU\S E)N TAI=S A)NAKLWME/NAIS AU)GAI=S E(STW=TAS OU) MO/NON SUMBAI/NEI TO\ FWTIZO/MENON O(RA=N, A)LLA\ KAI\ TO\ FWTI/ZON. O(/TAN GA/R, AU)GH=S A)F' U(/DATOS PRO\S TOI=XON A(LLOME/NHS, O)/YIS E)N AU)TW=| TW=| PEFWTISME/NW| KATA\ TH\N A)NA/KLASIN TO/PW| GE/NHTAI, TA\ TRI/A KAQORA=|, TH/N T' A)NAKLWME/NHN AU)GH\N KAI\ TO\ POIOU=N U(/DWR TH\N A)NA/KLASIN KAI\ TO\N H(/LION AU)TO/N, A)F' OU(= TO\ FW=S TW=| U(/DATI PROSPI=PTON A)NAKE/KLASTAI. TOU/TWN D' O(MO-LOGOUME/NWN KAI\ FAINOME/NWN, <20KELEU/OUSI TOU\S A)NAKLA/SEI FWTI/ZESQAI TH\N GH=N U(PO\ TH=S SELH/NHS A)CIOU=NTAS E)PIDEIKNU/NAI NU/KTWR E)MFAI-NO/MENON TH=| SELH/NH| TO\N H(/LION, W(/SPER E)MFAI/NETAI TW=| U(/DATI MEQ' H(ME/RAN, O(/TAN A)NA/KLASIS A)P' AU)TOU= GE/NHTAI: MH\ FAINOME/NOU DE\ TOU/TOU, KAT' A)/LLON OI)/ONTAI TRO/PON, OU)K A)NAKLA/SEI, GI/GNESQAI TO\N FWTISMO/N. EI) DE\ MH\ TOU=TO, MHDE\ GH=N EI)=NAI TH\N SELH/NHN>20. @&10Aetius Plac. II 29, 6.$10 *QALH=S *)ANACAGO/RAS *PLA/TWN <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 TOI=S MAQHMATIKOI=S SUMFW/NWS TA\S ME\N MHNIAI/OUS A)POKRU/YEIS SUNODEU/OUSAN AU)TH\N H(LI/W| KAI\ PERILAMPOME/NHN POIEI=SQAI, TA\S DE\ E)KLEI/YEIS EI)S TO\ SKI/ASMA TH=S GH=S E)MPI/PTOUSAN, METACU\ ME\N A)MFOTE/RWN TW=N A)STE/RWN GINOME/NHS, MA=LLON DE\ TH=S SELH/NHS A)NTIFRATTOME/NHS. @&10Plutarchus de facie lunae cp. 25 p. 940c.$10 KAI\ GA\R AU)TH\N <20TH\N SELH/NHN>20, W(/SPER TO\N H(/LION, ZW=|ON O)/NTA PU/RINON KAI\ TH=S GH=S O)/NTA POLLA-PLA/SION, A)PO\ TW=N U(GRW=N FASI TW=N A)PO\ TH=S GH=S TRE/FESQAI, KAI\ TOU\S A)/LLOUS A)STE/RAS A)PEI/ROUS O)/NTAS: OU(/TWS E)LAFRA\ KAI\ LITA\ TW=N A)NAGKAI/WN FE/REIN ZW=|A TO\N A)/NW TO/PON U(POLAMBA/NOUSIN. @&10Stobaeus ed. I p. 219, 24 W. [1de luna]1.$10 *XRU/SIPPOS TO\ A)QROISQE\N E)/CAMMA META\ TO\N H(/LION NOERO\N E)K TOU= A)PO\ TW=N POTI/MWN U(DA/TWN A)NAQUMIA/MA-TOS: DIO\ KAI\ TOU/TOIS TRE/FESQAI. SFAIROEIDH= DE\ EI)=NAI. MH=NA DE\ KALEI=SQAI TH\N TOU= DRO/MOU AU)TH=S PERI/ODON. MEI\S D' E)STI/, FHSI/, TO\ FAINO/MENON TH=S SELH/NHS PRO\S H(MA=S H)\ SELH/NH ME/ROS E)/XOUSA FAINO/MENON PRO\S H(MA=S. @&Stobaeus I p. 221, 23 W$ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 E)KLEI/PEIN TH\N SELH/NHN TH=S GH=S AU)TH=| E)PIPROSQOU/SHS KAI\ EI)S SKIA\N AU)TH=S E)MPI/PTOUSAN [1&DDG &p. 360&14b& 27 Ae%28t. Plac. II 29, 8]1. @&10Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 146.$10 TH\N DE\ SELH/NHN [1E)KLEI/PEIN]1 E)MPI/PTOUSAN EI)S TO\ TH=S GH=S SKI/ASMA: O(/QEN KAI\ TAI=S PANSELH/NOIS E)KLEI/PEIN MO/NAIS KAI/PER KATA\ DIA/METRON I(STAME/NHN KATA\ MH=NA TW=| H(LI/W|, O(/TI KATA\ LOCOU= W(S PRO\S TO\N H(/LION KINOUME/NH PARALLA/TTEI TW=| PLA/TEI, H)\ BOREIOTE/RA H)\ NOTIWTE/RA GINOME/NH. O(/TAN ME/NTOI TO\ PLA/TOS AU)TH=S KATA\ TO\N H(LIAKO\N KAI\ TO\N DIA\ ME/SWN GE/NHTAI, EI)=TA DIAMETRH/SH| TO\N H(/LION, TO/TE E)KLEI/PEI. GI/NETAI DE\ TO\ PLA/TOS AU)TH=S KATA\ TO\N DIA\ ME/SWN E)N XHLAI=S KAI\ SKORPI/W| KAI\ KRIW=| KAI\ TAU/RW| [1&10Posidonius]1. @1 &10@Plutarchus de facie lunae cp. 25 p. 940a.$10 W)KEANOU= TE PLHM-MU/RAS, W(S LE/GOUSIN OU(=TOI [1&10scil. Stoici$10]1, KAI\ PORQMW=N E)PIDO/SEIS, DIAXEOME/NWN KAI\ AU)CANOME/NWN U(PO\ TH=S SELH/NHS TW=| A)NUGRAI/NESQAI, PARATIQE/MENOS. @&10Philo de provid. II %14 77 [1p. 96 Aucher]1. Lunae phasibus spe-&10ciatim fructus nocte quodam modo maturescere videntur; debiles namque &10et magis femineos emittens splendores nec non serenos [1aut rore praeditos]1 &10optime lactat enutriendo et adaugendo; quandoquidem nimius violentus-&10que calor exsiccando arescere facit; qui vero absque exustione est, leniter &10ac paulatim calefaciendo solet perficere. &10@Ae%28tius Plac. II 14, 1.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 SFAIRIKOU\S TOU\S A)STE/RAS, KAQA/PER TO\N KO/SMON KAI\ H(/LION KAI\ SELH/NHN. @&10Achilles Isagoge 11 p. 133 in Petav. Uranol.$10 OI( <20*STWI+KOI\>20 DE\ E)K PURO\S LE/GOUSIN AU)TOU/S: PURO\S DE\ TOU= QEI/OU KAI\ A)I+DI/OU KAI\ OU) PARA-PLHSI/OU TW=| PAR' H(MI=N: TOU=TO GA\R FQARTIKO/N, KAI\ OU) PAMFAE/S. @&10idem 12.$10 *PERI\ SXH/MATOS A)STE/RWN. *KLEA/NQHS AU)TOU\S KWNOEIDE\S E)/XEIN SXH=MA/ FHSI. TINE\S DE\ PETA/LOIS E)OIKE/NAI E)K PURO/S, BA/QOS OU)K E)/XONTAS, A)LL' W(/SPER GRAFA\S EI)=NAI. *OI( DE\ <20*STWI+KOI\>20 SFAIRIKO\N E)/XEIN SXH=MA LE/GOUSI, KAQA/PER TO\N H(/LION KAI\ TO\N PERIE/XONTA OU)RANO/N. @&Stobaeus ecl. I p. 206, 25 W.$ <20*XRUSI/PPOU>20: *)ANATOLH\N D' EI)=NAI/ FHSIN O( *XRU/SIPPOS <20E)N TAI=S *FUSIKAI=S TE/XNAIS>20 U(PEROXH\N A)/STROU U(PE\R GH=S, DU/SIN DE\ KRU/YIN A)/STROU U(PO\ GH=N. *GI/GNESQAI D' A(/MA TW=N AU)TW=N A)NATOLH\N KAI\ DU/SIN PRO\S A)/LLOUS TE KAI\ A)/LLOUS. *)EPITOLH\N DE\ [2TH\N]2 A)/STROU A(/MA H(LI/W| A)NATOLH/N, DU/SIN DE\ TH\N A(/MA H(LI/W| DU/SIN. *DIXW=S GA\R LE/GESQAI DU/SIN, TH\N ME\N KATA\ TH\N A)NATOLH/N, TH\N DE\ KATA\ TH\N E)PITOLH/N. *KUNO\S D' E)PITOLH\N A(/MA H(LI/W| KUNO\S A)NA-TOLH/N, DU/SIN DE\ KUNO\S A(/MA H(LI/W| KUNO\S A)PO/KRUYIN U(PO\ GH=N. *TO\N D' O(/MOION LO/GON EI)=NAI KAI\ E)PI\ TH=S PLEIA/DOS [1&Diels Arii Didymi epit. &phys. fragm. 32]1. @&10Cicero de natura deorum II 15, 39. Atque hac mundi divini-&10tate perspecta tribuenda est sideribus eadem divinitas, quae ex mobilissima &10purissimaque aetheris parte gignuntur, neque ulla praeterea est admixta &10natura, totaque sunt calida atque perlucida, ut ea quoque rectissime et &10animantia esse et sentire atque intelligere dicantur. &10@Origenes contra Celsum V 10. Vol. II p. 11, 13 Ko+. p. 585 &10Delarue.$10 EI)/PER KAI\ OI( E)N OU)RANW=| A)STE/RES ZW=|A/ EI)SI LOGIKA\ KAI\ SPOUDAI=A. @&10Achilles Isasoge 13 p. 134 in Petav. Uranol.$10 O(/TI DE\ OI( A)STE/RES ZW=|A, XRW=NTAI PRO\S A)PO/DEICIN OI( <20*STWI+KOI\>20 TOU/TOIS: PA/NTA TA\ E)N TW=| OU)RANW=| PURW/DH, KAI\ KATA\ FU/SIN KAI\ POLUXRONI/WS KINEI=TAI KAI\ KUKLIKW=S. OU)KOU=N @1 KAI\ KRI/SIN E)/XEI. EI) DE\ KRI/SIN E)/XEI KAI\ ZW=|A/ E)STI. *KAI\ POIKI/LAS E)/XOUSI KI-NH/SEIS: TOU=TO DE\ TOI=S ZW/|OIS E(/PETAI. *KAI\ PA/NTA TA\ STOIXEI=A ZW=|A E)/XEI: A)/TOPON DE\ TO\ KREI=TTON PA/NTWN TW=N STOIXEI/WN ZW/|WN A)/MOIRON EI)PEI=N. @&Achilles Isasoge 13 p. 133 in Petav. Uranol.$ TOU\S A)STE/RAS DE\ ZW=|A EI)=NAI, OU)/TE *)ANACAGO/RA| OU)/TE *DHMOKRI/TW| DOKEI= OU)/TE *)EPIKOU/RW| E)N TH=| PRO\S *(HRO/DOTON E)PITOMH=|, *PLA/TWNI DE\ DOKEI= E)N *TIMAI/W| KAI\ *)ARISTO-TE/LEI E)N DEUTE/RW| PERI\ OU)RANOU= KAI\ <20*XRUSI/PPW| E)N TW=| PERI\ PRO-NOI/AS>20 KAI\ <20QEW=N>20. OI( DE\ *)EPIKOU/REIOI/ FASI MH\ EI)=NAI ZW/|DIA, E)PEI\ U(PO\ SWMA/TWN SUNE/XETAI, OI( DE\ *STWI+KOI\ TO\ A)NA/PALIN. @&10Philo de provid. II %14 74 [1p. 94 Aucher]1. Item sine labore ac &10defatigatione est eorum [1scil. stellarum fixarum]1 circumactio, primum uti-&10que ob proximitatem ad divinam naturam; ac deinde etiam propter ignis &10virtutem, quae nequit debilitari, eo quod optima esca instructa sit, neque &10tempore lassari. &10@Ae%28tius Plac. II 15, 2$10 [1PERI\ TA/CEWS A)STE/RWN]1 OI( DE\ A)/LLOI *STWI+-KOI\ PRO\ TW=N E(TE/RWN TOU\S E(TE/ROUS [1&10sc.$10 A)STE/RAS]1 E)N U(/YEI KAI\ BA/QEI. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. II 17, 4.$10 *(HRA/KLEITOS KAI\ <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 TRE/FESQAI TOU\S A)STE/RAS E)K TH=S E)PIGEI/OU A)NAQUMIA/SEWS. @&10Servius ad Verg. Aeneid. X 272. cometae autem latine crinitae &10appellantur. et <21Stoici>21 dicunt has stellas esse ultra XXXII. &10@Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 152.$10 <20I)=RIN>20 DE\ EI)=NAI AU)GA\S A)F' U(GRW=N NEFW=N A)NAKEKLASME/NAS &10[1additur accuratior Posidonii explicatio]1.$10 <20KOMH/TAS>20 TE KAI\ <20PWGWNI/AS>20 KAI\ <20LAMPADI/AS>20 PURA\ EI)=NAI U(FESTW=TA PA/XOUS A)E/ROS EI)S TO\N AI)-QERW/DH TO/PON A)NENEXQE/NTOS. <20SE/LAS>20 DE\ PURO\S A)QRO/OU E)/CAYIN E)N A)E/RI FERO-ME/NOU TAXE/WS KAI\ FANTASI/AN MH/KOUS E)MFAI/NONTOS. @&10Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 151.$10 TW=N DE\ E)N A)E/RI GINOME/NWN <20XEIMW=NA>20 ME\N EI)=NAI/ FASI TO\N U(PE\R GH=S A)E/RA KATEYUGME/NON DIA\ TH\N TOU= H(LI/OU PRO/SW A)/FODON: E)/AR DE\ TH\N EU)KRASI/AN TOU= A)E/ROS KATA\ TH\N PRO\S H(MA=S POREI/AN. <20QE/ROS>20 DE\ TO\N U(PE\R GH=S A)E/RA KATAQALPO/MENON TH=| TOU= H(LI/OU PRO\S A)/RKTON POREI/A|, <20METO/PWRON>20 DE\ TH=| PALINDROMI/A| TOU= H(LI/OU A)F' H(MW=N GI/NESQAI. @&Stobaeus ed. I p. 106, 24 W.$ <20*XRUSI/PPOU>20 [1&cf. n. 509$]1. __ *)/EAR DE\ E)/TOUS W(/RAN KEKRAME/NHN E)K XEIMW=NOS A)POLH/GONTOS KAI\ QE/ROUS A)RXOME/NOU: H)\ TH\N META\ XEIMW=NA W(/RAN PRO\ QE/ROUS. *QE/ROS DE\ W(/RAN E)/TOUS TH\N MA/LISQ' U(F' H(LI/OU DIAKEKAUME/NHN. *METO/PWRON DE\ W(/RAN E)/TOUS TH\N META\ QE/ROS ME/N, PRO\ XEIMW=NOS DE\ KEKRAME/NHN. *XEIMW=NA DE\ W(/RAN E)/TOUS TH\N MA/LISTA KATEYUGME/NHN H)\ TO\N PERI\ GH=N A)E/RA KATEYUGME/NON. GI/NESQAI DE\ I)SHMERI/AS DU/O KAQ' E(/KASTON E)NIAUTO\N KAI\ TROPA\S DU/O: @1 I)SHMERI/AS ME/N, O(/TAN H( NU\C KAI\ H( H(ME/RA I)/SAI W)=SI: TOU/TWN DE\ TH\N ME\N E)/ARI GI/GNESQAI, TH\N DE\ METOPW/RW|: TW=N DE\ TROPW=N TA\S ME\N QE/ROUS, TA\S DE\ XEIMW=NOS [1&Arii Didymi fr. phys. 26 Diels]1. @&10Philo de provid. II %14 78 [1p. 96 Aucher]1. Dierum autem noc-&10tiumque inaequalitatem Sol producit, inaequaliter ac varia lege circumac-&10tus et per accessum secessumque aestates, hiemes et aequinoctia peragens, &10quae sunt tempora annua nascendi, crescendi, perfectionis omnium sub &10caelo causa. &10@Philo de animal. sacrif. idon. Vol. II. Mang. p. 243.$10 E)/PEITA A)E/ROS KAI\ TW=N KAT' AU)TO\N METABOLW=N. *XEIMW\N GA\R KAI\ QE/ROS E)/AR TE KAI\ METO/PWRON, AI( E)TH/SIOI KAI\ BIWFELE/STATAI W(=RAI, PAQH/MATA A)E/ROS GEGO/NASIN, E)PI\ SWTHRI/A| TW=N META\ SELH/NHN TREPOME/NOU. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. III 8, 1.$10 *)EMPEDOKLH=S KAI\ OI( *STWI+KOI\ XEIMW=NA ME\N GI/NESQAI TOU= A)E/ROS E)PIKRATOU=NTOS TH=| PUKNW/SEI KAI\ EI)S TO\ A)NWTE/RW BIAZOME/-NOU, QEREI/AN DE\ TOU= PURO/S, O(/TAN EI)S TO\ KATWTE/RW BIA/ZHTAI. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. III 7, 2.$10 *OI( *STWI+KOI\ PA=N PNEU=MA A)E/ROS EI)=NAI R(U/SIN, TAI=S TW=N TO/PWN DE\ PARALLAGAI=S TA\S E)PWNUMI/AS PARALLA/TTOUSAN: OI(=ON TO\N A)PO\ TOU= ZO/FOU KAI\ TH=S DU/SEWS ZE/FURON, TO\N [2DE\]2 A)PO\ TH=S A)NATOLH=S KAI\ TOU= H(LI/OU A)PHLIW/THN, TO\N DE\ A)PO\ TW=N A)/RKTWN BORE/AN, TO\N DE\ A)PO\ TW=N NO-TI/WN LI/BA. @&10Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 152.$10 [2TOU\S DE\ A)NE/MOUS A)E/ROS EI)=NAI R(U/SEIS: PARALLATTOU/SAS DE\ TA\S E)PWNUMI/AS GI/NESQAI]2 PARA\ TOU\S TO/POUS, A)F' W(=N R(E/OUSI. TH=S DE\ GENE/SEWS AU)TW=N AI)/TION GI/NESQAI TO\N H(/LION E)CATMI/ZONTA TA\ NE/FH. @&10Cicero de divin. II 44. Placet enim <21Stoicis>21 eos anhelitus terrae, &10qui frigidi sint, cum fluere coeperint, ventos esse; cum autem se in nubem &10induerint eiusque tenuissimam quamque partem coeperint dividere atque &10disrumpere idque crebrius facere et vehementius, tum et fulgores et toni-&10trua existere%10 si autem nubium conflictu ardor expressus se emiserit, id &10esse fulmen. &10@Scholia Hesiod. Theog. v. 148.$10 "1*KO/TTOS TE *BRIA/REW/S TE *GU/GHS Q'."2 __OU(=TOI DE\ LE/GONTAI E)KNEFI/AI A)/NEMOI: EI)SI\ DE\ A(RPAKTIKOI\ PA/NTES. DIA\ TOU=TO KAI\ E(KATO/GXEIRES MUQIKW=S, DIA\ TO\ O(RMHTIKO\N TH=S MA/XHS. @*KO/TTOS, *BRIA/REWS KAI\ *GU/GHS OI( TREI=S KAIROI/ EI)SIN: *KO/TTOS H( O)RGH\ TOU= KAU/MATOS H)/GOUN O( QERINO/S: *BRIA/REWS TO\ E)/AR, PARA\ TO\ BRU/EIN KAI\ AU)/CESQAI TA\ FUTA/. *GU/GHS DE\ O( XEIMERINO\S KAIRO/S. OU(\S KAI\ E(KATO/GXEIRAS KALEI= DIA\ TO\ POLLA\S E)NERGEI/AS E)/XEIN. @&Stobaeus ecl. I p. 245, 23 W.$ <20*XRUSI/PPOU>20. *XRU/SIPPOS E)/FHSE TH\N O(MI/XLHN NE/FOS DIAKEXUME/NON, H)\ A)E/RA PA/XOS E)/XONTA: DRO/SON DE\ E)C @1 O(MI/XLHS KATAFERO/MENON U(GRO/N: U(ETO\N DE\ FORA\N U(/DATOS E)K NEFW=N: O)/M-BRON DE\ LA/BROU U(/DATOS KAI\ POLLOU= E)K NERW=N FORA/N: XA/LAZAN DE\ U(ETOU= PEPHGO/TOS DIA/QRUYIN: XIO/NA DE\ NE/FOS PEPHGO\S H)\ NE/FOUS PH=CIN: TO\ D' E)PI\ TH=S GH=S PEPHGO\S U(/DWR KRU/STALLON: PA/XNHN DE\ DRO/SON PEPHGUI=AN [1&Diels Arii Didymi epit. phys. fragm. 35]1. @&10Diogenes Lae%28rt VII 153.$10 <20U(ETO\N>20 DE\ E)K NE/FOUS METABOLH\N EI)S U(/DWR, E)PEIDA\N H)\ E)K GH=S H)\ E)K QALA/TTHS A)NENEXQEI=SA U(GRASI/A U(F' H(LI/OU MH\ TUGXA/NH| KATERGASI/AS. KATAYUXQE\N DE\ TOU=TO <20PA/XNHN>20 KALEI=SQAI. <20XA/LAZAN>20 DE\ NE/FOS PEPHGO/S, U(PO\ PNEU/MATOS DIAQRUFQE/N. <20XIO/NA>20 DE\ U(GRO\N E)K NE/FOUS PEPHGO/TOS [1&10Posidonius]1. @&Stobaeus ecl. I p. 233, 9 W.$ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 A)STRAPH\N E)/CAYIN NEFW=N E)KTRIBOME/NWN H)\ R(HGNUME/NWN U(PO\ PNEU/MATOS, BRONTH\N D' EI)=NAI TO\N TOU/TWN YO/FON: A(/MA DE\ GI/NESQAI E)N TW=| A)E/RI BRONTH/N TE KAI\ A)STRA-PH/N, PRO/TERON DE\ TH=S A)STRAPH=S A)NTILAMBA/NESQAI H(MA=S DIA\ TO\ TH=S A)KOH=S O)CUTE/RAN EI)=NAI TH\N O(/RASIN: O(/TAN D' H( TOU= PNEU/MATOS FORA\ SFO-DROTE/RA GE/NHTAI KAI\ PURW/DHS, KERAUNO\N A)POTELEI=SQAI, O(/TAN D' A)/QROUN E)KPE/SH| TO\ PNEU=MA KAI\ H(=TTON PEPURWME/NON, PRHSTH=RA GI/GNESQAI, O(/TAN D' E)/TI H(=TTON H)=| PEPURWME/NON TO\ PNEU=MA, TUFW=NA [1&DDG p. 369 b, 34 &Ae%28t. Plac. III 3, 13]1. @&10Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 153.$10 <20A)STRAPH\N>20 DE\ E)/CAYIN NEFW=N PARATRI-BOME/NWN H)\ R(HGNUME/NWN U(PO\ PNEU/MATOS, W(S *ZH/NWN E)N TW=| PERI\ TOU= O(/LOU: <20BRONTH\N>20 DE\ TO\N TOU/TWN YO/FON E)K PARATRI/YEWS H)\ R(H/CEWS: <20KERAUNO\N>20 DE\ E)/CAYIN SFODRA\N META\ POLLH=S BI/AS PI/PTOUSAN E)PI\ GH=S, NEFW=N PARATRIBOME/NWN H)\ R(HGNUME/NWN: OI( DE\ SUSTROFH\N PURW/DOUS A)E/ROS BIAI/WS KATAFEROME/NHN. <20TUFW=NA>20 DE\ KERAUNO\N POLU/N, BI/AION KAI\ PNEUMATW/DH H)\ PNEU=MA KAPNW=DES E)R)R(WGO/TOS NE/FOUS: <20PRHSTH=RA>20 NE/FOS PERISXISQE\N PURI\ META\ PNEU/MATOS. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. III 3, 12.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 BRONTH\N ME\N SUGKROUSMO\N NEFW=N, A)STRAPH\N DE\ E)/CAYIN E)K PARATRI/YEWS, KERAUNO\N DE\ SFODROTE/RAN E)/K-LAMYIN, PRHSTH=RA DE\ NWXELESTE/RAN. @&10Ioannes Laurentius Lydus de ostentis 7 p. 12 ed. Wachsmuth.$10 W(/STE POLLH\ KOINWNI/A TAI=S DIOSHMEI/AIS PRO\S TA\ GH/I+NA, KA)\N TOI=S <20A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 MH\ DOKH=|. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. III 15, 2.$10 <20*OI( DE\ *STWI+KOI/>20 FASI: SEISMO/S E)STI TO\ E)N TH=| GH=| U(GRO\N EI)S A)E/RA DIAKRINO/MENON KAI\ E)KPI=PTON. @1 @&10Ae%28tius Plac. V 26, 3.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 DE\ KAI\ *)EPIKOU/REIOI OU)K E)/MYUXA [1TA\ FUTA\&10 scil.]1.$10 TINA\ GA\R YUXH=S O(RMHTIKH=S EI)=NAI KAI\ E)PIQUMHTIKH=S, TINA\ DE\ KAI\ LOGIKH=S: TA\ DE\ FUTA\ AU)TOMA/TWS PWS KINEI=SQAI, OU) DIA\ YUXH=S. @&10Themistius paraphr. in Aristot. de anima II, 2 p. 83 Sp.$10 ME/SOS TOI/NUN *PLA/TWNOS KAI\ TW=N <20A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 *)ARISTOTE/LHS, E)/MYUXA ME\N TA\ FUTA\ LE/GWN, ZW=|A DE\ MH/: E)KEI/NWN DE\ O( ME\N A)/MFW, <20OI( DE\>20 OU)DE/TERON. @&10Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. plac. VI [1`509 M. 561 K.$10]1. OI( DE\ *STWI+KOI\ OU)DE\ YUXH\N O(/LWS O)NOMA/ZOUSI TH\N TA\ FUTA\ DIOIKOU=SAN, A)LLA\ FU/SIN. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de anima libri mant. p. 118, 12 Bruns.$10 O(/TI GA\R TO\ FUTIKO\N YUXH/ E)STI KAI\ YUXH=S ME/ROS KAI\ DU/NAMIS, OU(= MO/RIA TO\ QREPTI-KO\N KAI\ TO\ AU)CHTIKO\N KAI\ GENNHTIKO/N, A)LLA\ OU)K, W(/S <20TINE/S>20 FASIN, FU/SIS DEI/COMEN. @&Galenus de foetuum formatione 3. K IV p. 665.$ KAI\ ME/N-TOI KAI\ PERI\ TH=S TW=N FUTW=N GENE/SEWS E)SKE/FQAI TI XRH\ PRO/TERON: E)K GA\R TW=N EI)S TAU=TA A)NAGKAI/WN E(/N E)STI KAI\ TO\ GIGNW/SKEIN, O(POI/WN TE KAI\ O(PO/SWN DEI=TAI TO\ KU/HMA, ME/XRIS A)\N U(PO\ MIA=S DIOIKH=TAI YUXH=S, W(S TA\ FUTA/. *KALOU=MEN DE\ TH\N YUXH\N TAU/THN, O(/TAN MH\ PERI\ TOU/TOU PROKEI/MENON H)=| SKOPEI=N, TW=| KOINW=| PA/SHS OU)SI/AS PROSRH/MATI FU/SIN O)NOMA/ZONTES, O(\ KA)N TAI=S A)KRIBE/SI SKE/YESIN <20OI( PERI\ *XRU/SIPPON>20 ȈE)FU/LACAN &etc. @&10Philo de mundi opificio %14 43 Vol. I p. 13, 21 Wendl.$10 *)ALL' OU) MO/NON H)=SAN OI( KARPOI\ TROFAI\ ZW/|OIS, A)LLA\ KAI\ PARASKEUAI\ PRO\S TH\N TW=N O(MOI/WN A)EI\ GE/NESIN, TA\S SPERMATIKA\S OU)SI/AS PERIE/XOUSAI, E)N AI(=S A)/DHLOI KAI\ A)FANEI=S OI( LO/GOI TW=N O(/LWN EI)SI/, DH=LOI KAI\ FANEROI\ GINO/MENOI KAIRW=N PERIO/DOIS. @1 @&10Clemens Al. Stromat. II p. 487 Pott.$10 *TW=N GA\R KINOUME/NWN A(\ ME\N KAQ' O(RMH\N KAI\ FANTASI/AN KINEI=TAI, W(S TA\ ZW=|A: TA\ DE\ KATA\ META/QESIN, W(S TA\ A)/YUXA: KINEI=SQAI DE\ KAI\ TW=N A)YU/XWN TA\ FUTA\ METABATIKW=S FASI\N EI)S AU)/CHSIN, EI) TIS AU)TOI=S A)/YUXA EI)=NAI SUGXWRH/SEI TA\ FUTA/. *(/ECEWS ME\N OU)=N OI( LI/QOI, FU/SEWS DE\ TA\ FUTA/, O(RMH=S DE\ KAI\ FANTASI/AS TW=N TE AU)= DUOI=N TW=N PROEIRHME/NWN KAI\ TA\ A)/LOGA METE/XEI ZW=|A: H( LOGIKH\ DE\ DU/NAMIS I)DI/A OU)=SA TH=S A)NQRWPEI/AS YUXH=S OU)X W(SAU/TWS TOI=S A)LO/GOIS ZW/|OIS O(RMA=N O)FEI/LEI, A)LLA\ KAI\ DIAKRI/NEIN TA\S FANTASI/AS KAI\ MH\ SUNAPOFE/RESQAI AU)TAI=S. @&10Galenus comm. 5 in Hippocr. epid.&3 ed. Bas. V 510 K XVII B. 250$10 <20TOI=S *STWI+KOI=S>20 D' E)/QOS E)STI\ FU/SIN ME\N O)NOMA/ZEIN H(=| TA\ FUTA\ DIOIKEI=TAI, YUXH\N DE\ H(=| TA\ ZW=|A: TH\N [2D']2 OU)SI/AN A)MFOTE/RWN ME\N TI/QENTAI TO\ SU/MFUTON PNEU=MA KAI\ DIAFE/REIN A)LLH/LWN OI)/ONTAI POIO/THTI. CHRO/TERON ME\N GA\R PNEU=MA TO\ TH=S YUXH=S, U(GRO/TERON DE\ TO\ TH=S FU/SEWS EI)=NAI, DEI=SQAI D' A)/MFW PRO\S DIAMONH\N OU) TROFH=S MO/NON, A)LLA\ KAI\ A)E/ROS. @[&10Galenus] introductio s. medicus 9 ed. Bas. IV 375. K. XIV 697.$10 PNEU/MATA DE\ KATA\ TOU\S PALAIOU\S DU/O E)STI/, TO/ TE YUXIKO\N KAI\ TO\ FUSIKO/N. OI( DE\ <20*STWI+KOI\>20 KAI\ TRI/TON EI)SA/GOUSI TO\ E(KTIKO/N, O(\ KALOU=SIN E(/CIN. @&10ibid. p. 726.$10 TOU= DE\ E)MFU/TOU PNEU/MATOS DITTO\N EI)=DOS, TO\ ME\N FUSIKO/N, TO\ DE\ YUXIKO/N: EI)SI\ DE\ OI(\ KAI\ TRI/TON EI)SA/GOUSI, TO\ E(KTIKO/N: E(KTIKO\N ME\N OU)=N E)STI PNEU=MA TO\ SUNE/XON TOU\S LI/QOUS, FUSIKO\N DE\ TO\ TRE/FON TA\ ZW=|A KAI\ TA\ FUTA/, YUXIKO\N DE\ TO\ E)PI\ TW=N E)MYU/XWN AI)SQHTIKA/ TE POIOU=N TA\ ZW=|A KAI\ KINOU/MENA PA=SAN KI/NHSIN. @&10Proclus in Plat. Parmen. Vol. V p. 135 ed. Cousin.$10 I(/NA DE\ ME/NH| TA\ METE/XONTA TH=S I)DE/AS A)EI\ KAI\ MHDE/POTE E)KLEI/PH|, DEI= TINOS A)/LLHS AI)TI/AS, OU)K E)N AU)TOI=S OU)/SHS H)\ KINOUME/NHS, A)LL' E)F' E(AUTH=S I(DRUME/NHS, PRO\ TW=N KI-NOUME/NWN A)KINH/TOU KAI\ DIA\ TH\N OI)KEI/AN STAQERO/THTA PROCENOU/SHS KAI\ TOI=S KINOUME/NOIS TH\N A)NE/KLEIPTON METOXH/N: TAU/THS GA\R E)FIE/MENOI PA/NTES TH=S AI)-TI/AS, <20OI( ME\N TOU\S SPERMATIKOU\S LO/GOUS EI)=NAI TOU/TOUS OI)HQE/NTES, A)FQA/RTOUS AU)TOU\S E)POI/HSAN, W(S OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20: OI( DE\ &10etc. @&10Galenus adv. Iulianum 5. Vol. XVIII A p. 266 K.$10 A(/PAN ME\N GA\R FUTO\N U(PO\ FU/SEWS DIOIKEI=TAI, PA=N DE\ ZW=|ON U(PO\ FU/SEW/S TE A(/MA KAI\ YUXH=S: EI)/ GE DH\ TH\N ME\N TOU= TRE/FESQAI/ TE KAI\ AU)CA/NESQAI KAI\ TW=N TOIOU/-TWN E)/RGWN AI)TI/AN O)NOMA/ZOMEN A(/PANTES A)/NQRWPOI FU/SIN, TH\N DE\ TH=S AI)SQH/-SEW/S TE KAI\ E)C E(AUTH=S KINH/SEWS YUXH/N. @&10Philo de fuga et inventione %14 112 Vol. III p. 133, 26 Wendl.$10 *(/O TE GA\R TOU= *)/ONTOS LO/GOS, DESMO\S W)\N TW=N A(PA/NTWN, W(S EI)/RHTAI, KAI\ SUN-E/XEI TA\ ME/RH PA/NTA KAI\ SFI/GGEI, KWLU/WN AU)TA\ DIALU/ESQAI KAI\ DIARTA=SQAI. *(/H T' E)PI\ ME/ROUS YUXH/, KAQ' O(/SON DUNA/MEWS MEMOI/RATAI, TW=N TOU= SW/MATOS OU)DE\N A)POSXI/ZESQAI KAI\ A)POTE/MNESQAI MERW=N PARA\ FU/SIN E)A=|, TO\ D' E)P' AU)TH=| PA/NTA O(LO/KLHRA O)/NTA A(RMONI/AN KAI\ E(/NWSIN A)DIA/LUTON A)/GEI TH\N PRO\S A)/L-LHLA &10etc. &10@Iamblichus de anima apud Stobaeum ecl. I p. 375, 20 W.$10 KATA\ D' AU)= <20TOU\S *STWI+KOU\S>20 A)TELE/STERA A)EI\ A)POMERI/ZETAI TA\ TOIAU=TA TH=S ZWH=S @1 E)NERGH/MATA: KAI\ O(/SW| A)\N H)=| PROI+O/NTA PROSWTE/RW TH=S A)LOGI/AS, TOSW=|DE MA=LLON E)PI\ TO\ A)TELE/STERON A)POFE/RETAI TA\ KATADEE/STERA TW=N PRESBUTE/RWN. @&10Clemens Al. Stromat. VII 6 p. 850 Pott.$10 H)/DH DE\ TA\ ME\N XERSAI=A KAI\ TA\ PTHNA\ TO\N AU)TO\N TAI=S H(METE/RAIS YUXAI=S A)NAPNE/ONTA A)E/RA TRE/FETAI, SUGGENH= TW=| A)E/RI TH\N YUXH\N KEKTHME/NA: TOU\S DE\ I)XQU=S OU)DE\ A)NAPNEI=N FASI\ TOU=TON TO\N A)E/RA, A)LL' E)KEI=NON O(\S E)GKE/KRATAI TW=| U(/DATI EU)QE/WS KATA\ TH\N PRW/-THN GE/NESIN, KAQA/PER KAI\ TOI=S LOIPOI=S STOIXEI/OIS: O(\ KAI\ DEI=GMA TH=S U(LIKH=S DIAMONH=S. @&10Philo de mundi opificio %14 66 Vol. I p. 21, 21 Wendl.$10 *DIO\ TW=N E)MYU/XWN PRW/TOUS E)GE/NNHSEN I)XQU/AS, PLE/ON METE/XONTAS SWMATIKH=S H)\ YUXIKH=S OU)SI/AS, TRO/PON TINA\ ZW=|A KAI\ OU) ZW=|A, KINHTA\ A)/YUXA, PRO\S AU)TO\ MO/NON TH\N TW=N SWMA/TWN DIAMONH\N PARASPARE/NTOS AU)TOI=S TOU= YUXOEIDOU=S, KAQA/PER FASI\ TOU\S A(/LAS TOI=S KRE/ASIN, I(/NA MH\ R(A|DI/WS FQEI/ROINTO. @&10Cicero de finibus V 38. ut non inscite illud pictum videatur &10in sue, animum illi pecudi datum pro sale, ne putisceret. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 12 p. 1038b.$ <20E)N DE\ TW=| PRW/TW| PERI\ *DIKAIOSU/NHS>20 "1KAI\ TA\ QHRI/A FHSI\ SUMME/TRWS TH=| XREI/A| TW=N E)KGO/NWN W)|KEIW=SQAI PRO\S AU)TA/, PLH\N TW=N I)XQU/WN: AU)TA\ GA\R TA\ KUH/MATA TRE/FETAI DI' AU(TW=N."2 _H( GA\R OI)KEI/WSIS AI)/SQHSIS E)/OIKE TOU= OI)KEI/OU KAI\ A)NTI/LHYIS EI)=NAI. @&10Origenes contra Celsum IV 87 Vol. I p. 357, 25 Ko+. [1p. 567 Del]1.$10 *)/ESTW DE\ KAI\ A)/LLA U(PO\ TW=N ZW/|WN GIGNW/SKESQAI A)LECIFA/RMAKA, TI/ OU)=N TOU=TO PRO\S TO\ MH\ FU/SIN A)LLA\ LO/GON EI)=NAI TO\N EU(RI/SKONTA TAU=TA E)N TOI=S ZW/|OIS; EI) ME\N GA\R LO/GOS H)=N O( EU(RI/SKWN, OU)K A)\N A)POTETAGME/NWS TO/DE TI MO/NON EU(RI/SKETO E)N O)/FESIN, E)/STW KAI\ DEU/TERON KAI\ TRI/TON, KAI\ A)/LLO TI E)N A)ETW=| KAI\ OU(/TWS E)N TOI=S LOIPOI=S ZW/|OIS: A)LLA\ TOSAU=TA A)\N O(/SA KAI\ E)N A)NQRW/POIS: NUNI\ DE\ FANERO\N E)K TOU= A)POTETAGME/NWS PRO/S TINA E(KA/STOU FU/SIN ZW/|OU NENEUKE/NAI BOHQH/MATA, <20O(/TI OU) SOFI/A OU)DE\ LO/GOS E)STI\N E)N AU)TOI=S, A)LLA/ TIS FUSIKH\ PRO\S TA\ TOIA/DE SWTHRI/AS E(/NEKEN TW=N ZW/|WN KATASKEUH/, U(PO\ TOU= LO/GOU GEGENHME/NH>20. @&10Philo de animalibus adv. Alexandrum p. 147 Aucher. Canis &10cum persequebatur feram, perveniens ad fossam profundam, iuxta quam &10duae erant semitae, una ad dextram, altera in sinistram, paululum se &10sistens, quo ire oporteat, meditabatur. Currens autem ad dexteram et &10nullum inveniens vestigium, reversus per alteram ibat. Quando vero ne-&10que in ista aperte appareret aliquod signum, transiliens fossam curiose &10indagat, praeter odoratum cursum accelerans; satis declarans non obiter &10haec facere, sed potius vera inquisitione consilii. Consilium autem talis &10cogitationis dialectici appellant demonstrativum evidens quinti modi%10 "1Quo-&10niam vel ad dextram fera fugit vel ad sinistram aut demum transsiliit, &10[2atqui neque ad dextram fugit neque ad sinistram; ergo transsiliit]2."2 @1 &10@idem p. 166 Aucher. Proscribenda et opinio eorum, qui canem vena-&10ticum bestias persequentem autumarunt quinto argumenti modo uti. Idem &10dicendum de collectoribus conchyliorum deque quaerentibus quidquam; &10indicia enim rerum sequentur, apparenter sub specie dialectica, verum &10tamen nec per somnium quidem philosophentur; alioquin dicendum esset &10de omnibus aliquid quaerentibus, quod quintum illum modum usurpent. &10__Nos enim dicimus, quod ex decentibus bonisque sibi convenientibus &10multisque rebus invantibus ad sanitatem perseverationemque valetudinis &10habent appetitionem et universali comprehensione universorum carentes &10eam possident certitudinem, quae in propria specie cernitur. Verum tamen &10rationalis habitus necesse est illa nullam habere participationem. Ratio-&10nalis autem habitus est syllogismus ex apprehensione entium, quae minime &10adsunt; ut intellectus de deo, de mundo, de lege, de patrio more, de civi-&10tate, de politica__quorum nihil percipiunt bestiae. @&10Sextus adv. math. VIII 270.$10 KAI/TOI TI/ PERI\ A)NQRW/PWN LE/GOMEN, O(/TE KAI\ TOI=S A)LO/GOIS ZW/|OIS TINE\S AU)TW=N [1&10Stoicorum, scil. Chrysippus$10]1 META-DEDW/KASI TH=S TOU= SHMEI/OU NOH/SEWS; KAI\ GA\R O( KU/WN, O(/TE E)K TOU= I)/XNOUS ׄSTIBEU/EI TO\ QHRI/ON, SHMEIOU=TAI_KAI\ O( I(/PPOS KATA\ TH\N TOU= MU/WPOS PROS-BOLH\N H)\ TH\N TH=S MA/STIGOS E)PANA/TASIN E)CA/LLETAI_KAI\ O)ROU/EI PRO\S DRO/MON. @&10Philo de animalibus adv. Alexandrum p. 155 Aucher. Ecce &10enim quaedam animantia praeter iam dictas virtutes iustitiam etiam prae &10se tulerunt, natantia, terrestria et ae%28rea. Quandoquidem iam in marinis &10pinae et satellitis eius aequitas in societate manifesta est; contubernium &10enim commune cibi habent et aequaliter eum distribuunt. Idem facere &10et trochilum ac pompilum in confesso est apud omnes, qui minores iis &10comperiuntur in vita communi. Inter volucres autem vel ipsam supremam &10iustitiam ciconia demonstrat, parentes nutriens, et statim ut alata fuerit, &10nullum aliud opus sibi proponens, antequam gratias retribuat et benefa-&10cientibus sibi vices reddat. Verum hoc pariter et terrestrium aliqua agere &10persuasum est. __Aequum est quidem non nonnullis, sed universis &10partibus mundum compositum esse; verum partem eam, in quam cadit &10iustitia et iniustitia, illam omnino praeditam etiam ratione; utraque enim &10ad rationem pertinet. &10@Cicero de nat. deor. II 123. Pina vero__duabus grandibus &10patula conchis cum parva squilla quasi societatem coit comparandi cibi, &10itaque cum pisciculi parvi in concham hiantem innataverunt, tum admo-&10nita squillae morsu pina comprimit conchas. Sic dissimillimis bestiolis &10communiter cibus quaeritur. 124 In quo admirandum est, congressune &10aliquo inter se an iam inde ab ortu natura ipsa congregatae sint. @&Athenaeus Deipnosoph. III p. 89d.$8 <20*XRU/SIPPOS D' O( *SO-LEU\S>20 E)N TW=| PE/MPTW| <20PERI\ TOU= KALOU= KAI\ TH=S H(DONH=S "1H( PI/NNH, FHSI/, KAI\ O( PINNOTH/RHS SUNERGA\ A)LLH/LOIS, KAT' I)DI/AN OU) DUNA/-MENA SUMME/NEIN. H( ME\N OU)=N PI/NNH O)/STREO/N E)STIN, O( DE\ PINNO-TH/RHS KARKI/NOS MIKRO/S. KAI\ H( PI/NNH DIASTH/SATO TO\ O)/STRAKON @1 H(SUXA/ZEI THROU=SA TA\ E)PEISIO/NTA I)XQU/DIA, O( DE\ PINNOTH/RHS PARESTW/S, O(/TAN EI)SE/LQH| TI, DA/KNEI AU)TH\N W(/SPER SHMAI/NWN, H( DE\ DHXQEI=SA SUMMU/EI: KAI\ OU(/TWS TO\ A)POLHFQE\N E)/NDON KATE-SQI/OUSI KOINH=|>20"2. @&10Plutarchus$10 PO/TERA TW=N ZW/|WN FRONIMW/TERA&10 cp 3o p. 98oa.$10 A)LLA\ MA=LLON E)PI\ TA\S KAT' I)DI/AN KOINWNI/AS AU)TW=N KAI\ SUMBIW/SEIS I)TE/ON [1&10sc.$10 ZW/|WN]1. W(=N E)STI KAI\ O( TO\ PLEI=STON E)CANALW/SAS <20*XRUSI/PPOU>20 ME/LAN PIN-NOTH/RAS, PANTI\ KAI\ <20FUSIKW=| BIBLI/W| KAI\ H)QIKW=|>20 PROEDRI/AN E)/XWN: TO\N GA\R SPOGGOTH/RAN OU)X I(STO/RHKEN, OU) GA\R A)\N PARE/LIPEN. O( ME\N OU)=N PINNOTH/RAS ZW=|O/N E)STI KARKINW=DES, W(/S FASI, KAI\ TH=| PI/NNH| SU/NESTI KAI\ PULWREI= TH\N KO/GXHN PROKAQH/MENOS E)W=N A)NEW|GME/NHN KAI\ DIAKEXHNUI=AN, A)/XRI OU(= PROSPE/SH| TI TW=N A(LWSI/MWN AU)TOI=S I)XQUDI/WN: TO/TE DE\ TH\N SA/RKA TH=S PI/NNHS DAKW\N PAREISH=LQEN, H( DE\ SUNE/KLEISE TH\N KO/GXHN, KAI\ KOINW=S TH\N A)/GRAN E)NTO\S E(/RKOUS GENOME/NHN KATESQI/OUSI. @&10Philo de animalibus adv. Alexandrum p. 169 Aucher. quae &10vero dicuntur de pina et satellite eius, communem societatem demonstrant. &10__Quisquis autem haesitat, discat ex arboribus plantisque. __ &10Hae enim etsi nullam habeant animae partem, tamen familiaritatis abalie-&10nationisque non minorem praeferunt manifestationem. Moventur et crescunt &10atque tamquam osculo dilectionis salutando amplectuntur se invicem, ut &10olivam hedera et ulmum vitis; aliquas tamen non solum aversatur [1vitis]1, &10verum etiam evitat. ___<21Sed neminem arbitror adeo insanire, &10ut audeat dicere, haec ex fidelis amicitiae aut hostilitatis &10animo oriri, sed supremae naturae ratione quaedam in unum &10adducuntur, alia disiunguntur, haud sibi invicem convenientia>21. &10Hoc itaque tenore existimo falsum esse animalia mortalia quaeque praeter &10hominem contrarietatem societatemque et quae ad istas referuntur ratio-&10nali cum harmonia prae se ferre. Haec enim omnia ratione et mente &10solent conciliari; similitudines vero et tamquam imagines in animalibus &10delineari contigit; et speciem contemptus vel honoris, studii, gratiarum &10actionis et consimilium rerum exhibent aliqua subobscura delineamenta &10impressa, quae non pertinent ad veritatem; quandoquidem propriae, certae &10et solidae formae in animis sunt hominum. &10@Philo de animalibus adv. Alexandrum p. 163 Aucher. Con-&10sidera__utrum apes et araneae, puta quod textrices istae sint, illae &10favum mellis creabunt, iuxta artisne industriam ingeniosam [1id faciant]1, &10aut absque ratione per actionem naturalem. Siquidem horum omnino, si &10oportet verum fateri, admirabilis habenda diligentia, <21quae tamen non &10a disciplina deducta est. Ad quid enim disciplina, quam non &10praecedet comprehensio scientiae, quae oportet esse artium prin-&10cipium? quoniam ars est collectio concordantium conceptorum>21. &10@Philo de animalibus adv. Alexandrum p. 163 Aucher. Volucres &10solent per ae%28rem volare, aquatilia natare et gradi terrestria. An id per &10studium doctrinae? Minime; sed suapte natura singula memorata haec &10agunt. Similiter et apes sine doctrina naturaliter favum peragunt, et @1 &10araneae quasi per se edoctae subtilem illam elaborationem textorum mo-&10liuntur. Siquis autem aliter putat, adeat arbores, et perspiciens videbit &10cuiusque dotes clarissimas, quia et in istis multa sunt absque arte arti-&10ficiosa. Vitem non vides, dum in diebus vernalibus germen producit? &10Primum enim foliis illud operit, deinde more matris paulatim nutrit, et &10id augmentum ducit; postmodum remutans ex acido uvam efficit, donec &10omnino maturet fructum. At instructane his fuit cura adhibita? <21Certe &10omnino per mirabilem operique praesidentem naturam par fuit &10non solum utilissimo fructui ferendo, verum etiam adornando &10trunco decore>21. ___Dicimus enim et de invisibilibus naturis, quod, &10cum ordinatae et artificiosae sint, integrum servant esse rationales, etiam &10illa, quae omnino carent anima. Revera tamen non ista dantur, et in &10praedictis animalibus. Cuncta enim peragunt non provida curatione ac &10consilio, sed secundum irrevocabilem operationem eliciunt ex propria con-&10structione proprietates naturales. p. 165. Haud consulto__scorpio at-&10tollens aculeum dimovet, ac si per electionem statuerit debere ulcisci eum, &10qui iam injuriam sibi fecerit. __Item comparatio victus et morborum &10curatio et his similia iterum sunt naturae inventiones innatae animalibus &10invisibili virtute. Et haec omnia possident, ut salva se servent et ut &10vindicent se ab invasoribus. &10@Philo de animalibus adv. Alexandrum p. 168 Aucher. Quodsi &10censeas alia [1scil. bruta animalia]1 praedita esse oeconomica quadam pru-&10dentia, ut formica et apis, cum nemo istarum tamen politica gaudeat, &10concedas oportet posse falsum esse in specie, quod verum sit in genere &10sub quo cadit. Ut puto, non ignoras, quod <21eorum est oeconomia, &10quorum et politice; unius enim utraque virtutis proles, etsi &10sub specie pares, impares tamen magnitudine, ut domus et ci-&10vitas. Atqui deest iis politice, neque ergo dispensatio dicenda &10est de illis>21. &10@"1At quid quis dicere potest, inquies, cum antea collectione facta con-&10dit in thesauros formica et horrea sibi prius parat? His utilius in opus &10exit apis et collectis floribus alvearique pulchre constructo mirifice mel &10facit."2 Ita quidem ego etiam dico. Dico tamen haec providentiae, non &10animalium ratione carentium, sed eius qui universam moderatur naturam &10esse tribuenda. Illud enim [1animal]1 nihil agit intellectu. Isti vero [1deo]1 &10cura est variis de rebus; ut nimirum, sicut Creator, impetum singularum &10creaturarum constringit ac corroborat ad id, propter quod factae sunt, &10sive ad eam quae singulis convenit perfectionem. &10@Philo de animalibus adv. Alexandrum p. 171 Aucher. Hactenus &10satis locuti de ratione existente in intellectu, locutionem nunc examinemus. &10Siquidem merulae et corvi et psittaci et consimiles, etsi varie vocem pro-&10ferant, articulatum tamen nunquam et nullo modo vocabulum pronuntiare ޅ&10queunt. Sed puto quod quemadmodum in instrumentis musicis foramina &10quamvis habeant portionem veritatis constantis, non tamen rationales so-&10nitus sunt constantes, sed forma carentes et consequenter nihil manifeste &10exponere possunt, ita et praedictorum animantium voces sunt significatione @1 &10carentes et deformes, veritatem formae sermonis non vocabuli modo ex-&10primentes, sed per cantilenam etc. &10@Alexander Aphrod. de mixtione p. 233, 14 Bruns.$10 E)PEI\ DE\ PRO\S KATASKEUH\N TOU= SW=MA DIA\ SW/MATOS XWREI=N XRW=NTAI KAI\ TAI=S TW=N ZW/|WN DIA\ TH=S TROFH=S AU)CH/SESIN_H( GA\R AU)/CHSIS TH=| PROSQH/KH| TH=S TROFH=S [2GI/NETAI: W(/STE EI)]2 PA/NTH| [KAI\] AU)/CETAI TA\ AU)CANO/MENA, PA/NTH| A)\N H( TROFH\ PROSKRI/-NOITO TW=| PROUPA/RXONTI SW/MATI. OU)X OI(=O/N TE DE\ PA/NTH| PROSKRIQH=NAI TH\N MH\ DIA\ PANTO/S TE KAI\ PRO\S PA=N E)NEXQEI=SAN: A)LL' EI) DIA\ PANTO\S H( TROFH\ TOU= SW/MATOS FE/RETAI, SW=MA OU)=SA, A)NAGKAI=ON EI)=NAI DO/CEI, SW=MA DIA\ SW/MATOS XWREI=N, EI)/GE MO/NWS OU(/TWS OI(=O/N TE TH\N E)K TH=S TROFH=S PROSQH/KHN PANTI\ TW=| TREFOME/NW| GI/NESQAI SW/MATI_O(/TI OU)=N MH\ OU(/TWS TO\ TRE/FESQAI/ TE KAI\ AU)/-CESQAI GI/NETAI [1OU)DE\N GA\R TW=N A)DUNA/TWN GI/NETAI]1 FE/RE [2PARASTH/SW]2 E)KQE/-MENOS TH\N *)ARISTOTE/LOUS DO/CAN TH\N PERI\ AU)CH/SEW/S TE KAI\ TROFH=S. @&10p. 234, 23.$10 EI)/TE SW/MATI LE/GOITO H( AU)/CHSIS GI/NESQAI PROSTIQEME/NW|, E)/STAI SW=MA/ TE DIA\ SW/MATOS XWROU=N KAI\ GINO/MENON SW/MATI, EI)/GE KAQO\ ME\N AU)/-CETAI/ TI, KATA\ TOU=TO TH\N PROSQH/KHN LAMBA/NEI: KATA\ PA/NTA DE\ TO\ AU)CO/MENON AU)/CETAI: W(/STE KATA\ PA=N KAI\ PROSQH/KHN LH/YETAI. A)LL' EI) SW=MA O)\N KATA\ PA=N E(AUTO\ TH\N PROSQH/KHN LAMBA/NEI, DEH/SEI DIA\ PANTO\S AU)TOU= XWROU=N TO\ PROSTIQE/MENON AU)TW=| [1TOU=TO DE/ E)STIN H( TROFH/]1 TH\N AU)/CHSIN AU)TOU= POIEI=SQAI. EI) GA\R LE/GEI TIS DIA/ TINWN KENW=N GENE/SQAI TH\N DI/ODON TH=S TROFH=S, A)NA/GKH TOU/TW| LE/GEIN PA=N TO\ TREFO/MENON SW=MA EI)=NAI KENO/N, EI) KAQO\ ME\N H( PA/RO-DOS TH=S TROFH=S, KENO\N KATA\ TOU=TO: KATA\ PA/NTA D' AU)TOU= H( PA/RODOS TH=S TRO-FH=S, EI) DH\ KATA\ PA/NTA AU)/CETAI. @&10Galenus de symptomatum causis III 4. Vol. VII p. 227k.$10 O(/SOI D' OU) SUGXWROU=SIN U(PO\ TROFH=S A)LLOIOU=SQAI TA\ TREFO/MENA [1KRATOUME/NOU GA/R, OU) KRATOU=NTOS O)/NOMA U(PA/RXEIN TH\N TROFH/N]1, OU)/TE PERI\ TH=S KATA\ TA\ ZW=|A METABOLH=S OU)/TE POLU\ MA=LLON E)/TI PERI\ TH=S KATA\ TA\ FUTA\ DU/NANTAI LE/GEIN U(GIE\S MHDE/N &10etc. &10@ibid. 228.$10 O(/SOI FA/SKOUSI KRATOUME/NOU KAI\ A)LLOIOUME/NOU KAI\ METABAL-LOME/NOU TH\N TROFH\N U(PA/RXEIN O)/NOMA &10etc. &10@ibid.$10 TO\ ME\N O(MOIOU=N E(AUTW=| TH\N TROFH\N E)/RGON E)STI\ TOU= TREFOME/NOU, TO\ D' O(MOIOU=SQAI/ TE KAI\ METABA/LLESQAI PA/QOS TH=S TROFH=S. @&Plinius Not. Hist. XXV 103.&3 <21Chrysippus>21 philosophus tra-&3didit phryganion adalligatum remedio esse quartanis. quod esset ani-&3mal neque ille descripsit nec nos invenimus qui novisset. demonstran-&3dum tamen fuit a tam gravi auctore dictum, si cuius cura efficacior &3esset inquirendi. @&10Cicero de legibus I 8, 24. Nam cum de natura hominis quae-&10ritur, disputari solet__perpetuis cursibus conversionibus[2que]2 cae- @1&10lestibus exstitisse quandam maturitatem serendi generis humani; quod &10sparsum in terras atque satum divino auctum sit animorum munere. &10@Origenes contra Celsum I 37 Vol. I p. 89, 1 Ko+. [1p. 35 Delarue]1.$10 KAI\ KAT' AU)TOU\S DE\ TOU\S *(/ELLHNAS OU) PA/NTES A)/NQRWPOI E)C A)NDRO\S KAI\ GUNAI-KO\S E)GE/NONTO: <20EI) GA\R GENHTO/S E)STIN O( KO/SMOS>20, W(S KAI\ POLLOI=S *(ELLH/NWN H)/RESEN, <20A)NA/GKH TOU\S PRW/TOUS MH\ E)K SUNOUSI/AS GEGONE/NAI, A)LL' A)PO\ GH=S, SPERMATIKW=N LO/GWN SUSTA/NTWN E)N TH=| GH=|>20. @&10Philo quaest. et solut. in Genesin III 48 [1p. 222 Aucher]1. Porro &10magis naturalius instruit eos, qui se causam generationis existimant, vix &10animum referentes ad videndum genitorem universorum. Ipse enim est &10verus ac verax pater, nos autem, qui genitores dicimur, instrumenta su-&10mus ad serviendum generationi. Quoniam sicut in mira similitudine omnia, &10quae vident, inanimata sunt, quod vero nervos corroborat, invisibile qui-&10dem est, ipsum tamen causa exsistit virtutis motusque visus, simili modo &10ex sempiterno invisibilique spatio <21extendit virtutes conditor univer-&10sorum, nos autem tamquam miracula nervis corroboramur ad &10id, quod ad nos attinet, semen et generationem>21; nisi velimus etiam &10fistulam putare per se flatam esse, non vero ab artifice distributam ad &10harmoniae productionem, qua instrumentum in servitium ac opus necessa-&10rium fuit constructum. @&Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 158.$ SPE/RMA DE\ LE/GOUSIN EI)=NAI TO\ OI(=O/N TE GENNA=N TOIAU=TA A)F' OI(/OU KAI\ AU)TO\ A)PEKRI/QH. A)NQRW/POU DE\ SPE/RMA, O(\ MEQI/HSIN O( A)/NQRWPOS MEQ' U(GROU=, SUGKIRNA=SQAI TOI=S TH=S YUXH=S ME/RESI KATA\ MIGMO\N TOU= TW=N PROGO/NWN LO/GOU. EI)=NAI DE\ AU)TO\ <20*XRU/-SIPPO/S>20 FHSIN <20E)N TH=| DEUTE/RA| TW=N FUSIKW=N>20 PNEU=MA KATA\ TH\N OU)-SI/AN, W(S DH=LON E)K TW=N EI)S TH\N GH=N KATABALLOME/NWN SPERMA/TWN, A(\ PALAIWQE/NTA OU)KE/TI FU/ETAI, W(S DH=LON DIAPEPNEUKUI/AS AU)TOI=S TH=S DU-NA/MEWS. @&10Galenus defin. medicae 94 Vol. XIX p. 370 K.$10 SPE/RMA E)STI\ PNEU=MA E)/NQERMON E)N U(GRW=| E)C E(AUTOU= KINOU/MENON KAI\ DUNA/MENON TOIOU=TON GENNA=N OI(=ON A)F' OU(= KAI\ A)FEI/QH. __O( DE\ <20*KITIEU\S *ZH/NWN>20 OU(/TWS W(RI/-SATO: SPE/RMA E)STI\N A)NQRW/POU O(\ MEQI/HSIN A)/NQRWPOS MEQ' U(GROU= YUXH=S ME/-ROUS A(/RPAGMA KAI\ SU/MMIGMA TOU= TW=N PROGO/NWN GE/NOUS, OI(=O/N TE AU)TO\ H)=N KAI\ AU)TO\ SUMMIXQE\N A)PEKRI/QH. @&10ibid. 439.$10 TO\ SPE/RMA E)STI\N <20KATA\ ME\N TOU\S *STWI+KOU\S>20 O(\ MEQI/HSI TO\ ZW=|ON U(GRO\N META\ PNEU/MATOS KAI\ YUXH=S, W(S DE\ OU) ME/ROS. @&10Galenus de foet. format. 6. K. IV 699 ed. Bas. I 221.$10 MA/LISTA D' A)/N TIS QAUMA/SEIE TH\N PRO\S TOU\S GENNH/SANTAS O(MOIO/THTA TW=N E)KGO/NWN, O(/PWS GI/GNETAI: FAI/NETAI GA\R PA/LIN H( DIAPLA/TTOUSA TO\ SW=MA YUXH\ PARA\ TW=N GONE/WN EI)S TO\ KUOU/MENON H(/KEIN, W(S E)N TW=| SPE/RMATI PERIEXOME/NH. __ *KAI\ POU/ TINES AU)TW=N OU)X U(/LHN A)LL' O)/RGANON U(PA/RXEIN AU)TH=S TO\ SPE/RMA FASI/N, U(/LHN GA\R EI)=NAI TO\ TH=S MHTRO\S AI(=MA, LEGO/NTWN <20E(TE/RWN>20 [1&10scil.$10 TW=N @1 *STWI+KW=N]1 TA)NANTI/A: DOKEI= GA\R AU)TOI=S O( TEXNI/THS AU)TO\S EI)=NAI TO\ SPE/RMA, TISI\ ME\N O(/LON, E)NI/OIS DE\ TO\ PERIEXO/MENON E)N AU)TW=| PNEU=MA. KAI/ MOI PERI\ TOU/TWN I)DI/A| GE/GRAPTAI KATA/ TI BIBLI/ON, E)N W(=| PERI\ TW=N U(PO\ <20*XRUSI/PPOU>20 LEGOME/NWN <20E)N TOI=S PERI\ YUXH=S>20 AU)TOU= GRA/MMASIN E)PISKE/PTOMAI. @&10Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 35 p. 1077b.$10 H(=| KAI/ FASIN [1&10scil. &10Stoici$10]1 TO\ ME\N SPE/RMA [2DIA\]2 TH\N E)PI\ MIKRO\N O)/GKON E)K POLLOU= "3SPEI/RASIN"3 W)NOMA/SQAI, TH\N DE\ "3FU/SIN"3 E)MFU/SHSIN OU)=SAN KAI\ DIA/XUSIN TW=N U(P' AU)TH=S A)NOIGOME/NWN KAI\ LUOME/NWN LO/GWN H)\ A)RIQMW=N. @&10Philo de mundi opificio %14 67 Vol. I p. 22, 13 Wendl.$10 *TO\ SPE/RMA TW=N ZW/|WN GENE/SEWS A)RXH\N EI)=NAI SUMBE/BHKE. *TOU=TO W(S E)/STI FAULO/TATON, E)OI-KO\S A)FRW=| QEWREI=TAI: A)LL' O(/TAN EI)S TH\N MH/TRAN KATABLHQE\N E)NSTHRI/SH|, KI/NHSIN EU)QU\S LABO\N EI)S FU/SIN TRE/PETAI. *FU/SIS DE\ BELTI/WN SPE/RMATOS, E)PEI\ KAI\ KI/NHSIS H)REMI/AS E)N GENHTOI=S. *(H DE\ OI(=A TEXNI/THS H)\ KURIW/TERON EI)PEI=N A)NEPI/-LHPTOS TE/XNH ZW|OPLASTEI= TH\N ME\N U(GRA\N OU)SI/AN EI)S TA\ TOU= SW/MATOS ME/LH KAI\ ME/RH DIANE/MOUSA, TH\N DE\ PNEUMATIKH\N EI)S TA\S TH=S YUXH=S DUNA/MEIS, TH/N TE QREPTIKH\N KAI\ TH\N AI)SQHTIKH/N. @&10Origenes in evang. Ioannis XX 2.$10 *KAI\ SAFE/S GE O(/TI TO\ ME\N SPE/RMA [TINA\S] E)/XEI TOU\S LO/GOUS TOU= SPEI/RANTOS E)N E(AUTW=|, E)/TI H(SUXA/ZONTAS KAI\ A)POKEIME/NOUS: TO\ DE\ TE/KNON, METABALO/NTOS TOU= SPE/RMATOS KAI\ E)RGASAME/NOU TH\N PARAKEIME/NHN AU)TW=| U(/LHN, A)PO\ TH=S GUNAIKO\S KAI\ TW=N E)PISUNAGOME/NWN TROFW=N MORFWQE\N KAI\ EI)S GE/NESIN EU)TREPISQE\N U(FI/STATAI. @&10Origenes in evang. Ioannis XX 5.$10 *(\O DE\ LE/GW E)/STAI SAFE\S E)K TW=N LEXQHSOME/NWN: E)PEI\ GA\R E)/XEI E)N E(AUTW=| PROGONIKOU/S TE KAI\ SUGGENIKOU\S LO/GOUS O( SPEI/RWN, O(TE\ ME\N KRATEI= O( AU)TOU= LO/GOS KAI\ A)POTI/KTETAI TO\ GEN-NW/MENON TW=| SPEI/RANTI O(/MOION, O(TE\ DE\ O( LO/GOS TOU= A)DELFOU= TOU= SPEI/RANTOS H)\ TOU= PATRO\S TOU= SPEI/RANTOS H)\ TOU= QEI/OU TOU= SPEI/RANTOS, E)NI/OTE KAI\ PA/PPOU TOU= SPEI/RANTOS: PAR' O(\ GI/NONTAI OI( A)POTIKTO/MENOI O(/MOIOI TOI=SDE H)\ TOI=SDE. *)/ESTI DE\ I)DEI=N E)PIKRATOU=NTA KAI\ TO\N LO/GON TH=S GUNAIKO\S H)\ TOU= A)DELFOU= AU)-TH=S H)\ TOU= PA/PPOU AU)TH=S, KATA\ TOU\S E)N TAI=S MI/CESI BRASMOU\S A(/MA PA/NTWN SEIOME/NWN E(/WS E)PIKRATH/SH| TIS TW=N SPERMATIKW=N LO/GWN. @&Scholia in Hom. Iliad.$ *F& 483.$ E)PEIDH\ KATA\ ME\N TA\S PAN-SELH/NOUS NU/KTAS, W(/S FHSI <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20, EU)TOKW/TATAI GI/NONTAI AI( GU-NAI=KES, KATA\ DE\ SKOTOMHNI/AS DU/STOKOI A)/GAN. @&Scholia Genevensia I p. 210 Nicole.$ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 E)N <20TW=| PERI\ A)RXAI/AS FUSIKH=S>20 DEIKNU\S O(/TI SELH/NH H( *)/ARTEMIS KAI\ TA\ PERI\ TO/KOUS DE\ EI)S AU)TH\N [2A)NAFE/RWN, LE/GEI E)N]2 TAI=S PANSELH/NOIS OU) MO/NON TA\S GUNAI=KAS EU)TOKWTA/TAS EI)=NAI, A)LLA\ GI/GNESQAI [2R(A|DI/WS TA\ ZW=|A]2 PA/NTA. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. V 11, 3.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 A)PO\ TOU= SW/MATOS O(/LOU KAI\ TH=S YUXH=S FE/RESQAI TO\ SPE/RMA KAI\ TH=S O(MOIO/THTOS A)NAPLA/TTESQAI E)K TW=N @1 AU)TW=N GENW=N TOU\S TU/POUS KAI\ TOU\S XARAKTH=RAS, W(/SPER A)\N EI) ZW|GRA/FON A)PO\ TW=N O(MOI/WN XRWMA/TWN EI)KO/NA TOU= BLEPOME/NOU. @&10`4.$10 *PROI/+ESQAI DE\ KAI\ TH\N GUNAI=KA SPE/RMA: KA)\N ME\N E)PIKRATH/SH| TO\ TH=S GUNAIKO/S, O(/MOION EI)=NAI TO\ GENNW/MENON TH=| MHTRI/, E)A\N DE\ TO\ TOU= A)NDRO\S TW=| PATRI/. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. V 10, 4$10 [1*PW=S DI/DUMA KAI\ TRI/DUMA GI/NETAI &10G 114]1.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 PARA\ TOU\S E)N TH=| MH/TRA| TO/POUS, O(/TAN GA\R EI)S PRW=TON KAI\ DEU/-TERON E)MPE/SH| SPE/RMA, TO/TE GI/NESQAI TA\S E)PISULLH/YEIS KAI\ TA\ DI/DUMA KAI\ TA\ TRI/DUMA. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. V 9, 2$10 [1*DIA\ TI/ POLLA/KIS GUNH\ SUNOUSIA/ZOUSA OU) SULLAMBA/NEI]1 &10G. 113.$10 <20*OI( DE\ *STWI+KOI\>20 KATA\ LOCO/THTA TOU= KAULOU= MH\ DUNA-ME/NOU TO\N GO/NON EU)QUBOLEI=N H)\ PARA\ TO\ A)SU/MMETRON TW=N MORI/WN, W(S PRO\S TH\N A)PO/STASIN TH=S MH/TRAS. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. V 13, 3$10 [1*PW=S STEI=RAI GI/NONTAI AI( GUNAI=KES KAI\ A)/GO-NOI OI( A)/NDRES]1. <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 AI)TIW=NTAI TA\S A)SUMFU/LOUS EI)S E(KA/TERON TW=N PLHSIAZO/NTWN DUNA/MEIS TE KAI\ POIO/THTAS, OI(=S O(/TAN SUMBH=| XWRISQH=NAI ME\N A)P' A)LLH/LWN, SUNELQEI=N DE\ E(TE/ROIS O(MOFU/LOIS, SUNEKRA/QH TO\ KATA\ FU/SIN KAI\ BRE/FOS TELESIOURGEI=TAI. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. V 12, 3$10 [1*PW=S A)/LLOIS GI/NONTAI O(/MOIOI OI( GENNW/MENOI KAI\ OU) TOI=S GONEU=SIN]1. <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 SUMPAQEI/A| TH=S DIANOI/AS. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. V 16, 2$10 [1*PW=S TRE/FETAI TA\ E)/MBRUA &10G. 120$10]1. <20*OI( *STWI+-KOI\>20 DIA\ TOU= XORI/OU KAI\ TOU= O)MFALOU=. O(/QEN TOU=TON EU)QE/WS A)PODEI=N TA\S MAIOUME/NAS KAI\ A)NEURU/NEIN TO\ STO/MA, I(/NA E(TE/RA GE/NHTAI H( MELE/TH TH=S TROFH=S. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. V 17, 1.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 A(/MA O(/LON GI/GNESQAI [1&10scil.$10 TO\ E)/MBRUON]1. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. V 15, 2.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 ME/ROS EI)=NAI AU)TO\ [1&10scil.$10 TO\ E)/MBRUON]1 TH=S GASTRO/S, OU) ZW=|ON: W(/SPER GA\R TOU\S KARPOU\S ME/RH TW=N FUTW=N O)/NTAS PEPAINOME/NOUS A)POR)R(EI=N, OU(/TW KAI\ TO\ E)/MBRUON. @&10Galenus defin. medicae 445 Vol. XIX p. 452 K.$10 OI( DE\ MH\ EI)=NAI ZW=|ON LE/GONTES [1&10scil.$10 TO\ E)/MBRUON]1 TRE/FESQAI ME\N AU)TO\ KAI\ AU)/CESQAI W(/SPER KAI\ TA\ DE/NDRA, O(RMH\N DE\ KAI\ A)FORMH\N OU)K E)/XEIN W(/SPER TA\ ZW=|A. @[&10Galenus$10] EI) ZW=|ON TO\ KATA\ GASTRO/S&10 2 vol. XIX p. 165 K.$10 MO/RION GA\R KAI\ A)PO/SPASMA O)\N TOU= MEGA/LOU ZW/|OU TOU= KO/SMOU ME/NON ME\N E)N MUXOI=S KAI\ FWLEU=ON SUGKRI/SEWS E)PE/XEI LO/GON, DIAKRIQE\N DE\ KAI\ GENO/MENON E)/CW TOU/-TOU TOU= BA/QOUS OI(=ON XA/OUS A)SPA/ZETAI TH\N O(MO/FULON KAI\ O(MOI/AN FU/SIN TAI=S TH=S E)NERGEI/AS PRA/CESIN: KINEI=SQAI GA\R TAI=S E)C AU)TOU= KINH/SESIN A)/RXETAI. @&10Philo de fortitudine p. 398 Vol. II. Mang.$10 *EI) GA\R TA\ FUTW=N TRO/PON E)MPERIAUCANO/MENA KAI\ ME/RH NOMIZO/MENA TW=N KUOU/NTWN, NU=N ME\N H(NW-ME/NA, MHNW=N DE\ PERIO/DOIS AU)=QIS A)POSPASQHSO/MENA TH=S SUMFUI/+AS_FULA/T-TETAI &10etc. &10@Philo de fuga et inventione %14 13 Vol. III p. 112, 15 Wendl.$10 *TO\ GA\R GENO/MENON ZW=|ON A)TELE\S ME/N E)STI TW=| POSW=|: MA/RTURES D' AI( KAQ' H(LIKI/AN E(KA/STHN PARAUCH/SEIS: TE/LEION DE\ TW=| POIW=|: ME/NEI GA\R H( AU)TH\ POIO/THS, A(/TE A)PO\ ME/NONTOS E)KMAGEI=SA KAI\ MHDAMH= TREPOME/NOU QEI/OU LO/GOU. @1 @&Galenus de foet. format. 4 K. IV 674. ed Bas. I 217.$ *TI/ POT' OU)=N E)/DOCE <20*XRUSI/PPW|>20 KAI\ A)/LLOIS POLLOI=S FILOSO/FOIS <20*STWI+KOI=S>20 TE KAI\ *PERIPATHTIKOI=S A)POFH/NASQAI PERI\ KARDI/AS, W(S PRW/TH TE FU/ETAI TW=N TOU= ZW/OU MORI/WN, U(P' AU)TH=S TE TA)/LLA GI/GNOITO, KAI\ W(S TW=| PRW/-TWS DIAPLASQE/NTI KAI\ FLEBW=N KAI\ NEU/RWN A)NAGKAI=ON U(PA/RXEIN A)RXH/N; @&ibid. K. 677.$ OI( DE/ GE A)POFHNA/MENOI TH\N KARDI/AN PRW/THN DIA-PEPLA/SQAI, MH/TE FAINO/MENON E)C A)NATOMH=S E)/XONTES EI)PEI=N, E)C OU(= TH\N A)RXH\N TH=S EU(RE/SEWS E)POIH/SANTO, MH/TE LOGIKH/N TINA A)PO/DEICIN A)/LLHN, E(TE/RAN A)F' E(TE/RAS SUNA/PTOUSIN A)/GNOIAN, U(PO\ TH=S KARDI/AS TA)/LLA GEGO-NE/NAI FA/SKONTES, EI)=NAI/ TE TAU/THN, W(/SPER TH=S GENE/SEWS AU)TW=N, OU(/TW KAI\ TH=S DIOIKH/SEWS H(GEMO/NA. @&ibid. 6. K. 698. ed. Bas. I 221.$ PRW/THN_U(PO/QESIN__U(PO-TI/QENTAI, TH\N KARDI/AN A(PA/NTWN PRW/THN GI/GNESQAI LE/GONTES: DEUTE/RAN D' E)PI\ TH=|DE, TA)/LLA MO/RIA DIAPLA/TTEIN E)KEI/NHN, W(S A)POLLUME/NOU TOU= DIAPLA/SANTOS AU)TH\N KAI\ MHKE/T' O)/NTOS: EI)=T' E)FECH=S W(S A)KO/LOUQON E)PI-FE/RONTES, O(/TI KAI\ TO\ BOULEUO/MENON H(MW=N ME/ROS TH=S YUXH=S E)N TAU/TH| KAQE/STHKEN: EI) DE\ TO\ BOULEUO/MENON KAI\ [2TO\]2 TW=N SITI/WN, W(/S FASIN, KAI\ POMA/TWN KAI\ A)FRODISI/WN KAI\ XRHMA/TWN E)PIQUMOU=N, KAI\ DHLADH\ KAI\ TO\ QUMOU/MENON KAI\ FILONEIKOU=N &etc. &@Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 44 p. 1083a.$ *(O TOI/NUN <20PERI\ AU)CH/SEWS LO/GOS>20 E)STI\ ME\N A)RXAI=OS: H)RW/THTAI GA/R, <20W(/S FHSI *XRU/-SIPPOS>20, U(PO\ *)EPIXA/RMOU: TW=N D' E)N *)AKADHMEI/A| OI)OME/NWN, MH\ PA/NU R(A/|DION MHD' AU)TO/QEN E(/TOIMON EI)=NAI TH\N A)PORI/AN__KATEBO/HSAN, W(S TA\S PROLH/YEIS A)NAIROU/NTWN. __&p. 1083c.$ *OU(/TW DE/ PWS TOU/-TWN LEGOME/NWN KAI\ TIQEME/NWN [1&praecedit Academicorum sententia$ PERI\ AU)CH/SEWS]1 TI/ A)CIOU=SIN OI( PRO/DIKOI TH=S E)NARGEI/AS OU(=TOI KAI\ KANO/NES TW=N E)NNOIW=N; <20*(/EKASTON H(MW=N DI/DUMON EI)=NAI KAI\ DIFUA= KAI\ DITTO/N__DU/O SW/MATA TAU)TO\N E)/XONTA XRW=MA, TAU)TO\N DE\ SXH=MA, TAU)TO\N DE\ BA/ROS KAI\ TO/PON [2TO\N AU)TO/N, KAI\ TAU=Q']2 U(PO\ MHDENO\S A)NQRW/PWN O(RW/MENA PRO/TERON__W(S DU/O H(MW=N E(/KASTO/S E)STIN U(POKEI/MENA, TO\ ME\N OU)SI/A, TO\ DE\ [2POIO/-THS]2: KAI\ TO\ ME\N A)EI\ R(EI= KAI\ FE/RETAI, MH/T' AU)CO/MENON MH/TE MEIOU/MENON, MH/TE O(/LWS OI(=O/N E)STI DIAME/NON, TO\ DE\ DIAME/NEI KAI\ AU)CA/NETAI KAI\ MEIOU=TAI KAI\ PA/NTA PA/SXEI TA)NANTI/A QA-TE/RW|, SUMPEFUKO\S KAI\ SUNHRMOSME/NON KAI\ SUGKEXUME/NON, KAI\ TH=S DIAFORA=S TH=| AI)SQH/SEI MHDAMOU= PARE/XON A(/YASQAI.>20 @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 29 p. 1047b.$8 <20*)EN DE\ TAI=S FUSIKAI=S *QE/SESI>20 PERI\ TW=N E)MPEIRI/AS KAI\ I(STORI/AS DEOME/NWN DIAKELEU- @1SA/MENOS TH\N H(SUXI/AN E)/XEIN, A)\N MH/TI KREI=TTON KAI\ E)NARGE/STERON E)/XWMEN LE/GEIN "1<20I(/NA, FHSI/, MH/TE *PLA/TWNI PARAPLHSI/WS U(PONOH/SWMEN, TH\N ME\N U(GRA\N TROFH\N EI)S TO\N PLEU/MONA FE/RESQAI, TH\N DE\ CHRA\N EI)S TH\N KOILI/AN, MH/TE E(/TERA PARAPLH/SIA GEGONO/TA TOU/-TOIS DIAPTW/MATA>20."2 @&10Ae%28tius Plac. V 23, 1.$10 *(HRA/KLEITOS KAI\ <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 A)/RXESQAI TOU\S A)NQRW/POUS TH=S TELEIO/THTOS PERI\ TH\N DEUTE/RAN E(BDOMA/DA, PERI\ H(\N O( SPERMATIKO\S KINEI=TAI O)R)R(O/S. KAI\ GA\R TA\ DE/NDRA A)/RXETAI TO/TE TELEIO/THTOS, O(/TAN A)/RXHTAI GENNA=N TA\ SPE/RMATA, A)TELH= DE/ E)STIN A)/WRA KAI\ A)/KARPA O)/NTA: TE/LEIOS OU)=N TO/TE A)/NQRWPOS: PERI\ DE\ TH\N DEUTE/RAN E(BDOMA/DA E)/NNOIA GI/NETAI KALOU= TE KAI\ KAKOU= KAI\ TH=S DIDASKALI/AS AU)TW=N. @&10Galenus de usu respirationis toto libro probare studet,$10 O(/TI H( A)NAPNOH\ GI/NETAI DIA\ YU/CIN TINA\ TH=S E)MFU/TOU QERMASI/AS. @&10Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 158.$10 TO\N DE\ U(/PNON GI/NESQAI E)KLUOME/NOU TOU= AI)SQHTIKOU= TO/NOU PERI\ TO\ H(GEMONIKO/N. AI)TI/AS DE\ TW=N PAQW=N A)POLEI/POUSI TA\S PERI\ TO\ PNEU=MA TROPA/S. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. V 24, 4.$10 *PLA/TWN <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 TO\N ME\N U(/PNON GI/-NESQAI A)NE/SEI TOU= AI)SQHTIKOU= PNEU/MATOS, OU) KATA\ A)NAXALASMO\N KAQA/PER % E)PI\ TH=S GH=S, FEROME/NOU DE\ W(S E)PI\ TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N MESO/FRUON: O(/TAN DE\ PANTELH\S GE/NHTAI H( A)/NESIS TOU= AI)SQHTIKOU= PNEU/MATOS, TO/TE GI/GNESQAI QA/NATON. @&10Tertullianus de anima cp. 43. <21Stoici>21 somnum resolutionem &10sensualis vigoris affirmant etc. &10@ibid. __si forte cum <21Stoicis>21 resolutionem sensualis vigoris som-&10num determinemus. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. V 30, 5.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 SUMFW/NWS [1&10scil.$10 TW=| *PARME-NI/DH|]1 TO\ GH=RAS GI/GNESQAI DIA\ TH\N TOU= QERMOU= E)/LLEIYIN. OI( GA\R AU)TW=N PLE/ON E)/XONTES TO\ QERMO\N E)PI\ PLEI=ON GHRW=SIN. @&10Galenus de temperamentis l. I cp. 3 [1K. Vol. I p. 523$10]1. A)LL' EI)/PER O( QA/NATOS, FASI\ [1&10scil.$10 OI( A)P' *)AQHNAI/OU TOU= *)ATTALE/WS]1, TOIOU=TOS [1&10scil.$10 YUXRO\S KAI\ CHRO/S]1, A)NAGKAI=ON H)/DH TH\N ZWH/N, W(S A)\N E)NANTI/AN U(PA/RXOUSAN AU)TW=|, QERMH/N TE EI)=NAI KAI\ U(GRA/N: KAI\ MH\N EI)/PER H( ZWH/, FASI, QERMO/N TI XRH=MA KAI\ U(GRO/N E)STIN, A)NA/GKH PA=SA KAI\ TH\N O(MOIOTA/THN AU)TH=| KRA=SIN A)RI/STHN U(PA/RXEIN, EI) DE\ TOU=TO, PANTI/ POU DH=LON W(S EU)KRATOTA/THN. W(/ST' EI)S TAU)TO\ SUMBAI/NEIN U(GRA\N KAI\ QERMH\N FU/SIN EU)KRA/TW|, KAI\ MHDE\N A)/LLO EI)=NAI TH\N EU)-KRASI/AN H)\ TH=S U(GRO/THTO/S TE KAI\ QERMO/THTOS E)PIKRATOU/SHS. OI( ME\N DH\ TW=N A)MFI\ TO\N *)AQH/NAION LO/GOI TOIOI/DE. DOKEI= DE/ PWS H( AU)TH\ DO/CA KAI\ *)ARISTO-TE/LOUS EI)=NAI TOU= FILOSO/FOU KAI\ *QEOFRA/STOU GE MET' AU)TO\N KAI\ <20TW=N *STWI+KW=N>20. @&10Galenus adv. Iulianum 4 Vol. XVIII A p. 259.$10 OU)DE\N A)\N EU(/ROIS OU)/T' *)ARISTOTE/LOUS OU)/TE *QEOFRA/STOU BIBLI/ON, E)N W(=|, PERI\ NOSHMA/TWN A)NAGKA-SQE/NTES EI)PEI=N TI, [2A)/NEU TOU=]2 QERMOU= KAI\ YUXROU= KAI\ U(GROU= KAI\ CHROU= MNHMONEU=SAI DIH=LQON TO\N LO/GON, A)LLA\ KAI\ TOU/TWN A)EI\ ME/MNHNTAI KAI\ SU\N @1 AU)TOI=S POLLA/KIS E(KATE/RAS TH=S XOLH=S, MELAI/NHS TE KAI\ CANQH=S, OU)K O)LIGA/KIS DE\ KAI\ FLE/GMATOS, OI(/ GE TA\S DIAFORA\S AU)TW=N DIE/RXONTAI, TO\ ME\N O)CU/, TO\ D' A(LMURO\N H)\ A(LUKO/N, A)/LLO DE\ GLUKU\ PROSAGOREU/ONTES. <20OU) MH\N OU)DE\ *XRU/-SIPPOS E(TE/RWS, A)LL' OU(/TWS A)EI\ KAI\ PERI\ NOSHMA/TWN KAI\ PERI\ TW=N XUMW=N DIALE/GETAI>20. [2KAI\]2 EI)/ TIS E)QE/LOI MO/NWN TW=N EI)RHME/NWN TRIW=N A)N-DRW=N E)KLE/GEIN TA\S R(H/SEIS, OU)K O)LI/GA PLHRW/SEI BIBLI/A, SXOLA/ZWN DH\ OU(/TWS TIS W(/SPER *)IOULIANO\S E)PI\ TH=S *)ALECANDREI/AS E)SXO/LAZEN. E)A\N DE\ KAI\ TW=N A)/L-LWN, <20TW=N *STWI+KW=N>20 H)\ *PERIPATHTIKW=N E)KLE/GEIN TA\S R(H/SEIS, O(/LHN BIBLIOQH/KHN PLHRW/SEI. @&10Galenus de morborum causis 1 Vol. VII p. 1 K.$10 E)DEI/XQH <20KATA\ ME\N TOU\S H(NW=SQAI/ TE KAI\ H)LLOIW=SQAI TH\N U(POBEBLHME/NHN OU)SI/AN GENE/SEI KAI\ FQORA=| DOCA/ZONTAS>20 A(/PASA NO/SOS O(MOIOMEROU=S TE KAI\ A(PLOU= PRO\S AI)/SQHSIN SW/MATOS H)/TOI DUSKRASI/A TIS U(PA/RXOUSA H)\ TH=S SUNEXEI/AS AU)-TOU= TW=N MERW=N DIAI/RESIS. @1 @&10Nemesius de nat. hom cp. 2 p. 38.$10 *DIAFWNEI=TAI SXEDO\N A(/PASI TOI=S PALAIOI=S O( PERI\ TH=S YUXH=S LO/GOS. *DHMO/KRITOS ME\N GA\R KAI\ *)EPI/KOUROS KAI\ PA=N TO\ <20TW=N *STWI+KW=N>20 FILOSO/FWN SU/STHMA SW=MA TH\N YUXH\N A)POFAI/-NONTAI: KAI\ AU)TOI\ DE\ OU(=TOI OI( SW=MA TH\N YUXH\N A)POFAINO/MENOI, DIAFE/RONTAI PERI\ TH=S OU)SI/AS AU)TH=S: <20OI( ME\N GA\R *STWI+KOI\ PNEU=MA LE/GOUSIN AU)TH\N E)/NQERMON KAI\ DIA/PURON>20. @&10Tertullianus de anima cp. 5. Sed etiam Stoicos allego, qui spiritum &10praedicantes animam paene nobiscum, qua proxima inter se flatus et spi-&10ritus, tamen corpus animam facile persuadebunt. &10@Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 156.$10 DOKEI= DE\ AU)TOI=S TH\N ME\N FU/SIN EI)=NAI PU=R TEXNIKO/N, O(DW=| BADI/ZON EI)S GE/NESIN, O(/PER E)STI\ PNEU=MA PUROEIDE\S KAI\ TE-XNOEIDE/S: TH\N DE\ YUXH\N AI)SQHTIKH\N [2FU/SIN]2. TAU/THN DE\ EI)=NAI TO\ SUMFUE\S H(MI=N PNEU=MA: DIO\ KAI\ SW=MA EI)=NAI KAI\ META\ TO\N QA/NATON E)PIME/NEIN: FQARTH\N DE\ U(PA/RXEIN. TH\N DE\ TW=N O(/LWN A)/FQARTON, H(=S ME/RH EI)=NAI TA\S E)N TOI=S ZW/|OIS. @&10Commenta Lucani Lib. IX 7 p. 290 Us. Quos ignea virtus%10 &10animae virtutem significat, non corporis%10 quoniam Stoici animam ignem &10dicunt. &10@Hieronymus epist. 126 [1ad Marcellinum et Anapsychiam]1. Super &10animae statu memini vestrae quaestiunculae__utrum lapsa de caelo &10sit, ut Pythagoras philosophus omnesque Platonici et Origenes putant, &10an a propria Dei substantia, ut <21Stoici>21 etc. &10@Galenus de simpl. medicam. temp. et fac. V 9 ed. Bas. II 58 &10K. XI 731.$10 OI( ME\N OU)=N *STWI+KOI\ TAU)TO\N TOU=TO TO\ PNEU=MA TH\N OU)SI/AN TH=S YUXH=S EI)=NAI DOCA/ZOUSIN. @&10Scholia in Hom. Iliad. II 857.$10 E)K TOU/TOU KAI\ OI( <20*STWI+KOI\>20 O(RI/-ZONTAI TH\N YUXH/N: YUXH/ E)STI PNEU=MA SUMFUE\S KAI\ A)NAQUMI/ASIS AI)SQHTIKH\ E)K TW=N TOU= SW/MATOS U(GRW=N A)NADIDOME/NH. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. IV 3, 3$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 PNEU=MA NOERO\N QERMO/N [1TH\N YUXH/N]1. @1 @&10Galenus defin. medicae 29 Vol. XIX p. 355 K.$10 YUXH/ E)STIN_ _KATA\ DE\ TOU\S *STWI+KOU\S SW=MA LEPTOMERE\S E)C E(AUTOU= KINOU/MENON KATA\ SPERMATIKOU\S LO/GOUS. @&10Galenus de usu partium VI, 17. Vol III p. 496 K.$10 OU)DE\ GA\R OU)D' OU(=TOS O( LO/GOS A)DU/NATOS, W(S A)NAQUMI/ASI/S TIS, EI) GE E)STI/N, AI(/MATOS XRH-STOU= TO\ YUXIKO\N PNEU=MA. @&10Galenus comm. 5 in Hippocr. epid. 6 ed. Bas. V 509 K. XVII B 246.$10 O(/SOI GA\R OI)/ONTAI TH\N YUXH\N EI)=NAI PNEU=MA, DIASW/|ZESQAI LE/GOUSIN AU)TH\N E)/K TE TH=S A)NAQUMIA/SEWS TOU= AI(/MATOS KAI\ TOU= KATA\ TH\N EI)SPNOH\N E(LKOME/NOU DIA\ TH=S TRAXEI/AS A)RTHRI/AS EI)/SW TOU= SW/MATOS [2A)E/ROS]2. @&10Galenus de usu respirat. cp. 5 [1K. Vol. IV p. 502$10]1 A)NAGKAI=O/N E)STI TOU=TO TO\ PNEU=MA [1&10scil.$10 TO\ YUXIKO\N]1 TRE/FESQAI. PO/QEN OU)=N, FASI/N, A)/L-LOQEN E(/CEI TH\N TROFH/N, EI) MH\ PARA\ TOU= DIA\ TH=S EI)SPNOH=S E(LKOME/NOU; KAI/TOI KA)K TH=S TOU= AI(/MATOS A)NAQUMIA/SEWS OU)K A)PEIKO\S AU)TO\ TRE/FESQAI, KAQA/PER KAI\ POLLOI=S TW=N E)LLOGI/MWN I)ATRW=N TE KAI\ FILOSO/FWN E)/DOCEN. @&10Tertullianus de anima cp. 10. Quid est, oro te, spirare? flatum &10opinor ex semet ipso agere. Quid est vivere? flatum opinor ex semet &10ipso non agere? Hoc enim respondere debebo si non idem est spirare, &10quod vivere. Sed mortui erit non agere flatum%10 ergo viventis est agere &10flatum. Sed et spirantis est agere flatum%10 ergo et spirare viventis est. &10Utrumque si sine anima decurrere potuisset, non fuisset animae spirare, &10sed solummodo vivere. At enim vivere spirare est, et spirare vivere est. &10Ergo totum hoc et spirare et vivere eius est, cuius et vivere, id est &10animae etc. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de anima libri mant. p. 115, 6 Bruns.$10 E)/TI EI) H( YUXH\ SW=MA, H)\ PU=R H)\ PNEU=MA LEPTOMERE/S E)STI DIA\ PANTO\S DIH=KON TOU= E)MYU/XOU SW/MATOS. EI) DE\ TOU=TO, DH=LON W(S OU)K A)RGO\N OU)DE\ W(S E)/TUXEN E)/XON E)ROU=SIN AU)TO/. OU) GA\R PA=N PU=R OU)DE\ PA=N PNEU=MA TAU/THN E)/XEI TH\N DU/NAMIN. META/ TINOS OU)=N E)/STAI EI)/DOUS I)DI/OU KAI\ LO/GOU KAI\ DUNA/MEWS <20KAI/, W(S AU)TOI\ LE/GOUSIN, TO/NOU>20. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de anima p. 26, 13 Bruns.$10 MA=LLON DE\ KATA\ TOU\S TH\N YUXH\N GENNW=NTAS E)K POIA=S MI/CEW/S TE KAI\ SUNQE/SEW/S TINWN EI)/H A)\N H( YUXH\ H)/TOI A(RMONI/A H)\ SU/NQESIS KAQ' A(RMONI/AN TINW=N SWMA/TWN. W(=N EI)SIN OI(/ TE <20A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20, PNEU=MA AU)TH\N LE/GONTES EI)=NAI SUGKEI/MENO/N PWS E)/K TE PURO\S KAI\ A)E/ROS, KAI\ OI( PERI\ *)EPI/KOURON. @&10Galenus$10 PERI\ YUXH=S H)QW=N &10ed. Bas. I 346. K. IV. 783.$10 *)EN TAU)TW=| DE\ GE/NEI TH=S OU)SI/AS KAI\ H( <20TW=N *STWI+KW=N>20 PERIE/XETAI DO/CA: PNEU=MA ME\N GA/R TI TH\N YUXH\N EI)=NAI BOU/LONTAI, KAQA/PER KAI\ TH\N FU/SIN, A)LL' U(GRO/TERON ME\N KAI\ YUXRO/TERON TO\ TH=S FU/SEWS, CHRO/TERON DE\ KAI\ QERMO/TERON TO\ TH=S YUXH=S. W(/STE KAI\ TOU=Q' U(/LH ME/N TIS OI)KEI/A TH=S YUXH=S E)STI TO\ PNEU=MA, TO\ DE\ TH=S U(/LHS EI)=DOS H)/TOI KRA/SEWS E)N SUMMETRI/A| GIGNOME/NHS TH=S A)ERW/DOUS TE KAI\ PU-RW/DOUS OU)SI/AS: OU)/TE GA\R A)E/RA MO/NON OI(=O/N TE FA/NAI TH\N YUXH\N OU)/TE PU=R, O(/TI MH/TE YUXRO\N A)/KRWS E)MFANH=| GI/GNESQAI ZW/|OU SW=MA, MH/TE A)/KRWS QERMO/N, A)LLA\ MHDE\ E)PIKRATOU/MENON U(PO\ QATE/ROU KATA\ MEGA/LHN U(PEROXH/N, O(/POUGE KA)\N BRAXEI= PLE/ON GE/NHTAI TOU= SUMME/TROU, PURE/TTEI ME\N TO\ ZW=|ON E)N TAI=S TOU= PU-RO\S A)ME/TROIS U(PEROXAI=S, KATAYU/XETAI DE\ KAI\ PELIDNOU=TAI KAI\ DUSAI/SQHTON H)\ @1 PANTELW=S A)NAI/SQHTON GI/NETAI KATA\ TA\S TOU= A)E/ROS KRA/SEIS: OU(=TOS GA\R AU)TO\S O(/SON ME\N E)F' E(AUTW=| YUXRO/S E)STIN, E)K DE\ TH=S PRO\S TO\ PURW=DES STOIXEI=ON E)PI-MICI/AS EU)/KRATOS GI/NETAI: DH=LON OU)=N H)/DH SOI GE/GONEN, W(S H( TH=S YUXH=S OU)SI/A KATA\ POIA\N KRA=SIN A)E/ROS TE KAI\ PURO\S GI/NETAI KATA\ <20TOU\S *STWI+KOU/S>20, KAI\ SUNETO\S ME\N O( <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 A)PEI/RGASTAI DIA\ TH\N TOU/TWN EU)/KRATON MI=CIN. @&10Galenus$10 PERI\ T. T. YUXH=S H)QW=N. &10ed. Bas. I 346, K. IV 786.$10 _ U(F' *(HRAKLEI/TOU: KAI\ GA\R OU(=TOS OU(/TWS EI)=PEN: AU)GH\ CHRH\ YUXH\ SOFWTA/TH, TH\N CHRO/THTA PA/LIN A)CIW=N EI)=NAI SUNE/SEWS AI)TI/AN: TO\ GA\R TH=S AU)GH=S O)/NOMA TOU=T' E)NDEI/KNUTAI, KAI\ BELTI/ONA/ GE DO/CAN TAU/THN EI)=NAI NOMISTE/ON, E)NNOH/SAN-TAS KAI\ TOU\S A)STE/RAS AU)GOEIDEI=S TE A(/MA KAI\ CHROU\S O)/NTAS A)/KRAN SU/NESIN E)/XEIN: EI) GA\R MH/ TIS AU)TOI=S U(PA/RXEIN TOU=TO FAI/H, DO/CEI TH=S TW=N QEW=N U(PE-ROXH=S A)NAI/SQHTOS EI)=NAI. @&10Anonymi scholia in Hermog. ideas Walz. Rh. gr. VII p. 884.$10 OI( ME\N GA\R <20*STWI+KOI\>20 LE/GOUSI MH\ EI)=NAI YUXH/N, A)LL' E)K TH=S KRA/SEWS TW=N STOIXEI/WN A)POTELEI=SQAI TH\N GE/NESIN: O(/TAN ME\N GA\R PLEONA/SH| TO\ QERMO/N, POIEI= TO\N LE/ONTA, O(/QEN, FHSI/, KAI\ QUMIKO/S E)STIN: O(/TAN DE\ KATA\ LO/GON KAI\ SXEDO\N E)C I)/SOU SUNE/LQH|, POIEI= TO\N A)/NQRWPON: TAU/THS TH=S DO/CHS PROSTA/THS E)GE/NETO KAI\ *GALHNO/S. @&Nemesius de nat. hom. cp. 2 p. 46.$8 E)PEIDH\ DE\ KAI\ *KLEA/N-QOUS TOU= STWI+KOU= KAI\ *XRUSI/PPOU FE/RONTAI LO/GOI TINE\S OU)K EU)KATAFRO/-NHTOI, E)KQETE/ON KAI\ TOU/TWN TA\S LU/SEIS W(S E)PE/LUSAN OI( A)PO\ *PLA/TWNOS [1&sequuntur plura Cleanthis argumenta, quibus corpoream animae na-&turam probabat eorumque refutationes; dein p. 53$8]1 <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 DE/ FHSIN O(/TI "1O( <20QA/NATO/S E)STI YUXH=S XWRISMO\S A)PO\ SW/MATOS: OU)DE\N DE\ A)SW/MATON A)PO\ SW/MATOS XWRI/ZETAI: OU)DE\ GA\R E)FA/PTETAI SW/MATOS A)SW/MATON, H( DE\ YUXH\ KAI\ E)FA/PTETAI KAI\ XWRI/ZETAI TOU= SW/MATOS, SW=MA A)/RA H( YUXH/>20."2 @&Tertullianus de anima cp. 5.&3 Sed et <21Chrysippus>21 manum &3ei [1scil. Cleanthi]1 porrigit, constituens corporalia ab incorporalibus dere-&3linqui omnino non posse, quia nec contingantur ab eis [1unde et Lucre-&3tius%10 tangere enim et tangi nisi corpus nulla potest res]1 derelicto autem &3corpore ab anima affici morte. Igitur corpus anima, quae nisi corpo-&3ralis corpus non derelinqueret. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de anima libri mant. p. 117 @&10`1.$10 OU)/TE GA\R <20E)PEI\ KATHGOREI=TAI TO\ O(/MOION AU)TH=S>20, DIA\ TOU=TO/ E)STIN SW=MA. _&10`9.$10 A)LLA\ KAI\ O( LO/GOS YEUDH\S O( LE/GWN <20A)SW/MATON SW/MATI>20 MH\ <20SUMPA/SXEIN>20, W(/STE MH\ EI)=NAI A)SW/MATON TH\N YUXH/N. _&10`21.$10 OU)X U(GIH\S DE\ LO/GOS OU)DE\ O( LE/GWN <20MHDE\N A)SW/MATON SW/MATOS XWRI/ZESQAI, TH\N DE\ YUXH\N TOU= SW/MATOS XWRI/ZESQAI, W(/STE MH\ EI)=NAI A)SW/MATON>20. _&10`28.$10 OU)K A)LHQE\S DE\ OU)DE\ TO\ LE/GEIN <20TAU=TA XWRI/ZESQAI A)P' A)LLH/LWN, O(/SA A(/PTETAI A)LLH/LWN>20. _ &10`30.$10 E)/TI OU)K A)LHQE\S TO\ W(=| A)NAPNE/OMEN, TOU/TW| E)SME\N E)/MPNOI, TH=| DE\ YUXH=| @1 E)/MYUXOI: OU)DE\ EI) A)/NEU TOU= SUMFU/TOU PNEU/MATOS MH\ DU/NAITO TA\ ZW=|A EI)=NAI, DIA\ TOU=TO TOU=TO/ E)STI YUXH/. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de anima p. 18, 10 Bruns.$10 TO\ DE\ LE/GEIN TW=N TOU= SW/MATOS MERW=N A)NA/GKHN EI)=NAI KAI\ TA\ ME/RH SW/MATA EI)=NAI, W(/SPER KAI\ TH=S E)PIFANEI/AS KAI\ TH=S GRAMMH=S KAI\ TOU= XRO/NOU TA\ ME/RH TH=S ME\N E)PIFA/NEIAI, TH=S DE\ GRAMMAI/, TOU= DE\ XRO/NOI, ME/RH DE\ TOU= ZW/|OU SW/MATOS O)/NTOS TO/ TE EI)=DOS KAI\ H( U(/LH, W(/STE KAI\ SW/MATA, PEPLANHME/NWN. @&10idem p. 18, 27.$10 A)LL' OU)DE\ O( LE/GWN LO/GOS "1<20OU(= TO\ ME/ROS SW=MA KAI\ AU)TO\ SW=MA, TH=S DE\ YUXH=S H( AI)/SQHSIS ME/ROS OU)=SA SW=MA/ E)STI, KAI\ AU)TH\ A)/RA SW=MA>20"2, DEI/KNUSI/N TI. _&10p. 19, 2.$10 KAI\ GA\R EI) SW=MA H( YUXH/, KAI\ SW=MA OU)X W(S H( U(/LH, E)/STAI E)C U(/LHS KAI\ EI)/DOUS, EI)/GE PA=N SW=MA KAT' AU)-TOU\S TO\ PARA\ TH\N U(/LHN TOIOU=TON. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de anima libri mant. p. 113, 31 Bruns.$10 EI) H( YUXH\ SW=MA, PA=N DE\ SW=MA MIA=| GE/ TINI AI)SQH/SEI AI)SQHTO\N TH=| AU(TOU= FU/SEI [1LE/GW DE\ PERI\ TW=N E)NERGEI/A| O)/NTWN SWMA/TWN KAI/, <20W(/S FASIN AU)TOI/, PEPOIW-ME/NWN>20]1 EI)/H A)\N KAI\ H( YUXH\ AI)SQHTH/ [1OU) GA\R DH\ A)/POIO/N GE SW=MA AU)TH\N E)ROU=SIN, E)/STAI GA\R U(/LH]1 OU)K E)/STIN DE/: OU)K A)/RA SW=MA. @&10Tertullianus de anima cp. 8. Quid enim, <21inquit Soranus>21, &10si mare negent corpus, quia extra mare immobilis et gravis navis efficitur? &10Quanto ergo validius corpus animae, quod tanti postea ponderis corpus &10levissima mobilitate circumfert? @&10Chalcidius in Timaeum cp. 221. Ergo spiritum animam esse &10dicentes corpus esse animam plane fatentur. Quodsi ita est, corpus corpori &10sociatum est. Societas porro vel ex adplicatione fit vel ex permixtione &10vel ex concretione. Si adplicita sint corpus et anima, quid ex adplicatione &10compositum horum duum quatenus totum erit vivum? Vita enim secun-&10dum ipsos in solo spiritu, qui adplicitus non permanat ad corpus intimum. &10nihil enim penetrat adplicitum. et totum animal vivere aiunt%10 non igitur &10anima et corpus adplicatione sociantur. Si vero permixta sunt, anima &10unum aliquid non erit sed permixta multa. Stoici spiritum, id est ani-&10mam, unum quid esse profitentur%10 non ergo permixta sunt. Superest ut &10ex concretione manent%10 ergo et per se invicem transeunt duo corpora, et &10locus unus quo corpus continetur duobus corporibus praebebit capacitatem, &10cum vas quod aquam recipit vinum et aquam simul capere non possit. &10Neque igitur ex adplicatione neque permixtione neque vero concretione &10corpus et anima sociantur. ex quo confit animam non esse corpus. Est &10igitur virtus et potentia carens corpore. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de anima libri mant. p. 115, 32 Bruns.$10 A)LL' OU)DE\ W(S E)N A)GGEI/W| TW=| SW/MATI EI)/H A)\N H( YUXH/. EI)/H GA\R A)\N KAI\ OU(/TWS OU)X O(/LON E)/MYUXON TO\ SW=MA. A)LLA\ OU)DE\ KATA\ <20PARA/QESIN>20. OU)DE\ GA\R OU(/TWS O(/LON E)/MYUXON E)/STAI TO\ SW=MA. __EI) DE\ O(/LON DI' O(/LOU, E)PEIDH\ PA=N TO\ SW=MA E)/MYUXON, PW=S SW=MA DIA\ SW/MATOS DIH/KEI, DEIKNU/NAI DEI=. KAI\ GA\R KAI/, E)PEI\ AI( TH=S YUXH=S POIO/THTES SW/MATA KAT' <20AU)TOU\S>20 KAI\ AI( TOU= SW/MATOS, POLLA\ SW/MATA/ E)STIN E)N TW=| AU)TW=| KAI\ DIA/FORA DI' A)LLH/LWN DIH/KONTA KAI\ E)N TW=| AU)TW=| TO/PW|. @1 @&10p. 116, 13.$10 E)/TI EI) KAI\ AI( A)RETAI\ SW/MATA KAI\ AI( TE/XNAI, PW=S OU) PROS-GENO/MENA TAU=TA/ TINI STENOXWRH/SEI TO\ SW=MA H)\ AU)CH/SEI; @&10Alexander Aphrod. in Aristot. Topica II p. 93 Ald. p. 173, 14.$10 E)PEI\ TW=| LE/GONTI TH\N YUXH\N SW=MA E(/PETAI TO\ SW=MA DIA\ SW/MATOS XWREI=N KAI\ TO\ STOIXEI=ON AU)TH\N EI)=NAI H)\ E)K STOIXEI/WN. @&10Plotinus Ennead. IV lib. VII 10 [1Vol. II p. 114 Mu+.$10]1. E)/TI EI) SW=MA OU)=SA H( YUXH\ DIH=LQE DIA\ PANTO/S, KA)\N KRAQEI=SA EI)/H, O(\N TRO/PON TOI=S A)/LLOIS SW/MASIN H( KRA=SIS: EI) DE\ H( TW=N SWMA/TWN KRA=SIS OU)DE\N E)NERGEI/A| E)A=| EI)=NAI TW=N KRAQE/NTWN, OU)D' A)\N H( YUXH\ E)/TI [2E)NERGEI/A|]2 E)NEI/H TOI=S SW/MASIN, A)LLA\ DUNA/MEI MO/NON, A)POLE/SASA TO\ EI)=NAI YUXH/: W(/SPER EI) GLUKU\ KAI\ PIKRO\N KRAQEI/H, TO\ GLUKU\ OU)K E)/STIN: OU)K A)/RA E)/XOMEN YUXH/N. TO\ DE\ DH\ SW=MA O)\N SW/MATI KEKRA=SQAI O(/LON DI' O(/LOU, W(S O(/POU A)\N H)=|, KAI\ QA/TERON EI)=NAI, I)/SON O)/GKON A)MFOTE/RWN KAI\ TO\ PA=N KATEXO/NTWN, KAI\ MHDEMI/AN AU)/CHSIN GEGONE/NAI E)PEMBLHQE/NTOS TOU= E(TE/ROU, OU)DE\N A)POLEI/YEI O(\ MH\ TE/MH|. OU) GA\R KATA\ MEGA/LA ME/RH PARALLA\C H( KRA=SIS [1OU(/TW GA/R FASI PARA/QESIN E)/SESQAI]1, DIELHLUQO\S DE\ DIA\ PANTO\S TO\ E)PEMBLHQE\N [E)PI\] SMIKRO/TERON [1O(/PER A)DU/NATON, TO\ E)/LATTON I)/SON GENE/SQAI TW=| MEI/ZONI]1 A)LL' OU)=N DIELHLUQO\S PA=N TE/MNEI KATA\ PA=N. ___ OU) TOI/NUN O(/LON DI' O(/LOU XWREI=N DUNATO\N TO\ SW=MA: H( DE\ YUXH\ DI' O(/LWN: A)SW/MATOS A)/RA. @&Longinus apud Eusebium praep. evang. XV p. 823a.$ TW=N DE\ PERI\ YUXH\N I)/XNOS OU)DE\N OU)DE\ TEKMH/RION E)N TOI=S SW/MASIN EU(RI/SKE-TAI, KA)\N EI) FILOTIMOI=TO/ TIS, W(S *)EPI/KOUROS KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20, A(/PANTA LI/QON KINEI=N KAI\ PA=SAN E)REUNA=N DU/NAMIN SW/MATOS EI)S GE/NESIN TW=N PERI\ YUXH=S PRA/CEWN. @&10Jamblichus de anima apud Stobaeum ed. i p. 371, 22.$10 OU) MH\N E)/TI GE TOU/TOIS SUGXWROU=SIN OI( SW=MA TH\N YUXH\N U(POLAMBA/NONTES, OI(=ON <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 KAI\ A)/LLOI PLEI/ONES: __PA/NTES GA\R OU(=TOI SWMATOEIDEI=S TA\S KI-NH/SEIS AU)TH=| A)PODIDO/ASIN. @&10Philo quaest. et solut. in Genesin II 4 [1p. 77 Aucher]1. Corpus &10autem nostrum, ex multis compositum, extrinsecus et intrinsecus unitum &10est atque propria habitudine constat; superior autem habitudo conexionis &10istorum anima est, quae in medio consistens ubique permeat usque ad &10superficiem deque superficie in medium vertitur, ut unica natura spiri-&10tualis duplici convolvatur ligamine in firmiorem soliditatem unionemque &10coaptata. @&10Philo quaest. et solut. in Exod. II 120 [1p. 547 aucher]1. siqui-&10dem a se ipso est motus animae, ut convenit dicere maxime <21secundum &10ex Stoa philosophos>21. @1 &10@Plotinus Ennead. IV lib. VII 11 [1Vol. II p. 115 Mu+]1.$10 TO\ DE\ FU/SIN ME\N PRO/TERON TO\ AU)TO\ PNEU=MA LE/GEIN, <20E)N DE\ YUXRW=| GENOME/NHN KAI\ STOMWQEI=SAN YUXH\N GI/GNESQAI, LEPTOTE/RAN E)N YUXRW=| GENOME/NHN>20, _O(\ DH\ KAI\ AU)TO\ A)/TOPON: POLLA\ GA\R ZW=|A E)N QERMW=| GI/GNETAI KAI\ YUXH\N E)/XEI OU) YUXQEI=SAN_A)LL' OU)=N FASI/ GE PROTE/RAN FU/SIN YUXH=S EI)=NAI KATA\ SUNTUXI/AS TA\S E)/CW GIGNOME/NHS. SUMBAI/NEI OU)=N AU)TOI=S TO\ XEI=RON PRW=TON POIEI=N KAI\ PRO\ TOU/TOU A)/LLO E)/LATTON, H(\N LE/GOUSIN E(/CIN: O( DE\ NOU=S U(/STATOS, A)PO\ TH=S YUXH=S DHLONO/TI GENO/MENOS. @&10Tertullianus de anima cp. 25. __isti qui praesumunt, non &10in utero concipi animam, nec cum carnis figulatione compingi atque pro-&10duci, sed effuso iam partu nondum vivo infanti extrinsecus imprimi. Cete-&10rum semen ex concubitu muliebribus locis sequestratum motuque naturali &10vegetatum compinguescere in solam substantiam carnis; eam editam et de &10uteri fornace fumantem et calore solutam, ut ferrum ignitum et ibidem &10frigidae immersum, ita ae%28ris rigore percussam et vim animalem rapere et &10vocalem sonum reddere. Hoc <21Stoici>21 cum Aenesidemo etc. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 41 p. 1052f.$ <20*TO\ BRE/FOS E)N TH=| GASTRI\ FU/SEI TRE/FESQAI NOMI/ZEI KAQA/PER FUTO/N: O(/TAN DE\ TEXQH=|, YUXO/MENON U(PO\ TOU= A)E/ROS KAI\ STOMOU/MENON TO\ PNEU=MA METABA/LLEIN KAI\ GI/NESQAI ZW=|ON: O(/QEN OU)K A)PO\ TRO/-POU TH\N YUXH\N W)NOMA/SQAI PARA\ TH\N YU=CIN. *AU)TO\S DE\ PA/LIN "1TH\N YUXH\N A)RAIO/TERON PNEU=MA TH=S FU/SEWS KAI\ LEPTOMERE/-STERON"2 H(GEI=TAI, MAXO/MENOS AU(TW=|>20. @&p. 1053d.$ O( PERI\ YUXH=S GENE/SEWS AU)TW=| LO/GOS MAXOME/NHN E)/XEI PRO\S TO\ DO/GMA TH\N A)PO/DEICIN. <20*GI/NESQAI ME\N GA/R FHSI TH\N YUXH/N, O(/TAN TO\ BRE/FOS A)POTEXQH=|, KAQA/PER STOMW/SEI TH=| PERIYU/CEI TOU= PNEU/MATOS METABALO/NTOS: A)PODEI/CEI DE\ XRH=TAI TOU= GE-GONE/NAI TH\N YUXH\N KAI\ METAGENESTE/RAN EI)=NAI MA/LISTA TW=| KAI\ TO\N TRO/PON KAI\ TO\ H)=QOS E)COMOIOU=SQAI TA\ TE/KNA TOI=S GO-NEU=SI>20. ___*EI) DE\ FH/SEI TIS [1&Stoicorum sententiam sc. defen-&dens$]1, O(/TI TAI=S KRA/SESI TW=N SWMA/TWN E)GGINOME/NHS TH=S O(MOIO/THTOS, AI( YUXAI\ GENO/MENAI METABA/LLOUSI, DIAFQEI/REI TO\ TEKMH/RION TOU= GEGONE/NAI TH\N YUXH/N: E)NDE/XETAI GA\R OU(/TW KAI\ A)GE/NHTON OU)=SAN, O(/TAN E)PEISE/LQH|, METABA/LLEIN TH=| KRA/SEI TH=S O(MOIO/THTOS. @&idem de primo frigido cp. 2.$ <20*OI( DE\ *STWI+KOI\>20 KAI\ TO\ PNEU=MA LE/GOUSIN E)N TOI=S SW/MASI TW=N BREFW=N TH=| PERIYU/CEI STOMOU=SQAI KAI\ METABA/LLON E)K FU/SEWS GI/NESQAI YUXH/N. @1 PW=S DE\ OU)K AI)SXU/NHS GE/MWN O( PNEU=MA PW=S E)/XON AU)TH\N [1&scil.$ TH\N YU-XH\N]1 A)PODIDOU/S, H)\ PU=R NOERO/N, TH=| PERIYU/CEI KAI\ OI(=ON BAFH=| TOU= A)E/ROS A)NAFQE\N H)\ STOMWQE/N. @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 46 p. 1084e.$ TO\ QERMO/TATON PERI-YU/CEI KAI\ PUKNW/SEI TO\ LEPTOMERE/STATON GENNW=NTES. H( GA\R YUXH\ QER-MO/TATO/N E)STI DH/POU KAI\ LEPTOMERE/STATON: POIOU=SI D' AU)TH\N TH=| PERI-YU/CEI KAI\ PUKNW/SEI TOU= SW/MATOS, OI(=ON STOMW/SEI TO\ PNEU=MA METABA/LLONTOS, E)K FUTIKOU= YUXIKO\N GENO/MENON. <20GEGONE/NAI DE\ KAI\ TO\N H(/LION E)/M-YUXON LE/GOUSI, TOU= U(GROU= METABA/LLONTOS EI)S PU=R NOERO/N>20. @&10Hippolytus Philos. 21 [1DDG p. 571, 17]1 Stoici, Chrysippus et &10Zeno.$10 TH\N DE\ YUXH\N LE/GOUSIN A)QA/NATON EI)=NAI, SW=MA DE/, KAI\ GENE/SQAI E)K TH=S PERIYU/CEWS TOU= A)E/ROS TOU= PERIE/XONTOS, DIO\ KAI\ KALEI=SQAI YUXH/N: O(MO-LOGOU=SI DE\ KAI\ METENSWMA/TWSIN GI/NESQAI W(RISME/NWN OU)SW=N TW=N YUXW=N. @&10Origenes de principiis [1interpr. Rufino]1 II cp. 8 p. 96 ed. Delar.$10 YUXH\N PARA\ TH\N YU/CIN &10nominatam esse putat. &10@Arius didymus epit. phys. fr. 39 Diels [1DG p. 471, 18. Euseb. &10praep. evang. XV 20, 6]1.$10 TH\N DE\ YUXH\N GENHTH/N TE KAI\ FQARTH\N LE/GOUSIN. OU)K EU)QU\S DE\ TOU= SW/MATOS A)PALLAGEI=SAN FQEI/RESQAI, A)LL' E)PIME/NEIN TINA\S XRO/NOUS KAQ' E(AUTH/N: TH\N ME\N TW=N SPOUDAI/WN ME/XRI TH=S EI)S PU=R A)NALU/SEWS TW=N PA/NTWN, TH\N DE\ TW=N A)FRO/NWN PRO\S POSOU/S TINAS XRO/NOUS. TO\ DE\ DIA-ME/NEIN TA\S YUXA\S OU(/TWS LE/GOUSIN, O(/TI DIAME/NOMEN H(MEI=S YUXAI\ GENO/MENOI TOU= SW/MATOS XWRISQE/NTES KAI\ EI)S E)LA/TTW METABALO/NTES OU)SI/AN TH\N TH=S YUXH=S, TA\S DE\ TW=N A)FRO/NWN KAI\ A)LO/GWN ZW/|WN YUXA\S SUNAPO/LLUSQAI TOI=S SW/MASI. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. IV 7, 3.$10 <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 E)CIOU=SAN E)K TW=N SWMA/TWN OU)/PW FQEI/RESQAI: [2KAI\]2 TH\N ME\N A)SQENESTE/RAN A)MAURO\N SU/GKRIMA GI/NESQAI [1TAU/THN D' EI)=NAI [2TH\N]2 TW=N A)PAIDEU/TWN]1. TH\N DE\ I)SXUROTE/RAN [1OI(/A E)STI\ PERI\ TOU\S SOFOU/S]1 ZH=N ME/XRI TH=S E)KPURW/SEWS. @&10Theodoretus graec. aff. cur. V 23 p. 73, 24.$10 OI( DE\ *STWI+KOI\ TA\S XWRI-ZOME/NAS TW=N SWMA/TWN YUXA\S DIARKEI=N ME\N KAI\ KAQ' AU(TA\S ZH=N E)/FASAN, A)LLA\ TH\N ME\N A)SQENESTE/RAN E)P' O)LI/GON, TH\N DE/ GE I)SXUROTE/RAN ME/XRI TH=S TOU= PANTO\S E)KPURW/SEWS. @&Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 157.$ *KLEA/NQHS ME\N OU)=N PA/SAS [1&scil.$ TA\S YUXA\S]1 E)PIDIAME/NEIN ME/XRI TH=S E)KPURW/SEWS, <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 DE\ TA\S TW=N SOFW=N MO/NWN. @&10sextus adv. math. IV 71.$10 H( DE\ PERI\ QEW=N U(PO/LHYIS OU) TOIAU/TH TIS E)STI\N OU)DE\ MA/XHN U(PE/BALLEN, A)LLA\ SU/MFWNOS TOI=S GIGNOME/NOIS E)FAI/NETO. @1 KAI\ GA\R OU)DE\ TA\S YUXA\S E)/NESTIN U(PONOH=SAI KA/TW FEROME/NAS: LEPTOMEREI=S GA\R OU)=SAI KAI\ OU)X H(=TTON PURW/DEIS H)\ PNEUMATW/DEIS EI)S TOU\S A)/NW MA=LLON TO/POUS KOUFOFOROU=SIN. KAI\ KAQ' AU(TA\S DE\ DIAME/NOUSI KAI\ OU)X, W(S E)/LEGEN *)EPI/KOU-ROS, A)POLUQEI=SAI TW=N SWMA/TWN KAPNOU= DI/KHN SKI/DNANTAI. OU)DE\ GA\R PRO/-TERON TO\ SW=MA DIAKRATHTIKO\N H)=N AU)TW=N, A)LL' AU)TAI\ TW=| SW/MATI SUMMONH=S H)=SAN AI)/TIAI, POLU\ DE\ PRO/TERON KAI\ E(AUTAI=S. E)/KSKHNOI GOU=N H(LI/OU GENO/MENAI TO\N U(PO\ SELH/NHN OI)KOU=SI TO/PON, E)NQA/DE TE DIA\ TH\N EI)LIKRI/NEIAN TOU= A)E/ROS PLEI/ONA PRO\S DIAMONH\N LAMBA/NOUSI XRO/NON, TROFH=| TE XRW=NTAI OI)KEI/A| TH=| A)PO\ GH=S A)NAQUMIA/SEI W(S KAI\ TA\ LOIPA\ A)/STRA, TO\ DIALU=SO/N TE AU)TA\S E)N E)KEI/NOIS TOI=S TO/POIS OU)K E)/XOUSIN. EI) OU)=N DIAME/NOUSIN AI( YUXAI/, DAI/MOSIN AI( AU)TAI\ GI/GNONTAI: EI) DE\ DAI/MONE/S EI)SI R(HTE/ON KAI\ QEOU\S U(PA/RXEIN &10etc. &10@[Lactant. dn. instit. VII 20. Hic fortasse dixerit quispiam%10 si &10est immortalis anima, quomodo patibilis inducitur ac poenae sentiens? _ &10_Huic quaestioni sive argumento a <21Stoicis>21 ita occurritur%10 Animas qui-&10dem hominum permanere nec interventu mortis in nihilum resolvi; sed &10eorum, qui iusti fuerunt, puras et impatibiles et beatas ad sedem coelestem, &10unde illis origo sit, remeare, vel in campos quosdam fortunatos rapi, ubi &10fruantur miris voluptatibus%10 impios vero quoniam se malis cupiditatibus &10inquinaverunt mediam quandam gerere inter immortalem mortalemque na-&10turam et habere aliquid imbecillitatis ex contagione carnis, cuius desideriis &10ac libidinibus addictae ineluibilem quendam fucum trahant labemque ter-&10renam; quae cum temporis diuturnitate penitus inhaeserit, eius naturae &10reddi animas, ut si non exstinguibiles in totum [1quoniam ex deo sunt]1 &10tamen cruciabiles fiant per corporis maculam, quae peccatis inusta sensum &10doloris attribuit.] &10@Tertullianus de anima cp. 54. Omnes ferme philosophi, qui &10immortalitatem animae qualiter qualiter volunt tamen vindicant, ut Pytha-&10goras, ut Empedocles, ut Plato, quique aliquod illi tempus indulgent ab &10excessu usque in conflagrationem universitatis, ut <21Stoici>21, suas solas, id est &10sapientum animas in supernis mansionibus collocant. &10@ibidem%10 itaque apud illum [1scil. Platonem]1 in aetherem sublimantur &10animae sapientes, apud Arium in ae%28rem, apud <21Stoicos>21 sub lunam. &10@ibidem%10 reliquas animas ad inferos deiciunt. &10@cp. 55. Sed in aethere dormitio nostra__aut circa lunam cum &10Endymionibus Stoicorum. @&Scholia in Hom. Iliad.$ *Y& 65.$ A)/KRWS DE\ E)PECERGA/ZETAI TH\N E)PIFA/NEIAN TOU= O)NEI/ROU: E)/NAULOS GA\R TW=| *)AXILLEI= O( TOU= FI/LOU TU/POS. E)NTEU=QEN *)ANTISQE/NHS O(MOSXH/MONA/S FHSI TA\S YUXA\S TOI=S PERIE/XOUSI SW/MASIN EI)=NAI, <20*XRU/SIPPOS DE\ META\ TO\N XWRISMO\N TOU= SW/MATOS SFAIROEIDEI=S GENE/SQAI DOGMATI/ZEI>20. @&10Hieronymus ep. 108, 23 [1ad Eustochium]1. Ossa audis et carnem &10et pedes et manus; et globos mihi <21Stoicorum>21 atque ae%28ria quaedam deli-&10ramenta confingis. &10@Commenta Lucani lib. IX 1 p. 289 Us. alii existimant animas &10statim elisas corpore solvi ac dissipari in principia sua, inter quos Epi- @1&10curus. alii solidas quidem, postquam exierint de corpore, permanere, sed &10deinde tractu temporis dissipari%10 haec opinio <21Stoicorum>21. &10@Commenta Lucani Lib. VII 816 p. 252 Us. Non altius ibis in &10auras%10 quamdiu vivimus, habemus discretionem%10 mortui unum sumus omnes. &10sectas hic tangit Epicureorum et <21Stoicorum>21. &10@Origenes contra celsum I Vol. I p. 66, 2 Ko+. [1p. 331 ed. Delarue]1.$10 W(S EI) LE/GOIMEN KAI\ TO\N *PLATWNIKO/N, PISTEU/ONTA TH=| A)QANASI/A| TH=S YUXH=S KAI\ TOI=S PERI\ AU)TH=S LEGOME/NOIS PERI\ METENSWMATW/SEWS, MWRI/AN A)NEILHFE/NAI W(S PRO\S TOU\S *STWI+KOU/S, DIASU/RONTAS TH\N TOU/TWN SUGKATA/QESIN. @&10Seneca ep. 57. Nunc me putas de Stoicis dicere, qui existimant &10animam hominis magno pondere extriti permanere non posse et statim &10spargi, quia non fuerit illi exitus liber. &10@Arius Didymus epit. phys. fr. 39 Diels [1DG p. 471, 11]1.$10 EI)=NAI DE\ YUXH\N E)N TW=| O(/LW| FASI/N, O(\ KALOU=SIN AI)QE/RA KAI\ A)E/RA, KU/KLW| PERI[2E/XOUSAN]2 GH=N KAI\ QA/LASSAN KAI\ E)K TOU/TWN A)NAQUMIAQEI=S[2AN]2: TA\S DE\ LOIPA\S YUXA\S PROSPEFUKE/NAI TAU/TH|, O(/SAI TE E)N ZW/|OIS EI)SI\ KAI\ O(/SAI E)N TW=| PERIE/XONTI: DIA-ME/NEIN GA\R E)KEI= TA\S TW=N A)POQANO/NTWN YUXA/S. E)/NIOI DE\ TH\N ME\N TOU= O(/LOU A)I/+DION, TA\S DE\ LOIPA\S SUMMI/GNUSQAI E)PI\ TELEUTH=| EI)S E)KEI/NHN. E)/XEIN DE\ PA=SAN YUXH\N H(GEMONIKO/N TI E)N AU(TH=|, O(\ DH\ ZWH\ KAI\ AI)/SQHSI/S E)STI KAI\ O(RMH/. @&10Cicero Tuscul. disp. I 77. <21Stoici>21 autem usuram nobis largiun-&10tur tamquam cornicibus; diu mansuros aiunt animos, semper negant. &10@Alexander Aphrod. de anima libri mant. p. 118, 6 Bruns.$10 *(/OTI MH\ "1<20MI/A H( TH=S YUXH=S DU/NAMIS, W(S TH\N AU)TH/N PWS E)/XOUSAN POTE\ ME\N DIANOEI=SQAI, POTE\ DE\ O)RGI/ZESQAI, POTE\ D' E)PIQUMEI=N PARA\ ME/ROS>20"2 DEIKTE/ON. @&10Themistius paraphr. in Arist. de anima I 1 p. 5 Sp.$10 OI( ME\N POLUDU/NAMON A)CIOU=SIN EI)=NAI TH\N YUXH\N E)F' E(NO\S OU)=SAN U(POKEIME/NOU, OI( DE\ POLUMERH=, DIORI/ZONTES KAI\ TOI=S TO/POIS TA\ ME/RH, W(/SPER <20OI( *STWI+KOI/>20. @&10Jamblichus de anima apud Stobaeum ecl. I p. 373, 15 W.$10 E)PI\ DH\ TOU/TOIS DEI= NOEI=N W(S <20OI( ME\N *STWI+KOI\>20 PA/SAS TH=S O(POIASOU=N YUXH=S TA\S E)NERGEI/AS SUMMIGNU/OUSIN TOI=S DIOIKOUME/NOIS KAI\ A)YU/XOIS, OI( D' A)PO\ *PLA/TWNOS OU) PA/SAS. @&Jamblichus de anima apud Stobaeum ecl. I p. 367, 17 W.$ A)LLA\ MH\N OI(/ GE A)PO\ <20*XRUSI/PPOU>20 KAI\ *ZH/NWNOS FILO/SOFOI KAI\ PA/NTES O(/SOI SW=MA TH\N YUXH\N NOOU=SI TA\S ME\N DUNA/MEIS W(S E)N TW=| U(POKEIME/NW| POIO/THTAS SUMBIBA/ZOUSI, TH\N DE\ YUXH\N W(S OU)SI/AN PROU+POKEIME/NHN TAI=S @1 DUNA/MESI PROTIQE/ASIN, E)K D' A)MFOTE/RWN TOU/TWN SU/NQETON FU/SIN E)C A)NOMOI/WN SUNA/GOUSIN. @&p. 368, 6.$ KAQ' OU(\S DE\ MI/A ZWH\ TH=S YUXH=S E)STIN H( TOU= SUNQE/TOU, SUGKEKRAME/NHS TH=S YUXH=S TW=| SW/MATI, W(S OI( <20*STWI+KOI\>20 LE/GOUSIN, _ _KATA\ TOU/TOUS EI(=S E)STIN O( TRO/POS TH=S PAROUSI/AS AU)TW=N, O( E)N TW=| METE/XESQAI H)\ E)N TW=| KEKRA=SQAI TW=| O(/LW| ZW/|W|. PW=S OU)=N DIAKRI/NONTAI; KATA\ ME\N <20TOU\S *STWI+KOU\S>20 E)/NIAI ME\N DIAFORO/THTI [2TW=N]2 U(POKEIME/NWN SWMA/TWN: PNEU/MATA GA\R A)PO\ TOU= H(GEMONIKOU= FASIN OU(=TOI DIATEI/NEIN A)/LLA KAT' A)/LLA, TA\ ME\N EI)S O)FQALMOU/S, TA\ DE\ EI)S W)=TA, TA\ DE\ EI)S A)/LLA AI)SQHTH/RIA: E)/NIAI DE\ I)DIO/THTI POIO/THTOS PERI\ TO\ AU)TO\ U(POKEI/MENON: W(/SPER GA\R TO\ MH=LON E)N TW=| AU)TW=| SW/MATI TH\N GLUKU/THTA E)/XEI KAI\ TH\N EU)WDI/AN, OU(/TW KAI\ TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N E)N TAU)TW=| FANTASI/AN, SUGKATA/QESIN, O(RMH/N, LO/GON SUNEI/LHFE. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. IV 4, 4.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 E)C O)KTW\ MERW=N FASI SUNE-STA/NAI [1TH\N YUXH/N]1, PE/NTE ME\N TW=N AI)SQHTIKW=N O(RATIKOU= A)KOUSTIKOU= O)SFRAN-TIKOU= GEUSTIKOU= A(PTIKOU=, E(/KTOU DE\ FWNHTIKOU=, E(BDO/MOU DE\ SPERMATIKOU=, O)GDO/OU DE\ AU)TOU= TOU= H(GEMONIKOU=, A)F' OU(= TAU=TA PA/NTA E)PITE/TATAI DIA\ TW=N OI)KEI/WN O)RGA/NWN PROSFERW=S TAI=S TOU= POLU/PODOS PLEKTA/NAIS. @&10Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 110.$10 FASI\ DE\ TH\N YUXH\N EI)=NAI O)KTAMERH=: ME/RH GA\R AU)TH=S TA/ TE PE/NTE AI)SQHTH/RIA KAI\ TO\ FWNHTIKO\N MO/RION KAI\ TO\ DIANOHTIKO/N, O(/PER E)STI\N AU)TH\ H( DIA/NOIA, KAI\ TO\ GENNHTIKO/N. @&`157.$10 ME/RH DE\ YUXH=S LE/GOUSIN O)KTW/, TA\S PE/NTE AI)SQH/SEIS KAI\ TOU\S E)N H(MI=N SPERMATIKOU\S LO/GOUS KAI\ TO\ FWNHTIKO\N KAI\ TO\ LOGISTIKO/N. @&10Origenes contra Celsum V 47 Vol. II p. 51, 19 Ko+. [1p. 614 &10Delarue]1.$10 A)/LLH ME\N H( KAT' *)EPI/KOURON DIKAIOSU/NH, A)/LLH DE\ H( KATA\ TOU\S A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S, <20A)RNOUME/NOUS TO\ TRIMERE\S TH=S YUXH=S>20. @&10Porphyrius de anima apud Stobaeum ecl. I p. 350, 13.$10 AU)TI/KA <20OI( ME\N A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 O)KTAMERH= TH\N YUXH\N QE/NTES KAI\ PE/NTE ME\N ME/RH TA\ AI)SQHTIKA\ LABO/NTES, E(/KTON DE\ TO\ FWNHTIKO\N KAI\ E(/BDOMON TO\ SPERMATIKO/N, TO\ LOIPO\N TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N W(S A)\N A)/RXONTOS XW/RAN E)/XEIN U(PETI/QENTO, TA\ DE\ A)/LLA ME/RH E)N U(PHRE/TOU TA/CEI A)PEDI/DOSAN, W(/STE TO\ AU)TO\ E)C A)/RXONTOS KAI\ A)RXOME/NWN SUNESTA/NAI. @&10Jamblichus de anima apud Stobaeum ecl. I p. 369, 5.$10 OI( A)PO\ *ZH/NWNOS O)KTAMERH= TH\N YUXH\N [DIA]DOCA/ZOUSI, PERI\ [2H(\N]2 TA\S DUNA/MEIS EI)=NAI PLEI/ONAS, W(/SPER E)N TW=| H(GEMONIKW=| E)NUPARXOUSW=N FANTASI/AS, SUGKATAQE/SEWS, O(RMH=S, LO/GOU. @&10Philo quaest. et solut. in Genesin I 75 [1p. 49 Aucher]1. Cum &10octo partibus anima nostra constet, ex rationali individua et irrationali @1 &10in septem partes distingui solita, in quinque nempe sensus et in vocis &10instrumentum et geniturae etc. &10@Philo de animalibus adv. Alexandrum p. 170 Aucher. Non vides &10quod parvulum infantem nemo de ullo opere facto accusat unquam, eo &10quod prudentis aetatis nondum particeps fuerit? At puer, quamvis imper-&10fectus comperitur, quia tamen homo est rationalis natura, paulo ante ac-&10ceptis sapientiae seminibus, quamvis nondum formare rem potest, paulo †&10tamen post oriri faciet; etenim aura recepta seminales vires ad modum &10scintillae in silva iuxta tempora cum illo crescentes vigere ac adhaerere &10debent. Aliorum vero [1animalium]1 animae non habentes fontem mentis &10progressu deliberationis carent. &10@Jamblichus de anima apud Stobaeum ecl. I p. 317, 21 W.$10 PA/LIN TOI/NUN PERI\ TOU= NOU= KAI\ PASW=N TW=N KREITTO/NWN DUNA/MEWN TH=S YUXH=S <20OI( ME\N *STWI+KOI\>20 LE/GOUSI MH\ EU)QU\S E)MFU/ESQAI TO\N LO/GON, U(/STERON DE\ SUNA-QROI/ZESQAI A)PO\ TW=N AI)SQH/SEWN KAI\ FANTASIW=N PERI\ DEKATE/SSARA E)/TH. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. IV 21.$10 *PO/QEN AI)SQHTIKH\ GI/NETAI H( YUXH\ KAI\ TI/ AU)-TH=S TO\ H(GEMONIKO/N. &10G. 102.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI/>20 FASIN EI)=NAI TH=S YUXH=S A)NW/TA-TON ME/ROS TO\ H(GEMONIKO/N, TO\ POIOU=N TA\S FANTASI/AS KAI\ SUGKATAQE/SEIS KAI\ AI)SQH/SEIS KAI\ O(RMA/S: KAI\ TOU=TO LOGISMO\N KALOU=SIN. _*)APO\ DE\ TOU= H(GEMONI-KOU= E(PTA\ ME/RH E)STI\ TH=S YUXH=S E)KPEFUKO/TA KAI\ E)KTEINO/MENA EI)S TO\ SW=MA KAQA/PER AI( A)PO\ TOU= POLU/PODOS PLEKTA/NAI: TW=N DE\ E(PTA\ MERW=N TH=S YUXH=S PE/NTE ME/N EI)SI TA\ AI)SQHTH/RIA, O(/RASIS O)/SFRHSIS A)KOH\ GEU=SIS KAI\ A(FH/. _ *(=WN H( ME\N O(/RASIS E)STI\ PNEU=MA DIATEI=NON A)PO\ H(GEMONIKOU= ME/XRIS O)FQALMW=N, A)KOH\ DE\ PNEU=MA DIATEI=NON A)PO\ TOU= H(GEMONIKOU= ME/XRIS W)/TWN, O)/SFRHSIS DE\ PNEU=MA DIATEI=NON A)PO\ TOU= H(GEMONIKOU= ME/XRI MUKTH/RWN [LEPTU=NON], GEU=SIS DE\ PNEU=MA DIATEI=NON A)PO\ TOU= H(GEMONIKOU= ME/XRI GLW/TTHS, A(FH\ DE\ PNEU=MA DIATEI=-NON A)PO\ TOU= H(GEMONIKOU= ME/XRIS E)PIFANEI/AS EI)S QI/CIN EU)AI/SQHTON TW=N PROS-PIPTO/NTWN. _*TW=N DE\ LOIPW=N TO\ ME\N LE/GETAI SPE/RMA, O(/PER KAI\ AU)TO\ PNEU=MA/ E)STI DIATEI=NON A)PO\ TOU= H(GEMONIKOU= ME/XRI TW=N PARASTATW=N: TO\ DE\ "1FWNA=EN"2 U(PO\ TOU= *ZH/NWNOS EI)RHME/NON, O(\ KAI\ FWNH\N KALOU=SIN, E)/STI PNEU=MA DIATEI=NON A)PO\ TOU= H(GEMONIKOU= ME/XRI FA/RUGGOS KAI\ GLW/TTHS KAI\ TW=N OI)KEI/WN O)RGA/NWN. AU)TO\ DE\ TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N W(/SPER E)N KO/SMW| [2H(/LIOS]2 KATOIKEI= E)N TH=| H(METE/RA| SFAIROEIDEI= KEFALH=|. @&Seneca epist. 113, 23.&3 inter Cleanthen et discipulum eius Chry-&3sippum non convenit, quid sit ambulatio. Cleanthes ait spiritum esse a &3principali usque in pedes permissum, Chrysippus ipsum principale. @1 @&10Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 159.$10 <20H(GEMONIKO\N>20 DE\ EI)=NAI TO\ KURIW/TATON TH=S YUXH=S, E)N W(=| AI( FANTASI/AI KAI\ AI( O(RMAI\ GI/NONTAI KAI\ O(/QEN O( LO/GOS A)NA-PE/MPETAI: O(/PER EI)=NAI E)N KARDI/A|. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. IV 5, 6.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 PA/NTES E)N O(/LH| TH=| KARDI/A| H)\ TW=| PERI\ TH\N KARDI/AN PNEU/MATI [1&10sc.$10 EI)=NAI TO\ H(GEMONIKO/N]1. &10cf. Theodoret V 22 &10p. 73, 14. &10@Alexander Aphrod. de anima p. 97, 8 Bruns.$10 KAI\ O(/TI ME\N KAI\ H( AI)SQHTIKH\ [1&10scil.$10 YUXH\]1 W(/SPER KAI\ H( QREPTIKH\ PERI\ TH\N KARDI/AN E)STI/N_ _E)K TOU/TWN GNW/RIMON A)\N EI)/H. A)LLA\ MH\N O(/POU AI( AI)SQH/SEIS TELEUTW=SIN, E)KEI= KAI\ TH\N FANTASTIKH\N YUXH\N A)NAGKAI=ON EI)=NAI__A)LLA\ MH\N E)N W(=| H( FANTASI/A, E)N TOU/TW| KAI\ AI( SUGKATAQE/SEIS, E)N W(=| DE\ AI( SUGKATAQE/SEIS, E)N TOU/TW| KAI\ O(RMAI/ TE KAI\ O)RE/CEIS. @&10p. 98, 24.$10 O(/TI DE\ KAI\ TO\ LOGISTIKO\N MO/RION TH=S YUXH=S, O(\ KAI\ I)DI/WS H(GEMONIKO\N KALEI=TAI, E)N TH=| KARDI/A| KAI\ AU)TO/, DEIKNU/OITO A)\N TW=| &10etc. [1secuntur &10argumenta]1. @&Stobaeus Florileg. 3, 66.$ *XRUSI/PPOU: *XRU/SIPPOS O( *STWI+KO\S E)/FH, TH\N DIA/NOIAN EI)=NAI LO/GOU PHGH/N. @&Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. plac. V 3 [1`160]1 p. 421 M. In &libro qui inscriptus erat$8 PERI\ PAQW=N QERAPEUTIKO\S &Chrysippus dixerat%10$8 <20*)/ESTI DE/ GE TH=S YUXH=S ME/RH, DI' W(=N O( E)N AU)TH=| LO/GOS SUNE/STHKEN.>20 &G. ex aliis Chr. libris enucleare studet, quas dixerit Chr. animi partes%10$8 A)NAMIMNH/SKWN I)/SWS H(MA=S TW=N <20E)N TOI=S PERI\ TOU= LO/GOU>20 GEGRAMME/NWN, W(=N SU\ DIH=LQES, "1<20W(S E)/STIN E)NNOIW=N TE/ TINWN KAI\ PROLH/YEWN A)/QROISMA>20."2 A)LL' EI)/PER E(KA/STHN TW=N E)NNOIW=N KAI\ PROLH/YEWN EI)=NAI MO/RION NOMI/ZEIS TH=S YUXH=S, A(MARTA/NEIS DITTA/. PRW=TON ME\N GA\R OU) YU-XH=S E)XRH=N, A)LLA\ LO/GOU TAU=T' EI)=NAI MO/RIA FA/SKEIN, W(/SPER OU)=N KAI\ GRA/-FEIS <20E)N TH=| PERI\ LO/GOU PRAGMATEI/A|>20. OU) GA\R DH/POU TAU)TO/N E)STI YUXH\ KAI\ LO/GOS: A)/LLWS TE KAI\ DIA\ TH=S PROGEGRAMME/NHS R(H/SEWS E)NEDEI/CW TW=N E)N TH=| YUXH=| SUNISTAME/NWN W(S E(/N TI KAI\ O( LO/GOS E)STI/N. OU) TAU)TO\N DE\ YUXH/ E)STI KAI\ TO\ E)N AU)TH=| SUNISTA/MENON. E)/PEITA__TA/S G' E)NNOI/AS KAI\ PROLH/YEIS OU) MO/RIA TH=S YUXH=S EI)=NAI LEKTE/ON. ___<20AI( ME\N GA\R E)/NNOIAI KAI\ AI( PROLH/YEIS E)NE/RGEIAI [2MO/RIA DE\]2 TH=S YUXH=S, W(S AU)TO\S SU\ DI' E(TE/RWN E)KDIDA/SKEIS>20, TO/ TE A)KOUSTIKO\N PNEU=MA KAI\ TO\ O)PTIKO\N E)/TI TE PRO\S TOU/TOIS FWNHTIKO/N TE KAI\ GENNHTIKO/N, KAI\ PRO\ PA/N-TWN AU)TW=N TO\ H(GEMONIKO/N, E)N W(=| KAI\ TO\N LO/GON E)/FHS SUNI/STASQAI &etc.$8 __TOU=T' OU)=N TO\ PNEU=MA DU/O ME\N KE/KTHTAI MO/RIA/ TE KAI\ STOIXEI=A KAI\ KATASTA/SEIS, DI' O(/LWN A)LLH/LOIS KEKRAME/NA, TO\ YUXRO\N KAI\ QERMO/N, EI)/PER D' E(TE/ROIS O)NO/MASI KAI\ A)PO\ TW=N OU)SIW=N E)QE/LOI TIS AU)TA\ PROSAGO-REU/EIN, A)E/RA TE KAI\ PU=R: OU) MH\N A)LLA\ KAI\ I)KMA/DA TINA\ PROSEI/LHFEN A)PO\ TW=N SWMA/TWN, E)N OI(=S DIAITA=TAI. @&10Philo de sacrif. Abel et Cain %14 137 Vol. I p. 256, 22 Wendl.$10 O(/TI TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N KATA\ A)MERH= XRO/NWN DIASTH/MATA [2POLLA\S]2 PRO\S E(KA/TERON @1 TO/ TE EU)= KAI\ XEI=RON TROPA\S LAMBA/NON, A)LLA/TTONTAS A)EI\ TU/POUS DE/XETAI TO/TE ME\N KAQAROU= KAI\ DOKI/MOU, TO/TE DE\ PARAKEKOMME/NOU KAI\ KIBDH/LOU NOMI/SMATOS. *TH\N DEDEGME/NHN OU)=N XW/RAN A)/MFW TA\ MAXO/MENA, KALO/N TE KAI\ AI)SXRO\N KAI\ PRO\S E(KA/TERON W)|KEIWME/NHN KAI\ TH\N I)/SHN TIMH\N A)MFOTE/ROIS A)PONE/MOUSAN__ O( NOMOQE/THS A)PO\ TOU= QEI/OU BWMOU= KATEBI/BASE [1&10Dubitat Philo %14 136 utrum &10cerebro an cordi insit animi principale%10$10 EI)/GE KAI\ KATA\ TO\N NOMOQE/THN E)N E(TE/RW| TOU/TWN TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N A)NWMOLO/GHTAI]1. @&10Philo Leg. Alleg. I %14 59 Vol. I p. 75, 25 Wendl.$10 *OI( DE\ LE/GOUSI TH\N KARDI/AN CU/LON EI)RH=SQAI ZWH=S, E)PEIDH\ AI)TI/A TE TOU= ZH=N E)STI, KAI\ TH\N ME/SHN TOU= SW/MATOS XW/RAN E)/LAXEN, W(S A)\N KAT' AU)TOU\S H(GEMONIKO\N U(PA/RXOUSA. _ @&10%14 61.$10 TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N H(MW=N PANDEXE/S E)STI KAI\ E)/OIKE KHRW=| PA/NTAS TU/POUS, KALOU/S TE KAI\ AI)SXROU\S DEXOME/NW|. @&10Philo Leg. Alleg. I %14 30 Vol. I p. 68 Wendl.$10 *TO\ GA\R ZW=|ON TOU= MH\ ZW/|OU DUSI\ PROU)/XEI, FANTASI/A| KAI\ O(RMH=|: H( ME\N OU)=N FANTASI/A SUNI/STATAI KATA\ TH\N TOU= E)KTO\S PRO/SODON TUPOU=NTOS NOU=N DI' AI)SQH/SEWS: H( DE\ O(RMH/, TO\ A)DELFO\N TH=S FANTASI/AS, KATA\ TH\N TOU= NOU= TONIKH\N DU/NAMIN: H(\N TEI/NAS DI' AI)SQH/SEWS A(/PTETAI TOU= U(POKEIME/NOU KAI\ PRO\S AU)TO\ XWREI= GLIXO/MENOS E)FI-KE/SQAI KAI\ SULLABEI=N AU)TO/. @&10Tertullianus de carne Christi cp. 12. Opinor sensualis est ani-&10mae natura. Adeo nihil animale sine sensu, nihil sensuale sine anima. &10__Igitur cum omnibus anima sentire praestet, et ipsa sentiat omnium &10etiam sensus, nedum qualitates, cui veri simile est, ut ipsa sensum sui &10ab initio sortita non sit? Unde illi scire quod interdum sibi sit necessa-&10rium ex naturalium necessitate, si non scit suam qualitatem, cui quid &10necessarium est? Hoc quidem in omni anima recognoscere est, notitiam &10sui dico, sine qua notitia sui nulla anima se ministrare potuisset. Puto &10autem magis hominem, animal solum rationale, computes et animam esse &10sortitum, quae illum faciat animal rationale, ipsa in primis rationalis. &10Porro quomodo rationalis quae efficit hominem rationale animal, si ipsa &10rationem suam nescit, ignorans semet ipsam. &10@Plutarchus apud Olympiodorum in Plat. Phaedon. p. 124, 20 &10ed. Finckh.$10 <20*(/OTI OU)X H( YUXH\ TRE/PEI E(AUTH\N EI)S TH\N TW=N PRAGMA/TWN KATA/LHYIN KAI\ A)PA/THN KATA\ TOU\S A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20: PW=S GA\R AI)TI/A E(AUTH=| GNW/SEWS H( YUXH\ KAI\ A)GNOI/AS, MH/PW AU)TA\S E)/XOUSA A)RXH/N. @&10Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 47 p. 1084f.$10 FANTASI/A GA/R TIS ςH( E)/NNOIA/ E)STI, FANTASI/A DE\ TU/PWSIS E)N YUXH=|: YUXH=S DE\ FU/SIS A)NAQUMI/ASIS, H(\N TUPWQH=NAI ME\N E)RGW=DES DIA\ MANO/THTA, DECAME/NHN DE\ THRH=SAI TU/PWSIN A)DU/NATON: H(/ TE GA\R TROFH\ KAI\ H( GE/NESIS AU)TH=S E)C U(GRW=N OU)=SA SUNEXH= TH\N E)PIFORA\N E)/XEI KAI\ TH\N A)NA/LWSIN: H(/ TE PRO\S TO\N A)E/RA [2DIA\]2 TH=S A)NAPNOH=S E)PIMICI/A KAINH\N A)EI\ POIEI= TH\N A)NAQUMI/ASIN, E)CISTAME/NHN KAI\ TREPOME/NHN U(PO\ TOU= QU/RAQEN E)MBA/LLONTOS O)XETOU= KAI\ PA/LIN E)CIO/NTOS. @&10p. 1085a.$10 A)LL' OU(/TW PARAKOU/OUSIN E(AUTW=N, W(/STE TA\S E)NNOI/AS A)POKEI-ME/NAS TINA\S O(RIZO/MENOI NOH/SEIS, MNH/MAS DE\ MONI/MOUS KAI\ SXETIKA\S TUPW/SEIS, TA\S D' E)PISTH/MAS KAI\ PANTA/PASI PHGNU/NTES W(S TO\ A)META/PTWTON KAI\ BE/BAION E)XOU/SAS, EI)=TA TOU/TOIS U(POTI/QESQAI BA/SIN_OU)SI/AS_FEROME/NHS A)EI\ KAI\ R(EOU/SHS. @1 @&10Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 45 p. 1084a.$10 A)/TOPON GA\R EU)= MA/LA TA\S A)RETA\S KAI\ TA\S KAKI/AS, PRO\S DE\ TAU/TAIS TA\S TE/XNAS KAI\ TA\S MNH/MAS PA/SAS, E)/TI DE\ FANTASI/AS KAI\ PA/QH KAI\ O(RMA\S KAI\ SUGKATAQE/SEIS SW/MATA POIOUME/NOUS, E)N MHDENI\ FA/NAI KEI=SQAI MHD' U(PA/RXEIN TO/PON TOU/TOIS, E(/NA [2DE\]2 TO\N E)N TH=| KARDI/A| PO/RON STIGMIAI=ON A)POLIPEI=N, O(/POU TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N SUSTE/LLOUSI TH=S YUXH=S, U(PO\ TOSOU/TWN SWMA/TWN KATEXO/MENON, O(/SWN TOU\S PA/NU DOKOU=NTAS A)FORI/ZEIN KAI\ A)POKRI/NEIN E(/TERON E(TE/ROU POLU\ PLH=QOS DIAPE/FEUGE. TO\ DE\ MH\ MO/NON SW/MATA TAU=TA POIEI=N, A)LLA\ KAI\ ZW=|A LOGIKA\_U(PERBOLH/ TI/S E)STIN_PARANOMI/AS EI)S TH\N_SUNH/QEIAN. &10p. 1084c.$10 A)LLA\ PRO\S TOU/-TOIS E)/TI KAI\ TA\S E)NERGEI/AS SW/MATA KAI\ ZW=|A POIOU=SI &10etc. &10@Sextus adv. math. VII 307.$10 NAI/ FASIN [1&10scil. dogmatici i. e. Stoici$10]1 A)LLA\ TAU)TO/N E)STI DIA/NOIA KAI\ AI)/SQHSIS, OU) KATA\ TAU)TO\ DE/, A)LLA\ KAT' A)/LLO ME\N DIA/NOIA, KAT' A)/LLO DE\ AI)/SQHSIS: KAI\ O(\N TRO/PON TO\ AU)TO\ POTH/RION KOI=LO/N TE KAI\ PERI/KURTON LE/GETAI, OU) KATA\ TAU)TO\ DE/, A)LLA\ KAT' A)/LLO ME\N KOI=LON, OI(=ON TO\ E)NTO\S ME/ROS, KAT' A)/LLO DE\ PERI/KURTON, KAQA/PER TO\ E)KTO/S, KAI\ W(S H( AU)TH\ O(DO\S A)NA/NTHS TE KAI\ KATA/NTHS NOEI=TAI, A)NA/NTHS ME\N TOI=S A)NIOU=SI DI' AU)TH=S, KATA/NTHS DE\ TOI=S KATIOU=SIN, OU(/TWS H( AU)TH\ DU/NAMIS KAT' A)/LLO ME/N E)STI NOU=S KAT' A)/LLO DE\ AI)/SQHSIS, KAI\ OU)K EI)/RGETAI H( AU)TH\ OU)=SA TH=S PROEIRH-ME/NHS TW=N AI)SQH/SEWN KATALH/YEWS. @&10ibid. 359.$10 A)LL' E)/NIOI TW=N DOGMATIKW=N TH\N A)NW/TERON EI)RHME/NHN U(PO/-TEUCIN KAI\ E)PI\ TOU= PARO/NTOS QRULOU=SI, LE/GONTES MH\ KEXWRI/SQAI TAU=TA TA\ DIA-FE/RONTA TH=S YUXH=S ME/RH, TOUTE/STI TO\ LOGIKO\N KAI\ A)/LOGON, A)LL' W(S TO\ ME/LI O(/LON DI' O(/LOU U(GRO\N A(/MA KAI\ GLUKU/ E)STIN, OU(/TW KAI\ H( YUXH\ O(/LH DI' O(/LOU DU/O E)/XEI TA\S A)NTIPARHKOU/SAS A)LLH/LAIS DUNA/MEIS, W(=N H( ME/N E)STI LOGIKH\ H( DE\ A)/LO-GOS: KAI\ KINEI=SQAI TH\N ME\N LOGIKH\N U(PO\ TW=N NOHTW=N, TH\N DE\ A)/LOGON A)NTI-LHPTIKH\N GI/NESQAI TW=N AI)SQHTW=N O(/QEN KAI\ MA/TAION EI)=NAI TO\ LE/GEIN TH\N DIA/NOIAN H)\ KOINW=S TH\N YUXH\N MH\ DU/NASQAI TH=S E(TE/RAS TOU/TWN TW=N PRAGMA/-TWN DIAFORA=S A)NTILAMBA/NESQAI: DIA/FORON GA\R E)/XOUSA TH\N KATASKEUH/N, EU)QU\S KAI\ A)MFOTE/RWN E)/STAI A)NTILHPTIKH/. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. IV 8, 1.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 O(RI/ZONTAI OU(/TWS TH\N AI)/SQHSIN: AI)/SQHSI/S E)STIN A)NTI/LHYIS DI' AI)SQHTHRI/OU H)\ KATA/LHYIS. POLLAXW=S DE\ LE/GETAI H( AI)/SQHSIS: H(/ TE GA\R E(/CIS KAI\ H( DU/NAMIS KAI\ H( E)NE/RGEIA: KAI\ H( FANTASI/A H( KATALHPTIKH\ DI' AI)SQHTHRI/OU GI/NETAI KAT' AU)TO\ TO\ H(GEMONIKO/N. A)F' OU(= PA/LIN AI)SQHTH/RIA LE/GETAI PNEU/MATA NOERA\ A)PO\ TOU= H(GEMONIKOU= E)PI\ TA\ O)/RGANA TETAME/NA. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. IV 8, 8.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 SWMA/TWN TA\S AI)SQH/SEIS. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. IV 8, 7.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 TH/NDE TH\N KOINH\N AI)/SQHSIN E)NTO\S A(FH\N PROSAGOREU/OUSI, KAQ' H(\N KAI\ H(MW=N AU)TW=N A)NTILAMBANO/MEQA. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. IV 10, 1.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 PE/NTE TA\S EI)DIKA\S AI)SQH/SEIS, O(/RASIN A)KOH\N O)/SFRHSIN GEU=SIN A(FH/N. @1 @&10Ae%28tius Plac. IV 23, 1.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 TA\ ME\N PA/QH E)N TOI=S PEPON-QO/SI TO/POIS, TA\S DE\ AI)SQH/SEIS E)N TW=| H(GEMONIKW=|. @&10Galenus de symptomatum causis I 8 Vol. VII p. 139 K.$10 KAI\ PERI\ ME\N TW=N AI)SQHTIKW=N O)RGA/NWN A(PA/NTWN, E)/TI TE TW=N KATA\ TAU=TA DUNA/-MEWN H)/DH MOI DOKW= PE/RAS E)/XEIN TO\N LO/GON. E)P' AU)TO\ DE\ TO\ KATA/RXON AU)TW=N E)PIPE/MPON TE TOI=S KATA\ ME/ROS OI(=ON E)K PHGH=S TINOS E(AUTOU= TA\S DUNA/MEIS E)PI-E/NAI TW=| LO/GW| KAIRO/S. E)/STI DE\ DH/POU TO\ PRW=TON AI)SQHTIKO/N. E)N AU)TOI=S ME\N GA\R TOI=S KATA\ ME/ROS O)RGA/NOIS E(KA/STH| TW=N AI)SQH/SEWN H( A)PO\ TW=N AI)SQHTW=N A)LLOI/WSIS E)PITELEI=TAI. TAU/THS DE\ AI)SQHTIKO\N GI/GNETAI TO\ A)LLOIOU/MENON MO/RION, E)K TOU= DE/XESQAI TH\N A)P' E)GKEFA/LOU KATIOU=SAN EI)S AU)TO\ DIA\ TOU= NEU/ROU DU/NAMIN. @&10Galenus de locis affectis I 7 Vol. VIII p. 66 K.$10 KAI\ DIAFE/REI PA/MPOLU KATA\ TOU=TO TA\ FUSIKA\ TW=N YUXIKW=N O)RGA/NWN, EI)/ GE TOI=S ME\N FUSI-KOI=S E)DEI/XQH SU/MFUTOS H( TH=S E)NERGEI/AS DU/NAMIS OU)=SA, TOI=S YUXIKOI=S DE\ A)PO\ TH=S A)RXH=S E)PIR)R(EI=N O(MOI/WS H(LIAKW=| FWTI/. __&10`67$10. OI( DE\ MU/ES__O(/TI OU)K E)/XOUSI SU/MFUTON AI)SQH/SEW/S TE KAI\ KINH/SEWS A)RXH/N, DIA\ TOU=TO TW=N NEU/RWN A)EI\ XRH/|ZOUSI, XORHGOU/NTWN AU)TOI=S TAU=TA, KAQA/PER O( H(/LIOS TH\N AU)GH\N A(/PASIN OI(=S FWTI/ZEI. @&10ibid. IV 1. Vol. VIII p. 218 K. opticam facultatem dicit perire,$10 O(/TAN H)/TOI MHD' O(/LWS H)\ PANTA/PASIN O)LI/GON E)PIPE/MPHTAI <20TO\ AU)GOEIDE\S PNEU=MA>20 PARA\ TH=S KATA\ TO\N E)GKE/FALON A)RXH=S. @&10Galenus de locis affectis II 5 Vol. VII p. 127.$10 KATA\ ME\N GA\R TO\N A)LHQH= LO/GON KAI\ BLE/PEIN AU)TO\ TOU=TO [1&10scil.$10 TO\ TH=S YUXH=S H(GEMONIKO/N]1 KAI\ A)KOU/EIN U(POLHPTE/ON, A)LLA\ DI' O)FQALMW=N ME\N BLE/PEIN, DI' W)/TWN D' A)KOU/EIN: E)NNOEI=N ME/NTOI KAI\ MEMNH=SQAI KAI\ LOGI/ZESQAI KAI\ PROAIREI=SQAI MH/T' O)FQAL-MOI=S E)/TI MH/T' W)SI\ MH/TE GLW/TTH| MH/T' A)/LLW| TINI\ PROSXRW/MENON. @&10Plotinus Ennead. IV lib. VII 7 [1Vol. II p. 111, 10 Mu+.]1.$10 O(/TAN DA/KTULON LE/GHTAI A)LGEI=N A)/NQRWPOS, H( ME\N O)DU/NH PERI\ TO\N DA/KTULON DH/POU-QEN, H( D' AI)/SQHSIS TOU= A)LGEI=N DH=LON O(/TI O(MOLOGH/SOUSIN W(S PERI\ TO\ H(GEMO-NOU=N GI/GNETAI: A)/LLOU DH\ O)/NTOS TOU= PONOU=NTOS ME/ROUS TOU= PNEU/MATOS, TO\ H(GEMONOU=N AI)SQA/NETAI KAI\ O(/LH H( YUXH\ TO\ AU)TO\ PA/SXEI. PW=S OU)=N TOU=TO SUMBAI/NEI; DIADO/SEI, FH/SOUSI, PAQO/NTOS ME\N PRW/TWS TOU= PERI\ TO\N DA/KTULON YUXIKOU= PNEU/MATOS, METADO/NTOS DE\ TW=| E)FECH=S KAI\ TOU/TOU A)/LLW|, E(/WS OU(= PRO\S TO\ H(GEMONOU=N A)FI/KOITO. @&10Galenus de instrum. odoratus 3. Vol. II 862 K.$10 FWTOEIDE/STATON ME\N OU)=N E)POI/HSEN [1&10scil.$10 H( FU/SIS]1 TO\ TH=S O)/YEWS O)/RGANON, W(S A)\N KAI\ MO/NON AU)GH=S KAI\ FWTO\S AI)SQANO/MENON, A)ERW=DES TO\ TH=S A)KOH=S, AI)SQHTIKO\N E)SO/MENON KAI\ TOU=TO TW=N KATA\ TO\N A)E/RA YO/FWN. OU(/TW DE\ KAI\ TO\ TW=N XUMW=N DIAGNW-STIKO\N O)/RGANON, TH\N GLW=TTAN, E)K TH=S U(GROTE/RAS I)DE/AS TOU= SW/MATOS H( FU/SIS EI)RGA/SATO. METACU\ DE\ A)E/ROS TE KAI\ U(GROU= [KAI\ PURO\S] TO\ TH=S O)SFRH/SEW/S E)STIN AI)SQHTO/N, OU)/Q' OU(/TW LEPTOMERE\S U(PA/RXON, W(S O( A)H/R, OU)/Q' OU(/TW PAXU-MERE/S, W(S TO\ U(GRO/N. O(/SON GA\R A)POR)R(EI= TW=N SWMA/TWN E(KA/STOU, TOU=T' E)/STI TW=N O)SFRHTW=N H( OU)SI/A. @&10Galenus de usu partium VIII 6 Vol. III p. 639.$10 TETTA/RWN OU)=N O)/NTWN KATA\ TH\N KEFALH\N AI)SQHTIKW=N O)RGA/NWN, O)FQALMW=N KAI\ W)/TWN KAI\ R(I- @1NO\S KAI\ GLW/TTHS, __E)/STIN AU)TOI=S KAT' EI)=DOS A)NOMOIO/THS E)/N TE TAI=S AI)SQH-TIKAI=S DUNA/MESIN AU)TAI=S KAI\ TOI=S SW/MASI DI' W(=N A)FIKNOU=NTAI. AI( ME\N GA\R DUNA/MEIS H( ME\N O)DMW=N, H( DE\ XUMW=N, H( DE\ FWNW=N, H( DE\ XRWMA/TWN E)STI\ DIA-GNWSTIKH/. __E(/KASTON ME\N GA\R AU)TW=N A)LLOIWQH=NAI XRH\ PA/NTWS, I(/N' AI)/SQHSIS GE/NHTAI: A)LLOIOU=TAI D' OU)X U(PO\ PANTO\S AI)SQHTOU= PA=N, A)LLA\ TO\ ME\N AU)GOEIDE\S KAI\ FWTOEIDE\S U(PO\ XRWMA/TWN, TO\ D' A)ERW=DES U(PO\ FWNW=N, TO\ D' ܈A)TMW=DES U(PO\ TW=N O)SFRHTW=N, E(NI\ DE\ LO/GW| TO\ O(/MOION TW=| O(MOI/W| GNW/RIMON. OU)/TE DE\ TO\ A)ERW=DES AI)SQHTH/RION A)LLOIWQH=NAI DU/NATAI/ POT' U(PO\ XRWMA/TWN, LAMPRO\N GA\R EI)=NAI XRH\ KAI\ KAQARO\N KAI\ AU)GOEIDE/S, EI)/ TI ME/LLEI R(A|DI/WS TE KAI\ EI)LIKRINW=S E)KDE/CASQAI TH\N E)K TW=N XRWMA/TWN A)LLOI/WSIN, __OU)/T' AU)= TO\ QOLERO\N KAI\ A)TMW=DES, A)LL' OU)DE\ TO\ U(GRO/N TE KAI\ U(DATW=DES, W(/SPER OU)DE\ TO\ SKLHRO/N TE KAI\ GEW=DES. __A)LL' OU)DE\N H)=N PLE/ON, A)LLOIWQH=NAI ME\N TOU=TO, MH\ GNW=NAI DE\ TH\N A)LLOI/WSIN TO\ FANTASIOU/MENON KAI\ MEMNHME/NON KAI\ LOGIZO/MENON, O(/PER H)=N TO\ H(GEMONIKO/N. @&p. 642.$10 OU)KOU=N__AU)GOEIDEI= KAI\ LAMPROEIDEI= ME/LLONTI TW=| KATA\ TH\N O)/YIN AI)SQHTHRI/W| GENH/SESQAI TO\ PNEU=MA DEO/NTWS PLEI=STON A)PO\ TH=S A)RXH=S E)PIPE/MPETAI. @&p. 648.$10 SXEDO\N GA\R O(/SON LEI/PETAI PRO\S LEPTOME/REIAN O( A)H\R AU)GH=S, TO-SOU=TON KAI\ A)TMO\S A)E/ROS. @&10Philo de fuga et inventione %14 182 Vol. III p. 149, 31.$10 *POTI/ZE-TAI OU)=N, W(/SPER A)PO\ PHGH=S TOU= KATA\ YUXH\N H(GEMONIKOU= TO\ SW/MATOS H(GEMO-NIKO\N PRO/SWPON, TO\ ME\N O(RATIKO\N PNEU=MA TEI/NONTOS EI)S O)/MMATA, TO\ D' A)KOU-STIKO\N EI)S OU)=S, EI)S DE\ MUKTH=RAS TO\ O)SFRH/SEWS, TO\ D' AU)= GEU/SEWS EI)S STO/MA, KAI\ TO\ A(FH=S EI)S SU/MPASAN TH\N E)PIFA/NEIAN. @&10Philo de posteritate Caini %14 126 Vol. II p. 27, 26 Wendl.$10 OU) DEI\S GOU=N EU)= FRONW=N EI)/POI A)\N O)FQALMOU\S O(RA=N, A)LLA\ NOU=N DI' O)FQALMW=N, OU)D' W)=TA A)KOU/EIN, A)LLA\ DI' W)/TWN E)KEI=NON, OU)DE\ MUKTH=RAS O)SFRAI/NESQAI, A)LLA\ DIA\ MUKTH/RWN TO\ H(GEMONIKO/N &10etc. &10@Chalcidius ad Timaeum cp. 237. <21Stoici>21 vero videndi causam &10in nativi spiritus intentione constituunt, cuius effigiem coni similem volunt. &10Hoc quippe progresso ex oculorum penetrali, quod appellatur pupula, et ab &10exordio tenui, quo magis porrigitur, in soliditatem opimato exordio, penes &10id quod videtur locatam fundi omnifariam dilatarique visus inlustrationem. &10Quodque omnis natura modo mensuraque moveatur, spatii quoque magni-&10tudinisque coni modum fore, eaque re neque valde adplicata visui nec ni-&10mium distantia visibilia clare videri. certe conum ipsum pro modo men-&10suraque intentionis augeri, et prout basis eius vel directa vel inflexa erit &10incidetque in contemplabilem speciem, ita adparebunt quae videntur. One-&10raria quippe navis eminus visa perexigua apparet deficiente contemplationis &10vigore nec se per omnia navis membra fundente spiritu. turris item &10quadrata rotunditatem simulat cylindri, atque etiam ex obliquo visa por-&10ticus in exile deficit oculorum depravatione. Sic etiam stellarum ignis @1 &10exiguus adparet, atque ipse sol multis partibus quam terra maior intra &10bipedalis diametri ambitum cernitur. Sentire porro mentem <21putant>21 per-&10inde ut eam pepulerit spiritus, qui id quod ipse patitur ex visibilium &10specierum concretione mentis intimis tradit%10 porrectus siquidem et veluti &10patefactus candida esse denuntiat quae videntur, confusus porro et con-&10foecatior atra et tenebrosa significat. Similisque eius passio est eorum, &10qui marini piscis contagione torpent, siquidem per linum et harundinem &10perque manus serpat virus illud penetretque intimum sensum. &10@idem cp. 266. At vero <21Stoici>21 deum visum vocantes, quod optimum &10putabant. id enim pulchro dei nomine afficiendum esse duxerunt. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de anima libri mant. p. 130, 14 Bruns.$10 *EI)SI\N DE/ TINES, OI(\ DIA\ TH=S TOU= A)E/ROS SUNENTA/SEWS TO\ O(RA=N FASI GI/NESQAI. NUTTO/-MENON GA\R U(PO\ TH=S O)/YEWS TO\N SUNA/PTONTA TH=| KO/RH| A)E/RA SXHMATI/ZESQAI EI)S KW=NON: TOU/TOU DE\ OI(=ON TUPOUME/NOU KATA\ TH\N BA/SIN U(PO\ TW=N O(RATW=N TH\N AI)/SQHSIN GI/NESQAI, KAQA/PER KAI\ TH=| A(FH=|, DIA\ BAKTHRI/AS. @&10`26.$10 A)LLA\ KAI\ TH=S O)/YEWS A)PO\ TOU= H(GEMONIKOU= GINOME/NHS, <20EI) KAI\ E)PI\ TAU/THS TA\ TH=S TONIKH=S KINH/SEW/S E)STIN, W(/SPER LE/GETAI PRO\S AU)-TW=N>20, PW=S OU) GI/NONTAI DIALEI/YEIS TINE\S TOU= O(RA=N, <20A(/TE MH\ SUNEXOU=S E)PI\ TA\ PE/RATA TH=S TA/SEWS GINOME/NHS, DI' AU)TO\ DE\ TOU=TO MHDE\ TH=S E)PEREI/SEWS>20; O(/PER A)/N TIS E)PIZHTH/SEIEN KAI\ PERI\ TH=S A(FH=S, KAQ' H(\N A(PTO/-MEQA TW=N E(TE/RWN SWMA/TWN: OU)DE\ GA\R E)PI\ TAU/THS DIALEI/YEIS TH=S A)NTILH/YEWS GI/NONTAI: E)/DEI DE/ GE: <20TOIAU/TH GA\R H( TONIKH\ KI/NHSIS KAT' AU)TOU/S>20. EI) DE\ TO\ PNEU=MA TOU=TO DH/, O(\ KALOU=SIN O)/YIN, MO/NON KINEI=TAI TH\N PROEIRHME/NHN KI/NHSIN, H(\N LE/GOUSI TONIKH/N, A)/LOGON TO\ E)PI\ MO/NOU TOU/TOU LE/GEIN OU(/TW: KAI/-TOI GE OU)/ FASIN. @&10Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. plac. VII [1`642 M. K.]1.$10 MH\ TOI/NUN W(S DIA\ BAKTHRI/AS TOU= PE/RIC A)E/ROS O(RA=N H(MA=S OI( *STWI+KOI\ LEGE/TWSAN. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. IV 15, 3 [1DDG p. 406, 4]1.$ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 KATA\ TH\N SUNE/NTASIN TOU= METACU\ A)E/ROS O(RA=N H(MA=S, NUGE/NTOS ME\N U(PO\ TOU= O(RATIKOU= [1&Stob.$ O)PTIKOU=]1 PNEU/MATOS, O(/PER A)PO\ TOU= H(GEMONIKOU= ME/XRI TH=S KO/RHS DIH/KEI, KATA\ DE\ TH\N PRO\S TO\N PERIKEI/MENON A)E/RA E)PIBOLH\N E)NTEI/NONTOS AU)TO\N KWNOEIDW=S, O(/TAN H)=| O(MOGENH\S O( A)H/R. PROXE/ONTAI DE\ E)K TH=S O)/YEWS A)KTI=NES PU/RINAI, OU)XI\ ME/LAINAI KAI\ O(MIXLW/DEIS: DIO/PER O(RATO\N EI)=NAI TO\ SKO/TOS. @&10Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 157.$ O(RA=N DE\ TOU= METACU\ TH=S O(RA/SEWS KAI\ TOU= U(POKEIME/NOU FWTO\S E)NTEINOME/NOU KWNOEIDW=S, KAQA/ FHSI <20*XRU/-SIPPOS>20 E)N <20DEUTE/RA| TW=N FUSIKW=N>20 KAI\ *)APOLLO/DWROS. GI/NESQAI ME/NTOI TO\ KWNOEIDE\S TOU= A)E/ROS PRO\S TH=| O)/YEI, TH\N DE\ BA/SIN PRO\S TW=| O(RWME/NW|: W(S DIA\ BAKTHRI/AS OU)=N TOU= TAQE/NTOS A)E/ROS TO\ BLEPO/MENON A)NAGGE/LLESQAI. @1 @&10Alexander Aphrod. de anima libri mant. p. 131, 30 Bruns.$10 E)/TI DIA\ TI/ E)K ME\N FWTO\S TA\ E)N SKO/TW| O)/NTA OU)X O(RA=TAI, E)K DE\ SKO/TOUS TA\ E)N TW=| FWTI/; <20TO\ GA\R LE/GEIN, TO\N ME\N PEFWTISME/NON A)E/RA TW=| DIAKEKRI/SQAI MA=LLON E)/XEIN I)SXU\N KAI\ DU/NASQAI TH=| E)PEREI/SEI TH\N AI)/SQHSIN KI-NEI=N, TO\N DE\ A)FW/TISTON TW=| KEXALA=SQAI MH\ DU/NASQAI U(PO\ TH=S O)/YEWS SUNENTEI/NESQAI>20, KAI/TOI PUKNO/TERON O)/NTA TOU= PEFWTISME/NOU, PW=S PIQANO/N; @&10Ae%28tius Plac. IV 15, 2.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 O(RATO\N EI)=NAI TO\ SKO/TOS. E)K GA\R TH=S O(RA/SEWS PROXEI=SQAI/ TINA EI)S AU)TO\ AU)GH/N: KAI\ OU) YEU/DETAI H( O(/RASIS: BLE/PETAI GA\R TAI=S A)LHQEI/AIS O(/TI E)STI\ SKO/TOS. @&10Galenus de symptomatum causis I 2 Vol. VII p. 98 K. [1de ocu-&10lorum morbis locutus%10$10]1 OU(/TW DE\ KAI\ TO\ PNEU=MA TO\ YUXIKO\N H)\ A)KRIBW=S E)STI KAQARO/N, OI(=O/S PER O( AI)QH/R, H)\ U(GRO\N KAI\ QOLERO\N O(MI/XLHS DI/KHN: KAI\ KATA\ TO\ POSO\N TH=S OU)SI/AS H)/TOI PLE/ON H)\ E)/LATTON. E)A\N ME\N OU)=N A(/MA POLU/ TE KAI\ AI)QERW=DES U(PA/RCH|, KAI\ TA\ PLEI=STON A)PE/XONTA QEA=TAI KAI\ A)KRIBH= TH\N DIA/-GNWSIN AU)TW=N POIEI=TAI. E)A\N DE\ O)LI/GON ME\N H)=|, KAQARO\N DE/, TA\ ME\N E)GGU\S A)KRIBW=S DIAGINW/SKEI, TA\ PO/RRWQEN DE\ OU)X O(RA=|: E)A\N DE\ U(GRO/TERO/N TE A(/MA KAI\ POLU\ TU/XH|, ME/XRI ME\N PLEI/STOU, OU)K A)KRIBW=S D' O(RA=|: W(/SPER GE KAI\ EI) U(GRO/N TE A(/MA KAI\ O)LI/GON EI)/H, OU)/T' A)KRIBW=S OU)/T' A)/XRI PLEI/STOU O(RA=|. @&10Gellius Noct. Att. V 16, 2. <21Stoici>21 causas esse videndi dicunt &10radiorum ex oculis in ea, quae videri queunt, emissionem ae%28risque simul &10intentionem. &10@Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 158.$10 A)KOU/EIN DE\ [2H(MA=S]2 TOU= METACU\ TOU= [TE] FWNOU=NTOS KAI\ TOU= A)KOU/ONTOS A)E/ROS PLHTTOME/NOU SFAIROEIDW=S, EI)=TA KUMA-TOUME/NOU KAI\ TAI=S A)KOAI=S PROSPI/PTONTOS, W(S KUMATOU=TAI TO\ E)N TH=| DECAMENH=| U(/DWR KATA\ KU/KLOUS U(PO\ TOU= E)MBLHQE/NTOS LI/QOU. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de anima libri mant. p. 118, 25 Bruns.$10 E)/TI EI) TO\ GENNHTIKO\N MO/RION YUXIKO/N FASIN, TOU=TO DE\ U(PO\ TO\ FUTIKO/N, EI)/H A)\N KAI\ TO\ FUTIKO\N PA=N YUXIKO/N. @&10Philo de incorr. mundi p. 256, 7.$10 KAI\ GA\R EU)/HQES, A)/NQRWPON ZW=NTA ME\N O)GDO/W| ME/REI YUXH=S, O(\ KALEI=TAI GO/NIMON, PRO\S TH\N TOU= O(MOI/OU SPORA\N XRH=SQAI, TELEUTH/SANTA DE\ O(/LW| E(AUTW=|. QA/NATOS GA\R OU)/TI ZWH=S A)NUSI-MW/TEROS [1&10Sunt verba Stoici cuiusdam, fortasse Panaetii, contra <21Chrysip-&10pum>21 disputantis]1. &10@Galenus de causis pulsuum IV 3 Vol. IX p. 159 K.$10 DIAXEI=TAI GA\R TO\ QERMO\N TOI=S H(DOME/NOIS EI)S A(/PAN TO\ SW=MA KAI\ H( E)KTO\S AU)TOU= KRATEI= KI/NHSIS, W(/SPER TOI=S LUPOUME/NOIS H( E)NTO/S. @1 @&10Galenus de locis affectis V 1 Vol. VIII p. 301 K,$10 KAI\ MH\N KAI\ KAQ' E(/TERO/N TINA TRO/PON E)PI\__A)LGH/MASI/N TE SFODROI=S KAI\ FO/BOIS I)SXU-ROI=S H(DONAI=S TE MEGI/STAIS A)POQNH/SKOUSI/ TINES. O(/SOIS GA\R A)SQENH/S E)STIN O( ZWTIKO\S TO/NOS I)SXURA/ TE PA/QH YUXIKA\ PA/SXOUSIN E)C A)PAIDEUSI/AS, EU)DIA/LUTOS TOU/TOIS E)STI\N H( TH=S YUXH=S OU)SI/A. TW=N TOIOU/TWN E)/NIOI KAI\ DIA\ LU/PHN A)PE/-QANON, OU) MH\N EU)QE/WS, W(/SPER E)N TOI=S PROEIRHME/NOIS. A)NH\R D' OU)DEI\S MEGA-LO/YUXOS OU)/T' E)PI\ LU/PAIS OU)/T' E)PI\ TOI=S A)/LLOIS O(/SA LU/PHS I)SXURO/TERA QANA/TW| PERIE/PESEN. O(/ TE GA\R TO/NOS TH=S YUXH=S AU)TOI=S I)SXURO/S E)STI TA/ TE PAQH/MATA SMIKRA/. @&10Galenus de locis affectis IV 3 Vol. VIII p. 233 K.$10 E(/PETAI DE\ KAI\ SFODRAI=S O)DU/NAIS TO\ PA/QOS TOU=TO, KATAPI/PTONTOS E)N AU)TAI=S TOU= KATA\ TO\ YUXIKO\N PNEU=MA TO/NOU. @&10Galenus de sanitate tuenda II 9 Vol. VI p. 138 K.$10 O( ME/N GE QUMO\S OU)D' A(PLW=S AU)/CHSIS, A)LL' OI(=ON ZE/SIS KATA\ TH\N KARDI/AN QERMOU=: DIO\ KAI\ TH\N OU)SI/AN AU)TOU= TW=N FILOSO/FWN OI( DOKIMW/TATOI TOIAU/THN EI)=NAI/ FASI. SUMBEBHKO\S GA/R TI KAI\ OU)K OU)SI/A TOU= QUMOU= E)STIN H( TH=S A)NTITIMWRH/SEWS O)/RECIS. @&Chalcidius ad Timaeum cp. 220.&3 <21Stoici>21 vero cor quidem &3sedem esse principalis animae partis consentiunt, nec tamen sanguinem, &3qui cum corpore nascitur. Spiritum quippe animam esse <21Zenon>21 quaerit &3hactenus%10 quo recedente a corpore moritur animal, hoc certe anima est. &3naturali porro spiritu recedente moritur animal%10 naturalis igitur spiri-&3tus anima est. Item &1Chrysippus%10&3 una et eadem, inquit, certe re &3spiramus et vivimus. spiramus autem naturali spiritu%10 ergo etiam vivi-&3mus eodem spiritu. vivimus autem anima%10 naturalis igitur spiritus &3anima esse invenitur. Haec igitur, inquit, octo in partes divisa invenitur. &3constat enim e principali et quinque sensibus, etiam vocali substantia &3et serendi procreandique potentia. Porro animae partes velut ex capite &3fontis cordis sede manantes per universum corpus porriguntur omniaque &3membra usque quaque vitali spiritu complent reguntque et moderantur &3innumerabilibus diversisque virtutibus nutriendo, adolendo, movendo, mo-&3tibus localibus instruendo, sensibus compellendo ad operandum, totaque &3anima sensus, qui sunt eius officia, velut ramos ex principali parte illa &3tamquam trabe pandit, futuros eorum quae sentiunt nuntios, ipsa de iis &3quae nuntiaverint iudicat ut rex. Ea porro quae sentiuntur composita &3sunt, utpote corpora, singulique item sensus unum quiddam sentiunt%10 &3hic colores, sonus alius, ast ille sucorum sapores discernit, hic vapores @1 &3odoraminum, ille asperum levigationemque tactu. atque haec omnia ad &3praesens. neque tamen praeteritorum meminit sensus ullus nec suspi-&3catur futura. Intimae vero deliberationis et considerationis proprium &3cuiusque sensus intelligere passionem et ex iis quae nuntiant colligere quid &3sit illud, et praesens quidem accipere, absentis autem meminisse, futurum &3item providere. Definit idem intimam mentis deliberationem sic%10 <21inti-&3mus est motus animae vis rationabilis>21. Habent quippe etiam &3muta vim animae principalem, qua discernunt cibos, imaginantur, decli-&3nant insidias, praerupta et praecipitia supersiliunt, necessitudinem re-&3cognoscunt, non tamen rationabilem, quin potius naturalem. Solus vero &3homo ex mortalibus principali mentis bono, hoc est ratione, utitur, ut &3ait idem <21Chrysippus. "1Sicut aranea in medietate cassis omnia &3filorum tenet pedibus exordia, ut, cum quid ex bestiolis pla-&3gas incurrerit ex quacunque parte, de proximo sentiat, sic &3animae principale, positum in media sede cordis, sensuum &3exordia retinere, ut cum quid nuntiabunt de proximo reco-&3gnoscat>21."2 Vocem quoque <21dicunt>21 e penetrali pectoris, id est corde &3mitti, gremio cordis nitente spiritu, qua nervis obsitus limes interiectus &3cor a pulmone secernit utroque et vitalibus ceteris, quo faucium angustias &3arietante formanteque lingua et ceteris vocalibus organis articulatos edi &3sonos, sermonis elementa%10 quo quidem interpretis mentis arcani motus &3aperiantur. id porro principale animae <21vocat>21. @&Tertullianus de anima cp. 15&3 &3Etiam Protagoras, etiam Apollodorus et &3<21Chrysippus>21 haec sapiunt. @&Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. plac. V 1 [1`155]1 p. 404 Mu+.$ *(O PERI\ TW=N PAQW=N TH=S YUXH=S LO/GOS A)NAGKAI=OS ME\N H)=N H(MI=N E)SKE/FQAI KAI\ DI' E(AUTO/N: A)NAGKAIO/TERON DE\ E)POI/HSAN AU)TO\N <20OI( PERI\ TO\N *XRU/SIPPON>20 EI)S A)PO/DEICIN TOU= PERIE/XONTOS TO/POU TO\ TH=S YUXH=S H(GEMONOU=N PROS-XRHSA/MENOI. DEI/CANTES GA/R, W(S ME\N AU)TOI\ NOMI/ZOUSIN, A(/PANTA TA\ PA/QH SUNISTA/MENA KATA\ TH\N KARDI/AN, W(S DE\ TA)LHQE\S E)/XEI, TA\ KATA\ MO/NON TO\N QUMO/N, E)/PEITA PROSLABO/NTES, W(S E)/NQA A)\N H)=| TA\ PA/QH TH=S YUXH=S, E)NTAU=Q' E)STI\ KAI\ TO\ LOGIZO/MENON AU)TH=S, OU(/TWS H)/DH PERAI/NOUSIN, E)N TH=| KARDI/A| TO\ LOGISTIKO\N U(PA/RXEIN. @&Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. plac. II 5 [1`99.100]1 p. 208 Mu+.$ KAI\ TOU=TO BOU/LETAI/ GE <20*ZH/NWN KAI\ *XRU/SIPPOS>20 A(/MA TW=| SFETE/RW| XORW=| PANTI/, DIADI/DOSQAI TH\N E)K TOU= PROSPESO/NTOS E)/CWQEN E)GGINOME/NHN TW=| MORI/W| KI/NHSIN EI)S TH\N A)RXH\N TH=S YUXH=S, I(/N' AI)/SQHTAI TO\ ZW=|ON. @1 @&Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. plac. II 2 p. 170 Mu+.$ TA\ GA\R I)DIW/TIKA/ TE KAI\ R(HTORIKA\ LH/MMATA AI)DOU=NTAI [1&sc.$ OI( PERI\ *)ARISTOTE/LHN]1 PARALAM-BA/NEIN EI)S A)PODEI/CEIS E)PISTHMONIKA/S, W(=N <20PE/PLHSTAI TA\ *XRUSI/PPOU BIBLI/A>20, POTE\ ME\N I)DIW/TAS E)PIKALOU/MENA MA/RTURAS W(=N U(POTI/QETAI LHMMA/TWN, E)/STI D' O(/TE POIHTA/S, H)\ TH\N BELTI/STHN E)TUMOLOGI/AN, H)/ TI A)/LLO TOIOU=TON, A(\ PERAI/NEI ME\N OU)DE/N, A)NALI/SKEI DE\ KAI\ KATATRI/BEI MA/THN H(MW=N TO\N XRO/NON AU)TO\ TOU=TO MO/NON E)NDEIKNUME/NWN AU)TOI=S, W(S OU)K E)/STIN E)PISTHMONIKA\ TA\ TOU= SUMPERA/SMATOS LH/MMATA, META\ TAU=TA DE\ KAI\ SUGKATABAINO/NTWN TE KAI\ SUMPALAIO/NTWN AU)TOI=S U(PE\R TOU= DEI=-CAI KAI\ TOU\S I)DIW/TAS KAI\ TOU\S POIHTA\S OU)DE\N H(=TTON H(MI=N H)\ E)KEI/NOIS MARTUROU=NTAS, A)LL' E)/STIN O(/TE KAI\ MA=LLON &etc.$ __E)N E(TE/RA| PRAGMA-TEI/A| DE/DEIKTAI/ MOI TH=| PERI\ O)NOMA/TWN O)RQO/THTOS, E)/NQA KAI\ PERI\ TH=S "1E)GW\"2 FWNH=S E)PE/DEICA TO\N *XRU/SIPPON E)TUMOLOGOU=NTA YEUDW=S. TI/ ME\N OU)=N E)/TI DEOI/MHN U(PE\R TW=N AU)TW=N E)NTAU=QA DIECIE/NAI; *XRUSI/PPW| ME\N GA\R KAI\ TOU=TO FI/LON, OU) DI\S H)\ TRI/S, A)LLA\ KAI\ TETRA/KIS E)NI/OTE KAI\ PENTA/KIS U(PE\R TW=N AU)TW=N E)N DIAFEROU/SAIS PRAGMATEI/AIS DIE/RXESQAI: FULA/CAITO D' A)/N TIS AU)TO\ TW=N XRO/NOU FEIDOME/NWN. @&Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. III 5 [1`123]1 p. 293 Mu+.$ A)FE/MENOS OU)=N H)/DH TW=N PROGEGRAMME/NWN E)PI\ TA\ E)FECH=S TRE/YOMAI, DI' W(=N O( *XRU/SIP-POS A)/RXETAI PARATI/QESQAI TA\S TW=N POIHTW=N MARTURI/AS, METACU\ PAREN-TIQEI\S AU)TW=N O)LI/GOUS LO/GOUS E(AUTOU=, POLLA/KIS ME\N W(/SPER E)CH/GHSIN W(=N H( R(H=SIS BOU/LETAI, POLLA/KIS D' W(/SPER E)PITOMH/N TINA KAI\ OI(=ON KA-QO/LOU TI KEFA/LAION. A)RCA/MENOS OU)=N A)PO/ TINOS *)EMPEDOKLEI/OU R(H/SEWS E)CHGEI=TAI/ TE AU)TH\N KAI/ TINWN KATA\ TH\N E)CH/GHSIN A)CIOLOGWTE/RWN A)/RXE-TAI LO/GWN, E)N OI(=S E)STI KAI\ O( PERI\ TH=S FWNH=S, OU(= KATA\ TO\ DEU/TERON E)MNHMO/NEUSA TW=NDE TW=N U(POMNHMA/TWN, &ibi enim graviores Chrysippi &voces se refutavisse, plane futilibus omissis.$ DO/CAN DE\ TOI=S E(TAI/ROIS A)/MEINON EI)=NAI MHD' O(/SA PANTA/PASIN H)DOLE/SXHTAI TW=| *XRUSI/PPW| MHDE\ TAU=Q' U(PERBH=NAI PANTELW=S, A)LL' E)PISHMH/NASQAI/ TE TH\N A)TOPI/AN AU)TW=N, __DIA\ TOU=TO PROSE/QHKA PA/NTA TAU=TA. __PERI\ ME\N DH\ TH=S FWNH=S OU)DE\N E)/TI DE/OMAI LE/GEIN__O(/SA DE\ E)FECH=S E)/TI TOU= PERI\ TAU/THS LO/GOU KATA\ TO\ TOU= *XRUSI/PPOU BIBLI/ON EI)RHME/NA, TOU/TWN H)/DH MNHMONEU/SW. E)/STI DE\ TA/ TE KATA\ TA\S FORA\S TW=N XEIRW=N, O(/TAN E)FAPTW/-MEQA TW=N STE/RNWN H(MA=S AU)TOU\S DEIKNU/NTES, E)/TI TE TA\ KATA\ TH\N "1E)GW\"2 FWNH/N, A(\ <20DH\ KA)N TOI=S E)TUMOLOGIKOI=S EI)=PEN>20, E)/XEIN TI FA/SKWN AU)TH\N DEIKTIKO\N E)K TOU= FAINOME/NOU, DIA\ TO\ KATA\ TH\N PRW/THN E)N AU)TH=| SULLABH\N W(S E)PI\ TO\ STH=QOS A)PA/GESQAI TH/N TE KA/TW GE/NUN KAI\ TO\ XEI=LOS. __&p. 295.$ O(/MOIA DE\ TOI=S TOIOU/TOIS E)PIXEIRH/MASI KAI\ TA\ KATA\ TH\N E)TUMOLOGI/AN EI)SI\ TOU= TH=S KARDI/AS O)NO/MATOS, E(CH=S TW=N PRO- @1EIRHME/NWN U(PO\ TOU= *XRUSI/PPOU GEGRAMME/NA KATA\ TO\ PRW=TON PERI\ YU-XH=S, W(=DE/ PWS E)/XONTA [1&sequ. verba]1. Dein Chr. summam totius doctrinae &brevibus verbis attigisse refert. p. 296.$ O(RMW=MEN KATA\ TOU=TO TO\ ME/ROS_ PA/NTA. &p. 297.$ E(CH=S DE\ PERI/ TE FWNH=S MNHMONEU/EI KAI\ NEU/RWN A)RXH=S __KAI\ META\ TAU=TA TH\N "1A)KA/RDIOS"2 E)CHGEI=TAI PROSHGORI/AN. __ &p. 298.$ H(/ TE GA\R E)N TOI=S FO/BOIS PA/LSIS TH=S KARDI/AS. __&p. 303.$ A)TO/-PWS OU)=N AU)TO\ KATA\ TAU=TA E)CAXQHSO/MENON. __&p. 308.$ H(YA/MHN SOU TH=S KARDI/AS. __&p. 309.$ META\ DE\ TH\N PROGEGRAMME/NHN R(H=SIN E(TE/RA TIS E)FECH=S E)STIN E)N H(=| TOU\S A)SPLA/GXNOUS TE KAI\ TOU\S OU)K E)/XONTAS E)GKE/FALON E)CHGEI=TAI. __&p. 309.$ KATA\ TOIA/NDE MOI DOKOU=SI MA/LISTA FORA\N KAI\ OI( TIMWRHTIKW/TERON__&sequuntur quatuor alia frag-&menta huic cohaerentia, p. 314. 15.$ E)FECH=S DE\ TOI=SDE PLH=QOS E)PW=N O( *XRU/SIPPOS GRA/FEI TW=N PLEI/STWN E(AUTW=| MAXOME/NWN, W(S E)/MPROSQEN E)/DEICA. TA\ DE\ METACU\ TW=N E)PW=N E)STI ME\N O)LI/GISTA, PERIE/XETAI DE/ TIS KATA\ TAU=T' E)NANTIOLOGI/A TOU= *XRUSI/PPOU PRO\S E(AUTO/N, H(\N E)N TW=| META\ TOU=T' E)PIDEI/CW BIBLI/W|, KAQ' O(\ PERI\ TW=N TH=S YUXH=S PAQW=N E)/GNWKA POIH/SASQAI TO\N LO/GON. __&p. 315.$ O( DE\ POIHTH\S PLEONA/ZWN_O(/TI DE\ KAI\ TO\ E)PIQUMHTIKO\N E)NTAU=QA_O(/TI DE\ TO\ QUMOEIDE\S E)NTAU=QA/ POU/ E)STI. __&p. 316.$ TA\ D' U(PO/LOIPA KATA\ TO\ *XRUSI/PPOU BIBLI/ON E)PI-DRAMW/N, E)NTAU=QA/ POU KAI\ AU)TO\S H)/DH KATAPAU/SW TO\N E)NESTW=TA LO/GON. META\ DE\ TO\ PLH=QOS TW=N E)PW=N E)FECH=S O( *XRU/SIPPOS PERI/ TE FWNH=S KAI\ LO/GOU KAI\ NEU/RWN A)RXH=S, O(/SA TE TOU/TOIS SUNE/ZEUKTAI DIH=LQEN, A(\ DH\ KAI\ MO/NA TW=N KATA\ TO\ BIBLI/ON E)/PREPEN A)NDRI\ FILOSO/FW|, PERI\ W(=N KAI\ H(MEI=S E)N TW=| PRO\ TOU/TOU LO/GW| DIELHLU/QAMEN, U(PERBA/NTES TA\ PERITTW=S H)DOLESXHME/NA. __&p. 317.$ *NUNI\ ME/NTOI_E(CH=S PROSQH/SW TO\N PERI\ TH=S *)AQHNA=S LO/GON. @&Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. Plac. III 1 [1`112]1 p. 251 Mu+.$8 LE/GW DH\ O(/TI O( <20*XRU/SIPPOS KATA\ TO\N PRW=TON AU(TOU= PERI\ YUXH=S LO/GON>20 TW=N MERW=N AU)TH=S TOU= H(GEMONIKOU= MNHMONEU/EIN A)RXO/MENOS, E)/NQA DEIKNU/-NAI PEIRA=TAI, TH\N A)RXH\N TH=S YUXH=S E)N TH=| KARDI/A| MO/NH| PERIE/XESQAI, OU(-TWSI\ LE/GEI. @"1*(H <20YUXH\ PNEU=MA/ E)STI SU/MFUTON H(MI=N SUNEXE\S PANTI\ TW=| SW/MATI DIH=KON, E)/ST' A)\N H( TH=S ZWH=S EU)/PNOIA PARH=| E)N TW=| SW/-MATI. TAU/THS OU)=N TW=N MERW=N E(KA/STW| DIATETAGME/NWN MORI/W|, TO\ DIH=KON AU)TH=S EI)S TH\N TRAXEI=AN A)RTHRI/AN FWNH/N [2FAMEN]2 EI)=NAI, TO\ DE\ EI)S O)FQALMOU\S O)/YIN, TO\ DE\ EI)S W)=TA A)KOH/N, TO\ DE\ EI)S R(I=NAS O)/SFRHSIN, TO\ D' EI)S GLW=TTAN GEU=SIN, TO\ D' EI)S O(/LHN @1 TH\N SA/RKA A(FH/N, KAI\ TO\ EI)S O)/RXEIS E(/TERO/N TIN' E)/XON TOIOU=TON LO/GON SPERMATIKO/N, EI)S O(\ DE\ SUMBAI/NEI PA/NTA TAU=TA, E)N TH=| KARDI/A| EI)=NAI, ME/ROS O)\N AU)TH=S TO\ H(GEMONIKO/N. OU(/TW DE\ E)XO/N-TWN AU)TW=N, TA\ ME\N LOIPA\ SUMFWNEI=TAI, PERI\ DE\ TOU= H(GEMONIKOU= ME/ROUS TH=S YUXH=S DIAFWNOU=SIN, A)/LLOI E)N A)/LLOIS LE/GONTES AU)TO\ EI)=NAI TO/POIS. OI( ME\N GA\R PERI\ TO\N QW/RAKA/ FASIN EI)=NAI AU)TO/, OI( DE\ PERI\ TH\N KEFALH/N. KATA\ TA\ AU)TA\ DE\ TAU=TA DIAFWNOU=SI, POU= TH=S KEFALH=S KAI\ TOU= QW/RAKO/S E)STIN, OU) SUMFWNOU=NTES AU(TOI=S. *PLA/TWN DE\ KAI\ TRIMERH= TH\N YUXH\N FH/SAS EI)=NAI, TO\ ME\N LOGISTIKO\N E)/LEGEN E)N TH=| KEFALH=| EI)=NAI, TO\ DE\ QUMOEIDE\S PERI\ TO\N QW/RAKA, TO\ D' E)PIQUMHTIKO\N PERI\ TO\N O)MFALO/N. OU(/TW FAI/NETAI DIAFEU/GEIN O( TO/POS H(MA=S, OU)/T' AI)SQH/SEWS E)KFANOU=S GENOME/NHS, O(/PER E)PI\ TW=N LOIPW=N SUNTETU/XHKEN OU)/TE TW=N TEKMHRI/WN, DI' W(=N A)/N TIS SULLOGI/SAITO TOU=TO: OU)DE\ GA\R A)\N A)N-TILOGI/A E)PI\ TOSOU=TON PROH=LQEN KAI\ E)N I)ATROI=S KAI\ E)N FILO-SO/FOIS.>20"2 @AU(/TH PRW/TH R(H=SIS GE/GRAPTAI U(PO\ *XRUSI/PPOU PERI\ H(GEMONIKOU= <20KATA\ TO\ PRO/TERON PERI\ YUXH=S. TO\ ME\N GA\R H(/MISU ME/ROS AU)TW=| TH=S BI/BLOU TO\ PRO/TERON U(PE\R OU)SI/AS YUXH=S E)/XEI TH\N SKE/YIN>20. KATA\ DE\ TO\ E)FECH=S H(/MISU TO\ A)PO\ TH=S GEGRAMME/NHS R(H/SEWS A)RXO/MENON E)PIDEI-KNU/NAI PEIRA=TAI, TO\ TH=S YUXH=S H(GEMONOU=N E)N KARDI/A| PERIE/XESQAI. TH\N ME\N OU)=N A)RXH\N TOU= LO/GOU DI/KAION A)GA/SASQAI: SAFW=S TE GA\R A(/MA KAI\ A)KRIBW=S, W(S E)XRH=N EI)PEI=N A)RXO/MENON A)/NDRA THLIKOU/TOU DO/GMATOS, EI)/RH-TAI *XRUSI/PPW|___&p. 254.$8 TA\ D' E)FECH=S OU)KE/Q' O(MOI/WS E)/XEI. DI/-KAION GA\R H)=N, OI)=MAI, PRW=TON ME\N EI)PEI=N, U(PO\ TI/NWN PIQANW=N A)NAPEISQEI\S O( *PLA/TWN OU(/TWS E)DO/CAZEN, E)/PEITA DE\ E)CELE/GCAI KAI\ DIABALEI=N AU)TA/, KA)PI\ TOU/TW| TH\N E(AUTOU= KATASKEUA/SAI DO/CAN, &etc. @&Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. plac. III 1 [1`113]1 p.254 Mu+.$8 A)/RXETAI DE\ E)PIXEIREI=N A)PO\ TOU= GE/NOUS TW=N LHMMA/TWN, O(\ KATA\ MARTU/RWN DO/CAN H)\ PLH/QOUS, OU) KATA\ TH\N TOU= PRA/GMATOS FU/SIN A)/CION PISTEU/ESQAI. PARA-GRA/YW DE\ KAI\ TH\N R(H=SIN AU)TH\N W(=DE/ PWS E)/XOUSAN: @"1<20*PERI\ W(=N E(CH=S ZHTH/SOMEN PARAPLHSI/WS A)PO\ TH=S KOINH=S O(RMW/MENOI FORA=S KAI\ TW=N KATA\ TAU/THN EI)RHME/NWN LO/GWN.>20"2 @KOINH\N E)NTAU=QA FORA\N O( *XRU/SIPPOS EI)/RHKE TO\ KOINH=| PA=SIN @A)NQRW/POIS DOKOU=N: EI)=T' E)PIFE/RWN FHSI/: @"1<20*KAI\ E)PI\ TOU/TWN I(KANW=S FAI/NONTAI E)NHNE/XQAI A)P' A)RXH=S EI)S TO\ EI)=NAI TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N H(MW=N E)N TH=| KARDI/A|>20."2 @EI)=T' E)FECH=S TOU/TWN A(PTO/MENOS H)/DH TW=N E)PIXEIRHMA/TWN AU)-@TW=N W(=DE/ PWS GRA/FEI KATA\ LE/CIN: @1 @"1<20*KOINH=| DE/ MOI DOKOU=SIN OI( POLLOI\ FE/RESQAI E)PI\ TOU=TO, W(SA-NEI\ SUNAISQANO/MENOI PERI\ TO\N QW/RAKA AU)TOI=S TW=N KATA\ TH\N DIA/NOIAN PAQW=N GIGNOME/NWN, KAI\ MA/LISTA KAQ' O(\N H( KARDI/A TE/TAKTAI TO/PON, OI(=ON MA/LISTA E)PI\ TW=N LUPW=N KAI\ TW=N FO/BWN, KAI\ E)PI\ TH=S O)RGH=S, KAI\ MA/LISTA TOU= QUMOU=. [2W(SANEI\ GA\R TOU= QUMOU=]2 E)K TH=S KARDI/AS A)NAQUMIWME/NOU KAI\ W)QOUME/NOU E)KTO\S E)PI/ TINA KAI\ E)MFUSW=NTOS TO\ PRO/SWPON KAI\ TA\S XEI=RAS, GI/GNE-TAI H(MI=N E)/MFASIS.>20"2 [1&Dein probat Galenus, his verbis Chrysippum &Platonis decretum demonstravisse%10$8 TO\N QUMO\N E)N TOI=S KATA\ TO\N QW/RAKA TO/POIS U(PA/RXEIN]1. @&Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. plac. II 7 [1`106]1 p. 230, 16 Mu+. $8EU(RI/SKW DE\ OU)X H(/KISTA TO\N *XRU/SIPPON KAI\ A)/LLAS TINA\S E)NANTIOLOGI/AS E)N AU)TW=| TOU/TW| TW=| LO/GW| PERI\ TOU= TH=S YUXH=S H(GEMONIKOU= PEPOIHME/NON. E)N A)RXH=| GA\R PROEIPW/N, W(S TA\ ME\N A)/LLA ME/RH TH=S YUXH=S E)N OI(=S E)STI TOU= ZW/OU MORI/OIS O(MOLOGEI=TAI, PERI\ DE\ TOU= H(GEMONIKOU= MO/NOU ZHTEI=TAI, DIA\ TO\ MH/TE AI)/SQHSIN E)KFANH= MHDEMI/AN EI)=NAI AU)TOU=, MH/T' E)NARGE/S TI TEKMH/-RION, O)LI/GON U(/STERON W(S PERI\ FAINOME/NOU TOU= ME/ROUS DIALE/GETAI. E)/XOUSI D' AI( R(H/SEIS AU)TOU= TO/NDE TO\N TRO/PON. @"1<20*OU(/TW FAI/NETAI DIAFEU/GEIN O( TO/POS H(MA=S, OU)/TE AI)SQH/SEWS E)KFANOU=S GIGNOME/NHS, O(/PER E)PI\ TW=N LOIPW=N SUNTE/TEUXEN, OU)/TE TW=N TEKMHRI/WN, DI' W(=N A)/N TIS SULLOGI/SAITO TOU=TO: OU)DE\ GA\R A)\N [OU)D'] E)PI\ TOSOU=TON A)NTILOGI/AS PROH=LQEN I)ATROI=S TE KAI\ FILOSO/FOIS.>20"2 @*TAU=TA PROEIPW\N O( *XRU/SIPPOS E)FECH=S FHSIN, W(S A(/PANTES A)/NQRWPOI TW=N TH=S DIANOI/AS PAQW=N AI)SQA/NONTAI KATA/ TE TO\N QW/RAKA KAI\ TH\N KAR-DI/AN. E)/XEI DE\ KAI\ H(/DE H( R(H=SIS W(=DE: @"1<20*KOINH=| DE/ MOI DOKOU=SIN OI( POLLOI\ FE/RESQAI E)PI\ TOU=Q' W(S-ANEI\ AI)SQANO/MENOI PERI\ TO\N QW/RAKA AU)TOI=S TW=N KATA\ TH\N DIA/-NOIAN PAQW=N GIGNOME/NWN, KAI\ MA/LISTA KAQ' O(\N H( KARDI/A TE/TA-KTAI TO/PON, OI(=ON MA/LISTA E)PI\ TW=N FO/BWN KAI\ TW=N LUPW=N>20 [LE/GW] <20KAI\ E)PI\ TH=S O)RGH=S, KAI\ MA/LISTA TOU= QUMOU=>20."2 @*KATA\ TH/NDE TH\N R(H=SIN, EI) KAI\ MHDE\N A)/LLO, TO\ GOU=N W(SANEI\ PROS-E/QHKEN, OU) TOLMH/SAS A)/NTIKRUS EI)PEI=N, AI)SQA/NESQAI TOU\S A)NQRW/POUS TW=N KATA\ TH\N DIA/NOIAN PAQW=N E)N TW=| QW/RAKI GIGNOME/NWN. W(SANEI\ GA\R E)/FH SUNAISQANO/MENOI, MIKRO\N D' U(/STERON KAI\ TO\ "1W(SANEI\"2 PERIELW\N OU(TWSI\ GRA/FEI: @"1*(H <20GA\R PERI\ TH\N DIA/NOIAN GIGNOME/NH TARAXH\ KAQ' E(/KASTON @1 TOU/TWN AI)SQHTW=S PERI\ TOU\S QW/RAKA/S E)STIN>20."2 EI)=T' E)FECH=S "1<20TH=S ME\N GA\R O)RGH=S GIGNOME/NHS E)NTAU=QA, EU)/LOGON KAI\ TA\S LOIPA\S E)PIQUMI/AS E)NTAU=QA EI)=NAI.>20"2 KAI\ PA/LIN E)N TOI=S E(CH=S TOU= SUGGRA/MMA-TOS, KAI\ TA\ TW=N O)RGIZOME/NWN PA/QH, FHSI/, FAI/NETAI PERI\ TO\N QW/RAKA GIGNO/MENA, KAI\ TA\ TW=N E)RW/NTWN. KAI\ LOIPO\N OU)K E)/TI PAU/ETAI PERI\ TW=N PAQW=N DIALEGO/MENOS, W(S E)/N TE TW=| QW/RAKI KAI\ PERI\ TH\N KARDI/AN MA/LISTA SUNI/STASQAI FAINOME/NWN. W(/ST' E)/GWGE QAUMA/ZW TA)NDRO\S O(/PWS TO\ KAT' A)RXA\S U(F' E(AUTOU= GRAFO/MENON OU)K E)CH/LEIYEN, E)/NQA FHSI/N, OU)/T' AI)/SQHSIN OU)DEMI/AN E)MFANH= GI/GNESQAI, POU= TO\ KU/RION TH=S YUXH=S ME/ROS, OU)/TE TEK-MH/RION: OU) GA\R [2A)\N]2 E)PI\ TOSOU=TON DIENEXQH=NAI PRO\S A)LLH/LOUS I)ATROU/S TE KAI\ FILOSO/FOUS. @&Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. plac II 7 [1`107]1 p. 235 Mu+.$ A)LL' OU)/T' E)N TW=| BIBLI/W| <20TW=| PRW/TW| PERI\ YUXH=S>20, OU)/T' <20E)N TOI=S PERI\ PA-QW=N>20 A)PO/DEICI/N TINA EI)=PE TOU= XRH=NAI PA/NTWS, E)/NQA TO\ A)/LOGO/N E)STIN, E)NTAU=Q' EI)=NAI KAI\ TO\ LOGIZO/MENON, A)LL' E(TOI/MWS TE KA)K PROXEI/ROU PAN-TAXOU= LAMBA/NEI. @&10Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. plac. II 8 [1`109]1 p. 243 Mu+.$10 METABH/-SOMAI D' E)PI/ TI TW=N U(POLOI/PWN, OU(= SXEDO\N A(/PANTES MEMNHMONEU/KASIN, OI(=S H( KARDI/A PASW=N TW=N DUNA/MEWN A)RXH\ TW=N E)N TOI=S ZW/|OIS U(PEI/LHPTAI. *LE/GOUSI GA/R, O(/QEN H( TOU= TRE/FESQAI TOI=S ZW/|OIS A)RXH/, KAT' E)KEI=NO TO\ MO/RION EI)=NAI KAI\ TO\ LOGIZO/MENON TH=S YUXH=S: E)N KARDI/A| D' EI)=NAI TH\N TOU= TRE/FESQAI TOI=S ZW/|OIS A)RXH/N, W(/STE KAI\ TO\ LOGIZO/MENO/N TE KAI\ DIANOOU/MENON U(PA/RXEIN E)N AU)TH=|. @&10ibidem [1`110]1 p. 245 M.$10 OU) MH\N OU)D' O(/TAN EI)/PWSIN, O(/QEN H( XORHGI/A TOU= PNEU/MATOS, E)NTAU=Q' EI)=NAI TO\ H(GEMONIKO/N, EI)=T' E)P' AU)TW=| PROSLAMBA/NWSIN, E)K TH=S KARDI/AS XORHGEI=SQAI TO\ PNEU=MA, SUGXWRHTE/ON AU)TOI=S. @&Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. plac. III 2 [1`114]1 p. 258 Mu+.$8 *OU) MH\N TOU=TO/ G' H)=N SOI TO\ A)MFISBHTOU/MENON, EI) TO\ QUMOU/MENON TH=S Y?UXH=S E)N KARDI/A| KATW/|KISTAI, A)LL' EI) TO\ LOGIZO/MENON, O(/PER E)XRH=N A)PODEI/CANTA MH\ POLLA\ KA/MNEIN U(PE\R TOU= QUMOUME/NOU, MHD' E)MPIPLA/NAI TO\ BIBLI/ON E)PW=N POIHTIKW=N, W(=N E)FECH=S GRA/FEIS W(DI/ [1&Il.$ *S& 109$]1 <20*(/OS GE POLU\ GLUKI/WN ME/LITOS KATALEIBOME/NOIO @*)ANDRW=N E)N STH/QESSIN A)E/CETAI H)U/+TE KAPNO/S. *KAI\ PA/LIN>20: [1&frg. trag. adesp. 142 N.$]1 @<20*(O QUMO\S AU)TO\N TW=N FRENW=N E)CH=|R' A)/NW. *KAI\ PA/LIN>20: [1&frg. trag. adesp. 143 N.$]1 @<20*PHDW=N D' O( QUMO\S E)/NDOQEN MANTEU/ETAI>20. KAI\ MURI/A E(/TERA TOIAU=TA PAR' O(/LON TO\ GRA/MMA, KATASKEUA/ZONTA TO\ QU-MOU/MENON U(PA/RXEIN E)N TH=| KARDI/A|, DE/ON MH\ TOU=TO DEIKNU/EIN A)LLA\ TO\ LOGIZO/MENON, H)\ NH\ *DI/A, EI)/PER A)DU/NATOS H)=N A)/NTIKRUS E)PIDEIKNU/NAI TOU=TO, @1 PEIRASQH=NAI GOU=N [E)PIXEIRH=SAI] DEI=CAI, KAQ' E(\N TOU=TO TO\ MO/RION EI)=NAI TO/ TE QUMOU/MENON TH=S YUXH=S KAI\ TO\ LOGIZO/MENON. O( DE/ GE TOUTI\ ME\N OU)D' E)PEXEI/RHSE PRA=CAI KAT' OU)DE\N ME/ROS TOU= BIBLI/OU, XRH=TAI DE\ DIA\ PANTO\S E)C E(TOI/MOU LAMBA/NWN. EU)QU\S GOU=N E)N TOI=S E)FECH=S OU(/TW GRA/FEI: @"1<20*TH=S ME\N O)RGH=S GIGNOME/NHS E)NTAU=QA, EU)/LOGON KAI\ TA\S LOI-PA\S E)PIQUMI/AS E)NTAU=Q' EI)=NAI, KAI\ NH\ *DI/A TA\ LOIPA\ PA/QH KAI\ TOU\S DIALOGISMOU\S KAI\ O(/SON TOU/TOIS E)STI\ PARAPLH/SION>20."2 @&Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. plac. III 5 [1`122]1 p. 287 Mu+.$8 *)APO-XWRH/SANTES OU)=N H)/DH TW=N TOIOU/TWN, I)/DWMEN E(CH=S A(/PANTAS OU(\S E)RWTA=| LO/GOUS, E)PI\ TH\N A)RXH\N AU)=QIS A)NELQO/NTES A(/PANTOS TOU= LO/GOU, PRO\S TO\ MHDE\N PARELQEI=N. PARAQH/SOMAI DE\ TH\N R(H=SIN A(/PASAN, EI) KAI\ MAKROTE/RA PW/S E)STIN, E)/XOUSAN W(=DE: @"1<20*TH=S ME\N OU)=N O)RGH=S GIGNOME/NHS E)NTAU=QA, EU)/LOGON KAI\ TA\S LOIPA\S E)PIQUMI/AS E)NTAU=Q' EI)=NAI, KAI\ H)/DH TA\ LOIPA\ PA/QH KAI\ TOU\S DIALOGISMOU\S KAI\ O(/SA TOU/TOIS E)STI\ PARAPLH/SIA. SAINO/-MENOI DE\ FH/MH| OI( POLLOI\ TOU/TWN, POLLA\ KATA\ TH\N A)LH/QEIAN E)PILE/GOUSI TOIAU=TA, E)XO/MENOI TH=S R(HQEI/SHS FORA=S: PRW=TON ME\N GA/R, I(/NA PA/NTES E)NTEU=QEN A)/RCWMAI, KATA\ TOU=TO/ FASIN A)NA-BAI/NEIN TINW=N TO\N QUMO/N, KAI\ KATAPI/NEIN TH\N XOLH/N TINAS A)CIOU=SI, LE/GONTE/S TE KATAPI/NESQAI/ TINA AU)TOI=S SPARA/GMATA KAI\ MH\ KATAPI/NESQAI KATA\ TH\N TOIAU/THN FORA\N LE/GOMEN. OU(/TW DE\ LE/GETAI KAI\ MHDE\N AU)TOI=S TOU/TWN KATABAI/NEIN, KAI\ O(/TI KATAPIW\N TO\ R(HQE\N A)PH=LQEN, O(/ TE *ZH/NWN PRO\S TOU\S E)PILAM-BANOME/NOUS, O(/TI PA/NTA TA\ ZHTOU/MENA EI)S TO\ STO/MA FE/REI E)/FHSEN, "1A)LL' OU) PA/NTA KATAPI/NETAI"2, OU)/TE TH=S KATAPO/SEWS A)/LLWS A)\N OI)KEIO/TERON LEGOME/NHS, OU)/TE TH=S KATABA/SEWS TW=N R(HQE/NTWN, EI) MH\ PERI\ TO\N QW/RAKA TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N H(MW=N H)=N, EI)S O(\ TAU=TA PA/NTA FE/RETAI. E)N GOU=N TH=| KEFALH=| O)/NTOS AU)TOU= GE-LOI/WS R(HQH/SETAI KAI\ A)LLOTRI/WS KATABAI/NEIN, A)NABAI/NEIN [D'] A)\N OI)=MAI OI)KEIO/TERON AU)TW=N LEGOME/NWN KAI\ OU) KATABAI/NEIN, TO\N PROEIRHME/NON TRO/PON TH=S KATA\ TH\N A)KOH\N AI)SQH/SEWS KATA-FEROME/NHS PERI\ TH\N DIA/NOIAN, E)A\N H)=| PERI\ TO\N QW/RAKA, OI)KEI/WS KATA/BASIS R(HQH/SETAI: E)A\N DE\ PERI\ TH\N KEFALH/N, A)LLOTRIW/-TERON>20."2 @1 @&Ad haec verba explicanda aliquatenus utilia sunt quae addit G%10 $8*THNIKAU=TA GA\R OI)=DA KAI\ TO\ "1MH\ KATABAI/NEIN E(AUTOI=S TA\ EI)RHME/NA"2 LE/-GONTAS TOU\S POLLOU/S, OU)K E)PEIDA\N MH\ PARAKOLOUQW=SI MHDE\ MANQA/NWSI TW=N LEGOME/NWN, [2A)LL']2 E)PEIDA\N LE/GHTAI ME/N TINA W(S O)RGH\N H)\ LU/PHN H)\ QUMO\N H)/ TI TOIOU=TON PA/QOS E)KKALESO/MENA, MH\ FRONTI/ZH| DE\ AU)TW=N O( A)KOU/WN MHDE\ KINH=TAI KATA\ PA/QOS. @&Galenus De Hipp. et Plat. plac. III 5 [1`122]1 p. 290 Mu+.$8 AU(/TH ME\N OU)=N H( A)DOLESXI/A TOU=TO TO\ PE/RAS E)XE/TW. META\ TAU=TA D' O( *XRU/-SIPPOS TOIA=SD' E(TE/RAS ME/MNHTAI. @"1<20*AI( DE\ GUNAI=KES KAI\ MA=LLO/N TI TOU/TWN E)MFAI/NOUSIN. EI) GA\R MH\ KATABAI/NEI AU)TAI=S TA\ LEGO/MENA, POLLA/KIS TO\N DA/KTULON KATA/GOUSIN E(/WS TOU= KATA\ TH\N KARDI/AN TO/POU, OU) FA/SKOUSAI KATABAI/NEIN W(=DE TA\ EI)RHME/NA>20."2 @&Haec nihil facere ad probandam Chrys. sententiam, dicit G%10$8 OU)DE\ GA\R AU(=TAI LE/GOUSIN OU(/TWS, OU)D' O)RXOU=NTAI TAI=S XERSI/N, W(S EI)/RHKAS, E)PEI-DA\N A)RNW=NTAI SUNIE/NAI TW=N LEGOME/NWN, A)LL' O(/TAN U(PO\ LOIDORI/AS H)\ A)PEI-LH=S H)/ TINOS TOIOU/TOU MH/TE O)RGI/ZESQAI FA/SKWSI MH/TE QUMOU=SQAI MH/Q' O(/LWS A)GANAKTEI=N. O(/PER OU)D' AU)TO/N, OI)=MAI, LANQA/NEI TO\N *XRU/SIPPON. A)NTIFQEGGO/MENOS GOU=N KA)NTAU=QA E(AUTW=| MET' O)LI/GON W(DI/ PWS GRA/FEI. @"1<20*)AF' H(=S TE FORA=S LE/GOMEN MH\ KATABAI/NEIN TA\ LEGO/MENA, EI)/TE A)PEILA\S EI)/TE LOIDORI/AS, W(/STE KAQIKE/SQAI KAI\ A(/PTESQAI AU)TW=N KAI\ OU(/TWS KINEI=SQAI TH\N DIA/NOIAN, A)PO\ TH=S FORA=S TAU/-THS KAI\ BAQEI=S TINA/S FAMEN EI)=NAI, DIA\ TO\ MHDE\N TW=N TOIOU/TWN E)FIKNEI=SQAI KATABH=NAI AU)TW=N>20."2 @&p. 292.$8 __A)LLA\ TAU=TA ME\N E)N TOI=S E)FECH=S O( *XRU/SIPPOS LE/GEI, <20METACU\ DE\ TAU/THS, TH=S TE NU=N GEGRAMME/NHS LE/CEWS KAI\ H)=S O)LI/-GON E)/MPROSQEN E)/GRAYA PERI\ TW=N GUNAIKW=N, E(TE/RA R(H=SI/S E)STIN>20, H(\N H)/DH PARAGRA/YW, PRO\S TO\ MHDE\N O(/LWS U(PERBAI/NEIN DOKEI=N: E)/XEI DE\ W(=DE. @"1<20*TOU/TOIS D' A)KOLOU/QWS A)NEMEI=N TE/ TINA/S FAMEN TA\ FANE/NTA AU)TOI=S KAI\ E)/TI TO\N BAQU/N, LEGOME/NWN POLLW=N TOIOU/TWN SUM-FW/NWS TOI=S EI)RHME/NOIS: KATAPIO/NTES GA\R O(/MOION EI)PEI=N, O(/TI H(ME/RA E)STI/, KAI\ E)NAPOQE/MENOI TOU=TO EI)S TH\N DIA/NOIAN, KAI\ PA/LIN E)KEI=NO LE/GONTES O(/TI OU)K E)/STIN H(ME/RA, MENO/NTWN TW=N PRAGMA/-TWN, OU)K A)LLOTRI/WS OU)D' A)NOIKEI/WS A)NEMEI=N LE/GONTAI>20."2 @*TOU=TO TO\ "1A)NEMEI=N"2: E)GW\ ME\N OU)DE\ H)/KOUSA/ TINOS LE/GONTOS, A)LLA\ MA=LLON A)POPTU/SAI KAI\ E)KPTU/SAI KAI\ E)KBALEI=N KAI\ A)POR)R(I=YAI KAI\ A)PO-QE/SQAI LE/GOUSIN, E)PEIDA\N LE/GWSI/ TINA DOCW=N A)POSTH=NAI MOXQHRW=N &etc. @1 &@Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. plac. II 4 [1`96]1 p. 196, 97 M.$ EI)/PER H( FWNH\ TUPOUME/NOU PWS TOU= KATA\ TO\N PNEU/MONA PNEU/MATOS U(PO\ TOU= KATA\ TH\N KARDI/AN E)GI/GNETO, KA)/PEIQ' E(AUTW=| TO\ KATA\ TH\N FA/RUGGA SUN-TUPOU=NTOS, OU)K A)\N A)PW/LLUTO PARAXRH=MA TMHQE/NTWN NEU/RWN TINW=N &etc. &@ibidem [1`97]1.$ OU)D' E)STI\N OU)DEI\S LO/GOS, O(\S A)NAGKA/SEI MI/AN A)RXH\N A(PASW=N EI)=NAI TW=N KATA\ TO\ ZW=ON E)NERGEIW=N. @&Galenus de Hipp. et Plat plac. II 5 [1`98]1 p. 203 M.$8 BOU/LOMAI DE/, PRI\N E)LE/GXEIN AU)TOU/S, E)/TI KAI\ <20TO\N TOU= *XRUSI/PPOU>20 [1&sc.$8 LO/GON]1 PARAQE/SQAI, TO/NDE TO\N TRO/PON E)/XONTA: "1<20*EU)/LOGON DE/, EI)S O(\ GI/GNONTAI AI( E)N TOU/TW| SHMASI/AI, KAI\ E)C OU(= [2O(]2 LO/GOS, E)KEI=NO EI)=NAI TO\ KURIEU=ON TH=S YUXH=S ME/ROS. OU) GA\R A)/LLH ME\N [H(] PHGH\ LO/GOU E)STI/N, A)/LLH DE\ DIANOI/AS, OU)DE\ A)/LLH ME\N FWNH=S PHGH/, A)/LLH DE\ LO/GOU, OU)DE\ TO\ O(/LON A(PLW=S A)/LLH FWNH=S PHGH/ E)STIN, A)/LLO DE\ TO\ KURIEU=ON TH=S YUXH=S ME/ROS>20."2 _TOIOU/TOIS DE\ KAI\ TH\N DIA/NOIAN SUMFW/NWS A)FORIZO/MENOI LE/GOUSIN AU)TH\N PHGH\N EI)=NAI LO/GOU. _"1<20*TO\ GA\R O(/LON O(/QEN O( LO/GOS E)KPE/MPETAI, E)KEI=SE DEI= KAI\ TO\N DIA-LOGISMO\N GI/GNESQAI KAI\ TA\S DIANOH/SEIS KAI\ TA\S MELE/TAS TW=N R(H/SEWN, KAQA/PER E)/FHN. TAU=TA DE\ E)KFANW=S PERI\ TH\N KARDI/AN GI/GNETAI, E)K TH=S KARDI/AS DIA\ FA/RUGGOS KAI\ TH=S FWNH=S KAI\ TOU= LO/GOU E)KPEMPOME/NWN. PIQANO\N DE\ KAI\ A)/LLWS, EI)S O(\ E)NSHMAI/-NETAI TA\ LEGO/MENA, KAI\ SHMAI/NESQAI E)KEI=QEN, KAI\ TA\S FWNA\S A)P' E)KEI/NOU GI/GNESQAI KATA\ TO\N PROEIRHME/NON TRO/PON>20."2 @A(/LIS H)/DH MOI TW=N PERI\ TH=S FWNH=S LO/GWN TW=N *STWI+KW=N: EI) GA\R KAI\ TOU\S U(PO\ TW=N A)/LLWN H)RWTHME/NOUS E)FECH=S GRA/FOIMI SU/MPANTAS, EI)S A)/METRO/N TI MH=KOS E)KPESEI=TAI TO\ GRA/MMA. OU) GA\R A)\N OU)DE\ TW=N U(PO\ *XRU-SI/PPOU TE KAI\ *DIOGE/NOUS EI)RHME/NWN E)MNHMO/NEUSA LO/GWN, A)LL' H)RKE/SQHN E)CETA/SAS TO\N TOU= *ZH/NWNOS MO/NON, EI) MH\ PRO/S TINA TW=N *STWI+KW=N E)GE-GO/NEI MOI/ POTE A)MFISBH/THSIS U(PE\R TOU= "1XWREI="2 R(H/MATOS, O(/PER E)/LABEN O( <20*ZH/NWN E)N TW=| LO/GW| GRA/YAS W(DI/: FWNH\ DIA\ FA/RUGGOS XWREI=>20. TO\ GA\R "1XWREI="2 TOU=TO R(H=MA E)GW\ ME\N H)CI/OUN A)KOU/EIN E)N I)/SW| TW=| E)CE/R-XETAI H)\ E)KPE/MPETAI. O( DE\ TOU/TWN ME\N MHDE/TERON E)/FH SHMAI/NESQAI PRO\S AU)TOU=. KAI\ TRI/TON A)/LLO PARA\ TAU=TA LE/GEIN OU)K EI)=XEN. H)NAGKA/SQHN OU)=N AU)TW=| TA\ TW=N A)/LLWN *STWI+KW=N PARANAGIGNW/SKEIN BIBLI/A, METALAM-BANO/NTWN TH\N LE/CIN H)\ EI)S TO\ E)CE/RXETAI H)\ EI)S TO\ E)KPE/MPETAI, KAQA/PER KAI\ NU=N A)PE/DEICA *XRU/SIPPO/N TE KAI\ *DIOGE/NHN, MEQ' OU(\S OU)K A)NAGKAI=ON H(GOU=MAI TA\S TW=N A)/LLWN PARAGRA/FEIN R(H/SEIS &etc. &@p. 101, p. 214 M. Gal. de verbo$8 "1E)KEI=SE"2 &haec disputat%10$8 DH=LON GA\R DH/, O(/TI TO\ E)KEI=SE A)NTI\ TOU= E)KEI= O( *XRU/SIPPOS EI)/RHKEN, O(/PER I)/SON @1 DU/NATAI TW=| E)N E)KEI/NW| TW=| ME/REI TOU= SW/MATOS. OU) GA\R DH\ TO/ GE EI)S E)KEI=NO TO\ MO/RION H(GHTE/ON AU)TO\N BOU/LESQAI DHLOU=N E)N TW=| LE/GEIN E)KEI=SE, KA)\N O(/TI MA/LISTA TO\ ME\N E)KEI=SE EI)S TO/PON H)=| DHLOU=N, TO\ DE\ E)KEI= E)N TO/PW|. SOLOIKI/ZEIN GA\R MA=LLON U(POLHPTE/ON E)N TH=| FWNH=| TO\N *XRU/SIPPON H)/PER OU(/TW PROFANW=S A)DIANO/HTA LE/GEIN. TO\ ME\N GA\R I(KANW=S SU/NHQES AU)TW=| KAI\ MO/NON OU) KAQ' E(KA/STHN R(H=SIN GINO/MENON, TO\ D' A)DIANO/HTA LE/GEIN OU)-DAMW=S. E)NI/OTE GA/R POU KAI\ YEUDH= LE/GEI, KAQA/PER KAI\ KATA\ TOU=TON TO\N LO/GON, A)LL' OU)K A)DIANO/HTA/ GE. DIAFE/REI GA\R PA/MPOLU TO\ YEU=DOS TOU= A)DIANOH/TOU &etc. &@Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. plac. II 2 p. 172 Mu+.$8 A(\ D' OU)=N U(PE\R TH=S "1E)GW\"2 FWNH=S E)/GRAYEN <20E)N TW=| PRW/TW| PERI\ YUXH=S>20 O( *XRU/-SIPPOS U(PE\R H(GEMONIKOU= DIALEGO/MENOS, H)/DH PARAGRA/YW GNWRI/SMATOS E(/NEKA. @"1<20*OU(/TWS DE\ KAI\ TO\ E)GW\ LE/GOMEN KATA\ TOU=TO, DEIKNU/NTES AU(TOU\S E)N TW=| % A)POFAI/NESQAI % TH\N DIA/NOIAN EI)=NAI, TH=S DEI/-CEWS FUSIKW=S KAI\ OI)KEI/WS E)NTAU=QA FEROME/NHS. KAI\ A)/NEU DE\ TH=S KATA\ TH\N XEI=RA TOIAU/THS DEI/CEWS NEU/ONTES EI)S AU(TOU\S TO\ E)GW\ LE/GOMEN, EU)QU\S KAI\ TH=S E)GW\ FWNH=S TOIAU/THS OU)/SHS, KAI\ KATA\ TH\N E(CH=S U(POGEGRAMME/NHN DEI=CIN SUNEKFEROME/NHS. TO\ GA\R E)GW\ PROFERO/MEQA KATA\ TH\N PRW/THN SULLABH\N KATASPW=N-TES TO\ KA/TW XEI=LOS EI)S AU(TOU\S DEIKTIKW=S, A)KOLOU/QWS DE\ TH=| TOU= GENEI/OU KINH/SEI KAI\ E)PI\ TO\ STH=QOS NEU/SEI KAI\ TH=| TOIAU/TH| DEI/CEI H( E(CH=S SULLABH\ PARA/KEITAI, OU)DE\N A)POSTHMATIKO\N PAREMFAI/NOUSA, O(/PER E)PI\ TOU= E)KEI=NOS SUNTE/TEUXE>20"2. @&p. 175 Mu+.%10$8 DIA\ TI/ DE\ "1<20E)N TAI=S SUGKATAQE/SESIN E)PINEU/ONTES TH\N KEFALH/N, E)F' O(\ FE/ROMEN AU)TH\N ME/ROS, E)N E)KEI/NW| TH\N A)R-XH\N TH=S YUXH=S U(PA/RXEIN E)NDEIKNU/MEQA>20"2 MA=LLON, KAI\ OU)K AU)TW=| TW=| KINOUME/NW|. @&Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. plac. III 5 [1`124]1 p. 295 Mu+.$8 O(/MOIA DE\__TA\ KATA\ TH\N E)TUMOLOGI/AN TOU= TH=S KARDI/AS O)NO/MATOS, E(CH=S TW=N PROEIRHME/NWN <20U(PO\ TOU= *XRUSI/PPOU GEGRAMME/NA KATA\ TO\ PRW=-TON PERI\ YUXH=S>20 W(=DE/ PWS E)/XONTA. @"1<20*TOU/TOIS PA=SI SUMFW/NWS KAI\ TOU)/NOMA TOU=T' E)/SXHKEN H( KARDI/A KATA/ TINA KRA/THSIN KAI\ KUREI/AN, A)PO\ TOU= E)N AU)TH=| EI)=-NAI TO\ KURIEU=ON KAI\ KRATOU=N TH=S YUXH=S ME/ROS, W(S A)\N KRATI/A LEGOME/NH>20."2 @___E)FECH=S DE\ TOI=S EI)RHME/NOIS O( *XRU/SIPPOS TA/DE GRA/FEI: @1 @"1<20*(ORMW=MEN KATA\ TOU=TO TO\ ME/ROS KAI\ SUGKATATIQE/MEQA TOU/-TW| KAI\ EI)S TOU=TO SUNTEI/NEI TA\ AI)SQHTH/RIA PA/NTA.>20"2 @__*TAUTI\ ME\N OU)=N TA\ KEFA/LAIA, TO\ SU/MPAN KU=ROS E)N AU(TOI=S E)/XONTA PERI\ TW=N PROKEIME/NWN H(MI=N DOGMA/TWN, OU(/TWS TAXE/WS O( *XRU/-SIPPOS PARE/DRAMEN, W(S E)PIMNHSQH=NAI MO/NON: E)N OI(=S DE\ OU) XRH\ MHKU/NEI PERITTW=S. @&10Galenus de Hippocr. et Plat. plac. I 5 [1`78]1 p. 138 Mu+.$10 EI) TRW/-SAIS AU)TH\N [1&10sc.$10 TH\N KARDI/AN]1 EU)QU\S E)KXEI=TAI TO\ AI(=MA. E)XRH=N DE/ GE <20KATA\ TO\N *XRU/SIPPON>20 H)\ TO\ PNEU=MA PRO/TERON E)KKENOU/MENON FAI/NESQAI, KA)/PEIQ' OU(/TWS E(/PESQAI TO\ AI(=MA, H)\ MHDE\ O(/LWS E(/PESQAI, KAQA/PER OU)DE\ E)PI\ TW=N KATA\ TO\N E)GKE/FALON E(/PETAI KOILIW=N. @&10ibidem 6. [1`79]1 p. 141.$10 *)ERASI/STRATOS ME\N GA\R ZWTIKOU= PNEU/MATOS, <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 DE\ TOU= YUXIKOU= PNEU/MATOS PLH/RH FASI\N EI)=NAI TH\N KOILI/AN TAU/-THN [1&10sc.$10 TH\N A)RISTERA\N TH=S KARDI/AS]1. @&10ibidem 6. [1`80]1 p. 143 M.$10 E)/NQA NU=N KAI\ MA/LISTA MEMYAI/MHN A)\N <20TO\N *XRU/SIPPON>20, O(/TI BOULO/MENOS EI)LIKRINE/S TI KAI\ KAQARO\N EI)=NAI PNEU=MA TO\ KATA\ TH\N A)RXH\N TH=S YUXH=S, OU) PROSHKO/NTWS E)N TH=| KARDI/A| KAQI/DRUSEN AU)TO/. KAI/TOI *XRU/SIPPON ME\N A)/N TIS A)PODE/CAITO METRI/WS A)POFHNA/MENON, [W(S] MH/Q' O(/TI TW=N NEU/RWN A)RXH\ H( KARDI/A TH\N GNW=SIN AU)TW=| XARI/ZESQAI, MH/T' A)/LLO MHDE\N TW=N KATA\ TO\ PRO/BLHMA TOU=TO ZHTOUME/NWN: <20O(MOLOGEI= GA\R A)PEI/RWS E)/XEIN TW=N A)NATOMW=N>20. @&10ibidem 7 [1`81]1 p. 145 M.$10 *)EGW\ DE/, E)PEIDH/PER A(/PAC KATE/STHN EI)S TO\ PERI\ PA/NTWN DIASKE/YASQAI, BRAXE/A TW=| *PRACAGO/RA| DIALEXQH=NAI BOU/LOMAI, <20KAI\ MA/LISQ' O(/TI KAI\ *XRU/SIPPOS E)MNHMO/NEUSE TA)NDRO/S>20, A)NTIQEI\S TOI=S A)PO\ TH=S KEFALH=S A)/RXESQAI TA\ NEU=RA NOMI/ZOUSIN. @&10ibidem 10 [1`86]1 p. 163 M.$10 OU)/TE GA\R FILOYEUDH\S O( A)NH\R [1&10sc.$10 O( *)ARISTO-TE/LHS]1, OU)/TE PANTA/PASIN A)/PEIROS TH=S A)NATOMH=S, I(/NA KAI\ TOU=TO/N TIS, W(/SPER <20TOU\S PERI\ TO\N *XRU/SIPPON>20, E(TE/ROIS E)YEUSME/NOIS H)KOLOUQHKE/NAI NOMI/SEIEN. @&Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. plac. II 5 [1`102]1 p. 215 M.$8 KATA\ ME\N GA\R A)/LLHN TINA\ [1&sc.$8 R(H=SIN]1 MET' OU) PA/NU POLU\ TAU/THS GEGRAMME/NHN H)NAGKA/SQH TO\ A)LHQE\S O(MOLOGH=SAI. A)NAGKASQH=NAI DE\ EI)=PON AU)TO/N, O(/TI LO/GON E(/TERON A)NATRE/YAI BOULO/MENOS W(S OU)K A)LHQH=, KA)/PEITA TO\ TH=S A)NTILOGI/AS EI)=DOS AI)SQO/MENOS OU)DE\N H(=TTON E)PISTRE/YON KAI\ KAQ' E(AUTOU=, SUNANATRE/YAI KAI\ TO\N I)/DION OU)K W)/KNHSE TW=| TW=N E(TERODO/CWN. ___ PARAGRA/YW DE\ KAI\ TH\N R(H=SIN AU)TH/N, E)N H(=| DEI/KNUSIN O( <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20, W(S OU)K E)/STIN O( PROGEGRAMME/NOS LO/GOS A)PODEIKTIKO/S. E)/STI DE\ TOIA/DE: @"1<20*)/EXEI D' W(S E)/FHN PLEI/ONA AU)TOI=S E)PI\ PA=SI, MH/POQ' EI) KAI\ TOU=TO DOQEI/H, KAQA/PER E)PIPOREU/ONTAI, A)PO\ TH=S KEFALH=S EI)=NAI TH\N A)RXH\N E)PI\ TA\ EI)RHME/NA ME/RH, E)PIZHTH/SOMEN. SXEDO\N GA/R, OI(=A A)/N TINA LE/GOIEN PERI\ TOU= TH\N FWNH\N E)K TOU= STH/QOUS FE/-RESQAI DIA\ TH=S FA/RUGGOS, A)PO\ TH=S KEFALH=S POIA=S TINOS KATAR-XH=S GIGNOME/NHS, TOIAU=T' E)/CESTI LE/GEIN, E)N TH=| KARDI/A| ME\N TOU= @1 H(GEMONIKOU= O)/NTOS, TH=S DE\ TW=N KINH/SEWN A)RXH=S A)PO\ TH=S KEFA-LH=S OU)/SHS>20."2 @O(\ DH\ GA\R BOU/LETAI LE/GEIN O( *XRU/SIPPOS E)N TH=|DE TH=| R(H/SEI, TOIOU=TO/N E)STIN: EI) KAI\ SUGXWRH/SEIE/ TIS, A)RXH\N EI)=NAI NEU/RWN TH\N KEFALH/N, OU) PA/N-TWS E)N AU)TH=| SUGXWRH/SEI TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N U(PA/RXEIN. A(\ GA\R E)KEI=NOI DU/NAN-TAI LE/GEIN U(PE\R TOU= TH\N FWNH\N E)K TOU= STH/QOUS DIA\ TH=S FA/RUGGOS E)KFE/RESQAI, TH\N A)RXH\N TH=S E)NERGEI/AS TOI=S MORI/OIS E)PIPEMPOU/SHS TH=S KEFALH=S, TOIAU=T' E)/CESTI LE/GEIN U(PE\R TW=N NEU/RWN H(MI=N, W(S E)K ME\N TH=S KEFALH=S A)RXOME/NWN, A)PO\ DE\ TH=S KARDI/AS TH\N E)NE/RGEIAN E)XO/NTWN. @&ibidem [1`104]1 p. 224 M.$8 TAU=TA ME\N OU)=N O)RQW=S EI)/RHTAI TW=| *XRU-SI/PPW|, KAI\ DIA\ TOU=T' A)/N TIS AU)TW=| KAI\ MA=LLON ME/MYAITO, DIO/TI KATIDW\N TO\ A)LHQE\S O(/MWS OU) XRH=TAI: TA\ DE\ A)PO\ TH=S QE/SEWS E)PIKEXEIRHME/NA, KAI\ TOU/-TWN O(/SA MA=LLON POIHTAI\ MARTUROU=SIN H)\ OI( POLLOI\ TW=N A)NQRW/PWN H)\ E)TU-MOLOGI/A TIS H)/ TI TOIOU=TON E(/TERON, OU)K O)RQW=S. __AU)TO\S DE\ W(/SPER OU) KAT' E)PISTH/MHN, A)LLA\ KATA\ TU/XHN EI)RHKW\S TO\ A)LHQE/S, A)PEXW/RHSE/ TE TH=S ZHTH/SEWS KAI\ POIHTA\S E)PA/GETAI MA/RTURAS. @&Galen. de H. et Plat. dogm. II 7 [1`106]1 p. 230 M.$8 ME/MFOMAI DE\ AU)TW=| KAI\ DIO/TI KAQ' E(\N BIBLI/ON E)NANTI/A LE/GEIN U(PE/MEINEN, OU)K A)PO\ MA-KROU= DIASTH/MATOS A)LLH/LWN E)/MPROSQEN ME\N W(S A)PODEIKTIKO\N GRA/YAS TO\N TOU= *ZH/NWNOS LO/GON, E)PI\ PROH/KONTI DE\ TW=| SUGGRA/MMATI DEIKNU\S AU)TOU= TH\N LU/SIN. @&Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. plac. III 5 [1`124]1 p. 297 M.$8 KAI\ META\ TAU=TA TH\N "1A)KA/RDIOS"2 E)CHGEI=TAI PROSHGORI/AN__TOSOU=TON DE\ E)PISHMANOU=MAI KAI\ NU=N A)P' AU)TH=S TH=S LE/CEWS TOU= *XRUSI/PPOU MARTU-ROU/SHS OI(=S PROEI=PON: E)/XEI DE\ W(=DE: @"1<20*KATA\ TOU=TO KAI\ EU)KA/RDIOI LE/GONTAI/ POU EI)=NAI/ TINES KA-QA/PER EU)/YUXOI, KAI\ KARDI/AN A)LGEI=N OI( KHDO/MENOI/ TINWN, W(S A)\N KATA\ TH\N KARDI/AN TH=S KATA\ TH\N LU/PHN A)LGHDO/NOS GIGNO-ME/NHS>20."2 @__OU(/TW DE\ KA)PEIDA\N E)PIFE/RWN EI)/PH|: @"1<20*TO\ GA\R O(/LON, KAQA/PER E)N A)RXH=| EI)=PON, EU)= MA/L' E)MFAI/NOUSIN OI(/ TE FO/BOI KAI\ AI( LU=PAI KATA\ TOU=TO TO\ ME/ROS GIGNO/MENAI>20"2 @MARTUREI= KA)NTAU=QA TW=| TOU= *PLA/TWNOS LO/GW|. KAI\ DIA\ TW=N E(CH=S DE\ KATA\ TO\N PARAPLH/SION TRO/PON OU)K AI)SQA/NETAI KATASKEUA/ZWN, W(S E)N TH=| KARDI/A| TO\ QUMOEIDE\S I(/DRUTAI TH=S YUXH=S. @"1<20*(/H TE GA\R E)N TOI=S FO/BOIS PA/LSIS TH=S KARDI/AS E)KFANH/S E)STI KAI\ H( EI)S TOU=TO TH=S O(/LHS YUXH=S SUNDROMH/, OU)K A)/LLWS E)PIGENNHMATIKW=S GIGNOME/NWN AU)TW=N, KAQA/PER A)/LLOIS A)/LLOU SUMPA/SXEIN PEFUKO/TOS, KAQ' O(\ KAI\ SUNIZA/NOUSIN EI)S AU(TOU/S, @1 SUNAGO/MENOI PRO\S TOU=TO, W(S A)\N TO\ H(GEMONIKO/N, KAI\ KATA\ TH\N [2KARDI/AN]2 W(S A)\N [AU)TW=N] TOU/TOU FULAKTIKH/N. KAI\ TA\ TH=S LU/-PHS PA/QH E)NTAUQOI= POU EU)FUW=S GI/GNETAI, OU)DENO\S A)/LLOU SUM-PA/SXONTOS OU)DE\ SUNALGOU=NTOS TO/POU. A)LGHDO/NWN GA/R TINWN KATA\ TAU=TA GIGNOME/NWN SFODRW=N, E(/TEROS ME\N OU)DEI\S E)MFAI/NEI TO/POS TA\ PA/QH TAU=TA, O( DE\ PERI\ TH\N KARDI/AN MA/LISTA>20."2 @__A)LLA\ TOU=TO ME\N KAI\ PAR' AU)TW=N O(MOLOGOU/MENON LAMBA/NETAI TW=N *STWI+KW=N. OU) MO/NON GA\R *XRU/SIPPOS, A)LLA\ KAI\ *KLEA/NQHS KAI\ *ZH/NWN E(TOI/MWS AU)TA\ TIQE/ASIN. @&Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. plac. III 7 [1`126]1 p. 302 M.$8 *XRU/-SIPPOS E)N TH=| META\ TA\S PROGEGRAMME/NAS R(H/SEIS LE/CEI PROXEI/RWS PA/LIN E)C E(NO\S A)/RXESQAI MORI/OU TA\S DUNA/MEIS A)MFOTE/RAS LAMBA/NEI, MHDE\ MI/AN A)PO/DEICIN H)\ PARAMUQI/AN H)\ PIQANO/THTA TW=| LO/GW| PROSTIQEI/S, W(S E)C AU)-TH=S FANERO\N E)/STAI TH=S LE/CEWS AU)TOU=, TO/NDE TO\N TRO/PON E)XOU/SHS: @"1<20*)ATO/PWS OU)=N AU)TO\ KATA\ TAU=T...QHSO/MENON, E)A/N TE MH\ FW=SI TH\N LU/PHN KAI\ TH\N A)GWNI/AN A)LGHDO/NAS EI)=NAI, E)A/N TE A)L-GHDO/NAS E)N A)/LLW| GI/NESQAI TO/PW| H)\ TW=| H(GEMONIKW=|: TA\ DE\ AU)TA\ KAI\ E)PI\ TH=S XARA=S KAI\ E)PI\ TOU= QA/RSOUS E)ROU=MEN, A(/PER E)MFAI/-NEI PERI\ TH\N KARDI/AN GINO/MENA. O(\N TRO/PON GA/R, O(/TAN TO\N PO/DA PONW=MEN H)\ TH\N KEFALH/N, PERI\ TOU/TOUS TOU\S TO/POUS O( PO/NOS GI/NETAI, OU(/TWS SUNAISQANO/MEQA KAI\ TH=S KATA\ TH\N LU/PHN A)LGHDO/NOS PERI\ TO\N QW/RAKA GINOME/NHS, OU)/TE TH=S LU/PHS OU)K OU)/SHS A)LGHDO/NOS, OU)/TE E)N E(TE/RW| TINI\ TO/PW| H)\ TW=| H(GEMONIKW=| AU)TH=S GINOME/NHS>20."2 @&p 305 M.%10$8 O( DE\ *XRU/SIPPOS OU)DE\ TA\S DUNA/MEIS AU)TA\S DIALLA/TTEIN A)LLH/LWN O(MOLOGEI=, OU)D' E(TE/RA| ME/N TINI DUNA/MEI QUMOU=SQAI TO\ ZW=ON, E(TE/RA| D' E)PIQUMEI=N, E(TE/RA| DE\ LOGI/ZESQAI. @&Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. plac. III 7 [1`127]1 p. 307 M.$8 E)PEI\ D' E)N TW=| NU=N E)NESTW=TI LO/GW| MNHMONEU=SAI PA/NTWN DIE/GNWMEN W(=N EI)=PEN O( <20*XRU/SIPPOS E)N TW=| PROTE/RW| PERI\ YUXH=S>20 [2U(PE\R]2 H(GEMONIKOU= DIA-LEGO/MENOS, E(CH=S A)\N EI)/H KAIRO\S H)/DH SUNA/PTEIN TOI=S EI)RHME/NOIS TA\ LOIPA/. SUNEXH\S OU)=N TH=| PROGEGRAMME/NH| R(H/SEI TOU= *XRUSI/PPOU TOIA/DE TI/S E)STI. @"1<20*KAQ' H(\N E)/TI FORA\N KAI\ TA\ TOIAU=TA LE/GETAI PA/NTA: "3H(YA/-MHN SOU TH=S KARDI/AS"3, W(/SPER TH=S YUXH=S KAI\ "3A(/PTOMAI TH=S KARDI/AS"3 LE/GOMEN, OU)X W(S A)NTIPARE/LQOIEN [2A)/N]2 TINES H(MA=S E)PI\ TOU= E)GKEFA/LOU KAI\ TW=N SPLA/GXNWN LE/GONTES KAI\ TOU= H(/PA-TOS, A)LLA\ TOI=S PROEIRHME/NOIS PARAPLHSI/WS: E)KEI=NA GA/R MOI @1 DOKEI= LE/GESQAI, W(S A)/N TIS E)/FH, "3TW=N E)NTO/S SOU A(/PTOMAI"3 DII+-KNOUME/NHS TH=S KAKOPOII/+AS E)PI\ TOSOU=TON. TH=| DE\ KARDI/A| KA-QA/PER A)\N TH=| YUXH=| XRW/MEQA. KAI\ TOU/TWN E)/STAI E)/MFASIS E)FI-STA=SI MA=LLON>20."2 @&Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. plac. III 4 [1`118]1 p. 276 Mu+.$8 *KAI\ GA\R OU)=N O(/TAN EI)/PH| [1&sc. Chrysippus$8]1 DIA\ TOU=TO LE/GESQAI/ TINAS A)KARDI/OUS, O(/TI PEPISTEU/KASIN A(/PANTES A)/NQRWPOI TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N TH=S YUXH=S E)N TH=| KARDI/A| PERIE/XESQAI, QAUMA/ZEIN A)/CION TA)NDRO\S &etc.$8 __A)LLA\ NH\ *DI/A QAUMASI/WS O(/PWS E)CHGEI=TAI TOU)/NOMA TO\ A)KA/RDION H(=| TINI DIANOI/A| LE/GOUSIN OI( POLLOI/, SUNA/PTWN EU)QU\S AU)TW=| KAI\ TO\N A)/SPLAGXNON: E)/XEI DE\ H( R(H=SIS W(=DE. @"1<20*PARABA/LLOUSI DE\ TOI=S EI)RHME/NOIS KAI\ TA\ TOIAU=TA TW=N LEGOME/NWN, OI(=ON TOU\S A)SPLA/GXNOUS, KAQ' O(/ FAMEN MH\ E)/XEIN TINA\S E)GKE/FALON KAI\ E)/XEIN, OU(/TWS H(MA=S U(PONOOU=NTES LE/GEIN KAI\ MH\ E)/XEIN KARDI/AN TINA\S KAI\ E)/XEIN KATA\ TA\ PROEIRHME/NA, TW=N ME\N A)SPLA/GXNWN TA/XA LAMBANOME/NWN KATA\ TO\ MHDE\N E)/XEIN E)/NDON SUNALGOU=N KATA\ TA\ E)NANTI/A, KAI\ A)PO\ TH=S KARDI/AS OU(/-TWS AU)TW=N KOINO/TERON LEGOME/NWN, TOU= D' E)GKEFA/LOU LAMBA-NOME/NOU H)/TOI KATA\ TA\ AU)TA\ O(MOI/OU TINO\S O)/NTOS, H)\ DIA\ TO\ KAI\ TOU=TON E)/XEIN TINA\ KURI/AN TOI=S SPLA/GXNOIS O(MOI/AN>20."2 @*(H ME\N R(H=SIS AU(/TH: XRH\ D' AU)TH\N A)NAGNW=NAI/ TINA KAI\ TRI\S KAI\ TETRA/KIS E)PI\ SXOLH=| POLLH=| A)KRIBW=S PROSE/XONTA TO\N NOU=N TOI=S LEGOME/-NOIS. OU(/TW GA\R MO/NWS, OI)=MAI, PEISQH/SETAI TO\ KATA\ TH\N PAROIMI/AN LE-GO/MENON U(PA/RXEIN AU)TH=| TO\ "1LABE\ MHDE\N KAI\ KRA/TEI KALW=S."2 &Affirmat &porro G. summam cum nimia brevitate obscuritatem his verbis inesse.$8 KAI/TOI TH/N GE SUNTOMI/AN OU)DE\ KAQ' E(/NA TW=N E(AUTOU= LO/GWN E)ZH/LWKEN, A)LL' OU(/TW MAKRO/S E)STIN, W(S POLLA/KIS E)N O(/LW| BIBLI/W| POLUEIDW=S U(PE\R TW=N AU)TW=N A)/NW TE KAI\ KA/TW TOU\S LO/GOUS E(LI/TTEIN. TO\ ME\N DH\ TH=S A)SAFEI/AS AU)TW=| SU/NHQES, A)SQENEI/A| TH=S E(RMHNEUTIKH=S DUNA/MEWS E(PO/MENON __TO\ DE\ TH=S BRAXULOGI/AS A)/HQE/S TE KAI\ SPANI/WS U(P' AU)TOU= GIGNO/-MENON, E)N OI(=S A)\N MA/LISTA LO/GOIS A)/FUKTON AI)SQA/NHTAI TO\ SFA/LMA TW=N E(AUTOU= DOGMA/TWN___I(/NA DHLADH\ DOKH=| ME\N A)POLELOGH=SQAI PRO\S TOU)/GKLHMA KAI\ MH\ PARELHLUQE/NAI TELE/WS AU)TO/, MHDE\N DE\ H(MEI=S E)/XWMEN A)NTILE/GEIN TOI=S EI)RHME/NOIS, W(=N OU)D' O(/LWS MANQA/NOMEN. AU)TI/KA GE/ TOI KATA\ TH\N PROGEGRAMME/NHN R(H=SIN, E)N H(=| TO\ A)/SPLAGXNON KAI\ TO\ MH\ E)/XEIN E)GKE/FALON O(/PWS OI( POLLOI\ LE/GOUSIN E)CHGEI=TAI, E)MOI\ ME\N DOKEI= TOIO/NDE TI DHLOU=N: "1A)SPLA/GXNOUS ME\N KALOU=SIN E)NI/OUS E)N I)/SW| TW=| A)KARDI/OUS, E)PEIDH\ SPLA/GXNON H( KARDI/A, TO\ D' E)GKE/FALON MH\ E)/XEIN E)N I)/SW| TW=| A)/SPLAGX-NON EI)=NAI LE/GOUSIN, E)PEIDH\ KAI\ OU(=TOS SPLA/GXNON T' E)STI\ KAI\ KU/RION."2 @OU) MH\N PROSI/ENTAI/ GE PA/NTES OI( *STWI+KOI\ TH\N TOIAU/THN E)CH/GHSIN, @1 A)LL' E(/TERON ME/N TI LE/GESQAI/ FASIN, OU) DHLOU=SI DE\ AU)TO/, TW=N E)SWTERIKW=N U(PA/RXON DHLONO/TI, KAI\ E)PITIMW=SIN H(MI=N EU)QE/WS W(S PROPETW=S A)NTILE/GOUSI, PRI\N GNW=NAI TO\ LEGO/MENON. OI( DE\ KAI\ LOIDOROU=NTES SFODRO/TERON A)NEI-SA/KTOUS TE KAI\ FILONEI/KOUS A)POKALOU=SIN, OU)/ FASI/ TE DIDA/CEIN TO\ LEGO/ME-NON A)PAIDEU/TOUS A)NQRW/POUS: KAI/TOI TA/ G' A)/LLA KAI\ MH\ BOULOME/NWN H(MW=N DIECE/RXONTAI MAKRW=S. A)LL' O(/TAN, W(S EI)=PON, E)PI/ TI TOIOU=TON A)FI/KWNTAI, MHDEMI/AN E)/XON EU)PORI/AN FLUARI/AS, OI( ME\N GRA/FONTES TA\ BIBLI/A TAXE/WS Q' A(/MA KAI\ A)SAFW=S PARATRE/XOUSIN, OI( D' E)CHGOU/MENOI TA\ TOU/TWN SUGGRA/M-MATA FQO/NOU MA=LLON U(PO/NOIAN EI)S TOU\S A)KOU/ONTAS E)KPE/MPEIN E(/TOIMOI GI/GNONTAI, PROSPOIOU/MENOI MH\ BOU/LESQAI DIDA/SKEIN H(MA=S, H)/PER O(MOLO-GOU=SI NENIKH=SQAI. A)LLA\ TOU\S ME\N A)SPLA/GXNOUS TE KAI\ A)NEGKEFA/LOUS H)/DH PARE/LQWMEN, I(/NA MH\ LUPW=MEN E)PI\ PLE/ON TOU\S PERI\ TO\N *XRU/SIPPON E)NARGW=S KATAMARTUROUME/NOUS U(F' W(=N E)PIKALOU=NTAI MARTU/RWN. @&Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. plac. III 7 [1`128]1 p. 309 Mu+.$8 META\ DE\ TAU=TA TOIA/NDE TINA\ GRA/FEI R(H=SIN: "1<20*KATA\ TOIAU/THN DE/ MOI DO-KOU=SI MA/LISTA FORA\N KAI\ OI( TIMWRHTIKW/TERON PRO/S TINAS FE-RO/MENOI O(RMA=N E)PI\ TO\ TAU/THN E)KSPA/SAI, KAQ' H(\N FORA\N E)PITEI/-NONTES KAI\ PRO\S TA\ LOIPA\ TW=N SPLA/GXNWN O(MOEIDW=S FE/RONTAI>20."2 @&ibidem p. 311 M.$8 W(/SPER GE KA)N TOI=S E(CH=S TW=N PROGEGRAMME/NWN, E)N OI(=S FHSI: @"1<20*KAI\ TA\ TW=N O)RGIZOME/NWN DE\ PA/QH PERI\ TO\N QW/RAKA FAI/-NETAI GINO/MENA KAI\ TA\ TW=N E)RW/NTWN, W(/STE KAI\ TH\N E)PIQUMI/AN MA/LISTA GI/NESQAI PERI\ TOU/TOUS TOU\S TO/POUS>20."2 @&ibidem p. 312 M.$8 E)FECH=S DE\ TOU/TWN TA/DE GRA/FEI: @"1<20*EU)= MA/LA DE\ PARISTA=SI TO\ LEGO/MENON, W(S E)/FHN, KAI\ AI( E)N AU(TOI=S GINO/MENAI MELE/TAI KAI\ R(H/SEWN KAI\ TW=N PARAPLHSI/WN. E)N W(=| GA\R TAU=TA PA/NTA SUNTELEI=TAI, PA/NTWS EU)/LOGON E)N E)KEI/NW| KAI\ TH\N TOU= LO/GOU DIE/CODON GI/NESQAI, KAI\ LE/GEIN H(MA=S KAI\ DIANOEI=SQAI KAT' E)KEI=NO>20."2 @&ibidem [1`129]1 p. 313 M.$8 E)MOI\ ME\N DH\ DOKEI= TW=| PERI\ TH=S FWNH=S LO/GW| KAI\ NU=N PROSXRH=SQAI. TEKMAI/ROMAI DE\ KAI\ E)K TW=N E)PIFEROME/NWN: @"1<20*)APO\ GA\R TH=S DIANOI/AS, FHSI/, DEI= LE/GEIN KAI\ E)N E(AUTW=| LE/GEIN [H)\ FWNH\N DIECIE/NAI] KAI\ DIANOEI=SQAI KAI\ E)N E(AUTOI=S FWNH\N DIECIE/NAI KAI\ E)KTO\S E)KPE/MPEIN>20."2 @O(MOLOGOU/MENON GA/R TI LAMBA/NWN, W(S TOU= AU)TOU= MORI/OU TO\ LE/GEIN EI)/H KAI\ TO\ E)N E(AUTW=| LE/GEIN, EI)=TA PROSLAMBA/NWN AU)TO\ TH=S KARDI/AS E)/RGON EI)=NAI TO\ LE/GEIN, E)C A)MFOI=N E)/XEI PERAINO/MENON, E)N TH=| KARDI/A| GI/NESQAI TO\ E)N E(AUTW=| LE/GEIN. ___E)PISKEYW/MEQA OU)=N H)/DH TO\N E(CH=S. @1 @&p. 314 M.$8 "1<20*OI)KEI/WS DE\ TOU/TW| KAI\ OI( STENAGMOI\ E)NTEU=QEN PROI/+ENTAI>20."2 @&Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. plac. III 7 [1`129]1 p. 315 M.$8 TA\ DE\ METACU\ TW=N E)PW=N E)STI ME\N O)LI/GISTA, PERIE/XETAI DE/ TIS KATA\ TAU=T' E)NANTIO-LOGI/A *XRUSI/PPOU PRO\S E(AUTO\N___E)N DE\ TW=| PARO/NTI TW=N R(H/SEWN AU)TW=N E)PIMNHSQH/SOMAI MO/NON E)XOUSW=N W(=DE: @"1<20*(O DE\ POIHTH\S PLEONA/ZWN E)N TOU/TOIS DIA\ POLLW=N PARI/-STHSIN, O(/TI KAI\ TO\ LOGISTIKO\N KAI\ TO\ QUMOEIDE\S PERI\ TOU=TO/N E)STI TO\N TO/PON, SUNA/GWN W(S TAU)TO\N AU)TA/, KAQA/PER KAI\ DEI= POIH=SAI>20."2 @__KAI\ DIA\ TW=N E(CH=S DE\ PROEIPW/N, E)N OI(=S O( POIHTH\S E)N TH=| KARDI/A| TO\ LOGIZO/MENON U(PA/RXEIN A)POFAI/NETAI, META\ TAU=T' E)PIFE/REI: @"1<20*(/OTI DE\ KAI\ TO\ E)PIQUMHTIKO\N E)NTAU=QA, DIA\ TOU/TWN E)MFAI/NEI: [1*C& 315$8]1 *OU) GA\R PW/POTE/ M' W(=DE QEA=S E)/ROS OU)DE\ GUNAIKO\S @*QUMO\N E)NI\ STH/QESSI PERIPROXUQEI\S E)DA/MASSEN>20."2 EI)=T' E)FECH=S: @"1<20*(/OTI DE\ TO\ QUMOEIDE\S E)NTAU=QA/ POU/ E)STI, TA\ TOIAU=TA E)M-FAI/NEI PLEI/ONA O)/NTA: [1*D& 24]1 @$8*(/HRH| D' OU)K E)/XADE STH=QOS XO/LON, A)LLA\ PROSHU/DA. @KAI\: [1*S& 168]1 @$8*XO/LOS, O(/ST' E)FE/HKE POLU/FRONA/ PER XALEPH=NAI>20."2 @&Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. plac. IV 1 [1`134]1 p. 331 M.$8 EI) ME\N OU)=N A)EI\ TA\ AU)TA\ PERI\ TW=N AU)TW=N O( *XRU/SIPPOS E)/GRAFE, KAI\ MH\ DIEFE/-RETO PRO\S AU(TO\N E)N TOI=S PLEI/STOIS DO/GMASIN E)PAMFOTERI/ZWN, OU)D' A)\N E)MOI\ MAKRO\S O( TH=S A)NTILOGI/AS E)GI/NETO LO/GOS. E)PEI\ D' A)/LLOTE A)/LLA PERI\ TW=N AU)TW=N EU(RI/SKETAI GRA/FWN, OU)K E)/TI R(A/|DION OU)/TE TH\N GNW/MHN E(RMH-NEU=SAI TA)NDRO/S, OU)/Q' O(/PH| SFA/LLETAI DEIKNU/NAI: PERI\ GOU=N TW=N DIOIKOUSW=N H(MA=S DUNA/MEWN <20E)N TW=| PROTE/RW| PERI\ TH=S YUXH=S>20 EI)PW/N, W(S O( *PLA/-TWN U(PELA/MBANE, TO\ ME\N LOGISTIKO\N E)N TH=| KEFALH=| TETA/XQAI, TO\ DE\ QU-MOEIDE\S E)N TH=| KARDI/A|, TO\ DE\ E)PIQUMHTIKO\N PERI\ TO\N O)MFALO/N, E)N TOI=S E(CH=S AU)TO\S EI)S TH\N KARDI/AN PEIRA=TAI TA\ TRI/A SUNA/GEIN. E)/XOUSI DE\ AI( R(H/SEIS W(=DE: @"1<20*(O DE\ POIHTH\S PLEONA/ZWN E)N TOU/TOIS DIA\ POLLW=N PARI/-STHSIN, O(/TI KAI\ TO\ LOGISTIKO\N KAI\ TO\ QUMOEIDE\S PERI\ TOU=TO/N E)STI TO\N TO/PON, SUNA/PTWN EI)S TAU)TO\N KAI\ TO\ E)PIQUMHTIKO/N, KAQA/PER KAI\ E)/DEI POIH=SAI>20."2 @EI)=TA E)PIFE/RWN FHSI/: @"1<20*(/OTI ME\N GA\R TO\ LOGISTIKO/N E)STIN E)NTAU=QA, DIA\ TOU/TWN E)MFAI/NETAI: @1 @*)/ALLO D' E)NI\ STH/QESSI NO/OS KAI\ MH=TIS A)MU/MWN. [1&Od.$ H& 258$8]1 *)ALL' E)MO\N OU)/POTE QUMO\N E)NI\ STH/QESSIN E)/PEIQEN>20."2 @EI)=T' E)FECH=S E)/PH PARAQE/MENOS PLEI/W, META\ TAU=TA/ FHSIN: @"1<20*(/OTI DE\ KAI\ TO\ E)PIQUMHTIKO\N E)NTAU=QA, E)K TOU/TWN E)MFAI/NEI: [1&Il.$ *C& 315$8]1 *OU) GA\R PW/POT' E)/M' W(=DE QEA=S E)/ROS OU)DE\ GUNAIKO\S @*QUMO\N E)NI\ STH/QESSI PERIPROXUQEI\S E)DA/MASSE>20."2 @KAI\ MET' O)LI/GA PA/LIN: @"1<20*(/OTI DE\ KAI\ TO\ QUMOEIDE\S E)NTAU=QA AU)TW=| E)STI, TA\ TOIAU=TA E)MFAI/NEI PLEI/ONA O)/NTA: [1&Il.$ *D& 24$8]1 *(/HRH| D' OU)K E)/XADE STH=QOS XO/LON, A)LLA\ PROSHU/DA. @KAI\ E)/TI: [1&Il.$ *S& 108$8]1 *KAI\ XO/LON, O(/ST' E)FE/HKE POLU/FRONA/ PER XALEPH=NAI @*(/OSTE POLU\ GLUKI/WN ME/LITOS KATALEIBOME/NOIO @*)ANDRW=N E)N STH/QESSIN A)E/CETAI, H)U/+TE KAPNO/S>20."2 @&Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. plac. III 2 [1`114]1 p. 260 M.$8 KA/LLION OU)=N H)=N_<20TO\N *XRU/SIPPON>20_PEIRAQH=NAI TO\ TOU= *ZH/NWNOS A)PODEI=CAI [1&sc.$8 E)/NQ' A)\N H)=| TO\ PAQHTIKO\N TH=S YUXH=S, E)NTAU=QA KAI\ TO\ LOGISTIKO\N U(PA/R-XEIN]1 KAI\ MH\ PLH=QOS E)PW=N PARAGRA/FEIN E)C A(PA/NTWN TW=N POIHTW=N E)K-LE/GONTA, DEIKNU/NTWN O)RGH\N KAI\ QUMO\N KAI\ FO/BON KAI\ DEILI/AN KAI\ QRA/SOS KAI\ QA/RSOS KAI\ KARTERI/AN, O(/SA T' A)/LLA TOIAU=TA, TA\ ME\N E)NERGEI/AS TINA\S EI)=NAI TA\ DE\ PAQH/MATA TH=S KARDI/AS. TI/ GA\R AU)TW=| BOU/LETAI TAUTI\ TA\ E)/PH TA\ E)C *(OMH/ROU SUNEILEGME/NA; @[1&Od.$ U& 13$8]1 <20*KRADI/H DE/ OI( E)/NDON U(LA/KTEI>20 @KAI\: [1&ibid. 17. 18]1 @$8<20*STH=QOS DE\ PLH/CAS KRADI/HN H)NI/PAPE MU/QW|: @*TE/TLAQI DH/, KRADI/H: KAI\ KU/NTERON A)/LLO POT' E)/TLHS>20 @KAI\: [1&Il.$ *K& 9. 10 cf. I 433]1 @<20$8*(\WS PUKI/N' E)N STH/QESSIN A)NASTENA/XIZ' *)AGAME/MNWN @*NEIO/QEN E)K KRADI/HS, PERI\ GA\R DI/E NHUSI\N *)AXAIW=N.>20 @KAI\: [1&Il. I 646]1 @<20$8*)ALLA/ MOI OI)DA/NETAI KRADI/H XO/LW|.>20 @KAI\: [1&Il.$ *D& 24]1 @<20$8*(/HRH| D' OU)K E)/XADE STH=QOS XO/LON, A)LLA\ PROSHU/DA>20. @KAI\: [1&Il.$ *A& 82]1 @$8<20*)ALLA/ TE KAI\ METO/PISQEN E)/XEI KO/TON, O)/FRA TELE/SSH|, @*)EN STH/QESSIN E(OI=SIN.>20 @*)EN A(/PASI GA\R TOU/TOIS OU) TO\ LOGISTIKO\N A)LLA\ TO\ QUMOEIDE\S E)N TH=| KARDI/A| PERIE/XESQAI DHLOU=TAI, W(/SPER, OI)=MAI, KA)N TOI=SDE [1&Il.$ *S& 107]1 @<20$8*KAI\ XO/LOS, O(/ST' E)FE/HKE POLU/FRONA/ PER XALEPH=NAI. @1 @*(/OSTE POLU\ GLUKI/WN ME/LITOS KATALEIBOME/NOIO @*)ANDRW=N E)N STH/QESSIN A)E/CETAI H)U/+TE KAPNO/S>20. KAI\: [1&Il.$ *L& 12]1 @<20$8*KARDI/H| A)/LHKTON POLEMI/ZEIN H)DE\ MA/XESQAI>20 KAI\ PRO\S TOU/TOIS E)/TI: [1&Il.$ *R& 570]1 @<20$8*KAI/ OI( MUI/HS QA/RSOS E)NI\ STH/QESSIN E)/QHKE>20 KAI\: [1&Od.$ U& 286]1 @<20$8*DU/H A)/XOS KRADI/HN *LAERTIA/DEW *)ODUSH=OS>20. KAI\: [1&Il.$ *E& 125?]1 @<20$8*)EN D' A)/RA OI( STH/QESSI ME/NOS PATRW/I+ON H(=KE>20 KAI\: [1&Il.$ *I& 629.30 cf. 675]1 @$8__<20*AU)TA\R *)AXILLEU\S @*DEINO\N E)NI\ STH/QESSIN E)/XEI MEGALH/TORA QUMO/N>20. KAI\: [1&Il.$ *I& 636.37]1 @$8__<20*SOI\ D' A)/LHKTO/N TE KAKO/N TE @*QUMO\N E)NI\ STH/QESSI QEOI\ QE/SAN EI(/NEKA KOU/RHS>20. KAI\: [1&Il.$ *N& 494]1 @<20$8*(\WS *AI)NEI/A| QUMO\S E)NI\ STH/QESSI GEGH/QEI>20 KAI\: @<20*PRH=SEN E)NI\ STH/QESSIN E)RISQENE/OS *DIO\S A)LKH\N @*GNW/MENAI>20. KAI\ PRO\S TOU/TOIS E)/TI: [1&Il.$ *N& 73.74]1 @<20$8*KAI\ DE/ MOI AU)TW=| QUMO\S E)NI\ STH/QESSI FI/LOISI @*MA=LLON E)FORMA=TAI POLEMI/ZEIN H)DE\ MA/XESQAI>20. KAI\: [1&Il.$ *O& 321.22?]1 @<20$8*SEI=S', E)PI\ D' AU)TO\S A)/U+SE MA/LA ME/GA, TOI=SI DE\ QUMO\N @*)EN STH/QESSIN E)/QELCE, FO/BOU D' E)MNH/SAQ' E(/KASTOS>20. KAI\: [1&Il.$ *K& 220]1 @<20$8*NE/STOR, E)/M' O)TRU/NEI KRADI/H KAI\ QUMO\S A)GH/NWR>20. KAI\: [1&Il.$ *K& 244]1 @<20$8*OU(= PERI\ ME\N PRO/FRWN KRADI/H KAI\ QUMO\S A)GH/NWR>20. KAI\: [1&Il.$ *D& 313.14]1 @<20$8*)=W GE/RON, EI)/Q' W(S QUMO\S E)NI\ STH/QESSI FI/LOISI, @*(/WS TOI GOU/NAQ' E(/POITO>20. KAI\: [1&Od.$ O& 20]1 @<20$8*OI)=SQA GA\R OI(=OS QUMO\S E)NI\ STH/QESSI GUNAIKO/S>20. KAI\: [1&Od.$ P& 274.75]1 @<20$8*SO\N DE\ FI/LON KH=R @*TETLA/TW E)N STH/QESSI KAKW=S PA/SXONTOS E)MEI=O>20 KAI\: [1&Il.$ *B& 142]1 @<20$8*(\WS FA/TO, TOI=SI DE\ QUMO\N E)NI\ STH/QESSIN O)/RINE>20. @1 @KAI\: [1&Od.$ R& 489]1 @<20$8*THLE/MAXOS D' E)N ME\N KRADI/H| ME/GA PE/NQOS A)/ECEN>20. @KAI\: [1&Od.$ U& 22]1 @<20$8*(/WS FA/T' E)NI\ STH/QESSI KAQAPTO/MENOS FI/LON H)=TOR>20. @[KAI\] @<20*TW=| DE\ MA/L' E)N [E)]PI/SH| KRADI/H| SHMAI/NETE TLHUI=A>20. @PA/NTA ME\N GA\R TAU=TA TA\ E)/PH KAI\ PRO\S TOU/TOIS E)/TI MURI/A E(/TERA TO\ PLH=QOS W(=N *XRU/SIPPOS PARATI/QETAI TO\ QUMOEIDE\S E)N TH=| KARDI/A| FHSI\N U(PA/RXEIN. E)GW\ DE\ EI) PA/NTA PARAGRA/FOIMI, PLHRW/SW TO\ BIBLI/ON, W(/SPER KAI\ O( *XRU/SIPPOS E)PLH/RWSEN. A)LL' E)C *(OMH/ROU ME\N I(KANA\ KAI\ TAU=TA: TW=N D' E)C *(HSIO/DOU PARAGRAFE/NTWN U(PO\ *XRUSI/PPOU, PAMPO/LLWN KAI\ AU)TW=N O)/NTWN, A)RKE/SEI MOI DUOI=N H)\ TRIW=N E)PIMNHSQH=NAI PARADEIGMA/TWN E(/NEKA. [1&Rzach fr. 234]1 @<20$8*TOU=[DE] GA\R A)E/CETO QUMO\S E)NI\ STH/QESSI FI/LOISI>20. @KAI\: [1&ib. fr. 235]1 @<20$8*OI(=ON E)NI\ STH/QESSI XO/LON QUMA/LGE' E)/XOUSA>20. @KAI\: [1&Hes. Theog. 641]1 @<20$8*PA/NTWN E)N STH/QESSIN A)E/CETO QUMO\S A)GH/NWR>20. @&Vituperat dein Galenus Chrysippum quod non locos poe%28tarum &suis sententiis accommodatos attulerit, ceteros omiserit$8 O( D' O(MOI/WS E(CH=S A(PA/NTWN ME/MNHTAI. TA\ ME\N GA\R TOIAU=TA TW=N E)PW=N A(/PANT' E)XRH=N U(P' AU)TOU= PARALELEI=FQAI, DI' W(=N DE\ NOU=N KAI\ FRE/NAS KAI\ DIA/NOIAN KAI\ LOGISMO\N EI)=PE/ TIS POIHTH\S E)N KARDI/A| PERIE/XESQAI, SUNA/GEIN E)/DEI, KAQA/PER E)/XEI KAI\ TA\ TOIAU=TA: @<20*KAI\ TO/TE DH\ STHQE/WN *)AQA/MA FRE/NAS E)CE/LETO *ZEU/S>20. @KAI\: [1&Il.$ *U& 20]1 @<20$8*)/EGNWS, *)ENNOSI/GAIE, E)MH\N E)N STH/QESI BOULH/N>20. @KAI\: [1&Od.$ N& 330]1 @<20$8*AI)EI/ TOI TOIOU=TON E)NI\ STH/QESSI NO/HMA>20 @KAI\: [1&Od.$ R& 403]1 @$8__<20*OU)/ MOI TOIOU=TON E)NI\ STH/QESSI NO/HMA>20 @&Magnam eiusmodi versuum multitudinem apud poe%28tas occurrere &G. dicit. ibidem III cp. 3 [1`116]1 p. 267 M.$8 TO\ DE\ PLEI/W ME\N E)KEI=NA, TAUTI\ D' E)LA/TTW GRA/YAI TW=| ME\N TO\ A)LHQE\S TH=S I(STORI/AS E)PIDEIKNU/NTI KALW=S A)\N GI/GNOITO: PLEI/W GA\R O)/NTWS E)STI\N E)KEI=NA: TW=| D', O(/PER O( *XRU/-SIPPOS SPOUDA/ZEI, KATASKEUA/ZEIN E)PIXEIROU=NTI PRO\S E)NANTIW/MATOS A)\N EI)/H, KAI\ MA/LISQ' O(/SA FANERW=S E)PITIMW=NTA POIEI= TO\N LOGISMO\N TW=| QUMW=|, KAQA/PER KAI\ TA/DE: [1&Od.$ U& 17.18]1 @$8*STH=QOS DE\ PLH/CAS KRADI/HN H)NI/PAPE MU/QW|: @*TE/TLAQI DH\ KRADI/H, KAI\ KU/NTERON A)/LLO POT' E)/TLHS. @1 @&Probat dein Galenus, longiore disputatione pluribusque Homeri &versibus allatis, apud Homerum hoc loco$8 TO\ LOGISTIKO\N &partem animi &esse$8 TOU= QUMOEIDOU=S DIA/FORON. &p. 272 M.$8 *)EMOI\ ME\N DH\ TOU/TWN TW=N E)PW=N EU)KAIRO/TATA ME\N O( *PLA/TWN DOKEI= MNHMONEU/EIN E)N TETA/RTW| POLITEI/AS [1&p. 441b]1,$8 A)KAIRO/TATA D' O( *XRU/SIPPOS, E)/TI DE\ MA=LLON W(=N *EU)RIPI/DHS E)POI/HSE LE/GOUSAN TH\N *MH/DEIAN, H(NI/KA KAI\ KATA\ TH\N E)KEI/NHS YUXH\N O( LOGISMO\S E)STASI/AZE PRO\S TO\N QUMO/N. &Quod supra de loco homerico pro-&bavit, iam de euripideo Galenus demonstrat$8 DU/O O)/NTA AU)TA\ MO/RIA TH=S YUXH=S [1&sc.$8 TO\ LOGISTIKO\N KAI\ TO\ QUMOEIDE/S]1. &p. 274 M.$8 O( DE\ *XRU/SIPPOS OU)/TE MO/RIA YUXH=S TAU=T' EI)=NAI NOMI/ZWN, OU)/TE DUNA/MEIS A)LO/GOUS E(TE/RAS TH=S LOGIKH=S, O(/MWS OU)K O)KNEI= TW=N *)ODUSSE/WS TE KAI\ *MHDEI/AS E)PW=N MNH-MONEU/EIN, E)NARGW=S KATABALLO/NTWN TH\N DO/CAN AU)TOU=. __E)MPE/PLHSTAI GA\R O( PERI\ H(GEMONIKOU= LO/GOS U(PO\ *XRUSI/PPOU GEGRAMME/NOS E)PW=N POIH-TIKW=N H)/TOI TA\ PA/QH PERI\ TO\N QW/RAKA/ TE KAI\ TH\N KARDI/AN SUNI/STASQAI MARTUROU/NTWN, H)\ DU/O EI)=NAI TH=S YUXH=S DUNA/MEIS O(/LW| TW=| GE/NEI DIAFE-ROU/SAS A)LLH/LWN, TH\N ME\N A)/LOGON, TH\N DE\ LOGIKH/N. *(/WSPER GA\R E)C *(OMH/ROU KAI\ *(HSIO/DOU BRAXE/A PAREQE/MHN O)LI/GW| PRO/SQEN W(=N O( *XRU/SIP-POS E)/GRAYEN, OU(/TWS <20E)C *)ORFE/WS KAI\ *)EMPEDOKLE/OUS KAI\ *TURTAI/OU KAI\ *STHSIXO/ROU KAI\ *EU)RIPI/DOU KAI\ E(TE/RWN POIHTW=N E)PW=N MNH-MONEU/EI PAMPO/LLWN>20 O(MOI/AN E)XO/NTWN A)TOPI/AN, OI(=ON KAI\ <20O(/TAN EI)/PH| *TURTAI=ON LE/GONTA>20: [1&fr. 13 Bgk.$8]1 <20*AI)/QWNOS DE\ LE/ONTOS E)/XWN E)N STH/QESI QUMO/N>20. @O(/TI ME\N GA\R E)/XEI O( LE/WN QUMO/N, A)KRIBW=S A(/PANTES A)/NQRWPOI KAI\ PRI\N A)KOU=SAI *TURTAI/OU GIGNW/SKOMEN, OU) MH\N *XRUSI/PPW| G' E)/PREPE PARA-QE/SQAI TO\ E)/POS <20A)FAIROUME/NW| TOU\S LE/ONTAS TO\N QUMO/N. OU)DE\N GA/R, W(S OI)/ETAI, TW=N A)LO/GWN ZW/WN OU)/TE TO\ QUMOEIDE\S OU)/TE TO\ E)PIQUMHTIKO\N OU)/TE TO\ LOGISTIKO\N E)/XEI, A)LLA\__PARA\ PA=SAN TH\N E)NA/RGEIAN A)FAIROU=NTAI TW=N EI)RHME/NWN A(PA/NTWN AU)TA\ SXEDO\N A(/PANTES OI( *STWI+KOI/>20. @&Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. plac. III 4 [1`120]1 p. 281 M.$8 E)MPLH/SAS O( *XRU/SIPPOS O(/LON TO\ BIBLI/ON E)PW=N *(OMHRIKW=N KAI\ *(HSIODEI/WN KAI\ *STH-SIXOREI/WN, *)EMPEDOKLEI/WN TE KAI\ *)ORFIKW=N, E)/TI DE\ PRO\S TOU/TOIS E)K TH=S TRAGW|DI/AS KAI\ PARA\ *TURTAI/OU KAI\ TW=N A)/LLWN POIHTW=N OU)K O)LI/GA PARA-QE/MENOS, EI)=TA [MH\] SUNEI\S TH=S QAUMASTH=S DH\ TAU/THS A)PERANTOLOGI/AS [1TOU=TO GA\R AU)TH=| MA=LLON H(GOU=MAI PROSH/KEIN TOU)/NOMA]1 TAU=TA KATA\ LE/CIN E)PIFE/REI: @"1<20TAUTI\ ME\N FH/SOUSIN A)DOLESXI/AN EI)=NAI GRAW/DH, TUXO\N DE\ KAI\ GRAMMA/TWN DIDASKA/LOU BOULOME/NOU STI/XOUS O(/TI PLEI/STOUS U(PO\ TO\ AU)TO\ DIANO/HMA TA/CAI>20."2 @1 @&ibidem [1`121]1 p. 285 M.$8 E)/GWG' OU)=N H)NAGKA/SQHN U(PO\ [2TH=S]2 TOU= *XRUSI/PPOU PROAXQEI\S A)DOLESXI/AS E)CHGEI=SQAI TA/S TE TW=N I)DIWTW=N KAI\ TA\S *EU)RIPI/DOU FWNA/S, O(\ MH/POT' A)\N E(KW\N E)TO/LMHSA PRA=CAI PERI\ THLI-KOU/TOU DO/GMATOS A)PODEI/CEIS GRA/FWN. &Neque enim interesse, quid &poetae dixerint, sed quid verum sit atque probari possit. &@Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. plac. III 8 [1`130]1 p. 317 M.$8 E(CH=S TE PROSQH/SW <20TO\N PERI\ TH=S *)AQHNA=S LO/GON>20. AI)SQO/MENOS GA\R O( *XRU/-SIPPOS E)NANTIOU/MENON TOI=S E(AUTOU= DO/GMASI TO\N PERI\ TH=S QEOU= MU=QON, A)PO\ TH=S TOU= *DIO\S KEFALH=S U(PEILHMME/NHS GEGENH=SQAI, TOIA/DE LE/GEI [1PARA-GRA/YW GA\R A(/PASAN AU)TOU= TH\N R(H=SIN, EI) KAI\ MAKROTE/RA PW/S E)STIN]1. @"1<20*)AKOU/W DE/ TINAS LE/GEIN PARAMUQOUME/NOUS PRO\S TO\ E)N TH=| KEFALH=| EI)=NAI TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N TH=S YUXH=S ME/ROS: TO\ GA\R TH\N *)AQHNA=N, MH=TIN OU)=SAN KAI\ OI(=ON FRO/NHSIN, E)K TH=S KEFALH=S GE-NE/SQAI TOU= *DIO\S SU/MBOLO/N FASIN EI)=NAI TOU= TAU/TH| TO\ H(GEMONI-KO\N EI)=NAI: OU) GA\R A)/LLWS A)\N E)N TH=| KEFALH=| GENE/SQAI MH=TIN KAI\ FRO/NHSIN, EI) MH\ TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N E)N TAU/TH| E)STI/: PIQANOU= ME/N TINOS E)XO/MENOI, DIAMARTA/NONTES D', W(S E)MOI\ FAI/NETAI, KAI\ A)GNOOU=NTES TA\ PERI\ TOU/TWN I(STOROU/MENA, PERI\ W(=N OU) XEI=RO/N E)STIN E)PI\ PLE/ON EI)PEI=N TOI=S E)NESTW=SI ZHTH/MASI. FASI\ D' OI( ME\N OU(/TWS A(PLW=S, E)K TH=S TOU= *DIO\S KEFALH=S AU)TH\N GENE/SQAI, OU)DE\ PROSISTOROU=NTES TO\ PW=S H)\ KATA\ TI/NA LO/GON. O( DE\ *(HSI/O-DOS E)PI\ PLE/ON LE/GEI E)N TAI=S [QEOGONI/AIS] TINW=N ME\N E)N TH=| QEO-GONI/A| GRAFO/NTWN TH\N GE/NESIN AU)TH=S, PRW=TON ME\N *MH/TIDI SUG-GENOME/NOU TOU= *DIO/S, DEU/TERON DE\ *QE/MIDI, TINW=N DE\ E)N E(TE/ROIS A)/LLWS GRAFO/NTWN TH\N GE/NESIN AU)TH=S, W(S A)/RA GENOME/NHS E)/RI-DOS TW=| *DII\+ KAI\ TH=| *(/HRA| GENNH/SEIEN H( ME\N *(/HRA DI' E(AUTH=S TO\N *(/HFAISTON, O( DE\ *ZEU\S TH\N *)AQHNA=N E)K TH=S *MH/TIDOS KATAPO-QEI/SHS U(P' AU)TOU=. H( ME\N GA\R EI)S AU)TO\N KATA/POSIS TH=S *MH/TI-DOS KAI\ E)/NDON TOU= *DIO\S TH=S *)AQHNA=S GE/NESIS KAT' A)MFOTE/ROUS TOU\S LO/GOUS E)STI/N. DIAFE/ROUSI D' E)N TW=| PW=S TAU=TA SUNETE-LE/SQH PRO\S TO\N E)NESTW=TA LO/GON OU)QENO\S O)/NTOS TOIOU/TOU. TO\ GA\R KOINO\N E)N AU)TOI=S U(PA/RXON MO/NON XRH/SIMO/N E)STI PRO\S TA\ E)NESTW=TA: LE/GETAI D' E)N ME\N TH=| QEOGONI/A| OU(/TW: [1&Hes. Theog. &`886_90. 900]1 @$8*ZEU\S DE\ QEW=N BASILEU\S PRW/THN A)/LOXON QE/TO *MH=TIN, @*PLEI=STA QEW=N EI)DUI=AN I)DE\ QNHTW=N A)NQRW/PWN. @*)ALL' O(/TE DH/ R(' H)/MELLE QEA\N GLAUKW=PIN *)AQH/NHN @*TE/CESQAI, TO/T' E)/PEITA DO/LW| FRE/NAS E)CAPATH/SAS @1 @*AI(MULI/OISI LO/GOISIN E(H\N E)GKA/TQETO NHDU/N: @*(/WS OI( SUMFRA/SSAITO QEA\ A)GAQO/N TE KAKO/N TE. @EI)=TA PROELQW/N FHSIN OU(/TWS>20: [1&ibid. 924_26]1$ @<20*AU)TO\S D' E)K KEFALH=S GLAUKW/PIDA GEI/NAT' *)AQH/NHN, @*DEINH/N, E)GREKU/DOIMON, A)GE/STRATON, A)TRUTW/NHN, @*PO/TNIAN, H(=| KE/LADOI/ TE A(/DON, PO/LEMOI/ TE MA/XAI TE. @STH/QESI GA\R AU)TOI=S E)/NDON EU)/DHLON O(/TI A)PE/QETO TH\N *MH=TIN, KAI\ OU(/TWS FHSI\N AU)TH\N GENNH=SAI KATA\ TH\N KEFALH/N. E)N DE\ TOI=S META\ TAU=TA PLEI/W DIELHLUQO/TOS AU)TOU=, TOIAU=T' E)STI\ TA\ LEGO/MENA: @*)EK TAU/THS E)/RIDOS H( ME\N TE/KE FAI/DIMON UI(O\N @*(/HFAISTON TE/XNH|SIN A)/NEU *DIO\S AI)GIO/XOIO, @*)EK PA/NTWN PALA/MH|SI KEKLHME/NON OU)RANIW/NWN. @*AU)TA\R O(/ G' *)WKEANOU= KAI\ *THQU/OS H)U+KO/MOIO @*KOU/RHN NO/SF' *(/HRHS PAREDE/CATO KALLIPARH/|OU @*)ECAPAFW\N *MH=TIN, KAI/PER POLU\ DINEU/OUSAN: @*SUMMA/RYAS D' O(/ GE XERSI\N E(H\N E)GKA/TQETO NHDU/N, @*DEI/SAS, MH\ TE/CH| KRATERW/TERON A)/LLO KERAUNOU=. @*TOU)/NEKA/ MIN *KRONI/DHS U(YI/ZUGOS AI)QE/RI NAI/WN @*KA/PPIEN E)CAPI/NHS: H( D' AU)TI/KA *PALLA/D' *)AQH/NHN @*KU/SATO: TH\N ME\N E)/TIKTE PATH\R A)NDRW=N TE QEW=N TE @*PA\R KORUFH\N *TRI/TWNOS E)P' O)/XQH|SIN POTAMOI=O. @*MH=TIS D' AU)=TE *ZHNO\S U(PO\ SPLA/GXNOIS LELAQUI=A @*(=HSTO *)AQHNAI/HS MH/THR TE/KTAINA DIKAI/WN, @*PLEI=STA QEW=N EI)DUI=A KATAQNHTW=N T' A)NQRW/PWN. @*)/ENQA QEA\ PARE/LEKTO % *QE/MIS PALA/MAIS PERI\ PA/NTWN @*)AQANA/TWN E)KE/KASTO *)OLU/MPIA DW/MAT' E)/XOUSIN @*AI)GI/DA POIH/SASA FOBE/STRATON E)NTO\S *)AQH/NH|, @*SU\N TH=| E)GEI/NATO/ MIN, POLEMH/I+A TEU/XE' E)/XOUSAN.>20"2 @&Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. plac. III 8 [1`131]1 p. 321 M$8 TAU=TA PROEIPW\N O( *XRU/SIPPOS E(CH=S AU)TOI=S SUNA/PTWN TA/DE GRA/FEI: @"1<20*TA\ ME\N OU)=N PERI\ TH=S *)AQHNA=S LEGO/MENA TOIAU=TA/ E)STIN, A)/LLOU TINO\S SUMBO/LOU POIOU=NT' E)/MFASIN. PRW=TON ME\N GA\R H( *MH=TIS LE/GETAI W(SANEI/ TIS FRO/NHSIS KAI\ PERI\ TW=N KATA\ TO\N BI/ON TE/XNH: H(=| TA\S TE/XNAS DEI= KATAPI/NESQAI KAI\ E)NAPOTI/QESQAI, KAQ' O(\N LO/GON KAI\ TA\ LEGO/MENA/ TINAS KATAPI/NEIN FAME/N: DIA\ DE\ TH\N KATA/POSIN SUNHKOLOUQHKO/TWS LE/GETAI KAI\ EI)S TH\N KOI-LI/AN A)POTI/QESQAI AU)TA/. META\ TAU=TA TH\N KATAPOQEI=SAN TOIAU/-THN TE/XNHN TI/KTEIN EU)/LOGON E)N AU)TW=| PARAPLHSI/AN TH=S TIK- @1TOU/SHS MHTRO/S: PRO\S DE\ TOU/TOIS TA\ U(PO\ TW=N E)PISTHMW=N TIKTO/MENA E)N AU)TOI=S, PW=S [D'] A)\N E)KPOREU/OITO KAI\ DIA\ TI/NOS MA/LISTA, PA/RESTI SKOPEI=N. FANERO\N GA/R, O(/TI LO/GW| E)KFE/RETAI DIA\ TOU= STO/MATOS KATA\ TH\N KEFALH/N, E)C I)/SOU OU(/TWS TH=S KEFA-LH=S LEGOME/NHS, O(\N TRO/PON PROBA/TOU KEFALH\ LE/GETAI, KAI\ TA\S KEFALA\S A)FAIROU=SI/ TINWN: KAQ' O(\N LO/GON PARAGINO/MENON KAI\ E)K TH=S KORUFH=S LE/GETAI GENE/SQAI, TW=N TOIOU/TWN PARALLAGW=N KATA\ SU/MBOLON GINOME/NWN PLEIO/NWN: KAI\ XWRI\S DE\ TH=S I(STO-RI/AS TAU/THS A)P' AU)TOU= MO/NON TOU= GENE/SQAI TAU/THN KATA\ TH\N KEFALH\N TA\ PARAPLH/SIA [2A)/N]2 TIS LE/GOI: OU) GA\R E)N TH=| KEFALH=| FHSIN AU)TH\N GENE/SQAI, EI) MH/ TINES DIASTRE/FONTES H)\ PARALLA/T-TONTES TO\N LO/GON, E)CELQEI=N TAU/TH| GINOME/NHN A)/LLWS E)/ROINTO: W(/STE MA=LLON KAI\ TOU=TO SU/MBOLON PRO\S TO\N E(/TERON EI)=NAI, W(S E)/FHN: TA\ GA\R E)N AU)TOI=S GINO/MENA TEXNIKA\ KATA\ TH\N KEFALH\N E)CIO/NTA MA/LISTA A)POSHMAI/NEI TO\N PROEIRHME/NON LO/GON>20."2 @AU(/TH ME\N H( TOU= *XRUSI/PPOU R(H=SIS. @&Philodemus de pietate c. 16 [1DDG p. 549, 9]1.$ TINA\S DE\ TW=N *STWI+KW=N FA/SKEIN, O(/TI TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N E)N TH=| KEFALH=|: FRO/NHSIN GA\R EI)=NAI, DIO\ KAI\ *MH=TIN KALEI=SQAI: *XRU/SIPPON D' E)N TW=| STH/QEI TO\ H(GE-MONIKO\N EI)=NAI KA)KEI= TH\N *)AQHNA=N GEGONE/NAI FRO/NHSIN OU)=SAN, TW=| DE\ TH\N FWNH\N E)K TH=S KEFALH=S E)KKRI/NESQAI, LE/GEIN E)K TH=S KEFALH=S, U(PO\ DE\ *(HFAI/STOU DIO/TI TE/XNH| GI/NEQ' H( FRO/NHSIS, KAI\ *)AQHNA=N ME\N OI(=ON *)AQRHNA=N EI)RH=SQAI, *TRITWNI/DA DE\ KAI\ *TRITOGE/NEIAN DIA\ TO\ TH\N FRO/-NHSIN E)K TRIW=N SUNESTHKE/NAI LO/GWN, TW=N FUSIKW=N KAI\ TW=N H)QIKW=N KAI\ TW=N LOGIKW=N. KAI\ TA\S A)/LLAS D' AU)TH=S PROSHGORI/AS KAI\ TA\ FORH/[I]-MATA MA/LA KATAXRU/SWS TH=| FRONH/SEI SUNOIKEIOI=. @&10Chryippi de anima lib. I pars altera.$10 @*(H YUXH\ PNEU=MA/ E)STI SU/MFUTON H(MI=N, SUNEXE/S, PANTI\ TW=| SW/MATI DIH=-KON, E)/ST' A)\N H( TH=S ZWH=S EU)/PNOIA PARH=| E)N TW=| SW/MATI: TAU/THS OU)=N TW=N ME-RW=N E(KA/STW| DIATETAGME/NWN MORI/W| TO\ DIH=KON AU)TH=S EI)S TH\N TRAXEI=AN A)RTHRI/AN FWNH/N FAMEN EI)=NAI, TO\ DE\ EI)S O)FQALMOU\S O)/YIN, TO\ DE\ EI)S W)=TA A)KOH/N, TO\ DE\ EI)S R(I=NAS O)/SFRHSIN, TO\ D' EI)S GLW=TTAN GEU=SIN, TO\ D' EI)S O(/LHN TH\N SA/RKA A(FH\N KAI\ TO\ EI)S O)/RXEIS, E(/TERO/N TIN' E)/XON TOIOU=TON LO/GON, SPERMATIKO/N: EI)S O(\ DE\ SUMBAI/NEI PA/NTA TAU=TA, E)N TH=| KARDI/A| EI)=NAI, ME/ROS O)\N AU)TH=S TO\ H(GEMONI- @1KO/N. OU(/TW DE\ E)XO/NTWN AU)TW=N TA\ ME\N LOIPA\ SUMFWNEI=TAI, PERI\ DE\ TOU= H(GE-MONIKOU= ME/ROUS TH=S YUXH=S DIAFWNOU=SIN, A)/LLOI E)N A)/LLOIS LE/GONTES AU)TO\ EI)=NAI TO/POIS: OI( ME\N GA\R PERI\ TO\N QW/RAKA/ FASIN EI)=NAI AU)TO/, OI( DE\ PERI\ TH\N KE-FALH/N. KATA\ TA\ AU)TA\ DE\ TAU=TA DIAFWNOU=SI, POU= TH=S KEFALH=S KAI\ TOU= QW/-RAKO/S E)STIN, OU) SUMFWNOU=NTES AU(TOI=S. *PLA/TWN DE\ KAI\ TRIMERH= TH\N YUXH\N FH/SAS EI)=NAI, TO\ ME\N LOGISTIKO\N E)/LEGEN E)N TH=| KEFALH=| EI)=NAI, TO\ DE\ QUMOEIDE\S PERI\ TO\N QW/RAKA, TO\ D' E)PIQUMHTIKO\N PERI\ TO\N O)MFALO/N. OU(/TW FAI/NETAI DIAFEU/GEIN O( TO/POS H(MA=S OU)/T' AI)SQH/SEWS E)KFANOU=S GENOME/NHS, O(/PER E)PI\ TW=N LOIPW=N SUNTETU/XHKEN, OU)/TE TOIOU/TWN TEKMHRI/WN, DI' W(=N A)/N TIS SULLOGI/SAITO TOU=TO: OU)DE\ GA\R A)\N [2H(]2 A)NTILOGI/A E)PI\ TOSOU=TON PROH=LQEN KAI\ E)N I)ATROI=S KAI\ E)N FILOSO/FOIS. *PERI\ W(=N E(CH=S ZHTH/SOMEN PARAPLHSI/WS A)PO\ TH=S KOINH=S O(RMW/MENOI FORA=S KAI\ TW=N KATA\ TAU/THN EI)RHME/NWN LO/GWN. *KAI\ [2GA\R]2 E)PI\ TOU/TWN I(KANW=S FAI/NONTAI E)NHNE/XQAI A)P' A)RXH=S EI)S TO\ EI)=NAI TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N H(MW=N E)N TH=| KARDI/A|. *KOINH=| DE/ MOI DOKOU=SIN OI( POLLOI\ FE/RESQAI E)PI\ TOU=Q', W(SANEI\ AI)SQANO/MENOI PERI\ TO\N QW/RAKA AU)TOI=S TW=N KATA\ TH\N DIA/NOIAN PAQW=N GIGNOME/NWN KAI\ MA/LISTA KAQ' O(\N H( KARDI/A TE/TAKTAI TO/PON, OI(=ON MA/LISTA E)PI\ TW=N FO/BWN KAI\ TW=N LUPW=N KAI\ E)PI\ TH=S O)RGH=S KAI\ MA/LISTA TOU= QUMOU=. [2W(SA-NEI\ GA\R TOU= QUMOU=]2 E)K TH=S KARDI/AS A)NAQUMIWME/NOU KAI\ W)QOUME/NOU E)KTO\S E)PI/ TINA KAI\ E)MFUSW=NTOS TO\ PRO/SWPON KAI\ TA\S XEI=RAS GI/GNETAI H(MI=N E)/MFASIS ..... H( GA\R PERI\ TH\N DIA/NOIAN GIGNOME/NH TARAXH\ KAQ' E(/KASTON TOU/TWN AI)-SQHTW=S PERI\ TOU\S QW/RAKA/S E)STIN. *TH=S ME\N OU)=N O)RGH=S GIGNOME/NHS E)NTAU=QA, EU)/LOGON KAI\ TA\S LOIPA\S E)PIQUMI/AS E)NTAU=Q' EI)=NAI KAI\ NH\ *DI/A TA\ LOIPA\ PA/QH KAI\ TOU\S DIALOGISMOU\S KAI\ O(/SA TOU/TOIS E)STI\ PARAPLH/SIA. SAINO/MENOI DE\ FH/-MH| OI( POLLOI\ TOU/TWN POLLA\ KATA\ TH\N A)LH/QEIAN E)PILE/GOUSI TOIAU=TA, E)XO/MENOI TH=S R(HQEI/SHS FORA=S. PRW=TON ME\N GA\R PA/NTES, I(/NA E)NTEU=QEN A)/RCWMAI, KATA\ TOU=TO/ FASIN A)NABAI/NEIN TINW=N TO\N QUMO/N, KAI\ KATAPI/NEIN TH\N XOLH/N TINAS A)CIOU=SI, LE/GONTE/S TE KATAPI/NESQAI/ TINA AU)TOI=S SPARA/GMATA KAI\ MH\ KATAPI/-NESQAI KATA\ TH\N TOIAU/THN FORA\N LE/GOMEN. OU(/TW DE\ LE/GETAI KAI\ "1MHDE\N AU)-TOI=S TOU/TWN KATABAI/NEIN"2 KAI\ O(/TI "1KATAPIW\N TO\ R(HQE\N A)PH=LQEN"2, O(/ TE *ZH/NWN PRO\S TOU\S E)PILAMBANOME/NOUS O(/TI PA/NTA TA\ ZHTOU/MENA EI)S TO\ STO/MA FE/REI[N], E)/FHSEN "1A)LL' OU) PA/NTA KATAPI/NETAI"2, OU)/TE TH=S KATAPO/SEWS A)/LLWS A)\N OI)KEIO/-TERON LEGOME/NHS OU)/TE TH=S KATABA/SEWS TW=N R(HQE/NTWN, EI) MH\ PERI\ TO\N QW/RAKA TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N H(MW=N H)=N, EI)S O(\ TAU=TA PA/NTA FE/RETAI. E)N GOU=N TH=| KEFALH=| O)/NTOS AU)TOU=, GELOI/WS R(HQH/SETAI KAI\ A)LLOTRI/WS KATABAI/NEIN, A)NABAI/NEIN A)\N OI)=-MAI OI)KEIO/TERON AU)TW=N LEGOME/NWN KAI\ OU) KATABAI/NEIN, TO\N [2DE\]2 PROEIRHME/NON TRO/PON TH=S KATA\ TH\N A)KOH\N AI)SQH/SEWS KATAFEROME/NHS PERI\ TH\N DIA/NOIAN, E)A\N H)=| PERI\ TO\N QW/RAKA, OI)KEI/WS KATA/BASIS R(HQH/SETAI: E)A\N DE\ PERI\ TH\N KEFALH\N A)LLOTRIW/TERON. *AI( DE\ GUNAI=KES KAI\ MA=LLO/N TI TOU/TWN E)MFAI/-NOUSIN. EI) GA\R MH\ KATABAI/NEI AU)TAI=S TA\ LEGO/MENA, POLLA/KIS TO\N DA/KTULON KATA/GOUSI E(/WS TOU= KATA\ TH\N KARDI/AN TO/POU, OU) FA/SKOUSAI KATABAI/NEIN W(=DE TA\ EI)RHME/NA. *TOU/TOIS D' A)KOLOU/QWS A)NEMEI=N TE/ TINA/S FAMEN TA\ FA-NE/NTA AU)TOI=S KAI\ E)/TI TO\N BAQU/N, LEGOME/N[2WN]2 POLLW=N TOIOU/TWN SUMFW/NWS TOI=S EI)RHME/NOIS: KATAPIO/NTES GA\R O(/MOION EI)PEI=N, O(/TI H(ME/RA E)STI/, KAI\ E)NAPO- @1QE/MENOI TOU=TO EI)S TH\N DIA/NOIAN, KAI\ PA/LIN E)KEI=NO LE/GONTES O(/TI OU)K E)/STIN H(ME/RA, MENO/NTWN TW=N PRAGMA/TWN, OU)K A)LLOTRI/WS OU)D' A)NOIKEI/WS A)NEMEI=N LE/-GONTAI. *)AF' H(=S TE FORA=S LE/GOMEN, MH\ KATABAI/NEIN TA\ LEGO/MENA, EI)/TE A)PEILA\S EI)/TE LOIDORI/AS, W(/STE KAQIKE/SQAI KAI\ A(/PTESQAI AU)TW=N KAI\ OU(/TWS KINEI=SQAI TH\N DIA/NOIAN, A)PO\ TH=S FORA=S TAU/THS KAI\ BAQEI=S TINA/S FAMEN EI)=NAI, DIA\ TO\ MHDE\N TW=N TOIOU/TWN E)FIKNEI=SQAI KATABH=NAI AU)TW=N ..... *EU)/LOGON DE\ EI)S O(\ GI/GNONTAI AI( E)N TOU/TW| SHMASI/AI KAI\ E)C OU(= O( LO/GOS [1E)KPE/MPETAI]1, E)KEI=NO EI)=NAI TO\ KURIEU=ON TH=S YUXH=S ME/ROS: OU) GA\R A)/LLH ME\N PHGH\ LO/GOU E)STI/N, A)/LLH DE\ DIANOI/AS, OU)DE\ A)/LLH ME\N FWNH=S PHGH/, A)/LLH DE\ LO/GOU, OU)DE\ TO\ O(/LON A(PLW=S A)/LLH FWNH=S PHGH/ E)STIN, A)/LLO DE\ TO\ KURIEU=ON TH=S YUXH=S ME/ROS. TOIOU/TOIS DE\ KAI\ TH\N DIA/NOIAN SUMFW/NWS A)FORIZO/MENOI LE/GOUSIN AU)TH\N PHGH\N EI)=NAI LO/GOU. *TO\ GA\R O(/LON O(/QEN O( LO/GOS E)KPE/MPETAI, E)KEI=SE DEI= KAI\ TO\N DIALOGISMO\N GI/GNESQAI KAI\ TA\S DIANOH/SEIS KAI\ TA\S MELE/TAS TW=N R(H/SEWN, KAQA/PER E)/FHN. TAU=TA DE\ E)KFANW=S PERI\ TH\N KARDI/AN GI/GNETAI, E)K TH=S KARDI/AS DIA\ FA/RUGGOS KAI\ TH=S FWNH=S KAI\ TOU= LO/GOU E)KPEMPOME/NWN. PIQANO\N DE\ KAI\ A)/LLWS, EI)S O(\ E)NSHMAI/NETAI TA\ LEGO/MENA, KAI\ SHMAI/NESQAI E)KEI=QEN KAI\ TA\S FWNA\S A)P' E)KEI/NOU GI/GNESQAI KATA\ TO\N PROEIRHME/NON TRO/PON. *OU(/TWS DE\ KAI\ TO\ "1E)GW\"2 LE/GOMEN KATA\ TOU=TO, DEIKNU/NTES AU(TOU\S E)N TW=| [2LE/-GEIN, EI)S TO\ E)KEI=]2 A)POFAI/NESQAI TH\N DIA/NOIAN EI)=NAI, TH=S DEI/CEWS FUSIKW=S KAI\ OI)KEI/WS E)NTAU=QA FEROME/NHS: KAI\ A)/NEU DE\ TH=S KATA\ TH\N XEI=RA TOIAU/THS DEI/CEWS NEU/ONTES EI)S AU(TOU\S TO\ "1E)GW\"2 LE/GOMEN, EU)QU\S KAI\ TH=S "1E)GW\"2 FWNH=S TOIAU/THS OU)/SHS KAI\ KATA\ TH\N E(CH=S U(POGEGRAMME/NHN DEI=CIN SUNEKFEROME/NHS. TO\ GA\R "1E)GW\"2 PROFERO/MEQA, KATA\ TH\N PRW/THN SULLABH\N KATASPW=NTES TO\ KA/TW XEI=LOS EI)S AU(TOU\S DEIKTIKW=S, A)KOLOU/QWS DE\ TH=| TOU= GENEI/OU KINH/SEI KAI\ E)PI\ STH=QOS NEU/SEI KAI\ TH=| TOIAU/TH| DEI/CEI H( E(CH=S SULLABH\ PARA/KEITAI, OU)DE\N A)POSTHMATIKO\N PAREMFAI/NOUSA, O(/PER E)PI\ TOU= "1E)KEI=NOS"2 SUNTE/TEUXE. [1[2KAI\ GA\R]2 E)N TAI=S SUGKATAQE/SESIN E)PINEU/ONTES TH\N KEFALH/N, E)F' O(\ FE/ROMEN AU)TH\N ME/ROS, E)N E)KEI/NW| TH\N A)RXH\N TH=S YUXH=S U(PA/RXEIN E)NDEIKNU/MEQA]1. *TOU/TOIS PA=SI SUM-FW/NWS KAI\ TOU)/NOMA TOU=T' E)/SXHKEN H( KARDI/A KATA/ TINA KRA/THSIN KAI\ KUREI/AN, A)PO\ TOU= E)N AU)TH=| EI)=NAI TO\ KURIEU=ON KAI\ KRATOU=N TH=S YUXH=S ME/ROS, W(S A)\N KRATI/A LEGOME/NH. *(ORMW=ME/N [2TE GA\R]2 KATA\ TOU=TO TO\ ME/ROS KAI\ SUGKATATI-QE/MEQA TOU/TW| KAI\ EI)S TOU=TO SUNTEI/NEI TA\ AI)SQHTH/RIA PA/NTA ...... *)/EXEI D' W(S E)/FHN PLEI/ONA AU)TOI=S [2A)NTEIPEI=N]2 E)PI\ PA=SI, MH/POT' EI) KAI\ TOU=TO DO-QEI/H [1KAQA/PER E)PIPOREU/ONTAI]1 A)PO\ TH=S KEFALH=S EI)=NAI TH\N A)RXH\N E)PI\ TA\ EI)RH-ME/NA ME/RH, E)PIZHTH/SOMEN. SXEDO\N GA\R OI(=A A)/N TINA LE/GOIEN PERI\ TOU= TH\N FWNH\N E)K TOU= STH/QOUS FE/RESQAI DIA\ TH=S FA/RUGGOS, A)PO\ TH=S KEFALH=S POIA=S TINOS KATARXH=S GIGNOME/NHS, TOIAU=T' E)/CESTI LE/GEIN, E)N TH=| KARDI/A| ME\N TOU= H(GE-MONIKOU= O)/NTOS, TH=S DE\ TW=N KINH/SEWN A)RXH=S A)PO\ TH=S KEFALH=S OU)/SHS ..... *KATA\ TOU=TO KAI\ EU)KA/RDIOI LE/GONTAI/ POU EI)=NAI/ TINES, KAQA/PER EU)/YUXOI, KAI\ KARDI/AN A)LGEI=N OI( KHDO/MENOI/ TINWN, W(S A)\N KATA\ TH\N KARDI/AN TH=S KATA\ TH\N LU/PHN A)LGHDO/NOS GIGNOME/NHS. *TO\ GA\R O(/LON, KAQA/PER E)N A)RXH=| EI)=PON, EU)= MA/L' E)MFAI/NOUSIN OI(/ TE FO/BOI KAI\ AI( LU=PAI KATA\ TOU=TO TO\ ME/ROS GIGNO/MENAI. H(/ TE GA\R E)N TOI=S FO/BOIS PA/LSIS TH=S KARDI/AS E)KFANH/S E)STI KAI\ H( EI)S TOU=TO TH=S @1 O(/LHS YUXH=S SUNDROMH/, OU)K A)/LLWS E)PIGENNHMATIKW=S GIGNOME/NWN AU)TW=N, KA-QA/PER A)/LLOIS A)/LLOU SUMPA/SXEIN PEFUKO/TOS. KAQ' O(\ KAI\ SUNIZA/NOUSIN EI)S AU(TOU/S, SUNAGO/MENOI PRO\S TOU=TO, W(S A)\N TO\ H(GEMONIKO/N, KAI\ KATA\ TH\N [2KAR-DI/AN]2 W(S A)\N TOU/TOU FULAKTIKH/N. *KAI\ TA\ TH=S LU/PHS PA/QH E)NTAUQOI= POU E)KFANW=S GI/GNETAI, OU)DENO\S A)/LLOU SUMPA/SXONTOS OU)DE\ SUNALGOU=NTOS TO/POU. A)LGHDO/NWN GA/R TINWN KATA\ TAU=TA GIGNOME/NWN SFODRW=N, E(/TEROS ME\N OU)DEI\S E)MFAI/NEI TO/POS TA\ PA/QH TAU=TA, O( DE\ PERI\ TH\N KARDI/AN MA/LISTA. *)ATO/PON OU)=N TO\ KATA\ TAU=TA LEXQHSO/MENON, E)A/N TE MH\ FW=SI TH\N LU/PHN KAI\ TH\N A)GWNI/AN A)LGHDO/NAS EI)=NAI, E)A/N TE A)LGHDO/NAS E)N A)/LLW| GI/GNESQAI TO/PW| H)\ TW=| H(GEMO-NIKW=|: TA\ DE\ AU)TA\ KAI\ E)PI\ TH=S XARA=S KAI\ E)PI\ TOU= QA/RSOUS E)ROU=MEN, A(/PER E)MFAI/NEI PERI\ TH\N KARDI/AN GIGNO/MENA. O(\N TRO/PON GA/R, O(/TAN TO\N PO/DA PO-NW=MEN H)\ TH\N KEFALH/N, PERI\ TOU/TOUS TOU\S TO/POUS O( PO/NOS GI/GNETAI, OU(/TWS SUNAISQANO/MEQA KAI\ TH=S KATA\ TH\N LU/PHN A)LGHDO/NOS PERI\ TO\N QW/RAKA GIGNO-ME/NHS, OU)/TE TH=S LU/PHS OU)K OU)/SHS A)LGHDO/NOS, OU)/TE E)N E(TE/RW| TINI\ TO/PW| H)\ TW=| H(GEMONIKW=| AU)TH=S GIGNOME/NHS. *KAQ' H(\N E)/TI FORA\N KAI\ TA\ TOIAU=TA LE/GETAI PA/NTA: "1H(YA/MHN SOU TH=S KARDI/AS"2 W(/SPER TH=S YUXH=S, KAI\ "1A(/PTOMAI TH=S KARDI/AS"2 LE/GOMEN, OU)X, W(S A)NTIPARE/LQOIEN A)/N TINES H(MA=S, [2W(S]2 E)PI\ TOU= E)GKEFA/LOU KAI\ TW=N SPLA/GXNWN LE/GONTES KAI\ TOU= H(/PATOS, A)LLA\ TOI=S PROEIRH-ME/NOIS PARAPLHSI/WS. E)KEI=NA GA/R MOI DOKEI= LE/GESQAI, W(S A)/N TIS E)/FH "1TW=N E)NTO/S SOU A(/PTOMAI"2 DII+KNOUME/NHS TH=S KAKOPOII/+AS E)PI\ TOSOU=TON. TH=| DE\ KARDI/A| KAQA/PER A)\N TH=| YUXH=| XRW/MEQA. *KAI\ TOU/TWN E)/STAI E)/MFASIS E)FISTA=SI MA=L-LON ..... *PARABA/LLOUSI DE\ TOI=S EI)RHME/NOIS KAI\ TA\ TOIAU=TA TW=N LEGOME/NWN, OI(=ON TOU\S A)SPLA/GXNOUS, KAQ' O(/ FAMEN MH\ E)/XEIN TINA\S E)GKE/FALON H)\ E)/XEIN, OU(/-TWS H(MA=S U(PONOOU=NTES LE/GEIN KAI\ MH\ E)/XEIN KARDI/AN TINA\S KAI\ E)/XEIN KATA\ TA\ PROEIRHME/NA, TW=N ME\N A)SPLA/GXNWN TA/XA LAMBANOME/NWN KATA\ TO\ MHDE\N E)/XEIN E)/NDON SUNALGOU=N KATA\ TA\ E)NANTI/A KAI\ A)PO\ TH=S KARDI/AS OU(/TWS AU)TW=N KOINO/-TERON LEGOME/NWN, TOU= D' E)GKEFA/LOU LAMBANOME/NOU H)/TOI KATA\ TA\ AU)TA/, O(MOI/OU TINO\S O)/NTOS, H)\ DIA\ TO\ KAI\ TOU=TON E)/XEIN TINA\ KURI/AN TOI=S SPLA/GXNOIS O(MOI/AN. *KATA\ TOIAU/THN DE/ MOI DOKOU=SI MA/LISTA FORA\N KAI\ OI( TIMWRHTIKW/TERON PRO/S TINAS FERO/MENOI O(RMA=N E)PI\ TO\ TAU/THN E)KSPA/SAI, KAQ' H(\N FORA\N E)PITEI/NONTES KAI\ PRO\S TA\ LOIPA\ TW=N SPLA/GXNWN O(MOEIDW=S FE/RONTAI .... *KAI\ TA\ TW=N O)RGIZOME/NWN DE\ PA/QH PERI\ TO\N QW/RAKA FAI/NETAI GIGNO/MENA KAI\ TA\ TW=N E)RW/N-TWN, W(/STE KAI\ TH\N E)PIQUMI/AN MA/LISTA GI/GNESQAI PERI\ TOU/TOUS TOU\S TO/-POUS .... *EU)= MA/LA DE\ PARISTA=SI TO\ LEGO/MENON, W(S E)/FHN, KAI\ AI( E)N AU(TOI=S GIGNO/MENAI MELE/TAI KAI\ R(H/SEWN KAI\ TW=N PARAPLHSI/WN. E)N W(=| GA\R TAU=TA PA/NTA SUNTELEI=TAI, PA/NTWS EU)/LOGON E)N E)KEI/NW| KAI\ TH\N TOU= LO/GOU DIE/CODON GI/GNESQAI, KAI\ LE/GEIN H(MA=S KAI\ DIANOEI=SQAI KAT' E)KEI=NO: A)PO\ GA\R TH=S DIA-NOI/AS DEI= LE/GEIN KAI\ E)N E(AUTW=| LE/GEIN [H)\ FWNH\N DIECIE/NAI] KAI\ DIANOEI=SQAI KAI\ E)N E(AUTOI=S FWNH\N DIECIE/NAI KAI\ E)KTO\S E)KPE/MPEIN. *OI)KEI/WS DE\ TOU/TW| KAI\ OI( STENAGMOI\ E)NTEU=QEN PROI/+ENTAI .... *(O DE\ POIHTH\S PLEONA/ZWN E)N TOU/TOIS DIA\ POLLW=N PARI/STHSIN O(/TI KAI\ TO\ LOGISTIKO\N KAI\ TO\ QUMOEIDE\S PERI\ TOU=TO/N E)STI TO\N TO/PON, SUNA/PTWN EI)S TAU)TO\N KAI\ TO\ E)PIQUMHTIKO/N, KAQA/PER KAI\ E)/DEI POIH=SAI. *(/OTI ME\N GA\R TO\ LOGISTIKO/N E)STIN E)NTAU=QA, DIA\ TOU/TWN E)MFAI/NETAI: @1 @*)/ALLO D' E)NI\ STH/QESSI NO/OS KAI\ MH=TIS A)MU/MWN. @*)ALL' E)MO\N OU)/POTE QUMO\N E)NI\ STH/QESSIN E)/PEIQEN. [1&10plures versus allatos fuisse testatur Galenus$10]1 .......... @*(/OTI DE\ KAI\ TO\ E)PIQUMHTIKO\N E)NTAU=QA DIA\ TOU/TWN E)MFAI/NEI: @*OU) GA\R PW/POT' E)/M' W(=DE QEA=S E)/ROS OU)DE\ GUNAIKO\S @*QUMO\N E)NI\ STH/QESSI PERIPROXUQEI\S E)DA/MASSE. ......................... @*(/OTI DE\ KAI\ TO\ QUMOEIDE\S E)NTAU=QA/ POU/ E)STI TA\ TOIAU=TA E)MFAI/NEI PLEI/-ONA O)/NTA: @*(/HRH| D' OU)K E)/XADE STH=QOS XO/LON, A)LLA\ PROSHU/DA. KAI\ E)/TI: @*KAI\ XO/LON, O(/ST' E)FE/HKE POLU/FRONA/ PER XALEPH=NAI. @*(/OS TE POLU\ GLUKI/WN ME/LITOS KATALEIBOME/NOIO @*)ANDRW=N E)N STH/QESSIN A)E/CETAI, H)U/+TE KAPNO/S. [1&10sequebatur infinita fere versuum copia ex Homero, Hesiodo, Stesichoro, &10Empedocle, Orphicis, Tyrtaeo, tragoediae denique poe%28tis$10]1. @*TAUTI\ ME\N FH/SOUSIN A)DOLESXI/AN EI)=NAI GRAW/DH, TUXO\N DE\ KAI\ GRAMMA/TWN DIDASKA/LOU BOULOME/NOU STI/XOUS O(/TI PLEI/STOUS U(PO\ TO\ AU)TO\ DIANO/HMA TA/CAI. ......................... *)AKOU/W DE/ TINAS LE/GEIN PARAMUQOUME/NOUS PRO\S TO\ E)N TH=| KEFALH=| EI)=NAI TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N TH=S YUXH=S ME/ROS. TO\ GA\R TH\N *)AQHNA=N, MH=TIN OU)=SAN KAI\ OI(=ON FRO/NHSIN, E)K TH=S KEFALH=S GENE/SQAI TOU= *DIO\S SU/MBOLO/N FASIN EI)=NAI TOU= TAU/TH| TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N EI)=NAI: OU) GA\R A)/LLWS A)\N E)N TH=| KEFALH=| GENE/SQAI MH=TIN KAI\ FRO/NHSIN, EI) MH\ TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N E)N TAU/TH| E)STI/, PIQANOU= ME/N TINOS E)XO/-MENOI, DIAMARTA/NONTES D' W(S E)MOI\ FAI/NETAI KAI\ A)GNOOU=NTES TA\ PERI\ TOU/-TWN I(STOROU/MENA, PERI\ W(=N OU) XEI=RO/N E)STIN E)PI\ PLE/ON EI)PEI=N TOI=S E)NESTW=SI ZHTH/MASI. FASI\ D' OI( ME\N OU(/TWS A(PLW=S, E)K TH=S TOU= *DIO\S KEFALH=S AU)TH\N GENE/SQAI, OU)DE\ PROSISTOROU=NTES TO\ PW=S H)\ KATA\ TI/NA LO/GON: O( DE\ *(HSI/ODOS E)PI\ PLE/ON LE/GEI E)/N TISI, TINW=N ME\N E)N TH=| QEOGONI/A| GRAFO/NTWN TH\N GE/NESIN AU)TH=S [2W(S]2 PRW=TON ME\N *MH/TIDI SUGGENOME/NOU TOU= *DIO/S, DEU/TERON DE\ *QE/MIDI, TINW=N DE\ E)N E(TE/ROIS A)/LLWS GRAFO/NTWN TH\N GE/NESIN AU)TH=S, W(S A)/RA, GENOME/NHS E)/RIDOS TW=| *DII\+ KAI\ TH=| *(/HRA|, GENNH/SEIEN H( ME\N *(/HRA DI' E(AUTH=S TO\N *(/HFAISTON, O( DE\ *ZEU\S TH\N *)AQHNA=N E)K TH=S *MH/TIDOS KATAPOQEI/SHS U(P' AU)TOU=. H( ME\N GA\R EI)S AU)TO\N KATA/POSIS TH=S *MH/TIDOS KAI\ E)/NDON TOU= *DIO\S TH=S *)AQHNA=S GE/-NESIS KAT' A)MFOTE/ROUS TOU\S LO/GOUS E)STI/N. DIAFE/ROUSI D' E)N TW=| PW=S TAU=TA SUNETELE/SQH, PRO\S TO\N E)NESTW=TA LO/GON OU)QENO\S O)/NTOS TOIOU/TOU. TO\ GA\R KOI-NO\N E)N AU)TOI=S U(PA/RXON MO/NON XRH/SIMO/N E)STI PRO\S TA\ E)NESTW=TA: LE/GETAI D' E)N ME\N TH=| QEOGONI/A| OU(/TW: [1&10sequuntur Hesiodi theog. vv. 886_90 v. 900$10]1 EI)=TA PROELQW/N FHSIN OU(/TWS: [1&10sequuntur vv. 924_26$10]1 STH/QESI GA\R AU)TOI=S E)/NDON EU)/DHLON O(/TI A)PE/QETO TH\N *MH=TIN, KAI\ OU(/TWS FHSI\N AU)TH\N GENNH=SAI KATA\ TH\N KEFALH/N. E)N DE\ TOI=S META\ TAU=TA PLEI/W DIELHLUQO/TOS AU)TOU= TOIAU=T' E)STI\ TA\ LEGO/MENA [1&10sequuntur undeviginti versus Hesiodei$10]1. *TA\ ME\N OU)=N PERI\ TH=S *)AQHNA=S LEGO/MENA TOIAU=TA/ E)STIN, A)/LLOU TINO\S SUMBO/LOU POIOU=NT' @1 E)/MFASIN. PRW=TON ME\N GA\R H( *MH=TIS LE/GETAI [2KATAPOQH=NAI]2 W(SANEI/ TIS FRO/-NHSIS KAI\ PERI\ TW=N KATA\ TO\N BI/ON TE/XNH, H(=| TA\S TE/XNAS DEI= KATAPI/NESQAI KAI\ E)NAPOTI/QESQAI_KAQ' O(\N LO/GON KAI\ TA\ LEGO/MENA/ TINAS KATAPI/NEIN FAME/N _DIA\ DE\ TH\N KATA/POSIN SUNHKOLOUQHKO/TWS LE/GETAI KAI\ EI)S TH\N KOILI/AN A)POTI/QESQAI. EI)=TA META\ TAU=TA TH\N KATAPOQEI=SAN TOIAU/THN TE/XNHN TI/KTEIN EU)/LOGON E)N AU)TW=| PARAPLHSI/AN TH=S TIKTOU/SHS MHTRO/S. *PRO\S DE\ TOU/TOIS TA\ U(PO\ TW=N E)PISTHMW=N TIKTO/MENA E)NTO/S, PW=S A)\N E)KPOREU/OITO KAI\ DIA\ TI/NOS MA/-LISTA, PA/RESTI SKOPEI=N. FANERO\N GA\R O(/TI LO/GW| E)KFE/RETAI DIA\ TOU= STO/MATOS KATA\ TH\N KEFALH/N, E)C I)/SOU OU(/TWS TH=S KEFALH=S LEGOME/NHS, O(\N TRO/PON PRO-BA/TOU KEFALH\ LE/GETAI KAI\ TA\S KEFALA\S A)FAIROU=SI/ TINWN: KAQ' O(\N LO/GON PARA-GINO/MENON KAI\ E)K TH=S KORUFH=S LE/GETAI GENE/SQAI, TW=N TOIOU/TWN PARALLAGW=N KATA\ [2TA\]2 SU/MBOLA GIGNOME/NWN PLEIO/NWN. *KAI\ XWRI\S DE\ TH=S I(STORI/AS TAU/THS, A)P' AU)TOU= MO/NON TOU= GENE/SQAI TAU/THN KATA\ TH\N KEFALH/N, TA\ PARAPLH/SIA A)/N TIS LE/GOI: OU) GA\R E)N TH=| KEFALH=| FASIN AU)TH\N GENE/SQAI, EI) MH/ TINES DIA-STRE/FONTES H)\ PARALLA/TTONTES TO\N LO/GON, [2A)LL']2 E)CELQEI=N TAU/TH| GINOME/NHN A)/LLWS % E)/ROINTO %. W(/STE MA=LLON KAI\ TOU=TO SU/MBOLON PRO\S TO\ H(ME/TERON EI)=NAI, W(S E)/FHN: TA\ GA\R E)NTO\S GIGNO/MENA TEXNIKA\ KATA\ TH\N KEFALH\N E)CIO/NTA MA/-LISTA A)POSHMAI/NEI TO\N PROEIRHME/NON LO/GON. @1 @[&Plutarchus] de fato cp. 11 p. 574d. capita Chrysippeae de &fato disputationis enumerat%10$ KATA\ DE\ TO\N E)NANTI/ON [1&scil.$ LO/GON]1 MA/-LISTA ME\N [KAI\] <20PRW=TON>20 EI)=NAI DO/CEIE TO\ MHDE\N A)NAITI/WS GI/GNESQAI, A)LLA\ KATA\ PROHGOUME/NAS AI)TI/AS: <20DEU/TERON>20 DE\ TO\ FU/SEI DIOIKEI=SQAI TO/NDE TO\N KO/SMON, SU/MPNOUN KAI\ SUMPAQH= AU)TO\N AU(TW=| O)/NTA: <20TRI/TON>20 DE\ [TA\ PRO\S TOU/TOIS MARTU/RIA MA=LLON E)/OIKEN EI)=NAI] MANTIKH\ ME\N A(/PASIN A)NQRW/POIS EU)DO/KIMOS W(S A)LHQW=S [2SU\N]2 QEW=| U(PA/RXOUSA, H( DE\ TW=N SOFW=N PRO\S TA\ SUMBAI/NONTA EU)ARE/STHSIS, W(S PA/NTA KATA\ MOI=RAN GIGNO/-MENA [DEUTE/RA] <20TRI/TON>20 [1&immo$ TE/TARTON]1 DE\ TO\ POLUQRU/LHTON TOU=TO, O(/TI PA=N A)CI/WMA H)\ A)LHQE/S E)STIN H)\ YEUDE/S. @&Stobaeus eclog I 79, 1 W$8 <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 DU/NAMIN PNEUMATI-KH\N TH\N OU)SI/AN TH=S EI(MARME/NHS, TA/CEI TOU= PANTO\S DIOIKHTIKH/N. *TOU=TO ME\N OU)=N <20E)N TW=| DEUTE/RW| *PERI\ *KO/SMOU. *)EN DE\ TW=| DEUTE/RW| *PERI\ *(/ORWN KAI\ E)N TOI=S *PERI\ *TH=S *EI(MARME/NHS>20 KAI\ E)N A)/LLOIS SPORA/DHN POLUTRO/PWS A)POFAI/NETAI LE/GWN: "1<20*EI(MARME/NH E)STI\N O( TOU= KO/SMOU LO/GOS"2 H)\ "1LO/GOS TW=N E)N TW=| KO/SMW| PRONOI/A| DIOIKOUME/NWN"2 H)\ "1LO/GOS KAQ' O(\N TA\ ME\N GEGONO/TA GE/GONE, TA\ DE\ GINO/MENA GI/NE-TAI, TA\ DE\ GENHSO/MENA GENH/SETAI>20."2 *METALAMBA/NEI D' A)NTI\ TOU= LO/-GOU TH\N A)LH/QEIAN, TH\N AI)TI/AN, TH\N FU/SIN, TH\N A)NA/GKHN, PROSTIQEI\S KAI\ E(TE/RAS O)NOMASI/AS, W(S E)PI\ TH=S AU)TH=S OU)SI/AS TASSOME/NAS KAQ' E(TE/RAS KAI\ E(TE/RAS E)PIBOLA/S. *MOI/RAS DE\ KALEI=SQAI A)PO\ TOU= KAT' AU)TA\S DIAMERISMOU=, *KLWQW\ KAI\ *LA/XESIN KAI\ *)/ATROPON. *LA/XESIN ME/N, O(/TI O(\N KLH=RON LELO/G-XASIN E(/KASTOI KATA\ TO\ DI/KAION A)PONE/METAI: *)/ATROPON DE\ O(/TI A)META/QETOS KAI\ A)META/BLHTO/S E)STIN O( KAQ' E(/KASTA DIORISMO\S E)C A)I+DI/WN XRO/NWN: *KLWQW\ DE\ O(/TI H( KATA\ TH\N EI(MARME/NHN DIANE/MHSIS KAI\ TA\ GENNW/MENA TOI=S KLW- @1QOME/NOIS PARAPLHSI/WS DIECA/GETAI, KATA\ TH\N E)TUMOLOGIKH\N E)CH/GHSIN TW=N O)NOMA/TWN A(/MA KAI\ TW=N PRAGMA/TWN SUMPARISTAME/NWN EU)XRH/STWS. &cf. Plut. &de plac. I 28 et Theodoret. VI 14. &@Diogenianus apud Eusebium praep. ev. VI p. 263c.$ *TEKMH/RION DE\ KAI\ A)/LLO I)SXURO\N FE/REIN <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 OI)/ETAI TH=S E)N A(/PASIN EI(MAR-ME/NHS TH\N QE/SIN TW=N TOIOU/TWN O)NOMA/TWN. TH/N TE GA\R PEPRWME/NHN PEPERASME/NHN TINA/ FHSIN EI)=NAI KAI\ SUNTETELESME/NHN DIOI/KHSIN, TH/N TE EI(MARME/NHN EI)ROME/NHN TINA\ EI)/TE E)K QEOU= BOULH/SEWS EI)/TE E)C H(=S DH/POTE AI)TI/AS. A)LLA\ KAI\ TA\S *MOI/RAS W)NOMA/SQAI A)PO\ TOU= MEMERI/SQAI KAI\ KATANENEMH=SQAI/ TINA H(MW=N E(KA/STW|. OU(/TW DE\ KAI\ TO\ XREW\N EI)RH=SQAI TO\ E)PIBA/LLON KAI\ KAQH=KON KATA\ TH\N EI(MARME/NHN. TO/N TE A)RIQMO\N TW=N *MOIRW=N TOU\S TREI=S U(POBA/LLEI XRO/NOUS E)N OI(=S KUKLEI=TAI TA\ PA/NTA KAI\ DI' W(=N E)PITELEI=TAI. KAI\ *LA/XESIN ME\N KEKLH=SQAI PARA\ TO\ LAGXA/NEIN E(KA/STW| TO\ PEPRWME/NON, *)/ATROPON DE\ KATA\ TO\ A)/TREPTON KAI\ A)META/QE-TON TOU= MERISMOU=, *KLWQW\ DE\ PARA\ TO\ SUGKEKLW=SQAI KAI\ SUNEI/RESQAI TA\ PA/NTA, KAI\ MI/AN AU)TW=N TETAGME/NHN TINA\ EI)=NAI DIE/CODON. TAU=TA GA\R KAI\ TA\ TOU/TOIS PARAPLH/SIA FLUARW=N A)PODEIKNU/NAI TH\N E)N A(/PASIN A)NA/GKHN NOMI/ZEI. @&10Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 149.$10 KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN DE/ FASI TA\ PA/NTA GI/NESQAI <20*XRU/SIPPOS E)N TOI=S PERI\ EI(MARME/NHS>20 KAI\ *POSEIDW/NIOS E)N DEU-TE/RW| PERI\ EI(MARME/NHS KAI\ *ZH/NWN, *BO/HQOS DE\ E)N PRW/TW| PERI\ EI(MARME/NHS. <20E)/STI DE\ EI(MARME/NH AI)TI/A TW=N O)/NTWN EI)ROME/NH H)\ LO/GOS KAQ' O(\N O( KO/SMOS DIECA/GETAI>20. @&Theodoretus VI 14.$ *KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 DE\ O( *STWI+KO\S MHDE\N DIAFE/REIN EI)=PE TOU= EI(MARME/NOU TO\ KATHNAGKASME/NON, <20EI)=NAI DE\ TH\N EI(MARME/NHN KI/NHSIN A)I/+DION SUNEXH= KAI\ TETAGME/NHN>20. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. I 28, 4.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 EI(RMO\N AI)TIW=N, TOUTE/STI TA/CIN KAI\ E)PISU/NDESIN A)PARA/BATON [1&10sc.$10 TH\N EI(MARME/NHN]1. @&10Nemesius de nat. hom. cp. 37 p. 299.$10 <20EI) DE\ H( EI(MARME/NH @1 EI(RMO/S TIS OU)=SA AI)TIW=N A)PARA/BATOS>20: OU(/TW GA\R AU)TH\N OI( <20*STWI+KOI\>20 O(RI/ZONTAI: [1TOUTE/STI TA/CIN KAI\ E)PISU/NDESIN A)PARA/LLAKTON]1 OU) KATA\ TO\ SUM-FE/RON, A)LLA\ KATA\ TH\N OI)KEI/AN KI/NHSIN KAI\ A)NA/GKHN E)PA/GEI TA\ TE/LH. @&10Servius ad Verg. Aen. III 376. definitio fati secundum Tullium, &10qui ait%10 <21Fatum est conexio rerum per aeternitatem se invicem &10tenens, quae suo ordine et lege variatur, ita tamen, ut ipsa &10varietas habeat aeternitatem>21. &10@Alexander de anima libri mantissa p. 185, 1 Bruns.$10 A)LLA\ MH\N O(MOLOGEI=TAI PA/NTA TA\ KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN GIGNO/MENA KATA\ TA/CIN KAI\ A)KOLOUQI/AN GI/GNESQAI/ TINA KAI/ TI E)FECH=S E)/XEIN E)N AU(TOI=S. __<20EI(RMO\N GOU=N AI)TI/WN AU)TH/N FASIN EI)=NAI>20. @&10Cicero de divinatione I 55, 125. Fatum autem id appello, quod &10Graeci$10 EI(MARME/NHN, &10id est <21ordinem seriemque causarum>21, cum causa &10causae nexa rem ex se gignat. Ea est ex omni aeternitate fluens veritas &10sempiterna. Quod quum ita sit, nihil est factum, quod non futurum fuerit%10 &10eodemque modo nihil est futurum, cuius non causas id ipsum efficientes &10natura contineat. 126. Ex quo intelligitur ut fatum sit non id quod &10superstitiose, sed id quod physice dicitur, <21causa aeterna rerum, cur &10et ea quae praeterierunt facta sint, et quae instant fiant, et &10quae sequentur futura sint>21. @&10Cicero de nat. deor. III 14. praesertim cum vos iidem fato &10fieri dicatis omnia, quod autem semper ex omni aeternitate verum fuerit, &10id esse fatum. @&10Servius ad Verg. Aeneid. I 257. et simul per transitum <21Stoi-&10corum>21 dogma ostendit, nulla ratione posse fata mutari. @&10Commenta Lucani Lib. II 306 p. 69 Us. et hoc secundum &10<21Stoicos>21 qui omnia dicunt fato regi et semel constituta nec a numinibus &10posse mutari. @&Diogenianus apud Eusebium praep. evang. VI p. 261c.$ [PRW=TA DH\ OU)=N SOI PARANAGNW/SOMAI A)PO\ TW=N *DIOGENIANOU= TA\ PERI\ EI(MARME/-NHS, W(=DE/ PWS <20TW=| *XRUSI/PPW|>20 A)NTEIRHME/NA:] *)/ACION DE\ E)PI\ TOU/TOIS PA=SI PARAQE/SQAI KAI\ TA\ DOKOU=NTA <20*XRUSI/PPW| TW=| *STWI+KW=|>20 PERI\ TOU= LO/GOU TOU=DE. OU(=TOS GA\R <20E)N TW=| PRW/TW| PERI\ EI(MARME/NHS>20 BIBLI/W| BOULO/MENOS DEIKNU/NAI "1TO\ DH\ PA/NQ' U(PO\ TH=S A)NA/GKHS KAI\ TH=S EI(MAR-ME/NHS KATEILH=FQAI"2 MARTURI/OIS A)/LLOIS TE/ TISI XRH=TAI KAI\ TOI=S OU(TWSI\ PAR' *(OMH/RW| TW=| POIHTH=| LEGOME/NOIS: [1&Il.$ *Y& 78.79$]1 @A)LL' E)ME\ ME\N KH\R @A)MFE/XANE STUGERH/, H(/PER LA/XE GEINO/MENO/N PER. KAI\: [1&Il.$ *U& 127.128$]1 @U(/STERON AU)=TE TA\ PEI/SETAI A(/SSA OI( AI)=SA @GEINOME/NW| E)PE/NHSE LI/NW|, O(/TE MIN TE/KE MH/THR: @1 KAI\: [1&Il.$ *Z& 488$]1 @*MOI=RAN D' OU)/TINA/ FHMI PEFUGME/NON E)/MMENAI A)NDRW=N. @&Cf. p. 262d.$ OU) MH\N OU)D' E)KEI=NO SUNIDEI=N H)DUNH/QH, TO\ MHDAMW=S TO\N *(/OMHRON MHD' E)N E)KEI/NOIS TOI=S E)/PESI [1&supra adscriptis$]1 SUMMARTU-REI=N AU)TOU= TW=| DO/GMATI. OU) GA\R TO\ PA/NTA GI/NESQAI KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN, A)LLA\ MA=LLON TO\ TINA\ KAT' E)KEI/NHN SUMBAI/NEIN E)C AU)TW=N U(POBA/LLWN EU(REQH/SETAI. @&p. 263b.$ W(/ST' OU)X O(/PWS SU/MYHFON A)\N E)/XOI TO\N *(/OMHRON O( *XRU/-SIPPOS E)N TW=| PA/NTA KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN GI/NESQAI NOMI/ZEIN, A)LLA\ KAI\ E)NANTIOU/MENON. @&10Iustinus apol. II 7.$10 OI( *STWI+KOI\ KAQ' EI(MARME/NHS A)NA/GKHN PA/NTA GI/NESQAI A)PEFH/NANTO. @&10ibidem paulo post%10$10 GENNHTOU= DE\ PANTO\S H(/DE H( FU/SIS, KAKI/AS KAI\ A)RE-TH=S DEKTIKO\N EI)=NAI: OU) GA\R A)\N H)=N E)PAINETO\N OU)DE\N AU)TW=N, EI) OU)K A)\N E)P' A)MFO/TERA TRE/PESQAI KAI\ DU/NAMIN EI)=XE. *DEIKNU/OUSI DE\ TOU=TO KAI\ OI( PANTAXOU= KATA\ LO/GON TO\N O)RQO\N NOMOQETH/SANTES KAI\ FILOSOFH/SANTES A)/NQRWPOI E)K TOU= U(PAGOREU/EIN TA/DE ME\N PRA/TTEIN, TW=NDE DE\ A)PE/XESQAI. *KAI\ OI( *STWI+KOI\ FILO/-SOFOI E)N TW=| PERI\ H)QW=N LO/GW| TA\ AU)TA\ TIMW=SI KARTERW=S, W(S DHLOU=SQAI E)N TW=| PERI\ A)RXW=N KAI\ A)SWMA/TWN LO/GW| OU)K EU)ODOU=N AU)TOU/S. <20*EI)/TE GA\R KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN FH/SOUSI TA\ GINO/MENA PRO\S A)NQRW/PWN GI/GNESQAI>20 H)\ MHDE\N EI)=NAI QEO\N PARA\ TREPO/MENA KAI\ A)LLOIOU/MENA KAI\ A)NALUO/MENA EI)S TA\ AU)TA\ A)EI/, KAI\ FQARTW=N MO/NWN FANH/SONTAI KATA/LHYIN E)SXHKE/NAI KAI\ AU)TO\N TO\N QEO\N DIA/ TE TW=N MERW=N KAI\ DIA\ TOU= O(/LOU E)N PA/SH| KAKI/A| GINO/MENON, H)\ MHDE\N EI)=NAI KAKI/AN MHD' A)RETH/N, O(/PER KAI\ PARA\ PA=SAN SW/FRONA E)/NNOIAN KAI\ LO/GON KAI\ NOU=N E)STI/. @&Fulgentius Mytholog. prooem. in fine%10&3 tamen nequaquam &3apud humanos sensus nisi fortuitis compulsationibus moti nascuntur &3errores, ut etiam <21Chrysippus de fato>21 scribens ait%10 <21Compulsationi-&3bus lubricis volvuntur incursus>21. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 31.$10 PW=S DE\ SUNW|DA\ A)LLH/LOIS TO\ O(MOU= ME\N <20QEO\N LE/GEIN TH\N EI(MARME/NHN>20 KAI\ XRH=SQAI TOI=S OU)=SI/ TE KAI\ GINOME/NOIS E)N TW=| KO/SMW| E)PI\ SWTHRI/A| AU)TOU= TE TOU= KO/SMOU KAI\ TH=S TW=N E)N AU)TW=| TA/CEWS, O(MOU= DE\ TOIAU=TA PERI\ AU)TH=S LE/GEIN. @&10Proclus in Hesiod. Op. et Dies v. 105.$10 OU) DUNATO/N E)STI <20TO\N TOU= *DIO\S NOU=N E)KKLI=NAI, O(/ E)STI TH\N EI(MARME/NHN>20: TAU/THN GA\R OI( *STWI+KOI\ *DIO\S NOU=N PROSHGOREU/KASI. @&10Scholia Hesiod. Theog. v. 411.$10 "1*(EKA/THN TE/KE."2 __OU(/TW DE\ LE/GETAI DIA\ TO\ E(KA/STOU PRONOEI=SQAI. TW=N GA\R E)N GH=| KAI\ E)N QALA/SSH| PA/N-TWN E)/XEI TH\N E)COUSI/AN H( EI(MARME/NH. W(S GA\R QEA=| PA/NTES EU)/XONTAI TH=| *MOI/RA|. @&10Scholia in Hom. Iliad.$10 *Q&10 69.$10 *OI( <20*STWI+KOI\>20 DE/ FASIN W(S TAU)-TO\N EI(MARME/NH KAI\ *ZEU/S. @&10Augustinus de civ. dei V 8. Qui vero non astrorum constitu- @1&10tionem, sicuti est cum quidque concipitur vel nascitur vel inchoatur, sed &10omnium conexionem seriemque causarum, qua fit omne quod fit, fati no-&10mine appellant%10 non multum cum eis de verbi controversia laborandum &10atque certandum est, quandoquidem <21ipsum causarum ordinem et &10quandam conexionem Dei summi tribuunt voluntati et potestati>21, &10qui optime et veracissime creditur et cuncta scire, antequam fiant, et &10nihil inordinatum relinquere%10 a quo sunt omnes potestates, quamvis non &10sint ab illo omnium voluntates. Ipsam itaque praecipue Dei summi vo-&10luntatem, cuius potestas insuperabiliter per cuncta porrigitur, eos appellare &10fatum, sic probatur. @&Chalcidius in Timaeum cp. 144.&3 Itaque nonnulli putant, prae-&3sumi differentiam providentiae fatique cum reapse una sit. quippe pro-&3videntiam dei fore voluntatem. <21voluntatem porro eius seriem esse &3causarum. et ex eo quidem, quia voluntas, providentia est, &3porro quia eadem series causarum est, fatum cognominatam>21. &3Ex quo fieri, ut quae secundum fatum sunt etiam ex providentia sint. &3eodemque modo quae secundum providentiam ex fato, ut putat <21Chry-&3sippus>21. alii vero, quae quidem ex providentiae auctoritate, fataliter quo-&3que provenire, nec tamen quae fataliter ex providentia, ut <21Cleanthes>21. @&10Plotinus Ennead. 1II lib. I 4 [1Vol. I p. 164 Mu+.$]1. A)LL' A)=RA MI/A TIS YUXH\ DIA\ PANTO\S DIH/KOUSA PERAI/NEI TA\ PA/NTA, E(KA/STOU TAU/TH| KINOUME/NOU, W(S ME/ROUS, H(=| TO\ O(/LON A)/GEI; FEROME/NWN DE\ E)KEI=QEN TW=N AI)TI/WN A)KOLOUQEI=N A)NA/GKH TH\N [TOU] TW=N E)FECH=S SUNE/XEIAN KAI\ SUMPLOKH\N [2KAI\]2 EI(MARME/NHN: OI(=ON EI), FUTOU= E)K R(I/ZHS TH\N A)RXH\N E)/XONTOS, TH\N E)NTEU=QEN E)PI\ PA/NTA DIH/KOUSAN AU)TOU= TA\ ME/RH POI/HSI/N TE KAI\ PEI=SIN KAI\ PRO\S A)/LLHLA SUMPLOKH\N DIOI/KHSIN MI/AN KAI\ OI(=ON EI(MARME/NHN TOU= FUTOU= TIS EI)=NAI LE/GOI. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 47 p. 1056d.$ *OU)DE\ GA\R A(/PAC H)\ DI/S, A)LLA\ PANTAXOU=, MA=LLON D' <20E)N PA=SI TOI=S *FUSIKOI=S GE/-GRAFE TAI=S ME\N KATA\ ME/ROS FU/SESI KAI\ KINH/SESIN E)NSTH/MATA POLLA\ GI/NESQAI KAI\ KWLU/MATA, TH=| DE\ TW=N O(/LWN MHDE/N>20 @&10Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 9 p. 175, 7 Bruns.$10 *KAI/TOI PW=S OU)K A)/TOPA KAI\ PARA\ TA\ E)NARGH= KAI\ ME/XRI TOU/TOU TH\N A)NA/GKHN PROELHLUQE/NAI LE/GEIN, W(S MH/TE KINHQH=NAI/ TINA DU/NASQAI KI/NHSI/N TINA, MH/TE KINH=SAI/ TI TW=N AU(TOU= MERW=N, H(\N KI/NHSIN KAI\ MH\ KINEI=SQAI TO/TE OI(=O/N TE H)=N, A)LLA\ TH\N TU-XOU=SAN TOU= TRAXH/LOU PERISTROFH\N KAI\ TH\N DAKTU/LOU TINO\S E)/KTASIN KAI\ TO\ E)PA=RAI TA\ BLE/FARA H)/ TI TW=N TOIOU/TWN PROHGOUME/NAIS TISI\N AI)TI/AIS E(PO/MENON A)/LLWS U(F' H(MW=N MH\ DU/NASQAI GI/NESQAI/ POTE &10etc. @1 @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 34 p. 1049f.$8 *PRW=TON GA\R <20E)N TW=| PRW/TW| PERI\ *FU/SEWS>20 TO\ A)I/+DION TH=S KINH/SEWS KUKEW=NI PAREIKA/SAS, A)/LLA A)/LLWS STRE/FONTI KAI\ TARA/SSONTI TW=N GINOME/NWN, TAU=T' EI)/RHKEN: "1<20*OU(/TW DE\ TH=S TW=N O(/LWN OI)KONOMI/AS PROAGOU/SHS, A)NAGKAI=ON KATA\ TAU/THN, W(S A)/N POT' E)/XWMEN, E)/XEIN H(MA=S, EI)/TE PARA\ FU/SIN TH\N I)DI/AN NOSOU=NTES, EI)/TE PEPHRWME/NOI, EI)/TE GRAMMATIKOI\ GE-GONO/TES H)\ MOUSIKOI/."2 *KAI\ PA/LIN MET' O)LI/GON: "1*KATA\ TOU=TON DE\ TO\N LO/GON TA\ PARAPLH/SIA E)ROU=MEN KAI\ PERI\ TH=S A)RETH=S H(MW=N KAI\ PERI\ TH=S KAKI/AS, KAI\ TO\ O(/LON TW=N TEXNW=N KAI\ TW=N A)TEXNIW=N, W(S E)/FHN."2 *KAI\ MET' O)LI/GON>20 A(/PASAN A)NAIRW=N A)MFIBOLI/AN: "1<20*OU)QE\N GA\R E)/STIN A)/LLWS TW=N KATA\ ME/ROS GENE/SQAI OU)DE\ TOU)LA/XISTON, H)\ KATA\ TH\N KOINH\N FU/SIN KAI\ KATA\ TO\N E)KEI/NHS LO/GON>20."2 *(/OTI D' H( KOINH\ FU/SIS KAI\ O( KOINO\S TH=S FU/SEWS LO/GOS EI(MARME/NH KAI\ PRO/NOIA KAI\ *ZEU/S E)STIN, OU)DE\ TOU\S A)NTI/PODAS LE/LHQE: PANTAXOU= GA\R TAU=TA QRU-LEI=TAI U(P' AU)TW=N: KAI\ TO\ [1*A& 5$8]1 *DIO\S D' E)TELEI/ETO BOULH/, TO\N *(/OMHRON EI)RHKE/NAI FHSI\N O)RQW=S, E)PI\ TH\N EI(MARME/NHN A)NAFE/RONTA KAI\ TH\N TW=N O(/LWN FU/SIN, KAQ' H(\N PA/NTA DIOIKEI=TAI. @&p. 1050c.$8 O( DE\ *XRU/SIPPOS A)NAPEPTAME/NHN PAR)R(HSI/AN AU)TH=| [1&scil.$8 TH=| KAKI/A|]1 DI/DWSIN, W(S OU) MO/NON E)C A)NA/GKHS OU)DE\ KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN, A)LLA\ KAI\ KATA\ LO/GON QEOU= KAI\ KATA\ FU/SIN PEPOIHME/NH| TH\N A)RI/STHN. *)/ETI DE\ KAI\ TAU=TA O(RA=TAI KATA\ LE/CIN OU(/TWS E)/XONTA: "1<20*TH=S GA\R KOINH=S FU/SEWS EI)S PA/NTA DIATEINOU/SHS, DEH/SEI PA=N TO\ O(PWSOU=N GINO/MENON E)N TW=| O(/LW| KAI\ TW=N MORI/WN O(TW|OU=N KAT' E)KEI/NHN GENE/SQAI KAI\ TO\N E)KEI/NHS LO/GON KATA\ TO\ E(CH=S A)KWLU/TWS: DIA\ TO\ MH/T' E)/CW-QEN EI)=NAI TO\ E)NSTHSO/MENON TH=| OI)KONOMI/A|, MH/TE TW=N MERW=N MH-DE\N E)/XEIN O(/PWS KINHQH/SETAI H)\ SXH/SEI A)/LLWS [2H)\]2 KATA\ TH\N KOI-NH\N FU/SIN>20."2 [1*TI/NES OU)=N AI( TW=N MERW=N SXE/SEIS EI)SI\ KAI\ KINH/SEIS; DH=LON ME\N O(/TI SXE/SEIS AI( KAKI/AI KAI\ TA\ NOSH/MATA, FILARGURI/AI, FILHDONI/AI, FILODOCI/AI, DEILI/AI, A)DIKI/AI: KINH/SEIS DE\ MOIXEI=AI, KLOPAI/, PRODOSI/AI, A)N-DROFONI/AI, PATROKTONI/AI. *TOU/TWN OI)/ETAI *XRU/SIPPOS OU)/TE MIKRO\N OU)/TE ME/GA PARA\ TO\N TOU= *DIO\S LO/GON EI)=NAI KAI\ NO/MON KAI\ DI/KHN KAI\ PRO/-NOIAN &etc.]1. &@Plut. de comm. not. cp. 34 p. 1076e.$8 EI) DE/, W(/S FHSI *XRU/SIPPOS, OU)DE\ TOU)LA/XISTO/N E)STI TW=N MERW=N E)/XEIN A)/LLWS. A)LL' H)\ KATA\ TH\N TOU= *DIO\S BOU/LHSIN, A)LLA\ PA=N ME\N E)/MYUXON OU(/TWS I)/SXESQAI KAI\ OU(/TW KINEI=-SQAI PE/FUKEN, W(S E)KEI=NOS A)/GEI KA)KEI=NOS E)PISTRE/FEI KAI\ I)/SXEI KAI\ DIATI/-QHSIN &etc. &@Plut. de Stoic. repugn. cp. 47 p. 1056c.$8 TE/LOS DE/ FHSI MHDE\N @1 I)/SXESQAI MHDE\ KINEI=SQAI MHDE\ TOU)LA/XISTON A)/LLWS H)\ KATA\ TO\N TOU= *DIO\S LO/GON, O(\N TH=| EI(MARME/NH| TO\N AU)TO\N EI)=NAI. @&10Servius ad Verg. Aeneid. III 90. Visa repente%10 <21Stoicos>21 et &10Academicos secutus est, qui dicunt <21ea quae contra naturam sunt non &10fieri, sed fieri videri>21%10 unde magica ars omnis exclusa est, sicut Plinius &10Secundus docet in Naturali Historia. @&Diogenianus apud Eusebium praep. evang. IV 3 p. 136.$ [E)CAR-KEI=N E)/MOIGE H(GOU=MAI KAI\ MI/AN E(NO\S TOU/TWN PARA/QESIN A)PANTW=SAN PRO\S TA\ <20*XRUSI/PPW| PERI\ EI(MARME/NHS>20 A)PO\ TH=S TW=N MANTEI/WN PROR)-R(H/SEWS KATASKEUASQE/NTA. GRA/FEI D' OU)=N PRO\S AU)TO\N O( SUGGRAFEU\S A)PELE/GXWN O(/TI KAKW=S E)K TW=N MANTEI/WN SHMEIOU=TAI TH\N EI(MARME/NHN &etc.$] *FE/REI DE\ KAI\ A)/LLHN A)PO/DEICIN <20E)N TW=| PROEIRHME/NW|>20 BIBLI/W| [1&scil. &<21Chrysippus>21$ PERI\ EI(MARME/NHS]1 TOIAU/THN TINA/: @"1<20MH\ GA\R A)\N TA\S TW=N MA/NTEWN PROR)R(H/SEIS A)LHQEI=S EI)=NAI/ FHSIN, EI) MH\ PA/NTA U(PO\ TH=S EI(MARME/NHS PERIEI/XONTO>20."2 @_W(S GA\R E)NARGOU=S O)/NTOS TOU= PA/SAS A)POBAI/NEIN TA\S TW=N KALOU-ME/NWN MA/NTEWN PROR)R(H/SEIS H)\ W(S MA=LLON A)\N U(PO/ TINOS TOU/TOU SUGXW-RHQE/NTOS TOU= PA/NTA GI/NESQAI KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN__OU(/TW TH\N A)PO/-DEICIN H(MI=N <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 KEKO/MIKE, DI' A)LLH/LWN KATASKEUA/ZWN E(KA/TERA. <20TO\ ME\N GA\R PA/NTA GI/GNESQAI KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN E)K TOU= MANTI-KH\N EI)=NAI DEIKNU/NAI BOU/LETAI>20, TO\ DE\ EI)=NAI MANTIKH\N OU)K A)\N A)/L-LWS A)PODEI=CAI DU/NAITO, EI) MH\ PROLA/BOI TO\ PA/NTA SUMBAI/NEIN KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN. @&p. 138.$ E)/PEITA EI) KAI\ KAQ' U(PO/QESIN H)=N A)LHQE\S TO\ DH\ TH\N MAN-TIKH\N TW=N MELLO/NTWN A(PA/NTWN EI)=NAI QEWRHTIKH/N TE KAI\ PROAGOREUTI-KH/N, TO\ ME\N PA/NTA KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN EI)=NAI SUNH/GETO A)\N OU(/TWS, TO\ ME/NTOI XREIW=DES AU)TH=S KAI\ BIWFELE\S OU)K A)/N POTE E)DEI/KNUTO: DIO\ KAI\ MA/LISTA DOKEI= <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 U(MNEI=N TH\N MANTIKH/N__EI) GA\R FH/SEI TIS SWQH/SESQAI TO\ XRH/SIMON TH=S MANTIKH=S DIA\ TO\ PROLE/GESQAI TO\ PA/NTWS E)SO/MENON DUSXERE\S EI) MH\ FULACAI/MEQA, OU)KE/TI PA/NTA DEI/-CEI SUMBHSO/MENA KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN, E)F' H(MI=N O)/NTOS TOU= FULA/CASQAI/ TE KAI\ MH\ FULA/CASQAI EI) GA\R KAI\ TOU=TO KATHNAGKA/SQAI FH/SEI TIS, W(S EI)S PA/NTA TA\ O)/NTA DIATEI/NEIN TH\N EI(MARME/NHN, PA/LIN TO\ TH=S MANTIKH=S XRH/SIMON A)NAIREI=TAI: FULACO/MEQA GA\R EI) KAQEI/MARTAI, KAI\ OU) FULACO/MEQA, DH=-LON W(S, EI) MH\ KAQEI/MARTAI FULA/CASQAI, KA)\N PA/NTES OI( MA/NTEIS TO\ E)SO/MENON PROAGOREU/WSIN H(MI=N. @<20TO\N GOU=N *OI)DI/PODA KAI\ TO\N *)ALE/CANDRON TO\N TOU= *PRIA/MOU @1 KAI\ AU)TO\S O( *XRU/SIPPO/S FHSI POLLA\ MHXANHSAME/NWN TW=N GO-NE/WN W(/STE A)POKTEI=NAI, I(/NA TO\ A)P' AU)TW=N PROR)R(HQE\N AU)TOI=S KAKO\N FULA/CWNTAI, MH\ DUNHQH=NAI>20. OU(/TWS OU)DE\N O)/FELOS OU)DE\ AU)TOI=S TH=S TW=N KAKW=N PROAGOREU/SEW/S FHSIN EI)=NAI DIA\ TH\N E)K TH=S EI(MARME/NHS AI)TI/AN. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 30 p. 200, 12 Bruns.$10 TO\ DE\ LE/-GEIN <20EU)/LOGON EI)=NAI TOU\S QEOU\S TA\ E)SO/MENA PROEIDE/NAI [1A)/TOPON GA\R TO\ LE/GEIN E)KEI/NOUS A)GNOEI=N TI TW=N E)SOME/NWN>20]1 KAI\ TOU=TO LAMBA/NONTAS KATASKEUA/ZEIN PEIRA=SQAI DI' AU)TOU= TO\ PA/NTA E)C A)NA/GKHS TE GI/NESQAI KAI\ KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN OU)/TE A)LHQE\S OU)/TE EU)/LOGON. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 31 p. 201, 32.$10 OI( DE\ U(MNOU=NTES TH\N MANTIKH\N KAI\ KATA\ TO\N AU(TW=N LO/GON MO/NON SW/|ZESQAI LE/GONTES AU)TH\N KAI\ TAU/TH| [2TH=|]2 PI/STEI TOU= PA/NTA KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN GI/NESQAI XRW/MENOI_ A)/TOPA/ TINA_TOLMW=SI LE/GEIN. _A)POROU/NTWN GA/R TINWN PRO\S AU)TOU/S, TI/ DH/POTE, EI) PA/NTA TA\ GINO/MENA E)C A)NA/GKHS GI/NETAI, AI( PARA\ TW=N QEW=N MAN-TEI=AI [ME\N] GI/GNONTAI SUMBOULAI=S E)OIKUI=AI, W(S DUNAME/NWN DI' O(\ H)/KOUSAN KAI\ FULA/CASQAI/ TI KAI\ POIH=SAI TW=N A)KOUSA/NTWN, KAI\ DH\ KAI\ TO\N TW=| *LAI/+W| DO-QE/NTA XRHSMO\N PAREXOME/NWN, DI' OU(= LE/GEI PRO\S AU)TO\N O( *PU/QIOS PERI\ TOU= MH\ DEI=N PAIDOPOIEI=SQAI: [1&10Eur. Phoen. 19$10]1 "1EI) GA\R FUTEU/SEIS PAI=DA, A)POKTENEI= S' O( FU/S @KAI\ PA=S SO\S OI)=KOS BH/SETAI DI' AI(/MATOS,"2 FASI/N, W(S KHRU/TTEI TA\ SUGGRA/MMATA AU)TW=N, [2<20OU)X]2 OU(/TWS AU)TO\N XRH=SAI W(S OU)K EI)DO/TA O(/TI MH\ PEISQH/SETAI [1PANTO\S GA\R MA=LLON H)/|DEI]1, A)LL' O(/TI MHDE\N ME\N AU)TOU= TOIOU=TON XRH/SANTOS OU)DE\N E)/MELLEN TW=N KATA\ TH\N PERIPE/TEIAN TH\N PERI\ TO\N *LA/I+O/N TE KAI\ TO\N *OI)DI/POUN GENO-ME/NWN GI/NESQAI. OU)/TE GA\R A)\N E)CE/QHKEN O( *LA/I+OS TO\N GENO/MENON AU)TW=| PAI=DA, W(S E)CE/QHKEN, OU)/T' A)NAIREQEI\S O( PAI=S U(PO\ TOU= BOU-KO/LOU KAI\ DOQEI\S PRO\S EI)SPOI/HSIN TW=| *KORINQI/W| *POLU/BW|, A)NDRW-QEI\S KAI\ PERITUXW\N TW=| *LAI/+W| KATA\ TH\N O(DO\N A)GNOW=N TE KAI\ A)GNO-OU/MENOS A)PE/KTEINEN AU)TO/N. OU) GA\R A)/N POTE W(S UI(O\S E)/NDON PAR' AU)TOI=S TREFO/MENOS H)GNO/HSE TOU\S GONEI=S, W(S TO\N ME\N AU)TW=N A)PO-KTEI=NAI, TH\N DE\ A)GAGE/SQAI PRO\S GA/MON. O(/PWS OU)=N PA/NTA TAU=TA SWQH=| KAI\ PLHRWQH=| TO\ TH=S EI(MARME/NHS DRA=MA, FANTASI/AN O( QEO\S DIA\ TOU= XRHSMOU= TW=| *LAI/+W| PARE/SXEN W(S DUNAME/NW| FULA/CASQAI TA\ LEGO/MENA, KAI\ E)PEI\ MEQUSQEI\S E)PAIDOPOIH/SATO, E)CE/QHKEN TO\ GENO/-MENON PAIDI/ON W(S DIAFQERW=N, H(/TIS E)/KQESIS AI)TI/A TW=N A)NOSI/WN MU/QWN E)GE/NETO>20. @&10Proclus de prov. et fato cp. 49 [1ed. Cousin I 71]1. Alii autem &10determinatam cognitionem attribuentes deo, admiserunt necessitatem in &10omnibus quae fiunt. Peripateticorum et Stoicorum haeresium sunt haec &10dogmata. @&Chalcidius ad Timaeum cp. 160.&3 Aiunt ergo [1sc. Stoici Chry-&3sippum secuti]1 si deus cuncta ex initio scit, antequam fiant, nec sola &3caelestia, quae felici necessitate perpetuae beatitudinis quasi quodam fato @1 &3tenentur, sed illas etiam nostras cogitationes et voluntates, scit quoque &3dubiam illam naturam tenetque et praeterita et praesentia et futura, et &3hoc ex initio, nec potest falli deus%10 omnia certe ex initio disposita at-&3que decreta sunt, tam ea quae in nostra potestate posita esse dicuntur, &3quam fortuita nec non subiecta casibus. Porro cum haec omnia iam &3dudum decreta sint, cuncta quae proveniunt ex fato provenire concludunt. &3Leges etiam et exhortationes et obiurgationes et disciplinas quaeque huius-&3modi sunt, omnia teneri fatalibus condicionibus%10 quando, <21si cui quid &3accidere decretum est, una etiam illud decretum sit, cuius &3ope vel beneficio debeat provenire>21%10 ut si cui salus proventura erit &3in navigando, proveniat ei non alio quoquam sed illo gubernatore navim &3regente, vel si cui civitati proventurum erit, ut bonis utatur institutis et &3moribus, ut Spartae Lycurgi legibus hoc debeat provenire. item si quis &3erit iustus futurus, ut Aristides, huic educatio parentum adiumento sit &3in iustitiae atque aequitatis obtentu. @&cp. 161.&3 Artes quoque sub fati decretum cadere manifestum esse &3aiunt. nam et hinc iam dudum esse ordinatum, quis aeger quo me-&3dente revalescat. denique fieri frequenter, ut non a medico sed ab in-&3perito curetur aeger, cum talis erit condicio decreti. Similis ratio est &3laudum, vituperationum, animadversionum, praemiorum. fit enim fre-&3quenter, ut adversante fato quae recte gesta sunt non modo nullam lau-&3dem, sed contra reprehensionem suppliciaque adferant. At vero divina-&3tionem dicunt clare demonstrare proventus iam dudum esse decretos. &3neque enim, nisi decretum praecederet, ad rationem eius accedere potuisse &3praesagos. Animorum vero nostrorum motus nihil aliud esse, quam mi-&3nisteria decretorum fatalium, siquidem necesse sit agi per nos agente &3fato. Ita homines vicem obtinere eorum quae dicuntur, sine quibus agi &3non potest, sicut sine loco esse non potest motus aut statio. @&10Cicero de divinatione I 56, 127. Praeterea cum fato omnia &10fiunt__si quis mortalis possit esse, qui colligationem causarum om-&10nium perspiciat animo, nihil eum profecto fallat. Qui enim teneat causas &10rerum futurarum, idem necesse est omnia teneat quae futura sint. Quod &10cum nemo facere nisi deus possit, relinquendum est homini ut signis qui-&10busdam consequentia declarantibus futura praesentiat. Non enim illa, quae &10futura sunt, subito exsistunt; <21sed est quasi rudentis explicatio, sic &10traductio temporis>21, nihil novi efficientis et primum replicantis. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 22 p. 191, 30 Bruns.$10 FASI\N DH\ TO\N KO/SMON TO/NDE, E(/NA O)/NTA KAI\ PA/NTA TA\ O)/NTA E)N AU(TW=| PERIE/XONTA, KAI\ U(PO\ FU/SEWS DIOIKOU/MENON ZWTIKH=S TE KAI\ LOGIKH=S KAI\ NOERA=S, E)/XEIN TH\N TW=N @1 O)/NTWN DIOI/KHSIN A)I/+DION KATA\ EI(RMO/N TINA KAI\ TA/CIN PROI+OU=SAN, TW=N PRW/TWN TOI=S META\ TAU=TA GINOME/NOIS AI)TI/WN GINOME/NWN KAI\ TOU/TW| TW=| TRO/PW| SUNDEO-ME/NWN A)LLH/LOIS A(PA/NTWN, KAI\ MH/TE OU(/TWS TINO\S E)N AU)TW=| GINOME/NOU, W(S MH\ PA/NTWS E)PAKOLOUQEI=N AU)TW=| KAI\ SUNH=FQAI W(S AI)TI/W| E(/TERO/N TI, MH/T' AU)= TW=N E)PIGINOME/NWN TINO\S A)POLELU/SQAI DUNAME/NOU TW=N PROGEGONO/TWN, W(S MH/ TINI AU)TW=N A)KOLOUQEI=N W(/SPER SUNDEO/MENON, A)LLA\ PANTI/ TE TW=| GENOME/NW| E(/TERO/N TI E)PAKOLOUQEI=N, H)RTHME/NON [2E)C]2 AU)TOU= E)C A)NA/GKHS W(S AI)TI/OU, KAI\ PA=N TO\ GI-NO/MENON E)/XEIN TI PRO\ AU(TOU=, W(=| W(S AI)TI/W| SUNH/RTHTAI. MHDE\N GA\R A)NAITI/WS MH/TE EI)=NAI MH/TE GI/NESQAI TW=N E)N TW=| KO/SMW| DIA\ TO\ MHDE\N EI)=NAI TW=N E)N AU)-TW=| A)POLELUME/NON TE KAI\ KEXWRISME/NON TW=N PROGEGONO/TWN A(PA/NTWN. <20DIA-SPA=SQAI GA\R KAI\ DIAIREI=SQAI KAI\ MHKE/TI TO\N KO/SMON E(/NA ME/NEIN, AI)EI\ KATA\ MI/AN TA/CIN TE KAI\ OI)KONOMI/AN DIOIKOU/MENON, EI) A)NAI/TIO/S TIS EI)SA/GOITO KI/NHSIS>20: H(\N EI)SA/GESQAI, EI) MH\ PA/NTA TA\ O)/NTA TE KAI\ GINO/-MENA E)/XOI TINA AI)/TIA PROGEGONO/TA, OI(=S E)C A)NA/GKHS E(/PETAI: O(/MOIO/N TE EI)=NAI/ FASIN KAI\ O(MOI/WS A)DU/NATON TO\ A)NAITI/WS TW=| GI/NESQAI/ TI E)K MH\ O)/NTOS. TOI-AU/THN DE\ OU)=SAN TH\N TOU= PANTO\S DIOI/KHSIN E)C A)PEI/ROU EI)S A)/PEIRON E)NERGW=S TE KAI\ A)KATASTRO/FWS GI/NESQAI. OU)/SHS DE/ TINOS DIAFORA=S E)N TOI=S AI)TI/OIS, H(\N E)KTIQE/NTES <20SMH=NOS [GA\R] AI)TI/WN KATALE/GOUSIN, TA\ ME\N PROKATARKTIKA/, TA\ DE\ SUNAI/TIA, TA\ DE\ E(KTIKA/, TA\ DE\ SUNEKTIKA/>20, TA\ DE\ A)/LLO TI [1OU)DE\N GA\R DEI= TO\N LO/GON MHKU/NEIN, PA/NTA TA\ LEGO/MENA PARATIQE/MEN[2ON, A)LL]2A\ TO\ BOU/LHMA AU)TW=N DEI=CAI TOU= PERI\ TH=S EI(MARME/NHS DO/GMATOS]1: O)/NTWN DH\ PLEIO/-NWN AI)TI/WN, E)P' I)/SHS E)PI\ PA/NTWN AU)TW=N A)LHQE/S FASIN EI)=NAI TO\ A)DU/NATON EI)=NAI TW=N AU)TW=N A(PA/NTWN PERIESTHKO/TWN PERI/ TE TO\ AI)/TION KAI\ W(=| E)STIN AI)/-TION, O(TE\ ME\N DH\ MH\ OU(TWSI/ PWS SUMBAI/NEIN, O(TE\ DE\ OU(/TWS. E)/SESQAI GA/R, EI) OU(/TWS GI/NOITO, A)NAI/TIO/N TINA KI/NHSIN. TH\N DE\ EI(MARME/NHN AU)TH\N KAI\ TH\N FU/SIN KAI\ TO\N LO/GON, KAQ' O(\N DIOIKEI=TAI TO\ PA=N, QEO\N EI)=NAI/ FASIN, OU)=SAN E)N TOI=S OU)=SI/N TE KAI\ GINOME/NOIS A(/PASIN KAI\ OU(/TWS XRWME/NHN A(PA/NTWN TW=N O)/NTWN TH=| OI)KEI/A| FU/SEI PRO\S TH\N TOU= PANTO\S OI)KONOMI/AN. KAI\ TOIAU/TH ME\N W(S DIA\ BRAXE/WN EI)PEI=N H( PERI\ TH=S EI(MARME/NHS U(P' AU)TW=N KATABEBLHME/NH DO/CA. @&10p. 193, 4.$10 TO\ GOU=N PRW=TON EI)RHME/NON W(S PA/NTWN TW=N O)/NTWN AI)TI/WN TINW=N GINOME/NWN TW=N META\ TAU=TA KAI\ TOU=TON TO\N TRO/PON E)XOME/NWN A)LLH/LWN TW=N PRAGMA/TWN TW=| DI/KHN A(LU/SEWS TOI=S PRW/TOIS SUNHRTH=SQAI TA\ DEU/TERA, O(\ W(/SPER OU)SI/AN TH=S EI(MARME/NHS U(POTI/QENTAI &10etc. &10@Plotinus Ennead. III lib. I 2 [1Vol. I p. 162 Mu+.$10]1. OI( DE\ E)PI\ TH\N TOU= PANTO\S A)RXH\N E)LQO/NTES A)P' AU)TH=S KATA/GOUSI PA/NTA, DIA\ PA/NTWN FOITH/SASAN AI)TI/AN KAI\ TAU/THN OU) MO/NON KINOU=SAN A)LLA\ KAI\ POIOU=SAN E(/KASTA LE/GONTES, EI(MARME/NHN TAU/THN KAI\ KURIWTA/THN AI)TI/AN QE/MENOI, AU)TH\N POIOU=SAN TA\ PA/NTA, OU) MO/NON TA\ A)/LLA O(/SA GI/GNETAI, A)LLA\ KAI\ TA\S H(METE/RAS DIANOH/SEIS E)K TW=N E)KEI/NHS I)E/NAI KINHMA/TWN, OI(=ON ZW/|OU MORI/WN KINOUME/NWN E(KA/STWN OU)K E)C AU(TW=N, E)K DE\ TOU= H(GEMONOU=NTOS E)N E(KA/STW| TW=N ZW/|WN: A)/LLOI DE\___. <20KAI\ MH\N KAI\ TH\N TW=N AI)TI/WN E)PIPLOKH\N PRO\S A)/LLHLA KAI\ TO\N A)/NW-QEN EI(RMO\N KAI\ TO\ E(/PESQAI TOI=S PROTE/ROIS A)EI\ TA\ U(/STERA KAI\ TAU=TA E)P' E)KEI=NA A)NIE/NAI, DI' AU)TW=N GENO/MENA KAI\ A)/NEU E)KEI/NWN OU)K A)\N GENO/MENA, DOULEU/EIN TE TOI=S PRO\ AU)TW=N TA\ U(/STERA>20, TAU=TA EI)/ TIS LE/- @1GOI, EI(MARME/NHN E(/TERON TRO/PON EI)SA/GWN FANEI=TAI. DITTOU\S DE\ A)/N TIS QE/MENOS KAI\ TOU/TOUS, OU)K A)\N TOU= A)LHQOU=S A)POTUGXA/NOI: OI( ME\N GA\R A)F' E(NO/S TINOS TA\ PA/NTA A)NARTW=SIN, OI( DE\ OU)X OU(/TW. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 23 p. 193, 25$10 [1POLLA\ GA\R TW=N GINOME/NWN_OU)DENO\S E)/FQH GENO/MENA KATA\ TH\N U(PA/RXOUSAN DU/NAMIN AU)TOI=S AI)/TIA. *TI/NOS DE\ E)ROU=SIN AI)/TIA TA\ E)/N TISIN ME/RESIN TOU= SW/MATOS FUO/MENA PERITTW/MATA; TI/NOS DE\ TA\ TE/RATA;]1. TO\ D' O(MO/SE XWROU=NTAS [2<20AI)/TIA]2 ME\N LE/GEIN KAI\ TAU=TA, KATAFEU/GEIN DE\ E)PI\ TO\ A)/DHLON EI)=NAI, TI/NOS AI)/TIA>20 [1W(/SPER A)ME/LEI KAI\ E)PI\ TH=S PRONOI/AS TH=S KAT' AU)TOU\S A)NAGKA/ZONTAI POIEI=N POLLA/KIS]1 EU)PORI/AN E)STI\ TOI=S A)PO/ROIS MHXANWME/NWN. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 25 p. 194, 25 Bruns.$10 PW=S GA\R OU) FANERW=S YEU=DOS TO\ LE/GEIN PA=N TO\ E(PO/MENO/N TINI E)C E)KEI/NOU TH\N AI)TI/AN TOU= EI)=NAI E)/XEIN KAI\ PA=N TO\ PROHGOU/MENO/N TINOS AI)/TION U(PA/RXEIN E)KEI/NW|; @&10p. 195, 1.$10 O(/QEN KAI\ QAUMA/SEIEN A)/N TIS AU)TOU\S TH\N TW=N AI)TI/WN A)PO/-DOSIN TOU=TON POIOUME/NOUS TO\N TRO/PON W(S AI)EI\ TO\ PRW=TON GEGONO\S AI)TIA=SQAI TOU= META\ TOU=TO KAI\ POIEI=N <20E)PISU/NDESI/N TINA KAI\ SUNE/XEIAN TW=N AI)-TI/WN>20, KAI\ TAU/THN TOU= MHDE\N A)NAITI/WS GI/NESQAI FE/RESQAI TH\N AI)TI/AN. @&10`13.$10 [2OU) MH\N]2 O(/TI MH\ [2H(]2 NU\C TH=S H(ME/RAS AI)TI/A H)\ O( XEIMW\N TOU= QE/-ROUS MHDE\ E)MPE/PLEKTAI TAU=TA A)LLH/LOIS A(LU/SEWS DI/KHN, A)NAITI/WS TAU=TA GI/NE-TAI, H)\ EI) MH\ OU(/TWS GI/NOITO, DIASPASQH/SETAI H( TOU= KO/SMOU TE KAI\ TW=N E)N AU)TW=| GINOME/NWN TE KAI\ O)/NTWN E(/NWSIS. __W(/ST' OU)X O( TW=N AI)TI/WN EI(RMO\S U(P' AU)TW=N LEGO/MENOS EU)LO/GWS A)\N TOU= MHDE\N A)NAITI/WS GI/NESQAI FE/ROITO TH\N AI)TI/AN. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 25 p. 196, 1 Bruns.$10 PW=S GA\R OU)K A)/TOPON TO\ LE/GEIN <20E)P' A)/PEIRON EI)=NAI TA\ AI)/TIA>20 KAI\ TO\N EI(RMO\N AU)TW=N KAI\ TH\N E)PISU/NDESIN <20W(S MH/TE PRW=TO/N TI EI)=NAI MH/TE E)/SXATON>20; _A)NAI-ROI=TO D' A)\N KAI\ E)PISTH/MH KATA\ TO\N LO/GON TOU=TON, EI)/ GE E)PISTH/MH ME/N E)STI KURI/WS H( TW=N PRW/TWN AI)TI/WN GNW=SIS, OU)K E)/STI DE\ <20KAT' AU)TOU\S>20 E)N TOI=S AI)-TI/OIS TO\ PRW=TON. OU) PA=SA/ TE TA/CEWS PARA/BASIS A)NAIRETIKH\ TW=N E)N OI(=S GI/-NETAI_OU)DE\ EI)/ TI TOIOU=TON E)N TW=| KO/SMW| GI/NOITO, PA/NTWS H)/DH TOU=TO <20LU/EI TH\N EU)DAIMONI/AN TOU= KO/SMOU>20, KAQA/PER OU)DE\ TH\N TOU= OI)/KOU KAI\ TH\N TOU= DESPO/TOU H( TUXOU=SA TW=N OI)KETW=N R(A|DIOURGI/A. @&Cicero de fato 7.&3 ad <21Chrysippi>21 laqueos revertamur. Cui &3quidem primum <21de ipsa contagione rerum>21 respondeamus__. Inter &3<21locorum naturas>21 quantum intersit videmus; alios esse salubris, alios &3pestilentis, in aliis esse pituitosos et quasi redundantis, in aliis exsicca-&3tos atque aridos; multaque sunt alia, quae inter locum et locum pluri-&3mum differant. Athenis tenue caelum, ex quo etiam acutiores putantur &3Attici, crassum Thebis, itaque pingues Thebani et valentes. Tamen ne-&3que illud tenue caelum efficiet, ut aut Zenonem quis aut Arcesilam aut &3Theophrastum audiat, neque crassum, ut Nemea potius quam Isthmo &3victoriam petat.& 8.&3 Diiunge longius. Quid enim loci natura adferre @1 &3potest, ut in porticu Pompeii potius quam in campo ambulemus? Tecum &3quam cum alio? Idibus potius quam Kalendis? Ut igitur ad quasdam &3res natura loci pertinet aliquid, ad quasdam autem nihil, sic astrorum &3adfectio valeat, si vis, ad quasdam res, ad omnis certe non valebit. @&10Cicero de fato 8.&3 "1<21At enim, quoniam in naturis homi-&3num dissimilitudines sunt, ut alios dulcia, alios subamara &3delectent, alii libidinosi, alii iracundi aut crudeles aut su-&3perbi sint, alii [2a]2 talibus vitiis abhorreant__quoniam igi-&3tur, inquit, tantum natura a natura distat, quid mirum est &3has dissimilitudines ex differentibus causis esse factas>21?"2 &`9.&3 Haec disserens, qua de re agatur, et in quo causa consistat, non &3videt. Non enim, si alii ad alia propensiores sunt propter causas na-&3turalis et antecedentis, idcirco etiam nostrarum voluntatum atque ad-&3petitionum sunt causae naturales et antecedentes. Nam nihil esset in &3nostra potestate, si ita se res haberet. Nunc vero fatemur, acuti hebe-&3tesne, valentes imbecilline simus, non esse id in nobis. Qui autem ex &3eo cogi putat, ne ut sedeamus quidem aut ambulemus voluntatis esse, is &3non videt, quae quamque rem res consequatur. Ut enim et ingeniosi et &3tardi ita nascantur antecedentibus causis itemque valentes et imbecilli, &3non sequitur tamen, ut etiam sedere eos et ambulare et rem agere ali-&3quam principalibus causis definitum et constitutum sit. @&Cicero de fato 20.&3 Concludit enim <21Chrysippus>21 hoc modo%10 &3"1<21Si est motus sine causa, non omnis enuntiatio, quod>21$ A)CI/WMA&3 &3<21dialectici appellant, aut vera aut falsa erit; causas enim effi-&3cientis quod non habebit, id nec verum nec falsum erit. Omnis &3autem enuntiatio aut vera aut falsa est. Motus ergo sine &3causa nullus est.& 21.&3 Quod si ita est, omnia, quae fiunt, causis &3fiunt antegressis. Id si ita est, fato omnia fiunt. Efficitur &3igitur fato fieri, quaecunque fiant>21."2 ___Itaque contendit &3omnis nervos <21Chrysippus>21 ut persuadeat omne$ A)CI/WMA &3aut verum esse &3aut falsum. Ut enim Epicurus veretur, ne, si hoc concesserit, conceden-&3dum sit fato fieri, quaecunque fiant__sic <21Chrysippus>21 metuit, ne, &3si non obtinuerit omne, quod enuntietur, aut verum esse aut falsum, &3non teneat omnia fato fieri et ex causis aeternis rerum futurarum. &`38.&3 [2si]2 tenebitur id, quod a Chrysippo defenditur, omnem enuntiationem &3aut veram aut falsam esse. @1 @&10Cicero de fato 28 [1Carneades contra Chrysippum disputans%10]1 &10Nec si omne enuntiatum aut verum aut falsum est, sequitur ilico esse &10causas immutabilis easque aeternas, quae prohibeant quicquam secus ca-&10dere atque casurum sit; fortuitae sunt causae, quae efficiant, ut vere &10dicantur, quae ita dicentur "1veniet in senatum Cato,"2 non inclusae in &10rerum natura atque mundo; et tamen tam est immutabile venturum, &10cum est verum, quam venisse, nec ob eam causam fatum aut necessitas &10extimescenda est. Etenim erit confiteri necesse: "1Si hoc enuntiatum%10 "3ve-&10niet in Tusculanum Hortensius"3 verum non est, sequitur ut falsum sit."2 &10<21Quorum isti neutrum volunt>21; quod fieri non potest. &10@Cicero de fato 11 [1ex naturalibus causis vitia nasci possunt, &10extirpari autem et funditus tolli__non est id positum in naturalibus &10causis, sed in voluntate, studio, disciplina]1. Quae tolluntur omnia, si <21vis &10et natura fati ex divinationis ratione firmabitur>21. Etenim si est &10divinatio, qualibusnam a perceptis artis proficiscitur? [1percepta appello, &10quae dicuntur Graece$ QEWRH/MATA&3]1: Non enim credo nullo percepto aut &3ceteros artifices versari in suo munere, aut eos, qui divinatione utuntur &3futura praedicere. 12. Sint igitur astrologorum percepta huius modi%10 "1Si &3quis [1verbi causa]1 oriente Canicula natus est, is in mari non morietur."2 &3Vigila, Chrysippe, ne tuam causam, in qua tibi cum Diodoro, valente dia-&3lectico, magna luctatio est, deseras. Si enim est verum quod ita conecti-&3tur%10 "1Si quis oriente Canicula natus est, in mari non morietur,"2 illud quo-&3que verum est "1Si Fabius oriente Canicula natus est, Fabius in mari &3non morietur."2 __et quoniam certum in Fabio ponitur, natum esse &3eum Canicula oriente__illud "1morietur in mari Fabius"2 ex eo ge-&3nere est, quod fieri non potest. Omne ergo, quod falsum dicitur in fu-&3turo, id fieri non potest. 13. <21At hoc, Chrysippe, minime vis, &3maximeque tibi de hoc ipso cum Diodoro certamen est>21. Ille &3enim id solum fieri posse dicit, quod aut sit verum aut futurum sit ve-&3rum et, quicquid futurum sit, id dicit fieri necesse esse, et quicquid non &3sit futurum, id negat fieri posse. <21Tu et quae non sint futura, posse &3fieri dicis, ut frangi hanc gemmam, etiamsi id numquam futu-&3rum sit, neque necesse fuisse Cypselum regnare Corinthi, quam-&3quam id millensimo ante anno Apollinis oraculo editum esset>21. &3At si ista comprobabis divina praedicta, et quae falsa in futuris dicentur, &3in iis habebis, ut ea fieri non possint. __et si vere dicatur de fu-&3turo idque ita futurum sit, dicas esse necessarium; quae est tota Diodori &3vobis inimica sententia. 14. Etenim si illud vere conectitur%10 "1Si oriente &3Canicula natus es, in mari non moriere,"2 primumque quod est in conexo &3"1natus es oriente Canicula"2 necessarium est_<21omnia enim vera in &3praeteritis necessaria sunt, ut Chrysippo placet>21 dissentienti a ma-&3gistro Cleanthe, quia sunt immutabilia nec in falsum e vero praeterita &3possunt convertere__fit etiam, quod consequitur necessarium. <21Quam-&3quam hoc Chrysippo non videtur valere in omnibus>21; sed tamen &3si naturalis est causa, cur in mari Fabius non moriatur, in mari Fabius @1 &3mori non potest. 15. <21Hoc loco Chrysippus aestuans falli sperat Cha1-&3daeos ceterosque divinos neque eos usuros esse coniunctionibus, &3ut ita sua percepta pronuntient "1Si quis natus est oriente Ca-&3nicula, is in mari non morietur,"2 sed potius ita dicant: "1Non &3et natus est quis oriente Canicula, et is in mari morietur>21."2 &3O licentiam iocularem! ne ipse incidat in Diodorum, docet Chaldaeos. quo &3pacto eos exponere percepta oporteat. Quaero enim, si Chaldaei ita lo-&3quantur, ut negationes infinitarum coniunctionum potius quam infinita &3conexa ponant, cur idem medici, cur geometrae, cur reliqui facere non &3possint. 16. Quid est quod non possit isto modo ex conexo transferri &3ad coniunctionum negationem? Et quidem aliis modis easdem res efferre &3possumus. __Multa genera sunt enuntiandi nec ullum distortius quam &3hoc, <21quo Chrysippus>21 sperat Chaldaeos contentos Stoicorum causa fore. &3[1Sequentibus explicata Diodori sententia demonstratur, si vera sit, non sequi &3omnia fato fieri%10]1 non enim aeternis causis [2e]2 naturae necessitate mananti-&3bus verum est id, quod ita enuntiatur%10 "1descendit in Academiam Carneades"2 &3nec tamen sine causis, sed interest inter causas fortuito antegressas et inter &3causas cohibentis in se efficientiam naturalem. 20. Nec ii qui dicunt immu-&3tabilia esse, quae futura sint, nec posse verum futurum convertere in falsum &3[1i. e. Diodorus]1, fati necessitatem confirmant, sed verborum vim interpre-&3tantur. At qui introducunt causarum seriem sempiternam [1i. e. Chrysippus]1, &3ii mentem hominis voluntate libera spoliatam necessitate fati devinciunt. &3@Cicero de fato 33 [1Negat Carneades]1 de Oedipode potuisse &3Apollinem praedicere, nullis in rerum natura causis praepositis, cur ab &3eo patrem interfici necesse esset __Quocirca si Stoicis, qui omnia &3fato fieri dicunt, consentaneum est huius modi oracla ceteraque, quae a &3divinatione ducuntur, comprobare, iis autem, qui, quae futura sunt, ea &3vera esse ex aeternitate dicunt, non idem dicendum est, vide, ne non &3eadem sit illorum causa et Stoicorum; hi enim urguentur angustius, illo-&3rum ratio soluta ac libera est. @&Cicero de fato 3o [1postquam$ A)RGO\N LO/GON& explicavit&3]1. Haec &3ratio a <21Chrysippo>21 reprehenditur. <21Quaedam enim sunt, inquit, in &3rebus simplicia, quaedam copulata. Simplex est%10 "1Morietur &3illo die Socrates"2; huic, sive quid fecerit sive non fecerit, fi-&3nitus est moriendi dies. At si ita fatum sit: "1Nascetur Oedi-&3pus Laio"2, non poterit dici "1sive fuerit Laius cum muliere sive &3non fuerit"2; copulata enim res est et confatalis>21. Sic enim appel-&3lat, quia ita fatum sit, et concubiturum cum uxore Laium et ex ea &3Oedipum procreaturum; ut, si esset dictum%10 "1Luctabitur Olympiis Milo"2 @1 &3et referret aliquis%10 "1Ergo sive habuerit adversarium sive non habuerit, &3luctabitur"2, erraret; est enim copulatum "1luctabitur"2, quia sine adver-&3sario nulla luctatio est. Omnes igitur istius generis captiones eodem &3modo refelluntur. "1Sive tu adhibueris medicum sive non adhibueris, &3convalescas"2 captiosum; tam enim est fatale medicum adhibere quam &3convalescere. Haec, ut dixi, confatalia ille appellat. @&10Origenes contra Celsum II 20 Vol. I p. 149, 22 Ko+. [1p. 406 Del.]1. $10KAI\ PRO\S *(/ELLHNAS DE\ XRHSO/MEQA TW=| EI)RHME/NW| TOU=TON TO\N TRO/PON PRO\S TO\N *LA/I+ON__LE/GETAI TOI/NUN PRO\S AU)TO\N U(PO\ TOU= PROEGNWKO/TOS DH\ TA\ E)SO/-MENA: [1&10Eur. Phoen. 18_20]1 @$10*MH\ SPEI=RE PAI/DWN A)/LOKA DAIMO/NWN BI/A|: @*EI) GA\R TEKNW/SEIS PAI=D', A)POKTENEI= S' O( FU/S @*KAI\ PA=S SO\S OI)=KOS BH/SETAI DI' AI(/MATOS. @*KAI\ E)N TOU/TW| TOI/NUN DHLOU=TAI, O(/TI DUNATO\N ME\N H)=N TW=| *LAI/+W|, MH\ SPEI/-REIN TE/KNWN A)/LOKA: OU)K A)\N GA\R TO\ MH\ DUNATO\N PROSE/TACEN AU)TW=| O( XRHSMO/S: DUNATO\N DE\ H)=N KAI\ TO\ SPEI/REIN KAI\ OU)DE/TERON AU)TW=N KATHNA/GKASTO. *)HKO-LOU/QHSE DE\ TW=| MH\ FULACAME/NW| SPEI=RAI PAI/DWN A)/LOKA PAQEI=N E)K TOU= E)SPAR-KE/NAI TA\ TH=S KATA\ *OI)DI/PODA KAI\ *)IOKA/STHN KAI\ TOU\S UI(OU\S TRAGW|DI/AS. *)ALLA\ KAI\ O( <20A)RGO\S KALOU/MENOS LO/GOS>20, SO/FISMA W)/N, TOIOU=TO/S E)STI, LEGO/MENOS E)PI\ U(POQE/SEWS PRO\S TO\N NOSOU=NTA, KAI\ W(S SO/FISMA A)POTRE/PWN AU)TO\N XRH=SQAI TW=| I)ATRW=| PRO\S U(GI/EIAN, KAI\ E)/XEI GE OU(/TWS O( LO/GOS: <20EI) EI(/MARTAI/ SOI A)NA-STH=NAI E)K TH=S NO/SOU, E)A/N TE EI)SAGA/GH|S TO\N I)ATRO\N E)A/N TE MH\ EI)S-AGA/GH|S, A)NASTH/SH|: A)LLA\ KAI\ EI) EI(/MARTAI/ SOI MH\ A)NASTH=NAI E)K TH=S NO/SOU, E)A/N TE EI)SAGA/GH|S TO\N I)ATRO\N E)A/N TE MH\ EI)SAGA/GH|S, OU)K A)NASTH/SH|: H)/TOI DE\ EI(/MARTAI/ SOI A)NASTH=NAI E)K TH=S NO/SOU H)\ EI(/MAR-TAI/ SOI MH\ A)NASTH=NAI: MA/THN A)/RA EI)SA/GEIS TO\N I)ATRO/N>20. *)ALLA\ XA-RIE/NTWS TOU/TW| TW=| LO/GW| TOIOU=TO/N TI PARABA/LLETAI: EI) EI(/MARTAI/ SOI TEKNOPOI-H=SAI, E)A/N TE SUNE/LQH|S GUNAIKI\ E)A/N TE MH\ SUNE/LQH|S, TEKNOPOIH/SEIS, A)LLA\ KAI\ EI) EI(/MARTAI/ SOI MH\ TEKNOPOIH=SAI, E)A/N TE SUNE/LQH|S GUNAIKI\ H)\ MH\ SUNE/LQH|S, OU) TEKNOPOIH/SEIS: H)/TOI DE\ EI(/MARTAI/ SOI TEKNOPOIH=SAI H)\ MH\ TEKNOPOIH=SAI: MA/THN A)/RA SUNE/RXH| GUNAIKI/. _*(WS GA\R E)PI\ TOU/TOU, E)PEI\ A)MH/XANON KAI\ A)DU/-NATON TEKNOPOIH=SAI TO\N MH\ SUNELQO/NTA GUNAIKI/, OU) MA/THN PARALAMBA/NETAI TO\ SUNELQEI=N GUNAIKI/, OU(/TWS EI) TO\ A)NASTH=NAI E)K TH=S NO/SOU O(DW=| TH=| A)PO\ I)ATRI-KH=S GI/NETAI, A)NAGKAI/WS PARALAMBA/NETAI O( I)ATRO\S KAI\ YEU=DOS TO\ "3MA/THN EI)S-A/GEIS TO\N I)ATRO/N."3 @*(/OLA DE\ TAU=TA PAREILH/FAMEN DI' A(\ PARE/QETO O( SOFW/TATOS *KE/LSOS EI)PW/N: QEO\S W)\N PROEI=PE KAI\ PA/NTWS E)XRH=N GENE/SQAI TO\ PROEIRHME/NON. *EI) GA\R TO\ PA/NTWS A)KOU/EI A)NTI\ TOU= KATHNAGKASME/NWS, OU) DW/SOMEN AU)TW=|: DUNATO\N GA\R H)=N KAI\ MH\ GENE/SQAI: EI) DE\ TO\ PA/NTWS LE/GEI A)NTI\ TOU= E)/STAI, O(/PER OU) KWLU/E-TAI EI)=NAI A)LHQE/S, KA)\N DUNATO\N H)=| TO\ MH\ GENE/SQAI, OU)DE\N LUPEI= TO\N LO/GON &10etc. &10@Servius ad Verg. Aeneid. IV 696 [1codd. TF]1. nam si fato vi-&10vimus, quid agunt merita? si pensamur meritis, quae vis fati? quomodo &10hic et fatum admittit et meritum? deinde cum dixerit "1stat sua cuique &10dies"2 quomodo hic dicit "1ante diem?"2 harum rerum ratio sic redditur%10 @1 &10<21sunt fata quae dicuntur denuntiativa, sunt alia fata quae con-&10dicionalia vocantur. denuntiativa sunt, quae omni modo even-&10tura decernunt, ut verbi gratia "1Pompeius ter triumphaturus &10est"2%10 hoc illi fata decernunt, ut ubicunque terrarum fuerit ter &10triumphet, nec potest aliter evenire%10 et ideo fatum, quod hoc &10denuntiat, denuntiativum vocatur. condicionale vero huius &10modi est "1Pompeius si post Pharsalicum bellum Aegypti litus &10attigerit, ferro peribit"2%10 hic non omni modo necesse erat ut &10videret Aegyptum, sed si casus eum ad aliam forte regionem &10duxisset, evaserat>21 etc. &10@Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 10 p. 176, 14 Bruns.$10 TO\ DE\ LE/-GEIN <20MH\ A)NAIREI=SQAI PA/NTWN GINOME/NWN KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN TO\ DUNA-TO/N TE KAI\ TO\ E)NDEXO/MENON, TW=| DUNATO\N ME\N EI)=NAI GENE/SQAI TOU=TO O(\ U(P' OU)DENO\S KWLU/ETAI GENE/SQAI KA)\N MH\ GE/NHTAI, "1TW=N DE\ KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN GINOME/NWN OU) KEKW/LUTAI TA\ A)NTIKEI/MENA GENE/SQAI: DIO\ KAI/TOI MH\ GINO/MENA O(/MWS E)STI\ DUNATA/"2 KAI\ TOU= MH\ KEKWLU=-SQAI GENE/SQAI AU)TA\ A)PO/DEICIN FE/REIN TO\ H(MI=N TA\ KWLU/ONTA AU)TA\ A)/GNWSTA EI)=NAI>20, PA/NTWS ME/N TINA O)/NTA: A(\ GA/R E)STIN AI)/TIA TOU= GI/NESQAI TA\ A)NTIKEI/MENA AU)TOI=S KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN, TAU=TA KAI\ TOU= MH\ GI/NESQAI TOU/TOIS AI)/TIA, EI)/ GE, W(/S FASIN, A)DU/NATON TW=N AU)TW=N PERIESTW/TWN GI/NESQAI TA\ A)NTI-KEI/MENA: A)LL' O(/TI MH\ H(MI=N E)STI GNW/RIMA, TI/NA E)STI/, DIA\ TOU=TO A)KW/LUTON AU)-TW=N TO\ GI/NESQAI LE/GOUSIN_TO\ DH\ TAU=TA LE/GEIN PW=S OU) PAIZO/NTWN E)STI/N; @&10Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 10 p. 177, 2.$10 SW/|ZONTES DE\ TH\N TOU= DUNATOU= FU/SIN OU(/TWS W(S EI)RH/KAMEN, DIA\ TOU=TO/ FASIN <20MHDE\ TA\ GIGNO/-MENA KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN, KAI/TOI A)PARABA/TWS GIGNO/MENA, E)C A)NA/GKHS GI/NESQAI>20, O(/TI E)STI\N AU)TOI=S DUNATO\N GENE/SQAI KAI\ TO\ A)NTIKEI/MENON, DUNATO\N [2O)\N]2 OU(/TWS W(S PROEI/RHTAI. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 10 p. 177, 7 Bruns.$10 O(/MOION DE\ TOU/TW| KAI\ TO\ LE/GEIN, <20TO\ A)CI/WMA TO\ "1E)/STAI AU)/RION NAUMAXI/A"2 A)LHQE\S ME\N EI)=NAI DU/NASQAI, OU) ME/NTOI KAI\ A)NAGKAI=ON>20. A)NAGKAI=ON ME\N GA\R TO\ A)EI\ A)LHQE/S, TOU=TO DE\ OU)KE/T' A)LHQE\S ME/NEI, E)PEIDA\N H( NAUMAXI/A GE/NHTAI. EI) DE\ MH\ TOU=TO A)NAGKAI=ON, OU)DE\ TO\ U(P' AU)TOU= SHMAINO/MENON E)C A)NA/GKHS TO\ E)/SESQAI NAUMAXI/AN. EI) DE\ E)/STAI ME/N, OU)K E)C A)NA/GKHS DE\ [1A)LHQOU=S O)/NTOS TOU= E)/SESQAI NAUMAXI/AN, OU)K E)C A)NA/GKHS DE/]1 E)NDEXOME/NWS DHLONO/TI. EI) DE\ E)NDEXOME/NWS, OU)K A)NAIREI=TAI TO\ E)NDEXOME/NWS TINA\ GI/NESQAI U(PO\ TOU= PA/NTA GI/NESQAI KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN. @&10Alexander Aphrod. quaestiones I 4 p. 10, 8.$10 E(/POIT' A)\N TOI=S PA/NTA GI/NESQAI KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN LE/GOUSIN TO\ DUNATO\N EI)=NAI MO/NON TO\ E)C A)NA/GKHS, TOU= E)C A)NA/GKHS MH\ TOU= W(S BIAI/OU, A)LLA\ TOU/TOU LAMBANOME/NOU, OU(= TO\ A)NTI- @1KEI/MENON A)DU/NATON. KAI/TOI KATA\ MO/NOUS TOU\S PA/NTA KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN GI/NE-SQAI LE/GONTAS [OU)K] <20A)/LLO TI TOU= A)NAGKAI/WS GINOME/NOU TO\ GINO/MENON>20 [OU)/TE GINOME/NOU] <20E)C A)NA/GKHS, OU)D' E)/STIN TO\>20 [ME\N] <20E)C A)NA/GKHS GINO/-MENON, W(/S FASIN, TO\ GINO/MENON BI/A|, TO\ DE\>20 [A)NAGKAI/WS TO\] <20KATA\ TH\N TW=N AI)TI/WN A)KOLOUQI/AN>20. GNW/RIMON DE\ E)K TOU/TOU TO\ MHDE\ DU/NASQAI/ TI GI/NESQAI BI/A| KAQ' OU(\S KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN PA/NTA GI/NETAI. EI) GA\R TA\ KAQ' EI(-MARME/NHN GINO/MENA KAQ' EI(RMO\N AI)TI/WN GI/NETAI KAI\ KATA\ TA/CIN QEI/AN TINA/, OU)DE\N DE\ TW=N KATA\ TA/CIN GINOME/NWN TOIAU/THN BI/A| GI/NETAI, OU)DE\N A)\N TW=N KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN GINOME/NWN BI/A| GI/NOITO. __TO\ GA\R LE/GEIN <20TH\N EI(MAR-ME/NHN POIEI=N TINA TOIAU=TA, A(\ XWRI\S BI/AS OU) PEI/SETAI TOI=S AI)TI/OIS>20, PANTA/PASIN A)LLO/TRION A)\N EI)=NAI DO/CAI QEI/AS TA/CEWS. PA/NTWN [2DE\]2 KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN GINOME/NWN, A)NAIREI=TAI TO\ BI/A| TI GENE/SQAI: EI)/H GA\R A)\N KAI\ TOU=TO KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN TA/CIN, W(S PROEI/RHTAI. @&10`10, 32.$10 KAI\ GA\R E)/TI PRO\S TOU/TOIS, <20EI) TA\ KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN GINO/-MENA KAI\ KATA\ PRO/NOIAN GI/NETAI>20, PW=S EU)/LOGON KATA\ PRO/NOIA/N TINAS A)NTIPRA/SSEIN TOI=S KALW=S GINOME/NOIS KAI\ EU)TA/KTWS TOI=S KATA\ PRO/NOIAN. @&10Stephanus in Aristot. Rhetor. p. 263, 23 Rabe[1Comment. graec. &10XXI, 2$10]1. <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20_TO\ E)PI\ TO\ POLU\ E)TAU/TIZON TW=| A)NAGKAI/W|: PA/NTA GA\R KATA\ TO\ A)NAGKAI=ON GINO/MENA DOGMATI/ZONTES A)NH/|ROUN TO\ E)NDEXO/MENON H)/GOUN TO\ O(PO/TER' E)/TUXE, TO\ E)P' I)/SHS E)NDEXO/MENON. LE/GETAI OU)=N W(=DE, O(/TI TO\ W(S E)PI\ TO\ POLU\ E)NDEXO/MENO/N E)STI [1DIAKO/PTETAI GA/R POTE]1, OU)X A(PLW=S DE\ H)/GOUN A)EI\ KAI\ A)NAGKAI/WS GINO/MENON, W(S OI( *STWI+KOI\ I)/SWS W(RI/ZONTO. @&10Origenes commentaria in Genesin Tom. II p. 11 Delarue.$10 EI) ME\N GA\R TO\ "1PA/NTWS E)/STAI"2 OU(/TW TIS E(RMHNEU/EI, W(S A)NA/GKHN EI)=NAI GENE/SQAI TO\ PROEGNWSME/NON [1&10scil.$10 U(PO\ TOU= QEOU=]1, OU) DIDO/AMEN AU)TW=|. __EI) DE/ TIS DIHGH/SETAI TO\ "1PA/NTWS E)/STAI"2 KATA\ TO\ SHMAI/NEIN AU)TO\ LE/GWN O(/TI E)/STAI ME\N TA/DE TINA/, E)NEDE/XETO DE\ KAI\ E(TE/RWS GENE/SQAI, TOU=TO W(S A)LHQE\S SUGXWROU=MEN, TO\N ME\N GA\R QEO\N OU)K E)NDE/XETAI YEU/SASQAI: E)NDE/XETAI DE\ PERI\ TW=N E)NDEXO-ME/NWN GENE/SQAI KAI\ MH\ GENE/SQAI FRONH=SAI TO\ GENE/SQAI AU)TA\ KAI\ TO\ MH\ GENE/SQAI. __*KAI\ LE/GOI A)\N H( GNW=SIS TOU= QEOU= O(/TI "1E)NDE/XETAI ME\N TO/NDE TO/DE POIH=SAI, A)LLA\ KAI\ TO\ E)NANTI/ON: E)NDEXOME/NWN DE\ A)MFOTE/RWN, OI)=DA O(/TI TO/DE POIH/SEI"2. OU) GA\R W(/SPER O( QEO\S EI)/POI A)/N: "1OU)K E)NDE/XETAI TO/NDE TINA\ TO\N A)/NQRWPON PTH=NAI"2, OU(/TW XRHSMO/N, FE/RE EI)PEI=N, PERI\ TINO\S DIDOU\S E)REI= O(/TI "1OU)K E)NDE/XETAI TO/NDE SWFRONH=SAI"2. DU/NAMIS ME\N GA\R OU)K E)/STI TOU= PTH=-NAI OU)DAMW=S E)N TW=| A)NQRW/PW|, DU/NAMIS DE/ E)STI TOU= SWFRONH=SAI KAI\ TOU= A)KOLASTH=SAI: W(=N A)MFOTE/RWN DUNA/MEWN U(PARXOUSW=N O( MH\ PROSE/XWN LO/GOIS E)PISTREPTIKOI=S KAI\ PAIDEUTIKOI=S E(AUTO\N E)PIDI/DWSI TH=| XEIRI/STH|: KREI/TTONI DE\ O( ZHTH/SAS TO\ A)LHQE\S KAI\ BIW=SAI BEBOULHME/NOS KAT' AU)TO/: OU) ZHTEI= DE\ O(/DE ME\N TA)LHQH=, E)PEI\ E)PIR)R(E/PEI E)PI\ TH\N H(DONH/N: O(/DE DE\ E)CETA/ZEI PERI\ AU)TW=N, AI(RE-QEI\S U(PO\ TW=N KOINW=N E)NNOIW=N KAI\ LO/GOU PROTREPTIKOU=. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. Phys. p. 333, 1 Diels.$10 TINE\S DE\ KAI\ AU)-TO/QEN O(MOLOGOU=SIN EI)=NAI <20TH\N TU/XHN>20 KAI\ AI)TI/AN AU)TH\N EI)=NAI LE/GOUSI: TI/ DE/ @1 E)STIN, OU)K E)/XOUSI LE/GEIN, <20A)/DHLON AU)TH\N A)NQRWPI/NH| DIANOI/A| NOMI/ZON-TES>20, W(S QEI=O/N TI OU)=SAN KAI\ DAIMO/NION KAI\ DIA\ TOU=TO TH\N A)NQRWPI/NHN GNW=SIN U(PERBAI=NON, W(/SPER <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 DOKOU=SI LE/GEIN. _E)/OIKE DE\ H( ME\N W(S PERI\ QEI/OU TINO\S TH=S *TU/XHS OU)=SA DO/CA KAI\ PRO\ TOU= *)ARISTOTE/LOUS EI)=NAI PARA\ TOI=S *(/ELLHSI KAI\ OU)X U(PO\ PRW/TWN NOMISQH=NAI TW=N *STWI+KW=N, W(/S TINES OI)/-ONTAI. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. I 29, 7.$10 *)ANACAGO/RAS KAI\ <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 [1TH\N TU/XHN]1 A)/DHLON AI)TI/AN A)NQRWPI/NW| LOGISMW=|: A(\ ME\N GA\R EI)=NAI KAT' A)NA/GKHN, A(\ DE\ KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN, A(\ DE\ KATA\ PROAI/RESIN, A(\ DE\ KATA\ TU/XHN, A(\ DE\ KATA\ TO\ AU)TO/MATON. @&10Alexander de anima libri mantissa p. 179, 6 Bruns.$10 TO\ DE\ LE/GEIN <20TH\N TU/XHN AI)TI/AN A)/DHLON A)NQRWPI/NW| LOGISMW=|>20 OU)K E)/STI FU/SIN TINA\ TU/XHS TIQEME/NWN, A)LL' E)N TH=| TW=N A)NQRW/PWN PRO\S TA\ AI)/TIA POIA=| SXE/SEI TH\N TU/XHN EI)=NAI LEGO/NTWN. @&10ibid. 14.$10 EI) GA\R LE/GOIEN MH\ TH\N TISI\N A)NQRW/POIS AI)TI/AN A)/DHLON EI)=NAI TH\N TU/XHN, A)LLA\ TH\N KAQO/LOU PA=SIN A)NQRW/POIS, OU)D' O(/LWS EI)=NAI/ TI SUGXW-ROI=EN A)\N TH\N TU/XHN, DIDO/NTES TE EI)=NAI MANTIKH\N KAI\ TW=N A)DH/LWN DOKOU/NTWN EI)=NAI TOI=S A)/LLOIS GNWSTIKH\N AU)TH\N TIQE/MENOI. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 8 p. 173, 13.$10 O)/NTWN DH\ TW=N A)PO\ TU/XHS TE KAI\ AU)TOMA/TWS GINOME/NWN TOIOU/TWN, W(S MH\ GI/NESQAI KATA\ PROH-GOUME/NHN AI)TI/AN__PW=S A)\N SW/|ZOITO/ TI TW=N PROEIRHME/NWN KAQ' OU(\S PA/NTA ȄPROHGHSAME/NOIS TISI\N AI)TI/OIS KAI\ PROHGOUME/NOIS E)C A)NA/GKHS E)/STI TE TA\ O)/NTA KAI\ TA\ GINO/MENA GI/NETAI, E(KA/STOU TW=N GINOME/NWN AI)/TIO/N TI PROKATABEBLHME/-NON E)/XONTOS, OU(= O)/NTOS H)\ GEGONO/TOS A)NA/GKH KAI\ AU)TO\ H)\ EI)=NAI H)\ GENE/SQAI; TO\ [2DE\]2 MHDE\N ME\N SW/|ZONTAS TW=N PROEIRHME/NWN, KAT' A)/LLOU DE/ TINOS TO\ TH=S TU/XHS NOMOQETH/SANTAS O)/NOMA, TW=| MH\ A)NAIREI=SQAI E)KEI=NO U(PO\ TOU= PA/NTA E)C A)NA/GKHS GI/NESQAI TIQEME/NOU MHDE\ TH\N TU/XHN A)NAIREI=SQAI LE/GEIN, SOFIZOME/-NWN E)STI/N__OU(/TWS ME\N GA\R OU)DE\N KWLU/SEI LE/GEIN TAU)TO\N EI(MARME/NHN TE EI)=NAI KAI\ TU/XHN KAI\ TOSOU=TON A)PODEI=N TOU= TH\N TU/XHN A)NAIREI=N, W(S KAI\ PA/NTA TA\ GINO/MENA GI/NESQAI LE/GEIN A)PO\ TU/XHS. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 7 p. 172, 12 Bruns.$10 OU) GA\R SW/ZETAI TO\ GI/NESQAI/ TINA A)PO\ TU/XHS, A)\N A)NELW/N TIS TH\N TW=N OU(/TWS GINO-ME/NWN FU/SIN O)/NOMA QH=TAI TOI=S GINOME/NOIS E)C A)NA/GKHS TH\N TU/XHN. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 8 p. 174, 1 Bruns.$10 TI/ GA\R A)/LLO POIOU=SIN OI( TH\N TU/XHN KAI\ TO\ AU)TO/MATON O(RIZO/MENOI "1AI)TI/AN A)/DHLON A)NQRW-PI/NW| LOGISMW=|"2 H)\ TU/XHS TI SHMAINO/MENON I)/DION EI)SA/GOUSI/N TE KAI\ NOMOQETOU=SIN; TO\ GA\R EI)S TH\N TOU/TOU SU/STASIN XRH/SASQAI <20TW=| LE/GEIN TINA\S AU)TOMA/TWS NOSEI=N, O(/TAN A)/DHLOS H)=| AU)TOI=S H( AI)TI/A TH=S NO/SOU, YEU=DOS.>20 @&10Theodoretus graec. affect. cyr. p. 87, 41.$10 KAI\ OI( E)K TH=S *POI-KI/LHS W)NOMASME/NOI A)/DHLON AI)TI/AN A)NQRWPI/NW| LO/GW|. @&10Servius ad Verg. Aeneid. VIII 334. "1fortuna omnipotens et &10ineluctabile fatum"2. <21secundum Stoicos locutus est, qui nasci et &10mori fatis dant, media omnia fortunae>21%10 nam vitae humanae incerta &10sunt omnia. unde et miscuit, ut quasi plenum ostenderet dogma%10 nam &10nihil tam contrarium est fato, quam casus; sed secundum <21Stoicos>21 dixit. @1 @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 23 p. 1045b.$ *TOU= KATH-NAGKA/SQAI DOKOU=NTOS U(PO\ TW=N E)/CWQEN AI)TIW=N TAI=S O(RMAI=S A)PO/LUSIN PORI/ZEIN [2QE/LONTES]2 E)/NIOI TW=N FILOSO/FWN E)PELEUSTIKH/N TINA KI/NHSIN E)N TW=| H(GEMONIKW=| KATASKEUA/ZOUSIN, E)PI\ TW=N A)PARALLA/KTWN MA/LISTA GINOME/NHN E)/KDHLON: O(/TAN GA\R DUOI=N I)/SON DUNAME/NWN KAI\ O(MOI/WS E)XO/N-TWN QA/TERON H)=| LABEI=N A)NA/GKH, MHDEMIA=S AI)TI/AS E)PI\ QA/TERON A)GOU/SHS TW=| MHDE\N TOU= E(TE/ROU DIAFE/REIN, H( E)PELEUSTIKH\ DU/NAMIS AU(/TH TH=S YUXH=S E)PI/KLISIN E)C AU(TH=S LABOU=SA DIE/KOYE TH\N A)PORI/AN. <20*PRO\S TOU/TOUS O( *XRU/SIPPOS A)NTILE/GWN, W(S BIAZOME/NOUS TW=| A)NAITI/W| TH\N FU/SIN, E)N POLLOI=S PARATI/QHSI TO\N A)STRA/GALON KAI\ TO\N ZU-GO/N, KAI\ POLLA\ TW=N MH\ DUNAME/NWN A)/LLOTE A)/LLAS LAMBA/NEIN PTW/SEIS KAI\ R(OPA\S A)/NEU TINO\S AI)TI/AS KAI\ DIAFORA=S H)\ PERI\ AU)TA\ PA/NTWS H)\ PERI\ TA\ E)/CWQEN GINOME/NHS: TO\ GA\R A)NAI/TION O(/LWS A)NU/PARKTON EI)=NAI KAI\ TO\ AU)TO/MATON: E)N DE\ TAI=S PLATTO-ME/NAIS U(P' E)NI/WN KAI\ LEGOME/NAIS TAU/TAIS E)PELEU/SESIN AI)TI/AS A)DH/LOUS U(POTRE/XEIN, KAI\ LANQA/NEIN H(MA=S E)PI\ QA/TERA TH\N O(RMH\N A)GOU/SAS>20. *TAU=TA ME\N OU)=N E)N TOI=S GNWRIMOTA/TOIS E)STI\ <20TW=N U(P' AU)TOU= POLLA/KIS EI)RHME/NWN>20. @&Cicero de fato 39.&3 Ac mihi quidem videtur, cum duae sen-&3tentiae fuissent veterum philosophorum, una eorum, qui censerent omnia &3ita fato fieri, ut id fatum vim necessitatis adferret__altera eorum, &3quibus viderentur sine ullo fato esse animorum motus voluntarii, <21Chry-&3sippus>21 tamquam arbiter honorarius medium ferire voluisse, sed adplicat &3se ad eos potius, qui necessitate motus animorum liberatos volunt; dum &3autem verbis utitur suis, delabitur in eas difficultates, ut necessitatem &3fati confirmet invitus.& 40.&3 Atque hoc, si placet, quale sit videamus in &3adsensionibus_. Eas enim veteres illi, quibus omnia fato fieri vide-&3bantur, vi effici et necessitate dicebant. Qui autem ab iis dissentiebant, &3fato adsensiones liberabant negabantque fato adsensionibus adhibito &3necessitatem ab his posse removeri iique ita disserebant%10 [1sequitur Arce-&3silai, ni fallor, contra Zenonem et Cleanthem disputatio]1.& 41.&3 <21Chry-&3sippus>21 autem cum et necessitatem improbaret et nihil vellet sine prae-&3positis causis evenire, causarum genera distinguit, ut et necessitatem &3effugiat et retineat fatum. "1<21Causarum enim>21, inquit, <21aliae sunt @1 &3perfectae et principales, aliae adiuvantes et proximae. Quam &3ob rem, cum dicimus omnia fato fieri causis antecedentibus, &3non hoc intellegi volumus%10 causis perfectis et principalibus, &3sed causis adiuvantibus>21 [antecedentibus] <21et proximis>21."2 Itaque illi &3rationi, quam paulo ante conclusi, sic occurrit%10 "1<21si omnia fato fiant, &3sequi illud quidem, ut omnia causis fiant antepositis, verum &3non principalibus causis et perfectis, sed adiuvantibus et &3proximis. Quae si ipsae non sunt in nostra potestate, non &3sequitur, ut ne adpetitus quidem sit in nostra potestate. At &3hoc sequeretur, si omnia perfectis et principalibus causis &3fieri diceremus, ut cum eae causae non essent in nostra po-&3testate, ne ille quidem esset in nostra potestate.& 42.&3 Quam &3ob rem qui ita fatum introducunt, ut necessitatem adiungant, &3in eos valebit illa conclusio; qui autem causas antecedentis &3non dicent perfectas neque principalis, in eos nihil valebit>21."2 &3Quod enim dicantur adsensiones fieri causis antepositis, id quale sit, &3facile a se explicari putat. Nam quamquam adsensio non possit fieri &3nisi commota viso, tamen, cum id visum proximam causam habeat, non &3principalem, hanc habet rationem, ut <21Chrysippus>21 vult, quam dudum &3diximus, non ut illa quidem fieri possit nulla vi extrinsecus excitata &3[1necesse est enim adsensionem viso commoveri]1, sed revertitur ad cylin-&3drum et ad turbinem suum, quae moveri incipere nisi pulsa non pos-&3sunt. Id autem cum accidit, suapte natura, quod superest, et cylindrum &3volvi et versari turbinem putat.& 43.&3 "1<21Ut igitur,>21 inquit, <21qui protrusit &3cylindrum, dedit ei principium motionis, volubilitatem autem &3non dedit, sic visum obiectum imprimet illud quidem et quasi &3signabit in animo suam speciem, sed adsensio nostra erit in &3potestate, eaque quem ad modum in cylindro dictum est, ex-&3trinsecus pulsa, quod reliquum est, suapte vi et natura move-&3bitur. Quodsi aliqua res efficeretur sine causa antecedente, &3falsum esset omnia fato fieri; sin omnibus, quaecunque fiunt, &3verisimile est causam antecedere, quid adferri poterit, cur &3non omnia fato fieri fatendum sit? modo intellegatur, quae &3sit causarum distinctio ac dissimilitudo>21."2 __&`44.&3 Neque enim &3<21Chrysippus>21, concedens adsensionis proximam et continentem causam &3esse in viso positam, [neque] eam causam esse ad adsentiendum ne-&3cessariam concedet, ut, si omnia fato fiant, omnia causis fiant antece-&3dentibus et necessariis. @1 @&Hippolytus Philos. 21 [1DDG p. 571, 11]1.$ KAI\ AU)TOI\ DE\ [1&scil. &Chrysippus et Zeno$]1 TO\ KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN EI)=NAI PA/NTA DIEBEBAIW/SANTO PARADEI/GMATI XRHSA/MENOI TOIOU/TW|, O(/TI W(/SPER O)XH/MATOS E)A\N H)=| E)CHRTH-ME/NOS KU/WN, E)A\N ME\N BOU/LHTAI E(/PESQAI, KAI\ E(/LKETAI KAI\ E(/PETAI, POIW=N KAI\ TO\ AU)TECOU/SION META\ TH=S A)NA/GKHS [OI(=ON TH=S EI(MARME/NHS]: E)A\N DE\ MH\ BOU/LHTAI E(/PESQAI, PA/NTWS A)NAGKASQH/SETAI: TO\ AU)TO\ DH/POU KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N A)NQRW/PWN: KAI\ MH\ BOULO/MENOI GA\R A)KOLOUQEI=N A)NAGKASQH/-SONTAI PA/NTWS EI)S TO\ PEPRWME/NON EI)SELQEI=N. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. I 27, 3.$10 *PLA/TWN E)GKRI/NEI ME\N TH\N EI(MARME/NHN E)PI\ TW=N A)NQRWPI/NWN YUXW=N KAI\ BI/WN, SUNEISA/GEI DE\ KAI\ TH\N PAR' H(MA=S AI)TI/AN. <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 *PLA/TWNI E)MFERW=S: KAI\ TH\N ME\N A)NA/GKHN A)NI/KHTO/N FASIN AI)TI/AN KAI\ BIASTIKH/N, TH\N DE\ EI(MARME/NHN SUMPLOKH\N AI)TIW=N TETAGME/NHN, E)N H(=| SUM-PLOKH=| KAI\ TO\ PAR' H(MA=S, W(/STE TA\ ME\N EI(MA/RQAI, TA\ DE\ A)NEIMA/RQAI. @&Gellius noct. Att. VII 2, 15.&3 Itaque M. Cicero in libro quem &3de fato conscripsit, cum quaestionem istam diceret obscurissimam esse &3et implicatissimam, Chrysippum quoque philosophum non expedisse se ф&3in ea ait his verbis%10 <21Chrysippus aestuans laboransque, quonam &3[2pacto]2 explicet et fato omnia fieri et esse aliquid in nobis, &3intricatur hoc modo>21. @&Oenomaus apud Eusebium praep. evang. VI p. 255b.$ A)PO/-LWLE GA/R, TO/ G' E)PI\ TOI=S SOFOI=S, E)K TOU= A)NQRWPI/NOU BI/OU, A)PO/LWLEN, EI)/TE OI)/AKA/ TIS AU)TO\ EI)/TE E(/RMA EI)/TE KRHPI=DA O)NOMA/ZWN XAI/REI, TH=S H(ME-TE/RAS ZWH=S H( E)COUSI/A, H(\N H(MEI=S ME\N AU)TOKRA/TORA TW=N A)NAGKAIOTA/TWN TIQE/MEQA, *DHMO/KRITOS DE/ GE, EI) MH/ TI H)PA/THMAI, KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20, O( ME\N DOU=LON, <20O( DE\ H(MI/DOULON E)PINOEI=>20 TO\ KA/LLISTON TW=N A)NQRWPI/-NWN E)PIDEI=CAI [1&Theodoret VI 8 p. 86, 22$]1. @&p. 258 b.$ E)KEI=NO GA\R DH\ TO\ KATAGELASTO/TATON A(PA/NTWN, TO\ MI/GMA KAI\ H( SU/NODOS TOU= KAI\ E)PI\ TOI=S A)NQRW/POIS TI EI)=NAI, KAI\ EI(RMO\N OU)DE\N H(=TTON EI)=NAI. PROSEOIKE/NAI GA\R AU)TO/N, W(S LE/GOUSIN OI( SOFW/TATOI, TW=| *EU)RIPIDEI/W| LO/GW|: TEKNW=SAI ME\N GA\R E)QELH=SAI TO\N *LA/I+ON, KU/RION EI)=NAI TO\N *LA/I+ON, KAI\ TOU=TO E)KPEFEUGE/NAI TH\N *)APOLLWNI/AN O)/YIN: TEKNW/SANTI D' AU)TW=| E)PEI=NAI A)NA/GKHN A)/FUKTON U(PO\ TOU= FU/NTOS AU)TO\N A)POQANEI=N: OU(/TWS OU)=N TH\N E)PI\ TW=| ME/LLONTI A)NA/GKHN PARE/XEIN TW=| MA/NTEI TH\N TOU= GENHSOME/NOU PROAI/SQHSIN. @[1&p. 261 a.$ A)LLA\ KAI\ TO\N *)EPI/KOURON, O(\N SU\ POLLA/, W)= <20*XRU/SIPPE>20, E)BLASFH/MHSAS, E)GW\ TO/ GE E)PI\ SOI\ A)FI/HMI TW=N E)GKLHMA/TWN: TI/ GA\R PA/QH| O(\S OU)X E(KW\N H)=N MALAKO\S OU)DE\ A)/DIKOS, W(/SPER POLLA/KIS AU)TO\N E)LOIDO/RHSAS;]1 @1 @&Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 13 p. 181, 13 Bruns.$ A)NAI-ROU=NTES GA\R TO\ E)COUSI/AN E)/XEIN TO\N A)/NQRWPON TH=S AI(RE/SEW/S TE KAI\ PRA/CEWS TW=N A)NTIKEIME/NWN LE/GOUSIN <20E)F' H(MI=N EI)=NAI TO\ GINO/MENON [2KAQ' O(RMH\N]2 DI' H(MW=N>20. E)PEI\ GA/R, FASI/N, TW=N O)/NTWN TE KAI\ GINO-ME/NWN AI( FU/SEIS E(/TERAI/ TE KAI\ DIA/FOROI [1OU) GA\R AI( AU)TAI\ TW=N E)M-YU/XWN TE KAI\ TW=N A)YU/XWN, A)LL' OU)DE\ TW=N E)MYU/XWN A(PA/NTWN AI( AU)-TAI\ PA/LIN: AI( GA\R KAT' EI)=DOS TW=N O)/NTWN DIAFORAI\ TA\S TW=N FU/SEWN AU)TW=N DIAFORA\S DEIKNU/OUSIN]1, GI/NETAI DE\ TA\ U(F' E(KA/STOU GINO/MENA KATA\ TH\N OI)KEI/AN FU/SIN, TA\ ME\N U(PO\ LI/QOU KATA\ TH\N LI/QOU, TA\ D' U(PO\ PURO\S KATA\ TH\N PURO\S KAI\ TA\ U(PO\ ZW/|OU KATA\ TH\N ZW/|OU, OU)DE\N ME\N TW=N KATA\ TH\N OI)KEI/AN FU/SIN U(F' E(KA/STOU GINOME/NWN DU/NASQAI/ FASIN A)/LLWS E)/XEIN, A)LL' E(/KASTON TW=N GINOME/NWN U(P' AU)TW=N GI/NESQAI KATHNAGKASME/NWS, KAT' A)NA/GKHN OU) TH\N E)K BI/AS, A)LL' E)K TOU= MH\ DU/-NASQAI TO\ PEFUKO\S OU(/TWS, O)/NTWN TW=N PERIESTW/TWN TOIOU/TWN [2A(\]2 A)DU/NATON AU)TW=| MH\ PERIESTA/NAI, TO/TE A)/LLWS PWS KAI\ MH\ OU(/TWS KINH-QH=NAI. MH/TE GA\R TO\N LI/QON, EI) A)PO\ U(/YOUS A)FEQEI/H TINO/S, DU/NASQAI MH\ FE/RESQAI KA/TW MHDENO\S E)MPODI/ZONTOS: TW=| [2GA\R]2 BARU/THTA ME\N E)/XEIN AU)TO\N E)N AU(TW=|, TAU/THN D' EI)=NAI TH=S TOIAU/THS KINH/SEWS KATA\ FU/SIN [2AI)TI/AN]2, O(/TAN KAI\ TA\ E)/CWQEN AI)/TIA TA\ PRO\S TH\N KATA\ FU/SIN KI/NHSIN TW=| LI/QW| SUNTELOU=NTA PARH=|, E)C A)NA/GKHS TO\N LI/QON W(S PE/FUKEN FE/RESQAI, [1PA/NTWS D' AU)TW=| KAI\ E)C A)NA/GKHS PAREI=NAI TAU=TA TA\ AI)/TIA, DI' A(\ KINEI=TAI TO/TE]1, OU) MO/NON MH\ DUNA/MENON MH\ KINEI=SQAI TOU/TWN PARO/NTWN, A)LLA\ KAI\ E)C A)NA/GKHS KINEI=SQAI TO/TE KAI\ GI/NESQAI TH\N TOI-AU/THN KI/NHSIN U(PO\ TH=S EI(MARME/NHS DIA\ TOU= LI/QOU: O( D' AU)TO\S KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N A)/LLWN LO/GOS. W(S DE\ E)PI\ TW=N A)YU/XWN E)/XEI, OU(/TWS DE\ KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N ZW/|WN E)/XEIN FASI/N. EI)=NAI GA/R TINA KAI\ TOI=S ZW/|OIS KI/NHSIN KATA\ FU/SIN, TAU/THN D' EI)=NAI TH\N KAQ' O(RMH/N: <20PA=N GA\R ZW=|ON W(S ZW=|ON KINOU/MENON KINEI=SQAI [2TH\N]2 KAQ' O(RMH\N KI/NHSIN, U(PO\ TH=S EI(MARME/NHS DIA\ ZW/|OU GINOME/NHN>20. OU(/TWS DE\ TOU/TWN E)XO/NTWN KAI\ GINOME/NWN U(PO\ TH=S EI(MARME/NHS KINH/SEW/N TE KAI\ E)NERGEIW=N E)N TW=| KO/SMW| TW=N ME\N DIA\ GH=S, A)\N OU(/TW TU/XH|, TW=N DE\ DI' A)E/ROS, TW=N DE\ DIA\ PURO/S, TW=N DE\ DI' A)/LLOU TINO/S, GINOME/NWN DE/ TINWN KAI\ DIA\ ZW/|WN [1TOIAU=TAI DE\ AI( KAQ' O(RMH\N KINH/SEIS]1, <20TA\S DIA\ TW=N ZW/|WN U(PO\ TH=S EI(MAR-ME/NHS GINOME/NAS E)PI\ TOI=S ZW/|OIS EI)=NAI LE/GOUSIN>20, O(MOI/WS ME\N W(S PRO\S TO\ A)NAGKAI=ON TOI=S A)/LLOIS GINOME/NAS A(/PASIN, TW=| DEI=N KAI\ TA\ E)C A)NA/GKHS TA\ E)/CWQEN AI)/TIA PAREI=NAI TO/TE, W(/STE AU)TA\ TH\N E)C E(AUTW=N TE KAI\ KAQ' O(RMH\N KI/NHSIN E)C A)NA/GKHS OU(/TW PWS E)NERGEI=N, <20O(/TI DE\ AU(=TAI ME\N DI' O(RMH=S TE KAI\ SUGKATAQE/SEWS>20, E)KEI/NWN DE\ AI( ME\N @1 DIA\ BARU/THTA GI/NONTAI, AI( DE\ DIA\ QERMO/THTA, AI( DE\ KAT' A)/LLHN TINA %2%2 <20TAU/THN ME\N E)PI\ TOI=S ZW/|OIS LE/GONTES>20, OU)KE/TI DE\ E)KEI/NWN E(KA/-STHN TH\N ME\N E)PI\ TW=| LI/QW|, TH\N DE\ E)PI\ TW=| PURI/. KAI\ TOIAU/TH ME\N AU)TW=N H( PERI\ TOU= E)F' H(MI=N DO/CA, W(S DI' O)LI/GWN EI)PEI=N. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 14 p. 183, 21 Bruns.$10 E)PEI\ GA\R OU)K A)/LLWS [2A)\N]2 GE/NOITO TA\ DIA\ TOU= ZW/|OU GINO/MENA H)\ O(RMH/SANTOS TOU= ZW/|OU, A)LLA\ DIA\ TO\ SUGKATATI/QESQAI ME\N TO\ ZW=|ON KAI\ O(RMH=SAI GI/NETAI, MH\ SUGKA-TAQEME/NOU DE\ OU) GI/NETAI, TAU=TA E)PI\ TW=| ZW/|W| FASI\N EI)=NAI, E)C A)NA/GKHS ME\N E)SO/MENA U(P' AU)TOU= [1OU) GA\R OI(=O/N TE A)/LLWS]1, TW=| DE\ MH\ DU/NASQAI DI' A)/LLOU TINO\S H)\ DIA\ TOU/TOU GENE/SQAI MHD' A)/LLWS H)\ OU(/TWS DIA\ TOU/TOU, TO\ EI)=NAI AU)TA\ E)PI\ TW=| ZW/|W| OI)HQE/NTES. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 14 p. 183, 21 Bruns.$10 E)PI\ TOU/TW| DE\ E)KEI=NO A)/N TIS AU)TW=N QAUMA/SEIEN, TI/ PAQO/NTES E)N TH=| O(RMH=| TE KAI\ SUGKA-TAQE/SEI TO\ E)F' H(MI=N FASIN EI)=NAI, DI' O(\ KAI\ O(MOI/WS E)N PA=SI TOI=S ZW/|OIS TH-ROU=SIN AU)TO/. OU) GA\R <20TO\ E)F' H(MI=N E)N TW=| FANTASI/AS PROSPESOU/SHS EI)=CAI/ TE E)C E(AUTW=N TH=| FANTASI/A| KAI\ O(RMH=SAI E)PI\ TO\ FANE/N>20. @&10p. 184, 11.$10 EI) DE\ TO\ E)F' H(MI=N E)STI E)N TH=| LOGIKH=| SUGKATAQE/SEI, H(/TIS DIA\ TOU= BOULEU/ESQAI GI/NETAI [1&10ut putat Alex.$10]1, OI( DE\ [1&10scil. Chrys.$10]1 E)N TH=| SUGKATAQE/SEI TE KAI\ O(RMH=| FASIN EI)=NAI, O(/TI KAI\ A)LO/GWS GI/NETAI, DH=LOI DI' W(=N LE/GOUSI R(A|QUMO/TERON PERI\ TOU= E)F' H(MI=N DIALAMBA/NONTES &10etc. &10@p. 184, 20.$10 E)OI/KASI DE/, PARALELOIPO/TES TO\N LO/GON E)N TH=| O(RMH=| TO\ E)F' H(MI=N TI/QESQAI, O(/TI MHKE/T' E)N TW=| BOULEU/ESQAI LE/GOUSIN AU)TOI=S TO\ E)F' H(MI=N EI)=NAI PROXWREI= TO\ SO/FISMA. E)PI\ ME\N GA\R TH=S O(RMH=S E)/XOUSI LE/GEIN TO\ E)PI\ TOI=S ZW/|OIS EI)=NAI TA\ GINO/MENA KAQ' O(RMH/N, O(/TI MH\ OI(=A/ TE XWRI\S O(RMH=S TA\ DI' AU)TW=N GINO/MENA POIEI=N, EI) D' E)N TW=| BOULEU/ESQAI TO\ E)F' H(MI=N &10etc. &10@Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 15 p. 185, 7 Bruns.$10 TO\ D' E)PO-XOUME/NOUS TW=| "1EI) DH\ TW=N AU)TW=N PERIESTW/TWN O(TE\ ME\N OU(/TWS O(TE\ DE\ A)/LLWS E)NERGH/SEI TIS, A)NAI/TION KI/NHSIN EI)SA/GESQAI"2 DIA\ TOU=TO LE/GEIN <20MH\ DU/NASQAI OU(= PRA/CEI TIS PRA=CAI TO\ A)NTIKEI/MENON>20, MH/POTE KAI\ AU)TO\ TW=N_PARO-RWME/NWN. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 15 p. 186, 3 Bruns.$10 TO\ DE\ LE/-GEIN KAI\ TOU\S BOULEUSAME/NOUS TW=| FAINOME/NW| SUGKATATI/QESQAI KAI\ DIA\ TOU=TO KAI\ TH=| FANTASI/A| O(MOI/WS TOI=S A)/LLOIS ZW/|OIS E(/PESQAI, OU)K A)LHQE/S. @&Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 26 p. 196, 13 Bruns.$8 A(\ DE\ A)POROU=SIN PRO\S TO\ EI)=NAI TOIOU=TON TO\ E)F' H(MI=N, O(POI=ON H( KOINH\ PRO/LH-YIS TW=N A)NQRW/PWN PEPI/STEUKEN, A)POREI=N ME\N OU)K A)/LOGON, TO\ DE\ TOI=S A)POROUME/NOIS E)POXOUME/NOUS W(S O(MOLOGOUME/NOIS_SUNAGWNI/ZESQAI TOI=S A)POROUME/NOIS KAQ' AU(TW=N, PW=S OU) PANTA/PASIN A)/LOGON; @&`21.$8 OU) XEI=RON DE\ I)/SWS KAI\ H(MA=S TW=N A)POROUME/NWN U(P' AU)TW=N, <20OI(=S MA/LISTA QAR)R(OU=SIN>20, TAU=TA PROXEIRISAME/NOUS E)CETA/SAI. _E)/STI DH/ TI TW=N A)POROUME/NWN U(P' AU)TW=N KAI\ TOIOU=TON: @"1*EI), FASI/N, <20TAU=TA/ E)STIN E)F' H(MI=N, W(=N KAI\ TA\ A)NTIKEI/MENA @1 DUNA/MEQA, KAI\ E)PI\ TOI=S TOIOU/TOIS OI(/ TE E)/PAINOI KAI\ OI( YO/GOI PROTROPAI/ TE KAI\ A)POTROPAI\ KOLA/SEIS TE KAI\ TIMAI/, OU)K E)/STAI TO\ FRONI/MOIS EI)=NAI KAI\ TO\ A)RETA\S E)/XEIN E)PI\ TOI=S E)/XOUSIN, O(/TI MHKE/T' EI)SI\N TW=N A)NTIKEIME/NWN KAKIW=N TAI=S A)RETAI=S DEKTIKOI/, ؈O(MOI/WS DE\ OU)DE\ AI( KAKI/AI E)PI\ TOI=S KAKOI=S: OU)DE\ GA\R E)PI\ TOU/-TOIS TO\ MHKE/T' EI)=NAI KAKOI=S: A)LLA\ MH\N A)/TOPON TO\ MH\ LE/GEIN TA\S A)RETA\S KAI\ TA\S KAKI/AS E)F' H(MI=N MHDE\ TOU\S E)PAI/NOUS KAI\ TOU\S YO/GOUS E)PI\ TOU/TWN GI/NESQAI: OU)K A)/RA TO\ E)F' H(MI=N TOIOU=TON>20."2 @&10Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 32 p. 204, 12 Bruns.$10 E)PI\ DE\ TOI=S QEOI=S OU)KE/T' A)\N [2EI)/H]2 TO\ EI)=NAI TOIOU/TOIS [1&10scil.$10 FRONI/MOIS]1, <20O(/PER H)=N KAI\ AU)TO\ E)N TOI=S U(P' AU)TW=N A)POROUME/NOIS>20, O(/TI PA/RESTIN AU)TW=N E)N TH=| FU/SEI [2TO\]2 TOIOU=TON: OU)DE\N DE\ TW=N OU(/TWS U(PARXO/NTWN E)P' AU)TW=|. @&10Plotinus Ennead. III lib. I 7 [1Vol. I p. 168 Mu+.$10]1. LOIPO\N DE\ I)DEI=N TH\N E)PIPLE/KOUSAN KAI\ OI(=ON SUNEI/ROUSAN A)LLH/LOIS PA/NTA KAI\ TO/ PWS E)F' E(KA/STOU E)PIFE/ROUSAN, A)RXH\N TIQEME/NHN MI/AN, A)F' H(=S PA/NTA KATA\ LO/GOUS SPERMATIKOU\S PERAI/NETAI. E)/STI ME\N OU)=N KAI\ AU(/TH H( DO/CA E)GGU\S E)KEI/NHS TH=S PA=SAN KAI\ SXE/SIN KAI\ KI/NHSIN H(METE/RAN TE KAI\ PA=SAN E)K TH=S TW=N O(/LWN YU-XH=S H(/KEIN LEGOU/SHS, EI) KAI\ BOU/LETAI/ TI H(MI=N KAI\ E(KA/STOIS XARI/ZESQAI EI)S TO\ PAR' H(MW=N POIEI=N TI. E)/XEI ME\N OU)=N TH\N PA/NTWS PA/NTWN A)NA/GKHN: KAI\ PA/N-TWN EI)LHMME/NWN TW=N AI)TI/WN OU)K E)/STIN E(/KASTON MH\ OU) GI/GNESQAI: OU)DE\N GA\R E)/TI TO\ KWLU=SON H)\ A)/LLWS GENE/SQAI POIH=SON, EI) PA/NTA EI)/LHPTAI E)N TH=| EI(MAR-ME/NH|. TOIAU=TA DE\ O)/NTA, W(S A)PO\ MIA=S A)RXH=S W(RMHME/NA, H(MI=N OU)DE\N KATALEI/YEI H)\ FE/RESQAI, O(/PH| A)\N E)KEI=NA W)QH=|: AI(/ TE GA\R FANTASI/AI TOI=S PROHGHSAME/NOIS, AI(/ TE O(RMAI\ KATA\ TAU/TAS E)/SONTAI: O)/NOMA/ TE MO/NON TO\ E)F' H(MI=N E)/STAI. OU) GA\R O(/TI [MO/NON] O(RMW=MEN H(MEI=S, TAU/TH| TI PLE/ON E)/STAI, TH=S O(RMH=S KAT' E)KEI=NA GENNWME/NHS &10etc. &10@Cicero de fato 36. Interesse autem aiunt, utrum eius modi &10quid sit, sine quo effici aliquid non possit, an eius modi, cum quo effici &10aliquid necesse sit. Nulla igitur earum est causa, quoniam nulla eam &10rem sua vi efficit, cuius causa dicitur; <21nec id, sine quo quippiam non &10fit, causa est>21, sed id, quod cum accessit, id, cuius est causa, efficit ne-&10cessario. &10@Origenes de principiis lib. III p. 108 ed. Delarue.$10 *TW=N KINOU-ME/NWN TA\ ME/N TINA E)N E(AUTOI=S E)/XEI TH\N TH=S KINH/SEWS AI)TI/AN, E(/TERA DE\ E)/CWQEN MO/NON KINEI=TAI. E)/CWQEN OU)=N MO/NON KINEI=TAI TA\ FORHTA/, OI(=ON CU/LA KAI\ LI/QOI KAI\ PA=SA H( U(PO\ E(/CEWS MO/NHS SUNEXOME/NH U(/LH. U(PECH|RH/SQW DE\ NU=N TOU= LO/GOU TO\ KI/NHSIN LE/GEIN TH\N R(U/SIN TW=N SWMA/TWN, E)PEI\ MH\ XREI/A TOU/TOU PRO\S TO\ PROKEI/MENON. E)N E(AUTOI=S DE\ E)/XEI TH\N AI)TI/AN TOU= KINEI=SQAI ZW=|A KAI\ FUTA\ KAI\ A(PACAPLW=S O(/SA U(PO\ FU/SEWS KAI\ YUXH=S SUNE/XETAI, E)C W(=N FASIN EI)=NAI KAI\ TA\ ME/TALLA. PRO\S DE\ TOU/TOIS KAI\ TO\ PU=R AU)TOKI/NHTO/N E)STI, TA/XA DE\ KAI\ AI( PHGAI/. TW=N DE\ E)N E(AUTOI=S TOU= KINEI=SQAI TH\N AI)TI/AN E)XO/NTWN TA\ ME/N FASIN E)C E(AUTW=N KINEI=SQAI TA\ DE\ A)F' E(AUTW=N, E)C E(AUTW=N ME\N TA\ A)/YUXA, A)F' @1 E(AUTW=N DE\ TA\ E)/MYUXA: A)F' E(AUTW=N GA\R KINEI=TAI TA\ E)/MYUXA FANTASI/AS E)GGI-NOME/NHS O(RMH\N PROKALOUME/NHS: KAI\ PA/LIN E)/N TISI TW=N ZW/|WN FANTASI/AI GI/NON-TAI O(RMH\N PROKALOU/MENAI, FU/SEWS FANTASTIKH=S TETAGME/NWS KINOU/SHS TH\N O(RMH/N, W(S E)N TW=| A)RA/XNH| FANTASI/A TOU= U(FAI/NEIN GI/NETAI, KAI\ O(RMH\ A)KOLOUQEI= E)PI\ TO\ U(FAI/NEIN, _TH=S FANTASTIKH=S AU)TOU= FU/SEWS TETAGME/NWS E)PI\ TOU=TO AU)TO\N PROKALOUME/NHS KAI\ OU)DENO\S A)/LLOU META\ TH\N FANTASTIKH\N AU)TOU= FU/SIN PEPISTEUME/NOU TOU= ZW/|OU_KAI\ E)N TH=| MELI/SSH| E)PI\ TO\ KHROPLASTEI=N. *TO\ ME/NTOI LOGIKO\N ZW=|ON KAI\ LO/GON E)/XEI PRO\S TH=| FANTASTIKH=| FU/SEI TO\N KRI/NONTA TA\S FANTASI/AS, KAI\ TINA\S ME\N A)PODOKIMA/ZONTA, TINA\S DE\ PARADEXO/MENON, I(/NA A)/GHTAI TO\ ZW=|ON KAT' AU)TA/S. O(/QEN E)PEI\ E)N TH=| FU/SEI TOU= LO/GOU EI)SI\N A)FOR-MAI\ TOU= QEWRH=SAI TO\ KALO\N KAI\ TO\ AI)SXRO/N, AI(=S E(PO/MENOI QEWRH/SANTES TO\ KALO\N KAI\ TO\ AI)SXRO/N, AI(ROU/MEQA ME\N TO\ KALO/N, E)KKLI/NOMEN DE\ TO\ AI)SXRO/N: E)PAINETOI\ ME/N E)SMEN E)PIDO/NTES E(AUTOU\S TH=| PRA/CEI TOU= KALOU=, YEKTOI\ DE\ KATA\ TO\ E)NANTI/ON. OU)K A)GNOHTE/ON ME/NTOI GE O(/TI TO\ PLE/ON TH=S EI)S PA/NTA TETAGME/-NHS FU/SEWS POSW=S E)STIN E)N TOI=S ZW/|OIS, E)PI\ PLE/ON DE\ H)\ E)PI\ TO\ E)/LATTON, W(/STE E)GGU/S POU EI)=NAI, I(/N' OU(/TWS EI)/PW, TOU= LOGIKOU= TO\ E)N TOI=S I)XNEUTAI=S KUSI\N E)/RGON KAI\ E)N TOI=S POLEMIKOI=S I(/PPOIS. TO\ ME\N OU)=N U(POPESEI=N TO/DE TI TW=N E)/CWQEN FANTASI/AN H(MI=N KINOU=N TOIA/NDE H)\ TOIA/NDE, O(MOLOGOUME/NWS OU)K E)/STI TW=N E)F' H(MI=N: TO\ DE\ KRI=NAI OU(TWSI\ XRH/SASQAI TW=| GENOME/NW| H)\ E(TE/RWS OU)K A)/LLOU TINO\S E)/RGON H)\ TOU= E)N H(MI=N LO/GOU E)STI/N, H)/TOI PARA\ TA\S A)FORMA\S E)NER-GOU=NTOS [H(MA=S PRO\S] TA\S E)PI\ TO\ KALO\N PRO[S]KALOUME/NAS KAI\ TO\ KAQH=KON [O(RMA/S] H)\ E)PI\ TO\ E)NANTI/ON E)KTRE/PONTOS. *EI) DE/ TIS AU)TO\ TO\ E)/CWQEN LE/GEI EI)=NAI TOIO/NDE, W(/STE A)DUNA/TWS E)/XEIN A)NTIBLE/YAI AU)TW=| TOIW=|DE GENOME/NW|, OU(=TOS E)PISTHSA/TW TOI=S I)DI/OIS PA/QESI KAI\ KINH/MASIN, EI) MH\ EU)DO/KHSIS GI/NETAI KAI\ SUGKATA/QESIS KAI\ R(OPH\ TOU= H(GEMONIKOU= E)PI\ TO/DE TI DIA\ TA/SDE TA\S PIQANO/TH-TAS. OU) GA/R, FE/R' EI)PEI=N, H( GUNH\ TW=| KRI/NANTI E)GKRATEU/ESQAI KAI\ A)NE/XEIN E(AUTO\N A)PO\ MI/CEWN E)PIFANEI=SA KAI\ PROKALESAME/NH E)PI\ TO\ POIH=SAI/ TI PARA\ PRO/QESIN AU)TOTELH\S AI)TI/A GI/NETAI TOU= TH\N PRO/QESIN A)QETH=SAI. PA/NTWS GA\R EU)DOKH/SAS TW=| GARGALISMW=| KAI\ TW=| LEI/W| TH=S H(DONH=S, A)NTIBLE/YAI AU)TW=| MH\ BE-BOULHME/NOS MHDE\ TO\ KEKRIME/NON KURW=SAI, PRA/TTEI TO\ A)KO/LASTON. O( DE/ TIS E)/MPALIN, TW=N AU)TW=N SUMBEBHKO/TWN AU)TW=| PLEI/ONA MAQH/MATA A)NEILHFO/TI KAI\ H)SKHKO/TI, OI( ME\N GARGALISMOI\ KAI\ OI( E)REQISMOI\ SUMBAI/NOUSIN: O( LO/GOS DE\ A(/TE E)PI\ PLEI=ON I)SXUROPOIHQEI\S KAI\ TRAFEI\S TH=| MELE/TH| KAI\ BEBAIWQEI\S TOI=S DO/GMASI PRO\S TO\ KALO\N H)\ E)GGU/S GE TOU= BEBAIWQH=NAI GEGENHME/NOS, A)NAKROU/EI TOU\S E)REQISMOU\S KAI\ U(PEKLU/EI TH\N E)PIQUMI/AN. @&10Origenes de oratione 6 Vol. II p. 311, 16 Ko+. [1p. 206 ed. De-&10larue$10]1. *TW=N KINOUME/NWN TA\ ME/N TINA TO\ KINOU=N E)/CWQEN E)/XEI, W(/SPER TA\ A)/YUXA KAI\ U(PO\ E(/CEWS MO/NHS SUNEXO/MENA: KAI\ TA\ U(PO\ FU/SEWS KAI\ YUXH=S KINOU/MENA OU)X H(=| TOIAU=TA E)/SQ' O(/TE KINOU/MENA, A)LL' O(MOI/WS TOI=S U(PO\ E(/CEWS MO/NHS SUNEXO-ME/NOIS. *LI/QOI GA\R KAI\ CU/LA TA\ E)KKOPE/NTA TOU= META/LLOU H)\ TO\ FU/EIN A)POLW-LEKO/TA, U(PO\ E(/CEWS MO/NHS SUNEXO/MENA, TO\ KINOU=N E)/CWQEN E)/XEI. A)LLA\ KAI\ TA\ TW=N ZW/|WN SW/MATA KAI\ TA\ FORHTA\ TW=N PEFUTEUME/NWN U(PO/ TINOS METATIQE/MENA, OU)X H(=| ZW=|A KAI\ FUTA\ METATI/QETAI, A)LL' O(MOI/WS LI/QOIS KAI\ CU/LOIS TOI=S TO\ FU/EIN A)POLWLEKO/SI: KA)\N FQI/NH| DE\ KAQ' AU(TA/, TW=| R(EUSTA\ EI)=NAI PA/NTA TA\ SW/MATA FQI/NONTA PARAKOLOUQHTIKH\N E)/XEI TH\N E)N TW=| FQI/NEIN KI/NHSIN. _ @1 DEU/TERA DE\ PARA\ TAU=TA/ E)STI KINOU/MENA TA\ U(PO\ TH=S E)NUPARXOU/SHS FU/SEWS H)\ YUXH=S KINOU/MENA, A(\ KAI\ E)C AU(TW=N KINEI=SQAI LE/GETAI PARA\ TOI=S KURIW/TERON XRWME/NOIS TOI=S O)NO/MASI. TRI/TH DE/ E)STI KI/NHSIS H( E)N TOI=S ZW/|OIS, H(/TIS O)NOMA/-ZETAI H( A)F' AU(TOU= KI/NHSIS. OI)=MAI DE\ O(/TI H( TW=N LOGIKW=N KI/NHSIS DI' AU(TW=N E)STI KI/NHSIS. E)A\N DE\ PERIE/LWMEN A)PO\ TOU= ZW/|OU TH\N A)P' AU)TOU= KI/NHSIN, OU)DE\ ZW=|ON E)/TI O)\N U(PONOHQH=NAI DU/NATAI, A)LLA\ E)/STAI O(/MOION H)/TOI FUTW=| U(PO\ FU/-SEWS MO/NHS KINOUME/NW|, H)\ LI/QW| U(PO/ TINOS E)/CWQEN FEROME/NW|. E)A\N DE\ PARA-KOLOUQH=| TI TH=| I)DI/A| KINH/SEI, E)PEI\ TOU=TO DI' AU)TOU= KINEI=SQAI W)NOMA/SAMEN, A)NA/GKH TOU=TO EI)=NAI LOGIKO/N. _ @*OI( TOI/NUN QE/LONTES MHDE\N EI)=NAI E)F' H(MI=N, A)NAGKAI/WS H)LIQIW/TATO/N TI PARADE/CONTAI, PRW=TON ME\N O(/TI OU)K E)SME\N ZW=|A, DEU/TERON DE\ O(/TI OU)DE\ LOGIKA/, A)LL' OI(=ON U(PO\ E)/CWQEN KINOU=NTOS, AU)TOI\ OU)DAMW=S KINOU/MENOI, POIEI=N U(P' E)KEI/-NOU LEGOI/MEQ' [2A)/N]2 A(\ POIEI=N NOMIZO/MEQA: A)/LLWS TE KAI\ TOI=S I)DI/OIS PA/QESIN E)PISTH/SAS TIS O(RA/TW, EI) MH\ A)NAIDW=S E)REI=, MH\ AU)TO\S QE/LEIN KAI\ MH\ AU)TO\S ݈E)SQI/EIN KAI\ MH\ AU)TO\S PERIPATEI=N, MHDE\ AU)TO\S SUGKATATI/QESQAI KAI\ PARADE/-XESQAI O(POI=A DH/POTE TW=N DOGMA/TWN, MHDE\ AU)TO\S A)NANEU/EIN PRO\S E(/TERA W(S YEUDH=. _*(/WSPER OU)=N PRO/S TINA DO/GMATA A)MH/XANON DIATEQH=NAI A)/NQRWPON, KA)\N MURIA/KIS AU)TA\ KATASKEUA/ZH| EU(RESILOGW=N KAI\ PIQANOI=S LO/GOIS XRW/MENOS: OU(/TWS A)DU/NATON DIATEQEI=SQAI/ TINA PERI\ TW=N A)NQRWPI/NWN W(S MHDAMW=S TOU= E)F' H(MI=N SW|ZOME/NOU. TI/S GA\R DIA/KEITAI PERI\ TOU= MHDE\N EI)=NAI KATALHPTO\N H)\ OU(/TWS BIOI= W(S E)PE/XWN PERI\ PANTO\S OU(TINOSOU=N; TI/S DE\ OU)K E)PIPLH/TTEI, FAN-TASI/AN A(MARTH/SANTOS OI)KE/TOU LABW/N, TW=| QERA/PONTI; KAI\ TI/S E)STIN O(\S MH\ AI)-TIA=TAI UI(O\N TO\ PRO\S GONEI=S KAQH=KON MH\ A)PODIDO/NTA; H)\ MH\ ME/MFETAI KAI\ YE/GEI W(S AI)SXRO\N PEPOIHKUI=AN TH\N MEMOIXEUME/NHN; BIA/ZETAI GA\R H( A)LH/QEIA KAI\ A)NAGKA/ZEI, KA)\N MURIA/KIS TIS EU(RESILOGH=|, O(RMA=N KAI\ E)PAINEI=N KAI\ YE/GEIN, W(S THROUME/NOU TOU= E)F' H(MI=N KAI\ TOU/TOU E)PAINETOU= H)\ YEKTOU= GINOME/NOU PAR' H(MA=S. _ @*EI) DH\ TO\ E)F' H(MI=N SW/|ZETAI, MURI/AS O(/SAS A)PONEU/SEIS E)/XON PRO\S A)RETH\N H)\ KAKI/AN, KAI\ PA/LIN PRO\S TO\ KAQH=KON H)\ PRO\S TO\ PARA\ TO\ KAQH=KON, A)NAG-KAI/WS TOU=TO META\ TW=N LOIPW=N, PRI\N GE/NHTAI, TW=| QEW=| E)/GNWSTAI A)PO\ KTI/SEWS KAI\ KATABOLH=S KO/SMOU, O(POI=ON E)/STAI: KAI\ E)N PA=SIN OI(=S PRODIATA/SSETAI O( QEO/S, A)KOLOU/QWS OI(=S E(W/RAKE PERI\ E(KA/STOU E)/RGOU TW=N E)F' H(MI=N, PRODIATE/TA-KTAI KAT' A)CI/AN E(KA/STW| KINH/MATI TW=N E)F' H(MI=N TO\ KAI\ A)PO\ TH=S PRONOI/AS AU)TW=| A)PANTHSO/MENON, E)/TI DE\ KAI\ KATA\ TO\N EI(RMO\N TW=N E)SOME/NWN SUMBHSO/ME-NON, OU)XI\ TH=S PROGNW/SEWS TOU= QEOU= AI)TI/AS GINOME/NHS TOI=S E)SOME/NOIS PA=SI KAI\ E)K TOU= E)F' H(MI=N KATA\ TH\N O(RMH\N H(MW=N E)NERGHQHSOME/NOIS. EI) GA\R KAI\ KAQ' U(PO/QESIN MH\ GINW/SKOI O( QEO\S TA\ E)SO/MENA, OU) PARA\ TOU=TO A)POLOU=MEN TO\ TA/DE TINA\ E)NERGH/SEIN KAI\ TA/DE QELH/SEIN: PLE/ON DE\ A)PO\ TH=S PROGNW/SEWS GI/NETAI TO\ KATA/TACIN LAMBA/NEIN EI)S TH\N TOU= PANTO\S DIOI/KHSIN, XREIW/DH TH=| TOU= KO/SMOU KATASTA/SEI, TO\ E(KA/STOU E)F' H(MI=N. @&10Vol. II p. 314, 4 Ko+. [1p. 208 Del.$10]1. E)A\N DE/ TIS TARA/TTHTAI DIA\ TO\ MH\ OU) YEU/SASQAI TO\N QEO\N TA\ ME/LLONTA PROEGNWKO/TA, W(S TW=N PRAGMA/TWN KATH-NAGKASME/NWN, LEKTE/ON PRO\S TO\N TOIOU=TON, O(/TI AU)TO\ TOU=TO E)/GNWSTAI TW=| QEW=| A)RARO/TWS, TO\ MH\ A)RARO/TWS TO/NDE TINA\ TO\N A)/NQRWPON KAI\ BEBAI/WS BOU/LESQAI TA\ KREI/TTONA H)\ OU(/TW QELH/SEIN TA\ XEI/RONA, W(/STE A)NEPI/DEKTON AU)TO\N E)/SESQAI METABOLH=S TH=S E)PI\ TA\ SUMFE/RONTA. @1 @&10Origenes de principiis lib. III p. 110 ed. Delarue.$10 *TO\ DE\ TOU/-TWN OU(/TWS H(MI=N GINOME/NWN [2TA\]2 E)/CWQEN AI)TIA=SQAI KAI\ E(AUTOU\S A)POLU/EIN E)GKLH/MATOS, O(MOI/OUS E(AUTOU\S A)POFAINOME/NOUS CU/LOIS KAI\ LI/QOIS E(LKUSQEI=SIN U(PO\ TW=N E)/CWQEN AU)TA\ KINHSA/NTWN, OU)K A)LHQE\S OU)DE\ EU)/GNWMON, BOULOME/NOU TE LO/GOS E)STI\N O( TOIOU=TOS TH\N E)/NNOIAN TOU= AU)TECOUSI/OU PARAXARA/TTEIN. EI) GA\R PUQOI/MEQA AU)TOU= TI/ H)=N TO\ AU)TECOU/SION, LE/GOI A)\N O(/TI "1EI) MHDE\N TW=N E)/CWQEN A)PH/NTA, E)MOU= TO/DE TI PROQEME/NOU, TO\ E)PI\ TO\ E)NANTI/ON PROKALOU/ME-NON."2 _PA/LIN TE AU)= YILH\N TH\N KATASKEUH\N AI)TIA=SQAI, PARA\ TO\ E)NARGE/S E)STI, LO/GOU PAIDEUTIKOU= TOU\S A)KRATESTE/ROUS KAI\ TOU\S A)GRIWTA/TOUS PARALAM-BA/NONTOS, EI) TH=| PROTROPH=| PARAKOLOUQH/SAIEN, KAI\ METABA/LLONTOS, W(/STE PARA\ POLU\ GEGONE/NAI TH\N TROPH\N KAI\ TH\N E)PI\ TO\ KREI=TTON METABOLH/N, POLLA/KIS TW=N A)KOLASTOTA/TWN BELTIO/NWN GENOME/NWN PARA\ TOU\S TH=| FU/SEI PRO/TERON OU) DOKOU=NTAS EI)=NAI TOIOU/TOUS, KAI\ TW=N A)GRIWTA/TWN EI)S TOSOU=TON H(MERO/THTOS META-BALLO/NTWN, W(/STE TOU\S MHDE\ PW/POTE OU(/TWS A)GRIWQE/NTAS A)GRI/OUS EI)=NAI DOKEI=N SUGKRI/SEI TOU=DE/ TINOS METABEBLHKO/TOS E)PI\ TO\ H(/MERON. O(RW=ME/N TE E(TE/ROUS EU)STAQESTA/TOUS KAI\ SEMNOTA/TOUS E)K DIASTROFH=S E)PI\ TA\S XEI/ROUS DIATRIBA\S E)KKROUOME/NOUS TOU= SEMNOU= KAI\ EU)STAQOU=S, W(/STE EI)S A)KOLASI/AN AU)TOU\S META-BALEI=N, POLLA/KIS A)RXOME/NHS TH=S A)KOLASI/AS MESOU/SHS TH=S H(LIKI/AS, KAI\ E)MPI/P-TONTAS EI)S A)TACI/AN META\ TO\ PARELHLUQE/NAI TO\ TH=S NEO/THTOS O(/SON E)PI\ TH=| FU/SEI A)/STATON. OU)KOU=N O( LO/GOS DEI/KNUSIN O(/TI TA\ ME\N E)/CWQEN OU)K E)F' H(MI=N E)STI, TO\ DE\ OU(/TWS H)\ E)NANTI/WS XRH/SASQAI AU)TOI=S TO\N LO/GON KRITH\N PARALA-BO/NTA KAI\ E)CETASTH\N TOU= PW=S DEI= PRO\S TA/DE TINA\ TW=N E)/CWQEN A)PANTH=SAI, E)/RGON E)STI\ H(ME/TERON. @&Nemesius de nat. hom. c. 35 p. 258.$ OI( DE\ LE/GONTES O(/TI KAI\ TO\ E)F' H(MI=N KAI\ TO\ KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN SW/|ZETAI [1E(KA/STW| GA\R TW=N GINO-ME/NWN DEDO/SQAI TI KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN, W(S TW=| U(/DATI TO\ YU/XEIN KAI\ E(KA/STW| TW=N FUTW=N TO\ TOIO/NDE KARPO\N FE/REIN, KAI\ TW=| LI/QW| TO\ KATWFERE\S KAI\ TW=| PURI\ TO\ A)NWFERE/S, OU(/TW KAI\ TW=| ZW/|W| TO\ SUGKATATI/QESQAI KAI\ O(RMA=N: O(/TAN DE\ TAU/TH| TH=| O(RMH=| MHDE\N A)NTIPE/SH| TW=N E)/CWQEN KAI\ KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN, TO/TE TO\ PERIPATEI=N TE/LEON E)F' H(MI=N EI)=NAI KAI\ PA/NTWS PERIPATH/SOMEN]1 OI( TAU=TA LE/GONTES_EI)SI\ DE\ TW=N *STWI+KW=N <20*XRU/SIP-PO/S>20 TE KAI\ *FILOPA/TWR KAI\ A)/LLOI POLLOI\ KAI\ LAMPROI/, OU)DE\N E(/TERON A)PODEIKNU/OUSIN H)\ PA/NTA KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN GI/NESQAI. EI) GA\R KAI\ TA\S O(RMA\S PARA\ TH=S EI(MARME/NHS FASI\N H(MI=N DEDO/SQAI, KAI\ TAU/TAS POTE\ ME\N U(PO\ TH=S EI(MARME/NHS E)MPODI/ZESQAI, POTE\ DE\ MH/, DH=LON W(S PA/NTA KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN GI/NETAI KAI\ TA\ DOKOU=NTA E)F' H(MI=N EI)=NAI. __EI) GA\R TW=N AU)TW=N AI)TI/WN PERIESTHKO/TWN, <20W(/S FASIN AU)TOI/>20, PA=SA A)NA/GKH TA\ AU)TA\ GI/NESQAI KAI\ OU)X OI(=O/NTE POTE\ ME\N OU(/TWS POTE\ D' A)/LLWS GE-NE/SQAI, DIA\ TO\ E)C AI)W=NOS A)POKEKLHRW=SQAI TAU=TA, A)NA/GKH KAI\ TH\N O(RMH\N TH\N TOU= ZW/|OU PA/NTH TE KAI\ PA/NTWS TW=N AU)TW=N AI)TI/WN PERIESTH-KO/TWN OU(/TWS GENE/SQAI. &et paullo infra%10$ EI) GA\R TH\N O(RMH\N E)F' H(MI=N TA/TTOUSIN, O(/TI FU/SEI TAU/THN E)/XOMEN, TI/ KWLU/EI KAI\ E)PI\ TW=| PURI\ LE/-GEIN EI)=NAI TO\ KAI/EIN, E)PEIDH\ FU/SEI KAI/EI TO\ PU=R; W(/S POU KAI\ PAREM-FAI/NEIN E)/OIKEN O( <20*FILOPA/TWR>20 E)N TW=| PERI\ EI(MARME/NHS. @1 @&10Clemens Al. Stromat. II p. 458 Pott.$10 TA\S DE\ SUGKATAQE/SEIS OU) MO/NON OI( A)PO\ *PLA/TWNOS A)LLA\ KAI\ <20OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 E)F' H(MI=N EI)=NAI LE/GOUSIN: PA=SA OU)=N DO/CA KAI\ KRI/SIS KAI\ U(PO/LHYIS KAI\ MA/QHSIS__SUGKATA/QESI/S E)STIN. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 47 p. 1056e.$ *)/ANEU DE\ TOU/-TWN, EI) ME\N AI( FANTASI/AI MH\ GI/NONTAI KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN, [2PW=S AI)TI/A]2 TW=N SUGKATAQE/SEWN: EI) D' O(/TI POIEI= FANTASI/AS A)GWGOU\S E)PI\ TH\N SUGKA-TA/QESIN, KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN AI( SUGKATAQE/SEIS GI/NESQAI LE/GONTAI, PW=S OU) MA/XETAI PRO\S E(AUTH\N POLLA/KIS E)N TOI=S MEGI/STOIS DIAFO/ROUS POIOU=SA FANTASI/AS KAI\ PERISPW/SAS E)PI\ TA)NANTI/A TH\N DIA/NOIAN; O(/TE TOU\S PROS-TIQEME/NOUS TH=| E(TE/RA| KAI\ MH\ E)PE/XONTAS, A(MARTA/NEIN LE/GOUSIN: <20A)\N ME\N A)DH/LOIS EI)/KWSI PROPI/PTONTAS, A)\N DE\ YEUDE/SI, DIAYEUDOME/-NOUS: A)\N DE\ KOINW=S A)KATALH/PTOIS, DOCA/ZONTAS>20. *KAI/TOI DEI=, TRIW=N O)/NTWN, H)\ MH\ PA=SAN EI)=NAI FANTASI/AN EI(MARME/NHS E)/RGON, H)\ PA=SAN PARADOXH\N FANTASI/AS KAI\ SUGKATA/QESIN A)NAMA/RTHTON, H)\ MHDE\ AU)TH\N TH\N EI(MARME/NHN A)NEPI/LHPTON: OU)K OI)=DA GA/R, O(/PWS A)NE/GKLHTO/S E)STI TOIAU/TAS POIOU=SA FANTASI/AS, AI(=S TO\ MH\ MA/XESQAI MHD' A)NTIBAI/NEIN, A)LL' E(/PESQAI KAI\ EI)/KEIN, E)/GKLHTO/N E)STI. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. 47 p. 1055f.$ *)ALLA\ MH\N KAI\ TA\ PERI\ TW=N FANTASIW=N LEGO/MENA NEANIKW=S PRO\S TH\N EI(MARME/NHN E)NAN-TIOU=TAI. *TH\N GA\R FANTASI/AN BOULO/MENOS OU)K OU)=SAN AU)TOTELH= TH=S SUGKATAQE/SEWS AI)TI/AN A)PODEIKNU/EIN, EI)/RHKEN O(/TI "1<20BLA/YOUSIN OI( SOFOI\ YEUDEI=S FANTASI/AS E)MPOIOU=NTES, A)\N AI( FANTASI/AI POIW=SIN AU)TOTELW=S TA\S SUGKATAQE/SEIS: POLLA/KIS GA\R OI( SO-FOI\ YEU/DEI XRW=NTAI PRO\S TOU\S FAU/LOUS KAI\ FANTASI/AN PA-RISTA=SI PIQANH/N, OU) MH\N AI)TI/AN TH=S SUGKATAQE/SEWS: E)PEI\ KAI\ TH=S U(POLH/YEWS AI)TI/A TH=S YEUDOU=S E)/STAI KAI\ TH=S A)PA/THS>20."2 @&10Augustinus de civ. dei V 10. Unde nec illa necessitas formi-&10danda est, quam formidando <21Stoici laboraverunt causas rerum ita &10distinguere, ut quasdam subtraherent necessitati, quasdam sub-&10derent, atque in his, quas esse sub necessitate noluerunt, po-&10suerunt etiam nostras voluntates>21, ne videlicet non essent liberae, &10si subderentur necessitati. &10@Origenes comment. in Genesin Tom. II p. 13 Delarue.$10 O(/TI ME/N-TOI GE POLLW=N TW=N E)F' H(MI=N AI)/TIA PLEI=STA TW=N OU)K E)F' H(MI=N E)STI KAI\ H(MEI=S O(MOLOGH/SOMEN: W(=N MH\ GENOME/NWN, LE/GW DE\ TW=N OU)K E)F' H(MI=N, OU)K A)\N TA/DE TINA\ TW=N E)F' H(MI=N E)PRA/TTETO: PRA/TTETAI DE\ TA/DE TINA\ TW=N E)F' H(MI=N A)KO/LOUQA TOI=SDE TOI=S PROGENOME/NOIS OU)K E)F' H(MI=N, E)NDEXOME/NOU TOU= E)PI\ TOI=S AU)TOI=S PROGENOME/NOIS KAI\ E(/TERA PRA=CAI PAR' A(\ PRA/TTOMEN. EI) DE/ TIS ZHTEI= TO\ E)F' H(MI=N A)POLELUME/NON EI)=NAI TOU= PANTO\S W(/STE MH\ DIA\ TA/DE TINA\ SUMBEBHKO/TA H(MI=N H(MA=S AI(REI=SQAI TA/DE, E)PILE/LHSTAI KO/SMOU ME/ROS W)\N KAI\ E)MPERIEXO/MENOS A)NQRW/PWN KOINWNI/A| KAI\ TOU= PERIE/XONTOS. @1 @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 47 p. 1056b.$ *(O DE\ LE/GWN O(/TI *XRU/SIPPOS OU)K AU)TOTELH= TOU/TWN AI)TI/AN [1&sc.$ TOU= KATORQOU=N KAI\ FRONEI=N]1 A)LLA\ PROKATARKTIKH\N MO/NON E)POIEI=TO TH\N EI(MARME/NHN, E)KEI= PA/LIN AU)TO\N A)PODEI/CEI MAXO/MENON PRO\S AU(TO/N, O(/POU TO\N ME\N *(/OMHRON U(PERFUW=S E)PAINEI= PERI\ TOU= *DIO\S LE/GONTA [1&O 109$]1 @*TW=| E)/XEQ' O(/TTI KEN U)/MMI KAKO\N PE/MPHSIN E(KA/STW| H)\ A)GAQO/N: KAI\ TO\N *EU)RIPI/DHN [1&Suppl. 734$]1 @*)=W *ZEU=, TI/ DH=TA TOU\S TALAIPW/ROUS BROTOU\S @FRONEI=N LE/GOIM' A)/N; SOU= GA\R E)CHRTH/MEQA, @DRW=ME/N TE TOIA/D', A(\ SU/ [2GE]2 TUGXA/NEIS FRONW=N. AU)TO\S DE\ POLLA\ TOU/TOIS O(MOLOGOU/MENA GRA/FEI, TE/LOS DE/ FHSI MHDE\N I)/SXESQAI MHDE\ KINEI=SQAI MHDE\ TOU)LA/XISTON A)/LLWS H)\ KATA\ TO\N TOU= *DIO\S LO/GON: O(\N TH=| EI(MARME/NH| TO\N AU)TO\N EI)=NAI. *)/ETI TOI/NUN TO\ ME\N PROKATARKTIKO\N AI)/TION A)SQENE/STERO/N E)STI TOU= AU)TOTELOU=S, KAI\ OU)K E)CIKNEI=TAI KRATOU/MENON U(P' A)/LLWN E)CANISTAME/NWN: TH\N D' EI(MARME/NHN AI)TI/AN A)NI/KHTON KAI\ A)KW/LUTON KAI\ A)/TREPTON A)POFAI/NWN, AU)TO\S *)/ATRO-PON KALEI= KAI\ *)ADRA/STEIAN KAI\ *)ANA/GKHN KAI\ *PEPRWME/NHN, W(S PE/RAS A(/PASIN E)PITIQEI=SAN. [1&dein Plutarchus probare studet, si talis exstet &fatalis necessitas, qualem fingit Chrysippus, liberum hominum arbi-&trium tolli,$ TO\ E)F' H(MI=N KAI\ TO\ E(KOU/SION A)NAIREI=SQAI]1. @&Diogenianus apud Eusebium praep. evang. VI p. 265d.$8 *)EN ME\N OU)=N TW=| PRW/TW| <20*PERI\ EI(MARME/NHS>20 BIBLI/W| TOIAU/TAIS TISI\N A)PODEI/-CESIN KE/XRHTAI, <20E)N DE\ TW=| DEUTE/RW|>20 LU/EIN PEIRA=TAI TA\ A)KOLOUQEI=N DO-KOU=NTA A)/TOPA TW=| LO/GW| TW=| PA/NTA KATHNAGKA/SQAI LE/GONTI, A(/PER KAI\ H(MEI=S KAT' A)RXA\S E)TI/QEMEN: OI(=ON TO\ A)NAIREI=SQAI DI' AU)TOU= TH\N E)C H(MW=N AU)TW=N PROQUMI/AN PERI\ YO/GOUS TE KAI\ E)PAI/NOUS KAI\ PROTROPA\S KAI\ PA/NQ' O(/SA PARA\ TH\N H(METE/RAN AI)TI/AN GINO/MENA FAI/NETAI. @FHSI\N OU)=N <20E)N TW=| DEUTE/RW| BIBLI/W|>20 "1TO\ ME\N E)C H(MW=N POLLA\ GI/-NESQAI DH=LON EI)=NAI, OU)DE\N DE\ H(=TTON SUGKAQEIMA/RQAI KAI\ TAU=TA TH=| TW=N O(/LWN DIOIKH/SEI."2 KE/XRHTAI/ TE PARADEI/GMASI TOIOU/TOIS TISI/. @"1<20TO\ GA\R MH\ A)POLEI=SQAI>20, FHSI/, <20QOIMA/TION OU)X A(PLW=S KAQEI/-MARTO, A)LLA\ META\ TOU= FULA/TTESQAI, KAI\ TO\ E)K TW=N POLEMI/WN SWQH/SESQAI TO/NDE TINA\ META\ TOU= FEU/GEIN AU)TO\N TOU\S POLE-MI/OUS: KAI\ TO\ GENE/SQAI PAI=DAS META\ TOU= BOU/LESQAI KOINWNEI=N GUNAIKI/. W(/SPER GA/R>20, FHSI/N, <20LE/GONTO/S TINOS *(HGH/SARXON TO\N PU/KTHN E)CELEU/SESQAI TOU= A)GW=NOS PA/NTWS A)/PLHKTON, A)TO/PWS A)/N TIS H)CI/OU KAQIE/NTA TA\S XEI=RAS TO\N *(HGH/SARXON MA/XESQAI, E)PEI\ A)/PLHKTON AU)TO\N KAQEI/MARTO A)PELQEI=N, TOU= TH\N A)PO/FASIN POIHSAME/NOU DIA\ TH\N PERITTOTE/RAN TA)NQRW/POU PRO\S TO\ MH\ PLH/TTESQAI FULAKH\N TOU=TO EI)PO/NTOS, OU(/TW KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N A)/LLWN E)/XEI. POLLA\ GA\R MH\ DU/NASQAI GENE/SQAI XWRI\S TOU= KAI\ H(MA=S @1 BOU/LESQAI KAI\ E)KTENESTA/THN GE PERI\ AU)TA\ PROQUMI/AN TE KAI\ SPOUDH\N EI)SFE/RESQAI, E)PEIDH\ META\ TOU/TOU, FHSI/N, AU)TA\ GE-NE/SQAI KAQEI/MARTO>20."2 @&p. 266d.$8 "1<20A)LLA\ PAR' H(MA=S ME\N E)/STAI, FHSI/, PERIEILHMME/NOU ME/NTOI TOU= PAR' H(MA=S U(PO\ TH=S EI(MARME/NHS>20."2 @&p. 267a.$8 KAI\ E)C AU)TH=S DE\ TH=S DIASTOLH=S, H(\N POIEI=TAI <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20, DH=LON GI/NETAI TO\ A)POLELU/SQAI TH=S EI(MARME/NHS TH\N PAR' H(MA=S AI)TI/AN. KAQEI/MARTAI GA/R, FHSI/, SWQH=NAI QOIMA/TION, EI) FULA/TTOIS AU)TO/, KAI\ PAI=-DAS E)/SESQAI, EI) KAI\ SU\ BOULHQEI/HS, A)/LLWS DE\ MH\ A)\N E)/SESQAI/ TI TOU/TWN. E)PI\ DE\ TW=N U(PO\ TH=S EI(MARME/NHS PROKATEILHMME/NWN OU)K A)/N POTE U(POTI-MH/SESI TOIAU/TAIS XRHSAI/MEQA &etc. &@Diogenianus apud Eusebium Praep. evang. VI p. 262c.$8 [OU) QEWRW=N O(/TI TA\ A)LLAXOU= PA/LIN PARA\ TW=| POIHTH=| LEGO/MENA TOU/TOIS A)/NTI-KRUS H)NANTI/WTAI] OI(=S KAI\ AU)TO\S [1&sc. <21Chrysippus>21$8]1 <20E)N TW=| DEUTE/RW| BIBLI/W|>20 [1&sc.$8 <20PERI\ EI(MARME/NHS>20]1 XRH=TAI, BOULO/MENOS SUNISTA=N "1TO\ KAI\ PAR' H(MA=S POLLA\ GI/NESQAI"2 OI(=ON TO\ [1&Od.$ A& 7$8]1 @<20AU)TOI\ GA\R SFETE/RH|SIN A)TASQALI/H|SIN O)/LONTO. KAI\ TO\>20 [1&ibid. 32_34$8]1 @<20W)= PO/POI, OI(=ON DH/ NU QEOU\S BROTOI\ AI)TIO/WNTAI. @E)C H(MW=N GA/R FASI KA/K' E)/MMENAI, OI( DE\ KAI\ AU)TOI\ @SFH=|SIN A)TASQALI/H|SIN U(PE\R MO/RON A)/LGE' E)/XOUSI>20. @&Gellius N. A. VII 2.&3 Fatum, quod$8 EI(MARME/NHN&3 Graeci vocant, &3ad hanc ferme sententiam <21Chrysippus>21, Stoicae princeps philosophiae, &3definit%10 "1<21Fatum est>21"2, inquit, "1<21sempiterna quaedam et indeclinabi-&3lis series rerum et catena, volvens semetipsa sese et implicans &3per aeternos consequentiae ordines, ex quibus apta nexaque est>21"2. &3Ipsa autem verba Chrysippi, quantum valui memoria, ascripsi, ut, sicui &3meum istud interpretamentum videbitur esse obscurius, ad ipsius verba &3animadvertat. In <21libro>21$8 <20PERI\ PRONOI/AS>20&3 quarto$8 EI(MARME/NHN&3 esse dicit$8 <20FUSIKH/N TINA SU/NTACIN TW=N O(/LWN E)C A)I+DI/OU TW=N E(TE/RWN TOI=S E(TE/ROIS E)PAKOLOUQOU/NTWN KAI\ METAPOLOUME/NWN A)PARABA/TOU OU)/SHS TH=S TOIAU/THS E)PIPLOKH=S>20. @&3Aliarum autem opinionum disciplinarumque auctores huic definitioni &3ita obstrepunt%10 "1Si Chrysippus"2, inquiunt, "1fato putat omnia moveri et &3regi nec declinari transcendique posse agmina fati et volumina, peccata &3quoque hominum et delicta non suscensenda neque inducenda sunt ipsis &3voluntatibusque eorum, sed necessitati cuidam et instantiae, quae oritur &3ex fato, omnium quae sit rerum domina et arbitra, per quam necesse &3sit fieri, quicquid futurum est; et propterea nocentium poenas legibus &3inique constitutas, si homines ad maleficia non sponte veniunt, sed fato &3trahuntur."2 @1 &3@Contra ea <21Chrysippus>21 tenuiter multa et argute disserit; sed om-&3nium fere, quae super ea re scripsit, huiuscemodi sententia est%10 "1Quam-&3quam ita sit"2, inquit, "1ut ratione quadam necessaria et principali coacta &3atque conexa sint fato omnia, ingenia tamen ipsa mentium nostrarum &3proinde sunt fato obnoxia, ut proprietas eorum est ipsa et qualitas. Nam &3si sunt per naturam primitus salubriter utiliterque ficta, omnem illam &3vim quae de fato extrinsecus ingruit, inoffensius tractabiliusque trans-&3mittunt. Sin vero sunt aspera et inscita et rudia nullisque artium bo-&3narum adminiculis fulta, etiamsi parvo sive nullo fatalis incommodi &3conflictu urgeantur, sua tamen scaevitate et voluntario impetu in assidua &3delicta et in errores se ruunt. Idque ipsum ut ea ratione fiat, naturalis &3illa et necessaria rerum consequentia efficit, quae "1fatum"2 vocatur. Est &3enim genere ipso quasi fatale et consequens, ut mala ingenia peccatis et &3erroribus non vacent"2. &3@Huius deinde fere rei exemplo non hercle nimis alieno neque in-&3lepido utitur. "1<21Sicut>21"2 inquit "1<21lapidem cylindrum si per spatia &3terrae prona atque derupta iacias, causa quidem ei et ini-&3tium praecipitantiae fueris, mox tamen ille praeceps volvitur, &3non quia tu id iam facis, sed quoniam ita sese modus eius et 舨&3formae volubilitas habet%10 sic ordo et ratio et necessitas fati &3genera ipsa et principia causarum movet, impetus vero con-&3siliorum mentiumque nostrarum actionesque ipsas voluntas &3cuiusque propria et animorum ingenia moderantur>21."2 Infert &3deinde verba haec, his, quae dixi, congruentia%10 @<20$8*DIO\ KAI\ U(PO\ TW=N *PUQAGOREI/WN EI)/RHTAI: @*GNW/SEI D' A)NQRW/POUS AU)QAI/RETA PH/MAT' E)/XONTAS, W(S TW=N BLABW=N E(KA/STOIS PAR' AU)TOI=S GINOME/NWN KAI\ KAQ' O(R-MH\N AU)TW=N A(MARTANO/NTWN TE KAI\ BLAPTOME/NWN KAI\ KATA\ TH\N AU)TW=N DIA/NOIAN KAI\ QE/SIN>20. @&3Propterea negat oportere ferri audirique homines aut nequam aut &3ignavos et nocentes et audaces, qui, cum in culpa et in maleficio re-&3victi sunt, perfugiunt ad fati necessitatem, tamquam in aliquod fani &3asylum et, quae pessime fecerunt, ea non suae temeritati, sed fato esse &3attribuenda dicunt. &3@Primus autem hoc sapientissimus ille et antiquissimus poetarum &3dixit hisce versibus%10 [1&Od.$ A& 32_34]1 @<20$8*)\W PO/POI, OI(=ON DH/ NU QEOU\S BROTOI\ AI)TIO/WNTAI. @*)EC H(ME/WN GA/R FASI KA/K' E)/MMENAI: OI( DE\ KAI\ AU)TOI\ @*SFH=|SIN A)TASQALI/H|SIN U(PE\R MO/RON A)/LGE' E)/XOUSIN>20. @&Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 33 p. 205, 1 Bruns.$ TO\ DE\ @1 LE/GEIN PLANA=SQAI TOU\S OU)X H(GOUME/NOUS E)N TW=| SW/|ZESQAI TH\N KAQ' O(R-MH\N TW=N ZW/|WN E)NE/RGEIAN H)/DH SW/|ZESQAI KAI\ TO\ E)F' H(MI=N TW=| MH\ PA=N TO\ KAQ' O(RMH\N GINO/MENON E)PI\ TOI=S O(RMW=SIN EI)=NAI, KAI\ DIA\ TOU=TO E)RW-TA=N, EI) MH\ E)NE/RGHMA/ TI TO\ E)F' H(MI=N E)STI, KAI\ LABO/NTAS E)PI\ TOU/TW| PA/LIN E)RWTA=N, EI) MH\ TW=N E)NERGHMA/TWN TA\ ME\N EI)=NAI DOKEI= KAQ' O(RMH/N, TA\ D' OU) KAQ' O(RMH/N, O(\ LABO/NTAS PA/LIN PROSTIQE/NAI TOU/TW| TO\ MH\ TW=N E)NERGHMA/TWN ME/N, MH\ KAQ' O(RMH\N DE\ EI)=NAI/ TI E)F' H(MI=N, OU(= KAI\ AU)TOU= SUGXWROUME/NOU E)PI\ TOU/TOIS LAMBA/NEIN TO\ PA=N TO\ KAQ' O(RMH\N GINO/-MENON E)PI\ TOI=S OU(/TWS E)NERGOU=SIN EI)=NAI, E)PEIDH\ E)N MHDENI\ TW=N A)/LLWS E)NERGOUME/NWN E)STI/, KAI\ DIA\ TOU=TO LE/GEIN SW/|ZESQAI KAT' AU)TOU\S KAI\ TO\ TOIOU=TON E)F' H(MI=N, O(\ DUNATO\N U(F' H(MW=N GE/NESQAI/ TE KAI\ MH/, E)PEIDH\ KAI\ TA\ OU(/TWS GENO/MENA E)N TOI=S KAQ' O(RMH\N GINOME/NOIS E)STI/, PW=S OU) PANTA/PASIN A)GNOOU/NTWN TAU=TA &etc. &@Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 34 p. 205, 24 Bruns.$ LA-BO/NTES GA\R TO\ E(/KASTON TW=N SUNESTW/TWN FU/SEI KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN EI)=NAI TOIOU=TON, O(POI=O/N E)STI, W(S TAU)TOU= O)/NTOS TOU= TE FU/SEI KAI\ TOU= KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN, PROSTIQE/ASIN TO\ "1<20*OU)KOU=N KATA\ TH\N EI(MARME/NHN KAI\ AI)SQH/SETAI TA\ ZW=|A KAI\ O(RMH/SEI, KAI\ TA\ ME\N TW=N ZW/|WN E)NER-GH/SEI MO/NON, TA\ DE\ PRA/CEI TA\ LOGIKA/, KAI\ TA\ ME\N A(MARTH/SE-TAI TA\ DE\ KATORQW/SEI: TAU=TA GA\R TOU/TOIS KATA\ FU/SIN. ME-NO/NTWN DE\ KAI\ A(MARTHMA/TWN KAI\ KATORQWMA/TWN KAI\ TW=N TOIOU/TWN FU/SEWN KAI\ POIOTH/TWN MH\ A)NAIROUME/NWN, KAI\ E)/PAINOI ME/NOUSI KAI\ YO/GOI KAI\ KOLA/SEIS KAI\ TIMAI/. TAU=TA GA\R OU(/TWS E)/XEI A)KOLOUQI/AS TE KAI\ TA/CEWS>20."2 @&Alexander Aprod. de fato cp. 35 p. 207, 4 Bruns.$8 MHDE\ E)KEI=NON DE\ PARALI/PWMEN TO\N LO/GON, W(=| <20QAR)R(OU=SIN>20, W(S DEIKNU/NAI DUNA-ME/NOU TW=N PROKEIME/NWN TI. LE/GOUSIN GA/R. "1<20*OU) GA\R E)/STI ME\N TOI-AU/TH H( EI(MARME/NH, OU)K E)/STI DE\ PEPRWME/NH: [2OU)DE\ E)/STI ME\N PEPRWME/NH]2, OU)K E)/STI DE\ AI)=SA: OU)DE\ E)/STI ME\N AI)=SA, OU)K E)/STI DE\ NE/MESIS: OU)DE\ E)/STI ME\N NE/MESIS, OU)K E)/STI DE\ NO/MOS: OU)D' E)/STI ME\N NO/MOS, OU)K E)/STI DE\ LO/GOS O)RQO\S PROSTAKTIKO\S ME\N W(=N POIHTE/ON, A)PAGOREUTIKO\S DE\ W(=N OU) POIHTE/ON. A)LLA\ A)PAGO-REU/ETAI ME\N TA\ A(MARTANO/MENA, PROSTA/TTETAI DE\ TA\ KATORQW/-MATA. OU)K A)/RA E)/STI ME\N TOIAU/TH H( EI(MARME/NH, OU)K E)/STI DE\ A(MARTH/MATA KAI\ KATORQW/MATA. A)LL' EI) E)/STIN A(MARTH/MATA KAI\ KATORQW/MATA, E)/STIN A)RETH\ KAI\ KAKI/A, EI) DE\ TAU=TA, E)/STI KALO\N @1 KAI\ AI)SXRO/N: A)LLA\ TO\ ME\N KALO\N E)PAINETO/N, TO\ DE\ AI)SXRO\N YEKTO/N. OU)K A)/RA E)/STI ME\N TOIAU/TH H( EI(MARME/NH, OU)K E)/STI DE\ E)PAINETO\N KAI\ YEKTO/N. A)LLA\ TA\ ME\N E)PAINETA\ TIMH=S A)/CIA, TA\ DE\ YEKTA\ KOLA/SEWS. OU)K A)/RA E)/STI ME\N TOIAU/TH H( EI(MARME/NH, OU)K E)/STI DE\ TIMH\ KAI\ KO/LASIS. A)LL' E)/STI ME\N TIMH\ GE/RWS A)CI/-WSIS, H( DE\ KO/LASIS E)PANO/RQWSIS. OU)K A)/RA E)/STI ME\N TOIAU/TH H( EI(MARME/NH, OU)K E)/STI [2DE\]2 GE/RWS A)CI/WSIS KAI\ E)PANO/RQWSIS: EI) DE\ TAU=TA [2MH\]2 A)NH/|RHTAI, ME/NEI, KAI\ PA/NTWN GINOME/NWN KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN, KATORQW/MATA/ TE KAI\ A(MARTH/MATA KAI\ TIMAI\ KAI\ KOLA/SEIS KAI\ GE/RWS A)CIW/SEIS KAI\ E)/PAINOI KAI\ YO/GOI>20"2. @&p. 207, 29.$ TI/S OU)K A)\N AU)TW=N QAUMA/SAI TH\N SU/NQESIN TOU= LO/GOU W(S A)PE/RITTON KAI\ E)C O(MOLOGOUME/NWN KAI\ E)NARGW=N SUNA/GOUSAN; [2H)=]2 TO\ MHDE\N W)/NHNTO A)/RA TH=S PERI\ TOU\S SULLOGISMOU\S A)SXOLI/AS MAKRA=S; QE/MENOI GA\R TO\ TH\N EI(MARME/NHN XRH=SQAI PA=SIN TOI=S GEGONO/SI TE KAI\ GINOME/NOIS KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN, PRO\S TH\N A)KW/LUTON TW=N U(P' AU)TH=S GINOME/NWN E)NE/RGEIAN, OU(/TWS W(S GE/GONEN E(/KASTON AU)TW=N KAI\ FU/SEWS E)/XEI, LI/QW| ME\N W(S LI/QW|, FUTW=| DE\ W(S FUTW=|, ZW/|W| DE\ W(S ZW/|W|, EI) DE\ W(S ZW/|W| KAI\ [2W(S]2 O(RMHTIKW=|, E)N TW=| TIQE/NAI TO\ XRH=SQAI AU)TH\N TW=| ZW/|W| W(S ZW/|W| TE KAI\ O(RMHTIKW=| KAI\ GI/-NESQAI TA\ U(P' AU)TH=S DIA\ TW=N ZW/|WN GINO/MENA KATA\ TH\N TW=N ZW/|WN O(RMH\N [1E(POME/NWN KAI\ TOU/TWN TOI=S E)C A)NA/GKHS PERIESTW=SIN AU)TA\ TO/TE AI)TI/OIS, A(/TINA A)\N [2H)=|]2 H(GOU/MENOI DIA\ TOU= TO\ KAQ' O(RMH\N E)NERGEI=N TA\ ZW=|A THREI=N E)N TW=| A(/PANTA GI/NESQAI KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN KAI\ TO\ E)F' H(MI=N EI)=NAI/ TI THREI=N, TOU/S TE A)/LLOUS E)RWTW=SIN LO/GOUS KAI\ DH\ KAI\ TO\N PROEIRHME/NON, E)MOI\ DOKEI=, OU)X W(S A)LHQEI= PISTEU/ONTES TOSOU=TON AU)TW=| O(/SON DIA\ MH=KO/S TE KAI\ PLH=QOS O)NOMA/TWN KAI\ A)SAFH= SU/NQESIN PARA/CEIN H(GOU/MENOI TOU\S A)KOU/ONTAS. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 36 p. 210, 3 Bruns.$10 OU)DE\N A)/RA ME/NEI TW=N U(PO\ TOU= META\ TOSAU/THS TE/XNHS H)RWTHME/NOU LO/GOU KATESKEUASME/NWN, A)KOLOUQH/SEI TE AU)TOI=S A)RCAME/NOIS KA/TWQEN [2H(]2 A)KOLOUQI/A, H(\N E(/PESQAI LE/-GOUSIN TOI=S A)NAIREI=N PEIRWME/NOIS TO\ E)F' H(MI=N [2TI]2 EI)=NAI, W(S AU)TOI\ THROU=NTES O(MOLOGOUME/NWS AU)TO/, [2TO\]2 DIA\ TOU= PRW/[2TOU]2 LABO/NTAS A)/LLO E)PIFE/REIN AU)= TA\ TOU/TW| DOKOU=NTA E(/PESQAI A)/TOPA KAI\ [2TOU/]2TOIS DIABA/LLEIN [2TO\]2 H(GOU/MENON. EI) GA\R MH/ EI)SI TIMAI\ MHDE\ KOLA/SEIS, OU)DE\ E)/PAINOI OU)DE\ YO/GOI: EI) DE\ MH\ TAU=TA, OU)DE\ KATORQW/MATA/ TE KAI\ A(MARTH/MATA: EI) DE\ MH\ TAU=TA, OU)DE\ A)RETH\ @1 KAI\ KAKI/A: EI) DE\ MH\ TAU=TA, FASI\N E)/TI, MHDE\ QEOI/. A)LLA\ MH\N TO\ PRW=TON, TO\ MH\ EI)=NAI MH/TE TIMA\S MH/TE KOLA/SEIS, E(/PETAI TW=| PA/NTA GI/NESQAI KAQ' EI(MARME/-NHN, W(S DE/DEIKTAI. [2KAI\]2 TO\ TELEUTAI=ON A)/RA, O(\ A)/TOPON KAI\ A)DU/NATON. A)NAI-RETE/ON [2A)/RA]2 TO\ PA/NTA GI/NESQAI KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN, W(=| TOU=Q' EI(/PETO. @&Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 37 p. 210, 14 Bruns.$8 I)/DWMEN DE\ KAI\ [2TO\N]2 E)PI\ TOU/TW| LO/GON H)RWTHME/NON, EI) MH\ TA\S O(MOI/AS A)NA/GKAS E)/XEI. LE/GEI DE\ OU(/TWS: @"1<20*OU) PA/NTA ME\N E)/STI KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN, OU)K E)/STI DE\ A)KW/LU-TOS KAI\ A)PAREMPO/DISTOS H( TOU= KO/SMOU DIOI/KHSIS: OU)DE\ E)/STI ME\N TOU=TO, OU)K E)/STI DE\ KO/SMOS: OU)DE\ E)/STI ME\N KO/SMOS, OU)K EI)SI\N DE\ QEOI/. EI) DE/ EI)SI QEOI/, EI)SI\N A)GAQOI\ OI( QEOI/. A)LL' EI) TOU=TO, E)/STIN A)RETH/. A)LL' EI) E)/STIN A)RETH/, E)/STI FRO/NHSIS. A)LL' EI) TOU=TO, E)/STIN [H(] E)PISTH/MH POIHTE/WN TE KAI\ OU) POIHTE/WN. A)LLA\ POIH-TE/A ME/N E)STI TA\ KATORQW/MATA, OU) POIHTE/A DE\ TA\ A(MARTH/MATA. OU)K A)/RA PA=N ME\N GI/NETAI KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN, OU)K E)/STI DE\ A(MA/R-THMA KAI\ KATO/RQWMA. A)LLA\ TA\ ME\N KATORQW/MATA KALA/, TA\ DE\ A(MARTH/MATA AI)SXRA/: KAI\ TA\ ME\N KALA\ E)PAINETA/, TA\ DE\ AI)SXRA\ YEKTA/. OU)K A)/RA PA/NTA ME/N E)STI KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN, OU)K E)/STI DE\ E)PAINETA\ KAI\ YEKTA/. A)LL' EI) TOU=TO, EI)SI\N E)/PAINOI KAI\ YO/GOI. A)LL' A(\ ME\N E)PAINOU=MEN, TIMW=MEN, A(\ DE\ YE/GOMEN, KOLA/ZOMEN: KAI\ O( ME\N TIMW=N GERAI/REI, O( DE\ KOLA/ZWN E)PANORQOI=. OU)K A)/RA 툒PA/NTA ME\N GI/NETAI KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN, OU)K E)/STI DE\ GERAI/REIN KAI\ E)PANORQOU=N>20."2 @KAI\ OU(=TOS DH\ O( LO/GOS A)PO\ TH=S AU)TH=S PALAI/STRAS W)\N DH=LON W(S DIA\ TW=N AU)TW=N A)\N YEUDH\S W)\N E)LE/GXOITO. @&p. 212, 1.$8 PARAPLH/SIOI DE\ TOU/TOIS KAI\ O(/SOUS A)/LLOUS EI)S SU/STASIN TOU=DE TOU= DO/GMATOS LO/GOUS PARATI/QENTAI E)PI\ PLE/ON, [KAI\] ME/XRI R(HMA/-TWN TH\N KOMYEI/AN E)/XONTES, A)LL' OU)K E)K TH=S PRO\S TA\ PRA/GMATA PERI\ W(=N LE/GONTAI SUMFWNI/AS TH\N PI/STIN LAMBA/NONTES. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 38.$10 O(/TI DE\ MHDE\ OI( E)K TOU= DEIKNU/NAI TH\N KAQ' O(RMH\N KI/NHSIN TOI=S ZW/OIS ME/NOUSAN PA/NTWN GINOME/NWN KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN [1&10scil.$10 LO/GOI]1 SW/|ZOUSI TO\ E)F' H(MI=N, EI) MH\ BOU/LOITO/ TIS A(PLW=S TO\ A)PO/ TINOS KATA\ TH\N OI)KEI/AN GINO/MENON FU/SIN E)P' E)KEI/NW| LE/GEIN__ FQA/NEI DIA\ TW=N PRW/TWN_DEDEI=XQAI. @&Alexander Aphrod. quaestiones II 4 p. 50, 30 Bruns.$8 "1<20EI) E)F' H(MI=N E)STI TOU=TO, OU(= TO\ A)NTIKEI/MENON E)F' H(MI=N, TO\ OU(= TO\ A)NTIKEI/MENON OU)K E)F' H(MI=N, E)KEI=NO OU)K E)F' H(MI=N. TOU= D' E)F' H(MI=N TO\ A)NTIKEI/MENON OU)K E)F' H(MI=N: TW=| GA\R E)F' H(MI=N TO\ OU)K E)F' H(MI=N A)NTIKEI/MENON. OU)DE\ TO\ E)F' H(MI=N A)/RA E)F' H(MI=N. EI) DE\ TO\ @1 E)F' H(MI=N MH\ E)F' H(MI=N, OU)DE/N E)STIN E)F' H(MI=N. KAQ' OU(\S A)/RA E)F' H(MI=N E)STIN, OU(= KAI\ TO\ A)NTIKEI/MENON E)F' H(MI=N, KATA\ TOU/TOUS OU)DE/N E)STIN E)F' H(MI=N>20."2 @&ibidem II 5 p. 51, 20.$8 "1<20TW=| E)F' H(MI=N TI EI)=NAI A)NTI/KEITAI TO\ MHDE\N EI)=NAI E)F' H(MI=N. [2TO\ DE\ MHDE\N EI)=NAI E)F' H(MI=N]2 A)DU/NATON. TO\ OU)=N TW=| E)F' H(MI=N TI EI)=NAI A)NTIKEI/MENON A)DU/NATON. A)LLA\ MH\N W(=| TO\ A)NTIKEI/MENON A)DU/NATON, TOU=TO KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN, EI)/ GE TAU=TA KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN GI/NETAI, OI(=S TA\ A)NTIKEI/MENA A)DU/NATO/N E)STIN H)\ EI)=NAI H)\ GENE/SQAI. TO\ OU)=N E)F' H(MI=N TI EI)=NAI KAQ' EI(MAR-ME/NHN. TW=| DE\ E)F' H(MI=N TI EI)=NAI KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN, SW/|ZOITO A)\N TO\ E)F' H(MI=N TI EI)=NAI KATA\ TOU\S A(/PANTA GI/NESQAI KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN LE/GONTAS>20."2 @1 @&Etymologicum Magn. s. v.$ TELETH/& p. 750, 16.$ *XRU/SIPPOS DE/ FHSI, TOU\S PERI\ TW=N QEI/WN LO/GOUS EI)KO/TWS KALEI=SQAI TELETA/S: XRH=NAI GA\R TOU/TOUS TELEUTAI/OUS KAI\ E)PI\ PA=SI DIDA/SKESQAI, TH=S YUXH=S E)XOU/SHS E(/RMA KAI\ KEKRATHME/NHS KAI\ PRO\S TOU\S A)MUH/TOUS SIWPA=N DUNAME/NHS: ME/GA GA\R EI)=NAI TO\ A)=QLON U(PE\R QEW=N A)KOU=SAI/ TE O)RQA\ KAI\ E)GKRATEI=S GENE/SQAI AU)TW=N. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. I 6$10 *PO/QEN E)/NNOIAN E)/SXON QEW=N A)/NQRWPOI &10G 34.$10 *(ORI/ZONTAI DE\ TH\N TOU= QEOU= OU)SI/AN <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 OU(/TWS: PNEU=MA NOERO\N KAI\ PURW=DES, OU)K E)/XON ME\N MORFH/N, METABA/LLON D' EI)S O(\ BOU/LETAI KAI\ SUNECO-MOIOU/MENON PA=SIN. E)/SXON DE\ E)/NNOIAN TOU/TOU PRW=TON ME\N A)PO\ TOU= KA/LLOUS TW=N E)MFAINOME/NWN PROSLAMBA/NONTES. OU)DE\N GA\R TW=N KALW=N EI)KH= KAI\ W(S E)/TUXE GI/NETAI, A)LLA\ META/ TINOS TE/XNHS DHMIOURGOU/SHS. KALO\S DE\ O( KO/SMOS: DH=LON DE\ E)K TOU= SXH/MATOS KAI\ TOU= XRW/MATOS KAI\ TOU= MEGE/QOUS KAI\ TH=S PERI\ TO\N KO/SMON TW=N A)STE/RWN POIKILI/AS. SFAIROEIDH\S GA\R O( KO/SMOS, O(\ PA/NTWN SXHMA/TWN PRWTEU/EI. MO/NON GA\R TOU=TO TOI=S E(AUTOU= ME/RESIN O(MOIOU=TAI: PERI-FERH\S DE\ W)\N E)/XEI TA\ ME/RH PERIFERH=: DIA\ TOU=TO GA\R KATA\ TO\N *PLA/TWNA E)N TH=| KEFALH=| TO\ I(ERW/TATON SUNE/STHKE, NOU=S. *KAI\ TO\ XRW=MA DE\ KALO/N. KUA-NW/DEI GA\R KE/XRWSTAI, O(\ PORFU/RAS ME/N E)STI MELA/NTERON, STI/LBOUSAN DE\ E)/XEI TH\N POIO/THTA: KAI\ DIA\ TAU/THN TH\N AI)TI/AN TW=| TH=S XROIA=S SUNTO/NW| DIAKO/PTWN THLIKAU/THN A)E/ROS A)PO/STASIN E)K TOSOU/TWN DIASTHMA/TWN QEWREI=TAI. *KAI\ E)K TOU= MEGE/QOUS KALO/S. PA/NTWN GA\R TW=N O(MOGENW=N TO\ PERIE/XON KALO\N W(S ZW=|ON KAI\ DE/NDRON. E)PITELEI= TO\ KA/LLOS TOU= KO/SMOU KAI\ TAU=TA TA\ FAINO/MENA: O( ME\N GA\R LOCO\S KU/KLOS E)N OU)RANW=| DIAFO/ROIS EI)DW/LOIS PEPOI/KILTAI. @TW=| D' E)/NI KARKI/NOS E)STI/, LE/WN D' E)PI\ TW=|, META\ D' AU)TO/N @PARQE/NOS H)D' E)PI/ OI( XHLAI\ KAI\ SKORPI/OS AU)TO/S @TOCEUTH/S TE KAI\ AI)GO/KERWS, E)PI\ D' AI)GOKERH=I+ @U(DROXO/OS: DU/O D' AU)TO\N E)P' I)XQU/ES A)STERO/ENTES. @TOU\S DE\ META\ KRIO/S, TAU=ROS D' E)PI\ TW=| DI/DUMOI/ TE. @1 MURI/A D' A)/LLA KAQ' O(MOI/AS TOU= KO/SMOU PERIKLA/SEIS PEPOI/HKEN. O(/QEN KAI\ *EU)RIPI/DHS FHSI/: [1&10Crit. fr. 1, 33. 34 p. 598 N$10]1 @TO/ T' A)STERWPO\N OU)RANOU= SE/LAS @XRO/NOU KALO\N POI/KILMA TE/KTONOS SOFOU=. E)LA/BOMEN DE\ E)K TOU/TOU E)/NNOIAN QEOU=: A)EI/ TE GA\R H(/LIOS KAI\ SELH/NH KAI\ TA\ LOIPA\ TW=N A)/STRWN TH\N U(PO/GEION FORA\N E)NEXQE/NTA O(/MOIA ME\N A)NATE/LLEI TOI=S XRW/MASIN, I)/SA DE\ TOI=S MEGE/QESI, KAI\ KATA\ TO/POUS KAI\ KATA\ XRO/NOUS TOU\S AU)-TOU/S. DIO/PER OI( TO\N PERI\ TW=N QEW=N PARADO/NTES SEBASMO\N DIA\ TRIW=N E)CE/QH-KAN H(MI=N EI)DW=N, PRW=TON ME\N TOU= FUSIKOU=, DEU/TERON DE\ TOU= MUQIKOU=, TRI/TON DE\ TOU= TH\N MARTURI/AN E)K TW=N NO/MWN EI)LHFO/TOS. [DIOIKEI=SQAI &10del. Reiske$] DIDA/SKETAI DE\ TO\ ME\N FUSIKO\N U(PO\ TW=N FILOSO/FWN, TO\ DE\ MUQIKO\N U(PO\ TW=N POIHTW=N, TO\ DE\ NOMIKO\N U(F' E(KA/STHS A)EI\ PO/LEWS SUNI/STATAI. @*DIAIREI=TAI DE\ H( PA=SA DIDAXH\ EI)S EI)/DH E(PTA/: KAI\ <20PRW=TON>20 ME\N TO\ E)K TW=N FAINOME/NWN KAI\ METEW/RWN: QEOU= GA\R E)/NNOIAN E)/SXON A)PO\ TW=N FAINOME/NWN A)STE/RWN O(RW=NTES TOU/TOUS MEGA/LHS SUMFWNI/AS O)/NTAS AI)TI/OUS, KAI\ TETAGME/NWS H(ME/RAN TE KAI\ NU/KTA XEIMW=NA/ TE KAI\ QE/ROS A)NATOLA/S TE KAI\ DUSMA\S KAI\ TA\ U(PO\ TH=S GH=S ZW|OGONOU/MENA KAI\ KARPOGONOU/MENA. DIO\ PATH\R ME\N E)/DOCEN AU)-TOI=S OU)RANO\S U(PA/RXEIN, MH/THR DE\ GH=: TOU/TWN DE\ O( ME\N PATH\R DIA\ TO\ TA\S TW=N U(DA/TWN E)KXU/SEIS SPERMA/TWN E)/XEIN TA/CIN, H( DE\ [GH=] MH/THR DIA\ TO\ DE/-XESQAI TAU=TA KAI\ TI/KTEIN: BLE/PONTES DE\ TOU\S A)STE/RAS A)EI\ QE/ONTAS AI)TI/OUS TE TOU= QEWREI=N H(MA=S H(/LION KAI\ SELH/NHN QEOU\S PROSHGO/REUSAN. _EI)S <20DEU/-TERON>20 DE\ KAI\ <20TRI/TON>20 TO/PON TOU\S QEOU\S DIEI=LON EI)/S TE TO\ BLA/PTON KAI\ TO\ W)FELOU=N: KAI\ TOU\S ME\N W)FELOU=NTAS *DI/A, *(/HRAN, *(ERMH=N, *DH/MHTRAN, TOU\S DE\ BLA/PTONTAS *POINA/S, *)ERINU/AS, *)/ARHN, TOU/TOUS A)FOSIOU/MENOI XALEPOU\S O)/NTAS KAI\ BIAI/OUS. _<20TE/TARTON>20 KAI\ <20PE/MPTON>20 PROSTEQEI/KASI TOI=S PRA/GMASI KAI\ TOI=S PA/QESI, PAQW=N ME\N *)/ERWTA, *)AFRODI/THN, *PO/QON, PRAGMA/TWN DE\ *)ELPI/DA, *DI/KHN, *EU)NOMI/AN. _<20E(/KTON>20 DE\ TO/PON PROSE/LABON TO\ U(PO\ TW=N POIHTW=N PEPLASME/NON: *(HSI/ODOS GA\R BOULO/MENOS TOI=S GENHTOI=S QEOU\S PATE/RAS SUSTH=SAI EI)SH/GAGE TOIOU/TOUS AU)TOI=S GENNH/TORAS [1&10Hes. theog. 134$10]1 @*KOI=O/N TE *KREI=O/N Q' *(UPERI/ONA/ T' *)IAPETO/N TE. DIA\ TOU=TO KAI\ MUQIKO\N KE/KLHTAI. _<20E(/BDOMON>20 DE\ KAI\ E)PI\ PA=SI TO\ DIA\ TA\S EI)S TO\N KOINO\N BI/ON EU)ERGESI/AS E)KTETIMHME/NON, A)NQRW/PINON DE\ GENNHQE\N W(S *(HRAKLE/A W(S *DIOSKO/ROUS W(S *DIO/NUSON. _A)NQRWPOEIDEI=S D' AU)TOU\S E)/FASAN EI)=NAI, DIO/TI TW=N ME\N A(PA/NTWN TO\ QEI=ON KURIW/TATON, TW=N DE\ ZW/WN A)/NQRWPOS KA/LLISTON, KEKOSMHME/NON A)RETH=| DIAFO/RWS KATA\ TH\N TOU= NOU= SU/STASIN: [TO\ KRA/TISTON:] TOI=S OU)=N A)RISTEU/OUSI TO\ KRA/TISTON O(MOI/WS [KAI\ KALW=S] E)/XEIN DIENOH/QHSAN. @&10Philo de monarchia I p. 216 M.$10 *PO/QEN TOU= EI)=NAI QEO\N LAM-BA/NOMEN E)/NNOIAN. @__*DU/O D' E)N TAI=S PERI\ QEOU= ZHTH/SESI TA\ A)NWTA/TW TAU=TA E)PAPOREI= H( DIA/NOIA TOU= FILOSOFOU=NTOS A)NO/QWS: E(\N ME\N EI) E)/STI TO\ QEI=ON, E(/NEKA TW=N E)PITHDEUSA/NTWN A)QEO/THTA, KAKIW=N TH\N MEGI/STHN: E(/TERON DE\ TO\ TI/ E)/STI KATA\ TH\N OU)SI/AN. *TO\ ME\N OU)=N PRO/TERON OU) POLU\S PO/NOS I)DEI=N, TO\ DE\ DEU/TERON OU) XALEPO\N MO/NON, A)LLA\ KAI\ I)/SWS A)DU/NATON, E)PISKEPTE/ON D' E(KA/TERA. @1 @*)AEI\ TOI/NUN GNWRI/SMATA TW=N DHMIOURGW=N PE/FUKE/ PWS EI)=NAI TA\ DHMIOUR-GHQE/NTA: TI/S GA\R A)NDRIA/NTAS H)\ GRAFA\S QEASA/MENOS OU)K EU)QU\S E)NO/HSEN A)N-DRIANTOPOIO\N H)\ ZWGRA/FON; TI/S D' E)SQH=TAS H)\ NAU=S H)\ OI)KI/AS I)DW\N OU)K E)/NNOIAN E)/LABEN U(FA/NTOU KAI\ NAUPHGOU= KAI\ OI)KODO/MOU. *PARELQW\N DE/ TIS EI)S PO/LIN EU)/NOMON, E)N H(=| TA\ TH=S POLITEI/AS SFO/DRA KALW=S DIAKEKO/SMHTAI, TI/ E(/TERON U(PO-LH/YETAI H)\ O(/TI E)PISTATEI=TAI H(/DE H( PO/LIS U(P' A)RXO/NTWN [W(S] A)GAQW=N; *TO\N OU)=N A)FIKO/MENON EI)S TH\N A)LHQW=S *MEGALO/POLIN, TO/NDE TO\N KO/SMON, KAI\ QEA-SA/MENON TH\N O)REINH\N KAI\ PEDIA/DA PLH/QOUSAN ZW/|WN KAI\ FUTW=N, KAI\ POTAMW=N AU)QIGENW=N KAI\ XEIMA/RRWN FORA\S KAI\ PELAGW=N A)NAXU/SEIS KAI\ EU)KRASI/AN A)E/ROS KAI\ TW=N E)THSI/WN W(RW=N TROPA/S: EI)=TA H(/LION KAI\ SELH/NHN, TOU\S H(ME/RAS KAI\ NUKTO\S H(GEMO/NAS, KAI\ TA\S TW=N A)/LLWN PLANHTW=N TE KAI\ A)PLANW=N KAI\ TOU= SU/MPANTOS OU)RANOU= PERIPOLH/SEIS KAI\ XOREI/AS, OU)K EI)KO/TWS, MA=LLON DE\ A)NAG-KAI/WS E)/NNOIAN LH/YESQAI DEI= TOU= PATRO\S KAI\ POIHTOU= KAI\ PROSE/TI H(GEMO/NOS; *OU)DE\N GA\R TW=N TEXNIKW=N E)/RGWN A)PAUTOMATI/ZETAI: TEXNIKW/TATOS DE\ KAI\ O( KO/SMOS, W(S U(PO/ TINOS TH\N E)PISTH/MHN A)GAQOU= KAI\ TELEIOTA/TOU PA/NTWS DEDH-MIOURGH=SQAI. @&Cicero de nat. deor. III 10, 25.&3 Et <21Chrysippus>21 tibi acute &3dicere videbatur, homo sine dubio versutus et callidus [1versutos eos ap-&3pello, quorum celeriter mens versatur, callidos autem, quorum, tamquam &3manus opere, sic animus usu concalluit]1 is igitur%10 "1<21Si aliquid est>21, &3inquit, <21quod homo efficere non possit, qui id efficit, melior est &3homine. Homo autem haec, quae in mundo sunt, efficere non &3potest%10 qui potuit igitur, is praestat homini. Homini autem &3praestare quis possit, nisi deus? Est igitur deus>21."2 @&ibidem 26.&3 Idemque si dei non sint, negat esse in omni natura &3quicquam homine melius; id autem putare quemquam hominem, nihil &3homine esse melius, summae arrogantiae censet esse. __<21Et si do-&3mus pulchra sit, intelligamus eam dominis, inquit, aedifica-&3tam esse, non muribus%10 sic igitur mundum deorum domum &3existimare debemus>21. @&Cicero de natura deorum II 6, 16.&3 <21Chrysippus>21 quidem, &3quamquam est acerrimo ingenio, tamen ea dicit, ut ab ipsa natura di-&3dicisse, non ut ipse repperise videatur. "1<21Si enim>21,"2 inquit, "1<21est ali-&3quid in rerum natura, quod hominis mens, quod ratio, quod &3vis, quod potestas humana efficere non possit%10 est certe id, &3quod illud efficit, homine melius. Atqui res caelestes omnes-&3que eae, quarum est ordo sempiternus, ab homine confici non @1 &3possunt. Est igitur id, [2a]2 quo illa conficiuntur, homine me-&3lius. Id autem quid potius dixeris, quam deum? Etenim si &3dii non sunt, quid esse potest in rerum natura homine melius? &3In eo enim solo est ratio, qua nihil potest esse praestantius. &3Esse autem hominem, qui nihil in omni mundo melius esse &3quam se putet, desipientis arrogantiae est. Ergo est aliquid &3melius. Est igitur profecto deus>21."2 @&Cic. ibid. %14 17.&3 An vero, si domum magnam pulchramque videris, &3non possis adduci, ut, etiamsi dominum non videas, muribus illam et &3mustelis aedificatam putes%10 tantum ergo ornatum mundi, tantam varie-&3tatem pulchritudinemque rerum caelestium, tantam vim et magnitudinem &3maris atque terrarum, si tuum ac non deorum immortalium domicilium &3putes, nonne plane desipere videare? @&10Sextus adv. math. IX 78.$10 TW=N TE SWMA/TWN TA\ ME\N H(NW-ME/NA, TA\ DE\ E)K SUNAPTOME/NWN, TA\ DE\ E)K DIESTW/TWN. H(NWME/NA ME\N OU)=N E)STI\ TA\ U(PO\ MIA=S E(/CEWS KRATOU/MENA, KAQA/PER FUTA\ KAI\ ZW=|A, E)K SUNAPTOME/NWN DE\ TA\ E)/K TE PARAKEIME/NWN KAI\ PRO\S E(/N TI KEFA/LAION NEUO/NTWN SUNESTW=TA W(S A(LU/SEIS KAI\ PURGI/SKOI KAI\ NH=ES, E)K DIESTW/TWN DE\ TA\ E)K DIEZEUGME/NWN KAI\ [E)K] KEXWRISME/NWN KAI\ KAQ' AU(TA\ U(POKEIME/NWN SUGKEI/MENA, W(S STRATIAI\ KAI\ POI=MNAI KAI\ XOROI/. E)PEI\ OU)=N KAI\ O( KO/SMOS SW=MA/ E)STIN, H)/TOI H(NWME/NON E)STI\ SW=MA H)\ E)K SUNAPTOME/NWN H)\ E)K DIESTW/TWN. OU)/TE DE\ E)K SUNAPTOME/NWN OU)/TE E)K DIESTW/TWN, W(S DEI/KNUMEN E)K TW=N PERI\ AU)TO\N SUMPAQEIW=N. KATA\ GA\R TA\S TH=S SELH/NHS AU)CH/SEIS KAI\ FQI/SEIS POLLA\ TW=N TE E)PIGEI/WN ZW/|WN KAI\ QALASSI/WN FQI/NEI TE KAI\ AU)/CETAI, A)MPW/TEIS TE KAI\ PLHMMURI/DES PERI/ TINA ME/RH TH=S QALA/SSHS GI/NONTAI. W(SAU/TWS DE\ KAI\ KATA/ TINAS TW=N A)STE/RWN E)PITOLA\S KAI\ DU/SEIS METABOLAI\ TOU= PERIE/XONTOS KAI\ PAMPOI/KILOI PERI\ TO\N A)E/RA TROPAI\ SUM-BAI/NOUSIN, O(TE\ ME\N E)PI\ TO\ KREI=TTON, O(TE\ DE\ LOIMIKW=S. E)C W(=N SUMFANE\S O(/TI H(NWME/NON TI SW=MA KAQE/STHKEN O( KO/SMOS. E)PI\ ME\N GA\R TW=N E)K SUNAPTOME/-NWN H)\ DIESTW/TWN OU) SUMPA/SXEI TA\ ME/RH A)LLH/LOIS, EI)/ GE E)N STRATIA=| PA/NTWN, EI) TU/XOI, DIAFQARE/NTWN TW=N STRATIWTW=N OU)DE\N KATA\ DIA/DOSIN PA/SXEIN FAI/NE-TAI O( PERISWQEI/S: E)PI\ DE\ TW=N H(NWME/NWN SUMPA/QEIA/ TI/S E)STIN, EI)/ GE DAKTU/LOU TEMNOME/NOU TO\ O(/LON SUNDIATI/QETAI SW=MA. H(NWME/NON TOI/NUN E)STI\ SW=MA KAI\ O( KO/SMOS. A)LL' E)PEI\ TW=N H(NWME/NWN SWMA/TWN TA\ ME\N U(PO\ YILH=S E(/CEWS SUN-E/XETAI, TA\ DE\ U(PO\ FU/SEWS, TA\ DE\ U(PO\ YUXH=S, KAI\ E(/CEWS ME\N W(S LI/QOI KAI\ CU/LA, FU/SEWS DE\ KAQA/PER TA\ FUTA/, YUXH=S DE\ TA\ ZW=|A, PA/NTWS DH\ KAI\ O( KO/SMOS U(PO/ TINOS TOU/TWN DIAKRATEI=TAI. KAI\ U(PO\ ME\N YILH=S E(/CEWS OU)K A)\N SUNE/XOITO. TA\ GA\R U(PO\ E(/CEWS KRATOU/MENA OU)DEMI/AN A)CIO/LOGON METABOLH/N TE KAI\ TROPH\N A)NADE/XETAI, KAQA/PER CU/LA KAI\ LI/QOI, A)LLA\ MO/NON E)C AU(TW=N PA/SXEI TH\N KATA\ A)/NESIN KAI\ TH\N KATA\ SUMPIESMO\N DIA/QESIN: O( DE\ KO/SMOS A)CIOLO/GOUS A)NADE/XETAI METABOLA/S, O(TE\ ME\N KRUMALE/OU TOU= PERIE/XONTOS GIGNOME/NOU O(TE\ DE\ A)LEEINOU=, KAI\ O(TE\ ME\N AU)XMW/DOUS O(TE\ DE\ NOTEROU=, O(TE\ DE\ A)/LLWS PWS KATA\ TA\S @1 TW=N OU)RANI/WN KINH/SEIS E(TEROIOUME/NOU: OU) TOI/NUN U(PO\ YILH=S E(/CEWS O( KO/SMOS SUNE/XETAI. EI) DE\ MH\ U(PO\ TAU/THS, PA/NTWS U(PO\ FU/SEWS: KAI\ GA\R TA\ U(PO\ YUXH=S DIAKRATOU/MENA POLU\ PRO/TERON U(PO\ FU/SEWS SUNEI/XETO. A)NA/GKH A)/RA U(PO\ TH=S A)RI/STHS AU)TO\N FU/SEWS SUNE/XESQAI, E)PEI\ KAI\ PERIE/XEI TA\S PA/NTWN FU/SEIS. H( DE/ GE TA\S PA/NTWN PERIE/XOUSA FU/SEIS KAI\ TA\S LOGIKA\S PERIE/SXHKEN. A)LLA\ KAI\ H( TA\S LOGIKA\S PERIE/XOUSA FU/SIS PA/NTWS E)STI\ LOGIKH/. OU) GA\R OI(=O/N TE TO\ O(/LON TOU= ME/ROUS XEI=RON EI)=NAI, A)LL' EI) A)RI/STH E)STI\ FU/SIS H( TO\N KO/SMON DIOIKOU=SA, NOERA/ TE E)/STAI KAI\ SPOUDAI/A KAI\ A)QA/NATOS. TOIAU/TH DE\ TUGXA/-NOUSA QEO/S E)STIN, EI)SI\N A)/RA QEOI/. @&10Sextus adv. math. IX 86.$10 EI)/PER TE E)N GH=| KAI\ QALA/SSH|, POLLH=S OU)/SHS PAXUMEREI/AS, POIKI/LA SUNI/STATAI ZW=|A YUXIKH=S TE KAI\ AI)SQHTIKH=S ME-TE/XONTA DUNA/MEWS, POLLW=| PIQANW/TERO/N E)STIN E)N TW=| A)E/RI, POLU\ TO\ KAQARO\N KAI\ EI)LIKRINE\S E)/XONTI PARA\ TH\N GH=N KAI\ TO\ U(/DWR, E)/MYUXA/ TINA KAI\ NOERA\ SUNI/STASQAI ZW=|A. KAI\ TOU/TW| SUMFWNEI= TO\ TOU\S *DIOSKOU/ROUS A)GAQOU/S TINAS EI)=NAI DAI/MONAS, "1SWTH=RAS EU)SE/LMWN NEW=N"2 KAI\ TO\: [1&10Hes. Op. et D. 252$10]1 @TRI\S GA\R MU/RIOI/ EI)SIN E)PI\ XQONI\ POULUBOTEI/RH| @A)QA/NATOI *ZHNO\S FU/LAKES MERO/PWN A)NQRW/PWN. A)LL' EI) E)N TW=| A)E/RI PIQANO\N U(PA/RXEIN ZW=|A, PA/NTWS EU)/LOGON KAI\ E)N TW=| AI)QE/RI ZW/|WN EI)=NAI FU/SIN, O(/QEN KAI\ A)/NQRWPOI NOERA=S METE/XOUSI DUNA/MEWS, E)KEI=QEN AU)TH\N SPA/SANTES. O)/NTWN DE\ AI)QERI/WN ZW/|WN KAI\ KATA\ POLU\ TW=N E)PIGEI/WN U(PERFE/REIN DOKOU/NTWN TW=| A)/FQARTA EI)=NAI KAI\ A)GE/NNHTA, DOQH/SETAI KAI\ QEOU\S U(PA/RXEIN, TOU/TWN MH\ DIAFE/RONTAS. @&10Sextus adv. math. IX 95 [1antecedit locus Xenoph. Mem. I 4, 8$10]1. TOIOU=TOS ME\N OU)=N O( TOU= *CENOFW=NTO/S E)STI LO/GOS, DU/NAMI/N GE E)PAGWGIKH\N E)/XWN KAI\ TOIAU/THN: "1GH=S POLLH=S OU)/SHS E)N TW=| KO/SMW| MIKRO\N ME/ROS E)/XEIS, KAI\ U(GROU= POLLOU= O)/NTOS E)N TW=| KO/SMW| MIKRO\N ME/ROS E)/XEIS: KAI\ NOU= A)/RA POLLOU= O)/NTOS E)N TW=| KO/SMW| MIKRO\N ME/ROS E)/XEIS. NOERO\S A)/RA O( KO/SMOS E)STI/N, KAI\ DIA\ TOU=TO QEO/S."2 [1&10enarrantur deinde %14 96 97 quae alii philosophi huic argumentationi &10obiecerant et refutantur]1. 98.$10 E)/NESTI DE\ KAI\ OU(/TWS TO\N AU)TO\N SUNERWTA=N LO/GON. "1EI) MH\ H)=N TI GEW=DES E)N TW=| KO/SMW|, OU)DE\ E)N SOI/ TI A)\N H)=N GEW=DES, KAI\ EI) MH\ H)=N TI U(GRO\N E)N KO/SMW|, OU)D' A)\N E)N SOI\ H)=N TI U(GRO/N: KAI\ O(MOI/WS E)PI\ A)E/ROS KAI\ PURO/S: TOI/NUN KAI\ EI) MH\ H)=N TIS E)N KO/SMW| NOU=S, OU)D' A)\N E)N SOI/ TIS H)=N NOU=S: E)/STI DE/ GE E)N SOI/ TIS NOU=S: E)/STIN A)/RA KAI\ E)N KO/SMW|. KAI\ DIA\ TOU=TO NOERO/S E)STIN O( KO/SMOS. NOERO\S DE\ W)\N KAI\ QEO\S KAQE/STHKEN."2 TH=S DE\ AU)TH=S DUNA/MEW/S E)STI KAI\ O( TOU=TON TO\N TRO/PON E)/XWN LO/GOS: A)=RA/ GE A)/GALMA EU)= DEDHMIOURGHME/NON QEASA/MENOS DISTA/SEIAS A)/N, EI) TEXNI/THS NOU=S TOU=TO E)POI/HSEN; H)\ OU)/T' A)\N A)PO/SXOIS TOU= U(PONOEI=N TI TOIOU=TON, W(S KAI\ QAU-MA/ZEIN TH\N PERITTO/THTA TH=S DHMIOURGI/AS KAI\ TH\N TE/XNHN; A)=R' OU)=N E)PI\ ME\N TOU/TWN TO\N E)/CWQEN QEWRW=N TU/PON PROSMARTUREI=S TW=| KATESKEUAKO/TI KAI\ FH\S EI)=NAI/ TINA TO\N DHMIOURGO/N, TO\N DE\ E)N SOI\ O(RW=N NOU=N, TOSAU/TH| POIKILI/A| DIA-FE/RONTA PANTO\S A)GA/LMATOS KAI\ PA/SHS GRAFH=S, GENNHTO\N O)/NTA NOMI/ZEIS A)PO\ TU/XHS GEGONE/NAI, OU)XI\ DE\ U(PO/ TINOS DHMIOURGOU= DU/NAMIN KAI\ SU/NESIN U(PER-BA/LLOUSAN E)/XONTOS; O(/SPER OU)K A)\N A)/LLOQI/ POU DIATRI/BOI H)\ E)N TW=| KO/SMW|, DIOIKW=N AU)TO\N KAI\ TA\ E)N AU)TW=| GENNW=N TE KAI\ AU)/CWN. OU(=TOS DE/ E)STI QEO/S. EI)SI\N A)/RA QEOI/. @&10Sextus adv. math. IX 111.$10 PRO\S TOU/TOIS KAI\ A)PO\ TH=S TOU= @1 KO/SMOU KINH/SEWS E)PIXEIROU=SI KATASKEUA/ZEIN TH\N TW=N QEW=N U(/PARCIN <20OI(/TE A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 KAI\ OI( TOU/TOIS SUMPNE/ONTES. O(/TI GA\R KINEI=TAI O( KO/SMOS PA=S A)/N TIS O(MOLOGH/SEIEN U(PO\ POLLW=N EI)S TOU=TO E)NAGO/MENOS. H)/TOI OU)=N U(PO\ FU/-SEWS KINEI=TAI H)\ U(PO\ PROAIRE/SEWS H)\ U(PO\ DI/NHS KAI\ KAT' A)NA/GKHN. A)LL' U(PO\ ME\N DI/NHS KAI\ KAT' A)NA/GKHN OU)K EU)/LOGON. H)/TOI GA\R A)/TAKTO/S E)STIN H)\ DIA-TETAGME/NH H( DI/NH. KAI\ EI) ME\N A)/TAKTOS, OU)K A)\N DUNHQEI/H TETAGME/NWS TI KI-NEI=N: EI) DE\ META\ TA/CEW/S TI KINEI= KAI\ SUMFWNI/AS, QEI/A TIS E)/STAI KAI\ DAIMO/NIOS: OU) GA\R A)/N POTE TETAGME/NWS KAI\ SWTHRI/WS TO\ O(/LON E)KI/NEI MH\ NOERA\ KAI\ QEI/A KAQESTW=SA. TOIAU/TH DE\ OU)=SA OU)KE/TI A)\N EI)/H DI/NH: A)/TAKTON GA/R E)STIN AU(/TH KAI\ O)LIGOXRO/NION. W(/STE KAT' A)NA/GKHN ME\N KAI\ U(PO\ DI/NHS, W(S E)/LEGON OI( PERI\ TO\N *DHMO/KRITON, OU)K A)\N KINOI=TO O( KO/SMOS. KAI\ MH\N OU)DE\ FU/SEI A)FANTA/STW|, PARO/SON H( NOERA\ FU/SIS A)MEI/NWN E)STI\ TAU/THS. O(RW=NTAI DE\ TOIAU=TAI FU/SEIS E)N KO/SMW| PERIEXO/MENAI. A)NA/GKH A)/RA KAI\ AU)TO\N NOERA\N E)/XEIN FU/SIN, U(F' H(=S TETAGME/NWS KINEI=TAI, H(/TIS EU)QE/WS E)STI\ QEO/S. @&10Sextus adv. math. IX 123.$10 SKOPW=MEN DE\ E(CH=S KAI\ TO\N TRO/PON TW=N A)KOLOUQOU/NTWN A)TO/PWN TOI=S A)NAIROU=SI TO\ QEI=ON. EI) GA\R MH\ EI)SI\ QEOI/, OU)K E)/STIN EU)SE/BEIA, MO/NON TW=N AI(RETW=N U(PA/RXOUSA. E)/STI GA\R EU)SE/BEIA E)PI-STH/MH QEW=N QERAPEI/AS: TW=N D' A)NUPA/RKTWN OU) DU/NATAI/ TIS EI)=NAI QERAPEI/A, O(/QEN OU)DE\ E)PISTH/MH TIS PERI\ TAU/THN GENH/SETAI. _W(/STE EI) MH\ EI)SI\ QEOI/, A)NU/PARKTO/S E)STIN H( EU)SE/BEIA. U(PA/RXEI DE\ EU)SE/BEIA: TOI/NUN R(HTE/ON EI)=NAI QEOU/S. KAI\ PA/LIN EI) MH\ EI)SI\ QEOI/, A)NU/PARKTO/S E)STIN H( O(SIO/THS, DIKAIOSU/NH TIS OU)=SA PRO\S QEOU/S: E)/STI DE/ GE KATA\ TA\S KOINA\S E)NNOI/AS KAI\ PROLH/YEIS PA/NTWN A)NQRW/PWN O(SIO/THS, KAQO/ TI KAI\ O(/SIO/N E)STIN. KAI\ [2TO\]2 QEI=ON A)/RA E)/STIN. EI)/ GE MH\N MH\ EI)SI\ QEOI/, A)NAIREI=TAI SOFI/A, E)PISTH/MH OU)=SA QEI/WN TE KAI\ A)NQRWPEI/WN PRAGMA/TWN, __OU)DE\ E)PISTH/MH TIS E)/STAI QEI/WN KAI\ A)N-QRWPEI/WN PRAGMA/TWN, A)NQRW/PWN [2ME\N]2 U(PARXO/NTWN QEW=N DE\ MH\ U(FESTW/-TWN: A)/TOPON DE/ GE LE/GEIN MH\ EI)=NAI SOFI/AN: A)/TOPON A)/RA KAI\ TO\ TOU\S QEOU\S A)CIOU=N A)NUPA/RKTOUS. KAI\ MH\N EI)/PER KAI\ H( DIKAIOSU/NH KATA\ TH\N E)PIPLOKH\N TW=N A)NQRW/PWN PRO/S TE A)LLH/LOUS KAI\ PRO\S QEOU\S EI)SH=KTAI, EI) MH\ EI)SI\ QEOI/, OU)DE\ DIKAIOSU/NH SUSTH/SETAI: O(/PER A)/TOPON. _R(HTE/ON A)/RA KAI\ QEOU\S U(PA/RXEIN. @&10Sextus adv. math. IX 132.$10 PRO\S TOU/TOIS EI) MH\ EI)SI\ QEOI/, OU)DE\ MANTIKH\ U(PA/RXEI, E)PISTH/MH OU)=SA QEWRHTIKH\ KAI\ E)CHGHTIKH\ TW=N U(PO\ QEW=N A)NQRW/POIS DIDOME/NWN SHMEI/WN, OU)DE\ MH\N QEOLHPTIKH\ KAI\ A)STROMANTIKH/, OU) LOGIKH/, OU)X H( DI' O)NEI/RWN PRO/R)R(HSIS. A)/TOPON DE/ GE TOSOU=TO PLH=QOS PRAGMA/-TWN A)NAIREI=N PEPISTEUME/NWN H)/DH PARA\ PA=SIN A)NQRW/POIS: EI)SI\N A)/RA QEOI/. @&Themistius Paraphr. in Anal. poster. p. 79, 1 Spengel.$ TO\ EI)=NAI POLLAXW=S E)N TAI=S A)PODEI/CESI ME/TIMEN: E)NI/OTE ME\N GA\R A)PO\ SUM-BEBHKO/TOS KAI\ PO/R)R(W TH=S OU)SI/AS TOU= PRA/GMATOS, E)NIO/TE DE\ A)PO\ TOU= PRA/GMATOS KAI\ TOU= E)KEI/NOU TI E)/XEIN, OI(=ON "1O(/TI EI)SI\ QEOI\"2 A)PO\ SUMBE-BHKO/TOS ME/N, O(/TI EI)SI\ BWMOI\ W(S <20*XRU/SIPPO/S>20 FHSIN, A)PO\ DE\ TOU= PRA/G-MATOS O(/TI QERAPEU/OUSIN, O(/TI PROLE/GOUSIN, O(/TI KINOU=NTAI TO\N A)/PEIRON XRO/NON POIKI/LAS KINH/SEIS. @1 @&10Sextus adv. math. IX 77.$10 KAI\ E)/TI TO\ GENNHTIKO\N LOGIKOU= KAI\ FRONI/MOU PA/NTWS KAI\ AU)TO\ LOGIKO/N E)STI KAI\ FRO/NIMON. H( DE/ GE PROEIRHME/NH DU/NAMIS [1&10scil.$10 H( TH\N TW=N O)/NTWN OU)SI/AN KINOU=SA KAI\ SXHMATI/ZOUSA]1 A)NQRW/-POUS PE/FUKE KATASKEUA/ZEIN: LOGIKH\ TOI/NUN KAI\ FRONI/MH GENH/SETAI, O(/PER H)=N QEI/AS FU/SEWS. EI)SI\N A)/RA QEOI/. @&10Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 147.$10 *QEO\N DE\ EI)=NAI ZW=|ON A)QA/NATON LOGI-KO\N TE/LEION H)\ NOERO\N E)N EU)DAIMONI/A|, KAKOU= PANTO\S A)NEPI/DEKTON, PRONOHTIKO\N KO/SMOU TE KAI\ TW=N E)N KO/SMW|: MH\ EI)=NAI ME/NTOI A)NQRWPO/MORFON. EI)=NAI DE\ TO\N ME\N DHMIOURGO\N TW=N O(/LWN KAI\ W(/SPER PATE/RA PA/NTWN, KOINW=S TE KAI\ TO\ ME/ROS AU)TOU= TO\ DIH=KON DIA\ PA/NTWN, O(\ POLLAI=S PROSHGORI/AIS PROSONOMA/ZETAI KATA\ TA\S DUNA/MEIS. *DI/A ME\N GA/R FASI DI' O(\N TA\ PA/NTA, <20*ZH=NA>20 DE\ KALOU=SI PAR' O(/SON TOU= ZH=N AI)/TIO/S E)STIN H)\ DIA\ TOU= ZH=N KEXW/RHKEN, <20*)AQHNA=N>20 DE\ KATA\ TH\N EI)S AI)QE/RA DIA/TASIN TOU= H(GEMONIKOU= AU)TOU=, <20*(/HRAN>20 DE\ KATA\ TH\N EI)S A)E/RA KAI\ <20*(/HFAISTON>20 KATA\ TH\N EI)S TO\ TEXNIKO\N PU=R KAI\ <20*POSEIDW=NA>20 KATA\ TH\N EI)S TO\ U(GRO\N KAI\ <20*DH/MHTRAN>20 KATA\ TH\N EI)S GH=N. O(MOI/WS DE\ KAI\ TA\S A)/LLAS PROSHGORI/AS E)XO/MENOI/ TINOS OI)KEIO/THTOS A)PE/DOSAN. @&Diogenes Lae%28rt, VII 148.$ *OU)SI/AN DE\ QEOU= *ZH/NWN ME/N FHSI TO\N O(/LON KO/SMON KAI\ TO\N OU)RANO/N, O(MOI/WS DE\ KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS E)N TW=| PRW/TW| PERI\ QEW=N>20. @&Philodemus de pietate c. 15 [1DDG p. 548, 4]1.$ <20KA)N TOI=S PERI\ *PRONOI/AS>20 ME/NTOI TA\S AU)TA\S E)KTI/QHSIN SUNOIKEIW/SEIS TH=| YUXH=| TOU= PANTO\S KAI\ TA\ TW=N QEW=N O)NO/MATA E)FARMO/TTEI TH=S DREIMU/THTOS A)POLAU/WN A)KOPIA/TWS. @&10Seneca de beneficiis IV 7. "1Natura,"2 inquit, "1haec mihi prae &10stat."2 Non intellegis te, cum hoc dicis, mutare nomen deo? quid enim &10aliud est natura quam deus et divina ratio toti mundo partibusque eius &10inserta. Quotiens voles, tibi licet aliter hunc auctorem rerum nostrarum &10compellare%10 et Iovem illum optimum ac maximum rite dices et Tonantem &10et Statorem. __Hunc eundem et fatum si dixeris, non mentieris. &10nam cum fatum nihil aliud sit quam series inplexa causarum, ille est @1 &10prima omnium causa, ex qua ceterae pendent. Quaecunque voles illi no-&10mina proprie aptabis vim aliquam effectumque coelestium rerum continentia%10 &10tot appellationes eius possunt esse quot munera. cp. 8. Hunc et Liberum &10patrem et Herculem ac Mercurium nostri putant; Liberum patrem, quia &10omnium parens sit, quod primum inventa seminum vis est %2%2 consultura &10per voluptatem. Herculem quia vis eius invicta sit, quandoque lassata &10fuerit operibus editis in ignem recessura. Mercurium, quia ratio penes &10illum est numerusque et ordo et scientia. Quocunque te flexeris, ibi il-&10lum videbis occurrentem tibi. nihil ab illo vacat%10 opus suum ipse implet. @&Lactantius div. instit. I 5.&3 <21Chrysippus>21 naturalem vim di-&3vina ratione praeditam, interdum divinam necessitatem deum nuncupat. @&10Ioannes Damascenus de haeresibus 7.$10 *STWI+KOI\ SW=MA TO\ PA=N DOGMATI/ZONTES KAI\ AI)SQHTO\N TOU=TON TO\N KO/SMON QEO\N NOMI/ZONTES. *TINE\S DE\ E)K TH=S TOU= PURO\S OU)SI/AS TH\N FU/SIN E)/XEIN AU)TO\N A)PEFH/NANTO. *KAI\ TO\N ME\N QEO\N NOU=N O(RI/ZOUSI, W(S KAI\ YUXH\N PANTO\S TOU= O)/NTOS KU/TOUS OU)RANOU= KAI\ GH=S. SW=MA DE\ AU)TOU= TO\ PA=N, W(S E)/FHN, KAI\ O)FQALMOU\S TOU\S FWSTH=RAS. TH\N DE\ SA/RKA A)PO/LLUSQAI KAI\ TH\N YUXH\N PA/NTWN METAGGI/ZESQAI A)PO\ SWMA/TWN EI)S SW/MATA. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. I 7, 33.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 NOERO\N QEO\N A)POFAI/NONTAI, PU=R TEXNIKO/N, O(DW=| BADI/ZON E)PI\ GE/NESIN KO/SMOU, E)MPERIEILHFO\S PA/NTAS TOU\S SPERMATIKOU\S LO/GOUS, KAQ' OU(\S E(/KASTA KAQ' EI(MARME/NHN GI/NETAI: KAI\ PNEU=MA ME\N DIH=KON DI' O(/LOU TOU= KO/SMOU, TA\S DE\ PROSHGORI/AS METALAMBA/NON KATA\ TA\S TH=S U(/LHS, DI' H(=S KEXW/RHKE, PARALLA/CEIS. QEOU\S DE\ KAI\ TO\N KO/SMON KAI\ TOU\S A)STE/RAS KAI\ TH\N GH=N, TO\N D' A)NWTA/TW PA/NTWN NOU=N E)N AI)QE/RI [1E)NAI-QE/RION EI)=NAI QEO/N &10Stob.]1. &10@Theodoretus graec. affect. cur. p. 37, 33.$10 FEU/CETAI DE\ KAI\ TW=N *STWI+KW=N TH\N A)PREPH= PERI\ TOU= QEI/OU DO/CAN. SWMATOEIDH= GA\R OU(=TOI TO\N QEO\N E)/FASAN EI)=NAI. @&Hippolytus Philos. 21 [1DDG 571, 7$]1. *STWI+KOI\ KAI\ AU)TOI\ ME\N E)PI\ TO\ SULLOGISTIKW/TERON TH\N FILOSOFI/AN HU)/CHSAN KAI\ SXEDO\N O(/ROIS PERIE/LABON O(MO/DOCOI GENO/MENOI O(/ TE *XRU/SIPPOS KAI\ *ZH/NWN, OI(\ U(PE/QENTO KAI\ AU)TOI\ A)RXH\N ME\N QEO\N TW=N PA/NTWN, SW=MA O)/NTA TO\ KA-QARW/TATON, DIA\ PA/NTWN DE\ DIH/KEIN TH\N PRO/NOIAN AU)TOU=. @&10Olympiodorus ad Plat. Phaedon. p. 28 ed. Finckh.$10 DIO\ KAI\ O( FILO/SOFOS XORO\S O( <20TW=N *STWI+KW=N>20 DIA\ TO\ KATA\ FANTASI/AN E)NERGEI=N SW=MA TO\N QEO\N U(PE/LABON: AU(/TH GA\R TOI=S A)SWMA/TOIS SW/MATA PERITI/QHSI. @1 @&10Servius in Verg. Aeneid. VI 727. aut certe secundum eos lo-&10cutus est, qui dicunt deum corporalem esse et eum ita definiunt%10$10 PU=R NOERO/N,&10 id est ignem sensualem. quod si verum est, corpus est. &10@Eusebius Praep. evang. III 9, 9.$10 KATA\ <20TOU\S *STWI+KOU\S>20 TH\N PURW/DH KAI\ QERMH\N OU)SI/AN TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N FA/SKONTAS EI)=NAI TOU= KO/SMOU, KAI\ TO\N QEO\N EI)=NAI SW=MA KAI\ TO\N DHMIOURGO\N AU)TO/N, OU)D' E(/TERON TH=S TOU= PURO\S DUNA/MEWS. @&10Theophilus ad Autolycum I 4.$10 A)/LLOI D' AU)= TO\ DI' O(/LOU KEXWRH-KO\S PNEU=MA QEO\N DOGMATI/ZOUSIN. @&10Tertullianus Apologeticum cp. 47. Alii incorporalem [1deum &10scil.]1 adseverant, alii corporalem, ut tam Platonici quam <21Stoici. &10@ibidem>21%10 positum vero extra mundum <21Stoici>21, qui figuli modo ex-&10trinsecus torqueat molem hanc. &10@Clemens Al. Stromat. V 14 p. 699.$10 FASI\ GA\R SW=MA EI)=NAI TO\N QEO\N <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 KAI\ PNEU=MA KAT' OU)SI/AN, W(/SPER A)ME/LEI KAI\ TH\N YUXH/N. &10paulo post%10$10 A)LL' OI( ME\N DIH/KEIN DIA\ PA/SHS TH=S OU)SI/AS TO\N QEO\N FASI/N. @&10Tertullianus adv. Hermog. cp. 44. <21stoici>21 enim volunt deum &10sic per materiam decucurrisse quomodo mel per favos. &10@Sextus Pyrrh. Hypot. III 218.$10 W(S *)ARISTOTE/LHS ME\N A)SW/MATON EI)=PEN EI)=NAI TO\N QEO\N KAI\ PE/RAS TOU= OU)RANOU=, *STWI+KOI\ DE\ PNEU=MA DIH=KON KAI\ DIA\ TW=N EI)DEXQW=N. @&10Alexander Aphr. de anima libri mantissa p. 113, 12 Bruns. $10A)NTIPI/PTEIN E)DO/KEI MOI TOU/TOIS TO/ TE TO\N NOU=N KAI\ E)N TOI=S FAULOTA/TOIS EI)=NAI, QEI=ON O)/NTA, W(S KAI\ TOI=S <20A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 E)/DOCEN. @&10Clemens Al. Coh. ad. gent. p. 58 Pott.$10 *OU)DE\ MH\N TOU\S A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S PARELEU/SOMAI, DIA\ PA/SHS U(/LHS KAI\ DIA\ TH=S A)TIMOTA/THS TO\ QEI=ON DIH/KEIN LE/GONTAS. @&10Clemens Al. Stromat. I p. 346 Pott.$10 A)LLA\ KAI\ OI( *STWI+KOI\_ __SW=MA O)/NTA TO\N QEO\N DIA\ TH=S A)TIMOTA/THS U(/LHS PEFOITHKE/NAI LE/GOUSIN. @&10Lactantius div. instit. VII 3. <21stoici>21 naturam in duas partes &10dividunt%10 unam quae efficiat, alteram quae se ad faciendum tractabilem &10praebeat. in illa prima esse vim sentiendi, in hac materiam; nec alterum &10sine altero posse. Quomodo potest idem esse quod tractat et quod trac-&10tatur? Siquis dicat idem esse figulum, quod lutum, aut lutum idem esse &10quod figulum, nonne aperte insanire videatur? At isti uno naturae nomine &10duas res diversissimas comprehendunt, deum et mundum, artificem et opus, &10dicuntque alterum sine altero nihil posse, tanquam natura sit deus mundo &10permixtus. Nam interdum sic confundunt, ut sit deus ipse mens mundi &10et mundus sit corpus dei. Quasi vero simul esse coeperint mundus et &10deus ac non ipse mundum fecerit. Quod et ipsi fatentur alias, cum ho-&10minum causa praedicant esse fabricatum. @&Proclus in Plat. Timaeum p. 297 Schneider.$ POLLOU= A)/RA DEI= PARABA/LLESQAI TW=| KO/SMW| TOU/TW| O( U(PO\ <20*XRUSI/PPOU>20 KATASKEUA- @1ZO/MENOS. O( ME\N GA\R EI)S TAU)TO\N SUGXEI= TA/S TE A)MEQE/KTOUS AI)TI/AS KAI\ TA\S MEQEKTA\S TA/S TE QEI/AS KAI\ NOERA\S TA/S TE A)U/+LOUS KAI\ TA\S E)NU/LOUS. O( GA\R AU)TO\S QEO\S PAR' AU)TW=| PRW=TOS W)\N DIH/KEI DIA\ TOU= KO/SMOU KAI\ DIA\ TH=S U(/LHS KAI\ YUXH/ E)STI KAI\ FU/SIS A)XW/RISTOS TW=N DIOIKOUME/NWN. @&10Salvianus de gubern. dei I 3. Plato et omnes Platonicorum &10scholae moderatorem rerum omnium confitentur deum. <21Stoici>21 eum guber-&10natoris vice intra id quod regat semper manere testantur. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de mixtione p. 225, 18 Bruns.$10 PRO\S DE\ TOU/TOIS E)PIZHTH/SAI TIS A)/N, EI) TW=N E)K TH=S U(/LHS GENOME/NWN OI(=O/N TE DHMIOUR-GO\N LE/GEIN TO\N DIAPEFOITHKO/TA TH=S U(/LHS KAI\ O)/NTA E)N AU)TH=| QEO/N. FE/ROUSI ME\N GA\R EI)S TH\N KATASKEUH\N TOU=DE TO\ MH\ O(MOI/WS TOI=S FU/SEI GINOME/NOIS GI/NESQAI TA\ KATA\ TE/XNAS. TA\ ME\N GA\R A)PO\ TH=S FU/SEWS A)POTELE/SMATA OU)K E)PIPOLH=S, A)LLA\ DI' O(/LWN EI)DOPOIEI=TAI/ TE KAI\ DIAPLA/TTETAI, KAI\ TA\ E)/NDON AU)TW=N GLAFURW/TATA PEFILOTE/XNHTAI. TA\ DE\ TW=N TEXNW=N DIAMEMO/RFWTAI, W(S E)PI\ TW=N A)NDRIA/NTWN E)/XEI: TA\ GA\R E)/NDON TOU/TWN A)DIA/PLASTA. DIA\ DH\ TOU=TO/ FASIN TW=N ME\N GINOME/NWN KATA\ TE/XNHN E)/CWQEN EI)=NAI KAI\ KEXWRISME/NON TO\ POIOU=N, E)PI\ DE\ TW=N GINOME/NWN FU/SEI E)N TH=| U(/LH| EI)=NAI TH\N DU/NAMIN TH\N MORFOU=SA/N TE KAI\ GENNW=SAN AU)TA/. @&10Plutrachus de facie lunae cp. 12 p. 926c.$10 AU)TH\ D' H( YUXH/, PRO\S *DIO/S, EI)=PON, OU) PARA\ FU/SIN TW=| SW/MATI SUNEI=RKTAI BRADEI= TAXEI=A KAI\ YUXRW=| PURW/DHS, <20W(/SPER U(MEI=S FATE>20 [1&10scil. Stoici$10]1, KAI\ A)O/RATOS AI)SQHTW=|; DIA\ TOU=T' OU)=N SW/MATI YUXH\N MH\ LE/GWMEN EI)=NAI MHDE\ NOU= XRH=MA QEI=ON %2 U(PO\ BRI/QOUS H)\ PA/XOUS %2 OU)RANO/N TE PA/NTA KAI\ GH=N KAI\ QA/LASSAN E)N TAU)TW=| PERI-POLOU=N TE KAI\ DII+PTA/MENON, EI)S SA/RKAS H(/KEIN KAI\ NEU=RA KAI\ MUELOU\S KAI\ PA-QE/WN MURI/WN MESTA\S U(GRO/THTAS. <20*(O DE\ *ZEU\S H(MI=N OU(=TOS OU) TH=| ME\N AU(-TOU= FU/SEI XRW/MENOS E(/N E)STI ME/GA PU=R KAI\ SUNEXE/S, NUNI\ D' U(FEI=-TAI KAI\ KE/KAMPTAI KAI\ DIESXHMA/TISTAI, PA=N XRH=MA GEGONW\S KAI\ GIGNO/MENOS E)N TAI=S METABOLAI=S>20; @&10Sophonias de anima paraphrasis [1Comm. graec. Vol XXIII]1 &10ed. Hayd. p. 36, 9.$10 E)SXA/TH DE\ DO/CA KAI\ TELEUTAI/A PERI\ YUXH=S H(/DE: E)N GA\R TW=| O(/LW| TINE\S AU)TH\N MEMI=XQAI/ FASI, KAI\ A(/PAN SW=MA E)/MYUXON EI)=NAI U(PE/LABON, O(/QEN KAI\ *QALH=S W)|H/QH PA/NTA PLH/RH QEW=N. EI)S TOU=TO D' A)/N TIS E(/LKOI KAI\ <20TOU\S *STWI+KOU\S>20 SW=MA TO\ QEI=ON U(POLABO/NTAS KAI\ PANTAXOU= PAREI=NAI KAI\ SWMATIKW=S, A)LL' OU) MO/NAIS TAI=S E)NERGEI/AIS. &10@Alexander Aphrod. de mixtione p. 226, 10 Bruns.$10 E)OI/KASI DE/, DI' W(=N LE/GOUSIN, EI)=DOS TH=S U(/LHS LE/GEIN TO\N QEO/N: EI) GA\R OU(/TWS O( QEO\S ME/-MIKTAI TH=| U(/LH|, <20KAT' AU)TOU/S>20, W(S E)N TOI=S ZW/|OIS H( YUXH\ TW=| SW/MATI, KAI\ H( DU/NAMIS TH=S U(/LHS E)STI\ O( QEO/S [1FASI\ GA\R TH\N U(/LHN POIEI=N TH=| E)N AU)TH=| DU-NA/MEI]1 EI)=DOS [2OU(/T]2WS A)\N LE/GOIEN AU)TH=S TO\N QEO/N, W(S TH\N YUXH\N TOU= SW/MA-TOS KAI\ TH\N DU/NAMIN TOU= DUNA/MEI. A)LL' EI) TOU=TO, PW=S A)\N E)/TI H( U(/LH A)NEI/DEOS EI)/H KATA\ TO\N AU(TH=S LO/GON; EI)/ GE TO\ SUMME/NEIN AU)TH=| KAI\ EI)=NAI U(/LH| PARA\ TH=S OU)/SHS E)N AU)TH=| DUNA/MEWS. MA/LISTA D' E)N TH=| E)KPURW/SEI FAI/NETAI <20KAT' AU)-TOU\S>20 O( QEO\S TH=S U(/LHS EI)=DOS W)/N, EI)/GE E)N TW=| PURI/, O(\ MO/NON E)STI\ KAT' AU)TOU\S @1 TO/TE, H( U(/LH KAI\ O( QEO\S SW/|ZONTAI MO/NOI. EI)/H GA\R A)\N O( QEO\S TO/TE EI)=DOS TO\ E)PI\ TH=| U(/LH| TOU= PURO/S. EI) DE\ TOU=TO, METABA/LLEI DE\ TO\ PU=R EI)S A)/LLA TINA\ SW/MATA, TO\ EI)=DOS A)LLA/SSON, EI)/H A)\N O( QEO\S FQEIRO/MENOS TO/TE &10etc. &10@Alexander Aphrod. de mixtione p. 226, 24 Bruns.$10 PW=S D' OU)K A)NA/CIA TH=S QEI/AS PROLH/YEWS TO/ TE TO\N QEO\N DIA\ PA/SHS TH=S U(POKEIME/NHS PA=SIN U(/LHS KEXWRHKE/NAI LE/GEIN KAI\ ME/NEIN E)N AU)TH=| O(POI/A POT' A)\N H)=|, KAI\ TO\ PROHGOU/MENON E)/XEIN E)/RGON TO\ A)EI/ TI GENNA=N TE KAI\ DIAPLA/SSEIN TW=N E)C AU)TH=S GENE/SQAI DUNAME/NWN, KAI\ POIEI=N TO\N QEO\N DHMIOURGO\N SKWLH/KWN TE KAI\ E)M-PI/DWN, A)TEXNW=S W(/SPER KOROPLA/QON TINA\ TW=| PHLW=| SXOLA/ZONTA KAI\ PA=N TO\ DUNA/MENON E)C AU)TOU= GENE/SQAI TOU=TO POIOU=NTA. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 38 p. 1051f. Post relatam &Antipatri sententiam%10 universos Stoicos arbitratos esse, deos interitu &vacare%10$8 *OU)DEI\S OU)=N E)STI TW=N PA/NTWN O( *XRU/SIPPOS KAT' *)ANTI/PATRON: OU)DE/NA GA\R OI)/ETAI PLH\N TOU= PURO\S A)/FQARTON EI)=NAI TW=N QEW=N, A)LLA\ PA/NTAS O(MALW=S KAI\ GEGONO/TAS KAI\ FQARHSOME/NOUS. *TAU=TA DE\ PANTAXOU=, W(S E)/POS EI)PEI=N, U(P' AU)TOU= LE/GETAI. *PARAQH/SOMAI DE\ LE/CIN <20E)K TOU= TRI/-TOU PERI\ *QEW=N: "1*KAQ' E(/TERON LO/GON OI( ME\N [GA\R] GENHTOI\ EI)=-NAI KAI\ FQARTOI\ LE/GONTAI, OI( D' A)GE/NHTOI: KAI\ TAU=T' A)P' A)RXH=S U(PODEI/KNUSQAI FUSIKW/TERON. *(/HLIOS ME\N GA\R KAI\ SELH/NH KAI\ OI( A)/LLOI QEOI\ PARAPLH/SION E)/XONTES LO/GON, GENHTOI/ EI)SIN: O( DE\ *ZEU\S A)I/+DIO/S E)STIN."2 *KAI\ PA/LIN PROELQW/N: "1*(/OMOIA DE\ KAI\ PERI\ TOU= FQI/NEIN KAI\ PERI\ TOU= GENE/SQAI R(HQH/SETAI, PERI/ TE TW=N A)/LLWN QEW=N KAI\ TOU= *DIO/S: OI( ME\N GA\R FQARTOI/ EI)SI, TOU= DE\ TA\ ME/RH A)/FQARTA."2 @&idem de comm. not. cp. 31 p. 1075a.$ *)ALLA\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 KAI\ *KLEA/NQHS, E)MPEPLHKO/TES, W(S E)/POS EI)PEI=N, TW=| LO/GW| QEW=N TO\N OU)RANO/N, TH\N GH=N &etc.$ OU)DE/NA TW=N TOSOU/TWN A)/FQARTON OU)D' A)I/+DION A)POLELOI/-PASI PLH\N MO/NOU TOU= *DIO/S, EI)S O(\N PA/NTAS KATANALI/SKOUSI TOU\S A)/L-LOUS: W(/STE KAI\ TOU/TW| TO\ FQEI/REIN PROSEI=NAI TOU= FQEI/RESQAI MH\ E)PIEIKE/STERON. ___*TAU=TA DE\ OU)X W(S A)/LLA POLLA\ TW=N A)TO/PWN SULLOGIZO/MEQA E)/XEIN TA\S U(POQE/SEIS AU)TW=N KAI\ TOI=S DO/GMASIN E(/PESQAI, A)LL' AU)TOI\ ME/GA BOW=NTES <20E)N TOI=S PERI\ *QEW=N KAI\ *PRONOI/AS, *EI(-MARME/NHS TE KAI\ *FU/SEWS GRA/MMASI>20, DIAR)R(H/DHN LE/GOUSI, TOU\S A)/LLOUS QEOU\S A(/PANTAS EI)=NAI GEGONO/TAS KAI\ FQARHSOME/NOUS U(PO\ PURO/S, THKTOU\S KAT' AU)TOU\S W(/SPER KHRI/NOUS H)\ KATTITERI/NOUS O)/NTAS. @&ibid. 1075c.$ A)\N GA\R AU)= TO\ SOFO\N TOU=TO KAI\ KALO\N A)NTIQW=SI, QNHTO\N EI)=NAI TO\N A)/NQRWPON, OU) QNHTO\N DE\ TO\N QEO/N, A)LLA\ FQARTO/N &etc. @1 &@idem de defectu oraculorum cp. 19.$ *KAI/TOI <20TOU\S *STWI+KOU/S>20, E)/FH, GIGNW/SKOMEN OU) MO/NON KATA\ DAIMO/NWN H(\N LE/GW DO/CAN E)/XONTAS, A)LLA\ KAI\ QEW=N O)/NTWN TOSOU/TWN TO\ PLH=QOS E(NI\ XRWME/NOUS A)I+DI/W| KAI\ A)FQA/RTW|, TOU\S D' A)/LLOUS KAI\ GEGONE/NAI KAI\ FQARH/SESQAI NOMI/ZONTAS. @&10Porphyrius de anima apud Eusebium praep. evang. XV p. 818c. &10[1contra Stoicos disputans$10]1%10 *TO\N DE\ QEO\N OU)K O)KNOU=SI PU=R NOERO\N EI)PO/NTES A)I/+DION KATALEI/PEIN, KAI\ FQEI/REIN ME\N PA/NTA LE/GEIN KAI\ E)PINE/MESQAI, W(S TOI-OU=TON O)\N PU=R OI(=ON TO\ H(MI=N SUNEGNWSME/NON, A)NTILE/GEIN TE TW=| *)ARISTOTE/LEI, PARAITOUME/NW| TO\N AI)QE/RA E)K PURO\S LE/GEIN TOIOU/TOU. A)PAITOU/MENOI DE\ PW=S TO\ TOIOU=TON E)PIDIAME/NEI PU=R, A)LLOI=ON ME\N PU=R OU) LE/GOUSIN EI)=NAI, TO\ TOIOU=TON D' EI)PO/NTES KAI\ PISTEU/EIN AU)TOI=S EI)POU=SIN A)CIW/SANTES, TH=| A)LO/GW| TAU/TH| PI/STEI E)PISUNA/PTOUSIN O(/TI KAI\ A)I/+DIO/N E)STI PU=R, E)K ME/ROUS KAI\ TO\ AI)QE/RION SBE/N-NUSQAI KAI\ A)NA/PTESQAI TIQE/NTES. A)LLA\ TH\N TOU/TWN PRO\S ME\N TA\ AU(TW=N A)BLEYI/AN, PRO\S DE\ TA\ TW=N PALAIW=N R(A|QUMI/AN TE KAI\ KATAFRO/NHSIN, TI/ A)/N TIS E)PIW\N E)PI\ PLE/ON MHKU/NOI; @&10Origenes contra Celsum VI 7 Vol. II p. 141, 6 Ko+. [1p. 686 &10Del.$10]1. OI)O/MENOS H(MA=S LE/GONTAS PNEU=MA EI)=NAI TO\N QEO\N MHDE\N E)N TOU/TW| DIA-FE/REIN TW=N PAR' *(/ELLHSI <20*STWI+KW=N>20, FASKO/NTWN O(/TI O( QEO\S PNEU=MA/ E)STI DIA\ PA/NTWN DIELHLUQO\S KAI\ PA/NT' E)N E(AUTW=| PERIE/XON. _KAI\ PA/NTA ME\N PERIE/XEI TA\ PRONOOU/MENA H( PRO/NOIA KAI\ PERIEI/LHFEN AU)TA/. __ @&10paulo post%10$10 KATA\ ME\N OU)=N <20TOU\S A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 SWMATIKA\S LE/GONTAS EI)=NAI TA\S A)RXA\S KAI\ DIA\ TOU=TO PA/NTA FQEI/RONTAS, KINDUNEU/ONTAS DE\ KAI\ AU)-TO\N FQEI=RAI TO\N E)PI\ PA=SI QEO/N, EI) MH\ PA/NU A)PEMFAI=NON TOU=T' AU)TOI=S E)DO/KEI TUGXA/NEIN, <20KAI\ O( LO/GOS TOU= QEOU=, O( ME/XRI A)NQRW/PWN KAI\ TW=N E)LA-XI/STWN KATABAI/NWN, OU)DE\N A)/LLO E)STI\N H)\ PNEU=MA SWMATIKO/N>20. @&10Origenes contra Celsum IV 14 Vol. I p. 284, 23 Ko+. [1p. 510 &10Delarue$10]1. A)LLA\ KAI\ O( <20TW=N *STWI+KW=N>20 QEO/S, A(/TE SW=MA TUGXA/NWN, O(TE\ ME\N H(GEMONIKO\N E)/XEI TH\N O(/LHN OU)SI/AN, O(/TAN H( E)KPU/RWSIS H)=|, O(TE\ DE\ E)PI\ ME/ROUS GI/NETAI AU)TH=S, O(/TAN H)=| DIAKO/SMHSIS: OU)DE\ GA\R DEDU/NHNTAI OU(=TOI TRANW=SAI TH\N FUSIKH\N TOU= QEOU= E)/NNOIAN, W(S PA/NTH| A)FQA/RTOU KAI\ A(PLOU= KAI\ A)SUN-QE/TOU KAI\ A)DIAIRE/TOU. @&10Origenes contra Celsum I Vol. I p. 72, 11 Ko+. [1p. 339 Del.$10]1. EI)/QE_KAI\ OI( SW=MA EI)PO/NTES TO\N QEO\N <20*STWI+KOI\>20 TOU= LO/GOU TOU/TOU H)/KOUSAN, I(/NA MH\ PLHRWQH=| O( KO/SMOS LO/GOU_A)RXH\N FQARTH\N EI)SA/GONTOS TH\N SWMA-TIKH/N, KAQ' H(\N KAI\ O( QEO\S <20TOI=S *STWI+KOI=S>20 E)STI SW=MA, OU)K AI)DOUME/NOIS LE/-GEIN AU)TO\N TREPTO\N KAI\ DI' O(/LWN A)LLOIWTO\N KAI\ METABLHTO\N KAI\ A(PACAPLW=S DUNA/MENON FQARH=NAI, EI) E)/XOI TO\N FQEI/RONTA: EU)TUXOU=NTA DE\ MH\ FQARH=NAI, PARA\ TO\ MHDE\N EI)=NAI TO\ FQEI=RON AU)TO/N. @1 @&10Origenes in evang. Ioannis XIII 21.$10 O)LI/GOI GA\R DIEILH/FASI PERI\ TH=S TW=N SWMA/TWN FU/SEWS KAI\ MA/LISTA TW=N U(PO\ LO/GOU KAI\ PRONOI/AS KATA-KOSMOUME/NWN: <20KAI/TOI TO\ PRONOOU=N TH=S AU)TH=S OU)SI/AS LE/GONTES EI)=NAI TOI=S PRONOOUME/NOIS GENIKW=| LO/GW|, TE/LEION O(/MWS KAI\ A)LLOI=ON TOU= PRONOOUME/NOU>20. *PAREDE/CANTO DE\ TA\ A)PANTW=NTA TW=| LO/GW| AU)TW=N A)/TOPA OI( QE/LONTES EI)=NAI SW=MA TO\N QEO/N, A(/TE MH\ DUNA/MENOI A)NTIBLE/PEIN [2TOI=S]2 E)K LO/-GOU E)NARGW=S PARISTAME/NOIS. *TAU=TA DE/ FHMI KAQ' U(PECAI/RESIN TW=N PE/MPTHN LEGO/NTWN EI)=NAI FU/SIN SWMA/TWN PARA\ TA\ STOIXEI=A. *EI) DE\ PA=N SW=MA U(LIKH\N E)/XEI FU/SIN, TW=| I)DI/W| LO/GW| A)/POION TUGXA/NON, TREPTH\N DE\ KAI\ A)LLOIWTH\N KAI\ DI' O(/LWN METABLHTH\N KAI\ POIO/THTAS XWROU=SAN, A(\S A)\N BOU/LHTAI AU)TH=| PERITI-QE/NAI O( DHMIOURGO/S, A)NA/GKH KAI\ TO\N QEO\N U(LIKO\N O)/NTA TREPTO\N EI)=NAI KAI\ A)LLOIWTO\N KAI\ METABLHTO/N. *KAI\ E)KEI=NOI ME\N OU)K AI)DOU=NTAI LE/GEIN, <20O(/TI KAI\ FQARTO/S E)STI SW=MA W)/N, SW=MA DE\ PNEUMATIKO\N KAI\ AI)QERW=DES MA/-LISTA KATA\ TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N AU)TOU=: FQARTO\N DE\ O)/NTA MH\ FQEI/RESQAI TW=| MH\ EI)=NAI TO\N FQEI/RONTA AU)TO\N LE/GOUSIN>20. @&Plutarchus de defectu oraculorum cp. 29.$ OU(=TOI [1&scil. Stoici$]1 TOU\S QEOU\S A)E/RWN E(/CEIS POIOU=NTES KAI\ U(DA/TWN, KAI\ PURO\S DUNA/MEIS E)GKEKRAME/NAS H(GOU/MENOI, SUGGENNW=SI TW=| KO/SMW| KAI\ PA/LIN SUGKATA-KAI/OUSIN, OU)K A)POLU/TOUS OU)D' E)LEUQE/ROUS, OI(=ON H(NIO/XOUS H)\ KUBERNH/TAS O)/NTAS: A)LL' W(/SPER A)GA/LMATA PROSHLOU=TAI KAI\ SUNTH/KETAI BA/SESIN, OU(/-TWS E)GKEKLEISME/NOUS EI)S TO\ SWMATIKO\N KAI\ SUGKATAGEGOMFWME/NOUS, KOI-NWNOU=NTAS AU)TW=| ME/XRI FQORA=S KAI\ DIALU/SEWS A(PA/SHS KAI\ METABOLH=S. @&10Galenus de qualitatibus incorporeis 6. Vol. XIX p. 479 K.$10 EI) DE\ METAPOIH/SAS AU(TO\N O( *ZEU\S I)SARI/QMWS OI(=S E)/FHN SUMBEBHKO/SI TROPA\S E)/XEI POIOTH/TWN MURI/AS, XEI/RWN E)STI\ TOU= MUQOLOGOUME/NOU *PRWTE/WS: O( ME\N GA\R EI)S O)LI/GAS FU/SEIS AU(TO\N METEPOI/EI KAI\ METEMO/RFOU, KAI\ TAU/TAS OU)K A)PREPEI=S [1&10Od.$10 D&10 456_58$10]1 [2O(/S]2 R(' H)/TOI PRW/TISTA LE/WN GE/NET' H)U+GE/NEIOS, @AU)TA\R E)/PEITA DRA/KWN KAI\ PA/RDALIS H)DE\ ME/GAS SU=S, @GI/GNETO D' U(GRO\N U(/DWR KAI\ DE/NDREON U(YIPE/THLON, O( DE\ OU)K E)/STIN O(/,TI MH\ KAI\ TW=N AI)SXI/STWN GI/GNETAI___. EI) D' AU(TO\N ME\N OU)/POTE, TH\N [2D']2 U(/LHN METALLA/TTEI KAI\ SXHMATI/ZEI KAI\ POIOI=, ZHTW= PW=S E)STIN OI(=O/S TE TAU=TA POIEI=N. @&10Lactantius de ira cp. 18. Omitto de figura dei dicere, quia &10<21Stoici>21 negant habere ullam formam deum. &10@Clemens Al. Stromat. VII 7 p. 852 Pott.$10 OU)K OU)=N A)NQRWPOEI-DH\S O( QEO\S TOU=D' E(/NEKA [KAI\] I(/NA A)KOU/SH|: OU)DE\ AI)SQH/SEWN AU)TW=| DEI=, KAQ- @1A/PER H)/RESEN <20TOI=S *STWI+KOI=S>20, MA/LISTA A)KOH=S KAI\ O)/YEWS: MH\ GA\R DU/NASQAI/ POTE E(TE/RWS A)NTILAMBA/NESQAI. @&10Seneca Apocolocyntosis 8. modo dic nobis, qualem deum istum &10fieri velis.$10 *)EPIKOU/REIOS QEO\S&10 non potest esse%10$10 OU)/TE AU)TO\S PRA=GMA E)/XEI OU)/TE A)/LLOIS PARE/XEI;&10 Stoicus? quomodo potest "1rotundus"2 esse, ut ait Varro, &10sine capite sine praeputio? Est aliquid in illo Stoici dei, iam video%10 nec &10cor nec caput habet. &10V.H.&14`1&10 VI 2 p. 31 [1vulgo Metrodorus$10 PERI\ AI)SQH/SEWN&10]1 col. XVI &10cf. Scott. Frgm. Herc. p. 250.$10 KO/SMOU QEO\N OU)D' "1H)%5E/LION T' A)KA/MANTA SE%5LH/NHN TE PLH/QOUSAN"2 [1&10Il. XVIII 484$10]1 %5 <20*STWI+KW=|>20 DE\ KAI\ *PERI%5PATHTIKW=| TOU=T' E)/CES%5TIN LE/GEIN .. PW=S [1G]1A\R <20I)DI/%5AN E)/XEI MORFH\N TO\ SFAI%5ROEIDE/S>20; A)/LLWS Q' OI( TOU=%5TO LE/GONTES OU) BLE/POU%5SIN, DIO/TI TH=S FU/SEWS %5 !!!!DION TWN ON. @&10Servius ad Aeneid. X 18. "1O pater, o hominum divumque &10aeterna potestas."2 hunc locum Probus quaerit; sed dicit unam rem secun-&10dum physicos, alteram secundum mathematicos. <21nam divum potestas &10est, quia ipse est aether, qui elementorum possidet principa-&10tum>21; hominum vero ideo, quia bona Iovis inradiatio honores hominibus &10tribuit. @&Stobaeus Eclogae I p. 31, 11 W.$ <20*XRUSI/PPOU>20. *ZEU\S ME\N OU)=N FAI/NETAI W)NOMA/SQAI A)PO\ TOU= PA=SI DEDWKE/NAI TO\ ZH=N. *DI/A DE\ AU)TO\N LE/GOUSIN, O(/TI PA/NTWN E)STI\N AI)/TIOS KAI\ DI' AU)TO\N PA/NTA. [1&Diels &Arii Did. Epitom. phys. frgm. 30]1. &@Ioannes Laurentius Lydus de mensibus IV 48 n. 224 ed. &Ro+ther.$ *KRA/THS DE\ A)PO\ TOU= DIAI/NEIN, TOUTE/STI PIAI/NEIN TH\N *GH=N BOU/LETAI O)NOMASQH=NAI TO\N *DI/A, TO\N EI)S PA/NTA DIH/KONTA: *POSEIDW/NIOS TO\N *DI/A TO\N PA/NTA DIOIKOU=NTA: <20*XRU/SIPPOS DE\ DIA\ TO\ DI' AU)TO\N EI)=NAI TA\ PA/NTA>20. @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 36 p. 1077e.$ *LE/GEI GOU=N *XRU/SIPPOS "1E)OIKE/NAI TW=| ME\N A)NQRW/PW| TO\N *DI/A KAI\ TO\N KO/SMON, TH=| DE\ YUXH=| TH\N PRO/NOIAN: O(/TAN OU)=N E)KPU/RWSIS GE/NHTAI, MO/NON A)/FQARTON O)/NTA TO\N *DI/A TW=N QEW=N, A)NAXWREI=N E)PI\ TH\N PRO/NOIAN, EI)=TA O(MOU= GE-NOME/NOUS E)PI\ MIA=S TH=S TOU= AI)QE/ROS OU)SI/AS DIATELEI=N A)MFOTE/ROUS."2 @1 @&10Seneca epist. ad Lucil. 9, 16. Qualis tamen futura est vita &10sapientis, si sine amicis relinquatur__in desertum litus eiectus? qua-&10lis et Iovis, <21cum resoluto mundo et dis in unum confusis pau-&10lisper cessante natura adquiescit sibi cogitationibus suis tra-&10ditus>21. tale quiddam sapiens facit, in se reconditur, secum est. &10@Servius ad Verg. Aeneid. I 47. <21Physici>21 Iovem aetherem id &10est ignem volunt intellegi, Iunonem vero ae%28rem, et quoniam tenuitate &10haec elementa paria sunt, dixerunt esse germana. sed quoniam Iuno, hoc &10est ae%28r subiectus est igni, id est Iovi, iure superposito elemento mariti &10traditum nomen est. @&Cicero de nat. deor. II 24, 63.&3 Alia quoque ex ratione et &3quidem physica magna fluxit multitudo deorum, qui induti specie hu-&3mana fabulas poe%28tis suppeditaverunt, hominum autem vitam superstitione &3omni referserunt. Atque hic locus a Zenone tractatus post a Cleanthe &3et <21Chrysippo>21 pluribus verbis explicatus est. Nam [2cum]2 vetus haec &3opinio Graeciam opplevisset, exsectum Caelum a filio Saturno, vinctum &3autem Saturnum ipsum a filio Iove, physica ratio non inelegans inclusa &3est in inpias fabulas; caelestem enim altissimam aetheriamque naturam, &3id est igneam, quae per sese omnia gigneret, vacare voluerunt ea parte &3corporis, quae coniunctione alterius egeret ad procreandum. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 39 p. 1052b.$8 *KAI\ MH\N <20E)N TW=| TRI/TW| PERI\ QEW=N>20 O( *XRU/SIPPOS PERI\ TOU= TRE/FESQAI TOU\S A)/LLOUS QEOU\S TA/DE LE/GEI: "1<20*TROFH=| TE OI( ME\N A)/LLOI QEOI\ XRW=NTAI PARA-PLHSI/WS, SUNEXO/MENOI DI' AU)TH/N: O( DE\ *ZEU\S KAI\ O( KO/SMOS KAQ' E(/TERON TRO/PON %2 A)NALISKOME/NWN KAI\ E)K PURO\S GINOME/NWN>20."2 @&Cicero de nat. deor. III 24, 63.&3 Magnam molestiam susce-&3pit et minime necessariam primus Zeno, post Cleanthes, deinde <21Chry-&3sippus>21, commenticiarum fabularum reddere rationem, vocabulorum, cur &3quidque ita appellatum sit, causas explicare. Quod cum facitis, illud &3profecto confitemini, longe aliter se rem habere, atque hominum opinio &3sit; eos enim, qui di appellantur, rerum naturas esse, non figuras deorum. @&10Servius ad Verg. Aeneid. IV 638. et sciendum <21stoicos>21 di-&10cere unum esse deum, cui nomina variantur pro actibus et officiis. unde &10etiam <21duplicis sexus numina esse dicuntur, ut cum in actu sunt &10mares sint, feminae cum patiendi habent naturam>21%10 unde est%10 con-&10jugis in gremium laetae descendit [1Georg. II 326]1 cf. ad Georgica I 5. &10Stoici dicunt non esse nisi unum deum et unam eandemque potestatem, &10quae pro ratione officiorum [nostrorum] variis nominibus appellatur. Unde &10eundem Solem, eundem Apollinem, eundem Liberum vocant. Item Lunam &10eandem Dianam, eandem Cererem, eandem Iunonem, eandem Proserpinam &10dicunt etc. @1 @&Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 187.$ *EI)SI\ DE\ OI(\ KATATRE/XOUSI TOU= *XRUSI/PPOU W(S POLLA\ AI)SXRW=S KAI\ A)R)R(H/TWS A)NAGEGRAFO/TOS. *)EN ME\N GA\R <20TW=| PERI\ TW=N A)RXAI/WN FUSIOLO/GWN>20 SUGGRA/MMATI AI)SXRW=S TA\ PERI\ TH\N *(/HRAN KAI\ TO\N *DI/A A)NAPLA/TTEI, LE/GWN KATA\ TOU\S E(CAKOSI/OUS STI/XOUS A(\ MHDEI\S H)TUXHKW\S MOLU/NEIN TO\ STO/MA EI)/POI A)/N. AI)SXROTA/-THN GA/R, FASI/, TAU/THN A)NAPLA/TTEI I(STORI/AN, EI) KAI\ E)PAINEI= W(S FUSI-KH/N, XAMAITU/PAIS MA=LLON PRE/POUSAN H)\ QEOI=S, E)/TI TE KAI\ PARA\ TOI=S PERI\ PINA/KWN GRA/YASIN [2OU)]2 KATAKEXWRISME/NHN: MH/TE GA\R PARA\ *PO-LE/MWNI MH/TE PAR' *(UYIKRA/TEI, A)LLA\ MHDE\ PAR' *)ANTIGO/NW| EI)=NAI, U(P' AU)-TOU= DE\ PEPLA/SQAI. @&Clemens rom. homil. V 18.$ OU) *ZH/NWN A)DIAFOREI=N AI)NISSO/-MENOS DIA\ PA/NTWN TO\ QEI=ON EI)=NAI LE/GEI, I(/NA GNW/RIMON TOI=S SUNETOI=S GE/NHTAI, O(/TI W(=| A)/N TIS MIGH=| W(S E(AUTW=| MI/GNUTAI KAI\ PERISSO\N TO\ A)PA-GOREU/EIN TA\S LEGOME/NAS MOIXEI/AS H)\ MI/CEIS MHTRO\S H)\ QUGATRO\S H)\ A)DEL-FH=S H)\ PAI/DWN; <20*XRU/SIPPOS DE\ E)N TAI=S E)RWTIKAI=S E)PISTOLAI=S>20 KAI\ TH=S E)N *)/ARGEI EI)KO/NOS ME/MNHTAI, PRO\S TW=| TOU= *DIO\S AI)DOI/W| FU/RWN TH=S *(/HRAS TO\ PRO/SWPON. @&Theophilus ad Autolycum III 8.$ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 DE\ O( POLLA\ FLUARH/SAS, PW=S OU)XI\ EU(RI/SKETAI SHMAI/NEIN TH\N *(/HRAN STO/MATI MIARW=| SUGGI/NESQAI TW=| *DII/+. @&Origenes contra Celsum IV 48 Vol. I p. 321, 3 Ko+. [1p. 540 &Delarue]1.$ *KAI\ TI/ ME DEI= KATALE/GEIN TA\S PERI\ QEW=N A)TO/POUS *(ELLH/NWN I(STORI/AS, AI)SXU/NHS AU)TO/QEN A)CI/AS KAI\ A)LLHGOROUME/NAS, O(/POU GE O( *SO-LEU\S <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20, O( TH\N *STOA\N TW=N FILOSO/FWN POLLOI=S SUGGRA/M-MASI SUNETOI=S KEKOSMHKE/NAI NOMIZO/MENOS, PARERMHNEU/EI GRAFH\N TH\N E)N *SA/MW|, E)N H(=| A)R)R(HTOPOIOU=SA H( *(/HRA TO\N *DI/A E)GE/GRAPTO. *LE/GEI GA\R E)N TOI=S E(AUTOU= SUGGRA/MMASIN O( SEMNO\S FILO/SOFOS, O(/TI TOU\S SPERMA-TIKOU\S LO/GOUS TOU= QEOU= H( U(/LH PARADECAME/NH E)/XEI E)N E(AUTH=| EI)S KATA-KO/SMHSIN TW=N O(/LWN: U(/LH GA\R H( E)N TH=| KATA\ TH\N *SA/MON GRAFH=| H( *(/HRA KAI\ O( QEO\S O( *ZEU/S. @&10Cicero de nat. deorum II 66. Ae%28r autem ut <21stoici>21 dispu-&10tant, interiectus inter mare et caelum Iunonis nomine consecratur, quae &10est soror et coniunx Iovis, quod ei similitudo est aetheris et cum eo &10summa coniunctio. Effeminarunt autem eum Iunonique tribuerunt, quod &10nihil est eo mollius. @1 @&Philodemus de pietate c. 11 [1DDG 545&14b& 12$]1. A)LLA\ MH\N KAI\ *XRU/S[1I]1PPOS ....... E)N ME\]1N <20TW=| PRW/T[1W| PERI\ QEW=]1N>20 *DI/A FH[1SI\N EI)=NAI TO\]1N A(/PANT[1A DIOIKOU=]1NTA LO/GON K[1AI\ TH\N]1 TOU= O(/LOU YUXH\[1N KA]1I\ TH=| TOU/TOU M[1ETOX]1H=| PA/NTA [1ZH=N]1%1 ...... KAI\ TOU\S LI/QOUS, [1D]1IO\ KAI\ *ZH=NA KALE[1I=S]1QAI, *DI/A D' [1O(/]1TI [1PA/N]1TWN AI)/T[1I]1OS [1KAI\ KU/]1RIOS: TO/N TE KO/SMON E)/MY[1U]1XON EI)=NAI KAI\ QEO/[1N, K]1AI\ TO\ H([1GEMONI]1KO\N [1K]1AI\ TH\N O(/[1LHN Y]1UX[1H/]1N: KAI\ !!!!!IAN O)N[1OMA/ZES]1QAI TO\N *DI/A KAI\ TH\N KOINH\N PA/NTWN FU/SIN KAI\ EI(MARM[1E/]1NHN KAI\ A)NA/[1G]1KHN. KAI\ TH\N AU)TH\N EI)=NAI KAI\ EU)NOMI/AN KAI\ DI/KHN [1K]1AI\ O(MO/NOIAN KA[1I\ E]1I)RH/NHN KAI\ TO\ PAR[1A]1-PLH/SION PA=N. KAI\ MH\ EI)=NAI QEOU\S A)/R)R(ENAS MHDE\ QHLEI/AS, W(S MHD[1E\]1 PO/LEIS MHD' A)R[1E]1TA/S, [1O)]1NOMA/ZESQAI DE\ MO/NON A)R)R(ENIKW=S KAI\ QH[1L]1U-[1K]1W=S TAU)TA\ O)/NTA, KAQA/PER SELH/NHN KA[1I\ MH=]1NA. KAI\ TO\N *)/ARH [1KATA\ T]1OU= PO[1L]1E/MOU TE[1TA/XQ]1AI KAI\ TH=S TA/[1CEWS]1 KAI\ A)N[1T]1ITA/C[1EWS. *(/H]1FAI-STON DE\ PU=[1R EI)=N]1AI, KAI\ *KRO/NON [1ME\N TO\]1N TOU= R(EU/[1M]1ATOS R([1O/O]1N, *(RE/AN DE\ TH\N GH=N, *DI/A DE\ TO\N AI)QE/RA: TOU\S DE\ TO\N *)APO/LLW[I] KA[1I\]1 TH\N *DH/MHTRA G[1H=]1N H)\ TO\ E)N AU)TH=| PNEU=MA. KAI\ PAIDARIWDW=S LE/GESQAI KAI\ GRA/FESQAI KA[E]I\ PLA/T[1T]1ESQAI [1QEOU\]1S A)NQR[1WPOEIDEI=S]1 O(\N TRO/PON KAI\ PO/LEIS KAI\ POTAMOU\S KAI\ TO/POUS KAI\ PA/Q[1H. *K]1AI\ *DI/A ME\[1N EI)=]1NA[1I TO\N PE]1RI\ TH\N [1GH=]1N A)E/RA, [1T]1O\[1N]1 DE\ SKO[1TEI]1NO\N *AI(/D[1HN]1, TO\N DE\ DIA\ TH=S GH=[1S K]1AI\ QALA/T[1T]1HS *POS[1EIDW=]1. *KAI\ TO[1U\S]1 A)/LLOU[1S D]1E\ QEOU\S A)YU/XOIS W(S KAI\ TOU/TOUS SUNOIKEIOI=: KAI\ TO\N H(/L[1I]1O/N [1TE]1 KAI\ TH\[1N]1 SE-LH/NHN KAI\ TOU\S A)/LLOUS A)STE/[1R]1AS QEOU\S OI)/ETAI KAI\ TO\N NO/MON. *KA[1I\ A)N]1QRW/POUS EI)S QEO[1U/]1S FHSI ME[1T]1ABALEI=[1N]1. @&Cicero de nat. deor. I 15, 39.&3 Iam vero <21Chrysippus>21, qui &3Stoicorum somniorum vaferrumus habetur interpres, magnam turbam &3congregat ignotorum deorum, atque ita ignotorum, ut eos ne coniectura &3quidem informare possimus, cum mens nostra quidvis videatur cogitatione &3posse depingere; ait enim vim divinam in ratione esse positam et in &3universae naturae animo atque mente, ipsumque mundum deum dicit &3esse et eius animi fusionem universam, tum eius ipsius principatum, &3qui in mente et ratione versetur, communemque rerum naturam universi-&3tatemque omnia continentem, tum fatalem orbem et necessitatem rerum @1 &3futurarum, ignem praeterea et eum, quem ante dixi, aethera, tum ea &3quae natura fluerent atque manarent, ut et aquam et terram et ae%28ra, &3solem, lunam, sidera, universitatemque rerum, qua omnia continerentur, &3atque etiam homines eos, qui immortalitatem essent consecuti.& 40.&3 Idem-&3que disputat aethera esse eum, quem homines Iovem appellarent, quique &3ae%28r per maria manaret, eum esse Neptunum, terramque eam esse, quae &3Ceres diceretur, similique ratione persequitur vocabula reliquorum deo-&3rum. Idemque etiam legis perpetuae et aeternae vim, quae quasi dux &3vitae et magistra officiorum sit, Iovem dicit esse eandemque fatalem &3necessitatem appellat, sempiternam rerum futurarum veritatem; quorum &3nihil tale est, ut in eo vis divina inesse videatur.& 41.&3 Et haec quidem &3<21in primo libro de natura deorum>21, in <21secundo>21 autem volt Orphei, &3Musaei, Hesiodi, Homerique fabellas accommodare ad ea, quae ipse &3primo libro de deis immortalibus dixerat, ut etiam veterrimi poe%28tae, qui &3haec ne suspicati quidem sint, Stoici fuisse videantur. @&Philodemus de pietate c. 13 [1DDG p. 547&14b& 16$]1. <20E)N DE\ TW=| DEUTE/RW|>20 [1&scil.$ <20PERI\ QEW=N>20]1 TA/ TE EI)S *)ORFE/A KAI\ *MOUSAI=ON A)NAFE-RO/MENA KAI\ TA\ PAR' *(OMH/RW| KAI\ *(HSIO/DW| KAI\ *EU)RIPI/DH| K[I]AI\ POIHTAI=S A)/LLOIS, W(S KAI\ *KLEA/NQHS, PEIRA=TAI SUNOIKEIOU=N TAI=S DO/CAIS AU)TW=N. A(/PANTA/ T' E)STI\N AI)QH/R, O( AU)TO\S W)\N KAI\ PATH\R KAI\ UI(O/S, W(S <20KA)N TW=| PRW/TW|>20 MH\ MA/XESQAI TO\ TH\N *(RE/AN KAI\ MHTE/RA TOU= *DIO\S EI)=NAI KAI\ QUGATE/RA. @&10Philo de provid. II %14 41 [1p. 76 Aucher]1. Si quae de Vul-&10cano fabulose referuntur, reducas in ignem, et quod de Iunone, ad ae%28ris &10naturam, quod autem de Mercurio ad rationem, sicut etiam cetera, quae &10cuique propria sunt, ad ordinem iuxta vestigium theologiae, tunc profecto &10poe%28tarum a te paulo ante accusatorum [1i. e. Homeri et Hesiodi]1 laudator &10eris, utpote qui vere decenterque laudibus celebrarint divinitatem. &10@Cicero de nat. deor. II 71. Sed tamen his fabulis spretis ac &10repudiatis deus pertinens per naturam cuiusque rei, per terras Ceres, per &10maria Neptunus, alii per alia, poterunt intellegi qui qualesque sint, quo-&10que eos nomine consuetudo nuncupaverit, hoc eos et venerari et colere &10debemus. @&Philodemus de pietate c. 14 [1DDG p. 547&14b& 3$]1. TA\S D' AU)-TA\S POIE[1I=]1TAI S[1U]1NOIKEI[1W/SE]1IS <20KA)N TW=| PERI\ [1*X]1ARI/TWN>20, [1E)N W(=| T]1O\N *DI/A NO/MON FHSI\N EI)=NAI KAI\ TA\S *XA/RITAS TA\S H(METE/[1R]1AS KATARXA\S KA[1I\]1 TA\S A)NTAP[1O]1DO/SEIS TW=N EU)E[1RG]1ESIW=[1N]1. @&Seneca de beneficiis I 3.&3 Quorum quae vis quaeve proprie-&3tas sit dicam, si prius illa, quae ad rem non pertinent, transsilire mihi &3permiseris%10 quare tres Gratiae et quare sorores sint et quare manibus &3inplexis et quare ridentes [et iuvenes add. Gertz] et virgines solutaque @1 &3ac perlucida veste. Alii quidem videri volunt unam esse quae det bene-&3ficium, alteram quae accipiat, tertiam quae reddat. alii beneficiorum &3tria genera, promerentium, reddentium, simul et accipientium reddentium-&3que. Sed utrumlibet ex istis iudico verum, quid ista nos iuvat scientia? &3Quid ille consertis manibus in se reducitur chorus [1vulg. redeuntium]1? &3ob hoc, quia ordo beneficii per manus transeuntis nihilominus ad dantem &3revertitur et totius speciem perdit, si usquam interruptus est, pulcherri-&3mus si cohaeret et vices servat. Ideo ...... est aliqua tamen maior &3his dignatio, sicut promerentium. Voltus hilari sunt quales solent esse &3qui dant vel accipiunt beneficia, iuvenes, quia non debet beneficiorum &3memoria senescere, virgines, quia incorrupta sunt et sincera et omnibus &3sancta; in quibus nihil esse adligati decet nec adstricti, solutis itaque &3tunicis utuntur, perlucidis autem quia beneficia conspici volunt. Sit ali-&3quis usque eo Graecis emancipatus, ut haec dicat necessaria, nemo tamen &3erit, qui etiam illud ad rem iudicet pertinere, quae nomina illis Hesio-&3dus imposuerit. Aeglen maximam natu appellavit, mediam Euphro-&3synen, tertiam Thalian. Horum nominum interpretationem, prout cui-&3que visum est deflectit et ad rationem aliquam conatur perducere, cum &3Hesiodus puellis suis quod voluit nomen imposuerit. Itaque Homerus &3uni mutavit, Pasithean appellavit et in matrimonium produxit, ut scias &3illas non esse virgines Vestales. Inveniam alium poe%28tam, apud quem &3praecingantur et spissis aut Phryxianis prodeant. Ergo et Mercurius &3una stat, non quia beneficia ratio commendat vel oratio, sed quia pictori &3ita visum est. <21Chrysippus>21 quoque, penes quem subtile illud acumen &3est et in imam penetrans veritatem, qui rei agendae causa loquitur et &3verbis non ultra quam ad intellectum satis est utitur, <21totum librum &3suum>21 [1sc.$ PERI\ *XARI/TWN&3]1 his ineptiis replet, ita ut de ratione dandi, &3accipiendi, reddendique beneficii pauca admodum dicat, nec his fabulas, &3sed haec fabulis inserit. Nam praeter ista, quae <21Hecaton>21 transscribit, &3tres Chrysippus Gratias ait Iovis et Eurynomes filias esse, aetate autem &3minores quam horas, sed meliuscula facie et ideo Veneri dates comites. &3Matris quoque nomen ad rem iudicat pertinere%10 Eurynomen enim dic-&3tam, quia late patentis patrimonii sit beneficia dividere%10 tamquam matri &3post filias soleat nomen imponi aut poe%28tae vera nomina reddant. ....... &3[1paullo infra]1 ecce Thalia, de qua cum maxime agitur, apud Hesiodum &3Charis est, apud Homerum Musa. @&Idem de Benef. III 4.&3 tu modo nos tuere, siquis mihi obiciet, quod &3<21Chrysippum>21 in ordinem coe%28gerim, magnum mehercule virum, sed tamen &3Graecum, cuius acumen nimis tenue retunditur et in se saepe replicatur. &3Etiam cum agere aliquid videtur, pungit, non perforat. @&ibidem %14 4%10&3 ad hanc honestissimam contentionem beneficiis bene- @1&3ficia vincendi sic nos adhortatur <21Chrysippus>21 ut dicat, verendum esse, &3ne quia Charites Iovis filiae sunt parum se grate gerere sacrilegium sit &3et tam bellis puellis fiat iniuria. @[1&Sequentibus Seneca inludit Chrysippum, qui fabuloso sermone et &anilibus argumentis lectores oblectare studerit%10&3 istae vero ineptiae poe%28tis &3relinquantur, quibus aures oblectare propositum est et dulcem fabulam &3nectere]1. @&10Ad totam Senecae disputationem cf. Cornutus cp. 15 atque &10maxime haec verba%10$10 OI( D' E)C *EU)RUNO/MHS, KAI\ TOU/TOU PARISTA/NTOS O(/TI XARISTIKW/TEROI/ PW/S EI)SIN H)\ O)FEI/LOUSIN EI)=NAI OI( MEGA/LOUS KLH/ROUS NEMO/-MENOI. @&Etymologicum Magn. s. v.$ *(RE/A &p. 701, 24.$ *XRU/SIPPOS DE\ LE/GEI TH\N GH=N *(RE/AN KEKLH=SQAI, E)PEIDH\ A)P' AU)TH=S R(EI= TA\ U(/DATA. @&Scholia Hesiod. Theogon. v. 135.$ *(REI/A H( E)C O)/MBRWN XU/SIS E)STI/, KATA\ DE\ TO\N <20*XRU/SIPPON>20 H( GH= <20*(RE/A>20 H( FQARTIKH/, O(/TI EI)S AU)TH\N A)NALUO/MEQA KAI\ O(/TI PA/NTES TW=N E)N AU)TH=| DIAR)R(E/OUSI. <20*QE/MIN>20 GA\R TH\N QE/SIN TOU= PANTO\S TH\N A)META/QETON, <20*MNHMOSU/NHN>20 DE\ TH\N E)PIMONH\N TH=S DIAPLA/SEWS TW=N ZW/|WN. @&Ibid. v. 136.$ <20*FOI/BHN>20: TO\ KAQARO\N TOU= A)E/ROS, DIA\ TOU=TO KAI\ XRUSOSTE/FANON: KAQARO\S GA\R O( XRUSO/S. <20*THQU/N T' E)RATEINH/N>20: TH\N TROFO\N H)\ TH\N PLEUSTH\N QA/LASSAN, TH\N DIA\ KE/RDOS TRE/FOUSAN. @&10Scholia Hesiod. Theogon. v. 134.$10 A)LLHGOROU=SI DE\ A)/LLWS TO\N ME\N *KOI=ON EI)=NAI TH\N POIO/THTA KAI\ *KREI=ON TH\N KRI/SIN: *(UPERI/ONA DE\ TO\N OU)-RANO/N, TO\N U(PERA/NW H(MW=N I)O/NTA, KAI\ *)IAPETO\N TH\N KI/NHSIN AU)TOU=, PARA\ TO\ I(/ESQAI KAI\ PE/TESQAI. O( GA\R OU)RANO\S A)EIKI/NHTO/S E)STI. A)/LLWS: *)IAPETO\N LE/GEI TH\N TOU= LOGISMOU= KI/NHSIN PARA\ TO\ PA/NTA A)NEREUNA=N KAI\ ZHTEI=N PERI\ PA/NTWN. @&10Scholia Hesiod. Theog. v. 459.$10 NOMI/ZETAI DE\ PAI=S *OU)RANOU= KAI\ *GH=S [1&10scil.$10 O( *KRO/NOS]1 O(/TI E)K TH=S E)PITOLH=S TW=N U(PE\R GH=S KAI\ U(PO\ GH=N A)/STRWN O( XRO/NOS GI/NETAI. DIA\ GA\R TOU/TWN KAI\ H(MERONU/KTION KAI\ MH=NA KAI\ KAIRO\N DIORI/ZOMEN. KATAPI/NEIN DE\ LE/GETAI TA\ TE/KNA, O(/TI O(/SA DIA\ XRO/NOU GI/NETAI, TW=| XRO/NW| PA/LIN SUNDIAFQEI/RETAI. @&10Scholia Hesiod. Theog. v. 459.$10 H( DE\ E)KTOMH\ AU)TOU= [1&10 Scil.$10 TOU= KRO/NOU]1 OU(/TWS A)NALU/ETAI: O(/TI TOU= *OU)RANOU= KAI\ TH=S GH=S MI/CEWS GENOME/NHS E)ZW|OGONEI=TO POLLA/: EI)=TA TOU= XRO/NOU E(/KASTA DIAKRI/NANTOS KAI\ TA\ GENNHQE/NTA E)K TH=S PRO\S A)/LLHLA MI/CEWS ZW|OGONOU=NTOS E)KTETMH=SQAI TO\N *OU)RANO\N EI)/RHTAI. @1 @&Etymologicum Magn. s. v.$ *KRO/NOS. *TO\N *KRO/NON FASI\N E)K TOU= KRA=N KAI\ KIRNA=N E(/KASTA TW=N GENEQLIWMA/TWN KAI\ MI/CAI TO\ QH=LU TW=| A)/RRENI. <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 DE/ FHSIN [O(/TI] KAQU/GRWN O)/NTWN TW=N O(/LWN KAI\ O)/MBRWN KATAFEROME/NWN POLLW=N, TH\N E)/KKRISIN TOU/TWN *KRO/NON W)NOMA/SQAI. @&Scholia Hesiod. Theog. v. 459 [1p. 256 Flach]1.$ *KRO/NOS EI)/-RHTAI A)PO\ TOU= KERA=N KAI\ KIRNA=N E(/KASTA TW=N GENEQLIWMA/TWN KAI\ MI=CAI TO\ QH=LU TW=| A)/R)R(ENI. <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 DE/ FHSI, KAQU/GRWN O)/NTWN TW=N O(/LWN KAI\ O)/MBRWN KATAFEROME/NWN POLLW=N, TH\N TOU/TWN E)/KKRISIN *KRO/-NON W)NOMA/SQAI. @&10Cicero de nat. deor. II 64. Saturnum autem eum esse volue-&10runt, qui cursum et conversionem spatiorum ac temporum contineret, qui &10deus Graece id ipsum nomen habet;$10 *KRO/NOS&10 enim dicitur, qui est idem$10 XRO/NOS, &10id est spatium temporis. __ex se enim natos comesse fingi-&10tur solitus, quia consumit aetas temporum spatia__vinctus autem &10a Iove, ne immoderatos cursus haberet, atque ut eum siderum vinclis &10alligaret. @&10Scholia Hesiod. Theog. v. 211.$10 TREI=S DE/ FASIN EI)=NAI TA\S *MOI/-RAS, TH\N ME\N *KLWQW/, W(S E)PIKLW/QOUSAN E(NI\ E(KA/STW| TW=N U(PO\ GE/NESIN TO\ EI(-MARME/NON, TH\N DE\ *LA/XESIN A)PO\ TOU= LAGXA/NEIN, W(S E)PIKLHROU=SAN TW=| ME\N A)GAQO/N, TW=| DE\ E)NANTI/ON, TH\N DE\ *)/ATROPON, W(S POIOU=SAN TO\ A)POKLHRWQE\N A)META/TREPTON. @&10Plutarchus de Iside et Osiride cp. 40 p. 367c.$10 A)LLA\ TAU=TA ME\N O(/MOIA TOI=S U(PO\ <20TW=N *STWI+KW=N>20 QEOLOGOUME/NOIS E)STI/. KAI\ GA\R E)KEI=NOI TO\ ME\N GO/NIMON PNEU=MA KAI\ TRO/FIMON *DIO/NUSON EI)=NAI LE/GOUSI, TO\ PLHKTIKO\N DE\ KAI\ DIAIRETIKO\N *(HRAKLE/A, TO\ DE\ DEKTIKO\N *)/AMMWNA, *DH/MHTRA DE\ KAI\ *KO/RHN TO\ DIA\ TH=S GH=S KAI\ TW=N KARPW=N DIH=KON, *POSEIDW=NA DE\ TO\ DIA\ TH=S QALA/SSHS. @&Plutarchus in Amatorio cp. 13 p. 757b.$ O( DE\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 E)CHGOU/MENOS TOU)/NOMA TOU= QEOU= [1&scil. Martis$]1 KATHGORI/AN POIEI= KAI\ DIA-BOLH/N: A)NAIREI=N GA\R EI)=NAI TO\N *)/ARHN FHSI/N, A)RXA\S DIDOU\S TOI=S TO\ MAXHTIKO\N E)N H(MI=N KAI\ DIA/FORON KAI\ QUMOEIDE\S *)/ARHN KEKLH=SQAI NO-MI/ZOUSIN. @&Macrobius Saturn. I 17, 7. Plato solem$ *)APO/LLWNA &scribit &cognominatum$ A)PO\ TOU= A)POPA/LLEIN TA\S A)KTI=NAS &id est a iactu radio-&rum, <21Chrysippus>21 Apollinem$ W(S OU)XI\ TW=N POLLW=N KAI\ FAU/LWN OU)- @1SIW=N TOU= PURO\S O)/NTA, &primam enim nominis litteram retinere signifi-&cationem negandi,$ H)\ O(/TI MO/NOS E)STI\ KAI\ OU)XI\ POLLOI/. @&10Iustinus Apol. I 64.$10 *KAI\ TH\N *)AQHNA=N DE\ O(MOI/WS PONHREUO/ME-NOI QUGATE/RA TOU= *DIO\S E)/FASAN OU)K A)PO\ MI/CEWS, A)LL' E)PEIDH\ E)NNOHQE/NTA TO\N QEO\N DIA\ LO/GOU TO\N KO/SMON POIH=SAI E)/GNWSAN, W(S TH\N PRW/THN E)/NNOIAN E)/FASAN TH\N *)AQHNA=N. @&10Sextus adv. math. IX 40.$10 TINA\ ME\N GA\R LO/GOU I)/SWS E)/XETAI, KAQA/PER TO\ TH\N GH=N QEO\N NOMI/ZEIN, OU) TH\N AU)LAKOTOMOUME/NHN H)\ A)NASKAPTO-ME/NHN OU)SI/AN, A)LLA\ TH\N DIH/KOUSAN E)N AU)TH=| DU/NAMIN KAI\ KARPOFO/RON FU/SIN KAI\ O)/NTWS DAIMONIWTA/THN. @&Ioannes Laurentius Lydus de mensibus IV 44 p. 212 ed. &Ro+ther.$ *(O <20DE\ *XRU/SIPPOS>20 OU) *DIW/NHN A)LLA\ *DIDO/NHN AU)TH\N O)NOMA/-ZESQAI A)CIOI= PARA\ TO\ E)PIDIDO/NAI TA\S TH=S GENE/SEWS H(DONA/S, *KU/PRIN DE\ O)NOMASQH=NAI PARA\ TO\ KU/EIN PARE/XEIN, KAI\ *KUQEREI/HN O(MOI/WS PARA\ TO\ MH\ MO/NON A)NQRW/POIS, A)LLA\ KAI\ QHRI/OIS TO\ KU/EIN E)PIDIDO/NAI. @&Plutarchus Quaest. Conviv. IX 14. Herodes rhetor dicit%10$ E)GW\ DE\ METAPOIOU=MAI/ TI KAI\ TH=S *TERYIXO/RHS: EI)/PER, W(/S FHSI <20*XRU/-SIPPOS>20, AU(/TH TO\ PERI\ TA\S O(MILI/AS E)PITERPE\S EI)/LHXE KAI\ KEXARISME/NON. @&10Scholia in Aratum v. 1.$10 METE/BH E)PI\ TO\N KAT' E)PWNUMI/AN *DI/A, TO\N FUSIKO/N, O(/S E)STIN A)H/R. KAI\ GA\R TO\N A)E/RA *DI/A LE/GOUSIN: OU(=TOS GA/R E)STI KATA\ TOU\S <20*STWI+KOU\S>20 O( DIA\ PA/NTWN DIH/KWN. E)/NIOI GOU=N FASI\ TO\N *PRWTE/A TOU=TON EI)=NAI TO\N A)E/RA. AI)NI/TTETAI GA\R KAI\ *(/OMHROS LE/GWN "1GI/GNETO D' U(GRO\N U(/DWR, KAI\ DE/NDRON U(YIPE/THLON KAI\ PU=R."2 OU(=TOS GA/R E)STI PHGH\ PA/NTWN. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. I 8, 2.$10 *QALH=S *PUQAGO/RAS *PLA/TWN <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 DAI/MONAS U(PA/RXEIN OU)SI/AS YUXIKA/S: EI)=NAI DE\ KAI\ H(/RWAS TA\S KEXWRISME/NAS YUXA\S TW=N SWMA/TWN: KAI\ A)GAQOU\S ME\N TA\S A)GAQA/S, KAKOU\S DE\ TA\S FAU/LAS. @&10Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 151.$10 FASI\ DE\ EI)=NAI KAI/ TINAS DAI/MONAS A)NQRW/PWN SUMPA/QEIAN E)/XONTAS, E)PO/PTAS TW=N A)NQRWPEI/WN PRAGMA/TWN: KAI\ H(/RWAS TA\S U(POLELEIMME/NAS TW=N SPOUDAI/WN YUXA/S. @&Plutarchus de Iside et Osiride cp. 25 p. 360e.$ *BE/LTION OU)=N OI( TA\ PERI\ TO\N *TUFW=NA KAI\ *)/OSIRIN KAI\ *)=ISIN I(STOROU/MENA MH/TE QEW=N PAQH/MATA MH/T' A)NQRW/PWN, A)LLA\ DAIMO/NWN MEGA/LWN EI)=NAI NOMI/-ZONTES, OU(\S KAI\ *PLA/TWN KAI\ *PUQAGO/RAS KAI\ *CENOKRA/THS KAI\ <20*XRU/-SIPPOS>20, E(PO/MENOI TOI=S PA/LAI QEOLO/GOIS, E)R)R(WMENESTE/ROUS ME\N A)NQRW/-PWN GEGONE/NAI LE/GOUSI KAI\ POLU\ TH=| DUNA/MEI TH\N FU/SIN U(PERFE/RONTAS @1 H(MW=N, TO\ DE\ QEI=ON OU)K A)MIGE\S OU)DE\ A)/KRATON E)/XONTAS, A)LLA\ KAI\ YUXH=S FU/SEI KAI\ SW/MATOS AI)SQH/SEI [E)N] SUNEILHXO/S, H(DONH\N DEXO/MENON KAI\ PO/NON KAI\ O(/SA TAU/TAIS E)GGENO/MENA TAI=S METABOLAI=S PA/QH TOU\S ME\N MA=LLON TOU\S DE\ H(=TTON E)PITARA/TTEI. @&Plutarchus de oraculorum defectu cp. 17.$ *)ALLA\ FAU/LOUS ME/N, E)/FH, DAI/MONAS OU)K *)EMPEDOKLH=S MO/NON A)PE/LIPEN, A)LLA\ KAI\ *PLA/-TWN KAI\ *CENOKRA/THS KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20, E)/TI DE\ *DHMO/KRITOS. @&10Sextus adv. math. IX 71.$10 KAI\ GA\R OU)DE\ TA\S YUXA\S E)/NESTIN U(PONOH=SAI KA/TW FEROME/NAS [1&10scil.$10 EI)S *(/AIDOU]1. LEPTOMEREI=S GA\R OU)=SAI KAI\ OU)X H(=TTON PURW/DEIS H)\ PNEUMATW/DEIS EI)S TOU\S A)/NW MA=LLON TO/POUS KOUFOFO-ROU=SIN. KAI\ KAQ' AU(TA\S DE\ DIAME/NOUSI KAI\ OU)X, W(S E)/LEGEN *)EPI/KOUROS, A)PO-LUQEI=SAI TW=N SWMA/TWN KAPNOU= DI/KHN SKI/DNANTAI. OU)DE\ GA\R PRO/TERON TO\ SW=MA DIAKRATHTIKO\N H)=N AU)TW=N, A)LL' AU)TAI\ TW=| SW/MATI SUMMONH=S H)=SAN AI)/TIAI, POLU\ DE\ PRO/TERON KAI\ E(AUTAI=S. E)/KSKHNOI GOU=N H(LI/OU GENO/MENAI TO\N U(PO\ SELH/NHN OI)KOU=SI TO/PON, E)NQA/DE TE DIA\ TH\N EI)LIKRI/NEIAN TOU= A)E/ROS PLEI/ONA PRO\S DIAMONH\N LAMBA/NOUSI XRO/NON, TROFH=| TE XRW=NTAI OI)KEI/A| TH=| A)PO\ GH=S A)NAQUMIA/SEI W(S KAI\ TA\ LOIPA\ A)/STRA, TO\ DIALU=O/N TE AU)TA\S E)N E)KEI/NOIS TOI=S TO/POIS OU)K E)/XOUSIN. EI) OU)=N DIAME/NOUSIN AI( YUXAI/, DAI/MOSIN AI( AU)TAI\ GI/NONTAI. @1 @&10Ad totam <21de providentia>21 doctrinam conferenda est <21Cice-&10ronis>21 in <21altero "1de natura deorum>21"2 disputatio, quam exscribere &10nolui. &10@Cicero de nat. deor. III 92. vos enim ipsi dicere soletis nihil &10esse, quod deus efficere non possit, et quidem sine labore ullo; ut enim &10hominum membra nulla contentione mente ipsa ac voluntate moveantur, &10sic numine deorum omnia fingi moveri mutarique posse. Neque id dicitis &10superstitiose atque aniliter, sed physica constantique ratione; materiam &10enim rerum ex qua et in qua omnia sint, totam esse flexibilem et com-&10mutabilem, ut nihil sit, quod non ex ea quamvis subito fingi convertique &10possit; eius autem universae fictricem et moderatricem divinam esse provi-&10dentiam; hanc igitur, quocunque se moveat, efficere posse quicquid velit. &10@Plutarchus de Iside et Osiride cp. 45 p. 369a.$10 OU)/TE GA\R E)N A)YU/XOIS SW/MASIN TA\S TOU= PANTO\S A)RXA\S QETE/ON, W(S *DHMO/KRITOS KAI\ *)EPI/KOU-ROS, OU)/TE A)POI/OU DHMIOURGO\N U(/LHS E(/NA LO/GON KAI\ MI/AN PRO/NOIAN, W(S OI( <20*STWI+KOI/>20, PERIGIGNOME/NHN A(PA/NTWN KAI\ KRATOU=SAN. @&10Lactantius div. instit. I 2. quos tamen et ceteri philosophi &10ac maxime <21Stoici>21 acerrime retuderunt, docentes nec fieri mundum sine &10divina ratione potuisse, nec constare nisi summa ratione regeretur. &10@Commenta Lucani Lib. II 9 p. 48 Us. Hoc secundum <21Stoi-&10cos>21 dicit qui adfirmant mundum prudentia ac lege firmatum, ipsumque &10deum esse sibi legem. &10@Philo de provid. I %14 25 [1p. 13 Aucher]1. Providet__et homo &10filiis et armentarius pecoribus et agaso equis et gregi pastor, nauclerus &10navi et infirmis medicus%10 ipsa quoque apis sapiens et formica provida est. &10Haec autem partes sunt et particulae partium universorum; partes tamen &10sapientes et provide curam habentes. Cuius itaque pars sapiens est ac &10provida, nonne et totum sapiens erit? &10@Atqui haec omnia, quae recensuimus, habent principium creationis. &10Quod vero habet principium, incepit; et quod incepit, a quodam initio &10sumpto incepit. Ab alio ergo principium duxit ille, qui incipiendo factus @1 &10fuit sapiens ac providus. Ceterum quomodo erit quis providus sine pro-&10videntia aut sapiens absque sapientia? Si ergo providus et sapiens nemo &10erit sine providentia vel sapientia, utique fuit ens aliquod providum at-&10que sapiens, a quo initium haec sortita sunt. &10@Philo de provid. I %14 29 [1p. 14 Aucher]1. In viventis natura &10profecto datur cogitatio prudens, omnia exornans sapientesque motus effi-&10ciens. Quare iis qui corpora intuentur, manifeste patet in iis, quae sen-&10sibiliter operantur, motum dari spiritus praemoventis et praevidentis in-&10visibile consilium animae, ut opus instrumentorum operi ipsi inservientium &10perfectius reddatur. Non alio modo profecto accipiendi sunt et motus &10illi in orbem terrarum diffusi a providentia; ita ut videamus iuxta provi-&10dentiae incognitam voluntatem iam evidenter totum peractum. Etenim fieri &10nequit, ut haec omnia putentur a nullo aut animo aut voluntate profecta &10esse, cum et ipsae partes minutissimae consilio et instinctu providentiae &10cuncta exequantur. &10@Philo de provid. I %14 32 [1p. 15 Aucher]1. Neque enim decet &10__partes universi prudentes esse ac providas existimare, eam vero, &10quae ab initio inest universis, providentiam inter entia creata otiosam ac &10incuriosam esse, cum ex una universali harmonia ac compositione sint &10omnia. Quae enim a se invicem pendent, non sine utriusque motu actum &10sortiuntur. Itaque partes sapientes per acta perfecta, quae oriuntur ex &10ipsarum symphonia, argumentum praebent et declarationem universae pro-&10videntiae invisibiliter omnia moventis. &10@Philo de provid. I %14 40 [1p. 19 Aucher]1. Si nec providentia &10est nec universalis motor, nihil omnino in mundo moveri poterit. Quis &10enim dicere potest, totius mundi compositio inanimata cum sit, animatos &10motus fieri posse in natura perfectae creaturae? Quod si non constat, ar-&10gumenti loco sit civis huius mundi homo ipse, qui tamquam parvus mun-&10dus in magno mundo factus est, cum sine anima nequeat corpus actiones &10suas perficere, nisi prius consilio eius optimo velut amici cuiusdam utatur: &10quandoquidem postquam praevaluerunt in animo deliberationes invisibiles, &10visibiliter sequitur sensibilium membrorum officium. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. c. 38 p. 1051e.$ *PRO\S TO\N *)EPI/KOURON MA/LISTA MA/XETAI KAI\ PRO\S TOU\S A)NAIROU=NTAS TH\N PRO/NOIAN, A)PO\ TW=N E)NNOIW=N A(\S E)/XOMEN PERI\ QEW=N, EU)ERGETIKOU\S KAI\ FILANQRW/-POUS E)PINOOU=NTES. *KAI\ TOU/TWN POLLAXOU= GRAFOME/NWN KAI\ LEGOME/NWN PAR' AU)TOI=S OU)DE\N E)/DEI LE/CEIS PARATI/QESQAI. @&10Clemens Al. Paedag. I 8 p. 138 Pott.$10 TO\ DE\ W)FELOU=N TOU= MH\ W)FELOU=NTOS PA/NTWS A)/N POU KREI=TTON EI)/H. TOU= DE\ A)GAQOU= KREI=TTON OU)DE\ E(/N. W)FELEI= A)/RA TO\ A)GAQO/N. *)AGAQO\S DE\ O( QEO\S O(MOLOGEI=TAI: W)FELEI= A)/RA O( QEO/S. *TO\ DE\ A)GAQO\N H(=| A)GAQO/N E)STIN OU)DE\N A)/LLO POIEI= H)\ O(/TI W)FELEI=: PA/NTA A)/RA W)FELEI= O( QEO/S. *KAI\ OU) DH/POU W)FELEI= ME/N TI TO\N A)/NQRWPON, OU)XI\ DE\ KH/DE-TAI AU)TOU=, OU)DE\ KH/DETAI ME/N, OU)XI\ DE\ KAI\ E)PIMELEI=TAI AU)TOU=: KREI=TTON ME\N GA\R TO\ KATA\ GNW/MHN W)FELOU=N TOU= MH\ W)FELOU=NTOS KATA\ GNW/MHN: TOU= DE\ QEOU= KREI=TTON OU)DE/N: KAI\ OU)K A)/LLO TI E)STI\ TO\ KATA\ GNW/MHN W)FELEI=N, EI) MH\ E)PIMELEI=SQAI [TOU= A)NQRW/POU]. KH/DETAI A)/RA KAI\ E)PIMELEI=TAI TOU= A)NQRW/POU @1 O( QEO/S. ___TO\ DE\ A)GAQO\N EI)=NAI OU) TW=| TH\N A)RETH\N E)/XEIN A)GAQO\N EI)=NAI LE/GETAI: KAQO\ KAI\ H( DIKAIOSU/NH A)GAQO\N EI)=NAI LE/GETAI OU) TW=| A)RETH\N E)/XEIN, A)RETH\ GA/R E)STIN AU)TH/, A)LLA\ TW=| AU)TH\N KAQ' AU(TH\N KAI\ DI' AU(TH\N A)GAQH\N EI)=NAI &10etc. &10@Seneca ep. 95, 47. [1quomodo sint di colendi?]1 __deum &10colit, qui novit. __nunquam satis profectum erit, nisi qualem debet &10deum mente conceperit, omnia habentem, omnia tribuentem gratis. <21Quae &10causa est dis benefaciendi? natura. errat, siquis illos putat &10nocere nolle%10 non possunt>21. nec accipere iniuriam queunt nec facere. &10@Alexander Aphrod. Quaest. II 21 p. 68, 19 Bruns.$10 TO\ GA\R __TOU\S QEOU\S LE/GEIN DIA\ TH\N TW=N QNHTW=N SWTHRI/AN TA\S OI)-KEI/AS E)NERGEI/AS E)NERGEI=N>20 PANTELW=S A)LLO/TRION QEW=N: PARAPLH/SION GA\R TOU=TO TW=| LE/GONTI TOU\S E)LEUQE/ROUS KAI\ TOU\S DESPO/TAS TW=N OI)KETW=N EI)=NAI XA/RIN &10etc. @&ibid. 28.$8 KAI/TOI GE E)PI\ ME\N TW=N DOU/LWN KAI\ TW=N DESPOTW=N E)/STIN EI)PEI=N A)NTI/DOSIN AU)TOI=S TINA GI/GNESQAI PAR' A)LLH/LWN__TO\ DE\ TH\N TW=N QEW=N SWTHRI/AN DEI=SQAI LE/GEIN TH=S TW=N QNHTW=N E)NERGEI/AS A)/TOPON A)\N EI)=-NAI DO/CEIE PANTA/PASIN. *PW=S GA\R OU)/; *)/ATOPON DE\ TOU/TW| PARAPLHSI/WS KAI\ <20TO\ TE/LOS KAI\ TA)GAQO\N TW=N QEW=N EI)=NAI LE/GEIN E)N TH=| TW=N QNHTW=N TA/CEI TE KAI\ PRONOI/A|>20. __A)LL' EI) TA\S OI)KEI/AS TO\ QEI=ON E)NERGH/SEI E)NERGEI/AS TH=S TW=N QNHTW=N SWTHRI/AS, OU)X AU(TOU= XA/RIN, PANTA/-PASIN A)\N DO/CEIE TW=N QNHTW=N EI)=NAI XA/RIN. *POIH/SEI DE\ [1&scil.$8 O( QEO\S]1 TOU=TO <20KATA\ TOU\S E)N TW=| PRONOEI=N TH\N OU)SI/AN AU)TOU= TIQEME/NOUS>20. ވ*TI/ GA\R A)/LLO TO\ QEI=ON E)/STAI KATA\ TO\N GRA/FONTA: @"1<20*)EPEI\ TI/ TO\ KATALEIPO/MENON H)\ TH=S XIO/NOS, A)\N A)FE/LH| TO\ LEUKO\N KAI\ YUXRO/N; TI/ DE\ PURO/S, A)\N TO\ QERMO\N SBE/SH|S, ME/LI-TOS DE\ TO\ GLUKU\ KAI\ YUXH=S TO\ KINEI=SQAI KAI\ TOU= QEOU= TO\ PRO-NOEI=N>20;"2 @*EI) GA\R E)N TW=| PRONOEI=N TO\ EI)=NAI QEW=| KATA\ TO\N OU(/TW LE/GONTA/ TE KAI\ GRA/FONTA &etc. [1impium esse hoc Stoicorum placitum Al. evincit]1. @&10ibid. p. 70, 2.$10 A)/TOPON D' A)\N E(/POITO TOI=S A)NATIQEI=SI ME\N PA/NTA TH=| PRO-NOI/A|, LE/GOUSI DE\ KAI\ MO/NON TO\ KALO\N A)GAQO\N KAI\ TOU=T' E)F' H(MI=N EI)=NAI TIQE-ME/NOIS: TINO\S A)GAQOU= TOI=S A)NQRW/POIS KAT' AU)TOU\S OU)X OI(=O/N TE GI/NESQAI TH\N QEI/AN PRO/NOIAN, E)N H(=| TO\ EI)=NAI TOI=S QEOI=S FASIN EI)=NAI. @1 @&10Seneca de benificiis IV 25. Propositum est nobis secundum &10rerum naturam vivere et deorum exemplum sequi%10 <21di autem, quodcun-&10que faciunt, in eo quid praeter ipsam faciendi rationem sequun-&10tur>21? nisi forte illos existimas fructum operum suorum ex fumo extorum &10et turis odore percipere. &10@Lactantius de ira dei cp. 5. Existimantur <21Stoici>21 et alii non-&10nulli aliquanto melius de divinitate sensisse, qui aiunt, <21gratiam in Deo &10esse, iram non esse>21. Favorabilis admodum ac popularis oratio, non &10cadere in deum hanc animi pusillanimitatem, ut ab ullo se laesum putet, &10qui laedi non potest; ut quieta illa et sancta maiestas concitetur, pertur-&10betur, insaniat%10 quod est terrenae fragilitatis. Iram enim commotionem &10mentis esse ac perturbationem, quae sit a deo aliena. Quod si hominem &10quoque, qui modo sit sapiens et gravis, ira non deceat, siquidem cum in &10animum cuiusquam incidit velut saeva tempestas, tantos excitet fluctus ut &10statum mentis immutet, ardescant oculi, os tremat, lingua titubet, dentes &10concrepent, alternis vultum maculet nunc suffusus rubor, nunc pallor al-&10bescens, quanto magis deum non deceat tam foeda mutatio? Et si homo &10qui habeat imperium ac potestatem late noceat per iram, sanguinem fun-&10dat, urbes subvertat, populos deleat, provincias ad solitudinem redigat%10 &10quanto magis deum, qui habeat totius generis humani et ipsius mundi &10potestatem perditurum fuisse universa credibile sit, si irasceretur? &10@Abesse igitur ab eo tam magnum, tam perniciosum malum oportere, &10et si absit ab eo ira et concitatio, quia et deformis et noxia est, nec &10cuiquam male faciat%10 <21nihil aliud superesse, nisi ut sit lenis, tran-&10quillus, propitius, beneficus, conservator>21. Ita enim demum et &10communis omnium pater et optimus maximus dici poterit%10 quod expetit &10divina caelestisque natura. Nam si inter homines laudabile videtur, pro-&10desse potius quam nocere, vivificare quam occidere, salvare quam perdere &10[1nec immerito innocentia inter virtutes numeratur]1 et qui haec fecerit, di-&10ligitur, praefertur, ornatur benedictis omnibus votisque celebratur, denique &10ob merita et beneficia Dei simillimus iudicatur%10 quanto magis ipsum deum &10par est divinis perfectisque virtutibus praecellentem atque ab omni ter-&10rena labe submotum divinis et caelestibus beneficiis omne genus hominum &10promereri. &10@Seneca de beneficiis lib. II cp. 29. Quicquid nobis [1scil. a &10dis]1 negatum est, dari non potuit. __circumeas licet cuncta et, qui &10nihil totum invenies quod esse te malles, ex omnibus singula excerpas, &10quae tibi dari velles%10 bene aestimata naturae indulgentia confitearis ne-&10cesse est, in deliciis te illi fuisse. Ita est%10 <21carissimos nos habuerunt &10di immortales>21 habentque, et qui maximus tribui honos potuit, ab ipsis &10proximos conlocaverunt%10 magna accepimus, maiora non cepimus. &10@Origenes contra Celsum IV 79 Vol. I p. 349, 21 Ko+. [1p. 562 &10Delarue]1.$10 EI)/PER GA\R KATA\ PRO/NOIAN O( KO/SMOS GEGE/NHTAI KAI\ QEO\S E)FE/STHKE TOI=S O(/LOIS, A)NAGKAI=ON H)=N TA\ ZW/PURA TOU= GE/NOUS TW=N A)NQRW/PWN A)RCA/MENA U(PO/ TINA GEGONE/NAI FROURA\N TH\N A)PO\ KREITTO/NWN, W(/STE KAT' A)RXA\S E)PIMICI/AN GEGONE/NAI TH=S QEI/AS FU/SEWS PRO\S TOU\S A)NQRW/POUS, A(/PER KAI\ O( *)ASKRAI=OS POIHTH\S E)NNOW=N EI)=PE: @1 @CUNAI\ GA\R TO/TE DAI=TES E)/SAN, CUNOI\ DE\ QO/WKOI A)QANA/TOISI QEOI=SI KATAQNHTOI=S T' A)NQRW/POIS. @&10Clemens Al. Paed. c. 3 p. 102 Pott.$10 O( A)/NQRWPOS A)/RA O(\N PE-POI/HKEN O( QEO\S DI' AU(TO\ AI(RETO/N E)STIN: TO\ DE\ DI' AU(TO\ AI(RETO\N OI)KEI=O/N E)STIN O(/TW|PER A)\N H)=| DI' AU(TO\ AI(RETO/N: TOU=TO DE\ KAI\ A)SMENISTO\N KAI\ FILHTO/N: A)LL' OU)XI\ FILHTO\N ME\N TI/ E)STIN, OU)XI\ DE\ KAI\ FILEI=TAI U(P' AU)TOU=. FILHTO\S DE\ O( A)/NQRWPOS A)PODE/DEIKTAI: FILEI=TAI A)/RA PRO\S TOU= QEOU= O( A)/NQRWPOS. @&10Philodemus de deorum vita beata. col. I [1Scott. Fragm. Her-&10cul. p. 140$10]1 @O]1U) @MH\N A(/PANTA[1S]1 E!!!WN OI)HTE/ON [1FI/L]1OUS @H(=| KATA\ TO\ SU/N[1HQ]1E/S GE FI/LOI KALOU=NTAI: @TOU\S GA\[1R]1 A)PEI/ROUS [1O]1U) DUNATO\N A)LLH/LO[1IS]1 @EI)]1S GNW=SIN A)FIKNEI=SQAI: DI' O(/PER OU)[1D']1 A[1U)-@TW=N E!IH! [1TW=N SO]1FW=N F[1I/]1LOUS A)/N TIS EI)/POI @TO]1U\[1S QEOU\S]1 @__________ @.. TOI=S QEOI=S, KAI\ QAUMA/ZEI TH\N FU/SIN @KA]1I\ TH\N DIA/QESIN KAI\ PEIRA=TAI SUNEGGI/-@ZEI]1N AU)TH=| KAI\ KAQAPEREI\ GLI/XETAI QIGE[1I=]1N @KAI\ SU]1NEI=NAI, KALEI/TW KAI\ TOU\S SOFOU\S TW=N @QEW=]1N FI/LOUS KAI\ TOU\S QEOU\S TW=N SOFW=N. @[1A)LL' O]1U)K E)OI/KAME[1N PRO\S]1 TA\ TOIAU=TA TH\N FI-@[1LI/AN]1 E)REI=N, W(/STE BE/LTE[1I]1ON AU)TA\ TA\ PRA/GMA-@TA [1SKOP]1EI=N, TA!DR!!!!!!HSTWS MH\ PARA-@BIA/ZESQAI. KAI\ XARI/ZESQAI TOIGAROU=N A)LLH/LOIS @TOU\S QEOU\S TH=I ME/N, W(S E)NLEI/POUSI ME-@TA/DOSI/N TINWN OI)KEI/WN POIOUME/NOUS, OU) @R(HTE/ON: A(/PANTE[1S G]1A\[1R DH\]1 AU)TA/RKWS E(AUTOI=S @PARASKEUASTIKOI\ TH=S TELEIOTA/THS H(DO-@[1NH=]1S EI)[1SIN. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 33 p. 1049 e.$ *KAI/TOI LE/-GEI G' AU)TO\S <20E)N TW=| PERI\ TOU= *DIKA/ZEIN>20, KAI\ PA/LIN <20E)N TW=| DEUTE/RW| PERI\ *QEW=N>20, W(S "1TW=N AI)SXRW=N TO\ QEI=ON PARAI/TION GI/NESQAI OU)K EU)/-LOGO/N E)STIN: O(\N TRO/PON GA\R OU)/TE NO/MOS TOU= PARANOMEI=N PARAI/TIOS GE/NOITO A)/N, OU)/TE OI( QEOI\ TOU= A)SEBEI=N: OU(/TWS EU)/LOGON, MHD' AI)SXROU= MHDENO\S EI)=NAI PARAITI/OUS."2 *)ALLA\ NH\ *DI/A, FH/SEI TIS, E)PAINEI=N PA/LIN TOU= *EU)RIPI/DOU LE/GONTOS @*EI) QEOI/ TI DRW=SIN AI)SXRO\N OU)K EI)SI\N QEOI/. [1&Nauck fr. trag. p. 447$]1 KAI\ @TO\ R(A=|STON EI)=PAS AI)TIA/SASQAI QEOU/S. [1&ibidem p. 434]1.$ @1 @&10Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 32 p. 1075e.$10 KAI\ MH\N AU)TOI/ GE PRO\S TO\N *)EPI/KOURON OU)DE\N A)POLEI/POUSI TW=N GRAMMA/TWN "3I)OU\ I)OU\ FEU= FEU="3 BOW=NTES, W(S SUGXE/ONTA TH\N TW=N QEW=N PRO/LHYIN, A)NAIROUME/NHS TH=S PRONOI/AS. OU) GA\R A)QA/NATON KAI\ MAKA/RION MO/NON, A)LLA\ KAI\ FILA/NQRWPON KAI\ KHDEMONI-KO\N KAI\ W)FE/LIMON PROLAMBA/NESQAI KAI\ NOEI=SQAI TO\N QEO/N. @&10Cicero de nat. deor. II 78. Atqui necesse est, cum sint di__ &10animantis esse, nec solum animantis, sed etiam rationis compotes inter &10seque quasi civili conciliatione et societate coniunctos, unum mundum ut &10communem rem publicam atque urbem aliquam regentis. 79. Sequitur ut &10eadem sit in iis, quae humano in genere, ratio, eadem veritas utrobique &10sit eademque lex, quae est recti praeceptio pravique depulsio. __Cumque &10sint in nobis consilium, ratio, prudentia, necesse est deos haec ipsa habere &10maiora, nec habere solum, sed etiam iis uti in maxumis et optumis rebus%100 &10`80. nihil autem nec maius nec melius mundo%100 necesse est ergo eum deo-&10rum consilio et providentia administrari. &10@Jamblichus de anima apud Stobaeum ecl. I p. 372, 7 W.$10 W(S ME\N <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 LE/GOUSIN, EI(=S TE/ E)STIN O( LO/GOS KAI\ H( AU)TH\ PA/NTWS DIA-NO/HSIS KAI\ TA\ KATORQW/MATA I)=SA KAI\ AI( AU)TAI\ A)RETAI\ TW=N TE MERISTW=N KAI\ TW=N O(/LWN. @&10Dio Chrysost. Or XXXVI %14 37 [1V. II p. 11, 2 Arn.]1$10 OU) GA\R DH\ BASILE/A EI)PO/NTES TO\N E)PI\ TW=N O(/LWN OU)K A)\N BASILEU/ESQAI TO\ O(/LON O(MOLO-GOI=EN OU)DE\ BASILEU/ESQAI FH/SANTES OU)K A)\N POLITEU/ESQAI FAI=EN OU)D' EI)=NAI PO-LITEI/AN [BASILIKH\N] TOU= PANTO/S. POLITEI/AN D' AU)= SUGXWROU=NTES, PO/LIN OU)K A)\N A)POTRE/POINTO O(MOLOGEI=N H)/ TI TOU/TW| PARAPLH/SION TO\ POLITEUO/MENON. O(/DE ME\N OU)=N O( TW=N FILOSO/FWN LO/GOS, A)GAQH\N KAI\ FILA/NQRWPON A)PODEIKNU\S KOI-NWNI/AN DAIMO/NWN KAI\ A)NQRW/PWN, METADIDOU\S NO/MOU KAI\ POLITEI/AS OU) TOI=S TUXOU=SI TW=N ZW/|WN, A)LL' O(/SOIS ME/TESTI LO/GOU KAI\ FRONH/SEWS. @&10Dio Chrysost. Or XXXVI %14 29 [1V. II p. 9, 1 Arn.]1$10 TO\ ME\N DH\ TH=S PO/LEWS OU(/TWS, E)/FHN, DEI= A)KOU/EIN, W(S OU)K A)/NTIKRUS TW=N H(METE/RWN TO\N KO/SMON A)POFAINOME/NWN PO/LIN: E)NANTI/ON GA\R [2A)\N]2 U(PH=RXE TOU=TO TW=| LO/GW| TW=| PERI\ TH=S PO/LEWS, [2H(\N]2, W(/SPER OU)=N EI)=PON, SU/STHMA A)NQRW/PWN W(RI/SANTO: A(/MA TE OU)K H)=N I)/SWS PRE/PON OU)DE\ PIQANO\N KURI/WS EI)PO/NTAS EI)=NAI TO\N KO/SMON ZW=|ON E)/PEITA FA/SKEIN W(S E)/STI PO/LIS: TO\ GA\R AU)TO\ PO/LIN TE KAI\ ZW=|ON OU)K A)\N OI)=MAI R(A|DI/WS U(POME/NOI TIS U(POLABEI=N. A)LLA\ TH\N NU=N DIAKO/SMHSIN, O(PHNI/KA DIH/|RHTAI KAI\ MEME/RISTAI TO\ PA=N EI)S POLLA/S TINAS MORFA\S FUTW=N TE KAI\ ZW/|WN QNHTW=N KAI\ A)QANA/TWN, E)/TI DE\ A)E/ROS KAI\ GH=S KAI\ U(/DATOS KAI\ PURO/S, E(\N OU)-DE\N H(=TTON PEFUKO\S E)N A(/PASI TOU/TOIS KAI\ MIA=| YUXH=| KAI\ DUNA/MEI DIEPO/MENON, A(MH|GE/PH| PO/LEI PROSEIKA/ZOUSI DIA\ TO\ PLH=QOS TW=N E)N AU)TH=| GIGNOME/NWN TE KAI\ A)POGIGNOME/NWN, E)/TI DE\ TH\N TA/CIN KAI\ TH\N EU)KOSMI/AN TH=S DIOIKH/SEWS. O( DE\ LO/GOS OU(=TOS E)/MBRAXU E)SPOU/DAKE CUNARMO/SAI TW=| QEI/W| TO\ A)NQRW/PEION GE/NOS @1 KAI\ E(NI\ LO/GW| PERILABEI=N PA=N TO\ LOGIKO/N, KOINWNI/AS A)RXH\N KAI\ DIKAIOSU/NHS MO/NHN TAU/THN I)SXURA\N KAI\ A)/LUTON EU(RI/SKWN. @&10Cicero de nat. deor. II 133. Quorum igitur causa quis dixerit &10effectum esse mundum? Eorum scilicet animantium, quae ratione utuntur. &10Hi sunt di et homines, quibus profecto nihil est melius; ratio est enim, &10quae praestet omnibus. Ita fit credibile, deorum et hominum causa fac-&10tum esse mundum quaeque in eo sint omnia. 154. Principio ipse mun-&10dus deorum hominumque causa factus est, quaeque in eo sunt, ea parata &10ad fructum hominum et inventa sunt. <21Est enim mundus quasi com-&10munis deorum atque hominum domus aut urbs utrorumque>21. Soli &10enim ratione utentes iure ac lege vivunt. &10@Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 148.$10 <20FU/SIN>20 DE\ POTE\ ME\N A)POFAI/NONTAI TH\N SUNE/XOUSAN TO\N KO/SMON, POTE\ DE\ TH\N FU/OUSAN TA\ E)PI\ GH=S. E)/STI DE\ <20FU/SIS>20 E(/CIS E)C AU(TH=S KINOUME/NH KATA\ SPERMATIKOU\S LO/GOUS, A)POTELOU=SA/ TE KAI\ SUNE/XOUSA TA\ E)C AU)TH=S E)N W(RISME/NOIS XRO/NOIS KAI\ TOIAU=TA DRW=SA A)F' OI(/WN A)PEKRI/QH. <20TAU/THN DE\ KAI\ TOU= SUMFE/RONTOS STOXA/ZESQAI KAI\ H(DONH=S>20, W(S DH=LON E)K TH=S TOU= A)NQRW/POU DHMIOURGI/AS. @&10Galenus defin. medicae 95 Vol. XIX p. 371 K.$10 <20FU/SIS>20 E)STI\ PU=R TEXNIKO\N O(DW=| BADI/ZON EI)S GE/NESIN KAI\ E)C E(AUTOU= E)NERGHTIKW=S KINOU/MENON. __E(TE/RWS: <20FU/SIS>20 E)STI\ PNEU=MA E)/NQERMON E)C E(AUTOU= KINOU/MENON KAI\ KATA\ TA\S SPERMATIKA\S DUNA/MEIS GENNW=N TE KAI\ TELEIOU=N KAI\ DIATHROU=N TO\N A)/NQRW-PON. &10Secuntur complures definitiones huius valde similes.$10 FU/SIS KAI\ H( KRA=SIS LE/GETAI, FU/SIS KAI\ H( E(/CIS, FU/SIS KAI\ H( KAQ' O(RMH\N KI/NHSIS. FU/SIS KAI\ H( DIOIKOU=SA TO\ ZW=|ON DU/NAMIS LE/GETAI. @&10Clemens Al. Stromat. V 14 p. 708 Pott.$10 PU=R ME\N OU)=N TEXNI-KO\N O(DW=| BADI/ZON EI)S GE/NESIN TH\N FU/SIN O(RI/ZONTAI <20OI( *STWI+KOI/>20. @&10Galenus de usu partium 1. XVII cp. 1 [1vol. IV p. 350 K.$10]1. E)PEI\ D' E)/FQASAN E)/NIOI STOIXEI=A TW=N SWMA/TWN U(POQE/SQAI TA\ TOIAU=TA TAI=S OU)-SI/AIS, W(S SUNAFQH=NAI MH\ DU/NASQAI TE/XNH| FU/SEWS, H)NAGKA/SQHSAN AU)TH=| PO-LEMEI=N. O(/TI D' OU) DU/NATAI SUNAFQH=NAI, MAQEI=N E)/STIN E)NQE/NDE. *TO\ DIAPLA/T-TEIN ME/LLON O(TIOU=N TEXNIKW=S H)/TOI G' E)/CWQEN AU)TOU= YAU/EIN H)\ DI' O(/LOU TOU= DIAPLATTOME/NOU DIELHLUQE/NAI XRH/. *)ALL' OU)/T' E)/CWQE/N TI YAU=ON TW=N A)TO/MWN H)\ A)MERI/STWN SWMA/TWN, A(/PER E)/NIOI TI/QENTAI STOIXEI=A, DIAPLA/TTEIN AU)TA\ PEFU-KE/NAI FASI\N OU)D' AU)TOI\ [2DH/POU]2 OU)/TE DI' O(/LOU E)KTETA/SQAI. *LEI/PETAI OU)=N W(S E)/TUXEN A)LLH/LOIS PERIPLEKO/MENA TH\N TW=N AI)SQHTW=N SWMA/TWN E)RGA/SASQAI SU/STASIN. *(WS E)/TUXE DE\ PERIPLEKO/MENA, SPANI/WS ME/N POTE XRH/SIMON E)RGA/ZETAI TO\ DHMIOU/RGHMA, POLLA/KIS D' A)/XRHSTO/N TE KAI\ MA/TAION. *AU(/TH TOIGAROU=N AI)TI/A TOU= MH\ BOU/LESQAI TH\N FU/SIN EI)=NAI TEXNIKH\N E)KEI/NOUS TOU\S A)/NDRAS, O(/SOI TA\ PRW=TA SW/MATA TOIAU=TA EI)=NAI/ FASIN, OI(=A/PER OI( TA\S A)TO/MOUS EI)SA/GONTES LE/GOUSIN. *(ORWME/NWN GA\R E)NARGW=S A(PA/NTWN TW=N ZW/|WN EU)QU\S E)/CWQEN OU)DE\N @1 A)/XRHSTON E)XO/NTWN MO/RION, E)PIXEIROU=SI KAI\ MH\N E(NO\S EU)PORH=SAI/ TINOS EI)S A)NTI-LOGI/AN &10etc. &10@Galenus de usu partium V 4 Vol. III p. 354 K.$10 H(MEI=S ME\N GA\R A)PERISKEPTO/TERON AI(ROU/MEQA TO\ LUSITELOU=N, EI) KAI\ TU/XOI POTE\ MEIZO/NWS EI)S E(/TERA BLA/PTEIN PEFUKO\S H)\ W)FELEI=N EI)S A(\ XRH/|ZOMEN. H( FU/SIS D' OU) KAQ' E(\N TW=N AU(TH=S E)/RGWN A)PERISKE/PTWS OU)D' U(PO\ R(A|QUMI/AS E)NI/OTE MEGA/LA KAKA\ AI(ROUME/NH DI' E)/LATTON A)GAQO/N, A)LL' A)KRIBEI= ME/TRW| TO\ POSO\N E)N E(KA/STW| KRI/-NOUSA, POLLAPLA/SION A)EI\ TO\ XRHSTO\N A)POTELEI= TOU= MOXQHROU=. MA/LISTA ME\N GA/R, EI)/PER OI(=O/N T' H)=N, A)/NEU PANTO\S KAKOU= KATESKEUA/SAT' A)\N A(/PANTA TAU=TA: NUNI\ DE/, OU) GA\R E)NDE/XETAI TH=S U(/LHS FUGEI=N TH\N MOXQHRI/AN OU)DEMI/AN TW=N TEXNW=N, OU)D' A)DAMA/NTINO/N TE KAI\ PA/MPAN A)PAQE\S E)RGA/SASQAI TO\ DHMIOU/R-GHMA, KATALEI/PETAI KOSMEI=N AU)TO\ TO\N E)NDEXO/MENON KO/SMON. E)NDE/XETAI DE\ A)/L-LON A)/LLH TW=N U(LW=N: OU) GA\R E)K TH=S AU)TH=S DH/POUQEN OU)SI/AS TA/ TE A)/STRA GE/GONE KAI\ H(MEI=S. OU)/KOUN OU)DE\ TH\N A)PA/QEIAN TH\N AU)TH\N E)PIZHTEI=N XRH\ KAI\ ME/MFESQAI TH=| FU/SEI, SMIKRO\N EI)/ POU/ TI BLABERO\N I)/DOIMEN E)PI\ MURI/OIS XRHSTOI=S. @&10p. 402.$10 OU)DE\N OU)DAMOU= TH=| FU/SEI KAT' OU)DE/NA TRO/PON H)ME/LHTAI, PROGI-NWSKOU/SH| KAI\ PROORWME/NH| TA\ KAT' A)NA/GKHN A)KOLOUQH/SONTA TOI=S E(/NEKA/ TOU GINOME/NOIS KAI\ FQANOU/SH| PA/NTWN E)PANORQW/MATA PARASKEUA/ZESQAI. @&10Galenus de usu partium l. XVII cp. 1 [1vol. IV p. 355 K.$10]1. SU\ D', W)= GENNAIO/TATE KATH/GORE TW=N E)/RGWN TH=S FU/SEWS, OU)DE\N ME\N TOU/TWN BLE/PEIS, O(/TI D' E)N MURI/OIS MURIA/KIS A)NQRW/POIS A(/PAC POU/ TINA E)POI/HSEN E(\C DAKTU/LOUS E)/XONTA TOU=TO MO/NON O(RA=|S. @&10Galenus de nat. facult. I 12 Vol. II p. 27 K.$10 KAI\ DU/O AU(=TAI GEGO/NASIN AI(RE/SEIS KATA\ GE/NOS E)N I)ATRIKH=| TE KAI\ FILOSOFI/A|___TH\N U(POBEBLHME/NHN OU)SI/AN GENE/SEI KAI\ FQORA=| PA=SAN H(NWME/NHN TE A(/MA KAI\ A)LLOI-OU=SQAI DUNAME/NHN U(PE/QETO QA/TERON GE/NOS TH=S AI(RE/SEWS: A)META/BLHTON DE\ KAI\ A)NALLOI/WTON KAI\ KATATETMHME/NHN EI)S LEPTA\ KAI\ KENAI=S TAI=S METACU\ XW/RAIS DIEILHMME/NHN H( LOIPH/. KAI\ TOI/NUN O(/SOI GE TH=S A)KOLOUQI/AS TW=N U(POQE/SEWN AI)SQA/NONTAI, KATA\ ME\N TH\N DEUTE/RAN AI(/RESIN OU)/TE FU/SEWS OU)/TE YUXH=S I)DI/AN TINA\ NOMI/ZOUSIN OU)SI/AN H)\ DU/NAMIN U(PA/RXEIN, A)LL' E)N TH=| POIA=| SUNO/DW| TW=N PRW/TWN SWMA/TWN E)KEI/NWN KAI\ A)PAQW=N TW=N A(PLW=N A)POTELEI=SQAI. KATA\ DE\ TH\N PROTE/RAN EI)RHME/NHN AI(/RESIN OU)X U(STE/RA TW=N SWMA/TWN H( FU/SIS, A)LLA\ POLLW=| PROTE/RA TE KAI\ PRESBUTE/RA: KAI\ TOI/NUN KATA\ ME\N TOU/TOUS <20AU(/TH TA\ SW/MATA TW=N ZW/|WN KAI\ TW=N FUTW=N SUNI/STHSI, DUNA/MEIS TINA\S E)/XOUSA, TA\S ME\N E(LKTIKA/S TE A(/MA KAI\ O(MOIWTIKA\S TW=N OI)KEI/WN, TA\S D' A)POKRITIKA\S TW=N A)LLOTRI/WN, KAI\ TEXNIKW=S A(/PANTA DIAPLA/TTEI TE GENNW=SA KAI\ PRONOEI=TAI TW=N GENNWME/NWN>20 E(TE/RAIS AU)=QI/S TISI DUNA/-MESI, STORGIKH=| ME/N TINI KAI\ PRONOHTIKH=| TW=N E)GGO/NWN, KOINWNIKH=| DE\ KAI\ FI-LIKH=| TW=N O(MOGENW=N &10etc. &10@Galenus de usu partium l. XIV cp. 1 [1vol. IV p. 142 K.$10]1. *MA/LISTA ME\N OU)=N A)QA/NATON H( FU/SIS, EI)/PER OI(=O/N T' H)=N, E)SPOU/DASE TO\ E(AUTH=S A)PERGA/SASQAI DHMIOU/RGHMA: MH\ SUGXWROU/SHS DE\ TH=S U(/LHS__TH\N E)NDE-XOME/NHN AU)TW=| BOH/QEIAN EI)S A)QANASI/AN E)MHXANH/SATO DI/KHN A)GAQOU= PO/LEWS OI)KISTOU=, MH\ TH=S E)N TW=| PARAXRH=MA SUNOIKH/SEWS MO/NON FRONTI/SANTOS A)LL' O(/PWS E)PI\ TO\ PA=N H)\ TO\ PLEI=STO/N GE H( PO/LIS AU)TOU= DIAFULA/TTOITO, PRONOHSAME/NOU. @&10ibid. cp. 4 [1p. 151]1.$10 PRONOOUME/NH GA\R H( FU/SIS, O(/PWS A)\N MH\ ZW/|OU TI GE/NOS A)FANISQEI/H MHDENO/S, O(/SA DIA\ TH\N TOU= SW/MATOS A)SQE/NEIAN H)/TOI BRAXU-XRO/NIA TELE/WS H)\ BORA\ TOI=S I)SXUROTE/ROIS E)/MELLE GENH/SESQAI, TOU/TOIS A(/PASIN I)/AMA TH=S SUNEXOU=S FQORA=S E)CEU=RE TH\N POLUGONI/AN. @1 @&10ibid. [1p. 152$10]1. O(PO/SOIS DE\ TW=N ZW/|WN U(PO\ CHRO/THTOS TOU= SW/MATOS OU)X OI(=O/N T' U(GRO\N U(POQRE/YAI PERI/TTWMA [1&10de lacte locutus erat$10]1 KAQA/PER A(/PASI TOI=S PTHNOI=S, E(/TERON E)N TOU/TOIS TI TH=S A)NATROFH=S TW=N E)KGO/NWN E)PETEXNH/SATO SO/FISMA, QAUMASTH\N KHDEMONI/AN EI)S AU)TA\ TW=N GEINAME/NWN SUNA/YASA, DI' H(\N U(PERMAXEI= TE A(/MA TW=N NEOTTW=N_KAI\ TROFA\S E)PITHDEI/OUS AU)TOI=S E)KPORI/ZEI. @&Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 11 p. 179, 24 Bruns.$ PROS-TEQE/NTOS TOU= AU)TOI=S GE TOU/TOIS [1&scil. Chrysippo$]1 KAI\ KOINW=S PA=SI SXE-DO\N TOI=S FILOSOFOU=SI DOKOU=NTOS, <20TOU= MHDE\N U(PO\ TH=S FU/SEWS GI/NESQAI MA/THN>20. @&10Philo de provid. II %14 55 [1p. 84 Aucher]1. Similiter et deus, &10quin novum quidpiam elaborasset, de novo magnam istam urbem mundum &10creavit ac una cum eo locum etiam oriri fecit. Quoniam plenitudine cor-&10poris data, spatii__nulla pars erit, quae non sit locus. [1I. e.$10 OU(/TW KAI\ O( QEO/S, OU) GENNH/SAS TO\ KENO/N, E)N TW=| KENW=| TH\N MEGA/LHN PO/LIN E)/KTISE TO\N KO/SMON: SUNE/KTISE DE\ TOU/TW| KAI\ TO\N TO/PON. E)KPLHRWQE\N GA\R U(PO\ SW/-MATOS OU)DE\N ME/ROS TH=S XW/RAS O(/PER OU)K E)/STAI TO/POS.]1. @&10Philo de provid. II 57 [1p. 84 Aucher]1. Infinitum incorpore-&10umque tempus deus minime creavit, sed dies mensesque annosque, sole et &10luna usus in hac mensura, atque reliquorum planetarum periodis, propter &10animalia generationemque fructuum, quae nequeunt sine annuis tempesta-&10tibus consistere. Ad hoc dirigi cumulatim ortus et occasus solis consue-&10verunt. &10@Philo de provid. II %14 56 [1p. 84 Aucher]1. <21Figura autem &10mundi>21, sicut et mundus ipse, _<21per providentiam globi in formam &10facta fuit>21; primum quia omni figura velocius mobilis est et deinde magis &10necessaria, ne forte remissus [1mundus]1 deorsum ferretur ad immensam va-&10cuitatem, cunctis partibus in suum medium inclinantibus. Sic enim so-&10lummodo consistentiam habiturus erat, erga se invicem ad medium tendente &10aequali orbe. @&10Philo de provid. II %14 62 [1p. 87 Aucher]1. <21Tterra>21 occupavit &10medium, primum quidem, ne abrepta aliquatenus a centro dimoveatur; nam &10eius nisus ac statio in centrum tendit. Iterum autem, ut ita circumcirca &10habitetur; in quantum enim perstat, recte omnia super eam stant, cum &10et ipsa in centrum ferantur. <21Quo probatur et figuram eius per &10providentiam factam fuisse globosam>21, quia iam dictam circumhabi-&10tationem non patitur alia figura, quod patet ex iis, quae philosophice &10considerantur de figuris habitationibusque. &10@Philo de provid. II %14 64 [1p. 89 Aucher]1. Dicunt extensum &10mare hominum deorumque commodo. Diis enim ita fere adornari dicunt%10 @1 &10Sol, quem nonnulli rectorem esse dixerunt, eo quod largitur necessaria, ex &10mari, inquiunt, nutritur; quippe purgatissimas partes humidi elementi ad &10se trahens sorbet. Pro indicio sit praeter alia, quod per anni tempestates &10in contrarium tendit cursus solaris, aestate per Cancrum et hieme per &10Capricornum. Nam circumambulans Sol aeternos illos terminos haud &10transgreditur. Et ipsae quoque nutrices fixae [1stellae]1 nutriuntur, ex ae%28re &10purgatam ad se trahentes humiditatem. Quod ita probant%10 etenim pau-&10lum ipsius humoris, nullo modo permixtum, constanti lege sub aurora &10iugiter frigens in terram remittitur, aquae colore accepto, quod ros nomi-&10nare mos est. __Sicut autem magnae utilitatis est in totius caeli susten-&10tationem mare, ita quoque ad hominum vitam, quoniam incolarum terrae &10cum habitantibus in insulis et insulanorum ad terricolas nulla fuisset &10mutua communicatio neque bonorum commutatio in singulis regionibus &10nascentium. &10@Philo de Provid. II %14 67 [1p. 90 Aucher]1. At ex terra vapores &10ad quid utiles? O mirabilis vir, ex ae%28re distincta compositio an non est &10salutifera non animalibus tantum, verum etiam plantis? Immo si oporteat &10adhuc procedendo asserere, iis quoque qui solida natura secum invicem &10commixta sunt, causa est ut stent. Animantium inprimis esca est et ci-&10borum omnium potuumque frequentissima. __Nam quae in corpus &10recipiuntur, eorum tum ob nauseam tum ob dissolutionem cupiditatum__ &10innumeris fastidium et fatigatio subit. Quod autem per ae%28rem alimentum &10est, tam vigilem quam dormientem sequitur donum naturae, continuo a &10iuventute usque ad senium perpetuo conexum; quapropter, si aliquantisper &10corrumpatur, pestilentiam efficit. &10@Philo de provid. II %14 73 [1p. 93 Aucher]1. Fixae [1scil. stellae]1 &10in causa sunt etiam temperantiae ae%28ris, quia natura sunt frigida compo-&10sitae, de se liquefacta diffundunt; et iste [1ae%28r]1 dilatatus causa efficitur &10animalibus generationis faciendae, sicut etiam iam factis respirationis causa &10comperitur. Ad subtilitatem enim cooperatur multitudo; at ad illud, quod &10non ex parte, sed totus dilatetur ae%28r, circumlatio periodica. &10@Philo de provid. II 76 [1p. 95 Aucher]1. In primis__men-&10sium periodos luna apposite coaptavit, quae totidem sunt mensurae cursus &10solaris. Deinde, per incrementum et deminutionem, variationes commuta-&10tionesque pro emolumento universi facit. Fidem faciunt certam, quae in &10ae%28re sunt condiciones; status, serenitates, ventorum cessationes, nubes, vio &10lentiae ventorum et his similia, praeterea vastissimi maris refluxus; nunc &10enim deorsum absorbetur, nunc iterum fluctibus resilit. Maxime vero ani-&10malium quorundam variationes adimpletorum evacuatorumque, sicut testa-&10ceorum, ratio habet, et reliqua etc. &10@Philo de provid. II %14 84 [1p. 98 Aucher]1. An tu putas nos &10propter mundum et non potius mundum propter nos factum fuisse? nam &10minime id considerans ruminasti, quod <21rite disposita sit sectio terrae &10pro habitatione hominum proque spatio ad usum deorum res-&10pectu sensibilium>21. Nobis enim per distributionem concessae partes @1 &10plus quam satis sunt pro habitatione; oportebat tamen et sideribus con-&10venientem praeparare escam, nutriendis nempe ex mari magno. &10@Philo de provid. II %14 74 [1p. 94 Aucher&3]1. <21Numerus autem &3planetarum prodest universo>21; verum hominum est otio praeditorum &3dinumerare singulorum utilitatem. Haec autem nota sunt non solum &3ratione, verum etiam sensu, ita movente providentia, quae, ut dicit <21Chry-&3sippus>21 et Cleanthes, nihil praetermisit pertinentium ad certiorem utilio-&3remque dispensationem. quod si aliter melius esset dispensari res mundi, &3eo modo sumpsisset compositionem, quatenus nihil occurreret ad impedi-&3endum deum. @&10Galenus de usu partium l. XVII cp. 1 [1vol. IV p. 358 K.$10]1. TI/S D' OU)K A)\N EU)QU\S E)NEQUMH/QH NOU=N TINA, DU/NAMIN E)/XONTA QAUMASTH/N, E)PI-BA/NTA TH=S GH=S E)KTETA/SQAI KATA\ PA/NTA TA\ MO/RIA; PANTAXO/QEN GOU=N O(RA=TAI GINO/MENA ZW=|A QAUMASTH\N A(/PANTA KATASKEUH\N E)/XONTA. KAI/TOI TI/ A)\N EI)/H TW=N TOU= KO/SMOU MORI/WN A)TIMO/TERON TW=N PERI\ TH\N GH=N; A)LL' O(/MWS E)NTAU=QA FAI/-NETAI NOU=S TIS A)FIKNOU/MENOS E)K TW=N A)/NW SWMA/TWN, A(\ KAI\ QEASAME/NW| TINI\ PARAXRH=MA QAUMA/ZEIN E)PE/RXETAI TO\ KA/LLOS TH=S OU)SI/AS, H(LI/OU PRW=TON KAI\ MA/LISTA, MET' AU)TO\N DE\ SELH/NHS, EI)=TA TW=N A)STE/RWN, E)N OI(=S EI)KO/S, O(/SW| PE/R E)STI KAI\ H( TOU= SW/MATOS OU)SI/A KAQARWTE/RA, TOSOU/TW| KAI\ TO\N NOU=N E)NOIKEI=N POLU\ TOU= KATA\ TA\ GH/I+NA SW/MATA BELTI/W TE KAI\ A)KRIBE/STERON. __*)EMOI\ ME\N GA\R TAU=TA E)NNOOU=NTI KAI\ DI' AU)TOU= TOU= PERIE/XONTOS H(MA=S A)E/ROS OU)K O)LI/-GOS TIS E)KTETA/SQAI DOKEI= NOU=S. OU) GA\R DH\ AU)TO\S TH=S ME\N AU)GH=S TH=S H(LIA-KH=S METALAMBA/NEIN PE/FUKEN, OU)XI\ DE\ KAI\ TH=S DUNA/MEWS AU)TH=S. @&Porphyrius de abstin. III 20.$ A)LL' E)KEI=NO NH\ *DI/A <20TOU= *XRUSI/PPOU>20 PIQANO\N H)=N, W(S H(MA=S AU(TW=N KAI\ A)LLH/LWN OI( QEOI\ XA/RIN E)POIH/SANTO, H(MW=N DE\ TA\ ZW=|A, SUMPOLEMEI=N ME\N I(/PPOUS KAI\ SUNQH-REU/EIN KU/NAS, A)NDREI/AS DE\ GUMNA/SIA PARDA/LEIS KAI\ A)/RKTOUS KAI\ LE/ON-TAS. H( DE\ U(=S, E)NTAU=QA GA/R E)STI TW=N XARI/TWN TO\ H(/DISTON, OU) DI' A)/LLO TI PLH\N QU/ESQAI E)GEGO/NEI, KAI\ TH=| SARKI\ TH\N YUXH\N O( QEO\S OI(=ON A(/LAS E)NE/MICEN, EU)OYI/AN H(MI=N MHXANW/MENOS. O(/PWS DE\ ZWMOU= KAI\ PARA-DEIPNI/WN A)FQONI/AN E)/XWMEN, O)/STREA/ TE PANTODAPA\ KAI\ PORFU/RAS KAI\ A)KALH/FAS KAI\ GE/NH PTHNW=N POIKI/LA PARESKEU/ASEN, OU)K A)LLAXO/QEN, A)LL' W(S AU(TOU= ME/GA ME/ROS E)NTAU=QA TRE/YAS EI)S GLUKUQUMI/AS, TA\S TIT-QA\S U(PERBALO/MENOS KAI\ KATAPUKNW/SAS TAI=S H(DONAI=S KAI\ A)POLAU/SESIN TO\N PERI/GEION TO/PON. @&Cicero de nat. deor. II 14, 37.&3 Scite enim <21Chrysippus>21, @1 &3ut clipei causa involucrum, vaginam autem gladii, sic praeter mundum &3cetera omnia aliorum causa esse generata; ut eas fruges atque fructus, &3quos terra gignit, animantium causa; animantes autem hominum, ut &3equum vehendi causa, arandi bovem, venandi et custodiendi canem. [1Ipse &3autem homo ortus est ad mundum contemplandum et imitandum etc.]1. @&Cicero de nat. deor. II 64, 160.&3 Sus vero quid habet praeter &3escam? cui quidem ne putesceret animam ipsam pro sale datam dicit &3esse <21Chrysippus>21. qua pecude quod erat ad vescendum hominibus apta, &3nihil genuit natura fecundius. @&10Origenes contra Celsum IV 54 Vol. I p. 326, 31 Ko+. [1p. 545 &10Delarue$10]1. TOIAU=TA GA\R E)XRH=N AU)TO\N [1&10scil.$10 TO\N *KE/LSON]1 A)POFAINO/MENON KAI\ E)NANTI/A LE/GEIN OU) MO/NON H(MI=N PROQE/MENON, A)LLA\ KAI\ OU)K A)GENNEI= FILOSO/FWN AI(RE/SEI, TW=N A)PO\ TOU= *KITIE/WS <20*ZH/NWNOS>20, KATASKEUA/SAI O(/TI TA\ TW=N ZW/|WN SW/MATA OU)K E)/STIN E)/RGA TOU= QEOU=: KAI\ O(/TI H( TOSAU/TH PERI\ AU)TA\ TE/XNH OU)K A)PO\ TOU= PRW/TOU E)LH/LUQE NOU=: E)/DEI D' AU)TO\N KAI\ PERI\ TW=N TOSOU/TWN KAI\ U(P' E)NUPARXOU/SHS A)FANTA/STOU FU/SEWS DIOIKOUME/NWN PANTODAPW=N FUTW=N KAI\ PRO\S XREI/AN GEGONO/TWN OU)K EU)KATAFRO/NHTON E)N TW=| PANTI\ A)NQRW/PWN KAI\ TW=N A)N-QRW/POIS DIAKONOUME/NWN ZW/|WN, O(/PWS POTE\ A)/LLWS O)/NTWN, MH\ A)POFH/NASQAI MO/NON A)LLA\ KAI\ DIDA/CAI, O(/TI MH\ TE/LEIO/S TIS NOU=S TA\S TOSAU/TAS E)NEPOI/HSE POIO/THTAS TH=| U(/LH| TW=N FUTW=N. @&10Ex Origene Selecta in psalmos II p. 532 Delarue.$10 A(\ ME\N GA\R PROHGOUME/NWS GI/NETAI, A(\ DE\ KAT' E)PAKOLOU/QHSIN DIA\ TA\ PROHGOU/MENA. <20PROH-GOUME/NWS ME\N GA\R TO\ LOGIKO\N ZW=|ON, DIA\ DE\ TH\N AU)TOU= XREI/AN KTH/NH KAI\ TA\ A)PO\ TH=S GH=S FUO/MENA>20. @&10Origenes contra Celsum IV 74 Vol. I p. 343, 23 Ko+. [1p. 559 &10Del.]1.$10 O( *KE/LSOS ..... OU)X E(W/RAKEN O(/TI KAI\ <20TW=N A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S FILO-SO/FWN>20 KATHGOREI=, OU) KAKW=S PROTATTO/NTWN TO\N A)/NQRWPON KAI\ A(PACAPLW=S TH\N LOGIKH\N FU/SIN PA/NTWN TW=N A)LO/GWN KAI\ DIA\ TAU/THN LEGO/NTWN PROHGOU-ME/NWS TH\N PRO/NOIAN PA/NTA PEPOIHKE/NAI. <20KAI\ LO/GON ME\N E)/XEI TA\ LOGIKA/, A(/PER E)STI\ PROHGOU/MENA, PAI/DWN GENNWME/NWN: TA\ D' A)/LOGA KAI\ TA\ A)/YUXA XORI/OU SUGKTIZOME/NOU TW=| PAIDI/W|>20. *KAI\ H(GOU=MAI/ GE O(/TI W(/SPER E)N TAI=S PO/LESIN OI( PRONOOU/MENOI TW=N W)NI/WN KAI\ TH=S A)GORA=S DI' OU)DE\N A)/LLO PRONOOU=NTAI H)\ DIA\ TOU\S A)NQRW/POUS, PARAPOLAU/OUSI DE\ TH=S DAYILEI/AS KAI\ KU/NES KAI\ A)/LLA TW=N A)LO/GWN: OU(/TWS H( PRO/NOIA TW=N ME\N LOGIKW=N PROHGOU-ME/NWS PRONOEI=, E)PHKOLOU/QHSE DE\ TO\ KAI\ TA\ A)/LOGA A)POLAU/EIN TW=N DI' A)NQRW/-POUS GIGNOME/NWN. @&Plutarchus Quaest. Platon. II 1 p. 1000f.$ OU)DE\ GA\R XO-RI/OU FHSI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 PATE/RA KALEI=SQAI TO\N PARASXO/NTA TO\ SPE/RMA, KAI/PER E)K TOU= SPE/RMATOS GEGONO/TOS. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 23 p. 193, 16 Bruns.$10 EI) D' O( ME\N FLOIO\S E)N TOI=S FUTOI=S E(/NEKA TOU= PERIKARPI/OU, TO\ DE\ PERIKA/RPION TOU= KARPOU= XA/RIN, KAI\ A)RDEU/ETAI ME\N I(/NA TRE/FHTAI, TRE/FETAI DE\ I(/NA KARPO-FORH=| &10etc. @1 @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 21 p. 1044e. Chrysippus$ O( TH\N PRO/NOIAN E)GKWMIA/ZWN I)XQU=S KAI\ O)/RNIQAS KAI\ ME/LI KAI\ OI)=NON PARASKEUA/SASAN. @&10Cicero Acad. Pr. II 120. non mihi necesse_, quod tibi est, &10[2dicere]2, cur deus, omnia nostra causa cum faceret [1sic enim vultis]1 tan-&10tam vim natricum viperarumque fecerit__. negatis haec tam polite &10tamque subtiliter effici potuisse <21sine divina aliqua sollertia; cuius &10quidem vos maiestatem deducitis usque ad apium formicarum-&10que perfectionem>21, ut etiam inter deos Myrmecides aliqui minutorum &10opusculorum fabricator fuisse videatur. &10@Cicero de legibus I 8, 25. Itaque ad hominum commoditates &10et usus tantam rerum ubertatem natura largita est, ut ea, quae gignun-&10tur, donata consulto nobis, non fortuito nata videantur%10 <21nec solum ea, &10quae frugibus atque bacis terrae fetu profunduntur, sed etiam &10pecudes%10 quod perspicuum sit partim esse ad usum hominum, &10partim ad fructum, partim ad vescendum procreatas>21. 26. Artes &10vero innumerabiles repertae sunt, docente natura. Quam imitata ratio res &10ad vitam necessarias sollerter consecuta est. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 21 p. 1044c.$ *GRA/YAS TOI/-NUN <20E)N TOI=S PERI\ *FU/SEWS>20, O(/TI "1POLLA\ TW=N ZW/|WN E(/NEKA KA/LLOUS H( FU/SIS E)NH/NOXE, FILOKALOU=SA KAI\ XAI/ROUSA TH=| POIKILI/A|"2 KAI\ LO/GON E)PEIPW\N PARALOGW/TATON W(S "1O( TAW\S E(/NEKA TH=S OU)RA=S GE/GONE, DIA\ TO\ KA/LLOS AU)TH=S."2 @&p. 1044d.$8 <20*)EN ME\N OU)=N TW=| PE/MPTW| PERI\ FU/SEWS, EI)PW\N O(/TI "1OI( KO/REIS EU)XRH/STWS E)CUPNI/ZOUSIN H(MA=S, KAI\ OI( MU/ES E)PISTRE/-FOUSIN H(MA=S MH\ A)MELW=S E(/KASTA TIQE/NAI, FILOKALEI=N DE\ TH\N FU/SIN TH=| POIKILI/A| XAI/ROUSAN EI)KO/S E)STI"2>20 TAU=TA KATA\ LE/CIN EI)/-RHKE: "1<20*GE/NOITO D' A)\N MA/LISTA TOU/TOU E)/MFASIS E)PI\ TH=S KE/RKOU TOU= TAW/>20."2 E)NTAU=QA GA\R E)PIFAI/NEI TO\ ZW=|ON GEGONE/NAI E(/NEKA TH=S KE/RKOU KAI\ OU)K A)NA/PALIN "1<20TW=| D' A)/RRENI GINOME/NW| OU(/TWS H( QH/LEIA SUNH-KOLOU/QHKEN>20."2 @&10Galenus de usu partium XI 14 Vol. III p. 899 K.$10 TO\ D' E)C E)PIME/TROU POTE\ KAI\ TH=S EU)MORFI/AS STOXA/ZESQAI, A)NAGKAI=ON U(PA/RXON KAI\ AU)TO\ DH\ GINW/SKESQAI TOI=S PERI\ FU/SIN [E)/XOUSIN], OU)DAMOU= DIA\ TW=N E)/MPROSQEN LO/-GWN EI)RHKW/S, NU=N W)|H/QHN MA/LISTA PROSH/KEIN EI)PEI=N. KAI\ GA\R OU)=N KAI\ <20AI( KATA\ TA\ GE/NEIA TRI/XES OU) MO/NON SKE/POUSI TA\S GENU/AS, A)LLA\ KAI\ PRO\S KO/SMON SUNTELOU=SI>20. SEMNO/TERON GA\R TO\ A)/R)R(EN FAI/NETAI, KAI\ MA/-LISTA E)N TW=| PROI+E/NAI KATA\ TH\N H(LIKI/AN, EI) PANTAXO/QEN AU)TW=| KALW=S AU(=TAI PERIKE/OINTO. KAI\ DIA\ TOU=TO TA/ TE MH=LA KALOU/MENA KAI\ TH\N R(I=NA YILA\ KAI\ GUMNA\ TRIXW=N H( FU/SIS A)PE/LIPEN: A)/GRION GA\R A)\N OU(/TW KAI\ QHRIW=DES O(/LON E)GE/NETO TO\ PRO/SWPON, OU)DAMW=S OI)KEI=ON H(ME/RW| KAI\ POLITIKW=| ZW/|W|. @1 @&10Cicero de nat. deor I 47. Vos quidem, Lucili, soletis__ &10cum artificium effingitis fabricamque divinam, quam sint omnia in hominis &10figura non modo ad usum, verum etiam ad venustatem apta describere. &10@Cicero de finibus III 18. Iam membrorum, id est partium &10corporis, alia videntur propter eorum usum a natura esse donata, ut ma-&10nus, crura, pedes, ut ea, quae sunt intus in corpore, quorum utilitas &10quanta sit, a medicis etiam disputatur, <21alia autem nullam ob utili-&10tatem quasi ad quendam ornatum, ut cauda pavoni, plumae &10versicolores columbis, viris mammae atque barba>21. &10@Lactantius instit. div. II 10. Sed etiam illud explanare ten-&10tavit [1scil. Hermes]1 quam subtili ratione singula quaeque in corpore ho-&10minis membra formaverit [1scil. deus]1 cum eorum nihil sit, quod non tan-&10tundem ad usus necessitatem, quantum ad pulchritudinem valeat. <21Id &10vero etiam Stoici cum de providentia disserunt facere conantur>21 &10et secutus eos Cicero compluribus locis etc. [1cf. Lactant. de opificio dei]1. &10ibid. nam Stoici animantium fabricam divinae sollertiae tribuunt. &10@Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 34 p. 1076c.$10 *OU) MH\N E)NTAU=QA TO\ DEINO/TATO/N E)STIN, A)LLA\ *MENA/NDRW| ME\N EI)PO/NTI QEATRIKW=S [1&10Kock III fr. 724$10]1 A)RXH\ MEGI/STH TW=N E)N A)NQRW/POIS KAKW=N @TA\ LI/AN A)GAQA/ DUSKOLAI/NOUSI: TOU=TO GA\R EI)=NAI PARA\ TH\N E)/NNOIAN: AU)TOI\ DE\ TW=N KAKW=N A)R-XH\N A)GAQO\N O)/NTA TO\N QEO\N POIOU=SIN. OU) GA\R H(/ G' U(/LHN TO\ KAKO\N E)C E(AUTH=S PARE/SXHKEN: A)/POIOS GA/R E)STI KAI\ PA/SAS O(/SAS DE/XETAI DIAFORA\S U(PO\ TOU= KI-NOU=NTOS AU)TH\N KAI\ SXHMATI/ZONTOS E)/SXE. KINEI= D' AU)TH\N O( LO/GOS E)NUPA/RXWN KAI\ SXHMATI/ZEI, MH/TE KINEI=N E(AUTH\N MH/TE SXHMATI/ZEIN PEFUKUI=AN. @&Gellius N. A. VII 1.&3 Quibus non videtur mundus dei et &3hominum causa institutus neque res humanas providentia gubernari, &3gravi se argumento uti putant, cum ita dicunt%10 "1si esset providentia, &3nulla essent mala."2 Nihil enim minus aiunt providentiae congruere, &3quam in eo mundo, quem propter homines fecisse dicatur, tantam vim &3esse aerumnarum et malorum. Adversus ea <21Chrysippus>21 cum <21in libro>21$ <20PERI\ PRONOI/AS>20 &3<21quarto>21 dissereret "1<21nihil est prorsus istis>21"2, inquit, &3"1<21insubidius, qui opinantur bona esse potuisse, si non essent &3ibidem mala. Nam cum bona malis contraria sint, utraque &3necessum est opposita inter sese et quasi mutuo adversoque &3fulta nisu consistere; nullum adeo contrarium est sine con-&3trario altero. Quo enim pacto iustitiae sensus esse posset, &3nisi essent iniuriae? aut quid aliud iustitia est quam iniusti-&3tiae privatio? quid item fortitudo intellegi posset, nisi ex &3ignaviae adpositione? quid continentia, nisi ex intemperan-&3tiae? quo item modo prudentia esset, nisi foret contra impru- @1&3dentia? Proinde"2, inquit, "1homines stulti cur non hoc etiam &3desiderant, ut veritas sit et non sit mendacium? Namque iti-&3dem sunt bona et mala, felicitas et importunitas, dolor et &3voluptas. Alterum enim ex altero, sicuti Plato ait, verticibus &3inter se contrariis deligatum est; si tuleris unum, abstuleris &3utrumque>21."2 &3@Gellius N. A. VII 1, 7.&3 Idem <21Chrysippus>21 in eodem libro &3[1i. e. <21quarto>21$ <20PERI\ PRONOI/AS>20]1 &3tractat consideratque dignumque esse id &3quaeri putat,$ EI) AI( TW=N A)NQRW/PWN NO/SOI KATA\ FU/SIN GI/NONTAI&3 id est, &3[si] natura ipsa rerum vel providentia, quae compagem hanc mundi et &3genus hominum fecit, morbos quoque et debilitates et aegritudines corpo-&3rum, quas patiuntur homines, fecerit. Existimat autem non fuisse hoc &3pincipale naturae consilium, ut faceret homines morbis obnoxios, nun-&3quam enim hoc convenisse naturae auctori parentique omnium rerum &3bonarum. "1<21Sed cum multa>21"2, inquit, "1<21atque magna gigneret pare-&3retque aptissima et utilissima, alia quoque simul adgnata &3sunt incommoda his ipsis quae faciebat cohaerentia>21"2, eaque &3[neque] per naturam, sed per sequellas quasdam necessarias facta dicit, &3quod ipse appellat$ "1KATA\ PARAKOLOU/QHSIN."2&3 "1<21Sicut>21"2, inquit, "1<21cum &3corpora hominum natura fingeret, ratio subtilior et utilitas &3ipsa operis postulavit, ut tenuissimis minutisque ossiculis &3caput compingeret. Sed hanc utilitatem rei maiorem alia &3quaedam incommoditas extrinsecus consecuta est, ut fieret ca-&3put tenuiter munitum et ictibus offensionibusque parvis fra-&3gile. Proinde morbi quoque et aegritudines partae sunt, dum &3salus paritur. Sicut hercle>21"2, inquit, "1<21dum virtus hominibus &3per consilium naturae gignitur, vitia ibidem per adfinitatem &3contrariam nata sunt>21."2 @&10Philo de fortitudine Vol. II Mang. p. 413$10 *KAQA/PER GA\R I)ATRO\S ME\N E)N TAI=S MEGA/LAIS KAI\ E)PISFALE/SI NO/SOIS E)/STIN O(/TE SWMA/TWN ME/RH A)FAIREI=, STOXAZO/MENOS TH=S TOU= LOIPOU= SW/MATOS U(GEI/AS, KUBERNH/THS DE\ XEIMW/NWN E)PI-GINOME/NWN A)POFORTI/ZETAI, PRONOI/A| TH=S TW=N E)MPLEO/NTWN SWTHRI/AS, KAI\ ME/MYIS OU)/TE TW=| I)ATRW=| TH=S PHRW/SEWS, OU)/TE TW=| KUBERNH/TH| TH=S A)POBOLH=S E(/PETAI, TOU)-NANTI/ON DE\ E)/PAINOS E(KATE/RW|, TO\ SUMFE/RON PRO\ TOU= H(DE/OS I)DO/NTI KAI\ KATOR-QW/SANTI, TO\N AU)TO\N TRO/PON KAI\ TH\N TW=N O(/LWN FU/SIN A)EI\ QAUMASTE/ON, KAI\ TOI=S E)N TW=| KO/SMW| PRATTOME/NOIS A(/PASIN A)/NEU TH=S E(KOUSI/OU KAKI/AS EU)ARESTH-TE/ON, E)CETA/ZONTAS, OU)K EI)/ TI MH\ KAQ' H(DONH\N SUMBE/BHKEN, A)LL' EI) TRO/PON EU)-NO/MOU PO/LEWS O( KO/SMOS H(NIOXEI=TAI/ TE KAI\ KUBERNA=TAI. @&10Lactantius de ira cp. 13. Sed Academici, contra Stoicos disse-&10rentes, solent quaerere, cur si deus omnia hominum causa fecerit etiam &10multa contraria et inimica et pestifera nobis reperiantur tam in mari @1 &10quam in terra? Quod <21Stoici>21 veritatem non respicientes ineptissime repu-&10lerunt; <21aiunt enim multa esse in gignentibus et in numero ani-&10malium, quorum adhuc lateat utilitas; sed eam processu tem-&10porum inveniri>21, sicut iam plura prioribus saeculis incognita necessitas &10et usus invenerit. @&Origenes contra Celsum IV 75 Vol. I p. 345, 19 Ko+. [1p. 560 &Delarue$10]1. EI) DE\ KAI\ TOI=S A)GRIWTA/TOIS TW=N ZW/|WN TROFA\S KATESKEU/ASEN, OU)DE\N QAUMASTO/N: KAI\ TAU=TA GA\R TA\ ZW=|A KAI\ A)/LLOI TW=N FILOSOFHSA/NTWN EI)RH/KASI GUMNASI/OU E(/NEKA GEGONE/NAI TW=| LOGIKW=| ZW/|W|. @&10ibid. 78 Vol. I p. 348, 23 Ko+. [1p. 562 Del.$10]1. OU(/TWS <20EI)S GUMNA/SION TW=N TH=S A)NDREI/AS E)N H(MI=N SPERMA/TWN DEDO/SQAI H(MI=N LE/GETAI TO\ LEO/NTWN KAI\ A)/RKTWN PARDA/LEWN TE KAI\ SUW=N KAI\ TW=N TOIOU/TWN GE/NOS>20. @&Origenes contra Celsum IV 64 Vol. I p. 334, 33 Ko+. [1p. 552 &Delarue]1.$ EI) GA\R KAI\ MI/A TW=N O(/LWN FU/SIS KAI\ H( AU)TH/, OU) PA/NTWS KAI\ H( TW=N KAKW=N GE/NESIS A)EI\ H( AU)TH/. W(S GA\R MIA=S KAI\ TH=S AU)TH=S OU)/SHS TH=S TOU=DE/ TI-NOS A)NQRW/POU FU/SEWS, OU)K A)EI\ TA\ AU)TA/ E)STI PERI\ TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N AU)TOU= KAI\ TO\N LO/GON AU)TOU= KAI\ TA\S PRA/CEIS, O(TE\ ME\N OU)DE\ LO/GON A)NEILHFO/-TOS O(TE\ DE\ META\ TOU= LO/GOU KAKI/AN KAI\ TAU/THN H)/TOI E)PI\ PLEI=ON H)\ E)P' E)/LATTON XEOME/NHN, KAI\ E)/STIN O(/TE PROTRAPE/NTOS E)P' A)RETH\N KAI\ PRO-KO/PTONTOS E)PI\ PLEI=ON H)\ E)P' E)/LATTON, KAI\ E)NI/OTE FQA/NONTOS KAI\ E)P' AU)TH\N TH\N A)RETH\N <20E)N PLEI/OSI QEWRI/AIS GINOME/NHN H)\ E)N E)LA/TTOSIN>20: OU(/TWS E)/STIN EI)PEI=N MA=LLON KAI\ E)PI\ TH=S TW=N O(/LWN FU/SEWS, O(/TI EI) KAI\ MI/A E)STI\ KAI\ H( AU)TH\ TW=| GE/NEI, A)LL' OU) TA\ AU)TA\ A)EI\ OU)D' O(MOGENH= SUM-BAI/NEI E)N TOI=S O(/LOIS: OU)/TE GA\R EU)FORI/AI A)EI\ OU)/T' A)FORI/AI, A)LL' OU)DE\ E)POMBRI/AI OU)DE\ AU)XMOI/, OU(/TW DE\ OU)DE\ YUXW=N KREITTO/NWN EU)FORI/AI TETAGME/NAI H)\ A)FORI/AI KAI\ XEIRO/NWN E)PI\ PLEI=ON XU/SIS H)\ E)P' E)/LATTON. <20*KAI\ A)NAGKAI=O/N GE TOI=S A)KRIBOU=N PA/NTA KATA\ TO\ DUNATO\N BOULOME/NOIS O( PERI\ TW=N KAKW=N LO/GOS OU) MENO/NTWN A)EI\ E)N TAU)TW=| DIA\ TH\N H)/TOI THROU=SAN TA\ E)PI\ GH=S PRO/NOIAN H)\ KATA-KLUSMOI=S KAI\ E)KPURW/SESI KAQAI/ROUSAN>20: KAI\ TA/XA OU) TA\ E)PI\ GH=S MO/NON, A)LLA\ KAI\ TA\ E)N O(/LW| TW=| KO/SMW|, DEOME/NW| KAQARSI/OU O(/TAN POLLH\ H( KAKI/A GE/NHTAI E)N AU)TW=|. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 15 p. 1040c.$ *KAI\ O(MOI/WS <20E)N TW=| PRW/TW| PERI\ *DIKAIOSU/NHS>20 TA\ *(HSIO/DEIA TAUTI\ PROENEGKA/MENOS: @*TOI=SIN D' OU)RANO/QEN ME/G' E)PH/LASE PH=MA *KRONI/WN, @LIMO\N O(MOU= KAI\ LOIMO/N: A)POFQINU/QOUSI DE\ LAOI/: [1&Hesiod. Op. et D. 242$]1 "1<20TAU=TA/ FHSI TOU\S QEOU\S POIEI=N, O(/PWS KOLAZOME/NWN TW=N PONHRW=N OI( LOIPOI\ PARADEI/GMASI TOU/TOIS XRW/MENOI H(=TTON E)PIXEIRW=SI TOIOU=TO/N TI POIEI=N>20."2 @1 @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 35 p. 1050e.$8 *)ALLA\ MH\N TO\N QEO\N KOLA/ZEIN FHSI\ TH\N KAKI/AN KAI\ POLLA\ POIEI=N E)PI\ KOLA/SEI TW=N PONHRW=N, W(/SPER <20E)N TW=| DEUTE/RW| PERI\ *QEW=N "1POTE\ ME\N TA\ DU/S-XRHSTA SUMBAI/NEIN FHSI\ TOI=S A)GAQOI=S OU)X W(/SPER TOI=S FAU/LOIS KOLA/SEWS XA/RIN, A)LLA\ KAT' A)/LLHN OI)KONOMI/AN, W(/SPER E)N TAI=S PO/LESI."2 KAI\ PA/LIN E)N TOU/TOIS: "1*PRW=TON DE\ TW=N KAKW=N PARA-PLHSI/WS E)STI\N A)KOUSTE/ON TOI=S PROEIRHME/NOIS: EI)=TA O(/TI TAU=TA A)PONE/METAI KATA\ TO\N TOU= *DIO\S LO/GON, H)/TOI E)PI\ KOLA/SEI H)\ KAT' A)/LLHN E)/XOUSA/N PWS PRO\S TA\ O(/LA OI)KONOMI/AN>20."2 @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 32 p. 1049a.$8 *(O DE\ OU(/TW KATAGELA=| TW=N E)PI\ TOU/TOIS E)GKALOU/NTWN, W(/STE PERI\ TOU= *DIO/S, TOU= SW-TH=ROS KAI\ GENE/TOROS KAI\ PATRO\S *DI/KHS KAI\ *EU)NOMI/AS KAI\ *EI)RH/NHS TAU=TA GRA/FEIN <20E)N TW=| TRI/TW| PERI\ *QEW=N: "1*(WS DE\ AI( PO/LEIS PLEONA/SASAI EI)S A)POIKI/AS A)PAI/ROUSI TA\ PLH/QH KAI\ POLE/MOUS E)NI/STANTAI PRO/S TINAS, OU(/TWS O( QEO\S FQORA=S A)RXA\S DI/DWSI>20."2 KAI\ TO\N *EU)RIPI/DHN MA/RTURA KAI\ TOU\S A)/LLOUS PROSA/GETAI TOU\S LE/GONTAS W(S O( *TRWI+KO\S PO/LEMOS U(PO\ TW=N QEW=N A)PANTLH/SEWS XA/RIN TOU= PLH/QOUS TW=N A)NQRW/-PWN GE/NOITO. @&p. 1049b.$ SKO/PEI DE/, O(/TI TW=| QEW=| KALA\S ME\N E)PIKLH/SEIS A)EI\ KAI\ FILANQRW/POUS, A)/GRIA D' E)/RGA KAI\ BA/RBARA KAI\ *GALATIKA\ PROSTI/-QHSIN. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 37 p. 1051b.$8 *)/ETI PERI\ TOU= MHDE\N E)GKLHTO\N EI)=NAI MHDE\ MEMPTO\N KO/SMW|, KATA\ TH\N A)RI/STHN FU/SIN A(PA/NTWN PARAGOME/NWN, POLLA/KIS GEGRAFW\S E)/STIN O(/POU PA/LIN E)GKLHTA/S TINAS A)MELEI/AS OU) PERI\ MIKRA\ KAI\ FAU=LA A)POLEI/PEI. <20*)EN GOU=N TW=| TRI/TW| PERI\ *OU)SI/AS>20, MNHSQEI\S O(/TI SUMBAI/NEI TINA\ TOI=S KALOI=S KAI\ A)GA-QOI=S TOIAU=TA "1<20*PO/TERON>20, FHSI/N, <20A)MELOUME/NWN TINW=N, KAQA/PER E)N OI)KI/AIS MEI/ZOSI PARAPI/PTEI TINA\ PI/TURA KAI\ POSOI\ PUROI/ TINES, TW=N O(/LWN EU)= OI)KONOMOUME/NWN: H)\ DIA\ TO\ KAQI/STASQAI E)PI\ TW=N TOIOU/TWN DAIMO/NIA FAU=LA, E)N OI(=S TW=| O)/NTI GI/NONTAI KAI\ E)GKLH-TE/AI A)ME/LEIAI>20;"2 FHSI\ DE\ POLU\ KAI\ TO\ TH=S A)NA/GKHS MEMI=XQAI. *TO\ ME\N OU)=N TA\ TOIAU=TA SUMPTW/MATA TW=N KALW=N KA)GAQW=N A)NDRW=N, OI(=ON H( *SW-KRA/TOUS KATADI/KH KAI\ O( *PUQAGO/ROU ZW=NTOS E)MPRHSMO\S U(PO\ TW=N *KULW-NEI/WN KAI\ *ZH/NWNOS U(PO\ *DHMU/LOU TOU= TURA/NNOU KAI\ *)ANTIFW=NTOS U(PO\ *DIONUSI/OU STREBLOUME/NWN A)NAIRE/SEIS, PITU/ROIS PARAPI/PTOUSIN A)PEI- @1KA/ZEIN, O(/SHS E)STI\N EU)XEREI/AS, E)W=: TO\ DE\ FAU/LOUS DAI/MONAS E)K PRO-NOI/AS E)PI\ TA\S TOIAU/TAS E)PISTASI/AS KAQI/STASQAI, PW=S OU)K E)/STIN E)/GKLHMA TOU= QEOU= &10etc. &10@Cicero de nat. deor. III 86. At enim minora di neglegunt &10neque agellos singulorum nec viticulas persequuntur nec si uredo aut &10grando quippiam nocuit, id Iovi animadvertendum fuit; ne in regnis &10quidem reges omnia minima curant; <21sic enim dicitis>21. &10@Cicero de nat. deor. III 90. Non animadvertunt, inquit, omnia &10di, ne reges quidem. Quid est simile? Reges enim si scientes praeter-&10mittunt, magna culpa est; at deo ne excusatio quidem est inscientiae. &10Quem vos praeclare defenditis, cum <21dicitis eam vim deorum esse, ut, &10etiamsi quis morte poenas sceleris effugerit, expetantur eae &10poenae a liberis, a nepotibus, a posteris>21. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 35 p. 1050f.$8 E)PITEI/NEI DE\ TH\N U(PENANTI/WSIN <20E)N TW=| DEUTE/RW| PERI\ *FU/SEWS>20 GRA/FWN TA/DE "1<20*(H DE\ KAKI/A PRO\S TA\ DEINA\ SUMPTW/MATA I)/DIO/N TINA E)/XEI LO/GON: GI/NETAI ME\N GA\R KAI\ AU)TH/ PWS KATA\ TO\N TH=S FU/SEWS LO/GON, KAI/, I(/N' OU(/TWS EI)/PW, OU)K A)XRH/STWS GI/NETAI PRO\S TA\ O(/LA: OU)DE\ GA\R A)\N TA)GAQA\ H)=N>20."2 @&idem de comm. not. cp. 13 p. 1065b.$ A)LLA\ XOROU= ME/N E)STIN E)M-ME/LEIA, MHDENO\S A)PA/|DONTOS E)N AU)TW=|: KAI\ SW/MATOS U(GI/EIA, MHDENO\S MORI/OU NOSOU=NTOS: A)RETH\ D' A)/NEU KAKI/AS OU)K E)/XEI GE/NESIN, A)LL' W(/SPER E)NI/AIS TW=N I)ATRIKW=N DUNA/MEWN I)O\S O)/FEWS KAI\ XOLH\ U(AI/NHS A)NAGKAI=O/N E)STIN, OU(/TWS E)PITHDEIO/THS E(TE/RA TH=| *MELH/TOU MOXQHRI/A| PRO\S TH\N *SW-KRA/TOUS DIKAIOSU/NHN, KAI\ TH=| *KLE/WNOS A)NAGWGI/A| PRO\S TH\N *PERIKLE/OUS KALOKA)GAQI/AN: PW=S D' A)\N EU(=REN O( *ZEU\S TO\N *(HRAKLE/A FU=SAI KAI\ TO\N *LUKOU=RGON, EI) MH\ KAI\ *SARDANA/PALON H(MI=N E)/FUSE KAI\ *FA/LARIN; __ *TI/ GA\R DIAFE/ROUSI TW=N TAU=TA LHROU/NTWN KAI\ FLUAROU/NTWN OI( LE/GON-TES "1<20MH\ A)XRH/STWS GEGONE/NAI PRO\S TH\N E)GKRA/TEIAN TH\N A)KO-LASI/AN, KAI\ PRO\S TH\N DIKAIOSU/NHN TH\N A)DIKI/AN>20;"2 @&idem de comm. not. cp. 14 p. 1065d.$8 *)\H BOU/LEI TO\ H(/DISTON AU)-TOU= TH=S GLAFURI/AS KAI\ PIQANO/THTOS I(STORH=SAI: "1<20*(/WSPER GA\R AI( KW-MW|DI/AI>20, FHSI/N, <20E)PIGRA/MMATA GELOI=A FE/ROUSIN, A(\ KAQ' AU(TA\ ME/N E)STI FAU=LA, TW=| DE\ O(/LW| POIH/MATI XA/RIN TINA\ PROSTI/QHSIN: OU(/TW YE/CEIAS A)\N AU)TH\N E)F' E(AUTH=S TH\N KAKI/AN: TOI=S D' A)/LLOIS OU)K A)/XRHSTO/S E)STI>20."2 @&ibidem cp. 16 p. 1066d.$ *LA. __E)PIQUMW= GA\R PUQE/SQAI, TI/NA DH\ TRO/PON OI( A)/NDRES [1&Stoici$]1 TA\ KAKA\ TW=N A)GAQW=N, KAI\ TH\N KAKI/AN @1 TH=S A)RETH=S PROEISA/GOUSIN. *DIAD. __POLU\S ME\N O( YELLISMO\S AU)-TW=N, TE/LOS DE\ <20TH\N ME\N FRO/NHSIN E)PISTH/MHN A)GAQW=N KAI\ KA-KW=N OU)=SAN, [2A)NAIREQE/NTWN TW=N KAKW=N]2 KAI\ PANTA/PASIN A)NAIREI=SQAI LE/GOUSIN: W(S D' A)LHQW=N O)/NTWN A)DU/NATON MH\ KAI\ YEUDH= TINA EI)=NAI, PARAPLHSI/WS OI)/ONTAI PROSH/KEIN, A)GAQW=N U(PARXO/NTWN KAI\ KAKA\ U(PA/RXEIN>20. @&M. Antoninus VI 42.$ *)ALLA\ SU\ MH\ TOIOU=TO ME/ROS GE/NH|, OI(=OS O( EU)TELH\S KAI\ GELOI=OS STI/XOS E)N TW=| DRA/MATI, OU(= <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 ME/MNHTAI. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 36 p. 1051a.$8 *PA/LIN <20E)N TW=| PRW/TW| PERI\ *DIKAIOSU/NHS>20 EI)PW\N PERI\ TW=N QEW=N, W(S E)NISTAME/NWN E)NI/OIS A)DIKH/MASI, "1<20*KAKI/AN DE/ FHSI KAQO/LOU A)=RAI OU)/TE DUNATO/N E)STIN OU)/T' E)/XEI KALW=S A)RQH=NAI>20."2 @&Philodemus$ PERI\ QEW=N DIAGWGH=S &col. 7, 28 [1Scott. Frgm. &Herc. p. 156$]1. __EI) KAI\ TAU=[1T']1 E)[1DU/]1NATO, TH\N DU/NAMIN !!!!!!WS KAI\ TOU= PA/NT[1AS]1 POIH=SAI SOFOU\S KAI\ MAKARI/OUS KAI\ MHDE\N KAKO/N. TO\ DE\ TOIOU=TON A)SQE/NEIAN KAI/ TIN' E)/LLEIYIN SUNA/PTEI TW=| KRATI/STW|. POLLA/KIS DE\ AU)TO\ E)P' A)NATROPH=| TH=S NOH/SEWS TOU= QEOU= SUGXWROU=SI: KAQA/PER O( [1ME\N]1 <20*XRU/SIPPOS E)N TOI=S PERI\ MANTIKH=S>20 LE/GEI MH\ DU/-[1NASQAI]1 TO\N QEO\N EI)[1DE/NAI PA/NT]1A, DIA\ TO\ MHD' E)/XEIN ... @&ibid. col. 8 [1ibid. p. 157$]1. KAI\ KATA\ TH\N [1TOU= QE]1OU= [1DIA]1FORA\[1N I)]1DIWTIKW=S [1PAN]1TO\S AU)TW=| DU/NAMIN A)NAQE/NTES, [1O(/]1TAN U(PO\ TW=N E)LE/GXWN PIE/ZWNTAI, TO/TE KATAFEU/GOUSIN E)PI\ TO\ DIA\ TOU=TO FA/SKEIN TA\ SUNAPTO/-MENA MH\ POIEI=N O(/TI OU) PA/NTA DU/NATAI. @&10Clemens Al. Stromat. I p. 369 Pott.$10 *)ALLA\ KAI\ AI( TW=N A)PO-STATHSA/NTWN BOULAI/ TE KAI\ E)NE/RGEIAI, MERIKAI\ OU)=SAI, GI/NONTAI ME\N E)K FAU/LHS DIAQE/SEWS, KAQA/PER KAI\ AI( NO/SOI AI( SWMATIKAI/: KUBERNW=NTAI DE\ U(PO\ TH=S KAQO/LOU PRONOI/AS E)PI\ TE/LOS U(GIEINO/N, KA)\N NOSOPOIO\S H)=| H( AI)TI/A. <20*ME/GISTON GOU=N TH=S QEI/AS PRONOI/AS TO\ MH\ E)A=SAI TH\N E)C A)POSTA/SEWS E(KOUSI/OU FUEI=SAN KAKI/AN A)/XRHSTON KAI\ A)NWFELH= ME/NEIN MHDE\ MH\N KATA\ PA/NTA BLABERA\N AU)TH\N GENE/SQAI>20: TH=S GA\R QEI/AS SOFI/AS KAI\ A)RETH=S KAI\ DUNA/MEWS E)/RGON E)STI\N OU) MO/NON TO\ A)GAQOPOIEI=N: FU/SIS GA\R W(S EI)PEI=N AU(/TH TOU= QEOU=, W(S TOU= PURO\S TO\ QERMAI/NEIN KAI\ TOU= FWTO\S TO\ FWTI/ZEIN: A)LLA\ KA)KEI=NO MA/LISTA TO\ DIA\ KAKW=N TW=N E)PINOHQE/NTWN PRO\S TINW=N A)GAQO/N TI KAI\ XRHSTO\N TE/LOS A)POTELEI=N KAI\ W)FELI/MWS TOI=S DOKOU=SI FAU/LOIS XRH=SQAI. @&10Origenes de princip. III p. 162 ed. Delarue.$10 KAI\ GA\R E)PI\ TW=N TH=S A(PTOME/NHS TOU= PANTO\S KO/SMOU PRONOI/AS E)/RGWN TINA\ ME\N E)NARGE/STATA FAI/NETAI H(=| PRONOI/AS E)STI\N E)/RGA, E(/TERA DE\ OU(/TWS A)POKE/KRUPTAI, W(S A)PISTI/AS XW/RAN PARE/XEIN DOKEI=N TH=S PERI\ TOU= TE/XNH| A)FA/TW| KAI\ DUNA/MEI DIOIKOU=NTOS TA\ O(/LA QEOU=. *OU)X OU(/TW GA\R SAFH\S O( PERI\ TOU= PRONOOU=NTOS TEXNIKO\S LO/GOS E)N TOI=S E)PI\ GH=S, W(S E)N H(LI/W| KAI\ SELH/NH| KAI\ A)/STROIS: KAI\ OU)X OU(/TW DH=LOS @1 E)N TOI=S KATA\ TA\ A)NQRW/PINA SUMPTW/MATA W(S E)N TAI=S YUXAI=S KAI\ TOI=S SW/MASI TW=N ZW/|WN: SFO/DRA TOU= PRO\S TI/ KAI\ E(/NEKA TI/NOS EU(RISKOME/NOU TOI=S TOU/TWN E)PIMELOME/NOIS PERI\ TA\S O(RMA\S KAI\ TA\S FANTASI/AS KAI\ FU/SEIS TW=N ZW/|WN KAI\ TA\S KATASKEUA\S TW=N SWMA/TWN. @&10Cicero de nat. deor III 70 [1postquam disputavit deos male &10consuluisse hominibus, cum iis rationem largirentur]1. Huic loco sic sole-&10tis occurrere%10 <21non idcirco non optume nobis a dis esse provisum, &10quod multi eorum beneficio perverse uterentur>21; etiam patrimoniis &10multos male uti, nec ob eam causam eos beneficium a patribus nullum &10habere.$ @1 @&Cicero de divin. I 3, 6.&3 accessit acerrimo vir ingenio <21Chry-&3sippus>21, qui totam <21de divinatione duobus libris explicavit sen-&3tentiam, uno praeterea de oraculis, uno de somniis>21%10 quem sub-&3sequens unum librum Babylonius Diogenes edidit, eius auditor. @&10Cicero Acad. Pr. II 107. Cum Panaetius__ea de re dubi-&10tare se dicat, quam <21omnes praeter eum Stoici>21 certissimam putant, &10<21vera esse haruspicum [2responsa]2, auspicia, oracula, somnia, &10vaticinationes>21 etc. @&Cicero de divin. II 63, 130.&3 <21Chrysippus>21 quidem <21divina-&3tionem>21 definit his verbis%10 <21Vim cognoscentem et videntem et expli-&3cantem signa, quae a diis hominibus portendantur>21%10 officium &3autem esse eius praenoscere, dei erga homines mente qua sint quidque &3significent, quemadmodumque ea procurentur atque expientur. Idemque &3<21somniorum coniectionem>21 definit hoc modo%10 <21Esse vim cernentem &3et explanantem, quae a diis hominibus significentur in somnis>21. @&10Ae%28tius Plac. V 1, 1.$10 *PLA/TWN KAI\ OI( <20*STWI+KOI\>20 TH\N MANTIKH\N EI)SA/GOUSI KATA\ TO\ E)/NQEON O(/PER E)STI\N E)NQEASTIKO\N [KATA\ QEIO/THTA TH=S YUXH=S, O(/PER EI)=PEN E)NQOUSIASTIKO\N] KAI\ TO\ O)NEIROPOLIKO/N. OU(=TOI TA\ PLEI=STA ME/RH TH=S MANTIKH=S E)GKRI/NOUSI [1&10sc. Stoici]1. @&Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 149.$ KAI\ MH\N KAI\ MANTIKH\N U(FESTA/NAI PA=SA/N FASIN, EI) KAI\ PRO/NOIAN EI)=NAI: KAI\ AU)TH\N KAI\ TE/XNHN A)POFAI/-NOUSI DIA/ TINAS E)KBA/SEIS, W(/S FHSI *ZH/NWN TE KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS E)N TW=| DEUTE/RW| PERI\ MANTIKH=S>20. @&Cicero de divin. I 38, 82.&3 Quam quidem esse re vera hac &3Stoicorum ratione concluditur%10 "1<21Si sunt dii, neque ante declarant @1 &3hominibus, quae futura sint, aut non diligunt homines, aut &3quid eventurum sit ignorant, aut existimant nihil interesse &3hominum scire quid sit futurum; aut non censent esse suae &3maiestatis praesignificare hominibus quae sunt futura, aut &3ea ne ipsi quidem dii significare possunt. At neque non dili-&3gunt nos, sunt enim benefici generique hominum amici%10 ne-&3que ignorant ea, quae ab ipsis constituta et designata sunt%10 &3neque nostra nihil interest, scire ea quae eventura sunt; eri-&3mus enim cautiores, si sciemus%10 neque hoc alienum ducunt &3maiestate sua; nihil est enim beneficentia praestantius%10 neque &3non possunt futura praenoscere.& 83.&3 Non igitur sunt dii nec &3significant futura. Sunt autem dii%10 significant ergo. Et non, &3si significant, nullas vias dant nobis ad significationis scien-&3tiam%10 frustra enim significarent%10 nec, si dant vias, non est &3divinatio%10 est igitur divinatio>21"2.& 39, 84.&3 Hac ratione et <21Chrysip-&3pus>21 et Diogenes et Antipater utitur. @&10Cicero de divin. II 41. Ita enim, cum magis properant, con-&10cludere solent [1scil. Stoici]1%10 "1Si di sunt, est divinatio; sunt autem di; est &10ergo divinatio."2 &10@Cicero de legibus II 32. Si enim deos esse concedimus, edrum-&10que mente mundum regi, et eorum numen hominum consulere generi et &10posse nobis signa rerum futurarum ostendere, non video, cur esse divina-&10tionem negem. 33. sunt autem ea, quae posui; [2ex]2 quibus id, quod &10volumus, efficitur et cogitur. &10@Quintilianus Instit. orat. V 7, 35. his adicere siquis volet ea &10quae divina testimonia vocant, ex responsis, oraculis, ominibus, duplicem &10sciat esse eorum tractatum%10 generalem alterum, in quo inter Stoicos et &10Epicuri sectam secutos pugna perpetua est, regaturne providentia mundus, &10specialem alterum circa partis divinationis, ut quaeque in quaestionem &10cadet. aliter enim oraculorum, aliter haruspicum, augurum, coniectorum, &10mathematicorum fides confirmari aut refelli potest, cum sit rerum ipsarum &10ratio diversa. &10@Tertullianus de anima cp. 46. Sed et <21Stoici>21 deum malunt &10providentissimum humanae institutioni inter cetera praesidia divinatricum &10artium et disciplinarum somnia quoque nobis indidisse, peculiare solacium &10naturalis oraculi. &10@Cicero de nat. deor. III 93. Sed quo modo iidem dicitis non @1 &10omnia deos persequi, iidem voltis a dis immortalibus hominibus dispertiri &10ac dividi somnia? Idcirco haec tecum, quia vestra est de somniorum veri-&10tate sententia. Atque iidem etiam vota suscipi dicitis oportere. &10@Chalcidius ad timaeum cp. 251. <21Heraclitus>21 vero consen-&10tientibus <21Stoicis>21 rationem nostram cum divina ratione connectit regente &10ac moderante mundana%10 propter inseparabilem comitatum consciam decreti &10rationabilis factam quiescentibus animis ope sensuum futura denuntiare. &10ex quo fieri ut adpareant imagines ignotorum locorum simulacraque homi-&10num tam viventium quam mortuorum. Idemque asserit divinationis usum &10et praemoneri meritos, instruentibus divinis potestatibus; hi[c] quoque &10parte abutentes sententiae pro solida perfectaque scientia. &10@Cicero de divin. I 20,39.&3 veniamus ad somnia, de quibus &3disputans <21Chrysippus>21 multis et minutis somniis colligendis facit idem, &3quod Antipater, ea conquirens, quae Antiphontis interpretatione explicata &3declarant illa quidem acumen interpretis%10 sed exemplis grandioribus &3decuit uti. &3@Cicero de divin. I 56. Quid? illa duo somnia, <21quae creber-&3rume commemorantur a Stoicis>21_unum de Simonide, qui cum &3ignotum quendam proiectum mortuum vidisset eumque humavisset haberet-&3que in animo navem conscendere, moneri visus est, ne id faceret, ab eo, &3quem sepultura adfecerat; si navigavisset, eum naufragio esse periturum; &3itaque Simonidem redisse, perisse ceteros, qui tum navigassent. &3@Cicero de divin. II 65, 134.&3 Defert ad coniectorem quidam, &3somniasse se, ovum pendere ex fascea lecti sui cubicularis. Est hoc in &3<21Chrysippi libro>21 somnium. Respondet coniector, thesaurum defossum &3esse sub lecto. Fodit, invenit auri aliquantum idque circumdatum ar-&3gento. Misit coniectori quantulum visum est de argento. Tum ille &3"1nihilne, inquit, de vitello?."2 id enim ei ex ovo videbatur aurum declarasse, &3reliquum argentum. @&Photius lexicon s. v.$ NEOTTO/S: __O(/TI DE\ TO\ W)XRO\N NEOT-TO\N E)/LEGON, MARTUREI= KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS E)N TW=| PERI\ XRHSMW=N>20: "1O)/NAR GA/R TINA FASI\N QEASA/MENON E)K TH=S KLI/NHS AU)TOU= KRE/MASQAI W)A\ PROS-ANAQE/SQAI O)NEIROKRI/TH|, TO\N DE\ EI)PEI=N. O)RU/TTWN QHSAURO\N EU(RH/SEIS KATA\ TO\N TO/PON E)KEI=NON: EU(RO/NTA DE\ STAMNI/ON, E)N W(=| A)RGU/RION H)=N KAI\ XRUSI/ON, E)NEGKEI=N TI TOU= A)RGURI/OU TW=| MA/NTEI: TO\N DE\ MA/NTIN EI)PEI=N: TOU= DE\ NEOTTOU= OU)DE/N MOI DI/DWS;"2 @&10Apostolius XII.$10 NEOTTOU= OU)DE/N MOI DI/DWS.&10 laudatur <21Chry-&10sippus>21$10 <20E)N TW=| PERI\ XRHSMW=N>20. @&Cicero de divinatione I 27, 57.&3 Alterum ita traditum cla-&3rum admodum somnium. Cum duo quidam Arcades familiares iter &3una facerent et Megaram venissent, alterum ad coponem devertisse, ad &3hospitem alterum. Qui ut cenati quiescerent, concubia nocte visum esse &3in somnis ei, qui erat in hospitio, illum alterum orare, ut subveniret, @1 &3quod sibi a copone interitus pararetur; eum primo perterritum somnio &3surrexisse; dein cum se collegisset idque visum pro nihilo habendum &3esse duxisset, recubuisse; tum ei dormienti eundem illum visum esse &3rogare, ut quoniam sibi vivo non subvenisset, mortem suam ne inultam &3esse pateretur; se interfectum in plaustrum a copone esse coniectum et &3supra stercus iniectum; petere ut mane ad portam adesset, priusquam &3plaustrum ex oppido exiret. Hoc vero eum somnio commotum mane &3bubulco praesto ad portam fuisse. quaesisse ex eo, quid esset in plaustro; &3illum perterritum fugisse%10 mortuum erutum esse; coponem re patefacta &3poenas dedisse. @&Suidas s. v.$ *TIMWROU=NTOS: __*LE/GEI GOU=N <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 E)N *MEGA/ROIS KATAXQH=NAI/ TINA, XRUSI/OU ZW/NHN PEPLHRWME/NHN E)PAGO/-MENON. A)PE/KTEINE DE\ A)/RA AU)TO\N PANDOKEU\S O( U(PODECA/MENOS O)YISQE/NTA, E)POFQALMI/SAS TW=| XRUSI/W| EI)=TA E)/MELLEN E)KKOMI/ZEIN E)F' A(MA/CHS A)GOU/SHS KO/PRON, U(POKRU/YAS E)N TAU/TH| TO\N PEFONEUME/NON. H( TOI/NUN YUXH\ TOU= TEQNEW=TOS E)FI/STATAI *MEGAREI= TINI KAI\ LE/GEI O(/SA TE E)/PAQE KAI\ U(F' O(/TOU KAI\ O(/PWS E)KKOMI/ZESQAI ME/LLOI KAI\ KATA\ POI/AS PU/LAS: O( DE\ OU)K H)/KOUSE R(A|QU/MWS TA\ LEXQE/NTA, KNEFAI=OS DE\ DIANASTA\S KAI\ PARAFU-LA/CAS TOU= ZEU/GOUS E)PELA/BETO KAI\ A)NI/XNEUSE TO\N NEKRO/N. KAI\ O( ME\N E)TA/FH, O( DE\ E)KOLA/SQH. @&Cicero de divin. II 70, 144.&3 Quid? ipsorum interpretum &3coniecturae nonne magis ingenia declarant eorum quam vim consensum-&3que naturae? Cursor ad Olympia proficisci cogitans visus est in somnis &3curru quadrigarum vehi. Mane ad coniectorem. At ille%10 "1Vinces"2, in-&3quit "1id enim celeritas significat et vis equorum."2 Post idem ad &3Antiphontem. Is autem%10 "1Vincare, inquit, necesse est. An non intelli-&3gis, quattuor ante te cucurrisse?"2 _Ecce alius cursor [1atque horum &3somniorum et talium plenus est <21Chrysippi>21 liber, plenus Antipatri]1 sed &3ad cursorem redeo. Ad interpretem detulit, aquilam se in somnis visum &3esse factum. At ille%10 "1Vicisti. Ista enim avi volat nulla vehementius."2 &3Huic eidem Antiphon%10 "1Baro, inquit, victum te esse non vides? Ista &3enim avis, insectans alias aves et agitans, semper ipsa postrema est."2 _ &`145.&3 Parere quaedam matrona cupiens dubitans, essetne praegnas, visa &3est in quiete obsignatam habere naturam. Rettulit. Negavit eam, quo-&3niam obsignata fuisset, concipere potuisse. At alter praegnatem esse &3dixit; nam inane obsignari nihil solere. Quae est ars coniectoris elu-&3dentis ingenio. An ea quae dixi et innumerabilia, quae conlecta habent @1 &3Stoici, quicquam significant nisi acumen hominum ex similitudine aliqua &3coniecturam modo huc, modo illuc ducentium? @&10Cicero de divin. I 72. Quae vero aut coniectura explicantur &10aut eventis animadversa ac notata sunt, ea genera divinandi, ut supra &10dixi, non naturalia, sed <21artificiosa>21 dicuntur; in quo <21haruspices, au-&10gures coniectoresque>21 numerantur. Haec improbantur a Peripateticis, &10a <21Stoicis>21 defenduntur. &10@Cicero de divinatione I 49, 109. Quid? si etiam ratio exstat &10artificiosae praesensionis facilis, divinae autem paulo obscurior? <21quae &10enim extis, quae fulgoribus, quae portentis, quae astris prae-&10sentiuntur, haec notata sunt observatione diuturna>21. Affert &10autem vetustas omnibus in rebus longinqua observatione incredibilem scien-&10tiam%10 quae potest esse etiam sine motu atque impulsu deorum, cum quid &10ex quoque eveniat et quid quamque rem significet, crebra animadversione &10perspectum est. Altera divinatio est naturalis ut ante dixi; 110. quae &10physica disputandi subtilitate referenda est ad naturam deorum, a qua, &10ut doctissimis sapientissimisque placuit, haustos animos et libatos habe-&10mus%10 <21cumque omnia completa et referta sint aeterno sensu et &10mente divina, necesse est contagione divinorum animorum ani-&10mos humanos commoveri>21. @&Cicero de divinatione I 52, 118.&3 Hoc autem posito atque &3concesso, esse quandam vim divinam, hominum vitam continentem, non &3difficile est, quae fieri certe videmus, ea qua ratione fiant, suspicari. &3Nam et <21ad hostiam deligendam potest dux esse vis quaedam &3sentiens, quae est toto confusa mundo>21%10 et tum ipsum, cum immo-&3lare velis, <21extorum fieri mutatio potest>21, ut aut absit aliquid aut &3supersit%10 parvis enim momentis multa natura aut affingit aut mutat &3aut detrahit. @&10Cicero de divin. I 118. Nam non placet <21Stoicis>21 singulis &10iecorum fissis aut avium cantibus interesse deum; neque enim decorum &10est nec dis dignum nec fieri ullo pacto potest; sed ita a principio incho-&10atum esse mundum, ut certis rebus certa signa praecurrerent, alia in &10extis, alia in avibus, alia in fulgoribus, alia in ostentis, alia in stellis, @1 &10alia in somniantium visis, alia in furentium vocibus. Ea quibus bene &10percepta sunt, ii non saepe falluntur; male coniecta maleque interpretata &10falsa sunt non rerum vitio, sed interpretum inscientia. &10@Cicero de divin. II 33. Cum rerum autem natura quam &10cognationem habent [1scil. exta, e quibus haruspices futura praedicunt]1? &10<21quae ut uno consensu iuncta sit et continens>21, quod video placuisse &10physicis eisque maxume, qui omne, quod esset, unum esse dixerunt, quid &10habere mundus potest cum thesauri inventione coniunctum? Si enim extis &10pecuniae mihi amplificatio ostenditur idque fit natura, primum exta sunt &10coniuncta mundo, deinde meum lucrum natura rerum continetur. Nonne &10pudet physicos haec dicere? Ut enim iam sit aliqua in natura rerum con-&10tagio, quam esse concedo__multa enim <21Stoici>21 colligunt; nam et <21mus-&10culorum iecuscula bruma dicuntur augeri, et puleium aridum &10florescere brumali ipso die et inflatas rumpi vesiculas et se-&10mina malorum, quae in iis mediis inclusa sint, in contrarias &10partis se vertere, iam nervos in fidibus aliis pulsis resonare &10alios, ostreisque et conchyliis omnibus contingere, ut cum luna &10pariter crescant pariterque decrescant, arboresque ut hiemali &10tempore cum luna simul senescente quia tum exsiccatae sint, &10tempestive caedi putentur. 34. Quid de fretis aut de marinis &10aestibus plura dicam? quorum accessus et recessus lunae motu &10gubernantur>21. Sescenta licet eiusdem modi proferri, ut distantium rerum &10cognatio naturalis appareat__demus hoc__qua ex coniunctione na-&10turae et quasi concentu atque consensu, quam$10 SUMPA/QEIAN &10Graeci appel-&10lant, convenire potest aut fissum iecoris cum lucello meo aut meus quaesti-&10culus cum caelo, terra rerumque natura? &10@Origenes contra Celsum IV 88 Vol. I p. 360, 13 Ko+. [1p. 569 &10Del.$10]1. PRW=TON ME\N GA\R E)ZH/THTAI PO/TERON E)/STI TIS TE/XNH OI)WNISTIKH\ KAI\ A(PACAPLW=S H( DIA\ ZW/|WN MANTIKH\ H)\ OU)K E)/STI: DEU/TERON DE\ PARA\ TOI=S PARA-DECAME/NOIS EI)=NAI TH\N DI' O)RNI/QWN MANTIKH\N OU) SUMPEFW/NHTAI H( AI)TI/A TOU= TRO/POU TH=S MANTEI/AS: E)PEIDH/PER OI( ME\N A)PO/ TINWN DAIMO/NWN H)\ QEW=N MANTI-KW=N FASI GI/GNESQAI TA\S KINH/SEIS TOI=S ZW/|OIS, O)/RNISI ME\N EI)S DIAFO/ROUS PTH/-SEIS KAI\ EI)S DIAFO/ROUS FWNA/S, TOI=S DE\ LOIPOI=S EI)S TA\S TOIASDI\ KINH/SEIS H)\ TOIASDI/, A)/LLOI DE\ QEIOTE/RAS AU)TW=N KAI\ PRO\S TOU=T' E)PITHDEI/OUS EI)=NAI TA\S YUXA/S: O(/PER E)STI\N A)PIQANW/TATON. @&10ibid. 90 Vol. I p. 362, 22 Ko+. [1p. 570, 71 Del.$10]1. *LEKTE/ON OU)=N O(/TI EI)/PER TIS QEI/A FU/SIS H)=N E)N AU)TOI=S TW=N MELLO/NTWN PROGNWSTIKH\ KAI\ E)PI\ TO-SOU=TON PLOUSI/A, W(S E)K PERIOUSI/AS KAI\ TW=| BOULOME/NW| TW=N A)NQRW/PWN DHLOU=N TA\ E)SO/MENA, DHLONO/TI POLU\ PRO/TERON TA\ PERI\ E(AUTW=N E)GI/GNWSKON &10etc. &10@Cicero de divinatione I 53, 120. Eademque efficit in avibus &10divina mens, ut tum huc tum illuc volent alites%10 tum in hac tum in illa &10parte se occultent, tum a dextra tum a sinistra parte canant oscines. &10Nam si animal omne, ut vult, ita utitur motu sui corporis, prono, obli-&10quo, supino, membraque quocunque vult flectit, contorquet, porrigit, con- @1&10trahit, eaque ante efficit paene quam cogitat%10 quanto id deo est facilius, &10cuius numini parent omnia. &10@Cicero de divin. II 56, 115.&3 Sed iam ad te venio, o sancte &3Apollo__tuis enim oraculis <21Chrysippus>21 totum volumen implevit, &3partim falsis, ut ego opinor, partim casu veris, ut fit in omni oratione &3saepissime, partim flexiloquis et obscuris, ut interpres egeat interprete et &3sors ipsa ad sortes referenda sit, partim ambiguis et quae ad dialecti-&3cum referenda sint. @&10Cicero de divin. II 117. [1contra Chrysippum disputans, qui &10multa Apollinis oracula collegerat]1%10 Sed__cur isto modo iam oracla &10Delphis non eduntur, non modo nostra aetate, sed iam diu, iam ut nihil &10possit esse contemptius? Hoc loco cum urguentur, <21evanuisse aiunt &10vetustate vim loci eius, unde anhelitus ille terrae fieret, quo &10Pythia mente incitata oracla ederet>21. @&Lactantius instit. div. I 6.&3 [1in Sibyllarum catalago]1 tertiam &3Delphida, de qua <21Chrysippus>21 loquitur in eo <21libro>21, quem <21de divi-&3natione>21 composuit. @1 @&Diog. Lae%28rt VII 84.$ *TO\ DE\ H)QIKO\S ME/ROS TH=S FILOSOFI/AS DI-AIROU=SIN EI)/S TE TO\N <20PERI\ O(RMH=S>20 KAI\ EI)S <20TO\N PERI\ A)GAQW=N KAI\ KAKW=N>20 TO/PON KAI\ EI)S <20TO\N PERI\ PAQW=N>20 KAI\ <20PERI\ A)RETH=S>20 KAI\ <20PERI\ TE/LOUS>20 PERI/ TE <20TH=S PRW/THS A)CI/AS>20 KAI\ <20TW=N PRA/CEWN>20 KAI\ <20PERI\ TW=N KAQHKO/NTWN PROTROPW=N TE KAI\ A)POTROPW=N>20. KAI\ OU(/TW D' U(PODIAIROU=SIN <20OI( PERI\ *XRU/SIPPON>20 KAI\ *)ARXE/DHMON KAI\ *ZH/NWNA TO\N *TARSE/A KAI\ *)APOLLO/DWRON KAI\ *DIOGE/NHN KAI\ *)ANTI/PATRON KAI\ *POSEI-DW/NION. *(O ME\N GA\R *KITTIEU\S *ZH/NWN KAI\ O( *KLEA/NQHS, W(S A)\N A)RXAI-O/TEROI, A)FELE/STERON PERI\ TW=N PRAGMA/TWN DIE/LABON. OU(=TOI DE\ DIEI=LON KAI\ TO\N LOGIKO\N KAI\ TO\N FUSIKO/N. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II p. 46 W. [1ex Arii didymi epitome]1.$10 LE/GETAI D' U(PO\ ME\N <20TW=N *STWI+KW=N>20 O(RIKW=S: "1<20TE/LOS E)STI\N OU(= E(/NEKA PA/NTA PRA/T-TETAI KAQHKO/NTWS, AU)TO\ DE\ PRA/TTETAI OU)DENO\S E(/NEKA>20."2 KA)KEI/NWS: "1<20OU(= XA/RIN TA)=LLA, AU)TO\ D' OU)DENO\S E(/NEKA>20."2 *KAI\ PA/LIN: "1<20E)F' O(\ PA/NTA TA\ E)N TW=| BI/W| PRATTO/MENA KAQHKO/NTWS TH\N A)NAFORA\N LAMBA/NEI, AU)TO\ D' E)P' OU)DE/N>20."2 @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 76, 16 W.$10 *TO\ DE\ TE/LOS LE/GESQAI TRIXW=S U(PO\ TW=N E)K TH=S AI(RE/SEWS TAU/THS: <20TO/ TE GA\R TELIKO\N A)GAQO\N>20 LE/GESQAI TE/LOS E)N TH=| FILOLO/GW| SUNHQEI/A|, W(S TH\N O(MOLOGI/AN LE/GOUSI TE/LOS EI)=NAI: LE/GOUSI DE\ <20KAI\ TO\N SKOPO\N TE/LOS>20, OI(=ON TO\N O(MOLOGOU/MENON BI/ON A)NAFORIKW=S LE/GONTES E)PI\ TO\ PARAKEI/MENON KATHGO/RHMA: KATA\ DE\ TO\ TRI/TON SHMAINO/MENON LE/GOUSI TE/LOS <20TO\ E)/SXATON TW=N O)REKTW=N>20, E)F' O(\ PA/NTA TA\ A)/LLA A)NAFE/RESQAI. @&Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 87.$ PA/LIN D' <20I)/SON E)STI\ TO\ KAT' A)RETH\N ZH=N TW=| KAT' E)MPEIRI/AN TW=N FU/SEI SUMBAINO/NTWN ZH=N>20, W(/S FHSI <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 E)N <20TW=| PRW/TW| PERI\ *TELW=N>20. ME/RH GA/R EI)SIN AI( H(ME/TE-RAI FU/SEIS TH=S TOU= O(/LOU. DIO/PER TE/LOS GI/NETAI TO\ A)KOLOU/QWS TH=| @1 FU/SEI ZH=N: O(/PER E)STI\ KATA/ TE TH\N AU(TOU= KAI\ KATA\ TH\N TW=N O(/LWN, OU)-DE\N E)NERGOU=NTAS W(=N A)PAGOREU/EIN EI)/WQEN O( NO/MOS O( KOINO/S, O(/SPER E)STI\N O( O)RQO\S LO/GOS DIA\ PA/NTWN E)RXO/MENOS, O( AU)TO\S W)\N TW=| *DII/+, KAQHGE-MO/NI TOU/TW| TH=S TW=N O)/NTWN DIOIKH/SEWS O)/NTI. EI)=NAI D' AU)TO\ TOU=TO TH\N TOU= EU)DAI/MONOS A)RETH\N KAI\ <20EU)/ROIAN BI/OU>20, O(/TAN PA/NTA PRA/TTHTAI KATA\ TH\N SUMFWNI/AN TOU= PAR' E(KA/STW| DAI/MONOS PRO\S TH\N TOU= O(/LOU DIOIKHTOU= BOU/LHSIN. @&ibid. 89.$ FU/SIN DE\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 ME\N E)CAKOU/EI, H(=| A)KOLOU/QWS DEI= ZH=N TH/N TE KOINH\N KAI\ I)DI/WS TH\N A)NQRWPI/NHN. @&Commenta Lucani lib. II 380 p. 73 Us.&3 His versibus declara-&3vit Stoicum Catonem fuisse%10 cuius philosophiae finis secundum <21Chry-&3sippum>21 ille est$ <20O(MOLOGOUME/NWS TH=| FU/SEI ZH=N>20,&3 hoc est%10 congruenter &3naturae vivere. @&10Clem. Al. Strom. V 14 p. 703 Pott.$10 E)NTEU=QEN <20OI( ME\N *STWI+KOI\>20 TO\ TE/LOS TH=S FILOSOFI/AS TO\ A)KOLOU/QWS TH=| FU/SEI ZH=N EI)RH/KASI. @&10Philo de plantatione Noe%28 %14 49 Vol. II p. 143, 20 Wendl.$10 *TO\ GA\R A)KOLOUQI/A| FU/SEWS I)SXU=SAI ZH=N EU)DAIMONI/AS TE/LOS EI)=PON OI( PRW=TOI. @&10Philo de migrat. Abrah. %14 128 Vol. II p. 293, 4 Wendl.$10 *TOU=TO DE/ E)STI TO\ PARA\ TOI=S A)/RISTA FILOSOFH/SASIN A)|DO/MENON TE/LOS, TO\ A)KOLOU/QWS TH=| FU/SEI ZH=N. @&10Clem. Al. Strom. II p. 482 Pott.$10 E)NTEU=QEN KAI\ OI( <20*STWI+KOI\>20 TO\ A)KOLOU/QWS TH=| FU/SEI ZH=N TE/LOS EI)=NAI E)DOGMA/TISAN, TO\N QEO\N EI)S FU/SIN METO-NOMA/SANTES A)PREPW=S: E)PEIDH\ H( FU/SIS KAI\ EI)S FUTA\__KAI\ EI)S LI/QOUS DIATEI/NEI. @&10Philo de Moyse lib. III Vol. II Mang. p. 158.$10 E)FIEME/NHN TH=S A)/KRAS EU)DAIMONI/AS KAI\ TOU= <20TE/LOUS>20, E)F' O(\ SPEU/DEIN A)NAGKAI=ON KAI\ TA\S PRA/-CEIS A(PA/SAS A)NAFE/REIN, STOXAZOME/NOUS W(/SPER E)N TAI=S TOCEI/AIS <20SKOPOU=>20 TOU= PERI\ BI/ON. @&10Cicero de finibus III 23. Atque ut membra nobis ita data sunt, &10ut ad quandam rationem vivendi data esse appareat, sic appetitio animi, &10quaf$10 O(RMH\&10 Graece vocatur, non ad quodvis genus vitae, sed ad Quandam &10formam vivendi videtur data, itemque et ratio et perfecta ratio. 24. ut &10enim histrioni actio, saltatori motus non quivis, sed certus quidam est &10datus, sic vita agenda est certo genere quodam, non quolibet; quod genus &10conveniens consentaneumque dicimus. Nec enim gubernationi aut medi-&10cinae similem <21sapientiam esse arbitramur>21, sed actioni illi potius, &10quam modo dixi, et saltationi, <21ut in ipsa insit, non foris petatur &10extremum, id est artis effectio>21. Et tamen est etiam alia cum his &10ipsis artibus sapientiae dissimilitudo, propterea quod in illis quae recte &10facta sunt, non continent tamen omnes partes, e quibus constant; quae &10autem__illi appellant$10 KATORQW/MATA,&10 omnes numeros virtutis continent. &10Sola enim sapientia in se tota conversa est. __25. Sapientia enim et @1 &10animi magnitudinem complectitur et iustitiam et ut omnia, quae homini &10accidant, infra se esse iudicet. &10@Galen. de H. et Plat. decr. V 6 [1`168]1 p. 450 M.$10 OU)K A)RKESQEI\S DE\ TOU/TOIS O( <20*POSEIDW/NIOS>20 E)NARGE/STERO/N TE KAI\ SFODRO/TERON <20KAQA/PTETAI TW=N PERI\ TO\N *XRU/SIPPON, W(S OU)K O)RQW=S E)CHGOUME/NWN TO\ TE/LOS>20. E)/XEI DE\ H( R(H=SIS W(=DE: "1A(\ DH\ PARE/NTES E)/NIOI TO\ O(MOLOGOUME/NWS ZH=N SUSTE/L-LOUSIN EI)S TO\ PA=N TO\ E)NDEXO/MENON POIEI=N E(/NEKA TW=N PRW/TWN KATA\ FU/SIN, O(/MOION AU)TO\ POIOU=NTES TW=| SKOPO\N E)KTI/QESQAI TH\N H(DONH\N H)\ TH\N A)OXLHSI/AN H)\ A)/LLO TI TOIOU=TON. E)/STI DE\ MA/XHN E)MFAI=NON KAT' AU)TH\N TH\N E)KFORA/N, KALO\N DE\ KAI\ EU)DAIMONIKO\N OU)DE/N. PARE/PETAI GA\R KATA\ TO\ A)NAGKAI=ON TW=| TE/LEI, TE/-LOS DE\ OU)K E)/STIN."2 *)ALLA\ KAI/, TOU/TOU DIALHFQE/NTOS O)RQW=S, E)/CESTI ME\N AU)TW=| XRH=SQAI PRO\S TO\ DIAKO/PTEIN TA\S A)PORI/AS, A(\S OI( SOFISTAI\ PROTEI/NOUSI, MH\ ME/NTOI GE TW=| "1<20KAT' E)MPEIRI/AN TW=N KATA\ TH\N O(/LHN FU/SIN SUMBAINO/N-TWN ZH=N,"2 O(/PER I)SODUNAMEI= TW=| O(MOLOGOUME/NWS EI)PEI=N ZH=N>20, H(NI/KA MH\ TOU=TO MIKROPREPW=S SUNTEI/NEI EI)S TO\ TW=N A)DIAFO/RWN TUGXA/NEIN. @&10Stob Eclog. II 76, 3 W.$10 *KLEA/NQHS GA\R PRW=TOS DIADECA/MENOS AU)TOU= [1&10sc.$10 TOU= *ZH/NWNOS]1 TH\N AI(/RESIN PROSE/QHKE "1TH=| FU/SEI"2 KAI\ OU(/TWS A)PE/DWKE: "1TE/LOS E)STI\ TO\ O(MOLOGOUME/NWS TH=| FU/SEI ZH=N."2 <20*(/OPER O( *XRU/SIPPOS SA-FE/STERON BOULO/MENOS POIH=SAI, E)CH/NEGKE TO\N TRO/PON TOU=TON: "1ZH=N KAT' E)MPEIRI/AN TW=N FU/SEI SUMBAINO/NTWN>20"2&10 etc. &10@Cicero de finibus IV 14. Cum enim superiores, e quibus pla-&10nissime Polemo, secundum naturam vivere summum bonum esse dixissent, &10his verbis tria significari <21Stoici>21 dicunt, unum eius modi "1<21vivere adhi-&10bentem scientiam earum rerum, quae natura evenirent>21"2%100 hunc &10ipsum Zenonis aiunt esse finem, declarantem illud, quod a te dictum est, &10"1convenienter naturae vivere"2; alterum significari idem, ut si diceretur &10"1officia media omnia aut pleraque servantem vivere."2 15. Hoc sic expo-&10situm dissimile est superiori. Illud enim rectum est [1quod$10 KATO/RQWMA&10 &10dicebas]1 contingitque sapienti soli, hoc autem inchoati cuiusdam officii est, &10non perfecti, quod cadere in nonnullos insipientes potest. Tertium autem, &10omnibus aut maximis rebus iis, quae secundum naturam sint, fruentem &10vivere. Hoc non est positum in nostra actione; completur enim et ex eo &10genere vitae, quod virtute fruitur, et ex iis rebus, quae sunt secundum &10naturam neque sunt in nostra potestate. Sed hoc summum bonum, quod &10tertia significatione intellegitur, eaque vita, quae ex summo bono degitur, &10quia coniuncta ei virtus est, in sapientem solum cadit, isque finis bono-&10rum, <21ut ab ipsis Stoicis scriptum videmus>21, a Xenocrate atque ab &10Aristotele constitutus est. &10@Cicero de fin. II 34. His omnibus, quos dixi, consequentes sunt &10fines bonorum, Aristippo simplex voluptas, <21Stoicis>21 consentire naturae, &10quod esse volunt"3 e virtute"3 id est honeste vivere; quod ita interpretan-&10tur%10 <21vivere cum intelligentia rerum earum, quae natura eveni-&10rent>21, eligentem ea, quae essent secundum naturam, reicientemque contraria. @1 &10`35. Ita tres sunt fines expertes honestatis__una simplex, cuius <21Zeno>21 &10auctor, posita in decore tota, id est in honestate. &10@Cicero de finibus III 9, 31. relinquitir ut summum bonum sit, &10<21vivere scientiam adhibentem earum rerum, quae natura eveni-&10ant>21, seligentem quae secundum naturam, et, quae contra naturam sint, &10reicientem, id est convenienter congruenterque naturae vivere. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 77, 16 W.$10 *TE/LOS DE/ FASIN EI)=NAI TO\ EU)DAIMONEI=N, OU(= E(/NEKA PA/NTA PRA/TTETAI, AU)TO\ DE\ PRA/TTETAI ME\N OU)DENO\S DE\ E(/NEKA: TOU=TO DE\ U(PA/RXEIN E)N TW=| KAT' A)RETH\N ZH=N, E)N TW=| O(MOLOGOUME/NWS ZH=N, E)/TI, TAU)TOU= O)/NTOS, E)N TW=| KATA\ FU/SIN ZH=N. *TH\N DE\ EU)DAIMONI/AN O( *ZH/NWN W(RI/SATO TO\N TRO/PON TOU=TON: EU)DAIMONI/A D' E)STI\N EU)/ROIA BI/OU. *KE/XRHTAI DE\ KAI\ *KLEA/NQHS TW=| O(/RW| TOU/TW| E)N TOI=S E(AUTOU= SUGGRA/MMASI <20KAI\ O( *XRU/SIPPOS>20 KAI\ OI( A)PO\ TOU/TWN PA/NTES, TH\N EU)DAIMONI/AN EI)=NAI LE/GONTES OU)X E(TE/RAN TOU= EU)DAI/MONOS BI/OU, KAI/TOI GE LE/GONTES TH\N ME\N EU)DAIMONI/AN SKOPO\N E)KKEI=SQAI, TE/LOS D' EI)=NAI TO\ TUXEI=N TH=S EU)DAIMONI/AS, O(/PER TAUTO\N EI)=NAI TW=| EU)DAIMONEI=N. @*DH=LON OU)=N E)K TOU/TWN, O(/TI I)SODUNAMEI= "3TO\ KATA\ FU/SIN ZH=N"3 KAI\ "3TO\ KA-LW=S ZH=N"3 KAI\ "3TO\ EU)= ZH=N"3 KAI\ PA/LIN "3TO\ KALO\N KA)GAQO/N"3 KAI\ "3H( A)RETH\ KAI\ TO\ ME/TOXON A)RETH=S"3: KAI\ O(/TI PA=N A)GAQO\N KALO/N, O(MOI/WS DE\ KAI\ PA=N AI)SXRO\N KAKO/N: DI' O(\ KAI\ TO\ *STWI+KO\N TE/LOS I)=SON DU/NASQAI TW=| KAT' A)RETH\N BI/W|. @&10Michae%28l in Eth. Nicom. [1Comm. graec. Vol. XX]1 ed. Heylb. p. 598, 20.$10 O(/TI KATA\ ME\N TA\S TW=N A)/LLWN FILOSO/FWN, *)EPIKOUREI/WN TE KAI\ TW=N U(/STERON <20*STWI+KW=N>20 PERI\ EU)DAIMONI/AS U(POLH/YEIS DU/NATAI/ TIS EU)DAIMONI/AN METADIDO/NAI KAI\ TOI=S A)LO/GOIS ZW/|OIS__DIA\ TOU/TWN A)/N TIS PARASTH/SEIEN. __EI) <20TO\ KATA\ FU/SIN DIA/GEIN KATA\ TOU\S *STWI+KOU\S EU)= ZH=N E)STI, TO\ DE\ EU)= ZH=N KAI\ KAT' AU)TOU\S>20 KAI\ KAT' *)EPI/KOURON <20EU)DAIMONEI=N E)STI>20, TO\ KATA\ FU/SIN A)/RA DIA/GEIN EU)DAIMONEI=N E)STIN. A)LLA\ MH\N U(PA/RXEI TOI=S A)LO/GOIS ZW/|OIS TO\ KATA\ FU/SIN DIA/GEIN A)PO\ GENE/SEWS ME/XRI TH=S A)KMH=S: EU)DAIMONEI=N E)/STI A)/RA TA\ A)/LOGA ZW=|A. @&10p. 599, 6.$10 PA/LIN EI) TO\ EU)DAIMONEI=N E)STI KATA\ TOU\S *STWI+KOU\S <20TO\ E)/SXA-TON TH=S FUSIKH=S O)RE/CEWS>20, E)F' O(\ E)LQOU=SA H( FU/SIS TO\ OU(= E(/NEKA KAI\ TO\ TE/LOS E)/XEI, OU(= TUXOU=SA PLE/ON OU)QE\N E)PIPOQEI= PLH\N TOU= KATE/XEIN AU)TO\ TO\ OI)-KEI=ON A)GAQO\N AU)TH=| KAI\ MH\ A)POLLU/NAI, TOU=TO DE\ U(PA/RXEI KAI\ TOI=S A)LO/GOIS, METE/XEI A)/RA KAI\ TA\ A)/LOGA ZW=|A EU)DAIMONI/AS. @&10Cicero de finibus III 22. Sed ex hoc primum error tollendus &10est, ne quis sequi existimet, ut duo sint ultima bonorum. Ut enim, si &10cui propositum sit conliniare hastam aliquo aut sagittam, sicut nos ulti-&10mum in bonis dicimus, sic illi facere omnia quae possit ut conliniet, huic &10in eiusmodi similitudine omnia sint facienda, ut conliniet, et tamen ut &10omnia faciat quo propositum assequatur sit hoc quasi ultimum quale nos &10summum in vita bonum dicimus, illud autem ut feriat quasi seligendum, &10non expetendum. &10@Alexander Aphrod. Quaest. II 16 p. 61, 1 Bruns.$10 *EI) TW=N STO-XASTIKW=N TEXNW=N TE/LOS EI)=NAI/ TIS LE/GOI TO\ PA/NTA TA\ PAR' AU)TA\S POIEI=N PRO\S TO\ TOU= PROKEIME/NOU TUGXA/NEIN, PW=S OU)X O(MOI/WS KAI\ AU(=TAI TOU= OI)KEI/OU TEU/- @1CONTAI TE/LOUS TAI=S OU) STOXASTIKAI=S TW=N TEXNW=N; DOKOU=SI DE\ KATA\ TOU=TO MA/-LISTA DIAFE/REIN TW=N A)/LLWN AI( STOXASTIKAI\ TW=| MH\ O(MOI/WS TOU= TE/LOUS TUGXA/-NEIN. KAQ' OU(\S ME\N [2GA\R]2 TE/LOS E)STI\N AU)TAI=S TO\ TUXEI=N TOU= PROKEIME/NOU, DIAFE/ROIEN A)\N TAU/TH|: KAQ' OU(\S DE\ TO\ PROEIRHME/NON E)STI\N AU)TAI=S TE/LOS, EI) KAI\ [TA\] TOU= TE/LOUS [MH\] O(MOI/WS TUGXA/NOUSI, DIAFE/ROIEN [2A)\N]2 AU)TW=N KATA\ TO\ MH\ O(/MOION AU)TAI=S TO\ TE/LOS E)/XEIN. E)KEI=NAI ME\N GA\R TW=| TOI=S KATA\ TH\N TE/XNHN GINOME/NOIS E(/PESQAI TO\ OU(= XA/RIN GI/NONTAI KAI\ TH\N A)POTUXI/AN AU)TAI=S TOU= PROKEIME/NOU KATA\ TH\N DIAMARTI/AN TW=N GINOME/NWN, OU) TEXNIKW=S GINOME/-NWN, E(/PESQAI, TE/LOS E)/XOUSI TO\ TUXEI=N TOU= PROKEIME/NOU [1I)/SON GA\R E)N E)KEI/NAIS TW=| PA/NTA TA\ PAR' AU)TA\S POIH=SAI PRO\S TO\ TUXEI=N TOU= PROKEIME/NOU TO\ KAI\ TUXEI=N AU)TOU=: TAU=TA GA\R POIOUSW=N TA\ PAR' AU)TA\S GI/GNETAI]1. E)PI\ DE\ TW=N STOXASTIKW=N TW=| MH\ PA/NTWS TOI=S GINOME/NOIS KATA\ TH\N TE/XNHN E(/PESQAI TO\ OU(= XA/RIN, DIA\ TO\ DEI=SQAI PRO\S TO\ TUXEI=N E)KEI/NOU POLLW=N, A(\ MH\ E)/STIN E)PI\ MO/NH| TH=| TE/XNH|, E)/TI DE\ KAI\ AU)TA\ TA\ KATA\ TH\N TE/XNHN GINO/MENA MH\ W(RI/SQAI MHDE\ TW=N AU)TW=N EI)=NAI POIHTIKA\ TW=| MH\ PA/NTH| O(MOI/WS E)/XOUSIN PROSFE/RESQAI, DIA\ [2TO\]2 PA/NTA H)\ DIA\ [2TO\]2 TINA\ KAI\ A)/LLWS E)N AU)TAI=S, OU)X W(S PROSEDOKA=TO, E(/PESQAI, OU) TO\ TUXEI=N TOU= PROKEIME/NOU TE/LOS E)STI/N, A)LLA\ TO\ A)POPLHRW=SAI TA\ TH=S TE/XNHS. @&Cicero de finib. IV 11, 28.&3 <21Chrysippus>21 autem exponens diffe-&3rentias animantium, ait alias eorum corpore excellere, alias autem animo, &3nonnullas valere utraque re%10 deinde disputat, quod cuiusque generis ani-&3mantium statui deceat extremum. Cum autem hominem in eo genere &3posuisset, ut ei tribueret animi excellentiam, summum bonum id consti-&3tuit, non ut excellere animo, sed ut nihil esse praeter animum videretur. @&Cicero Acad. Pr. II 45, 138.&3 Testatur saepe <21Chrysippus>21, tres &3solas esse sententias quae defendi possint de finibus bonorum. Circum-&3cidit et amputat multitudinem%10 aut enim honestatem esse finem aut vo-&3luptatem aut utrumque; nam qui summum bonum dicant id esse, si &3vacemus omni molestia, eos invidiosum nomen voluptatis fugere, sed in &3vicinitate versari%10 quod facere eos etiam, qui illud idem cum honestate &3coniungerent; nec multo secus eos qui ad honestatem prima naturae &3commoda adiungerent%10 ita tres relinquit sententias, quas putat probabi-&3liter posse defendi. @&ibid. 46, 140.&3 Unum igitur par, quod depugnet, reliquum est, vo-&3luptas cum honestate. De quo Chrysippo fuit, quantum ego sentio, non &3magna contentio. <21Alteram si sequare, multa ruunt et maxime @1 &3communitas cum hominum genere, caritas, amicitia, iustitia, &3reliquae virtutes>21; quarum esse nulla potest, nisi erit gratuita. Nam &3quae voluptate quasi mercede aliqua ad officium impellitur, ea non &3est virtus, sed fallax imitatio simulatioque virtutis. @&Cicero de finib. II 14, 44.&3 Ita ceterorum sententiis semotis re-&3linquitur, non mihi cum Torquato, sed virtuti cum voluptate certatio. &3Quam quidem certationem homo et acutus et diligens, <21Chrysippus>21 non &3contemnit; totumque discrimen summi boni in earum comparatione posi-&3tum putat. @&Plut. de Stoic. repugn. cp. 15 p. 1040c.$8 *PA/LIN <20E)N TOI=S PERI\ *DIKAIOSU/NHS>20 U(PEIPW\N O(/TI TOU\S A)GAQO\N A)LLA\ MH\ TE/LOS TIQEME/NOUS TH\N H(DONH\N E)NDE/XETAI SW/|ZEIN KAI\ TH\N DIKAIOSU/NHN, QEI\S TOU=TO KATA\ LE/CIN EI)/RHKE: "1<20*TA/XA GA\R A)GAQOU= AU)TH=S A)POLEIPOME/NHS, TE/LOUS DE\ MH/, TW=N DE\ DI' AU(TA\ AI(RETW=N O)/NTOS KAI\ TOU= KALOU=, SW/|ZOIMEN A)\N TH\N DIKAIOSU/NHN, MEI=ZON A)GAQO\N A)POLIPO/NTES TO\ KALO\N KAI\ TO\ DI/KAION TH=S H(DONH=S>20."2 @&10Plut. de comm. not. cp. 25 p. 1070d.$10 <20E)/N GE TOI=S PERI\ *DIKAIOSU/-NHS>20, EI) ME/N TIS U(PO/QOITO TH\N H(DONH\N TE/LOS, OU)K OI)/ETAI SW/|ZESQAI TO\ DI/-KAION: EI) DE\ MH\ TE/LOS A)LLA\ A(PLW=S A)GAQO/N, OI)/ETAI: TA\S DE\ LE/CEIS OU)K OI)/OMAI/ SE DEI=SQAI NU=N A)KOU/EIN E)MOU= KATALE/GONTOS: <20TO\ GA\R TRI/TON PERI\ *DIKAIO-SU/NHS BIBLI/ON>20 E)STI\ PANTAXO/QEN LABEI=N. @&Plut. de Stoic. repugn. cp. 15 p. 1040e.$8 *(/INA DE\ MHD' A)POLO-GI/AN U(POLI/PH| TOI=S E)NANTIW/MASIN, <20*)ARISTOTE/LEI PERI\ DIKAIOSU/NHS A)NTIGRA/FWN>20 "1OU)/ FHSIN AU)TO\N O)RQW=S LE/GEIN, O(/TI TH=S H(DONH=S TE/LOUS OU)/SHS A)NAIREI=TAI ME\N H( DIKAIOSU/NH, SUNANAIREI=TAI DE\ TH=| DIKAIOSU/NH| KAI\ TW=N A)/LLWN A)RETW=N E(KA/STH: TH\N ME\N GA\R DIKAIOSU/NHN U(P' AU)TW=N W(S A)LH-QW=S A)NAIREI=SQAI, TA\S D' A)/LLAS A)RETA\S OU)DE\N KWLU/EIN U(PA/RXEIN, EI) KAI\ MH\ DI' AU(TA\S AI(RETA/S, A)LL' A)GAQA\S GOU=N KAI\ A)RETA\S E)SOME/NAS"2 EI)=TA E(KA/STHN E)C O)NO/MATOS PROSAGOREU/EI. *BE/LTION DE\ TA\S E)KEI/NOU LE/CEIS A)NALABEI=N: "1<20*TH=S GA\R H(DONH=S>20, FHSI/N, <20E)MFAINOME/NHS TE/LOUS KATA\ TO\N TOIOU=-TON LO/GON, TO\ ME\N TOIOU=TO PA=N MOI DOKEI= OU)K E)MPERILAMBA/-NESQAI: DIO\ R(HTE/ON, MH/TE TW=N A)RETW=N TINA DI' AU(TH\N AI(RETH\N EI)=NAI, MH/TE TW=N KAKIW=N FEUKTH/N, A)LLA\ PA/NTA TAU=TA DEI=N A)NA-FE/RESQAI PRO\S TO\N U(POKEI/MENON SKOPO/N: OU)DE\N ME/NTOI KWLU/SEI KAT' AU)TOU/S, TH\N A)NDREI/AN ME\N KAI\ TH\N FRO/NHSIN KAI\ TH\N E)GKRA/-TEIAN KAI\ TH\N KARTERI/AN KAI\ TA\S O(MOI/AS TAU/TAIS A)RETA\S EI)=NAI TW=N A)GAQW=N, TA\S D' E)NANTI/AS [2KAKI/AS]2 U(PA/RXEIN FEUKTA/S>20."2 @&Plut. de comm. not. cp. 25 p. 107d.$ *KAI\ MH\N O(/TI DUOI=N @1 A)GAQW=N, TOU= ME\N TE/LOUS, TOU= DE\ PRO\S TO\ TE/LOS, MEI=ZO/N E)STI TO\ TE/LOS KAI\ TELEIO/TERON, U(P' OU)DENO\S A)GNOEI=TAI. *GINW/SKEI DE\ KAI\ *XRU/SIPPOS TH\N DIAFORA/N, W(S DH=LO/N E)STIN <20E)N TW=| TRI/TW| PERI\ *)AGAQW=N>20: TOI=S GA\R TE/LOS H(GOUME/NOIS TH\N E)PISTH/MHN A)NOMOLOGEI=. @&Plut. de comm. not. cp. 27 p. 107if.$ *(ORA=|S GA\R O(/TI KAI\ <20*XRU/-SIPPOS>20 EI)S TAU/THN [MA=LLON] <20SUNELAU/NEI TO\N *)ARI/STWNA TH\N>20 A)PO-RI/AN, W(S TW=N PRAGMA/TWN [2OU) DIDO/NTWN]2 TH\N PRO\S TO\ MH/T' A)GAQO\N MH/TE KAKO\N A)DIAFORI/AN E)PINOH=SAI, TOU= A)GAQOU= KAI\ TOU= KAKOU= MH\ PROEPINOHQE/NTWN: OU(/TW GA\R AU(TH=S FANEI=SQAI TH\N A)DIAFORI/AN PROU+-FISTAME/NHN, EI) NO/HSIN ME\N AU)TH=S OU)K E)/STI LABEI=N, MH\ PRO/TERON TOU= A)GAQOU= NOHQE/NTOS, A)/LLO D' OU)DE\N A)LL' AU)TH\ MO/NON TO\ A)GAQO/N E)STIN. @&Cicero de finibus IV 25, 68.&3 Cum enim, quod honestum sit, &3id solum bonum esse confirmatur, tollitur cura valetudinis, diligentia rei &3familiaris, administratio rei publicae, ordo gerendorum negotiorum, officia &3vitae%10 ipsum denique illud honestum, in quo uno vultis esse omnia, &3deserendum est. Quae diligentissime contra <21Aristonem>21 dicuntur a &3<21Chrysippo.>21 @&10Galenus de animi peccatis dignoscendis 4 Vol. V p. 77 K.$10 A)RXH\ ME\N OU)=N E)STI POLLW=N A(MARTHMA/TWN H( PERI\ TE/LOUS E(KA/STOU BI/OU U(PO/LHYIS YEUDH/S: FU/ETAI GA\R W(/SPER E)K R(I/ZHS TINO\S TAU/THS TA\ KATA\ ME/ROS A(MARTH/-MATA. DU/NATAI DE/ TIS, E)N TH=| PERI\ TE/LOUS DO/CH| MH\ SFALEI/S, E)/N TINI TW=N KATA\ ME/ROS SFALH=NAI, MH\ SUNIEI\S TH=S A)KOLOUQI/AS. @&Plut. de Stoic. repugn. c. 13 p. 1039c.$8 *KAI\ MH\N <20E)N TW=| PERI\ *KALOU=>20 PRO\S A)PO/DEICIN TOU= MO/NON TO\ KALO\N A)GAQO\N EI)=NAI, TOIOU/TOIS LO/-GOIS KE/XRHTAI: "1<20*TO\ A)GAQO\N AI(RETO/N: TO\ D' AI(RETO\N A)RESTO/N: TO\ D' A)RESTO\N E)PAINETO/N: TO\ D' E)PAINETO\N KALO/N>20."2 *KAI\ PA/LIN "1<20*TO\ A)GAQO\N XARTO/N, TO\ DE\ XARTO\N SEMNO/N, TO\ DE\ SEMNO\N KALO/N>20."2 @&Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 101.$ <20LE/GOUSI DE\ MO/NON TO\ KALO\N A)GA-QO\N EI)=NAI>20, KAQA/ FHSIN *(EKA/TWN E)N TW=| TRI/TW| PERI\ A)GAQW=N, KAI\ <20*XRU/-SIPPOS E)N TOI=S PERI\ TOU= *KALOU=>20. EI)=NAI DE\ TOU=TO A)RETH\N KAI\ TO\ METE/XON A)RETH=S: W(=| E)STIN I)/SON TO\ PA=N A)GAQO\N KALO\N EI)=NAI KAI\ TO\ I)SO-DUNAMEI=N TW=| KALW=| TO\ A)GAQO/N: O(/PER I)/SON E)STI\ TOU/TW|. E)PEI\ GA/R E)STIN A)GAQO\N KALO/N E)STIN: E)/STI DE\ KALO/N: A)GAQO\N A)/RA E)STI/. @&10Philo de posteritate Caini %14 133 Vol. II p. 29, 7 Wendl. memo-&10rat%10$10 TO\ *STWI+KO\N DO/GMA <20TO\ MO/NON EI)=NAI TO\ KALO\N A)GAQO/N>20. @&10Alexander Aphrod. Quaest. I 14 p. 26 Bruns.$10 O(/TI DE\ MHDE\N PARA\ @1 QEW=N A)GAQO\N TOI=S A)NQRW/POIS KATA\ TOU\S PROEIRHME/NOUS [1&10scil.$10 KAQ' OU(\S MO/NON TO\ KALO\N A)GAQO/N E)STIN &10i. e. Stoicos$10]1 GI/NETAI, DH=LON E)NTEU=QEN. TO\ KALO\N E)F' H(MI=N: O(\ E)F' H(MI=N E)STI, TOU=TO DI' E(AUTW=N KTW/MEQA: O(\ DI' E(AUTW=N KTW/MEQA, TOU=Q' U(P' OU)DENO\S A)/LLOU PERIGI/NETAI: TO\ KALO\N A)/RA U(P' OU)DENO\S A)/LLOU H(MI=N PERIGI/NETAI: EI) U(PO\ MHDENO\S OU)D' U(PO\ TW=N QEW=N. A)LLA\ MH\N <20TAU)TO\N A)GA-QO/N TE KAI\ KALO/N, KAQ' OU(\S MO/NON TO\ KALO\N A)GAQO/N>20: OU)DE\N [2A)/RA]2 A)GAQO\N TOI=S A)NQRW/POIS U(PO\ TW=N QEW=N PERIGI/NETAI. @&10Philo Quod deterius potiori insidiari soleat %14 7 Vol. I p. 259, 25 &10Wendl. [1de Iosepho]1%10$10 PRO\S GA\R POLITEI/AN MA=LLON H)\ PRO\S A)LH/QEIAN FILOSO-FW=N TA\ TRI/A GE/NH TW=N A)GAQW=N TA/ TE E)KTO\S KAI\ PERI\ SW=MA KAI\ YUXH/N, O(/LAIS FU/SESIN A)LLH/LWN DIHRTHME/NA, EI)S TO\ AU)TO\ A)/GEI KAI\ SUNEI/REI, XREI=ON E(/KASTON E(KA/STOU KAI\ PA/NTA PA/NTWN A)POFAI/NEIN A)CIW=N KAI\ TO\ E)C A)QRO/WN SUNTEQE\N A)/RTION KAI\ PLH=RES O)/NTWS A)GAQO/N, TA\ D' E)C W(=N TOU=TO E)PA/GH, ME/RH ME\N H)\ STOI-XEI=A A)GAQW=N, A)GAQA\ D' OU)K EI)=NAI TE/LEIA. *KAQA/PER GA\R MH/TE PU=R MH/TE GH=N MH/TE TI TW=N TETTA/RWN, E)C W(=N E)DHMIOURGH/QH TO\ PA=N, KO/SMON EI)=NAI, TH\N DE\ TW=N STOIXEI/WN EI)S TAU)TO\ SU/NODO/N TE KAI\ KRA=SIN, TO\N AU)TO\N TRO/PON KAI\ TO\ EU)/DAIMON MH/TE E)N TOI=S E)KTO\S I)DI/A| MH/TE E)N TOI=S PERI\ SW=MA MH/TE E)N TOI=S PERI\ YUXH\N KAQ' AU(TA\ E)CETA/ZESQAI_TW=N GA\R EI)RHME/NWN E(/KASTON MERW=N TINA KAI\ STOIXEI/WN LO/GON E)/XEIN_A)LLA\ KATA\ TO\ E)K PA/NTWN A)/QROISMA. *TAU/-THN OU)=N TH\N DO/CAN PE/MPETAI METADIDAXQHSO/MENOS PRO\S A)/NDRAS <20MO/NON TO\ KALO\N A)GAQO\N NOMI/ZONTAS O(\ YUXH=S W(S YUXH=S E)STIN I)/DION>20. TA\ D' E)KTO\S KAI\ PERI\ SW=MA LEGO/MENA PLEONEKTH/MATA MO/NON, OU) PRO\S A)LH/QEIAN O)/NTA A)GAQA\ PEPISTEUKO/TAS. @&10Cicero de finibus III 28 [1argumenta explicans placiti$10 O(/TI MO/NON TO\ KALO\N A)GAQO/N]1.&10 Deinde quaero, quis aut de misera vita possit gloriari &10aut de non beata. De sola igitur beata. Ex quo efficitur gloriatione__ &10dignam esse beatam vitam, quod non possit nisi honestae vitae iure con-&10tingere. Ita fit, ut honesta vita beata vita sit. Et quoniam is, cui con-&10tingit ut iure laudetur, habet insigne quiddam ad decus et ad gloriam, &10ut ob ea, quae tanta sint, beatus dici iure possit, idem de vita talis viri &10rectissime dicetur. Ita, si beata vita honestate cernitur, <21quod honestum &10est, id bonum solum habendum est>21. &10@Cicero de finibus III 29. Quid vero? negarine ullo modo possit, &10[2nunquam]2 quemquam stabili et firmo et magno animo, quem fortem vi-&10rum dicimus, effici posse, nisi constitutum sit, non esse malum dolorem? &10Ut enim, qui mortem in malis ponit, non potest eam non timere, sic &10nemo ulla in re potest id, quod malum esse decreverit, non curare idque &10contemnere. Quo posito__illud assumitur, eum qui magno sit animo &10ac forti, omnia quae cadere in hominem possint despicere ac pro nihilo &10putare. Quae cum ita sunt, effectum est <21nihil esse malum, quod &10turpe non sit>21. &10@Cicero de finibus III 29. Atque iste vir altus et excellens, magno &10animo, vere fortis, infra se omnia humana ducens__certe et confidere @1 &10sibi debet ac suae vitae et actae et consequenti et bene de sese iudicare &10statuens nihil posse mali incidere sapienti. Ex quo intelligitur idem illud, &10<21solum bonum esse, quod honestum sit>21; idque esse beate vivere%10 ho-&10neste, id est cum virtute, vivere. &10@Cicero de finibus III 8, 27. Quod est bonum, omne laudabile &10est; quod autem laudabile est, omne est honestum%10 bonum igitur quod &10est, honestum est. __Illud autem perabsurdum, bonum esse aliquid, &10quod non expetendum sit, aut expetendum, quod non placens%10 aut, si id, &10non etiam diligendum%10 ergo etiam probandum. ita etiam laudabile%10 id &10autem honestum. Ita fit ut <21quod bonum sit, id etiam honestum sit>21. &10@Tusc. disp. V 43. Atque etiam omne bonum laetabile est; quod &10autem laetabile, id praedicandum et prae se ferendum; quod tale autem, &10id etiam gloriosum; si vero gloriosum, certe laudabile; quod laudabile &10autem, profecto etiam honestum; quod bonum igitur, id honestum. &10@`45 Quicquid est, quod bonum sit, id expetendum est, quod autem &10expetendum, id certe adprobandum; quod vero adprobaris, id gratum ac-&10ceptumque habendum; ergo etiam dignitas ei tribuenda est. Quod si ita &10est, laudabile sit necesse est; bonum igitur omne laudabile. Ex quo effi-&10citur ut quod sit honestum, id sit solum bonum. &10@Sextus adv. math. XI 99.$10 *NAI/, A)LLA\ KAI\ <20OI( MO/NON TO\ KALO\N A)GAQO\N DOCA/ZONTES>20 DEI/KNUSQAI NOMI/ZOUSIN <20O(/TI FU/SEI TOU=TO AI(RETO/N>20 E)STI KAI\ A)PO\ TW=N A)LO/GWN ZW/|WN. *(ORW=MEN GA/R, FASI/N, W(/S TINA GENNAI=A ZW=|A, KAQA/PER TAU=ROS KAI\ A)LEKTRUO/NES, [A(/PER] MHDEMIA=S AU)TOI=S U(POKEIME/NHS TE/R-YEWS KAI\ H(DONH=S DIAGWNI/ZETAI ME/XRI QANA/TOU. *KAI\ TW=N A)NQRW/PWN DE\ OI( U(PE\R PATRI/DOS H)\ GONE/WN H)\ TE/KNWN EI)S A)NAI/RESIN E(AUTOU\S E)PIDIDO/NTES OU)K A)/N POTE TOU=T' E)POI/OUN, MHDEMIA=S AU)TOI=S E)LPIZOME/NHS META\ QA/NATON H(DONH=S, <20EI) MH\ FUSIKW=S TO\ KALO\N KAI\ A)GAQO\N TOU/TOUS TE KAI\ PA=N TO\ GEN-NAI=ON A)EI\ ZW=|ON E)PESPA=TO PRO\S TH\N AU(TOU= AI(/RESIN>20. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 89.$10 TH/N TE A)RETH\N DIA/QESIN EI)=NAI O(MOLOGOUME/NHN: KAI\ <20AU)TH\N DI' AU(TH\N EI)=NAI AI(RETH/N>20, OU) DIA/ TINA FO/BON H)\ E)LPI/DA H)/ TI TW=N E)/CWQEN: E)N AU)TH=| TE EI)=NAI TH\N EU)DAIMONI/AN, A(/TE OU)/SH| YUXH=| PEPOIHME/NH| PRO\S TH\N O(MOLOGI/AN PANTO\S TOU= BI/OU. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 127.$10 KAI\ <20AU)TH\N DI' [2AU(TH\N]2 AI(RETH\N EI)=NAI>20 [1&10scil.$10 <20TH\N A)RETH/N]1>20: AI)SXUNO/MEQA GOU=N E)F' OI(=S KAKW=S PRA/TTOMEN, W(S A)\N MO/-NON TO\ KALO\N EI)DO/TES A)GAQO/N. @1 @&10Cicero de finibus III 36. Omne autem <21quod honestum sit, &10id esse propter se expetendum>21_haec est tuenda sententia maxime &10_Stoicis. 38. et eodem modo <21turpia per se esse fugienda>21. 39. Stul-&10titiam autem et timiditatem et iniustitiam et intemperantiam cum dicimus &10esse fugienda propter eas res, quae ex ipsis eveniant, non ita dicimus, ut &10cum illo, quod positum est, solum id esse malum quod turpe sit, haec &10pugnare videatur oratio, propterea quod ea non ad corporis incommodum &10referuntur, sed ad turpes actiones, quae oriuntur e vitiis. Quas enim$10 KA-KI/AS&10 Graeci appellant, vitia malo quam malitias nominare. &10@Cicero de legibus I 14, 40. Quodsi homines ab iniuria poena, &10non natura arcere deberet, quaenam sollicitudo vexaret impios, sublato sup-&10pliciorum metu? quorum tamen nemo tam audax unquam fuit, quin aut &10abnueret a se commissum esse facinus, aut iusti sui doloris causam ali-&10quam fingeret, defensionemque facinoris a naturae iure aliquo quaereret. &10Quae si appellare audent impii, quo tandem studio colentur a bonis? _ &10Quodsi poena, si metus supplicii, non ipsa turpitudo deterret ab iniuriosa &10facinorosaque vita, nemo est iniustus, atque incauti potius habendi sunt &10improbi. 41. Tum autem qui non ipso honesto movemur, ut boni viri &10simus, sed utilitate aliqua atque fructu, callidi sumus, non boni. Nam &10quid faciet is homo in tenebris, qui nihil timet nisi testem et iudicem? &10quid in deserto quo loco nactus, quem multo auro spoliare possit, imbe-&10cillum atque solum? Noster quidem hic natura iustus vir ac bonus etiam &10colloquetur, iuvabit, in viam deducet%10 is vero qui nihil alterius causa &10faciet, metietur suis commodis omnia, videtis credo quid sit acturus. Quodsi &10negabit, se illi vitam erepturum et aurum ablaturum, nunquam ob eam &10causam negabit, quod id natura turpe iudicet, sed quod metuat, ne ema-&10net, id est ne malum habeat. &10@Cicero de legibus I 18, 48. Sequitur__et <21ius et omne ho-&10nestum sua sponte esse expetendum>21. Etenim omnes viri boni ipsam &10aequitatem et ius ipsum amant, nec est viri boni errare et diligere, quod &10per se non sit diligendum. Per se igitur ius et expetendum et colendum. &10Quod si ius, etiam iustitia%10 si iustitia, reliquae quoque virtutes per se &10colendae sunt. Quid? liberalitas gratuitane est an mercenaria? Si sine &10praemio benignus est, gratuita%10 si cum mercede, conducta%10 nec est dubium, &10quin is, qui liberalis benignusve dicitur, officium, non fructum sequatur. &10Ergo item iustitia nihil expetit praemii, nihil pretii. Per se igitur ex-&10petitur. __49. ubi illa sancta amicitia, si non ipse amicus per se &10amatur toto pectore, ut dicitur? __Quodsi amicitia per se colenda &10est, societas quoque hominum et aequalitas et iustitia per se [2est]2 ex-&10petenda. &10@Cicero de finibus V 2o [1Antiochus Carneadeam$10 TW=N TELW=N &10divi-&10sionem enarrans]1. At vero facere omnia, ut adipiscamur, quae secundum &10naturam sunt, etiamsi ea non assequamur, <21id esse et honestum et so-&10lum per se expetendum>21 et solum bonum <21Stoici>21 dicunt. @1 @&10Servius ad Aeneid I 604. Et mens sibi conscia recti%10 secundum &10<21Stoicos>21, qui dicunt, <21ipsam virtutem esse pro praemio, etiamsi &10nulla sint praemia>21. &10@Clem. Al. Strom. IV 8 p. 594 Pott.$10 EI) DH\ TW=N A)DIAFO/RWN E)/NIA TOIAU/THN EI)/LHXE TIMH/N, W(/STE KAI\ A)KO/NTWN TINW=N AI(RETA\ EI)=NAI DOKEI=N, POLU\ DE\ PLE/ON TH\N A)RETH\N PERIMA/XHTON NOMISTE/ON: MH\ EI)S A)/LLO TI A)FORW=NTAS, A)LLA\ EI)S AU)TO\ TO\ KALW=S PRAXQH=NAI DUNA/MENON, E)A/N TE E(TE/ROIS DOKH=| TISIN E)A/N TE MH/. @&10Lactant. instit. div. III 12. Sed et <21Stoici>21__negant sine &10virtute effici quemquam beatum posse. Ergo virtutis praemium beata vita &10est, si virtus, ut recte dictum est, beatam vitam facit. Non <21est>21 igitur, &10<21ut aiunt, propter se ipsam virtus expetenda etc>21. &10@Lactant. div. instit. V 17. Nam et <21cum de virtute disputant>21, &10quamvis intellegant aerumnis ac miseriis esse plenissimam, tamen <21expe-&10tendam esse aiunt sua causa>21. @&Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 127.$ <20AU)TA/RKH TE EI)=NAI AU)TH\N>20 [1&scil.$ <20TH\N A)RETH\N]1 PRO\S EU)DAIMONI/AN>20, KAQA/ FHSI *ZH/NWN KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS E)N TW=| PRW/TW| PERI\ *)ARETW=N>20 KAI\ *(EKA/TWN E)N TW=| DEUTE/RW| PERI\ A)GA-QW=N. *EI) GA/R, FHSI/N, AU)TA/RKHS E)STI\N H( MEGALOYUXI/A PRO\S TO\ PA/NTWN U(PERA/NW POIEI=N, E)/STI DE\ ME/ROS A)RETH=S, AU)TA/RKHS E)STI\ KAI\ H( A)RETH\ PRO\S EU)DAIMONI/AN, KATAFRONOU=SA KAI\ TW=N DOKOU/NTWN O)XLHRW=N. @&10Porphyrio ad Hor. carm. III 2, 17. Haec de <21stoicorum>21 secta &10sunt, qui dicunt <21virtutem solam sufficere ad vitam beatam>21. &10@Cicero de fin. I 61. Muttoque hoc melius nos [1i. e. Epicurei]1 &10veriusque quam <21Stoici>21. Illi enim negant esse bonum quicquam nisi nescio &10quam illam umbram, quod appellant honestum non tam solido quam splen-&10dido nomine; virtutem autem nixam hoc honesto <21nullam requirere vo-&10luptatem atque ad beate vivendum se ipsa esse contentam>21. &10@Proclus in Platonis Timaeum p. 61 B. Schn.$10 OU)X W(/SPER <20OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 TO\N SPOUDAI=ON OU)DE/N FASI DEI=SQAI TH=S TU/XHS OU(/TW KAI\ O( *PLA/TWN. @&Plut. de Stoic. repugn. cp. 26 p. 1046d.$ EI) ME\N OU)=N TH\N FRO/NHSIN H(GEI=TO [1&scil. Chrysippus$]1 POIHTIKO\N EI)=NAI TH=S EU)DAIMONI/AS A)GAQO/N, W(/SPER O( *)EPI/KOUROS &non ipse sibi repugnaret,$ E)PEI\ D' H( <20FRO/-NHSIS OU)X E(/TERO/N E)STI TH=S EU)DAIMONI/AS KAT' AU)TO\N A)LL' EU)-DAIMONI/A>20 &etc. &@Plut. de comm. not. 8 p. 1061f.$ *OU) MO/NON OU)=N TAU=TA LE/- @1GOUSIN OI( A)/NDRES, A)LLA\ KA)KEI=NA PRO\S TOU/TOIS, O(/TI "1A)GAQO\N O( XRO/NOS OU)K AU)/CEI PROSGINO/MENOS, A)LLA\ KA)\N A)KARE/S TIS W(/RAS GE/NHTAI FRO/NI-MOS, OU)DENI\ PRO\S EU)DAIMONI/AN A)POLEIFQH/SETAI TOU= TO\N AI)W=NA XRWME/-NOU TH=| A)RETH=| KAI\ MAKARI/WS E)N AU)TH=| KATABIOU=NTOS."2 @&Plut. de Stoic. repugn. cp. 26 p. 1046c.$ *)EN POLLOI=S EI)RHKW\S [1&sc. &Chrysippus$]1 O(/TI PARA\ TO\N PLEI/ONA XRO/NON OU)DE\N MA=LLON EU)DAIMONOU=SIN, A)LL' O(MOI/WS KAI\ E)PI/SHS TOI=S TO\N A)MERH= XRO/NON EU)DAIMONI/AS METASXOU=SIN. @&Stobaeus Eclog. II 98, 17 W.$ *DI' O(\ KAI\ PA/NTWS EU)DAIMONEI=N A)EI\ TW=N A)NQRW/PWN TOU\S A)GAQOU/S, TOU\S DE\ FAU/LOUS KAKODAIMONEI=N. KAI\ [2E)KEI/NWN]2 TH\N EU)DAIMONI/AN MH\ DIAFE/REIN TH=S QEI/AS EU)DAIMONI/AS, MHDE\ TH\N A)MERIAI/AN O( <20*XRU/SIPPO/S>20 FHSI DIAFE/REIN TH=S TOU= *DIO\S EU)DAIMO-NI/AS, [2KAI\]2 KATA\ MHDE\N AI(RETWTE/RAN EI)=NAI MH/TE KALLI/W MH/TE SEMNO-TE/RAN TH\N TOU= *DIO\S EU)DAIMONI/AN TH=S TW=N SOFW=N. A)NDRW=N. @&Themistius Orat. VIII p. 101d.$ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 DE\ A)/XRI TW=N R(HMA/-TWN E)/OIKEN A)NDRI/ZESQAI, TAU)TO\N DU/NASQAI FA/SKWN A)NDRI\ SPOUDAI/W| MI/AN H(ME/RAN, MA=LLON DE\ KAI\ MI/AN W(/RAN POLLOI=S E)NIAUTOI=S. @&Plut. de Stoic. repugn. cp. 18 p. 1042a.$ *OU)SI/AN KAKODAIMO-NI/AS A)POFAI/NEI TH\N KAKI/AN [1&sc. Chrysippus$]1 <20E)N PANTI\ BIBLI/W| FU-SIKW=| KAI\ H)QIKW=|>20 GRA/FWN KAI\ DIATEINO/MENOS O(/TI TO\ KATA\ KAKI/AN ZH=N TW=| KAKODAIMO/NWS ZH=N TAU)TO/N E)STIN. @&10Gellius Noct. Att. XVIII 1, 4. Atqui ibi <21Stoicus>21 censebat, et &10<21vitam beatam homini virtute animi sola et miseriam summam &10malitia sola posse effici>21 etiamsi cetera bona omnia, quae corporalia &10et externa appellarentur, virtuti deessent, malitiae adessent [1sequitur Peri-&10patetici responsum]1. 6. Reclamabat hoc in loco Stoicus et, tamquam &10duas ille res diversas poneret, mirabatur; quod, cum essent malitia et &10virtus duo contraria, vita misera et beata quoque aeque contraria, non &10servaret in utrisque vim et naturam contrarii et ad miseriam quidem &10vitae conficiendam satis valere malitiam solam putaret, ad praestandam &10vero beatam vitam non satis solam esse virtutem diceret. Atque id ma-&10xime dissidere neque convenire dicebat, quod qui profiteretur, vitam nullo &10pacto beatam effici posse, si virtus sola abesset, idem contra negaret, be-&10atam fieri vitam, cum sola virtus adesset, et quem daret haberetque vir-&10tuti absenti honorem, eundem petenti atque praesenti adimeret. @&Alexander de anima libri mantissa p. 166, 21 Brnns.$8 E)/TI OU)K, "1EI) W(=| O(RW=MEN, TH=| TOU/TOU A)RETH=| EU)= O(RW=MEN, KAI\ W(=| A)KOU/OMEN, TH=| TOU/TOU A)RETH=| EU)= A)KOU/OMEN, KAI\ DIA\ TOU=TO, W(=| ZW=MEN, TH=| TOU/TOU A)RETH=| EU)= ZW=MEN, W(/STE EI)/H A)\N [2H(]2 TH=S YUXH=S A)RETH\ EU)-DAIMONI/A: YUXH=| GA\R ZW=MEN."2 OU) DH\ DIA\ TOU=TO &etc. @&10Seneca ep. 85, 2. Qui prudens est, et temperans est tempe-&10rans, est et constans. qui constans est, imperturbatus est. qui impertur- @1&10batus est, sine tristitia est. qui sine tristitia est, beatus est%10 ergo pru-&10dens beatus est et prudentia ad beatam vitam satis est. &10@ibid. 24. Qui fortis est, sine timore est. qui sine timore est, sine &10tristitia est. qui sine tristitia est, beatus est. &10@Cicero Tusc. disp. V 48. iam vero qui potest vir bonus non ad &10id, quod laudabile sit, omnia referre, quae agit quaeque sentit? Refert &10autem omnia ad beate vivendum. Beata igitur vita laudabilis. Nec quic-&10quam sine virtute laudabile. <21Beata igitur vita virtute conficitur>21. &10@`49. Atque hoc sic etiam concluditur%10 Nec in misera vita quicquam &10est praedicabile aut gloriandum nec in ea, quae nec misera sit nec beata. &10Et est in aliqua vita praedicabile aliquid et gloriandum ac prae se feren-&10dum. __50. Quod si [2est]2, beata vita glorianda et praedicanda et &10prae se ferenda est; nihil est enim aliud, quod praedicandum et prae se &10ferendum sit. Quibus positis intellegis, quid sequatur. &10@Et quidem, nisi ea vita beata est, quae est eadem honesta, sit aliud &10necesse est melius vita beata; quod erit enim honestum, certe fatebuntur &10esse melius. Ita erit vita beata melius aliquid; quo quid potest dici per-&10versius? &10@Cicero de finibus III 43. Ne illud quidem est consentaneum__ &10ut qui plura habent ea, quae in corpore magni aestimantur, sit beatior. &10_Nam cum ita placeat, <21ne eorum quidem bonorum, quae nos &10bona vere appellemus, frequentia beatiorem vitam fieri aut &10magis expetendam aut pluris aestimandam>21, certe minus ad beatam &10vitam pertinet multitudo corporis commodorum. 44. Etenim si et sapere &10expetendum sit et valere, coniunctum utrumque magis expetendum sit &10quam sapere solum, neque tamen, si utrumque sit aestimatione dignum, &10pluris sit coniunctum quam sapere ipsum separatim. Nam qui valetu-&10dinem aestimatione aliqua dignam iudicamus neque eam tamen in bonis &10ponimus, iidem censemus nullam esse tantam aestimationem, ut ea vir-&10tuti anteponatur. __45. Ut enim obscuratur et offunditur luce solis &10lumen lucernae, et ut interit [2in]2 magnitudine maris Aegaei stilla mellis, &10et ut in divitiis Croesi teruncii accessio et gradus unus in ea via, quae &10est hinc in Indiam, sic cum sit is bonorum finis, quem Stoici dicunt, &10omnis ista rerum corporearum aestimatio splendore virtutis et magnitu-&10dine obscuretur et obruatur atque intereat necesse est. &10@Cicero de finibus IV 30 [1Antiochus contra Stoicos pugnans]1 ut &10mihi in hoc <21Stoici>21 iocari videantur interdum, cum ita dicant "1<21si ad &10illam vitam, quae cum virtute degatur, ampulla aut strigilis &10accedat, sumpturum sapientem eam vitam potius, quo haec &10adiecta sint, nec beatiorem tamen ob eam causam fore>21."2 &10@Alexander in Aristot. Topica p. 211, 9.$10 OU(/TWS DEIKNU/OIT' A)\N E(/KA-STON TW=N LEGOME/NWN A)DIAFO/RWN TE KAI\ PROHGME/NWN <20U(PO\ TW=N NEWTE/RWN>20 AI(RETO/N TE KAI\ A)GAQO/N: E(/KASTON GA\R AU)TW=N PROSTIQE/MENON TH=| A)RETH=| TO\ O(/LON AI(RETW/TERON TW=| SPOUDAI/W| POIEI=. AI(RETW/TEROS GA\R BI/OS O( KAT' A)RETH/N, EI) MEQ' U(GEI/AS EI)/H KAI\ EI) META\ EU)PORI/AS KAI\ EI) META\ A)GAQH=S DO/CHS: TA\ GA\R AI(RETA\ KAI\ FEUKTA\ KRI/NETAI TH=| TOU= SPOUDAI/OU AI(RE/SEI TE KAI\ FUGH=|. @1 @&10Alexander Aphrod. de anima libri mant. p. 161, 26 Bruns.$10 AI( DE\ AI)SQH/SEIS KAI\ AU)TAI/, EI) ME\N PRO\S TO\ EI)=NAI TO\N A)/NQRWPON A)NAGKAI/OU XW/RAN E)/XOUSIN, MHKE/TI DE\ SUNERGOU=SIN PRO\S TA\S E)NERGEI/AS TH=S A)RETH=S, <20TO\N W(=N OU)K A)/NEU LO/GON E)/XOIEN A)/N>20. EI) DE\ PRO\S TW=| A)NAGKAI=AI EI)=NAI TW=| A)NQRW/PW| KAI\ SUNERGOU=SIN PRO\S TA\S PRA/CEIS KAI\ <20PROSXRH=TAI AU)TAI=S H( A)RETH\ PRO\S TA\S I)DI/AS E)NERGEI/AS>20 [1H( GA\R FANTASI/A KRHPI\S TW=N KAT' A)RETH\N PRA/CEWN]1 OU)K E)/XOUSIN TO\N W(=N OU)K A)/NEU LO/GON PRO\S TA\S KAT' AU)TH\N E)NERGEI/AS, W(S E)/XEI O( OU)RANO\S KAI\ H( GH= KAI\ O( TO/POS KAI\ O( XRO/NOS. EI) GA\R <20E)NERGH/SOMEN KATA\ A)RETH\N O(PWSOU=N E)XOUSW=N TW=N AI)SQH/SEWN>20, H)/TOI KAI\ TAI=S YEUDE/SIN FANTASI/AIS TAI=S A)PO\ TW=N TOIOU/TWN AI)SQH/SEWN SUGKATAQHSO/MEQA KAI\ TAU/TAIS A)KO/LOUQA PRA/COMEN [1KAI\ PW=S SPOUDAI/OU TOU=TO;]1 H)\ EI) E)FE/COMEN KAI\ MH\ SUG-KATAQHSO/MEQA, OU)DE\ PRA/COME/N TI TW=N E)P' AU)TAI=S, W(/ST' OU)DE\N E)NERGH/SOMEN. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de anima libri mant. p. 160, 3 Bruns.$10 H( A)RETH\ A)/RA OU)K E)/STIN AU)TA/RKHS PRO\S EU)DAIMONI/AN. H)/TOI GA\R PERI\ TH\N E)KLOGH/N E)STI TW=N H(DE/WN KAT' *)EPI/KOURON H)\ PERI\ TH\N E)KLOGH\N TW=N KATA\ FU/SIN, W(S TOI=S <20A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 DOKEI=. __TW=N GA\R KATA\ FU/SIN OU)X H( KATA\ A)RETH\N E)NE/RGEIA/ E)STI POIHTIKH/. EI) DH\ PERI\ U(POKEI/MENA/ TINA H( E)NE/RGEIA AU)TH=S, W(=N OU)K E)/STIN AU)TH\ POIHTIKH/, OU)K E)/STIN AU)TA/RKHS H( A)RETH\ PRO\S TA\S OI)KEI/AS E)NER-GEI/AS, E)PEI\ DEI=TAI KAI\ TW=N PERI\ A(\ H( E)NE/RGEIA E)/CWQEN O)/NTWN AU)TH=S. <20OU)DE\ GA/R, W(S FASI/N, TO\N W(=N OU)K A)/NEU LO/GON E)/XEI TAU=TA, A)LL' E)/STIN KI-NHTIKA\ TH=S A)RETH=S KAI\ TOU= PRA/TTEIN AU)TH\N KAI\ E)NERGEI=N AI)/TIA. STOXA/ZETAI GA\R AU)TW=N, W(S KAI\ TH=S OI)KEI/AS U(/LHS OI( TEXNI=TAI. A)NAI-REQH/SESQAI GOU=N FASI TA\S PRA/CEIS AU)TOI=S, TOU/TWN MH\ E)PISPW-ME/NWN KAI\ KINOU/NTWN TAI=S E)N AU)TOI=S DIAFORAI=S TA\S A)RETA/S>20. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de anima libri mant. p. 162, 32 Bruns.$10 E)/TI EI) AI( KOINAI\ PERI\ EU)DAIMONI/AS E)/NNOIAI AU)TA/RKEIA/N TE AU)TH\N ZWH=S TI/QENTAI [1<20A)NEPIDEH= GA\R TO\N EU)DAI/MONA PROEILH/FASIN>20]1 KAI\ TH\N EU)DAIMONI/AN <20TO\ E)/SXATON TW=N O)REKTW=N>20 U(POLAMBA/NOUSIN [1A)LLA\ KAI\ TO\ ZH=N KATA\ FU/SIN KAI\ TO\N KATA\ FU/SIN BI/ON EU)DAIMONI/AN LE/GOUSIN, PRO\S DE\ TOU/TOIS TO\ EU)= ZH=N KAI\ TO\ EU)= BIOU=N KAI\ TH\N EU)ZWI/+AN EU)DAIMONI/AN FASI\N EI)=NAI]1 EI) TOIOU=TON ME\N H( EU)DAIMONI/A PROEI/LHPTAI, PRO\S MHDE\N DE\ TOU/TWN AU)TA/RKHS H( A)RETH/, OU)D' A)\N PRO\S EU)DAIMONI/AN AU)TA/RKHS EI)/H. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de anima libri mant. p. 159, 33 Bruns.$10 E)/TI EI) PA=SA TE/XNH E(/TERON E(AUTH=S POIEI= TI KAI\ OU)X E(AUTH/N, H( DE\ A)RETH\ TE/XNH KAT' ƒAU)TOU\S EU)DAIMONI/AS POIHTIKH/, E(/TERON A)\N EI)/H TH=S A)RETH=S H( EU)DAIMONI/A. @&10Alexander in Aristot. Top. p. 93 Ald. p. 173, 11.$10 OU(/TWS E)PEI\ TW=| LE/GONTI <20TH\N A)RETH\N AU)TA/RKH PRO\S EU)DAIMONI/AN>20 E(/PETAI TO/ TE MH\ EI)=NAI EU)/LOGON E)CAGWGH\N KAI\ TO\ MH\ EI)=NAI AI(RETO\N TH\N U(GEI/AN MHDE/ TI A)/LLO PARA\ TH\N A)RETH/N, A)\N TOU/TWN TI A)NAIREQH=|, A)NH|RHME/NON A)\N EI)/H TO\ TH\N A)RETH\N AU)-TA/RKH EI)=NAI PRO\S EU)DAIMONI/AN. @1 @&Plut. de Stoic. repugn. cp. 9 p. 1035c.$8 *PA/LIN <20E)N TAI=S *FU-SIKAI=S *QE/SESIN "1*OU) GA\R E)/STIN A)/LLWS OU)D' OI)KEIO/TERON E)PEL-QEI=N E)PI\ TO\N TW=N A)GAQW=N KAI\ KAKW=N LO/GON, OU)D' E)PI\ TA\S A)RE-TA/S, OU)D' E)PI\ EU)DAIMONI/AN, A)LL' H)\ A)PO\ TH=S KOINH=S FU/SEWS KAI\ A)PO\ TH=S TOU= KO/SMOU DIOIKH/SEWS"2 PROELQW\N D' AU)=QIS: "1DEI= GA\R TOU/TOIS SUNA/YAI TO\N PERI\ A)GAQW=N KAI\ KAKW=N LO/GON, OU)K OU)/SHS A)/LLHS A)RXH=S AU)TW=N A)MEI/NONOS OU)D' A)NAFORA=S, OU)D' A)/LLOU TI-NO\S E(/NEKEN TH=S FUSIKH=S QEWRI/AS PARALHPTH=S OU)/SHS, H)\ PRO\S TH\N PERI\ A)GAQW=N H)\ KAKW=N DIA/STASIN>20."2 @&Plut. de Stoic. repugn. cp. 17 p. 1041e.$ *TO\N PERI\ A)GAQW=N KAI\ KAKW=N LO/GON O(\N AU)TO\S EI)SA/GEI KAI\ DOKIMA/ZEI "1<20SUMFWNO/TATON EI)=NAI/ FHSI TW=| BI/W| KAI\ MA/LISTA TW=N E)MFU/TWN A(/PTESQAI PRO-LH/YEWN>20."2 *TAUTI\ GA\R <20E)N TW=| TRI/TW| TW=N *PROTREPTIKW=N>20 EI)/RHKEN. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 57, 19 W.$10 *TW=N D' O)/NTWN TA\ ME\N A)GAQA/, TA\ DE\ KAKA/, TA\ DE\ A)DIA/FORA. *)AGAQA\ ME\N TA\ TOIAU=TA: FRO/NHSIN, SWFROSU/NHN, DIKAIOSU/NHN, A)NDREI/AN KAI\ PA=N O(/ E)STIN A)RETH\ H)\ METE/XON A)RETH=S: KAKA\ DE\ TA\ TOIAU=TA: A)FROSU/NHN, A)KOLASI/AN, A)DIKI/AN, DEILI/AN KAI\ PA=N O(/ E)STI KAKI/A H)\ METE/XON KAKI/AS: A)DIA/FORA DE\ TA\ TOIAU=TA: ZWH\N QA/NATON, DO/CAN A)DOCI/AN, H(DONH\N PO/NON, PLOU=TON PENI/AN, U(GI/EIAN NO/SON, KAI\ TA\ TOU/TOIS O(/MOIA. @&10Sextus adv. math XI 3.$10 OI(/ TE A)PO\ TH=S A)RXAI/AS *)AKADHMI/AS KAI\ OI( A)PO\ TOU= *PERIPA/TOU E)/TI DE\ <20TH=S *STOA=S>20 EI)W/QASI DIAIROU/MENOI LE/GEIN TW=N O)/N-TWN TA\ ME\N EI)=NAI A)GAQA\ TA\ DE\ KAKA\ TA\ DE\ METACU\ TOU/TWN, A(/PER KAI\ A)DIA/-FORA LE/GOUSI. @&10Cicero de finibus III 33. Cumque rerum notiones in animis &10fiant, si aut usu aliquid cognitum sit aut coniunctione aut similitudine &10aut <21collatione rationis>21, hoc quarto, quod extremum posui, <21boni no- @1&10titia facta est>21. Cum enim ab iis rebus, quae sunt secundum naturam, &10ascendit animus collatione rationis, tum ad notionem boni pervenit. 34. Hoc &10autem ipsum bonum non accessione neque crescendo aut cum ceteris com-&10parando, sed propria vi sua et sentimus et appellamus bonum. Ut enim &10mel, etsi dulcissimum est, suo tamen proprio genere saporis, non compa-&10ratione cum aliis dulce esse sentitur, sic bonum hoc, de quo agimus, est &10illud quidem plurimi aestimandum, sed ea aestimatio genere valet non &10magnitudine. Nam cum aestimatio, quae $10A)CI/A&10 dicitur, neque in bonis nu-&10merata sit nec rursus in malis, quantumcumque eo addideris, in suo genere &10manebit. Alia est igitur propria aestimatio virtutis, quae genere, non &10crescendo valet. &10@Sextus adv. math. XI 30.$10 H)=SAN DE\ OI( FA/SKONTES A)GAQO\N U(PA/RXEIN TO\ DI' AU(TO\ AI(RETO/N. OI( D' OU(/TWS "1<20A)GAQO/N E)STI TO\ SULLAMBANO/MENON PRO\S EU)DAIMONI/AN>20,"2 TINE\S DE\ "1<20TO\ SUMPLHRWTIKO\N EU)DAIMONI/AS>20"2 EU)-DAIMONI/A DE/ E)STIN, W(S OI(/ TE PERI\ TO\N <20*ZH/NWNA>20 KAI\ <20*KLEA/NQHN>20 KAI\ <20*XRU/-SIPPON>20 A)PE/DOSAN, EU)/ROIA BI/OU. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II p. 69, 17 W.$10 TO\ D' A)GAQO\N LE/GESQAI/ FASI PLEO-NAXW=S, TO\ ME\N PRW=TON OI(=ON PHGH=S E)/XON XW/RAN, O(/PER OU(/TWS A)PODI/DOSQAI: A)F' OU(= SUMBAI/NEI W)FELEI=SQAI [1TO\ DE\ PRW/TWS EI)=NAI AI)/TION]1 H)\ U(F' OU(=: TO\ [2DE\]2 DEU/TERON, KAQ' O(\ SUMBAI/NEI W)FELEI=SQAI: KOINO/TERON DE\ KAI\ DIATEI=NON KAI\ E)PI\ TA\ PROEIRHME/NA, TO\ OI(=ON W)FELEI=N. *(OMOI/WS DE\ KAI\ TO\ KAKO\N KATA\ TH\N TOU= A)GAQOU= A)NALOGI/AN U(POGRA/FESQAI. *TO\ ME\N OU)=N A)F' OU(= SUMBAI/NEI BLA/PTESQAI H)\ U(F' OU(=: TO\ DE\ KAQ' O(\ SUMBAI/NEI BLA/PTESQAI: KOINO/TERON DE\ TOU/TWN TO\ OI(=ON BLA/PTEIN. @&10Sextus adv. math XI 22.$10 <20OI( ME\N OU)=N *STWI+KOI\>20 TW=N KOINW=N W(S EI)PEI=N E)NNOIW=N E)XO/MENOI O(RI/ZONTAI TA)GAQO\N TRO/PW| TW=|DE "1<20A)GAQO/N E)STIN W)FE/LEIA H)\ OU)X E(/TERON W)FELEI/AS>20"2 W)FE/LEIAN ME\N LE/GONTES TH\N A)RETH\N KAI\ TH\N SPOU-DAI/AN PRA=CIN, OU)X E(/TERON DE\ W)FELEI/AS TO\N SPOUDAI=ON A)/NQRWPON KAI\ TO\N FI/LON. *(H ME\N GA\R A)RETH/ PWS E)/XON H(GEMONIKO\N KAQESTHKUI=A KAI\ H( SPOUDAI/A PRA=CIS E)NE/RGEIA/ TIS OU)=SA KAT' A)RETH/N, A)/NTIKRU/S E)STIN W)FE/LEIA: O( DE\ SPOUDAI=OS A)/NQRW-POS KAI\ O( FI/LOS, PA/LIN TW=N A)GAQW=N O)/NTES KAI\ AU)TOI/, OU)/TE W)FE/LEIA LEXQEI=EN A)\N U(PA/RXEIN OU)/Q' E(/TEROI W)FELEI/AS DI' AI)TI/AN TOIAU/THN. *TA\ GA\R ME/RH, <20*STWI+-KW=N FASI PAI=DES>20, OU)/TE TA\ AU)TA\ TOI=S O(/LOIS E)STI\N OU)/TE E(TEROI=A TW=N O(/LWN, OI(=ON H( XEI\R OU)/TE H( AU)TH/ E)STIN O(/LW| A)NQRW/PW|, OU) GA\R O(/LOS A)/NQRWPO/S E)STIN H( XEI/R, OU)/TE E(TE/RA TOU= O(/LOU, SU\N GA\R TH=| [O(/LH|] XEIRI\ O(/LOS O( A)/NQRWPOS NOEI=-TAI A)/NQRWPOS. *)EPEI\ OU)=N KAI\ TOU= SPOUDAI/OU A)NQRW/POU KAI\ TOU= FI/LOU ME/-ROS E)STI\N H( A)RETH/, TA\ DE\ ME/RH OU)/TE TAU)TA\ TOI=S O(/LOIS E)STI\N OU)/TE E(/TERA TW=N O(/LWN, EI)/RHTAI O( SPOUDAI=OS A)/NQRWPOS KAI\ O( FI/LOS OU)X E(/TEROS W)FELEI/AS. *(/WSTE PA=N A)GAQO\N TW=| O(/RW| E)MPERIEILH=FQAI, E)A/N TE E)C EU)QEI/AS W)FE/LEIA TUGXA/NH| E)A/N TE MH\ H)=| E(/TERON W)FELEI/AS. *)/ENQEN KAI\ KAT' A)KOLOUQI/AN TRIXW=S EI)PO/NTES A)GA-QO\N PROSAGOREU/ESQAI, E(/KASTON TW=N SHMAINOME/NWN KAT' I)DI/AN PA/LIN E)PIBOLH\N U(POGRA/FOUSIN. *LE/GETAI GA\R A)GAQO/N, FASI/, KAQ' E(/NA ME\N TRO/PON <20TO\ U(F' OU(= H)\ A)F' OU(= E)/STIN W)FELEI=SQAI>20, O(\ DH\ A)RXIKW/TATON U(PH=RXE KAI\ A)RETH/: A)PO\ @1 GA\R TAU/THS W(/SPER TINO\S PHGH=S PA=SA PE/FUKEN A)NI/SXEIN W)FE/LEIA. *KAQ' E(/TE-RON DE\ TO\ <20KAQ' O(\ SUMBAI/NEI W)FELEI=SQAI>20: OU(/TWS OU) MO/NON AI( A)RETAI\ LEXQH/SONTAI A)GAQA\ A)LLA\ KAI\ AI( KAT' AU)TA\S PRA/CEIS, EI)/PER KAI\ KATA\ TAU/TAS SUMBAI/NEI W)FELEI=SQAI. *KATA\ DE\ TO\N TRI/TON KAI\ TELEUTAI=ON TRO/PON LE/GETAI A)GAQO\N <20TO\ OI(=O/N TE W)FELEI=N>20, E)MPERILAMBANOU/SHS TH=S A)PODO/SEWS TAU/THS TA/S TE A)RETA\S KAI\ TA\S E)NARE/TOUS PRA/CEIS KAI\ TOU\S FI/LOUS KAI\ TOU\S SPOU-DAI/OUS A)NQRW/POUS QEOU/S TE KAI\ SPOUDAI/OUS DAI/MONAS. @&10ibid. 30.$10 <20OI( D' A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 QE/LOUSIN E)PI\ TH=S TOU= A)GAQOU= PROS-HGORI/AS TO\ DEU/TERON SHMAINO/MENON E)MPERILHPTIKO\N EI)=NAI TOU= PRW/TOU KAI\ TO\ TRI/TON PERILHPTIKO\N TW=N DUOI=N. @&ibid. 33 [1adversarii dixerant%10$8 W(S EI) TAI=S A)LHQEI/AIS A)GAQO/N E)STI TO\ A)F' OU(= E)/STIN W)FELEI=SQAI, MO/NHN R(HTE/ON TH\N GENIKH\N A)RETH\N A)GAQO\N U(PA/RXEIN__E)KPI/PTEIN DE\ TOU= O(/ROU E(KA/STHN TW=N EI)DIKW=N]1 OI( D' A)NTI-KAQISTA/MENOI PRO\S TOU=TO TO\ E)/GKLHMA TOU=TO/ FASIN. <20*(/OTAN LE/GWMEN "1A)GAQO/N E)STIN A)F' OU(= SUMBAI/NEI TO\ W)FELEI=SQAI"2 E)N I)/SW| TOU=TO LE/GOMEN [2TW=|]2 "1A)GAQO/N E)STIN A)F' OU(= SUMBAI/NEI TI TW=N E)N TW=| BI/W| W)FELEI=SQAI>20."2 OU(/TW GA\R KAI\ E(KA/STH TW=N E)P' EI)/DOUS A)RETW=N A)GAQO\N GENH/SETAI, KOINW=S ME\N TO\ W)FELEI=N MH\ E)PIFE/ROUSA, TI\ DE\ TW=N E)N TW=| [2BI/W|]2 W)FELEI=SQAI PAREXOME/NH, OI(=ON H( ME\N FRONEI=N, KAQA/PER H( FRO/NHSIS, H( DE\ SWFRONEI=N, W(S H( SWFROSU/NH. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 94.$10 <20A)GAQO\N DE\ KOINW=S ME\N <20TO\ TI\ O)/FELOS>20, I)DI/WS DE\ H)/TOI <20TAU)TO\N H)\ OU)X E(/TERON W)FELEI/AS>20. O(/QEN <20AU)TH/N TE TH\N A)RETH\N KAI\ TO\ METE/XON AU)TH=S>20 A)GAQO\N TRIXW=S OU(/TWS LE/GESQAI: OI(=ON TO\ [2ME\N]2 A)GAQO\N A)F' OU(= SUMBAI/NEI [2W)FELEI=SQAI, TO\ DE\ KAQ' O(\ SUMBAI/NEI]2, W(S TH\N PRA=CIN TH\N KAT' A)RETH/N: <20U(F' OU(=>20 DE/, W(S TO\N SPOUDAI=ON TO\N METE/XONTA TH=S A)RETH=S: [1A)/LLWS DE\ OU(/TWS I)DI/WS O(RI/ZONTAI TO\ A)GAQO\N "1TO\ TE/LEION KATA\ FU/SIN LOGIKOU= W(S LOGIKOU=."2 TOIOU=TON D' EI)=NAI TH\N A)RETH/N]1 W(/S[2TE]2 <20METE/XONTA>20 TA/S TE PRA/CEIS ̈TA\S KAT' A)RETH\N KAI\ TOU\S SPOUDAI/OUS EI)=NAI, <20E)PIGENNH/MATA>20 DE\ TH/N TE XARA\N KAI\ TH\N EU)FROSU/NHN KAI\ TA\ PARAPLH/SIA. W(SAU/TWS DE\ TW=N KAKW=N TO\ ME\N EI)=NAI A)FROSU/NHN, DEILI/AN, A)DIKI/AN KAI\ TA\ PARAPLH/SIA: <20METE/XONTA DE\ KAKI/AS>20 TA/S TE PRA/CEIS TA\S KATA\ KAKI/AN KAI\ TOU\S FAU/LOUS: <20E)PIGENNH/MATA>20 DE\ TH/N TE DUSQUMI/AN KAI\ TH\N DUSFROSU/NHN KAI\ TA\ O(/MOIA. @&10Sextus adv. math. XI 40.$10 <20KAKO\N>20 GA/R E)STI TO\ E)NANTI/ON TW=| A)GAQW=|: <20O(/PER BLA/BH E)STI\N H)\, OU)X E(/TERON BLA/BHS>20, KAI\ BLA/BH ME\N W(/SPER KAKI/A KAI\ H( FAU/LH PRA=CIS, OU)X E(/TERON DE\ BLA/BHS KAQA/PER O( FAU=LOS A)/NQRWPOS KAI\ O( E)XQRO/S. @&10Origenes contra Celsum VIII 8 Vol. II p. 226, 24 Ko+. [1p. 748]1 &10Del.$10]1. EI) DE\ BLA/BHN TH\N KI/NHSIN H)\ SXE/SIN LE/GOI KATA\ KAKI/AN, DH=LON O(/TI OU)DEMIA=S GINOME/NHS BLA/BHS PERI\ TOU\S SOFOU/S&10 etc. &10@Sextus adv. math. XI 90.$10 TH=S A)FROSU/NHS, H(\N MO/NHN FASI\N EI)=NAI KAKO\N <20OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20. @1 @&10Simplicius in aristot. Phys. p. 1167, 21.$10 E)/STI ME\N GA\R TO\ E)N A)RXH=| AI)TEI=SQAI TO\ DI' AU(TOU= DEIKNU/NAI TO\ MH\ DI' AU(TOU= DH=LON: TOU=TO DE\ GI/NETAI H)\ A)/NTIKRUS KAI\ FANERW=S A)CIOU/NTWN TO\ PROKEI/MENON, W(/SPER H(MW=N LEGO/NTWN TINA\ A)GAQA\ MH\ EU)QU\S A)GAQOU\S POIEI=N, OI(=ON TA\S DUNA/MEIS, AI(=S E)/STIN EU)= KAI\ KAKW=S XRH=SQAI [1A)GAQH\ ME\N GA\R H( E)F' E(KA/TERA DU/NAMIS, A)GAQO\N DE\ OU) POIEI=, EI) MH\ TO\ EU)= XRW/MENON AU)TH=|]1 <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 TOU=TO A)NAIROU=NTES "1<20PA=N, FASI/, TO\ A)GAQO\N A)GAQOU\S POIEI=>20,"2 TO\ E)N A)RXH=| LAMBA/NONTES. @&10Seneca epistul. ad Lucil. 45, 10. Necessaria iudicat, quorum &10magna pars supervacua est. etiam quae non est supervacua, nihil in se &10momenti habet in hoc, ut possit fortunatum beatumque praestare. non &10enim statim bonum est, si quid necessarium est%10 aut proicimus bonum, si &10hoc nomen pani et polentae damus et ceteris sine quibus vita non duci-&10tur. <21Quod bonum est, utique necessarium est; quod necessarium &10est, non utique bonum est>21, quoniam quidem necessaria sunt quaedam, &10eadem vilissima. &10@Origenes contra Celsum VIII 62 Vol. II p. 278, 15 K. [1p+. 788 Del.$10]1. EI) D' H)KRIBW/KEI *KE/LSOS TH\N TOU= SUMFE/RONTOS E)/NNOIAN KAI\ E(WRA/KEI O(/TI TO\ KURI/WS SUMFE/RON A)RETH/ E)STI KAI\ H( KAT' A)RETH\N PRA=CIS &10etc. &10@Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 100.$10 <20KALO\N DE\ LE/GOUSI TO\ TE/LEION A)GAQO\N>20 PARA\ TO\ PA/NTAS A)PE/XEIN TOU\S E)PIZHTOUME/NOUS A)RIQMOU\S U(PO\ TH=S FU/SEWS H)\ <20TO\ TELEI/WS SU/MMETRON>20. EI)/DH DE\ EI)=NAI TOU= KALOU= TE/TTARA, DI/KAION, A)N-DREI=ON, KO/SMION, E)PISTHMONIKO/N: E)N GA\R TOI=SDE TA\S KALA\S PRA/CEIS SUNTELEI=-SQAI. A)NA\ LO/GON DE\ KAI\ TOU= AI)SXROU= EI)/DH EI)=NAI TE/TTARA, TO/ TE A)/DIKON KAI\ TO\ DEILO\N KAI\ A)/KOSMON KAI\ A)/FRON. LE/GESQAI DE\ TO\ KALO\N MONAXW=S ME\N TO\ E)PAINETOU\S PAREXO/MENON TOU\S E)/XONTAS [2H)\]2 A)GAQO\N E)PAI/NOU A)/CION: E(TE/RWS DE\ TO\ EU)= PEFUKO\S PRO\S TO\ I)/DION E)/RGON: A)/LLWS DE\ TO\ E)PIKOSMOU=N, O(/TAN LE/GWMEN MO/NON TO\N SOFO\N A)GAQO\N KAI\ KALO\N EI)=NAI. @&10Seneca epist. ad Lucilium 106, 2. Scis enim me moralem philo-&10sophiam velle complecti et omnes ad eam pertinentes quaestiones explicare. &10Itaque dubitavi utrum differrem te an, donec suus isti rei veniret locus, &10ius tibi extra ordinem dicerem%10 humanius visum est tam longe venientem &10non detinere. Itaque et hoc ex illa serie rerum cohaerentium <21excerpam>21 &10et, si qua erunt eiusmodi, non quaerenti tibi ultro mittam. Quae sint &10haec interrogas? Quae scire magis iuvat quam prodest, sicut hoc, de quo &10quaeris%10 <21bonum an corpus sit>21? &10@Bonum facit%10 prodest enim. Quod facit, corpus est. Bonum agitat &10animum et quodammodo format et continet, quae propria sunt corporis. &10Quae corporis bona sunt, corpora sunt%10 ergo et quae animi sunt. Nam &10et hoc corpus est. Bonum hominis necesse est corpus sit, cum ipse sit &10corporalis. Mentior, nisi et quae alunt illum et quae valetudinem eius &10vel custodiunt vel restituunt, corpora sunt%10 ergo et bonum eius corpus &10est. <21Non puto te dubitaturum, an affectus corpora sint>21_ut &10aliud quoque, de quo non quaeris, infulciam__tamquam ira, amor, tri- @1&10stitia%10 si dubitas, vide an voltum nobis mutent, an frontem adstringant, &10an faciem diffundant, an ruborem evocent, an fugent sanguinem. Quid &10ergo? Tam manifestas notas corpori credis imprimi nisi a corpore? &10@<21Si affectus corpora sunt, et morbi animorum>21 et avaritia, cru-&10delitas, indurata vitia et in statum inemendabilem adducta%10 <21ergo et ma-&10litia>21 et species eius omnes, malignitas, invidia, superbia%10 <21ergo et bona>21, &10primum quia contraria istis sunt, deinde quia eadem tibi indicia praesta-&10bunt; an non vides, quantum oculis det vigorem fortitudo? quantam inten-&10tionem prudentia? quantam modestiam et quietem reverentia? quantam &10serenitatem laetitia? quantum rigorem severitas? quantam remissionem &10lenitas? corpora ergo sunt, quae colorem habitumque corporum mutant, &10quae in illis regnum suum exercent. Omnes autem, quas rettuli, virtutes &10bona sunt et quicquid ex illis est. Numquid est dubium, an id, quo &10quid tangi potest, corpus sit? _Omnia autem ista, quae dixi, non mu-&10tarent corpus, nisi tangerent%10 ergo corpora sunt. Etiamnunc cui tanta &10vis est, ut impellat et cogat et retineat et iubeat, corpus est. Quid ergo? &10Non timor retinet? non audacia impellit? non fortitudo immittit et im-&10petum dat? Non moderatio refrenat ac revocat? Non gaudium extollit? &10Non tristitia adducit? Denique quicquid facimus, aut malitiae aut virtutis &10gerimus imperio%10 quod imperat corpori, corpus est, quod vim corpori affert, &10corpus. Bonum corporis corporalis res est. Bonum hominis et corporis &10bonum est%10 itaque corporalis res est. [1Cf. eiusdem epist. 113, 20]1. &10@Tertullianus de anima cp. 6. Bene autem quod et artes Stoici cor-&10porales adfirmant. @&Plut. de Stoic. repugn. cp. 19.$8 *TA)GAQA\ PRO\S TA\ KAKA\ TH\N PA=SAN E)/XEIN DIAFORA\N O(MOLOGEI= *XRU/SIPPOS: KAI\ A)NAGKAI=O/N E)STIN& etc. _ _$8*AI)SQHTA\ D' EI)=NAI TA)GAQA\ KAI\ TA\ KAKA\ FHSI/N, <20E)N TW=| PROTE/RW| PERI\ *TE/LOUS>20 TAU=TA GRA/FWN: "1<20*(/OTI ME\N GA\R AI)SQHTA/ E)STI TA)GAQA\ KAI\ TA\ KAKA/, KAI\ TOU/TOIS E)KPOIEI= LE/GEIN: OU) GA\R MO/NON TA\ PA/QH E)STI\N AI)SQHTA\ SU\N TOI=S EI)/DESIN, OI(=ON LU/PH KAI\ FO/BOS KAI\ TA\ PARAPLH/SIA, A)LLA\ KAI\ KLOPH=S KAI\ MOIXEI/AS KAI\ TW=N O(MOI/WN E)/STIN AI)SQE/SQAI: KAI\ KAQO/LOU A)FROSU/NHS KAI\ DEILI/AS KAI\ A)/L-LWN OU)K O)LI/GWN KAKIW=N: OU)DE\ MO/NON XARA=S KAI\ EU)ERGESIW=N KAI\ A)/LLWN POLLW=N KATORQW/SEWN, A)LLA\ KAI\ FRONH/SEWS KAI\ A)NDREI/AS KAI\ TW=N LOIPW=N A)RETW=N>20."2 @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 9 p. 1062c.$ *FU/SEI GA\R A)NEPAI/SQH-TON OU)K E)/STI KAT' AU)TOU/S: A)LLA\ KAI\ LE/GEI DIAR)R(H/DHN *XRU/SIPPOS <20E)N TOI=S PERI\ *TE/LOUS>20, AI)SQHTO\N EI)=NAI TO\ A)GAQO/N: W(S D' OI)/ETAI, KAI\ A)PODEI/KNUSI. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II p. 69, 11 W.$10 PA/NTA DE\ TA)GAQA\ W)FE/LIMA EI)=NAI KAI\ EU)/XRHSTA KAI\ SUMFE/RONTA KAI\ LUSITELH= KAI\ SPOUDAI=A KAI\ PRE/PONTA KAI\ @1 KALA\ KAI\ OI)KEI=A. TA\ DE\ KAKA\ E)K TW=N E)NANTI/WN PA/NTA BLABERA\ KAI\ DU/SXRHSTA KAI\ A)SU/MFORA KAI\ A)LUSITELH= KAI\ FAU=LA KAI\ A)PREPH= KAI\ AI)SXRA\ KAI\ A)NOI/KEIA. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 98.$10 <20PA=N DE\ A)GAQO\N>20 SUMFE/RON EI)=NAI KAI\ DE/ON KAI\ LUSITELE\S KAI\ XRH/SIMON KAI\ EU)/XRHSTON KAI\ KALO\N KAI\ W)FE/LIMON KAI\ AI(RE-TO\N KAI\ DI/KAION. <20SUMFE/RON>20 ME\N O(/TI FE/REI TOIAU=TA W(=N SUMBAINO/NTWN W)FE-LOU/MEQA: <20DE/ON>20 DE\ O(/TI SUNE/XEI E)N OI(=S XRH/: <20LUSITELE\S>20 DE\ O(/TI LU/EI TA\ TELOU/-MENA EI)S AU)TO/, W(/STE TH\N A)NTIKATA/LLACIN TH\N E)K TH=S PRAGMATEI/AS U(PERAI/REIN TH=| W)FELEI/A|: <20XRH/SIMON>20 DE\ O(/TI XREI/AN W)FELEI/AS PARE/XETAI: <20EU)/XRHSTON>20 DE\ O(/TI TH\N XREI/AN E)PAINETH\N A)PERGA/ZETAI: <20KALO\N>20 DE\ O(/TI SUMME/TRWS E)/XEI PRO\S TH\N E(AUTOU= XREI/AN: <20W)FE/LIMON>20 DE\ O(/TI TOIOU=TO/N E)STIN W(/STE W)FELEI=N: <20AI(RE-׈TO\N>20 DE\ O(/TI TOIOU=TO/N E)STIN W(/STE EU)LO/GWS AU)TO\ AI(REI=SQAI: <20DI/KAION>20 DE\ O(/TI NO/MW| E)STI\ SU/MFWNON KAI\ KOINWNI/AS POIHTIKO/N. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II p. 72, 19 W.$10 *KAI\ PA=N ME\N A)GAQO\N AI(RETO\N EI)=NAI: A)RESTO\N GA\R KAI\ DOKIMASTO\N KAI\ E)PAINETO\N U(PA/RXEIN: PA=N DE\ KAKO\N FEUKTO/N. *TO\ GA\R A)GAQO\N KAQ' O(\ ME\N AI(/RESIN EU)/LOGON KINEI=, AI(RETO/N E)STI: KAQ' O(\ DE\ A)NUPO/PTWS EI)S AI(/RESIN E)/RXETAI, A)RESTO/N: [2KAQ' O(\ DE\ ...., DOKIMASTO/N]2: KAQ' O(\ DE\ PA/LIN EU)LO/GWS A)/N TIS PERI\ AU)TOU= KAQUPOLAMBA/NOI TW=N A)P' A)RETH=S EI)=NAI, [2E)PAINETO/N]2. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 78, 7.$10 <20DIAFE/REIN>20 DE\ LE/GOUSI <20TO\ AI(RETO\N KAI\ TO\ AI(RETE/ON>20. AI(RETO\N ME\N EI)=NAI [2A)GAQO\N]2 PA=N, AI(RETE/ON DE\ W)FE/LHMA PA=N, O(\ QEWREI=TAI PARA\ TO\ E)/XEIN TO\ A)GAQO/N. DI' O(\ AI(ROU/MEQA ME\N TO\ AI(RETE/ON, OI(=ON TO\ FRONEI=N, O(\ QEWREI=TAI PARA\ TO\ E)/XEIN FRO/NHSIN: TO\ DE\ AI(RETO\N OU)X AI(ROU/MEQA, A)LL' EI) A)/RA, E)/XEIN AU)TO\ AI(ROU/MEQA. O(MOI/WS DE\ KAI\ TA\ ME\N A)GAQA\ PA/NTA E)STI\N U(POMENETA\ KAI\ E)MMENETA\ KAI\ A)NA/LOGON E)PI\ TW=N A)/LLWN A)RETW=N E)STIN, EI) KAI\ MH\ KATWNO/MASTAI: TA\ DE\ W)FELH/MATA PA/NTA U(POMENETE/A KAI\ E)MME-NETE/A. KAI\ KATA\ TO\N AU)TO\N LO/GON E)PI\ TW=N A)/LLWN TW=N KATA\ TA\S KAKI/AS. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 98, 7 W.$10 *LE/GOUSI DE\ O(MOI/WS KAI\ TA)GAQA\ PA/NTA EI)=NAI U(POMENETA\ KAI\ E)MMENETA\ KAI\ A)NA/LOGON E)PI\ TW=N A)/LLWN A)RETW=N, EI) KAI\ MH\ KATWNO/MASTAI: TA\ DE\ W)FELH/MATA PA/NTA U(POMENETE/A KAI\ E)MMENETE/A KAI\ TA\ O(/MOIA. *(WSAU/TWS DE\ DIAFE/REIN U(POLAMBA/NOUSI KAI\ TA\ EU)LABHTA\ KAI\ TA\ EU)-LABHTE/A KAI\ A)NUPOMENETA\ KAI\ A)NUPOMENETE/A. *TW=N D' A)/LLWN TW=N KATA\ TA\S KAKI/AS O( AU)TO\S LO/GOS. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 97, 15.$10 *DIAFE/REIN DE\ LE/GOUSIN, W(/SPER AI(RETO\N KAI\ AI(RETE/ON, OU(/TW KAI\ <20O)REKTO\N>20 KAI\ <20O)REKTE/ON>20 KAI\ <20BOULHTO\N>20 KAI\ <20BOULH-TE/ON>20 KAI\ A)PODEKTO\N KAI\ A)PODEKTE/ON. *AI(RETA\ ME\N GA\R EI)=NAI KAI\ BOULHTA\ KAI\ O)REKTA\ [2KAI\ A)PODEKTA\ TA)GAQA/: TA\ D' W)FELH/MATA AI(RETE/A KAI\ BOULHTE/A KAI\ O)REKTE/A]2 KAI\ A)PODEKTE/A, KATHGORH/MATA O)/NTA, PARAKEI/MENA D' A)GAQOI=S. *AI(REI=SQAI ME\N GA\R H(MA=S TA\ AI(RETE/A KAI\ BOU/LESQAI TA\ BOULHTE/A KAI\ O)RE/GE-SQAI TA\ O)REKTE/A. <20*KATHGORHMA/TWN GA\R AI(/ TE AI(RE/SEIS KAI\ O)RE/CEIS KAI\ BOULH/SEIS GI/NONTAI, W(/SPER KAI\ AI( O(RMAI/>20: E)/XEIN ME/NTOI AI(ROU/MEQA KAI\ BOULO/MEQA KAI\ O(MOI/WS O)REGO/MEQA TA)GAQA/, DIO\ KAI\ AI(RETA\ KAI\ BOULHTA\ KAI\ O)REKTA\ TA)GAQA/ E)STI. *TH\N GA\R FRO/NHSIN AI(ROU/MEQA E)/XEIN KAI\ TH\N SWFRO- @1SU/NHN, OU) MA\ *DI/A TO\ FRONEI=N KAI\ SWFRONEI=N, A)SW/MATA O)/NTA KAI\ KATHGO-RH/MATA. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 101.$10 DOKEI= DE\ PA/NTA <20TA\ A)GAQA\ I)/SA EI)=NAI>20 KAI\ PA=N A)GAQO\N E)P' A)/KRON EI)=NAI AI(RETO\N KAI\ MH/TE A)/NESIN MH/TE E)PI/TASIN DE/XESQAI. @&10Cicero de finibus III 69. Ut vero conservetur omnis homini &10erga hominem societas, coniunctio, caritas, et emolumenta et detrimenta, &10quae$10 <20W)FELH/MATA>20&10 et$10 <20BLA/MMATA>20&10 appellant, <21communia esse voluerunt>21: &10quorum altera prosunt, nocent altera. <21Neque solum ea communia, &10verum etiam paria>21 esse dixerunt. Incommoda autem et commoda [1ita &10enim$10 <20EU)XRHSTH/MATA>20&10 <21et>21$10<20DUSXRHSTH/MATA>20&10 appello]1 <21communia esse &10voluerunt, paria noluerunt>21. Illa enim quae prosunt aut quae nocent, &10aut bona sunt aut mala, quae sint paria necesse est; commoda autem et &10incommoda in eo genere sunt, quae praeposita et reiecta dicimus; ea pos-&10sunt paria non esse. Sed emolumenta communia esse dicuntur, <21recte &10autem facta et peccata non habentur communia>21. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 95, 3 W.$10 *EI)=NAI DE\ KAI\ QA/TERON TRO/PON KOINA\ TA\ A)GAQA/. *PA/NTA GA\R TO\N O(NTINOU=N W)FELOU=NTA I)/SHN W)FE/LEIAN A)POLAMBA/NEIN NOMI/ZOUSI PAR' AU)TO\ TOU=TO, MHDE/NA DE\ FAU=LON MH/TE W)FELEI=SQAI MH/TE W)FE-LEI=N. *EI)=NAI GA\R TO\ W)FELEI=N I)/SXEIN KAT' A)RETH\N KAI\ TO\ W)FELEI=SQAI KINEI=SQAI KAT' A)RETH/N. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II p. 58, 5 W.$10 *TW=N DE\ A)GAQW=N TA\ ME\N EI)=NAI A)RE-TA/S, TA\ D' OU)/. *FRO/NHSIN ME\N OU)=N KAI\ SWFROSU/NHN [2KAI\ DIKAIOSU/NHN]2 KAI\ A)NDREI/AN [2KAI\ MEGALOYUXI/AN KAI\ R(W/MHN KAI\ I)SXU\N YUXH=S]2 A)RETA/S: XARA\N DE\ KAI\ EU)FROSU/NHN KAI\ QA/RROS KAI\ BOU/LHSIN KAI\ TA\ PARAPLH/SIA OU)K EI)=NAI A)RETA/S. *TW=N DE\ A)RETW=N TA\S ME\N E)PISTH/MAS TINW=N KAI\ TE/XNAS, TA\S D' OU)/. *FRO/NHSIN ME\N OU)=N KAI\ SWFROSU/NHN KAI\ DIKAIOSU/NHN KAI\ A)NDREI/AN E)PISTH/MAS EI)=NAI TINW=N KAI\ TE/XNAS: MEGALOYUXI/AN DE\ KAI\ R(W/MHN KAI\ I)SXU\N YUXH=S OU)/T' E)PISTH/MAS TINW=N EI)=NAI OU)/TE TE/XNAS. *)ANA/LOGON DE\ KAI\ TW=N KAKW=N TA\ ME\N EI)=-NAI KAKI/AS, TA\ D' OU)/. *)AFROSU/NHN ME\N OU)=N KAI\ A)DIKI/AN KAI\ DEILI/AN KAI\ MIKRO-YUXI/AN KAI\ A)DUNAMI/AN KAKI/AS EI)=NAI: LU/PHN DE\ KAI\ FO/BON KAI\ TA\ PARAPLH/SIA OU)K EI)=NAI KAKI/AS. *TW=N DE\ KAKIW=N TA\S ME\N EI)=NAI A)GNOI/AS TINW=N KAI\ A)TEXNI/AS, TA\S D' OU)/. *)AFROSU/NHN ME\N OU)=N KAI\ A)KOLASI/AN KAI\ A)DIKI/AN KAI\ DEILI/AN A)GNOI/AS EI)=NAI TINW=N KAI\ A)TEXNI/AS: MIKROYUXI/AN DE\ KAI\ A)DUNAMI/AN [2KAI\ A)SQE/-NEIAN]2 OU)/TE A)GNOI/AS TINW=N OU)/TE A)TEXNI/AS. @&10Sextus adv. math. XI 46.$10 <20OI( DE\ A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 TRI/A ME\N GE/NH TW=N A)GAQW=N KAI\ AU)TOI\ TUGXA/NEIN E)/LECAN, OU)X W(SAU/TWS DE/: TOU/TWN GA\R TA\ ME\N PERI\ YUXH\N TA\ D' E)KTO\S TA\ DE\ OU)/TE PERI\ YUXH\N OU)/TE E)KTO/S, E)CAIROU=NTES TO\ GE/NOS TW=N PERI\ TO\ SW=MA A)GAQW=N W(S MH\ A)GAQW=N. *KAI\ DH\ <20PERI\ ME\N YUXH\N>20 EI)=NAI/ FASI TA\S A)RETA\S KAI\ [2TA\S]2 SPOUDAI/AS PRA/CEIS, <20E)KTO\S DE\>20 EI)=NAI TO/N TE FI/LON KAI\ TO\N SPOUDAI=ON A)/NQRWPON KAI\ TA\ SPOUDAI=A TE/KNA KAI\ GONEI=S KAI\ TA\ O(/MOIA, <20OU)/TE DE\ PERI\ YUXH\N OU)/TE E)KTO\S>20 AU)TO\N TO\N SPOUDAI=ON @1 A)/NQRWPON W(S PRO\S E(AUTO/N. OU)/TE GA\R E)KTO\S E(AUTOU= DUNATO\N EI)=NAI AU)TO\N OU)/TE PERI\ YUXH/N: E)K GA\R YUXH=S KAI\ SW/MATOS SUNE/STHKEN. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 70, 8 W.$10 *TW=N D' A)GAQW=N TA\ ME\N EI)=NAI PERI\ YUXH/N, TA\ D' E)KTO/S, TA\ D' OU)/TE PERI\ YUXH\N OU)/T' E)KTO/S. <20*PERI\ YUXH\N ME\N>20 TA\S A)RETA\S KAI\ [2TA\S]2 SPOUDAI/AS E(/CEIS KAI\ KAQO/LOU TA\S E)PAINETA\S E)NERGEI/AS: <20E)KTO\S DE\>20 TOU/S TE FI/LOUS KAI\ TOU\S GNWRI/MOUS KAI\ TA\ PARAPLH/SIA: <20OU)/TE DE\ PERI\ YUXH\N OU)/T' E)KTO/S>20, TOU\S SPOUDAI/OUS KAI\ KAQO/LOU [2TOU\S]2 TA\S A)RETA\S E)/XONTAS. *(OMOI/WS DE\ KAI\ TW=N KAKW=N TA\ ME\N PERI\ YUXH/N, TA\ D' E)KTO/S, TA\ D' OU)/TE PERI\ YUXH\N OU)/T' E)KTO/S: <20PERI\ YUXH\N>20 ME\N TA/S TE KAKI/AS SU\N TAI=S MOX-QHRAI=S E(/CESI KAI\ KAQO/LOU TA\S YEKTA\S E)NERGEI/AS: <20E)KTO\S DE\>20 TOU\S E)XQROU\S SU\N TOI=S EI)/DESIN: <20OU)/TE [2DE\]2 PERI\ YUXH\N OU)/T' E)KTO\S>20 TOU\S FAU/LOUS KAI\ PA/NTAS TOU\S TA\S KAKI/AS E)/XONTAS. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 95.$10 E)/TI TW=N A)GAQW=N TA\ ME\N EI)=NAI PERI\ YUXH/N, TA\ DE\ E)KTO/S, TA\ D' OU)/TE PERI\ YUXH\N OU)/TE E)KTO/S. <20TA\ ME\N PERI\ YUXH\N>20 A)RE-TA\S KAI\ TA\S KATA\ TAU/TAS PRA/CEIS, <20TA\ D' E)KTO\S>20 TO/ TE SPOUDAI/AN E)/XEIN PA-TRI/DA KAI\ SPOUDAI=ON FI/LON KAI\ TH\N TOU/TWN EU)DAIMONI/AN, <20TA\ D' OU)/TE E)KTO\S OU)/TE PERI\ YUXH\N>20 TO\ AU)TO\N E(AUTW=| EI)=NAI SPOUDAI=ON KAI\ EU)DAI/MONA. *)ANA/-PALIN DE\ KAI\ TW=N KAKW=N TA\ ME\N PERI\ YUXH\N EI)=NAI, TA\S KAKI/AS KAI\ TA\S KAT' AU)TA\S PRA/CEIS, TA\ DE\ E)KTO/S, TO\ A)/FRONA PATRI/DA E)/XEIN KAI\ A)/FRONA FI/LON KAI\ TH\N TOU/TWN KAKODAIMONI/AN, TA\ DE\ OU)/TE E)KTO\S OU)/TE PERI\ YUXH/N, TO\ AU)TO\N E(AUTW=| EI)=NAI FAU=LON KAI\ KAKODAI/MONA. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 94, 21 W.$10 *TRIXW=S DE\ LEGOME/NHS TH=S FILI/AS, KAQ' E(/NA ME\N TRO/PON TH=S KOINH=S E(/NEK' W)FELEI/AS, KAQ' H(\N FI/LOI EI)=NAI LE/GONTAI, TAU/THN ME\N OU)/ FASI TW=N A)GAQW=N EI)=NAI, <20DIA\ TO\ MHDE\N E)K DIESTHKO/TWN A)GAQO\N EI)=NAI KAT' AU)TOU/S>20: TH\N DE\ KATA\ TO\ DEU/TERON SHMAINO/MENON LEGO-ME/NHN FILI/AN, KATA/SXESIN OU)=SAN FILIKH\N PRO\S TW=N PE/LAS, <20TW=N E)KTO\S>20 LE/-GOUSIN A)GAQW=N: TH\N DE\ PERI\ AU)TO\N FILI/AN, KAQ' H(\N FI/LOS E)STI\ TW=N PE/LAS, <20TW=N PERI\ YUXH\N>20 A)POFAI/NOUSIN A)GAQW=N. @&10Seneca ep. 74, 22. dicitis enim inter bona esse liberos pios et &10bene moratam patriam et parentes bonos. @&10Seneca ep. 102, 3. probare conabar, id quod <21nostris>21 placet, &10claritatem quae post mortem contingit bonum esse. &10@ibid. 8. claritas__bonorum virorum secunda opinio est. &10@ibid. 9. claritas__laus est a bonis bono reddita. &10@Stobaeus ecl. II 74, 15 W.$10 E)/TI DE\ TW=N A)GAQW=N TA\ ME\N EI)=NAI <20A)/MIKTA>20 OI(=ON E)PISTH/MHN, TA\ DE\ <20MEMIGME/NA>20, OI(=ON EU)TEKNI/AN, EU)GHRI/AN, EU)-ZWI/+AN. E)/STI D' H( ME\N EU)TEKNI/A XRH=SIS TE/KNOIS KATA\ FU/SIN E)/XOUSI SPOUDAI/A, H( DE\ EU)GHRI/A XRH=SIS SPOUDAI/A GH/RA| KATA\ FU/SIN E)/XONTI, KAI\ O(MOI/WS H( EU)ZWI/+A. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 98.$10 KOINW=S DE\ TW=N A)GAQW=N <20MIKTA\>20 ME/N E)STIN EU)TEKNI/A KAI\ EU)GHRI/A, <20A(PLOU=N>20 D' E)STI\N A)GAQO\N E)PISTH/MH. @KAI\ <20A)EI\ ME\N PARO/NTA>20 AI( A)RETAI/, <20OU)K A)EI\>20 DE/, OI(=ON XARA/, PERIPA/THSIS. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II p. 68, 24 W.$10 E)/TI DE\ TW=N A)GAQW=N TA\ ME\N PA=SI TOI=S FRONI/MOIS U(PA/RXEIN KAI\ A)EI/, TA\ DE\ OU)/, A)RETH\N ME\N KAI\ FRONI/MHN AI)/SQHSIN @1 KAI\ FRONI/MHN O(RMH\N KAI\ TA\ O(/MOIA <20PA=SI>20 TOI=S <20FRONI/MOIS U(PA/RXEIN KAI\ E)N PANTI\ KAIRW=|>20: XARA\N DE\ KAI\ EU)FROSU/NHN KAI\ FRONI/MHN PERIPA/THSIN <20OU)/TE PA=SI TOI=S FRONI/MOIS U(PA/RXEIN OU)/TE AI)EI/>20. A)NA/LOGON DE\ KAI\ TW=N KA-KW=N TA\ ME\N PA=SI TOI=S A)/FROSIN U(PA/RXEIN KAI\ AI)EI/, TA\ D' OU)/. KAKI/AN ME\N OU)=N PA=SAN KAI\ A)/FRONA AI)/SQHSIN KAI\ A)/FRONA O(RMH\N KAI\ TA\ PARAPLH/SIA PA=SI TOI=S A)/FROSIN U(PA/RXEIN [2KAI\]2 AI)EI/. LU/PHN DE\ KAI\ FO/BON KAI\ A)/FRONA A)PO/-KRISIN OU)/TE PA=SI TOI=S A)/FROSIN U(PA/RXEIN OU)/T' E)N PANTI\ KAIRW=|. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 70, 21 W.$10 TW=N DE\ PERI\ YUXH\N A)GAQW=N TA\ ME\N EI)=NAI DIAQE/SEIS, TA\ DE\ E(/CEIS ME/N, DIAQE/SEIS D' OU)/, TA\ D' OU)/TE E(/CEIS OU)/TE DIA-QE/SEIS. <20DIAQE/SEIS ME\N>20 TA\S A)RETA\S PA/SAS, <20E(/CEIS DE\>20 MO/NON KAI\ OU) DIA-QE/SEIS TA\ E)PITHDEU/MATA W(S TH\N MANTIKH\N KAI\ TA\ PARAPLH/SIA: <20OU)/TE DE\ E(/CEIS OU)/TE DIAQE/SEIS>20 TA\S KAT' A)RETA\S E)NERGEI/AS, OI(=ON FRONI/MEUSIN KAI\ TH\N TH=S SWFROSU/NHS KTH=SIN KAI\ TA\ PARAPLH/SIA. O(MOI/WS DE\ KAI\ TW=N PERI\ YUXH\N KAKW=N TA\ ME\N EI)=NAI DIAQE/SEIS, TA\ D' E(/CEIS ME/N, DIAQE/SEIS D' OU)/, TA\ DE\ OU)/TE E(/CEIS OU)/TE DIAQE/SEIS. DIAQE/SEIS ME\N TA\S KAKI/AS PA/SAS, E(/CEIS DE\ MO/NON TA\S EU)KATAFORI/AS, OI(=ON TH\N FQONERI/AN, TH\N E)PILUPI/AN KAI\ TA\ O(/MOIA KAI\ E)/TI TA\ NOSH/MATA KAI\ A)R)R(WSTH/MATA, OI(=ON FILARGURI/AN, OI)NOFLUGI/AN KAI\ TA\ PARA-PLH/SIA. OU)/TE [2D']2 E(/CEIS OU)/TE DIAQE/SEIS TA\S KATA\ KAKI/AS E)NERGEI/AS, OI(=ON A)FRO/NEUSIN, A)DI/KEUSIN KAI\ TA\ TAU/TAIS PARAPLH/SIA. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 98.$10 E)/TI TW=N PERI\ YUXH\N A)GAQW=N TA\ ME/N EI)SIN E(/CEIS, TA\ DE\ DIAQE/SEIS, TA\ D' OU)/TE E(/CEIS OU)/TE DIAQE/SEIS: <20DIAQE/SEIS>20 ME\N AI( A)RETAI/, <20E(/CEIS>20 DE\ TA\ E)PITHDEU/MATA, <20OU)/TE DE\ E(/CEIS OU)/TE DIAQE/SEIS>20 AI( E)NE/RGEIAI. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II p. 71, 15.$10 TW=N TE A)GAQW=N TA\ ME\N EI)=NAI TELIKA/, TA\ DE\ POIHTIKA/, TA\ DE\ A)MFOTE/RWS E)/XONTA: O( ME\N OU)=N FRO/NIMOS A)/NQRWPOS KAI\ O( FI/LOS <20POIHTIKA\>20 MO/NON E)STI\N A)GAQA/: XARA\ DE\ KAI\ EU)FROSU/NH KAI\ QA/R-ROS KAI\ FRONI/MH PERIPA/THSIS <20TELIKA\>20 MO/NON E)STI\N A)GAQA/: AI( D' A)RETAI\ PA=SAI <20KAI\ POIHTIKA/ E)STIN A)GAQA\ KAI\ TELIKA/>20, KAI\ GA\R A)POGENNW=SI TH\N EU)DAI-MONI/AN KAI\ SUMPLHROU=SI, ME/RH AU)TH=S GINO/MENAI. *)ANA/LOGON DE\ KAI\ TW=N KA-KW=N TA\ ME/N E)STI POIHTIKA\ TH=S KAKODAIMONI/AS, TA\ DE\ TELIKA/, TA\ DE\ A)MFOTE/RWS E)/XONTA. *(O ME\N OU)=N A)/FRWN A)/NQRWPOS KAI\ O( E)XQRO\S POIHTIKA\ MO/NON E)STI\ KAKA/: LU/PH DE\ KAI\ FO/BOS KAI\ KLOPH\ KAI\ A)/FRWN E)RW/THSIS KAI\ TA\ O(/MOIA TELIKA/ [2MO/NON E)STI\ KAKA/]2: AI( DE\ KAKI/AI KAI\ POIHTIKA\ KAI\ TELIKA/ E)STI KAKA/: A)PO-GENNW=SI GA\R TH\N KAKODAIMONI/AN KAI\ SUMPLHROU=SI, ME/RH AU)TH=S GINO/MENAI. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 96.$10 E)/TI TW=N <20A)GAQW=N>20 TA\ ME\N EI)=NAI <20TELIKA/>20, TA\ DE\ <20POIHTIKA/>20, TA\ DE\ <20TELIKA\ KAI\ POIHTIKA/>20. *TO\N ME\N OU)=N FI/LON KAI\ TA\S A)P' AU)TOU= GINOME/NAS W)FELEI/AS <20POIHTIKA\>20 EI)=NAI A)GAQA/: QA/RSOS DE\ KAI\ FRO/NHMA KAI\ E)LEUQERI/AN KAI\ TE/RYIN KAI\ EU)FROSU/NHN KAI\ A)LUPI/AN KAI\ PA=SAN TH\N KAT' A)RETH\N PRA=CIN <20TELIKA/. POIHTIKA\ DE\ KAI\ TELIKA\>20 [2TA\S A)RETA\S]2 EI)=NAI A)GAQA/: KAQO\ ME\N GA\R A)POTELOU=SI TH\N EU)DAIMONI/AN, POIHTIKA/ E)STIN A)GAQA/: KAQO\ DE\ SUMPLHROU=SIN AU)TH/N, W(/STE ME/RH AU)TH=S GI/NESQAI, TELIKA/. @1 @O(MOI/WS DE\ KAI\ <20TW=N KAKW=N>20 TA\ ME\N EI)=NAI TELIKA/, TA\ DE\ POIHTIKA/, TA\ DE\ A)MFOTE/RWS E)/XONTA: TO\N ME\N E)XQRO\N KAI\ TA\S A)P' AU)TOU= GINOME/NAS BLA/BAS <20POIHTIKA\>20 EI)=NAI: KATA/PLHCIN DE\ KAI\ TAPEINO/THTA KAI\ DOULEI/AN KAI\ A)TERPI/AN KAI\ DUSQUMI/AN KAI\ PERILUPI/AN KAI\ PA=SAN TH\N KATA\ KAKI/AN PRA=CIN <20TELIKA/>20: A)MFOTE/RWS DE\ E)/XONTA [2TA\S KAKI/AS]2: E)PEI\ KAQO\ ME\N A)POTELOU=SI TH\N KAKODAI-MONI/AN, POIHTIKA/ E)STI: KAQO\ DE\ SUMPLHROU=SIN AU)TH/N, W(/STE ME/RH AU)TH=S GI/NE-SQAI, TELIKA/. @&10Cicero de finibus III 55. Sequitur illa divisio, ut bonorum alia &10sint ad illud ultimum pertinentia [1sic enim appello, quae $10TELIKA/&10 dicun-&10tur_]1, alia autem efficientia, quae Graeci $10POIHTIKA/&10, alia utrumque. De &10pertinentibus nihil est bonum praeter actiones honestas, de efficientibus &10nihil praeter amicum, sed et pertinentem et efficientem sapientiam volunt &10esse. Nam quia sapientia est conveniens actio, est [2ex]2 illo pertinenti &10genere quod dixi; quod autem honestas actiones affert et efficit, efficiens &10dici potest. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 72, 14 W.$10 *)/ETI DE\ TW=N A)GAQW=N TA\ ME\N EI)=NAI DI' AU(TA\ AI(RETA/, TA\ DE\ POIHTIKA/. *(OPO/SA ME\N OU)=N OU)DENO\S A)/LLOU E(/NEKEN EI)S EU)/LOGON AI(/RESIN E)/RXETAI, DI' AU(TA\ AI(RETA/: O(PO/SA DE\ TW=| E(TE/RWN TINW=N PARASKEUASTIKA\ GI/NESQAI, KATA\ TO\ POIHTIKO\N LE/GESQAI. @&10Clem. Al. Strom. VI 12 p. 789 Pott.$10 AU)TI/KA O( ME\N KAKO\S FU/SEI A(MARTHTIKO\S DIA\ KAKI/AN GENO/MENOS FAU=LOS KAQE/STHKEN, E)/XWN H(\N E(KW\N EI(/LETO: A(MARTHTIKO\S DE\ W)\N KAI\ KATA\ [2TA\S]2 PRA/CEIS DIAMARTA/NEI: E)/MPALIN DE\ O( SPOU-DAI=OS KATORQOI=. *DIO\ OU) MO/NON TA\S A)RETA\S A)LLA\ KAI\ TA\S PRA/CEIS TA\S KALA\S A)GAQA\ KALOU=MEN: <20TW=N DE\ A)GAQW=N I)/SMEN TA\ ME\N AU)TA\ DI' AU(TA\ AI(RETA/>20, W(S TH\N GNW=SIN: OU) GA\R A)/LLO TI E)C AU)TH=S QHRW=MEN, E)PEIDA\N PARH=| H)\ MO/NON TO\ PAREI=NAI AU)TH/N__<20TA\ DE\ DI' E(/TERA &10etc. &10@Stobaeus ecl. II p. 73, 1.$10 E)/TI DE\ TW=N A)GAQW=N TA\ ME\N EI)=NAI E)N KINH/SEI, TA\ DE\ E)N SXE/SEI, <20E)N KINH/SEI>20 ME\N TA\ TOIAU=TA, XARA/N, EU)FROSU/NHN, SW/FRONA O(MILI/AN: <20E)N SXE/SEI>20 DE\ TA\ TOIAU=TA, EU)/TAKTON H(SUXI/AN, MONH\N A)TA/-RAXON, PROSOXH\N E)/PANDRON. <20TW=N DE\ E)N SXE/SEI>20 TA\S ME\N <20KAI\ E)N E(/CEI>20 EI)=NAI, OI(=ON TA\S A)RETA/S: <20TA\ D' E)N SXE/SEI MO/NON>20, W(S TA\ R(HQE/NTA. E)N E(/CEI DE\ OU) MO/NAS EI)=NAI TA\S A)RETA/S, A)LLA\ KAI\ TA\S TE/XNAS TA\S E)N TW=| SPOUDAI/W| A)NDRI\ A)L-LOIWQEI/SAS U(PO\ TH=S A)RETH=S KAI\ GENOME/NAS A)METAPTW/TOUS: OI(ONEI\ GA\R A)RETA\S GI/NESQAI. FASI\ DE\ KAI\ TW=N E)N E(/CEI A)GAQW=N EI)=NAI KAI\ TA\ E)PITHDEU/MATA KA-LOU/MENA, OI(=ON FILOMOUSI/AN, FILOGRAMMATI/AN, FILOGEWMETRI/AN KAI\ TA\ PARA-PLH/SIA. EI)=NAI GA\R O(DO/N TINA E)KLEKTIKH\N TW=N E)N TAU/TAIS TAI=S TE/XNAIS OI)KEI/WN PRO\S A)RETH/N, A)NAFE/ROUSAN AU)TA\ E)PI\ TO\ TOU= BI/OU TE/LOS. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II p. 74, 16 W.$10 *)/ETI DE\ TW=N A)GAQW=N TA\ ME\N EI)=NAI KAQ' E(AUTA/, TA\ DE\ PRO/S TI/ PWS E)/XEIN. *KAQ' E(AUTA\ ME\N E)PISTH/MHN, DIKAIO-PRAGI/AN KAI\ TA\ O(/MOIA: PRO/S TI DE\ TIMH/N, EU)/NOIAN, FILI/AN, [2SUMFWNI/AN]2. *EI)=NAI DE\ TH\N E)PISTH/MHN KATA/LHYIN A)SFALH= KAI\ A)META/PTWTON U(PO\ LO/GOU: E(TE/RAN DE\ E)PISTH/MHN SU/STHMA E)C E)PISTHMW=N TOIOU/TWN, OI(=ON H( TW=N KATA\ ME/-ROS LOGIKH\ E)N TW=| SPOUDAI/W| U(PA/RXOUSA: A)/LLHN DE\ SU/STHMA E)C E)PISTHMW=N @1 TEXNIKW=N E)C AU(TOU= E)/XON TO\ BE/BAION, W(S E)/XOUSIN AI( A)RETAI/: A)/LLHN DE\ E(/CIN FANTASIW=N DEKTIKH\N A)META/PTWTON U(PO\ LO/GOU, H(/N TINA/ FASIN E)N TO/NW| KAI\ DUNA/MEI KEI=SQAI. *FILI/AN D' EI)=NAI KOINWNI/AN BI/OU: SUMFWNI/AN DE\ O(MODOGMA-TI/AN PERI\ TW=N KATA\ TO\N BI/ON. *TH=S DE\ FILI/AS EI)=NAI GNWRIMO/THTA ME\N FILI/AN E)GNWSME/NWN: SUNH/QEIAN DE\ FILI/AN SUNEIQISME/NWN: E(TAIRI/AN DE\ FILI/AN KAQ' AI(/RESIN, W(S A)\N O(MHLI/KWN: CENI/AN DE\ FILI/AN A)LLODAPW=N. *EI)=NAI DE\ KAI\ SUG-GENIKH/N TINA FILI/AN E)K SUGGENW=N: KAI\ E)RWTIKH\N E)C E)/RWTOS. *)ALUPI/AN DE\ KAI\ EU)TACI/AN TA\S AU)TA\S EI)=NAI TH=| SWFROSU/NH|, NOU=N DE\ KAI\ FRE/NAS FRONH/SEI, METADOTIKH\N DE\ KAI\ E)PIDOTIKH\N XRHSTO/THTI: TW=| ME/NTOI GE PRO/S TI/ PWS E)/XEIN W)NOMA/SQHSAN: O(/PER KAQH/KEI KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N A)/LLWN A)RETW=N PARATHREI=N. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 77, 6.$10 *KAI\ TW=N <20A)GAQW=N>20 TA\ ME\N <20A)NAGKAI=A>20 EI)=NAI PRO\S EU)DAIMONI/AN, TA\ DE\ MH/. *KAI\ <20A)NAGKAI=A>20 ME\N TA/S TE A)RETA\S PA/SAS KAI\ TA\S E)NERGEI/AS TA\S XRHSTIKA\S AU)TW=N: <20OU)K A)NAGKAI=A>20 DE\ XARA/N TE KAI\ EU)FROSU/NHN KAI\ TA\ E)PITHDEU/MATA. *PARAPLHSI/WS DE\ KAI\ TW=N KAKW=N TA\ ME\N A)NAGKAI=A W(S A)\N KAKA\ PRO\S KAKODAIMONI/AN EI)=NAI, TA\ D' OU)K A)NAGKAI=A: A)NAG-KAI=A ME\N TA/S TE KAKI/AS PA/SAS KAI\ TA\S E)NERGEI/AS TA\S A)P' AU)TW=N: OU)K A)NAG-KAI=A DE\ TA/ TE PA/QH PA/NTA KAI\ TA\ A)RRWSTH/MATA KAI\ TA\ TOU/TOIS PARAPLH/SIA. @&10Clem. Al. Strom. IV 6 p. 581 Pott.$10 A)GAQA\ GOU=N TA\ ME\N AU)TA\ KAQ' E(AUTA/: <20TA\ DE\ METE/XONTA TW=N A)GAQW=N, W(S TA\S KALA\S PRA/CEIS FAME/N>20: A)/NEU DE\ TW=N METACU/, A(\ DH\ U(/LHS E)PE/XEI TA/CIN, OU)/Q' AI( A)GAQAI\ OU)Q' AI( KAKAI\ SUNI/STANTAI PRA/CEIS: OI(=ON ZWH=S LE/GW KAI\ U(GIEI/AS TW=N TE A)/LLWN TW=N A)NAGKAI/WN H)\ PERISTATIKW=N. @&10Seneca ep. 66, 5. Hoc primo die quaesitum est, quomodo pos-&10sint paria bona esse, si triplex eorum condicio est%10 quaedam, ut nostris &10videtur, <21prima bona>21 sunt, tamquam gaudium, pax, salus patriae, quae-&10dam <21secunda, in materia infelici expressa>21, tamquam tormentorum &10patientia et in morbo gravi temperantia: illa bona directo optabimus no-&10bis, haec si necesse erit. sunt adhuc tertia, tamquam modestus incessus &10et compositus ac probus voltus et conveniens prudenti viro gestus. @&10Philo Leg. Alleg. III %14 177 Vol. I p. 152, 14 Wendl.$10 *)ARE/SKEI GA\R AU)TW=| [1&10scil. Moysi]1$10 TA\ ME\N PROHGOU/MENA A)GAQA\ AU)TOPROSW/PWS AU)TO\N TO\N *)/ONTA DIDO/NAI, TA\ DEU/TERA DE\ TOU\S A)GGE/LOUS KAI\ LO/GOUS AU)TOU=: DEU/TERA D' E)STI/N, O(/SA PERIE/XEI KAKW=N A)PALLAGH/N. @1 @&Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 102.$10 TW=N DE\ O)/NTWN FASI\ TA\ ME\N A)GAQA\ EI)=NAI, TA\ DE\ KAKA/, TA\ DE\ OU)DE/TERA___OU)DE/TERA DE\ O(/SA MH/TE W)FELEI= MH/TE BLA/PTEI: OI(=ON ZWH/, U(GI/EIA, H(DONH/, KA/LLOS, I)SXU/S, PLOU=TOS, EU)DOCI/A, EU)GE/NEIA: KAI\ TA\ TOU/TOIS E)NANTI/A, QA/NATOS, NO/SOS, PO/NOS, AI)=SXOS, A)SQE/NEIA, PENI/A, A)DOCI/A, DUSGE/NEIA KAI\ TA\ TOU/TOIS PARAPLH/SIA: KAQA/ FHSIN *(EKA/TWN E)N E(BDO/MW| PERI\ TE/LOUS KAI\ *)APOLLO/DWROS E)N TH=| H)QIKH=| KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20. MH\ GA\R EI)=NAI TAU=TA A)GAQA/, A)LL' A)DIA/FORA, KAT' EI)=DOS PROHGME/NA: W(S GA\R I)/DION QERMOU= TO\ QERMAI/NEIN, OU) TO\ YU/-XEIN, OU(/TW KAI\ A)GAQOU= TO\ W)FELEI=N, OU) TO\ BLA/PTEIN. OU) MA=LLON DE\ W)FELEI= H)\ BLA/PTEI O( PLOU=TOS KAI\ H( U(GI/EIA: OU)K A)/RA A)GAQO\N OU)/TE PLOU=-TOS OU)/TE U(GI/EIA: E)/TI TE/ FASIN: W(=| E)/STIN EU)= KAI\ KAKW=S XRH=SQAI, TOU=TO OU)K E)/STIN A)GAQO/N: PLOU/TW| DE\ KAI\ U(GIEI/A| E)/STIN EU)= KAI\ KAKW=S XRH=SQAI: OU)K A)/RA A)GAQO\N PLOU=TOS KAI\ U(GI/EIA. @&ibid. 104.$ W)FELEI=N DE/ E)STI KINEI=N H)\ I)/SXEIN KAT' A)RETH/N: BLA/PTEIN DE\ KINEI=N H)\ I)/SXEIN KATA\ KAKI/AN. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 79, 1 W.$10 <20A)DIA/FORA>20 D' EI)=NAI LE/GOUSI TA\ METACU\ TW=N A)GAQW=N KAI\ TW=N KAKW=N, DIXW=S TO\ A)DIA/FORON NOEI=SQAI FA/MENOI: <20KAQ' E(/NA ME\N TRO/PON>20 TO\ MH/TE A)GAQO\N MH/TE KAKO\N KAI\ TO\ MH/TE AI(RETO\N MH/TE FEUKTO/N: <20KAQ' E(/TERON DE\>20 TO\ MH/TE O(RMH=S MH/TE A)FORMH=S KINHTIKO/N: KAQ' O(\ KAI\ LE/GESQAI/ TINA KAQA/PAC A)DIA/FORA EI)=NAI, OI(=ON TO\ [2A)RTI/AS E)/XEIN E)PI\ TH=S KEFALH=S TRI/XAS H)\ PERITTA/S, H)\ TO\]2 PROTEI=NAI TO\N DA/KTULON W(DI\ H)\ W(DI/, H)\ TO\ A)NELE/SQAI TI TW=N E)MPODW/N, KA/RFOS H)\ FU/LLON. KATA\ TO\ PRO/TERON DH\ LEKTE/ON TA\ METACU\ A)RETH=S KAI\ KAKI/AS A)DIA/FORA LE/GESQAI__, OU) MH\N PRO\S E)KLO-GH\N KAI\ A)PEKLOGH/N: DI' O(\ KAI\ TA\ ME\N A)CI/AN E)KLEKTIKH\N E)/XEIN, TA\ D' A)PACI/AN A)PEKLEKTIKH/N, SUMBLHTIKH\N D' OU)DAMW=S PRO\S TO\N EU)DAI/MONA BI/ON. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 104.$10 <20DIXW=S DE\ LE/GESQAI A)DIA/FORA: A(/PAC ME\N>20 TA\ MH/TE PRO\S EU)DAIMONI/AN MH/TE PRO\S KAKODAIMONI/AN SUNERGOU=NTA, W(S E)/XEI PLOU=TOS, DO/CA, U(GI/EIA, I)SXU\S KAI\ TA\ O(/MOIA: E)NDE/XETAI GA\R KAI\ XWRI\S TOU/- @1TWN EU)DAIMONEI=N, TH=S POIA=S AU)TW=N XRH/SEWS EU)DAIMONIKH=S OU)/SHS H)\ KAKODAI-MONIKH=S. <20A)/LLWS DE\ LE/GETAI A)DIA/FORA>20 TA\ MH/TE O(RMH=S MH/TE A)FORMH=S KI-NHTIKA/, W(S E)/XEI TO\ A)RTI/AS E)/XEIN E)PI\ TH=S KEFALH=S TRI/XAS H)\ PERITTA\S H)\ E)KTEI=-NAI TO\N DA/KTULON H)\ SUSTEI=LAI, TW=N PROTE/RWN A)DIAFO/RWN OU)KE/Q' OU(/TWS LEGO-ME/NWN: O(RMH=S GA/R E)STIN E)KEI=NA KAI\ A)FORMH=S KINHTIKA/, DIO\ TA\ ME\N AU)TW=N E)KLE/GETAI, [2TA\ DE\ A)PEKLE/GETAI]2, TW=N E(TE/RWN E)PI/SHS E)XO/NTWN PRO\S AI(/RESIN KAI\ FUGH/N. @&10Seneca ep. 82, 15. Est et horum, Lucili, quae appellamus media, &10grande discrimen. non enim sic mors indifferens est, quomodo utrum ca-&10pillos pares habeas. &10@Stobaeus ecl. II 82, 5.$10 *)/ETI DE\ TW=N A)DIAFO/RWN FASI\ TA\ ME\N EI)=-NAI O(RMH=S KINHTIKA/, TA\ DE\ A)FORMH=S, TA\ DE\ OU)/TE O(RMH=S OU)/TE A)FORMH=S. *(OR-MH=S ME\N OU)=N KINHTIKA/, A(/PER E)LE/GOMEN EI)=NAI KATA\ FU/SIN: A)FORMH=S DE\ O(/SA PARA\ FU/SIN: OU)/TE DE\ O(RMH=S OU)/TE A)FORMH=S TA\ MHDETE/RWS E)/XONTA, OI(=A/ E)STI TO\ PERITTA\S H)\ A)RTI/AS E)/XEIN TA\S TRI/XAS. @&10Sextus adv. math. XI 59.$10 OU)K A)GAQO\N D' <20OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 E)/LECAN AU)TH\N [1&10scil.$10 TH\N U(GEI/AN]1 A)LL' A)DIA/FORON. *TO\ <20A)DIA/FORON D' OI)/ONTAI LE/GESQAI TRIXW=S, KAQ' E(/NA ME\N TRO/PON>20 PRO\S O(\ MH/TE O(RMH\ MH/TE A)FORMH\ GI/GNETAI, OI(=O/N E)STI TO\ PERITTOU\S H)\ A)RTI/OUS EI)=NAI TOU\S A)STE/RAS H)\ TA\S E)PI\ TH=| KEFALH=| TRI/XAS, <20KAQ' E(/TERON>20 DE\ PRO\S O(\ O(RMH\ ME\N KAI\ A)FORMH\ GI/GNETAI, OU) MA=LLON DE\ PRO\S TO/DE H)\ TO/DE, OI(=ON E)PI\ DUOI=N DRAXMW=N A)PARALLA/KTWN TW=| TE XARAKTH=RI KAI\ TH=| LAMPRO/THTI, O(/TAN DE/H| TH\N E(TE/RAN AU)TW=N AI(REI=SQAI: O(RMH\ ME\N GA\R GI/GNETAI PRO\S TO\ E(/TERON AU)TW=N, OU) MA=LLON DE\ PRO\S TO/DE H)\ TO/DE, <20KATA\ DE\ TRI/TON KAI\ TELEUTAI=ON TRO/PON>20 FASI\N A)DIA/FORON TO\ MH/TE PRO\S EU)DAIMONI/AN MH/TE PRO\S KAKODAIMONI/AN SULLAMBANO/MENON. *KAQ' O(\ SHMAINO/ME-NO/N FASI TH/N TE U(GEI/AN KAI\ NO/SON KAI\ PA/NTA TA\ SWMATIKA\ KAI\ TA\ PLEI=STA TW=N E)KTO\S A)DIA/FORA TUGXA/NEIN DIA\ TO\ MH/TE PRO\S EU)DAIMONI/AN MH/TE PRO\S KAKODAIMONI/AN SUNTEI/NEIN. *(=WI GA\R E)/STIN EU)= KAI\ KAKW=S XRH=SQAI TOU=T' A)\N EI)/H A)DIA/FORON: DIA\ PANTO\S D' A)RETH=| ME\N KALW=S, KAKI/A| DE\ KAKW=S, U(GEI/A| DE\ KAI\ TOI=S PERI\ SW/MATI POTE\ ME\N EU)= POTE\ DE\ KAKW=S E)/STI XRH=SQAI, DIO\ TAU=T' A)\N EI)/H A)DIA/FORA. *)/HDH DE\ TW=N A)DIAFO/RWN FASI\ TA\ ME\N EI)=NAI PROHGME/NA TA\ D' A)POPROHGME/NA TA\ DE\ MH/TE PROHGME/NA MH/TE A)POPROHGME/NA: KAI\ <20PROHGME/NA>20 ME\N EI)=NAI TA\ I(KANH\N A)CI/AN E)/XONTA, <20A)POPROHGME/NA>20 DE\ TA\ I(KANH\N A)PACI/AN E)/XONTA, <20MH/TE DE\ PROH=XQAI MH/TE A)POPROH=XQAI>20 OI(=ON TO\ E)KTEI=NAI H)\ SUG-KA/MYAI TO\N DA/KTULON KAI\ PA=N O(\ TOU/TW| PARAPLHSIO/N E)STIN. *TA/TTESQAI D' E)N ME\N TOI=S PROHGME/NOIS TH/N TE U(GEI/AN KAI\ TH\N I)SXU\N KAI\ TO\ KA/LLOS PLOU=TO/N TE KAI\ DO/CAN KAI\ TA\ E)OIKO/TA, E)N DE\ TOI=S A)POPROHGME/NOIS NO/SON KAI\ PENI/AN KAI\ A)LGHDO/NA KAI\ TA\ A)NA/LOGA. W(=DE ME\N KAI\ <20OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. 31 p. 1048c.$ *)/ETI DE\ MA=L-LON TH=| A)PODEI/CEI TO\ E)NANTI/WMA POIOU=SI FANERW/TERON. *(=WI GA\R E)/STIN EU)= XRH/SASQAI KAI\ KAKW=S, TOU=TO/ FASI MH/T' A)GAQO\N EI)=NAI, MH/TE KAKO/N. *PLOU/TW| DE\ KAI\ U(GIEI/A| KAI\ R(W/MH| SW/MATOS KAKW=S XRW=NTAI PA/NTES OI( A)NO/HTOI. *DIO/PER OU)DE/N E)STI TOU/TWN A)GAQO/N. @1 @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 23 p. 1070a.$ *TA\ AU)TA\ PRA/GMATA LHPTA\ KAI\ OU)X AI(RETA/, KAI\ OI)KEI=A KAI\ OU)K A)GAQA/, KAI\ A)NWFELH= ME/N, EU)/XRHSTA DE/, KAI\ OU)DE\N ME\N PRO\S H(MA=S, A)RXA\S DE\ TW=N KAQHKO/NTWN O)NOMA/ZONTES. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 83, 10.$10 PA/NTA DE\ TA\ KATA\ FU/SIN <20A)CI/AN>20 E)/XEIN KAI\ PA/NTA TA\ PARA\ FU/SIN <20A)PACI/AN>20. TH\N DE\ A)CI/AN <20LE/GESQAI TRIXW=S, TH/N TE DO/SIN KAI\ TIMH\N>20 KAQ' AU(TO\ KAI\ <20TH\N A)MOIBH\N TOU= DOKIMASTOU=>20: KAI\ TH\N TRI/THN, <20H(\N O( *)ANTI/PATROS E)KLEKTIKH\N PROSAGOREU/EI>20, KAQ' H(\N DIDO/NTWN TW=N PRAGMA/TWN TA/DE TINA\ MA=LLON A)NTI\ TW=NDE AI(ROU/MEQA, OI(=ON U(GI/EIAN A)NTI\ NO/SOU KAI\ ZWH\N A)NTI\ QANA/TOU KAI\ PLOU=TON A)NTI\ PENI/AS. KATA\ TO\ A)NA/LOGON DE\ KAI\ TH\N A)PACI/AN TRIXW=S FASI LE/GESQAI, A)NTITIQEME/NWN TW=N SHMAINOME/NWN TOI=S E)PI\ TH=S PRW/THS A)CI/AS EI)RHME/NOIS. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 84, 4 W.$10 *TH\N DE\ DO/SIN FHSI\N O( *DIOGE/NHS KRI/SIN EI)=NAI, E)F' O(/SON KATA\ FU/SIN E)STI\N H)\ E)F' O(/SON XREI/AN TH=| FU/SEI PARE/XETAI. *TO\ DE\ DOKIMASTOU=, OU)X W(S LE/GETAI TA\ PRA/GMATA DOKIMASTA\ PARALAMBA/NESQAI, A)LL' W(S DOKIMASTH/N FAMEN EI)=NAI TO\N TA\ PRA/GMATA DOKIMA/ZONTA: TH=S OU)=N A)MOIBH=S TO\N TOIOU=TO/N FHSI DOKIMASTH\N EI)=NAI. *KAI\ TAU/TAS ME\N TA\S DU/O A)CI/AS KAQ' A(\S LE/GOME/N TINA TH=| A)CI/A| PROH=XQAI, TRI/THN DE/ FHSIN EI)=NAI, KAQ' H(/N FAMEN A)CI/WMA/ TINA E)/XEIN KAI\ A)CI/AN, H(/PER PERI\ A)DIA/FORA OU) GI/NETAI, A)LLA\ PERI\ MO/NA TA\ SPOUDAI=A. *XRH=SQAI D' H(MA=S FHSIN E)NI/OTE TW=| O)NO/MATI TH=S A)CI/AS A)NTI\ TOU= E)PIBA/LLONTOS: W(S E)N TW=| TH=S DIKAIOSU/NHS O(/RW| PAREI/LHPTAI, O(/TAN LE/GHTAI EI)=NAI E(/CIS A)PONEMHTIKH\ TOU= KAT' A)CI/AN E(KA/STW|: E)/STI GA\R OI(=ON TOU= E)PIBA/LLONTOS E(KA/STW|. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt VII 105.$10 TW=N A)DIAFO/RWN TA\ ME\N LE/GOUSI <20PROHG-ME/NA>20, TA\ DE\ <20A)POPROHGME/NA>20: PROHGME/NA ME\N TA\ E)/XONTA A)CI/AN, A)POPROHG-ME/NA DE\ TA\ A)PACI/AN E)/XONTA. @<20A)CI/AN>20 DE\ TH\N ME/N TINA LE/GOUSI <20SU/MBLHSIN PRO\S TO\N O(MOLOGOU/-MENON BI/ON>20, H(/TIS E)STI\ PERI\ PA=N A)GAQO/N, TH\N DE\ EI)=NAI ME/SHN TINA DU/NAMIN H)\ <20XREI/AN SUMBALLOME/NHN PRO\S TO\N KATA\ FU/SIN BI/ON>20, O(/MOION EI)PEI=N H(/N TINA PROSFE/RETAI PRO\S TO\N KATA\ FU/SIN BI/ON PLOU=TOS H)\ U(GI/EIA: TH\N D' EI)=NAI A)CI/AN <20A)MOIBH\N DOKIMASTOU=>20, H(\N A)\N O( E)/MPEIROS TW=N PRAGMA/TWN TA/CH|, O(/MOION EI)PEI=N A)MEI/BESQAI PUROU\S PRO\S TA\S SU\N H(MIO/NW| KRIQA/S. @1 @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 106.$10 <20PROHGME/NA>20 ME\N OU)=N EI)=NAI A(\ KAI\ A)CI/AN E)/XEI, OI(=ON <20E)PI\ ME\N TW=N YUXIKW=N>20 EU)FUI/+AN, TE/XNHN, PROKOPH\N KAI\ TA\ O(/MOIA: <20E)PI\ DE\ TW=N SWMATIKW=N>20 ZWH/N, U(GI/EIAN, R(W/MHN, EU)ECI/AN, A)RTIO/THTA, KA/LLOS: <20E)PI\ DE\ TW=N E)KTO\S>20 PLOU=TON, DO/CAN, EU)GE/NEIAN KAI\ TA\ O(/MOIA. <20A)POPROHG-ME/NA>20 DE\ E)PI\ ME\N TW=N YUXIKW=N A)FUI/+AN, A)TEXNI/AN KAI\ TA\ O(/MOIA: E)PI\ DE\ TW=N SWMATIKW=N QA/NATON, NO/SON, A)SQE/NEIAN, KAXECI/AN, PH/RWSIN, AI)=SXOS KAI\ TA\ O(/MOIA: E)PI\ DE\ TW=N E)KTO\S PENI/AN, A)DOCI/AN, DUSGE/NEIAN KAI\ TA\ PARAPLH/SIA. <20OU)/TE DE\ PROH/XQH OU)/TE A)POPROH/XQH>20 TA\ OU)DETE/RWS E)/XONTA. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 84, 18.$10 *TW=N D' A)CI/AN E)XO/NTWN TA\ ME\N E)/XEIN POLLH\N A)CI/AN, TA\ DE\ BRAXEI=AN. *(OMOI/WS DE\ KAI\ TW=N A)PACI/AN E)XO/NTWN A(\ ME\N E)/XEIN POLLH\N A)PACI/AN, A(\ DE\ BRAXEI=AN. *TA\ ME\N [2OU)=N]2 POLLH\N E)/XONTA A)CI/AN PROHGME/NA LE/GESQAI, TA\ DE\ POLLH\N A)PACI/AN A)POPROHGME/NA, *ZH/NWNOS TAU/TAS TA\S O)NOMASI/AS QEME/NOU PRW/TOU TOI=S PRA/GMASI. *PROHGME/NON D' EI)=NAI LE/GOUSIN, O(\ A)DIA/FORON [2O)\N]2 E)KLEGO/MEQA KATA\ PROHGOU/MENON LO/GON. *TO\N D' O(/MOION LO/GON E)PI\ TW=| A)POPROHGME/NW| EI)=NAI, KAI\ TA\ PARADEI/GMATA KATA\ TH\N A)NALOGI/AN TAU)TA/. *OU)DE\N DE\ TW=N A)GAQW=N EI)=NAI PROHGME/NON DIA\ TO\ TH\N MEGI/STHN A)CI/AN AU)TA\ E)/XEIN. *TO\ DE\ PROHGME/NON, TH\N DEUTE/RAN XW/RAN KAI\ A)CI/AN E)/XON, SUNEG-GI/ZEIN PWS TH=| TW=N A)GAQW=N FU/SEI: OU)DE\ GA\R E)N AU)LH=| TW=N PROHGME/NWN EI)=NAI TO\N BASILE/A, A)LLA\ TOU\S MET' AU)TO\N TETAGME/NOUS. *PROHGME/NA DE\ LE/GESQAI, OU) TW=| PRO\S EU)DAIMONI/AN TINA\ SUMBA/LLESQAI SUNERGEI=N TE PRO\S AU)TH/N, A)LLA\ TW=| A)NAGKAI=ON EI)=NAI TOU/TWN TH\N E)KLOGH\N POIEI=SQAI PARA\ TA\ A)POPROHGME/NA. @&10Cicero de finibus III 50. cum esset satis constitutum id solum &10esse bonum, quod esset honestum, et id malum solum, quod turpe, tum &10inter illa, quae nihil valerent ad beate misereve vivendum, aliquid tamen &10quod differret esse voluerunt, ut essent eorum alia aestimabilia, alia contra, &10alia neutrum. 51. Quae autem aestimanda essent, eorum <21in aliis satis &10esse causae, quam ob rem quibusdam anteponerentur>21, ut in vale-&10tudine, ut in integritate sensuum, ut in doloris vacuitate, ut gloriae, divi-&10tiarum, similium rerum, alia autem non esse eius modi; itemque eorum &10quae nulla aestimatione digna essent, partim satis habere causae, quam &10ob rem reicerentur, ut dolorem, morbum, sensuum amissionem, pauper-&10tatem, ignominiam, similia horum, partim non item. Hinc est illud ex-&10ortum quod Zeno$10 PROHGME/NON&10 contraque quod$10 A)POPROHGME/NON&10 nominavit. &10@Cicero de finibus III 53. Quoniam autem omne, quod est bo-&10num, primum locum tenere dicimus, necesse est nec bonum esse nec ma-&10lum hoc, <21quod praepositum>21 vel praecipuum nominamus. Idque ita defi-&10nimus%10 <21quod sit indifferens cum aestimatione mediocri>21. __ @1 &10Neque enim illud fieri poterat ullo modo, ut nihil relinqueretur in mediis, &10quod aut secundum naturam esset aut contra, nec cum id relinqueretur, &10nihil in his poni, quod satis aestimabile esset, nec hoc posito non aliqua &10esse praeposita. __54. atque etiam ab iis__hoc simile ponitur%10 Ut &10enim, inquiunt, si hoc fingamus esse quasi finem et ultimum, ita iacere &10talum, ut rectus assistat, qui ita talus erit iactus, ut cadat rectus, prae-&10positum quiddam habebit ad finem, qui aliter, contra, neque tamen illa &10praepositio tali ad eum quem dixi finem pertinebit, sic ea quae sunt prae-&10posita, referuntur illa quidem ad finem, sed ad eius vim naturamque nihil &10pertinent. @&10Stobaeus ecl. p. 75, 1 W.$10 *DIAFE/REIN DE\ LE/GOUSIN AI(RETO\N KAI\ LHPTO/N. *AI(RETO\N ME\N GA\R EI)=NAI TO\ O(RMH=S AU)TOTELOU=S KINHTIKO/N, [2LHPTO\N DE\ O(\ EU)LOGI/STWS E)KLEGO/MEQA]2. *(/OSW| DE\ DIAFE/REI TO\ AI(RETO\N TOU= LHPTOU=, TOSOU/-TW| KAI\ TO\ [2KAQ']2 AU(/Q' AI(RETO\N TOU= KAQ' AU(TO\ LHPTOU=, KAI\ KAQO/LOU TO\ A)GA-QO\N TOU= A)CI/AN E)/XONTOS. @&10Cicero de finibus IV 39 [1i. e. Antiochus contra Stoicos pugnans]1. &10Naturalem enim appetitionem, quam vocant$10 O(RMH/N,&10 itemque officium, ipsam &10etiam virtutem volunt esse earum rerum, quae secundum naturam sunt. &10Cum autem ad summum bonum volunt pervenire, transiliunt omnia et &10duo nobis opera pro uno relinquunt, <21ut alia sumamus, alia expeta-&10mus>21, potius quam uno fine utrumque concluderent. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 80, 14 W.$10 *)/ETI DE\ TW=N A)DIAFO/RWN TA\ ME\N PLEI/W A)CI/AN E)/XEIN, TA\ D' E)LA/TTW: KAI\ <20TA\ ME\N KAQ' AU(TA/, TA\ DE\ POIHTIKA/>20: KAI\ TA\ ME\N PROHGME/NA, TA\ D' A)POPROHGME/NA, TA\ D' OU)DETE/RWS E)/XONTA. *PROHGME/NA ME/N, O(/SA A)DIA/FORA O)/NTA POLLH\N E)/XEI A)CI/AN, W(S E)N A)DIAFO/ROIS: A)POPROHGME/NA DE/, O(/SA POLLH\N E)/XEI A)PACI/AN O(MOI/WS: OU)/TE DE\ PROHGME/NA OU)/TE A)POPROHGME/NA, O(/SA MH/TE POLLH\N E)/XEI [2A)CI/AN MH/TE]2 A)PACI/AN. @&10Cicero de finibus III 56. Haec quae praeposita dicimus, <21par-&10tim sunt per se ipsa praeposita, partim quod aliquid efficiunt, &10partim utrumque>21; per se, ut quidam habitus oris et vultus, ut status, &10ut motus, in quibus sunt et praeponenda quaedam et reicienda; alia ob &10eam rem praeposita dicentur, quod ex se aliquid efficiant, ut pecunia, alia &10autem ob utramque rem, ut integri sensus, ut bona valetudo. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 107.$10 E)/TI TW=N <20PROHGME/NWN>20 TA\ ME\N DI' AU(TA\ PROH=KTAI, TA\ DE\ DI' E(/TERA, TA\ DE\ KAI\ DI' AU(TA\ KAI\ DI' E(/TERA. <20DI' AU(TA\>20 ME\N EU)FUI/+A, PROKOPH\ KAI\ TA\ O(/MOIA, <20DI' E(/TERA>20 DE\ PLOU=TOS, EU)GE/NEIA KAI\ TA\ O(/MOIA, <20DI' AU(TA\ DE\ KAI\ DI' E(/TERA>20 I)SXU/S, EU)AISQHSI/A, A)RTIO/THS: DI' AU(TA\ ME/N, O(/TI KATA\ FU/SIN E)STI/, DI' E(/TERA DE/, O(/TI PERIPOIEI= XREI/AS OU)K O)LI/GAS. O(MOI/WS DE\ E)/XEI KAI\ TO\ A)POPROHGME/NON KATA\ TO\N E)NANTI/ON LO/GON. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 80, 22.$10 TW=N DE\ <20PROHGME/NWN>20 TA\ ME\N EI)=NAI PERI\ YUXH/N, TA\ DE\ PERI\ SW=MA, TA\ D' E)KTO/S. <20PERI\ YUXH\N ME\N EI)=NAI>20 TA\ TOI-AU=TA: EU)FUI/+AN, PROKOPH/N, MNH/MHN, O)CU/THTA DIANOI/AS, E(/CIN KAQ' H(\N E)PI/MONOI/ @1 EI)SIN E)PI\ TW=N KAQHKO/NTWN KAI\ TE/XNAS O(/SAI DU/NANTAI SUNERGEI=N E)PI\ PLEI=ON PRO\S TO\N KATA\ FU/SIN BI/ON: <20PERI\ SW=MA>20 D' EI)=NAI PROHGME/NA U(GI/EIAN, EU)AI-SQHSI/AN KAI\ TA\ PARAPLH/SIA TOU/TOIS: <20TW=N D' E)KTO\S>20 GONEI=S, TE/KNA, KTH=SIN SU/MMETRON, A)PODOXH\N PARA\ A)NQRW/PWN. @<20TW=N D' A)POPROHGME/NWN PERI\ YUXH\N>20 ME\N EI)=NAI TA\ E)NANTI/A TOI=S EI)-RHME/NOIS: <20PERI\ SW=MA DE\ KAI\ E)KTO\S>20 TA\ O(MOI/WS A)NTITIQE/MENA TOI=S EI)RHME/NOIS PERI/ TE SW=MA KAI\ TOI=S E)KTO\S PROHGME/NOIS. @<20OU)/TE DE\ PROHGME/NA OU)/T' A)POPROHGME/NA PERI\ YUXH\N>20 [2ME\N]2 FAN-TASI/AN KAI\ SUGKATA/QESIN KAI\ O(/SA TOIAU=TA: <20PERI\ DE\ SW=MA>20 LEUKO/THTA KAI\ MELANO/THTA KAI\ XAROPO/THTA KAI\ H(DONH\N PA=SAN KAI\ PO/NON KAI\ EI)/ TI A)/LLO TOI-OU=TO. <20TW=N D' E)KTO\S>20 OU)/TE PROHGME/NA [2OU)/TE A)POPROHGME/NA]2 EI)=NAI TA\ TOI-AU=TA, O(/SA EU)TELH= O)/NTA KAI\ MHDE\N XRH/SIMON PROSFERO/MENA MIKRA\N PANTELW=S E)/XEI TH\N A)F' AU(TW=N XREI/AN. @TH=S DE\ YUXH=S OU)/SHS KURIWTE/RAS TOU= SW/MATOS KAI\ PRO\S TO\ KATA\ FU/SIN ZH=N FASI\ <20TA\ PERI\ TH\N YUXH\N KATA\ FU/SIN O)/NTA KAI\ PROHGME/NA PLEI/ONA TH\N A)CI/AN E)/XEIN TW=N PERI\ SW=MA KAI\ TW=N E)KTO/S>20, OI(=ON EU)-FUI/+AN YUXH=S PRO\S A)RETH\N U(PERA/GEIN TH=S TOU= SW/MATOS EU)FUI/+AS KAI\ O(MOI/WS E)PI\ TW=N A)/LLWN E)/XEIN. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 3o p. 1048a.$8 <20*)EN DE\ TW=| PRW/TW| PERI\ *)AGAQW=N>20 TRO/PON TINA\ SUGXWREI= KAI\ DI/DWSI TOI=S BOULO-ME/NOIS TA\ PROHGME/NA KALEI=N A)GAQA/, KAI\ KAKA\ TA)NANTI/A, TAU/TAIS TAI=S LE/CESIN: "1<20*EI)/ TIS BOU/LETAI KATA\ TA\S TOIAU/TAS PARALLAGA\S TO\ ME\N A)GAQO\N AU)TW=N LE/GEIN>20 [1&sc. $8<20TW=N A)DIAFO/RWN]1, TO\ DE\ KAKO/N, E)PI\ TAU=TA FERO/MENOS TA\ PRA/GMATA KAI\ MH\ A)/LLWS A)POPLANW/-MENOS %2 E)N ME\N TOI=S SHMAINOME/NOIS OU) DIAPI/PTONTOS AU)TOU=, TA\ D' A)/LLA STOXAZOME/NOU TH=S KATA\ TA\S O)NOMASI/AS SUNHQEI/AS>20."2 @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 30 p. 1047e [1Antecedit Ze-&nonis de$ PROHGME/NW|& sententia$]1. *)ALL' O( *XRU/SIPPOS E)/TI MA=LLON TO\ PRA=GMA DUSDIA/QETON PEPOI/HKEN: <20O(TE\ ME\N GA/R FHSI>20 "1MAI/NESQAI TOU\S TO\N PLOU=TON KAI\ TH\N U(GI/EIAN KAI\ TH\N A)PONI/AN KAI\ TH\N O(LOKLHRI/AN TOU= SW/MATOS E)N MHDENI\ POIOUME/NOUS, MHD' A)NTEXOME/NOUS TW=N TOIOU/TWN"2 <20O(TE\ DE\>20 PARAQE/MENOS TA\ TOU= *(HSIO/DOU [1&Op. et D. 299$]1 @*)ERGA/ZEU, *PE/RSH, DI=ON GE/NOS E)PIPEFW/NHKEN O(/TI TA)NANTI/A PARAINEI=N MANIKO/N E)STI, TO\ @*MH\ E)RGA/ZEU, *PE/RSH, DI=ON GE/NOS. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 17 p. 1041e.$ *)EN DE\ TW=| PRW/TW| [1&scil.$ TW=N *PROTREPTIKW=N]1 "1<20TOU=TON TO\N LO/GON FHSI\N A)PO\ TW=N A)/LLWN A(PA/NTWN A)FE/LKEIN TO\N A)/NQRWPON, W(S OU)DE\N @1 O)/NTWN PRO\S H(MA=S OU)DE\ SUNERGOU/NTWN PRO\S EU)DAIMONI/AN OU)DE/N>20."2 @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 30 p. 1048a.$ *OU(/TW DE\ TO\ PRO-HGME/NON TW=| A)GAQW=| SUNAGAGW\N E)GGU\S E)NTAU=QA KAI\ SUMMI/CAS E)N E(TE/ROIS PA/LIN "1<20OU)DE\N EI)=NAI/ FHSI TOU/TWN KAQO/LOU PRO\S H(MA=S, A)LL' A)POSPA=N TO\N LO/GON H(MA=S KAI\ A)POSTRE/FEIN A(PA/NTWN TW=N TOI-OU/TWN>20."2 TAU=TA GA\R <20E)N TW=| PRW/TW| PERI\ TOU= *PROTRE/PESQAI>20 GE/GRAFEN. @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 5 p. 1060E.$ *EI) DE\ W(S *XRU/SIPPOS <20E)N TW=| PRW/TW| PERI\ TOU= *PROTRE/PESQAI>20 GE/GRAFEN, E)N TW=| KAT' A)RE-TH\N BIOU=N MO/NON E)STI\ TO\ EU)DAIMO/NWS, <20TW=N A)/LLWN, FHSI/N, OU)DE\N O)/NTWN PRO\S H(MA=S OU)D' EI)S TOU=TO SUNERGOU/NTWN>20 &etc. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 79, 18 W.$10 KAI\ TA\ ME\N EI)=NAI KATA\ FU/SIN, TA\ DE\ PARA\ FU/SIN, TA\ DE\ OU)/TE PARA\ FU/SIN OU)/TE KATA\ FU/SIN. <20KATA\ FU/SIN ME\N OU)=N>20 TA\ TOIAU=TA: U(GI/EIAN, I)SXU/N, AI)SQHTHRI/WN A)RTIO/THTA, KAI\ TA\ PARA-PLH/SIA TOU/TOIS: <20PARA\ FU/SIN>20 DE\ TA\ TOIAU=TA: NO/SON, A)SQE/NEIAN, PH/RWSIN KAI\ TA\ TOIAU=TA: <20OU)/TE DE\ PARA\ FU/SIN OU)/TE KATA\ FU/SIN>20: YUXH=S KATA/-STASIN KAI\ SW/MATOS, KAQ' H(\N H( ME/N E)STI FANTASIW=N YEUDW=N DEKTIKH/, TO\ DE\ TRAUMA/TWN KAI\ PHRW/SEWN DEKTIKO/N, KAI\ TA\ TOU/TOIS O(/MOIA. *POIEI=SQAI DE\ LE/GOUSI TO\N PERI\ TOU/TWN LO/GON [2A)PO\]2 TW=N PRW/TWN KATA\ FU/SIN KAI\ PARA\ FU/SIN. *TO\ GA\R DIAFE/RON KAI\ TO\ A)DIA/FORON TW=N PRO/S TI LEGOME/NWN EI)=NAI. *DIO/TI KA)/N, FASI/, LE/GWMEN A)DIA/FORA TA\ SWMATIKA\ KAI\ TA\ E)KTO/S, PRO\S TO\ EU)SXH-MO/NWS ZH=N [1E)N W(=|PE/R E)STI TO\ EU)DAIMO/NWS]1 A)DIA/FORA/ FAMEN AU)TA\ EI)=NAI, OU) MA\ *DI/A PRO\S TO\ KATA\ FU/SIN E)/XEIN OU)DE\ PRO\S O(RMH\N KAI\ A)FORMH/N. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 82, 11 W.$10 *TW=N DE\ KATA\ FU/SIN A)DIAFO/RWN O)/N-TWN TA\ ME/N E)STI PRW=TA KATA\ FU/SIN, TA\ DE\ KATA\ METOXH/N. <20*PRW=TA ME/N E)STI KATA\ FU/SIN>20 KI/NHSIS H)\ SXE/SIS KATA\ TOU\S SPERMATIKOU\S LO/GOUS GINO-ME/NH, OI(=ON [2A)RTIO/THS KAI\]2 U(GI/EIA KAI\ AI)/SQHSIS [1LE/GW DE\ TH\N KATA/LHYIN]1 KAI\ I)SXU/S. <20*KATA\ METOXH\N>20 DE/, O(/SA METE/XEI KINH/SEWS KAI\ SXE/SEWS KATA\ TOU\S SPERMATIKOU\S LO/GOUS, OI(=ON XEI\R A)RTI/A KAI\ SW=MA U(GIEINO\N KAI\ AI)SQH/SEIS MH\ PEPHRWME/NAI. *(OMOI/WS DE\ KAI\ TW=N PARA\ FU/SIN KATA\ TO\ A)NA/LOGON. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 82, 20 W.$10 <20PA/NTA DE\ [2TA\]2 KATA\ FU/SIN LHPTA\ EI)=NAI KAI\ PA/NTA TA\ PARA\ FU/SIN A)/LHPTA>20. TW=N DE\ KATA\ FU/SIN TA\ ME\N KAQ' AU(TA\ LHPTA\ EI)=NAI, TA\ DE\ DI' E(/TERA. <20KAQ' AU(TA\>20 ME\N, O(/SA E)STI\N O(RMH=S KINHTIKA\ KATATREPTIKW=S E)F' E(AUTA\ H)\ E)PI\ TO\ A)NTE/XESQAI AU)TW=N, OI(=ON U(GI/EIAN, EU)AISQHSI/AN, A)PONI/AN KAI\ KA/LLOS SW/MATOS. <20POIHTIKA\>20 [2DE\]2 O(/SA @1 E)STI\N O(RMH=S KINHTIKA\ A)N[2EN]2EKTIKW=S E)F' E(/TERA KAI\ MH\ KATATREPTIKW=S, OI(=ON PLOU=TON, DO/CAN KAI\ TA\ TOU/TOIS O(/MOIA. PARAPLHSI/WS DE\ KAI\ TW=N PARA\ FU/SIN TA\ ME\N EI)=NAI KAQ' AU(TA\ A)/LHPTA, TA\ DE\ TW=| POIHTIKA\ EI)=NAI TW=N KAQ' AU(TA\ A)LH/PTWN. @&10Cicero de finibus III 20. Aestimabile esse dicunt__id quod &10aut ipsum secundum naturam sit aut tale quid efficiat, ut selectione dig-&10num propterea sit, quod aliquod pondus habeat dignum aestimatione, quam &10illi $10A)CI/AN &10vocant, contraque inaestimabile, quod sit superiori contrarium. @&10Arrianus Epict. dissert. I 4, 27.$10 EI) GA\R E)CAPATHQE/NTA TINA\ E)/DEI MAQEI=N, O(/TI TW=N E)KTO\S A)PROAIRE/TWN OU)DE/N E)STI PRO\S H(MA=S, E)GW\ ME\N H)/QELON TH\N A)PA/THN TAU/THN, E)C H(=S H)/MELLON EU)RO/WS KAI\ A)TARA/XWS BIW/SESQAI. __ TI/ OU)=N H(MI=N PARE/XEI <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20; "1I(/NA GNW=|S, FHSI/N, O(/TI OU) YEUDH= TAU=TA/ E)STIN, E)C W(=N H( EU)/ROIA/ E)STI KAI\ A)PA/QEIA, A(/PANTA LA/BE MOU TA\ BIBLI/A KAI\ GNW/SH| W(S [2A)LHQH=]2 TE KAI\ SU/MFWNA/ E)STI TH=| FU/SEI TA\ A)PAQH= ME POIOU=NTA."2 @&10Alexander Aphrod. de anima libri mant. p. 167, 13 Bruns.$10 E)/TI TA\ OI)KEI=A [2KAI\]2 PROHGME/NA KAI\ EU)/XRHSTA KAI\ A)CI/AN E)/XONTA PRO\S TI/ POTE TAU/-TAS E)/XEI TA\S O)NOMASI/AS, EI) MHDE\N SUNERGEI= PRO\S EU)DAIMONI/AN; PA=N GA\R TO\ PROHGME/NON PRO/S TI PROH=KTAI KAI\ TW=| FORO\N EI)=NAI PRO\S TO\ PROKEI/MENON MA=L-LON A)/LLOU, DIA\ TOU=TO LE/GETAI KAI\ PROH=XQAI PRO\S TO\ TE/LOS KAI\ H( PROAGWGH\ AU)TW=N DH=LON W(S SUNERGEI= PRO\S EU)DAIMONI/AN. <20EI) DE\ MH\ PRO\S TOU=TO SUN-ERGEI=, PRO\S DE\ TO\N KATA\ FU/SIN BI/ON>20, A)/CION E)RE/SQAI PERI\ TOU= KATA\ FU/SIN AU)TOU\S BI/OU, PO/TERON OU(=TOS A)GAQO/N E)STIN, H)\ OU)K A)GAQO\N ME/N, OI)KEI=ON DE\ KAI\ AU)TO\ KAI\ PROHGME/NON, H)\ A)LLO/TRION KAI\ A)POPROHGME/NON, H)\ A)R)R(EPE\S O(/LWS. PARA\ GA\R TAU=TA OU)DE\N OI(=O/N TE A)POKRI/NASQAI. OU) GA\R DH\ KAKO/N GE E)ROU=SIN AU)TO/N. EI) ME\N OU)=N A)GAQO\N__OU) MO/NON E)/STAI TO\ KALO\N A)GA-QO/N: KAI\ GA\R O( KATA\ FU/SIN BI/OS. @&10Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 4 p. 1060c. Stoicos dicit%10$10 TOU\S TA\ KATA\ FU/SIN A)DIA/FORA NOMI/ZONTAS KAI\ MH/Q' U(GI/EIAN MH/T' EU)ECI/AN MH/TE KA/L-LOS MH/T' I)SXU\N H(GOUME/NOUS AI(RETA\ MHD' W)FE/LIMA MHDE\ LUSITELH= MHDE\ SUM-PLHRWTIKA\ TH=S KATA\ FU/SIN TELEIO/THTOS: MH/TE TA)NANTI/A FEUKTA\ KAI\ BLABERA/, PHRW/SEIS A)LGHDO/NAS AI)/SXH NO/SOUS: W(=N AU)TOI\ LE/GOUSI PRO\S A(\ ME\N A)LLOTRIOU=N PRO\S A(\ D' OI)KEIOU=N H(MA=S TH\N FU/SIN__KAI\ O(\ MEI=ZO/N E)STIN, OI)KEIOU=N E)PI\ TOSOU=TO KAI\ A)LLOTRIOU=N, W(/STE TW=N ME\N MH\ TUGXA/NONTAS TOI=S DE\ PERIPI/PTON-TAS EU)LO/GWS E)CA/GEIN TOU= ZH=N E(AUTOU\S KAI\ TO\N BI/ON A)POLE/GESQAI. @&Alexander Aphrod. comm. in Aristot. Topica I p. 43. Ald. &p. 79, 5 Wal.$ KAI\ PO/TERON H( U(GI/EIA A)GAQO\N H)\ OU)/, W(S <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 LE/GEI. @[&Plutarchus pers. de nobilitate cp. 17.$ <20*)ALLA\ TO\N *XRU/SIP-PON>20 A)FW=MEN, OU)X A(/PAC E)NANTIOU/MENON E(AUTW=|, W(/SPER <20E)N TW=| PRW/TW| @1 PERI\ *)AGAQW=N>20 KAI\ <20E)N TW=| PERI\ *(RHTORIKH=S>20, U(GI/EIAN E)A/N TIS TOI=S A)GAQOI=S E)NARIQMH=| OU)K A)NTIMA/XESQAI, KAI\ E)N TW=| PERI\ <20*TW=N *KAQ' *AU(TA\ *AI(RETW=N>20 OU)DE\ MANI/AS A)POSTEREI= TOU\S TOU/TWN KATAFRONOU=NTAS]. @&10Theodoret. graec. affect. cur. p. 153, 45.$10 OI( DE\ *STWI+KOI\ E)NANTI/A TOU/TOIS A)/NTIKRUS E)YHFI/SANTO. *TO\ GA\R A)KOLOU/QWS TH=| FU/SEI ZH=N W(RI/SANTO TE/LOS, KAI\ <20TH\N YUXH\N E)/FASAN MHDE\N U(PO\ TOU= SW/MATOS H)\ W)FELEI=SQAI H)\ BLA/PTESQAI: OU)/TE GA\R EI)S A)RETH\N AU)TH\N H( U(GEI/A MH\ BOULOME/NHN BIA/ZETAI, OU)/TE EI)S KAKI/AN PARA\ GNW/MHN H( NO/SOS KAQE/LKEI>20: A)DIA/-FORA GA\R TAU=TA E)/LEGON EI)=NAI. *)EKEI=NO DE/ GE AU)TW=N KOMIDH=| TOLMHRO/N: A)N-QRW/POU GA\R KAI\ QEOU= TH\N AU)TH\N E)/LEGON A)RETH/N. @&10Clem. Al. Strom. IV 5 p. 572 Pott.$10 *QAUMA/ZEIN DE\ A)/CION KAI\ TW=N *STWI+KW=N OI(/ TINES FASI/, MHDE\N TH\N YUXH\N U(PO\ TOU= SW/MATOS DIATI/-QESQAI MH/TE PRO\S KAKI/AN U(PO\ TH=S NO/SOU, MH/TE PRO\S A)RETH\N U(PO\ TH=S U(GIEI/AS. A)LL' A)MFO/TERA TAU=TA LE/GOUSIN A)DIA/FORA EI)=NAI. @&10Seneca ep. 87, 12. Quod bonum est, bonos facit. nam et in &10arte musica quod bonum est, bonum facit musicum. <21fortuita>21 bonum &10non faciunt%10 ergo non snnt bona. &10@ibid. 15. Quod contemptissimo cuique contingere ac turpissimo potest, &10bonum non est. <21opes>21 autem et lenoni et lanistae contingunt%10 ergo non &10sunt bona. &10@ibid. 22. Bonum ex malo non fit%10 divitiae fiunt. fiunt autem ex &10avaritia%10 divitiae ergo non sunt bonum. &10@ibid. 28. Quod dum consequi volumus, in multa mala incidimus, id &10bonum non est. dum divitias autem consequi volumus, in multa mala &10incidimus%10 ergo <21divitiae>21 bonum non sunt. @&10Alexander Aphrod. Comm. in Aristot. Topica II p. 107 Ald. &10p. 201, 21 Wal.$10 EI) GA\R TOU=TO, DO/CEI KALW=S U(PO\ <20TW=N A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 LE/GESQAI: "1TO\ DIA\ KAKOU= GINO/MENON OU)K E)/STIN A)GAQO/N: PLOU=TOS DE\ KAI\ DIA\ PORNOBOSKI/AS KAKOU= O)/NTOS GI/NETAI: OU)K A)/RA O( PLOU=TOS A)GAQO/N."2 @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 20 p. 1043e.$ *KAI/TOI POL-LAXOU= ME\N A)POKNAI/EI TAU=T' E)PAINW=N: [1&Eur. inc. fab. fr. 884 N$]1 @*)EPEI\ TI/ DEI= BROTOI=SI PLH\N DUOI=N MO/NWN, @*DH/MHTROS A)KTH=S PW/MATOS Q' U(DRHXO/OU; <20E)N DE\ TOI=S PERI\ *FU/SEWS>20 LE/GEI "1<20TO\N SOFO\N EI) TH\N MEGI/STHN OU)SI/AN A)POBA/LOI, DRAXMH\N MI/AN E)KBEBLHKE/NAI DO/CEIN>20."2 @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 30 p. 1048b.$ <20*)EN DE\ TW=| TRI/TW| PERI\ *FU/SEWS MAKARI/ZESQAI/ FHSIN E)NI/OUS BASILEU/ONTAS KAI\ PLOUTOU=NTAS, O(/MOION EI) XRUSAI=S A)MI/SI XRW/MENOI KAI\ XRUSOI=S KRASPE/DOIS E)MAKARI/ZONTO: TW=| D' A)GAQW=| TO\ TH\N OU)SI/AN A)PO-BALEI=N OI(ONEI\ DRAXMH\N A)POBALEI=N KAI\ TO\ NOSH=SAI OI(=ON PROS-KO/YAI>20. @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 22 p. 1069c.$ A)NWFELW=N PRAGMA/- @1TWN KAI\ A)DIAFO/RWN: TOIAU=TA GA\R TA\ KATA\ FU/SIN, KAI\ TA\ E)KTO\S E)/TI MA=LLON: <20EI)/GE KRASPE/DOIS KAI\ A)MI/SI XRUSAI=S, KAI\ NH\ *DI/A LHKU/-QOIS, O(/TAN TU/XWSI, PARABA/LLOUSI TO\N ME/GISTON PLOU=TON>20. @&10Cicero de finibus III 17. In principiis autem naturalibus <21ple-&10rique Stoici>21 non putant <21voluptatem>21 esse ponendam. @&10Sextus adv. math. XI 73.$10 OI(=ON <20TH\N H(DONH\N>20 O( ME\N *)EPI/KOUROS A)GAQO\N EI)=NAI/ FHSIN, O( DE\ EI)PW\N "1MANEI/HN MA=LLON H)\ H(SQEI/HN"2 KAKO/N, <20OI( DE\ A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S A)DIA/FORON KAI\ OU) PROHGME/NON>20, A)LLA\ *KLEA/NQHS ME\N MH/TE KATA\ FU/SIN AU)TH\N EI)=NAI MH/TE A)CI/AN E)/XEIN E)N TW=| BI/W|, KAQA/PER DE\ TO\ KA/LLUNTRON KATA\ FU/SIN MH\ EI)=NAI, O( DE\ <20*)ARXE/DHMOS>20 KATA\ FU/SIN ME\N EI)=NAI W(S TA\S E)N MASXA/LH| TRI/XAS, OU)XI\ DE\ KAI\ A)CI/AN E)/XEIN, *PANAI/TIOS DE\ TINA\ ME\N KATA\ FU/SIN U(PA/RXEIN, TINA\ DE\ PARA\ FU/SIN. @&Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 103.$ A)LL' OU)DE\ TH\N H(DONH\N A)GAQO/N FASIN *(EKA/TWN TE E)N TW=| Q# PERI\ A)GAQW=N KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 E)N <20TOI=S PERI\ *(HDONH=S>20: EI)=NAI GA\R KAI\ AI)SXRA\S H(DONA/S: MHDE\N DE\ AI)SXRO\N EI)=NAI A)GAQO/N. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 15 p. 1040d.$ <20*)EN DE\ TOI=S PRO\S *PLA/TWNA>20 [1&scil.$ <20PERI\ *DIKAIOSU/NHS>20]1 KATHGORW=N AU)TOU= DOKOU=N-TOS A)GAQO\N A)POLIPEI=N TH\N U(GI/EIAN "1<20OU) MO/NON TH\N DIKAIOSU/NHN>20, FHSI/N, <20A)LLA\ KAI\ TH\N MEGALOYUXI/AN A)NAIREI=SQAI KAI\ TH\N SW-FROSU/NHN KAI\ TA\S A)/LLAS A)RETA\S A(PA/SAS, A)\N H)\ TH\N H(DONH\N H)\ TH\N U(GI/EIAN H)/ TI TW=N A)/LLWN, O(\ MH\ KALO/N E)STIN, A)GAQO\N A)PO-LI/PWMEN.>20"2 @&Cicero de finibus I 11, 39.&3 At etiam Athenis, ut a patre au-&3diebam, facete et urbane Stoicos irridente, statua est in Ceramico <21Chry-&3sippi>21 sedentis, porrecta manu, quae manus significet, illum in hac esse &3rogatiuncula delectatum%10 "1<21Num quidnam manus tua sic affecta, &3quemadmodum affecta nunc est, desiderat? Nihil sane. At, &3si voluptas esset bonum, desideraret? Ita credo. Non est igi-&3tur voluptas bonum>21."2 &3@[1paullo post%10]1 primum tibi recte, Chrysippe, concessum est, nihil &3desiderare manum, cum ita esset affecta%10 secundum non recte, si volup-&3tas esset bonum, fuisse desideraturam. @&Cicero de finibus III 17, 57.&3 De bona autem fama [1quam &3enim appellant$ EU)DOCI/AN,&3 aptius est bonam famam hoc loco appellare &3quam gloriam]1 <21Chrysippus>21 quidem et Diogenes, detracta utilitate, ne &3digitum quidem eius causa porrigendum esse dicebant%10 quibus ego vehe-&3menter assentior. Qui autem post eos fuerunt, cum Carneadem sustinere &3non possent, hanc quam dixi bonam famam ipsam propter se praepo-&3sitam et sumendam esse dixerunt. @1 @&10Seneca epist. ad Lucil. 102, 5. [1probaturus "1claritatem quae post &10mortem contingit bonum esse"2 sic disputat%10]1 &10@at quae a <21dialecticis>21 contra hanc opinionem dicuntur segreganda &10fuerunt et ideo seposita sunt. Nunc quia omnia exigis, omnia quae di-&10cunt, persequar. Deinde singulis occurram. Nisi aliquid praedixero, in-&10tellegi non poterunt, quae refellentur. quid est quod praedicere velim? &10@quaedam <21continua esse corpora>21, ut hominem, quaedam esse <21com-&10posita>21 ut navem, domum, omnia denique, quorum diversae partes iunc-&10tura in unum coactae sunt. quaedam <21ex distantibus>21, quorum adhuc &10membra separata sunt, tanquam exercitus populus senatus. illi enim per &10quos ista corpora efficiuntur, iure aut officio cohaerent, natura diducti et &10singuli sunt. &10@quid est quod etiam nunc praedicere velim? &10@<21nullum bonum putamus esse, quod ex distantibus constat>21. &10uno enim spiritu unum bonum contineri ac regi debet, unum esse unius &10boni principale. &10@hoc si quando desideraveris per se probabitur%10 interim ponendum fuit, &10quia in nos nostra tela mittuntur. &10@"1Dicitis, inquit, nullum bonum ex distantibus esse%10 claritas autem &10ista bonorum virorum secunda opinio est. nam quomodo fama non est &10unius sermo nec infamia unius mala existimatio, sic nec claritas uni bono &10placuisse. consentire in hoc plures insignes et spectabiles viri debent, ut &10claritas sit. haec autem ex iudiciis plurium efficitur, id est distantium%10 &10ergo non est bonum. Claritas, inquit, laus est a bonis bono reddita. laus &10oratio. oratio vox est aliquid significans%10 vox autem, licet virorum sit &10bonorum, non est bonum etc. ergo claritas bonum non est. __Ad sum-&10mam dicite nobis, utrum laudantis an laudati bonum sit%10 si laudati bo-&10num esse dicitis, tam ridiculam rem facitis, quam si adfirmetis meum esse, &10quod alius bene valeat. sed laudare dignos honesta actio est%10 ita lau-&10dantis bonum est, cuius actio est, non nostrum, qui laudamur%10 atqui hoc &10quaerebatur."2 &10@[1Dein tria argumenta a "1dialectico"2 prolata deinceps a Seneca refel-&10luntur et additur%10]1 &10@`20. Cavillatoribus istis abunde responderimus. sed non debet hoc &10nobis esse propositum arguta disserere et philosophiam in has angustias &10ex sua maiestate detrahere%10 quanto satius est ire aperta via et recta quam &10sibi ipsum flexus disponere, quos cum magna molestia debeas relegere? &10Neque enim quicquam aliud istae disputationes sunt, quam inter se perite &10captantium lusus. @&10Schol. ad Plat. Leg. p. 625 A.$10 KAI\ OI( *STWI+KOI\ PLATWNI/ZONTES KLE/OS FASI\ TO\ E)PI\ TW=N SPOUDAI/WN GENO/MENON DI/KAION, DO/CAN DE\ TH\N E)PI\ TW=N A)SPOU/DWN DO/KHSIN. @&10Commenta Lucani Lib. II 240 ed Us. p. 66. Cunctisque ti-&10mentem securumque sui%10 secundum <21Stoicos>21 qui dicunt vitam contemnen-&10dam esse pro laude pulcrumque esse inpendere gloriae quicquid te scias &10debere naturae. Virgilius "1vitamque volunt pro laude pacisci."2 @1 @&10Clem. Al. Strom. II p. 503 Pott.$10 E)/TI KATA\ ME\N <20TOU\S A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 A)DIA/FORON O(/ TE <20GA/MOS>20 H(/ TE <20PAIDOTROFI/A>20. @&10Theodoret. graec. affect. cur. p. 176, 21.$10 OI( DE\ [2A)PO\]2 TH=S *POI-KI/LHS ME/SHN TINA\ O(DO\N W(/DEUSAN: TOI=S GA\R A)DIAFO/ROIS TO\N <20GA/MON>20 KAI\ TH\N <20PAIDOGONI/AN>20 SUNE/ZEUCAN. @&10Alexander Aphrod. Quaest. IV 1 p. 119, 23 Bruns.$10 PW=S GA\R OU)K A)PEMFAI=NON TO\ O(MOU= ME\N LE/GEIN H(MA=S U(PO\ TH=S FU/SEWS PRO\S TOU=TO [1&10scil.$10 <20TO\ ZH=N>20]1 OI)KEIOU=SQAI KAI\ TH=S E(AUTW=N SWTHRI/AS XA/RIN POIEI=N PA/NTA, O(MOU= DE\ MH\ LE/GEIN [H(MA=S] W(S PRO\S A)GAQO\N AU)TO\ TH\N FU/SIN H(MA=S OI)KEIOU=N. @&10Seneca ep. 85, 30. Quod malum est nocet. quod nocet dete-&10riorem facit. <21dolor et paupertas>21 deteriorem non faciunt%10 ergo mala &10non sunt. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 14 p. 1039ef.$8 E)N AU)TOI=S TOU/TOIS [1&scil. $8E)N TOI=S PERI\ TOU= *PROTRE/PESQAI]1 POTE\ ME\N TOU= *)ANTISQE/-NOUS E)PAINW=N FAI/NETAI TO\ *DEI=N KTA=SQAI NOU=N H)\ BRO/XON: KAI\ TOU= *TUR-TAI/OU TO\ [1&B.P.L. II p. 20]1$8 *PRI\N A)RETH=S PELA/SAI TE/RMASIN H)\ QANA/TOU: ___POTE\ DE\ TO\N *QE/OGNIN E)PANORQOU/MENOS, "1<20*OU)K E)/DEI, FHSI/N, EI)PEI=N: @*XRH\ PENI/HN FEU/GONTA>20 [1&Theogn. 175$]1 <20MA=LLON DE\: @*XRH\ KAKI/AN FEU/GONTA KAI\ E)S BAQUKH/TEA PO/NTON @R(IPTEI=N KAI\ PETRW=N, *KU/RNE, KAT' H)LIBA/TWN>20."2 @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 22 p. 1069d.$ *TO\N TOI/NUN *QE/OGNIN AU)TOI\ PANTELW=S A)GENNH= KAI\ MIKRO\N H(GOU=NTAI LE/GONTA [1&Theogn. 175$]1 *XRH\ PENI/HN FEU/GONTA KAI\ E)S MEGAKH/TEA PO/NTON, @R(IPTEI=N KAI\ PETRW=N, *KU/RNE, KAT' H)LIBA/TWN: OU(/TWS A)PODEILIW=NTA PRO\S TH\N PENI/AN A)DIA/FORON OU)=SAN. @&10Gellius Noct. Att. XII 5, 4. si tanta, inquit, doloris acerbitas &10est, ut__invitum hominem cogat ad gemendum__cur <21dolor apud &10Stoicos indifferens esse dicitur, non malum>21? cur deinde aut Stoi-&10cus homo cogi aliquid potest aut dolor cogere, cum et dolorem Stoici &10nihil cogere et sapientem nihil cogi posse dicant? @1 @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 86, 17$10 <20TO\ DE\ KINOU=N TH\N O(RMH\N>20 OU)DE\N E(/TERON EI)=NAI LE/GOUSIN A)LL' H)\ <20FANTASI/AN O(RMHTIKH\N TOU= KAQH/KONTOS AU)TO/QEN>20, TH\N DE\ O(RMH\N EI)=NAI FORA\N YUXH=S E)PI/ TI KATA\ TO\ GE/NOS. TAU/THS D' E)N EI)/DEI QEWREI=SQAI TH/N TE E)N TOI=S LOGIKOI=S GIGNOME/NHN O(RMH\N KAI\ TH\N E)N TOI=S A)LO/-GOIS ZW/|OIS: OU) KATWNOMASME/NAI D' EI)SI/N: H( <20GA\R O)/RECIS OU)K E)/STI LOGIKH\ O(RMH/, A)LLA\ LOGIKH=S O(RMH=S EI)=DOS>20 TH\N DE\ LOGIKH\N O(RMH\N DEO/NTWS A)/N TIS A)FORI/ZOITO, LE/GWN EI)=NAI FORA\N DIANOI/AS E)PI/ TI TW=N E)N TW=| PRA/TTEIN: TAU/TH| D' A)NTITI/QESQAI A)FORMH/N, FORA/N TINA [2DIANOI/AS A)PO/ TINOS TW=N E)N TW=| PRA/T-TEIN]2. I)DI/WS DE\ KAI\ TH\N O)/ROUSIN O(RMH\N LE/GOUSI, TH=S PRAKTIKH=S O(RMH=S OU)=SAN EI)=DOS. EI)=NAI DE\ <20TH\N O)/ROUSIN FORA\N DIANOI/AS E)PI/ TI ME/LLON>20. W(/STE ME/XRI ME\N TOU/TWN TETRAXW=S O(RMH\N LE/GESQAI, DIXW=S D' A)FORMH/N: PROSTEQEI/SHS DE\ KAI\ TH=S E(/CEWS TH=S O(RMHTIKH=S, H(\N DH\ KAI\ I)DI/WS O(RMH\N LE/GOUSIN, A)F' OU(= SUMBAI/NEI O(RMA=N, PENTAXW=S. @&10Seneca epist. 113, 18. Omne rationale animal nihil agit, nisi primum &10specie alicuius rei inritatum est, deinde impetum cepit, deinde adsensio &10confirmavit hunc impetum. quid sit adsensio dicam. oportet me ambulare%10 &10tunc demum ambulo, cum hoc mihi dixi et adprobavi hanc opinionem meam. &10@Origenes comment. in Matthaeum Tom. III p. 446 Delarue.$10 O(/PER KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N A)/LLWN SUMBE/BHKEN, W(S TETHRH/KASIN OI( DEINOI\ PERI\ TH\N TW=N POL-LW=N O)NOMA/TWN QE/SIN, OI(/TINES LE/GOUSI <20KAI\ GENIKWTA/THN EI)=NAI TH\N O(RMH\N POLLW=N EI)DW=N, W(/SPER KAI\ A)FORMH=S KAI\ O(RMH=S>20, E)N EI)/DEI LE/GONTES O(MW-NU/MWS TW=| GENIKW=| PARALAMBA/NESQAI PRO\S A)NTIDIASTOLH\N TH=S A)FORMH=S TH\N O(RMH/N. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 88, 1 W.$10 *PA/SAS DE\ TA\S O(RMA\S SUGKATAQE/SEIS EI)=NAI, TA\S DE\ PRAKTIKA\S KAI\ TO\ KINHTIKO\N PERIE/XEIN. *)/HDH DE\ A)/LLWN ME\N EI)=-NAI SUGKATAQE/SEIS, E)P' A)/LLO DE\ O(RMA/S: KAI\ SUGKATAQE/SEIS ME\N A)CIW/MASI/ TISIN, O(RMA\S DE\ E)PI\ KATHGORH/MATA, TA\ PERIEXO/MENA/ PWS E)N TOI=S A)CIW/MASIN, OI(=S SUGKATAQE/SEIS. @1 @&10Galenus de animi peccatis dignoscendis 1 Vol. V p. 58 K.$10 A)/RXO-MAI OU)=N KAI\ NU=N A)RXH\N A)RI/STHN__TI/ POTE LE/GOUSIN A(MA/RTHMA, LO/GW| DIELQW\N DEIKNU\S W(/S GE EI)W/QASI XRH=SQAI TH=| FWNH=| TAU/TH| PA/NTES OI( *(/ELLHNES. E)NI/OTE ME\N GA\R E)PI\ TW=N KATA\ KRI/SIN OU)K O)RQW=S GIGNOME/NWN, W(S EI)=NAI TOU= LOGISTIKOU= MO/NOU TH=S YUXH=S, E)NI/OTE DE\ KOINH=|, W(S KAI\ TH=S A)LO/GOU DUNA/MEWS A(/PTESQAI. [1&10Sequitur magna lacuna, quae hausit Galeni disputationem, qua$10 KATA\ YEUDH= DO/CAN TA\ A(MARTH/MATA GI/GNESQAI&10 docuerat; deinde videtur contra &10Stoicos quosdam disputare, qui$10 TH\N A)SQENH= SUGKATA/QESIN&10 in peccatorum &10numero posuerant%10$10]1 %2%2 TI SUGKATA/QESIS A(MARTH/MATOS, SUNWMOLO/GHTAI PA=SI: [2O(/]2TI DE\ KAI\ A)SQENH/S, OU)KE/TI: METACU\ GA\R DOKEI= TISIN A)/MEINON EI)=NAI TI/QE-SQAI TH\N A)SQENH= SUGKATA/QESIN A)RETH=S TE KAI\ KAKI/AS. A)SQENH= DE\ LE/GOUSI SUGKATA/QESIN, O(/TAN MHDE/PW PEPEIKO/TES W)=MEN H(MA=S AU)TOU\S [OU(/TWS], A)LHQH= TH/NDE TINA\ DO/CAN U(PA/RXEIN, W(S TO\ PE/NTE DAKTU/LOUS E)/XEIN, EI) TU/XOI, KAQ' E(KATE/RAN XEI=RA KAI\ TA\ DI\S DU/O TE/TTARA EI)=NAI. I)/SWS ME\N E)PI\ PRESBU/TOU DI' O(/LOU TOU= BI/OU SXOLA/SANTOS EU(RH/SEIS TW=N A)LHQW=N A(MARTHMA/TWN TO\ SUGKATA-QE/SQAI TINI\ TW=N A)PO/DEICIN E)PISTHMONIKH\N E)XO/NTWN A)SQENW=S. E)PISTH/MH GOU=N E)STI TOU= GEWMETRIKOU= TOIAU/TH PERI\ TA\ DEDEIGME/NA DIA\ TW=N *EU)KLEI/DOU STOI-XEI/WN, O(POI/A TW=N POLLW=N E)STI TOU= TA\ DI\S DU/O TE/TTARA EI)=NAI. __E)A\N OU)=N A)MFIBA/LHTAI BRAXU\ KAI\ MH\ BEBAI/AN AU)TOI=S E)/XH| SUGKATA/QESIN, H(\N KATA/LHYIN O)NOMA/ZOUSI/ TINES, A(MA/RTHMA EI)=NAI TOU=TO SUGXWRH/SEIEN A)/N TIS, W(S GEWMETRI-KOU= DHLONO/TI TA)NQRW/POU. <20TOU= ME/NTOI KATA\ TO\N BI/ON A(MARTA/NONTOS E)N TOI=S PERI\ A)GAQW=N TE KAI\ KAKW=N GNW/SEW/S TE KAI\ KTH/SEWS KAI\ FUGH=S AI( MOXQHRAI\ DO/CAI SUNI/STANTAI KAI\ [2H(]2 YEUDH\S SUGKATA/-QESIS H)\ PROPETH\S H)\ A)SQENH/S>20. E)NTAU=QA OU)=N H)/DH KI/NDUNOS OU) SMIKRO/S, A(/MA [2D']2 A(MA/RTHMA KAI\ ME/GISTON, E)A\N YEUDW=S SUGKATATIQW/MEQA TH=| TW=N A)GA-QW=N TE KAI\ KAKW=N DO/CH|. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 87, 14 W.$10 <20TH=S DE\ PRAKTIKH=S O(RMH=S EI)/DH>20 PLEI/ONA EI)=NAI, E)N OI(=S KAI\ TAU=TA: PRO/QESIN, E)PIBOLH/N, PARASKEUH/N, E)GXEI/RHSIN, [2AI(/RESIN]2, PROAI/RESIN, BOU/LHSIN, QE/LHSIN. <20PRO/QESIN>20 ME\N OU)=N EI)=NAI LE/GOUSI SHMEI/WSIN E)PITELE/SEWS: <20E)PIBOLH\N>20 DE\ O(RMH\N PRO\ O(RMH=S: <20PARASKEUH\N>20 DE\ PRA=CIN PRO\ PRA/CEWS: <20E)GXEI/RHSIN>20 DE\ O(RMH\N E)PI/ TINOS E)N XERSI\N H)/DH O)/NTOS: <20AI(/RESIN>20 DE\ BOU/LHSIN E)C A)NALOGISMOU=: <20PROAI/RESIN>20 DE\ AI(/RESIN PRO\ AI(RE/SEWS: <20BOU/LHSIN>20 DE\ EU)/LOGON O)/RECIN: <20QE/LHSIN>20 DE\ E(KOU/SION BOU/LHSIN. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 23 p. 1045e.$8 <20*)EN DE\ TW=| E(/KTW| PERI\ *KAQH/KONTOS>20 "1EI)=NAI/ TINA FH/SAS PRA/GMATA MH\ PA/NU POL-LH=S A)/CIA [O)/NTA] PRAGMATEI/AS MHDE\ PROSOXH=S"2 A)FIE/NAI PERI\ TAU=TA TH=| W(S E)/TUXEN E)PIKLI/SEI TH=S DIANOI/AS OI)/ETAI DEI=N TH\N AI(/RESIN A)POKLHRW/SAN-TAS: "1<20*OI(=ON, FHSI/N, EI) TW=N DOKIMAZO/NTWN TA/SDE TINA\S DRAXMA\S DU/O E)PI\ TOSO/NDE, OI( ME\N TH/NDE OI( DE\ TH/NDE FAI=EN EI)=NAI KALH/N, DE/OI DE\ MI/AN AU)TW=N LABEI=N: THNIKAU=TA A)FE/NTES TO\ E)PI\ PLEI=ON @1 E)PIZHTEI=N, H(\N E)/TUXE LHYO/MEQA, KAT' A)/DHLO/N TINA A)POKLHRW/-SANTES AU)TA\S LO/GON, KAI\ EI) MA/LISTA TH\N MOXQHRA\N LHYO/MEQA AU)TW=N>20."2 @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 11 p. 1037p.$ *KAI\ MH\N H( O(RMH/, KATA/ G' AU)TO\N [1&sc.$ *XRU/SIPPON]1, TOU= A)NQRW/POU LO/GOS E)STI\ PROS-TAKTIKO\S AU)TW=| TOU= POIEI=N, W(S <20E)N TW=| PERI\ *NO/MOU>20 GE/GRAFEN. *OU)K-OU=N KAI\ H( A)FORMH\ LO/GOS A)PAGOREUTIKO\S KAI\ H( E)/KKLISIS: [2H( <20DE\ EU)-LA/BEIA]2 EU)/LOGOS E)/KKLISIS>20: KAI\ H( EU)LA/BEIA TOI/NUN LO/GOS E)STI\N A)PAGOREUTIKO\S TW=| SOFW=|: <20TO\ GA\R EU)LABEI=SQAI SOFW=N I)/DION, OU) FAU/LWN E)STI/N>20. *EI) ME\N OU)=N E(/TERON E)STI\N O( TOU= SOFOU= LO/GOS KAI\ E(/TERON O( NO/MOS, MAXO/MENON TW=| NO/MW| LO/GON OI( SOFOI\ TH\N EU)LA/BEIAN E)/XOUSIN: EI) D' OU)K A)/LLO TI NO/MOS E)STI\N H)\ O( TOU= SOFOU= LO/GOS, EU(/RHTAI NO/MOS A)PAGOREUTIKO\S TOI=S SOFOI=S TOU= POIEI=N A(\ EU)LABOU=NTAI. @&10Clem. Al. Strom. VII 7 p. 853 Pott.$10 W(=N ME\N OU)=N KAI\ O)RE/CEIS EI)SI\ KAI\ E)PIQUMI/AI KAI\ O(/LWS EI)PEI=N <20AI( O(RMAI\>20 TOU/TWN EI)SI\ KAI\ AI( EU)XAI/: DIO/PER OU)DEI\S E)PIQUMEI= PO/MATOS, A)LLA\ TOU= PIEI=N TO\ POTO/N: OU)DE\ MH\N KLHRO-NOMI/AS, A)LLA\ TOU= KLHRONOMH=SAI: OU(TWSI\ DE\ OU)DE\ GNW/SEWS A)LLA\ TOU= GNW=NAI: OU)DE\ GA\R POLITEI/AS O)RQH=S, A)LLA\ TOU= POLITEU/ESQAI: TOU/TWN OU)=N AI( EU)XAI/, W(=N KAI\ AI)TH/SEIS: KAI\ TOU/TWN AI( AI)TH/SEIS W(=N KAI\ E)PIQUMI/AI: TO\ DE\ EU)/XESQAI KAI\ O)RE/GESQAI KATALLH/LWS GI/GNESQAI EI)S TO\ E)/XEIN TA\ A)GAQA\ KAI\ TA\ PARAKEI/MENA W)FELH/MATA. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 47 p. 1057a.$ *KAI\ MH\N <20E)/N GE TOI=S PRO\S TOU\S *)AKADHMAI+KOU\S A)GW=SIN>20 O( PLEI=STOS LO/GOS <20AU)-TW=| TE *XRUSI/PPW|>20 KAI\ <20*)ANTIPA/TRW|>20 PERI\ TI/NOS GE/GONE; PERI\ TOU= "1MH/TE PRA/TTEIN MH/TE O(RMA=N A)SUGKATAQE/TWS, A)LLA\ PLA/SMATA LE/GEIN KAI\ KENA\S U(POQE/SEIS TOU\S A)CIOU=NTAS, OI)KEI/AS FANTASI/AS GENOME/NHS, EU)QU\S O(RMA=N MH\ EI)/CANTAS MHDE\ SUGKATAQEME/NOUS."2 <20*AU)=QIS DE/ FHSI *XRU/SIPPOS>20, "1KAI\ TO\N QEO\N YEUDEI=S E)MPOIEI=N FANTASI/AS, KAI\ TO\N SOFO/N, OU) SUGKATATIQEME/NWN OU)D' EI)KO/NTWN DEOME/NOUS H(MW=N, A)LLA\ PRATTO/NTWN MO/NON KAI\ O(RMW/NTWN E)PI\ TO\ FAINO/MENON: H(MA=S DE\ FAU/-LOUS O)/NTAS, U(P' A)SQENEI/AS SUGKATATI/QESQAI TAI=S TOIAU/TAIS FANTASI/AIS."2 __&p. 1057b.$ *(O GA\R OU) DEO/MENOS SUGKATATIQEME/NWN A)LLA\ PRATTO/N-TWN MO/NON, OI(=S E)NDI/DWSI TA\S FANTASI/AS, EI)/TE QEO\S EI)/TE SOFO/S, OI)=DEN O(/TI PRO\S TO\ PRA/TTEIN A)RKOU=SIN AI( FANTASI/AI KAI\ PARE/LKOUSIN AI( SUG-KATAQE/SEIS: [2W(S]2 EI) DE\ GIGNW/SKWN O(/TI PRAKTIKH\N O(RMH\N OU) PARI/STHSI FANTASI/A DI/XA SUGKATAQE/SEWS, YEUDEI=S E)NERGA/ZETAI KAI\ PIQANA\S FAN-TASI/AS, E(KW\N AI)/TIO/S E)STI TOU= PROPI/PTEIN KAI\ A(MARTA/NEIN A)KATALH/PTOIS SUGKATATIQEME/NOUS. @1 @&Diog. Lae%28rt VII 85.$ *TH\N DE\ PRW/THN O(RMH/N FASI TO\ ZW=|ON I)/SXEIN E)PI\ TO\ THREI=N E(AUTO/, OI)KEIOU/SHS AU)TW=| TH=S FU/SEWS A)P' A)RXH=S: KAQA/ FHSIN O( <20*XRU/SIPPOS E)N TW=| PRW/TW| PERI\ *TELW=N>20, PRW=TON OI)KEI=ON LE/GWN EI)=NAI PANTI\ ZW/|W| TH\N AU(TOU= SU/STASIN KAI\ TH\N TAU/THS SUNEI/DHSIN. OU)/TE GA\R A)LLOTRIW=SAI EI)KO\S H)=N AU(TW=| TO\ ZW=ON, OU)/TE POIH/SASAN AU)TO\ MH/TE A)LLOTRIW=SAI MH/TE [OU)K] OI)KEIW=SAI. A)POLEI/PETAI TOI/NUN LE/GEIN, SUSTHSAME/NHN AU)TO\ OI)KEIW=SAI PRO\S E(AUTO/. OU(/TW GA\R TA/ TE BLA/PTONTA DIWQEI=TAI KAI\ TA\ OI)KEI=A PROSI/ETAI. O(\ DE\ LE/GOUSI/ TINES, PRO\S H(DONH\N GI/GNESQAI TH\N PRW/THN O(RMH\N TOI=S ZW/|OIS, YEU=DOS A)POFAI/NOUSIN. E)PI-GE/NNHMA GA\R FASI/N, EI) A)/RA E)STI/N, H(DONH\N EI)=NAI, O(/TAN AU)TH\N KAQ' AU(TH\N H( FU/SIS E)PIZHTH/SASA TA\ E)NARMO/ZONTA TH=| SUSTA/SEI A)POLA/BH|: O(\N TRO/PON A)FILARU/NETAI TA\ ZW=|A KAI\ QA/LLEI TA\ FUTA/. OU)DE/N TE, FASI/, DIH/LLACEN H( FU/SIS E)PI\ TW=N FUTW=N KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N ZW/|WN, O(/TE XWRI\S O(RMH=S KAI\ AI)SQH/SEWS KA)KEI=NA OI)KONOMEI=, KAI\ E)F' H(MW=N TINA FUTOEIDW=S GI/NE-TAI. E)K PERITTOU= DE\ TH=S O(RMH=S TOI=S ZW/|OIS E)PIGENOME/NHS, H(=| SUGXRW/-MENA POREU/ETAI PRO\S TA\ OI)KEI=A, TOU/TOIS ME\N TO\ KATA\ FU/SIN TW=| KATA\ TH\N O(RMH\N DIOIKEI=SQAI: TOU= DE\ LO/GOU TOI=S LOGIKOI=S KATA\ TELEIOTE/RAN PROSTASI/AN DEDOME/NOU TO\ KATA\ LO/GON ZH=N O)RQW=S GI/NESQAI [2TOU/]2TOIS KATA\ FU/SIN. TEXNI/THS GA\R OU(=TOS E)PIGI/NETAI TH=S O(RMH=S. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 12 p. 1038b.$ *PW=S OU)=N A)POKNAI/EI PA/LIN [1&sc. Chrysippus$]1 <20E)N PANTI\ BIBLI/W| FUSIKW=|, NH\ *DI/A, KAI\ H)QIKW=|>20 GRA/FWN W(S "1<20OI)KEIOU/MEQA PRO\S AU(TOU\S EU)QU\S GENO/MENOI KAI\ TA\ ME/RH KAI\ TA\ E)/KGONA TA\ E(AUTW=N>20."2 @&10Alexander de anima libri mantissa p. 163, 14 Bruns.$10 H( GA\R FU/SIS H( TH\N YUXH\N H(MI=N DOU=SA E)/DWKE KAI\ TO\ SW=MA KAI\ PRO\S TA\S E(KATE/ROU TOU/TWN TELEIO/THTA/S TE KAI\ OI(/AS DEI= KATASKEUA\S W)|KEI/WSEN H(MA=S, W(/STE O( TH=S TOU= E(TE/ROU TOU/TWN TELEIO/THTOS KATA\ FU/SIN STERO/MENOS OU)D' A)\N KATA\ FU/SIN BIOI= [1TO\ GA\R KATA\ FU/SIN TO\ KATA\ TO\ BOU/LHMA TH=S FU/SEWS A)KOU/ETAI]1: EI) DE\ MH\ TOU=TO, OU)DE\ EU)DAIMO/NWS. @&10Gellius Noct. Att. XII 5, 7 [1Taurum facit disputantem quae &10"1fuisse dicturum putat, siquis nunc adesset Stoicorum"2]1 "1Natura, inquit, &10omnium rerum, quae nos genuit, induit nobis inolevitque in ipsis statim &10principiis, quibus nati sumus, amorem nostri et caritatem, ita prorsus, ut &10nihil quicquam esset carius pensiusque nobis quam nosmet ipsi, atque &10hoc esse fundamentum ratast conservandae hominum perpetuitatis, si unus-&10quisque nostrum, simul atque editus in lucem foret, harum prius rerum &10sensum adfectionemque caperet, quae a veteribus philosophis$10 TA\ PRW=TA @1 KATA\ FU/SIN&10 appellata sunt%10 ut omnibus scilicet corporis sui commodis gau-&10deret, ab incommodis omnibus abhorreret. Postea per incrementa aetatis &10exorta e seminibus suis ratiost et utendi consilii reputatio et honestatis &10utilitatisque verae contemplatio subtiliorque et exploratior commodorum &10[2incommodorum]2que dilectus; atque ita prae ceteris omnibus enituit et &10praefulsit decori et honesti dignitas ac, si ei retinendae obtinendaeve in-&10commodum extrinsecus aliquod obstaret, contemptum est; neque aliud esse &10vere et simpliciter bonum nisi honestum, aliud quicquam malum, nisi &10quod turpe esset, existimatum est. Reliqua omnia, quae in medio forent, &10ac neque honesta essent neque turpia, neque bona esse neque mala de-&10cretum est. Productiones tamen et relationes suis quaeque momentis dis-&10tinctae divisaeque sunt, quae$10 PROHGME/NA&10 et$10 A)POPROHGME/NA&10 ipsi vocant. &10Propterea voluptas quoque et dolor, quod ad finem ipsum bene beateque &10vivendi pertinet, et in mediis relicta et neque in bonis neque in malis &10iudicata sunt."2 &10@Cicero de finibus III 5, 16. Placet his__simulatque na-&10tum sit animal [1hinc enim est ordiendum]1 ipsum sibi conciliari et com-&10mendari ad se conservandum et ad suum statum eaque quae conservantia &10sunt eius status diligenda%10 alienari autem ab interitu iisque rebus, quae &10interitum videantur afferre. Id ita esse sic probant, quod, ante quam vo-&10luptas aut dolor attigerit, salutaria appetant parvi aspernenturque con-&10traria%10 quod non fieret nisi statum suum diligerent, interitum timerent. &10Fieri autem non posset, ut appeterent aliquid, <21nisi sensum haberent &10sui>21 eoque se diligerent. Ex quo intellegi debet, principium ductum esse &10a se diligendo. &10@Alexander Aphrod. de anima libri mant. p. 150, 25 Bruns.$10 TOU=TO DH\ TO\ PRW=TON OI)KEI=ON E)ZH/THTAI TI/ POTE/ E)STI PARA\ TOI=S FILOSO/FOIS KAI\ OU) TAU)TO\ PA=SIN E)/DOCEN, A)LLA\ SXEDO\N KATA\ TH\N TOU= E)SXA/TOU O)REKTOU= DIAFORA\N KAI\ H( PERI\ TOU= PRW/TOU TOI=S PERI\ AU)TOU= LE/GOUSIN GI/NETAI. OI( ME\N OU)=N <20*STWI+-KOI/>20, OU) PA/NTES DE/, LE/GOUSIN PRW=TON OI)KEI=ON EI)=NAI TO\ ZW=|ON AU(TW=| [1E(/KASTON GA\R ZW=|ON EU)QU\S GENO/MENON PRO\S AU(TO\ OI)KEIOU=SQAI KAI\ DH\ KAI\ TO\N A)/NQRW-PON]1 OI( DE\ XARIE/STERON DOKOU=NTES LE/GEIN AU)TW=N KAI\ MA=LLON DIARQROU=N PERI\ TOU=DE/ FASIN PRO\S TH\N SU/STASIN KAI\ TH/RHSIN W)|KEIW=SQAI EU)QU\S GENOME/NOUS H(MA=S TH\N H(MW=N AU)TW=N. @&10Seneca cp. 121, 5. quaerebamus, an esset omnibus animalibus &10constitutionis suae sensus? esse autem ex eo maxime apparet, quod membra &10apte et expedite movent non aliter quam in hoc erudita. &10@ibid. 10. Constitutio, inquit, est, ut vos dicitis, principale animi &10quodammodo se habens erga corpus. &10@ibid. 14. Dicitis, inquit, omne animal primum constitutioni suae &10conciliari. hominis autem constitutionem rationalem esse et ideo conci-&10liari hominem sibi non tanquam animali, sed tanquam rationali. ea enim &10parte sibi carus est homo, qua homo. &10@Alexander Aphrod. de anima libri mant. p. 162, 29 Bruns.$10 TO\ GA\R OI)KEIW=SQAI ME\N LE/GEIN H(MA=S PRO\S PLEI/W, MHDE\N ME/NTOI DIAFE/REIN H(MI=N O(PWSOU=N E)XO/NTWN AU)TW=N, MAXO/MENA LE/GEIN E)STI/N. @1 @&10Cicero de finibus III 7, 23, Cum autem omnia officia a prin-&10cipiis naturae proficiscantur, ab iisdem necesse est proficisci ipsam sapien-&10tiam. Sed quemadmodum saepe fit, ut is qui commendatus sit alicui, &10pluris eum faciat, cui commendatus sit, quam illum, a quo sit; sic mi-&10nime mirum est, <21primo nos sapientiae commendari ab initiis &10naturae, post autem ipsam sapientiam nobis cariorem fieri, &10quam illa sint, a quibus ad hanc venerimus>21. &10@Cicero de finibus III 17. Satis esse autem argumenti videtur, &10quam ob rem illa, quae prima sunt adscita natura, diligamus, quod est &10nemo, quin cum utrumvis liceat, aptas malit et integras omnis partis cor-&10poris quam, eodem usu, imminutas aut detortas habere. &10@Cicero de finibus III 20. Initiis igitur ita constitutis, ut ea, &10quae secundum naturam sunt, ipsa propter se sumenda sint, contrariaque &10item reicienda, primum est officium [1id enim appello$10 KAQH=KON]1&10]1 ut se con-&10servet in naturae statu, deinceps ut ea teneat, quae secundum naturam &10sint pellatque contraria; qua inventa selectione et item reiectione sequitur &10deinceps cum officio selectio, deinde ea perpetua, tum ad extremum con-&10stans consentaneaque naturae, in qua primum inesse incipit et intellegi, &10quid sit, quod vere bonum possit dici.& 21. <21&10prima est enim conci-&10liatio hominis ad ea, quae suut secundum naturam>21. simul autem &10cepit intellegentiam vel notionem potius, quam appellant$10 E)/NNOIAN&10 illi, vidit-&10que rerum agendarum ordinem et, ut ita dicam, concordiam, multo eam &10pluris aestimavit quam omnia illa, quae prima dilexerat, atque ita cogni-&10tione et ratione collegit, ut statueret in eo collocatum summum illud ho-&10minis per se laudandum et expetendum bonum. quod cum positum sit &10in eo, quod$10 O(MOLOGI/AN&10 Stoici [1appellant]1__cum igitur in eo sit id &10bonum, quo omnia referenda sunt, honeste facta ipsumque honestum, quod &10solum in bonis ducitur, quamquam post oritur, tamen id solum vi sua &10et dignitate expetendum est; eorum autem, quae sunt prima naturae, &10propter se nihil est expetendum. &10@Cicero de finibus III 17. Rerum autem cognitiones, quas vel &10comprehensiones vel perceptiones vel, si haec verba aut minus placent &10aut minus intelleguntur,$10 <20KATALH/YEIS>20&10 appellemus licet, eas igitur <21ipsas &10propter se adsciscendas>21 arbitramur, quod habeant quiddam in se &10quasi complexum et continens veritatem. Id autem in parvis intellegi &10potest, quos delectari videamus, etiamsi eorum nihil intersit, si quid ra-&10tione per se ipsi invenerint. &10@`18. Artis etiam ipsas <21propter se assumendas>21 putamus, cum quia &10sit in iis aliquid dignum assumptione, tum quod constent ex cognitionibus &10et contineant quiddam in se ratione constitutum et via. &10@A falsa autem assensione magis nos alienatos esse quam a ceteris &10rebus, quae sint contra naturam, arbitrantur. @1 &10@Cicero de finibus III 31. [1commemoratis Herilli et Aristonis sen-&10tentiis]1 quid autem apertius quam, si <21selectio>21 nulla sit ab iis rebus, &10quae contra naturam sint, earum rerum, quae sint secundum naturam, &10[2fore ut]2 tollatur omnis__prudentia. @&Arrianus Epictet. dissert. II 6, 9.$ *DIA\ TOU=TO KALW=S O( *XRU/-SIPPOS LE/GEI O(/TI "1*ME/XRIS A)\N A)/DHLA/ MOI H)=| TA\ E(CH=S, A)EI\ TW=N EU)FUE-STE/RWN E)/XOMAI PRO\S TO\ TUGXA/NEIN TW=N KATA\ FU/SIN: AU)TO\S GA/R M' O( QEO\S TOIOU/TWN <20E)KLEKTIKO\N>20 E)POI/HSEN. *EI) DE/ GE H)/|DEIN O(/TI NOSEI=N MOI KAQEI/MARTAI NU=N, KAI\ W(/RMWN A)\N E)P' AU)TO/. *KAI\ GA\R O( POU/S, EI) FRE/-NAS EI)=XEN, W(/RMA A)\N E)PI\ TO\ PHLOU=SQAI."2 @&10Alexander Aphrod. de anima libri mant. p. 163, 4 Bruns.$10 LE/-GOUSI GA\R "1EI)=NAI/ TINA PROHGME/NA TW=| SOFW=| KAI\ A)CI/AN E)/XONTA KAI\ OI)KEI=A/ TINA KAI\ <20E)PISPASTIKA/>20,"2 A)LLA\ KAI\ "1<20DI/XA KEIME/NWN A)RETH=S TE SU\N TOU/TOIS KAI\ A)RETH=S MO/NHS, MHDE/POT' A)\N TO\N SOFO\N TH\N KEXWRISME/NHN E(LE/-SQAI, EI) EI)/H AU)TW=| DUNATO\N TH\N META\ TW=N A)/LLWN LABEI=N>20"2 EI) DE\ TOU=TO, DH=LON W(S XREI/AN O( SOFO\S E(/CEI TOU/TWN. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de anima libri mant. p. 164, 7 Bruns.$10 EI) GA\R A)DIA/FOROS H( KTH=SIS <20TW=N E)KLEGOME/NWN>20 KAI\ MH\ SUNTEI/NOUSA PRO\S TO\ TE/LOS, KENH\ A)\N EI)/H KAI\ MATAI/A H( <20E)KLOGH/>20. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de anima libri mant. p. 163, 32 Bruns.$10 E)/TI EI) U(PO\ <20E)KLOGH\N>20 PI/PTEI TAU=TA TH=| A)RETH=| <20KAT' AU)TOU\S>20 KAI\ H( FU/SIS TH=S TOU/TWN <20E)KLOGH=S>20 E(/NEKEN, OI)KEI/WN O)/NTWN H(MI=N, TH\N A)RETH\N PARALAMBA/NEI, TW=N DE\ TOU/TOIS A)NTIKEIME/NWN A)POIKONOMI/AS, A)=RA <20E)KLE/GESQAI>20 ME\N DEI= TA\ SWMA-TIKA\ KAI\ E)KTO\S A)GAQA/, OU)XI\ DE\ KAI\ E)PIMELEI=SQAI AU)TW=N; @&10Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 26 p. 1071a.$10 EI) GA\R AU)TA\ ME\N TA\ PRW=TA KATA\ FU/SIN A)GAQA\ MH/ E)STIN, H( D' <20EU)LO/GISTOS E)KLOGH\ KAI\ LH=YIS AU)TW=N>20 KAI\ TO\ PA/NTA TA\ PAR' E(AUTO\N POIEI=N E(/KASTON E(/NEKA TOU= TUG-XA/NEIN TW=N PRW/TWN KATA\ FU/SIN, E)P' E)KEI=NO DEI= PA/NTA E)/XEIN TA\ PRATTO/MENA TH\N A)NAFORA/N, TO\ TUGXA/NEIN TW=N PRW/TWN KATA\ FU/SIN: OU) GA\R OI(=O/N TE MH\ STOXAZOME/NOUS MHD' E)FIEME/NOUS TOU= TUXEI=N E)KEI/NWN TO\ TE/LOS E)/XEIN, A)/LLO [2O)\N]2 TW=N E)F' A(\ DEI= E)KEI=NA A)NAFE/RESQAI, TH\N TOU/TWN <20E)KLOGH\N>20 KAI\ MH\ TAU=TA: TE/LOS ME\N GA\R TO\ <20E)KLE/GESQAI>20 KAI\ LAMBA/NEIN E)KEI=NA FRONI/MWS: E)KEI=NA D' AU)TA\ KAI\ TO\ TUGXA/NEIN AU)TW=N OU) TE/LOS, A)LL' W(/SPER U(/LH TIS U(PO/KEITAI TH\N E)KLEKTIKH\N A)CI/AN E)/XOUSA: TOU=TO GA\R OI)=MAI KAI\ TOU)/NOMA LE/GEIN KAI\ GRA/FEIN AU)TOU/S, E)NDEIKNUME/NOUS TH\N DIAFORA/N. @1 @&10M. Frontonis epistulae [1ad M. Antoninum de eloquentia]1 p. 143 &10ed. Naber. Quis dubitat sapientem ab insipiente vel praecipue consilio &10et <21dilectu rerum>21 et opinione discerni? Ut si sit optio atque electio divi-Ą&10tiarum atque egestatis, quamquam utraque et malitia et virtute careant, &10tamen electionem laude et culpa non carere. <21Proprium namque sa-&10pientis officium est recte eligere>21, neque perperam vel postponere &10vel anteferre. Si me interroges, concupiscamne bonam valetudinem, ab-&10nuam equidem, si sim philosophus; nihil est enim fas concupiscere sa-&10pienti aut adpetere, quod fors fuat an frustra concupiscat; nec quidquam &10quod in manu fortunae situm videat concupiscet. Tamen si necessario &10sit altera res eligenda, Achillei potius pernicitatem eligam quam debili-&10tatem Philoctetae. @1 &10@Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 89.$10 TH/N TE A)RETH\N DIA/QESIN EI)=NAI O(MO-LOGOUME/NHN>20. @&10`90.$10 A)RETH\ DE/ TOI H( ME/N TIS KOINW=S PANTI\ TELEI/WSIS, W(/SPER A)NDRIA/NTOS: KAI\ H( A)QEW/RHTOS, W(/SPER U(GI/EIA: KAI\ H( QEWRHMATIKH/, W(S FRO/NHSIS. @&10Cicero Tusc. disp. IV 34. <21virtus est adfectio animi con-&10stans conveniensque, laudabiles efficiens eos, in quibus est>21. &10@[1ibid. paulo post]1 ipsa virtus brevissume recta ratio dici potest. &10@Commenta Lucani p. 75 Usener. Prudentiae nulla fit mentio, &10sed ut dixi per "1honestum"2 <21generalis virtus>21 ipsa explicatur, cuius haec &10definitio est%10 "1habitus consentiens vitae."2 sed potest per analogiam, &10si alias nominat, et illam significare. nam qui generalem, habet et spe-&10ciales, qui speciales et generalem virtutem. &10@Seneca epistul. ad. Lucil. 31, 8. Huc et illud accedat, ut <21per-&10fecta virtus>21 sit <21aequalitas ac tenor vitae per omnia consonans &10sibi>21, quod non potest esse, nisi rerum scientia contingit et ars, per quam &10humana ac divina noscantur. &10@Seneca ep. 76, 9. In homine quid proprium est? ratio%10 hac &10antecedit animalia, deos sequitur. ratio ergo perfecta proprium bonum est, &10cetera illi cum animalibus satisque communia sunt. &10@ibid. 10. Quid in homine proprium? ratio. haec recta et consum-&10mata felicitatem hominis implevit. ergo si omnis res, cum bonum suum &10perfecit, laudabilis est et ad finem naturae suae pervenit, homini autem &10suum bonum ratio est, si hanc perfecit, laudabilis est et finem naturae &10suae tetigit. haec <21ratio perfecta virtus vocatur>21 eademque honestum &10est. Id itaque unum bonum est in homine, quod unum hominis est. &10@Anonymus in Aristot. Eth. Nicom. [1Comm. graec. Vol. XX]1 ed. &10Heylb. p. 128, 5.$10 I)STE/ON DE\ O(/TI KAI\ PRO\ TW=N *STWI+KW=N H)=N H( DO/CA AU(/TH, H( TA\S A)RETA\S E)N A)PAQEI/A| TIQEI=SA. @&10Philo Leg. Alleg. I %14 56 Vol. I p. 75, 6 Wendl. [1de arboribus &10horti Edem locutus]1.$10 E)/STI DE\ TAU=TA AI(/ TE KATA\ ME/ROS A)RETAI\ KAI\ AI( KAT' @1 AU)TA\S E)NE/RGEIAI, KAI\ TA\ KATORQW/MATA KAI\ TA\ LEGO/MENA PARA\ TOI=S FILOSOFOU=SI KAQH/KONTA. &10%14 57.$10 E)/NIAI GA\R TW=N TEXNW=N QEWRHTIKAI\ ME/N EI)SIN, OU) PRAKTI-KAI\ DE/, GEWMETRI/A A)STRONOMI/A, E)/NIAI DE\ PRAKTIKAI\ ME/N, OU) QEWRHTIKAI\ DE/, TEKTONIKH/, XALKEUTIKH\ KAI\ O(/SAI BA/NAUSOI LE/GONTAI. <20H( DE\ A)RETH\ KAI\ QEW-RHTIKH/ E)STI KAI\ PRAKTIKH/>20. KAI\ GA\R QEWRI/AN E)/XEI, O(PO/TE KAI\ H( E)P' AU)-TH\N O(DO\S FILOSOFI/A DIA\ TW=N TRIW=N AU)TH=S MERW=N, TOU= LOGIKOU=, TOU= H)QIKOU=, TOU= FUSIKOU=. KAI\ PRA=CIN: <20O(/LOU GA\R TOU= BI/OU E)STI\ TE/XNH H( A)RETH/>20, E)N W(=| KAI\ AI( SU/MPASAI PRA/CEIS. *)ALLA\ KAI/TOI QEWRI/AN E)/XOUSA KAI\ PRA=CIN, PA/LIN E)N E(KATE/RW| U(PERBA/LLEI KATA\ TO\ KREI=TTON. *KAI\ GA\R H( QEWRI/A TH=S A)RETH=S PAGKA/LH KAI\ H( PRA=CIS KAI\ H( XRH=SIS PERIMA/XHTOS. @&10Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 58A ed. Bas.$10 EI) ME\N GA\R W(S <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 A)PODIDO/ASI <20DU/NAMI/S E)STIN H( PLEIO/NWN E)POISTIKH\ SUMPTW-MA/TWN>20, W(S H( FRO/NHSIS TOU= TE FRONI/MWS PERIPATEI=N KAI\ TOU= FRONI/MWS DIA-LE/GESQAI, E)/SONTAI KATA\ TO\N TOIOU=TON DIORISMO\N KAI\ AI( NU=N LEGO/MENAI A)DUNA-MI/AI DUNA/MEIS: KAI\ GA\R AI( A)TEXNI/AI PLEI/ONA DIAPTW/MATA E)PIFE/ROUSIN. EI) ME/NTOI KAT' A)/LLHN DIA/TACIN TW=N *STWI+KW=N LE/GOITO <20DU/NAMIS H( PLEIO/NWN E)POISTIKH\ SUMPTWMA/TWN KAI\ KATAKRATOU=SA TW=N U(POTASSOME/NWN E)NERGEIW=N>20, KAI\ OU(/TWS E)FARMO/TTEI O( TOU= *PLWTI/NOU O(/ROS. KAI\ GA\R H( KAKI/A A)DUNAMI/A OU)=SA KATA\ TO\N TW=N *STWI+KW=N O(/RON KATAKRATEI= TW=N OI)KEI/WN E)NER-GEIW=N: KAI\ AI( ME/SAI TE/XNAI, W(S A)\N A)POPI/PTOUSAI TOU= BEBAI/WS E)NERGEI=N, O(/MWS TOIAU=TAI/ EI)SIN, A)F' W(=N TO\ E)/XON DU/NATAI A(\ DU/NATAI, W(/STE AI( TOIAU=TAI A)DUNA-MI/AI PERIE/XONTAI E)N TH=| KATA\ TH\N POIO/THTA DUNA/MEI. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de anima libri mant. p. 167, 4 Bruns.$10 TO\ DE\ FA/NAI "1<20W(/SPER TH\N AU)LHTIKH\N PANTI\ TW=| DOQE/NTI ME/LEI O)RQW=S DU/NASQAI XRH=SQAI, OU(/TWS KAI\ TH\N A)RETH\N PANTI\ PRA/GMATI>20"2 U(GIE\S ME/N E)STI, PROSDIASTALTE/ON DE/ &10etc. &10@Alexander Aphrod. de anima libri mant. p. 167, 9 Bruns.$10 E)/TI OU)K "1<20E)PEI\ PA=SIN TOI=S PRA/GMASIN KALW=S XRH=TAI>20 [1&10scil.$10 H( A)RETH/]1"2 H)/DH KAI\ "1<20H( PANTO\S XRH=SIS EU)DAIMONIKH/>20."2 @&10Proclus in Plat. Timaeum p. 18 C. Schneider.$10 MEIZO/NWS TO\ TH=S A)RETH=S DEI/KNUSI ME/GEQOS O( PO/LEMOS TH=S EI)RH/NHS, W(S KAI\ TH=S KUBERNHTIKH=S AI( TRIKUMI/AI KAI\ O( KLU/DWN, KAI\ O(/LWS AI( PERISTA/SEIS, W(S KAI\ <20OI( *STWI+KOI\ LE/GEIN EI)W/QASI "1DO\S PERI/STASIN KAI\ LA/BE TO\N A)/NDRA."2 TO\ GA\R A)H/TTHTON U(PO\ TW=N TOU\S A)/LLOUS KATADOULOUME/NWN TH=S ZWH=S DHLOI= PANTA/PASIN A)CI/AN. @&10Philo quaest. et solut. in Genesin IV 11 [1p. 254 Aucher]1. Ad &10interrogationem ergo respondet [1scil. intellectus]1%10 <21Ecce virtus non tan-&10tum in me intellectu est>21, verum etiam in vacuo securoque taberna-&10culo corporis, <21extendens se usque ad sensus aliaque instrumenta &10partialia>21. Nam video secundum virtutem et audio, olfacio, gusto, tango &10ceterosque motus exerceo secundum prudentiam, castitatem, fortitudinem &10et iustitiam. &10@Stobaeus ecl. II 100, 15 W.$10 <20*TH\N D' A)RETH\N>20 POLLOI=S O)NO/MASI PROSAGOREU/OUSIN. <20*)AGAQO/N>20 TE GA\R LE/GOUSIN AU)TH/N, O(/TI A)/GEI H(MA=S E)PI\ TO\N O)RQO\N BI/ON: KAI\ <20A)RESTO/N>20, O(/TI DOKIMASTO/N E)STIN A)NUPO/PTWS: KAI\ <20POLLOU= @1 A)/CION>20, [2O(/TI]2 A)NUPE/RBLHTON E)/XEI TH\N A)CI/AN: KAI\ <20SPOUDAI=ON>20, A)/CION GA\R EI)=-NAI POLLH=S SPOUDH=S: KAI\ <20E)PAINETO/N>20, EU)LO/GWS GA\R A)/N TIS AU)TH\N E)PAINOI/H: KAI\ <20KALO/N>20, O(/TI PRO\S E(AUTH\N KALEI=N PE/FUKE TOU\S O)REGOME/NOUS AU)TH=S: KAI\ <20SUMFE/RON>20, FE/REIN GA\R TOIAU=TA A(\ SUNTEI/NEI PRO\S TO\ EU)= ZH=N: KAI\ <20XRH/SI-MON>20, O(/TI E)N TH=| XREI/A| W)FE/LIMO/N E)STI: KAI\ <20AI(RETO/N>20, SUMBAI/NEIN GA\R A)P' AU)-TH=S A(\ EU)LO/GWS E)/STIN AI(REI=SQAI: KAI\ <20A)NAGKAI=ON>20, O(/TI PAROU=SA/ TE W)FELEI= KAI\ MH\ PAROU/SHS OU)K E)/STIN W)FELEI=SQAI: KAI\ <20LUSITELE/S>20, TA\S GA\R A)P' AU)TH=S W)FELEI/AS KREI/TTOUS EI)=NAI TH=S PRAGMATEI/AS TH=S EI)S TAU/TAS SUNTEINOU/SHS: KAI\ <20AU)/TARKES>20, E)CARKEI=N GA\R TW=| E)/XONTI: KAI\ <20A)NENDEE/S>20, O(/TI E)NDEI/AS A)PALLA/TTEI PA/SHS: KAI\ <20A)POXRW=N>20 DIA\ TO\ E)N TH=| XRH/SEI I(KANO\N EI)=NAI KAI\ DIATEI/NEIN EI)S PA=SAN TH\N KATA\ TO\N BI/ON XREI/AN. @&10Philo quod det. potiori insidiari soleat %14 72 Vol. I p. 274, 30 &10Wendl.$10 *)APOKNAI/OUSI GOU=N H(MW=N TA\ W)=TA [1&10scil.$10 OI( SOFISTAI\]1 TH\N DIKAIOSU/NHN KOINWNIKO/N, TH\N SWFROSU/NHN SUMFE/RON, TH\N E)GKRA/TEIAN A)STEI=ON, TH\N EU)SE/-BEIAN W)FELIMW/TATON, TH\N A)/LLHN A)RETH\N U(GIEINO/TATO/N TE KAI\ SWTH/RION A)PO-FAI/NONTES: KAI\ PA/LIN TH\N A)DIKI/AN A)/SPONDON, TH\N A)KOLASI/AN NOSERO/N, TH\N A)SE/BEIAN E)/KQESMON, TH\N A)/LLHN KAKI/AN BLABERW/TATON DIECIO/NTES. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 26 p. 1046c.$8 <20E)N POLLOI=S>20 PA/LIN EI)/RHKEN, W(S "1OU)D' [2A)\N]2 TO\N DA/KTULON KAQH/KOI PROTEI=NAI XA/RIN A)MERIAI/AS FRONH/SEWS, KAQA/PER A)STRAPH=S DIERXOME/NHS."2 *)ARKE/SEI DE\ PARAQEI=NAI TA\ <20E)N TW=| E(/KTW| TW=N *)HQIKW=N *ZHTHMA/TWN>20 U(P' AU)TOU= GEGRAMME/NA PERI\ TOU/TWN: U(PEIPW\N GA\R W(S "1<20OU)/TE PA=N A)GAQO\N E)PI/SHS EI)S XARA\N PI/PTEI, OU)/TE PA=N KATO/RQWMA EI)S SEMNOLOGI/AN,>20"2 E)PENH/NOXE TAU=TA: "1<20*KAI\ GA\R EI) MO/NON ME/LLOI A)MERH= XRO/NON H)\ TO\N ҈E)/SXATON E(/CEIN FRO/NHSIN, OU)D' A)\N TO\N DA/KTULON KAQH/KOI E)KTEI=-NAI E(/NEKA TH=S OU(/TW PARESOME/NHS FRONH/SEWS."2 @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 8 p. 1062a.$ PA/LIN "1OU)DE\N EI)=NAI/ FASIN A)RETH=S O)/FELOS O)LIGOXRONI/OU: TI/ GA/R, A)\N ME/LLONTI NAUAGEI=N EU)-QU\S H)\ KATAKRHMNI/ZESQAI FRO/NHSIS E)PIGE/NHTAI; TI/ D' A)\N O( *LI/XAS, U(PO\ TOU= *(HRAKLE/OUS A)POSFENDONW/MENOS, EI)S A)RETH\N E)K KAKI/AS METABA/LH|;"2 @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 13 p. 1038f.$8 *)EPAINEI=N DE\ MH\ PA=N TO\ PRATTO/MENON KAT' A)RETH\N KELEU/WN, E)MFAI/NEI TINA\ TW=N KATOR-QWMA/TWN DIAFORA/N: LE/GEI DE\ OU(/TWS <20E)N TW=| PERI\ TOU= *DIO/S: "1*)/ERGWN GA\R KATA\ TA\S A)RETA\S O)/NTWN OI)KEI/WN, E)/STI TA\ PROENEXQE/NTA KAI\ TOU/TWN: OI(=ON A)NDREI/WS TO\N DA/KTULON E)KTEI=NAI, KAI\ E)GKRA-TW=S A)POSXE/SQAI DUSQANATW/SHS GRAO/S, KAI\ A)PROPTW/TWS A)KOU=-SAI TOU= TA\ TRI/A TE/SSARA [MH\] EI)=NAI TELE/WS, TI/NA E)MFAI/NEI YU-XRI/AN O( DIA\ TW=N TOIOU/TWN E)PAINEI=N TINAS E)GXEIRW=N KAI\ E)GKW-MIA/ZEIN>20;"2 @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 13 p. 1039a.$ *(/OMOIA D' @1 EI)/RHTAI TOU/TOIS <20E)N TW=| TRI/TW| PERI\ QEW=N: "1*)/ETI GA\R OI)=MAI, FHSI/, TOU\S E)PAI/NOUS A)LLOTRIW/SESQAI KATA\ TA\ TOIAU=TA TW=N SUMBAI-NO/NTWN A)P' A)RETH=S, OI(=ON DUSQANATW/SHS GRAO\S A)POSXE/SQAI, KAI\ KARTERW=S U(POMEI=NAI MUI/AS DHGMO/N>20."2 @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 6 p. 1061a.$ *LE/GEI DE\ KAI\ *XRU/SIP-POS E)N TW=| PERI\ TOU= *DIO\S SUGGRA/MMATI KAI\ <20TW=| TRI/TW| PERI\ QEW=N>20, "1YUXRO\N EI)=NAI KAI\ A)/TOPON KAI\ A)LLO/TRION TA\ TOIAU=TA TW=N A)P' A)RETH=S SUMBAINO/NTWN E)PAINEI=N, O(/TI DH=GMA MUI/AS A)NDREI/WS U(PE/MEINE KAI\ DUS-QANATW/SHS GRAO\S A)PE/SXETO SWFRO/NWS. @&10Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 7 p. 1061c.$10 O( GA\R SOFO\S AU)TOI=S KAI\ FRO/NIMOS E)N POLLAI=S KATALH/YESI KAI\ MNH/MAIS KATALH/YEWN GEGONW\S O)LI/-GAS PRO\S AU(TO\N H(GEI=TAI: TW=N T' A)/LLWN OU) PEFRONTIKW\S OU)D' E)/LATTON E)/XEIN OU)DE\ PLE/ON OI)/ETAI, MNHMONEU/WN O(/TI PE/RUSI KATA/LHYIN E)/LABE PTARNUME/NOU *DI/WNOS H)\ SFAIRI/ZONTOS *QE/WNOS. KAI/TOI PA=SA KATA/LHYIS E)N TW=| SOFW=| KAI\ MNH/MH TO\ A)SFALE\S E)/XOUSA KAI\ BE/BAION EU)QU/S E)STIN E)PISTH/MH KAI\ A)GAQO\N ME/GA KAI\ ME/GISTON. @&10Anecdota graeca Paris. ed. Cramer Vol. I p. 171 [1Quomodo ho-&10mines boni et mali fiant?]1.$10 *)ARISTOTE/LHS DE\ FU/SEI KAI\ E)/QEI KAI\ LO/GW|: A)ME/LEI KAI\ OI( <20*STWI+KOI/: TE/XNH GA\R H( A)RETH/.>20 PA=SA DE\ TE/XNH SU/STHMA E)K QEW-RHMA/TWN SUGGEGUMNASME/NWN: KAI\ <20KATA\ ME\N TA\ QEWRH/MATA O( LO/GOS: KATA\ DE\ TH\N SUGGUMNASI/AN TO\ E)/QOS: FU/SEI DE\ PA/NTES PRO\S A)RE-TH\N GENNW/MEQA, KAQ' O(/SON A)FORMA\S E)/XOMEN>20 &10etc. &10@Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 31 p. 1048d.$10 EI)/PER OU)=N O( <20QEO\S A)RETH\N ME\N OU) DI/DWSIN A)NQRW/POIS>20, A)LLA\ TO\ KALO\N AU)QAI/RETO/N E)STIN &10etc.$10 *KAI/TOI EI) ME\N DU/NANTAI TH\N A)RETH\N PARE/XEIN OI( QEOI/, OU)/K EI)SI XRHSTOI\ MH\ PARE/XONTES: EI) DE\ MH\ DU/NANTAI POIEI=N A)GAQOU/S, OU)D' W)FELEI=N DU/-NANTAI, MHDENO/S GE TW=N A)/LLWN O)/NTOS A)GAQOU= MHD' W)FELI/MOU, TO\ DE\ TOU\S A)/L-LWS GENOME/NOUS A)GAQOU\S KRI/NEIN KAT' A)RETH\N H)\ I)SXU\N OU)DE/N E)STI: KAI\ GA\R TOU\S QEOU\S OI( A)GAQOI\ KRI/NOUSI KAT' A)RETH\N KAI\ I)SXU/N: W(/STE MHDE\N MA=LLON W)FELEI=N H)\ W)FELEI=SQAI TOU\S QEOU\S U(PO\ TW=N A)NQRW/PWN. @&10Lactant. div. instit. VI 9. Si autem <21virtus>21 [1ut ab his rec-&10tissime dicitur]1 <21capessenda est, quia constet ad eam nasci ho-&10minem>21 etc. &10@Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 62$10 *G&10 ed. Bas.$10 KAI\ GA\R <20OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 PRO\S ME\N TA\S TE/XNAS E)PITHDEIO/THTA MO/NHN A)PE/LIPON TH\N A(PLW=S OU(TWSI\ QEWROUME/NHN, <20PRO\S DE\ TA\S A)RETA\S TH\N A)CIO/LOGON PROKOPH\N E)K FU/SEWS PROU+PA/RXEIN>20 A)PEFH/NANTO, H(\N KAI\ OI( A)PO\ TOU= *PERIPA/TOU FUSIKH\N A)RETH\N E)KA/LOUN. @&10Origenes contra Celsum VIII 52 Vol. II p. 267, 15Ko+. [1p. 780 &10Del.]1.$10 OU)DE\ GA\R <20TA\S KOINA\S E)NNOI/AS>20 PERI\ KALW=N KAI\ AI)SXRW=N KAI\ DIKAI/WN [2KAI\ A)DI/KWN]2 EU(/ROI TIS A)\N PA/NTWS A)POLWLEKO/TAS. @1 @&10Seneca ep. 49, 11. dociles natura nos edidit et rationem dedit &10imperfectam, sed quae perfici posset. &10@Cicero de legibus I 9, 27. ipsam per se naturam longius pro-&10gredi, quae etiam nullo docente, profecta ab iis, quorum ex prima et in-&10choata intelligentia genera cognovit, confirmat ipsa per se rationem et &10perficit. &10@Clemens Al. Strom. IV 6 p. 575 Pott.$10 TH\N DE\ METASTROFH\N TH\N E)PI\ TA\ QEI=A <20OI( ME\N *STWI+KOI\>20 E)K METABOLH=S FASI\ GI/NESQAI, <20METABALLOU/SHS TH=S YUXH=S EI)S SOFI/AN>20. @&10Philo quis rer. div. heres %14 299 Vol. III p. 68, 7 Wendl.$10 PRW=-TOS ME\N GA\R A)RIQMO\S KAQ' O(\N OU)/TE A)GAQW=N OU)/TE KAKW=N E)/NNOIAN LABEI=N E)/STIN, A)TUPW/TOU TH=S YUXH=S U(PARXOU/SHS, DEU/TEROS DE\ KAQ' O(\N FORA=| TW=N A(MARTH-MA/TWN XRW/MEQA, TRI/TOS D' E)N W(=| QERAPEUO/MEQA, TA\ NOSERA\ DIWQOU/MENOI KAI\ TH\N A)KMH\N TW=N PAQW=N A)FHBW=NTES, TE/TARTOS DE\ E)N W(=| PANTELOU=S U(GIEI/AS KAI\ R(W/SEWS METAPOIOU/MEQA, O(PO/TE A)POSTREFO/MENOI TA\ FAU=LA TOI=S KALOI=S E)GXEIREI=N DOKOU=MEN, PRO/TERON DE\ OU)K E)/CESTI. @&Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 91.$ <20DIDAKTH/N TE EI)=NAI>20 AU)TH\N [1LE/GW DE\ <20TH\N A)RETH\N>20]1 KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS E)N TW=| PRW/TW| PERI\ *TE/LOUS FHSI/>20 ___O(/TI DE\ DIDAKTH/ E)STI DH=LON E)K TOU= GI/NESQAI A)GAQOU\S E)K FAU/LWN. @&10Clemens Al. Strom. VII 3 p. 839 Pott.$10 <20OU)/TE GA\R FU/SEI TH\N A)RETH\N GENNW/MEQA E)/XONTES>20 OU)/TE GENOME/NOIS W(/SPER A)/LLA TINA\ TW=N TOU= SW/MATOS MERW=N FUSIKW=S U(/STERON E)PIGI/GNETAI: E)PEI\ OU)D' A)\N H)=N E)/Q' E(KOU/SION OU)DE\ E)PAINETO/N: OU)DE\ MH\N E)K TH=S TW=N SUMBA/NTWN [KAI\] E)PIGENOME/NHS SUNH-QEI/AS, O(\N TRO/PON H( DIA/LEKTOS, TELEIOU=TAI H( A)RETH/: SXEDO\N GA\R H( KAKI/A TOU=-TON E)GGI/GNETAI TO\N TRO/PON: OU) MH\N OU)DE\ E)K TE/XNHS TINO\S H)/TOI TW=N PORISTI-KW=N H)\ TW=N PERI\ TO\ SW=MA QERAPEUTIKW=N H( GNW=SIS PERIGI/GNETAI: A)LL' OU)D' E)K PAIDEI/AS TH=S E)GKUKLI/OU &10etc. &10@Clemens Al. Strom. I p. 336 Pott.$10 OU) GA\R FU/SEI, MAQH/SEI DE\ OI( KALOI\ KA)GAQOI\ GI/NONTAI, KAQA/PER I)ATROI\ KAI\ KUBERNH=TAI. @&10paulo post%10$10 TO\ D' <20A)/LLOUS PAR' A)/LLOUS EU)= PEFUKE/NAI PRO\S A)RE-TH\N>20 E)PITHDEU/MATA ME/N TINA TW=N OU(/TW PEFUKO/TWN PARA\ TOU\S E(TE/ROUS E)N-DEI/KNUTAI: <20TELEIO/THTA DE\ KAT' A)RETH\N OU)D' H(NTINOU=N TW=N A)/MEINON FU/NTWN KATHGOREI=>20, O(PO/TE KAI\ OI( KAKW=S PEFUKO/TES PRO\S A)RETH\N TH=S PROSHKOU/SHS PAIDEI/AS TUXO/NTES W(S E)PI/PAN KALOKA)GAQI/AS H)/NUSAN: KAI\ AU)= TA\ E)NANTI/A OI( E)PITHDEI/WS FU/NTES A)MELEI/A| GEGO/NASI KAKOI/. *FU/SEI D' AU)= KOINW-NIKOU\S KAI\ DIKAI/OUS O( QEO\S H(MA=S E)DHMIOU/RGHSEN, O(/QEN OU)DE\ TO\ DI/KAION E)K MO/NHS FAI/NESQAI TH=S QE/SEWS R(HTE/ON: E)K DE\ TH=S E)NTOLH=S A)NAZWPUREI=SQAI TO\ TH=S DHMIOURGI/AS A)GAQO\N NOHTE/ON, MAQH/SEI PAIDEUQEI/SHS TH=S YUXH=S E)QE/LEIN AI(REI=SQAI TO\ KA/LLISTON. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 13 p. 1038e.$ *)/ETI TO\ ME\N LE/GEIN AU)TO\N <20E)N TW=| PERI\ TOU= *DIO\S>20 "1AU)/CESQAI TA\S A)RETA\S KAI\ DIA-BAI/NEIN"2 A)FI/HMI, MH\ DO/CW TW=N O)NOMA/TWN E)PILAMBA/NESQAI, KAI/TOI PI-KRW=S E)N TW=| GE/NEI TOU/TW| KAI\ *PLA/TWNA KAI\ TOU\S A)/LLOUS TOU= *XRUSI/P-POU DA/KNONTOS. @1 @&10Philo de Moyse lib. III Vol. II Mang. p. 162.$10 OU(/TWS E)/XEI KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N A)RETW=N: E(KA/STH| GA\R SUMBE/BHKEN EI)=NAI KAI\ A)RXH\N KAI\ TE/LOS, A)RXH\N ME\N O(/TI OU)K E)C E(TE/RAS DUNA/MEWS, A)LL' E)C E(AUTH=S FU/ETAI: TE/LOS DE\ O(/TI PRO\S AU)TH\N O( KATA\ FU/SIN BI/OS SPEU/DEI. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 89.$10 <20DIASTRE/FESQAI DE\ TO\ LOGIKO\N ZW=|ON>20 POTE\ ME\N DIA\ TA\S TW=N E)/CWQEN PRAGMA/TWN PIQANO/THTAS, POTE\ DE\ DIA\ TH\N KATH/XHSIN TW=N SUNO/NTWN, E)PEI\ H( FU/SIS A)FORMA\S DI/DWSIN A)DIASTRO/FOUS. @&10Chalcidius ad Timaeum cp. 165. Dicunt porro non spontanea &10esse delicta, ideo quod omnis anima particeps divinitatis naturali adpetitu &10bonum quidem semper expetit, errat tamen aliquando in iudicio bonorum &10et malorum. namque alii nostrum summum bonum voluptatem putant, &10divitias alii, plerique gloriam et omnia magis quam ipsum verum bonum. &10Est erroris causa multiplex. <21Prima quam Stoici duplicem perver-&10sionem vocant>21. haec autem nascitur tam <21ex rebus ipsis>21 quam <21ex &10divulgatione famae>21. Quippe mox natis exque materno viscere deci-&10dentibus provenit ortus cum aliquo dolore, propterea quod ex calida at-&10que umida sede ad frigus et siccitatem ae%28ris circumfusi migrent. Adver-&10sum quem dolorem frigusque puerorum opposita est, medicinae loco, &10artificiosa obstetricum provisio, ut aqua calida confoveantur recens nati &10adhibeanturque vices et similitudo materni gremii ex calefactione atque &10fotu, quo laxatum corpus tenerum delectatur et quiescit. Ergo ex utro-&10que sensu, tam doloris quam delectationis, opinio quaedam naturalis exo-&10ritur, omne suave ac delectabile bonum, contraque quod dolorem adferat &10malum esse atque vitandum. cp. 166. Par atque eadem habetur sententia &10de indigentia quoque et exsaturatione, blanditiis obiurgationibusque, cum &10aetatis fuerint auctioris. proptereaque confirmata eadem aetate in anti-&10cipata sententia permanent%10 omne blandum bonum, etiamsi sit inutile, &10omne etiam laboriosum, etiamsi commoditatem adferat, malum existimantes. &10Consequenter divitias, quod praestantissimum sit in his instrumentum &10voluptatis, eximie diligunt, gloriamque pro honore amplexantur. Natura &10quippe omnis homo laudis atque honoris est adpetens. est enim honor &10virtutis testimonium. Sed prudentes quidem versatique in sciscitatione &10sapientiae viri sciunt, quam et cuiusmodi debeant excolere virtutem. Vul-&10gus vero imperitum propter ignorationem rerum pro honore gloriam po-&10pularemque existimationem colunt. pro virtute vero vitam consectantur &10voluptatibus delibutam, potestatem faciendi quae velint regiam quandam &10esse eminentiam existimantes%10 natura siquidem regium animal est homo, &10et quia regnum semper comitatur potestas, potestati quoque regnum ob-&10sequi suspicatur, cum regnum sit iusta tutela parentum. simul quia be-&10atum necesse est libenter vivere, putant etiam eos, qui cum voluptate @1 &10vivant, beatos fore. Talis error est, opinor, qui <21ex rebus>21 ortus homi-&10num animos possidet. cp. 167. ex <20divulgatione>20 autem succedit errori &10supra dicto ex matrum et nutricum votis de divitiis gloriaque et ceteris &10falso putatis bonis insusurratio, in terriculis etiam, quibus tenera aetas &10vehementius commovetur, nec non in solaciis et omnibus huiusmodi per-&10turbatio. Quin etiam corroboratarum mentium delinitrix poe%28tica et cetera &10scriptorum et auctorum opera magnifica quantam animis rudibus invehunt, &10iuxta voluptatem laboremque, inclinationem favoris? Quid? pictores quoque &10et fictores, nonne rapiunt animos ad suavitatem ab industria? Maxima &10vero vitiorum excitatio est in corporis atque animi concretione, quorum &10abundantia vel indigentia propensiores ad libidinem aut iracundiam sumus. &10His accedunt vitae ipsius agendae sortisque discrimina, aegritudo, servi-&10tium inopiaque rerum necessariarum, quibus occupati ab studiis honestis &10ad consentanea vitae institutae officia deducimur atque a cognitione veri &10boni revocamur. Opus est ergo futuris sapientibus tam educatione libe-&10rali praeceptisque ad honestatem ducentibus quam eruditione a vulgo se-&10parata, videndaque iis et spectanda sunt lecta omnia quae protelent ad &10sapientiam. @&10Galen de H. et Plat. decr. V 5 [1`165]1 p. 437 Mu+.$10 KAI\ PRW=-TO/N GE__PROXEIRISW/MEQA <20TO\ PERI\ TH=S TW=N PAI/DWN DIOIKH/SEWS>20. OU)/TE GA\R U(PO\ LO/GOU TA\S O(RMA\S AU)TW=N E)PITROPEU/ESQAI DUNATO\N EI)PEI=N [1OU) GA\R E)/XOUSIN H)/DH TO\N LO/GON]1 OU)/Q' W(S OU) QUMOU=TAI/ TE KAI\ LUPEI=TAI KAI\ H(/DE-TAI KAI\ GELA=| KAI\ KLAI/EI KAI\ TOIAU=Q' E(/TERA PA/QH PA/SXEI MURI/A. POLU\ GA\R DH\ KAI\ PLEI/W KAI\ SFODRO/TERA TA\ PA/QH TOI=S PAIDI/OIS E)STI\N H)\ TOI=S TELEI/OIS. OU) MH\N A)KOLOUQEI= GE TAU=TA TOI=S <20*XRUSI/PPOU>20 DO/GMASIN, W(/SPER OU)DE\ TW=| MHDE-MI/AN OI)KEI/WSIN EI)=NAI FU/SEI PRO\S H(DONH\N H)\ A)LLOTRI/WSIN PRO\S PO/NON. __ ___TRIW=N OU)=N TOU/TWN H(MI=N OI)KEIW/SEWN U(PARXOUSW=N FU/SEI KAQ' E(/KA-STON TW=N MORI/WN TH=S YUXH=S EI)=DOS, PRO\S ME\N TH\N H(DONH\N DIA\ TO\ E)PIQUMHTI-KO/N, PRO\S DE\ TH\N NI/KHN DIA\ TO\ QUMOEIDE/S, PRO\S DE\ TO\ KALO\N DIA\ TO\ LOGISTI-KO/N, *)EPI/KOUROS ME\N TH\N TOU= XEIRI/STOU MORI/OU TH=S YUXH=S OI)KEI/WSIN E)QEA/SATO MO/NHN, O( DE\ *XRU/SIPPOS TH\N TOU= BELTI/STOU, FA/MENOS H(MA=S OI)KEIOU=SQAI PRO\S MO/NON TO\ KALO/N, O(/PER EI)=NAI DHLONO/TI KAI\ A)GAQO/N. A(PA/SAS DE\ TA\S TREI=S OI)-KEIW/SEIS QEA/SASQAI MO/NOIS TOI=S PALAIOI=S U(PH=RCE FILOSO/FOIS. E)A/SAS OU)=N TA\S DU/O O( <20*XRU/SIPPOS EI)KO/TWS A)POREI=N E)REI= TH=S KATA\ TH\N KAKI/AN GE-NE/SEWS, OU)/T' AI)TI/AN E)/XWN EI)PEI=N AU)TH=S, OU)/TE TRO/POUS TH=S SUSTA/-SEWS>20, OU)/Q' O(/PWS A(MARTA/NEI TA\ PAIDI/A DUNA/MENOS E)CEUREI=N, A(/PER EU)LO/GWS, OI)=MAI, PA/NTA KAI\ O( *POSEIDW/NIOS AU)TOU= KATAME/MFETAI KAI\ E)LE/GXEI.&10 Sequitur &10Posidonii contra Chr. argumentatio.$10 A)LLA\ MH\N O(RA=TAI/ GE, KA)\N XRHSTOI=S E)/QESIN E)NTRE/FHTAI KAI\ PROSHKO/NTWS PAIDEU/HTAI, PA/NTWS E)CAMARTA/NONTA/ <20TI KAI\ TOU=T' AU)TO\ KAI\ O( *XRU/SIPPOS O(MOLOGEI=>20. KAI/TOI G' E)NH=N AU)TW=| U(PERIDO/NTI TW=N E)NARGW=S FAINOME/NWN AU)TO\ MO/NON O(MOLOGH=SAI TO\ TAI=S I)DI/AIS U(POQE/SESIN A)KO/-LOUQON, EI) KALW=S A)XQEI/H TA\ PAIDI/A, PA/NTWS AU)TA\ FA/SKONTI SOFOU\S A)/NDRAS GENH/SESQAI TOU= XRO/NOU PROI+O/NTOS. A)LL' OU)K E)TO/LMHSE TOU=TO/ GE KATAYEU/SA-SQAI TW=N FAINOME/NWN, A)LLA\ <20KA)\N U(PO\ FILOSO/FW| TRE/FHTAI MO/NW| KAI\ MHDE\N MH/TE QEA/SHTAI MH/T' A)KOU/SH| PW/POTE PARA/DEIGMA KAKI/AS>20, @1 O(/MWS OU)K E)C A)NA/GKHS AU)TA\ FILOSOFH/SEIN. DITTH\N GA\R EI)=NAI TH=S DIASTROFH=S TH\N AI)TI/AN, E(TE/RAN ME\N E)K KATHXH/SEWS TW=N POLLW=N A)NQRW/PWN E)GGIGNOME/NHN, E(TE/RAN D' E)C AU)TH=S TW=N PRAGMA/TWN TH=S FU/SEWS>20. ___EI) GA\R MH\ TAI=S FWNAI=S, A)LLA\ TH=| GE DUNA/MEI TW=N LEGO-ME/NWN O(MOLOGEI=N E)/OIKEN O( *XRU/SIPPOS, W(S E)/STIN OI)KEI/WSI/S TE/ TIS H(MI=N KAI\ A)LLOTRI/WSIS FU/SEI PRO\S E(/KASTON TW=N EI)RHME/NWN [1&10sc.$10 PRO\S H(DONH\N KAI\ PO/-NON, TIMH\N KAI\ A)TIMI/AN]1. E)PEIDA\N GA\R LE/GH|, <20TA\S PERI\ A)GAQW=N KAI\ KA-KW=N E)GGI/NESQAI TOI=S FAU/LOIS DIASTROFA\S DIA/ TE TH\N PIQANO/THTA TW=N FANTASIW=N KAI\ TH\N KATH/XHSIN>20, E)RWTHTE/ON AU)TO\N TH\N AI)TI/AN, DI' H(\N H(DONH\ ME\N W(S A)GAQO/N, A)LGHDW\N D' W(S KAKO\N PIQANH\N PROBA/LLOUSI FAN-TASI/AN: OU(/TWS DE\ KAI\ DIA\ TI/ <20TH\N ME\N NI/KHN TH\N E)N *)OLUMPI/ASIN KAI\ TH\N TW=N A)NDRIA/NTWN A)NA/QESIN E)PAINOU/MENA/ TE KAI\ MAKARIZO/MENA PRO\S TW=N POLLW=N A)KOU/ONTES W(S A)GAQA/, PERI\ DE\ TH=S H(/TTHS TE KAI\ TH=S A)TIMI/AS W(S KAKW=N E(TOI/MWS PEIQO/MEQA>20. _____E)N DE\ [1&10`167$10]1 TW=| PARO/NTI PRO\S TOU\S PERI\ TO\N *XRU/SIPPON O( LO/GOS E)NE/STHKE/ MOI, MH/T' A)/LLO GIGNW/SKONTAS TW=N KATA\ TA\ PA/QH, MH/Q' W(S AI( TOU= SW/MATOS KRA/SEIS OI)KEI/AS E(AUTAI=S E)RGA/ZONTAI TA\S PAQHTIKA\S KINH/SEIS. &10 De eadem re paullo &10infra%10$ O( DE\ *XRU/SIPPOS OU) MO/NON AU)TO\S OU)DE\N I(KNOU/MENON EI)=PEN, A)LL' OU)DE\ TW=N A)P' AU)TOU= TINI KATE/LIPEN A)FORMH\N EU(RE/SEWS, MOXQHRA\N U(POBALLO/MENOS TW=| LO/GW| TH\N KRHPI=DA. @&10Cicero de legibus I 17, 47. Sed perturbat nos opinionum va-&10rietas hominumque dissensio%10 et quia non idem contingit in sensibus, hos &10natura certos putamus%10 illa quae aliis sic, aliis secus, nec iisdem semper &10uno modo videntur, ficta esse ducimus. Quod est longe aliter. Nam &10sensus nostros non parens, non nutrix, non magister, non poe%28ta, non &10scaena depravat, non multitudinis consensus abducit a vero%10 <21animis &10omnes tenduntur insidiae, vel ab iis>21 quos modo enumeravi, <21qui &10teneros et rudes>21 cum acceperunt, <21inficiunt et flectunt>21, ut volunt, &10<21vel ab ea, quae penitus>21 in omni sensu implicata <21insidet>21, imitatrix &10boni, <21voluptas>21, malorum autem mater omnium%10 cuius blanditiis corrupti, ∋&10quae natura bona sunt, quia dulcedine hac et scabie carent, non cernunt &10satis. Cf. Chalcidius in Timaeum cp. 165sq. Seneca ep. 115. &10@Cicero de legibus I 11, 31. Nec solum in rectis, sed etiam in &10pravitatibus insignis est humani generis similitudo. Nam et <21voluptate &10capiuntur omnes, quae, etsi est illecebra turpitudinis, tamen habet quid-&10dam simile naturali bono%10 levitate enim et suavitate delectans sic ab er-&10rore mentis, tamquam salutare aliquid, asciscitur; similique inscientia mors &10fugitur, quasi dissolutio naturae%10 vita expetitur, quia nos, in quo nati &10sumus, continet%10 dolor in maximis malis ducitur, cum sua asperitate, tum &10quod natura interitus videtur sequi. 32. propterque honestatis et gloriae &10similitudinem, beati, qui honorati sunt, videntur%10 miseri autem, qui sunt &10inglorii. Molestiae, laetitiae, cupiditates, timores similiter omnium mentes &10pervagantur%10 nec, si opiniones aliae sunt apud alios, idcirco qui canem et @1 &10felem ut deos colunt, non eadem superstitione qua ceterae gentes con-&10flictantur. &10@Seneca cp. 115, 11. Admirationem nobis <21parentes>21 auri argen-&10tique fecerunt et teneris infusa cupiditas altius sedit crevitque nobiscum. &10deinde totus <21populus>21 in alia discors in hoc convenit, hoc suspiciunt, hoc &10suis optant. __12. Accedunt deinde <21carmina poe%28tarum>21__qui &10bus divitiae velut unicum vitae decus ornamentumque laudantur. &10@Seneca ep. 94, 53. Nulla ad aures nostras vox impune perfer-&10tur%10 nocent qui optant, nocent qui exsecrantur%10 nam et horum imprecatio &10falsos nobis metus inserit et illorum amor male docet bene optando. mittit &10enim nos ad longinqua bona et incerta et errantia, cum possimus felici-&10tatem domo promere. &10@Origenes contra Celsum III 69 Vol. I p. 261, 12 Ko+. [1p. 492 &10Delarue]1.$10 H(MEI=S DE\ MI/AN FU/SIN E)PISTA/MENOI PA/SHS LOGIKH=S YUXH=S KAI\ MH-DEMI/AN FA/SKONTES PONHRA\N U(PO\ TOU= KTI/SANTOS TA\ O(/LA DEDHMIOURGH=SQAI, <20GEGO-NE/NAI [2DE\]2 POLLOU\S KAKOU\S PARA\ TA\S A)NATROFA\S KAI\ TA\S DIASTRO-FA\S KAI\ TA\S PERIHXH/SEIS>20, W(/STE KAI\ FUSIWQH=NAI E)/N TISI TH\N KAKI/AN &10etc. &10@Galenus$10 PERI\ T. T. YUXH=S H)QW=N&10 ed. Bas. I 351 K. IV p. 816.$10 QAU-MA/ZW DE\ E)N TW=|DE <20TW=N *STWI+KW=N>20 A(/PANTAS ME\N A)NQRW/POUS EI)S A)RETH=S KTH=SIN E)PITHDEI/WS E)/XEIN OI)OME/NWN, <20DIASTRE/FESQAI>20 DE\ U(PO\ TW=N OU) KALW=S ZW/NTWN. @&10ibid. K. p. 818.$10 PA/NU D' H)LI/QIOI/ EI)SI KAI\ <20OI( DIASTRE/FESQAI LE/-GONTES H(MA=S U(PO/ GE TH=S H(DONH=S>20, KAI/TOI GE AU)TH=S ME\N E)XOU/SHS POLU\ [2TO\ E)PAGWGO/N]2, TOU= [2PO/NOU]2 A)POSTREPTIKOU= TE KAI\ TRAXE/OS O)/NTOS. @&10Galenus$10 PERI\ T. T. YUXH=S H)QW=N&10 ed. Bas. I 351 K. IV p. 820.$10 OU) GA/R, W(S OI( *STWI+KOI/ FASIN, <20E)/CWQEN E)PE/RXETAI TAI=S YUXAI=S H(MW=N TO\ SU/MPAN TH=S KAKI/AS>20, A)LLA\ TO\ PLE/ON E)C E(AUTW=N E)/XOUSIN OI( PONHROI\ TW=N A)NQRW/PWN: E)/CWQEN DE\ E)/LATTON TOU/TOU POLLW=| TO\ E)PERXO/MENO/N E)STIN. @&10Clemens Al. Strom. I p. 368 Pott.$10 *OU)/TE DE\ OI( E)/PAINOI OU)/TE OI( YO/GOI OU)Q' AI( TIMAI\ OU)Q' AI( KOLA/SEIS DI/KAIAI, MH\ TH=S YUXH=S E)XOU/SHS TH\N E)COUSI/AN TH=S O(RMH=S KAI\ A)FORMH=S, A)LL' A)KOUSI/OU TH=S KAKI/AS OU)/SHS. __ *)EPEI\ DE\ TW=N A(MARTHMA/TWN PROAI/RESIS KAI\ O(RMH\ KATA/RXEI, DIHMARTHME/NH DE\ U(PO/LHYIS E)/SQ' O(/TE KRATEI=, H(=S A)GNOI/AS KAI\ A)MAQI/AS OU)/SHS O)LIGWROU=MEN A)PO-STH=NAI, EI)KO/TWS E)KO/LASEN [1&10scil.$10 O( QEO/S]1. *KAI\ GA\R TO\ PURE/TTEIN A)KOU/SION: A)LL' O(/TAN DI' E(AUTO/N TIS KAI\ DI' A)KRASI/AN PURE/TTH|, AI)TIW/MEQA TOU=TON. *OU(/TWS DE\ KAI\ TH=S KAKI/AS, A)KOUSI/OU OU)/SHS: OU) GA\R AI(REI=TAI/ TIS KAKO\N H(=| KAKO/N: TH=| DE\ PERI\ AU)TO\ H(DONH=| SUNAPAGO/MENOS, A)GAQO\N U(POLABW/N, LHPTO\N H(GEI=TAI. @&Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 127.$ KAI\ MH\N TH\N A)RETH\N <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 ME\N A)POBLHTH/N, *KLEA/NQHS DE\ A)NAPO/BLHTON: O( ME\N A)POBLHTH\N DIA\ ME/QHN KAI\ MELAGXOLI/AN, O( DE\ A)NAPO/BLHTON DIA\ BEBAI/OUS KATALH/YEIS. @1 @&10Simplicius in Aristot. categ. f. 102A ed. Bas.$10 [1E)K ME\N FAU/LOU SPOUDAI=OS GI/NETAI]1 TO\ D' A)NA/PALIN OI( <20*STWI+KOI\>20 OU) DIDO/ASIN. OU)K EI)=NAI GA/R FASIN A)POBLHTH\N TH\N A)RETH/N. @&10ibid. B.$10 *PRO\S DH\ TAU=TA R(A/|DION LE/GEIN, W(S PRO/XEIRON EI)/LHPTAI TO\ A)NA-PO/BLHTON EI)=NAI TH\N A)RETH/N. KAI\ GA\R *QEO/FRASTOS PERI\ TH=S METABOLH=S AU)TH=S I(KANW=S A)PE/DEICE KAI\ *)ARISTOTE/LEI DOKEI=, OU)K A)NQRW/PEION EI)=NAI TO\ A)NAPO/BLH-TON: E)/TI DE\ KAI\ <20OI( *STWI+KOI\ E)N MELAGXOLI/AIS KAI\ KA/ROIS KAI\ LHQA/R-GOIS KAI\ E)N FARMA/KWN LH/YESI SUGXWROU=SIN A)POBOLH\N GI/NESQAI MEQ' O(/LHS TH=S LOGIKH=S E(/CEWS KAI\ AU)TH=S TH=S A)RETH=S>20, KAKI/AS ME\N OU)K A)NTEISAGOME/NHS, TH=S DE\ BEBAIO/THTOS XALWME/NHS KAI\ EI)S H(\N LE/GOUSIN E(/CIN ME/SHN OI( PALAIOI\ METAPIPTOU/SHS. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de anima libri mant. p. 161, 16 Bruns.$10 E)/TI EI) <20OI(=O/N TE TH\N A)RETH\N E)/XONTA KAI\ E)N LHQA/RGW| KAI\ E)N MELAGXOLI/A| KAI\ E)N SKOTW/SEI KAI\ E)N PARAKOPH=| GENE/SQAI>20, E)N OI(=S O)/NTA A)DU/NATON KAT' A)RETH\N E)NERGEI=N, OU)K AU)TA/RKHS H( A)RETH\ PRO\S TA\S OI)KEI/AS E)NERGEI/AS. PW=S GA\R OI(=O/N TE LE/GEIN TO\N PARAKO/PTONTA KAI\ DESMW=N DEO/MENON DIA\ TOU=TO KAI\ TH=S E)K TW=N FI/LWN BOHQEI/AS FRONI/MWS E)NERGEI=N TO/TE, MH\ BOULOME/NOUS QE/SIN FU-LA/TTEIN; E)/TI EI) H( A)RETH\ TA\ ME\N DIWQEI= KAI\ E)KKLI/NEI TW=N A)DIAFO/RWN <20KATA\ TOU/TOUS>20, TA\ DE\ AI(REI=TAI KAI\ E)KLE/GETAI, OU)K AU)TA/RKHS A)\N EI)/H PRO\S EU)DAIMO-NI/AN. PW=S GA\R EU)DAI/MWN O( W)\N E)N TOU/TOIS, A(\ H( A)RETH\ DIWQEI=TAI; @&10Clemens Al. Strom. IV 22 p. 627 Pott.$10 OU)X E(/CEI TH\N A)RETH\N A)PO/BLHTON OU(=TOS OU)DAMW=S, OU)/TE U(/PAR OU)/TE O)/NAR, OU)DE\ KATA\ FANTASI/AN TINA/. E)PEI\ MHD' E)CI/STATAI/ POQ' E(AUTH=S H( E(/CIS, A)POPESOU=SA TOU= E(/CIS EI)=NAI, EI)/T' OU)=N E(/CIS H( GNW=SIS EI)/TE DIA/QESIS EI)=NAI LE/GOITO. TW=| GA\R MH\ PAREISIE/NAI POTE\ E)N-NOI/AS DIAFO/ROUS, A)NALLOI/WTON TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N ME/NON OU) PROSLAMBA/NEI TINA\ E(TEROI/WSIN FANTASIW=N, TA\S E)K TW=N MEQHMERINW=N KINH/SEWN A)NEIDWLOPOII/+AS O)NEIRW=TTON. @&10Theognetus comicus$10 *FA/SMATI H)\ *FILARGU/RW|&10 IV p. 549 Mein.$10 *)/ANQRWP', A)POLEI=S ME: TW=N GA\R <20E)K TH=S POIKI/LHS %5 *STOA=S>20 LOGARI/WN A)NAPE-PLHSME/NOS NOSEI=S: %5 "1A)LLO/TRIO/N E)SQ' O( PLOU=TOS A)NQRW/PW|"2 PA/XNH: %5 "1SOFI/A D' I)/DION"2, KRU/STALLOS. "1<20OU)DEI\S PW/POTE %5 TAU/THN LABW\N A)PW/LES'>20."2 W)= TA/-LAS E)GW/, %5 OI(/W| M' O( DAI/MWN FILOSO/FW| SUNW/|KISEN; @&10Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 29 p. 199, 27.$10 TH\N ME\N OU)=N E(/CIN MHKE/T' E)/XEIN OU)K E)P' AU)TW=| [1&10scil. penes eum qui virtutem adeptus est]1__ $10E)P' AU)TW=N DE\ TW=N E)NERGEIW=N, W(=N TH\N E(/CIN E)/XWN E)NERGEI=, E)P' AU)TW=| KAI\ MH\ POIH=SAI/ TINA. KAI\ GA\R EI) O(/TI MA/LISTA <20EU)/LOGON TO\ TO\N FRO/NIMON TA\S KATA\ TO\N LO/GON KAI\ TH\N FRO/NHSIN E)NERGEI/AS E)NERGEI=N>20, PRW=TON ME\N OU)X W(RISME/NWS AI(/DE TINE\S TOIAU=TAI&10 etc. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 27 p. 1046f.$8 *)ALLA\ TW=| E(/KTW| TW=N *)HQIKW=N *ZHTHMA/TWN>20 O( *XRU/SIPPOS "1OU)K A)EI/ FHSIN A)N- @1DRI/ZESQAI TO\N A)STEI=ON, OU)DE\ DEILAI/NEIN TO\N FAU=LON, W(S DE\ E)N FANTASI/AIS E)PIFEROME/NWN TINW=N, TO\N ME\N E)MME/NEIN TOI=S KRI/MASI, TO\N D' A)FI/STASQAI. "1<20*PIQANO\N DE/, FHSI/, MHD' A)KOLASTAI/NEIN A)EI\ TO\N FAU=LON>20."2 @&10Philo de sobrietate %14 34 Vol. II p. 222, 10 Wendl.$10 SXE/SIS KAI\ KI/NHSIS DIAFE/ROUSIN A)LLH/LWN: H( ME\N GA/R E)STIN H)REMI/A, FORA\ DE\ H( KI/NHSIS: H(=S EI)/DH DU/O, TO\ ME\N METABATIKO/N, TO\ DE\ PERI\ TO\N AU)TO\N TO/PON EI)LOU/MENON. SXE/SEI ME\N OU)=N A)DELFO\N E(/CIS, KINH/SEI D' E)NE/RGEIA. TO\ DE\ LEGO/MENON PARA-DEI/GMATI OI)KEI/W| GNWRIMW/TERON GE/NOIT' A)/N: TE/KTONA KAI\ ZWGRA/FON KAI\ GEWRGO\N KAI\ MOUSIKO\N KAI\ TOU\S A)/LLOUS TEXNI/TAS, KA)\N H(SUXI/AN A)/GWSI MHDE\N TW=N KATA\ TA\S TE/XNAS E)NERGOU=NTES, OU)DE\N H(=TTON TOI=S EI)RHME/NOIS E)/QOS KALEI=N O)NO/MASIN, E)PEI\ TH\N E)N E(KA/STOIS E)MPEIRI/AN KAI\ E)PISTH/MHN A)NEILHFO/TES E)/XOUSIN. E)PEIDA\N DE\ O( TEKTONIKO\S CU/LON [U(/LHN] E)RGA/ZHTAI LABW/N__KAI\ TW=N A)/LLWN E(/KA-STOS TEXNITW=N EI)/PER E)GXEIREI= TOI=S KATA\ TA\S E)PISTH/MAS, E(/TERA E)C A)NA/GKHS OI)-KEI=A TOI=S PROTE/ROIS O)NO/MATA PROSGI/NETAI, TW=| ME\N TE/KTONI TO\ TEKTONEI=N, TW=| DE\ ZWGRA/FW| TO\ ZWGRAFEI=N &10etc.$10 <20TI/SIN OU)=N OI( YO/GOI KAI\ OI( E)/PAINOI PARA-KOLOUQOU=SIN; A)=R' OU)XI\ TOI=S E)NERGOU=SI KAI\ DRW=SI; KATORQOU=NTES ME\N GA\R E)/PAINON, YO/GON D' E)/MPALIN KARPOU=NTAI DIAMARTA/NONTES. _&10%14 38.$10 O( AU)TO\S TOI/NUN LO/GOS E)FARMO/TTEI KAI\ TOI=S KAT' A)FROSU/NHN KAI\ SUNO/LWS TOI=S KAT' A)RETH/N TE KAI\ KAKI/AN>20. OI( FRO/NIMOI/ TE KAI\ SW/FRONES KAI\ A)NDREI=OI KAI\ DI/KAIOI TA\S YUXA\S MURI/OI GEGO/NASI__TO\ DE\ KA/LLOS TW=N E)N TAI=S DIANOI/AIS A)GALMA/TWN OU)K I)/SXUSAN E)PIDEI/CASQAI DIA\ PENI/AN H)\ A)DOCI/AN H)\ NO/SON SW/MATOS_. OU)KOU=N OU(=TOI ME\N W(/SPER DEDEME/NA KAI\ KAQEIRGME/NA E)KTH/SANTO A)GAQA/, E(/TEROI D' EI)SI\N OI(\ LELUME/NOIS_E)XRH/SANTO PA=SI, TA\S EI)S E)PI/DEICIN U(/LAS A)FQONWTA/TAS PROSLABO/NTES: O( ME\N FRO/NIMOS I)DI/WN TE KAI\ KOINW=N PROSTASI/AN PRAGMA/TWN, OI(=S SU/NESIN KAI\ EU)BOULI/AN E)NEPI-DEI/CETAI: O( DE\ SW/FRWN TO\N EI)S A)SWTI/AN DEINO\N E)PA=RAI KAI\ PARAKALE/SAI TU-FLO\N PLOU=TON I(/NA BLE/PONTA A)PODEI/CH|: O( DE\ DI/KAIOS A)RXH/N, DI' H(=S TO\ KAT' A)CI/AN A)PONE/MEIN E(KA/STW| TW=N O)/NTWN A)KWLU/TWS DUNATO\S E)/STAI. __A)/NEU DE\ TOU/TWN A)RETAI\ ME/N EI)SIN, A)KI/NHTOI DE\ A)RETAI\ KAI\ H(SUXI/AN A)/GOUSAI. &10Idem &10ad vitia pertinere docet sequentibus. &10@Cicero de legibus I 8, 25. Iam vero <21virtus eadem in ho-&10mine ac deo>21 est, neque alio ullo in genere praeterea. Est autem virtus &10nihil aliud nisi perfecta et ad summum perducta natura. @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 33 p. 107a.$ *)ALLA\ KATA\ <20*XRU/-SIPPON>20 OU)DE\ TOU=TO PERI/ESTIN AU)TOI=S [1&sc.$ QEOI=S TO\ EU)DAIMONEI=N]1 "1<20A)RETH=| TE GA\R OU)X U(PERE/XEIN TO\N *DI/A TOU= *DI/WNOS, W)FELEI=-SQAI/ TE O(MOI/WS U(P' A)LLH/LWN TO\N *DI/A KAI\ TO\N *DI/WNA, SOFOU\S O)/NTAS, O(/TAN E(/TEROS QATE/ROU TUGXA/NH| KINOUME/NOU>20."2 @1 @&10Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 37 p. 211, 13 Bruns.$10 OU) GA\R <20TA\S AU)TA\S A)RETA\S OI(=O/N TE LE/GEIN EI)=NAI TW=N TE A)NQRW/PWN KAI\ TW=N QEW=N>20: OU)/TE GA\R A)/LLWS A)LHQE\S TO\ TA\S TW=N TOSOU=TON A)LLH/LWN KATA\ TH\N FU/SIN DIESTW/TWN TA\S AU)TA\S TELEIO/THTA/S TE KAI\ A)RETA\S LE/GEIN, OU)/Q' OI( PRO\S AU)TW=N [1&10scil. a Chrysippo]1$10 PERI\ AU)TW=N LEGO/MENOI LO/GOI EU)/LOGO/N TI E)N AU(TOI=S E)/XOUSIN. @&10Origenes contra Celsum VI 48 Vol. II p. 119, 16 Ko+. [1p. 670 &10Delarue]1.$10 EI)=TA E)A\N ME\N <20TH\N AU)TH\N A)RETH\N LE/GONTES A)NQRW/POU KAI\ QEOU= OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 FILO/SOFOI MH\ EU)DAIMONE/STERON LE/GWSIN EI)=NAI TO\N E)PI\ PA=SI QEO\N TOU= E)N A)NQRW/POIS KAT' AU)TOU\S SOFOU=, A)LL' I)/SHN EI)=NAI TH\N A)MFOTE/RWN EU)DAIMONI/AN *KE/LSOS OU) KATAGELA=|&10 etc. &10@Origenes contra Celsum IV 29 Vol. I p. 298, 27 [1p. 522 Del.$10]1. W(/STE KAI\ H( AU)TH\ A)RETH\ A)NQRW/POU KAI\ QEOU=. @&10Clemens Al. Strom. VII 14 p. 886 Pott.$10 OU) GA\R KAQA/PER. <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 A)QE/WS PA/NU TH\N AU)TH\N A)RETH\N A)NQRW/POU LE/GOMEN KAI\ QEOU=. @&Themistius Orat. II p. 27c.$ *EI) D' AU)= FH/SEIE/ TIS KOLAKEI/AN EI)=NAI TW=| *PUQI/W| PARABA/LLEIN TO\N BASILE/A, <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 ME\N U(MI=N KAI\ *KLEA/NQHS OU) SUGXWRH/SEI KAI\ O(/LON E)/QNOS FILOSOFI/AS, O( E)K TH=S POI-KI/LHS XORO/S, OI( FA/SKONTES EI)=NAI TH\N AU)TH\N A)RETH\N KAI\ A)LH/QEIAN A)N-DRO\S KAI\ QEOU=. @&10Proclus in Platonis Timaeum p. 106 F. Schn.$10 OI( DE\ <20A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 KAI\ TH\N AU)TH\N A)RETH\N EI)=NAI KAI\ A)NQRW/PWN EI)RH/KASI, POLLOU= DEO/NTES TH=S TOU= *PLA/TWNOS O(SIO/THTOS EI)=NAI ZHLWTAI\ KAI\ TH=S *SWKRATIKH=S ME-TRIO/THTOS. @&10Lactant. instit. div. III 25. Quodsi natura hominis sapientiae &10capax est, oportuit et <21opifices et rusticos et mulieres>21 et omnes de-&10nique, qui humanam formam gerunt, doceri, <21ut sapiant>21; populumque &10[2sapientum]2 ex omni lingua et conditione et sexu et aetate conflari. __ &10Senserunt hoc adeo <21Stoici, qui et servis et mulieribus philoso-&10phandum esse dixerunt>21, Epicurus quoque qui rudes omnium literarum &10ad philosophiam invitat. @&10Clemens Al. Strom. IV 8 p. 590.$10 W(MOLO/GHTAI D' H(MI=N TH\N AU)-TH\N FU/SIN KATA\ GE/NOS E(/KASTON TH\N AU)TH\N KAI\ I)/SXEIN A)RETH/N: OU)K A)/LLHN TOI/NUN PRO\S TH\N A)NQRWPO/THTA FU/SIN E)/XEIN H( GUNH/, A)/LLHN DE\ O( A)NH\R FAI/-NETAI, A)LLA\ TH\N AU)TH/N: W(/STE KAI\ TH\N A)RETH/N. @&10idem p. 592.$10 FILOSOFHTE/ON OU)=N KAI\ TAI=S GUNAICI/N, E)MFERW=S TOI=S A)N-DRA/SIN &10etc. @&Plutarchus de virtute morali cp. 2 p. 441a.$ E)/OIKE DE\ KAI\ *ZH/NWN EI)S TOU=TO/ PWS U(POFE/RESQAI O( *KITIEU\S [1&praecedentibus Aristo-&nis de virtutibus sententia enarratur]1$ O(RIZO/MENOS TH\N FRO/NHSIN E)N ME\N @1 A)PONEMHTE/OIS DIKAIOSU/NHN, E)N D' AI(RETE/OIS SWFROSU/NHN, E)N DE\ U(POME-NETE/OIS A)NDREI/AN: A)POLOGOU/MENOI DE\ A)CIOU=SIN E)N TOU/TOIS TH\N E)PISTH/MHN FRO/NHSIN U(PO\ TOU= *ZH/NWNOS W)NOMA/SQAI. <20*XRU/SIPPOS DE\ KATA\ TO\ POIO\N A)RETH\N I)DI/A| POIO/THTI SUNI/STASQAI NOMI/ZWN>20 E)/LAQEN E(AU-TO\N KATA\ TO\N *PLA/TWNA "1SMH=NOS A)RETW=N"2 OU) SU/NHQES OU)DE\ GNW/RIMON E)GEI/RAS: W(S GA\R PARA\ TO\N A)NDREI=ON A)NDREI/AN KAI\ PARA\ TO\N PRA=|ON PRA|O/THTA KAI\ DIKAIOSU/NHN PARA\ TO\N DI/KAION, OU(/TWS PARA\ TO\N XARI/ENTA <20XARIENTO/THTA>20 KAI\ PARA\ TO\N E)SQLO\N <20E)SQLO/THTA>20, KAI\ PARA\ TO\N ME/-GAN <20MEGALO/THTA>20, KAI\ PARA\ TO\N KALO\N <20KALO/THTA>20, E(TE/RAS TE TOIAU/-TAS <20E)PIDECIO/THTAS, EU)APANTHSI/AS, EU)TRAPELI/AS>20 A)RETA\S TIQE/ME-NOS, POLLW=N KAI\ A)TO/PWN O)NOMA/TWN OU)DE\N DEOME/NHN E)MPE/PLHKE FILO-SOFI/AN. @&Galenus de H. et Plat. decr. VII 2 [1`208. 591 M.]1 de Chrysippi &libro, quem contra Aristonem conscripsit$ <20PERI\ TOU= POIA\S EI)=NAI TA\S A)RETA/S>20,& disputans%10$ NOMI/SAS GOU=N O( *)ARI/STWN MI/AN EI)=NAI TH=S YUXH=S DU/NAMIN, H(=| LOGIZO/MEQA, KAI\ TH\N A)RETH\N TH=S YUXH=S E)/QETO MI/AN, E)PI-STH/MHN A)GAQW=N KAI\ KAKW=N. O(/TAN ME\N OU)=N AI(REI=SQAI/ TE DE/H| TA)GAQA\ KAI\ FEU/GEIN TA\ KAKA/, TH\N E)PISTH/MHN TH/NDE KALEI= SWFROSU/NHN: O(/TAN DE\ PRA/TTEIN ME\N TA)GAQA/, MH\ PRA/TTEIN DE\ TA\ KAKA/, FRO/NHSIN: A)NDREI/AN DE\ O(/TAN TA\ ME\N QARRH=|, TA\ DE\ FEU/GH|: O(/TAN DE\ TO\ KATA\ A)CI/AN E(KA/STW| NE/MH|, DIKAIOSU/NHN: E(NI\ DE\ LO/GW| GINW/SKOUSA ME\N H( YUXH\ XWRI\S TOU= PRA/TTEIN TA)GAQA/ TE KAI\ KAKA\ SOFI/A TE/ E)STI KAI\ E)PISTH/MH, PRO\S DE\ TA\S PRA/CEIS A)FIKNOUME/NH TA\S KATA\ TO\N BI/ON, O)NO/MATA PLEI/W LAMBA/NEI TA\ PROEIRHME/NA, FRO/NHSI/S TE KAI\ SWFROSU/NH KAI\ DIKAIOSU/NH KAI\ A)N-DREI/A KALOUME/NH. TOIAU/TH ME/N TIS H( *)ARI/STWNOS DO/CA PERI\ TW=N TH=S YUXH=S A)RETW=N. O(/ GE MH\N *XRU/SIPPOS OU)K OI)=DA O(/PWS A)NTILE/GEIN E)PI-XEIREI= TA)NDRI\ TH\N KOINH\N PRO\S AU)TO\N U(PO/QESIN A)KRIBW=S DIAFULA/T-TONTI. <20KALW=S GA\R A(/PANTA GINWSKO/NTWN TE KAI\ PRATTO/NTWN H(MW=N A)\N O( BI/OS DIOIKOI=TO KATA\ E)PISTH/MHN, KAKW=S DE\ KAI\ YEU-DW=S GINWSKO/NTWN TE KAI\ PRATTO/NTWN KATA\ A)/GNOIAN, W(S AU)-TO\S O( *XRU/SIPPOS BOU/LETAI>20, KAI\ DIA\ TAU=TA MI/A ME\N A)RETH\ GI/NOITO A)/N, H( E)PISTH/MH, MI/A DE\ W(SAU/TWS H( KAKI/A, PROSAGOREUOME/NH KAI\ H(/DE POTE\ ME\N A)/GNOIA, POTE\ DE\ A)NEPISTHMOSU/NH. E)A\N OU)=N TIS TO\N QA/NATON H)\ TH\N PENI/AN H)\ TH\N NO/SON W(S KAKA\ DEDIW\S H)=|, DE/ON QAR)R(EI=N, W(S E)PI\ A)DIAFO/ROIS, E)NDEI/A| ME\N E)PISTH/MHS AU)TO\N TI/QENTAI A)GNOEI=N TA)LHQE/S, W(S A)\N *)ARI/STWN TE KAI\ *XRU/SIPPOS EI)/POI, KAKI/AN DE\ E)/XEIN YUXH=S, H(\N O)NOMA/ZOUSI DEILI/AN, H(=| E)NANTI/AN A)RETH\N AU)TOI/ FASIN EI)=NAI <20TH\N A)N-DREI/AN, E)PISTH/MHN OU)=SAN W(=N XRH\ QAR)R(EI=N H)\ MH\ QARREI=N>20, TOU-TE/STIN A)GAQW=N TE KAI\ KAKW=N TW=N O)/NTWS DHLONO/TI TOIOU/TWN, OU) KATA\ @1 YEUDH= DO/CAN U(PEILHMME/NWN, OI(=A/PER E)STI\N U(GI/EIA KAI\ PLOU=TOS KAI\ NO/SOS KAI\ PENI/A. TOU/TWN GA\R OU)DE\N OU)/TE A)GAQO\N OU)/TE KAKO\N EI)=NAI/ FASIN, A)LLA\ A)DIA/FORA PA/NTA. KAI\ TOI/NUN, EI) TO\ ME\N H(DU\ NOMI/SAS TIS A)GAQO/N, TO\ DE\ A)NIARO\N KAKO\N A)KOLOUQW=N TH=| DO/CH| TH=|DE TOU= ME\N TH\N AI(/RESIN POIOI=TO, TOU= DE\ TH\N FUGH/N, A)MAQH/S E)STIN OU)SI/AS A)GAQOU= KAI\ DIA\ TAU=TA A)KO/LASTOS. E)N A(PA/SAIS GA\R PRA/CESIN AI(ROUME/NWN H(MW=N TO\ FAINO/MENON A)GAQO/N, FEUGO/NTWN DE\ TO\ FAINO/MENON KAKO/N, E)XO/NTWN DE\ FU/SEI TA\S O(RMA\S TAU/TAS E)F' E(KA/TERON H( FILOSOFI/A DIDA/SKOUSA TO\ KATA\ A)LH/QEIAN A)GAQO/N TE KAI\ KAKO\N A)NAMARTH/TOUS E)RGA/ZETAI. *XRU/SIPPOS DE\ OU)K OI)=DA O(/PWS, W(/SPER OI( I)DIW=TAI LO/GWN, TH=| DIAFORA=| TW=N FWNW=N, OU) TOI=S TUGXA/NOUSIN AU)TAI=S PRA/GMASI PROSE/XEI TO\N NOU=N, <20E(/TERO/N TI NOMI/ZWN DHLOU=SQAI KAQ' E(KA/STHN TW=NDE TW=N FWNW=N, AI(RE-TE/ON, POIHTE/ON, QARRHTE/ON, A)GAQO/N>20. E)/STI DE\ OU)X E(/TERON, A)LLA\ E)N A(PA/SAIS TAU)TO/N, O(/PER E)K TH=S A)GAQO\N DHLOU=TAI. ___A(PA/SAIS GA\R TAU/TAIS TAI=S LE/CESIN A)GAQO\N KAI\ KAKO\N LE/GEI <20KAI\ KATA\ AU)TO\N TO\N *XRU/SIPPON, EI)/ GE DH\ TO\ A)GAQO\N AU)TO\ MO/NON E)STI\ AI(RE-TE/ON KAI\ POIHTE/ON KAI\ QARRHTE/ON>20: W(/STE TH\N TW=N A)GAQW=N E)PI-STH/MHN E)N DIAFO/ROIS U(/LAIS H)\ PRA/CESIN E)CETAZOME/NHN O)NO/MATA PLEI/W LAMBA/NEIN, E(/KASTON E)N TW=| PRO/S TI KATA\ TH\N U(/LHN H)\ TH\N PRA=CIN U(FI-STA/MENON. ___OU(/TWS OU)=N KA)N <20TOI=S PERI\ TH=S TW=N A)RETW=N DIAFORA=S>20 O( *XRU/SIPPOS A)POXWRW=N TW=N E)PISTHMONIKW=N KAI\ A)PODEIKTI-KW=N LHMMA/TWN E)N TOI=S U(POLOI/POIS A)LA=TAI TRISI\ GE/NESIN, O(\S <20E)/N GE TW=| POIA\S EI)=NAI TA\S A)RETA\S>20 E)PISTHMONIKW=N MA=LLON A(/PTETAI, KATABAL-LO/NTWN ME\N O)/NTWS TO\N *)ARI/STWNOS LO/GON, OU) MH\N TH=| GE OI)KEI/A| PRE-PO/NTWN U(POQE/SEI. @&Galenus de H. et Plat. decr. V 5 [1`167]1 p. 446 Mu+.$ E(/PETAI D' AU)=QIS TOI=SDE [1&sc.$ TW=| PERI\ TW=N PAQW=N LO/GW|]1 KAI\ O( PERI\ TW=N A)RETW=N LO/GOS AU)TO\S E)/XWN TO\ SFA/LMA DITTO/N, EI)/T' E)PISTH/MAS TIS A(PA/SAS AU)-TA/S, EI)/TE DUNA/MEIS U(POLA/BOI. TW=N ME\N GA\R A)LO/GWN TH=S YUXH=S MERW=N A)LO/GOUS A)NA/GKH KAI\ TA\S A)RETA\S EI)=NAI, TOU= LOGISTIKOU= DE\ MO/NOU LOGI-KH/N. W(/ST' EU)LO/GWS E)KEI/NWN ME\N AI( A)RETAI\ DUNA/MEIS EI)SI/N, E)PISTH/MH DE\ MO/NOU TOU= LOGISTIKOU=. <20*XRU/SIPPOS DE\ MEGA/LA SFA/LLETAI, OU)X O(/TI MHDEMI/AN A)RETH\N E)POI/HSE DU/NAMIN>20 [1OU) GA\R ME/GA TO\ TOIOU=-TON SFA/LMA E)STI/N, OU)DE\ DIAFERO/MEQA PRO\S AU)TO\]1 <20A)LL' O(/TI POLLA\S E)PISTH/MAS TE KAI\ A)RETA\S EI)=NAI FH/SAS MI/AN E)/FHSEN EI)=NAI DU/-NAMIN TH=S YUXH=S>20. OU) GA\R E)NDE/XETAI MIA=S DUNA/MEWS A)RETA\S EI)=NAI POLLA/S, EI)/GE MHDE\ TELEIO/THTAS POLLA\S E(NO\S PRA/GMATOS. MI/A GA\R E(KA/-STOU TW=N O)/NTWN H( TELEIO/THS, H( D' <20A)RETH\ TELEIO/THS E)STI\ TH=S E(KA/-STOU FU/SEWS, W(S AU)TO\S O(MOLOGEI=>20. KA/LLION OU)=N *)ARI/STWN O( *XI=OS, @1 OU)/TE POLLA\S EI)=NAI TA\S A)RETA\S TH=S YUXH=S A)POFHNA/MENOS, A)LLA\ MI/AN, H(\N E)PISTH/MHN A)GAQW=N TE KAI\ KAKW=N EI)=NAI/ FHSIN, OU)/TE PERI\ TW=N PA-QW=N E)NANTI/A TAI=S I)DI/AIS U(POQE/SESI GRA/YAS, W(/SPER O( *XRU/SIPPOS. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 7 p. 1034d.$ *OU) MO/NON DE\ O( *ZH/NWN PERI\ TAU=TA FAI/NETAI AU(TW=| MAXO/MENOS [1&unane sit virtus an &complures]1,$ A)LLA\ KAI\ *XRU/SIPPOS, *)ARI/STWNI ME\N E)GKALW=N, O(/TI MIA=S A)RETH=S SXE/SEIS E)/LEGE TA\S A)/LLAS EI)=NAI, *ZH/NWNI DE\ SUNHGORW=N OU(/TWS O(RIZOME/NW| TW=N A)RETW=N E(KA/STHN. @&Galenus de H. et Plat. decr. VII [1`206. 583 M.]1.$ OU) MO/NON DE\ TOU\S PERI\ YUXH=S H(GEMONIKOU= LO/GOUS H)RWTHME/NOUS U(PO\ AU)TW=N E)LE/GXON-TES E)MHKU/NAMEN, A)LLA\ KAI\ TA\ PERI\ TW=N PAQW=N TH=S YUXH=S U(PO\ *XRU-SI/PPOU GEGRAMME/NA, TOU=TO ME\N E)N TOI=S LOGIKOI=S U(POMNH/MASI TRISI/, TOU=TO DE\ E)N TW=| QERAPEUTIKW=|, META\ TOU= KAI\ DEIKNU/EIN AU)TO\N E(AUTW=| DIAFERO/MENON. E)PEMNH/SQHMEN DE\ KAI\ TW=N *POSEIDWNI/OU SUGGRAMMA/TWN, E)N OI(=S E)PAINEI= TO\N PALAIO\N LO/GON E)LE/GXWN TA\ *XRUSI/PPW| KAKW=S EI)RH-ME/NA PERI/ TE TW=N PAQW=N TH=S YUXH=S KAI\ TW=N A)RETW=N TH=S DIAFORA=S. W(/SPER GA\R A)NAIREI=TAI TA\ PA/QH TH=S YUXH=S, EI) MO/NON EI)/H TO\ LOGISTIKO\N AU)TH=|, MHDENO\S MH/TE E)PIQUMHTIKOU= MH/TE QUMOEIDOU=S O)/NTOS, OU(/TW KAI\ TW=N A)RETW=N PLH\N FRONH/SEWS AI( LOIPAI\ PA=SAI. KAI/TOI KA)NTAU=QA EI)/ TIS E)PECE/RXOITO TW=| LO/GW| <20TA/ TE PERI\ TH=S DIAFORA=S TW=N A)RETW=N E)N TE/TTARSI BIBLI/OIS U(PO\ *XRUSI/PPOU GEGRAMME/NA>20 BASANI/ZWN O(/SA TE KAQ' E(\N A)/LLO DIH=LQEN, W(=| DEI/KNUSI <20POIA\S EI)=NAI TA\S A)RETA\S>20 E)LE/GXWN TO\N *)ARI/STWNOS LO/GON, OU)X E(NO\S H)\ DUOI=N A)LLA\ TRIW=N H)\ TET-TA/RWN A)\N DEHQEI/H BIBLI/WN. E)/STI ME\N GA\R KA)NTAU=QA LO/GOS EI(=S BRAXU\S E)PISTHMONIKO\S E)LE/GXWN TO\N *XRU/SIPPON, OU)/TE TA)LHQH= PRESBEU/ONTA KAI\ MHKU/NONTA PERITTW=S. A)LLA\ OI( MH/TE PAIDEUQE/NTES E)N A)PODEIKTIKH=| ME-QO/DW| MH/Q' O(/LWS GNO/NTES, O(POI/A TI/S E)STI, MO/NW| DE\ TW=| MEGE/QEI KAI\ PLH/QEI TW=N U(PO\ *XRUSI/PPOU GRAFE/NTWN BIBLI/WN PROSE/XONTES TO\N NOU=N A)LHQH= NOMI/ZOUSI PA/NQ' U(PA/RXEIN AU)TA/. KAI\ GA\R KAI\ O)/NTWS E)STI\ TA\ PLEI=STA AU)TW=N A)LHQH= KAI\ MA/LISTA/ GE TA\ KATA\ E)KEI=NO TO\ BIBLI/ON, E)N W(=| DEI/KNUSI POIA\S EI)=NAI TA\S A)RETA/S. A)LLA\ O(/TI TW=| MI/AN U(POQEME/NW| DU/NAMIN U(PA/RXEIN E)N TH=| YUXH=| TH\N LOGIKH/N TE KAI\ KRITIKH\N O)NOMAZO-ME/NHN, A)NELO/NTI DE\ TH\N E)PIQUMHTIKH/N TE KAI\ QUMOEIDH=, KAQA/PER O( *XRU/SIPPOS A)NEI=LE, MA/XETAI TA\ KATA\ TOU=TO TO\ BIBLI/ON EI)RHME/NA, TAUTI\ ME/MYAITO A)/N TIS AU)TW=|: TO\ ME/NTOI KATABA/LLESQAI TH\N *)ARI/STWNOS AI(/-RESIN A)LHQW=S U(PO\ TW=N GEGRAMME/NWN OU)K A)/N TIS ME/MYAITO. NOMI/ZEI GA\R O( A)NH\R E)KEI=NOS MI/AN OU)=SAN TH\N A)RETH\N O)NO/MASI PLEI/OSIN O)NOMA/- @1ZESQAI KATA\ TH\N PRO/S TI SXE/SIN. <20O( TOI/NUN *XRU/SIPPOS DEI/KNUSIN OU)K E)N TH=| PRO/S TI SXE/SEI GINO/MENON TO\ PLH=QOS TW=N A)RETW=N TE KAI\ KAKIW=N, A)LLA\ E)N TAI=S OI)KEI/AIS OU)SI/AIS U(PALLATTOME/-NAIS KATA\ TA\S POIO/THTAS, W(S O( TW=N PALAIW=N H)BOU/LETO LO/-GOS>20: O(/PER KAI\ AU)TO\ BRAXU\ PARATRE/YAS O( *XRU/SIPPOS E(TE/RAIS LE/CESI DIH=LQEN <20E)N TW=| POIA\S EI)=NAI TA\S A)RETA\S>20 TOI=S TE E)PIXEIRH/MASIN OU) PRE/POUSI TW=| TO\ LOGIKO\N EI)=NAI MO/NON TH=S YUXH=S TEQEIME/NW|, TO\ PAQHTI-KO\N DE\ A)NH|RHKO/TI. PW=S OU)=N E)GW\ TOU= MH/KOUS TW=N LO/GWN AI)/TIOS, E)A\N A)NAGKASQW= NU=N A)PODEIKNU/EIN A)LLOTRI/AS AI(RE/SEWS E)PIXEIRH/MASI XRW/-MENON TO\N *XRU/SIPPON EI)KO/TWS KATABALEI=N TH\N *)ARI/STWNOS DO/CAN; @&10Galenus in Hippocr. de humoribus lib. II Vol. XVI p. 303 K.$10 A)LL' O(/MWS E)/NIOI/ FASI MI/AN EI)=NAI TH=S YUXH=S OU)SI/AN: TH\N D' A)RETH\N EI)=NAI BOU/LONTAI TE-LEIO/THTA TH=S E(KA/STOU FU/SEWS. EI) ME\N OU)=N TI TOIOU=TON PRA=GMA/ E)STIN H( A)RETH/, MI/A E)/STAI, EI)/PER KAI\ TELEIO/THS E)STI\ MI/A: KAI\ OU(/TW KATA\ TO\ LOGISTIKO\N ME/ROS TH=S YUXH=S A)NAGKAI=ON E)PISTH/MHN EI)=NAI TH\N A)RETH/N: KAI\ EI)/PER E(\N MO/NON E)STI\ TOU=TO E)N TAI=S YUXAI=S H(MW=N, TO\ LOGIZO/MENON, OU) XRH\ ZHTEI=N A)RETA\S POLLA/S. @&Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 92.$ *PANAI/TIOS ME\N OU)=N DU/O FHSI\N A)RETA/S __TE/TTARAS DE\ OI( PERI\ *POSEIDW/NION KAI\ PLEI/ONAS OI( PERI\ *KLE-A/NQHN <20KAI\ *XRU/SIPPON>20. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 59, 4 W.$10 <20FRO/NHSIN>20 D' EI)=NAI E)PISTH/MHN W(=N POIHTE/ON KAI\ OU) POIHTE/ON KAI\ OU)DETE/RWN H)\ E)PISTH/MHN A)GAQW=N KAI\ KAKW=N KAI\ OU)DETE/RWN FU/SEI POLITIKOU= ZW/|OU [1KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N LOIPW=N DE\ A)RETW=N OU(/TWS A)KOU/EIN PARAGGE/LLOUSI]1. <20SWFROSU/NHN>20 D' EI)=NAI E)PISTH/MHN AI(RETW=N KAI\ FEUKTW=N KAI\ OU)DETE/RWN: <20DIKAIOSU/NHN>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MHN A)PONEMHTIKH\N TH=S A)CI/AS E(KA/STW|: <20A)NDREI/AN>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MHN DEINW=N KAI\ OU) DEINW=N KAI\ OU)DETE/RWN: <20A)FROSU/NHN>20 DE\ [2A)/GNOIAN]2 A)GAQW=N KAI\ KAKW=N KAI\ OU)DETE/RWN, H)\ A)/GNOIAN W(=N POIHTE/ON KAI\ OU) POIHTE/ON KAI\ OU)DETE/RWN: <20A)KOLASI/AN>20 DE\ A)/GNOIAN AI(RE-TW=N KAI\ FEUKTW=N KAI\ OU)DETE/RWN: [2<20A)DIKI/AN>20 DE\ A)/GNOIAN MH\ A)PONEMHTIKH\N TH=S A)CI/AS E(KA/STW|]2: <20DEILI/AN>20 DE\ A)/GNOIAN DEINW=N KAI\ OU) DEINW=N KAI\ OU)DETE/-RWN. *PARAPLHSI/WS DE\ KAI\ TA\S A)/LLAS A)RETA\S KAI\ KAKI/AS O(RI/ZONTAI, TW=N EI)RHME/NWN E)XO/MENOI. *KOINO/TERON DE\ TH\N A)RETH\N DIA/QESIN EI)=NAI/ FASI YUXH=S SU/MFWNON AU(TH=| PERI\ O(/LON TO\N BI/ON. @&10Philo Leg. Alleg. I %14 63 Vol. I p. 77, 12 Wendl$10 *DIA\ TOU/TWN BOU/LETAI TA\S KATA\ ME/ROS A)RETA\S U(POGRA/FEIN: EI)SI\ DE\ TO\N A)RIQMO\N TE/SSARES, FRO/NHSIS, SWFROSU/NH, A)NDRI/A, DIKAIOSU/NH. @%14&10 65.$10 H( ME\N <20FRO/NHSIS>20 PERI\ TA\ POIHTE/A, O(/ROUS AU)TOI=S TIQEI=SA, H( DE\ @1 <20A)NDREI/A>20 TOI=S U(POMENETE/OIS: H( DE\ <20SWFROSU/NH>20 TOI=S AI(RETE/OIS: H( DE\ <20DIKAIO-SU/NH>20 TOI=S A)PONEMHTE/OIS. @%14&10 67.$10 KATA\ DE\ TO\N TO/PON TH=S FRONH/SEWS DU/O EI)SI\ POIOI/, O(/ TE FRO/NI-MOS KAI\ O( FRONW=N.&10 fere eadem redeunt p. 79 addito%10$10 O( ME\N SUNISTA/MENOS KATA\ TH\N FRO/NHSIN, O( DE\ FRONW=N KATA\ TO\ FRONEI=N. &10<21de fortitudine>21%14 68%10$10 E)PISTH/MH GA/R E)STIN U(POMENETE/WN KAI\ OU)X U(PO-MENETE/WN KAI\ OU)DETE/RWN. &10<21de iustitia>21 %14 87 p. 84, 2.$10 O(/TI A)PONEMHTIKH\ TW=N KAT' A)CI/AN E)STI\N H( DIKAIOSU/NH KAI\ TE/TAKTAI OU)/TE KATA\ TO\N KATH/GORON OU)/TE KATA\ TO\N A)POLOGOU/-MENON, A)LLA\ KATA\ TO\N DIKASTH/N. *(/WSPER OU)=N O( DIKASTH\S OU)/TE NIKH=SAI/ TINAS PROH/|RHTAI OU)/TE POLEMH=SAI/ TISI KAI\ E)NANTIWQH=NAI, GNW/MHN D' A)POFHNA/MENOS BRABEU/EI TO\ DI/KAION: OU(/TWS H( DIKAIOSU/NH OU)DENO\S OU)=SA A)NTI/DIKOS, A)PONE/MEI TO\ KAT' A)CI/AN E(KA/STW| PRA/GMATI. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 60, 9 W.$10 *TW=N D' A)RETW=N TA\S ME\N EI)=NAI PRW/TAS, TA\S DE\ TAI=S PRW/TAIS U(POTETAGME/NAS: <20PRW/TAS>20 DE\ TE/TTARAS EI)=NAI, FRO/NHSIN, SWFROSU/NHN, A)NDREI/AN, DIKAIOSU/NHN. *KAI\ TH\N ME\N FRO/NHSIN PERI\ TA\ KAQH/-KONTA GI/NESQAI: TH\N DE\ SWFROSU/NHN PERI\ TA\S O(RMA\S TOU= A)NQRW/POU: TH\N DE\ A)NDREI/AN PERI\ TA\S U(POMONA/S: TH\N DE\ DIKAIOSU/NHN PERI\ TA\S A)PONEMH/SEIS. <20*TW=N DE\ U(POTETAGME/NWN>20 TAI=S A)RETAI=S TAU/TAIS TA\S ME\N TH=| FRONH/SEI U(POTETA/XQAI, TA\S DE\ TH=| SWFROSU/NH|, TA\S DE\ TH=| A)NDREI/A|, TA\S DE\ TH=| DIKAIOSU/NH|. *TH=| ME\N OU)=N FRONH/SEI U(POTA/TTESQAI EU)BOULI/AN, EU)LOGISTI/AN, A)GXI/NOIAN, NOUNE/XEIAN, [2EU)STOXI/AN]2, EU)MHXANI/AN: TH=| DE\ SWFROSU/NH| EU)TACI/AN, KOSMIO/THTA, AI)DHMOSU/-NHN, E)GKRA/TEIAN: TH=| DE\ A)NDREI/A| KARTERI/AN, QARRALEO/THTA, MEGALOYUXI/AN, EU)-YUXI/AN, FILOPONI/AN: TH=| DE\ DIKAIOSU/NH| EU)SE/BEIAN, XRHSTO/THTA, EU)KOINWNHSI/AN, EU)SUNALLACI/AN. <20*EU)BOULI/AN>20 ME\N OU)=N EI)=NAI LE/GOUSIN E)PISTH/MHN TOU= POI=A KAI\ PW=S PRA/TTONTES PRA/COMEN SUMFERO/NTWS: <20EU)LOGISTI/AN>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MHN A)NTANAIRETIKH\N KAI\ SUGKEFALAIWTIKH\N TW=N GINOME/NWN KAI\ A)POTELOUME/NWN: <20A)GXI/NOIAN>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MHN EU(RETIKH\N TOU= KAQH/KONTOS E)K TOU= PARAXRH=MA: <20NOUNE/XEIAN>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MHN [2TW=N XEIRO/NWN KAI\ BELTIO/NWN: <20EU)STOXI/AN>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MHN]2 E)PITEUKTIKH\N TOU= E)N E(KA/STW| SKOPOU=: <20EU)MHXANI/AN>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MHN EU(RETIKH\N DIECO/DOU PRAGMA/TWN: <20EU)TACI/AN>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MHN TOU= PO/TE PRAKTE/ON KAI\ TI/ META\ TI/ KAI\ KAQO/LOU TH=S TA/CEWS TW=N PRA/CEWN: <20KOSMIO/THTA>20 DE\ [2E)PI-STH/MHN]2 PREPOUSW=N KAI\ A)PREPW=N KINH/SEWN: <20AI)DHMOSU/NHN>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MHN EU)LABHTIKH\N O)RQOU= YO/GOU: <20E)GKRA/TEIAN>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MHN A)NUPE/RBATON TW=N KATA\ TO\N O)RQO\N LO/GON FANE/NTWN: <20KARTERI/AN>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MHN E)MMENHTIKH\N TOI=S O)RQW=S KRIQEI=SI: <20QAR)R(ALEO/THTA>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MHN KAQ' H(\N OI)/DAMEN O(/TI OU)DENI\ DEINW=| MH\ PERIPE/SWMEN: <20MEGALOYUXI/AN>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MHN U(PERA/NW POI-OU=SAN TW=N PEFUKO/TWN E)N SPOUDAI/OIS TE GI/NESQAI KAI\ FAU/LOIS: <20EU)YUXI/AN>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MHN YUXH=S PAREXOME/NHS E(AUTH\N A)H/TTHTON: <20FILOPONI/AN>20 DE\ E)PISTH/-MHN E)CERGASTIKH\N TOU= PROKEIME/NOU, OU) KWLUOME/NHN DIA\ PO/NON: <20EU)SE/BEIAN>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MHN QEW=N QERAPEI/AS: <20XRHSTO/THTA>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MHN EU)POIHTIKH/N: <20EU)-KOINWNHSI/AN>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MHN I)SO/THTOS E)N KOINWNI/A|: <20EU)SUNALLACI/AN>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MHN TOU= SUNALLA/TTEIN A)ME/MPTWS TOI=S PLHSI/ON. @*PASW=N DE\ TOU/TWN TW=N A)RETW=N TO\ TE/LOS EI)=NAI TO\ A)KOLOU/QWS TH=| FU/SEI ZH=N: E(KA/STHN DE\ TOU/TOU DIA\ TW=N I)DI/WN PARE/XESQAI TUGXA/NONTA TO\N A)/NQRW- @1PON. *)/EXEIN GA\R A)FORMA\S PARA\ TH=S FU/SEWS KAI\ PRO\S TH\N TOU= KAQH/KONTOS EU(/RESIN KAI\ PRO\S TH\N TW=N O(RMW=N EU)STA/QEIAN KAI\ PRO\S TA\S U(POMONA\S KAI\ PRO\S TA\S A)PONEMH/SEIS. *KAI\ [2KATA\]2 TO\ SU/MFWNON KAI\ TO\ E(AUTH=S E(KA/STH TW=N A)RETW=N PRA/TTOUSA PARE/XETAI TO\N A)/NQRWPON A)KOLOU/QWS TH=| FU/SEI ZW=NTA. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 92.$10 TW=N DE\ A)RETW=N TA\S ME\N <20PRW/TAS>20, TA\S DE\ TAU/TAIS <20U(POTETAGME/NAS>20: PRW/TAS ME\N TA/SDE: FRO/NHSIN, A)NDREI/AN, DIKAIO-SU/NHN, SWFROSU/NHN: E)N EI)/DEI DE\ TOU/TWN MEGALOYUXI/AN, E)GKRA/TEIAN, KARTERI/AN, A)GXI/NOIAN, EU)BOULI/AN. KAI\ TH\N ME\N <20FRO/NHSIN>20 EI)=NAI E)PISTH/MHN KAKW=N KAI\ A)GAQW=N KAI\ OU)DETE/RWN, TH\N DE\ <20DIKAIOSU/NHN>20 E)PISTH/MHN W(=N AI(RETE/ON KAI\ EU)LABHTE/ON KAI\ OU)DETE/RWN %2%2%2%2 TH\N DE\ <20MEGALOYUXI/AN>20 E)PISTH/MHN [2H)\]2 E(/CIN U(PERA/NW POIOU=SAN TW=N SUMBAINO/NTWN KOINH=| FAU/LOIS TE KAI\ SPOUDAI/OIS, TH\N DE\ <20E)GKRA/TEIAN>20 DIA/QESIN A)NUPE/RBATON TW=N KAT' O)RQO\N LO/GON H)\ E(/CIN A)H/TTHTON H(DONW=N, TH\N DE\ <20KARTERI/AN>20 E)PISTH/MHN H)\ E(/CIN W(=N E)MMENETE/ON KAI\ MH\ KAI\ OU)DETE/RWN, TH\N DE\ <20A)GXI/NOIAN>20 E(/CIN EU(RETIKH\N TOU= KAQH/KONTOS E)K TOU= PARAXRH=MA, TH\N DE\ <20EU)BOULI/AN>20 E)PISTH/MHN TOU= SKOPEI=SQAI POI=A KAI\ PW=S PRA/TTONTES PRA/COMEN SUMFERO/NTWS. @A)NA\ LO/GON DE\ KAI\ TW=N KAKIW=N TA\S ME\N EI)=NAI PRW/TAS, TA\S DE\ U(PO\ TAU/-TAS: OI(=ON A)FROSU/NHN ME\N KAI\ DEILI/AN KAI\ A)DIKI/AN KAI\ A)KOLASI/AN E)N TAI=S PRW/TAIS, A)KRASI/AN DE\ KAI\ BRADU/NOIAN KAI\ KAKOBOULI/AN E)N TAI=S U(PO\ TAU/TAS. EI)=NAI DE\ A)GNOI/AS TA\S KAKI/AS W(=N AI( A)RETAI\ E)PISTH=MAI. @&10Andronicus$10 PERI\ PAQW=N&10 p. 19 Schuchardt.$10 @<20*FRO/NHSIS>20 ME\N OU)=N E)STIN E)PISTH/MH A)GAQW=N KAI\ KAKW=N KAI\ OU)DETE/RWN. __ @<20*SWFROSU/NH>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MH AI(RETW=N KAI\ OU)X AI(RETW=N KAI\ OU)DETE/RWN. @<20*DIKAIOSU/NH>20 DE\ E(/CIS A)PONEMHTIKH\ TOU= KAT' A)CI/AN E(KA/STW|. @<20*)ANDREI/A>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MH DEINW=N KAI\ OU) DEINW=N KAI\ OU)DETE/RWN. @&10Andronicus$10 PERI\ PAQW=N &10p. 20, 21 Schuchardt.$10 @<20EU)BOULI/A>20 ME\N OU)=N E)STIN E)PISTH/MH SUMFERO/NTWN. @<20A)GXI/NOIA>20 DE\ E(/CIS E)C U(POGU/OU TO\ KAQH=KON EU(RI/SKOUSA. _ @<20PRO/NOIA>20 DE\ E(/CIS O(DOPOIEI=SQAI DUNAME/NH EI)S TO\ ME/LLON, W(S A)\N PRA/TTHTAI @W(S XRH/. __ @<20BASILIKH\>20 DE\ E)MPEIRI/A TOU= A)/RXEIN PLH/QOUS A)NUPEUQU/NWS. @<20STRATHGIKH\>20 DE\ E(/CIS QEWRHTIKH\ KAI\ PRAKTIKH\ TW=N STRATOPE/DW| SUMFE-@RO/NTWN. __ @<20POLITIKH\>20 DE\ E(/CIS QEWRHTIKH\ [2KAI\ PRAKTIKH\]2 TW=N PO/LEI SUMFERO/NTWN. @<20OI)KONOMIKH\>20 DE\ E(/CIS QEWRHTIKH\ [2KAI\ PRAKTIKH\]2 TW=N OI)/KW| SUMFERO/N-@TWN. __ @<20DIALEKTIKH\>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MH TOU= EU)= DIALE/GESQAI. @<20R(HTORIKH\>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MH TOU= EU)= LE/GEIN. @<20FUSIKH\>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MH TW=N PERI\ FU/SIN. @&10Andronicus$10 PERI\ PAQW=N&10 p. 27, 16 Schuchardt [1[1ex cod. Par. 2131$10]1 <20KATA\ *XRU/SIPPON>20. @*FRO/NHSI/S>20 E)STIN E)PISTH/MH TOU= POI=A DEI= POIEI=N, POI=A D' OU)/. @<20*)AFROSU/NH>20 DE\ H( A)/GNOIA TW=N AU)TW=N KAI\ A)/FRONES OI( TOU/TWN TI A)GNOOU=N- @1@TES KAI\ PERI\ TAU=TA DIEYEUSME/NOI: E)/STI GA\R A)FROSU/NH A)/GNOIA TOU= @POI=A DEI= POIEI=N, POI=A D' OU)/. @<20*(UPOTE/TAKTAI>20 DE\ TH=| FRONH/SEI EU)BOULI/A, EU)LOGISTI/A, A)GXI/NOIA, NOUNE/XEIA, @EU)STOXI/A, EU)MHXANI/A. @<20EU)LOGISTI/A>20 DE/ E)STIN E)PISTH/MH SUGKEFALAIWTIKH\ TW=N GINOME/NWN KAI\ A)PO-@TELOUME/NWN. @<20A)GXI/NOIA/>20 E)STIN E)PISTH/MH EU(RETIKH\ TOU= KAQH/KONTOS E)K TOU= PARAXRH=MA. @<20NOUNE/XEIA/>20 E)STIN E)PISTH/MH XEIRO/NWN KAI\ BELTIO/NWN. @<20EU)STOXI/A>20 E)STI\N E)PISTH/MH E)PITEUKTIKH\ TOU= E)N E(KA/STW| SKOPOU=. @<20EU)MHXANI/A>20 E)STI\N E)PISTH/MH EU(RETIKH\ DIECO/DOU PRAGMA/TWN. @&10Andronicus$10 PERI\ PAQW=N &10p. 28, 1 Schuchart [1ex Paris. 2131$10]1 [1*KATA\ *XRU/SIPPON]1. @<20*(UPOTE/TAKTAI>20 DE\ TH=| A)NDREI/A|: KARTERI/A, QAR)R(ALEO/THS, MEGALOYUXI/A, EU)-@YUXI/A, FILOPONI/A. @<20KARTERI/A>20 E)STI\N E)PISTH/MH E)/MMONOS TOI=S O)RQW=S KRIQEI=SI. @<20QAR)R(ALEO/THS>20 E)STI\N E)PISTH/MH KAQ' H(\N OI)/DAMEN O(/TI OU) PERIPE/SOMEN. @<20MEGALOYUXI/A>20 E)STI\N E)PISTH/MH [2U(PERA/NW POIOU=SA]2 TW=N PEFUKO/TWN E)N @SPOUDAI/OIS TE GI/NESQAI KAI\ FAU/LOIS. @<20EU)YUXI/A>20 E)STI\N E)PISTH/MH YUXH=S PAREXOME/NH AU)TH\N A)H/TTHTON. @<20FILOPONI/A>20 E)STI\N E)PISTH/MH E)CERGASTIKH\ ME\N TOU= PROKEIME/NOU, OU) KATANA-@LISKOME/NH DE\ U(PO\ PO/NWN. @&10Andronicus$10 PERI\ PAQW=N&10 p. 22, 13 Schuchardt.$10 @<20EU)YUXI/A>20 ME\N OU)=N E)STIN EU)TONI/A YUXH=S PRO\S TO\ E)PITELEI=N TA\ E(AUTH=S E)/RGA. @<20LH=MA>20 DE\ E(/CIS PROXEI/ROUS PAREXOME/NH PRO\S TO\ E)PIXEIREI=N TE OI(=S XRH\ KAI\ @U(POME/NEIN A(\ LO/GOS AI(REI=. @<20MEGALOYUXI/A>20 DE\ E(/CIS U(PERA/NW POIOU=SA TOU= KOINH=| SUMBAI/NONTOS FAU/LOIS @TE KAI\ SPOUDAI/OIS. @<20A)R)R(ENO/THS>20 DE\ E(/CIS AU)TA/RKEIS PAREXOME/NH E)N TOI=S KAT' A)RETH\N PO/NOIS. @<20KARTERI/A>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MH E)MMENETW=N [2KAI\ OU)K E)MMENETW=N]2 KAI\ OU)DETE/RWN. @<20MEGALOPRE/PEIA>20 DE\ E(/CIS E)PAI/ROUSA TOU\S E)/XONTAS AU)TH\N KAI\ FRONH/MATOS @PLHROU=SA. @&10Philo quaest et solut. in Genesin IV 136 [1p. 348 Aucher]1. No-&10mina autem ancillarum perseverantiae sunt impropendens, indeclinatum in &10unam partem, minime declivum in contrarium, impoenitens, immutabile, &10indifferens, constans, basi fixum, invincibile, rectum, et quaecunque horum &10fratres sunt, qui cupiunt stabilem perseverantiam. &10@Andronicus$10 PERI\ PAQW=N&10 p. 23, 17 Schuchardt.$10 @<20AU)STHRI/A>20 ME\N OU)=N E)STIN E(/CIS KAQ' H(\N OU)/TE PROSFE/ROUSIN A)/LLOIS TH\N @PERI\ H(DONW=N O(MILI/AN OU)/TE PAR' A)/LLWN PROSDE/XONTAI. __ @<20E)GKRA/TEIA>20 DE\ E(/CIS A)H/TTHTOS U(F' H(DONW=N. @<20EU)TE/LEIA>20 DE\ E(/CIS A)NUPE/RARTOS E)N DAPA/NAIS KAI\ PARASKEUAI=S. @<20LITO/THS>20 DE\ E(/CIS A)RKOUME/NH TOI=S PAROU=SIN. @<20KOSMIO/THS>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MH PERI\ TO\ PRE/PON E)N KINH/SEI KAI\ SXE/SEI. @1 <20EU)TACI/A>20 DE\ E)MPEIRI/A KATAXWRISMOU= PRA/CEWN H)\ PERI\ TA\S PRA/CEIS E)/XOUSA @TO\ BE/BAION H)\ TOU\S KATAXWRISMOU\S TW=N PRA/CEWN. <20AU)TA/RKEIA>20 DE\ E(/CIS A)RKOUME/NH OI(=S DEI= KAI\ DI' AU(TH=S PORISTIKH\ TW=N PRO\S @TO\ ZH=N KAQHKO/NTWN. @&10Andronicus$10 PERI\ PAQW=N&10 p. 25, 9 Schuchardt.$10 <20E)LEUQERIO/THS>20 ME\N OU)=N E)STIN E(/CIS E)N PROE/SEI KAI\ LH/YEI O(MOLOGOUME/NWS @A)NASTREFOME/NOUS PAREXOME/NH. <20XRHSTO/THS>20 DE\ E(/CIS E(KOUSI/WS EU)POIHTIKH/. <20DIKASTIKH\>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MH KRI/SEWN KAI\ KOLA/SEWN KAI\ A)DIKHMA/TWN. <20EU)GNWMOSU/NH>20 DE\ E(KOU/SIOS DIKAIOSU/NH. <20EU)SE/BEIA>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MH QEW=N QERAPEI/AS. <20EU)XARISTI/A>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MH TOU= TI/SI KAI\ PO/TE PAREKTE/ON XA/RIN KAI\ PW=S KAI\ @PARA\ TI/NWN LHPTE/ON. <20O(SIO/THS>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MH PAREXOME/NH PISTOU\S KAI\ THROU=NTAS TA\ PRO\S TO\ QEI=ON @DI/KAIA. __ <20EU)SUNALLACI/A>20 DE\ E(/CIS E)N SUNALLAGAI=S FULA/TTOUSA TO\ DI/KAION. <20NOMOQETIKH\>20 DE\ E)PISTH/MH DIATAGMA/TWN POLITIKW=N PRO\S KOINWNI/AN A)NAFE-@ROME/NWN. @&10Sextus adv. math. IX 153$10 <20E)GKRA/TEIA>20 GA/R E)STI DIA/QESIS A)NUPE/RBATOS TW=N KAT' O)RQO\N LO/GON GIGNOME/NWN H)\ A)RETH\ U(PERA/NW POIOU=SA H(MA=S TW=N DOKOU/NTWN EI)=NAI DUSA-POSXE/TWN. E)GKRATEU/ETAI GA/R, FASI/N, OU)X O( QANATIW/SHS GRAO\S A)PEXO/MENOS, A)LL' O( *LAI/+DOS KAI\ *FRU/NHS H)/ TINOS TOIAU/THS, DUNA/MENOS A)POLAU=SAI, EI)=TA A)PEXO/MENOS. <20KARTERI/A>20 DE/ E)STIN E)PISTH/MH U(POMENETE/WN KAI\ OU)X U(POMENETE/WN H)\ A)RETH\ U(PERA/NW POIOU=SA H(MA=S TW=N DOKOU/NTWN EI)=NAI DUSUPOMENH/TWN. @&10ibid. 158.$10 EI) DE\ <20A)NDRI/AN>20 E)/XEI, E)PISTH/MHN E)/XEI DEINW=N KAI\ OU) DEINW=N KAI\ TW=N METACU/. @&10ibid. 161.$10 EI) DE\ <20MEGALOYUXI/AN>20 E)/XEI, E)PISTH/MHN E)/XEI POIOU=SAN U(PER-AI/REIN TW=N SUMBAINO/NTWN. @&10ibid. 162.$10 EI) <20FRO/NHSIN>20 E)/XEI, E)/XEI KAI\ E)PISTH/MHN A)GAQW=N TE KAI\ KA-KW=N KAI\ A)DIAFO/RWN. @&10ibid. 167.$10 EI)/PER TE PANA/RETO/N E)STI TO\ QEI=ON KAI\ TH\N FRO/NHSIN E)/XEI, E)/XEI KAI\ TH\N <20EU)BOULI/AN>20, PARO/SON H( EU)BOULI/A FRO/NHSI/S E)STI PRO\S TA\ BOULEUTA/. @&10ibid. 174.$10 E)/STI GA\R H( <20SWFROSU/NH>20 E(/CIS E)N AI(RE/SESI KAI\ FUGAI=S SW/-ZOUSA TA\ TH=S FRONH/SEWS KRI/MATA. @&10Clemens Al. Strom. II p. 470 Pott.$10 E)PEI\ D' OU)=N TH\N ME\N <20A)N-DREI/AN>20 O(RI/ZONTAI E)PISTH/MHN DEINW=N KAI\ OU) DEINW=N KAI\ TW=N METACU/: TH\N DE\ <20SWFROSU/NHN>20 E(/CIN EI)=NAI AI(RE/SEI KAI\ FUGH=| SW/ZOUSAN TA\ TH=S FRONH/SEWS KRI/MATA: PARA/KEITAI TH=| ME\N A)NDREI/A| H(/ TE U(POMONH/, H(\N <20KARTERI/AN>20 KALOU=SIN, E)PISTH/MHN E)MMENETE/WN KAI\ OU)K E)MMENETE/WN: H(/ TE <20MEGALOYUXI/A>20 E)PISTH/MH TW=N SUMBAINO/NTWN U(PERAI/ROUSA: A)LLA\ KAI\ TH=| SWFROSU/NH| H( <20EU)LA/BEIA>20 E)/K-KLISIS OU)=SA SU\N LO/GW|. @&10paulo post dicit%10$10 O(/TI O( MI/AN E)/XWN A)RETH\N_PA/SAS E)/XEI DIA\ TH\N A)NTA-KOLOUQI/AN. *AU)TI/KA H( <20E)GKRA/TEIA>20 DIA/QESI/S E)STIN A)NUPE/RBATOS TW=N KATA\ @1 TO\N O)RQO\N LO/GON FANE/NTWN: E)GKRATEU/ETAI DE\ O( KATE/XWN TA\S PARA\ TO\N O)RQO\N LO/GON O(RMA/S: H)\ O( KATE/XWN AU(TO\N W(/STE MH\ O(RMA=N PARA\ TO\N O)RQO\N LO/GON. @&10Clemens Al. Paedag. II p. 247 Pott.$10 <20I(KANO/THS>20 DE\ E(/CIS E)STI\N E)CIKNOUME/NH PRO\S TO\ OI)KEI=ON PE/RAS A)NELLIPW=S KAI\ A)PERI/TTWS. @<20H( AU)TA/RKEIA>20__E(/CIS E)STI\N A)RKOUME/NH OI(=S DEI= KAI\ DI' AU(TH=S PO-RISTIKH\ TW=N PRO\S TO\N MAKA/RION SUNTELOU/NTWN BI/ON. @&10idem III p. 286 Pott.$10 H( ME\N <20KAQARIO/THS>20 E(/CIS E)STI\N PARASKEUASTIKH\ DIAI/THS KAQARA=S KAI\ A)MIGOU=S AI)SXROI=S: H( DE\ <20A)FE/LEIA>20 E(/CIS A)FAIRETIKH\ TW=N PERITTW=N. @&10p. 287.$10 <20EU)KOLI/A>20 DE/ E)STIN E(/CIS A)PE/RITTOS, PROSDEKTIKH\ PRO\S TO\ A)NEL-LIPE\S E)CARKOU/NTWN EI)S TO\N KATA\ LO/GON TO\N U(GIH= KAI\ MAKA/RION BI/ON. @&10p. 303.$10 <20EU)TACI/A>20 E)STI/__DU/NAMIS TETAGME/NH BEBAI/A TW=N E(CH=S A)L-LH/LOIS KEIME/NWN E)N E)/RGW| KALW=S A)PODOTIKH/, KAT' A)RETH\N A)NUPE/RBLHTOS. @&10Philo quaest. et solut. in Exodum II 112 [1p. 541 Aucher]1. &10Quatuor virtutum unaquaeque elementum sortita est ex his tribus, ex &10habitudine, habendo et habere. Sicut et in sensibus est, e. g. visus, &10visibile, et videre; itidem auditus, audibile, et audire. Sic ergo est &10scientia, scibile, scire, sicut et continentia, continendum, continere; ite-&10rumque fortitudo, fortificandum et habere fortitudinem, quod magis com-&10muniter dicitur fortificari; similiter iustitia, iustum et habere iustitiam, &10quod appellatur iustificari. &10@Stobaeus ecl. II 62, 15 W.$10 *TAU/TAS ME\N OU)=N TA\S R(HQEI/SAS A)RE-TA\S TELEI/AS EI)=NAI LE/GOUSI PERI\ TO\N BI/ON KAI\ <20SUNESTHKE/NAI E)K QEWRHMA/-TWN>20: A)/LLAS DE\ <20E)PIGI/NESQAI TAU/TAIS, OU)K E)/TI TE/XNAS OU)/SAS, A)LLA\ DUNA/MEIS TINA/S>20, E)K TH=S A)SKH/SEWS PERIGIGNOME/NAS, OI(=ON TH\N U(GI/EIAN TH=S YUXH=S KAI\ TH\N A)RTIO/THTA KAI\ TH\N I)SXU\N AU)TH=S KAI\ TO\ KA/LLOS. *(/WSPER GA\R TH\N TOU= SW/MATOS U(GI/EIAN EU)KRASI/AN EI)=NAI TW=N E)N TW=| SW/MATI QERMW=N KAI\ YUXRW=N KAI\ CHRW=N KAI\ U(GRW=N, OU(/TW KAI\ TH\N TH=S YUXH=S U(GI/EIAN EU)KRASI/AN EI)=NAI TW=N E)N TH=| YUXH=| DOGMA/TWN. *KAI\ O(MOI/WS W(/SPER I)SXU\S TOU= SW/MATOS TO/NOS E)STI\N I(KANO\S E)N NEU/ROIS, OU(/TW KAI\ H( TH=S YUXH=S I)SXU\S TO/NOS E)STI\N I(KANO\S E)N TW=| KRI/NEIN KAI\ PRA/TTEIN H)\ MH/: W(/SPER TE TO\ KA/LLOS TOU= SW/MATO/S E)STI SUMMETRI/A TW=N MELW=N KAQESTW/TWN AU)TW=| PRO\S A)/LLHLA/ TE KAI\ PRO\S TO\ O(/LON, OU(/TW KAI\ TO\ TH=S YUXH=S KA/LLOS E)STI\ SUMMETRI/A TOU= LO/GOU KAI\ TW=N MERW=N AU)TOU= PRO\S [2TO\]2 O(/LON TE AU)TH=S KAI\ PRO\S A)/LLHLA.&10 Cf. III n. 95. 197. &10@Cicero Tusculan. disput. IV 13, 30. Atque ut in malis attingit &10animi naturam corporis similitudo, sic in bonis. Sunt enim in corpore &10praecipua valetudo, pulchritudo, vires, firmitas, velocitas%10 sunt item in &10animo. [2Ut]2 enim corporis temperatio, cum ea congruunt inter se, e &10quibus constamus, sanitas%10 sic animi dicitur, cum eius iudicia opiniones-&10que concordant. __31. Et ut corporis est quaedam apta figura mem-&10brorum cum coloris quadam suavitate, eaque dicitur pulchritudo%10 sic in &10animo opinionum iudiciorumque aequabilitas et constantia, cum firmitate &10quadam et stabilitate__pulchritudo vocatur. Itemque viribus corporis &10et nervis et efficacitati similes similibus quoque verbis animi vires nomi- @1&10nantur. Velocitas autem corporis celeritas appellatur, quae eadem ingenii &10etiam laus habetur propter animi multarum rerum brevi tempore per-&10cursionem. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 63, 6 W.$10 PA/SAS DE\ TA\S A)RETA\S O(/SAI E)PISTH=MAI/ EI)SI KAI\ TE/XNAI <20KOINA/ TE QEWRH/MATA E)/XEIN KAI\ TE/LOS>20, W(S EI)/RHTAI, TO\ AU)TO/: DIO\ <20KAI\ A)XWRI/STOUS EI)=NAI>20: TO\N GA\R MI/AN E)/XONTA PA/SAS E)/XEIN, KAI\ TO\N KATA\ MI/AN PRA/TTONTA KATA\ PA/SAS PRA/TTEIN. DIAFE/REIN D' A)LLH/LWN TOI=S KEFALAI/OIS. <20FRONH/SEWS>20 ME\N GA\R EI)=NAI KEFA/LAIA TO\ ME\N QEWREI=N KAI\ PRA/T-TEIN, O(\ POIHTE/ON, PROHGOUME/NWS, KATA\ DE\ TO\N DEU/TERON LO/GON TO\ QEWREI=N KAI\ A(\ DEI= A)PONE/MEIN [2KAI\ A(\ DEI= AI(REI=SQAI KAI\ A(\ DEI= U(POME/NEIN]2, XA/RIN TOU= A)DI-APTW/TWS PRA/TTEIN O(\ POIHTE/ON. TH=S DE\ <20SWFROSU/NHS>20 I)/DION KEFA/LAIO/N E)STI TO\ PARE/XESQAI TA\S O(RMA\S EU)STAQEI=S KAI\ QEWREI=N AU)TA\S PROHGOUME/NWS, KATA\ DE\ TO\N DEU/TERON LO/GON TA\ U(PO\ TA\S A)/LLAS A)RETA/S, E(/NEKA TOU= A)DIAPTW/TWS E)N TAI=S O(RMAI=S A)NASTRE/FESQAI: KAI\ O(MOI/WS TH\N <20A)NDREI/AN>20 PROHGOUME/NWS ME\N PA=N O(\ DEI= U(POME/NEIN, KATA\ DE\ TO\N DEU/TERON LO/GON TA\ U(PO\ TA\S A)/LLAS: KAI\ TH\N <20DIKAIOSU/NHN>20 PROHGOUME/NWS ME\N TO\ KAT' A)CI/AN E(KA/STW| SKOPEI=N, KATA\ DE\ TO\N DEU/TERON LO/GON KAI\ TA\ LOIPA/. PA/SAS GA\R TA\S A)RETA\S TA\ PASW=N BLE/PEIN KAI\ TA\ U(POTETAGME/NA A)LLH/LAIS. O(/MOION GA\R E)/LEGEN EI)=NAI O( *PANAI/-TIOS TO\ SUMBAI=NON A)PO\ TW=N A)RETW=N, W(S EI) POLLOI=S TOCO/TAIS EI(=S SKOPO\S EI)/H KEI/MENOS, E)/XOI D' OU(=TOS E)N AU(TW=| GRAMMA\S DIAFO/ROUS TOI=S XRW/MASIN: EI)=Q' E(/KA-STOS ME\N STOXA/ZOITO TOU= TUXEI=N TOU= SKOPOU=, H)/DH D' O( ME\N DIA\ TOU= PATA/CAI EI)S TH\N LEUKH\N EI) TU/XOI GRAMMH/N, O( DE\ DIA\ TOU= EI)S TH\N ME/LAINAN, A)/LLOS [2DE\]2 DIA\ TOU= EI)S A)/LLO TI XRW=MA GRAMMH=S. *KAQA/PER GA\R TOU/TOUS W(S ME\N A)NWTA/TW TE/LOS POIEI=SQAI TO\ TUXEI=N TOU= SKOPOU=, H)/DH D' A)/LLON KAT' A)/LLON TRO/PON PROTI/QESQAI TH\N TEU=CIN, TO\N AU)TO\N TRO/PON KAI\ TA\S A)RETA\S PA/SAS POIEI=SQAI ME\N TE/LOS TO\ EU)DAIMONEI=N, O(/ E)STI KEI/MENON E)N TW=| ZH=N O(MOLOGOUME/-NWS TH=| FU/SEI, TOU/TOU D' A)/LLHN KAT' A)/LLON TUGXA/NEIN. @&10Cicero de finibus III 72. Ad easque virtutes, de quibus dispu-&10tatum est, dialecticam etiam adiungunt et physicam easque ambas vir-&10tutum nomine appellant, alteram, quod habeat rationem, ne cui falso &10assentiamur neve umquam captiosa probabilitate fallamur, eaque quae de &10bonis et malis didicerimus, ut tenere tuerique possimus. Nam sine hac &10arte quemvis arbitrantur a vero abduci fallique posse. Recte igitur, si &10omnibus in rebus temeritas ignoratioque vitiosa est, ars ea, quae tollit &10haec, virtus nominata est. &10@Cicero de finibus III 73. Physicae quoque non sine causa tri-&10butus idem est honos [1scil. ut virtus appellaretur]1 propterea quod, qui &10convenienter naturae victurus est, ei proficiscendum est ab omni mundo &10atque ab eius procuratione. Nec vero potest quisquam de bonis et malis &10vere iudicare nisi omni cognita ratione naturae et vitae etiam deorum, &10et utrum conveniat necne natura hominis cum universa. Quaeque sunt &10vetera praecepta sapientium, qui iubent "1tempori parere"2 et "1sequi deum"2 &10et "1se noscere"2 et "1nihil nimis"2 haec sine physicis quam vim habeant [1et @1 &10habent maximam]1, videre nemo potest. Atque etiam ad iustitiam colen-&10dam, ad tuendas amicitias et reliquas caritates quid natura valeat, haec &10una cognitio potest tradere. Nec vero pietas adversus deos nec quanta &10iis gratia debeatur, sine explicatione naturae intellegi potest. &10@Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 36 p. 211, 17.$10 A)NQRW/POU DE\ H( FRO/NHSIS A)RETH/, H(/ E)STIN, W(/S FASIN, E)PISTH/MH POIHTE/WN TE KAI\ OU) POIHTE/WN. @&10Sextus adv. math. VII 158$10 TH\N ME\N GA\R EU)DAIMONI/AN PERIGI/NESQAI DIA\ TH=S FRONH/SEWS, TH\N DE\ FRO/NHSIN KINEI=SQAI E)N TOI=S KATORQW/MASIN, TO\ DE\ KATO/RQWMA EI)=NAI O(/PER PRAXQE\N EU)/LOGON E)/XEI TH\N A)POLOGI/AN. @&Cicero Tusculan. disput IV 24, 53.&3 Fortitudo est igitur af-&3fectio animi, legi summae in perpetiendis rebus obtemperans; vel conser-&3vatio stabilis iudicii in eis rebus, quae formidolosae videntur, subeundis &3et repellendis; vel scientia rerum formidolosarum contrariarumque aut &3omnino neglegendarum, conservans earum rerum stabile iudicium; vel &3brevius, ut <21Chrysippus>21%10 _nam superiores definitiones erant <21Sphaeri>21, &3hominis in primis bene definientis, ut putant Stoici%10 sunt enim omnino &3omnes fere similes, sed declarant communes notiones alia magis alia__ &3quo modo <21igitur Chrysippus? Fortitudo est, inquit, scientia &3rerum perferendarum vel affectio animi, in patiendo ac per-&3ferendo summae legi parens sine timore>21. @&10Philo de sept. et fest. dieb. Vol. II Mang. p. 360.$10 <20TH\N A)N-DREI/AN>20 A)RETH\N PERI\ TA\ DEINA\ PRAGMATEUOME/NHN I)/SASIN OI( MH\ PANTELW=S A)/MOUSOI KAI\ A)XO/REUTOI, KA)\N E)PI\ BRAXU\ PAIDEI/AS PROSA/YWNTAI <20TW=N U(POME-NETE/WN OU)=SAN E)PISTH/MHN>20. @&10Scholia in Hom. Iliad. E 2.$10 <20*QA/RSOS DE/ E)STI KATA\ ME\N *STWI+-KOU\S FILOSO/FOUS TO\ A)SFALW=S PEPOIQE/NAI AU(TW=| O(/TI OU)DENI\ A)\N DEINW=| PERIPE/SOI>20, KATA\ DE\ <20TOU\S E)K TOU= *PERIPA/TOU>20 TO\ EU)/ELPIN EI)=NAI TOU= MHDENI\ A)\N DEINW=| PERIPESEI=N&10 etc. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 16 p. 1041b.$ *XRUS1. [1<20E)N TOI=S PRO\S *PLA/TWNA PERI\ DIKAIOSU/NHS>20]1. *TOU= DE\ *PLA/TWNOS EI)PO/NTOS TH\N A)DIKI/AN, W(S DIAFQORA\ YUXH=S OU)=SA KAI\ STA/SIS, OU)D' E)N AU)TOI=S TOI=S E)/XOUSIN A)POBA/LLEI TH\N DU/NAMIN, A)LL' AU)TO\N E(AUTW=| SUMBA/LLEI KAI\ [2SUG]2-KROU/EI KAI\ TARA/TTEI TO\N PONHRO/N: <20E)GKALW=N *XRU/SIPPOS, "1A)TO/PWS, FHSI/, LE/GESQAI TO\ A)DIKEI=N E(AUTO/N: EI)=NAI GA\R PRO\S E(/TERON OU) PRO\S E(AUTO\N TH\N A)DIKI/AN>20."2 @&p. 1041c.$8 E)N ME\N TOI=S PRO\S *PLA/TWNA TAU=T' EI)/RHKE PERI\ TOU= TH\N A)DIKI/AN LE/GESQAI MH\ PRO\S E(AUTO\N A)LLA\ PRO\S E(/TERON: "1<20OI( GA\R KAT' I)DI/AN A)/DIKOI [2OU)]2 SUNESTH/KASIN E)K PLEIO/NWN TOIOU/TWN TA)NAN- @1TI/A LEGO/NTWN, KAI\ A)/LLWS TH=S A)DIKI/AS LAMBANOME/NHS W(S A)\N E)N PLEI/OSI PRO\S E(AUTOU\S OU(/TWS E)/XOUSIN, EI)S DE\ TO\N E(/NA MHDENO\S DIATEI/NONTOS TOIOU/TOU: KAQ' O(/SON DE\ PRO\S TOU\S PLHSI/ON E)/XEI OU(/TWS>20."2 @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 16 p. 1041c.$ E)PILAQO/MENOS GA\R TOU/TWN AU)=QIS <20E)N TAI=S PERI\ *DIKAIOSU/NHS A)PODEI/CESIN "1A)DI-KEI=SQAI/ FHSIN U(F' E(AUTOU= TO\N A)DIKOU=NTA KAI\ AU(TO\N A)DIKEI=N, O(/TAN A)/LLON A)DIKH=|, GENO/MENON E(AUTW=| TOU= PARANOMEI=N AI)/TION, KAI\ BLA/PTONTA PAR' A)CI/AN E(AUTO/N>20."2 @&p. 1041d.$8 <20*)EN DE\ TAI=S *)APODEI/CESI>20 TOIOU/TOUS H)RW/THKE LO/GOUS PERI\ TOU= TO\N A)/DIKON KAI\ E(AUTO\N A)DIKEI=N: "1<20*PARAI/TION GENE/SQAI PARA-NOMH/MATOS A)PAGOREU/EI O( NO/MOS, KAI\ TO\ A)DIKEI=N E)STI PARANO/-MHMA: O( TOI/NUN PARAI/TIOS GENO/MENOS AU(TW=| TOU= A)DIKEI=N, PARA-NOMEI= EI)S E(AUTO/N: O( DE\ PARANOMW=N EI)S E(/NA KAI\ A)DIKEI= E)KEI=NON: O( A)/RA KAI\ O(NTINOU=N A)DIKW=N KAI\ E(AUTO\N A)DIKEI=."2 *PA/LIN "1TO\ A(MA/RTHMA TW=N BLAMMA/TWN E)STI/, KAI\ PA=S A(MARTA/NWN PAR' E(AU-TO\N A(MARTA/NEI: PA=S A)/RA O( A(MARTA/NWN BLA/PTEI E(AUTO\N PARA\ TH\N A)CI/AN, EI) DE\ TOU=TO KAI\ A)DIKEI= E(AUTO/N."2 *)/ETI KAI\ OU(/TWS: "1*(O BLAPTO/MENOS U(F' E(TE/ROU E(AUTO\N BLA/PTEI, KAI\ PARA\ TH\N A)CI/AN E(AUTO\N BLA/PTEI: TOU=TO D' H)=N TO\ A)DIKEI=N: O( A)/RA A)DI-KOU/MENOS KAI\ U(F' O(TOUOU=N PA=S E(AUTO\N A)DIKEI=>20."2 @&10Seneca de clementia lib. II 3. <21Clementia est temperantia &10animi in potestate ulciscendi vel lenitas superioris adversus &10inferiorem in constituendis poenis>21. Plura proponere tutius est, ne &10una finitio parum rem comprehendat et, ut ita dicam, formula excidat: &10itaque dici potest et <21inclinatio animi ad lenitatem in poena exi-&10genda>21. Illa finitio contradictiones inveniet, quamvis maxime ad verum &10accedat%10 si dixerimus clementiam esse moderationem aliquid ex merita &10ac debita poena remittentem; reclamabitur nullan virtutem cuiquam mi-&10nus debito facere. &10@Hieronymus comment. in epist. ad Galatas Lib. III cp. 5 v. 22. &10Denique et hanc [1scilicet$10 TH\N XRHSTO/THTA]1&10 <21Stoici>21 ita definiunt%10 <21benigni-&10tas est virtus sponte ad bene faciendum exposita>21. Non multum &10bonitas a benignitate diversa est__hanc quoque sectatores Zenonis &10ita definiunt%10 <21bonitas est virtus quae prodest>21%10 sive virtus ex qua &10oritur utilitas%10 aut virtus propter semet ipsam%10 aut affectus qui fons sit &10utilitatum. @&10Clemens Al. Strom. II p. 450 Pott.$10 <20A)GA/PH>20 DE\ O(MO/NOIA A)\N EI)/H TW=N KATA\ TO\N LO/GON KAI\ TO\N BI/ON KAI\ TO\N TRO/PON: H)\ SUNELO/NTI FA/NAI KOI-NWNI/A BI/OU: H)\ E)KTE/NEIA FILI/AS KAI\ FILOSTORGI/AS META\ LO/GOU O)RQOU= PERI\ XRH=SIN E(TAI/RWN. @1 @&10paullo post%10$10 PARA/KEITAI DE\ TH=| A)GA/PH| H(/ TE <20FILOCENI/A>20, FILOTEXNI/A TIS OU)=SA PERI\ XRH=SIN CE/NWN. @&10p. 451.$10 H(/ TE <20FILANQRWPI/A>20__FILIKH\ XRH=SIS A)NQRW/PWN U(PA/R-@@XOUSA. @@H(/ TE <20FILOSTORGI/A>20 FILOTEXNI/A TIS OU)=SA PERI\ STE/RCIN FI/LWN @@H)\ OI)KEI/WN. @@<20STE/RCIS>20 D' AU)= TH/RHSI/S E)STIN EU)NOI/AS H)\ A)GAPH/SEWS: @@<20A)GA/PHSIS>20 DE\ A)PO/DECIS PANTELH/S__ @@DI' <20O(MO/NOIAN>20, E)PISTH/MHN OU)=SAN KOINW=N A)GAQW=N. @&10Clemens Al. Paedag. I 13 p. 159 Pott. hasce Stoicorum defi-&10nitiones prodit%10 @$10H( <20A)RETH\>20_DIA/QESI/S E)STI YUXH=S SU/MFWNOS U(PO\ TOU= LO/GOU PERI\ O(/LON @TO\N BI/ON. @<20TH\N FILOSOFI/AN>20 E)PITH/DEUSIN LO/GOU O)RQO/THTOS A)PODIDO/ASIN. @&10p. 160.$10 KAI\ E)/STIN H( ME\N <20PRA=CIS [2H( SPOUDAI/A>20]2 YUXH=S E)NE/RGEIA LO-@@GIKH=S KATA\ KRI/SIN A)STEI/AN [KAI\ O)/RECIN A)LHQEI/AS], DIA\ TOU= @@SUMFUOU=S KAI\ SUNAGWNISTOU= SW/MATOS E)KTELOUME/NH. @@<20KAQH=KON>20 DE\ A)KO/LOUQON E)N TW=| BI/W|. @@KAI\ GA\R O( <20BI/OS [2O( SPOUDAI=OS>20]2 SU/STHMA/ TI/ E)STI LOGIKW=N @@PRA/CEWN, TOUTE/STI TW=N U(PO\ TOU= LO/GOU DIDASKOME/NWN A)DIA/-@@PTWTOS E)NE/RGEIA. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 67, 5 W.$10 FILOMOUSI/AN DE\ KAI\ FILOGRAMMATI/AN KAI\ FILIPPI/AN KAI\ FILOKUNHGI/AN KAI\ KAQO/LOU [2TA\S]2 E)GKUKLI/OUS LEGOME/NAS TE/XNAS E)PITHDEU/MATA ME\N KALOU=SIN, E)PISTH/MAS D' OU)/: E)N [2DE\]2 TAI=S SPOUDAI/AIS E(/CESI TAU=TA KATALEI/POUSI, KAI\ A)KOLOU/QWS MO/NON TO\N SOFO\N FILO/MOUSON EI)=NAI LE/GOUSI KAI\ FILOGRA/MMATON, KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N A)/LLWN KATA\ TO\ A)NA/LOGON. TO/ TE E)PITH/DEUMA TOU=TON U(POGRA/FOUSI TO\N TRO/PON: O(DO\N DIA\ TE/XNHS H)\ ME/ROUS A)/GOU-SAN E)PI\ [2TA\]2 KAT' A)RETH/N. @&Diog Lae%28rt. VII 125.$ <20TA\S DE\ A)RETA\S LE/GOUSIN A)NTA-KOLOUQEI=N A)LLH/LAIS>20, KAI\ TO\N MI/AN E)/XONTA PA/SAS E)/XEIN. <20EI)=NAI GA\R AU)TW=N TA\ QEWRH/MATA KOINA/>20, KAQA/PER <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 E)N TW=| <20PRW/TW| PERI\ *)ARETW=N>20 FHSI/N, *)APOLLO/DWROS DE\ E)N TH=| FUSIKH=| KATA\ TH\N A)RXAI/AN, *(EKA/TWN DE\ E)N TW=| TRI/TW| PERI\ A)RETW=N. TO\N GA\R E)NA/RE-TON QEWRHTIKO/N TE EI)=NAI KAI\ PRAKTIKO\N TW=N POIHTE/WN: TA\ DE\ POIHTE/A KAI\ AI(RETE/A E)STI/, KAI\ U(POMENETE/A KAI\ A)PONEMHTE/A KAI\ E)MMENHTE/A. W(/STE EI) TA\ ME\N AI(RETIKW=S POIEI=, TA\ DE\ U(POMENETIKW=S, TA\ DE\ A)PONEMHTIKW=S, @1 TA\ DE\ E)MMENHTIKW=S, FRO/NIMO/S TE/ E)STI KAI\ A)NDREI=OS KAI\ DI/KAIOS KAI\ SW/FRWN. KEFALAIOU=SQAI/ TE E(KA/STHN TW=N A)RETW=N PERI/ TI I)/DION KE-FA/LAION: OI(=ON TH\N A)NDREI/AN PERI\ TA\ U(POMENETE/A, TH\N FRO/NHSIN PERI\ TA\ POIHTE/A KAI\ MH\ KAI\ OU)DE/TERA: O(MOI/WS TE KAI\ TA\S A)/LLAS PERI\ TA\ OI)KEI=A TRE/PESQAI. E(/PONTAI DE\ TH=| ME\N FRONH/SEI EU)BOULI/A KAI\ SU/NESIS: TH=| DE\ SWFROSU/NH| EU)TACI/A KAI\ KOSMIO/THS: TH=| DE\ DIKAIOSU/NH| I)SO/THS KAI\ EU)GNW-MOSU/NH: TH=| DE\ A)NDREI/A| A)PARALLACI/A KAI\ EU)TONI/A. @&10Galenus optimum medicum esse philosophum Vol. I p. 61 K.$10 OU(/TW DE\ KAI\ TA\S A)/LLAS A)RETA\S A)NAGKAI=ON E)/XEIN AU)TO/N [1&10scil. medicum sapien-&10tem]1.$10 SU/MPASAI GA\R A)LLH/LAIS E(/PONTAI, KAI\ OU)X OI(=O/N TE MI/AN H(NTINAOU=N LA-BO/NTI MH\ OU)XI\ KAI\ TA\S A)/LLAS A(PA/SAS EU)QU\S A)KOLOUQOU/SAS E)/XEIN, W(/SPER E)K MIA=S MHRI/NQOU DEDEME/NAS. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 15 p. 1041a.$8 *KAI\ MH\N <20E)N TAI=S PERI\ *DIKAIOSU/NHS A)PODEI/CESI>20 LE/GEI R(HTW=S O(/TI "1<20PA=N KAT-O/RQWMA KAI\ EU)NO/MHMA KAI\ DIKAIOPRA/GHMA/ E)STI: TO\ DE/ GE KAT' E)GKRA/TEIAN H)\ KARTERI/AN H)\ FRO/NHSIN H)\ A)NDREI/AN PRATTO/MENON KATO/RQWMA/ E)STIN: W(/STE KAI\ DIKAIOPRA/GHMA.>20"2 @&10Lactant. div. instit. V 17. Denique, ut concludam disputationem, &10non posse eundem iustum esse ac stultum, eundem sapientem et iniustum, &10docet ipsa ratio. Qui enim stultus est, quid sit iustum ac bonum nescit &10et ideo semper peccat. Ducitur enim quasi captivus a vitiis, nec resistere &10ullo modo potest, quia caret virtute, quam nescit. Iustus autem ab omni &10peccato se abstinet; quod aliter facere non potest, quam si habeat recti &10pravique notitiam. Rectum autem discernere a pravo quis potest nisi sa-&10piens? Ita fit ut <21nunquam possit esse iustus, qui stultus est>21, ne-&10que sapiens qui fuerit iniustus. &10@ibidem%10 Stultitia igitur est in factis dictisque per ignorantiam recti &10ac boni erratio. @&10Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 27 p. 1046e.$10 "1*TA\S A)RETA/S FHSIN A)NTAKOLOUQEI=N A)LLH/LAIS, OU) MO/NON TW=| TO\N MI/AN E)/XONTA PA/SAS E)/XEIN, A)LLA\ KAI\ TW=| TO\N KATA\ MI/AN O(TIOU=N E)NERGOU=NTA KATA\ PA/SAS E)NER-GEI=N: OU)/TE GA\R A)/NDRA FHSI\ TE/LEION EI)=NAI TO\N MH\ PA/SAS E)/XONTA TA\S A)RETA/S, OU)/TE PRA=CIN TELEI/AN, H(/TIS OU) KATA\ PA/SAS PRA/TTETAI TA\S A)RETA/S."2 @&10Hieronymus ep. 66 [1ad Pammachium]1 3. Quattuor virtutes &10describunt <21Stoici>21, ita <21sibi invicem nexas et mutuo cohaerentes,>21 &10ut qui unam non habuerit omnibus careat%10 prudentiam, iustitiam, fortitu-&10dinem, temperantiam. @&10Philo de ebrietate %14 88 Vol. II p. 186, 21 Wendl.$10 *XRH\ ME/NTOI MHDE\ TOU=T' A)GNOEI=N O(/TI H( SOFI/A, TE/XNH TEXNW=N OU)=SA, DOKEI= ME\N TAI=S DIAFO/ROIS U(/LAIS E)NALLA/TTESQAI, TO\ D' AU(TH=S A)LHQE\S EI)=DOS A)/TREPTON E)MFAI/NEI TOI=S O)CU-DORKOU=SI KAI\ MH\ TW=| PERIKEXUME/NW| TH=S OU)SI/AS O)/GKW| MEQELKOME/NOIS, A)LLA\ TO\N @1 E)NESFRAGISME/NON U(PO\ TH=S TE/XNHS AU)TH=S XARAKTH=RA DIORW=SI. *TO\N A)NDRIANTO-POIO\N *FEIDI/AN E)KEI=NON, KAI\ XALKO\N LABO/NTA FASI\ KAI\ E)LE/FANTA KAI\ XRUSO\N KAI\ A)/LLAS DIAFO/ROUS U(/LAS, A)NDRIA/NTAS A)PERGA/SASQAI KAI\ E)N A(/PASI TOU/TOIS MI/AN KAI\ TH\N AU)TH\N E)NSHMH/NASQAI TE/XNHN, W(S MH\ MO/NON E)PISTH/MONAS A)LLA\ KAI\ LI/AN I)DIW/TAS TO\N DHMIOURGO\N A)PO\ TW=N DHMIOURGHQE/NTWN GNWRI/SAI. _ *KAQA/PER GA\R E)PI\ TW=N DIDU/MWN H( FU/SIS XRHSAME/NH TW=| AU)TW=| POLLA/KIS XARAK-TH=RI, PARA\ MIKRO\N A)PARALLA/KTOUS O(MOIO/THTAS E)TU/PWSE: TO\N AU)TO\N TRO/PON KAI\ H( TELEI/A TE/XNH, MI/MHMA KAI\ A)PEIKO/NISMA FU/SEWS OU)=SA, O(/TAN DIAFO/ROUS U(/LAS PARALA/BH|, SXHMATI/ZEI KAI\ E)NSFRAGI/ZETAI TH\N AU)TH\N A(PA/SAIS I)DE/AN, W(S TAU/TH| MA/LISTA SUGGENH= KAI\ A)DELFA\ KAI\ DI/DUMA TA\ DHMIOURGHQE/NTA GENE/SQAI. _*TAU)TO\N OU)=N KAI\ H( E)N TW=| SOFW=| DU/NAMIS E)PIDEI/CETAI: PRAGMATEUOME/NH GA\R TA\ PERI\ TOU= *)/ONTOS, <20EU)SE/BEIA>20 KAI\ O(SIO/THS O)NOMA/ZETAI, TA\ DE\ PERI\ OU)RANOU= KAI\ TW=N KAT' AU)TO/N, <20FUSIOLOGI/A: METEWROLOGIKH\>20 DE\ TA\ PERI\ TO\N A)E/RA KAI\ O(/SA KATA\ TA\S TROPA\S AU)TOU= KAI\ METABOLA\S E)/N TE TAI=S O(LOSXERE/SIN E)TH-SI/OIS W(/RAIS KAI\ TAI=S E)N ME/REI KATA/ TE MHNW=N KAI\ H(MERW=N PERIO/DOUS PE/FUKE SUNI/STASQAI: <20H)QIKH\>20 DE\ TA\ PRO\S A)NQRWPI/NWN E)PANO/RQWSIN H)QW=N, H(=S I)DE/AI <20POLITIKH/>20 TE H( PERI\ PO/LIN, KAI\ H( PERI\ OI)KI/AS E)PIME/LEIAN <20OI)KONOMIKH/, SUMPOTIKH/>20 TE H( PERI\ TA\ SUMPO/SIA KAI\ TA\S EU)WXI/AS. *)/ETI D' AU)= H( ME\N PERI\ A)NQRW/PWN E)PISTASI/AN <20BASILIKH/>20, H( DE\ PERI\ PROSTA/CEIS KAI\ A)PAGOREU/-SEIS <20NOMOQETIKH/>20. *PA/NTA GA\R TAU=TA O( POLU/FHMOS W(S A)LHQW=S KAI\ POLU-W/NUMOS SOFO\S KEXW/RHKEN KAI\ E)N A(PA/-SAIS E(\N EI)=DOS KAI\ TAU)TO\N E)/XWN O)FQH/SETAI. @&10Olympiodorus in Plat. Alcib. pr. p. 214 Creuzer.$10 O(/TI <20EI) KAI\ A)NTAKOLOUQOU=SIN A)LLH/LAIS AI( A)RETAI/, A)LLA\ TH=| I)DIO/THTI DIAFE/-ROUSIN>20. OU) GA/R EI)SI MI/A, A)LLA\ PA=SAI E)N ME\N TH=| A)NDREI/A| EI)SI\N A)NDREI/WS, E)N A)/LLW| DE\ SWFRONIKW=S: W(S KAI\ PA/NTES OI( QEOI\ E)N ME\N TW=| *DII/+ EI)SI DII/+WS, E)N A)/LLW| DE\ H(RAI/WS: OU)DEI\S GA\R QEO\S A)TELH/S. *KAI\ W(S *)ANACAGO/RAS E)/LEGE PA/NTA E)N PA=SIN, E(\N DE\ PLEONA/ZEIN, OU(/TW KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N QEI/WN E)ROU=MEN. *PA=SA GA\R A)RETH\ FRONHSI/S E)STIN, W(S TA\ PRAKT[2E/]2A EI)DUI=A: PA=SA A)NDREI/A, W(S A)GW-NIZOME/NH: PA=SA SWFROSU/NH, W(S E)PI\ TO\ KREI=TTON E)PANA/GOUSA: PA=SA DIKAIOSU/NH. H(=| TA\ PROSH/KONTA TOI=S PRAKTOI=S A)PONE/MOUSA. @&10Philo de Mose lib. II Vol. II Mang. p. 135.$10 O(\ KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N A)RETW=N EI)/WQE LE/GESQAI O(/TI O( MI/AN E)/XWN KAI\ PA/SAS E)/XEI. @&10Philo de sacrif. Abel et Cain %14 82 Vol. I p. 236, 3 Wendl.$10 DIAIRETE/ON OU)=N AU)TO\N [1&10scil.$10 TO\N LO/GON]1 EI)S KEFA/LAIA PROHGOU/MENA, TA\ LEGO/-MENA E)MPI/PTONTA, KAI\ E)FARMOSTE/ON E(KA/STW| TA\S OI)KEI/OUS KATASKEUA/S, MIMOU-ME/NOUS TOU\S A)GAQOU\S TW=N TOCOTW=N, OI(\ SKOPO/N TINA PROQE/MENOI TA\ BE/LH PA/NTA E)P' AU)TO\N A)FIE/NAI PEIRW=NTAI. *SKOPW=| ME\N GA\R TO\ KEFA/LAION, BE/LESI DE\ E)/OIKEN H( KATASKEUH/. OU(/TWS TO\ PA/NTWN A)/RISTON E)SQHMA/TWN O( LO/GOS A(R-MONI/WS SUNUFAI/NETAI. @&10p. 237, 2 %14 84.$10 TO\ GA\R O(/LON KAI\ E(/N E)STIN H( A)RETH\ H(\ KATA\ EI)/DH TA\ PROSEXH= TE/MNETAI, FRO/NHSIN KAI\ SWFROSU/NHN, DIKAIOSU/NHN KAI\ A)NDREI/AN, I(/NA TA\S KAQ' E(/KASTON EI)DO/TES DIAFORA\S E(KOU/SION U(POME/NWMEN LATREI/AN KAI\ KAQ' O(/LON KAI\ KATA\ ME/RH. @1 @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 64, 18 W.$10 *)ARETA\S D' EI)=NAI PLEI/OUS FASI\ KAI\ A)XWRI/STOUS A)P' A)LLH/LWN, KAI\ <20TA\S AU)TA\S TW=| H(GEMONIKW=| ME/REI TH=S YU-XH=S>20 KAQ' U(PO/STASIN, KAQ' O(\ <20DH\ KAI\ SW=MA PA=SAN A)RETH\N>20 EI)=NAI/ TE KAI\ LE/GESQAI, TH\N GA\R DIA/NOIAN KAI\ TH\N YUXH\N SW=MA EI)=NAI: TO\ GA\R SUMFUE\S PNEU=MA H(MI=N E)/NQERMON O)\N YUXH\N H(GOU=NTAI. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 65, 1 Wachsm.$10 BOU/LONTAI DE\ KAI\ TH\N E)N H(MI=N YUXH\N ZW=|ON EI)=NAI: ZH=N TE GA\R KAI\ AI)SQA/NESQAI: KAI\ MA/LISTA TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N ME/ROS AU)TH=S, O(\ DH\ KALEI=TAI DIA/NOIA. DIO\ KAI\ <20PA=SAN A)RETH\N ZW=|ON EI)=NAI>20, E)PEIDH\ H( AU)TH\ [2TH=|]2 DIANOI/A| E)STI\ KATA\ TH\N OU)SI/AN. KATA\ TOU=TO GA/R FASI KAI\ TH\N FRO/NHSIN FRONEI=N: A)KOLOUQEI= GA\R AU)TOI=S TO\ OU(/TWS LE/GEIN. @&10Seneca epist. 113, 1. quid sentiam de hac quaestione, iactata &10apud nostros%10 <21an iustitia fortitudo prudentia ceteraeque virtutes &10animalia sint>21. Hac subtilitate effecimus, Lucili carissime, ut exercere &10ingenium inter inrita videremur et disputationibus nihil profuturis otium &10terere. Faciam, quod desideras, et quid nostris videatur, exponam. __ &10_quae sint ergo, quae <21antiquos moverint>21, dicam. Animum constat &10animal esse, cum ipse efficiat, ut simus animalia, [et] cum ab illo ani-&10malia nomen hoc traxerint. virtus autem nihil aliud est quam <21animus &10quodammodo se habens>21%10 ergo animal est. Deinde virtus agit aliquid. &10agi autem nihil sine <21inpetu>21 potest. si inpetum habet, qui nulli est nisi &10animali, animal est. "1Si animal est, inquit, virtus, habet ipsa virtutem."2 &10Quidni habeat se ipsam? quomodo sapiens omnia per virtutem gerit, sic &10virtus per se. "1Ergo, inquit, et omnes artes animalia sunt et omnia, &10quae cogitamus quaeque mente conplectimur. sequitur, ut multa milia &10animalium habitent in his angustiis pectoris et singuli multa simus ani-&10malia aut multa habeamus animalia."2 <21Quaeris, quid adversus istuc &10respondeatur>21? unaquaeque ex istis res animal erit%10 multa animalia non &10erunt. quare? dicam, si mihi adcommodaveris subtilitatem et intentionem &10tuam. Singula animalia singulas habere debent substantias. ista omnia &10unum animum habent. itaque singula esse possunt, multa esse non pos-&10sunt. Ego et animal sum et homo, non tamen duos esse dices. quare? &10quia separati debent esse [1ita dico, alter ab altero debet esse diductus]1 &10ut duo sint. Quicquid in uno multiplex est, sub unam naturam cadit. &10itaque unum est. Et animus meus animal est et ego animal sum%10 duo &10tamen non sumus. quare? quia animus mei pars est. Tunc aliquid per &10se numerabitur, cum per se stabit%10 ubi vero alterius membrum erit, non &10poterit videri aliud. quare? dicam%10 quia quod aliud est, suum oportet &10esse et proprium et totum et intra se absolutum. &10@Ibidem %14 24%10 Non sunt, inquit, virtutes multa animalia et tamen &10animalia sunt. nam quemaqmodum aliquis et poe%28ta est et orator, et &10tamen unus, sic virtutes istae animalia sunt, sed multa non sunt. @1 @&Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 128.$ <20FU/SEI TE TO\ DI/KAION EI)=NAI>20 KAI\ MH\ QE/SEI, W(S KAI\ TO\N NO/MON KAI\ TO\N O)RQO\N LO/GON, KAQA/ FHSI <20*XRU/-SIPPOS E)N TW=| PERI\ TOU= *KALOU=>20. @&10Cicero de finibus III 21, 71. <21Ius autem>21, quod ita dici apel-&10larique possit, id <21esse natura>21, alienumque esse a sapiente non modo &10iniuriam cui facere, verum etiam nocere. Nec vero rectum est cum ami-&10cis aut bene meritis consociare aut coniungere iniuriam. Gravissimeque &10_defenditur <21numquam aequitatem ab utilitate posse seiungi>21, &10et, quicquid aequum iustumque esset, id etiam honestum, vicissimque &10quicquid esset honestum, iustum etiam atque aequum fore. @&Proclus in Plat. Alcib. pr. p. 318 Creuzer.$8 *(O ME\N DH\ SUL-LOGISMO\S O(/LOS O( KATASKEUA/ZWN O(/TI TO\ DI/KAION SUMFE/RON OU(TWSI\ PRO/EISI: <20PA=N DI/KAION KALO/N, PA=N KALO\N A)GAQO/N: PA=N A)/RA DI/KAION A)GA-QO/N: A)LLA\ MH\N KAI\ TO\ A)GAQO\N TW=| SUMFE/RONTI TAU)TO/N: PA=N A)/RA DI/KAION SUMFE/RON>20. *OU)/TE GA\R TO\ A)GAQO\N TH=S YUXH=S E)N A)/LLW| TINI\ H)\ E)N TH=| A)RETH=| U(FE/STHKEN, OU)/TE TO\ KALO/N, A)LLA\ PA=N TO\ A)GAQO\N KAT' A)RETH\N A)FW/RISTAI, KAI\ TO\ AU)TO\ KALO/N E)STIN O(/PER A)GAQO/N, KAI\ TAU=TA A)MFO/TERA DI/KAIA/ E)STI. *KA)\N GA\R SW=FRON H)=| KAI\ A)NDREI=ON, DI/KAIO/N E)STI DIA\ TH\N TW=N A)RETW=N A)N-TAKOLOU/QHSIN: OU) GA/R E)STI SWFRONEI=N ME\N A)DI/KWS DE\ ZH=N, OU)DE\ A)NDRI/-ZESQAI ME/N, STE/RESQAI DE/ POTE DIKAIOSU/NHS, A)LLA\ TO\ AU)TO\ TH=S ZWH=S EI)=-DOS E)K PASW=N U(FE/STHKE TW=N A)RETW=N. @&10Cicero de legibus I 16, 44. <21Nec solum ius et iniuria na-&10tura diiudicantur, sed omnino omnia honesta ac turpia>21. Nam &10et communis intelligentia notas nobis res efficit easque in animis nostris &10inchoavit, ut honesta in virtute ponantur, in vitiis turpia. Haec autem &10in opinione existimare, non in natura posita, dementis est. Nam nec ar-&10boris nec equi virtus, quae dicitur [1in quo abutimur nomine]1 in opinione @1 &10sita est, sed in natura. Quodsi ita est', honesta quoque et turpia natura &10diiudicanda sunt. Nam si opinione universa virtus, eadem eius etiam &10partes probarentur. Quis igitur prudentem et, ut ita dicam, catum non &10ex ipsius habitu, sed ex aliqua re externa iudicet? <21Est enim virtus &10perfecta ratio; quod certe in natura est>21. Igitur omnis honestas &10eodem modo. &10@Cicero de legibus I 17, 45. Nam ut vera et falsa, ut conse-&10quentia et contraria sua sponte, non aliena iudicantur%10 sic constans et &10perpetua ratio vitae, quae est virtus, itemque inconstantia, quod est vi-&10tium, sua natura probabitur. Nos ingenia iuvenum iudicamus natura%10 &10non item virtutes et vitia, quae existunt ab ingeniis, iudicabuntur? An &10ea aliter%10 honesta et turpia non ad naturam referri necesse erit? Quod &10laudabile bonum est, in se habeat quod laudetur necesse est%10 ipsum enim &10bonum non est opinionibus, sed natura. Nam ni ita esset, beati quoque &10opinione essent. Quo quid dici potest stultius? Quare <21quum et bonum &10et malum natura iudicetur>21 et ea sint principia naturae%10 certe <21ho-&10nesta quoque et turpia>21 simili ratione diiudicanda et <21ad naturam &10referenda sunt>21. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 15 p. 1040a.$ <20*)EN DE\ TOI=S PRO\S AU)TO\N *PLA/TWNA PERI\ *DIKAIOSU/NHS>20 EU)QU\S E)C A)RXH=S E)NA/L-LETAI TW=| PERI\ QEW=N LO/GW| KAI/ FHSIN "1<20OU)/T' O)RQW=S A)POTRE/PEIN TW=| A)PO\ TW=N QEW=N FO/BW| TH=S A)DIKI/AS TO\N *KE/FALON, EU)DIA/BLHTO/N T' EI)=NAI KAI\ PRO\S TOU)NANTI/ON E)CA/GEIN POLLOU\S PERISPASMOU\S KAI\ PIQANO/THTAS A)NTIPIPTOU/SAS TO\N PERI\ TW=N U(PO\ TOU= QEOU= KOLA/SEWN LO/GON, W(S OU)DE\N DIAFE/RONTA TH=S *)AKKOU=S KAI\ TH=S *)ALFITOU=S, DI' W(=N TA\ PAIDA/RIA TOU= KAKOSXOLEI=N AI( GUNAI=KES A)NEI/RGOUSIN>20."2 *OU(/TW DE\ DIASU/RAS TA\ TOU= *PLA/TWNOS, E)PAINEI= PA/LIN <20E)N A)/LLOIS>20 KAI\ PROFE/RETAI TA\ TOU= *EU)RIPI/DOU TAUTI\ POLLA/KIS: [1&Nauck fr. trag. p. 679$]1 A)LL' E)/STI, KEI)/ TIS E)GGELA=| LO/GW|, @*ZEU\S KAI\ QEOI\ BRO/TEIA LEU/SSONTES PA/QH. @&Marcianus libro I institut. [1Vol. I p. 11, 25 Mommsen]1 sed &et philosophus summae Stoicae sapientiae <21Chrysippus>21 sic incipit &<21libro>21 quem fecit $8<20PERI\ NO/MOU%10 O( NO/MOS PA/NTWN E)STI\ BASILEU\S QEI/WN TE KAI\ A)NQRWPI/NWN PRAGMA/TWN: DEI= DE\ AU)TO\N PROSTA/-THN TE EI)=NAI TW=N KALW=N KAI\ TW=N AI)SXRW=N KAI\ A)/RXONTA KAI\ H(GEMO/NA, KAI\ KATA\ TOU=TO KANO/NA TE EI)=NAI DIKAI/WN KAI\ A)DI/KWN KAI\ TW=N FU/SEI POLITIKW=N *ZW/|WN PROSTAKTIKO\N ME\N W(=N POIHTE/ON, A)PAGOREUTIKO\N DE\ W(=N OU) POIHTE/ON. @1 @&10Cicero de legibus I 6, 18. Igitur doctissimis viris proficisci &10placuit a lege%10 haud scio an recte, si modo, ut iidem definiunt, <21lex est &10ratio summa, insita in natura, quae iubet ea quae facienda &10sunt prohibetque contraria>21. Eadem ratio, cum est hominis mente &10confirmata et perfecta, lex est. 19. Itaque arbitrantur prudentiam esse &10legem, cuius ea vis sit, ut recte facere iubeat, vetet delinquere%10 eamque &10rem illi Graeco putant nomine [2a]2 suum cuique tribuendo appellatam__ &10___a <21lege ducendum est iuris exordium>21%10 ea est enim naturae &10vis, ea mens ratioque prudentis, ea iuris atque iniuriae regula__ &10quae saeclis omnibus ante nata est, quam scripta lex ulla aut quam om-&10nino civitas constituta. &10@Cicero de legibus II 8. legem neque hominum ingeniis excogi &10tatam nec scitum aliquod esse populorum, sed aeternum quiddam, quod &10universum mundum regeret imperandi prohibendique sapientia. Ita <21prin-&10cipem legem>21 illam et ultimam <21mentem esse dicebant omnia ra-&10tione aut cogentis aut vetantis dei>21; ex quo illa lex, quam di hu-&10mano generi dederunt, recte est laudata; est enim ratio mensque sapientis &10ad iubendum et ad deterrendum idonea. 9. iussa ac vetita populorum &10vim habere ad recte facta vocandi et a peccatis avocandi, quae vis non &10modo senior est quam aetas populorum et civitatium, sed aequalis illius &10caelum atque terras tuentis et regentis dei. 10. Neque enim esse mens &10divina sine ratione potest, nec ratio divina non hanc vim in rectis pra-&10visque sanciendis habet. __Quam ob rem <21lex vera>21 atque princeps apta &10ad iubendum et ad vetandum <21ratio est recta summi Iovis>21. &10@Cicero de legibus I 12, 33. Quodsi, quo modo est natura, sic &10iudicio homines "1humani [1ut ait poe%28ta]1 nihil a se alienum putarent"2 cole-&10retur ius aeque ab omnibus. <21Quibus enim ratio a natura data est, &10iisdem etiam recta ratio data est%10 ergo etiam lex, quae est &10recta ratio in iubendo et vetando%10 si lex, ius quoque. At om-&10nibus ratio. Ius igitur datum est omnibus>21. Recteque Socrates &10exsecrari eum solebat, qui primus utilitatem a iure seiunxisset%10 id enim &10querebatur caput esse exitiorum omnium. &10@Cicero de legibus II 11. <21Omnem enim legem, quae qui &10dem recte lex appellari possit, esse laudabilem>21 quibusdam talibus &10argumentis docent. Constat profecto ad salutem civium civitatumque in-&10columitatem vitamque hominum quietam et beatam inventas esse leges, &10eosque, qui primum eius modi scita sanxerint, populis ostendisse ea se &10scripturos atque laturos, quibus illi adscitis susceptisque honeste beateque &10viverent; quaeque ita composita sanctaque essent, eas leges videlicet nomi-&10narunt. Ex quo intellegi par est eos, qui perniciosa et iniusta populis &10iussa descripserint, cum contra fecerint quam polliciti professique sint, &10quidvis potius tulisse quam leges. 12. Quaero igitur__sicut illi solent: &10<21quo si civitas careat, ob eam ipsam causam, quod eo careat, @1 &10pro nihilo habenda sit, id estne numerandum in bonis? _Ac &10maxumis quidem. _Lege autem carens civitas estne ob [2id]2 &10ipsum habenda nullo loco? _Dici aliter non potest. _Necesse &10est igitur legem haberi in rebus optimis>21. &10@Cicero de legibus I 15, 42. Iam vero illud stultissimum, exis-&10timare omnia iusta esse, quae sancita sint in populorum institutis aut le-&10gibus. Etiamne si quae leges sint tyrannorum? ____Est enim &10unum ius, quo devincta est hominum societas et quod lex constituit una; &10quae lex est recta ratio imperandi atque prohibendi%10 quam qui ignorat, &10is est iniustus, sive est illa scripta uspiam, sive nusquam. &10@Cicero de legibus I 15, 42. Quod si iustitia est obtemperatio &10scriptis legibus institutisque populorum et si, ut iidem dicunt, utilitate &10omnia metienda sunt, negliget leges eosque perrumpet, si poterit, is, qui &10sibi eam rem fructuosam putabit fore. Ita fit, ut nulla sit omnino iustitia, &10si neque natura est eaque, quae propter utilitatem constituitur, utilitate &10alia convellitur. &10@Cicero de legibus I 16, 43. Quodsi populorum iussis, si princi-&10pum decretis, si sententiis iudicum iura constituerentur%10 ius esset latroci-&10nari, ius adulterare, ius testamenta falsa supponere, si haec suffragiis aut &10scitis multitudinis probarentur. 44. Quod si tanta potestas est stultorum &10sententiis atque iussis, ut eorum suffragiis rerum natura vertatur%10 cur non &10sanciunt, ut quae mala perniciosaque sunt habeantur pro bonis ac salu-&10taribus? aut cur ius ex iniuria lex facere possit, bonum eadem facere &10non possit ex malo? Atqui nos legem bonam a mala nulla alia nisi na-&10turae norma dividere possumus. @&Cicero Tusculan. disp. I 45, 108.&3 Sed quid singulorum opi-&3niones animadvertam, nationum varios errores perspicere cum liceat? &3<21Condiunt Aegyptii mortuos et eos servant domi, Persae etiam &3cera circumlitos condunt, ut quam maxime permaneant diu-&3turna corpora. Magorum mos est, non humare corpora suo-&3rum, nisi a feris sint ante laniata. In Hyrcania plebs publi-&3cos alit canes, optimates domesticos [1nobile autem genus &3canum illud scimus esse]1 sed pro sua quisque facultate parat, &3a quibus lanietur, eamque optimam illi esse censent sepultu-&3ram>21. Permulta alia colligit Chrysippus, ut est in omni historia &3curiosus%10 sed ita tetra sunt quaedam, ut ea fugiat et reformidet oratio. @&10Philo de Joseph. Vol. II Mang. p. 46.$10 PROSQH/KH GA/R E)STI TH=S TO\ KU=ROS A(PA/NTWN A)NHMME/NHS FU/SEWS H( KATA\ DH/MOUS POLITEI/A H( <20ME\N GA\R MEGALO/POLIS O(/DE O( KO/SMOS E)STI\ KAI\ MIA=| XRH=TAI POLITEI/A| KAI\ NO/MW| E(NI/. *LO/GOS DE/ E)STI FU/SEWS PROSTAKTIKO\S ME\N W(=N PRAKTE/ON, A)PA-GOREUTIKO\S DE\ W(=N OU) POIHTE/ON>20. *AI( DE\ KATA\ TO/POUS AU(=TAI PO/LEIS A)PERI/- @1GRAFOI/ TE EI)SI\N A)RIQMW=| KAI\ POLITEI/AIS XRW=NTAI DIAFEROU/SAIS KAI\ NO/MOIS OU)XI\ TOI=S AU)TOI=S. *)/ALLA GA\R PAR' A)/LLOIS E)/QH KAI\ NO/MIMA PARECHURHME/NA KAI\ PROSTEQEIME/NA. _*AI)/TION DE\ TO\ A)/MIKTON KAI\ A)KOINW/NHTON, OU) MO/NON *(ELLH/NWN PRO\S BARBA/ROUS H)\ BARBA/RWN PRO\S *(/ELLHNAS A)LLA\ KAI\ TO\ E(KATE/ROU GE/NOUS I)DI/A| PRO\S TO\ O(MO/FULON. *EI)=Q', W(S E)/OIKE, TA\ A)NAI/TIA AI)TIW/MENOI, KAIROU\S A)BOULH/TOUS, A)GONI/AN KARPW=N, TO\ LUPRO/GEION, TH\N QE/SIN, O(/TI PARA/LIOS H)\ MESO/GEIOS H)\ KATA\ NH=SON H)\ KATA\ H)/PEIRON H)\ O(/SA TOU/TOIS O(MOIO/TROPA TA)LHQE\S H(SUXA/ZOUSIN. *)/ESTI D' H( PLEONECI/A KAI\ H( PRO\S A)LLH/LOUS A)PISTI/A, DI' A(/S, OU)K A)RKESQE/NTES TOI=S TH=S FU/SEWS QESMOI=S, <20TA\ DO/CANTA SUMFE/REIN KOINH=| TOI=S O(MOGNW/MOSIN O(MI/LOIS TAU=TA NO/MOUS E)PEFH/MISAN, W(/STE EI)KO/-TWS PROSQH=KAI MA=LLON AI( KATA\ ME/ROS POLITEI=AI MIA=S TH=S KATA\ FU/SIN>20. *PROSQH=KAI ME\N GA\R OI( KATA\ PO/LEIS NO/MOI TOU= TH=S FU/SEWS O)RQOU= LO/GOU. &10p. 47.$10 OI)KI/A GA\R PO/LIS E)STI\N E)STALME/NH KAI\ BRAXEI=A, KAI\ OI)KONOMI/A ÈSUNHGME/NH TIS POLITEI/A: W(S KAI\ PO/LIS ME\N OI)=KOS ME/GAS, POLITEI/A DE\ KOINH/ TIS OI)KONOMI/A. *DI' W(=N MA/LISTA PARI/STATAI <20TO\N AU)TO\N OI)KONOMIKO/N TE EI)=NAI KAI\ POLITIKO/N>20, KA)\N TA\ PLH/QH KAI\ MEGE/QH TW=N U(POKEIME/NWN DIALLA/TTH|. @&Diogenianus apud Eusebium praep. evang. VI p.264b.$ PW=S DE\ TOU\S KEIME/NOUS NO/MOUS H(MARTH=SQAI FH\S A(/PANTAS KAI\ TA\S <20POLI-TEI/AS>20. @&10Cicero de republ. III 33 [1Lactant. instit. div. VI 8]1. Est qui-&10dem vera lex recta ratio, naturae congruens, diffusa in omnes, constans, &10sempiterna, quae vocet ad officium iubendo, vetando a fraude deterreat; &10<21quae tamen neque probos frustra iubet aut vetat nec improbos &10iubendo aut vetando movet>21. Huic legi nec obrogari fas est neque &10derogari ex hac aliquid licet neque tota abrogari potest, nec vero_solvi &10hac lege possumus, neque est quaerendus explanator aut interpres eius &10alius, nec erit alia lex Romae alia Athenis, alia nunc alia posthac, sed &10et omnes gentes et omni tempore una lex et sempiterna et immutabilis &10continebit, unusque erit communis quasi magister et imperator omnium &10deus, ille legis huius inventor, disceptator, lator; <21cui qui non parebit, &10ipse se fugiet ac naturam hominis aspernatus>21 hoc ipso luet maxi-&10mas poenas, etiamsi cetera supplicia, quae putantur, effugerit. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 9 p. 1035c.$8 *)/AKOUE DE\ A(\ LE/GEI PERI\ TOU/TWN <20E)N TW=| TRI/TW| PERI\ *QEW=N "1OU) GA/R E)STIN EU(REI=N TH=S DIKAIOSU/NHS A)/LLHN A)RXH/N, OU)D' A)/LLHN GE/NESIN, H)\ TH\N E)K TOU= *DIO\S KAI\ TH\N E)K TH=S KOINH=S FU/SEWS: E)NTEU=QEN GA\R DEI= PA=N TO\ TOIOU=TON TH\N A)RXH\N E)/XEIN, EI) ME/LLOME/N TI E)REI=N PERI\ A)GA-QW=N KAI\ KAKW=N>20."2 @&10Clemens Al. Strom. IV 26 p. 642 Pott.$10 LE/GOUSI GA\R KAI\ <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 TO\N ME\N OU)RANO\N KURI/WS PO/LIN: TA\ DE\ E)PI\ GH=S E)NTAU=QA OU)KE/TI PO/LEIS. LE/GESQAI ME\N GA/R, OU)K EI)=NAI DE/: SPOUDAI=ON GA\R H( <20PO/LIS KAI\>20 O( @1 DH=MOS A)STEI=O/N TI SU/STHMA KAI\ <20PLH=QOS A)NQRW/PWN U(PO\ NO/MOU DIOI-KOU/MENON>20. @&10Stobaeus eclog. II 7 p. 103, 9 W.$10 *LE/GOUSI DE\ KAI\ FUGA/DA PA/NTA FAU=LON EI)=NAI KAQ' O(/SON STE/RETAI NO/MOU KAI\ POLITEI/AS KATA\ FU/SIN E)PIBAL-LOU/SHS. <20*TO\N GA\R NO/MON EI)=NAI, KAQA/PER EI)/POMEN, SPOUDAI=ON, O(MOI/WS DE\ KAI\ TH\N PO/LIN>20. *(IKANW=S DE\ KAI\ *KLEA/NQHS PERI\ TO\ SPOUDAI=ON EI)=NAI TH\N PO/LIN LO/GON H)RW/THSE TOIOU=TON: *PO/LIS ME\N [2EI)]2 E)/STIN OI)KHTH/RION KATASKEU/ASMA, EI)S O(\ KATAFEU/GONTAS E)/STI DI/KHN DOU=NAI KAI\ LABEI=N, OU)K A)STEI=ON DH\ PO/LIS E)STI/N; A)LLA\ MH\N TOIOU=TO/N E)STIN H( PO/LIS OI)KHTH/RION: A)STEI=ON A)/R' E)/STIN H( PO/LIS. <20*TRIXW=S DE\ LEGOME/NHS TH=S PO/LEWS>20, TH=S TE KATA\ TO\ OI)KHTH/RION KAI\ TH=S KATA\ TO\ SU/STHMA TW=N A)NQRW/PWN KAI\ TRI/TON TH=S KAT' A)MFO/TERA TOU/TWN, KATA\ DU/O SHMAINO/MENA LE/GESQAI TH\N PO/LIN A)STEI/AN, KATA/ TE TO\ SU/STHMA TW=N A)N-QRW/PWN KAI\ KATA\ TO\ SUNAMFO/TERON DIA\ [2TH\N EI)S]2 TOU\S E)NOIKOU=NTAS A)NA-FORA/N. @&10Dio Chrysost. or. XXXVI %14 20 [1Vol. II p. 6, 13$10]1. <20TH\N PO/LIN>20 FASI\N EI)=NAI <20PLH=QOS A)NQRW/PWN E)N TAU)TW=| KATOIKOU/NTWN U(PO\ NO/MOU DIOIKOU/MENON>20. @&10Philo de septen. et fest. dieb. p. 284 Vol. II Mang.$10 SUNO/LWS GA\R E)NA/RETOS H( POLITEI/A KAI\ NO/MOIS OI(\ MO/NON TO\ KALO\N A)GAQO\N EI)SHGOU=NTAI. @&10Dio Chrysost. or. III %14 43 [1Vol. I p. 41, 7 Arn.$10]1. LE/GETAI GA\R <20H( ME\N A)RXH\>20 "1NO/MIMOS A)NQRW/PWN DIOI/KHSIS"2 KAI\ "1PRO/NOIA A)NQRW/PWN KATA\ NO/MON."2 @&10Clemens Al. Strom. II p. 420 Pott.$10 H(=| TINES__LO/GON O)RQO\N TO\N <20NO/MON>20 E)/FASAN, PROSTAKTIKO\N ME\N W(=N POIHTE/ON, A)PAGOREUTIKO\N DE\ W(=N OU) POIHTE/ON. __ @<20POLITEI/AN>20__H( DE/ E)STI TROFH\ A)NQRW/PWN KALH\ KATA\ KOINWNI/AN. @<20TH\N DIKASTIKH\N>20_E)PISTH/MHN OU)=SAN DIORQWTIKH\N TW=N A(MARTANOME/-NWN E(/NEKEN TOU= DIKAI/OU. @SU/STOIXOS DE\ AU)TH=| H( <20KOLASTIKH\>20 TOU= KATA\ TA\S KOLA/SEIS ME/TROU E)PISTH-MONIKH/ TIS OU)=SA. KO/LASIS DE\ OU)=SA DIO/RQWSI/S E)STI YUXH=S__ @MO/NON GOU=N TO\N SOFO\N OI( FILO/SOFOI BASILE/A, NOMOQE/THN, STRATHGO/N, DI/-KAION, O(/SION, QEOFILH= KHRU/TTOUSIN. __ @KAQA/PER OU)=N TH\N POIMENIKH\N TW=N PROBA/TWN PRONOEI=N FAME/N__ OU(/TW GE KAI\ TH\N NOMOQETIKH\N TH\N A)NQRW/PWN A)RETH\N KATASKEUA/ZEIN E)ROU=MEN, TO\ A)NQRW/PINON KATA\ DU/NAMIN A)GAQO\N A)NAZWPUROU=SAN, E)PISTATIKH\N KAI\ KHDE-MONIKH\N OU)=SAN TH=S A)NQRW/PWN A)GE/LHS. @&10Cicero de finibus III 19, 64. <21Mundum autem censent regi &10numine deorum eumque esse quasi communem urbem et civi-&10tatem hominum et deorum>21, et unumquemque nostrum eius mundi &10esse partem%10 ex quo illud natura consequi, ut communem utilitatem nostrae &10anteponamus. Ut enim leges omnium salutem singulorum saluti antepo-&10nunt, sic vir bonus et sapiens et legibus parens et civilis officii non igna- @1&10rus utilitati omnium plus quam unius alicuius aut suae consulit. Nec &10magis est vituperandus proditor patriae quam communis utilitatis aut sa-&10lutis desertor propter suam utilitatem aut salutem. Ex quo fit, ut lau-&10dandus is sit, qui mortem oppetat pro re publica, quod deceat cariorem &10nobis esse patriam quam nosmet ipsos. @&10Dio Chrysost. Or. XXXVI %14 23 [1Vol. II p. 7, 7 Arn.$10]1. MI/AN GA\R DH\ TAU/THN KAQARW=S EU)DAI/MONA POLITEI/AN EI)/TE KAI\ PO/LIN XRH\ KALEI=N, <20TH\N QEW=N PRO\S A)LLH/LOUS KOINWNI/AN, E)A/N TE KAI\ CU/MPAN TO\ LOGIKO\N PERILA/BH| TIS, A)NQRW/PWN SU\N QEOI=S A)RIQMOUME/NWN, W(S PAI=DES SU\N A)NDRA/SI LE/GONTAI METE/XEIN PO/LEWS>20, FU/SEI POLI=TAI O)/NTES, OU) TW=| FRONEI=N TE KAI\ PRA/TTEIN TA\ TW=N POLITW=N OU)DE\ TW=| KOINWNEI=N TOU= NO/MOU, A)CU/NETOI O)/NTES AU)TOU=. @&10Dio Chrysost. Or. I %14 42 [1Vol. I p. 8, 8 Arn.$10]1. KALO\N OU)=N EI)-PEI=N U(PE\R TW=N O(/LWN TH=S DIOIKH/SEWS, O(POI=O/N GE TO\ CU/MPAN AU)TO/ TE EU)/DAIMON KAI\ SOFO\N A)EI\ DIAPOREU/ETAI TO\N A)/PEIRON AI)W=NA SUNEXW=S E)N A)PEI/ROIS PERIO/DOIS META\ YUXH=S TE A)GAQH=S KAI\ DAI/MONOS O(MOI/OU KAI\ PRONOI/AS KAI\ A)RXH=S TH=S DIKAIOTA/THS TE KAI\ A)RI/STHS, H(MA=S TE O(MOI/OUS PARE/XETAI, KATA\ FU/SIN KOINH\N TH\N AU(TOU= KAI\ TH\N H(METE/RAN <20U(F' E(NI\ QESMW=| KAI\ NO/MW| KEKOSMHME/NOUS KAI\ TH=S AU)TH=S METE/XONTAS POLITEI/AS>20: H(\N O( ME\N TIMW=N KAI\ FULA/TTWN KAI\ MHDE\N E)NANTI/ON PRA/TTWN NO/MIMOS KAI\ QEOFILH\S KAI\ KO/SMIOS, O( DE\ TARA/T-TWN O(/SON E)F' E(AUTW=| KAI\ PARABAI/NWN KAI\ A)GNOW=N A)/NOMOS KAI\ A)/KOSMOS, O(MOI/WS ME\N I)DIW/THS, O(MOI/WS DE\ KAI\ A)/RXWN O)NOMAZO/MENOS. @&10Philo de mundi opificio %14 3 Vol. I p. 1, 11 Wendl.$10 TOU= NOMI/-MOU A)NDRO\S EU)QU\S O)/NTOS <20KOSMOPOLI/TOU>20, PRO\S TO\ BOU/LHMA TH=S FU/SEWS TA\S PRA/CEIS A)PEUQU/NONTOS, KAQ' H(\N KAI\ O( SU/MPAS KO/SMOS DIOIKEI=TAI. @&10Philo de mundi opificio %14 142 Vol. I p. 50, 2 Wendl.$10 *TO\N DE\ A)RXHGE/THN E)KEI=NON OU) MO/NON PRW=TON A)/NQRWPON A)LLA\ KAI\ MO/NON <20KOSMOPO-LI/THN>20 LE/GONTES A)FEUDE/STATA E)ROU=MEN. *)=HN GA\R OI)=KOS AU)TW=| KAI\ PO/LIS O( KO/SMOS. __%14&10 143.$10 *)EPEI\ DE\ PA=SA PO/LIS EU)/NOMOS E)/XEI POLITEI/AN, A)NAG-KAI/WS CUNE/BAINE TW=| KOSMOPOLI/TH| <20XRH=SQAI POLITEI/A| H(=| KAI\ SU/MPAS O( KO/SMOS>20. *AU(/TH DE/ E)STIN O( TH=S FU/SEWS O)RQO\S LO/GOS, O(\S KURIWTE/RA| KLH/SEI PROSONOMA/ZETAI QESMO/S, NO/MOS QEI=OS W)/N, KAQ' O(\N TA\ PROSH/KONTA KAI\ E)PI-BA/LLONTA E(KA/STOIS A)PENEMH/QH. *TAU/THS TH=S PO/LEWS KAI\ POLITEI/AS E)/DEI TINA\S EI)=NAI PRO\ A)NQRW/POU POLI/TAS, OI(\ LE/GOINT' A)\N E)NDI/KWS MEGALOPOLI=TAI__ OU(=TOI DE\ TI/NES A)\N EI)=EN O(/TI MH\ LOGIKAI\ KAI\ QEI=AI FU/SEIS, AI( ME\N A)SW/MATOI KAI\ NOHTAI/, AI( DE\ OU)K A)/NEU SWMA/TWN, O(POI/OUS SUMBE/BHKEN EI)=NAI TOU\S A)STE/RAS. @&10Cicero de republ. I 19. An tu ad domos nostras non censes &10pertinere scire, quid agatur et quid fiat domi? quae non ea est, quam &10parietes nostri cingunt, sed <21mundus hic totus, quod domicilium &10quamque patriam di nobis communem secum dederunt>21. &10@Cicero de legibus I 7, 22. Animal hoc providum, sagax, mul-&10tiplex, acutum, memor, plenum rationis et consilii, quem vocamus hominem, Ӄ&10praeclara quadam condicione generatum esse a supremo deo. Solum est &10enim ex tot animantium generibus atque naturis particeps rationis et @1 &10cogitationis, cum cetera sint omnia expertia. Quid est autem, non dicam &10in homine, sed in omni caelo atque terra ratione divinius? quae cum adu-&10levit atque perfecta est, nominatur rite sapientia. 23. <21Est igitur, quo-&10niam nihil est ratione melius, eaque [2est]2 et in homine et in &10deo, prima homini cum deo rationis societas>21. Inter quos autem &10ratio, inter eosdem etiam recta ratio [et] communis est. Quae cum sit &10lex, lege quoque consociati homines cum diis putandi sumus. Inter quos &10porro est communio legis, inter eos communio iuris est. Quibus autem &10haec sunt [2inter eos]2 communia, ei <21civitatis eiusdem habendi sunt>21. &10Si vero iisdem imperiis et potestatibus parent, multo iam magis. Parent &10autem huic caelesti discriptioni mentique divinae et praepotenti deo%10 ut &10iam <21universus hic mundus una civitas communis deorum atque &10hominum>21 existimanda [2sit]2. Et quod in civitatibus ratione quadam_ &10de qua dicetur idoneo loco_agnationibus familiarum distinguuntur sta-&10tus, id in rerum natura tanto est magnificentius tantoque praeclarius, ut &10homines deorum agnatione et gente teneantur. @&10Cicero de finibus III 62. Pertinere autem ad rem arbitrantur &10intellegi <21natura fieri, ut liberi a parentibus amentur; a quo initio &10profectam communem humani generis societatem>21 persequimur. &10Quod primum intellegi debet figura membrisque corporum, quae ipsa de-&10clarant procreandi a natura habitam esse rationem. Neque vero haec &10inter se congruere possent, ut natura et procreari vellet et diligi procrea-&10tos non curaret. Atque etiam in bestiis vis naturae perspici potest; qua-&10rum in fetu et in educatione laborem cum cernimus, naturae ipsius vocem &10videmur audire. Quare [2ut]2 perspicuum est natura nos a dolore abhor-&10rere, sic apparet a <21natura ipsa, ut eos, quos genuerimus, amemus, &10impelli.>21 &10@`63. Ex hoc nascitur, ut etiam <21communis hominum inter homines &10naturalis sit commendatio>21, ut oporteat hominem ab homine ob id &10ipsum, quod homo sit, non alienum videri. &10@Cicero de finibus III 64. Quoniamque illa vox inhumana et &10scelerata ducitur eorum, qui negant se recusare, quominus ipsis mortuis &10terrarum omnium deflagratio consequatur [1quod vulgari quodam versu Graeco &10pronuntiari solet]1, certe verum est <21etiam iis, qui aliquando futuri &10sint, esse propter ipsos consulendum>21. Ex hac animorum affectione &10testamenta commendationesque morientium natae sunt. &10@Cicero de finibus III 65. Quodque nemo in summa solitudine &10vitam agere velit ne cum infinita quidem voluptatum abundantia, facile &10intellegitur <21nos ad coniunctionem congregationemque hominum &10et ad naturalem communitatem esse natos>21. Impellimur autem na- @1&10tura, ut prodesse velimus quam plurimis in primisque docendo rationibus-&10que prudentiae tradendis. 66. Itaque non facile est invenire, qui, quod &10sciat ipse, non tradat alteri; ita non solum ad discendum <21propensi su-&10mus>21, verum <21etiam ad docendum>21. Atque ut tauris natura datum est, &10ut pro vitulis contra leones summa vi impetuque contendant, sic ii qui &10valent opibus atque id facere possunt, ut de Hercule et de Libero acce-&10pimus, <21ad servandum genus hominum natura incitantur>21. _Quem &10ad modum igitur membris utimur prius quam didicimus, cuius ea causa &10utilitatis habeamus, sic inter nos natura ad civilem communitatem con-&10iuncti et consociati sumus. Quod ni ita se haberet, nec iustitiae ullus &10esset nec bonitati locus. &10@Cicero de legibus I 10, 28. nihil est profecto praestabilius, &10quam plane intellegi, nos ad iustitiam esse natos, neque opinione, sed na-&10tura constitutum esse ius. Id iam patebit, <21si hominum inter ipsos &10societatem coniunctionemque perspexeris>21. 29. Nihil est enim &10unum uni tam simile, tam par, quam omnes inter nosmet ipsos sumus%10 &10quod si depravatio consuetudinum, si opinionum vanitas non imbecillitatem &10animorum torqueret et flecteret, quocunque coepisset, sui nemo ipse tam &10similis esset, quam omnes sunt omnium. Itaque quaecunque est hominis &10definitio, una in omnes valet. 30. Quod argumenti satis est, nullam dis-&10similitudinem esse in genere%10 quae si esset, non una omnes definitio con-&10tineret. Etenim <21ratio>21, qua una praestamus beluis, per quam coniectura &10valemus, argumentamur, refellimus, disserimus, conficimus aliquid, conclu-&10dimus certe est communis, doctrina differens, discendi quidem facultate &10par. Nam et <21sensibus>21 eadem omnia comprehenduntur%10 et ea quae mo-&10vent sensus, itidem movent omnium%10 quaeque in animis imprimuntur, de &10quibus ante dixi, <21inchoatae intelligentiae>21, similiter in omnibus im-&10primuntur%10 interpresque mentis oratio verbis discrepat, sententiis congruens. &10Nec est quisquam gentis ullius, qui ducem [2naturam]2 nactus ad virtutem &10pervenire non possit. &10@Cicero de legibus I 15, 43. Atque si natura confirmatura ius &10non erit, virtutes omnes tollentur. Ubi enim liberalitas, ubi patriae ca-&10ritas, ubi pietas, ubi aut bene merendi de altero aut referendae gratiae &10voluntas poterit existere? Nam haec nascuntur ex eo, quia <21natura pro-&10pensi sumus ad diligendos homines>21, quod fundamentum iuris est. &10Neque solum in homines obsequia, sed etiam in deos caerimoniae religio-&10nesque tollentur%10 quas non metu, sed ea <21coniunctione, quae est ho-&10mini cum deo>21, conservandas puto. &10@Lactant. div. instit. V 17. In omnibus enim videmus animali-&10bus, quia sapientia carent, conciliatricem sui esse naturam. Nocent igitur &10aliis, ut sibi prosint; nesciunt enim, quia malum est nocere. Homo vero, &10qui scientiam boni ac mali habet, abstinet se a nocendo, etiam cum in-&10commodo suo; quod animal irrationale facere non potest%10 et ideo inter &10summas hominis virtutes innocentia numeratur. Quibus rebus apparet, @1 &10sapientissimum esse, qui mavult perire, ne noceat, ut id offi-&10cium, quo a mutis discernitur servet>21. &10Origenes contra Celsum VIII 50 Vol. II p. 265, 22 Ko+. [1p. 778 &10Del.]1.$10 OU)DE\ GA\R <20TO\ KOINWNIKO\N>20 PERIGE/GRAPTAI W(/SPER A)PO\ TW=N A)LO/GWN ZW/|WN OU(/TW KAI\ A)PO\ TW=N A)GROIKOTE/RWN A)NQRW/PWN: A)LL' E)PI/SHS O( POIH/SAS H(MA=S PRO\S PA/NTAS A)NQRW/POUS PEPOI/HKE KOINWNIKOU/S. @&10Proclus in Plat. Alcib. pr. Vol. III p. 64 ed. Cousin.$10 *OI( ME\N GA\R <20A)PO\ [2TH=S]2 *STOA=S>20 EU)QU\S TA\ TOIAU=TA PA/NTA W(S MOXQHRA\ DIABA/LLOUSIN. <20*OU)/TE GA\R E)CAPATA=N E)STI DIKAI/WS KAT' AU)TOU\S OU)/TE BIA/ZESQAI OU)/TE A)POSTEREI=N>20, A)LL' E(KA/STH TW=N PRA/CEWN TOU/TWN A)PO\ MOXQHRA=S PRO/EISIN E(/CEWS KAI\ A)/DIKO/S E)STIN. *OI( DE\ A)RXAI=OI ME/SA TA\ TOIAU=TA TI/QENTAI PA/NTA &10etc. &10@Cicero de finibus III 70. Amicitiam autem adhibendam esse &10censent, quia sit ex eo genere, quae prosunt. Quamquam autem in ami-&10citia alii dicant aeque caram esse sapienti rationem amici ac suam, alii &10autem sibi cuique cariorem suam, tamen hi quoque posteriores fatentur &10alienum esse a iustitia, ad quam nati esse videamur, detrahere quid de &10aliquo, quod sibi assumat. Minime vero probatur_aut iustitiam aut &10amicitiam propter utilitates adscisci aut probari. Eaedem enim utilitates &10poterunt eas labefactare atque pervertere. Etenim nec iustitia nec ami-&10citia esse omnino poterunt, nisi ipsae per se expetuntur. &10@Seneca de beneficiis lib. III cp. 28. eadem omnibus principia &10eademque origo, <21nemo altero nobilior, nisi cui rectius ingenium &10et artibus bonis aptius>21. __Unus omnium parens mundus est%10 &10sive per splendidos sive per sordidos gradus ad hunc prima cuiusque origo &10perducitur. @&Plutarchus pers. de nobil. cp. 12.$ <20O( DE\ *XRU/SIPPOS>20 E)N TW=| <20PERI\ TW=N *)ARETW=N>20 "1I)SOTIMI/AS PERI/THGMA KAI\ DIA/CUSMA TH\N EU)GE/NEIAN KALEI=."2 MHDE\N A)/RA DIAFE/REIN O(/TOU PARA\ PATRO\S GEGONW\S TUGXA/NH|S, EU)GENOU=S H)\ MH/. ޅ@&ibid. cp. 13.$ *PA/LIN PRO\S <20*XRU/SIPPON>20 A)NAXWRW=, O(\S KATA\ TH=S EU)GENEI/AS U(PO\ TOU= CUNETWTA/TOU POIHTOU= PEPOIH=SQAI GRA/FEI TA/DE: @*(/ON KEN E)GW\ DH/SAS A)GA/GW H)\ A)/LLOS *)AXAIW=N: &paullo infra%10$ PA/LIN U(LAKTEI= LE/GWN U(PO\ TOU= AU)TOU= POIHTOU= TA\ TW=N EU)GENW=N KAKW=S PEPRAGME/NA DHLWQE/NTA, O(/TAN TH\N *)/AREWS KAI\ *)AFRO-DI/THS MOIXEI/AN O( *(/HFAISTOS KATEI/LHFE: *Q&`308 sq.$ W(\S E)ME\ XWLO\N E)O/NTA <20*DIO\S QUGA/THR>20 *)AFRODI/TH @AI)E\N A)TIMA/ZEI, FILE/EI D' A)I/+DHLON *)/ARHA. &paullo infra%10$ EI) DE\ MH\ TH\N *STOA\N KATABA/LLETE, TA\ PA/NTA A(MARTH/MATA FA/SKONTES I)/SA TUGXA/NEIN, TI/ TA\ TW=N EU)GENW=N A)KRIBE/STERON E)PITHREI=TE; QUGATRO\S A)POKEXRH=SQAI TO\N E)K DH/MOU KAI\ TO\N BASILE/A MHDE\N DIA- @1FE/REIN LE/GETE: O(/MWS POLLA\ FLUAROU=NTES EI)S TO\N TW=N EU)GENW=N TU/FON, A)LAZONEI/AN, E)/RWTAS, A)QEMI/STOUS SUNOUSI/AS, W)MO/THTA A)NTIDI/KWN E)PI-QUMHTIKOU\S KALEI=TE, KAI\ TW=N ME\N EU)ERGESIW=N A)MNH/MONAS, A)DIKOUME/NOUS DE\ DRIMUTA/TOUS PRO\S TO\ A)POTI/NEIN. @&cp. 16.$ *)ALL' E)PEI\ O( *XRU/SIPPOS E)C E)RASTOU= *EU)RIPI/DOU PRO\S H(MA=S A)NAMA/XETAI, FE/RE DH/, PROFE/RWMEN A(/PER E)KEI=NOS TH=S EU)GENEI/AS KH=RUC H)=|DE PERI\ AU)TH=S: OU(/TW GA\R AU)TO/S: &sq. frgm. Eur.$ PERI\ EU)GENEI/AS. @&Seneca de beneficiis III 22.&3 <21Servus, ut placet Chrysippo, &3perpetuus mercenarius est>21. Quemadmodum ille beneficium dat, ubi &3plus praestat quam in quod operas locavit, sic servus ubi benevolentia &3erga dominum fortunae suae modum transiit et altius aliquid ausus &3quod etiam felicius natis decori esset [et] spem domini antecessit, bene-&3ficium est intra domum inventum. &10Philo de septen. et fest. dieb. p. 283 Vol. II Mang.$10 A)/NQRWPOS GA\R E)K FU/SEWS DOU=LOS OU)DEI/S. @&10p. 291.$10 OI( DE\ DESPO/TAI TOI=S A)RGURWNH/TOIS <20MH\ W(S FU/SEI DOU/LOIS A)LL' W(S MISQWTOI=S>20 PROSFE/RWNTAI. &@Athenaeus Deipnosoph. VI p. 267b.$8 DIAFE/REIN DE/ FHSI *XRU/-SIPPOS DOU=LON OI)KE/TOU, GRA/FWN <20E)N DEUTE/RW| PERI\ O(MONOI/AS>20, DIA\ TO\ TOU\S A)PELEUQE/ROUS ME\N DOU/LOUS E)/TI EI)=NAI, OI)KE/TAS DE\ TOU\S MH\ TH=S KTH/SEWS A)FEIME/NOUS. "1O( <20GA\R OI)KE/THS [1FHSI/]1 DOU=LOS E)N KTH/SEI KATATETAGME/NOS."2>20 @&10Clemens Al. Paed. III p. 288 Pott.$10 TO\ DE\ EU)GENE\S TH=S A)LHQEI/AS, E)N TW=| FU/SEI KALW=| KATA\ YUXH\N E)CETAZO/MENON, <20OU) PRA/SEI KAI\ W)NH=| TO\N DOU=LON>20, A)LLA\ TH=| GNW/MH| TH=| A)NELEUQE/RW| DIAKE/KRIEN. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 121.$10 <20MO/NON TE E)LEU/QERON>20 [1&10scil.$10 EI)=NAI TO\N SOFO/N]1, TOU\S DE\ FAU/LOUS DOU/LOUS: EI)=NAI GA\R <20TH\N E)LEUQERI/AN E)COUSI/AN AU)TOPRAGI/AS>20, TH\N DE\ DOULEI/AN STE/RHSIN AU)TOPRAGI/AS: EI)=NAI DE\ KAI\ A)/LLHN DOULEI/AN TH\N E)N U(POTA/CEI, KAI\ TRI/THN TH\N E)N KTH/SEI TE KAI\ U(POTA/CEI, H(=| A)N-TITI/QETAI H( DESPOTEI/A, FAU/LH OU)=SA KAI\ AU)TH/. @&10Dio Chrysost. or. XIV %14 16 [1Vol. II p. 230, 1 7 Arn.]1.$10 *(ENI\ DH\ LO/GW| TA\ ME\N FAU=LA_OU)K E)/CESTI PRA/TTEIN, TA\ DE\ DI/KAIA KAI\ SUMFE/RONTA KAI\ A)GAQA\ XRH\ FA/NAI O(/TI PROSH/KEI TE KAI\ E)/CESTIN. _OU)KOU=N OU)DENI\ TA/ TE FAU=LA KAI\ A)SU/MFORA POIEI=N A)ZH/MIO/N E)STIN__. TA\ DE/ GE E)NANTI/A PA=SIN O(MOI/WS E)FEI=TAI, KAI\ OI( ME\N TA\ E)FEIME/NA PRA/TTONTES A)ZH/MIOI DIATELOU=SIN, OI( DE\ TA\ KEKWLUME/NA ZHMIOU=NTAI. A)/LLOI OU)=N DOKOU=SI/ SOI PRA/TTEIN A(\ E)/CESTIN H)\ OI( E)PISTA/MENOI TAU=TA, KAI\ A)/LLOI TA)NANTI/A H)\ OI( A)GNOOU=NTES; _OU)KOU=N OI( @1 FRO/NIMOI O(/SA BOU/LONTAI PRA/TTEIN, E)/CESTIN AU)TOI=S: OI( DE\ A)/FRONES O(/SA BOU/LON-TAI OU)K E)CO\N E)PIXEIROU=SI PRA/TTEIN. W(/STE A)NA/GKH <20TOU\S ME\N FRONI/MOUS E)LEUQE/ROUS TE EI)=NAI KAI\ E)CEI=NAI AU)TOI=S POIEI=N W(S E)QE/LOUSI>20, TOU\S DE\ A)NOH/TOUS DOU/LOUS TE EI)=NAI KAI\ A(\ MH\ E)/CESTIN AU)TOI=S, TAU=TA POIEI=N. OU)KOU=N KAI\ <20TH\N E)LEUQERI/AN XRH\ LE/GEIN E)PISTH/MHN TW=N E)FEIME/NWN KAI\ TW=N KEKWLUME/NWN>20, TH\N DE\ DOULEI/AN A)/GNOIAN W(=N TE E)/CESTI KAI\ W(=N MH/. @&10Philo quod omnis probus liber Vol. II p. 450, 23 Mang.$10 O(/TI D' <20OU)X AI( U(PHRESI/AI MHNU/MAT' EI)SI\ DOULEI/AS>20, E)NARGESTA/TH PI/STIS OI( PO/LE-MOI: TOU\S GA\R STRATEUOME/NOUS I)DEI=N E)/STIN AU)TOURGOU\S A(/PANTAS, OU) MO/NON TA\S PANOPLI/AS KOMI/ZONTAS, A)LLA\ KAI\ O(/SA PRO\S TH\N A)NAGKAI/AN XRH=SIN U(POZUGI/WN TRO/PON E)PHXQISME/NOUS, A(/T' E)F' U(DREI/AN E)CIO/NTAS KAI\ FRUGANISMO\N KAI\ XILO\N KTH/NESI. __E)/STI DE/ TIS KAI\ KAT' EI)RH/NHN PO/LEMOS TW=N E)N TOI=S O(/PLOIS OU)K A)PODE/WN, O(\N A)DOCI/A KAI\ PENI/A KAI\ DEINH\ SPA/NIS TW=N A)NAGKAI/WN SUGKRO-TOU=SIN: U(F' OU(= BIASQE/NTES E)GXEIREI=N KAI\ TOI=S DOULOPREPESTA/TOIS A)NAGKA/ZONTAI, SKA/PTONTES, GEWPONOU=NTES, BANAU/SOUS E)PITHDEU/ONTES TE/XNAS, U(PHRETOU=NTES A)O/KNWS E(/NEKA TOU= PARATRE/FESQAI &10etc. &10@p. 451, 2.$10 KAI\ PW=S PATRO\S ME\N H)\ MHTRO\S E)PITAGMA/TWN PAI=DES A)NE/XON-TAI, GNW/RIMOI DE\ W(=N A)\N U(FHGHTAI\ DIAKELEU/WNTAI: DOU=LOS GA\R E(KW\N OU)DEI/S. OI(/ GE MH\N TOKE/ES OU) TOSAU/THN U(PERBOLH\N E)PIDEI/CONTAI/ POTE MISOTEKNI/AS, W(/SQ' A(\ MO/NON [2OU)]2 SU/MBOLA DOULEI/AS E)STI/, TA\S U(PHRESI/AS, A)NAGKA/SAI A)\N PAI=DAS TOU\S E(AUTW=N U(POME/NEIN. @&10Philo quod omnis probus liber Vol. II p. 451, 9 Mang.$10 EI) DE/ TINAS U(P' A)NDRAPODOKAPH/LWN E)PEUWNIZOME/NOUS I)DW/N TIS OI)/ETAI DOU/LOUS EU)QU\S EI)=NAI, POLU\ DIAMARTA/NEI TH=S A)LHQEI/AS. <20OU) GA\R H( PRA=SIS KU/RION A)PO-FAI/NEI TO\N PRIA/MENON H)\ TO\N PRAQE/NTA DOU=LON>20, E)PEI\ KAI\ PATE/RES UI(W=N TIMA\S KATE/QESAN KAI\ UI(OI\ POLLA/KIS PATE/RWN, H)\ KATA\ LH|STEI/AS A)PAXQE/N-TWN H)\ KATA\ PO/LEMON AI)XMALW/TWN GENOME/NWN. __H)/DH DE/ TINES KAI\ PROS-UPERBA/LLONTES EI)S TOU)NANTI/ON PERIH/GAGON TO\ PRA=GMA. DESPO/TAI GENO/MENOI TW=N PRIAME/NWN A)NTI\ DOU/LWN. __ @&10Philo quod omnis probus liber Vol. II p. 451, 47 Mang.$10 PRO\S TOU/TOIS E)/TI [2<20PW=S]2 OU)K A)\N EI)/POI TIS TOU\S FI/LOUS TOU= QEOU= E)LEUQE/-ROUS EI)=NAI>20; EI) MH\ TOI=S ME\N TW=N BASILE/WN E(TAI/ROIS A)/CION [2OU)]2 MO/NON E)LEU-QERI/AN A)LLA\ KAI\ A)RXH\N SUNOMOLOGEI=N, SUNEPITROPEU/OUSI KAI\ SUNDIE/POUSI TH\N H(GEMONI/AN, TOI=S DE\ QEW=N TW=N *)OLUMPI/WN DOULEI/AN E)PIFHMISTE/ON, OI(\ DIA\ TO\ FILO/QEON EU)QU\S GENO/MENOI QEOFILEI=S, I)/SH| A)NTITIMHQE/NTES EU)NOI/A|, PAR' A)LHQEI/A| DIKAZOU/SH|, KAQA/PER OI( POIHTAI/ FASI, PANA/RXONTE/S TE KAI\ BASILE/WN BASI-LH=E/S EI)SI. @&10Philo quod omnis probus liber Vol. II p. 452, 22 Mang.$10 E)/TI TOI/NUN W(/SPER TW=N PO/LEWN AI( ME\N O)LIGARXOU/MENAI KAI\ TURANNOU/MENAI DOULEI/AN U(POME/NOUSI, XALEPOU\S KAI\ BAREI=S E)/XOUSAI DESPO/TAS TOU\S U(PAGOME/NOUS KAI\ KRATOU=NTAS, AI( DE\ NO/MOIS E)PIMELHTAI=S XRW/MENAI KAI\ PROSTA/TAIS EI)SI\N E)LEU/QE-RAI, OU(/TW KAI\ TW=N A)NQRW/PWN, PAR' OI(=S ME\N A)\N O)RGH\ H)\ E)PIQUMI/A H)/ TI A)/LLO PA/QOS H)\ KAI\ E)PI/BOULOS KAKI/A DUNASTEU/H|, PA/NTWS EI)SI\ DOU=LOI, <20O(/SOI DE\ META\ NO/MOU ZW=SIN E)LEU/QEROI>20. NO/MOS DE\ A)YEUDH\S O( O)RQO\S LO/GOS, OU)X U(PO\ TOU= DEI=NOS H)\ TOU= DEI=NOS QNHTOU= FQARTO\S E)N XARTIDI/OIS H)\ STH/LAIS A)/YU- @1XOS A)YU/XOIS, A)LL' U(P' A)QANA/TOU FU/SEWS A)/FQARTOS E)N A)QANA/TW| DIANOI/A| TU-PWQEI/S: DIO\ KAI\ QAUMA/SAI A)/N TIS TH=S A)MBLUWPI/AS TOU\S TRANA\S OU(/TW PRAG-MA/TWN I)DIO/THTAS MH\ SUNORW=NTAS, OI(\ MEGI/STOIS ME\N DH/MOIS *)AQHNAI/WN KAI\ *LAKEDAIMONI/WN PRO\S E)LEUQERI/AN AU)TARKESTA/TOUS EI)=NAI/ FASI TOU\S *SO/LWNOS KAI\ *LUKOU/RGOU NO/MOUS, KRATOU=NTA/S TE KAI\ A)/RXONTAS PEIQARXOU/NTWN AU)TOI=S TW=N POLITEUOME/NWN: SOFOI=S DE\ A)NDRA/SI TO\N O)RQO\N LO/GON, O(\S KAI\ TOI=S A)/LLOIS E)STI\ PHGH\ NO/MOIS, OU)X I(KANO\N EI)=NAI PRO\S METOUSI/AN E)LEUQERI/AS TOI=S U(PAKOU/-OUSI PA/NTWN, A(/TT' A)\N H)\ PROSTA/TTH| H)\ A)PAGOREU/H|. @&10Philo quod omnis probus liber Vol. II p. 452, 46 Mang.$10 PRO\S TOI/NUN TOI=S EI)RHME/NOIS <20E)NARGESTA/TH PI/STIS E)LEUQERI/AS H( I)SHGORI/A>20, H(\N OI( SPOUDAI=OI PA/NTES A)/GOUSI PRO\S A)LLH/LOUS: O(/QEN KAI\ TA\ TRI/METRA FILO-SO/FWS E)KEI=NA/ FASIN EI)RH=SQAI: @OU) GA\R METEI=NAI TW=N NO/MWN DOU/LOIS E)/FU KAI\ PA/LIN: @DOU=LOS PE/FUKAS, OU) ME/TESTI/ SOI LO/GOU. KAQA/PER OU)=N O( MOUSIKO\S LO/GOS A(/PASI TOI=S E)PITETHDEUKO/SI MOUSIKH\N I)SHGORI/AS 鈉TH=S E)N TH=| TE/XNH| METADI/DWSI KAI\ O( GRAMMATIKO\S H)\ GEWMETRIKO\S GRAMMATIKOI=S H)\ GEWME/TRAIS, OU(/TW KAI\ O( E)N TW=| BI/W| NO/MOS TOI=S E)MPEI/ROIS TW=N BIWTIKW=N. OI( DE\ SPOUDAI=OI A(/PANTES E)/MPEIROI TW=N KATA\ TO\N BI/ON PRAGMA/TWN EI)SI/, O(PO/TE KAI\ TW=N E)N A(PA/SH| TH=| FU/SEI: KAI\ EI)SI/ TINES AU)TW=N E)LEU/QEROI: W(/STE KAI\ O(/SOI TOU/TOIS I)SHGORI/AS METE/XOUSIN: OU)DEI\S A)/RA TW=N SPOUDAI/WN DOU=LOS, A)LL' E)LEU/-QEROI PA/NTES. A)PO\ DE\ TH=S AU)TH=S A)FORMH=S KAI\ O(/TI DOU=LOS O( A)/FRWN E)STI\N E)PI-DEIXQH/SETAI: W(/SPER GA\R O( KATA\ MOUSIKH\N NO/MOS OU) DI/DWSIN I)SHGORI/AN A)MOU/SOIS PRO\S MEMOUSWME/NOUS OU)D' O( KATA\ GRAMMATIKH\N A)GRAMMA/TOIS PRO\S GRAMMATIKOU\S OU)DE\ SUNO/LWS O( TEXNIKO\S PRO\S TEXNI/TAS A)TE/XNOIS, OU(/TWS OU)D' O( BIWTIKO\S NO/MOS I)SHGORI/AS METADI/DWSI TOI=S KATA\ TO\N BI/ON A)PEI/ROIS PRO\S TOU\S E)MPEI/ROUS: TOI=S DE\ E)LEUQE/ROIS H( E)K NO/MOU PA=SIN I)SHGORI/A DI/DOTAI: KAI\ EI)SI/ TINES TW=N SPOUDAI/WN E)LEU/QEROI: KAI\ TW=N BIWTIKW=N A)/PEIROI ME\N OI( FAU=-LOI, E)MPEIRO/TATOI D' OI( SOFOI/: OU)K A)/RA EI)SI/ TINES TW=N FAU/LWN E)LEU/QEROI, DOU=LOI DE\ PA/NTES. @&10Philo quod omnis probus liber Vol. II p. 454, 12 Mang.$10 LE/GETAI TOI/NUN OU)K A)PO\ SKOPOU=, O(/TI O( FRONI/MWS PA/NTA POIW=N EU)= POIEI= PA/NTA: O( D' EU)= POIW=N PA/NTA O)RQW=S POIEI= PA/NTA: O( D' O)RQW=S PA/NTA POIW=N KAI\ A)NAMAR-TH/TWS KAI\ A)ME/MPTWS KAI\ A)NEPIPLH/KTWS KAI\ A)NUPEUQU/NWS KAI\ A)ZHMI/WS. W(/ST' E)COUSI/AN SXH/SEI PA/NTA DRA=N KAI\ ZH=N W(S BOU/LETAI: W(=| DE\ TAU=T' E)/CESTIN, E)LEU/-QEROS A)\N EI)/H. A)LLA\ MH\N <20PA/NTA FRONI/MWS POIEI= O( A)STEI=OS: MO/NOS A)/RA E)STI\N E)LEU/QEROS>20. @&10Philo quod omnis probus liber Vol. II p. 454, 31 Mang.$10 KAI\ MH\N O(\N MH\ E)NDE/XETAI MH/T' A)NAGKA/SAI MH/TE KWLU=SAI, E)KEI=NOS OU)K A)\N EI)/H DOU=-LOS: <20TO\N DE\ SPOUDAI=ON OU)K E)/STIN A)NAGKA/SAI OU)DE\ KWLU=SAI: OU)K A)/RA DOU=LOS O( SPOUDAI=OS>20: O(/TI D' OU)/T' A)NAGKA/ZETAI OU)/TE KWLU/ETAI DH=LON. KWLU/ETAI ME\N GA\R O( MH\ TUGXA/NWN W(=N O)RE/GETAI: O)RE/GETAI D' O( SOFO\S TW=N A)P' A)RETH=S, W(=N A)POTUGXA/NEIN OU) PE/FUKE. KAI\ MH\N EI) A)NAGKA/ZETAI, DH=LON O(/TI A)/KWN TI POIEI=. A)NQRW/POIS DE\ AI( PRA/CEIS H)\ A)P' A)RETH=S EI)SI KATORQW/MATA H)\ A)PO\ KAKI/AS A(MARTH/MATA H)\ ME/SA KAI\ A)DIA/FORA. TA\ ME\N OU)=N A)P' A)RETH=S OU) @1 BIASQEI/S, A)LL' E(KW/N [1AI(RETA\ GA/R E)STIN AU)TW=|]1 PA/NQ' O(/SA DRA=|: TA\ D' A)PO\ KA-KI/AS A(/TE FEUKTA\ OU)D' O)/NAR PRA/TTEI. OU)DE\ MH\N TA\ A)DIA/FORA EI)KO/S [1&10scil.$10 A)/KONTA PRA/TTEIN]1, PRO\S A(\ KAQA/PER E)PI\ PLA/STIGGOS H( DIA/NOIA I)SOR)R(OPEI=, DIDAGME/NH MH/TE W(S O(LKO\N E)/XOUSI DU/NAMIN E)NDIDO/NAI MH/T' W(S A)POSTROFH=S A)CI/OIS DUSXE-RAI/NEIN. E)C W(=N E)STI DH=LON O(/TI OU)DE\N A)/KWN POIEI= OU)D' A)NAGKA/ZETAI. DOU=LOS D' EI)/PER H)=N, H)NAGKA/ZET' A)/N: W(/ST' E)LEU/QEROS A)\N EI)/H O( A)STEI=OS. @&10Philo de poster. Caini %14 138 Vol. II p. 30, 17 Wendl.$10 TOU=TO D' E)STI\ TO\ DOGMATIKW/TATON O(/TI O( SOFO\S MO/NOS E)LEU/QERO/S TE KAI\ A)/RXWN KA)\N MURI/OUS TOU= SW/MATOS E)/XH| DESPO/TAS. @&10Dio Chrysost. or. XV %14 31 [1Vol. II p. 240, 32 Arn.$10]1. W(/STE O(\S A)\N H)=| PRO\S A)RETH\N KALW=S GEGONW/S, TOU=TON PROSH/KEI GENNAI=ON LE/GESQAI__. A)LLA\ MH\N OU)X OI(=O/N TE GENNAI=ON ME\N EI)=NAI/ TINA, MH\ EU)GENH= DE\ TOU=TON, OU)D' EU)GENH= O)/NTA MH\ E)LEU/QERON EI)=NAI. W(/STE KAI\ TO\N A)GENNH= PA=SA A)NA/GKH DOU=-LON EI)=NAI. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 107, 14 W.$10 PERI\ DE\ EU)FUOU=S, E)/TI DE\ EU)GENOU=S OI( ME\N TW=N E)K TH=S AI(RE/SEWS E)PHNE/XQHSAN E)PI\ TO\ LE/GEIN PA/NTA SOFO\N TOIOU=-TON EI)=NAI, OI( D' OU)/. OI( ME\N GA\R OI)/ONTAI OU) MO/NON <20EU)FUEI=S>20 GI/GNESQAI PRO\S A)RETH\N E)K FU/SEWS, A)LLA\ KAI/ TINAS E)K KATASKEUH=S, KAI\ TO\ E)N TAI=S PAROIMI/AS LEGO/MENON TOU=TO A)PEDE/CANTO [1&10frg. trag. adesp. 227 N.$10]1 @MELE/TH XRONISQEI=S' EI)S FU/SIN KAQI/STATAI, TO\ D' O(/MOION KAI\ PERI\ EU)GENEI/AS U(PE/LABON, W(/STE <20EU)FUI/+AN ME\N EI)=NAI KOINW=S E(/CIN E)K FU/SEWS H)\ E)K KATASKEUH=S OI)KEI/AN PRO\S A)RETH/N>20, H)\ E(/CIN KAQ' H(\N EU)ANA/LHPTOI A)RETH=S EI)SI/ TINES: <20TH\N D' EU)GE/NEIAN E(/CIN E)K GE/NOUS H)\ E)K KATASKEUH=S OI)KEI/AN PRO\S A)RETH/N>20. @&Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 129.$ E)/TI A)RE/SKEI AU)TOI=S MHDE\N EI)=NAI H(MI=N DI/KAION PRO\S TA\ A)/LLA ZW=|A, DIA\ TH\N A)NOMOIO/THTA, KAQA/ FHSI <20*XRU/-SIPPOS>20 E)N <20TW=| PRW/TW| PERI\ *DIKAIOSU/NHS>20. @&10Origenes contra Celsum IV 81 Vol. I p. 351, 7 Ko+. [1`563 &10Delarue]1 [1Celsus formicarum et apum sollertiam laudibus extulerat]1.$10 OU)D' E)N TOU/TOIS DE\ E(W/RAKE TI/NI DIAFE/REI TA\ A)PO\ LO/GOU KAI\ LOGISMOU= E)PITELOU/MENA TW=N A)P' A)LO/GOU FU/SEWS KAI\ KATASKEUH=S YILH=S GINOME/NWN, W(=N TH\N AI)TI/AN OU)DEI\S ME\N E)NUPA/RXWN TOI=S POIOU=SI LO/GOS A)NADE/XETAI: OU)DE\ GA\R E)/XOUSIN AU)-TO/N__PO/LEIS OU)=N PAR' A)NQRW/POIS META\ POLLW=N U(PE/STHSAN TEXNW=N KAI\ DIATA/CEWS NO/MWN: POLITEI=AI DE\ KAI\ A)RXAI\ KAI\ H(GEMONI/AI E)N A)NQRW/POIS H)/TOI AI( KURI/WS EI)SI\N OU(/TWS KALOU/MENAI, SPOUDAI=AI/ TINES E(/CEIS KAI\ E)NE/RGEIAI, H)\ KAI\ AI( KATAXRHSTIKW/TERON OU(/TWS O)NOMAZO/MENAI PRO\S TH\N KATA\ TO\ DUNATO\N E)KEI/NWN MI/MHSIN: E)KEI/NAIS GA\R E)NORW=NTES OI( E)PITETEUGME/NWS NOMOQETH/SANTES SUNESTH/SANTO TA\S A)RI/STAS POLITEI/AS KAI\ TA\S A)RXA\S KAI\ TA\S H(GEMONI/AS, <20W(=N OU)DE\N E)N TOI=S A)LO/GOIS E)/STIN EU(REI=N>20. @1 @&10Vol. I p. 352, 4 Ko+.$10 <20TH\N QEI/AN DE\ FU/SIN QAUMASTE/ON ME/XRI TW=N A)LO/GWN E)KTEI/NASAN TO\ OI(ONEI\ PRO\S TA\ LOGIKA\ MI/MHMA>20. @&10Cicero de finibus III 19, 63. Ut enim in membris alia sunt &10tamquam sibi nata, ut oculi, ut aures, aliqua etiam ceterorum membro-&10rum usum adiuvant, ut crura, ut manus, sic immanes quaedam bestiae &10sibi solum natae sunt%10 at <21illa quae in concha patula pina dicitur, &10isque qui enat e concha>21, qui quod eam custodit <21pinoteres>21 vocatur, &10in eamque cum se recepit includitur, ut videatur monuisse ut caveret%10 &10<21itemque formicae, apes, ciconiae aliorum etiam causa quaedam &10faciunt>21. Multo%2%2%2 haec coniunctio est hominis. Itaque natura sumus &10apti ad coetus, concilia, civitates. &10@Sextus adv. math. IX 130.$10 TAU=TA DH\ PARH/|NOUN OI( PERI\ TO\N *PUQAGO/RAN PTAI/ONTES [1&10scil.$10 KOINWNI/AN EI)=NAI/ TINA H(MI=N PRO\S TA\ A)/LOGA TW=N ZW/|WN]1. <20OU) GA\R>20 EI) E)/STI TI DIH=KON DI' H(MW=N TE KAI\ E)KEI/NWN PNEU=MA, EU)QU\S <20E)/STI TIS H(MI=N DIKAIOSU/NH PRO\S TA\ A)/LOGA TW=N ZW/|WN>20. I)DOU\ GA\R KAI\ DIA\ TW=N LI/QWN KAI\ DIA\ TW=N FUTW=N PEFOI/THKE/ TI PNEU=MA, W(/STE H(MA=S AU)TOI=S SUNENOU=SQAI, A)LL' OU)DE/N E)STIN H(MI=N DI/KAION PRO\S TA\ FUTA\ KAI\ [2TOU\S]2 LI/QOUS OU)DE\ MH\N TE/MNONTES KAI\ PRI/ZONTES TA\ TOIAU=TA TW=N SWMA/TWN A)DIKOU=MEN. TI/ OU)=N FASIN <20OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 DIKAIOSU/NHN TINA\ KAI\ E)PIPLOKH\N E)/XEIN TOU\S A)NQRW/-POUS PRO\S A)LLH/LOUS KAI\ TOU\S QEOU/S; OU) KAQO/SON E)STI\ TO\ E)LHLAKO\S DIA\ PA/N-TWN PNEU=MA, E)PEI\ A)\N KAI\ PRO\S TA\ A)/LOGA TW=N ZW/|WN E)SW/|ZETO/ TI DI/KAION H(MI=N, A)LL' E)PEI\ LO/GON E)/XOMEN TO\N E)P' A)LLH/LOUS TE KAI\ QEOU\S DIATEI/NONTA, OU(= TA\ A)/LOGA TW=N ZW/|WN MH\ METE/XONTA OU)K A)\N E)/XOI TI PRO\S H(MA=S DI/KAION. @&Cicero de finibus III 20, 67.&3 Et quomodo hominum inter ho-&3mines iuris esse vincula putant, sic homini nihil iuris esse cum bestiis. &3Praeclare enim <21Chrysippus>21, cetera nata esse hominum causa et deo-&3rum; eos autem communitatis et societatis suae%10 ut bestiis homines uti &3ad utilitatem suam possent sine iniuria; quoniamque ea natura esset &3hominis, ut ei cum genere humano quasi civile ius intercederet%10 qui id &3conservaret, eum iustum%10 qui migraret, iniustum fore. Sed quemadmo-&3dum, theatrum cum commune sit, recte tamen dici potest, eius esse eum &3locum, quem quisque occuparit%10 sic in urbe mundove communi non ad-&3versatur ius quo minus suum quidque cuiusque sit. @&10Philo de mundi opificio %14 73 Vol. I p. 24, 21 Wendl.$10 *TW=N O)/N-TWN <20TA\ ME\N OU)/TE A)RETH=S OU)/TE KAKI/AS METE/XEI, W(/SPER FUTA\ KAI\ ZW=|A A)/LOGA>20, TA\ ME\N O(/TI A)/YUXA/ TE/ E)STI KAI\ A)FANTA/STW| FU/SEI DIOIKEI=TAI, TA\ DE\ O(/TI NOU=N KAI\ LO/GON E)KTE/TMHTAI. *KAKI/AS DE\ KAI\ A)RETH=S W(S A)\N OI)=KOS NOU=S KAI\ LO/GOS, W(=| PEFU/KASIN E)NDIAITA=SQAI. *TA\ DE\ AU)= MO/NHS KEKOINW/NHKEN A)RE-TH=S, A)ME/TOXA PA/SHS O)/NTA KAKI/AS, W(/SPER OI( A)STE/RES. *OU(=TOI GA\R ZW=|A/ TE EI)=NAI LE/GONTAI KAI\ ZW=|A NOERA/. __*TA\ DE\ TH=S MIKTH=S E)STI FU/SEWS, W(/SPER A)/N-QRWPOS, O(\S E)PIDE/XETAI_A)RETH\N KAI\ KAKI/AN. @&10Plutarchus$10 PO/TERA TW=N ZW/WN FRONIMW/TERA&10 cp. p. 6 963f.$10 OI( GA\R @1 <20A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 KAI\ TOU= *PERIPA/TOU MA/LISTA PRO\S TOU)NANTI/ON E)NTEI/NONTAI TW=| LO/GW|, <20TH=S DIKAIOSU/NHS E(TE/RAN GE/NESIN OU)K E)XOU/SHS, A)LLA\ PAN-TA/PASIN A)SUSTA/TOU KAI\ A)NUPA/RKTOU GINOME/NHS, EI) PA=SI TOI=S ZW/|OIS LO/GOU ME/TESTI>20: GI/NETAI GA\R H)\ TO\ A)DIKEI=N A)NAGKAI=ON H(MI=N A)FEIDOU=SIN AU)-TW=N H)\ MH\ XRWME/NWN AU)TOI=S TO\ ZH=N A)DU/NATON KAI\ A)/PORON: KAI\ TRO/PON TINA\ QHRI/WN BI/ON BIWSO/MEQA, TA\S A)PO\ TW=N QHRI/WN PROE/MENOI XREI/AS. _ @&10Plutarchus de esu carnium II 6 p. 999a.$10 *OU)K I)/SOS DE/ TIS OU(=TOS O( A)GW\N <20TOI=S *STWI+KOI=S U(PE\R TH=S SARKOFAGI/AS>20. TI/S GA\R O( POLU\S TO/NOS EI)S TH\N GASTE/RA KAI\ TA\ O)PTANEI=A; TI/ TH\N H(DONH\N QHLU/NONTES KAI\ DIABA/LLON-TES, W(S OU)/TE A)GAQO\N OU)/TE PROHGOU/MENON OU)/TE OI)KEI=ON, OU(/TW [PRO\S TA\] PERI\ TW=N H(DONW=N E)SPOUDA/KASI; KAI\ MH\N A)KO/LOUQON H)=N AU)TOI=S, EI) MU=RON E)CELAU/-NOUSI KAI\ PE/MMA TW=N SUMPOSI/WN, MA=LLON AI(=MA KAI\ SA/RKA DUSXERAI/NEIN. NU=N D' W(/SPER EI)S E)FHMERI/DA FILOSOFOU=NTES DAPA/NHN A)FAIROU=SI TW=N DEI/PNWN E)N TOI=S A)XRH/STOIS KAI\ PERITTOI=S, TO\ DE\ A)NH/MERON TH=S POLUTELEI/AS KAI\ FONIKO\N OU) PARAITOU=NTAI: "1NAI/, FHSI/N, <20OU)DE\N GA\R H(MI=N PRO\S TA\ A)/LOGA DI/KAIO/N E)STI>20."2 OU)DE\ GA\R PRO\S TO\ MU=RON, FAI/H TIS A)/N, OU)DE\ PRO\S TA\ CENIKA\ TW=N H(DUSMA/TWN: A)LLA\ KAI\ TOU/TWN A)POTRE/PESQE, TO\ MH\ XRH/SIMON MHDE\ A)NAGKAI=ON E)N H(DONH=| PANTAXO/QEN E)CELAU/NONTES. @&10Philo de sacrif. Abel et Cain %14 46 Vol. I p. 220, 19 Wendl.$10 <20DITTO\N EI)=NAI PE/FUKE TO\ A)/LOGON>20, TO\ ME\N PARA\ TO\N AI(ROU=NTA LO/GON, O(\N A)/FRONA FASI/ TINES, <20TO\ DE\ KAT' E)KTOMH\N LO/GOU, W(S TW=N ZW/|WN TA\ MH\ LOGIKA/>20. @&10Anecdota Paris. ed. Cramer Vol. I p. 244 [1Schol. in Eth. Nicom$10]1. *OI( *)EPIKOU/REIOI KAI/ <20TINES TW=N U(/STERON *STWI+KW=N>20 METEDI/DOSAN KAI\ TOI=S A)LO/GOIS EU)DAIMONI/AS. @1 @&10Clemens Al. Strom. II p. 460 Pott.$10 <20*(ORMH\>20 ME\N OU)=N FORA\ DIA-NOI/AS E)PI/ TI H)\ A)PO/ TOU: <20PA/QOS DE\ PLEONA/ZOUSA O(RMH\>20 H)\ U(PERTEI/NOUSA TA\ KATA\ TO\N LO/GON ME/TRA: H)\ <20O(RMH\ E)KFEROME/NH KAI\ A)PEIQH\S LO/GW|>20. *PARA\ FU/SIN OU)=N KINH/SEIS YUXH=S KATA\ TH\N PRO\S TO\N LO/GON A)PEI/QEIAN TA\ PA/QH. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 88, 6 W.$10 <20*)EPEI\ D' E)N EI)/DEI TO\ PA/QOS TH=S O(RMH=S E)STI, LE/GWMEN E(CH=S PERI\ PAQW=N>20. @&10`10.$10 *PA/QOS D' EI)=NAI/ FASIN O(RMH\N PLEONA/ZOUSAN KAI\ A)PEIQH= TW=| AI(ROU=NTI LO/GW| H)\ KI/NHSIN YUXH=S [2A)/LOGON]2 PARA\ FU/SIN [1EI)=NAI DE\ PA/QH PA/NTA TOU= H(GEMONIKOU= TH=S YUXH=S]1, DIO\ KAI\ PA=SAN PTOI/AN PA/QOS EI)=NAI, [2KAI\]2 PA/LIN [2PA=N]2 PA/QOS PTOI/AN. *TOU= DE\ PA/QOUS TOIOU/TOU O)/NTOS U(POLHPTE/ON, TA\ ME\N PRW=TA EI)=NAI KAI\ A)RXHGA/, TA\ D' EI)S TAU=TA TH\N A)NAFORA\N E)/XEIN. *PRW=TA D' EI)=NAI TW=| GE/NEI TAU=TA TA\ TE/SSARA, E)PIQUMI/AN, FO/BON, LU/PHN, H(DONH/N. *)EPI-QUMI/AN ME\N OU)=N KAI\ FO/BON PROHGEI=SQAI, TH\N ME\N PRO\S TO\ FAINO/MENON A)GA-QO/N, TO\N DE\ PRO\S TO\ FAINO/MENON KAKO/N. *)EPIGI/GNESQAI DE\ TOU/TOIS H(DONH\N KAI\ LU/PHN, H(DONH\N ME\N O(/TAN TUGXA/NWMEN W(=N E)PEQUMOU=MEN H)\ E)KFU/GWMEN A(\ E)FOBOU/MEQA: LU/PHN DE/, O(/TAN A)POTUGXA/NWMEN W(=N E)PEQUMOU=MEN H)\ PERIPE/SWMEN OI(=S E)FOBOU/MEQA. *)EPI\ PA/NTWN DE\ TW=N TH=S YUXH=S PAQW=N, E)PEI\ DO/CAS AU)TA\ LE/GOUSIN EI)=NAI, PARALAMBA/NESQAI TH\N DO/CAN A)NTI\ TH=S A)SQENOU=S U(POLH/YEWS, TO\ DE\ PRO/SFATON A)NTI\ TOU= KINHTIKOU= SUSTOLH=S A)LO/GOU [2H)\]2 E)PA/RSEWS. @&10Cicero Tusc. disp. IV 22. Omnium autem perturbationum fontem &10esse dicunt <21intemperantiam>21, quae est [a] tota mente a recta ratione &10defectio, sic aversa a praescriptione rationis, ut nullo modo adpetitiones &10animi nec regi nec contineri queant. Quem ad modum igitur temperantia &10sedat adpetitiones et efficit, ut eae rectae rationi pareant, conservatque &10considerata iudicia mentis, sic huic inimica intemperantia omnem animi &10statum inflammat, conturbat, incitat, itaque et aegritudines et metus et &10reliquae perturbationes omnes gignuntur ex ea. &10@Cicero Tusc. disp. IV 14. Sed <21omnes perturbationes iu- @1&10dicio censent fieri et opinione>21. Itaque eas definiunt pressius, ut &10intellegatur, non modo quam vitiosae, sed etiam quam in nostra sint po-&10testate. __15. Sed quae iudicia quasque opiniones perturbationum &10esse dixi, non in eis perturbationes solum positas esse dicunt, verum illa &10etiam, quae efficiuntur perturbationibus, ut aegritudo quasi morsum ali-&10quem doloris efficiat, metus recessum quendam animi et fugam, laetitia &10profusam hilaritatem, lubido effrenatam adpetentiam. Opinationem autem, &10quam in omnis definitiones superiores inclusimus, volunt esse imbecillam &10adsensionem. &10@Cicero de finibus III 35. perturbationes animorum_quas Graeci$10 PA/QH&10 appellant. _omnesque eae sunt genere quattuor, partibus plures%10 &10aegritudo, formido, libido, quamque Stoici communi nomine corporis et &10animi$10 H(DONH/N&10 appellant_quasi gestientis animi elationem voluptariam. &10Perturbationes autem nulla naturae vi commoventur, omniaque ea sunt &10opiniones ac iudicia levitatis. Itaque his sapiens semper vacabit. &10@Themistius paraphr. in Aristot. de anima III 5 p. 197 Sp.$10 KAI\ OU) KAKW=S: <20OI( A)PO\ *ZH/NWNOS>20 TA\ PA/QH TH=S A)NQRWPI/NHS YUXH=S TOU= LO/GOU DIASTROFA\S EI)=NAI TIQE/MENOI KAI\ LO/GOU KRI/SEIS H(MARTHME/NAS&10 etc. &10@Proclus in Plat. Alcib. pr. Vol. III p. 159 ed. Cousin.$10 OU) GA\R MO/NON A)PO\ TW=N DOGMA/TWN TOIA/DE KINEI=TAI PA/QH TOI=S A)NQRW/POIS, W(S OI( <20A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 LE/GOUSIN, A)LLA\ KAI\ TOU)NANTI/ON DIA\ TA\ TOIA/DE PA/QH KAI\ TA\S O)RE/CEIS METABA/LLOUSI TA\S DO/CAS&10 etc. @&Plutarchus de virtute morali cp. 9 p. 449c.$ KAI\ FASI\N AU)-TOI\ [1&scil. Stoici$]1 TW=N PRAGMA/TWN E)KBIAZOME/NWN "1<20OU) PA=SAN EI)=NAI KRI/SIN PA/QOS, A)LLA\ TH\N KINHTIKH\N O(RMH=S BIAI/OU KAI\ PLEONA-ZOU/SHS>20"2 O(MOLOGOU=NTES E(/TERON EI)=NAI TO\ KRI=NON KAI\ TO\ PA/SXON E)N H(MI=N, W(/SPER TO\ KINOU=N KAI\ TO\ KINOU/MENON. AU)TO/S TE <20*XRU/SIPPOS E)N POL-LOI=S O(RIZO/MENOS TH\N KARTERI/AN KAI\ TH\N E)GKRA/TEIAN E(/CEIS A)KO-LOUQHTIKA\S TW=| AI(ROU=NTI LO/GW|>20, DH=LO/S E)STIN U(PO\ TW=N PRAGMA/TWN O(MOLOGEI=N A)NAGKAZO/MENOS W(S E(/TERO/N E)STI TO\ A)KOLOUQOU=N E)N H(MI=N TOU= W(=| A)KOLOUQEI= PEIQO/MENON, H)\ PA/LIN MA/XETAI MH\ PEIQO/MENON. @&10Cicero Tusculan. disput. III 11, 24. Est igitur causa omnis in &10opinione, nec vero aegritudinis solum, sed etiam reliquarum omnium per-&10turbationum, quae sunt genere quattuor, partibus plures. Nam cum omnis &10perturbatio sit animi motus vel rationis expers vel rationem aspernans &10vel rationi non oboediens, isque motus aut boni aut mali opinione citetur &10bifariam, quattuor perturbationes aequaliter distributae sunt. Nam <21duae &10sunt ex opinione boni>21, quarum altera, voluptas gestiens, id est praeter &10modum elata laetitia, opinione praesentis magni alicuius boni, altera, quae &10est immoderata appetitio opinati magni boni, rationi non obtemperans vel &10cupiditas recte vel libido dici potest. 25. Ergo haec duo genera, voluptas &10gestiens et libido, bonorum opinione turbantur, <21ut duo reliqua, metus &10et aegritudo malorum>21. Nam et metus opinio magni mali impendentis, &10et aegritudo est opinio magni mali praesentis, et quidem recens opinio @1 &10talis mali, ut in eo rectum videatur esse angi; id autem est, ut is, qui &10doleat, oportere opinetur se dolere. &10@Aspasius in Aristot. Eth. Nicom. p. 44, 12 Heylb.$10 OI( ME\N OU)=N <20E)K TH=S *STOA=S>20 W)|H/QHSAN PA/QOS EI)=NAI O(RMH\N SFODRA\N H)\ O(RMH\N A)/LOGON, LAM-BA/NONTES TO\ U(PENANTI/ON TW=| O)RQW=| LO/GW|.&10 cf. ibid. 23. &10@idem p. 45, 16.$10 GENIKA\ DE\ PA/QH <20OI( ME\N E)K TH=S *STOA=S>20 E)/FASAN EI)=NAI H(DONH\N KAI\ LU/PHN FO/BON [2KAI\]2 E)PIQUMI/AN: GI/NESQAI ME\N GA\R TA\ PA/QH E)/FASAN DI' U(PO/LHYIN A)GAQOU= KAI\ KAKOU=, A)LL' O(/TAN ME\N W(S E)PI\ PAROU=SI TOI=S A)GAQOI=S KINH=TAI H( YUXH/, H(DONH\N EI)=NAI, O(/TAN DE\ W(S E)PI\ PAROU=SI TOI=S KAKOI=S, LU/PHN: PA/LIN DE\ E)PI\ TOI=S PROSDOKWME/NOIS A)GAQOI=S E)PIQUMI/A SUMBAI/NEI, O)/RECIS OU)=SA W(S FAINOME/NOU A)GAQOU=, KAKW=N DE\ PROSDOKWME/NWN TO\ SUMBAI=NON PA/QOS FO/BON E)/LEGON EI)=NAI. @&10Anonymus in Aristot. Eth. Nicom. [1Michae%28l, Eustratius]1 ed. Heylb. &10p. 180, 14.$10 TOIAU/TH E)STI\N H( LU/PH, H(\N <20OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 A)NTI\ LU/PHS SUSTOLH\N KALOU=SI. @&10Servius ad Aeneid. VI 733. Varro et omnes philosophi dicunt, &10quattuor esse passiones, <21duas a bonis opinatis, et duas a malis opi-&10natis>21 rebus%10 nam dolere et timere duae opiniones malae sunt, una prae-&10sentis, alia futuri%10 item gaudere et cupere opiniones bonae sunt, una &10praesentis, altera futuri. @&10Philo de fortitudine p. 419 Vol. II Mang.$10 TETTA/RWN O)/NTWN E)N TH=| YUXH=| PAQW=N, <20DUOI=N ME\N PERI\ TO\ A)GAQO\N>20 E)NESTW\S H)\ ME/LLON, H(DONH=S KAI\ E)PIQUMI/AS, <20DUOI=N DE\ PERI\ TO\ KAKO/N>20, PARO\N H)\ PROSDOKW/MENON, LU/PHS KAI\ FO/BOU&10 etc. &10@Stobaeus ecl. II 89, 4 W.$10 TO\ DE\ "1A)/LOGON"2 KAI\ TO\ "1PARA\ FU/SIN"2 [1&10scil. in$10 PA/QOUS&10 definitione$10]1 OU) KOINW=S, A)LLA\ <20TO\ ME\N "1A)/LOGON"2 I)/SON TW=| "1A)PEIQE\S TW=| LO/GW|."2>20 PA=N GA\R PA/QOS BIASTIKO/N E)STI, W(S POLLA/KIS O(RW=NTAS TOU\S E)N TOI=S PA/QESIN O)/NTAS O(/TI OU) SUMFE/REI TO/DE POIEI=N, U(PO\ TH=S SFODRO/-THTOS E)KFEROME/NOUS, KAQA/PER U(PO/ TINOS A)PEIQOU=S I(/PPOU, A)NA/GESQAI PRO\S TO\ POIEI=N AU)TO/, PAR' O(\ KAI\ POLLA/KIS TINA\S E)COMOLOGEI=SQAI LE/GONTAS TO\ QRULOU/-MENON TOU=TO: [1&10Eur. fr. 837 Nauck$]1 @@GNW/MHN D' E)/XONTA M' H( FU/SIS BIA/ZETAI: GNW/MHN GA\R LE/GEI NU=N TH\N EI)/DHSIN KAI\ GNW=SIN TW=N O)RQW=N PRAGMA/TWN. <20KAI\ TO\ "1PARA\ *FU/SIN"2 D' EI)/LHPTAI>20 E)N TH=| TOU= PA/QOUS U(POGRAFH=|, <20W(S SUM-BAI/NONTOS PARA\ TO\N O)RQO\N KAI\ KATA\ FU/SIN LO/GON.>20 PA/NTES D' OI( E)N TOI=S PA/QESIN O)/NTES A)POSTRE/FONTAI TO\N LO/GON, OU) PARAPLHSI/WS DE\ TOI=S E)CH-PATHME/NOIS E)N O(TW|OU=N, A)LL' I)DIAZO/NTWS. OI( ME\N GA\R H)PATHME/NOI LO/GOU XA/RIN PERI\ [2TOU=]2 TA\S A)TO/MOUS A)RXA\S EI)=NAI, DIDAXQE/NTES O(/TI OU)/K EI)SIN, A)FI/STANTAI TH=S KRI/SEWS: OI( D' E)N TOI=S PA/QESIN O)/NTES, KA)\N MA/QWSI, KA)\N METADIDAXQW=SIN O(/TI OU) DEI= LUPEI=SQAI H)\ FOBEI=SQAI, H)\ O(/LWS E)N TOI=S PA/QESIN EI)=NAI TH=S YUXH=S, O(/MWS OU)K A)FI/STANTAI TOU/TWN, A)LL' A)/GONTAI U(PO\ TW=N PAQW=N EI)S TO\ U(PO\ TH=S TOU/TWN KRATEI=SQAI TURANNI/DOS. @&Plutarchus de virtute morali cp. 10 p. 450c.$8 <20E)N DE\ TOI=S PERI\ *)ANOMOLOGI/AS O( *XRU/SIPPOS EI)PW\N "1O(/TI TUFLO/N E)STIN H(>20 @1 $8O)RGH\ KAI\ POLLA/KIS ME\N OU)K E)A=| O(RA=N TA\ E)KFANH=, POLLA/KIS DE\ TOI=S KATALAMBANOME/NOIS E)PIPROSQEI="2 MIKRO\N PROELQW\N "1<20*TA\ GA\R E)PIGIGNO/MENA,"2 FHSI\ "1PA/QH E)KKROU/EI TOU\S LOGISMOU\S KAI\ TA\ W(S E(TE/RWS FAINO/MENA, BIAI/WS PROWQOU=NTA E)PI\ TA\S E)NANTI/AS PRA/CEIS."2 EI)=TA XRH=TAI MA/RTURI TW=| *MENA/NDRW| LE/GONTI [1&Kock Frg. Com. &III p. 173]1 @$8<20*OI)/MOI TA/LAS E)/GWGE, POU= POQ' AI( FRE/NES @H(MW=N E)KEI=NON H)=SAN E)N TW=| SW/MATI @TO\N XRO/NON, O(/T' OU) TAU=T', A)LL' E)KEI=N' H(|ROU/MEQA>20; KAI\ PA/LIN O( <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 PROELQW\N "1<20*TOU= LOGIKOU= [1FHSI\]1 ZW/|OU FU/-SIN E)/XONTOS PROSXRH=SQAI EI)S E(/KASTA TW=| LO/GW| KAI\ U(PO\ TOU/TOU KUBERNA=SQAI, POLLA/KIS A)POSTRE/FESQAI AU)TO\N H(MA=S, A)/LLH| BI-AIOTE/RA| FORA=| XRWME/NOUS>20."2 @&10Andronicus$10 PERI\ PAQW=N&10 1 [1p. 11 Kreuttner]1.$10 *PA/QOS E)STI\N A)/LO-GOS YUXH=S KI/NHSIS KAI\ PARA\ FU/SIN H)\ O(RMH\ PLEONA/ZOUSA. __TA\ DE\ GENI-KW/TERA PA/QH TE/SSARA: LU/PH, FO/BOS, E)PIQUMI/A, H(DONH/. @<20LU/PH>20 ME\N OU)=N E)STIN A)/LOGOS SUSTOLH/. H)\ DO/CA PRO/SFATOS KAKOU= PAROU-@SI/AS, E)F' W(=| OI)/ONTAI DEI=N SUSTE/LLESQAI. @<20FO/BOS>20 DE\ A)/LOGOS E)/KKLISIS: H)\ FUGH\ A)PO\ PROSDOKWME/NOU DEINOU=. @<20E)PIQUMI/A>20 DE\ A)/LOGOS O)/RECIS: H)\ DI/WCIS PROSDOKWME/NOU A)GAQOU=. @<20H(DONH\>20 DE\ A)/LOGOS E)/PARSIS: H)\ DO/CA PRO/SFATOS A)GAQOU= PAROUSI/AS, E)F' @W(=| OI)/ONTAI DEI=N E)PAI/RESQAI. @&10Philo de Mose lib. III Vol. II Mang. p. 156.$10 E)C A)LO/GOU PA/QOUS, H)\ PARA\ FU/SIN E)PAIROU/SHS KAI\ METEWRIZOU/SHS <20H(DONH=S>20, H)\ SUSTELLOU/SHS E)/M-PALIN <20LU/PHS>20 KAI\ KAQAIROU/SHS H)\ A)POSTRE/FONTOS KAI\ A)POKLI/NONTOS TH\N E)P' EU)QEI/AS O(RMH\N <20FO/BOU>20, H)\ TH=S <20E)PIQUMI/AS>20 PRO\S TA\ MH\ PARO/NTA E(LKOU/SHS KAI\ A)POTEINOU/SHS BI/A|. &10ibid.$10 TO\ ME\N GA\R TOU= SW/MATOS [1&10scil.$10 KA/LLOS]1 E)N SUM-METRI/A| MERW=N EU)XROI/A| TE KAI\ EU)SARKI/A| KEI=TAI, __TO\ DE\ TH=S DIANOI/AS E)N A(RMONI/A| DOGMA/TWN KAI\ A)RETW=N SUMFWNI/A| &10etc. &10@Cicero Tusculan. disput. IV 7, 14. Est ergo <21aegritudo>21 opinio &10recens mali praesentis, in quo demitti contrahique animo rectum esse vi-&10deatur; <21laetitia>21 opinio recens boni praesentis, in quo efferri rectum esse &10videatur; <21metus>21 opinio impendentis mali, quod intolerabile esse videatur; &10<21libido>21 opinio venturi boni, quod sit ex usu iam praesens esse atque &10adesse. &10@Stobaeus ecl. II 90, 7 W.$10 *TH\N ME\N OU)=N <20E)PIQUMI/AN>20 LE/GOUSIN O)/RECIN EI)=NAI A)PEIQH= LO/GW|: AI)/TION D' AU)TH=S TO\ DOCA/ZEIN A)GAQO\N E)PIFE/RESQAI, OU(= PARO/NTOS EU)= A)PALLA/COMEN, TH=S DO/CHS AU)TH=S E)XOU/SHS TO\ A)TA/KTWS KINHTIKO\N [2PRO/SFATON TOU= O)/NTWS AU)TO\ O)REKTO\N EI)=NAI]2. <20*FO/BON>20 D' EI)=NAI E)/KKLISIN A)PEIQH= LO/GW|, AI)/TION D' AU)TOU= TO\ DOCA/ZEIN KAKO\N E)PIFE/RESQAI, TH=S DO/CHS TO\ KINHTI-KO\N [KAI\] PRO/SFATON E)XOU/SHS TOU= O)/NTWS AU)TO\ FEUKTO\N EI)=NAI. <20*LU/PHN>20 D' EI)=NAI SUSTOLH\N YUXH=S A)PEIQH= LO/GW|, AI)/TION D' AU)TH=S TO\ DOCA/ZEIN PRO/SFATON KAKO\N PAREI=NAI, E)F' W(=| KAQH/KEI [2SUSTE/LLESQAI. <20*(HDONH\N>20 D' EI)=NAI E)/PARSIN @1 YUXH=S A)PEIQH= LO/GW|, AI)/TION D' AU)TH=S TO\ DOCA/ZEIN PRO/SFATON A)GAQO\N PAREI=-NAI, E)F' W(=| KAQH/KEI]2 E)PAI/RESQAI. @<20*(UPO\ ME\N OU)=N TH\N E)PIQUMI/AN>20 U(PA/GETAI TA\ TOIAU=TA: O)RGH\ KAI\ TA\ EI)/DH AU)TH=S [1QUMO\S KAI\ XO/LOS KAI\ MH=NIS KAI\ KO/TOS KAI\ PIKRI/AI KAI\ TA\ TOI-AU=TA]1, E)/RWTES SFODROI\ KAI\ PO/QOI KAI\ I(/MEROI KAI\ FILHDONI/AI KAI\ FILOPLOUTI/AI KAI\ FILODOCI/AI KAI\ TA\ O(/MOIA: <20U(PO\ DE\ TH\N H(DONH\N>20 E)PIXAIREKAKI/AI KAI\ A)SME-NISMOI\ KAI\ GOHTEI=AI KAI\ TA\ O(/MOIA: <20U(PO\ DE\ TO\N FO/BON>20 O)/KNOI KAI\ A)GWNI/AI KAI\ E)/KPLHCIS KAI\ AI)SXU/NAI KAI\ QO/RUBOI KAI\ DEISIDAIMONI/AI KAI\ DE/OS KAI\ DEI/-MATA: <20U(PO\ DE\ TH\N LU/PHN>20 FQO/NOS, ZH=LOS, ZHLOTUPI/A, E)/LEOS, PE/NQOS, A)/XQOS, A)/XOS, A)NI/A, O)DU/NH, A)/SH. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 92, 18.$10 TOU/TWN DE\ TW=N PAQW=N TA\ ME\N E)MFAI/NEIN TO\ E)F' W(=| GI/GNETAI, OI(=ON E)/LEON, FQO/NON, E)PIXAIREKAKI/AN, AI)SXU/NHN: TA\ DE\ TH\N I)DIO/THTA TH=S KINH/SEWS, OI(=ON O)DU/NHN, DEI=MA. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 91, 10.$10 <20O)RGH\>20 ME\N OU)=N E)STIN E)PIQUMI/A [2TOU=]2 TIMWRH/SASQAI TO\N DOKOU=NTA H)DIKHKE/NAI PARA\ TO\ PROSH=KON: <20QUMO\S>20 DE\ O)RGH\ E)NARXOME/NH: <20XO/LOS>20 DE\ O)RGH\ DIOIDOU=SA: <20MH=NIS>20 DE\ O)RGH\ EI)S PALAI/WSIN A)PO-TEQEIME/NH H)\ E)NAPOKEIME/NH: <20KO/TOS>20 DE\ O)RGH\ E)PITHROU=SA KAIRO\N EI)S TIMWRI/AN: <20PIKRI/A>20 DE\ O)RGH\ PARAXRH=MA E)KRHGNUME/NH: <20E)/RWS>20 DE\ E)PIBOLH\ FILOPOII/+AS DIA\ KA/LLOS E)MFAINO/MENON: <20PO/QOS>20 DE\ E)PIQUMI/A TOU= E)/RWTI A)PO/NTOS: <20I(/MEROS>20 DE\ E)PIQUMI/A FI/LOU A)PO/NTOS O(MILI/AS: <20FILHDONI/A>20 DE\ E)PIQUMI/A H(DONW=N: <20FILO-PLOUTI/A>20 DE\ PLOU/TOU: <20FILODOCI/A>20 DE\ DO/CHS. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 113.$10 <20E)PIQUMI/A>20 DE/ E)STIN A)/LOGOS O)/RECIS, U(F' H(\N TA/TTETAI KAI\ TAU=TA: SPA/NIS, MI=SOS, FILONIKI/A, O)RGH/, E)/RWS, MH=NIS, QUMO/S. E)/STI DE\ H( ME\N <20SPA/NIS>20 E)PIQUMI/A TIS E)N A)POTEU/CEI KAI\ OI(=ON KEXWRISME/NH E)K TOU= PRA/GMATOS, TETAME/NH DE\ DIAKENH=S E)P' AU)TO\ KAI\ SPWME/NH: <20MI=SOS>20 DE/ E)STIN E)PIQUMI/A TIS TOU= KAKW=S EI)=NAI/ TINI META\ PROKOPH=S TINOS KAI\ PARATA/SEWS, <20FILONIKI/A>20 DE\ E)PIQUMI/A TIS PERIAIRE/SEWS, <20O)RGH\>20 DE\ E)PIQUMI/A TIMWRI/AS TOU= DOKOU=NTOS H)DIKHKE/NAI OU) PROSHKO/NTWS: <20E)/RWS>20 DE/ E)STIN E)PIQUMI/A TIS [2KAI\]2 OU)XI\ PERI\ SPOUDAI/OUS: E)/STI GA\R E)PIBOLH\ FILOPOII/+AS DIA\ KA/LLOS E)MFAINO/MENON: <20MH=NIS>20 DE/ E)STIN O)RGH/ TIS PEPALAIWME/NH KAI\ E)PI%2%2%2<20KO/TOS>20 E)PITHRHTIKH\ [DE/], O(/PER E)MFAI/NETAI DIA\ TW=NDE: @EI)/PER GA/R TE XO/LON GE KAI\ AU)TH=MAR KATAPE/YH|, @A)LLA/ TE KAI\ METO/PISQEN E)/XEI KO/TON, O)/FRA TELE/SSH|. O( DE\ <20QUMO/S>20 E)STIN O)RGH\ A)RXOME/NH. @&10Andronicus$10 PERI\ PAQW=N&10 4 [1p. 16 Kreuttner$10]1. {3*)EPIQUMI/AS EI)/DH KZ#.}3 @<20*)ORGH\>20 ME\N OU)=N E)STIN E)PIQUMI/A TIMWRI/AS TOU= H)DIKHKE/NAI DOKOU=NTOS. @<20*QUMO\S>20 DE\ O)RGH\ E)NARXOME/NH. @<20*XO/LOS>20 DE\ O)RGH\ DIOIDOU=SA. @<20*PIKRI/A>20 DE\ O)RGH\ PARAXRH=MA E)KRHGNUME/NH. @<20*MH=NIS>20 DE\ O)RGH\ EI)S PALAI/WSIN A)POTIQEME/NH. @<20*KO/TOS>20 DE\ O)RGH\ KAIRO\N E)PITHROU=SA EI)S TIMWRI/AN. @<20*)/ERWS>20 DE\ E)PIQUMI/A SWMATIKH=S SUNOUSI/AS. @1 @<20A)/LLOS E)/RWS>20: E)PIQUMI/A FILI/AS. @<20A)/LLOS E)/RWS>20: [U(PHRESI/A QEW=N EI)S NAW=N KATAKO/SMHSIN KAI\ KALW=N] O(\N E)PI-@BOLH\N KALOU=SI FILOPOII/+AS DIA\ KA/LLOS E)MFAINO/MENON. @<20*(/IMEROS>20 DE\ E)PIQUMI/A FI/LOU A)PO/NTOS O(MILI/AS. @<20*PO/QOS>20 DE\ E)PIQUMI/A KATA\ E)/RWTA A)PO/NTOS. @<20*DUSME/NEIA>20 DE\ DU/SNOIA E)PITHRHTIKH\ KAI\ KAKOPOIO/S. @<20*DU/SNOIA>20 DE\ E)PIQUMI/A TOU= KAKW=S EI)=NAI/ TINI AU)TOU= E(/NEKEN E)KEI/NOU. @<20*(AYIKORI/A>20 DE\ E)PIQUMI/A TAXU\ E)MPIPLAME/NH. @<20*(RIYOFQALMI/A>20 DE\ TAXUTH\S PERI\ TO\ I)DEI=N TO\ POQOU/MENON. @<20*SPA/NIS>20 DE\ E)PIQUMI/A A)TELH/S. @<20*TRAXUTH\S>20 DE\ E)PIQUMI/A A)NW/MALOS. @<20*)/ERIS>20 DE\ E)PIQUMI/A EI)S A)NTI/TACIN KAKOPOIHTIKH/N. @<20*PROSPA/QEIA>20 DE\ E)PIQUMI/A DEDOULWME/NH. @<20*FILHDONI/A>20 DE\ E)PIQUMI/A H(DONW=N A)/METROS. @<20*FILOXRHMATI/A>20 DE\ E)PIQUMI/A [A)/XRHSTOS H)\] A)/METROS XRHMA/TWN. @<20*FILOTIMI/A>20 DE\ E)PIQUMI/A A)/METROS TIMH=S. @<20*FILOZWI/+A>20 DE\ E)PIQUMI/A ZWH=S A)/LOGOS. @<20*FILOSWMATI/A>20 DE\ E)PIQUMI/A SW/MATOS EU)QHNI/AS PARA\ TO\ DE/ON. @<20*GASTRIMARGI/A>20 DE\ E)PIQUMI/A A)/METROS SITI/WN. @<20*OI)NOFLUGI/A>20 DE\ E)PIQUMI/A OI)/NOU A)/PLHSTOS. @<20*LAGNEI/A>20 DE\ E)PIQUMI/A SUNOUSIW=N A)/METROS. @&10Cicero Tusc. disp. IV 21. Quae autem libidini subiecta sunt, &10ea sic definiunt, ut <21ira>21 sit libido poeniendi eius, qui videatur laesisse &10iniuria, <21excandescentia>21 autem sit ira nascens et modo existens, quae $10QU/MWSIS&10 Graece dicitur, odium ira inveterata, <21inimicitia>21 ira ulciscendi &10tempus observans, <21discordia>21 ira acerbior intimo animo et corde con-&10cepta, <21indigentia>21 libido inexplebilis, <21desiderium>21 libido eius, qui non-&10dum adsit, videndi. &10@Distinguunt illud etiam, ut libido sit earum rerum, quae dicuntur &10de quodam aut quibusdam, quae $10KATHGORH/MATA&10 dialectici appellant, ut ha-&10bere divitias, capere honores, indigentia rerum ipsarum sit, ut honorum, &10ut pecuniae. @&10Sextus adv. math. VII 239.$10 O( LE/GWN TO\N <20E)/RWTA "1E)PIBOLH\N EI)=NAI FILOPOII/+AS>20"2 SUNEMFAI/NEI TO\ "1NE/WN W(RAI/WN"2, KAI\ EI) MH\ KATA\ R(HTO\N TOU=TO E)KFE/RH|: OU)QEI\S GA\R GERO/NTWN KAI\ A)KMH=S W(/RAN MH\ E)XO/NTWN E)RA=|. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 114.$10 <20H(DONH\>20 DE/ E)STIN A)/LOGOS E)/PARSIS E)F' AI(-RETW=| DOKOU=NTI U(PA/RXEIN, U(F' H(\N TA/TTETAI KH/LHSIS, E)PIXAIREKAKI/A, TE/RYIS, DIA/-XUSIS. <20KH/LHSIS>20 ME\N OU)=N E)STIN H(DONH\ DI' W)/TWN KATAKHLOU=SA, <20E)PIXAIREKAKI/A>20 DE\ H(DONH\ E)P' A)LLOTRI/OIS KAKOI=S, <20TE/RYIS>20 DE/, OI(=ON TRE/YIS, PROTROPH/ TIS YUXH=S E)PI\ TO\ A)NEIME/NON, <20DIA/XUSIS>20 DE\ A)NA/LUSIS A)RETH=S. @&10Andronicus$10 PERI\ PAQW=N&10 5 [1p. 19 Kreuttner$10]1 {3*(HDONH=S EI)/DH E#.}3 @<20*)ASMENISMO\S>20 ME\N OU)=N E)STIN H(DONH\ E)PI\ A)PROSDOKH/TOIS A)GAQOI=S. @<20*TE/RYIS>20 DE\ H(DONH\ DI' O)/YEWS H)\ DI' A)KOH=S. @1 @<20*KH/LHSIS>20 DE\ H(DONH\ DI' A)KOH=S KATAKHLOU=SA: H)\ H(DONH\ E)K LO/GOU TE KAI\ @MOUSIKH=S H)\ DI' A)PA/THS GINOME/NH. @<20*)EPIXAIREKAKI/A>20 DE\ H(DONH\ E)PI\ TOI=S TW=N PE/LAS A)TUXH/MASIN. @<20*GOHTEI/A>20 DE\ H(DONH\ KAT' A)PA/THN H)\ DIA\ MAGEI/AS. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 91, 20 W.$10 <20E)PIXAIREKAKI/A>20 DE\ H(DONH\ E)P' A)LLO-TRI/OIS KAKOI=S: <20A)SMENISMO\S>20 DE\ H(DONH\ E)PI\ A)PROSDOKH/TOIS: <20GOHTEI/A>20 DE\ H(DONH\ DI' O)/YEWS KATA\ A)PA/THN. @&10Cicero Tusc. disp. IV 20. Voluptatis autem partes hoc modo &10discribunt, ut <21malivolentia>21 sit voluptas ex malo alterius sine emolu-&10mento suo, <21delectatio>21 voluptas suavitate auditus animum deleniens; et &10qualis est haec aurium, tales sunt et oculorum et tactionum et odoratio-&10num et saporum, quae sunt omnes unius generis ad perfundendum ani-&10mum tamquam inliquefactae voluptates. <21Iactatio>21 est voluptas gestiens &10et se efferens insolentius. &10@Cicero de finibus II 4, 13. Sed hoc interest, quod <21voluptas>21 &10dicitur etiam in animo, vitiosa res, ut <21Stoici>21 putant, qui eam sic defi-&10niunt%10 <21sublationem animi sine ratione, opinantis se magno &10bono frui.>21 &10@Clemens Al. Strom. II p. 491 Pott. [1allato notissimo illo Sarda-&10napalli epigrammate]1%10$10 KAQO/LOU GA\R OU)K A)NAGKAI=ON TO\ TH=S H(DONH=S PA/QOS, E)PAKOLOU/QHMA DE\ XREI/AIS TISI\ FUSIKAI=S, PEI/NH|, DI/YEI, R(I/GEI, GA/MW|. *EI) GOU=N TAU/THS DI/XA PIEI=N OI(=O/N TE H)=N H)\ TROFH=S PROSI/ESQAI H)\ PAIDOPOIEI=N, E)DEI/XQH A)\N OU)DEMI/A E(TE/RA XREI/A TAU/THS. *OU)/TE GA\R E)NE/RGEIA, OU)/TE DIA/QESIS OU)DE\ MH\N ME/ROS TI H(ME/TERON H(DONH/: A)LL' U(POURGI/AS E(/NEKA PARH=LQEN EI)S TO\N BI/ON, W(/SPER TOU\S A(/LAS FASI\ TH=S PARAPE/YEWS TH=S TROFH=S XA/RIN. *(H DE\ A)FHNIA/SASA KAI\ TOU= OI)/KOU KATAKRATH/SASA, PRW/THN E)PIQUMI/AN GENNA=|, E)/FESIN KAI\ O)/RECIN OU)=SAN A)/LOGON TOU= KEXARISME/NOU AU)TH=|. [1&10Deinde impugnatur Epicurus, laudantur &10Diogenis ex quadam tragoedia, Antisthenis, Cratetis in voluptatem in-&10vectivae, Philemonis porro comici de Zenone Citiensi testimonium]1. @&10Philo Leg. Alleg. III %14 246 Vol. I p. 167, 23 Wendl.$10 H( <20H(DONH\ E)/PARSIS A)/LOGOS YUXH=S>20: AU(/TH KATA/RATOS E)C E(AUTH=S, MO/NW| GE/ TOI TW=| FAU/LW| PROSGI/NETAI, SPOUDAI/W| D' OU)DENI/. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt VII 112.$10 O( DE\ <20FO/BOS>20 E)STI\ PROSDOKI/A KAKOU=: EI)S DE\ TO\N FO/BON A)NA/GETAI KAI\ TAU=TA: DEI=MA, O)/KNOS, AI)SXU/NH, E)/KPLHCIS, QO/RUBOS, A)GWNI/A. <20DEI=MA>20 ME\N OU)=N E)STI FO/BOS DE/OS E)MPOIW=N, <20AI)SXU/NH>20 DE\ FO/BOS A)DO-CI/AS, <20O)/KNOS>20 DE\ FO/BOS MELLOU/SHS E)NERGEI/AS, <20E)/KPLHCIS>20 DE\ FO/BOS E)K FAN-TASI/AS A)SUNH/QOUS PRA/GMATOS, <20QO/RUBOS>20 DE\ FO/BOS META\ KATEPEI/CEWS FWNH=S, A)GWNI/A DE\ FO/BOS A)DH/LOU PRA/GMATOS. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 92 W.$10 <20*)/OKNOS>20 DE\ FO/BOS MELLOU/SHS E)NERGEI/AS: <20A)GWNI/A>20 DE\ FO/BOS DIAPTW/SEWS KAI\ E(TE/RWS FO/BOS H(/TTHS: <20E)/KPLHCIS>20 DE\ FO/-BOS E)C A)SUNH/QOUS FANTASI/AS: <20AI)SXU/NH>20 DE\ FO/BOS A)DOCI/AS: <20QO/RUBOS>20 DE\ FO/BOS META\ FWNH=S KATEPEI/GWN: <20DEISIDAIMONI/A>20 DE\ FO/BOS QEW=N H)\ DAIMO/NWN: <20DE/OS>20 DE\ FO/BOS DEINOU=: <20DEI=MA>20 DE\ FO/BOS E)K LO/GOU. @&10Andronicus$10 PERI\ PAQW=N&10 3 [1p. 15 Kreuttner$10]1. {3*FO/BOU EI)/DH IG#.}3 @<20*)/OKNOS>20 ME\N OU)=N E)STI FO/BOS MELLOU/SHS E)NERGEI/AS. @1 @<20*AI)SXU/NH>20 DE\ FO/BOS A)DOCI/AS. @<20*DEI=MA>20 DE\ FO/BOS U(FORWME/NOU. @<20*DE/OS>20 DE\ FO/BOS SUNDE/WN. @<20*)/EKPLHCIS>20 DE\ FO/BOS E(/NEKA A)SUNH/QOUS FANTASI/AS DEINOU=. @<20*KATA/PLHCIS>20 DE\ FO/BOS E)K MEI/ZONOS FANTASI/AS. @[*DEILI/A>20 DE\ A)POXW/RHSIS A)PO\ FAINOME/NOU KAQH/KONTOS DIA\ FANTASI/AN DEINOU=.] @<20*YOFODE/EIA>20 DE\ FO/BOS KENO/S. @<20*)AGWNI/A>20 DE\ FO/BOS DIAPTW/SEWS: H)\ FO/BOS H(/TTHS: H)\ FO/BOS E)MPOIHTIKO\S @TW=N E)NANTI/WN E)LPI/DWN, PERI\ W(=N O)/RECIN SFODRA\N E)/XOMEN. @<20*ME/LLHSIS>20 DE\ O)/KNOS DIEGNWKO/TOS POIEI=N. @<20*)OR)R(WDI/A>20 DE\ FO/BOS E)NNOHQE/NTOS. @<20*QO/RUBOS>20 DE\ FO/BOS META\ FWNH=S KATEPEI/GWN. @<20*DEISIDAIMONI/A>20 DE\ FO/BOS TOU= DAIMONI/OU. [H)\ U(PERE/KPTWSIS TH=S PRO\S @QEOU\S TIMH=S.] @&10Cicero Tusc. disp. VI 19. Quae autem subiecta sunt sub metum, &10ea sic definiunt%10 <21pigritiam>21 metum consequentis laboris 8989898989 <21terrorem>21 &10metum concutientem, ex quo fit, ut pudorem rubor, terrorem pallor et &10tremor et dentium crepitus consequatur, <21timorem>21 metum mali adpro-&10pinquantis, <21pavorem>21 metum mentem loco moventem__<21exanima-&10tionem>21 metum subsequentem et quasi comitem pavoris, <21conturbationem>21 &10metum excutientem cogitata, <21formidinem>21 metum permanentem. @&10Clemens Al. Strom. II p. 446 Pott.$10 NAI/, FASI/N, A)/LOGOS E)/KKLISIS O( <20FO/BOS>20 E)STI\ KAI\ PA/QOS. __A)LL' EI) SOFI/ZONTAI TA\ O)NO/MATA <20EU)LA/BEIAN>20 KALOU/NTWN OI( FILO/SOFOI TO\N TOU= NO/MOU FO/BON, EU)/LOGON OU)=SAN E)/KKLISIN. O)NOMATOMA/XOUS TOU/TOUS OU)K A)PO\ TRO/POU O( *FASHLI/THS E)KA/LEI *KRITO/LAOS. @&10p. 448 Pott.$10 E)/STI ME\N OU)=N H( ME\N <20E)/KPLHCIS>20 FO/BOS E)K FANTASI/AS A)SUNH/QOUS H)\ E)P' A)PROSDOKH/TW| FANTASI/A| %2%2 A(/TE KAI\ A)GGELI/AS: FO/BOS DE\ W(S GEGONO/TI H)\ O)/NTI H)\ QAUMASIO/THS U(PERBA/LLOUSA. @&10p. 450.$10 H( GOU=N DEISIDAIMONI/A PA/QOS, FO/BOS DAIMO/NWN OU)=SA. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 110.$10 E)K DE\ TW=N YEUDW=N E)PIGI/GNESQAI TH\N DIA-STROFH\N E)PI\ TH\N DIA/NOIAN, A)F' H(=S POLLA\ PA/QH BLASTA/NEIN KAI\ A)KATASTASI/AS AI)/TIA. E)/STI DE\ AU)TO\ TO\ PA/QOS KATA\ *ZH/NWNA H( A)/LOGOS KAI\ PARA\ FU/SIN YU-XH=S KI/NHSIS H)\ O(RMH\ PLEONA/ZOUSA. TW=N DE\ PAQW=N TA\ A)NWTA/TW, KAQA/ FHSIN *(EKA/TWN_KAI\ *ZH/NWN E)N TW=| PERI\ PAQW=N, EI)=NAI GE/NH TE/TTARA, LU/PHN, FO/-BON, E)PIQUMI/AN, H(DONH/N. ___ @&10VII 111.$10 KAI\ TH\N ME\N LU/PHN EI)=NAI SUSTOLH\N A)/LOGON, EI)/DH DE\ AU)TH=S E)/LEON, FQO/NON, ZH=LON, ZHLOTUPI/AN, A)/XQOS, E)NO/XLHSIN, A)NI/AN, O)DU/NHN, SU/GXUSIN. <20E)/LEON>20 ME\N OU)=N EI)=NAI LU/PHN W(S E)PI\ A)NACI/WS KAKOPAQOU=NTI, <20FQO/NON>20 DE\ LU/PHN E)P' A)LLOTRI/OIS A)GAQOI=S, <20ZH=LON>20 DE\ LU/PHN E)PI\ TW=| A)/LLW| PAREI=NAI, W(=N AU)TO\S E)PIQUMEI=, <20ZHLOTUPI/AN>20 DE\ LU/PHN E)PI\ TW=| KAI\ A)/LLW| PAREI=NAI, A(\ KAI\ AU)TO\S E)/XEI, <20A)/XQOS>20 DE\ LU/PHN BARU/NOUSAN, <20E)NO/XLHSIN>20 LU/PHN STENOXWROU=SAN KAI\ DUSXWRI/AN PARASKEUA/ZOUSAN, <20A)NI/AN>20 LU/PHN E)K DIALOGISMW=N ME/NOUSAN H)\ @1 E)PITEINOME/NHN, <20O)DU/NHN>20 LU/PHN E)PI/PONON, <20SU/GXUSIN>20 LU/PHN A)/LOGON, A)POKNAI/-OUSAN KAI\ KWLU/OUSAN TA\ PARO/NTA SUNORA=N. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 92, 7 W.$10 <20*FQO/NOS>20 DE\ LU/PH E)P' A)LLOTRI/OIS A)GA-QOI=S: <20ZH=LOS>20 DE\ LU/PH E)PI\ TW=| E(/TERON E)PITUGXA/NEIN W(=N AU)TO\S E)PIQUMEI=, AU)TO\N DE\ MH/: LE/GESQAI DE\ KAI\ E(TE/RWS ZH=LON, MAKARISMO\N E)NDEOU=S KAI\ E)/TI A)/LLWS MI/MHSIN W(S A)\N KREI/TTONOS: <20ZHLOTUPI/AN>20 DE\ LU/PHN E)PI\ TW=| [2KAI\]2 E(/TERON E)PI-TUGXA/NEIN W(=N AU)TO\S E)PEQU/MEI: <20E)/LEON>20 DE\ LU/PHN E)PI\ TW=| DOKOU=NTI A)NACI/WS KAKOPAQEI=N: <20PE/NQOS>20 DE\ LU/PHN E)PI\ QANA/TW| A)W/RW|: <20A)/XQOS>20 DE\ LU/PHN BARU/-NOUSAN: <20A)/XOS>20 DE\ LU/PHN A)FWNI/AN E)MPOIOU=SAN: <20A)NI/AN>20 DE\ LU/PHN KATA\ DIA-LOGISMO/N: <20O)DU/NHN>20 DE\ LU/PHN EI)SDU/NOUSAN KAI\ KAQIKNOUME/NHN: <20A)/SHN>20 DE\ LU/-PHN META\ R(IPTASMOU=. @&10Andronicus$10 PERI\ PAQW=N&10 2 [1p. 12 Kreuttner$10]1. @<20*EI)/DH LU/PHS KE#>20. @__ @<20*)/ELEOS>20 ME\N OU)=N E)STI LU/PH E)P' A)LLOTRI/OIS KAKOI=S, A)NACI/WS PA/SXONTOS E)KEI/NOU. @<20*FQO/NOS>20 DE\ LU/PH E)P' A)LLOTRI/OIS A)GAQOI=S: [H)\ LU/PH E)PI\ TH=| TW=N E)PIEIKW=N @EU)PRAGI/A.] @<20*ZH=LOS>20 DE\ LU/PH E)PI\ TW=| E(/TERON TUGXA/NEIN, W(=N AU)TO\S E)PIQUMEI=: H)\ LU/PH @E)PI\ TW=| A)/LLOIS U(PA/RXEIN, H(MI=N DE\ MH/: [H)\ ZH=LOS MAKARISMO\S A)STEI-@O/THTOS.] __ @<20*ZHLOTUPI/A>20 DE\ LU/PH E)PI\ TW=| A)/LLOIS U(PA/RXEIN, A(\ KAI\ H(MI=N U(PA/RXEI. @<20*DUSQUMI/A>20 DE\ LU/PH E)P' A)LU/TW| H)\ DUSKINH/TW|. @<20*SUMFORA\>20 DE\ LU/PH E)PI\ SUMPEFRAGME/NOIS KAKOI=S. @<20*)/AXQOS>20 DE\ LU/PH BARU/NOUSA. @<20*)/AXOS>20 DE\ LU/PH A)FWNI/AN E)MPOIOU=SA. @<20*SFAKELISMO\S>20 DE\ LU/PH SFODRA/. @<20*PE/NQOS>20 DE\ LU/PH E)PI\ A)W/RW| TELEUTH=|. @<20*DUSXE/RANSIS>20 DE\ LU/PH E)C E)NANTI/WN LOGISMW=N. @<20*)/OXLHSIS>20 DE\ LU/PH STENOXWROU=SA H)\ A)NASTROFH\N OU) DIDOU=SA. @<20*)ODU/NH>20 DE\ LU/PH EI)SDU/NOUSA KAI\ O)CEI=A. @<20*)ANI/A>20 DE\ LU/PH E)C A)NALOGISMW=N. @<20*METAME/LEIA>20 DE\ LU/PH E)PI\ A(MARTH/MASI PEPRAGME/NOIS W(S DI' AU(TOU= GEGO-@NO/SIN. @<20*SU/GXUSIS>20 DE\ LU/PH KWLU/OUSA DIORA=N TO\ ME/LLON. @<20*)AQUMI/A>20 DE\ LU/PH A)PELPI/ZONTOS W(=N E)PIQUMEI= TUXEI=N. @<20*)/ASH>20 DE\ LU/PH META\ R(IPTASMOU=. @<20*NE/MESIS>20 DE\ LU/PH E)PI\ E)PAIROME/NOIS PARA\ TO\ PROSH=KON. @<20*DUSFORI/A>20 DE\ LU/PH MET' A)PORI/AS TOU= PW=S XRH/SETAI TOI=S PAROU=SIN. @<20*GO/OS>20 DE\ QRH=NOS A)GOME/NOU KATA\ LU/PHN. @<20*BARUQUMI/A>20 DE\ LU/PH BARU/NOUSA KAI\ A)NA/NEUSIN OU) DIDOU=SA. @<20*KLAU=SIS>20 DE\ DA/KRUSIS LUPOUME/NOU NEU/ONTOS E)PI\ TO\ XEI=RON. @<20*FRONTI\S>20 DE\ LOGISMO\S LUPOUME/NOU. @<20*OI)=KTOS>20 DE\ LU/PH E)P' A)LLOTRI/OIS KAKOI=S. @1 @&10Cicero Tusc. disp. IV 17. <21Invidentiam>21 esse dicunt aegritur &10dinem susceptam propter alterius res secundas, quae nihil noceant invi-&10denti. Nam si qui doleat eius rebus secundis, a quo ipse laedatur, non &10recte dicatur invidere__<21Aemulatio>21 autem dupliciter illa quidem &10dicitur, ut et in laude et in vitio nomen hoc sit; nam et imitatio vir-&10tutis aemulatio dicitur; [1sed ea nihil hoc loco utimur; est enim laudis]1 &10et est aemulatio aegritudo, si eo, quod concupierit, alius potiatur, ipse &10careat. 18. <21Obtrectatio>21 autem est ea quam intellegi $10ZHLOTUPI/AN&10 volo, &10aegritudo ex eo, quod alter quoque potiatur eo, quod ipse concupiverit. &10<21Misericordia>21 est aegritudo ex miseria alterius iniuria laborantis; nemo &10enim parricidae aut proditoris supplicio misericordia commovetur; <21angor>21 &10aegritudo premens, <21luctus>21 aegritudo ex eius, qui carus fuerit, interitu &10acerbo, <21maeror>21 aegritudo flebilis, aerumna aegritudo laboriosa, <21dolor>21 &10aegritudo crucians, <21lamentatio>21 aegritudo cum eiulatu, <21sollicitudo>21 aegri-&10tudo cum cogitatione, <21molestia>21 aegritudo permanens, <21adflictatio>21 aegri-&10tudo cum vexatione corporis, <21desperatio>21 aegritudo sine ulla rerum ex-&10spectatione meliorum. &10@<21Stoicae>21 affectuum definitiones apud Nemesium de nat. hom. &10cp. 19_21. cp. 19.$10 *TH=S DE\ <20LU/PHS>20 EI)/DH TE/SSARA: A)/XOS, A)/XQOS, FQO/NOS E)/LEOS. E)/STI DE\ <20A)/XOS>20 LU/PH A)FWNI/AN E)MPOIOU=SA: <20A)/XQOS>20 DE\ LU/PH BARU/NOUSA: <20FQO/NOS>20 DE\ LU/PH E)P' A)LLOTRI/OIS A)GAQOI=S: <20E)/LEOS>20 DE\ LU/PH E)P' A)LLOTRI/OIS KA-KOI=S: PA=SA DE\ LU/PH KAKO\N TH=| E(AUTH=S FU/SEI: EI) GA\R KAI\ O( SPOUDAI=OS LUPH-QH/SETAI POTE\ XRHSTW=N A)NDRW=N DIAFQEIROME/NWN H)\ TE/KNWN H)\ PO/LEWS PORQOU-ME/NHS, A)LL' OU) PROHGOUME/NWS: OU)DE\ KATA\ PRO/QESIN, A)LLA\ KATA\ PERI/STASIN. KAI\ E)N TOU/TOIS DE\ O( ME\N QEWRHTIKO\S A)PAQH\S E)/STAI PANTA/PASIN A)LLOTRIW/SAS E(AUTO\N TW=N TH=|DE KAI\ SUNA/YAS QEW=|: O( DE\ SPOUDAI=OS METRIOPAQH\S E)N AU)TAI=S KAI\ OU)X U(PERBA/LLWN OU)DE\ AI)XMALWTIZO/MENOS U(P' AU)TW=N A)LLA\ MA=LLON KRATW=N AU)TW=N &10etc. &10@cp. 20.$10 *DIAIREI=TAI DE\ KAI\ <20FO/BOS>20 EI)S E(/C, EI)S O)/KNON, EI)S AI)DW/, EI)S AI)S-XU/NHN, EI)S KATA/PLHCIN, EI)S A)GWNI/AN, EI)S E)/KPLHCIN: E)/STI DE\ <20O)/KNOS>20 ME\N FO/BOS MELLOU/SHS E)NERGEI/AS: <20KATA/PLHCIS>20 DE\ FO/BOS E)K MEGA/LHS FANTASI/AS: <20E)/KPLH-CIS>20 DE\ FO/BOS E)C A)SUNH/QOUS FANTASI/AS: <20A)GWNI/A>20 DE\ FO/BOS DIAPTW/SEWS, TOUTE/STIN A)POTUXI/AS: FOBOU/MENOI GA\R A)POTUXEI=N TH=S PRA/CEWS A)GWNIW=MEN: <20AI)DW\S>20 DE\ FO/BOS E)PI\ PROSDOKI/A| YO/GOU: KA/LLISTON DE\ TOU=TO TO\ PA/QOS: <20AI)S-XU/NH>20 DE\ FO/BOS E)P' AI)SXRW=| PEPRAGME/NW|: OU)DE\ TOU=TO DE\ A)NE/LPISTON EI)S SWTH-RI/AN: TAU/TH| DE\ DIAFE/REI AI)DW\S AI)SXU/NHS, O(/TI O( ME\N AI)SXUNO/MENOS E)F' OI(=S E)/PRACE KATADU/ETAI: O( DE\ AI)DOU/MENOS FOBEI=TAI PERIPESEI=N A)DOCI/A| TINI/: KA-LOU=SI DE\ OI( PALAIOI\ POLLA/KIS KAI\ TH\N AI)DW\ AI)SXU/NHN, KATAXRW/MENOI TOI=S O)NO/MASI: GI/NETAI DE\ O( FO/BOS KATA\ PERI/YUCIN TOU= QERMOU= PANTO\S SUNTRE/XON-TOS EI)S TH\N KARDI/AN E)PI\ TO\ A)RXIKO/N, KAQA/PER KAI\ O( DH=MOS O(/TAN FOBH=TAI KATAFEU/GEI PRO\S TOU\S A)/RXONTAS: TH=S DE\ LU/PHS O)/RGANON TO\ STO/MA TH=S KOILI/AS: TOU=TO GA/R E)STI TO\ TH=S DH/CEWS AI)SQANO/MENON E)N TAI=S LU/PAIS. W(S O( *GALHNO\S <20E)N TW=| TRI/TW| TH=S A)PODEIKTIKH=S>20 &10etc. &10@cp. 21.$10 <20*QUMO\S>20 DE/ E)STI ZE/SIS TOU= PERI\ KARDI/AN AI(/MATOS E)C A)NAQUMIA/SEWS TH=S XOLH=S H)\ A)NAQOLW/SEWS GINOME/NH: DIO\ KAI\ XOLH\ LE/GETAI KAI\ XO/LOS. E)/STI D' O(/TE KAI\ O( QUMO/S E)STIN O)/RECIS A)NTITIMWRH/SEWS: A)DIKOU/MENOI GA\R H)\ NOMI/-ZONTES A)DIKEI=SQAI QUMOU/MEQA: KAI\ GI/NETAI TO/TE MIKTO\N TO\ PA/QOS E)C E)PIQU-MI/AS KAI\ QUMOU=. EI)/DH DE\ TOU= QUMOU= TRI/A: <20O)RGH/>20, H(\ KAI\ XOLH\ KAI\ XO/LOS KALEI=TAI: <20MH=NIS>20 KAI\ <20KO/TOS. *QUMO\S>20 ME\N GA\R A)RXH\N KAI\ KI/NHSIN E)/XWN O)RGH\ @1 KAI\ XOLH\ KAI\ XO/LOS LE/GETAI. <20MH=NIS>20 DE\ XOLH\ EI)S PALAI/WSIN A)GOME/NH: EI)/RHTAI GA\R PARA\ TO\ ME/NEIN KAI\ TH=| MNH/MH| PARADEDO/SQAI. <20KO/TOS>20 DE\ O)RGH\ PARATH-ROU=SA KAIRO\N EI)S TIMWRI/AN: EI)/RHTAI DE\ KAI\ OU(=TOS PARA\ TO\ KEI=SQAI. E)/STI DE\ O( QUMO\S TO\ DORUFORIKO\N TOU= LOGISMOU=. O(/TAN GA\R OU(=TOS A)/CION KRI/NH| TO\ GINO/MENON A)GANAKTH/SEWS, TO/TE O( QUMO\S U(PECE/RXETAI, E)A\N KATA\ FU/SIN TH\N OI)-KEI/AN TA/CIN FULA/TTWSIN. @&Cicero Tusc. disp. III 52.&3 Cyrenaicorum restat sententia; qui &3tum aegritudinem censent existere, si necopinato quid evenerit. Est id &3quidem magnum, ut supra dixi; etiam <21Chrysippo>21 ita videri scio, quod &3provisum ante non sit, id ferire vehementius. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 25 p. 1046b.$8 <20*)EN DE\ TW=| DEUTE/RW| PERI\ *)AGAQOU= TO\N FQO/NON E)CHGHSA/MENOS, O(/TI "1LU/PH E)STI\N E)P' A)LLOTRI/OIS A)GAQOI=S, W(S DH/POTE BOULOME/NWN TAPEI-NOU=N TOU\S PLHSI/ON, O(/PWS U(PERE/XWSIN AU)TOI/>20,"2 SUNA/PTEI TA\ TH=S E)PIXAIREKAKI/AS: "1<20*TAU/TH| DE\ SUNEXH\S H( E)PIXAIREKAKI/A GI/NETAI, TA-PEINOU\S BOULOME/NWN EI)=NAI TOU\S PLHSI/ON DIA\ TA\S O(MOI/AS AI)-TI/AS: KAQ' E(TE/RAS DE\ FUSIKA\S FORA\S E)KTREPOME/NWN O( E)/LEOS GI/NETAI>20."2 @&10Cicero Tusc. disp. III 83. Sed ratio una omnium est aegritur &10dinum, plura nomina. Nam et invidere aegritudinis est et aemulari et &10obtrectare et misereri et angi, lugere, maerere, aerumna adfici, lamentari, &10sollicitari, dolere, in molestia esse, adflictari, desperare. 84. Haec omnia &10definiunt <21Stoici>21, eaque verba, quae dixi, singularum rerum sunt, non ut &10videntur easdem res significant, sed aliquid differunt. &10@Galenus in Hippocr. de humoribus lib. I Vol. XVI p. 174 K.$10 EI)SI\ DE\ KAI\ QUMO\S KAI\ DUSQUMI/A TH=S YUXH=S PA/QH: DIAFE/REI DE\ O( QUMO\S KAI\ [2H(]2 O)RGH\ TH=S DUSQUMI/AS KAI\ LU/PHS KATA\ TA\S E)NERGEI/AS: E)N GA\R TH=| O)RGH=| KAI\ TW=| QUMW=| H( E)/MFUTOS AU)TH=| QERMASI/A E)KTEI/NETAI. KAI\ XOLH\ TO/TE GI/NETAI/ TE KAI\ AU)CA/NETAI. E)N DE\ TH=| LU/PH| KAI\ DUSQUMI/A| SUNAIREI=TAI KAI\ O( YUXRO/S TE KAI\ FLEGMATIKO\S XUMO\S E)/NQEN TH\N GE/NESIN E)/XEI. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 93. 1.$10 <20EU)EMPTWSI/AN>20 D' EI)=NAI EU)KATAFORI/AN EI)S PA/QOS H)/ TI TW=N PARA\ FU/SIN E)/RGWN, OI(=ON E)PILUPI/AN, O)RGILO/THTA, FQONERI/AN, A)KROXOLI/AN KAI\ TA\ O(/MOIA. GI/GNESQAI DE\ EU)EMPTWSI/AS KAI\ EI)S A)/LLA E)/RGA TW=N PARA\ FU/SIN, OI(=ON EI)S KLOPA\S KAI\ MOIXEI/AS KAI\ U(/BREIS, KAQ' A(\S KLE/PTAI TE KAI\ MOIXOI\ KAI\ U(BRISTAI\ LE/GONTAI. <20NO/SHMA>20 D' EI)=NAI DO/CAN E)PIQUMI/AS E)R)R(UH-KUI=AN EI)S E(/CIN KAI\ E)NESKIRWME/NHN, KAQ' H(\N U(POLAMBA/NOUSI TA\ MH\ AI(RETA\ SFO/DRA AI(RETA\ EI)=NAI, OI(=ON FILOGUNI/AN, FILOINI/AN, FILARGURI/AN: EI)=NAI DE/ TINA KAI\ E)NANTI/A [2TOU/TOIS]2 TOI=S NOSH/MASI <20KATA\ PROSKOPH\N GINO/MENA>20, OI(=ON @1 MISOGUNI/AN, MISOINI/AN, MISANQRWPI/AN. TA\ DE\ NOSH/MATA MET' A)SQENEI/AS SUM-BAI/NONTA <20A)R)R(WSTH/MATA>20 KALEI=SQAI. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 115.$10 W(S DE\ LE/GETAI/ TINA E)PI\ TOU= SW/MATOS <20A)R)R(W-STH/MATA>20, OI(=ON PODA/GRA KAI\ A)RQRI/TIDES, OU(/TW KA)PI\ TH=S YUXH=S FILODOCI/A KAI\ FILHDONI/A KAI\ TA\ PARAPLH/SIA. TO\ GA\R <20A)R)R(W/STHMA/>20 E)STI NO/SHMA META\ A)SQE-NEI/AS, TO\ DE\ <20NO/SHMA>20 OI)/HSIS SFO/DRA DOKOU=NTOS AI(RETOU=. @KAI\ W(S E)PI\ TOU= SW/MATOS <20EU)EMPTWSI/AI>20 TINE\S LE/GONTAI, OI(=ON KATA/R)R(OUS KAI\ DIA/R)R(OIA, OU(/TW KA)PI\ TH=S YUXH=S EI)SIN EU)KATAFORI/AI, OI(=ON FQONERI/A, E)LEH-MOSU/NH, E)/RIDES KAI\ TA\ PARAPLH/SIA. @&10Cicero Tusc. disp. IV 27. ut sunt alii ad alids morbos pro-&10cliviores [1itaque dicimus gravedinosos quosdam, torminosos, non quia iam &10sint, sed quia saepe]1, sic alii ad metum, alii ad aliam perturbationem; &10ex quo in aliis <21anxietas>21, unde anxii, in aliis <21iracundia>21 dicitur, quae &10ab ira differt, estque aliud iracundum esse, aliud iratum, ut <21differt an-&10xietas ab angore>21; neque enim omnes anxii, qui anguntur aliquando, &10nec qui anxii, semper anguntur, ut inter ebrietatem [2et ebriositatem]2 in-&10terest, aliudque est amatorem esse, aliud amantem. @&Cicero Tusculan. disp. IV 10, 23.&3 Quemadmodum, cum san-&3guis corruptus est aut pituita redundat aut bilis, in corpore morbi aegro-&3tationesque nascuntur%10 sic pravarum opinionum conturbatio et ipsarum &3inter se repugnantia sanitate spoliat animum morbisque perturbat. Ex &3perturbationibus autem primum morbi conficiuntur, quae vocant illi $<20NOSH/MATA,>20&3 eaque quae sunt eis morbis contraria, quae habent ad res &3certas <21vitiosam offensionem atque fastidium>21, deinde aegrotationes, &3quae appellantur a Stoicis$ <20A)R)R(WSTH/MATA,>20&3 hisque item oppositae con-&3trariae offensiones. Hoc loco nimium operae consumitur a Stoicis, ma-&3xime a <21Chrysippo>21, dum morbis corporum comparatur morborum animi &3similitudo. Qua oratione praetermissa minime necessaria, ea quae rem &3continent pertractemus.& 24.&3 Intellegatur igitur perturbationem iactanti-&3bus se opinionibus inconstanter et turbide in motu esse semper; cum &3autem hic fervor concitatioque animi inveteravit et tamquam in venis &3medullisque insedit, tum exsistit et morbus et aegrotatio et offensiones &3eae, quae sunt eis morbis aegrotationibusque contrariae. Haec, quae dico, &3cogitatione inter se differunt, re quidem copulata sunt, eaque <21oriuntur &3ex libidine et ex laetitia>21. Nam cum est concupita pecunia nec ad-&3hibita continuo ratio quasi quaedam Socratica medicina, quae sanaret &3eam cupiditatem, permanat in venas et inhaeret in visceribus illud ma-&3lum, existitque morbus et aegrotatio, quae evelli inveterata non possunt, &3eique morbo nomen est avaritia;& 25.&3 similiterque ceteri morbi, ut gloriae &3cupiditas, ut mulierositas, ut ita appellem eam quae Graece $FILOGUNI/A&3 @1 &3dicitur, ceterique similiter morbi aegrotationesque nascuntur. _Quae &3autem sunt his contraria, <21ea nasci putantur a metu>21, ut odium muli-&3erum, quale in $MISOGU/NW|&3 Atilii est, ut in hominum universum genus, &3quod accepimus de Timone, qui $MISA/NQRWPOS&3 appellatur, ut inhospita-&3litas est; quae omnes aegrotationes animi ex quodam metu nascuntur ea-&3rum rerum, quas fugiunt et oderunt. @&10Cicero Tusc. disp. IV 29. Quo modo autem in corpore est &10morbus, est aegrotatio, est vitinm, sic in animo. <21Morbum>21 appellant to-&10tius corporis corruptionem, <21aegrotationem>21 morbum cum imbecillitate, &10<21vitium>21, cum partes corporis inter se dissident, ex quo pravitas membro-&10rum, distortio, deformitas. Itaque illa duo, morbus et aegrotatio, ex to-&10tius valetudinis corporis conquassatione et perturbatione gignuntur, <21vitium>21 &10autem integra valetudine ipsum ex se cernitur. Sed in animo tantum-&10modo cogitatione possumus morbum ab aegrotatione seiungere; vitiositas &10autem est habitus aut adfectio in tota vita inconstans et a se ipsa dissen-&10tiens. Ita fit, ut in altera corruptione opinionum morbus efficiatur et &10aegrotatio, in altera inconstantia et repugnantia. Non enim omne vitium &10paris habet dissensiones, ut eorum, qui non longe a sapientia absunt, ad-&10fectio est illa quidem discrepans sibi ipsa, dum est insipiens, sed non &10distorta nec prava. Morbi autem et aegrotationes partes sunt vitiositatis, &10sed perturbationes sintne eiusdem partes, quaestio est. 30. <21Vitia enim &10adfectiones sunt manentes>21, perturbationes autem moventes, ut non &10possint adfectionum manentium partes esse. &10@Cicero Tusc. disp. IV 31. Illud animorum corporumque dissi-&10mile, quod animi valentes morbo temptari [non] possunt, [2ut]2 corpora &10possunt; sed corporum offensiones sine culpa accidere possunt, animorum &10non item, quorum <21omnes morbi et perturbationes ex aspernatione &10rationis eveniunt; itaque in hominibus solum existunt; nam &10bestiae simile quiddam faciunt, sed in perturbationes non in-&10cidunt>21. &10@Cicero Tusc. disp. IV 26. Definiunt autem animi <21aegrota-&10tionem>21 opinationem vehementem de re non expetenda, tamquam valde &10expetenda sit, inhaerentem et penitus insitam. Quod autem nascitur ex &10<21offensione>21 ita definiunt%10 opinionem vehementem de re non fugienda in-&10haerentem et penitus insitam tamquam fugienda. Haec autem <21opinatio>21 &10est iudicatio se scire, quod nesciat. &10@Aegrotationi autem talia quaedam subiecta sunt%10 avaritia, ambitio, &10mulierositas, pervicacia, ligurritio, vinulentia, cuppedia et siqua similia%10 &10Est autem <21avaritia>21 opinatio vehemens de pecunia, quasi valde expetenda &10sit, inhaerens et penitus insita, similisque est eiusdem generis definitio &10reliquarum. &10@`27. Offensionum autem definitiones sunt eius modi, ut <21inhospitali-&10tas>21 sit opinio vehemens valde fugiendum esse hospitem, eaque inhaerens &10et penitus insita, similiterque definitur et <21mulierum odium>21, ut Hippo-&10lyti, et, ut Timonis, <21generis humani>21. @1 @&10Seneca ep. 75, 11. Ut breviter finiam%10 "1<21morbus est iudicium &10in pravo pertinax, tamquam valde expetenda sint, quae leviter &10expetenda sunt>21"2 vel si mavis ita finiamus%10 "1nimis imminere leviter &10petendis vel ex toto non petendis aut in magno pretio habere in aliquo &10habenda vel in nullo."2 &10@Galenus de locis affectis I 3 Vol. VIII p. 32 K.$10 KINH/SEWS D' OU)/SHS KATA\ GE/NOS DITTH=S, A)LLOIW/SEW/S TE KAI\ FORA=S, O(/TAN EI)S MO/NIMON A)FI/-KHTAI DIA/QESIN H( A)LLOI/WSIS, O)NOMA/ZETAI NO/SHMA, PARA\ FU/SIN OU)=SA DHLONO/TI DIA/QESIS: KATAXRW/MENOI D' E)NI/OTE KAI\ TH\N TOIAU/THN DIA/QESIN O)NOMA/ZOMEN PA/QOS. @&10Cicero Tusc. disp. IV 32. Aegrotationes autem morbique ani-&10morum difficilius evelli posse putantur, quam summa illa vitia, quae vir-&10tutibus sunt contraria. Morbis enim manentibus vitia sublata esse pos-&10sunt, quia non tam celeriter sanantur, quam illa tolluntur. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 115.$10 EI)=NAI DE\ KAI\ <20EU)PAQEI/AS>20 FASI\ TREI=S, XA-RA/N, EU)LA/BEIAN, BOU/LHSIN. KAI\ TH\N ME\N <20XARA\N>20 E)NANTI/AN FASI\N EI)=NAI TH=| H(DONH=|, OU)=SAN EU)/LOGON E)/PARSIN, TH\N DE\ <20EU)LA/BEIAN>20 TW=| FO/BW|, OU)=SAN EU)/LOGON E)/KKLISIN: FOBHQH/SESQAI ME\N GA\R TO\N SOFO\N OU)DAMW=S, EU)LABHQH/SESQAI DE/. TH=| DE\ E)PIQUMI/A| E)NANTI/AN FASI\N EI)=NAI TH\N <20BOU/LHSIN>20, OU)=SAN EU)/LOGON O)/RECIN. KAQA/PER OU)=N U(PO\ TA\ PRW=TA PA/QH PI/PTEI TINA/, TO\N AU)TO\N TRO/PON KAI\ U(PO\ TA\S PRW/TAS EU)PAQEI/AS: KAI\ U(PO\ ME\N TH\N <20BOU/LHSIN>20 EU)/NOIAN, EU)ME/NEIAN, A)SPASMO/N, A)GA/PHSIN, U(PO\ DE\ TH\N <20EU)LA/BEIAN>20 AI)DW=, A(GNEI/AN, U(PO\ DE\ TH\N <20XARA\N>20 TE/RYIN, EU)FROSU/NHN, EU)QUMI/AN. @&10Andronicus$10 PERI\ PAQW=N&10 6 [1p. 20 Kreuttner$10]1. {3*EU)PAQEI/AS EI)/DH G#.}3 @<20*BOU/LHSIS>20 ME\N OU)=N E)STIN EU)/LOGOS O)/RECIS. @<20*XARA\>20 DE\ EU)/LOGOS E)/PARSIS. @<20*EU)LA/BEIA>20 DE\ EU)/LOGOS E)/KKLISIS. {3*BOULH/SEWS EI)/DH D#.}3 @<20*EU)/NOIA>20 ME\N OU)=N E)STI BOU/LHSIS A)GAQW=N [2E(TE/RW|]2 AU)TOU= E(/NEKEN E)KEI/NOU. @<20*EU)ME/NEIA>20 DE\ EU)/NOIA E)PI/MONOS. @<20*)ASPASMO\S>20 DE\ A)DIA/STATOS [2EU)/NOIA]2 @<20*)AGA/PHSIS>20___ {3*XARA=S EI)/DH G#.}3 @<20*TE/RYIS>20 ME\N OU)=N E)STI XARA\ PRE/POUSA TAI=S PERI\ AU)TO\N W)FELEI/AIS. @<20*EU)FROSU/NH>20 DE\ XARA\ E)PI\ TOI=S TOU= SW/FRONOS E)/RGOIS. @<20*EU)QUMI/A>20 DE\ XARA\ E)PI\ DIAGWGH=| H)\ A)NEPIZHTHSI/A| PANTO/S. {3*EU)LABEI/AS EI)/DH B#.}3 @<20*AI)DW\S>20 ME\N OU)=N E)STIN EU)LA/BEIA O)RQOU= YO/GOU. @<20*(AGNEI/A>20 DE\ EU)LA/BEIA TW=N PERI\ Q[2EOU\S]2 A(MARTHMA/TWN. @1 @&10Clemens Al. Strom. II p. 466 Pott.$10 TH\N ME\N GA\R <20XARA\N>20 EU)/LO-GON E)/PARSIN A)PODIDO/ASI: KAI\ TO\ A)GA/LLESQAI XAI/REIN E)PI\ KALOI=S: TO\ DE\ <20E)/LEOS>20 LU/PHN E)PI\ A)NACI/WS KAKOPAQOU=NTI: TROPA\S DE\ EI)=NAI YUXH=S KAI\ PA/QH TA\ TOIAU=TA. @&10Alexander Aphrod. comm. in Aristot. Topica II p. 96 Ald. &10p. 181, 1 Wal.$10 TAU)TO\N GA\R KATA\ TO\ U(POKEI/MENO/N TE KAI\ SHMAINO/MENON H(DONH\ KAI\ XARA\ KAI\ EU)FROSU/NH KAI\ TE/RYIS, *PRO/DIKOS DE\ E)PEIRA=TO E(KA/STW| TW=N O)NO-MA/TWN TOU/TWN I)/DIO/N TI SHMAINO/MENON U(POTA/SSEIN, W(/SPER KAI\ <20OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S, XARA\N>20 ME\N LE/GONTES EU)/LOGON E)/PARSIN, <20H(DONH\N>20 DE\ A)/LOGON E)/PARSIN, <20TE/RYIN>20 DE\ TH\N DI' W)/TWN H(DONH/N, <20EU)FROSU/NHN>20 DE\ TH\N DIA\ LO/GWN: NOMO-QETOU/NTWN DE/ E)STI TOU=TO, A)LL' OU)DE\N U(GIE\S LEGO/NTWN. @&10Seneca ep. 59, 2. vitium esse <21voluptatem>21 credimus. __ &10Scio, inquam, et voluptatem, si ad nostrum album verba dirigimus, rem &10infamem esse, et <21gaudium>21 nisi sapienti non contingere. est enim <21animi &10elatio suis bonis verisque fidentis. _gaudio autem iunctum &10est non desinere nec in contrarium verti>21. @&10Philo de migrat. Abrah. %14 156 Vol. II p. 299, 3 Wendl.$10 *)ALLA\ GA\R KAI\ TOI=S XOREUTAI=S A)RETH=S STENA/ZEIN KAI\ DAKRU/EIN E)/QOS, H)\ TA\S TW=N A)FRO/-NWN O)DUROME/NOIS SUMFORA/S, DIA\ TO\ FU/SEI KOINWNIKO\N KAI\ FILA/NQRWPON, H)\ DIA\ PERIXA/REIAN: GI/NETAI DE\ AU(/TH, O(/TAN A)QRO/A A)GAQA\ MHDE\ PROSDOKHQE/NTA POTE\ AI)FNI/DION O)MBRH/SANTA PLHMMURH=|: A)F' OU(= KAI\ TO\ POIHTIKO\N EI)RH=SQAI/ MOI DOKEI= [1&10Hom. $10*Z&10& 484$10]1 @*DAKRUO/EN GELA/SASA. *PROSPESOU=SA GA\R E)K TOU= A)NELPI/STOU H( <20EU)PAQEIW=N A)RI/STH XARA\>20 YUXH=|, MEI/ZONA AU)TH\N H)\ PRO/TERON H)=N E)POI/HSEN, W(S DIA\ TO\N O)/GKON MHKE/TI XWREI=N TO\ SW=MA: QLIBO/MENON DE\ KAI\ PIEZO/MENON A)POSTA/ZEIN LIBA/DAS, A(\S KALEI=N E)/QOS DA/KRUA. @&10Lactantius div. instit. VI 15. Videamus nunc iidem illi, qui &10vitia penitus excidunt, quid effecerint. Quattuor illos affectus, quos ex &10opinione bonorum malorumque nasci putant, quibus evulsis sanandum esse &10animum sapientis existimant, quoniam intelligunt et natura insitos esse &10et sine his nihil moveri, nihil agi posse, alia quaedam in eorum locum &10vicemque supponunt. Pro cupiditate substituunt <21voluntatem>21%10 quasi vero &10non multo sit praestabilius, bonum cupere quam velle%10 item pro laetitia &10<21gaudium>21, pro metu <21cautionem>21. At in illo quarto immutandi nominis &10eos ratio defecit. Itaque aegritudinem penitus, id est moestitiam dolorem-&10que animi sustulerunt. &10@ibidem paulo post%10 sed putemus, ut ipsi volunt, esse diversa. Nempe &10igitur cupiditatem esse dicent perseverantem ac perpetuam voluntatem%10 &10laetitiam vero insolenter se efferens gaudium%10 metum autem nimiam et &10excedentem modum cautionem. __Eo igitur imprudentes revolvuntur, &10quo Peripatetici ratione perveniunt, ut vitia, quoniam tolli non possunt, &10medie temperanda sint. &10@Cicero Tusc. disp. IV 12. Natura enim omnes ea, quae bona &10videntur, sequuntur fugiuntque contraria. Quam ob rem simul obiecta &10species est cuiuspiam, quod bonum videatur, ad id adipiscendum impellit @1 &10ipsa natura. Id cum constanter prudenterque fit, eius modi adpetitionem &10Stoici$10 BOU/LHSIN&10 appellant, nos appellemus voluntatem. Eam illi putant &10<21in solo esse sapiente>21, quam sic definiunt%10 voluntas est, quae quid cum &10ratione desiderat. Quae autem [2a]2 ratione aversa incitata est vehemen-&10tius, ea libido est vel cupiditas effrenata, quae in omnibus stultis inveni-&10tur. 13. Itemque cum ita movemur, ut in bono simus aliquo, dupliciter &10id contingit. Nam cum ratione animus movetur placide atque constanter, &10tum illud <21gaudium>21 dicitur; cum autem inaniter et effuse animus exultat, &10tum illa laetitia gestiens vel nimia dici potest, quam ita definiunt%10 sine &10ratione animi elationem. Quoniamque ut bona natura adpetimus, sic a &10malis natura declinamus, quae declinatio cum ratione fiet, <21cautio>21 appel-&10letur, eaque intellegatur <21in solo esse sapiente>21; quae autem sine ratione &10et cum exanimatione humili atque fracta, nominatur metus; est igitur &10metus [2a]2 ratione aversa cautio. 14. Praesentis autem mali sapientis &10affectio nulla est, stultorum aegritudo est, eaque adficiuntur in malis opi-&10natis animosque demittunt et contrahunt rationi non obtemperantes. Ita-&10que haec prima definitio est, ut aegritudo sit animi adversante ratione &10contractio. Sic quattuor perturbationes sunt, tres constantiae, quoniam &10aegritudini nulla constantia opponitur. @&10Plutarchus de virtute morali cp. 9 p. 449a.$10 *OI(=S KAI\ AU)TOI\ [1&10scil. &10Stoici]1$10 TRO/PON TINA\ DIA\ TH\N E)NA/RGEIAN U(PEI/KONTES "1<20AI)DEI=SQAI TO\ AI)SXU/-NESQAI>20 KALOU=SI KAI\ TO\ <20H(/DESQAI XAI/REIN>20 KAI\ <20TOU\S FO/BOUS EU)LABEI/AS>20"2 TAU/THN ME\N OU)DENO\S A)\N AI)TIASAME/NOU TH\N EU)FHMI/AN, EI) TA\ AU)TA\ PA/QH PROS-TIQE/MENA ME\N TW=| LOGISMW=| TOU/TOIS KALOU=SI TOI=S O)NO/MASI, MAXO/MENA DE\ KAI\ BIAZO/MENA TO\N LOGISMO\N E)KEI/NOIS. O(/TAN DE\ DAKRU/OIS E)LEGXO/MENOI KAI\ TRO/MOIS KAI\ XRO/AS METABOLAI=S A)NTI\ LU/PHS KAI\ FO/BOU <20DHGMOU/S>20 TINAS KAI\ <20SUNEO/RSEIS>20 LE/GWSI, KAI\ <20PROQUMI/AS>20 TA\S E)PIQUMI/AS U(POKORI/ZWNTAI, SOFISTIKA\S DOKOU=SIN, OU) FILOSO/FOUS DIKAIW/SEIS KAI\ A)PODRA/SEIS E)K TW=N PRAGMA/TWN MHXANA=SQAI DIA\ TW=N O)NOMA/TWN. KAI/TOI PA/LIN AU)TOI\ TA/S TE XARA\S E)KEI/NAS KAI\ TA\S BOU-LH/SEIS KAI\ TA\S EU)LABEI/AS <20EU)PAQEI/AS>20 KALOU=SIN, OU)K A)PAQEI/AS, O)RQW=S E)N-TAU=QA XRW/MENOI TOI=S O)NO/MASI. @&Galenus de H. et Plat. decr. IV 4 [1`140]1 p. 354 M. <21Chrysip-&pus>21 inducitur%10$ MH\ SUGXWRW=N E)PI\ TAU)TOU= LE/GEIN AI)SXU/NESQAI KAI\ AI)-DEI=SQAI, MH/D' H(/DESQAI KAI\ XAI/REIN, A)LL' A)KRIBOU=N A(/PANTA KAI\ ME/XRI TW=N O)NOMA/TWN A)CIW=N [1AU)TO\N]1 E)N TOI=S SUGGRA/MMASIN. @&10Galenus de H. et Plat. decr. V 7 [1`173]1 p. 468 M.$10 EI)/TE DE\ PROS-I/ESQAI KAI\ FEU/GEIN LE/GEIS, EI)/TE DIW/KEIN, EI)/T' E)FI/ESQAI, DIAFE/REI OU)DE/N, W(/SPER OU)DE\ EI) BOU/LESQAI H)\ O)RE/GESQAI H)\ A)NTIPOIEI=SQAI H)\ A)SPA/ZESQAI H)\ E)PIQUMEI=N. H( GA\R TW=N TOIOU/TWN O)NOMA/TWN DIAI/RESIS OU)DE\N EI)S TH\N PAROU=SAN SKE/YIN O)NI/-NHSIN, A)LL' AU)TO\ TOU)NANTI/ON A)/KAIRO/S T' E)STI\ KAI\ TH\N PERI\ TW=N PRAGMA/TWN ZH/THSIN EI)S TH\N PERI\ TW=N O)NOMA/TWN A)MFISBH/THSIN A)PA/GEI. DIO\ KAI\ TEXNA/-ZONTAI/ TINES E)CEPI/THDES U(PE\R TOU= MHDE\N PERANQH=NAI PRO\S E(/KASTON TW=N O)NO- @1MA/TWN E)NI/STASQAI, EI) ME\N O)RE/GESQAI PO/MATOS EI)/POIS TO\N DIYW=NTA, MH\ SUG-XWROU=NTES "1O)RE/GESQAI"2 LE/GEIN, <20A)STEI=ON GA/R TI TH\N O)/RECIN EI)=NAI KAI\ MO/NOU TOU= SOFOU=>20, U(PA/RXEIN GOU=N AU)TH\N <20O(RMH\N LOGISTIKH\N E)PI/ TI O(/SON XRH\ H(/DONTOS>20, A)\N DE\ "1E)PIQUMEI=N"2, OU)DE\ OU(/TWS O)NOMA/ZEIN SUGXWROU=N-TES: <20TO\ ME\N GA\R DIYH=N OU)K E)N TOI=S FAU/LOIS MO/NON, A)LLA\ KAI\ TOI=S A)STEI/OIS GI/GNESQAI, TH\N D' E)PIQUMI/AN AU)TH/N TE FAU/LHN EI)=NAI KAI\ MO/NOIS TOI=S FAU/LOIS E)GGI/NESQAI, EI)=NAI GA\R O)/RECIN A)QRO/WS R(EPTI-KH\N PRO\S TO\ TUGXA/NEIN>20. EI) DE\ MH\ MAKRO\N OU(/TWS AU)TH=S O(RISMO\N POIH/SEIEN, A)LL' O)/RECI/N [TE] A)/LOGON U(PA/RXEIN EI)PW/N, E)PITIMH/SEI MA/LA SEMNW=S A)NDRI\ POL-LA/KIS OU)K E)N TH=| PRAGMA/TWN E)PISTH/MH| MO/NON, A)LLA\ KA)N TH=| TW=N O)NOMA/TWN XRH/SEI MURI/WN DIAFE/RONTI. TOIOU=TOI D' A)ME/LEI KAI\ TW=N PALAIW=N H)=SAN OU)K O)LI/GOI, KAQA/PER KAI\ AU)TO\S O( *PLA/TWN FHSI/N, O)NO/MASI XRW/MENOI KAINW=S METW-NOMASME/NOIS. @&10Clemens Al. Strom. IV 18 p. 617 Pott.$10 <20O)/RECIN>20 OU)=N E)PIQUMI/AS DIAKRI/NOUSIN OI( PERI\ TAU=TA DEINOI/: KAI\ TH\N ME\N E)PI\ H(DONAI=S KAI\ A)KOLASI/A| TA/TTOUSIN, A)/LOGON OU)=SAN: TH\N DE\ O)/RECIN E)PI\ TW=N KATA\ FU/SIN A)NAGKAI/WN, LOGIKH\N U(PA/RXOUSAN KI/NHSIN. @&10Seneca ep. 116, 1. Utrum satius sit modicos habere adfectus &10an nullos, saepe quaesitum est%10 <21nostri illos expellunt>21, Peripatetici &10temperant. &10@Lactant. div. instit. VI 14. Nam <21Stoici>21 affectus omnes, quo-&10rum impulsu animus commovetur, ex homine tollunt, cupiditatem, laeti-&10tiam, metum, moestitiam%10 quorum duo priora ex bonis sunt aut futuris &10aut praesentibus; posteriora ex malis. Eodem modo haec quattuor morbos &10[1ut dixi]1 vocant, non tam natura insitos, quam prava opinione susceptos%10 &10et idcirco eos censent exstirpari posse radicitus, si bonorum malorumque &10opinio falsa tollatur. Si enim nihil censeat sapiens bonum, nihil malum, &10nec cupiditate ardescet, nec laetitia gestiet, nec metu terrebitur nec aegri-&10tudine contrahetur. &10@Lactant. de ira cp. 17. Sed <21Stoici>21 non viderunt esse discrimen &10recti et pravi; esse iram iustam, esse et iniustam; et quia medelam rei &10non inveniebant, <21voluerunt eam penitus excidere>21. &10@Clemens Al. Paed. I 13 p. 158 Pott.$10 <20*PA=N TO\ PARA\ TO\N LO/-GON TO\N O)RQO\N TOU=TO A(MA/RTHMA/ E)STI. AU)TI/KA GOU=N TA\ PA/QH>20 TA\ GENIKW/TATA W(=DE/ PWS O(RI/ZESQAI A)CIOU=SIN OI( FILO/SOFOI: TH\N ME\N E)PIQUMI/AN O)/RECIN A)PEIQH= LO/GW|: TO\N DE\ FO/BON E)/KKLISIN A)PEIQH= LO/GW|: H(DONH\N DE\ E)/PARSIN YUXH=S A)PEIQH= LO/GW|. @1 @&10Philo de septen. et festis dieb. Vol. II Mang. p. 348.$10 <20*PA=N ME\N PA/QOS E)PI/LHPTON>20, E)PEI\ KAI\ PA=SA A)/METROS KAI\ PLEONA/ZOUSA O(RMH\ KAI\ TH=S YUXH=S H( A)/LOGOS KAI\ PARA\ FU/SIN KI/NHSIS U(PAI/TIOS. @&Hieronymus ep. 132 [1ad Ctesiphontem]1 1.&3 venena_quae &3de philosophorum et maxime Pythagorae et <21Zenonis>21 principis <21Stoico-&3rum>21 fonte manarunt. Illi enim quae Graeci appellant$ PA/QH,&3 nos per-&3turbationes possumus dicere%10 aegritudinem videlicet et gaudium, spem et &3metum: quorum duo praesentia, duo futura sunt, <21asserunt exstirpari &3posse de mentibus et nullam fibram radicemque vitiorum in &3homine omnino residere>21, meditatione et assidua exercitatione vir-&3tutum. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 117.$10 FASI\ DE\ KAI\ <20A)PAQH= EI)=NAI TO\N SOFO/N>20, DIA\ TO\ A)NE/MPTWTON EI)=NAI. EI)=NAI DE\ KAI\ A)/LLON A)PAQH=, TO\N FAU=LON, E)N I)/SW| LEGO/MENON TW=| SKLHRW=| KAI\ A)TE/GKTW|. @&10Porphyrion ad Hor. Serm. II 4, 1. Catius Epicureus fuit, qui &10scripsit quattuor libros de rerum natura et de summo bono. Sub eius &10nomine quomodo in proxima Stoicos ita in hac Epicureos inrisurus est, &10qui dicunt summum bonum$10 H(DONH\N&10 rerum honestarum. Unde <21Stoici>21 hanc &10gulae et corporis libidinem criminantur,$10 <20TH\N A)TARACI/AN TH=S YUXH=S>20,&10 &10<21hoc est nihil timere nec cupere, summum bonum esse>21. Unde &10Varro dicit$10 LOGOMAXI/AN&10 inter illos esse. &10@Lactant. div. instit. VI 10 [1de humanitate disputans]1. Ad hanc &10partem philosophorum nulla praecepta sunt; quippe qui falsae virtutis &10specie capti <21misericordiam>21 de homine sustulerunt; et dum volunt sa-&10nare vitia, auxerunt. Et cum iidem plerumque fateantur, societatis hu-&10manae communionem esse retinendam, ab ea plane se ipsos inhumanae suae &10virtutis rigore dissociant. &10@ibid. 11. Quaero igitur ab iis, qui <21flecti ac misereri non putant &10esse sapientis>21, si homo ab aliqua bestia comprehensus auxilium sibi &10armati hominis imploret, utrumne succurrendum putent an minime? non &10sunt tam impudentes, ut negent fieri oportere quod flagitat, quod exposcit &10humanitas. Item si aliquis circumveniatur igni, ruina opprimatur, merga-&10tur mari, flumine rapiatur, num putent hominis esse non auxiliari? non &10sunt ipsi homines si putent. Nemo enim potest eiusmodi periculis non ˆ&10esse subiectus. Immo vero et hominis et fortis viri esse dicent, servare &10periturum. <21Si ergo in eiusmodi casibus, qui periculum vitae ho-&10mini afferunt, succurrere humanitatis esse concedunt%10 quid &10causae est, cur si homo esuriat, sitiat, algeat, succurrendum &10esse non putent>21? Quae cum sint paria natura cum illis casibus fortuitis &10et unam eandemque humanitatem desiderent, tamen illa discernunt, quia &10non re ipsa vera, sed utilitate praesenti omnia metiuntur. &10@Origenes comm. in Ezechielem cp. 8 Tom. III p. 424 Delarue.$10 <20E)/LEOS>20: _O(/NTINA W(RI/SANTO OI( PERI\ TAU=TA DEINOI\ <20LU/PHN EI)=NAI E)PI\ TH=| TOU= PLHSI/ON DUSPRAGI/A|>20: KAI\ FASI\ <20MH\ DEI=N I)ATRO\N H)\ DIKASTH\N TOU=TON TO\N E)/LEON E)LEEI=N>20, MH/ POTE SUGXUQE/NTES U(PO\ TH=S E)PI\ TO\ OU(/TWS E)LEEI=N E)PA-GOU/SHS LU/PHS E)MPODISQW=SIN A)PODOU=NAI TO\ I)ATRIKO\N H)\ TO\ DIKASTIKO\N SUMFE-RO/NTWS TW=| QERAPEUOME/NW| H)\ TW=| DIKAZOME/NW| E)/RGON. @1 @&10Seneca de clementia lib. II cp. 4. Ad rem pertinet quaerere &10hoc loco, quid sit <21misericordia>21. plerique enim ut virtutem eam lau-&10dant et bonum hominem vocant misericordem. Et haec <21vitium animi &10est>21 etc. &10@cp. 5. Scio male audire apud imperitos <21sectam Stoicorum>21 tan-&10quam nimis duram et minime principibus regibusque bonum daturam con-&10silium. obicitur enim illi, quod <21sapientem negat misereri, negat &10ignoscere>21. __Misericordia est aegritudo animi ob alienarum mise-&10riarum speciem, aut tristitia ex alienis malis contracta, quae accidere &10immerentibus credit. aegritudo autem in sapientem virum non cadit. &10@Seneca de clementia lib. II cp. 7. Constituamus nunc quoque, &10quid sit <21venia>21, et <21sciemus illam dari a sapiente non debere>21. &10Venia est poenae debitae remissio. Hanc sapiens quare non debeat dare, &10reddunt rationem diutius, quibus hoc propositum est. ego ut breviter &10tamquam in alieno iudicio dicam%10 Ei ignoscitur, qui puniri debuit, sa-&10piens autem nihil facit quod non debet, nihil praetermittit quod debet%10 &10itaque poenam, quam exigere debet, non donat. sed illud quod ex venia &10consequi vis, honestiore tibi via tribuit%10 <21parcit enim sapiens, consulit &10et corrigit>21. &10@Origenes comment. in Matthaeum Vol. III p. 674 Delarue.$10 EI)/PER TE/LEIO/S E)STIN O( PA/SAS E)/XWN TA\S A)RETA\S KAI\ MHKE/TI A)PO\ KAKI/AS PRA/TTWN&10 etc.$10 @PW=S A)\N KAI\ <20A)O/RGHTOS>20 GE/NOIT' A)\N A)QRO/WS, EI) TU/XOI EU)E/MPTWTOS W)\N EI)S O)RGH/N; PW=S DE\ KAI\ <20A)/LUPOS>20 KAI\ KREI/TTWN PANTO\S OU(TINOSOU=N SUMBH=NAI DU-NAME/NOU, TH\N LU/PHN PROKALOUME/NOU; PW=S DE\ KAI\ <20E)/CW FO/BOU>20 PA/NTH E)/STAI TOU= PERI\ PO/NWN H)\ QANA/TOU H)\ TW=N O(/SA DU/NATAI TH\N E)/TI A)TELESTE/RAN YUXH\N FOBH=SAI; TI/NA DE\ TRO/PON__<20E)KTO\S E)/STAI PA/SHS E)PIQUMI/AS>20; __ EI) DE\ KAI\ H( LEGOME/NH H(DONH/, A)/LOGOS OU)=SA E)/PARSIS TH=S YUXH=S, PA/QOS E)STI/, PW=S A)/N TIS__A)PALLAGEI/H TOU= A)LO/GWS E)PAI/RESQAI. @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 25 p. 1070e.$ *)ALL' O(MOLOGEI= GE *XRU/SIPPOS, <20EI)=NAI/ TINAS FO/BOUS KAI\ LU/PAS KAI\ A)PA/TAS, AI(\ BLA/PTOUSI ME\N H(MA=S, XEI/RONAS D' OU) POIOU=SIN>20. *)/ENTUXE DE\ TW=| <20PRW/TW| TW=N PRO\S *PLA/TWNA GEGRAMME/NWN PERI\ *DIKAIOSU/NHS>20: KAI\ GA\R A)/LLWN E(/NEKA TH\N E)KEI= TOU= A)NDRO\S EU(RHSILOGI/AN A)/CION I(STO-RH=SAI, PA/NTWN A(PLW=S PRAGMA/TWN KAI\ DOGMA/TWN, OI)KEI/WN O(MOU= KAI\ A)LLOTRI/WN, A)FEIDOU=SAN. @&Diog. Lae%28rt. Zeno 111.$10 DOKEI= DE\ AU)TOI=S TA\ PA/QH KRI/SEIS EI)=NAI, KAQA/ FHSI <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 E)N <20TW=| PERI\ *PAQW=N>20: H(/ TE GA\R FILAR-GURI/A U(PO/LHYI/S E)STI TOU= TO\ A)RGU/RION KALO\N EI)=NAI, KAI\ H( ME/QH DE\ KAI\ H( A)KOLASI/A O(MOI/WS KAI\ TA\ A)/LLA. @1 @&Galenus de locis affectis III 1 ed. Bas. III 270 K. VIII 138.$ TA\ ME\N OU)=N TOIAU=TA LOGIKW/TERA/ PWS E)/FHN EI)=NAI: LOGIKA\ GA\R O)/NTWS E)STI\N O(/SA TH=S XREI/AS E)PE/KEINA PROERXO/MENA TH\N FU/SIN A)QREI= TW=N PRAGMA/TWN, O(POI/A TIS U(PA/RXEI KATA\ TH\N OI)KEI/AN OU)SI/AN: OU(/TWS GOU=N KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 O( FILO/SOFOS E)/GRAYEN PERI\ TW=N TH=S YUXH=S PAQW=N E(\N ME\N TO\ QERAPEUTIKO\N BIBLI/ON, OU(= MA/LISTA XRH/|ZOMEN EI)S TH\N I)/ASIN AU)TW=N, E(/TERA DE\ TRI/A LOGIKA\S E)/XONTA ZHTH/SEIS. @&Galenus de H. et Plat. decr. V 6 [1`171]1 p. 459 M.$ W(S TOU=-TO/ GE KAI\ E)C AU)TW=N W(=N E)/GRAFE *XRU/SIPPOS PERI\ PAQW=N E)/NESTI KATAMA-QEI=N. TETTA/RWN GA\R BIBLI/WN OU(/TW MEGA/LWN AU)TW=| GEGRAMME/NWN, W(/SQ' E(/KASTON EI)=NAI DIPLA/SION TW=N H(METE/RWN, O(/MWS H(MEI=S OU)D' E)N O(/LOIS DU/O TH\N PERI\ TW=N PAQW=N AU)TW=| GNW/MHN E)CHTA/KAMEN & etc. &@Plutarchus de virtute morali cp. 3 p. 441 c.$ *KOINW=S DE\ A(/PAN-TES OU(=TOI [1&scil. Stoici, Aristo, Zeno, Chrysippus$]1 TH\N A)RETH\N TOU= H(GEMONIKOU= TH=S YUXH=S DIA/QESI/N TINA KAI\ DU/NAMIN, GEGENHME/NHN U(PO\ LO/GOU, MA=LLON DE\ LO/GON OU)=SAN AU)TH\N O(MOLOGOU/MENON KAI\ BE/BAION KAI\ A)META/PTWTON, U(POTI/QENTAI: KAI\ NOMI/ZOUSIN OU)K EI)=NAI TO\ PAQHTIKO\N KAI\ A)/LOGON DIAFORA=| TINI KAI\ FU/SEI YUXH=S TOU= LOGIKOU= DIAKEKRIME/NON, A)LLA\ TO\ AU)TO\ TH=S YUXH=S ME/ROS, O(\ DH\ KALOU=SI DIA/NOIAN KAI\ H(GEMONI-KO/N, DIO/LOU TREPO/MENON KAI\ METABA/LLON E)/N TE TOI=S PA/QESI KAI\ TAI=S KATA\ E(/CIN H)\ DIA/QESIN METABOLAI=S, KAKI/AN TE GI/GNESQAI KAI\ A)RETH/N, KAI\ MHDE\N E)/XEIN A)/LOGON E)N E(AUTW=|: LE/GESQAI DE\ A)/LOGON, O(/TAN TW=| PLEO-NA/ZONTI TH=S O(RMH=S, I)SXURW=| GENOME/NW| KAI\ KRATH/SANTI, PRO/S TI TW=N A)TO/PWN PARA\ TO\N AI(ROU=NTA LO/GON E)KFE/RHTAI: KAI\ GA\R TO\ PA/QOS EI)=NAI LO/GON PONHRO\N KAI\ A)KO/LASTON, E)K FAU/LHS KAI\ DIHMARTHME/NHS KRI/SEWS SFODRO/THTA KAI\ R(W/MHN PROSLABOU/SHS. @&Galenus de H et Plat. decr. V 6 [1`168]1 p. 448 M. <21Posido- @1&nius>21 Chrysippi sententiam spectans%10$ "1TO\ DH\ TW=N PAQW=N AI)/TION, TOU-TE/STI TH=S TE A)NOMOLOGI/AS KAI\ TOU= KAKODAI/MONOS BI/OU, TO\ MH\ KATA\ PA=N E(/PESQAI TW=| E)N AU(TW=| DAI/MONI SUGGENEI= TE O)/NTI KAI\ TH\N O(MOI/AN FU/SIN E)/XONTI TW=| TO\N O(/LON KO/SMON DIOIKOU=NTI, TW=| DE\ XEI/RONI KAI\ ZW|W/DEI POTE\ SUNEKKLI/NONTAS FE/RESQAI. <20OI( DE\>20 [1&sc.$ OI( PERI\ *XRU/SIPPON]1 <20TOU=TO PA-RIDO/NTES OU)/TE E)N TOU/TOIS BELTIOU=SI TH\N AI)TI/AN TW=N PAQW=N, OU)/T' E)N TOI=S PERI\ TH=S EU)DAIMONI/AS KAI\ O(MOLOGI/AS O)RQODO-COU=SIN>20. OU) GA\R BLE/POUSIN, O(/TI PRW=TO/N E)STIN E)N AU)TH=| TO\ KATA\ MH-DE\N A)/GESQAI U(PO\ TOU= A)LO/GOU TE KAI\ KAKODAI/MONOS KAI\ A)QE/OU TH=S YUXH=S."2 E)N TOU/TOIS FANERW=S O( *POSEIDW/NIOS E)DI/DACE, PHLI/KON A(MAR-TA/NOUSIN <20OI( PERI\ TO\N *XRU/SIPPON>20, OU) MO/NON E)N TOI=S PERI\ TW=N PAQW=N LOGISMOI=S, A)LLA\ KAI\ PERI\ TOU= TE/LOUS. OU) GA\R W(S E)KEI=NOI LE/-GOUSIN A)LL' W(S O( *PLA/TWN E)DI/DACE, TO\ TH=| FU/SEI ZH=N O(MOLOGOUME/NWS E)STI/N. @&Galenus de H et Plat. decr. IV 1 [1`135]1 p. 334 M.$ <20KATA\ ME\N TO\ PRO/TERON PERI\ YUXH=S>20 BIBLI/ON O( *XRU/SIPPOS OU)X O(/PWS A)NTILE/GEI, MHDEMI/AN EI)=NAI TH=S YUXH=S DU/NAMIN H)\ E)PIQUMHTIKH\N H)\ QU-MOEIDH=, A)LLA\ KAI\ TA\ PAQH/MAT' AU)TW=N E)KDIDA/SKEI KAI\ TO/PON A)PONE/MEI TOU= SW/MATOS E(/NA: KATA\ <20DE\ TA\ PERI\ TW=N PAQW=N>20 A(/PANTA, TA/ TE TRI/A, DI' W(=N E)PISKE/PTETAI TA\ LOGIKA\ PERI\ AU)TW=N ZHTH/MATA, KAI\ PROSE/TI TO\ QERAPEUTIKO/N, O(\ DH\ KAI\ H)QIKO\N E)PIGRA/FOUSI/ TINES, OU)KE/Q' O(MOI/WS EU(-RI/SKETAI GIGNW/SKWN, A)LLA\ TA\ ME\N W(S E)PAMFOTERI/ZWN GRA/FEI, TA\ DE\ W(S MHDEMI/AN H(GOU/MENOS EI)=NAI DU/NAMIN TH=S YUXH=S MH/TE E)PIQUMHTIKH\N MH/TE QUMOEIDH=. KATA\ ME\N GA\R TH\N E)CH/GHSIN TW=N O(RISMW=N TOU= PA/QOUS, E)MFAI/NEI TINA\ DU/NAMIN A)/LOGON E)N TH=| YUXH=| TW=N PAQW=N AI)TI/AN U(PA/RXEIN, W(S O)LI/GON U(/STERON E)PIDEI/CW TH\N R(H=SIN E)CHGHSA/MENOS AU)TOU=: E)N DE\ TOI=S E)FECH=S E)/NQA ZHTEI=, PO/TERA [2KRI/SEIS E)STI\N H)\]2 KRI/SESIN E)PIGI/GNETAI TA\ PA/QH, PROFANW=S A)POXWREI= TH=S *PLA/TWNOS DO/CHS, O(/S G' OU)DE\ TH\N A)RXH\N E)N TH=| DIAIRE/SEI TOU= PROBLH/MATOS H)CI/WSE KAI\ TAU/THS E)PIMNHSQH=NAI. KAI/TOI TOU=TO PRW=TON EU)QU\S E)GKALE/SEIEN A)/N TIS AU)TW=| PARA\ TO\ TH=S DIAIRE/SEWS E)LLIPE\S E)SFALME/NW|. TO\ GA/R TOI PA/QOS, OI(=ON O( E)/RWS, H)/TOI ͈KRI/SIS TI/S E)STIN, H)\ KRI/SESIN E)PIGIGNO/MENON, H)\ KI/NHSIS E)/KFOROS TH=S E)PIQUMHTIKH=S DUNA/MEWS. OU(/TW DE\ KAI\ O( XO/LOS H)/TOI KRI/SIS H)\ E(PO/MENO/N TI TAU/TH| PA/QOS A)/LOGON, H)\ KI/NHSIS SFODRA\ TH=S QUMOEIDOU=S DUNA/MEWS. O( DE/ G' OU)D' OU(/TWS E)GXWROU=N EI)S TRI/A TE/MNESQAI TO\ PRO/BLHMA META-XEIRI/ZETAI TO\N LO/GON <20E)PIDEIKNU/NAI PEIRW/MENOS, W(S A)/MEINON EI)/H KRI/SEIS U(POLAMBA/NEIN AU)TA\ KAI\ OU)K E)PIGINO/MENA/ TINA TAI=S KRI/SESIN>20, E)PILAQO/MENOS W(=N AU)TO\S <20E)N TW=| PROTE/RW| TW=| PERI\ YUXH=S>20 E)/GRAYE, <20TO\N ME\N E)/RWTA TH=S E)PIQUMHTIKH=S EI)=NAI DUNA/MEWS, TO\N DE\ XO/LON TH=S QUMOEIDOU=S>20. @1 @&idem V 1 [1`155 i. f.]1 p. 405 M.$ *XRU/SIPPOS ME\N OU)=N <20E)N TW=| PRW/-TW| PERI\ PAQW=N>20 A)PODEIKNU/NAI PEIRA=TAI, KRI/SEIS TINA\S EI)=NAI TOU= LO-GISTIKOU= TA\ PA/QH, *ZH/NWN D' OU) TA\S KRI/SEIS AU)TA/S, A)LLA\ TA\S E)PIGIG-NOME/NAS AU)TAI=S SUSTOLA\S KAI\ XU/SEIS, E)PA/RSEIS TE KAI\ PTW/SEIS TH=S YUXH=S E)NO/MIZEN EI)=NAI TA\ PA/QH. @&idem V 7 [1`175]1 p. 477 M.$ A)LLA\ KAI\ KATA\ TA\ PERI\ PAQW=N SUG-GRA/MMATA, TA/ TE TRI/A TA\ LOGIKA\ KAI\ TO\ XWRI\S AU)TW=N I)DI/A| GEGRAMME/NON U(P' AU)TOU=, TO\ QERAPEUTIKO/N TE KAI\ H)QIKO\N E)PIGRAFO/MENON. @&Galenus de propriorum animi affectuum curat. 1 Vol. V p. 3 K.$ GE/GRAPTAI ME\N OU)=N <20*XRUSI/PPW|>20 KAI\ A)/LLOIS POLLOI=S TW=N FILOSO/FWN QERAPEUTIKA\ SUGGRA/MMATA TW=N TH=S YUXH=S PAQW=N. @&Galenus de H. et Plat. decr. IV 2 [1`136]1 p. 338 M.$ KAI\ GA\R OU) KATA\ TAU=TA MO/NON AU)TO\S E(AUTW=| DIAFE/RETAI FANERW=S, A)LLA\ KA)PEI-DA\N U(PE\R TW=N KATA\ TO\ PA/QOS O(RISMW=N GRA/FWN A)/LOGO/N TE KAI\ PARA\ FU/SIN KI/NHSIN YUXH=S AU)TO\ FA/SKH| KAI\ PLEONA/ZOUSAN O(RMH/N, EI)=TA TO\ ME\N A)/LOGON E)CHGOU/MENOS TO\ XWRI\S LO/GOU TE KAI\ KRI/SEWS EI)RH=SQAI FA/SKH|, TH=S DE\ PLEONAZOU/SHS O(RMH=S PARA/DEIGMA TOU\S TRE/XONTAS SFO-DRW=S PARALAMBA/NH|: TAUTI\ GA\R A)MFO/TERA MA/XETAI TW=| KRI/SEIS EI)=NAI TA\ PA/QH: EI)SO/MEQA D' E)NARGE/STERON AU)TA\S TA\S R(H/SEIS AU)TOU= PARAGRA/-YANTES: E)/XEI D' H( ME\N E(TE/RA TO/NDE TO\N TRO/PON. @"1$8<20*DEI= DE\ PRW=TON E)NTEQUMH=SQAI, O(/TI TO\ LOGIKO\N ZW=|ON A)KO-LOUQHTIKO\N FU/SEI E)STI\ TW=| LO/GW|, KAI\ KATA\ TO\N LO/GON W(S A)\N H(GEMO/NA PRAKTIKO/N. POLLA/KIS ME/NTOI KAI\ A)/LLWS FE/RETAI E)PI/ TINA KAI\ A)PO/ TINWN, A)PEIQW=S TW=| LO/GW| W)QOU/MENON E)PI\ PLEI=ON, KAQ' H(\N FORA\N A)MFO/TEROI E)/XOUSIN OI( O(/ROI, TH=S PARA\ FU/SIN KINH/SEWS A)LO/GWS OU(/TWS GINOME/NHS KAI\ TOU= E)N TAI=S O(RMAI=S PLEONASMOU=. TO\ GA\R A)/LOGON TOUTI\ LHPTE/ON A)PEIQE\S LO/GW| KAI\ A)PESTRAMME/NON TO\N LO/GON, KAQ' H(\N FORA\N KAI\ E)N TW=| E)/QEI TINA/ FAMEN W)QEI=SQAI KAI\ A)LO/GWS FE/RESQAI A)/NEU LO/GOU KRI/SEWS, OU)XI\ EI) DIHMARTHME/NWS FE/RETAI KAI\ PARIDW/N TI KATA\ TO\N LO/-GON TAU=T' E)PISHMAINO/MEQA, A)LLA\ MA/LISTA KAQ' H(\N U(POGRA/FEI FORA/N, OU) PEFUKO/TOS TOU= LOGIKOU= ZW/|OU KINEI=SQAI OU(/TWS KATA\ TH\N YUXH/N, A)LLA\ KATA\ TO\N LO/GON>20."2$ @*(H ME\N OU)=N E(TE/RA TW=N TOU= *XRUSI/PPOU R(H/SEWN E)CHGOUME/NH TO\N PRO/TERON TW=N O(/RWN TOU= PA/QOUS E)NTAUQOI= TELEUTA=|: TH\N D' U(PO/LOIPON, E)N H(=| TO\N E(/TERON O(/RON E)CHGEI=TAI, GEGRAMME/NHN E)FECH=S TH=|DE <20KATA\ TO\ PRW=TON SU/GGRAMMA PERI\ PAQW=N>20 H)/DH SOI PARAQH/SOMAI. @1 @"1$8<20*KATA\ TOU=TO DE\ KAI\ O( PLEONASMO\S TH=S O(RMH=S EI)/RHTAI, DIA\ TO\ TH\N KAQ' AU(TOU\S KAI\ FUSIKH\N TW=N O(RMW=N SUMMETRI/AN U(PER-BAI/NEIN. GE/NOITO D' A)\N TO\ LEGO/MENON DIA\ TOU/TWN GNWRIMW/TERON. OI(=ON E)PI\ TOU= POREU/ESQAI KAQ' O(RMH\N OU) PLEONA/ZEI H( TW=N SKE-LW=N KI/NHSIS, A)LLA\ SUNAPARTI/ZEI TI TH=| O(RMH=| W(/STE KAI\ STH=NAI, O(/TAN E)QE/LH|, KAI\ METABA/LLEIN. E)PI\ DE\ TW=N TREXO/NTWN KAQ' O(R-MH\N OU)KE/TI TOIOU=TON GI/NETAI, A)LLA\ PLEONA/ZEI PARA\ TH\N O(RMH\N H( TW=N SKELW=N KI/NHSIS, W(/STE E)KFE/RESQAI KAI\ MH\ METABA/LLEIN EU)PEIQW=S OU(/TWS EU)QU\S E)NARCAME/NWN. OI(=S OI)=MAI/ TI PARAPLH/SION KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N O(RMW=N GI/NESQAI DIA\ TO\ TH\N KATA\ LO/GON U(PERBAI/-NEIN SUMMETRI/AN, W(/SQ' O(/TAN O(RMA=| MH\ EU)PEIQW=S E)/XEIN PRO\S AU)-TO/N, E)PI\ ME\N TOU= DRO/MOU TOU= PLEONASMOU= LEGOME/NOU PARA\ TH\N O(RMH/N, E)PI\ DE\ TH=S O(RMH=S PARA\ TO\N LO/GON. SUMMETRI/A GA/R E)STI FUSIKH=S O(RMH=S H( KATA\ TO\N LO/GON, KAI\ E(/WS TOSOU/TOU [KAI\] E(/WS AU)TO\S A)CIOI=. DIO\ DH\ KAI\ TH=S U(PERBA/SEWS KATA\ TOU=TO KAI\ OU(/-TWS GINOME/NHS PLEONA/ZOUSA/ TE O(RMH\ LE/GETAI EI)=NAI KAI\ PARA\ FU/SIN KAI\ A)/LOGOS KI/NHSIS YUXH=S>20."2$ @*AI( ME\N TOU= *XRUSI/PPOU R(H/SEIS AU(=TAI. &Similia$ <20E)N TW=| PERI\ PA-QW=N H)QIKW=|>20 &exstitisse testatur Gal. IV 5 [1`144]1 p. 365 M. &@Has affectus definitiones Galenus probare studet cum Platonis &decretis congruere. Ad intellegenda Chr. verba utilia haecce%10$ E)PEIDH\ GA\R H)PI/STATO DU/O SHMAINO/MENA PRO\S TH=S "1A)/LOGOS"2 FWNH=S, W(=N TO\ E(/TERON BOU/LETAI MO/NON DHLOU=SQAI KATA\ TO\N O(/RON, TO\ XWRI\S KRI/SEWS, O)RQW=S E)POI/HSE MHDEMI/AN U(POLIPO/MENOS A)MFIBOLI/AN, A)LL' AU)TO\S DHLW/SAS, O(/TI TH\N KATA\ TO\ PA/QOS O(RMH\N A)/LOGON EI)=NAI/ FHSI, KAQ' O(/SON A)PE/STRAPTAI TO\N LO/GON KAI\ A)PEIQEI= TW=| LO/GW| KAI\ XWRI\S KRI/SEWS GI/NETAI. DIA\ ME\N OU)=N TOU= A)PESTRA/FQAI FA/NAI TO\N LO/GON E)XW/RISE TH\N KATA\ TO\ PA/QOS A)/LOGON KI/NHSIN TW=N A)YU/XWN TE KAI\ TW=N A)LO/GWN ZW/|WN. __E)K ME\N DH\ TW=N TOIOU/TWN DEI/KNUTAI TO\ MH/T' A)YU/XW| TINI\ MH/T' A)LO/GW| ZW/W| PA/QOS E)GGI/-NESQAI YUXIKO/N. E)PEIDA\N DE\ GRA/FH|, XWRI\S LO/GOU KAI\ KRI/SEWS GI/GNE-SQAI TH\N KATA\ TO\ PA/QOS KI/NHSIN, EI)=TA SUNA/PTWN E)FECH=S LE/GH|, "1OU)XI\ EI) DIHMARTHME/NWS FE/RETAI KAI\ PARIDW/N TI KATA\ TO\N LO/GON"2, KAI\ "1A)PESTRAMME/NWS TE KAI\ A)PEIQW=S AU)TW=|"2, DIORI/ZEI TW=N A(MARTHMA/TWN TA\ PA/QH KAI\ PA/NU DEO/NTWS. TA\ ME\N GA\R A(MARTH/MATA MOXQHRAI\ KRI/-SEIS EI)SI/, KAI\ [O(] LO/GOS E)YEUSME/NOS TH=S A)LHQEI/AS KAI\ DIHMARTHME/NOS. TO\ DE\ PA/QOS_A)PEIQH/S E)STI TW=| LO/GW| KI/NHSIS YUXH=S. @&ibid. cp. 3 [1`139]1 p. 349 Mu+. Gal. ideo potissimum Chrys. vitu- @1&perandum iudicat$ O(/TI MH/TE E)PEXEI/RHSEN O(/LWS TA\ PRO\S TW=N PALAIW=N EI)RHME/NA DIALU/SASQAI KAI\ PRO\S AU(TO\N DIAFE/RETAI, NUNI\ ME\N GI/NESQAI NOMI/ZWN TA\ PA/QH A)/NEU LO/GOU KAI\ KRI/SEWS, NUNI\ D' OU) MO/NON KRI/SESIN E(/PESQAI FA/SKWN, A)LL' AU)TO\ DH\ TOU=TO KRI/SEIS EI)=NAI. TO\ GA\R MHD' O(/LWS E)FA/PTESQAI KRI/SEWS E)NANTIW/TATON DH/POU TW=| KRI/SIN EI)=NAI TO\ PA/-QOS, EI) MH/, NH\ *DI/A, BOHQW=N TIS AU)TW=| FAI/H, PLEI/W SHMAI/NEIN TO\ TH=S KRI/SEWS O)/NOMA, KAI\ KATA\ ME\N TH\N E)CH/GHSIN TOU= O(/ROU TH\N OI(=ON "1PERI/SKEYIN"2 EI)RH=SQAI KRI/SIN, W(S EI)=NAI TO\ A)/NEU KRI/SEWS I)/SON TW=| A)/NEU PERISKE/YEWS, E)/NQA DE\ KRI/SEIS EI)=NAI/ FHSI TA\ PA/QH, TA\S O(RMA/S TE KAI\ TA\S SUGKATAQE/SEIS O)NOMA/ZESQAI KRI/SEIS. A)LL' EI)/PER TOU=TO/ TIS DE/CAITO, PLEONA/ZOUSA SUGKATA/QESIS E)/STAI TO\ PA/QOS, KAI\ PA/LIN O( *POSEIDW/NIOS E)RH/SETAI TH\N AI)TI/AN, U(F' H(=S PLEONA/ZETAI, PRO\S TW=| KAI\ ME/GISTON A(MA/R-THMA KATA\ TH\N DIDASKALI/AN H(MARTH=SQAI TW=| *XRUSI/PPW|. EI) GA\R E)N AU)TW=| DH\ TOU/TW| TO\ KU=ROS TOU= DO/GMATO/S E)STIN, E)N TW=| DIASTEI/LASQAI TH\N O(MWNUMI/AN KAI\ DEI=CAI, KATA\ TI/ ME\N SHMAINO/MENON A)/NEU KRI/SEWS GI/NETAI TA\ PA/QH, KATA\ TI/ DE\ KRI/SEIS EI)SI/N, O( D' OU)DE\ KAQ' E(\N TW=N TETTA/RWN BIBLI/WN, A(\ PERI\ TW=N PAQW=N E)/GRAYEN, E)POI/HSEN AU)TO/, PW=S OU)K A)/N TIS AU)TO\N DIKAI/WS ME/MYAITO. @&ibid. cp. 4[1`140]1 p. 353 M. Gal. dicit absurdum esse%10$ E)PEIDA\N A)PEIQW=S TE KAI\ A)PESTRAMME/NWS TOU= LO/GOU [1&sc.$ LE/GH| TA\ PA/QH GI/NESQAI]1 TO\ MH-DEMI/AN E)PIZHTEI=N E(TE/RAN E)N TH=| YUXH=| DU/NAMIN, H(=S KINOUME/NHS A)PEIQW=S TW=| LO/GW| GI/GNESQAI TA\ PA/QH: <20MHDE\ GA\R EI)=NAI/ TINA TOIAU/THN>20, W(S E)/NIOI TW=N FILOSO/FWN U(POLAMBA/NOUSIN, <20E)PIQUMHTIKH/N TE KAI\ QU-MOEIDH= PROSAGOREU/ONTES, TO\ O(/LON GA\R EI)=NAI TO\ TW=N A)NQRW/-PWN H(GEMONIKO\N LOGIKO/N>20. @&Galenus de H. et Plat. decr. IV 2 [1`135]1 p. 336 M.$ KATA\ TO\N AU)TO\N TRO/PON <20E)N TOI=S O(RISMOI=S TW=N GENIKW=N PAQW=N>20, OU(\S PRW/-TOUS E)CE/QETO, TELE/WS A)POXWREI= TH=S GNW/MHS AU)TW=N [1&sc.$ TW=N PALAIW=N]1, τ"1<20TH\N LU/PHN O(RIZO/MENOS DO/CAN PRO/SFATON KAKOU= PAROUSI/AS, TO\N DE\ FO/BON PROSDOKI/AN KAKOU=, TH\N D' H(DONH\N DO/CAN PRO/S-FATON A)GAQOU= PAROUSI/AS>20."2 A)/NTIKRUS GA\R E)N TOU/TOIS TOU= LOGISTI-KOU= TH=S YUXH=S MO/NOU ME/MNHTAI, PARALEI/PWN TO/ T' E)PIQUMHTIKO\N KAI\ TO\ QUMOEIDE/S. "1<20*KAI\ GA\R TH\N DO/CAN KAI\ TH\N PROSDOKI/AN E)N TW=| LOGISTIKW=| MO/NW| SUNI/STASQAI NOMI/ZEI>20."2 *KATA\ ME/NTOI <20TO\N TH=S E)PIQUMI/AS O(/RON, H(\N O)/RECIN A)/LOGON EI)=NAI/ FHSIN>20, E)FA/PTETAI ME/N PWS O(/SON E)PI\ TH=| LE/CEI TH=S A)LO/GOU KATA\ TH\N YUXH\N DUNA/MEWS, A)PO-XWREI= DE\ KA)NTAU=QA KATA\ TH\N E)CH/GHSIN AU)TH=S, EI)/ GE KAI\ H( <20O)/RECIS>20, H(\N KATA\ TO\N O(RISMO\N PARE/LABE, TH=S LOGIKH=S E)STI DUNA/MEWS. <20O(RI/ZETAI GOU=N AU)TH\N O(RMH\N LOGIKH\N E)PI/ TI O(/SON XRH\ H(=DON>20. E)N ME/NTOI @1 DH\ TOU/TOIS TOI=S O(/ROIS O(RMA\S KAI\ DO/CAS KAI\ KRI/SEIS U(PA/RXEIN OI)/ETAI TA\ PA/QH, KATA\ DE/ TINAS TW=N E(CH=S *)EPIKOU/RW| KAI\ *ZH/NWNI MA=LLON H)\ TOI=S E(AUTOU= DO/GMASIN A)KO/LOUQA GRA/FEI. <20TH/N TE GA\R LU/PHN O(RI-ZO/MENOS MEI/WSIN EI)=NAI/ FHSIN E)PI\ FEUKTW=| DOKOU=NTI U(PA/R-XEIN, TH/N Q' H(DONH\N E)/PARSIN E)F' AI(RETW=| DOKOU=NTI U(PA/RXEIN>20. KAI\ GA\R AI( MEIW/SEIS KAI\ AI( E)PA/RSEIS KAI\ AI( SUSTOLAI\ KAI\ AI( DIAXU/SEIS [1KAI\ GA\R TOU/TWN E)NI/OTE ME/MNHTAI]1 TH=S A)LO/GOU DUNA/MEW/S E)STI PAQH/-MATA TAI=S DO/CAIS E)PIGIGNO/MENA. TOIAU/THN DE/ TINA TH\N OU)SI/AN TW=N PAQW=N *)EPI/KOUROS KAI\ *ZH/NWN, OU)K AU)TO\S U(POLAMBA/NEI. O(\ KAI\ QAU-MA/ZEIN E)PE/RXETAI/ MOI TA)NDRO/S, E)N E)PAGGELI/A| LOGIKH=S TE A(/MA KAI\ A)KRI-BOU=S DIDASKALI/AS OU)K A)KRIBOU=NTOS. @&Galenus de H. et Plat. decr. IV 4 [1`139]1 p. 351 Mu+.$ *PERI\ DE\ TOU= MH\ FRONTI/ZEIN TH=S PRO\S E(AUTO\N E)NANTIOLOGI/AS AU)TO\N E)/XWN E)/TI MURI/A LE/GEIN, A(\ TA/X' A)\N KAI\ U(/STERON, EI) MAKROTE/RAS E)PILABOI/MHN SXO-LH=S, EI)S MI/AN A)QROI/SAIMI PRAGMATEI/AN A(/PANTA, PARALIPW\N TA)/LLA MO/-NWN TW=N OI)KEI/WN TOI=S NU=N PROKEIME/NOIS MNHMONEU/SW. <20TH\N TOI/NUN E)PIQUMI/AN E)N TW=| PRW/TW| PERI\ PAQW=N O(RISA/MENOS O)/RECIN A)/LO-GON>20, AU)TH\N PA/LIN TH\N <20O)/RECIN E)N E(/KTW| TW=N KATA\ GE/NOS O(/RWN O(RMH\N LOGIKH\N EI)=NAI/ FHSIN E)PI/ TI, O(/SON XRH/, H(=DON AU)TW=|>20. OU(/TW DE\ AU)TH\N O(RI/ZETAI <20KA)N TOI=S PERI\ TH=S O(RMH=S>20. @&Ad primam sententiam confer Gal. V 1 p. 407 M.%10$ TO\ DE\ MHDE\ A(/PER U(PE/QENTO DU/NASQAI DIAFULA/TTEIN, A)LL' E)NANTI/A GRA/FEIN AU)TW=N, A)GUMNA/STWN PERI\ LO/GON A)NQRW/PWN, OI(=O/S PER KAI\ O( QAUMASIW/TATOS *XRU/SIPPOS E)N PAMPO/LLAIS EU(RI/SKETAI PRAGMATEI/AIS. A)LLA\ PERI\ ME\N TW=N A)/LLWN E(TE/RWQI. @&Galenus de H. et Plat. decr. V 2 [1`156]1 p. 407 Mu+.$ TO\ PA/-QOS TH=S YUXH=S KI/NHSI/N TINA PARA\ FU/SIN A)/LOGON U(PA/RXEIN, OU)X OI( PALAIOI\ MO/NON, A)LLA\ KAI\ *XRU/SIPPOS O(MOLOGEI=. KAI\ ME\N DH\ W(S H( KI/-NHSIS AU(/TH TAI=S TW=N A)STEI/WN OU)K E)GGI/NETAI YUXAI=S, W(MOLO/GHTAI PAR' A)MFOI=N. O(POI/A DE\ TI/S E)STIN H( TW=N FAU/LWN YUXH\ KATA/ TE TA\ PA/QH KAI\ PRO\ TW=N PAQW=N, OU)K E)/Q' O(MOI/WS E)CHGOU=NTAI. *XRU/SIPPOS ME\N GA\R <20A)NA/LOGON E)/XEIN AU)TH/N FHSI TOI=S E)PITHDEI/OIS SW/MASIN EI)S PURETOU\S E)MPI/PTEIN H)\ DIAR)R(OI/AS H)/ TI TOIOU=TON E(/TERON E)PI\ SMIKRA=| KAI\ TUXOU/SH| PROFA/SEI>20. @*XRU/SIPPOS D' A)TOPW/TERON E)/TI [1&sc.$ TOU= *POSEIDWNI/OU]1, MHD' E)N TAI=S PERIODIKAI=S TISI NO/SOIS KAQESTW=SI, OI(ONEI\ TRITAI/WN H)\ TETARTAI/WN PURETW=N, W(MOIW=SQAI SUGXWRW=N TH\N NO/SON TH=S YUXH=S: GRA/FEI GOU=N W(=DE: @1 @"1$8<20*(UPONOHTE/ON TOI/NUN, TH\N ME\N TH=S YUXH=S NO/SON O(MOIOTA/-THN EI)=NAI TH=| TOU= SW/MATOS PURETW/DEI KATASTA/SEI, KAQ' H(\N OU) PERIODIKW=S A)LL' A)TA/KTWS PURETOI\ KAI\ FRI=KAI GI/NONTAI, KAI\ A)/LLWS A)PO\ TH=S DIAQE/SEWS KAI\ MIKRW=N E)PIGINOME/NWN AI)TI/WN>20."2 @OU)K OI)=DA TI/ POTE DO/CAN AU)TW=| TOU\S ME\N E(TOI/MWS E)/XONTAS PRO\S TO\ NOSH=SAI NOSEI=N H)/DH FHSI/, TOU\S D' H)/DH NOSOU=NTAS OU)D' O(/LWS NOSEI=N. @&Galenus de H. et Plat. decr. IV 7 [1`152]1 p. 394 Mu+. ex Posi-&donio%10$ O(/TI D' E)N TW=| XRO/NW| MALA/TTETAI TA\ PA/QH, KA)\N AI( DO/CAI ME/NWSI TOU= KAKO/N TI AU)TOI=S GEGONE/NAI, KAI\ O( *XRU/SIPPOS <20E)N TW=| DEUTE/RW| PERI\ PAQW=N>20 MARTUREI=, GRA/FWN W(=DE: @"1$8<20*ZHTH/SAI D' A)/N TIS KAI\ PERI\ TH=S A)NE/SEWS TH=S LU/PHS, PW=S GI/NETAI, PO/TERON DO/CHS TINO\S METAKINOUME/NHS, H)\ PASW=N DIA-MENOUSW=N, KAI\ DIA\ TI/ TOU=T' E)/STAI>20."2 [1&cf. p. 455, 2 M.$8 TH\N AI)TI/AN A)PODI/DWSIN, U(PE\R H(=S O( *XRU/SIPPOS E)N TW=| DEUTE/RW| PAQW=N A)POREI=N W(MOLO/GHSEN]1. @EI)=T' E)PIFE/RWN FHSI/: @"1$8<20*DOKEI= DE/ MOI H( ME\N TOIAU/TH DO/CA DIAME/NEIN, O(/TI KAKO\N AU)TO/, O(\ DH\ PA/RESTIN, E)GXRONIZOME/NHS D' A)NI/ESQAI H( SUSTOLH\ KAI/, W(S OI)=MAI, H( E)PI\ TH\N SUSTOLH\N O(RMH/. TUXO\N DE\ KAI\ TAU/-THS DIAMENOU/SHS, OU)X U(PAKOU/SETAI TA\ E(CH=S, DIA\ POIA\N A)/LLHN E)PIGINOME/NHN DIA/QESIN A)SULLO/GISTON TOU/TWN GINOME/NWN. OU(/-TW GA\R KAI\ KLAI/ONTES PAU/ONTAI KAI\ MH\ BOULO/MENOI KLAI/EIN KLAI/OUSIN, O(/TAN [MH\] O(MOI/AS TA\S FANTASI/AS TA\ U(POKEI/MENA POIH=| KAI\ E)NI/STHTAI/ TI H)\ MHDE/N. O(\N TRO/PON GA\R H( QRH/NWN PAU=SIS GI/NETAI KAI\ KLAUQMW=N, TOIAU=TA EU)/LOGON KAI\ E)P' E)KEI/NWN SUN-TUGXA/NEIN, E)N TAI=S A)RXAI=S MA=LLON TW=N PRAGMA/TWN KINOU/NTWN, KAQA/PER E)PI\ TW=N TO\N GE/LWTA KINOU/NTWN GI/NESQAI E)/FHN, KAI\ TA\ O(/MOIA TOU/TOIS>20."2$ @O(/TI ME\N OU)=N TW=| XRO/NW| PAU/ETAI TA\ PA/QH, KAI/TOI TH=S DO/CHS DIA- @1MENOU/SHS, AU)TO\S O( *XRU/SIPPOS O(MOLOGEI=: DIA\ TI/NA ME/NTOI TH\N AI)TI/AN TOU=TO GI/NETAI, DUSLO/GISTON EI)=NAI/ FHSIN. EI)=Q' E(CH=S E(/TERA PARAPLHSI/WS GINO/MENA GRA/FEI, PERI\ W(=N OU)D' AU)TW=N DHLONO/TI TH\N AI)TI/AN E)PAGGE/L-LETAI GINW/SKEIN. __SU\ D'__OI)/EI LELU/SQAI TO\ ZHTOU/MENON, A)\N O(MOLOGH/SH|S A)GNOEI=N TH\N AI)TI/AN. KAI/TOI TO/ GE SUNE/XON O(/LHN TH\N PRAG-MATEI/AN TH/N TE TW=N LOGIKW=N ZHTHMA/TWN KAI\ TH\N QERAPEUTIKH\N TW=N PAQW=N OU)DE\N A)/LLO E)STI/N, H)\ TO\ TA\S AI)TI/AS E)CEUREI=N, U(F' W(=N GI/NETAI/ TE KAI\ PAU/ETAI TA\ PA/QH. OU(/TW GA\R A)/N TIS, OI)=MAI, KAI\ TH\N GE/NESIN AU)-TW=N KWLU/SEIE KAI\ GENOME/NAS PAU=SAI DUNHQEI/H. SUNANAIREI=SQAI GA\R EU)/LOGON OI)=MAI TAI=S AI)TI/AIS TA/S TE GENE/SEIS KAI\ TA\S U(PA/RCEIS TW=N PRAGMA/TWN. TAU=TA/ TOI KAI\ A)POREI=S KATA\ TO\ PERI\ TW=N PAQW=N BIBLI/ON TI KAI\ GRA/YAI TOIOU=TON H(MI=N, W(=| PROSE/XONTES TO\N NOU=N KWLU/SOME/N TE TW=N PAQW=N E(/KASTON GI/NESQAI KAI\ GENO/MENON I)ASO/MEQA& etc. @&Galenus de H. et Plat. decr. IV 7 [1`152]1 p. 397 Mu+. de Posi-&donio%10$ PROSXRH=TAI D' EI)S TOU=TO [1&sc.$ U(PO\ QUMOU= KAI\ E)PIQUMI/AS GI/GNE-SQAI TA\ PA/QH]1 MA/RTURI KAI\ AU)TW=| TW=| *XRUSI/PPW| <20KATA\ TO\ DEU/TERON PERI\ TW=N PAQW=N>20 W(=DE/ PWS GRA/FONTI: @"1$8<20*PERI\ DE\ TH=S LU/PHS [KAI\] W(S A)\N E)MPLHSQE/NTES TINE\S O(MOI/WS FAI/NONTAI A)FI/STASQAI, KAQA/PER KAI\ E)PI\ *)AXILLE/WS TAU=TA LE/-GEI O( POIHTH\S PENQOU=NTOS TO\N *PA/TROKLON:$ [1D& 541.$ *W& 514$]1 @*)ALL' O(/TE DH\ KLAI/WN TE KULINDO/MENO/S T' E)KORE/SQH, @*KAI/ OI( A)PO\ PRAPI/DWN H)=LQ' I(/MEROS H)D' A)PO\ GUI/WN, E)PI\ TO\ PARAKALEI=N W(/RMHSE TO\N *PRI/AMON, TH\N TH=S LU/PHS A)LO-GI/AN AU)TW=| PARISTA/S>20."2 @EI)=T' E)FECH=S E)PIFE/REI KAI\ TAU=TA: @"1<20*KAQ' O(\N LO/GON OU)K A)\N A)PELPI/SAI TIS OU(/TWS TW=N PRAGMA/-TWN E)GXRONIZOME/NWN, KAI\ TH=S PAQHTIKH=S FLEGMONH=S A)NIEME/NHS, TO\N LO/GON PAREISDUO/MENON KAI\ OI(ONEI\ XW/RAN LAMBA/NONTA PARISTA/NAI TH\N TOU= PA/QOUS A)LOGI/AN>20."2 @E)NARGW=S GA\R E)N TOU/TOIS O( *XRU/SIPPOS O(MOLOGEI=, TH/N TE PAQHTI-KH\N FLEGMONH\N A)NI/ESQAI KATA\ TO\N XRO/NON, E)/TI TH=S U(POLH/YEW/S TE KAI\ DO/CHS MENOU/SHS, E)MPI/PLASQAI/ TE TW=N PAQHTIKW=N KINH/SEWN TOU\S A)NQRW/-POUS, KAI\ DIA\ TOU=TO PAU=LA/N TINA LAMBA/NONTOS TOU= PA/QOUS KAI\ H(SU-XA/SANTOS, TO\N LO/GON E)PIKRATE/STERON GI/NESQAI. TAU=TA GA\R A)LHQH= ME/N E)STIN, EI)/PER TINA\ KAI\ A)/LLA, MA/XETAI DE\ TAI=S U(POQE/SESIN AU)TOU=, KAQA/PER KAI\ TA\ E)PIFERO/MENA TO/NDE TO\N TRO/PON E)/XONTA. @1 @"1$8<20*LE/GETAI DE\ KAI\ TOIAU=TA EI)S TH\N METABOLH\N TW=N PAQW=N>20: [1D& 103$]1 @__<20LAIYHRO\S DE\ KO/ROS STUGEROI=O GO/OIO. ӈKAI\ E)/TI TA\ TOIAU=TA EI)S TO\ KATA\ TH\N LU/PHN A)GWGO/N>20 [1&Eur. fr. 576N$]1 @__<20TOI=S DE\ DUSTUXOU=SI/ PWS @*TERPNO\N TO\ KLAU=SAI KA)PODU/RASQAI TU/XAS. KAI\ E)/TI TOU/TWN E)FECH=S>20: [1D& 113$%1]1 @<20*(WS FA/TO: TOI=SI DE\ PA=SIN U(F' I(/MERON W)=RSE GO/OIO. KAI/>20: [1&Eur. El. 125. 126$]1 @<20*TO\N AU)TO\N A)NE/GEIRE GO/ON, A)/NAGE POLU/DAKRUN A)HDO/NA.>20"2$ @E)/STI DE\ A)ME/LEI PA/MPOLLA KAI\ A)/LLA TOIAU=TA PARA\ TW=N POIHTW=N A)QROI=SAI MARTU/RIA TOU= KAI\ LU/PHS KAI\ DAKRU/WN KAI\ KLAUQMW=N KAI\ QRH/NOU KAI\ NI/KHS KAI\ TIMH=S KAI\ PA/NTWN [TE] TW=N TOIOU/TWN E)MPI/PLA-SQAI TOU\S A)NQRW/POUS, E)F' OI(=S OU)DE\N XALEPO/N E)STI SULLOGI/ZESQAI TH\N AI)TI/AN, DI' H(\N E)N TW=| XRO/NW| PAU/ETAI ME\N TA\ PA/QH, KRATEI= DE\ TW=N O(R-MW=N O( LO/GOS. W(S GA\R E)FI/ETAI TO\ PAQHTIKO\N TH=S YUXH=S OI)KEI/WN TI-NW=N O)REKTW=N, OU(/TWS KAI\ TUGXANO/NTWN AU)TW=N E)MPI/PLATAI, KA)\N TOU/TW| TH\N E(AUTW=N KI/NHSIN KAQI/STHSIN, H(/TIS E)KRA/TEI TH=S O(RMH=S TOU= ZW/|OU KAI\ KAQ' E(AUTH\N H)=GEN E)F' O(/TI PARH/GETO. @&Plutarchus de virtute morali cp. 10 p. 449d.$ *)/ISA TOI/NUN TA\ A(MARTH/MATA PA/NTA KAI\ PA/SAS TIQE/MENOI TA\S A(MARTI/AS, EI) ME\N A)/LLH| PH| PARORW=SI TO\ A)LHQE\S OU)K E)/STI KAIRO\S E)N TW=| PARO/NTI DIELE/GXEIN, E)N DE\ TOI=S PLEI/OSI FAI/NONTAI KOMIDH=| PARA\ TH\N E)NA/RGEIAN E)NISTA/MENOI TW=| LO/GW|. PA=N ME\N GA\R PA/QOS A(MARTI/A KAT' AU)TOU/S E)STI KAI\ PA=S O( LU-POU/MENOS H)\ FOBOU/MENOS H)\ E)PIQUMW=N A(MARTA/NEI. MEGA/LAI DE\ TW=N PA-QW=N DIAFORAI\ KATA\ TO\ MA=LLON KAI\ TO\ H(=TTON O(RW=NTAI____ TAU=TA TOI/NUN KAI\ TA\ TOIAU=TA DIAKROUO/MENOI "1<20TA\S E)PITA/SEIS TW=N PAQW=N KAI\ TA\S SFODRO/THTAS OU)/ FASI GI/GNESQAI KATA\ TH\N KRI/SIN, E)N H(=| TO\ A(MARTHTIKO/N, A)LLA\ TA\S DH/CEIS KAI\ TA\S SUSTO-LA\S KAI\ TA\S DIAXU/SEIS EI)=NAI TA\S TO\ MA=LLON KAI\ TO\ H(=TTON TW=| LO/GW| DEXOME/NAS>20."2 @&p. 450b.$ E)KEI=NO D' E)K TOU/TOU LHPTE/ON, O(/TI SUGXWROU=SI KAI\ AU)TOI\ TH=S KRI/SEWS E(/TERON EI)=NAI TO\ A)/LOGON, <20KAQ' O(/ FASI GI/GNESQAI TO\ PA/QOS SFODRO/TERON KAI\ MEI=ZON>20, E)RI/ZONTES PRO\S TOU)/NOMA KAI\ TO\ R(H=MA, TA\ DE\ PRA/GMATA DIDO/NTES TOI=S DIAFE/REIN TO\ PAQHTIKO\N KAI\ A)/LO-GON TOU= LOGIZOME/NOU KAI\ KRI/NONTOS A)POFAINOME/NOIS. @&10Galenus$10 PERI\ T. T. YUXH=S H)QW=N&10 ed. Bas. I 351 K. p. 820.$10 DIA\ @1 TOU=TO [1&10scil. Posidonius]1$10 KATA/ GE TH\N PERI\ TW=N PAQW=N PRAGMATEI/AN E)NANTIW/-TATA FRONEI= *XRUSI/PPW| KAI\ E)N TW=| PERI\ TH=S DIAFORA=S TW=N A)RETW=N, POLLA\ ME\N W(=N EI)=PE *XRU/SIPPOS E)N TOI=S LOGIKW=S ZHTOUME/NOIS PERI\ TW=N PAQW=N TH=S YUXH=S MEMYA/MENOS, E)/TI DE\ PLEI/W TW=N E)N TOI=S PERI\ DIAFORW=N TW=N A)RETW=N. @&Philodemus$ PERI\ O)RGH=S &Col. I [1p. 17 Gomp.$]1. EI) ME\N OU)=N E)PETI/MA TOI=S YE/GOUSI MO/NON, A)/LLO DE\ MHDE\ E(\N POIOU=SIN H)\ % BA!!LWS % *BI/WN E)N TW=| PERI\ TH=S O)RGH=S KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS E)N T[1W=]1I PE[1RI\]1 PAQW=N [1QE]1R[1A]1PEU[1TI]1KW=|>20, KA)\N METRI/WS I(/STATO. @&Galenus de H. et Plat. decr. V 2 [1`158]1 p. 413 Mu+.$ A)LLA/, NH\ *DI/A, FH/SEI TIS I)/SWS TW=N *STWI+KW=N, W(/SPER OU)=N KAI\ LE/GOUSIN, OU) TH\N AU)TH\N A)NALOGI/AN EI)=NAI TH=| YUXH=| PRO\S TO\ SW=MA KATA/ TE TA\ PA/QH KAI\ TA\ NOSH/MATA KAI\ TH\N U(GI/EIAN. &At, Galenus inquit, Chrysippus &ipse hanc corporis et animi analogiam instituit.$ TI/ DE\ *XRU/SIPPOS <20E)N TW=| PERI\ PAQW=N H)QIKW=|>20 GRA/FEI TAUTI/; @"1<20*OU)/TE GA\R PERI\ TO\ NOSOU=N SW=MA/ E)STI/ TIS TE/XNH, H(\N PROS-AGOREU/OMEN I)ATRIKH/N, OU)XI\ DE\ KAI\ PERI\ TH\N NOSOU=SAN YUXH\N E)STI/ TIS TE/XNH, OU)/T' E)N TH=| KATA\ ME/ROS QEWRI/A| TE KAI\ QERAPEI/A| DEI= LEI/PESQAI TAU/THN E)KEI/NHS. DIO\ KAI/, KAQA/PER TW=| PERI\ TA\ SW/MATA I)ATRW=| KAQH/KEI TW=N TE SUMBAINO/NTWN AU)TOI=S PAQW=N E)N-TO\S EI)=NAI, W(S EI)W/QASI TOU=TO LE/GEIN, KAI\ TH=S E(KA/STW| OI)KEI/AS QERAPEI/AS, OU(/TW KAI\ TW=| TH=S YUXH=S I)ATRW=| E)PIBA/LLEI, A)MFO-TE/RWN TOU/TWN E)NTO\S EI)=NAI, W(S E)/NI A)/RISTA. KAI\ O(/TI OU(/TWS E)/XEI, MA/QOI A)/N TIS TH=S PRO\S TAU=TA A)NALOGI/AS PARATEQEI/SHS A)P' A)R-XH=S. H( GA\R PRO\S TAU=TA A)NTIPARATEI/NOUSA OI)KEIO/THS PARASTH/-SEI, W(S OI)/OMAI, KAI\ TH\N TW=N QERAPEIW=N O(MOIO/THTA, KAI\ E)/TI TH\N A)MFOTE/RWN TW=N I)ATREIW=N PRO\S A)LLH/LAS A)NALOGI/AN>20."2$ @O(/TI ME\N OU)=N A)NALOGI/AN TINA\ BOU/LONTAI EI)=NAI TW=N E)N TH=| YUXH=| TOI=S KATA\ TO\ SW=MA, DH=LON OI)=MAI GEGONE/NAI, KAI\ OU) MO/NON GE DIA\ TH=S PROGEGRAMME/NHS R(H/SEWS, A)LLA\ KAI\ DI' W(=N E)FECH=S GRA/FEI, TO/NDE TO\N TRO/PON E)XO/NTWN: @"1<20*KAQA/PER GA\R KAI\ E)PI\ TOU= SW/MATOS QEWREI=TAI I)SXU/S TE KAI\ A)SQE/NEIA, EU)TONI/A KAI\ A)TONI/A [KAI\ TO/NOS], PRO\S DE\ TOU/TOIS U(GI/EIA/ TE KAI\ NO/SOS, EU)ECI/A TE KAI\ KAXECI/A>20,"2 KAI\ TA)/LLA O(/SA TOU/-TOIS E(CH=S KATALE/GEI PA/QH TE KAI\ A)R)R(WSTH/MATA KAI\ NOSH/MATA, "1<20KATA\ TO\N AU)TO/N, FHSI/, TRO/PON A)NA/LOGO/N TINA PA=SI TOU/TOIS KAI\ E)N YUXH=| LOGIKH=| SUNI/STATAI/ TE KAI\ O)NOMA/ZETAI>20."2 @EI)=Q' E(CH=S E)PIFE/RWN FHSI/N "1<20*(WS OI)/OMAI, A)PO\ TH=S TOIAU/THS A)NA-LOGI/AS TE KAI\ O(MOIO/THTOS KAI\ TH=S E)N AU)TOI=S SUNWNUMI/AS GEGE-NHME/NHS. *KAI\ GA\R KAI\ KATA\ YUXH/N TINAS LE/GOMEN I)SXU/EIN KAI\ @1 A)SQENEI=N KAI\ EU)TO/NOUS KAI\ A)TO/NOUS EI)=NAI, KAI\ E)/TI NOSEI=N KAI\ U(GIAI/NEIN, OU(/TW PWS KAI\ TOU= PA/QOUS KAI\ TOU= KAT' AU)TH\N A)R)-R(WSTH/MATOS LEGOME/NOU KAI\ TW=N TOU/TOIS PARAPLHSI/WN>20."2 @&His verbis dicit Galenus Chrysippum analogiam statuisse quae &inter synonymas et corporis et animi condiciones intercedat%10$ "1<20KAI\ GA\R TOU)/NOMA KAI\ TO\N LO/GON AU)TW=N EI)=NAI TO\N AU)TO/N, EI)/ GE DH\ SUNW/NUMA/ FHSIN U(PA/RXEIN AU)TA/.>20"2 __O(/TI ME\N OU)=N PRO/KEITAI TW=| *XRUSI/PPW| A)NALOGI/AN A(/PASAN E)CHGEI=SQAI/ TE KAI\ FULA/TTEIN, E)K TOU/TWN DH=LON. EI) DE\ E)PIXEIRH/SAS AU)TO\ POIEI=N, OU) TUGXA/NEI TOU= PROTEQE/NTOS, OU)K A)POSTATE/ON E)STI\ TH=S O(MOIO/THTOS, A)LLA\& 416 Mu+.$ TH=| DIDASKALI/A| MEMPTE/ON, W(S OU)K A)LHQEI=. TOU=TO D' OU)DE\N H(=TTON AU)TW=| KAI\ KATA\ TO\N E)FECH=S U(PA/RXEI LO/GON A(/PANTA TO\N E)N TW=| PERI\ PAQW=N H)QIKW=|. GRA/FEI GOU=N W(=DE: @"1$8<20*DIO\ KAI\ KATA\ TRO/PON PROH=KTAI *ZH/NWNI LO/GOS. H( DE\ TH=S YUXH=S NO/SOS O(MOIOTA/TH E)STI\ TH=| TOU= SW/MATOS A)KATASTASI/A|. LE/GETAI DE\ EI)=NAI SW/MATOS NO/SOS H( A)SUMMETRI/A TW=N E)N AU)TW=|, QERMOU= KAI\ YUXROU=, CHROU= KAI\ U(GROU=>20."2 @*KAI\ MET' O)LI/GA: @"1<20*(H D' E)N TW=| SW/MATI U(GI/EIA EU)KRASI/A TIS KAI\ SUMMETRI/A TW=N D' EI)RHME/NWN>20."2 @*KAI\ PA/LIN E)FECH=S: @"1<20*OI)=MAI GA\R EI)=NAI EU)ECI/AN SW/MATOS TH\N A)RI/STHN TW=N R(HQE/N-TWN EU)KRASI/AN>20."2 @*KAI\ PA/LIN E)FECH=S: @"1<20*LE/GETAI DE\ KAI\ TAU=TA OU)K A)/PO TRO/POU E)PI\ TOU= SW/MATOS, DIO/TI H( E)N QERMOI=S KAI\ YUXROI=S KAI\ U(GROI=S KAI\ CHROI=S GENOME/NH SUMMETRI/A H)\ A)SUMMETRI/A E)STI\N U(GI/EIA H)\ NO/SOS, H( D' E)N NEU/ROIS SUMMETRI/A H)\ A)SUMMETRI/A I)SXU\S H)\ A)SQE/NEIA KAI\ EU)TONI/A H)\ A)TONI/A, H( D' E)N TOI=S ME/LESI SUMMETRI/A H)\ A)SUMMETRI/A KA/LLOS H)\ AI)=SXOS>20."2 @&Galenus de H. et Plat. decr. V 2 [1`160]1 p. 420 M.$ KAI/TOI GRA/FEI G' E)FECH=S W(=N O)LI/GON E)/MPROSQEN AU)TOU= PAREQE/MHN R(H/SEWN W(DI/. @"1<20*DIO\ KAI\ KALH\ H)\ AI)SXRA\ YUXH\ A)NA/LOGON R(HQH/SETAI KATA\ SUMMETRI/AN TE/ TINA KAI\ A)SUMMETRI/AN TOIW=NDE/ TINWN MERW=N>20."2 @__TI/NA D' E)STI\ TAU=TA TA\ TH=S YUXH=S MO/RIA, MH\ DUNA/MENOS EI)-PEI=N, W(S A)\N E)N E(NI\ MO/NW|, TW=| LOGISTIKW=|, KAI\ TH\N U(GI/EIAN AU)TH=S KAI\ TH\N NO/SON KAI\ TO\ KA/LLOS KAI\ TO\ AI)=SXOS TIQE/MENOS, A)NAGKA/ZETAI PERI- @1PLE/KEIN TE TO\N LO/GON KAI\ TW=N E)NERGEIW=N AU)TH=S W(S MERW=N MNHMONEU/EIN. E)FECH=S GOU=N OI(=S PAREQE/MHN W(DI\ GRA/FEI: @"1<20*)/ESTI DE\ TH=S YUXH=S ME/RH, DI' W(=N O( E)N AU)TH=| LO/GOS SUN-E/STHKE KAI\ H( E)N AU)TW=| DIA/QESIS. *KAI\ E)/STI KALH\ H)\ AI)SXRA\ YUXH\ KATA\ TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N MO/RION E)/XON OU(/TWS H)\ OU(/TWS KATA\ TOU\S OI)KEI/OUS MERISMOU/S>20."2 @POI/OUS OI)KEI/OUS MERISMOU/S, W)= *XRU/SIPPE, PROSGRA/YAS E)FECH=S A)PAL-LA/CEIS H(MA=S PRAGMA/TWN. A)LL' OU)/T' E)NTAU=QA PROSE/GRAYAS, OU)/T' E)N A)/LLW| TINI\ TW=N SEAUTOU= BIBLI/WN, A)LL' W(/SPER OU)K E)N TOU/TW| TO\ PA=N KU=ROS ሑU(PA/RXON TH=S PERI\ TW=N PAQW=N PRAGMATEI/AS, A)POXWREI=S TE PARAXRH=MA TH=S DIDASKALI/AS AU)TOU= KAI\ MHKU/NEIS TO\N LO/GON E)N TOI=S OU) PROSH/KOUSI, DE/ON E)PIMEI=NAI KAI\ DEI=CAI, TI/NA POTE/ E)STI TA\ MO/RIA TOU= LOGISTIKOU= TH=S YUXH=S. @&Galenus de H. et Plat. decr. V 3 [1`161]1 p. 425 Mu+. Ana-&logiam, quam inter corporis et animi condiciones intercedere iudicat, &demonstrare Chrysippus non potuit$ META\ TOU= KAI\ SUGXEI=N EI)S TAU)TO\N TH/N Q' U(GI/EIAN TH=S YUXH=S KAI\ TO\ KA/LLOS. E)PI\ ME\N GA\R TOU= SW/MATOS A)KRIBW=S AU)TA\ DIWRI/SATO, <20TH\N ME\N U(GI/EIAN E)N TH=| TW=N STOIXEI/WN SUMMETRI/A| QE/MENOS, TO\ DE\ KA/LLOS E)N TH=| TW=N MORI/WN>20. E)DH/LWSE GA\R SAFW=S TOU=TO DIA\ TH=S PROGEGRAMME/NHS O)LI/GON E)/MPROSQEN R(H/SEWS, E)N H(=| TH\N ME\N U(GI/EIAN TOU= SW/MATOS E)N QERMOI=S KAI\ YUXROI=S KAI\ CHROI=S KAI\ U(GROI=S SUMMETRI/AN EI)=NAI/ FHSIN, A(/PER DH\ STOIXEI=A DHLONO/TI TW=N SWMA/TWN E)STI/N, TO\ DE\ KA/LLOS OU)K E)N TH=| TW=N STOIXEI/WN, A)LL' E)N TH=| TW=N MORI/WN SUMMETRI/A| SUNI/STASQAI NOMI/ZEI& etc. &@p. 427 M.$ <20KATA\ GA\R TOU\S OI)KEI/OUS TOU= LO/GOU MERISMOU\S KALH\N H)\ AI)SXRA\N E)/FHSE GI/GNESQAI YUXH/N>20. U(GIAI/NOUSA D' H)\ NO-SOU=SA PW=S A)\N GE/NOITO, PARE/LIPEN, EI)S TAU)TO\N OI)=MAI SUGXE/WN A)/MFW, KAI\ MH\ DUNA/MENOS A)KRIBW=S TE KAI\ W(RISME/NWS U(PE\R AU)TW=N A)PO-FH/NASQAI. @&Galenus de h. et Plat. decr. IV 6 [1`147]1 p. 376 M.$ *(/O%19TI D' O( *XRU/SIPPOS OU)X A(/PAC H)\ DI/S, A)LLA\ PA/NU POLLA/KIS AU)TO\S O(MOLOGEI=, DU/NAMI/N TINA E(TE/RAN EI)=NAI TH=S LOGIKH=S E)N TAI=S YUXAI=S TW=N A)NQRW/PWN AI)TI/AN TW=N PAQW=N, E)/NESTIN H(MI=N E)K TW=N TOIOU/TWN KATAMAQEI=N, E)N OI(=S @1 <20AI)TIA=TAI TW=N PRATTOME/NWN OU)K O)RQW=S A)TONI/AN TE KAI\ A)SQE/-NEIAN TH=S YUXH=S: OU(/TW GA\R AU)TA\S O)NOMA/ZEI, KAQA/PER GE KAI\ TA)NANTI/A TO\ ME\N EU)TONI/AN TO\ D' I)SXU/N>20. O(/SA GA\R OU)K O)RQW=S PRA/TTOUSIN A)/NQRWPOI, TA\ ME\N EI)S MOXQHRA\N KRI/SIN A)NAFE/REI, TA\ D' EI)S A)TONI/AN KAI\ A)SQE/NEIAN TH=S YUXH=S, W(/SPER GE <20KAI\ W(=N KATORQOU=-SIN H( O)RQH\ KRI/SIS E)CHGEI=TAI META\ TH=S KATA\ TH\N YUXH\N EU)-TONI/AS>20. A)LLA\ TOIOU/TWN, W(/SPER H( KRI/SIS E)/RGON E)STI\ TH=S LOGIKH=S DU-NA/MEWS, OU(/TWS H( EU)TONI/A R(W/MH TE KAI\ A)RETH\ DUNA/MEWS E(TE/RAS PARA\ TH\N LOGIKH/N, <20H(\N AU)TO\S O( *XRU/SIPPOS O)NOMA/ZEI TO/NON, A)FI/STA-SQAI/ TE/ FHSIN E)/STIN O(/TE TW=N O)RQW=S E)GNWSME/NWN H(MI=N, E)N-DO/NTOS TOU= TO/NOU TH=S YUXH=S KAI\ MH\ PARAMEI/NANTOS E(/WS PANTO\S MH/D' E)CUPHRETH/SANTOS TOI=S TOU= LO/GOU PROSTA/GMASIN>20, E)NARGW=S E)N TOI=S TOIOU/TOIS E)NDEIKNU/MENOS, OI(=O/N TI TO\ PA/QOS E)STI/N. H)/DH DE\ KAI\ R(H=SIN AU)TOU= TINA PARAGRA/YW, PERI\ TOU/TWN E)KDIDA/SKOUSAN. <20E)/STI D' E)K TOU= PERI\ PAQW=N H)QIKOU=>20. @"1$8<20*)/ETI DE\ KAI\ KATA\ TOU=T' I)/SWS OI( E)PI\ TOU= SW/MATOS LE/GONTAI TO/NOI A)/TONOI KAI\ EU)/TONOI EI)=NAI KATA\ TO\ NEURW=DES, TW=| DU/NASQAI H(MA=S H)\ A)DUNATEI=N E)N TOI=S DIA\ TOU/TWN E)PITELOUME/NOIS E)/RGOIS, KAI\ O( E)N TH=| YUXH=| TO/NOS LE/GETAI, W(S EU)TONI/A KAI\ A)TONI/A>20."2 @*KAI\ E)FECH=S: @"1<20*(/WSPER GA\R E)N DRO/MW| KAI\ A)NQE/ZEI TINO\S KAI\ TOI=S PARA-PLHSI/OIS H)/DH, A(\ DIA\ TW=N NEU/RWN E)NERGEI=TAI, E)/STI TIS E)PITE-LESTIKH\ KATA/STASIS KAI\ E)NDOTIKH/, TW=N NEU/RWN PROEKLELUME/NWN KAI\ A)NEIME/NWN, A)NALO/GWS KAI\ E)PI\ YUXH=S E)STI TOIOU=TO NEU-RW=DES, KAQ' O(\ KAI\ KATA\ METAFORA\N A)NEU/ROUS TINA\S LE/GOMEN KAI\ NEU=RA E)/XEIN>20."2 @EI)=Q' E(CH=S E)CHGOU/MENOS AU)TO\ TOU=TO TA/DE GRA/FEI: @"1<20*(O ME\N DEIMW=N E)PIGINOME/NWN A)FI/STATAI, O( DE\ KE/RDOUS H)\ ZHMI/AS FEROME/NHS E)CELU/QH KAI\ E)NE/DWKEN, O( DE\ KAQ' E(/TERA TOI-AU=TA OU)K O)LI/GA. E(/KASTON GA\R TW=N TOIOU/TWN TRE/PETAI/ TE KAI\ DOULOU=TAI H(MA=S, W(S E)NDIDO/NTAS AU)TOI=S KAI\ FI/LOUS KAI\ PO/LEIS PRODIDO/NAI, KAI\ AU(TOU\S EI)S POLLA\S KAI\ A)SXH/MONAS PRA/CEIS E)PIDIDO/NAI, TH=S PRO\S QA/TERA FORA=S E)KLUQEI/SHS. OI(=OS EI)SH=KTAI KAI\ TW=| *EU)RIPI/DH| O( *MENE/LAOS: SPASA/MENOS GA\R TH\N MA/XAIRAN FE/RETAI E)PI\ TH\N *(ELE/NHN W(S A)NAIRH/SWN, I)DW\N DE\ KAI\ KATA-PLAGEI\S EI)S TO\ KA/LLOS E)CE/BALE TH\N MA/XAIRAN, OU)DE\ TAU/THS E)/TI DUNA/MENOS KRATEI=N, KAQA\ KAI\ H( E)PI/PLHCIS AU(/TH EI)/RHKEN AU)TW=|>20: [1&Eur. Andr. 629.630$]1 @1 @<20SU\ D' W(S E)SEI=DES MASTO\N [E)KEI/NHS] E)KBALW\N CI/FOS @FI/LHM' E)DE/CW, PRODO/TIN AI)KA/LLWN KU/NA>20."2 @&p. 380 Mu+.$ O(/QEN KAI\ AU)TO\S O( *XRU/SIPPOS E)PIFE/RWN E)REI=: @"1<20*DIO\ PA/NTWN TW=N FAU/LWN OU(/TWN PRATTO/NTWN A)POSTATI-KW=S KAI\ E)NDOTIKW=S KATA\ POLLA\S AI)TI/AS, A)SQENW=S KAI\ KAKW=S E(/KASTA PRA/TTEIN A)\N LE/GOINTO>20."2 @&De verbis$ "1KATA\ POLLA\S AI)TI/AS"2 &disputat Galenus%10 Utinam mul-&tas illas Chr. causas protulisset%10$ EI) GA/R TIS PROSE/XOI TO\N NOU=N, OU)DE\N OU(/TWS EU(RH/SEI SUNE/XON TH\N PERI\ TW=N PAQW=N PRAGMATEI/AN, <20KAI\ MA/-LISTA TH\N QERAPEUTIKH/N>20, E)N H(=| TAU=T' E)/GRAYEN, W(S TO\ PA/SAS GNW=NAI TA\S AI)TI/AS, U(F' W(=N A)POXWROU=SI TW=N E)C A)RXH=S KRI/SEWN OI( KATA\ PA/QOS TI PRA/TTONTES. O( DE/ GE TOSOU/TOU DEI= SUMPA/SAS A)KRIBW=S E)KDIDA/SKEIN, W(/ST' OU)D' AU)TH\N TAU/THN H(=S ME/MNHTAI NU=N E)DH/LWSE SAFW=S. @&Versus quosdam Medeae Euripidis attulisse Chrys. in hoc libro &G. testatur p. 382 Mu+.%10$ H( DE/ GE *MH/DEIA BIASQEI=SA PRO\S TOU= QUMOU=, PERI\ H(=S KAI\ AU)TH=S OU)K OI)=D' O(/PWS O( *XRU/SIPPOS OU)K AI)SQA/NETAI KAQ' E(AUTOU= TW=N *EU)RIPI/DOU MEMNHME/NOS E)PW=N: [1&Eur. Med. 1078. 1079$]1 @*KAI\ MANQA/NW ME/N, OI(=A DRA=N ME/LLW KAKA/, @*QUMO\S DE\ KREI/SSWN TW=N E)MW=N BOULEUMA/TWN. &Origenes contra Celsum I 64 Vol. I p. 117, 16 Ko+. [1p. 379 &Delarue]1.$ KAI\ TAU=TA D' A)\N PROSQEI/HN TOI=S LEGOME/NOIS O(/TI <20*XRU/SIP-POS E)N TW=| PERI\ PAQW=N QERAPEUTIKW=|>20 PEIRA=TAI U(PE\R TOU= KATASTEI=-LAI TA\ E)N A)NQRW/POIS PA/QH TW=N YUXW=N, MH\ PROSPOIHSA/MENOS POI=ON TO\ TH=S A)LHQEI/AS E)STI\ DO/GMA, QERAPEU/EIN KATA\ TA\S DIAFO/ROUS AI(RE/SEIS TOU\S E)N TOI=S PA/QESI PROKATEILHMME/NOUS, KAI\ FHSI\N O(/TI KA)\N H(DONH\ TE/LOS H)=|, OU(TWSI\ QERAPEUTE/ON TA\ PA/QH: KA)\N TRI/A GE/NH TW=N A)GAQW=N, OU)DE\N H(=TTON KAI\ KATA\ TO\N LO/GON TOU=TON TW=N PAQW=N OU(/TWS A)PALLAK-TE/ON TOU\S E)NEXOME/NOUS AU)TOI=S. @&Cf. VIII 51 Vol. II p. 266, 18 K. [1p+. 779 Del.]1.$ A)LLA\ FILANQRW-PO/TERON OI)=MAI *KE/LSOU <20*XRU/SIPPON>20 PEPOIHKE/NAI <20E)N TW=| PERI\ PAQW=N QERAPEUTIKW=|>20. BOULO/MENON QERAPEU=SAI TA\ PA/QH W(S KATEPEI/GONTA KAI\ E)NOXLOU=NTA TH\N A)NQRWPI/NHN YUXH/N, PROHGOUME/NWS ME\N TOI=S DO-KOU=SIN AU)TW=| U(GIE/SI LO/GOIS, DEUTE/RWS DE\ KAI\ TRI/TWS KA)\N TOI=S MH\ A)RE/SKOUSI TW=N DOGMA/TWN: @"1<20*KA)\N GA\R TRI/A, FHSI/N, H)=| GE/NH TW=N A)GAQW=N, KAI\ OU(/TW QERA-PEUTE/ON TA\ PA/QH: OU) PERIERGAZO/MENON E)N TW=| KAIRW=| TH=S FLEG- @1MONH=S TW=N PAQW=N TO\ PROKATALABO\N DO/GMA TO\N U(PO\ TOU= PA/-QOUS E)NOXLOU/MENON: MH/ PWS TH=| A)KAI/RW| PERI\ TH\N A)NATROPH\N TW=N PROKATALABO/NTWN TH\N YUXH\N DOGMA/TWN SXOLH=| H( E)GXW-ROU=SA QERAPEI/A PARAPO/LHTAI."2 *FHSI\ DE\ O(/TI "1KA)\N H(DONH\ H)=| TO\ A)GAQO\N KAI\ TOU=TO FRONH=| O( U(PO\ TOU= PA/QOUS KRATOU/MENOS: OU)-DE\N H(=TTON AU)TW=| BOHQHTE/ON KAI\ PARADEIKTE/ON, O(/TI KAI\ TOI=S H(DONH\N TA)GAQO\N KAI\ TE/LOS TIQEME/NOIS A)NOMOLOGOU/MENO/N E)STI PA=N PA/QOS>20."2 @&Galenus de H. et Plat. decr. IV 6 [1`149]1 p. 383 Mu+.$ *XRU/-SIPPOS D' OU)/TE TH=S E)N TOU/TOIS E)NANTIW/SEWS AI)SQA/NETAI KAI\ MURI/A E(/TERA GRA/FEI TOIAU=TA, KAQA/PER E)PEIDA\N LE/GH|: @"1$8<20*)/ESTI D', W(S OI)=MAI, KOINO/TATON H( A)/LOGOS AU(/TH FORA\ KAI\ A)PESTRAMME/NH TO\N LO/GON, KAQ' O(\ KAI\ QUMW=| FAME/N TINAS FE/-RESQAI>20."2 @KAI\ PA/LIN: @"1<20*DIO\ KAI\ E)PI\ TW=NDE TW=N E)MPAQW=N W(S PERI\ E)CESTHKO/TWN E)/XOMEN KAI\ W(S PRO\S PARHLLAXO/TAS POIOU/MEQA TO\N LO/GON KAI\ OU) PAR' E(AUTOI=S OU)D' E)N E(AUTOI=S O)/NTAS>20."2 @KAI\ E)FECH=S DE\ PA/LIN E)CHGOU/MENOS AU)TA\ TAU=TA: @"1<20*(H DE\ PARALLAGH\ GI/GNETAI KAI\ H( E)C AU)TOU= A)NAXW/RHSIS OU) KAT' A)/LLO TI H)\ TH\N TOU= LO/GOU A)POSTROFH/N, W(S PROEI/POMEN>20."2$ @TO/ TE GA\R "1<20QUMW=| FE/RESQAI"2 KAI\ "1E)CESTHKE/NAI>20"2 KAI\ "1<20OU) PAR' ۈE(AUTOI=S OU)D' E)N E(AUTOI=S EI)=NAI>20"2 KAI\ PA/NQ' O(/SA TOIAU=TA, FANERW=S MARTUREI= TW=| KRI/SEIS EI)=NAI TA\ PA/QH KA)N TH=| LOGIKH=| DUNA/MEI TH=S YUXH=S SUNI/STASQAI, KAQA/PER KAI\ TA\ OU(/TWS E)/XONTA: @"1$8<20*DIO\ KAI\ TOIAU/TAS E)/STIN A)KOU=SAI FWNA\S E)PI/ TE TW=N E)RW/N-TWN KAI\ TW=N A)/LLWS SFO/DRA E)PIQUMOU/NTWN, KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N O)RGI-ZOME/NWN, O(/TI TE TW=| QUMW=| QE/LOUSI XARI/ZESQAI KAI\ E)A=N AU)TOU\S EI)/T' A)/MEINON EI)/TE MH\ KAI\ MHDE\N LE/GEIN AU)TOI=S KAI\ W(S TOU=TO E)K PANTO/S GE TRO/POU POIHTE/ON, KAI\ EI) DIAMARTA/NOUSI KAI\ EI) A)SU/MFORO/N E)STIN AU)TOI=S>20."2$ @KAI\ GA\R KAI\ TA\ OU(/TWS U(PO\ TOU= *XRUSI/PPOU LEGO/MENA& etc.$ __ O(/MOIA DE\ TOI=S PROGEGRAMME/NOIS KAI\ TA\ OU(/TWS U(PO\ TOU= *XRUSI/PPOU LEGO/MENA, KAQA/PER E)/XEI KAI\ TA/DE: @"1$8<20*OI(/AS MA/LISTA FORA\S KAI\ OI( E)RW/MENOI A)CIOU=SI PRO\S E(AU-TOU\S E)/XEIN TOU\S E)RASTA/S, A)PERISKEPTO/TERON KAI\ A)/NEU E)PISTRO-FH=S LOGIKH=S I(STAME/NOUS, KAI\ E)/TI TOU= PARAINOU=NTOS LO/GOU AU)TOI=S U(PERBATIKOU\S O)/NTAS, MA=LLON D' OU)D' O(/LWS U(POMONHTI-KOU\S A)KOU=SAI/ TINOS TOIOU/TOU>20."2 @1 @$*KAI\ GA\R TA\ TOIAU=TA PA/NTA TH=| PALAIA=| DO/CH| MARTUREI=, KAQA/PER KAI\ TA\ E)FECH=S AU)TW=N TA/DE: @"1$8<20*OU(/TWS TE MAKRA\N A)PE/XOUSIN A)PO\ TOU= LO/GOU, W(S A)\N A)KOU=-SAI H)\ PROSE/XEIN TINI\ TOIOU/TW|, W(/STE MHDE\ TA\ TOIAU=TA A)/PO TRO/-POU E)/XEI G' AU)TOI=S LE/GESQAI: [1&Eur. fr. 341 N]1$8 *KU/PRIS GA\R OU)DE\ NOUQETOUME/NH XALA=|: @*)\AN GA\R BIA/ZH|, MA=LLON E)NTEI/NEIN FILEI=. [1&Eur. fr. 668 N]1$8___*NOUQETOU/MENOS D' E)/RWS @*MA=LLON PIE/ZEI>20."2 __ @$*KAI\ GA\R KAI\ TAU=TA KAI\ TA\ E)FECH=S LEGO/MENA TW=| PALAIW=| MARTUREI= DO/GMATI PERI\ TH=S TW=N PAQW=N GENE/SEWS: E)/XEI D' OU(/TWS: @"1$8<20*(/OTI D' W(/SPER A)/KAIRON E)PITIMHTH\N KAI\ OU)K E)PIGNW/MONA TOI=S GINOME/NOIS E)N TW=| E)RA=N A)POKLI/NOUSI TO\N LO/GON, KAQA/PER A)/NQRWPON A)KAI/RWS DOKOU=NTA NOUQETEI=N, H(NI/KA DH\ KAI\ OI( QEOI\ DOKOU=SIN AU)TOI=S E)FIE/NAI E)PIORKEI=N>20."2 @KAI\ E)/TI TA\ TOU/TWN E(CH=S: @"1<20*)/ETI MA=LLON [2A)\N]2 E)CEI/H, FHSI/N, AU)TOI=S TO\ E)PIO\N POIEI=N A)KOLOUQOU=SI TH=| E)PIQUMI/A|>20."2 @&Galenus de H. et Plat. dogm. IV 4 [1`141]1 p. 356 Mu+. dicit$ "1A)/LOGOS"2 &vocem adhiberi aut de$ STERH/SEI &aut de$ KAKW/SEI TOU= LO/GOU. A)/LLO DE\ TRI/TON H)\ KAI\ NH\ *DI/A TE/TARTON, W(S OU(=TOI [1&Chrysippi sc. secta-&tores]1$ BIA/ZONTAI, SHMAINO/MENON OU)K E)/STIN E)N E)/QEI TOI=S *(/ELLHSIN, O(\ E)CHGEI=SQAI TH\N FWNH\N E)PAGGE/LLONTAI. DHLOI= DE\ TOU=TO KAI\ AU)TO\S O( *XRU/SIPPOS E)N TH=|DE TH=| R(H/SEI. @"1$8<20*DIO\ KAI\ OU)K A)PO\ TRO/POU LE/GETAI U(PO/ TINWN TO\ TH=S YU-XH=S PA/QOS EI)=NAI KI/NHSIS PARA\ FU/SIN, W(S E)PI\ FO/BOU E)/XEI KAI\ E)PIQUMI/AS KAI\ TW=N O(MOI/WN. PA=SAI GA\R AI( TOIAU=TAI KINH/SEIS TE KAI\ KATASTA/SEIS A)PEIQEI=S TE TW=| LO/GW| EI)SI\ KAI\ A)PESTRAM-ME/NAI. KAQ' O(\ KAI\ A)LO/GWS FAME\N FE/RESQAI TOU\S TOIOU/TOUS, OU)X OI(=ON KAKW=S E)N TW=| DIALOGI/ZESQAI, W(S A)/N TIS EI)/POI KATA\ TO\ E)/XEIN E)NANTI/WS PRO\S TO\ EU)LO/GWS, A)LLA\ KATA\ TH\N TOU= LO/-GOU A)POSTROFH/N>20."2 @&Unde haec sumpta sint, ex sequentibus apparet p. 358 Mu+.$ W(S EI)/GE XRW/MEQA LO/GW| KAI\ KAT' AU)TH\N [1&sc.$ TH\N TOU= PA/QOUS KI/NHSIN]1, OU)K O)R-QW=S O( *XRU/SIPPOS EI)=PEN, <20E)/N TE TW=| PRW/TW| PERI\ PAQW=N>20, "1OU)XI\ DIH-MARTHME/NWS FE/RETAI KAI\ PARIDW/N TI KATA\ TO\N LO/GON, A)LL' A)PESTRAM-ME/NWS TE KAI\ A)PEIQW=S AU)TW=|,"2 KAI\ PA/LIN <20E)N TW=| QERAPEUTIKW=| TW=N PAQW=N>20 AU)TA\ DH\ TAU=TA TA\ SMIKRW=| PRO/SQEN MOI PARAGEGRAMME/NA DIA\ @1 TH=S R(H/SEWS, E)N H(=| TO\ ME\N E)NANTI/WS TW=| EU)LO/GWS LEGO/MENON A)/LOGON OU)K E)/FASKEN &etc.$ __E)PIFE/RWN GOU=N FHSIN: @$8<20"1*OI(=AI KAI\ A)KRATEI=S AI( TOIAU=TAI KATASTA/SEIS EI)SI/N, W(S A)\N OU) KRATOU/NTWN E(AUTW=N, A)LL' E)KFEROME/NWN, KAQA/PER OI( TW=| TO/NW| TRE/XONTES PROSEKFE/RONTAI, OU) KRATOU=NTES TH=S TOIAU/THS KINH/SEWS. OI( DE\ KATA\ TO\N LO/GON KINOU/MENOI W(S A)\N H(GEMO/NA KAI\ TOU/TW| OI)AKI/ZONTES, KA)\N O(POIOSOU=N H)=|, KRATOU=SIN [H)/TOI A)PAQEI=S EI)SI] TH=S TOIAU/THS KINH/SEWS KAI\ TW=N KAT' AU)TH\N O(RMW=N."2 @"1KRATOU=SI TW=N KINH/SEWN KAI\ TW=N KAT' AU)TA\S O(RMW=N, W(/STE PEISQH=NAI, E)A/N PER E)NDEIKNU/HTAI AU)TO/S, PARAPLHSI/WS TOI=S PERIPATOU=SIN>20."2 @OU)K A)RKESQEI\S DE\ TOU/TOIS E)PIFE/REI: @"1<20*DIO\ KAI\ AI( OU(/TWS A)/LOGOI KINH/SEIS PA/QH TE LE/GONTAI KAI\ PARA\ FU/SIN EI)=NAI, A(/T' E)KBAI/NOUSAI TH\N LOGIKH\N SU/STASIN>20."2 @&ibidem cp. 5 [1`143]1 p. 364 Mu+.$ OU) MO/NON TOI/NUN OI( A)/LLOI, A)LLA\ KAI\ O( *XRU/SIPPOS AU)TO\S E)N TOI=S PERI\ PAQW=N SUGGRA/MMASIN E)P' OU)DE-MIA=S O(RMI/ZEI BEBAI/WS DO/CHS, A)LL' A)EI\ SALEU/EI KAQA/PER E)N KLU/DWNI. KAI\ GA\R KAI\ XWRI\S LO/GOU PANTO\S GI/GNESQAI/ FHSI TA\ PA/QH, KAI\ AU)=QIS TH=S LOGIKH=S EI)=NAI DUNA/MEWS MO/NHS, W(/STE DIA\ TOU=TO MHDE\ E)N TOI=S A)LO/-GOIS ZW/|OIS SUNI/STASQAI, KAI\ XWRI\S KRI/SEWS GI/NESQAI, KAI\ AU)=QIS KRI/-SEIS EI)=NAI. E)MPI/PTEI DE/ POTE KAI\ EI)S TO\ FA/SKEIN, EI)KH= GI/NESQAI TA\S KATA\ TA\ PA/QH KINH/SEIS, O(/PER OU)DE\N A)/LLO E)STI\N H)\ A)NAITI/WS, EI)/ TIS A)KRIBW=S E)CETA/ZOI TO\ R(H=MA. AI(=S GOU=N O)LI/GON E)/MPROSQEN GE/GRAFA R(H/SESIN E)FECH=S FHSIN: @"1$8<20*OI)KEI/WS DE\ TW=| TW=N PAQW=N GE/NEI A)PODI/DOTAI KAI\ H( PTOIA\ KATA\ TO\ E)NSESOBHME/NON TOU=TO KAI\ FERO/MENON EI)KH=|>20."2 @&Origenes comment. in Matthaeum Vol. III p. 591 Delarue$ O(/PER DE\ E)PI\ TW=N KATA\ TA\ A)FRODI/SIA LE/LEKTAI PERI\ TW=N PAIDI/WN, TOU=T' @1 A)\N LEXQEI/H KAI\ PERI\ TW=N LOIPW=N PAQW=N KAI\ A)R)R(WSTHMA/TWN KAI\ NOSH-MA/TWN TH=S YUXH=S, EI)S A(\ MH\ PE/FUKE PAIDI/A E)MPI/PTEIN, O(/SA TO\N LO/GON MHDE/PW SUMPEPLH/RWKEN. @&paulo post%10$ O( STRAFEI\S W(S PAIDI/A KAI\ E(/CIN A)NALABW\N E)K LO/GOU TH=S LU/PHS A)PARA/DEKTON. _ @&p. 592.$ W(S ME\N OU)=N PRO\S TO\ A)KRIBE\S A)PODE/DEIKTAI KAI\ A)/LLOIS O(/TI OU)DE\N TW=N PAQW=N PI/PTEI EI)S TA\ MHDE/PW SUMPEPLHRWKO/TA TO\N LO/GON PAIDI/A: EI) D' OU)DE\N DHLONO/TI KAI\ O( FO/BOS: A)LL' EI) A)/RA A)NA/LOGO/N TI TOI=S PA/QESI, KAI\ TAU=TA A)MUDRA\ KAI\ TA/XISTA A)NASKEUAZO/MENA KAI\ QERA-PEUO/MENA GI/NETAI E)N TOI=S PAIDI/OIS. __O(/TI TA\ PAIDI/A TO\N ME\N FO/-BON TW=N FAU/LWN OU) PA/SXEI, A)/LLO DE/ TI OI( DIAKRIBOU=NTES TA\ TW=N PAQW=N KAI\ TW=N O)NOMA/TWN E)KEI/NWN LE/GOUSIN EI)=NAI FO/BON. OI(=ON DE\ KAI\ TO\ TW=N PAIDI/WN A)MNHSI/KAKON, PAR' AU)TOU\S TOU\S TW=N DAKRU/WN KAI-ROU\S E)N A)KAREI= METABALLOME/NWN KAI\ GELW/NTWN KAI\ SUMPAIZO/NTWN TOI=S NOMIZOME/NOIS LELUPHKE/NAI KAI\ PEFOBHKE/NAI, A)LL' OU) KATA\ TH\N A)LH/QEIAN TAU=TA E)NHRGHKO/SIN. @&Galenus de H. et Plat. decr. IV 6 [1`149]1 p. 386 Mu+.$ KAI\ ME\N DH\ KAI\ O(/TAN MNHMONEU/H| TOU= *MENANDREI/OU E)/POUS, E)N W(=| FHSI: TO\N NOU=N E)/XWN U(POXEI/RION EI)S TO\N PI/QON DE/DWKA, FANERW=S KA)NTAU=QA MAR-TUROU=SAN A)PO/FASIN TH=| PALAIA=| DO/CH| PARATI/QETAI, KAQA/PER KA)PEIDA\N E)CHGOU/MENOS TO\ MH\ PAR' E(AUTOI=S EI)=NAI MHD' E)N E(AUTOI=S LE/GH| TAUTI/: @"1$8<20*OI)KEI/WS DE\ KAI\ E)KFE/RESQAI LE/GONTAI OI( OU(/TWS O)RGIZO/ME-NOI, TOI=S E)PI\ TW=N DROME/WN PROEKFEROME/NOIS PARAPLHSI/WS KATA\ TO\ PLEONA/ZON, TW=N ME\N PARA\ TH\N E)N TW=| TRE/XEIN O(RMH/N, TW=N DE\ PARA\ TO\N I)/DION LO/GON. OU) GA\R A)\N OU(/TWS OI(/ GE KRATOU=N-TES TH=S KINH/SEWS KAQ' E(AUTOU\S A)\N KINEI=SQAI LE/GOINTO, A)LLA\ KAT' A)/LLHN TINA\ BI/AN E)/CWQEN AU)TW=N>20."2$ @O(MOLOGEI= KA)NTAU=QA BI/AN TINA\ TH\N KINOU=SAN EI)=NAI PA=SI TOI=S E)M-PAQE/SIN O(RMA/S, O)RQO/TATA GIGNW/SKWN, PLH\N O(/TI TH\N BI/AN E)/CWQEN AU)-TW=N E)/FHSEN EI)=NAI, DE/ON OU)K E)/CWQEN, A)LL' E)N TOI=S A)NQRW/POIS U(PA/RXEIN EI)PEI=N &etc.$ ___O(/PER, OI)=MAI, KAI\ DIA\ TW=N TOIOU/TWN PARADEIGMA/-TWN O( *XRU/SIPPOS KATASKEUA/ZWN OU)K AI)SQA/NETAI. <20PARATI/QETAI GOU=N TO\N *EU)RIPI/DOU GEGRAMME/NON *(HRAKLEI= PRO\S *)/ADMHTON DIA/LO-GON. E)/XEI D' W(=DE>20: [1&Alc. 1079$]1 @<20*TI/ D' A)\N PROKO/PTOIS, EI) QE/LEIS STE/NEIN A)EI/; TAUTI\ ME\N *(HRAKLH=S LE/GEI, O( D' *)/ADMHTOS A)POKRI/NETAI: @*)/EGNWKA K' AU)TO/S, A)LL' E)/RWS TIS E)CA/GEI.>20 DH=LON GA\R O(/TI TH=S E)PIQUMHTIKH=S DUNA/MEWS, OU) TH=S LOGIKH=S O( E)/RWS ވPA/QOS U(PA/RXWN E)CA/GEI TH\N O(/LHN YUXH\N KAI\ A)/GEI TO\N A)/NQRWPON EI)S @1 E)NANTI/AS PRA/CEIS W(=N E)C A)RXH=S E)KEKRI/KEI. <20PARATI/QETAI DE\ KAI\ TA\ TOU= *)AXILLE/WS PRO\S TO\N *PRI/AMON EI)RHME/NA>20: [1*W& 549_551$]1 @<20*)/ANSXEO MHD' A)LI/ASTON O)DU/REO SO\N KATA\ QUMO/N: @*OU) GA/R TI PRH/CEIS, A)KAXH/MENOS UI(=OS E)H=OS, @*OU)DE/ MIN A)NSTH/SEIS, PRI\N KAI\ KAKO\N A)/LLO PA/QH|SQA>20. @$8*TAU=TA ME/N FHSI LE/GEIN AU)TO\N "1<20PAR' AU)TW=| DIALEGO/MENON>20 [1OU(/TW GA\R E)/GRAYEN AU)TOI=S O)NO/MASIN]1, <20E)CI/STASQAI D' OU)K O)LIGA/KIS E)K TW=N AU)TW=N TOU/TWN KRI/SEWN E)N TOI=S SUMPI/PTOUSIN, KAI\ MH\ KRATEI=N E(AUTOU= NIKWME/NOU U(PO\ TW=N PAQW=N>20."2$ @*KAI\ GA\R OU)=N KA)NTAU=QA "1TO/ TE TW=N KRI/SEWN E)CI/STASQAI"2 KAI\ TO\ "1MH\ KRATEI=N E(AUTOU="2 KAI\ TO\ "1POTE\ ME\N EI)=NAI PAR' E(AUTW=|, POTE\ D' OU)\"2 KAI\ PA/NQ' O(/SA TOIAU=TA, TOI=S TE FAINOME/NOIS E)NARGW=S O(MOLOGEI= KAI\ TH=| PALAIA=| DO/CH| PERI\ PAQW=N TE KAI\ YUXH=S DUNA/MEWN, OU) MH\N OI(=S U(PE/-QETO *XRU/SIPPOS. O(MOI/WS D' EI)/RHTAI KAI\ TA\ TOIAU=TA <20KATA\ TO\ PERI\ TW=N PAQW=N BIBLI/ON:>20 @"1$8<20*TO\ GA\R DH\ SESOBHME/NON KAI\ PARHLLAXO\S E)N H(MI=N KAI\ A)PEI-QE\S TW=| LO/GW| OU)X H(=TTON E)PI\ TH=S H(DONH=S KATAGI/NETAI>20."2 @KAI\ PA/LIN: @"1<20*OU(/TW GA\R E)CISTA/MEQA KAI\ E)/CW GINO/MEQA E(AUTW=N KAI\ TE-LE/WS A)POTUFLOU/MEQA E)N TOI=S SFALLOME/NOIS, W(/ST' E)/STIN O(/TE SPO/GGON E)/XONTES H)\ E)/RION E)N TAI=S XERSI\N TOU=TO DIARA/MENOI BA/LLOMEN W(S DH/ TI PERANOU=NTES DI' AU)TW=N: EI) D' E)TUGXA/NOMEN MA/XAIRAN E)/XONTES H)\ A)/LLO TI, TOU/TW| A)\N E)XRHSA/MEQA PARA-PLHSI/WS>20."2 @KAI\ E)FECH=S: @"1<20*POLLA/KIS DE\ KATA\ TH\N TOIAU/THN TUFLO/THTA TA\S KLEI=S DA/KNOMEN, KAI\ TA\S QU/RAS TU/PTOMEN, OU) TAXU\ AU)TW=N A)NOIGO-ME/NWN, PRO/S TE TOU\S LI/QOUS E)A\N PROSPTAI/SWMEN, TIMWRHTIKW=S PROSFERO/MEQA KATAGNU/NTES KAI\ R(IPTOU=NTES AU)TOU\S EI)/S TINAS TO/POUS, KAI\ E)PILE/GONTES KAQ' E(/KASTA TOU/TWN A)TOPW/TATA>20."2 @W(SAU/TWS DE\ KA)N TOI=S E(CH=S FHSIN: @"1<20*)ENNOH/SEIE D' A)/N TIS E)K TW=N TOIOU/TWN KAI\ TH\N E)N TOI=S PA/QESIN A)LOGISTI/AN, KAI\ W(S E)N TOI=S TOIOU/TOIS A)POTUFLOU/MEQA KAIROI=S, W(S A)\N E(/TEROI/ TINES GEGONO/TES TW=N PRODIALELOGIS-ME/NWN>20."2$ @O(/LWS D' EI)/TIS E)KLE/GOI PA/NTA KAI\ PARAGRA/FOI NU=N, O(/SA KATA\ TO\ PERI\ P. BIBLI/ON EI)/RHTAI AU)TW=|, MAXO/MENA ME\N OI(=S AU)TO\S U(PE/QETO DO/G-MASIN, O(MOLOGOU=NTA DE\ TOI=S TE FAINOME/NOIS E)NARGW=S KAI\ TH=| *PLA/TWNOS DO/CH|, MH=KOS A)\N A)/METRO/N TI GE/NOITO TOU= BIBLI/OU. MESTO\N GA/R E)STIN @1 AU)TW=| TO\ GRA/MMA TW=N TE [KAI\] KRI/SEWN E)CI/STASQAI LE/GONTI KAI\ TW=N PRODIALELOGISME/NWN DIA\ TO\N QUMO\N H)\ TH\N E)PIQUMI/AN H)\ TH\N H(DONH/N, H)/ TI TOIOU=TON& etc. &@Galenus de H. et Plat. decr. IV 5 [1`144]1 p. 366 Mu+. Cum &de motu in affectibus verba facit, dicit%10$ TH=S A)ME/TROU KAI/, W(S AU)TO\S EI)/WQEN O)NOMA/ZEIN, E)KFO/ROU KINH/SEWS. __H( D' OU)=N R(H=SIS H( <20KATA\ TO\ QERAPEUTIKO\N TW=N PAQW=N BIBLI/ON>20 W(=D' E)/XEI: @"1$8<20*OI)KEI/WS DE\ KAI\ O(RMH\ PLEONA/ZOUSA LE/GETAI EI)=NAI TO\ PA/-QOS, W(S A)/N TIS E)PI\ TW=N E)KFEROME/NWN KINH/SEWN PLEONA/ZOUSAN KI/NHSIN EI)/POI, TOU= PLEONASMOU= E)N AU)TH=| GINOME/NOU KATA\ TH\N TOU= LO/GOU A)POSTROFH\N KAI\ TO\ A)/NEU TOU= PLEONASMOU= TOU/TOU SWSTIKO/N. U(PERBAI/NOUSA GA\R TO\N LO/GON H( O(RMH\ KAI\ PARA\ TOU=-TON A)QRO/WS FEROME/NH OI)KEI/WS T' A)\N PLEONA/ZEIN R(HQEI/H KAI\ KATA\ TOU=TO PARA\ FU/SIN GI/GNESQAI KAI\ EI)=NAI A)/LOGOS, W(S U(PO-GRA/FOMEN>20."2 @&Galenus de H. et Plat. decr. IV 5 [1`144]1 p. 368 M.$ TH\N ME\N OU)=N E)K TOU= PRW/TOU PERI\ PAQW=N R(H=SIN, E)/NQA FHSI\N XWRI\S KRI/SEWS GI/NESQAI TA\ PA/QH, PAREQE/MHN E)/MPROSQEN. O(/TI DE\ KAI\ <20KATA\ TO\ QERA-PEUTIKO\N AU(TOU= BIBLI/ON>20, O(\ DH\ KAI\ H)QIKO\N E)PIGRA/FETAI, TH=S AU)TH=S DO/CHS E)/XETAI, MAQEI=N E)/STIN E)K TH=SDE TH=S R(H/SEWS. @[1&`145]1 "1$8<20*OU) GA\R E)N TW=| KRI/NEIN A)GAQA\ E(/KASTA TOU/TWN LE/GE-TAI A)R)R(WSTH/MATA TAU=TA, A)LLA\ KATA\ TO\ E)PI\ PLE/ON E)KPEPTW-KE/NAI PRO\S TAU=TA TOU= KATA\ FU/SIN>20."2 @[1&Quae siquis falso interpretatus sit,$]1 E)K TW=N E)PIFEROME/NWN H( GNW/MH TOU= *XRUSI/PPOU KATAFANH/SETAI @"1$8<20*(/OQEN OU)K A)LO/GWS GUNAIKOMANEI=S TINES LE/GONTAI KAI\ O)R-NIQOMANEI=S>20."2$ __*)ALLA\ NH\ *DI/A I)/SWS A)/N TIS FH/SEIE, TO\ MANIW=DES OU) DIA\ TH\N A)/LOGON GI/NESQAI DU/NAMIN, A)LLA\ DIA\ TO\ E)PI\ PLE/ON H)\ PROSH=KEN E)CH=XQAI TH/N TE KRI/SIN KAI\ TH\N DO/CAN, W(S EI) KAI\ OU(/TWS E)/LEGEN, A)R)R(WSTH/MATA GI/NESQAI KATA\ TH\N YUXH\N OU)X A(PLW=S TW=| YEUDW=S U(PEILHFE/NAI PERI/ TINWN, W(S A)GAQW=N H)\ KAKW=N, A)LLA\ TW=| ME/GISTA NOMI/ZEIN AU)TA/: <20MHDE/PW GA\R A)R)R(W/STHMA TH\N PERI\ TW=N XRHMA/TWN EI)=NAI DO/CAN, W(S A)GAQW=N, A)LL' E)PEIDA/N TIS AU)TA\ ME/GISTON A)GAQO\N EI)=NAI NO-MI/ZH| KAI\ MHDE\ ZH=N A)/CION U(POLAMBA/NH| TW=| STERHQE/NTI XRHMA/-TWN>20. E)N TOU/TW| GA\R SUNI/STASQAI TH/N TE FILOXRHMATI/AN KAI\ TH\N FILARGURI/AN A)R)R(WSTH/MATA OU)/SAS. *)ALLA\ TW=| TAU=TA FA/SKONTI *POSEI-DW/NIOS A)NTILE/GWN W(=DE/ PW/S FHSI: TOIOU/TWN D' U(PO\ TOU= *XRUSI/PPOU LEGOME/NWN &etc. @1 @&<21Posidonius>21 apud Galenum de h. et Plat. decr. IV 7 p. 391 Mu+.$ O( GOU=N O(/ROS OU(=TOS, FHSI/N, O( TH=S A)/THS, W(/SPER OU)=N KAI\ A)/LLOI POLLOI\ TW=N PAQW=N, U(PO/ TE *ZH/NWNOS EI)RHME/NOI KAI\ PRO\S TOU= *XRUSI/PPOU GEGRAM-ME/NOI, SAFW=S E)CELE/GXOUSI TH\N GNW/MHN AU)TOU=. "1DO/CAN GA\R EI)=NAI PRO/S-FATON, TOU= KAKO\N AU)TW=| PAREI=NAI,"2 FHSI\ TH\N LU/PHN. E)N W(=| KAI\ SUN-TOMW/TERON E)NI/OTE LE/GONTES W(=DE/ PWS PROFE/RONTAI: "1LU/PH E)STI\ DO/CA PRO/SFATOS KAKOU= PAROUSI/AS."2 EI)=NAI ME\N DH\ TO\ PRO/SFATO/N FHSI "1TO\ U(PO/GUON KATA\ TO\N XRO/NON,"2 A)CIOI= DE\ [1&sc. Posidonius$]1 TH\N AI)TI/AN U(P' AU)TW=N R(HQH=NAI, DI' H(\N H( TOU= KAKOU= DO/CA PRO/SFATOS ME\N OU)=SA SUSTE/LLEI TE TH\N YUXH\N KAI\ LU/PHN E)RGA/ZETAI, XRONISQEI=SA D' H)\ OU)D' O(/LWS H)\ OU)K E)/Q' O(MOI/WS SUSTE/LLEI. KAI/TOI OU)DE\ TO\ PRO/SFATON E)XRH=N E)GKEI=SQAI KATA\ TO\N O(/RON, EI)/PER A)LHQH= TA\ *XRUSI/PPOU. <20KATA\ GA\R TH\N GNW/MHN AU)TOU= MA=LLON TOU= MEGA/LOU KAKOU= H)\ A)NUPOMONH/TOU H)\ A)KAR-TERH/TOU, KAQA/PER AU)TO\S EI)/WQEN O)NOMA/ZEIN>20, TH\N LU/PHN EI)RH=SQAI E)/DEI DO/CAN, OU) PROSFA/TOU. E)/NQA KAI\ DIXO/QEN O( *POSEIDW/NIOS A)NTI-LE/GEI TW=| *XRUSI/PPW|, KATA\ ME\N TOU=TON TO\N DEU/TERON O(RISMO\N A)NAMI-MNH/SKWN TW=N TE SOFW=N KAI\ TW=N PROKOPTO/NTWN, W(S E)/MPROSQEN EI)/RHTAI: OI( ME\N GA\R E)N MEGI/STOIS A)GAQOI=S, OI( D' E)N MEGI/STOIS KAKOI=S E(AUTOU\S U(POLAMBA/NONTES EI)=NAI, O(/MWS OU) GI/NONTAI DIA\ TOU=T' E)N PA/QEI: KATA\ DE\ TO\N PRW=TON E)RWTA=| TH\N AI)TI/AN, DI' H(\N OU)X H( TH=S TOU= KAKOU= PAROUSI/AS DO/CA TH\N LU/PHN, A)LL' H( PRO/SFATOS E)RGA/ZETAI MO/NH& etc. &@Galenus de Platonis et Hippocr. plac. IV 7 p. 392 M.$ KAI/ FHSI DIO/TI PA=N TO\ A)MELE/THTON KAI\ CE/NON A)QRO/WS PROSPI=PTON E)KPI/PTEI TE KAI\ TW=N PALAIW=N E)CI/STHSI KRI/SEWN, A)SKHQE\N DE\ KAI\ SUNEQISQE\N KAI\ XRONI/SAN H)\ OU)D' O(/LWS E)CI/STHSIN, W(S KATA\ PA/QOS KINEI=N, H)\ E)PI\ MI-KRO\N KOMIDH=|: DIO\ KAI\ PROENDHMEI=N DEI=N FHSI TOI=S PRA/GMASI MH/PW TE PAROU=SIN OI(=ON PAROU=SI XRH=SQAI. BOU/LETAI DE\ TO\ PROENDHMEI=N R(H=MA TW=| *POSEIDWNI/W| TO\ OI(=ON PROANAPLA/TTEIN TE KAI\ PROTUPOU=N TO\ PRA=GMA PAR' E(AUTW=| TO\ ME/LLON GENH/SESQAI KAI\ W(S PRO\S H)/DH GENO/MENON E)QISMO/N TINA POIEI=SQAI KATA\ BRAXU/. DIO\ KAI\ TO\ TOU= *)ANACAGO/ROU PAREI/LHFEN E)NTAU=QA, W(S A)/RA TINO\S A)NAGGEI/LANTOS AU)TW=| TEQNA/NAI TO\N UI(O\N EU)= MA/LA KAQESTHKO/TWS EI)=PEN "1H)/|DEIN QNHTO\N GENNH/SAS"2 KAI\ W(S TOU=TO LA-BW\N *EU)RIPI/DHS TO\ NO/HMA TO\N *QHSE/A PEPOI/HKE LE/GONTA: [1&Eur. fr. 392 N$]1 @@E)GW\ DE\ [2TOU=TO]2 PARA\ SOFOU= TINOS MAQW\N @@EI)S FRONTI/DAS NOU=N SUMFORA/S T' E)BALLO/MHN, @@FUGA/S T' E)MAUTW=| PROSTIQEI\S PA/TRAS E)MH=S @@QANA/TOUS T' A)W/ROUS KAI\ KAKA\S A)/LLAS O(DOU/S, @1 @@W(/ST' EI)/ TI PA/SXOIM' W(=N E)DO/CAZO/N POTE @@MH/ MOI NEW=RES PROSPESO\N YUXH\N DA/KOI."2 OU(/TW DE\ EI)RH=SQAI/ FHSI KAI\ TA\ TOIAU=TA: [1&Eur. fr. 818 N$]1 @@"1EI) ME\N TO/D' H)=MAR PRW=TON H)=N KAKOUME/NH| ∕@@KAI\ MH\ MAKRA\N DH\ DIA\ PO/NWN E)NAUSTO/LOUN, @@EI)KO\S SFADA/|ZEIN H)=N A)\N W(S NEO/ZUGA @@PW=LON, XALINO\N A)RTI/WS DEDEGME/NON: @@NU=N D' A)MBLU/S EI)MI KAI\ KATHRTUKW\S KAKW=N"2 E)/SQ' O(/TE TA\ TOIAU=TA: [1&Eur. Alc. 1085$]1 @@@MAKRO\S @@XRO/NOS MALA/CEI: NU=N D' E)/T' H(BA/SKEI KAKO/N. @&Cicero Tusculan. disput. IV 5, 9.&3 <21Chrysippus>21et Stoici, &3cum de animi perturbationibus disputant, magnam partem in his par-&3tiendis et definiendis occupati sunt; illa eorum perexigua oratio est, qua &3medeantur animis nec eos turbulentos esse patiantur. @&Cicero Tusculan. disput. IV 29, 63.&3 quodque vetat <21Chrysippus>21 &3ad recentes quasi tumores animi remedium adhibere, id nos fecimus &etc. &@Cicero Tusculan. disput. III 25, 61.&3 Omnibus enim modis &3fulciendi sunt qui ruunt nec cohaerere possunt propter magnitudinem &3aegritudinis. Ex quo ipsam aegritudinem $LU/PHN&3 <21Chrysippus>21, quasi &3solutionem totius hominis, appellatam putat. @&Cicero Tusculan. disput. III 31, 76.&3 <21Chrysippus>21 autem ca-&3put esse censet in consolando, detrahere illam opinionem maerenti, si se &3officio fungi putet iusto atque debito. @&Cicero Tusculan. disp. III 25, 59.&3 Quocirca Carneades, ut &3video nostrum scribere Antiochum, reprehendere <20Chrysippum>20 solebat, &3laudantem Euripideum carmen illud%10 &3@@Mortalis nemo est, quem non attingit dolor &3@@Morbusque; multis sunt humandi liberi, &3@@Rursum creandi; morsque est finita omnibus; &3@@Quae generi humano angorem nequiquam afferunt. &3@@Reddenda terrae est terra%10 tum vita omnibus &3@@Metenda, ut fruges. Sic iubet Necescitas. @&`60.&3 Negabat genus hoc orationis quicquam omnino ad levandam &3aegritudinem pertinere. @&10Cicero Tusculan. disput. IV 29, 62. Quare omnium philosopho-&10rum, ut ante dixi, una ratio est medendi, ut nihil, quale sit illud, quod @1 &10perturbet animum, sed de ipsa sit perturbatione dicendum. Itaque pri-&10mum in ipsa cupiditate, cum id solum agitur, ut ea tollatur, non est &10quaerendum, bonum illud necne sit, quod libidinem moveat; sed libido &10ipsa tollenda est, ut sive, quod honestum est, id sit summum bonum, sive &10voluptas, sive horum utrumque coniunctum, sive tria illa genera bonorum, &10tamen, etiamsi virtutis ipsius vehementior appetitus sit, eadem sit omni-&10bus ad deterrendum adhibenda oratio. @&10Olympiodorus in Plat. Alcib. Vol. II p. 54 Creuzer.$10 *)ISTE/ON GA\R O(/TI_TREI=S EI)SI TRO/POI KAQA/RSEWS, *PUQAGORIKO/S, *SWKRATIKO/S, *PERIPATHTI-KO\S H)/TOI *STWI+KO/S: KAI\ O( ME\N <20*STWI+KO\S>20 DIA\ TW=N E)NANTI/WN TA\ E)NANTI/A I)A=TAI, TW=| ME\N QUMW=| TH\N E)PIQUMI/AN E)PA/GWN KAI\ OU(/TW MALA/SSWN AU)TH/N, TH\N DE\ E)PI-QUMI/AN TW=| QUMW=| KAI\ OU(/TW R(WNNU/WN AU)TH\N KAI\ A)NA/GWN PRO\S TO\ A)NDRIKW/TE-RON, DI/KHN TW=N KEKAMME/NWN R(A/BDWN, A(\S OI( QE/LONTES EU)QU=NAI PRO\S TO\ E)NAN-TI/ON PERILUGI/ZOUSIN, I(/NA E)K TH=S EI)S TO\ E)NANTI/ON PERIFORA=S TO\ SU/MMETRON A)NAFANH=|. *OU(/TW KAI\ E)PI\ YUXH=S E)K TOU= TOIOU/TOU TRO/POU A(RMONI/AN E)MPOIEI=N E)PETH/DEUON. @&10Clemens Al. Strom. VII 17 p. 893. Pott.$10 TRITTH\ DE\ QERAPEI/A OI)H/SEWS, KAQA/PER KAI\ PANTO\S PA/QOUS: MA/QHSI/S TE TOU= AI)TI/OU KAI\ TOU= PW=S A)\N E)CAIREQEI/H TOU=TO: KAI\ TRI/TON H( A)/SKHSIS TH=S YUXH=S KAI\ O( E)QISMO\S PRO\S [2TO\]2 TOI=S KRIQEI=SIN O)RQW=S E)/XEIN A)KOLOUQEI=N DU/NASQAI. @1 @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 23 p. 1069e.$ *PO/QEN OU)=N, FHSI/N, A)/RCWMAI; KAI\ TI/NA LA/BW <20TOU= KAQH/KONTOS>20 A)RXH\N KAI\ U(/LHN TH=S A)RETH=S, A)FEI\S TH\N FU/SIN KAI\ TO\ KATA\ FU/SIN; [1&Incertum an sit ex &libro$ PERI\ TOU= *KAQH/KONTOS& Chrysippi.]1 @&10Commenta Lucani p. 74 Usener. %2%2%2 <21de officiis>21 declarat%10 &10<21quae homini a prima conciliatione nascendi sumuntur>21. inde &10enim colligit [1scil. Cicero]1 unum hominem sociale esse animal et cum &10sibi tum omnibus hominibus natura esse conciliatum. &10@Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 107.$10 E)/TI DE\ <20KAQH=KO/N>20 FASIN EI)=NAI O(\ PRAXQE\N EU)/LOGON [TE] I)/SXEI A)POLOGISMO/N, OI(=ON TO\ A)KO/LOUQON E)N [TH=|] ZWH=|, O(/PER KAI\ E)PI\ TA\ FUTA\ KAI\ ZW=|A DIATEI/NEI: O(RA=SQAI GA\R KA)PI\ TOU/TWN KAQH/KONTA. KATWNO-MA/SQAI DE\ OU(/TWS U(PO\ PRW/TOU *ZH/NWNOS TO\ KAQH=KON, A)PO\ TOU= KATA/ TINAS H(/KEIN TH=S PROSONOMASI/AS EI)LHMME/NHS. E)NE/RGHMA DE\ AU)TO\ EI)=NAI TAI=S KATA\ FU/SIN KATASKEUAI=S OI)KEI=ON. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 85, 13.$10 *)AKO/LOUQOS D' E)STI\ TW=| LO/GW| TW=| PERI\ TW=N PROHGME/NWN O( <20PERI\ TOU= KAQH/KONTOS TO/POS>20. *(ORI/ZETAI DE\ TO\ KAQH=-KON: "3TO\ A)KO/LOUQON E)N ZWH=|, O(\ PRAXQE\N EU)/LOGON A)POLOGI/AN E)/XEI:"3 PARA\ TO\ KAQH=KON DE\ TO\ E)NANTI/WS. *TOU=TO DIATEI/NEI KAI\ EI)S TA\ A)/LOGA TW=N ZW/|WN, E)NER-GEI= GA/R TI KA)KEI=NA A)KOLOU/QWS TH=| E(AUTW=N FU/SEI: E)PI\ [2DE\]2 TW=N LOGIKW=N ZW/|WN OU(/TWS A)PODI/DOTAI: "3TO\ A)KO/LOUQON E)N BI/W|."3 *TW=N DE\ KAQHKO/NTWN TA\ ME\N EI)=NAI/ FASI <20TE/LEIA>20, A(\ DH\ KAI\ <20KATORQW/MATA>20 LE/GESQAI. *KATORQW/MATA D' EI)=NAI TA\ KAT' A)RETH\N E)NERGH/MATA, OI(=ON TO\ FRONEI=N, TO\ DIKAIOPRAGEI=N. OU)K EI)=NAI DE\ KATORQW/MATA TA\ MH\ OU(/TWS E)/XONTA, A(\ DH\ OU)DE\ TE/LEIA KAQH/KONTA PROSAGOREU/OUSIN, A)LLA\ <20ME/SA>20, OI(=ON TO\ GAMEI=N, TO\ PRESBEU/EIN, TO\ DIALE/GESQAI, TA\ TOU/TOIS O(/MOIA. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 108.$10 TW=N GA\R KAQ' O(RMH\N E)NERGOUME/NWN TA\ ME\N <20KAQH/KONTA>20 EI)=NAI, TA\ DE\ <20PARA\ TO\ KAQH=KON>20, TA\ DE\ <20OU)/TE KAQH/-KONTA OU)/TE PARA\ TO\ KAQH=KON. KAQH/KONTA>20 ME\N OU)=N EI)=NAI O(/SA LO/GOS @1 AI(REI= POIEI=N, W(S E)/XEI GONEI=S TIMA=N, A)DELFOU/S, PATRI/DA, SUMPERIFE/RESQAI FI/-LOIS: <20PARA\ TO\ KAQH=KON>20 DE/, O(/SA MH\ AI(REI= LO/GOS, W(S E)/XEI TA\ TOIAU=TA, GO-NE/WN A)MELEI=N, A)DELFW=N A)FRONTISTEI=N, FI/LOIS MH\ SUNDIATI/QESQAI, PATRI/DA U(PERORA=N KAI\ TA\ PARAPLH/SIA. <20OU)/TE DE\ KAQH/KONTA OU)/TE PARA\ TO\ KA-QH=KON>20, O(/SA OU)/TE AI(REI= LO/GOS PRA/TTEIN OU)/TE A)PAGOREU/EI, OI(=ON KA/RFOS A)NE-LE/SQAI, GRAFEI=ON KRATEI=N [2H)\]2 STLEGGI/DA KAI\ TA\ O(/MOIA TOU/TOIS. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 109.$10 KAI\ TA\ ME\N EI)=NAI <20KAQH/KONTA A)/NEU PERISTA/SEWS, TA\ DE\ PERISTATIKA/>20. KAI\ <20A)/NEU ME\N PERISTA/SEWS>20 TA/DE: U(GIEI/AS E)PIMELEI=SQAI KAI\ AI)SQHTHRI/WN KAI\ TA\ O(/MOIA: <20KATA\ PERI/STASIN>20 DE\ TO\ PHROU=N E(AUTO\N KAI\ TH\N KTH=SIN DIAR)R(IPTEI=N. @A)NA\ LO/GON DE\ KAI\ TW=N PARA\ TO\ KAQH=KON. @E)/TI TW=N KAQHKO/NTWN TA\ ME\N <20A)EI\>20 KAQH/KEI, TA\ DE\ <20OU)K A)EI/>20. KAI\ <20A)EI\ ME\N KAQH/KEI>20 TO\ KAT' A)RETH\N ZH=N, <20OU)K A)EI\>20 DE\ TO\ E)RWTA=N KAI\ A)POKRI/NESQAI KAI\ PERIPATEI=N KAI\ TA\ O(/MOIA. O( D' AU)TO\S LO/GOS KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N PARA\ TO\ KAQH=KON. @E)/STI DE\ KAI\ <20E)N TOI=S ME/SOIS>20 TI KAQH=KON, W(S TO\ PEI/QESQAI TOU\S PAI=DAS TOI=S PAIDAGWGOI=S. @&10Cicero de finibus III 22. <21Cum vero illa, quae officia esse &10dixi, proficiscantur ab initiis naturae>21, necesse est ea ad haec re-&10ferri, ut recte dici possit omnia officia eo referri, ut adipiscamur principia &10naturae, nec tamen ut hoc sit bonorum ultimum, propterea quod non inest &10in primis naturae conciliationibus honesta actio; consequens enim est et &10post oritur, ut dixi. Est tamen ea secundum naturam multoque nos ad &10se expetendam magis hortatur quam superiora omnia. &10@Cicero de finibus III 17, 58. Sed cum quod honestum sit, id &10solum bonum esse dicamus, consentaneum tamen est, fungi officio, <21cum &10id officium nec in bonis ponamus, nec in malis>21. Est enim &10aliquid in his rebus probabile, et quidem ita, ut eius ratio reddi pos-&10sit, ergo ut etiam probabiliter acti ratio reddi possit. Est autem offi-&10cium, quod ita factum est, ut eius facti probabilis ratio reddi possit. &10Ex quo intelligitur, officium medium quiddam esse, quod neque in bo-&10nis ponatur, neque in contrariis. Quoniamque in iis rebus, quae ne-&10que in virtutibus sunt neque in vitiis, est tamen quiddam, quod usui &10possit esse, tollendum id non est. Est autem eius generis actio quoque &10quaedam, et quidem talis, ut ratio postulet agere aliquid et facere eorum; &10quod autem ratione actum est, id officium appellamus; est igitur officium &10eius generis, quod nec in bonis putatur nec in contrariis. 59. Atque &10perspicuum etiam illud est, in istis rebus mediis aliquid agere sapientem. &10Iudicat igitur, cum agit, officium illud esse. Quodquoniam nunquam falli-&10tur in iudicando, erit in mediis rebus officium. Quod efficitur hac etiam &10conclusione rationis%10 Quoniam enim videmus esse quiddam, quod <21recte &10factum>21 appellemus, id autem est <21perfectum officium>21, erit etiam in-&10choatum, ut si "1iuste depositum reddere"2 in recte factis sit, in officiis &10ponatur "1depositum reddere"2; illo enim addito "1iuste"2 fit recte factum, @1 &10per se autem hoc ipsum reddere in officio ponitur. Quoniamque non du-&10bium est, quin in iis, quae media dicamus, sit aliud sumendum, aliud &10reiciendum, quicquid ita fit aut dicitur, omne officio continetur. Ex quo &10intelligitur, quoniam se ipsi omnes natura diligant, tam insipientem quam &10sapientem sumpturum, quae secundum naturam sint, reiecturumque con-&10traria. Ita est quoddam commune officium sapientis et insipientis; ex &10quo efficitur versari in iis, quae media dicamus. &10@Stobaeus ecl. II 86, 10 W.$10 PA=N DE\ TO\ PARA\ TO\ KAQH=KON E)N LOGIKW=| GINO/MENON A(MA/RTHMA EI)=NAI: TO\ DE\ KAQH=KON TELEIWQE\N KATO/RQWMA GI/-NESQAI. PARAMETREI=SQAI DE\ TO\ ME/SON KAQH=KON A)DIAFO/ROIS TISI/, KALOUME/NOIS DE\ PARA\ FU/SIN KAI\ KATA\ FU/SIN, TOIAU/THN D' EU)FUI/AN PROSFEROME/NOIS, W(/ST' EI) MH\ LAMBA/NOIMEN AU)TA\ H)\ DIWQOI/MEQA A)PERISPA/STWS, MH\ A)\N EU)DAIMONEI=N. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 93, 14 W.$10 <20KATO/RQWMA>20 D' EI)=NAI LE/GOUSI KAQH=-KON PA/NTAS E)PE/XON TOU\S A)RIQMOU/S, H)\__TE/LEION KAQH=KON: <20A(MA/RTHMA/>20 TE TO\ PARA\ TO\N O)RQO\N LO/GON PRATTO/MENON H)\ E)N W(=| PARALE/LEIPTAI/ TI KAQH=KON U(PO\ LOGIKOU= ZW/|OU. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 96, 18 W.$10 E)/TI DE\ TW=N E)NERGHMA/TWN FASI\ TA\ ME\N EI)=NAI KATORQW/MATA, TA\ DE\ A(MARTH/MATA, TA\ D' OU)DE/TERA: <20KATORQW/MATA>20 ME\N TA\ TOIAU=TA: FRONEI=N, SWFRONEI=N, DIKAIOPRAGEI=N, XAI/REIN, EU)ERGETEI=N, EU)FRAI/-NESQAI, FRONI/MWS PERIPATEI=N, PA/NQ' O(/SA KATA\ TO\N O)RQO\N LO/GON PRA/TTETAI: <20A(MARTH/MATA>20 D' EI)=NAI TO/ TE A)FRAI/NEIN KAI\ TO\ A)KOLASTAI/NEIN KAI\ TO\ A)DIKEI=N KAI\ TO\ LUPEI=SQAI KAI\ TO\ FOBEI=SQAI KAI\ TO\ KLE/PTEIN KAI\ KAQO/LOU O(/SA PARA\ TO\N O)RQO\N LO/GON PRA/TTETAI: <20OU)/TE DE\ KATORQW/MATA OU)/TE A(MARTH/MATA>20 TA\ TOIAU=TA: LE/GEIN, E)RWTA=N, A)POKRI/NESQAI, PERIPATEI=N, A)PODHMEI=N KAI\ TA\ TOU/-TOIS PARAPLH/SIA. @&10Stobaeus eclog. II 7 p. 97, 5 Wachsm.$10 <20*PA/NTA DE\ TA\ KATORQW/-MATA DIKAIOPRAGH/MATA EI)=NAI KAI\ EU)NOMH/MATA KAI\ EU)TAKTH/MATA KAI\ EU)EPITHDEU/MATA KAI\ EU)TUXH/MATA KAI\ EU)DAIMONH/MATA KAI\ EU)-KAIRH/MATA KAI\ EU)SXHMONH/MATA>20: OU)K E)/TI ME/NTOIGE FRONIMEU/MATA, A)LLA\ MO/NA TA\ A)PO\ FRONH/SEWS: KAI\ O(MOI/WS E)PI\ TW=N A)/LLWN A)RETW=N, EI) KAI\ MH\ W)NO/MASTAI, OI(=ON SWFRONH/MATA ME\N TA\ A)PO\ SWFROSU/NHS, DIKAIW/MATA DE\ TA\ A)PO\ DIKAIOSU/NHS. *TA\ DE\ A(MARTH/MATA E)K TW=N A)NTIKEIME/NWN A)DIKOPRAGH/MATA KAI\ A)NOMH/MATA KAI\ A)TAKTH/MATA. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 86, 5.$10 <20TW=N DE\ KATORQWMA/TWN>20 TA\ ME\N EI)=NAI W(=N XRH/, TA\ D' OU)/. <20W(=N XRH\ ME\N>20 EI)=NAI [2TA\]2 KATHGOROU/MENA W)FELH/MATA, OI(=ON @1 TO\ FRONEI=N, TO\ SWFRONEI=N: <20OU)K EI)=NAI DE\ W(=N XRH\>20 TA\ MH\ OU(/TWS E)/XONTA. O(MOI/WS DE\ KAI\ TW=N PARA\ TO\ KAQH=KON TH\N AU)TH\N GI/NESQAI TEXNOLOGI/AN. @&10Cicero de finibus III 32. Sed in ceteris artibus cum dicitur &10"1artificiose"2 posterum quodam modo et consequens putandum est, quod illi$10 E)PIGENNHMATIKO/N&10 appellant; cum autem in quo "1sapienter"2 dicimus, id a &10primo rectissime dicitur. <21Quicquid enim a sapiente proficiscitur, &10id continuo debet expletum esse omnibus suis partibus>21; in eo &10enim positum est id, quod dicimus esse expetendum. Nam ut peccatum &10est patriam prodere, parentes violare, fana depeculari, quae sunt in effectu, &10sic timere, sic maerere, sic in libidine esse peccatum est etiam sine effectu. &10Verum ut haec non in posteris et in consequentibus, sed in primis con-&10tinuo peccata sunt, sic ea, <21quae proficiscuntur a virtute, suscep-&10tione prima, non perfectione recta sunt iudicanda>21. &10@Philo de sacrif. Abel et Cain %14 115 p. 249, 4 Wendl$10. LE/GW DE\ TAU=TA OU) PERI\ TW=N A)RETW=N, A)LLA\ PERI\ <20TW=N ME/SWN TEXNW=N>20 KAI\ W(=N A)/LLWN A)NAGKAI/WN PERI/ TE SW/MATOS E)PIME/LEIAN KAI\ TH\N TW=N E)KTO\S PERIOUSI/AN PRAGMA-TEU/ONTAI. E)PEI\ <20O(/GE PERI\ A)GAQW=N KAI\ KALW=N TELEI/WN PO/NOS KA)\N U(STE-RI/ZH| TOU= TE/LOUS I(KANO\S E)C AU(TOU= PROSWFELH=SAI TOU\S XRWME/NOUS>20, TA\ D' O(/SA E)KTO\S A)RETH=S E)A\N MH\ PROSGE/NHTAI TO\ PE/RAS A)NWFELH= PA/NTA. @&10Seneca de beneficiis I 6. Magnum autem esse inter ista dis-&10crimen vel ex hoc intellegas licet, quod <21beneficium utique bonum>21 &10est, id autem quod fit aut datur, nec bonum nec malum est. __Non &10est beneficium ipsum, quod numeratur aut traditur: sicut ne in victimis &10quidem, licet opimae sint auroque praefulgeant, deorum est honor, sed pia &10ac recta voluntate venerantium. itaque boni etiam farre ac fitilla religiosi &10sunt, mali rursus non effugiunt impietatem, quamvis aras sanguine multo &10cruentaverint. &10@Seneca de beneficiis II 31. Hoc ex paradoxis <21Stoicae sectae>21 &10minime mirabile, ut mea fert opinio, aut incredibile est, <21eum qui li-&10benter accipit beneficium reddidisse>21. nam cum omnia ad animum &10referamus, fecit quisque quantum voluit. et <21cum pietas, fides, iu-&10stitia, omnis denique virtus intra se perfecta sit>21, etiamsi illi &10manum exserere non licuit, gratus quoque potest esse homo voluntate. &10@Seneca de beneficiis III cp. 18. refert enim cuius animi sit qui &10praestat, non cuius status: nulli praeclusa virtus est, omnibus patet, omnes &10admittit, omnes invitat, ingenuos, libertinos, servos, reges, exules. non &10eligit domum nec censum, nudo homine contenta est. &10@Seneca de beneficiis IV 21. Quomodo est disertus etiam qui &10tacet, fortis etiam qui compressis manibus vel etiam adligatis, quomodo &10gubernator etiam qui in sicco est, quia consummatae scientiae nihil deest, &10etiamsi quid obstat, quominus se utatur%10 ita gratus est etiam qui vult &10tantum nec habet huius voluntatis suae ullum alium quam se testem. @&Stobaeus Florileg. 103, 22.$8 <20*XRUSI/PPOU. *(O D' E)P' A)/KRON, FHSI/, PROKO/PTWN A(/PANTA PA/NTWS A)PODI/DWSI TA\ KAQH/KONTA KAI\ OU)DE\N PARALEI/PEI.$ @*TO\N DE\ TOU/TOU BI/ON OU)K EI)=NAI/ PW FHSI\N EU)DAI/MONA, A)LL' @1 E)PIGI/GNESQAI AU)TW=| TH\N EU)DAIMONI/AN O(/TAN AI( ME/SAI PRA/CEIS AU(=TAI PROSLA/BWSI TO\ BE/BAION KAI\ E(KTIKO\N KAI\ I)DI/AN PH=CIN TINA\ LA/BWSI>20. @&10Clemens Al. Strom. VII 10 p. 867 Pott.$10 KAI/TOI PRA/SSETAI/ TINA KAI\ PRO\S TW=N MH\ GNWSTIKW=N O)RQW=S, A)LL' OU) KATA\ LO/GON: OI(=ON E)PI\ A)N-DREI/AS: E)/NIOI GA\R E)K FU/SEWS QUMOEIDEI=S GENO/MENOI, EI)=TA A)/NEU TOU= LO/GOU TOU=TO QRE/YANTES, A)LO/GWS E)PI\ TA\ POLLA\ O(RMW=SI KAI\ O(/MOIA TOI=S A)NDREI/OIS DRW=SIN, W(/STE E)NI/OTE TA\ AU)TA\ KATORQOU=N OI(=ON BASA/NOUS U(POME/NEIN EU)KO/LWS: A)LL' OU)/TE A)PO\ TH=S AU)TH=S AI)TI/AS TW=| GNWSTIKW=| OU)/TE KAI\ TO\ AU)TO\ PROQE/MENOI, OU)D' A)\N TO\ SW=MA A(/PAN E)PIDIDW=SIN. __<20*PA=SA OU)=N H( DIA\ TOU= E)PISTH/-MONOS PRA=CIS EU)PRAGI/A, H( DE\ DIA\ TOU= A)NEPISTH/MONOS KAKOPRAGI/A>20, KA)\N E)/NSTASIN SW/|ZH|. E)PEI\ MH\ E)K LOGISMOU= A)NDRI/ZETAI MHDE\ E)PI/ TI XRH/SIMON TW=N E)PI\ A)RETH\N KAI\ A)PO\ A)RETH=S KATASTREFO/NTWN TH\N PRA=CIN KATEUQU/NEI. *(O DE\ AU)TO\S LO/GOS KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N A)/LLWN A)RETW=N. @&10Philo Leg. Alleg. III %14 210 Vol. I p. 160, 2 Wendl.$10 E)PEI\ KAI\ O( <20FAU=LOS E)/NIA DRA=| TW=N KAQHKO/NTWN OU)K A)F' E(/CEWS KAQHKOU/SHS>20: KAI\ O( MEQU/WN ME/NTOI KAI\ MEMHNW\S E)/STIN O(/TE NHFA/LIA FQE/GGETAI/ TE KAI\ POIEI=, A)LL' OU)K A)PO\ NHFOU/SHS DIANOI/AS: KAI\ OI( E)/TI KOMIDH=| NH/PIOI PAI=DES OU)K A)PO\ LOGIKH=S E(/CEWS [1OU)/PW GA\R AU)TOU\S H( FU/SIS LOGIKOU\S PEPAI/DEUKE]1 POLLA\ PRA/T-TOUSI KAI\ LE/GOUSI W(=N OI( LOGIKOI/. *BOU/LETAI DE\ O( NOMOQE/THS TO\N SOFO\N MH\ SXETIKW=S KAI\ EU)ALW/TWS KAI\ W(S A)\N E)K TU/XHS EU)LO/GISTON DOKEI=N EI)=NAI, A)LL' A)PO\ E(/CEWS KAI\ DIAQE/SEWS EU)LOGI/STOU. @&10Philo de Cherubim %14 14 Vol. I p. 173, 12 Wendl.$10 TO\ DE/ON POLLA/KIS DEO/NTWS OU)K E)NERGEI=TAI KAI\ TO\ MH\ KAQH=KON E)/STIN O(/TE DRA=TAI KAQH-KO/NTWS. *OI(=ON H( ME\N TH=S PARAKATAQH/KHS A)PO/DOSIS, O(/TAN MH\ A)PO\ GNW/MHS U(GIOU=S GI/GNHTAI, A)LL' H)\ E)PI\ BLA/BH| TOU= LAMBA/NONTOS H)\ E)P' E)NE/DRA| TH=S PERI\ MEI/ZONA PI/STIN A)RNH/SEWS, KAQH=KON E)/RGON OU) DEO/NTWS E)PITELEI=TAI. *TO\ DE\ TW=| KA/MNONTI MH\ A)LHQEU=SAI TO\N I)ATRO/N, KENOU=N H)\ TE/MNEIN H)\ KAI/EIN DIEGNWKO/TA E)P' W)FELEI/A| TOU= NOSOU=NTOS, I(/NA MH\ PROLABW\N TA\ DEINA\ FU/GH| TH\N QERAPEI/AN, H)\ E)CASQENH/SAS A)PEI/PH| PRO\S AU)TH/N: H)\ PRO\S TOU\S POLEMI/OUS TO\N SOFO\N YEU/-SASQAI E)PI\ TH=| TH=S PATRI/DOS SWTHRI/A|, DEI/SANTA MH\ E)K TOU= A)LHQEU=SAI R(WSQH=| TA\ TW=N A)NTIPA/LWN, OU) KAQH=KON E)/RGON DEO/NTWS E)NERGEI=TAI. @&10Frontonis epistulae [1de eloquentia ad M. Antoninum]1 p. 140 ed. &10Naber. __officiorum genera duo, rationes tripertitae%10 prima species &10substantiae, ut sit; altera qualitatis, ut talis sit; tertia rei, ut rem ipsam, &10cuius causa superiora officia suscepit, expleat___[2dis]2cendae exer-&10cendaeque sapientiae%10 tertiam autem hanc speciem rei dico ac negotiis &10solam terminatam, se quasi contentam. Hac officiorum partititione, si &10tamen aut ille verum aiebat aut ego olim audita memoria retineo [2Stoici &10utuntur]2, ut prima homini ad sapientiam tendenti sint [2moli]2menta quae &10ad vitam salutemque pertinent [2conservandam]2. Igitur et prandere et &10lavari et ungui et cetera eiusmodi munera sunt sapientis officia. Quam-&10quam neque in balneis quisquam sapientia etc. &10@Non est sapientiae negotium vesci; sed sine vita quae cibo constat &10nulla sapientia, studia nulla esse possunt. @1 @&10Clemens Al. Strom. VI 14 p. 796 Pott.$10 W(/SPER OU)=N TO\ ME\N A(PLW=S SW/|ZEIN TW=N ME/SWN E)STI/N: TO\ D' O)RQW=S KAI\ DEO/NTWS KATO/RQWMA: OU(/TWS KAI\ PA=SA PRA=CIS GNWSTIKOU= ME\N KATO/RQWMA, TOU= DE\ A(PLW=S PISTOU= ME/SH PRA=CIS LE/GOIT' A)/N, MHDE/PW KATA\ LO/GON E)PITELOUME/NH MHDE\ MH\N KAT' E)PI/STASIN KATOR-QOUME/NH: PANTO\S DE\ E)/MPALIN TOU= E)QNIKOU= A(MARTHTIKH/: OU) GA\R A(PLW=S TO\ EU)= PRA/TTEIN A)LLA\ TO\ PRO/S TINA SKOPO\N TA\S PRA/CEIS POIEI=SQAI KAI\ [2KATA\]2 LO/GON E)NERGEI=N KAQH=KON AI( GRAFAI\ PARISTA=SIN. @&10Sextus adv. math. XI 200 [1Sextus probaverat$10 O(/TI H( FRO/NHSIS OU)K E)/STI TE/XNH TIS PERI\ TO\N BI/ON, H(=S I)/DION OU)DE\N TEXNIKO/N E)STIN E)/RGON]1. *)ALLA\ PRO\S TOU=Q' U(PANTW=NTE/S FASI <20PA/NTA ME\N KOINA\ EI)=NAI KAI\ PA/NTWN TA\ E)/RGA, DIORI/ZESQAI DE\ TW=| A)PO\ TEXNIKH=S DIAQE/SEWS H)\ A)PO\ A)TE/X-NOU GI/GNESQAI.>20 *OU) GA\R TO\ E)PIMELEI=SQAI GONE/WN KAI\ A)/LLWS TIMA=N GONEI=S TOU= SPOUDAI/OU E)STI\N E)/RGON, A)LLA\ SPOUDAI/OU TO\ A)PO\ FRONH/SEWS TOU=TO POIEI=N: KAI\ W(S TO\ ME\N U(GIA/ZEIN KOINO/N E)STI TOU= TE I)ATROU= KAI\ I)DIW/TOU, TO\ DE\ I)ATRI-KW=S U(GIA/ZEIN TOU= TEXNI/TOU I)/DION, W(=DE KAI\ TO\ ME\N TIMA=N TOU\S GONEI=S KOINO\N TOU= TE SPOUDAI/OU KAI\ MH\ SPOUDAI/OU, <20TO\ DE\ A)PO\ FRONH/SEWS TIMA=N TOU\S GONEI=S I)/DION TOU= SOFOU=>20, W(/STE KAI\ TE/XNHN AU)TO\N E)/XEIN PERI\ TO\N BI/ON, H(=S I)/DIO/N E)STIN E)/RGON TO\ E(/KASTON TW=N PRATTOME/NWN A)PO\ A)RI/STHS DIAQE/SEWS PRA/TTEIN. @&10Seneca ep. 95, 57. <21Actio recta non erit, nisi recta fuerit &10voluntas%10 ab hac enim est actio. Rursus voluntas non erit &10recta, nisi habitus animi rectus fuerit%10 ab hoc enim est volun-&10tas. Habitus porro animi non erit in optimo, nisi totius vitae &10leges perceperit et quid de quoque iudicandum sit exegerit>21 etc. &10@Philo quod deus sit immutab. %14 100 Vol. II p. 78, 4 Wendl.$10 KAI\ TOU\S A)/LLO TI TW=N DEO/NTWN A)SUGKATAQE/TW| GNW/MH| PRA/TTONTAS E)QELOUSI/WS, BIAZOME/NOUS DE\ TO\ PAR' AU(TOI=S E(KOU/SION, MH\ KATORQOU=N. @&10Philo Leg. Alleg. I %14 93 Vol. I p. 85, 17 Wendl.$10 *DIAFE/REI DE\ TRI/A TAU=TA, PRO/STACIS, A)PAGO/REUSIS, E)NTOLH\ KAI\ PARAI/NESIS. H( <20ME\N GA\R A)PAGO/REUSIS PERI\ A(MARTHMA/TWN GI/NETAI KAI\ PRO\S FAU=LON: H( DE\ PRO/STACIS [2PERI\]2 KATORQWMA/TWN: H( DE\ PARAI/NESIS PRO\S TO\N ME/SON TO\N MH/TE FAU=LON MH/TE SPOUDAI=ON>20. OU)/TE GA\R A(MARTA/NEI W(S A)PAGOREU/EIN A)/N TINA AU)TW=|, OU)/TE KATORQOI= KATA\ TH\N TOU= O)RQOU= LO/GOU PRO/STACIN, A)LLA\ XREI/AN E)/XEI PARAINE/SEWS, TH=S A)NE/XEIN ME\N TW=N FAU/LWN DIDASKOU/SHS, PROTRE-POU/SHS DE\ E)FI/ESQAI TW=N A)STEI/WN. *TW=| ME\N OU)=N TELEI/W| [1&10scil.$10 SOFW=|]1__ @1 PROSTA/TTEIN H)\ A)PAGOREU/EIN H)\ PARAINEI=N OU)XI\ DEI=: OU)DENO\S GA\R TOU/TWN O( TE/-LEIOS DEI=TAI: TW=| DE\ FAU/LW| PROSTA/CEWS KAI\ A)PAGOREU/SEWS XREI/A: TW=| DE\ NHPI/W| PARAINE/SEWS KAI\ DIDASKALI/AS. *(/WSPER TW=| TELEI/W| GRAMMATIKW=| H)\ MOUSIKW=| OU)-DENO\S DEI= PARAGGE/LMATOS TW=N EI)S TA\S TE/XNAS: TW=| DE\ SFALLOME/NW| PERI\ TA\ QEWRH/MATA W(SANEI/ TINWN NO/MWN, PROSTA/CEIS KAI\ A)PAGOREU/SEIS E)XO/NTWN: TW=| D' A)/RTI MANQA/NONTI DIDASKALI/AS. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 11 p. 1037c.$ [1<20*)EN TW=| PERI\ *NO/MOU>20%1]1 *TO\ KATO/RQWMA/ FASI NO/MOU PRO/STAGMA EI)=NAI: TO\ D' A(MA/R-THMA NO/MOU A)PAGO/REUMA, DIO\ TO\N NO/MON POLLA\ TOI=S FAU/LOIS A)PAGO-REU/EIN, PROSTA/TTEIN DE\ MHDE/N: OU) GA\R DU/NANTAI KATORQOU=N. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 11 p. 1037 e.$ [1<20*XRU/SIPPOS E)N TW=| PERI\ *NO/MOU>20%1]1 *KAI\ TO\N I)ATRO\N TW=| MAQHTH=| PROSTA/TTEIN <20LE/-GOUSI>20 TEMEI=N KAI\ KAU=SAI, KATA\ PARA/LEIYIN TOU= EU)KAI/RWS KAI\ METRI/WS: KAI\ TO\N MOUSIKO\N LURI/SAI KAI\ A)=|SAI, KATA\ PARA/LEIYIN TOU= E)MMELW=S KAI\ SUMFW/NWS: DIO\ TOU\S TAU=TA POIH/SANTAS A)TE/XNWS KAI\ KAKW=S KOLA/ZOUSIN: [W(S] PROSETA/XQH GA\R O)RQW=S OI( D' OU)K O)RQW=S E)POI/HSAN. *OU)KOU=N KAI\ O( SOFO\S TW=| QERA/PONTI PROSTA/TTWN EI)PEI=N TI KAI\ PRA=CAI, KA)\N MH\ EU)-KAI/RWS TOU=TO PRA/CH| MHDE\ W(S DEI= KOLA/ZWN, DH=LO/S E)STI KATO/RQWMA PROSTA/TTWN, OU) ME/SON: EI) DE\ ME/SA PROSTA/TTOUSIN OI( SOFOI\ TOI=S FAU/-LOIS, TI/ KWLU/EI KAI\ TA\ TOU= NO/MOU PROSTA/GMATA TOIAU=TA EI)=NAI. @&10Philo de sacrificiis Abel et Cain %14 43 Vol. I p. 219, 14 Wendl.$10 AI( TE/LEIOI A)RETAI\ MO/NOU TOU= TELEI/OU KAI\ GNHSI/OU KTH/MATA: <20TA\ DE\ ME/SA TW=N KAQHKO/NTWN E)FARMO/TTEI KAI\ TOI=S A)TELE/SI>20 ME/XRI TW=N E)GKUKLI/WN PRO-PAIDEUMA/TWN E)LQOU=SIN. @&10Origenes comment. in Matthaeum Vol. III p. 494 Delarue.$10 KAI\ PRE/PON GE/ E)STI QEOU= NO/MW| A)PAGOREU/EIN TA\ A)PO\ KAKI/AS KAI\ PROSTA/SSEIN TA\ KAT' A)RETH/N: TA\ DE\ TW=| I)DI/W| LO/GW| A)DIA/FORA TAU=TA E)A=N E)PI\ XW/RAS, DUNA/MENA DIA\ TH\N PROAI/RESIN KAI\ TO\N E)N H(MI=N LO/GON A(MARTANO/MENA ME\N KAKW=S PRA/T-TESQAI, KATORQOU/MENA DE\ GI/NESQAI KALW=S. @&10Cicero de finibus III 14, 45. Et quemadmodum opportunitas &10[1sic enim appellemus$10 EU)KAIRI/AN]1&10 non fit maior productione temporis [1habent &10enim suum modum quae opportuna dicuntur]1 sic recta effectio$10 [1KATO/RQWSIN&10 &10enim ita appello, quoniam recte factum$10 KATO/RQWMA]1&10 <21recta igitur effectio>21, &10item convenientia, denique ipsum bonum, quod in eo positum est, ut na-&10turae consentiat, <21crescendi accessionem nullam habet.>21 46. Ut &10enim opportunitas illa, sic haec de quibus dixi, non fiunt temporis pro-&10ductione maiora%10 ob eamque causam Stoicis non videtur optabilior nec @1 &10magis expetenda beata vita, si sit longa, quam si brevis, utunturque si-&10mili%10 Ut si cothurni laus illa esset, ad pedem apte convenire, neque multi &10cothurni paucis anteponerentur nec maiores minoribus, sic quorum omne &10bonum convenientia atque opportunitate finitur, nec plura paucioribus nec &10longinquiora brevioribus anteponent. &10@Porphyrius in Aristot. categ. p. 137, 29 Busse.$10 OI( DE\ TINA\S ME\N E(/CEIS KAI\ TOU\S KATA\ TAU/TAS POIOU\S U(PELA/MBANON MH\ E)PIDE/XESQAI TO\ MA=LLON KAI\ TO\ H(=TTON W(S [2TA\S A)RETA\S KAI\]2 TOU\S KATA\ TAU/TAS [2POIOU/S, TINA\S DE\ E(/CEIS]2 KAI\ POIOU\S E)PIDE/XESQAI E)PI/TASIN KAI\ A)/NESIN, W(S PA/SAS [2TA\S ME/SAS]2 TE/XNAS KAI\ TA\S ME/SAS POIO/THTAS KAI\ TOU\S KATA\ TAU/TAS POIOU/S. H(=S GEGO/NASI DO/CHS <20OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 13 p. 1038c.$8 *XRU/SIPPOS, EI) KAI\ POLLA\ PRO\S TOU)NANTI/ON GE/GRAFE, DH=LO/S E)STI PROSTIQE/MENOS TW=| MH/TE KAKI/AN KAKI/AS H)\ A(MARTI/AN A(MARTI/AS U(PERE/XOUSAN EI)=NAI, MH/T' A)RETH\N A)RETH=S H)\ KATO/R-QWSIN KATORQW/SEWS O(/S GE FHSI\N <20E)N TW=| TRI/TW| PERI\ *FU/SEWS "1*(/WSPER TW=| *DII\ PROSH/KEI SEMNU/NESQAI E)P' AU)TW=| TE KAI\ TW=| BI/W| KAI\ ME/GA FRONEI=N, KAI/, EI) DEI= OU(/TWS EI)PEI=N, U(YAUXEI=N KAI\ KOMA=N KAI\ MEGALHGOREI=N A)CI/WS BIOU=NTI MEGALHGORI/AS: OU(/TW TOI=S A)GAQOI=S PA=SI TAU=TA PROSH/KEI, KAT' OU)QE\N PROEXOME/NOIS U(PO\ TOU= *DIO/S.>20"2 @&Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 120.$ <20A)RE/SKEI TE AU)TOI=S I)/SA H(GEI=SQAI TA\ A(MARTH/MATA>20, KAQA/ FHSI <20*XRU/SIPPOS E)N TW=| TETA/RTW| TW=N *)HQIKW=N *ZHTHMA/TWN>20 KAI\ *PERSAI=OS KAI\ *ZH/NWN. EI) GA\R A)LHQE\S A)LHQOU=S MA=LLON OU)K E)/STIN OU)DE\ YEU=DOS YEU/DOUS: OU(/TWS OU)DE\ A)PA/TH A)PA/THS OU)DE\ A(MA/RTHMA A(MARTH/MATOS. *KAI\ GA\R O( E(KATO\N STADI/OUS A)PE/XWN *KANW/BOU KAI\ O( E(/NA E)PI/SHS OU)K EI)SI\N E)N *KANW/BW|: OU(/TW KAI\ O( PLEI=ON KAI\ O( E)/LATTON A(MARTA/NWN E)PI/SHS OU)K EI)SI\N E)N TW=| KATORQOU=N. @&10Stobaeus eclog. II 7 p. 106, 21.$10 <20*)=ISA/ TE PA/NTA LE/GOUSIN EI)=-NAI TA\ A(MARTH/MATA, OU)KE/TI D' O(/MOIA>20. *KAQA/PER GA\R A)PO\ MIA=S TINOS PHGH=S TH=S KAKI/AS FE/RESQAI PE/FUKE, TH=S KRI/SEWS OU)/SHS E)N PA=SI TOI=S A(MAR-TH/MASI TH=S AU)TH=S: PARA\ DE\ TH\N E)/CWQEN AI)TI/AN TW=N E)F' OI(=S AI( KRI/SEIS A)POTE-LOU=NTAI ME/SWN DIALLATTO/NTWN, DIA/FORA KATA\ POIO/THTA GI/NESQAI TA\ A(MARTH/-MATA. *LA/BOIS D' A)\N EI)KO/NA SAFH= TOU= DHLOUME/NOU TW=|D' E)PISTH/SAS: <20PA=N GA\R TO\ YEU=DOS E)P' I)/SHS YEU=DOS SUMBE/BHKEN>20, OU) GA\R EI)=NAI E(/TERON E(TE/ROU MA=LLON DIEYEUSME/NON: TO/ [TE] GA\R NU/KT' [2A)EI\]2 EI)=NAI YEU=DO/S E)STI, KAQA/PER TO\ I(PPOKE/NTAURON ZH=N: KAI\ OU) MA=LLON EI)PEI=N E)/STI YEU=DOS EI)=NAI QA/TERON QA-TE/ROU: A)LL' OU)XI\ TO\ YEU=DOS E)PI/SHS YEU=DO/S E)STIN, OU)XI\ DE\ KAI\ OI( DIEYEUSME/NOI E)PI/SHS EI)SI\ DIEYEUSME/NOI. <20*KAI\ A(MARTA/NEIN DE\ MA=LLON KAI\ H(=TTON OU)K @1 E)/STIN>20, PA=SAN GA\R A(MARTI/AN KATA\ DIA/YEUSIN PRA/TTESQAI. *)/ETI OU)XI\ KATO/R-QWMA ME\N MEI=ZON KAI\ E)/LATTON OU) GI/GNESQAI, A(MA/RTHMA DE\ MEI=ZON KAI\ E)/LATTON GI/GNESQAI: PA/NTA GA/R E)STI TE/LEIA, DIO/PER OU)/T' E)LLEI/PEIN OU)/T' U(PERE/XEIN DU/NAIT' A)\N A)LLH/LWN. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 113, 18 W.$10 PA/NTWN TE TW=N A(MARTHMA/TWN I)/SWN O)/NTWN KAI\ TW=N KATORQWMA/TWN, KAI\ <20TOU\S A)/FRONAS E)PI/SHS PA/NTAS A)/FRO-NAS EI)=NAI>20, TH\N AU)TH\N KAI\ I)/SHN E)/XONTAS DIA/QESIN. I)/SWN DE\ O)/NTWN TW=N A(MARTHMA/TWN <20EI)=NAI/ TINAS E)N AU)TOI=S DIAFORA/S>20, KAQ' O(/SON TA\ ME\N AU)TW=N A)PO\ SKLHRA=S KAI\ DUSIA/TOU DIAQE/SEWS GI/NETAI, TA\ D' OU)/. @KAI\ <20TW=N SPOUDAI/WN DE\ A)/LLOUS A)/LLWN PROTREPTIKWTE/ROUS GI/GNESQAI KAI\ PEISTIKWTE/ROUS, E)/TI DE\ KAI\ A)GXINOUSTE/ROUS, KATA\ TA\ ME/SA TA\ E)MPERILAMBANO/MENA TW=N E)PITA/SEWN SUMBAINOUSW=N>20. @&10Cicero de finibus III 14, 48. Ut enim qui demersi sunt in &10aqua, nihilo magis respirare possunt, si non longe absunt a summo, ut &10iam iamque possint emergere, quam si etiamtum essent in profundo%10 nec &10catulus ille, qui iam appropinquat, ut videat, plus cernit, quam is qui &10modo est natus%10 item <21qui processit aliquantum ad virtutis habi-&10tum nihilo minus in miseria est quam ille, qui nihil processit>21 &10__Sed quamquam negant nec virtutes nec vitia crescere, tamen utrum-&10que eorum fundi quodam modo et quasi dilatari putant. &10@Cicero de finibus IV 75. <21Peccata paria>21. _Quonam modo? &10__Ut, inquit, in fidibus pluribus, si nulla earum ita contenta nervis &10sit, ut concentum servare possit, omnes aeque incontentae sint, sic peccata &10quia discrepant, aeque discrepant; paria sunt igitur. @&10`76. Ut enim, inquit, <21gubernator aeque peccat, si palearum &10navem evertit et si auri>21, item aeque peccat, qui parentem et qui &10servum iniuria verberat. @&10`77. Quoniam, inquiunt, <21omne peccatum imbecillitatis et in-&10constantiae>21 est, haec autem vitia in omnibus stultis aeque magna sunt, &10necesse est paria esse peccata. &10@Cicero de finibus IV 21. Omnium insipientiam, iniustitiam, &10alia vitia similia esse, omniaque peccata esse paria, eosque <21qui natura &10doctrinaque longe ad virtutem processissent, nisi eam plane &10consecuti essent, summe esse miseros>21, neque inter eorum vitam et &10improbissimorum quicquam omnino interesse. &10@Porphyrion ad Hor. Serm. I 2, 62. Negat interesse quicquam, &10utrum quis in matrona an in ancilla an etiam in adultera delinquat, <21se-&10cutus opinionem Stoicorum, qui omnia peccata paria esse di-&10cunt;>21 neque enim rei admissae quantitatem, sed admittentis voluntatem &10spectant. &10@Acro ad Hor. ep. I 1, 17. Stoicorum sectator_qui non dant &10virtutem nisi perfectae philosophiae. Peripatetici et alii et non perfectis &10honorem derelinquunt. @1 @&10Plutarchus quomodo quis in virt. sent. prof, cp. 2 p. 75f.$10 OI( DE\ MH\ TIQE/MENOI TA\ DO/GMATA PRO\S TOI=S PRA/GMASIN A)LLA\ TA\ PRA/GMATA PRO\S TA\S E(AUTW=N U(POQE/SEIS O(MOLOGEI=N MH\ PEFUKO/TA KATABIAZO/MENOI POLLW=N A)PORIW=N E)MPEPLH/KASI TH\N FILOSOFI/AN, MEGI/STHS DE\ TH=S EI)S MI/AN O(MOU= KAKI/AN PA/NTAS A)NQRW/POUS PLH\N E(NO\S TOU= TELEI/OU TIQEME/NHS, U(F' H(=S AI)/NIGMA GE/GONEN H( <20LE-GOME/NH PROKOPH/>20, MIKRO\N A)POLEI/POUSA A)FROSU/NHS E)SXA/THS, <20TOU\S DE\ MH\ PA/NTWN A(/MA PAQW=N KAI\ NOSHMA/TWN A)FEIME/NOUS U(P' AU)TH=S E)/TI TOI=S MHDENO\S A)PHLLAGME/NOIS TW=N KAKI/STWN O(MOI/WS PARE/XOUSA KAKODAIMONOU=NTAS>20: OU(=TOI ME\N OU)=N E(AUTOU\S E)LE/GXOUSIN, <20E)N ME\N TAI=S SXO-LAI=S>20 I)/SHN A)DIKI/AN TH\N *)ARISTEI/DOU TH=| *FALA/RIDOS TIQE/MENOI, KAI\ DEILI/AN TH\N *BRASI/DOU TH=| *DO/LWNOS KAI\ NH\ *DI/A TH=S *MELH/TOU MHD' O(TIOU=N TH\N *PLA/TWNOS A)GNWMOSU/NHN DIAFE/ROUSAN, E)N DE\ TW=| BI/W| KAI\ TOI=S PRA/GMASIN E)KEI/NOUS ME\N E)KTREPO/MENOI KAI\ FEU/GONTES W(S A)MEILI/KTOUS, TOU/TOIS D' W(S A)CI/OIS POLLOU= TA\ ME/GISTA KAI\ XRW/MENOI KAI\ PISTEU/ONTES. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 227.$10 A)RE/SKEI DE\ AU)TOI=S <20MHDE\N ME/SON EI)=NAI A)RETH=S KAI\ KAKI/AS>20, TW=N *PERIPATHTIKW=N METACU\ A)RETH=S KAI\ KAKI/AS EI)=NAI LEGO/NTWN TH\N PROKOPH/N: W(S GA\R DEI=N FASIN H)\ O)RQO\N EI)=NAI CU/LON H)\ STREBLO/N, OU(/TWS H)\ DI/KAION H)\ A)/DIKON, OU)/TE DE\ DIKAIO/TERON OU)/TE A)DIKW/TERON, KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N A)/LLWN O(MOI/WS. @&10Alexander Aphrod. Quaest. IV 3 p. 121, 14 Bruns.$10 *(/OTI DIKAIO-SU/NHS TE KAI\ A)DIKI/AS KAI\ O(/LWS A)RETH=S TE KAI\ KAKI/AS E)/STI TIS E(/CIS METACU\ H(\N ME/SHN E(/CIN LE/GOMEN. EI) H( DIKAIOSU/NH KAI\ H( A)DIKI/A DIAQE/SEIS <20KAT' AU)-TOU/S>20, AI( DE\ DIAQE/SEIS A)NAPO/BLHTOI, OU)/T' A)\N E)C A)DI/KOU GI/NOITO/ TIS DI/KAIOS, OU)/TE E)K DIKAI/OU A)/DIKOS.&10 __24.$10 EI) DE\ LE/GOIEN <20TA\S KAKI/AS MH\ EI)=NAI DIAQE/SEIS MHD' A)NAPOBLH/TOUS>20, A)LLA\ METABA/LLEIN TINA\S MHDE\N KWLU/EIN E)C A)DIKI/AS EI)S DIKAIOSU/NHN KAI\ O(/LWS E)K KAKI/AS EI)S A)RETH/N, A)LL' EI)/S GE TH\N KA-KI/AN PO/QEN METABA/LLOUSIN; @&10ibid. 32.$10 EI) DE\ LE/GOIEN <20MHDE/PW TOU\S PAI=DAS LOGIKOU\S EI)=NAI, DIO\ MHDE\ DIKAI/OUS MHDE\ A)DI/KOUS>20 [1LOGIKOU= GA\R AI( E(/CEIS AU(=TAI, EI) D' AU(=TAI LOGIKOU= KAI\ H( ME/SH, DIO\ O( PAI=S A)/LOGOS W)\N OU)/T' E)N A)RETH=| E)STIN OU)/T' E)N KAKI/A| OU)/T' E)N TW=| METACU\ TOU/TWN, W(/SPER OU)D' A)/LLO TI TW=N A)LO/GWN]1 <20METABA/LLONTAS D' EI)S TO\ LOGIKO\N EU)QU\S EI)=NAI KAKOU/S, A)LL' OU) GI/NESQAI>20, O(MOLOGOI=EN A)\N DIA\ TOU/TWN&10 etc. &10@Origenes de princ. III p. 129 ed. Delarue.$10 TRI/TON DE\ E)ROU=SIN O(/TI <20TW=N ME/SWN E)STI\ TO\ QE/LEIN TA\ KALA\ KAI\ TO\ TRE/XEIN E)PI\ TA\ KALA/, KAI\ OU)/TE A)STEI=ON OU)/TE FAU=LON>20: LEKTE/ON DE\ PRO\S TOU=TO O(/TI EI) TO\ QE/LEIN TA\ KALA\ KAI\ TO\ TRE/XEIN E)PI\ TA\ KALA\ ME/SON E)STI/, KAI\ TO\ E)NANTI/ON AU)TW=| ME/SON E)STI/&10 etc. @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 10 p. 1063a.$8 <20*NAI/, FASI/N, A)LLA\ W(/SPER O( PH=XUN A)PE/XWN E)N QALA/TTH| TH=S E)PIFANEI/AS, OU)-DE\N H(=TTON PNI/GETAI TOU= KATADEDUKO/TOS O)RGUIA\S PENTAKOSI/AS, OU(/TWS OU)DE\ OI( PELA/ZONTES A)RETH=| TW=N MAKRA\N O)/NTWN H(=TTO/N EI)SIN E)N KAKI/A|: KAI\ KAQA/PER OI( TUFLOI\ TUFLOI/ EI)SI, KA)\N O)LI/GON U(/STERON A)NABLE/PEIN ME/LLWSIN, OU(/TWS OI( PROKO/PTONTES, A)/XRIS @1 OU(= TH\N A)RETH\N A)NALA/BWSIN, A)NO/HTOI KAI\ MOXQHROI\ DIAME/NOUSIN>20. @&Plutarchus Quomodo quis in virtute sentiat profectus cp. 1 p. 75c.$ OU(/TWS E)N TW=| FILOSOFEI=N OU)/TE PROKOPH\N OU)/TE TINA\ PROKOPH=S AI)/SQHSIN U(POLHPTE/ON, EI) MHDE\N H( YUXH\ MEQI/HSI MHD' A)POKAQAI/RETAI TH=S A)BEL-TERI/AS, A)/XRI DE\ TOU= LABEI=N A)/KRATON TO\ A)GAQO\N KAI\ TE/LEION A)KRA/TW| TW=| KAKW=| XRH=TAI. *KAI\ GA\R <20A)KAREI= XRO/NOU KAI\ W(/RAS E)K TH=S W(S E)/NI MA/LISTA FAULO/THTOS EI)S OU)K E)/XOUSAN U(PERBOLH\N A)RETH=S DIA/QESIN METABALW\N O( SOFO/S, H(=S OU)D' E)N XRO/NW| POLLW=| ME/ROS A)FEI=LE KAKI/AS A(/MA PA=SAN E)CAI/FNHS E)KPE/FEUGE>20. KAI/TOI H)/DH <20TOU\S TAU=TA/ GE LE/GONTAS>20 OI)=SQA DH/POU PA/LIN POLLA\ PARE/XONTAS AU(-TOI=S PRA/GMATA KAI\ MEGA/LAS A)PORI/AS <20PERI\ TOU= DIALELHQO/TOS, O(\S AU)TO\S E(AUTO\N OU)DE/PW KATEI/LHFE GEGONW\S SOFO/S, A)LL' A)GNOEI= KAI\ A)MFIDOCEI= TW=| KATA\ MIKRO\N E)N XRO/NW| POLLW=| TA\ ME\N A)FAI-ROU=NTI TA\ DE\ PROSTIQE/NTI GIGNOME/NHN TH\N E)PI/DOSIN KAQA/PER POREI/AN TH=| A)RETH=| LAQEI=N A)TRE/MA PROSMI/CASAN>20. EI) DE/ GE H)=N TA/XOS TOSOU=TON TH=S METABOLH=S KAI\ ME/GEQOS, W(/STE TO\N PRWI\+ KA/KISTON E(SPE/RAS GEGONE/NAI KRA/TISTON, H)\ A)\N OU(/TW TINI\ SUNTU/XH| TA\ TH=S META-BOLH=S, KATADARQO/NTA FAU=LON A)NEGRE/SQAI SOFO\N KAI\ PROSEIPEI=N E)K TH=S YUXH=S MEQEIKO/TA TA\S XQIZA\S A)BELTERI/AS KAI\ A)PA/TAS @"1YEUDEI=S O)/NEIROI, XAI/RET': OU)DE\N H)=T' A)/RA,"2 TI/S A)\N A)GNOH/SEIEN AU(TOU= DIAFORA\N E)N AU(TW=| TOSAU/THN GENOME/NHN KAI\ FRO/NHSIN A)QRO/ON E)KLA/MYASAN; @&10Stobaeus eclog. II 7 p. 113 W.$10 <20*GI/NESQAI DE\ KAI\ DIALELH-QO/TA TINA\ SOFO\N>20 NOMI/ZOUSI KATA\ TOU\S PRW/TOUS XRO/NOUS, OU)/TE O)REGO/MENO/N TINOS OU)/Q' O(/LWS GINO/MENON E)/N TINI TW=N E)N TW=| BOU/LESQAI EI)DIKW=N O)/NTWN, DIA\ TO\ MH\ KRI/NONTI AU)TW=| PAREI=NAI W(=N XRH/. *OU) MO/NON D' E)PI\ TH=S FRONH/SEWS A)LLA\ KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N A)/LLWN TEXNW=N TA\S TOIAU/TAS E)/SESQAI DIALH/YEIS. @&10Philo de agricultura %14 160 Vol. II p. 127, 23 Wendl.$10 *OI( DE\ MH\ TOU/TWN [1&10scil.$10 MELE/THS SUNEXOU=S KAI\ GUMNASMA/TWN]1 TUGXA/NONTES PARA\ TOI=S FILOSO/FOIS <20DIALELHQO/TES LE/GONTAI EI)=NAI SOFOI/>20. *TOU\S GA\R A)/XRI SOFI/AS A)/KRAS E)LHLAKO/TAS KAI\ TW=N O(/RWN AU)TH=S A)/RTI PRW=TON A(YAME/NOUS, A)MH/XANON EI)DE/NAI FASI\ TH\N E(AUTW=N TELEI/WSIN. *MH\ GA\R KATA\ TO\N AU)TO\N XRO/NON A)/MFW SUNI/STASQAI, TH/N TE PRO\S TO\ PE/RAS A)/FICIN KAI\ TH\N TH=S A)FI/CEWS KATA/LHYIN: A)LL' EI)=NAI MEQO/RION A)/GNOIAN, OU) TH\N MAKRA\N A)PELHLAME/NHN E)PISTH/MHS, A)LLA\ TH\N E)GGU\S KAI\ A)GXI/QURON AU)TH=|. @&10Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 8 p. 1061f.$10 E)/TI PARA\ TH\N E)/NNOIA/N @1 E)STIN A)GAQW=N ME\N EI)=NAI ME/GISTON TO\ A)META/PTWTON E)N TAI=S KRI/SESI KAI\ BE/BAION, <20MH\ DEI=SQAI DE\ TOU/TOU TO\N E)P' A)/KRON PROKO/PTONTA MHDE\ FRONTI/ZEIN PARAGENOME/NOU>20: POLLA/KIS DE\ MHDE\ TO\N DA/KTULON PROTEI=NAI TAU/THS G' E(/NEKA TH=S A)SFALEI/AS KAI\ BEBAIO/THTOS, H(\N TE/LEION A)GAQO\N KAI\ ME/GA NOMI/ZOUSIN. @&10Proclus in Plat. Alcib. pr. Vol. III p. 158 ed. Cousin.$10 *)ORQW=S OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 LE/GEIN EI)W/QASIN, W(S O( ME\N A)PAI/DEUTOS A)/LLOUS AI)TIA=TAI KAI\ OU)X E(AUTO\N TH=S AU)TOU= KAKODAIMONI/AS: O( <20DE\ PROKO/PTWN EI)S AU(TO\N A)NAFE/REI TH\N AI)TI/AN W(=N POIEI= PA/NTWN H)\ LE/GEI KAKW=S>20: O( DE\ PEPAI-DEUME/NOS OU)/TE E(AUTO\N OU)/TE A)/LLOUS AI)TIA=TAI TW=N OI)KEI/WN PARORAMA/TWN. *OU)DE\ GA\R AU)TO\S PARORA=| TW=N DEO/NTWN OU)DE\N A)LL' E)/STIN AU)TO\S TH=S TOU= KAQH/KONTOS EU(RE/SEWS A)RXHGO/S. @1 @&10Origenes in evang. Ioannis II 10 p. 122 Lo.$10 *)/ESTI TINA\ <20DO/G-MATA>20 PAR' *(/ELLHSI <20KALOU/MENA PARA/DOCA, TW=| KAT' AU)TOU\S SOFW=| PLEI=STA O(/SA PROSA/PTONTA META/ TINOS A)PODEI/CEWS H)\ FAINOME/NHS A)PODEI/CEWS>20. KAQ' A(/ FASI MO/NON KAI\ PA/NTA TO\N SOFO\N EI)=NAI I(ERE/A, TW=| MO/NON KAI\ PA/NTA TO\N SOFO\N E)PISTH/MHN E)/XEIN TH=S TOU= QEOU= QERAPEI/AS, KAI\ MO/NON KAI\ PA/NTA TO\N SOFO\N EI)=NAI E)LEU/QERON, E)COUSI/AN AU)TOPRAGI/AS A)PO\ TOU= QEI/OU NO/MOU EI)LHFO/TA: KAI\ TH\N E)COUSI/AN DE\ O(RI/ZONTAI NOMI/MHN E)PITROPH/N. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 17 p. 1041f.$8 <20E)N TW=| TRI/TW| PERI\ *DIKAIOSU/NHS>20 TAU=T' EI)/RHKE: "1<20*DIO\ KAI\ DIA\ TH\N U(PERBOLH\N TOU= TE MEGE/QOUS KAI\ TOU= KA/LLOUS, PLA/SMASI DOKOU=MEN O(/MOIA LE/-GEIN, KAI\ OU) KATA\ TO\N A)/NQRWPON KAI\ TH\N A)NQRWPI/NHN FU/SIN>20."2 @&Plutarchus Quaest. Conv. I 9 p. 626f.$ *QE/WN__PRO\S *QEMISTOKLE/A TO\N *STWI+KO\N DIHPO/RHSE TI/ DH/POTE <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 E)N POL-LOI=S TW=N PARALO/GWN KAI\ A)TO/PWN E)PIMNHSQEI/S, OI(=O/N E)STI TO\ "1<20TA/RIXOS, A)\N A(/LMH| BRE/XHTAI, GLUKU/TERON GI/GNESQAI"2 KAI\ TO\ "1<20TW=N E)RI/WN TOU\S PO/KOUS H(=TTON U(PAKOU/EIN TOI=S BI/A| DIASPW=SIN H)\ TOI=S A)TRE/MA DIALU/OUSI>20"2 KAI\ TO\ "1<20NHSTEU/SANTAS A)RGO/TERON E)SQI/EIN H)\ PROFAGO/NTAS>20"2 OU)DENO\S AU)TW=N AI)TI/AN A)PE/DWKEN. @*(O DE\ *QEMISTOKLH=S EI)PW\N O(/TI <20TAU=TA *XRU/SIPPOS A)/LLWS E)N PARADEI/GMATOS LO/GW| PROU)/QETO, R(A|DI/WS H(MW=N KAI\ A)LO/GWS U(PO\ TOU= EI)KO/TOS A(LISKOME/NWN KAI\ PA/LIN A)PISTOU/NTWN TW=| PARA\ TO\ EI)KO\S>20 E)PISTRE/FWN: *SOI\ D', E)/FH,& etc. @&10Proclus in Eucliden 35, 25 p. 397 Friedlein.$10 E)CEIRGA/SANTO GA\R KAI\ OI( A)PO\ TW=N MAQHMA/TWN TO\N PARA/DOCON LEGO/MENON TO/PON, W(/SPER OI( <20A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 E)PI\ TW=N DEIGMA/TWN&10 etc. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 111, 18 W.$10 <20YEU=DOS D' U(POLAMBA/NEIN OU)DE/-POTE/ FASI TO\N SOFO/N>20, OU)DE\ TO\ PARA/PAN A)KATALH/PTW| TINI\ SUGKATATI/QE- @1SQAI, DIA\ TO\ MHDE\ <20DOCA/ZEIN>20 AU)TO\N MHD' A)GNOEI=N MHDE/N. TH\N GA\R A)/GNOIAN METAPTWTIKH\N EI)=NAI SUGKATA/QESIN KAI\ A)SQENH=. *MHDE\N D' U(POLAMBA/NEIN A)SQE-NW=S, A)LLA\ MA=LLON A)SFALW=S KAI\ BEBAI/WS, DIO\ KAI\ MHDE\ DOCA/ZEIN TO\N SOFO/N. *DITTA\S GA\R EI)=NAI DO/CAS, TH\N ME\N A)KATALH/PTW| SUGKATA/QESIN, TH\N DE\ U(PO/LHYIN A)SQENH=: TAU/TAS [2D']2 A)LLOTRI/OUS EI)=NAI TH=S TOU= SOFOU= DIAQE/SEWS: DI' O(\ KAI\ TO\ PROPI/PTEIN PRO\ KATALH/YEWS [2KAI\]2 SUGKATATI/QESQAI KATA\ TO\N PROPETH= FAU=LON EI)=NAI KAI\ MH\ PI/PTEIN EI)S TO\N EU)FUH= KAI\ TE/LEION A)/NDRA KAI\ SPOU-DAI=ON. *OU)DE\ <20LANQA/NEIN>20 DE\ AU)TO/N TI, TH\N GA\R LH=SIN EI)=NAI YEU/DOUS U(PO/-LHYIN A)POFANTIKH\N PRA/GMATOS. *TOU/TOIS D' A)KOLOU/QWS OU)K A)PISTEI=N, TH\N GA\R A)PISTI/AN EI)=NAI YEU/DOUS U(PO/LHYIN: <20TH\N DE\ PI/STIN A)STEI=ON U(PA/RXEIN>20, EI)=NAI GA\R KATA/LHYIN I)SXURA/N, BEBAIOU=SAN TO\ U(POLAMBANO/MENON. *(OMOI/WS DE\ KAI\ TH\N E)PISTH/MHN A)META/PTWTON U(PO\ LO/GOU: DIA\ TAU=TA/ FASI MH/TE E)PI/STASQAI/ TI TO\N FAU=LON MH/TE PISTEU/EIN. *)EXOME/NWS DE\ TOU/TWN <20OU)/TE PLEONEKTEI=SQAI>20 TO\N SOFO\N <20OU)/TE BOUKOLEI=SQAI>20 OU)/TE DIAITA=SQAI OU)/TE <20PARARIQMEI=N>20 OU)/TE U(F' E(TE/ROU PARARIQMEI=SQAI. TAU=TA GA\R PA/NTA TH\N A)PA/THN PERIE/XEIN KAI\ TOI=S KATA\ TO\N TO/PON YEU/DESI PRO/SQESIN. *OU)DE/NA DE\ TW=N A)STEI/WN OU)/Q' <20O(DOU= DIAMARTA/NEIN>20 OU)/T' OI)KI/AS OU)/TE SKOPOU=: A)LL' OU)DE\ <20PARORA=N>20 [A)LL'] OU)DE\ <20PARAKOU/EIN>20 NOMI/ZOUSI TO\N SOFO/N, OU)DE\ TO\ SU/NOLON PARAPAI/EIN KATA/ TI TW=N AI)SQHTHRI/WN: KAI\ GA\R TOU/TWN E(/KASTON E)/XESQAI NOMI/ZOUSI TW=N[DE] YEU-DW=N SUGKATAQE/SEWN. <20OU)D' U(PONOEI=N>20 DE/ FASI TO\N SOFO/N: KAI\ GA\R TH\N U(PO/NOIAN A)KATALH/PTW| EI)=NAI TW=| GE/NEI SUGKATA/QESIN: <20OU)DE\ METANOEI=N>20 D' U(POLAMBA/NOUSI TO\N NOU=N E)/XONTA: KAI\ GA\R TH\N META/NOIAN E)/XESQAI YEUDOU=S SUGKATAQE/SEWS, [2W(S]2 A)\N PRODIAPEPTWKO/TOS. <20OU)DE\ METABA/LLESQAI>20 DE\ KAT' OU)DE/NA TRO/PON OU)DE\ METATI/QESQAI OU)DE\ SFA/LLESQAI: TAU=TA GA\R EI)=NAI PA/NTA TW=N TOI=S DO/GMASI METAPIPTO/NTWN, O(/PER A)LLO/TRION EI)=NAI TOU= NOU=N E)/XONTOS: <20OU)DE\ DOKEI=N AU)TW=| TI>20 FASI\ PARAPLHSI/WS TOI=S EI)RHME/NOIS. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 121.$10 E)/TI TE <20MH\ DOCA/SEIN TO\N SOFO/N>20, TOU-TE/STI YEUDEI= MH\ SUGKATAQH/SESQAI MHDENI/. @&10Sextus adv. math. VII 157 [1Arcesilaus]1.$10 <20OU)XI\ DE/ GE TW=N DO-CASTW=N E)STIN O( SOFO/S>20. TOU=TO GA\R A)FROSU/NHS H)=N KAT' AU)TOU\S KAI\ TW=N A(MARTHMA/TWN AI)/TION. @&10Cicero Acad. Pr. II 48. praesertim. cum ipsi dicatis [1scil. Stoici]1 &10sapientem in furore sustinere se ab omni adsensu, quia nulla in visis &10distinctio appareat. &10@Augustinus Soliloq. I 5, 9 R. Ergo istarum rerum disciplinam, &10siqua tibi est, non dubitas vocari scientiam? A. Non, si <21Stoici>21 sinant, &10<21qui scientiam tribuunt nulli nisi sapienti>21. Perceptionem sane &10istorum me habere non nego, quam etiam stultitiae concedunt. &10@Lactant. iustit. div. III 4. Recte igitur <21Zeno>21 ac <21Stoici>21 opi-&10nationem repudiarunt. <21Opinari enim te scire, quod nescias, non @1 &10est sapientis>21, sed temerarii potius ac stulti. Ergo si neque sciri quic-&10quam potest, ut Socrates docuit, nec opinari oportet, ut Zeno%10 tota philo-&10sophia sublata est. &10@Stobaeus eclog. II 7 p. 111, 10.$10 *LE/GESQAI DE\ <20MH\ YEU/DESQAI TO\N SOFO/N>20, A)LL' E)N PA=SIN A)LHQEU/EIN: OU) GA\R E)N TW=| LE/GEIN TI YEU=DOS TO\ YEU/DESQAI U(PA/RXEIN, A)LL' E)N TW=| DIAYEUST[2IK]2W=S TO\ YEU=DOS LE/GEIN KAI\ E)PI\ A)PA/TH| TW=N PLHSI/ON. *TW=| ME/NTOI YEU/DEI POTE\ SUGXRH/SESQAI NOMI/ZOUSIN AU)-TO\N KATA\ POLLOU\S TRO/POUS A)/NEU SUGKATAQE/SEWS: KAI\ GA\R KATA\ STRATHGI/AN [2KATA\]2 TW=N A)NTIPA/LWN KAI\ KATA\ TH\N TOU= SUMFE/RONTOS PROO/RASIN KAI\ KAT' A)/LLAS OI)KONOMI/AS TOU= BI/OU POLLA/S. @&10Quintilianus instit. orat. XII 1, 38. ac primum concedant mihi &10omnes oportet, quod <21Stoicorum>21 quoque asperrimi confitentur, <21facturum &10aliquando virum bonum, ut mendacium dicat>21, et quidem nonnun-&10quam levioribus causis, ut in pueris aegrotantibus utilitatis eorum gratia &10multa fingimus, multa non facturi promittimus%10 nedum si ab homine occi-&10dendo grassator avertendus sit aut hostis pro salute patriae fallendus, ut &10hoc quod alias in servis quoque reprehendendum est, sit alias in ipso sa-&10piente laudandum. &10@Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 122.$10 E)/TI KAI\ <20A)NAMARTH/TOUS>20 [1&10scil.$10 EI)=NAI TOU\S SOFOU/S]1 TW=| A)PERIPTW/TOUS EI)=NAI A(MARTH/MATI. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 65, 12 W.$10 FASI\ DE\ KAI\ <20PA/NTA POIEI=N TO\N SOFO\N [2KATA\]2 PA/SAS TA\S A)RETA/S>20. PA=SAN GA\R PRA=CIN TELEI/AN AU)TOU= EI)=NAI, DIO\ KAI\ MHDEMIA=S A)POLELEI=FQAI A)RETH=S. @&10Philo de fortitudine Vol. II Mang. p. 426.$10 W(S DH\ E(KA/STHN H(ME/-RAN TOU= SPOUDAI/OU MHDE\N E)/RHMON KAI\ KENO\N E)A=N EI)S PA/RODON A(MARTHMA/TWN, A)LLA\ PA=SI TOI=S ME/RESI KAI\ DIASTH/MASIN AU)TH=S KALOKA)GAQI/AS PEPLHRW=SQAI. *KRI/NETAI GA\R OU) POSO/THTI A)LLA\ POIO/THTI H( A)RETH\ KAI\ TO\ KALO/N: O(/QEN I)SO/TI-MON KALW=| BI/W| SOFOU= KAI\ MI/AN H(ME/RAN U(PE/LABON EI)=NAI KATORQOUME/NHN. _ __DIO/TI <20PA/SAIS ME\N TAI=S KINH/SESI, PA/SAIS DE\ TAI=S SXE/SESIN O( SPOUDAI=OS E)PAINETO/S>20, E)/NDON TE KAI\ E)/CW, POLITIKO/S TE O(MOU= KAI\ OI)KONO/MOS, TA\ ME\N E)/NDON E)CORQW=N OI)KONOMIKW=S, TA\ D' E)/CW POLITIKW=S H(=| SUMFE/RON E)PANOR-QOU=SQAI. @&10Philo de anim. sacrif. idon. Vol. II Mang. p. 249.$10 TO\N AU)TO\N TRO/PON KAI\ TW=N SPOUDAI/WN KAI\ FILOQE/WN SUMBAI/NEI TA\S PRO\S KALOKAGAQI/AN A)FORI/AS A)MEI/NOUS EI)=NAI W(=N E)K TU/XHS OI( FAU=LOI KATORQOU=SI. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 66, 14 W.$10 *LE/GOUSI DE\ KAI\ <20PA/NT' EU)= POIEI=N TO\N SOFO/N>20, A(\ POIEI=: DH=LON. *(\ON TRO/PON GA\R LE/GOMEN PA/NT' EU)= POIEI=N TO\N AU)LHTH\N H)\ KIQARW|DO/N, SUNUPAKOUOME/NOU TOU= O(/TI TA\ ME\N KATA\ TH\N AU)/LHSIN, TA\ DE\ KATA\ TH\N KIQARW|DI/AN, TO\N AU)TO\N TRO/PON PA/NT' EU)= POIEI=N TO\N FRO/NI-MON, KAI\ O(/SA POIEI= KAI\ OU) MA\ *DI/A KAI\ A(\ MH\ POIEI=. *TW=| GA\R KATA\ LO/GON O)RQO\N E)PITELEI=N PA/NTA KAI\ OI(=ON KAT' A)RETH/N, PERI\ O(/LON OU)=SAN TO\N BI/ON TE/X- @1NHN, A)KO/LOUQON W)|H/QHSAN TO\ PERI\ TOU= PA/NT' EU)= POIEI=N TO\N SOFO\N DO/GMA. KATA\ TO\ A)NA/LOGON DE\ KAI\ TO\N FAU=LON PA/NTA O(/SA POIEI= KAKW=S POIEI=N KATA\ PA/SAS TA\S KAKI/AS. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 125.$10 <20PA/NTA TE EU)= POIEI=N>20 TO\N SOFO/N, W(S KAI\ PA/NTA FAME\N TA\ AU)LH/MATA EU)= AU)LEI=N TO\N *)ISMHNI/AN. @&10Dio Chrysost. or. LXXI %14 5 [1Vol. II p. 182 Arn.$10]1. E)GW\ DE/ FHMI TO\N FILO/SOFON TA\S ME\N TE/XNAS OU)X OI(=O/N TE EI)=NAI PA/SAS EI)DE/NAI [1XALEPO\N GA\R KAI\ MI/AN A)KRIBW=S E)RGA/SASQAI]1, <20POIH=SAI D' A)\N A(/PANTA BE/LTION O(/, TI A)\N TU/XH| POIW=N TW=N A)/LLWN A)NQRW/PWN>20, KAI\ TA\ KATA\ TA\S TE/XNAS, A)\N A)/RA A)NAGKASQH=| POTE A(/YASQAI TOIOU/TOU TINO/S, OU) KATA\ TH\N TE/XNHN DIAFE/RONTA_ TOU=TO GA\R OU)X OI(=O/N TE, TOU= TE/KTONOS TO\N I)DIW/THN A)/MEINON POIH=SAI/ TI KATA\ TH\N TEKTONIKH\N H)\ TOU= GEWRGOU= TO\N OU)K O)/NTA GEWRGI/AS E)/MPEIRON E)N TW=| POIEI=N TI TW=N GEWRGIKW=N E)MPEIRO/TERON FANH=NAI_POU= D' A)\N DIAFE/ROI; TW=| SUMFE-RO/NTWS POIEI=N H)\ MH\ POIEI=N KAI\ O(/TE DEI= KAI\ O(/POU KAI\ TO\N KAIRO\N GNW=NAI TOU= DHMIOURGOU= MA=LLON KAI\ TO\ DUNATO/N. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 102, 20 W.$10 <20*PA/NTA TE EU)= POIEI= O( NOU=N E)/XWN>20, KAI\ GA\R FRONI/MWS KAI\ E)GKRATW=S KAI\ KOSMI/WS KAI\ EU)TA/KTWS TAI=S PERI\ TO\N BI/ON E)MPEIRI/AIS XRW/MENOS SUNEXW=S. O( DE\ FAU=LOS, A)/PEIROS W)\N TH=S O)RQH=S XRH/-SEWS, PA/NTA KAKW=S POIEI= KAQ' H(\N E)/XEI DIA/QESIN E)NERGW=N, EU)META/PTWTOS W)\N KAI\ PAR' E(/KASTA METAMELEI/A| SUNEXO/MENOS. *EI)=NAI DE\ TH\N METAME/LEIAN LU/PHN E)PI\ PEPRAGME/NOIS W(S PAR' AU(TOU= H(MARTHME/NOIS, KAKODAIMONIKO/N TI PA/QOS YUXH=S KAI\ STASIW=DES: E)F' O(/SON GA\R A)/XQETAI TOI=S SUMBEBHKO/SIN O( E)N TAI=S METAMELEI/AIS W)/N, E)PI\ TOSOU=TON A)GANAKTEI= PRO\S E(AUTO\N W(S AI)/TION GEGONO/TA TOU/TWN: DI' O(\ KAI\ A)/TIMON EI)=NAI PA/NTA FAU=LON, MH/TE TIMH=S A)/CION O)/NTA MH/TE TI/MION U(PA/RXONTA. TH\N GA\R TIMH\N EI)=NAI GE/RWS A)CI/WSIN, TO\ DE\ GE/RAS A)=QLON A)RETH=S EU)ERGETIKH=S. TO\N OU)=N A)RETH=S A)ME/TOXON A)/TIMON DIKAI/WS LE/GESQAI. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 115, 5 W.$10 *LE/GOUSI DE\ MH/TE PARA\ TH\N O)/RECIN MH/TE PARA\ TH\N O(RMH\N MH/TE PARA\ TH\N E)PIBOLH\N GI/NESQAI/ TI PERI\ TO\N SPOU-DAI=ON, <20DIA\ TO\ MEQ' U(PECAIRE/SEWS PA/NTA POIEI=N>20 TA\ TOIAU=TA KAI\ MHDE\N AU)TW=| TW=N E)NANTIOUME/NWN A)PRO/LHPTON PROSPI/PTEIN. @&10Seneca de beneficiis IV 34. Non mutat sapiens consilium om &10nibus his manentibus, quae erant, cum sumeret. ideo <21nunquam illum &10poenitentia subit>21, quia nihil melius illo tempore fieri potuit, quam &10quod factum est, nihil melius constitui, quam quod constitutum est. cete-&10rum <21ad omnia cum exceptione venit%10 si nihil inciderit>21, quod &10impediat. ideo omnia illi succedere dicimus et nihil contra opinionem &10accidere, quia praesumit animo posse aliquid intervenire, quod destinata &10prohibeat. &10@Philo Quod deus sit immut. %14 22 Vol. II p. 61, 1 Wendl.$10 KAI/-TOI TINW=N A)CIOU/NTWN MHDE\ PA/NTAS A)NQRW/POUS TAI=S GNW/MAIS E)PAMFOTERI/ZEIN. *TOU\S GA\R A)DO/LWS KAI\ KAQARW=S FILOSOFH/SANTAS ME/GISTON E)K TH=S E)PISTH/MHS A)GAQO\N EU(/RASQAI, TO\ <20MH\ TOI=S PRA/GMASI SUMMETABA/LLEIN>20, A)LLA\ META\ STER)R(O/THTOS A)KLINOU=S KAI\ PAGI/OU BEBAIO/THTOS A(/PASI TOI=S A(RMO/TTOUSIN E)GXEIREI=N. @1 @&10Stobaeus eclog. II 7 p. 99, 9 W.$10 *KAI\ TO\N ME\N SPOUDAI=ON, TAI=S PERI\ TO\N BI/ON E)MPEIRI/AIS XRW/MENON E)N TOI=S PRATTOME/NOIS U(P' AU)TOU=, PA/NT' EU)= POIEI=N, KAQA/PER FRONI/MWS KAI\ SWFRO/NWS KAI\ KATA\ TA\S A)/LLAS A)RETA/S: TO\N DE\ FAU=LON KATA\ TOU)NANTI/ON KAKW=S. *KAI\ TO\N ME\N SPOUDAI=ON ME/GAN EI)=NAI KAI\ A(DRO\N KAI\ U(YHLO\N KAI\ I)SXURO/N. <20*ME/GAN>20 ME/N, O(/TI DU/NATAI E)FIKNEI=SQAI TW=N KATA\ PROAI/RESIN O)/NTWN AU)TW=| KAI\ PROKEIME/NWN: <20A(DRO\N>20 DE\ O(/TI E)STI\N HU)-CHME/NOS PA/NTOQEN: <20U(YHLO\N>20 D' O(/TI METEI/LHFE TOU= E)PIBA/LLONTOS U(/YOUS A)NDRI\ GENNAI/W| KAI\ SOFW=|: KAI\ <20I)SXURO\N>20 D' O(/TI TH\N E)PIBA/LLOUSAN I)SXU\N PERIPEPOI/H-TAI, A)H/TTHTOS W)\N KAI\ A)KATAGW/NISTOS. *PAR' O(\ KAI\ <20OU)/TE A)NAGKA/ZETAI U(PO/ TINOS>20 OU)/TE A)NAGKA/ZEI TINA/, <20OU)/TE KWLU/ETAI>20 OU)/TE KWLU/EI, <20OU)/TE BIA/ZETAI>20 U(PO/ TINOS OU)/T' AU)TO\S BIA/ZEI TINA/, OU)/TE DESPO/ZEI OU)/TE DESPO/ZETAI, OU)/TE KAKO-POIEI= TINA <20OU)/T' AU)TO\S KAKOPOIEI=TAI, OU)/TE KAKOI=S PERIPI/PTEI>20 [2OU)/T' A)/LLON POIEI= KAKOI=S PERIPI/PTEIN]2 <20OU)/T' E)CAPATA=TAI>20 OU)/TE E)CAPATA=| A)/LLON, OU)/TE DIAYEU/DETAI OU)/TE A)GNOEI= OU)/TE LANQA/NEI E(AUTO\N OU)/TE KAQO/LOU YEU=DOS U(PO-LAMBA/NEI: EU)DAI/MWN D' E)STI\ MA/LISTA KAI\ EU)TUXH\S KAI\ MAKA/RIOS KAI\ O)/LBIOS KAI\ EU)SEBH\S KAI\ QEOFILH\S KAI\ A)CIWMATIKO/S, BASILIKO/S TE KAI\ STRATHGIKO\S KAI\ POLITIKO\S KAI\ OI)KONOMIKO\S KAI\ XRHMATISTIKO/S. *TOU\S DE\ FAU/LOUS A(/PANTA TOU/-TOIS E)NANTI/A E)/XEIN. @&10Ae%28t. Plac. IV 9, 17.$10 <20*OI( *STWI+KOI\>20 TO\N SOFO\N AI)SQH/SEI KATA-LHPTO\N A)PO\ TOU= EI)/DOUS TEKMHRIWDW=S. @&10Varro$10 TAFH\ *MENI/PPOU&10 II [1Satur. Men. ed. Riese p. 222]1. In &10charto stadio$10 E)PITA/FION&10 ago$10 A)GW=NA,&10 quam qui certassit animo, bellus homo, &10magis delectatus <21Stoicorum pancratio>21 quam athletarum. &10@Cicero Tuscul, disp. III 14. Qui fortis est, idem est fidens, qui &10autem est fidens, is profecto non extimescit; discrepat enim a timendo &10confidere. Atqui in quem cadit aegritudo, in eundem timor; quarum &10enim rerum praesentia sumus in aegritudine, easdem impendentes et ve-&10nientes timemus. Ita fit ut fortitudini aegritudo repugnet. _Verisi-&10mile est igitur, in quem cadat aegritudo, cadere in eundem timorem et &10infractionem quidem animi et demissionem. Quae in quem cadunt, in &10eundem cadit ut serviat, ut victum, si quando, se esse fateatur. Quae qui &10recipit, recipiat idem necesse est timiditatem et ignaviam. Non cadunt &10autem haec in virum fortem; igitur ne aegritudo quidem. At nemo sa-&10piens nisi fortis; <21non cadet ergo in sapientem aegritudo>21. @1 @&10`19. Praeterea necesse est, qui fortis sit, eundem esse magni animi; &10[2qui magni animi]2 sit, invictum; qui invictus sit, eum res humanas de-&10spicere atque infra se positas arbitrari; despicere autem nemo potest eas &10res, propter quas aegritudine adfici potest; ex quo efficitur fortem virum &10aegritudine numquam adfici; omnes autem sapientes fortes; <21non cadit &10igitur in sapientem aegritudo.>21 &10@Et quem ad modum oculus conturbatus non est probe adfectus ad &10suum munus fungendum, et reliquae partes totumve corpus, statu cum &10est motum, deest officio suo et muneri, sic conturbatus animus non est &10aptus ad exsequendum munus suum. Munus autem animi est ratione &10bene uti, et sapientis animus ita semper adfectus est, ut ratione optime &10utatur; numquam igitur est perturbatus. <21At aegritudo perturbatio &10est animi; semper igitur ea sapiens vacabit.>21 @&10`18. Qui sit frugi igitur vel, si mavis, moderatus et temperans, eum &10necesse est esse constantem; qui autem constans, quietum; qui quietus, &10perturbatione omni vacuum, ergo etiam aegritudine. Et sunt illa sapien-&10tis; <21aberit igitur a sapiente aegritudo.>21 &10@Philo quaest. et. solut. in Genesin IV 73 [1p. 302 Aucher]1. <21Luc-&10tus non habet locum in incorruptis>21; atqui tam sapientia quam vir-&10tus omnis incorruptibilis est; in illis vero, quae haberi possunt et defici-&10unt tamen, necesse est aegre ferri. Verum optime diligentia habenda in &10hoc, quod nec planctum neque luctum usurpasse sapientem inducit__; &10quoniam res ex improviso occurrentes praeterque voluntatem impingentes &10hominem pusillae mentis coarctant et praecipitant, constantem vero undi-&10que, humiliant tantum impetu facto, haud tamen tali, quae usque in finem &10perducant, sed a rectore consilii fortissime repulsae retroverti coguntur. &10@Augustinus de vita beata c. 25. Ergo, inquam, miserum esse &10omnem qui egeat, dubitat nemo%10 nec nos terrent quaedam sapientium &10corpori necessaria. Non enim eis eget ipse animus, in quo posita est &10vita beata. Ipse enim perfectus est, <21nullus autem perfectus aliquo &10eget>21 et quod videtur corpori necessarium, sumet, si adfuerit%10 si non ad-&10fuerit, non eum istarum rerum franget inopia. Omnis namque sapiens &10fortis est, nullus autem fortis aliquid metuit. Non igitur metuit sapiens &10aut mortem corporis aut dolores, quibus pellendis vel vitandis vel diffe-&10rendis sunt necessaria illa, quorum ei potest contingere inopia. Sed tamen &10non desinit eis bene uti, si ipsa non desunt. Verissima est enim illa &10sententia%10 [1Ter. Eun. IV 6]1 Nam tu quod vitare possis, stultum admittere &10est. Vitabit ergo mortem ac dolorem quantum potest et quantum decet, &10ne si minime vitaverit non ex eo miser sit quia haec accidunt, sed quia &10vitare cum posset noluit%10 quod manifestum stultitiae signum est. Erit &10ergo ista non vitans non earum rerum perpessione, sed stultitia miser. Si &10autem non valuerit evitare, cum id sedulo ac decenter egerit, non eum &10ista irruentia miserum facient. Etenim et illa eiusdem Comici sententia &10non minus vera est%10 Quoniam non potest id fieri quod vis, id velis quod &10possit [1Ter. Andr. II 1]1. <21Quomodo erit miser, cui nihil accidit &10praeter voluntatem>21? Quia quod sibi videt non posse provenire, non &10potest velle. Habet enim rerum certissimarum voluntatem, id est ut @1 &10quidquid agit non agat nisi ex virtutis quodam praescripto et divina lege &10sapientiae, quae nullo ab eo pacto eripi possunt. &10@Seneca de beneficiis II 18. Totiens admoneam necesse est, non &10loqui me <21de sapientibus, quos quicquid oportet et iuvat>21, qui &10animum in potestate habent et legem sibi quam volunt dicunt, quam &10dixerunt servant etc. @&Stobaeus Florilegium 7, 21.$ *XRUSI/PPOU: *)/ELEGEN DE\ O( *XRU/-SIPPOS A)LGEI=N ME\N TO\N SOFO/N, MH\ BASANI/ZESQAI DE/: MH\ GA\R E)NDIDO/NAI TH=| YUXH=|. *KAI\ DEI=SQAI ME/N, MH\ PROSDE/XESQAI DE/. @&10Commenta Lucani lib. IX 569 p. 304 Us. Sapientem enim uio-&10lentia nulla commutat, nec fortuna terret amissione aut adquisitione re-&10rum. libenter subit quicquid inimica fortuna protulerit. <21Stoici negant &10sapientem malis adfici>21, cum%2%2 &10@Minuc. Fel. Octav. cp. 37. Quam pulchrum spectaculum deo &10cum Christianus cum dolore congreditur, cum adversum minas et supplicia &10et tormenta componitur, cum strepitum mortis et horrorem carnificis in-&10ridens inculcat, cum libertatem suam adversus reges et principes erigit, &10soli deo cuius est cedit, cum triumphator et victor ipsi qui adversum se &10sententiam dixit, insultat. Vicit enim qui quod contendit obtinuit. &10@Sen. dial. I 2, 7 sq. Minucium hic Stoica exempla sequi probant. &10@Lactant. div. instit. V 13. Haec est vera virtus, quam philo-&10sophi quoque gloriabundi non re, sed verbis inanibus iactant, disserentes &10nihil esse tam congruens viri sapientis gravitati atque constantiae, quam &10<21nullis terroribus de sententiae proposito posse depelli>21; sed tanti &10esse cruciari et emori, ne fidem prodat, ne ab officio discedat, ne metu &10mortis aut dolore acerbo subactus aliquid faciat iniustum. &10@Stobaeus eclog. II 7 p. 110 W.$10 *LE/GOUSI DE\ KAI\ <20TO\N SOFO\N A)NU/BRISTON EI)=NAI>20: OU)/Q' U(BRI/ZESQAI GA\R OU)/Q' U(BRI/ZEIN DIA\ TO\ TH\N U(/BRIN A)DIKI/AN EI)=NAI KATAISXU/NOUSAN KAI\ BLA/BHN: <20MH/TE DE\ A)DIKEI=SQAI MH/TE BLA/PTESQAI>20 TO\N SPOUDAI=ON: A)DIKHTIKW=S ME/NTOI GE/ TINAS AU)TW=| PROSFE/RESQAI KAI\ U(BRISTIKW=S KAI\ KATA\ TOU=TO A)DIKOPRAGEI=N. *PRO\S TOU/TW| MHDE\ [2TH\]2N TUXOU=SAN A)DIKI/AN EI)=NAI TH\N U(/BRIN, A)LLA\ [2TH\N]2 KATAISXU/NOUSAN KAI\ U(BRISTI-KH\N OU)=SAN. *)APERI/PTWTON D' U(PA/RXEIN TO\N NOU=N E)/XONTA TOU/TOIS KAI\ MHDAMW=S KATAISXU/NESQAI: E)N E(AUTW=| GA\R E)/XEIN TO\ A)GAQO\N KAI\ TH\N QEI/AN A)RETH/N, DI' O(\ KAI\ PA/SHS A)PHLLA/XQAI KAKI/AS KAI\ BLA/BHS. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 20 p. 1044a.$ A)DIKEI=TAI GA\R OU)DEI\S MH\ BLAPTO/MENOS: O(/QEN <20MH\ A)DIKEI=SQAI TO\N SOFO\N E)N A)/L-LOIS A)POFHNA/MENOS>20 [1&scil. Chrysippus$]1 E)NTAU=QA/ FHSIN [1&scil.$ E)N TW=| ÄPRW/TW| PERI\ BI/WN]1 A)DIKHMA/ TI TO\N TO/PON E)PIDE/XESQAI. @&10Seneca de beneficiis II 35. A consuetudine quaedam quae di-&10cimus abhorrent, deinde alia via ad consuetudinem redeunt. <21Negamus @1 &10iniuriam accipere sapientem>21, tamen qui illum pugno percusserit, &10iniuriarum damnabitur; negamus stulti quicquam esse, et tamen eum, qui &10rem aliquam stulto subripuit, furti condemnabimus; insanire omnes dici-&10mus, nec tamen omnes curamus elleboro; his ipsis, quos vocamus insanos, &10et suffragium et iurisdictionem committimus. &10@Stobaeus ecl. II 115, 18 W.$10 <20*)ADIA/BOLON D' EI)=NAI>20 PA/NTA TO\N KALO\N KA)GAQO/N, A)PARA/DEKTON O)/NTA DIABOLH=S, O(/QEN KAI\ A)DIA/BOLON EI)=NAI KATA/ TE TOU=TON TO\N TRO/PON KAI\ TW=| MH\ DIABA/LLEIN E(/TERON. *EI)=NAI DE\ TH\N DIABOLH\N DIA/STASIN FAINOME/NWN FI/LWN YEUDEI= LO/GW|: TOU=TO DE\ MH\ GI/NESQAI PERI\ TOU\S A)GAQOU\S A)/NDRAS, MO/NOUS DE\ TOU\S FAU/LOUS KAI\ DIABA/LLESQAI KAI\ DIABA/LLEIN, DI' O(\ KAI\ TOU\S ME\N KAT' A)LH/QEIAN FI/LOUS MH/TE DIABA/LLEIN MH/TE DIABA/LLESQAI, TOU\S DE\ DOKOU=NTAS KAI\ FAINOME/NOUS. @&10Cicero de finibus III 26. cum igitur hoc sit extremum, con-&10gruenter naturae convenienterque vivere, necessario sequitur <21omnes sa-&10pientes semper feliciter, absolute, fortunate vivere>21, nulla re &10impediri, nulla prohiberi, nulla egere. &10@Philo quaest. et solut. in Genesin IV 92 [1p. 318 Aucher]1. <21Vita &10sapientis omnis omnino plena est felicitate>21 nulla relicta parte &10vacua, in quam irreperet peccatum. @&Dio Chrysost. or. LXIX %14 4 [1Vol. II p. 175, 14 Arn.]1$8 A)\N DE\ H( YUXH\ E)/MFRWN GE/NHTAI KAI\ O( NOU=S A)GAQO\S KAI\ I(KANOI\ W)=SI TA/ TE AU(-TW=N PRA/GMATA O)RQW=S PRA/TTEIN KAI\ TA\ TW=N A)/LLWN, <20TOU/TOUS A)NA/GKH KAI\ EU)DAIMO/NWS ZH=N>20, NOMI/MOUS A)/NDRAS GENOME/NOUS KAI\ A)GAQOU= DAI/MO-NOS TUXO/NTAS KAI\ FI/LOUS O)/NTAS TOI=S QEOI=S. @<20OU) GA\R A)/LLOUS ME\N FRONI/MOUS EI)KO\S EI)=NAI, A)/LLOUS DE\ E)M-PEI/ROUS TW=N A)NQRWPI/NWN PRAGMA/TWN, OU)DE\ A)/LLOUS ME\N TA)N-QRW/PEIA E)PI/STASQAI, A)/LLOUS DE\ TA\ QEI=A, OU)DE\ A)/LLOUS ME\N EI)=-NAI TW=N QEI/WN E)PISTH/MONAS, A)/LLOUS DE\ O(SI/OUS, OU)DE\ A)/LLOUS ME\N O(SI/OUS, A)/LLOUS DE\ QEOFILEI=S: OU)DE\ E(/TEROI ME\N E)/SONTAI QEOFILEI=S, E(/TEROI DE\ EU)DAI/MONES. @OU)DE\ E(/TEROI ME/N EI)SIN A)/NQRWPOI A)/FRONES, E(/TEROI D' A)GNO-OU=SI TA\ KAQ' AU(TOU\S PRA/GMATA: OU)DE\ OI(\ TA\ SFE/TERA PRA/GMATA A)GNOOU=SI, TA\ QEI=A I)/SASIN: OU)DE\ OI( FAU/LWS PERI\ TW=N QEI/WN U(PEILHFO/TES OU)K A)NO/SIOI/ EI)SIN. OU)DE/ GE TOU\S A)NOSI/OUS OI(=O/NTE FI/LOUS EI)=NAI QEOI=S, OU)DE\ TOU\S MH\ FI/LOUS QEOI=S MH\ DUSTUXEI=S EI)=NAI>20. @&10Stephanus fragm. comment. in Aristot. Rhet. III p. 325, 13 Rabe.$10 <20OI( *STWI+KOI\ EU)DAI/MONA LE/GOUSI TO\N TA\S *PRIAMIKA\S SUMFORA\S U(PO-ME/NONTA>20. @1 @&10Gregorius Nazianzenus epist. 32.$10 *)EPAINW= DE\ TW=N <20A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 TO\ NEANIKO/N TE KAI\ MEGALO/NOUN, OI(\ MHDE\N KWLU/EIN FASI\ PRO\S EU)DAI-MONI/AN TA\ E)/CWQEN, A)LL' <20EI)=NAI TO\N SPOUDAI=ON MAKA/RION, KA)\N O( *FALA/-RIDOS TAU=ROS E)/XH| KAIO/MENON>20. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 101, 5 W.$10 TW=N TE A)GAQW=N MHDENO\S METE/XEIN TOU\S FAU/LOUS, E)PEIDH\ TO\ A)GAQO\N A)RETH/ E)STIN H)\ TO\ METE/XON A)RETH=S: TA/ TE PARAKEI/MENA TOI=S A)GAQOI=S, A(/PER E)STI\N W(=N XRH/, W)FELH/MATA O)/NTA, MO/NOIS TOI=S SPOUDAI/OIS SUMBAI/NEIN: KAQA/PER KAI\ TA\ PARAKEI/MENA TOI=S KAKOI=S, A(/PER E)STI\N W(=N OU) XRH/, MO/NOIS TOI=S KAKOI=S: BLA/MMATA GA\R EI)=NAI. KAI\ DIA\ TOU=TO <20TOU\S ME\N A)GAQOU\S A)BLABEI=S PA/NTAS EI)=NAI>20 KAT' A)MFO/TERA, OU)/TE BLA/PTEIN OI(/OUS TE O)/NTAS OU)/TE BLA/PTESQAI, TOU\S DE\ FAU/LOUS KATA\ TOU)NANTI/ON. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 123.$10 <20A)BLABEI=S TE EI)=NAI>20: OU)/[2TE]2 GA\R A)/LLOUS BLA/PTEIN OU)/TE AU(TOU/S. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II p. 100, 7 W.$10 *KAQO/LOU DE\ <20TOI=S ME\N SPOU-DAI/OIS PA/NTA TA)GAQA\ U(PA/RXEIN>20, TOI=S DE\ FAU/LOIS PA/NTA TA\ KAKA/. *OU) NOMISTE/ON DE\ LE/GEIN AU)TOU\S OU(/TWS, W(S EI)/ TINA/ E)STIN A)GAQA/, E)KEI=NA U(PA/RXEI TOI=S SPOUDAI/OIS, O(MOI/WS DE\ KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N KAKW=N: A)LLA/ TOI TOU\S ME\N TOSAU=TA E)/XEIN A)GAQA\ W(/STE MHDE\N E)LLEI/PEIN EI)S TO\ TE/LEION AU)TOI=S EI)=NAI TO\N BI/ON [2KAI\ EU)DAI/MONA]2, TOU\S DE\ TOSAU=TA KAKA/, W(/STE TO\N BI/ON A)TELH= EI)=NAI KAI\ KAKO-DAI/MONA. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 125.$10 KAI\ <20TW=N SOFW=N DE\ PA/NTA EI)=NAI>20: DE-DWKE/NAI GA\R AU)TOI=S PANTELH= E)COUSI/AN TO\N NO/MON. TW=N DE\ FAU/LWN EI)=NAI/ TINA LE/GETAI, O(\N TRO/PON KAI\ TW=N A)DI/KWN A)/LLWS ME\N TH=S PO/LEWS, A)/LLWS DE\ TW=N XRWME/NWN FAME/N. @&10Cicero de finibus III 75. [1de sapiente parodoxa enumerans]1 &10<21recte eius omnia dicentur, qui scit uti solus omnibus>21, recte etiam &10pulcher appellabitur [1animi enim liniamenta sunt pulchriora quam cor-&10poris]1 recte solus liber nec dominationi cuiusquam parens nec oboediens &10cupiditati, recte <21invictus>21, cuius etiamsi corpus constringatur, animo tamen &10vincula inici nulla possint etc. @&10Philo quaest. et. solut. in Genesin IV 99 [1p. 323 Aucher]1. Noli &10tamen existimare <21pulchritudinem>21 corporis nunc in medium referre iuxta &10illam formositatem nominatam, quae ex symmetria partium decoreque &10formae constat, qualis inest et meretricibus, quas tamen nunquam pulchras &10esse dixerim, sed ex adverso turpes; id enim nomen est eis proprium; &10siquidem_sicut per speculum proprietates corporis apparent, sic etiam &10animae per vultum ac faciem. @1 &10aspectus vero impudens et cervix &10alta frequensque motus supercilio-&10rum atque gressus lascivus et nullo &10modo erubescens de malis ac pudens &10indicium est animae turpissimae, quae &10occultas proprii vituperii figuras pin-&10git describitque evidenter in visibili &10corpore.$10 @2 A)NAIDE\S BLE/MMA KAI\ METE/WROS AU)XH\N KAI\ SUNEXH\S KI/NHSIS O)FRU/WN KAI\ BA/-DISMA SESOBHME/NON KAI\ TO\ E)PI\ MHDENI\ TW=N FAU/LWN E)RUQRIA=N SHMEI=A YUXH=S E)STIN AI)SXI/STHS, TOU\S A)FANEI=S TW=N OI)-KEI/WN O)NEIDW=N TU/POUS E)GGRAFOU/SHS TW=| FANERW=| SW/MATI. @2 &10In quo vero dei oracula habitaverint sapientiae studio atque virtutis, <21etsi &10Silenum superaverit corporis deformitate, pulcherrimus est &10necessario>21%10 bonum est enim ei proprio pudore venerabiliter conformari &10acceptationi videntium. &10@Stobaeus ecl. II 101, 14 W.$10 <20TO\N DE\ KAT' A)LH/QEIAN PLOU=-TON A)GAQO\N>20 EI)=NAI LE/GOUSI KAI\ TH\N KAT' A)LH/QEIAN PENI/AN KAKO/N. KAI\ <20TH\N ME\N KAT' A)LH/QEIAN E)LEUQERI/AN A)GAQO/N>20, TH\N DE\ KAT' A)LH/QEIAN DOULEI/AN KAKO/N: DI' O(\ DH\ KAI\ <20TO\N SPOUDAI=ON EI)=NAI MO/NON PLOU/SION KAI\ E)LEU/-QERON>20, TO\N DE\ FAU=LON TOU)NANTI/ON PE/NHTA, TW=N EI)S TO\ PLOUTEI=N A)FORMW=N E)STERHME/NON, KAI\ DOU=LON DIA\ TH\N U(POPTWTIKH\N E)N AU)TW=| DIA/QESIN. @&10Alexander Aphrod. comm. in Aristot. Topica II p. 72. Ald. &10p. 134, 13 Wal.$10 W(S OI( LE/GONTES MO/NON TO\N SOFO\N <20PLOU/SION>20 H)\ MO/NON <20KA-LO\N>20 H)\ MO/NON <20EU)GENH=>20 H)\ MO/NON <20R(H/TORA>20: OU) GA\R A)GNOU=NTES OU(=TOI TA\ U(PA/R-XONTA TW=| SOFW=| PLOU=TON TAU=TA LE/GOUSIN H)\ KA/LLOS H)\ EU)GE/NEIAN, A)LLA\ PARA-BAI/NONTES TH\N KEIME/NHN LE/CIN. @&10Alexander in Aristot. Top. p. 79 Ald. p. 147, 12 Wal.$10 A)PO\ TOU/-TOU TOU= TO/POU E)PIXEIROI/H TIS A)\N KAI\ PRO\S TA\ <20U(PO\ TW=N *STWI+KW=N>20 PARA/-DOCA LEGO/MENA: <20EI) GA\R TW=N POLLW=N PLOU/SION LEGO/NTWN MO/NON TO\N POLUKTH/MONA MH\ KATA\ TOU/TOU TIS XRW=|TO TW=| O)NO/MATI TOU/TW|, KATA\ DE\ TOU= SOFOU= KAI\ TOU= TA\S A)RETA\S E)/XONTOS>20 PARABAI/NOI A)\N TO\N KEI/ME-NON TH=S TW=N O)NOMA/TWN XRH/SEWS DIORISMO/N. @&10ibid. 22.$10 PA/LIN OI( ME\N POLLOI\ EU)TUXH= LE/GOUSI TO\N E)N TOI=S TUXHROI=S A)GAQOI=S EU)QHNOU=NTA: <20OI( DE\ TO\N TH\N A)RETH\N E)/XONTA/ FASIN EU)TUXH=>20, O(\ OU)K E)/STI TW=N TUXHRW=N A)GAQW=N. PARABAI/NOUSIN OU)=N KAI\ OU(=TOI TH\N PROSH/-KOUSAN XRH=SIN TW=N O)NOMA/TWN. @&10Philo de plantatione Noe%28 %14 69 Vol. II p. 147, 15 Wendl.$10 <20*TOU\S ME\N OU)=N PA/NTA TOU= SPOUDAI/OU FA/SKONTAS EI)=NAI>20 PARADOCOLOGEI=N ԃW)|H/QHSA/N TINES, A)FORW=NTES EI)S TH\N [2TW=N]2 E)KTO\S E)/NDEIA/N TE KAI\ PERIOUSI/AN KAI\ MHDE/NA TW=N A)XRHMA/TWN H)\ A)KTHMO/NWN PLOU/SION NOMI/ZONTES. @&10Acro ad Hor. Serm. I 3, 124. Dicunt <21Stoici>21 sapientem <21di-&10vitem>21 esse, si mendicet, et <21nobilem>21 esse, si servus sit, et <21pulcherri-&10mum>21 esse, etiamsi sit sordidissimus. &10@Porphyrio ad Serm. I 3, 124. Porro autem <21Stoici>21 existimant, per-&10fectae sapientiae virum omnia habere; in quo sensu et Lucilius versatus &10sic ait%10 nondum etiam haec omnia habebit formosus, dives, liber, rex solus. &10@Acron ad Hor. ep. I 19, 19. negant <21Stoici>21 quemquam <21liberum>21 &10esse praeter sapientem. @1 @&10Sextus adv. math. XI 170.$10 <20OI( DE\ *STWI+KOI\>20 KAI\ A)/NTIKRU/S FASI TH\N FRO/NHSIN, E)PISTH/MHN OU)=SAN A)GAQW=N KAI\ KAKW=N KAI\ OU)DETE/RWN, TE/XNHN U(PA/RXEIN PERI\ TO\N BI/ON, H(\N OI( PROSLABO/NTES MO/NOI GI/GNONTAI <20KALOI/>20, MO/NOI <20PLOU/SIOI>20, SOFOI\ MO/NOI. *(O <20GA\R POLLOU= A)/CIA KEKTHME/NOS PLOU/SIO/S E)STIN>20, H( DE\ A)RETH\ POLLOU= E)STIN A)CI/A, KAI\ MO/NOS TAU/THN O( SOFO\S KE/KTHTAI: MO/NOS A)/RA O( SOFO/S E)STI PLOU/SIOS. *KAI\ O( <20A)CIE/RASTO/S E)STI KALO/S>20, MO/NOS DE\ O( SOFO/S E)STIN A)CIE/RASTOS: MO/NOS A)/RA O( SOFO/S E)STI KALO/S. @&10Cicero Acad. Pr. II 136. Illa vero ferre non possum, non quo &10mihi displiceant [1sunt enim Socratica pleraque mirabilia <21Stoicorum>21, &10quae$10 PARA/DOCA&10 nominantur]1 sed ubi Xenocrates, ubi Aristoteles ista te-&10tigit? _Illi unquam dicerent sapientes solos reges, solos <21divites>21, solos &10<21formosos>21? omnia, quae ubique essent, sapientis esse? neminem consulem &10praetorem, imperatorem, nescio an ne quinquevirum quidem quemquam &10nisi sapientem? postremo solum civem, solum <21liberum>21, insipientes omnes &10peregrinos, exsules, servos, furiosos? denique scripta Lycurgi, Solonis, duo-&10decim tabulas nostras non esse leges? ne urbes quidem aut civitates, nisi &10quae essent sapientium? &10@Cicero de republ. I 28. Quis vero <21divitiorem>21 quemquam &10putet quam eum, cui nihil desit, quod quidem natura desideret, aut <21po-&10tentiorem>21 quam illum, qui omnia, quae expetat, consequatur, aut <21bea-&10tiorem>21, quam qui sit omni perturbatione animi liberatus, aut <21firmiore &10fortuna>21, quam qui ea possideat, quae secum, ut aiunt, vel e naufragio &10possit ecferre? Quod autem imperium, qui magistratus, quod regnum potest &10esse praestantius quam despicientem omnia humana et inferiora sapientia &10ducentem nihil unquam nisi sempiternum et divinum animo volutare? &10@Stobaeus ecl. II p. 114, 4.$10 <20*EU)TEKNEI=N>20 DE\ MO/NON TO\N A)STEI=ON, OU)/ TI MH\N PA/NTA, DEI=N GA\R TO\N EU)TEKNOU=NTA A)STEI=A TE/KNA E)/XONTA XRH/SASQAI AU)TOI=S W(S TOIOU/TOIS. <20*EU)GHREI=N>20 TE MO/NON KAI\ <20EU)QANATEI=N>20 TO\N SPOUDAI=ON: EU)GHREI=N GA\R EI)=NAI TO\ META\ POIOU= GH/RWS DIECA/GEIN KAT' A)RETH/N, EU)QANATEI=N DE\ TO\ META\ POIOU= QANA/TOU KAT' A)RETH\N TELEUTA=N. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 114, 10 W.$10 *KAI\ TA/ TE U(GIEINA\ KAI\ NOSERA\ PRO\S A)/NQRWPON LE/GESQAI KAI\ W(S TRO/FIMA, KAI\ TA\ LUTIKA\ KAI\ STATIKA\ KAI\ TA\ TOU/-TOIS PARAPLH/SIA. *(UGIEINA\ ME\N GA\R EI)=NAI TA\ EU)FUW=S E)/XONTA PRO\S TO\ PERI-POIEI=N U(GI/EIAN H)\ SUNE/XEIN: NOSERA\ DE\ TA\ E)NANTI/WS E)/XONTA TOU/TOIS. *PARA-PLH/SION D' EI)=NAI KAI\ TO\N E)PI\ TW=N A)/LLWN LO/GON. @&10Philo de sobrietate %14 56 Vol. II p. 226, 16 Wendl.$10 O( DE\ E)/XWN TO\N KLH=RON PE/RAN O(/RWN A)NQRWPI/NHS EU)DAIMONI/AS PROELH/LUQE: MO/NOS GA\R <20EU)GENH\S>20 A(/TE QEO\N E)PIGEGRAMME/NOS PATE/RA KAI\ GEGONW\S EI)SPOIHTO\S AU)TW=| MO/-NOS UI(O/S: OU) PLOU/SIOS, A)LLA\ <20PA/MPLOUTOS>20, E)N A)FQO/NOIS KAI\ GNHSI/OIS, OU) XRO/NW| PALAIOUME/NOIS, KAINOUME/NOIS DE\ KAI\ H(BW=SIN A)EI\ TRUFW=N A)GAQOI=S MO/-NOIS: OU)K E)/NDOCOS, A)LL' <20EU)KLEH/S>20, TO\N MH\ KOLAKEI/A| NOQOU/MENON, A)LLA\ BEBAI-OU/MENON A)LHQEI/A| KARPOU/MENOS E)/PAINON: MO/NOS <20BASILEU/S>20, PARA\ TOU= PANH-GEMO/NOS LABW\N TH=S E)F' A(/PASIN A)RXH=S TO\ KRA/TOS A)NANTAGW/NISTON: MO/NOS <20E)LEU/QEROS>20, A)FEIME/NOS A)RGALEWTA/THS DESPOI/NHS, KENH=S DO/CHS. @1 @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 67, 20 W.$10 LE/GOUSI DE\ KAI\ <20I(ERE/A MO/NON EI)=NAI TO\N SOFO/N>20, FAU=LON DE\ MHDE/NA. TO\N GA\R I(ERE/A EI)=NAI DEI=N E)/MPEIRON NO/MWN TW=N PERI\ QUSI/AS KAI\ EU)XA\S KAI\ KAQARMOU\S KAI\ I(DRU/SEIS KAI\ PA/NTA TA\ TOI-AU=TA, PRO\S DE\ TOU/TOIS KAI\ A(GISTEI/AS TE KAI\ EU)SEBEI/AS DEI=SQAI KAI\ E)MPEIRI/AS TH=S TW=N QEW=N QERAPEI/AS, KAI\ [2TOU=]2 E)NTO\S EI)=NAI TH=S FU/SEWS TH=S QEI/AS. *MHD' E(\N [2DE/ T]2I TOU/TWN U(PA/RXEIN TW=| FAU/LW|, DIO\ KAI\ PA/NTAS EI)=NAI TOU\S A)/FRONAS A)SEBEI=S. *TH\N GA\R A)SE/BEIAN KAKI/AN OU)=SAN, A)/GNOIAN EI)=NAI QEW=N QERAPEI/AS, TH\N D' EU)SE/BEIAN, W(S EI)/POMEN [1&10p. 62, 2$10]1, E)PISTH/MHN QEW=N QERA-PEI/AS. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 114, 16 W.$10 *KAI\ <20MANTIKO\N DE\ MO/NON EI)=NAI TO\N SPOUDAI=ON>20, W(S A)\N E)PISTH/MHN E)/XONTA DIAGNWSTIKH\N SHMEI/WN TW=N E)K QEW=N H)\ DAIMO/NWN PRO\S A)NQRW/PINON BI/ON TEINO/NTWN. *DI' O(\ KAI\ TA\ EI)/DH TH=S MANTIKH=S EI)=NAI PERI\ AU)TO/N, TO/ TE O)NEIROKRITIKO\N KAI\ TO\ OI)WNOSKOPIKO\N KAI\ QUTIKO\N KAI\ EI)/ TINA A)/LLA TOU/TOIS E)STI\ PARAPLH/SIA. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 119.$10 <20QEI/OUS>20 TE EI)=NAI [1&10scil.$10 TOU\S SPOUDAI/OUS.]1 E)/XEIN GA\R E)N E(AUTOI=S OI(ONEI\ QEO/N: TO\N DE\ FAU=LON A)/QEON: DITTO\N DE\ EI)=NAI TO\N A)/QEON, TO/N TE E)NANTI/WS TW=| QEI/W| LEGO/MENON KAI\ TO\N E)COUQENHTIKO\N TOU= QEI/OU: O(/PER OU)K EI)=NAI PERI\ PA/NTA FAU=LON. @&10Cicero de divin. II 129. <21Stoici>21 autem tui negant quemquam &10nisi sapientem <21divinum>21 esse posse. &10@Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 119.$10 <20QEOSEBEI=S TOU\S SPOUDAI/OUS>20: E)MPEI/-ROUS GA\R EI)=NAI TW=N PERI\ QEW=N NOMI/MWN: EI)=NAI/ TE TH\N <20EU)SE/BEIAN>20 E)PISTH/MHN QEW=N QERAPEI/AS. A)LLA\ MH\N KAI\ <20QU/EIN>20 AU)TOU\S QEOI=S <20A(GNOU/S>20 TE U(PA/RXEIN: E)KNEU/EIN GA\R TA\ PERI\ TOU\S QEOU\S A(MARTH/MATA. KAI\ TOU\S QEOU\S A)/GASQAI AU)TOU/S: <20O(SI/OUS>20 TE GA\R EI)=NAI KAI\ DIKAI/OUS PRO\S TO\ QEI=ON. <20MO/NOUS I(ERE/AS>20 TOU\S SOFOU/S: E)PESKE/FQAI GA\R PERI\ QUSIW=N, I(DRU/SEWN, KAQARMW=N, TW=N A)/LLWN TW=N PRO\S QEOU\S OI)KEI/WN. @&10Philo de sacrif. Abel et Cain %14 111 Vol. I p. 247, 9 Wendl. $10E(ORTH\ GA\R YUXH=S H( E)N A)RETAI=S EU)FROSU/NH TELEI/AIS__<20MO/NOS DE\ E(OR-TA/ZEI>20 TH\N TOIAU/THN E(ORTH\N O( <20SOFO/S>20, TW=N D' A)/LLWN OU)DEI/S: A)/GEUSTON GA\R PAQW=N H)\ KAKIW=N YUXH\N EU(REI=N SPANIW/TATON. @&10Philo de septenario et festis diebus p. 279 Vol. II Mang. [1$10O(/TI OI( SOFOI\]1 A(/PANTA TO\N BI/ON E(ORTH\N A)/GOUSI. @&10p. 280.$10 TW=N FAU/LWN OU)DEI\S A)LL' OU)DE\ TO\N BRAXU/TATON XRO/NON E(ORTA/ZEI. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 94, 7 W.$10 *TO/ TE DI/KAIO/N FASI FU/SEI EI)=NAI KAI\ MH\ QE/SEI. *(EPO/MENON DE\ TOU/TOIS U(PA/RXEIN KAI\ TO\ <20POLITEU/ESQAI TO\N SO- @1FO\N>20 KAI\ MA/LIST' E)N TAI=S TOIAU/TAIS POLITEI/AIS TAI=S E)MFAINOU/SAIS TINA\ PROKO-PH\N PRO\S TA\S TELEI/AS POLITEI/AS: KAI\ <20TO\ NOMOQETEI=N>20 DE\ KAI\ TO\ PAIDEU/EIN A)NQRW/POUS, E)/TI DE\ SUGGRA/FEIN TA\ DUNA/MENA W)FELEI=N TOU\S E)NTUGXA/NONTAS TOI=S GRA/MMASIN OI)KEI=ON EI)=NAI TOI=S SPOUDAI/OIS KAI\ TO\ SUGKATABAI/NEIN KAI\ EI)S GA/MON KAI\ EI)S TEKNOGONI/AN KAI\ AU(TOU= XA/RIN KAI\ TH=S PATRI/DOS KAI\ U(POME/NEIN PERI\ TAU/THS, E)A\N H)=| METRI/A, KAI\ PO/NOUS KAI\ QA/NATON. *PARAKEI=SQAI DE\ TOU/-TOIS FAU=LA, TO/ TE DHMOKOPEI=N KAI\ TO\ SOFISTEU/EIN KAI\ TO\ SUGGRA/FEIN E)PI-BLABH= TOI=S E)NTUGXA/NOUSIN, A(/PER EI)S SPOUDAI/OUS OU)K A)\N PE/SOI. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 122.$10 O(MOI/WS DE\ KAI\ <20A)RXIKOU\S DIKASTIKOU/S TE KAI\ R(HTORIKOU\S>20 MO/NOUS EI)=NAI, TW=N DE\ FAU/LWN OU)DE/NA. @&10Stobaeus eclog. II 7 p. 96 Wachsm.$10 *TO/N TE NO/MON SPOUDAI=ON EI)=NAI/ FASI, LO/GON O)RQO\N O)/NTA PROSTAKTIKO\N ME\N W(=N POIHTE/ON, A)PAGOREUTIKO\N DE\ W(=N OU) POIHTE/ON. *TOU= DE\ NO/MOU A)STEI/OU O)/NTOS KAI\ O( <20NO/MIMOS A)STEI=OS A)\N [2EI)/H]2>20: NO/MIMON ME\N GA\R EI)=NAI A)/NDRA KAI\ A)KOLOUQHTIKO\N TW=| NO/MW| KAI\ PRAKTIKO\N TW=N U(P' AU)TOU= PROSTATTOME/NWN, <20NOMIKO\N>20 DE\ TO\N E)CHGHTIKO\N TOU= NO/MOU. *MHDE/NA DE\ TW=N FAU/LWN MH/TE NO/MIMON EI)=NAI MH/TE NOMIKO/N. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 102, 4 W.$10 *TOU= DE\ NO/MOU O)/NTOS SPOUDAI/OU, KAQA/PER EI)/POMEN, E)PEIDH\ LO/GOS O)RQO/S E)STI PROSTAKTIKO\S ME\N W(=N POIHTE/ON, A)PAGOREUTIKO\S DE\ W(=N OU) POIHTE/ON, MO/NON TO\N SOFO\N EI)=NAI LE/GOUSI NO/MIMON, PRAKTIKO\N O)/NTA TW=N U(PO\ TOU= NO/MOU PROSTATTOME/NWN KAI\ MO/NON E)CHGHTIKO\N TOU/TOU, DI' O(\ KAI\ NOMIKO\N EI)=NAI: TOU\S D' H)LIQI/OUS E)NANTI/WS E)/XEIN. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 102, 11 W.$10 <20*)ASTEI/OIS D' E)/TI KAI\ TH\N A)RXI-KH\N KATANE/MOUSIN E)PISTASI/AN>20 KAI\ TA\ TAU/THS EI)/DH, BASILEI/AN, STRATH-GI/AN, NAUARXI/AN KAI\ TA\S TAU/TAIS PARAPLHSI/OUS. *KATA\ TOU=TO DH\ KAI\ MO/NOS O( SPOUDAI=OS A)/RXEI KAI\ EI) MH\ PA/NTWS KAT' E)NE/RGEIAN, KATA\ DIA/QESIN DE\ KAI\ PA/NTWS. *KAI\ <20PEIQARXIKO\S MO/NOS O( SPOUDAI=O/S>20 E)STIN, A)KOLOUQHTIKO\S W)\N A)/RXONTI. *TW=N D' A)FRO/NWN OU)DEI\S TOIOU=TOS: OU)/TE GA\R A)/RXEIN OU)/T' A)/RXESQAI OI(=O/S [2T']2 E)STIN O( A)/FRWN, AU)QA/DHS TIS W)\N KAI\ A)NA/GWGOS. @&10Cicero de finibus III 68. Cum autem ad tuendos conservan-&10dosque homines hominem natum esse videamus, consentaneum est huic &10naturae, ut <21sapiens velit gerere et administrare rem publicam>21 &10atque, ut e natura vivat, uxorem adiungere et velle ex ea liberos. @&Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 122.$ OU) MO/NON DE\ E)LEUQE/ROUS EI)=NAI TOU\S SOFOU/S, <20A)LLA\ KAI\ BASILE/AS>20, TH=S BASILEI/AS OU)/SHS A)RXH=S A)NUPEUQU/-NOU, H(/TIS PERI\ MO/NOUS A)\N TOU\S SOFOU\S [2SU]2STAI/H, KAQA/ FHSI <20*XRU/-SIPPOS>20 E)N TW=| <20*PERI\ TOU= KURI/WS KEXRH=SQAI *ZH/NWNA TOI=S O)NO/-MASIN>20. E)GNWKE/NAI GA/R FHSI DEI=N TO\N A)/RXONTA PERI\ A)GAQW=N KAI\ KAKW=N: MHDE/NA DE\ TW=N FAU/LWN E)PI/STASQAI TAU=TA. @1 @&10Olympiodorus in Plat. Alcib. pr. p. 55 ed. Creuzer.$10 *TRI/TON O(/TI KATA\ TH\N TW=N <20*STWI+KW=N>20 MEGALOR)R(HMOSU/NHN O( <20A)RXIKO/S, TOUTE/STIN O( EI)-DW\S A)/RXEIN, MO/NOS A)/RXWN E)STI/N>20, EI) KAI\ MH\ E)/XOI TA\ O)/RGANA TH=S A)RXIKH=S E)PISTH/MHS: KAI\ O(/TI MO/NOS O( SOFO\S PLOU/SIOS, TOUTE/STIN O( EI)DW\S XRH/SASQAI PARO/NTI TW=| PLOU/TW|, EI) KAI\ MH\ PA/RESTIN. @&10Clemens Al. Strom. II p. 438 Pott.$10 <20*SPEU/SIPPOS>20 GA\R <20E)N TW=| PRO\S *KLEOFW=NTA PRW/TW|>20 TA\ O(/MOIA TW=| *PLA/TWNI E)/OIKE DIA\ TOU/TOU GRA/FEIN. *EI) GA\R H( BASILEI/A SPOUDAI=ON, O(/ TE SOFO\S MO/NOS BASILEU\S KAI\ A)/RXWN: O( NO/-MOS, LO/GOS W)\N O)RQO/S, SPOUDAI=OS: A(\ KAI\ E)STI/N. <20*TOU/TOIS A)KO/LOUQA OI( *STWI+KOI\ FILO/SOFOI DOGMATI/ZOUSIN, BASILEI/AN>20, I(ERWSU/NHN, PROFHTEI/AN, <20NOMOQETIKH/N>20, PLOU=TON, KA/LLOS A)LHQINO/N, EU)GE/NEIAN, E)LEUQERI/AN MO/NW| PROS-A/PTONTES TW=| SOFW=|: O( DE\ DUSEU/RETOS PA/NU SFO/DRA KAI\ PRO\S AU)TW=N O(MOLO-GEI=TAI. @&10Philo de nominum mutat. %14 152 Vol. III p. 182, 23 Wendl.$10 <20MO/NON TO\N SOFO\N BASILE/A>20. *KAI\ GA\R O)/NTWS O( ME\N FRO/NIMOS H(GEMW\N A)FRO/NWN E)STI/N, EI)DW\S A(\ XRH\ POIEI=N TE KAI\ KAI\ A(\ MH/: O( DE\ SW/FRWN A)KO-LA/STWN, TA\ PERI\ TA\S AI(RE/SEIS KAI\ FUGA\S H)KRIBWKW\S OU)K A)MELW=S, DEILW=N DE\ O( A)NDREI=OS, A(\ DEI= U(POME/NEIN KAI\ A(\ MH\ SAFW=S E)KMAQW/N, A)DI/KWN DE\ O( DI/-KAIOS, I)SO/THTOS E)N TOI=S A)PONEMHTE/OIS A)R)R(EPOU=S STOXAZO/MENOS. @&10Philo de migrat. Abrah. %14 197 Vol. II p. 307, 8 Wendl.$10 BASI-LEI/AN DE\ SOFI/AN EI)=NAI LE/GOMEN, E)PEI\ KAI\ <20TO\N SOFO\N BASILE/A>20. @&10Lucian. vitarum auctio 20 [1Mercurius Chrysippum vendens dicit%10$10]1 O(/TI MO/NOS OU(=TOS SOFO/S, MO/NOS KALO/S, MO/NOS DI/KAIOS A)NDREI=OS <20BASILEU\S>20 R(H/TWR PLOU/SIOS <20NOMOQE/THS>20. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 95, 9 W.$10 <20*OI)KONOMIKO\N D' EI)=NAI MO/NON LE/-GOUSI TO\N SPOUDAI=ON>20 KAI\ A)GAQO\N OI)KONO/MON, E)/TI DE\ XRHMATISTIKO/N. *TH\N ME\N GA\R OI)KONOMIKH\N EI)=NAI QEWRHTIKH\N E(/CIN KAI\ PRAKTIKH\N TW=N OI)/KW| SUM-FERO/NTWN: TH\N D' OI)KONOMI/AN DIA/TACIN PERI\ A)NALWMA/TWN KAI\ E)/RGWN KAI\ KTH/-SEWS E)PIME/LEIAN KAI\ TW=N KAT' A)GRO\N E)RGAZOME/NWN: <20TH\N DE\ XRHMATISTIKH\N>20 E)MPEIRI/AN PERIPOIH/SEWS XRHMA/TWN A)F' W(=N DE/ON KAI\ E(/CIN O(MOLOGOUME/NWS A)NA-STRE/FESQAI POIOU=SAN E)N SUNAGWGH=| XRHMA/TWN KAI\ THRH/SEI KAI\ A)NALW/SEI PRO\S EU)PORI/AN: TO\ DE\ XRHMATI/ZESQAI/ TINES ME\N ME/SON EI)=PON EI)=NAI, TINE\S DE\ A)STEI=ON. @1 *FAU=LON DE\ MHDE/NA PROSTA/THN A)GAQO\N OI)/KOU GI/NESQAI, MHDE\ DU/NASQAI OI)KI/AN EU)= OI)KONOMOUME/NHN PARASXEI=N. *MO/NON DE\ TO\N SPOUDAI=ON A)/NDRA XRHMATISTIKO\N EI)=NAI, GINW/SKONTA A)F' W(=N XRHMATISTE/ON KAI\ PO/TE KAI\ PW=S KAI\ ME/XRI PO/TE. @&10Philo quaest. et solut. in Genesin IV 165 [1p. 372 Aucher]1. &10Sapiens et solidus duo haec itidem possidet, incomptus et domi habitans. &10Indoles incompta patefacit veritatem simplicitatis carentiamque adulatio-&10nis__; altera vero, domus custodia una cum domestico more oppo-&10sitio est agresti vitae. Unum enim istorum oeconomicum est et urbani-&10tatis exiguae comprehensio; quoniam <21urbanitas et oeconomia cognatae &10sunt virtutes>21, quas translatas fere inter se monstrare non frustra erit%10 &10urbanitas namque oeconomia urbis est et oeconomia urbanitas est domi. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 93, 19 W.$10 <20TA/ TE A)GAQA\ PA/NTA TW=N SPOU-DAI/WN EI)=NAI [2KOINA\]2 LE/GOUSI, KAQ' O(\ KAI\ TO\N W)FELOU=NTA/ TINA TW=N PLHSI/ON KAI\ E(AUTO\N W)FELEI=N>20. *TH/N TE O(MO/NOIAN E)PISTH/MHN EI)=NAI KOINW=N A)GAQW=N, DI' O(\ KAI\ TOU\S SPOUDAI/OUS PA/NTAS O(MONOEI=N A)LLH/LOIS DIA\ TO\ SUM-FWNEI=N E)N TOI=S KATA\ TO\N BI/ON: TOU\S DE\ FAU/LOUS DIAFWNOU=NTAS PRO\S A)LLH/-LOUS E)XQROU\S EI)=NAI KAI\ KAKOPOIHTIKOU\S A)LLH/LWN KAI\ POLEMI/OUS. @&10Stobaeus eclog. II 7 p. 101, 21 W.$10 <20*TA\ D' A)GAQA\ PA/NTA KOINA\ EI)=NAI TW=N SPOUDAI/WN>20, TW=N DE\ FAU/LWN TA\ KAKA/. *DI' O(\ KAI\ TO\N W)FE-LOU=NTA/ TINA KAI\ AU)TO\N W)FELEI=SQAI, TO\N DE\ BLA/PTONTA KAI\ E(AUTO\N BLA/PTEIN. <20*PA/NTAS DE\ TOU\S SPOUDAI/OUS W)FELEI=N A)LLH/LOUS>20, OU)/TE FI/LOUS O)/NTAS A)LLH/LWN PA/NTWS OU)/TE EU)/NOUS [2OU)/TE]2 EU)DOKI/MOUS OU)/TE A)PODEXOME/NOUS PARA\ TO\ MH/TE KATALAMBA/NESQAI MH/T' E)N TAU)TW=| KATOIKEI=N TO/PW|, EU)NOHTIKW=S ME/NTOI GE PRO\S A)LLH/LOUS DIAKEI=SQAI KAI\ FILIKW=S KAI\ DOKIMASTIKW=S KAI\ A)PODEKTIKW=S: TOU\S DE\ A)/FRONAS E)N TOI=S E)NANTI/OIS TOU/TWN U(PA/RXEIN. @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 22 p. 1068f.$ *)\AN EI(=S SOFO\S O(POUDH/POTE PROTEI/NH| TO\N DA/KTULON FRONI/MWS, OI( KATA\ TH\N OI)KOUME/NHN SOFOI\ PA/NTES W)FELOU=NTAI.& p. 1069a.$ E)LH/REI D' *)ARISTOTE/LHS, E)LH/REI DE\ *CENOKRA/THS_<20TH\N QAUMASTH\N A)GNOOU=NTES W)FE/LEIAN H(\N OI( SOFOI\ KINOUME/NWN KAT' A)RETH\N A)LLH/LWN W)FELOU=NTAI>20, KA)\N MH\ SUNW=SI MHDE\ GINW/SKONTES TUGXA/NWSIN. @&Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 123.$10 A)LLA\ MH\N OU)D' E)N E)RHMI/A|, FASI/, BIW/SETAI O( SPOUDAI=OS: <20KOINWNIKO\S>20 GA\R FU/SEI KAI\ <20PRAKTIKO/S>20. @&10Lactant. div. instit. V 17 fin. Lucro autem nunquam sapiens &10studet, quia bona haec terrena contemnit%10 <21nec quemquam falli pati-&10tur>21, quia boni viri officium est, errores hominum corrigere eosque in viam &10reducere; siquidem socialis est hominis ac benefica natura, quo solo cogna-&10tionem cum deo habet. &10@Stobaeus ecl. II 108, 5 W.$10 <20*TO\N DE\ SPOUDAI=ON, O(MILHTIKO\N O)/NTA>20 KAI\ E)PIDE/CION KAI\ PROTREPTIKO\N KAI\ QHREUTIKO\N DIA\ TH=S O(MILI/AS EI)S @1 EU)/NOIAN KAI\ FILI/AN, W(S DUNATO\N EU)A/RMOSTON EI)=NAI PRO\S PLH=QOS A)NQRW/PWN, PAR' O(\ KAI\ E)PAFRO/DITON EI)=NAI KAI\ E)PI/XARIN KAI\ PIQANO/N, E)/TI DE\ AI(MU/LON KAI\ EU)/STOXON KAI\ EU)/KAIRON KAI\ A)GXI/NOUN KAI\ A)FELH= KAI\ A)PERI/ERGON KAI\ A(PLOU=N KAI\ A)/PLASTON: TO\N DE\ FAU=LON E)/NOXON PA=SI TOI=S E)NANTI/OIS. *TO\ D' <20EI)RW-NEU/ESQAI>20 FAU/LWN EI)=NAI/ FASIN, OU)DE/NA GA\R E)LEU/QERON KAI\ SPOUDAI=ON EI)RW-NEU/ESQAI: O(MOI/WS DE\ KAI\ TO\ <20SARKA/ZEIN>20, O(/ E)STIN EI)RWNEU/ESQAI MET' E)PISURMOU= TINOS. *)EN MO/NOIS TE TOI=S SOFOI=S A)POLEI/POUSI <20FILI/AN>20, E)PEI\ E)N MO/NOIS TOU/-TOIS O(MO/NOIA GI/NETAI PERI\ TW=N KATA\ TO\N BI/ON: TH\N D' O(MO/NOIAN EI)=NAI KOINW=N A)GAQW=N E)PISTH/MHN. *FILI/AN GA\R A)LHQINH\N KAI\ MH\ YEUDW/NUMON A)DU/NATON XWRI\S PI/STEWS KAI\ BEBAIO/THTOS U(PA/RXEIN: E)N DE\ TOI=S FAU/LOIS, A)PI/STOIS KAI\ A)BEBAI/OIS OU)=SI KAI\ DO/GMATA POLEMIKA\ KEKTHME/NOIS, OU)K EI)=NAI FILI/AN, E(TE/RAS DE/ TINAS E)PIPLOKA\S KAI\ SUNDE/SEIS E)/CWQEN A)NA/GKAIS KAI\ DO/CAIS KATEXOME/NAS GI/NESQAI. *FASI\ DE\ KAI\ TO\ A)GAPA=N KAI\ TO\ A)SPA/ZESQAI KAI\ TO\ FILEI=N MO/NWN EI)=NAI SPOUDAI/WN. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 124.$10 LE/GOUSI DE\ KAI\ <20TH\N FILI/AN>20 E)N MO/NOIS TOI=S SPOUDAI/OIS EI)=NAI DIA\ TH\N O(MOIO/THTA. FASI\ DE\ AU)TH\N KOINWNI/AN TINA\ EI)=NAI TW=N KATA\ TO\N BI/ON, XRWME/NWN H(MW=N TOI=S FI/LOIS W(S E(AUTOI=S. DI' AU(TO/N TE AI(RETO\N TO\N FI/LON A)POFAI/NONTAI KAI\ <20TH\N POLUFILI/AN A)GAQO/N>20. E)/N TE TOI=S FAU/LOIS MH\ EI)=NAI FILI/AN MHDE/NA TE TW=N FAU/LWN FI/LON E)/XEIN. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 115, 10 W.$10 *EI)=NAI DE\ KAI\ PRA=ON, TH=S <20PRAO/TH-TOS>20 OU)/SHS E(/CEWS KAQ' H(\N PRA/WS E)/XOUSI PRO\S TO\ POIEI=N TA\ E)PIBA/LLONTA E)N PA=SI KAI\ MH\ E)KFE/RESQAI EI)S O)RGH\N E)N MHDENI/. *KAI\ H(SU/XION DE\ KAI\ KO/SMION EI)=NAI, TH=S <20KOSMIO/THTOS>20 OU)/SHS E)PISTH/MHS KINH/SEWN PREPOUSW=N, <20H(SUXIO/-THTOS>20 DE\ EU)TACI/AS PERI\ TA\S KATA\ FU/SIN KINH/SEIS KAI\ MONA\S YUXH=S KAI\ SW/-MATOS, TW=N E)NANTI/WN TOU/TOIS E)PI\ PA/NTWN FAU/LWN GIGNOME/NWN. @&10Seneca ep. 81, 8. non omnes grati sciunt debere beneficium__ &10uni sapienti notum est, quanti res quaeque taxanda sit%10 nam ille, de quo &10loquebar modo, stultus, etiamsi bonae voluntatis est, aut minus quam &10debet aut tempore aut quo non debet loco reddit. &10@ibid. 10. Sapiens omnia examinabit secum%10 quantum acceperit, a &10quo, quando, ubi, quemadmodum. itaque <21negamus quemquam scire &10gratiam referre nisi sapientem>21%10 non magis quam beneficium dare &10quisquam scit nisi sapiens. &10@ibid. 12. solus sapiens scit amare. <21solus sapiens amicus est>21. &10__quod dicimus%10 fidem nisi in sapiente non esse. &10@Philo quaest. et solut. in Genesin IV 74 [1p. 303 Aucher]1. Stu-&10diosus sapientiae cum nullo ex vanis ac vacuis [rebus], quamvis ex natura &10cognatus sit illis, cohabitat vel conversatur, sed longius ab illis est se-&10iunctus consilio; ita ut <21non navigationis socius nec comes in via &10nec concivis nec vitae consors neque coaemulator dicitur pro-&10prie sapiens cum insipiente>21, eo quod principalis dux non concordat &10vel convenit in mente unius alteriusque. &10@Cicero de nat. deor. I 121. Quanto <21Stoici>21 melius__. Censent &10autem <21sapientes sapientibus etiam ignotis esse amicos>21. Nihil @1 &10est enim virtute amabilius; quam qui adeptus erit, ubicumque erit gen-&10tium, a nobis diligetur. &10@Philo de sacrif. Abel et Cain %14 121 Vol. I p. 251, 3 Wendl.$10 MH/POTE DE\ KAI\ DO/GMA EI)SHGEI=TAI SFO/DRA A)NAGKAI=ON, O(/TI <20PA=S SOFO\S LU/TRON E)STI\ TOU= FAU/LOU>20, MHD' A)\N PRO\S O)LI/GON XRO/NON E)CARKE/SANTOS, EI) MH\ E)LE/W| KAI\ PROMHQEI/A| XRW/MENOS E)KEI=NOS PROU)NO/EI TH=S DIAMONH=S AU)TOU=, KAQA/PER I)ATRO\S TOU= NOSOU=NTOS A)NTITETAGME/NOS TOI=S A)R)R(WSTH/MASI KAI\ PRA|O/TERA KATA-SKEUA/ZWN AU)TA\ H)\ SUNO/LWS A)NAIRW=N, EI) MH/ POU META\ FORA=S A)NEPISXE/TOU BIA-SA/MENA KAI\ TH\N TH=S QERAPEI/AS U(PERBA/LLOI FRONTI/DA. @&10p. 251, 15 %14 123.$10 PEIRA=SQAI ME/NTOI DEI= KAI\ TOU\S PA/NTWS U(PO\ TH=S E)N AU)TOI=S DIAFQARHSOME/NOUS KAKI/AS W(S OI(=O/N TE DIASW/|ZEIN, MIMOUME/NOUS TOU\S A)GAQOU\S TW=N I)ATRW=N, OI(\ KA)\N O(RW=SIN A)DU/NATON TOI=S KA/MNOUSI TO\ SW/|ZESQAI, PROSFE/ROUSI TH\N QERAPEI/AN O(/MWS A)/SMENOI, TOU= MH\ TH=| PAR' AU)TOU\S O)LIGWRI/A| DOKEI=N SUMBH=NAI/ TI TW=N PARA\ GNW/MHN. *EI) DE/ TI KAI\ MIKRO\N O(/SON U(GEI/AS SPE/RMA E)MFAI/NOITO, TOU=TO W(/SPER E)MPU/REUMA PA/SAIS E)PIMELEI/AIS ZWPURHTE/ON: E)LPI\S GA\R MHKUNQE/NTOS KAI\ SUNAUCHQE/NTOS A)MEI/NONI KAI\ A)PTAISTOTE/RW| XRH/-SASQAI TW=| BI/W|. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 117.$10 KAI\ <20AU)STHROU\S DE/ FASIN EI)=NAI PA/N-TAS TOU\S SPOUDAI/OUS>20, TW=| MH/TE AU)TOU\S PRO\S H(DONH\N O(MILEI=N MH/TE PAR' A)/LLWN TA\ PRO\S H(DONH\N PROSDE/XESQAI. KAI\ A)/LLON DE\ EI)=NAI AU)STHRO/N, PARA-PLHSI/WS LEGO/MENON TW=| AU)STHRW=| OI)/NW|, W(=| PRO\S ME\N FARMAKOPOII/+AN XRW=NTAI, PRO\S DE\ PRO/POSIN OU) PA/NU. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 114, 22 W.$10 <20*AU)STHRO/N>20 TE LE/GESQAI TO\N SPOU-DAI=ON KAQ' O(/SON OU)/TE PROSFE/REI TINI\ OU)/TE PROSI/ETAI TO\N PRO\S XA/RIN LO/GON. <20*KUNIEI=N>20 TE TO\N SOFO\N LE/GOUSIN, I)=SON [2O)\N]2 TW=| E)PIME/NEIN TW=| KUNISMW=|, OU) MH\N SOFO\N O)/NTA E)NA/RCESQAI TOU= KUNISMOU=. @&10Clemens Al. Strom. VII 7 p. 858 Pott.$10 <20AU)STHRO\S>20 OU(=TOS H(MI=N, AU)STHRO\S OU)K EI)S TO\ A)DIA/FQORON MO/NON, A)LLA\ KAI\ EI)S TO\ A)PEI/RASTON. OU)DAMH=| GA\R E)NDO/SIMON OU)DE\ A(LW/SIMON H(DONH=| TE KAI\ LU/PH| TH\N YUXH\N PARI/STHSIN: DIKASTH/S, E)A\N O( LO/GOS KALH=|, A)KLINH\S GENO/MENOS, MHD' O(TIOU=N TOI=S PA/QESI XA-RIZO/MENOS, A)METASTA/TW| [2PODI\]2 H(=| PE/FUKE [TO\] DI/KAION POREU/ESQAI BADI/ZWN. @&10p. 859.$10 TO\ A)NAPO/BLHTON TH=S A)RETH=S. @&10Stobaeus eclog. II 7 p. 95, 24 W.$10 *FASI\ <20MHDE\ SUGGNW/MHN E)/XEIN [2MHDENI\ TO\N NOU=N E)/XONTA>20: TOU= GA\R AU)TOU= SUGGNW/MHN TE E)/XEIN]2 KAI\ NOMI/ZEIN TO\N H(MARTHKO/TA MH\ PAR' AU(TO\N H(MARTHKE/NAI, PA/NTWN A(MARTANO/NTWN PARA\ TH\N I)DI/AN KAKI/AN: DIO\ KAI\ DEO/NTWS LE/GESQAI TO\ MHDE\ SUGGNW/MHN E)/XEIN TOI=S A(MARTA/NOUSIN. <20*OU)K E)PIEIKH= DE/ FASIN EI)=NAI TO\N A)GAQO\N A)/NDRA>20, TO\N GA\R E)PIEIKH= PARAITHTIKO\N EI)=NAI TH=S KAT' A)CI/AN KOLA/SEWS KAI\ TOU= AU)TOU= EI)=NAI E)PIEIKH= TE EI)=NAI KAI\ U(POLAMBA/NEIN TA\S E)K TOU= NO/MOU TETAGME/NAS KO- @1LA/SEIS TOI=S A)DIKOU=SI SKLHROTE/RAS EI)=NAI KAI\ TO\ H(GEI=SQAI PARA\ TH\N A)CI/AN A)PO-NE/MEIN TA\S KOLA/SEIS TO\N NOMOQE/THN. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 123.$10 <20E)LEH/MONA/S TE MH\ EI)=NAI>20 SUGGNW/MHN TE E)/XEIN MHDENI/: MH\ GA\R PARIE/NAI TA\S E)PIBALLOU/SAS E)K TOU= NO/MOU KOLA/SEIS [1E)PEI\ TO/ GE EI)/KEIN KAI\ O( E)/LEOS AU)TH/ TE H( E)PIEI/KEIA OU)DEMI/A E)STI\ YUXH=S PRO\S KO-LA/SEIS PROSPOIOUME/NH XRHSTO/THTA]1 MHDE\ OI)/ESQAI SKLHROTE/RAS AU)TA\S EI)=NAI. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 123.$10 E)/TI GE TO\N SOFO\N <20OU)DE\N QAUMA/ZEIN>20 TW=N DOKOU/NTWN PARADO/CWN, OI(=ON XARW/NEIA KAI\ A)MPW/TIDAS KAI\ PHGA\S QERMW=N U(DA/TWN KAI\ PURO\S A)NAFUSH/MATA. @&10Stobaeus eclog. II 7, p. 109, 5.$10 <20*OU)X OI(=ON DE\ MEQUSQH/SESQAI TO\N NOU=N E)/XONTA>20: TH\N GA\R ME/QHN A(MARTHTIKO\N PERIE/XEIN, LH/RHSIN EI)=NAI [2GA\R]2 PARA\ TO\N OI)=NON, E)N MHDENI\ DE\ TO\N SPOUDAI=ON A(MARTA/NEIN, DI' O(\ PA/NTA KAT' A)RETH\N POIEI=N KAI\ TO\N A)PO\ TAU/THS O)RQO\N LO/GON. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 118.$10 KAI\ <20OI)NWQH/SESQAI ME/N, OU) MEQUSQH/-SESQAI DE/>20&10 [1scil.$10 TO\N SPOUDAI=ON]1, E)/TI DE\ OU)DE\ MANH/SESQAI: PROSPESEI=SQAI ME/NTOI POTE\ AU)TW=| FANTASI/AS A)LLOKO/TOUS DIA\ MELAGXOLI/AN H)\ LH/RHSIN, OU) KATA\ TO\N TW=N AI(RETW=N LO/GON, A)LLA\ PARA\ FU/SIN. @&10Cicero de finibus III 68. <21Cynicorum autem rationem>21 at-&10que vitam alii cadere in sapientem dicunt, si qui eius modi forte casus &10inciderit, ut id faciendum sit, alii nullo modo. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 117.$10 <20A)/TUFO/N>20 TE EI)=NAI TO\N SOFO/N: I)/SWS GA\R E)/XEIN PRO/S TE TO\ E)/NDOCON KAI\ TO\ A)/DOCON. EI)=NAI DE\ KAI\ A)/LLON A)/TUFON, KATA\ TO\N EI)KAI=ON TETAGME/NON, O(/S E)STI FAU=LOS. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 118.$10 <20A)KIBDH/LOUS>20 TOU\S SPOUDAI/OUS FULAKTI-KOU/S TE EI)=NAI TOU= E)PI\ TO\ BE/LTION AU(TOU\S PARISTA/NEIN, DIA\ PARASKEUH=S TH=S TA\ FAU=LA ME\N A)POKRUPTOU/SHS, TA\ DE\ U(PA/RXONTA A)GAQA\ FAI/NESQAI POIOU/SHS. [2KAI\]2 <20A)PLA/STOUS>20: PERIH|RHKE/NAI GA\R E)N TH=| FWNH=| TO\ PLA/SMA KAI\ TW=| EI)/DEI. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 116, 1 W.$10 <20OU)D' A)NABA/LLESQAI>20 DE/ POTE TO\N SPOUDAI=ON OU)DE/N, EI)=NAI GA\R TH\N A)NABOLH\N U(PE/RQESIN E)NERGEI/AS DI' O)/KNON: <20U(PERTI/QESQAI DE/ TINA>20 MO/NON, A)NEGKLH/TOU TH=S U(PERQE/SEWS OU)/SHS. E)PI\ GA\R TOU= A)NABA/LLESQAI TO\N *(HSI/ODON TAU=T' EI)RHKE/NAI:&10 &10@[1Op. et D. 410]1$10 MHD' A)NABA/LLESQAI E)/S T' AU)/RION E)/S T' E)/NNHFI KAI\&10 &10@[1ibid. 413]1$10 AI)EI\ D' A)MBOLIERGO\S A)NH\R A)/TH|SI PALAI/EI: TH=S [D'] A)NABOLH=S E)/KPTWSI/N TINA TW=N PROSHKO/NTWN E)/RGWN E)MPOIOU/SHS. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 118.$10 <20A)PRA/GMONA/S>20 TE EI)=NAI&10 [1scil.$10 TOU\S SPOU-DAI/OUS]1: E)KKLI/NEIN GA\R TO\ PRA/TTEIN TI PARA\ TO\ KAQH=KON. @1 @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 115, 1 W.$ *TO\N DE\ E)/RWTA/ FASIN E)PIBOLH\N EI)=NAI FILOPOII/AS DIA\ KA/LLOS E)MFAINO/MENON NE/WN W(RAI/WN: DI' O(\ KAI\ <20E)RWTIKO\N EI)=-NAI TO\N SOFO\N>20 KAI\ E)RASQH/SESQAI TW=N A)CIERA/STWN, EU)GENW=N O)/NTWN KAI\ EU)FUW=N. @&10Cicero de finibus III 68. Ne amores quidem sanctos a sapiente &10alienos esse arbitrantur. &10@Cicero Tusc. disp. IV 72. <21Stoici>21 vero et <21sapientem ama-&10turum esse dicunt>21 et amorem ipsum conatum amicitiae faciendae ex &10pulchritudinis specie. &10@Cicero Tusculan. disput. IV 33, 70. Ad magistros virtutis, philo-&10sophos veniamus: qui amorem negant stupri esse, et in eo litigant cum &10Epicuro, non multum, ut opinio mea fert, mentiente. Quis est enim iste &10amor amicitiae? etc. &10@Stobaeus ecl. II 67, 13 W.$10 <20MO/NON DE/ FASI TO\N SOFO\N KAI\ MA/NTIN A)GAQO\N>20 EI)=NAI KAI\ <20POIHTH\N>20 KAI\ <20R(H/TORA>20 KAI\ <20DIALEKTIKO\N>20 KAI\ <20KRITIKO/N, OU) PA/NTA DE/>20, DIA\ TO\ PROSDEI=SQAI E)/TI TINA\ TOU/TWN KAI\ QEWRH-MA/TWN TINW=N A)NALH/YEWS. EI)=NAI DE\ TH\N MANTIKH/N FASIN E)PISTH/MHN QEWRHTIKH\N SHMEI/WN TW=N A)PO\ QEW=N H)\ DAIMO/NWN PRO\S A)NQRW/PINON BI/ON SUNTEINO/NTWN: O(MOI/WS DE\ KAI\ TA\ EI)/DH TH=S MANTIKH=S. @&10Plutarchus de tranq. animi cp. 12 p. 472a.$10 A)LL' E)/NIOI TOU\S ME\N *STWI+KOU\S OI)/ONTAI PAI/ZEIN, O(/TAN A)KOU/SWSI TO\N SOFO\N PAR' AU)TOI=S MH\ MO/NON FRO/NIMON KAI\ DI/KAION KAI\ A)NDREI=ON, A)LLA\ KAI\ <20R(H/TORA>20 KAI\ <20POIHTH\N>20 KAI\ STRATHGO\N KAI\ PLOU/SION KAI\ BASILE/A PROSAGOREUO/MENON&10 etc. &10@Stobaeus ecl. II 109, 1 W.$10 *LE/GOUSI DE\ KAI\ <20A)/RISTON AU(TOU= I)ATRO\N EI)=NAI TO\N SPOUDAI=ON A)/NDRA>20: E)PIMELH= GA\R O)/NTA TH=S I)DI/AS FU/-SEWS PARATHRHTH\N U(PA/RXEIN KAI\ TW=N PRO\S U(GI/EIAN E)PISTH/MONA SUMFERO/NTWN. @&10Sextus Emp. adv. math. VII 432.$10 *)/ALLWS TE, EI) <20PA=SA FAU/LOU KAT' AU)TOU\S U(PO/LHYIS A)/GNOIA/ E)STI>20 KAI\ MO/NOS O( SOFO\S A)LHQEU/EI KAI\ E)PISTH/MHN E)/XEI TA)LHQOU=S BEBAI/AN, A)KOLOUQEI= ME/XRI DEU=RO A)NEURE/TOU KAQESTW=-TOS TOU= SOFOU= KAT' A)NA/GKHN KAI\ TA)LHQE\S A)NEU/RETON EI)=NAI, DIA\ DE\ TOU=TO KAI\ PA/NTA A)KATA/LHPTA TUGXA/NEIN, E)PEI/PER FAU=LOI PA/NTES O)/NTES OU)K E)/XOMEN BE-BAI/AN TW=N O)/NTWN KATA/LHYIN. TOU/TOU DE\ OU(/TWS E)/XONTOS A)POLEI/PETAI, TA\ U(PO\ TW=N <20*STWI+KW=N>20 PRO\S TOU\S A)PO\ TH=S SKE/YEWS LEGO/MENA PARA\ ME/ROS KAI\ U(PO\ @1 TW=N SKEPTIKW=N PRO\S E)KEI/NOUS LE/GESQAI. E)PEI\ GA\R TOI=S FAU/LOIS KAT' AU)TOU\S E)GKATARIQMOU=NTAI *ZH/NWN TE KAI\ *KLEA/NQHS KAI\ *XRU/SIPPOS KAI\ OI( LOIPOI\ TW=N A)PO\ TH=S AI(RE/SEWS, PA=S DE\ FAU=LOS A)GNOI/A| KRATEI=TAI, PA/NTWS H)GNO/EI *ZH/NWN PO/TERON E)N KO/SMW| PERIE/XETAI H)\ AU)TO\S TO\N KO/SMON PERIE/SXHKEN KAI\ PO/TERON A)NH/R E)STIN H)\ GUNH/, KAI\ OU)K H)PI/STATO *KLEA/NQHS EI)/TE A)/NQRWPO/S E)STIN EI)/TE TI QHRI/ON *TUFW=NOS POLUPLOKW/TERON. KAI\ MH\N H)\ E)GI/GNWSKE TO\ DO/GMA TOU=TO <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 STWI+KO\N O)/N, FHMI\ DH\ TO\ "1<20PA/NTA A)GNOEI= O( FAU=LOS>20"2 H)\ OU)DE\ AU)TO\ TOU=TO H)PI/STATO. KAI\ EI) ME\N H)PI/STATO, YEU=DOS TO\ PA/NTA A)GNOEI=N TO\N FAU=LON: AU)TO\ GA\R TOU=TO FAU=LOS W)\N E)GI/NWSKEN O( *XRU/SIPPOS, TO\ PA/NTA A)GNOEI=N TO\N FAU=LON. EI) D' OU)D' AU)TO\ TOU=TO H)/|DEI TO\ O(/TI PA/NTA A)GNOEI=, PW=S PERI\ POLLW=N DOGMATI/ZEI, TIQEI\S TO\ E(/NA EI)=NAI KO/SMON KAI\ PRONOI/A| TOU=TON DIOI-KEI=SQAI KAI\ DIO/LOU TREPTH\N EI)=NAI TH\N OU)SI/AN KAI\ A)/LLA PAMPLHQH=; PA/RESTI DE\ EI)/ TINI FI/LON E)STI/, KAI\ TA\S A)/LLAS A)PORI/AS TO\N A)NTERWTW=NTA, W(S E)/QOS E)/XOUSIN AU)TOI\ TOI=S SKEPTIKOI=S, PROSA/GEIN. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de fato cp. 28 p. 199, 7 Bruns.$10 OI( DE\ FA/S-KONTES E)C A)NA/GKHS H(MA=S EI)=NAI/ TE KAI\ GI/NESQAI TOIOU/TOUS&10 [1scil.$10 A)GAQOU\S H)\ KAKOU/S]1, KAI\ MH\ KATALIPO/NTES H(MI=N TH\N E)COUSI/AN TOU= TAU=TA PRA/TTEIN TE KAI\ MH/, DI' W(=N A)\N TOIOU=TOI GENOI/MEQA_PW=S OU)X O(MOLOGH/SOUSIN KA/KISTON GE-GONE/NAI TW=N ZW/|WN A(PA/NTWN U(PO\ TH=S FU/SEWS TO\N A)/NQRWPON, DI' O(/N FASIN PA/NTA TA)=LLA GENE/SQAI, W(S SUNTELE/SONTA PRO\S TH\N TOU/TOU SWTHRI/AN; EI) GA\R H( ME\N A)RETH/ TE KAI\ H( KAKI/A MO/NAI KAT' AU)TOU\S H( ME\N A)GAQO/N, H( DE\ KAKO/N, KAI\ OU)DE\N TW=N A)/LLWN ZW/|WN OU)DETE/ROU TOU/TWN E)STI\N E)PIDEKTIKO/N, TW=N DE\ A)N-QRW/PWN OI( PLEI=STOI KAKOI/, MA=LLON DE\ A)GAQO\S ME\N EI(=S H)\ DEU/TEROS U(P' AU)TW=N GEGONE/NAI MUQEU/ETAI, W(/SPER TI PARA/DOCON ZW=|ON KAI\ PARA\ FU/SIN SPANIW/TERON TOU= FOI/NIKOS TOU= PAR' *AI)QI/OYIN, <20OI( DE\ PA/NTES KAKOI\ KAI\ E)PI/SHS A)L-LH/LOIS TOIOU=TOI, W(S MHDE\N DIAFE/REIN A)/LLON A)/LLOU, MAI/NESQAI DE\ O(MOI/WS PA/NTAS O(/SOI MH\ SOFOI/>20, PW=S OU)K A)\N A)QLIW/TATON ZW=|ON A(PA/NTWN O( A)/NQRWPOS EI)/H, E)/XWN TH/N TE KAKI/AN KAI\ TO\ MAI/NESQAI SU/MFUTA AU(TW=| KAI\ SUGKEKLHRWME/NA; @&10Seneca de beneficiis IV 27. timidus dicitur aliquis, quia stul-&10tus est%10 et hoc malos sequitur, quos indiscreta et universa vitia circum-&10stant; dicitur timidus proprie natura etiam ad inanes sonos pavidus. &10Stultus omnia vitia habet, sed non in omnia natura pronus est%10 alius in &10avaritiam, alius in luxuriam, alius in petulantiam inclinatur. Itaque er-&10rant illi, qui interrogant <21Stoicos>21%10 quid ergo? Achilles timidus est?__ &10<21Non hoc dicimus, sic omnia vitia esse in omnibns, quomodo in &10quibusdam singula eminent, sed malum ac stultum nullo vitio &10vacare>21. ne audacem quidem timoris absolvimus, ne prodigum quidem &10avaritia liberamus. &10@Stobaeus ecl. II 68, 8 W.$10 *(OMOI/WS DE\ <20MHD' O(SI/OUS EI)=NAI/ FASI TOU\S FAU/LOUS>20. *TH\N GA\R O(SIO/THTA U(POGRA/FESQAI DIKAIOSU/NHN PRO\S QEOU/S: TOU\S DE\ FAU/LOUS PAREKBAI/NEIN POLLA\ TW=N PRO\S QEOU\S DIKAI/WN, PAR' O(\ KAI\ A)NOSI/OUS EI)=NAI KAI\ A)KAQA/RTOUS KAI\ A)NA/GNOUS KAI\ MIAROU\S KAI\ A)NEORTA/STOUS. @*TO\ GA\R E(ORTA/ZEIN A)STEI/OU FASI\N EI)=NAI, TH=S E(ORTH=S OU)/SHS XRO/NOU TINO\S E)N W(=| XRH\ PERI\ TO\ QEI=ON GI/GNESQAI TIMH=S XA/RIN KAI\ KAQHKOU/SHS E)PISHMASI/AS, @1 O(/QEN KAI\ TO\N E(ORTA/ZONTA SUGKAQEIKE/NAI DEI= MET' EU)SEBEI/AS EI)S TH\N TOIAU/THN TA/CIN. @&10Stobaeus eclog. II 7 p. 105 W.$10 *)ARE/SKEI DE\ KAI\ <20PA=N A(MA/R-THMA A)SE/BHMA EI)=NAI>20. *TO\ GA\R PARA\ TH\N BOU/LHSI/N TI PRA/TTESQAI TOU= QEOU= A)SEBEI/AS EI)=NAI TEKMH/RION. *TW=N GA\R QEW=N OI)KEIOUME/NWN ME\N TH=| A)RETH=| KAI\ TOI=S TAU/THS E)/RGOIS, A)LLOTRIOUME/NWN DE\ TH=| KAKI/A| KAI\ TOI=S A)PO\ TAU/THS SUNTELOUME/NOIS, TOU= D' A(MARTH/MATOS O)/NTOS E)NERGH/MATOS KATA\ KAKI/AN, KATE-FAI/NETO PA=N A(MA/RTHMA A)PARESTO\N QEOI=S U(PA/RXON [1TOU=TO D' E)STI\N A)SE/BHMA]1: [KAI\] KAQ' E(/KASTON GA\R A(MA/RTHMA O( FAU=LOS A)PARESTO/N TI POIEI= QEOI=S. _ *)/ETI DE\ E)PEI\ PA=S FAU=LOS O(/SA POIEI= KATA\ KAKI/AN POIEI=, KAQA/PER O( SPOUDAI=OS KAT' A)RETH/N, KAI\ O( MI/AN E)/XWN KAKI/AN PA/SAS E)/XEI, E)N DH\ TAU/TAIS O(RA=SQAI KAI\ TH\N A)SE/BEIAN, OU) TH\N TETAGME/NHN KATA\ TH\N E)NE/RGEIAN, A)LLA\ TH\N TH=| EU)SEBEI/A| E)NANTI/AN E(/CIN. *TO\ DE\ KATA\ A)SE/BEIAN PEPRAGME/NON A)SE/BHMA EI)=NAI, PA=N [2A)/R']2 A(MA/RTHMA A)SE/BHMA EI)=NAI. @*)/ETI D' A)RE/SKEI AU)TOI=S KAI\ <20PA/NT' EI)=NAI TO\N A)/FRONA QEOI=S E)XQRO/N>20: TH\N GA\R E)/XQRAN A)SUMFWNI/AN EI)=NAI [2PERI\]2 TW=N KATA\ TO\N BI/ON KAI\ DIXO/NOIAN, W(/SPER KAI\ TH\N FILI/AN SUMFWNI/AN KAI\ O(MO/NOIAN. *DIAFWNOU=SI D' OI( FAU=LOI PRO\S TOU\S QEOU\S PERI\ TW=N KATA\ TO\N BI/ON, DIO/PER PA=S A)/FRWN QEOI=S E)XQRO/S E)STIN. *)/ETI EI) PA/NTES TOU\S E)NANTI/OUS AU)TOI=S E)XQROU\S EI)=NAI NOMI/ZOUSI, TW=| DE\ SPOUDAI/W| O( FAU=LO/S E)STIN E)NANTI/OS KAI\ SPOUDAI=O/S E)STIN O( QEO/S, O( FAU=LOS QEOI=S E)STIN E)XQRO/S. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 31 p. 1048e.$ *KAI\ MH\N OU)/Q' AU(TO\N O( <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 A)POFAI/NEI SPOUDAI=ON OU)/TE TINA\ TW=N AU(TOU= GNW-RI/MWN H)\ KAQHGEMO/NWN, TI/ OU)=N PERI\ TW=N A)/LLWN FRONOU=SIN H)\ TAU=TA A(/PER LE/GOUSI; <20MAI/NESQAI PA/NTAS, A)FRAI/NEIN, A)NOSI/OUS EI)=NAI>20, PARANO/MOUS, E)P' A)/KRON H(/KEIN DUSTUXI/AS, KAKODAIMONI/AS A(PA/SHS. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 68, 18 W.$10 *)/ETI DE\ LE/GOUSI <20PA/NTA FAU=LON MAI/NESQAI>20, A)/GNOIAN E)/XONTA AU(TOU= KAI\ TW=N KAQ' AU(TO/N, O(/PER E)STI\ MANI/A. *TH\N D' A)/GNOIAN EI)=NAI E)NANTI/AN KAKI/AN TH=| FRONH/SEI: TAU/THN DE\ PRO/S TI/ PWS E)/XOUSAN A)KATASTA/TOUS KAI\ PTOIW/DEIS PAREXOME/NHN TA\S O(RMA\S MANI/AN EI)=NAI: DIO\ KAI\ U(POGRA/FOUSI TH\N MANI/AN OU(/TWS: A)/GNOIAN PTOIW/DH. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VIII 124.$10 <20PA/NTAS TE TOU\S A)/FRONAS MAI/NESQAI>20: OU) GA\R EI)=NAI FRONI/MOUS, A)LLA\ KATA\ TH\N I)/SHN TH=| A)FROSU/NH| MANI/AN PA/NTA PRA/TTEIN. @&10Cicero Tusc. disp. IV 54. Quid? Stoici, qui <21omnes insipientes &10insanos esse dicunt>21, nonne ista colligunt? Remove perturbationes &10maxumeque iracundiam, iam videbuntur monstra dicere. Nunc autem ita &10disserunt, sic se dicere omnes stultos insanire, ut male olere omne caenum. &10At non semper. Commove, senties. Sic iracundus non semper iratus est; &10lacesse, iam videbis furentem. &10@Porphyrion ad Hor. Serm. II 3, 32. Quia <21Stoici omnes ho-&10mines insanos et stultos esse dicunt>21, excepto sapiente [1cf. ad v. 187: @1 &10Dogma autem <21Stoicorum>21 quoddam$10 PRAGMATIKO\N&10 vocatur, quo continetur, &10omnes homines insanos esse]1. @&Athenaeus Deipnosoph. XI p. 464d.$ TH\N DE\ MANI/AN TOU\S POLLOU/S FHSIN O( <20*XRU/SIPPOS E)N TH=| EI)SAGWGH=| TH=S PERI\ A)GAQW=N KAI\ KAKW=N PRAGMATEI/AS>20 TOI=S PLEI/STOIS PROSA/PTESQAI. KALEI=SQAI GOU=N TH\N ME\N <20GUNAIKOMANI/AN>20, TH\N DE\ <20O)RTUGOMANI/AN>20. TINE\S DE\ KAI\ <20DOCOMANEI=S>20 KALOU=SI TOU\S FILODO/COUS, KAQA/PER TOU\S FILOGU/NAS <20GUNAIKOMANEI=S>20 KAI\ TOU\S FILO/RNIQAS <20O)RNIQOMANEI=S>20, TO\ AU)TO\ SHMAI-NO/NTWN TW=N O)NOMA/TWN TOU/TWN. W(/STE KAI\ TA\ LOIPA\ MH\ A)LLOTRI/WS KA-LEI=SQAI TO\N TRO/PON TOU=TON. KAI\ GA\R O( FI/LOYOS KAI\ O( O)YOFA/GOS OI(=ON <20O)YOMANH/S>20 E)STI, KAI\ O( FI/LOINOS <20OI)NOMANH/S>20, KAI\ W(SAU/TWS E)PI\ TW=N O(MOI/WN, OU)K A)LLOTRI/WS TH=S MANI/AS KEIME/NHS E)N AU)TOI=S, W(S A(MARTA/NOUSI MANIKW=S KAI\ TH=S A)LHQEI/AS E)PI\ PLEI=ON A)PARTWME/NOIS. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 31 [1cf. de comm. not. cp. 33 &p. 1076b]1.$ *KAI\ MH\N OU)/Q' AU(TO\N O( *XRU/SIPPOS A)POFAI/NEI SPOUDAI=ON OU)/TE TINA\ TW=N AU(TOU= GNWRI/MWN H)\ KAQHGEMO/NWN. *TI/ OU)=N PERI\ TW=N A)/LLWN FRONOU=SIN, H)\ TAU=TA A(/PER LE/GOUSI; <20MAI/NESQAI PA/NTAS, A)FRAI/-NEIN, A)NOSI/OUS EI)=NAI, PARANO/MOUS>20, E)P' A)/KRON H(/KEIN DUSTUXI/AS, KAKODAIMONI/AS A(PA/SHS [EI)=TA PRONOI/A| QEW=N DIOIKEI=SQAI TA\ KAQ' H(MA=S OU(/TWS A)QLI/WS PRA/TTONTAS &addit Plutarchus]. paullo infra%10 si dei no-&bis nocere vellent,$ OU)K A)\N DU/NAINTO DIAQEI=NAI XEI=RON H)\ NU=N E)/XOMEN, W(S *XRU/SIPPOS A)POFAI/NEI, <20MH/TE KAKI/AS U(PERBOLH\N A)POLEI/PEIN MH/TE KAKODAIMONI/AS TO\N BI/ON: W(/ST' EI) LA/BOI FWNH/N, EI)PEI=N A)\N AU)TO\N TA\ TOU= *(HRAKLE/OUS>20: [1&Eur. Herc. 1245]1$ @<20*GE/MW KAKW=N DH\ KOU)KE/T' E)/SQ' O(/POU TEQH=|>20: *TI/NAS OU) A)/N TIS EU(/ROI MAXOME/NAS MA=LLON A)LLH/LAIS A)POFA/SEIS TH=S PERI\ QEW=N *XRUSI/PPOU KAI\ TH=S PERI\ A)NQRW/PWN, TOU\S ME\N W(S E)/NI BE/L-TISTA PRONOEI=N, TOU\S DE\ W(S E)/NI XEI/RISTA PRA/TTEIN LE/GONTOS; @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 10 p. 1062f.$ E)/TI DE\ MA=LLON E)N TOI=S PRA/GMASIN, O(/TAN PA/NTAS E)PI/SHS KAKOU\S KAI\ A)DI/KOUS KAI\ A)PI/STOUS KAI\ A)/FRONAS TOU\S MH\ SOFOU\S A)POFAI/NONTES& etc. &@Diogenianus apud Eusebium praep. evang. VI p. 264b.$ PW=S OU)=N OU)DE/NA FH\S A)/NQRWPON, O(\S OU)XI\ MAI/NESQAI/ SOI DOKEI= KAT' I)/SON *)ORE/STH| TE KAI\ *)ALKMAI/WNI, PLH\N TOU= SOFOU=; E(/NA DE\ H)\ DU/O MO/NOUS FH\S SOFOU\S GEGONE/NAI, TOU\S DE\ A)/LLOUS DI' A)FROSU/NHN E)PI/SHS TOI=S PROEIRHME/NOIS MEMHNE/NAI; @&ibidem c.$ PRW=TON ME\N GA\R OU)DE\ SU\ FH\S SOFO\N EI)=NAI SEAUTO/N& etc. @&10Porphyrio ad Hor. ep. I 1, 82. Utraque haec a <21Stoicis>21 dicun-&10tur in insaniam vulgi%10 primum quod inter se dissideant, deinde quod a &10semet ipsis mutent subinde proposita. &10@Philo de posteritate Caini %14 75 Vol. II p. 16, 22 Wendl.$10 PA=N @1 O(/, TI A)\N E(AUTW=| LAMBA/NH| FAU=LOS, PA/NTWS E)STI\N E)PI/LHPTON, A(/TE GNW/MH| DUSKA-QA/RTW| MIAINO/MENON. KAI\ GA\R E)/MPALIN AI( TW=N SPOUDAI/WN E(KOU/SIOI PRA/CEIS E)PAINETAI\ PA=SAI. @&10Philo Leg. Alleg. III %14 247 Vol. I p. 168, 5 Wendl.$10 <20*)EPWDU/-NWS GA\R O( FAU=LOS PA/NTA TO\N BI/ON XRH=TAI TH=| E(AUTOU= YUXH=|>20, MHDE\N E)/XWN XARA=S AI)/TION, O(\ PE/FUKE GENNA=N DIKAIOSU/NH KAI\ FRO/NHSIS KAI\ AI( SU/N-QRONOI TAU/THS A)RETAI/. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 25 p. 1046b.$ [1<20E)N PRW/TW| PERI\ TW=N *KATORQWMA/TWN>20]1 *TH\N E)PIXAIREKAKI/AN <20O(/POU ME\N>20 A)NU/-PARKTON EI)=NAI/ FHSIN: E)PEI\ TW=N ME\N A)STEI/WN OU)DEI\S E)P' A)LLOTRI/OIS KA-KOI=S XAI/REI, [2TW=N DE\ FAU/LWN OU)DEI\S XAI/REI]2 TO\ PARA/PAN. @&p. 1046c.$ H(\N [1&sc.$ TH\N E)PIXAIREKAKI/AN]1 <20E)N E(TE/ROIS>20 A)NU/PARKTON EI)=NAI/ FHSIN, W(/SPER TH\N MISOPONHRI/AN KAI\ TH\N AI)SXROKE/RDEIAN. @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 21 p. 1068d.$8 <20"1A)LL' OU)K W)FELOU=N-TAI>20 [1&scil.$8 <20OI( FAU=LOI]1 TOU/TWN TUGXA/NONTES, OU)D' EU)= PA/SXOUSIN, OU)D' EU)ERGE/TAS E)/XOUSIN, OU)D' EU)ERGETW=N A)MELOU=SIN>20."2 *OU) TOI/NUN OU)D' A)XARISTOU=SIN OI( FAU=LOI: KAI\ MH\N OU)DE\ OI( NOU=N E)/XONTES. *)ANU/PAR-KTON OU)=N E)STI TO\ A)XA/RISTON: OI( ME\N GA\R OU)K A)POSTEROU=SI XA/RIN LAMBA/-NONTES, OI( DE\ LAMBA/NEIN XA/RIN OU) PEFU/KASIN. *(/ORA DH/, TI/ PRO\S TAU=TA LE/GOUSIN O(/TI "1H( XA/RIS EI)S TA\ ME/SA DIATEI/NEI, KAI\ TO\ ME\N W)FE-LEI=N KAI\ W)FELEI=SQAI SOFW=N E)STI, XA/RITOS DE\ KAI\ OI( FAU=LOI TUGXA/NOUSIN>20."2 @&10Clemens Al. Strom. VI 17 p. 822 Pott.$10 DIO/PER KOINA\ ME\N TW=N A)GAQW=N [ME/N] E)STIN KAI\ TW=N KAKW=N A)NQRW/PWN POLLA\ TW=N PROTERHMA/TWN, GI/NETAI D' O(/MWS W)FE/LIMA MO/NOIS TOI=S A)GAQOI=S TE KAI\ SPOUDAI/OIS. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 12 p. 1038a.$ "1<20*TOI=S FAU/-LOIS OU)DE\N EI)=NAI XRH/SIMON"2 O( *XRU/SIPPO/S FHSIN "1OU)D' E)/XEIN XREI/AN TO\N FAU=LON OU)DENO\S OU)DE\ DEI=SQAI>20."2 *TAU=TA D' EI)PW\N <20E)N TW=| PRW/TW| TW=N *KATORQWMA/TWN>20, AU)=QIS LE/GEI "1<20KAI\ TH\N EU)XRHSTI/AN KAI\ TH\N XA/RIN EI)S TA\ ME/SA DIATEI/NEIN>20"2 W(=N OU)DE/N E)STI XRH/SIMON KAT' AU)TOU/S. *KAI\ MH\N OU)D' OI)KEI=ON OU)D' A(RMO/TTON OU)DE\N EI)=NAI TW=| FAU/LW| FHSI\N E)N TOU/TOIS: @"1$8 <20*KATA\ TAU)TA\ DE\ TW=| ME\N A)STEI/W| A)LLO/TRION OU)DE/N, TW=| DE\ FAU/LW| OI)KEI=ON OU)DE/N E)STIN: E)PEIDH\ TO\ ME\N A)GAQO/N, TO\ DE\ KA-KO/N E)STIN AU)TW=N>20."2 @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 20 p. 1068a.$ GRA/FWN <20E)N TOI=S PERI\ @1 <20*KATORQWMA/TWN>20, W(S "1O( <20FAU=LOS OU)DENO\S DEI=TAI, OU)DENO\S E)/XEI XREI/AN: OU)DE/N E)STIN AU)TW=| XRH/SIMON, OU)DE\N OI)KEI=ON, OU)DE\N A(RMO/TTON>20."2 [1H( KAKI/A MEQ' H(=S OU)DE\ U(GI/EIA XRH/SIMON, OU)DE\ PLH=QOS XRHMA/TWN, OU)DE\ PROKOPH/]1. @&ibid. c.$8 *NUNI\ DE\ TI/S O( I)/LIGGOS OU(=TOS, TO\N ME\N A)NENDEA= DEI=SQAI W(=N E)/XEI A)GAQW=N, TO\N DE\ FAU=LON E)NDEA= ME\N EI)=NAI POLLW=N, DEI=SQAI DE\ MHDE-NO/S; TOUTI\ GA\R LE/GEI *XRU/SIPPOS, W(S "1<20OU) DE/ONTAI ME/N, E)NDE/ONTAI DE\ OI( FAU=LOI>20."2 @&Seneca ep. 9, 14.&3 Volo tibi <21Chrysippi>21 quoque distinctionem indi-&3care. ait%10 "1<21sapientem nulla re egere et tamen multis illi rebus &3opus esse. contra stulto nulla re opus est, nulla enim re uti &3scit, sed omnibus eget>21."2 @&10Schol. in Hom. Iliad.$10 *W&10 536.$10 O)/LBW|: DU/NATAI TH=| FRONH/SEI, EI)/GE KAI\ A)/NOLBOS <20PARA\ *STWI+KOI=S>20 O( A)PAI/DEUTOS. @&10Philo Leg. Alleg. III %14 201 Vol. I p. 157, 25 Wendl.$10 W(/SPER GA\R E(TE/RWS TU/PTETAI O( A)QLHTH\S KAI\ O( DOU=LOS: O( ME\N KAQ' U(PO/PTWSIN E)NDI-DOU\S PRO\S TA\S AI)KI/AS KAI\ U(PEI/KWN, O( D' A)QLHTH\S A)NTE/XWN KAI\ A)NTISTATW=N KAI\ TA\S E)PIFEROME/NAS A)POSEIO/MENOS: KAI\ KEI/REIS E(TE/RWS ME\N A)/NQRWPON, E(TE/-RWS DE\ TO\ KW/DION: TO\ ME\N GA\R E)N TW=| PA/SXEIN MO/NON E)CETA/ZETAI: O( D' A)/NQRW-POS KAI\ A)NTIDRA=| KAI\ W(/SPER A)NTIPE/PONQE, SXHMATI/ZWN E(AUTO\N PRO\S TO\ KEI/-RESQAI: OU(/TWS O( <20ME\N A)LO/GISTOS A)NDRAPO/DWN DI/KHN E(TE/RW| U(PEI/KEI KAI\ U(POPI/PTEI TAI=S A)LGHDO/SIN>20 W(S A)FORH/TOIS DESPOI/NAIS, A)NTIBLE/YAI PRO\S AU)TA\S A)DUNATW=N_. *PARO\ DH\ KAI\ PLH=QOS A)/PEIRON DIA\ TW=N AI)SQH/-SEWN AU)TW=| TW=N O)DUNHRW=N E)PANTLEI=TAI. *(O D' E)PISTH/MWN, A)QLHTOU= TRO/PON META\ DUNA/MEWS KAI\ R(W/MHS KARTERW=S A)NTIBA/S, PRO\S TA\ A)LGEINA\ PA/NTA A)NTIPNEI=, W(S MH\ TITRW/SKESQAI PRO\S AU)TW=N, A)LL' E)CADIAFOREI=N E(/KASTON. *KAI/ MOI DOKEI= NEA-NIEUSA/MENOS A)\N E)PIFWNH=SAI TO\ TRAGIKO\N PRO\S TH\N A)LGHDO/NA OU(/TWS: [1&10Eur. fr. 687N]1$10 *PI/MPRA KA/TAIQE SA/RKAS, E)MPLH/SQHTI/ MOU @@*PI/NOUSA KELAINO\N AI(=MA: PRO/SQE GA\R KA/TW @@*GH=S EI)=SIN A)/STRA, GH= D' A)/NEIS' [2E)S]2 AI)QE/RA @@*PRI\N E)C E)MOU= SOI QW=P' A)PANTH=SAI LO/GON. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 103, 24 W.$10 FASI\ DE\ KAI\ <20A)/GROIKON>20 EI)=NAI PA/NTA FAU=LON: TH\N GA\R A)GROIKI/AN A)PEIRI/AN EI)=NAI TW=N KATA\ PO/LIN E)QW=N KAI\ NO/MWN: H(=| PA/NTA FAU=LON E)/NOXON U(PA/RXEIN. EI)=NAI DE\ KAI\ <20A)/GRION>20, E)NANTIWTIKO\N O)/NTA TH=| KATA\ NO/MON DIECAGWGH=| KAI\ QHRIW/DH KAI\ BLAPTIKO\N A)/NQRWPON. *TO\N D' AU)TO\N TOU=TON KAI\ A)NH/MERON U(PA/RXEIN KAI\ TURANNIKO/N, OU(/TWS DIAKEI/MENON W(/STE DESPOTIKA\ POIEI=N, E)/TI DE\ W)MA\ KAI\ BI/AIA KAI\ PARA/NOMA KAIRW=N E)PILABO/MENON. *EI)=NAI DE\ KAI\ A)XA/RISTON, OU)/TE PRO\S A)NTAPO/DOSIN XA/RITOS OI)KEI/WS E)/XONTA OU)/TE @1 PRO\S META/DOSIN DIA\ TO\ MH/TE KOINW=S TI POIEI=N MH/TE FILIKW=S MH/T' A)MELE-TH/TWS. @&10Philo quaest. et solut in Genesin IV 165 [1p. 371 Aucher]1. Ad &10haec cum <21agrestis>21 sit [1scil.$10 O( FAU=LOS]1,&10 est etiam urbe carens et transfuga &10a lege et rectae vitae gustus nescius, rebellis et contumax, nullius rei &10iustorum aut bonorum particeps, familiaritatis, humanitatis et communi-&10tatis inimicus, vitam agens insociam. @&10Philo Leg. Alleg. III %14 1 Vol. I p. 113, 3 Wendl.$10 DO/GMA EI)SH-GEI=TAI DIDA/SKON, O(/TI O( <20FAU=LOS FUGA/S E)STIN>20. EI) GA\R PO/LIS OI)KEI/A TW=N SOFW=N H( A)RETH/, TAU/THS O( MH\ DUNA/MENOS METE/XEIN A)PELH/LATAI PO/LEWS, H(=S A)DUNATEI= METE/XEIN O( FAU=LOS. A)PELH/LATAI A)/RA KAI\ PEFUGA/DEUTAI MO/NOS O( FAU=LOS. @&10Philo de Gigantibus %14 67 Vol. II p. 55, 5 Wendl.$10 O(/TI_O( ME\N FAU=LOS, W(/SPER A)/OIKOS KAI\ <20A)/POLIS>20 KAI\ A)NI/DRUTOS KAI\ <20FUGA\S>20 OU(/TWS KAI\ AU)TO/MOLOS, O( DE\ SPOUDAI=OS BEBAIO/TATOS SU/MMAXOS. @&10Philo quaest. et solut. in Genesin IV 76 [1p. 304 Aucher]1. Se-&10cundo vero legem statuit nimis naturalem, quam nonnulli philosophorum &10sibi conciliarunt. Lex autem est, ut ex insipientibus nullus sit rex, quam-&10vis terrae et maris totam vim subiugarit, sed solus sapiens et dei amans, &10praeter partes apparatuum armorumque, quibus multi proficiunt per vim &10violentam. Etenim sicut nauticae vel medicinae vel musicae si quis im-&10peritus sit, pro argumento sunt ei clavus et medicaminum commixtura et &10tibia et lyra [1nullum enim istorum usurpare potest ad usum destinatum, &10at nauarcho et medico ac musico dicatur omnino convenire]1 ita profecto, &10siquidem ars est quaedam regium hoc munus et artifex homo virtute prae-&10ditus. Nam qui imperitus est et nescius rerum homines iuvantium, <21rudis &10atque rusticus>21 est censendus, rex autem dicendus solus peritus gnarusque. &10@Stobaeus ecl. II 104, 10 W.$10 <20*MHDE\ FILO/LOGON EI)=NAI TO\N FAU=LON MHDE\ FILH/KOON>20, PARA\ TO\ MHD' A)RXH\N PARESKEUA/SQAI PRO\S TH\N TW=N O)RQW=N LO/GWN PARADOXH\N DIA\ TH\N U(PEI/KOUSAN E)K TH=S DIASTROFH=S A)FRO-SU/NHN, PARA\ TO\ <20MH/TE PROTETRA/FQAI TINA\ TW=N FAU/LWN MH/TE PROTRE/-PEIN PRO\S A)RETH/N>20: TO\N GA\R PROTETRAMME/NON H)\ PROTRE/PONTA E(TE/ROUS E(/TOI-MON EI)=NAI DEI= PRO\S TO\ FILOSOFEI=N, TO\N D' E(/TOIMON A)NEMPODI/STWS E)/XEIN, MHDE/NA [2DE\]2 TW=N A)FRO/NWN EI)=NAI TOIOU=TON. *OU) GA\R TO\N PROQU/MWS A)KOU/ONTA KAI\ U(POMNHMATIZO/MENON TA\ LEGO/MENA U(PO\ TW=N FILOSO/FWN E(/TOIMON EI)=NAI PRO\S TO\ FILOSOFEI=N, A)LLA\ TO\N E(TOI/MWS E)/XONTA PRO\S TO\ TA\ DIA\ TH=S FILOSOFI/AS PARAG-GELLO/MENA METAFE/REIN E)PI\ TA\ E)/RGA KAI\ KAT' AU)TA\ BIOU=N. *OU)DE/NA DE\ TW=N FAU/LWN TOIOU=TON EI)=NAI, PROKATEILHMME/NON TOI=S TH=S KAKI/AS DO/GMASIN. *EI) GA\R PROETE/TRAPTO/ TIS TW=N FAU/LWN, KAI\ A)PO\ TH=S KAKI/AS A)\N E)TE/TRAPTO. *OU)DEI\S D' @1 E)/XWN TH\N KAKI/AN PRO\S A)RETH\N TE/TRAPTAI, W(S OU)DE\ NOSW=N PRO\S U(GI/EIAN. MO/-NON DE\ PROTETRA/FQAI TO\N SOFO\N KAI\ MO/NON PROTRE/PEIN DU/NASQAI, TW=N D' A)FRO/NWN MHDE/NA. KATA\ GA\R PARAGGE/LMATA BIOU=N MHDE/NA TW=N A)FRO/NWN: <20MHD' EI)=NAI FILO/LOGON, LOGO/FILON DE\ MA=LLON>20, ME/XRI LALIA=S E)PIPOLAI/OU PRO-BAI/NONTA, MHKE/TI DE\ KAI\ TOI=S E)/RGOIS E)KBEBAIOU/MENON TO\N TH=S A)RETH=S LO/GON. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 105, 7.$10 <20MHDE\ GA\R FILO/PONO/N TINA TW=N FAU/-LWN EI)=NAI>20: TH\N GA\R FILOPONI/AN DIA/QESIN E)CERGASTIKH\N EI)=NAI TW=N E)PIBAL-LO/NTWN A)NUPO/PTWS DIA\ PO/NON: OU)DE/NA DE\ TW=N FAU/LWN A)NUPO/PTWS E)/XEIN PRO\S TO\N PO/NON. @&10Stobaeus eclog. II 7 p. 105, 11 Wachsm.$10 <20*MHDE\ GA\R TH\N KAT' A)CI/AN POIEI=SQAI DO/SIN TH=S A)RETH=S TW=N FAU/LWN TINA/>20, SPOUDAI=ON ME\N GA\R EI)=NAI TH\N DO/SIN, E)PISTH/MHN OU)=SAN, KAQ' H(\N A)CIO/LOGO/N TI H(GOU/MEQA PERI-POIEI=SQAI. *TW=N DE\ SPOUDAI/WN MHDE\N EI)S FAU/LOUS PI/PTEIN, W(/STE MHDE\ TH\N A)CI/AN TH=S A)RETH=S DO/SIN POIEI=SQAI/ TINA TW=N FAU/LWN. *EI) GA\R TH\N KAT' A)CI/AN TIS E)POIEI=TO DO/SIN TW=N A)FRO/NWN TH=S A)RETH=S, E)F' O(/SON E)TI/MA TAU/THN, A)PW|-KONOMEI=TO A)\N TH\N KAKI/AN. *PA=S DE/ TIS A)/FRWN SU/NESTIN H(DE/WS TH=| E(AUTOU= KAKI/A|. *SKOPEI=N GA\R DEI= MH\ TO\N E)CW/FORON AU)TW=N LO/GON, FAU=LON O)/NTA, A)LLA\ TO\N TW=N PRA/CEWN. *)EK TOU/TWN GA\R A)PELE/GXONTAI [KAI\] MH\ PERI\ TA\ KALA\ KAI\ SPOUDAI=A PARWRMHME/NOI, A)LLA\ PERI\ TA\S A)NDRAPODW/DEIS A)ME/TROUS A)POLAU/SEIS. @1 @&Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 188$ <20E)N DE\ TW=| DEUTE/RW| PERI\ *BI/WN KAI\ PORISMOU= PRONOEI=N, LE/GWN O(/PWS PORISTE/ON TW=| SOFW=|>20. *KAI/TOI TI/NOS XA/RIN PORISTE/ON AU)TW=|; EI) ME\N GA\R TOU= ZH=N E(/NEKEN, A)DIA/FORON TO\ ZH=N: EI) DE\ H(DONH=S, KAI\ AU(/TH A)DIA/FOROS: EI) DE\ TH=S A)RETH=S, AU)TA/R-KHS AU(/TH PRO\S EU)DAIMONI/AN. <20KATAGE/LASTOI DE\ KAI\ OI( TRO/POI TOU= PORISMOU=, OI(=ON OI( A)PO\ BASILE/WS>20: EI)/KEIN GA\R AU)TW=| DEH/SEI, <20KAI\ OI( A)PO\ FILI/AS>20: LH/MMATOS GA\R W)/NIOS H( FILI/A E)/STAI. <20KAI\ OI( A)PO\ SOFI/AS>20: MISQARNH/SEI GA\R H( SOFI/A. @&10Stobaeus eclog. II 7 p. 109, 10.$10 *TREI=S DE\ PROHGOUME/NOUS EI)=NAI BI/OUS, TO/N TE BASILIKO\N KAI\ TO\N POLITIKO\N KAI\ TRI/TON TO\N E)PISTHMONIKO/N: O(MOI/WS DE\ KAI\ <20XRHMATISMOU\S TREI=S PROHGOUME/NOUS, TO/N TE A)PO\ TH=S BASILEI/AS>20, KAQ' O(\N H)\ AU)TO\S BASILEU/SEI H)\ MONARXIKW=N XRHMA/TWN EU)PORH/SEI: <20DEU/TERON DE\ TO\N A)PO\ TH=S POLITEI/AS>20, POLITEU/SESQAI GA\R KATA\ TO\N PROH-GOU/MENON LO/GON: KAI\ GA\R GAMH/SEIN KAI\ PAIDOPOIH/SESQAI, A)KOLOUQEI=N [2GA\R]2 TAU=TA TH=| TOU= LOGIKOU= ZW/|OU KAI\ KOINWNIKOU= KAI\ FILALLH/LOU [2FU/SEI]2. *XRH-MATIEI=SQAI OU)=N KAI\ A)PO\ TH=S POLITEI/AS KAI\ A)PO\ TW=N FI/LWN, TW=N E)N U(PERO-XAI=S O)/NTWN. <20*PERI\ DE\ TOU= SOFISTEU/SEIN>20 KAI\ A)PO\ SOFISTEI/AS EU)PORH/SEIN XRHMA/TWN DIE/STHSAN OI( A)PO\ TH=S AI(RE/SEWS KATA\ TO\ SHMAINO/MENON. *TO\ ME\N GA\R XRHMATIEI=SQAI A)PO\ TW=N KATA\ TH\N PAIDEI/AN KAI\ MISQOU/S POTE LH/YESQAI PARA\ TW=N FILOMAQOU/NTWN DIWMOLOGH/SANTO: PERI\ DE\ TO\ SHMAINO/MENON E)GE/NETO/ TIS E)N AU)TOI=S A)MFISBH/THSIS, TW=N ME\N AU)TO\ TOU=TO LEGO/NTWN SOFISTEU/EIN, TO\ E)PI\ MISQW=| METADIDO/NAI TW=N TH=S FILOSOFI/AS DOGMA/TWN, TW=N D' U(POTOPHSA/N-TWN E)N TW=| SOFISTEU/EIN PERIE/XESQAI/ TI FAU=LON, OI(ONEI\ LO/GOUS KAPHLEU/EIN, OU) @1 FAME/NWN DEI=N A)PO\ PAIDEI/AS PARA\ TW=N E)PITUXO/NTWN XRHMATI/ZESQAI, KATA-DEE/STERON GA\R EI)=NAI TO\N TRO/PON TOU=TON TOU= XRHMATISMOU= TOU= TH=S FILOSOFI/AS A)CIW/MATOS. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 130.$10 <20BI/WN DE\ TRIW=N, QEWRHTIKOU= KAI\ PRAKTIKOU= KAI\ LOGIKOU=>20, TO\N TRI/TON FASI\N AI(RETE/ON: GEGONE/NAI GA\R U(PO\ TH=S FU/SEWS E)PI/THDES TO\ LOGIKO\N ZW=|ON PRO\S QEWRI/AN KAI\ PRA=CIN. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 3o p. 1047f.$ <20E)N DE\ TW=|. E(BDO/MW| TOU= *KAQH/KONTOS>20 KAI\ KUBISTH/SEIN TRI\S [1&sc.$ TO\N SOFO\N]1 E)PI\ TOU/TW| LABO/NTA TA/LANTON. @&Cicero de officiis III 10, 42.&3 Scite <21Chrysippus>21 ut multa%10 &3<21"1Qui stadium, inquit, currit, eniti et contendere debet, quam &3maxime possit, ut vincat; supplantare eum, quocum certet, &3aut manu depellere nullo modo debet. Sic in vita sibi quem-&3que petere quod pertineat ad usum, non iniquum est%10 alteri &3deripere ius non est>21."2 @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 111, 3 W.$10 *KAI\ <20BASILEU/SEIN TE/ POTE TO\N NOU=N [2E)/XONTA]2 KAI\ BASILEI= SUMBIW/SESQAI>20 KAI\ EU)FUI/+AN E)MFAI/NONTI KAI\ FILOMA/QEIAN. E)/FAMEN D' O(/TI KAI\ POLITEU/ESQAI KATA\ TO\N PROHGOU/MENON LO/GON OI(=O/N E)STI, MH\ POLITEU/ESQAI DE\ E)A/N TI [2KWLU/H|]2 KAI\ MA/LIST' [2A)\N]2 MHDE\N W)FELEI=N ME/LLH| TH\N PATRI/DA, KINDU/NOUS DE\ PARAKOLOUQEI=N U(POLAMBA/NH| MEGA/LOUS KAI\ XALEPOU\S E)K TH=S POLITEI/AS. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 20 p. 1043bc.$ A)LL' AU)TO\S O( *XRU/SIPPOS <20E)N TW=| PRW/TW| PERI\ *BI/WN "1BASILEI/AN TE TO\N SOFO\N E(KOUSI/WS A)NADE/XESQAI, LE/GEI, XRHMATIZO/MENON A)P' AU)TH=S: KA)\N AU)TO\S BASILEU/EIN MH\ DU/NHTAI, SUMBIW/SETAI BASILEI= KAI\ STRA-TEU/SETAI META\ BASILE/WS, OI(=OS H)=N *)IDA/NQURSOS O( *SKU/QHS H)\ *LEU/KWN O( *PONTIKO/S>20."2 *PARAQH/SOMAI DE\ KAI\ TAU/THN AU)TOU= TH\N DIA/LEKTON &etc. __ @"1$8<20*(/OTI GA/R, FHSI/, KAI\ STRATEU/SETAI META\ DUNASTW=N KAI\ BIW/-SETAI, PA/LIN E)PISKEYW/MEQA TOU/TWN E)XO/MENOI, TINW=N ME\N OU)DE\ TAU=TA U(PONOOU/NTWN DIA\ TOU\S O(MOI/OUS U(POLOGISMOU/S, H(MW=N DE\ KAI\ TAU=TA A)POLEIPO/NTWN, DIA\ TOU\S PARAPLHSI/OUS LO/GOUS>20."2 KAI\ META\ MIKRO/N: "1<20*OU) MO/NON DE\ META\ TW=N PROKEKOFO/TWN E)PI\ POSO\N KAI\ E)N A)GWGAI=S KAI\ E)N E)/QESI POIOI=S GEGONO/TWN, OI(=ON PARA\ *LEU/KWNI KAI\ *)IDANQU/RSW|>20."2 @1 @&p. 1043e.$ <20O( DE\ *XRU/SIPPOS E(/NEKA XRHMATISMOU= TO\N SOFO\N E)PI\ KEFALH\N E)S *PANTIKA/PAION W)QEI= KAI\ TH\N *SKUQW=N E)RHMI/AN>20. @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 7 p. 1061d.$ *)=AR' OU)=N O(MOI/WS U(GI-EI/AS E)PILEIPOU/SHS, AI)SQHTHRI/OU KAMO/NTOS, OU)SI/AS A)POLLUME/NHS A)FRO/N-TISTO/S E)STI KAI\ PRO\S AU(TO\N OU)DE\N H(GOU/MENOS TOU/TWN O( SOFO/S; H)\ "1<20NOSW=N ME\N I)ATROI=S TELEI= MISQOU/S, XRHMA/TWN D' E(/NEKA PRO\S *LEU/KWNA PLEI= TO\N E)N *BOSPO/RW| DUNA/STHN, KAI\ PRO\S *)IDA/N-QURSON A)PODHMEI= TO\N *SKU/QHN"2; W(/S FHSI *XRU/SIPPOS, "1TW=N D' AI)SQH/SEWN E)/STIN A(\S A)POBALW\N OU)DE\ ZH=N U(POME/NEI>20"2; @&Strabo VII 8 p. 301 [1de scytharum veterum probitate$]1. *OI( ME/NTOI PRO\ H(MW=N__U(PELAMBA/NONTO PARA\ TOI=S *(/ELLHSIN O(POI/OUS *(/OMHRO/S FHSIN. O(/RA DE\ A(\ LE/GEI *(HRO/DOTOS__<20O(/RA DE\ KAI\ A(\ LE/GEI *XRU/SIPPOS PERI\ TW=N TOU= *BOSPO/ROU BASILE/WN TW=N PERI\ *LEU/KWNA>20. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 20 p. 1043e.$ *(/OTI GA\R E)R-GASI/AS E(/NEKA KAI\ XRHMATISMOU= TAU=TA POIEI= [1®es et principes comi-&tatur]1,$ KAI\ PRODEDH/LWKE [1&antecedunt duo primi libri fragmenta$]1 "1<20TREI=S U(POQE/MENOS A(RMO/ZONTAS MA/LISTA TW=| SOFW=| XRHMATISMOU/S, TO\N A)PO\ BASILEI/AS KAI\ TO\N A)PO\ FI/LWN KAI\ TRI/TON E)PI\ TOU/-TOIS TO\N A)PO\ SOFISTEI/AS>20."2 @&cp. 30 p. 1047f.$ <20*KAI\ TO\N ME\N SOFO\N E)N TOI=S PERI\ *BI/WN KAI\ BASILEU=SI SUNE/SESQAI/ FHSIN E(/NEKA XRHMATISMOU=, KAI\ SOFISTEU/SEIN E)P' A)RGURI/W|, PAR' W(=N ME\N PROLAMBA/NONTA, PRO\S OU(\S DE\ SUNTIQE/MENON TW=N MAQHTW=N>20. @&Stobaeus Florileg. 45, 29.$ <20*XRUSI/PPOU: *XRU/SIPPOS E)RW-THQEI\S DIA\ TI/ OU) POLITEU/ETAI, EI)=PE: *DIO/TI EI) ME\N PONHRA/[TIS] POLITEU/ETAI, TOI=S QEOI=S A)PARE/SEI: EI) DE\ XRHSTA\ TOI=S PO-LI/TAIS>20. &Seneca ad Serenum de otio 8, 1.&3 Adice nunc, quod <21e lege &3Chrysippi vivere otioso licet>21%10 non dico, ut otium patiatur, sed ut &3eligat. Negant nostri sapientem ad quamlibet rempublicam accessurum. @&idem ad Serenum de tranq. animi 1, 10.&3 promptus, compositus &3sequor Zenona, Cleanthen, <21Chrysippum>21, quorum tamen nemo ad rem-&3publicam accessit, <21nemo non misit>21. @&10Seneca ep. 68, 2. Nec ad omnem rem publicam mittimus nec &10semper nec sine ullo fine: praeterea, cum sapienti rempublicam ipso dig- @1&10nam dedimus, id est mundum, non est extra rem publicam, etiamsi re-&10cesserit. @&Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 121.$ <20POLITEU/SESQAI FASI\ TO\N SOFO\N A)\N MH/ TI KWLU/H|, W(/S FHSI *XRU/SIPPOS E)N PRW/TW| PERI\ *BI/WN>20: KAI\ GA\R KAKI/AN E)FE/CEIN KAI\ E)P' A)RETH\N PARORMH/SEIN. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. c. 5 p. 1034b.$ *XRU/SIPPOS DE\ PA/LIN <20E)N TW=| PERI\ *(RHTORIKH=S>20 GRA/FWN "1<20OU(/TW R(HTOREU/SEIN KAI\ POLITEU/SESQAI TO\N SOFO/N, W(S KAI\ TOU= PLOU/TOU O)/NTOS A)GA-QOU=, KAI\ TH=S DO/CHS KAI\ TH=S U(GEI/AS>20"2, O(MOLOGEI= TOU\S LO/GOUS AU)-TW=N A)NECO/DOUS EI)=NAI KAI\ A)POLITEU/TOUS, KAI\ TA\ DO/GMATA TAI=S XREI/AIS A)NA/RMOSTA KAI\ TAI=S PRA/CESIN. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 23 p. 1045d.$ *(\A DE\ TOU/-TOIS PA/LIN AU)TO\S E)C E)NANTI/AS EI)/RHKEN, OU)X O(MOI/WS OU(/TWS E)N ME/SW| KEI/-MENA, DI' AU)TW=N PARAQH/SOMAI TW=N E)KEI/NOU LE/CEWN. <20*)EN ME\N GA\R TW=| PERI\ TOU= *DIKA/ZEIN U(POQE/MENOS DU/O DROMEI=S O(MOU= SUNEKPI/P-TEIN A)LLH/LOIS, DIAPOREI= TI/ TW=| BRABEUTH=| KAQH/KEI POIH=SAI>20: @"1$8<20*PO/TERON, FHSI/N, E)/CESTI TO\N BRABEUTH\N TO\N FOI/NIKA O(PO-TE/RW| BOU/LETAI A)PODOU=NAI, K[2AQ' O(\]2 A)\N TU/XWSIN AU)TW=| SUNHQE/-STEROI O)/NTES, W(S A)\N E)NTAU=QA TW=N AU(TOU= TI XARISA/MENON TRO/-PON TINA/, [2H)\]2 MA=LLON W(S KOINOU= TOU= FOI/NIKOS GEGONO/TOS A)MFOTE/RWN, OI(ONEI/ TINOS KLH/ROU GINOME/NOU E)NA/LLWS KATA\ TH\N E)PI/KLISIN W(S E)/TUXE DOU=NAI AU)TO/N: LE/GW DE\ H(\N E)/TUXEN E)PI/-KLISIN, OI(/A GI/NETAI O(/TAN DUEI=N PROKEIME/NWN DRAXMW=N O(MOI/WN KATA\ TA\ LOIPA\ E)PI\ TH\N E(TE/RAN E)PIKLI/NANTES LAMBA/NWMEN AU)TH/N>20."2 @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 131.$10 <20POLITEI/AN DE\ A)RI/STHN TH\N MIKTH\N E)/K TE DHMOKRATI/AS KAI\ BASILEI/AS KAI\ A)RISTOKRATI/AS>20. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 20 p. 1043e.$ *OU(/TW DE\ AU)-TO\N [1&sc. sapientem$]1 A)/RAS E)KEI= [1&in libro$ PERI\ *FU/SEWS]1 KAI\ O)GKW/SAS E)NTAU=QA PA/LIN EI)S MISQARNI/AN KATABA/LLEI KAI\ SOFISTEI/AN: <20KAI\ GA\R AI)TH/SEIN KAI\ PROLH/YESQAI, TO\ ME\N EU)QU\S A)RXOME/NOU, TO\ DE\ XRO/NOU TW=| MAQHTH=| DIELQO/NTOS, O(/PER EU)GNWMONE/STERON EI)=NAI/ @1 FHSIN, A)SFALE/STERON DE\ TO\ PROLAMBA/NEIN, W(S A)DIKH/MATA TOU= TO/POU E)PIDEXOME/NOU. *LE/GEI DE\ OU(/TWS>20: @"1$8<20*EI)SPRA/TTONTAI DE\ TO\N MISQO\N OU) PA/NTAS OI( NOU=N E)/XONTES W(SAU/TWS: A)LL' A)/LLWS [2A)/LLOUS]2, W(S A)\N O( KAIRO\S FE/RH|, OU)K E)PAGGELLO/MENOI POIH/SEIN A)GAQOU/S, KAI\ TAU=T' E)N E)NIAUTW=|: O(/SA DE\ PRO\S E(AUTOU/S, TAU=TA POIH/SEIN PRO\S TO\N SUMFWNHQE/NTA XRO/NON."2 *KAI\ PA/LIN PROELQW/N: "1*TO/N TE KAIRO\N EI)/SETAI, PO/TERON EU)QU\S DEI= TO\N MISQO\N LAMBA/NEIN A(/MA TH=| PROSO/DW|, KAQA/PER PLEI/OUS PEPOIH/KASIN, H)\ KAI\ XRO/NON AU)TOI=S DIDO/NAI, TOU= TO/-POU TOU/TOU MA=LLON KAI\ A)DIKH/MATA E)PIDEXOME/NOU, DO/CANTOS D' A)\N EI)=NAI EU)GNWMONESTE/ROU>20."2 @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 2 p. 1033d.$ *AU)TO\S GOU=N *XRU/SIPPOS <20E)N TW=| TETA/RTW| PERI\ *BI/WN>20 OU)DE\N OI)/ETAI TO\N SXOLASTI-KO\N BI/ON TOU= H(DONIKOU= DIAFE/REIN: AU)TA\S DE\ PARAQH/SOMAI TA\S LE/CEIS: @"1$8<20*(/OSOI DE\ U(POLAMBA/NOUSI FILOSO/FOIS E)PIBA/LLEIN MA/LISTA TO\N SXOLASTIKO\N BI/ON A)P' A)RXH=S, OU(=TOI/ MOI DOKOU=SI DIAMAR-TA/NEIN, U(PONOOU=NTES DIAGWGH=S TINOS E(/NEKEN DEI=N TOU=TO POIEI=N H)\ A)/LLOU TINO\S TOU/TW| PARAPLHSI/OU, KAI\ TO\N O(/LON BI/ON OU(/TW PWS DIELKU/SAI: TOU=TO D' E)STI/N, A)\N SAFW=S QEWRHQH=|, H(DE/WS. *OU) GA\R DEI= LANQA/NEIN TH\N U(PO/NOIAN AU)TW=N, POLLW=N ME\N SAFW=S TOU=TO LEGO/NTWN, OU)K O)LI/GWN D' A)DHLO/TERON>20."2 @$*TOU=TO OU)=N O( *XRU/SIPPOS, <20O( GE/RWN>20, O( FILO/SOFOS, O( TO\N BASILI-KO\N KAI\ POLITIKO\N E)PAINW=N BI/ON.& ibidem. &@Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 20 p. 1043a.$ *MI/A <20SU/N-TACIS H( PERI\ *BI/WN, TE/TTARA BIBLI/A>20: TOU/TWN <20E)N TW=| TETA/RTW|>20 LE/GEI, <20TO\N SOFO\N A)PRA/GMONA/ TE EI)=NAI KAI\ O)LIGOPRA/GMONA KAI\ TA\ AU(TOU= PRA/TTEIN>20: E)/STI DE\ H( LE/CIS AU(/TH: @"1$8<20*OI)=MAI GA\R E)/GWGE TO\N FRO/NIMON KAI\ A)PRA/GMONA EI)=NAI KAI\ O)LIGOPRA/GMONA, KAI\ TA\ AU(TOU= PRA/TTEIN, O(MOI/WS TH=S TE AU)TO-PRAGI/AS KAI\ TH=S O)LIGOPRAGMOSU/NHS A)STEI/WN O)/NTWN>20."2 @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 20 p. 1043b.$ *TA\ DE\ O(/MOIA SXEDO\N <20E)N TW=| PERI\ TW=N *DI' AU(TA\ *AI(RETW=N>20 EI)/RHKE TAU/TAIS TAI=S LE/CESI: @"1$8<20*TW=| GA\R O)/NTI FAI/NETAI O( KATA\ TH\N H(SUXI/AN BI/OS A)KI/NDU-NO/N TI KAI\ A)SFALE\S E)/XEIN, OU) PA/NU TW=N POLLW=N DUNAME/NWN TOU=TO SUNIDEI=N>20."2 @1 @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 32 p. 1049a.$8 *)EGKALOU=SIN AU)TW=| TINE\S TW=N *PUQAGORIKW=N <20E)N TOI=S PERI\ *DIKAIOSU/NHS>20 GRA/FONTI PERI\ TW=N A)LEKTRUO/NWN, O(/TI "1<20XRHSI/MWS GEGO/NASI: E)PEGEI/ROUSI GA\R H(MA=S KAI\ TOU\S SKORPI/OUS E)KLE/GOUSI KAI\ KATA\ TA\S MA/XAS E)PISTRE/FOUSI, ZH=LO/N TINA PRO\S A)LKH\N E)MPOIOU=NTES: O(/MWS DE\ DEI= KATESQI/EIN KAI\ TOU/TOUS, I(/NA MH\ TH\N XREI/AN U(PERBA/LLH| TO\ PLH=QOS TW=N NEOTTW=N>20."2 @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 21 p. 1044b.$ <20*)EN DE\ TW=| PERI\ *POLITEI/AS "1OU)DE\N H(DONH=S E(/NEKA PRA/CEIN OU)DE\ PARA-SKEUA/SESQAI/ FHSI TOU\S POLI/TAS>20"2 KAI\ TO\N *EU)RIPI/DHN E)PAINEI=, TAU=TA PROFERO/MENOS [1&fab. inc. 884N$]1 @<20*)EPEI\ TI/ DEI= BROTOI=SI, PLH\N DUOI=N MO/NWN, @*DH/MHTROS A)KTH=S PW/MATO/S Q' U(DRHXO/OU>20; EI)=TA MIKRO\N A)PO\ TOU/TWN PROELQW\N <20E)PAINEI= TO\N *DIOGE/NH, TO\ AI)-DOI=ON A)POTRIBO/MENON E)N FANERW=| KAI\ LE/GONTA PRO\S TOU\S PA-RO/NTAS: *EI)/QE KAI\ TO\N LIMO\N OU(/TWS A)POTRI/YASQAI TH=S GASTRO\S H)DUNA/MHN>20. @&10Philo de fortitudine p. 376 Vol. II Mang.$10 *)ENDEH\S DE\__ TO\ PARA/PAN OU)DE\ EI(=S E)STI XORHGO\N E)/XWN TO\N TH=S FU/SEWS A)KAQAI/RETON PLOU=-TON: A)E/RA ME\N TH\N PRW/THN KAI\ A)NAGKAIOTA/THN KAI\ SUNEXH= TROFH/N, A)DIASTA/-TWS MEQ' H(ME/RAN TE KAI\ NU/KTWR A)NAPNEO/MENON: E)/PEITA DE\ PHGA\S A)FQO/NOUS __PRO\S PO/TOU XRH=SIN: E)/PEITA EI)S E)DWDH\N FORA\S PANTOI/WN KARPW=N KAI\ DE/NDRWN I)DE/AS, AI(\ TA\S E)THSI/OUS O)PW/RAS A)EI\ FE/ROUSI. @&10Athenaeus I 18b.$ E)S TO\ PRE/PON DE\ *(/OMHROS A)FORW=N TOU\S H(/RWAS OU) PARH/GAGEN A)/LLO TI DAINUME/NOUS H)\ KRE/A KAI\ TAU=TA E(AUTOI=S SKEUA/ZONTAS. OU) GA\R E)/XEI GE/LWTA OU)D' AI)SXU/NHN O)YARTU/ONTAS AU)TOU\S KAI\ E(/YONTAS O(RA=N. <20E)PETH/DEUON GA\R TH\N AU)TODIAKONI/AN KAI\ @1 E)KALLWPI/ZONTO, FHSI\ *XRU/SIPPOS, TH=| E)N TOU/TOIS EU)STROFI/A|>20. *)ODUSSEU\S GOU=N DAITREU=SAI/ TE KAI\ "1PU=R NHH=SAI"2 OI(=OS OU)K A)/LLOS DECIO\S EI)=NAI/ FHSI [1O& 322$]1. KAI\ E)N *LITAI=S DE\ *PA/TROKLOS KAI\ *)AXILLEU\S PA/NTA EU)TREPI/ZEI [1*I& 202. 209$]1. KAI\ *MENELA/OU DE\ TELOU=NTOS GA/MOUS O( NUM-FI/OS *MEGAPE/NQHS OI)NOXOEI= [1O& 141$]1. NU=N DE\ E)PI\ TOSOU=TON E)KPEPTW/-KAMEN, W(S KATAKEI=SQAI DAINU/MENOI. @&Athenaeus III 104b.$ EI)S TAU=T' OU)=N TIS A)POBLE/PWN, A)/NDRES FI/LOI, EI)KO/TWS A)\N E)PAINE/SEIEN TO\N KALO\N <20*XRU/SIPPON>20 KATIDO/NTA A)KRI-BW=S TH\N *)EPIKOU/ROU FU/SIN KAI\ <20EI)PO/NTA MHTRO/POLIN EI)=NAI TH=S FILOSOFI/AS AU)TOU= TH\N *)ARXESTRA/TOU *GASTROLOGI/AN>20, H(\N PA/NTES OI( TW=N FILOSO/FWN GASTRI/MARGOI *QE/OGNI/N TINA AU(TW=N EI)=NAI LE/GOUSI TH\N KALH\N TAU/THN E)POPOII/+AN. @&idem VII 278e.$ <20*XRU/SIPPOS D' AU)TO\N [1&scil. Archestratum$]1, O( O)/NTWS FILO/SOFOS KAI\ PERI\ PA/NTA A)NH\R A)RXHGO\N *)EPIKOU/RW| FHSI\ GENE/SQAI KAI\ TOI=S TA\ TOU/TOU E)PISTAME/NOIS TH=S PA/NTA DIALUMHNAME/NHS H(DONH=S>20: KAI\ GA\R OU)K E)GKALUPTO/MENOS O( *)EPI/KOU-ROS LE/GEI, A)LLA\ MEGA/LH| TH=| FWNH=|: "1OU) GA\R E)/GWGE DU/NAMAI NOH=SAI TA)-GAQO\N A)FELW\N ME\N TH\N DIA\ XULW=N, A)FELW\N DE\ TH\N DI' A)FRODISI/WN H(DONH/N."2 OI)/ETAI GA\R OU(=TOS O( SOFO\S KAI\ TO\N TW=N A)SW/TWN BI/ON A)NE-PI/LHPTON EI)=NAI, EI)/PER AU)TW=| PROSGE/NOITO TO\ A)DEE\S KAI\ I(/LEWN. @&Athenaeus Deipnosoph. IV p. 158a.$ *STWI+KO\N DE\ DO/GMA E)STI\N O(/TI TE PA/NTA EU)= POIH/SEI O( SOFO\S KAI\ <20FAKH=N FRONI/MWS A)R-TU/SEI>20. DIO\ KAI\ *TI/MWN O( *FLIA/SIOS E)/FH "1KAI\ *ZHNW/NEIO/N GE FAKH=N E(/YEIN O(\S MH\ FRONI/MWS MEMA/QHKEN"2 W(S OU)K A)/LLWS DUNAME/NHS E(YHQH=NAI FAKH=S, EI) MH\ KATA\ TH\N *ZHNW/NEION U(FH/GHSIN, O(\S E)/FH @EI)S DE\ FAKH=N E)/MBALLE DUWDE/KATON KORIA/NNOU *KAI\ *KRA/THS D' O( *QHBAI=OS E)/LEGE @@MH\ PRO\ FAKH=S LOPA/D' AU)/CWN @EI)S STA/SIN A)/MME BA/LH|S. <20*XRU/SIPPOS DE\ E)N TW=| PERI\ TOU= KALOU= GNW/MAS TINA\S H(MI=N EI)S-FE/RWN FHSI/>20 @$8<20MH\ [2MOI/]2 POT' E)LAI/AN E)/SQI' A)KALH/FHN E)/XWN. @XEIMW=NOS W(/RA| BOLBOFAKH=N BABAI\ BABAI/. @BOLBOFAKH= D' I)/SON A)MBROSI/H| YU/XOUS KRUO/ENTOS>20. @&10Georgius Nazianzenus carmin. lib. I sect. II 10$10 [1PERI\ A)RETH=S]1&10 v. 604$10 @*KA)KEI=NO D' OI(=ON <20*STWI+KW=N>20 TW=N FILTA/TWN @*(WS A)/LLOS A)/LLW| SARKI/W| TIS PROSLALW=N: @"1*TI/ SOI XREWSTW=, FHSI/N, A)/QLION DE/ROS; @1 @@*FAGEI=N; ME/GISTON A)/RTOS E)NDEW=S DOQEI/S. @@*PIEI=N; U(/DWR SOI DW/SOMEN KAI\ O)CI/NHN. @@*OU) TAU=TA/ M' AI)TEI=S, TA\ TRUFH=S DE\ KAI\ KO/ROU @@*KRUSTALLI/NWN TE A(BRO/THT' E)KPWMA/TWN. @@*LI/AN E(TOI/MWS DW/SOMEN G', A)LL' A)GXO/NHN."2 @&10Alexander in Aristot. Top. p. 46 Ald. p. 84, 14 Wal.$10 TA\ ME\N GA\R W(=N SU/NEGGUS H( A)PO/DEICIS R(A/|DIA KAI\ EU)/GNWSTA KAI\ DIA\ BRAXEI/AS E)PISTA/-SEWS GNWRIZO/MENA. __TOIAU=TA/ E)STI KAI\ TA\ E)N <20TOI=S PERI\ KAQHKO/NTWN U(PO\ TW=N A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 ZHTOU/MENA, OI(=ON PO/TERON XRH\ SUNARISTW=NTA/ TISIN H)\ TW=| PATRI\ E)KTEI/NEIN E)PI\ TA\ POR)R(WTE/RW ME/RH TH\N XEI=RA, A)\N H)=| MEI/ZW, H)\ MH\ A)LL' A)RKEI=SQAI TOI=S PARAKEIME/NOIS, H)\ EI) XRH\ A)KOU/ONTAS FILOSO/FOU E)PHLLA-XE/NAI TOU\S PO/DAS. @&10Philo de plantatione Noe%28 %14 142 Vol. II p. 161, 18 Wendl.$10 *)ESPOUDA/SQH DE\ PARA\ POLLOI=S TW=N FILOSO/FWN H( SKE/YIS OU) METRI/WS: PRO-TEI/NETAI DE\ OU(/TWS: <20EI) MEQUSQH/SETAI O( SOFO/S>20; *)/ESTI TOI/NUN TO\ MEQU/EIN DITTO/N, E(\N ME\N I)/SON TI TW=| OI)NOU=SQAI: E(/TERON DE\ I)/SON TW=| LHREI=N E)N OI)/NW|. *TW=N DE\ E)PIXEIRHSA/NTWN TH=| PROTA/SEI <20OI( ME\N>20 E)/FASAN MH/TE A)KRA/TW| PLEI/ONI XRH/-SESQAI TO\N SOFO\N MH/TE LHRH/SEIN: TO\ ME\N GA\R A(MA/RTHMA, TO\ DE\ A(MARTH/MATOS EI)=NAI POIHTIKO/N, E(KA/TERON DE\ A)LLO/TRION KATORQOU=NTOS. <20*OI( DE\>20 TO\ ME\N OI)-NOU=SQAI KAI\ SPOUDAI/W| PROSH=KON A)PEFH/NANTO, TO\ DE\ LHREI=N A)NOI/KEION. *TH\N GA\R E)N AU)TW=| FRO/NHSIN I(KANH\N EI)=NAI TOI=S BLA/PTEIN E)PIXEIROU=SIN A)NTISTATH=SAI KAI\ TO\N E)PI\ TH=| YUXH=| NEWTERISMO\N AU)TW=N KAQELEI=N: DU/NAMIN DE\ PERIBEBLH=SQAI FRO/NHSIN PAQW=N SBESTH/RION, EI)/TE U(PO\ FLEGMAI/NONTOS E)/RWTOS OI)/STRW| A)NER)-R(IPISME/NWN, EI)/TE U(PO\ POLLOU= KAI\ ZE/ONTOS E)CHMME/NWN OI)/NOU, DI' H(\N U(PERA/NW STH/SETAI. *)EPEI\ KAI\ TW=N KATA\ POTAMOU= BAQE/OS H)\ QALA/TTHS DUOME/NWN OI( ME\N A)/PEIROI TOU= NAUTI/LLESQAI DIAFQEI/RONTAI, OI( DE\ TOU= PRA/GMATOS E)PISTH/-MONES TA/XISTA DIASW/|ZONTAI. __ @%14&10`149.$10 *TA\ ME\N OU)=N W(SANEI\ PROOI/MIA TH=S SKE/YEWS TOIAU=TA/ E)STI. TO\N DE\ PERI\ AU)TH=S LO/GON H)/DH PERAI/NWMEN, DIPLOU=N W(S EI)KO\S O)/NTA: TO\N ME\N O(/TI O( SOFO\S MEQUSQH/SETAI KATASKEUA/ZONTA, TO\N DE\ TOU)NANTI/ON O(/TI OU) MEQUSQH/-SETAI BEBAIOU/MENON. @*TOU= DE\ <20PROTE/ROU TA\S PI/STEIS>20 A(RMO/TTON LE/GEIN PRO/TERON, POIHSAME/-NOUS E)NQE/NDE TH\N A)RXH/N: TW=N PRAGMA/TWN TA\ ME\N O(MW/NUMA, TA\ DE\ SUNW/NUMA EI)=NAI SUMBE/BHKEN [1&10Sequitur longior de homonymia et synonymia disputatio]1. &10@%14 154.$10 TO\N A)/KRATON W(/SPER OI)=NON, OU(/TWS KAI\ ME/QU OI( PALAIOI\ E)KA/LOUN: POLLAXOU= GOU=N TH=S POIH/SEW/S E)STI TOUTI\ TOU)/NOMA E)MFERO/MENON, W(/ST' EI) TA\ SUNWNUMOU=NTA KAQ' E(NO\S U(POKEIME/NOU LE/GETAI, OI)=NOS KAI\ ME/QU, KAI\ TA\ A)PO\ TOU/TWN OU)DE\N O(/TI MH\ FWNAI=S DIOI/SEI MO/NON, TO/ TE OI)NOU=SQAI KAI\ TO\ A)PO\ [E(/N]. E(KA/TERON DE\ PLEI/ONOS OI)/NOU XRH=SIN E)MFAI/NEI, H(\N POLLW=N E(/NEKA AI)TIW=N OU)K A)\N A)POSTRE/FOITO O( SPOUDAI=OS. *EI) DE\ OI)NWQH/SETAI, KAI\ MEQUSQH/SETAI, XEI=RON OU)DE\N E)K TH=S ME/QHS DIATEQEI/S, A)LLA\ TAU)TO\N O(/PER KAI\ [O(] E)K YILH=S TH=S OI)NW/SEWS PAQW/N. *MI/A ME\N A)PO/DEICIS PERI\ TOU= TO\N SOFO\N MEQUSQH=NAI LE/LEKTAI, DEUTE/RA DE/ E)STI TOIAU/TH. @1 @&Stobaeus Florileg. 18, 24.$ <20*XRUSI/PPOU: *MIKRA\N FASI\ MANI/AN EI)=NAI TH\N ME/QHN>20. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 21 p. 1044d.$ *)EN DE\ TW=| PERI\ *POLITEI/AS>20 EI)PW\N O(/TI "1<20E)GGU/S E)SMEN TOU= KAI\ TOU\S KOPRW=-NAS ZWGRAFEI=N>20"2 MET' O)LI/GON "1<20TA\ GEWRGIKA/ FHSI KALLWPI/ZEIN TINA\S A)NADENDRA/SI KAI\ MUR)R(I/NAIS, KAI\ TAW\S KAI\ PERISTERA\S TRE/FOUSI KAI\ PE/RDIKAS, I(/NA KAKKABI/ZWSIN AU)TOI=S, KAI\ A)HDO/-NAS>20."2 *(HDE/WS D' A)\N AU)TOU= PUQOI/MHN, TI/ FRONEI= PERI\ MELITTW=N KAI\ ME/LITOS &etc.$__EI) DE\ TAU/TAIS TO/PON E)N PO/LEI DI/DWSI, DIA\ TI/ <20TW=N PRO\S A)KOH\N KAI\ O)/YIN E)PITERPW=N A)PEI/RGEI TOU\S POLI/TAS>20; @&10Diog. Lae%28rt VII 123.$10 TH\N ME/NTOI <20A)/SKHSIN A)PODE/CETAI&10 [1scil.$10 O( SOFO\S]1 U(PE\R TH=S TOU= SW/MATOS U(POMONH=S. @&Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 129.$ KAI\ <20E)RASQH/SESQAI DE\ TO\N SOFO\N TW=N NE/WN, TW=N E)MFAINO/NTWN DIA\ TOU= EI)/DOUS TH\N PRO\S A)RETH\N EU)FUI/+AN>20, W(/S FHSI *ZH/NWN E)N TH=| POLITEI/A| KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS E)N TW=| PRW/TW| PERI\ *BI/WN>20 KAI\ *)APOLLO/DWROS E)N TH=| H)QIKH=|. EI)=NAI DE\ TO\N E)/RWTA E)PIBOLH\N FILOPOII/+AS, DIA\ KA/LLOS E)MFAINO/MENON: KAI\ MH\ EI)=NAI SUNOUSI/AS, A)LLA\ FILI/AS. TO\N GOU=N *QRASWNI/DHN KAI/PER E)N E)COUSI/A| E)/XONTA TH\N E)RWME/NHN DIA\ TO\ MISEI=SQAI A)PE/XESQAI AU)TH=S [1&cf. n. 650sq.]1. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 65, 15 W.$10 DOGMATI/ZOUSI KAI\ O(/TI KAI\ NOUNEXO/N-TWS KAI\ DIALEKTIKW=S POIEI= [1&10scil.$10 O( SOFO\S]1 KAI\ <20SUMPOTIKW=S KAI\ E)RWTIKW=S>20. TO\N DE\ E)RWTIKO\N KAI\ DIXH=| LE/GESQAI, <20TO\N ME\N>20 KATA\ TH\N A)RETH\N POIO\N SPOU-DAI=ON O)/NTA, <20TO\N DE\>20 KATA\ TH\N KAKI/AN E)N YO/GW|, W(S A)\N E)RWTOMANH= TINA. EI)=NAI D' E)/RWTA [2TO\N SPOUDAI=ON FILI/AS]2. TO/N T' A)CIE/RASTON O(MOI/WS LE/GESQAI TW=| A)CIOFILH/TW|, KAI\ OU) TW=| A)CIAPOLAU/STW|: TO\N GA\R A)/CION SPOUDAI/OU E)/RWTOS, TOU=TON EI)=NAI A)CIE/RASTON. *(OMOI/WS DE\ TH=| E)RWTIKH=| <20TH\N SUMPOTIKH\N>20 PARA-LAMBA/NOUSIN EI)S TA\S A)RETA/S, <20TH\N ME\N>20 PERI\ TO\ E)N SUMPOSI/W| KAQH=KON A)NA-STREFOME/NHN E)PISTH/MHN OU)=SAN TOU= PW=S DEI= E)CA/GESQAI TA\ SUMPO/SIA KAI\ TOU= PW=S DEI= SUMPI/NEIN: TH\N D' E)PISTH/MHN NE/WN QH/RAS EU)FUW=N, PROTREPTIKH\N OU)=SAN E)PI\ TH\N KAT' A)RETH/N, KAI\ KAQO/LOU E)PISTH/MHN TOU= KALW=S E)RA=N: DIO\ KAI/ FASIN E)RASQH/SESQAI TO\N NOU=N E)/XONTA. *TO\ DE\ E)RA=N AU)TO\ MO/NON A)DIA/FO-RON EI)=NAI, E)PEIDH\ GI/NETAI/ POTE KAI\ PERI\ FAU/LOUS. *TO\N DE\ E)/RWTA OU)/TE E)PI-QUMI/AN EI)=NAI OU)/TE TINO\S FAU/LOU PRA/GMATOS, A)LL' E)PIBOLH\N FILOPOII/AS DIA\ KA/LLOUS E)/MFASIN. @&Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 129.$ EI)=NAI OU)=N TO\N E)/RWTA FILI/AS, W(S KAI\ @1 *XRU/SIPPOS E)N TW=| PERI\ *)/ERWTOS>20 FHSI/, KAI\ MH\ EI)=NAI E)PI/MEMPTON AU)TO/N. EI)=NAI DE\ KAI\ TH\N W(/RAN A)/NQOS A)RETH=S. @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 28 p. 1072f.$ *TW=N DE\ <20PERI\ *)/ERWTOS>20 FILOSOFOUME/NWN E)N TH=| *STOA=| PARA\ TA\S KOINA\S E)NNOI/AS, TH=S A)TOPI/AS <20PA=SIN AU)TOI=S>20 ME/TESTIN. "1<20*AI)SXROU\S ME\N GA\R EI)=NAI TOU\S NE/OUS, FAU/LOUS G' O)/NTAS KAI\ A)NOH/TOUS, KALOU\S DE\ TOU\S SO-FOU/S: E)KEI/NWN DE\ TW=N KALW=N MHDE/NA MH/T' E)RA=SQAI MH/T' A)CI-E/RASTON EI)=NAI>20."2 *KAI\ OU) TOU=TO/ PW DEINO/N: A)LLA\ KAI\ "1TOU\S E)RASQE/N-TAS AI)SXRW=N PAU/ESQAI LE/GOUSI KALW=N GENOME/NWN."2 &p. 1072b.$ *(\HN DE\ LE/GONTES KAI\ O)NOMA/ZONTES <20E)/MFASIN KA/LLOUS E)PAGWGO\N EI)=NAI TOU= E)/RWTOS LE/GOUSI>20, PRW=TON ME\N OU)K E)/XEI TO\ PIQANO/N: E)N GA\R AI)S-XI/STOIS KAI\ KAKI/STOIS OU)K A)\N E)/MFASIS GE/NOITO KA/LLOUS: <20EI)/PER, W(S LE/GOUSIN, H( MOXQHRI/A TOU= H)/QOUS A)NAPI/MPLHSI TO\ EI)=DOS>20. @&ibidem.$ QH/RA GA/R TIS, FASI/N, E)STI\N O( E)/RWS, A)TELOU=S ME/N, EU)-FUOU=S DE\ MEIRAKI/OU PRO\S A)RETH/N. @&Stobaeus Florileg. 63, 31 Mein.$ *XRUSI/PPOU: *EI)PO/NTOS TINO/S, OU)K E)RASQH/SETAI O( SOFO/S: MARTUREI= GOU=N *MENE/DHMOS, *)EPI/KOUROS, *)ALECI=NOS: *TAU/TH|, E)/FH, XRH/SOMAI A)PODEI/CEI: EI) GA\R *)ALECI=NOS O( A)NA/-GWGOS KAI\ *)EPI/KOUROS O( A)NAI/SQHTOS KAI\ *MENE/DHMOS O(__OU)/ FHSIN, E)RASQH/SETAI A)/RA. @&10Scholia Dionys. Thrac. Bekker Anecd. Gr. p. 667.$10 KAI\ PA/LIN TO\N E)/RWTA OI( ME\N *)EPIKOU/REIOI/ FASIN EI)=NAI SU/NTONON A)FRODISI/WN O)/RECIN, OI( DE\ <20A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20 E)PIBOLH\N FILOPOII/+AS NE/WN [KORW=N] DIA\ KA/LLOS E)MFAI-NO/MENON: DIPLOU=S DE\ O( E)/RWS E)STI/N, O( ME\N YUXH=S, O( DE\ SW/MATOS. @&10Alexander Aphrod. comm. in Aristot. Topica II p. 75 Ald. p. 139, 21 &10Wal.$10 A)LLA\ KAI\ TO\ O(/TI OU)DEI\S E)/RWS A)STEI=OS PRO/BLHMA KAQO/LOU O)\N A)POFATI-KO\N A)NASKEUA/SOMEN O(/TI MH\ PA=S E)/RWS FAU=LOS, DIELO/NTES TO\N E)/RWTA EI)/S TE SU/NTONON O)/RECIN A)FRODISI/WN W(S *)EPI/KOUROS LE/GEI, O(\N OU)X OI(=O/N TE A)STEI=ON EI)=NAI, KAI\ EI)S E)PIBOLH\N FILOPOII/+AS DIA\ KA/LLOS E)MFAINO/MENON, W(S <20OI( A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20. @&10Clemens Al. Strom. II p. 483 Pott.$10 <20*TRITTA\ DE\ EI)/DH FILI/AS>20 DIDASKO/MEQA KAI\ TOU/TWN TO\ ME\N PRW=TON KAI\ A)/RISTON TO\ KAT' A)RETH/N: STER)R(A\ GA\R H( E)K LO/GOU A)GA/PH: TO\ DE\ DEU/TERON KAI\ ME/SON KAT' A)MOIBH/N: KOINWNIKO\N DE\ TOU=TO KAI\ METADOTIKO\N KAI\ BIWFELE/S: KOINH\ GA\R H( E)K XA/RITOS FILI/A: TO\ DE\ U(/STATON KAI\ TRI/TON H(MEI=S ME\N TO\ E)K SUNHQEI/AS FAME/N: OI( DE\ TO\ KAQ' H(DONH\N TREPTO\N KAI\ METABLHTO/N. @1 @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 13 p. 1039b.$ *)/ETI TOI/NUN <20E)N TW=| DEUTE/RW| PERI\ *FILI/AS>20, DIDA/SKWN W(S OU)K E)PI\ PA=SI DEI= TOI=S A(MARTH/MASI TA\S FILI/AS DIALU/ESQAI, TAU/TAIS KE/XRHTAI TAI=S LE/CESI [1&sc. &Chrysippus]1 @"1$8<20*PROSH/KEI GA\R TA\ ME\N O(/LWS PARAPE/MPESQAI, TA\ DE\ MIKRA=S E)PISTROFH=S TUGXA/NEIN, TA\ DE\ KAI\ E)PI\ MEI=ZON, TA\ DE\ O(/LWS DIA-LU/SEWS A)CIOU=SQAI"2__E)N TW=| AU)TW=|>20 FHSIN O(/TI "1<20TOI=S ME\N E)PI\ PLEI=ON, TOI=S D' E)P' E)/LATTON SUMBALOU=MEN: W(/STE TOU\S ME\N MA=L-LON, TOU\S DE\ H(=TTON FI/LOUS EI)=NAI: E)PI\ POLU\ DE\ TH=S TOIAU/THS PARALLAGH=S GENOME/NHS, OI( ME\N TOSAU/THS OI( DE\ TOSAU/THS GI/NON-TAI FILI/AS A)/CIOI: KAI\ OI( ME\N E)PI\ TOSOU=TON [2OI( DE\ E)PI\ TOSOU=-TON]2 PI/STEWS KAI\ TW=N O(MOI/WN KATACIWQH/SONTAI>20."2 @&Seneca de beneficiis II 17, 3.&3 Volo <21Chrysippi>21 nostri uti &3similitudine de pilae lusu%10 quam cadere non est dubium aut mittentis &3vitio aut excipientis. tunc cursum suum servat, ubi inter manus utrius-&3que apte ab utroque et iactata et excepta versatur. necesse est autem &3lusor bonus aliter illam conlusori longo, aliter brevi mittat. Eadem bene-&3ficii ratio est%10 nisi utrique personae dantis et accipientis aptatur, nec &3ab hoc exibit nec ad illum perveniet, ut debet. Si cum exercitato et &3docto negotium est, audacius pilam mittemus. Utcumque enim venerit, &3manus illam expedita et agilis repercutiet. Si cum tirone et indocto, &3non tam rigide nec tam excusse, sed languidius et in ipsam eius diri-&3gentes manum remisse occurremns. Idem faciendum est in beneficiis%10 &3quosdam doceamus et satis iudicemus, si conantur, si audent, si volunt. &3Facimus autem plerumque ingratos et ut sint favemus, tamquam ita &3demum magna sint beneficia nostra, si gratia illis referri non potuit%10 &3ut malignis lusoribus propositum est conlusorem traducere, cum damno &3scilicet ipsius lusus, qui non potest nisi consentitur extendi. @[1&cp. 31__35.&3 agitur de paradoxo Stoicorum%10 eum qui libenter ac-&3cepit, gratiam reddidisse. &cp. 32.&3 pilae similitudo recurrit. Unde effi-&3cere possis hic quoque Hecatonem Chrysippo uti]1. @&Seneca de beneficiis II 25, 3.&3 Qui gratus futurus est, statim &3dum accipit de reddendo cogitet. <21Chrysippus>21 quidem dicit illum velut &3in certamen cursus compositum et carceribus inclusum opperiri debere &3tempus suum, ad quod velut dato signo prosiliat. Et quidem magna &3illi celeritate opus est, magna contentione, ut consequatur antecedentem. @1 @&Hieronymus adv. Iovinianum II 48.&3 Ridicule <21Chrysippus>21 &3ducendam uxorem sapienti praecipit, ne Iovem Gamelium et Genethlium &3violet. Isto enim modo apud Latinos ducenda uxor non erit, quia &3Iovem non habent nuptialem. @&Dio Chrys. VII %14 134 [1de lenonibus]1$ OU)K AI)SXUNOME/NOUS OU)DE/NA ׆A)NQRW/PWN H)\ QEW=N, OU)/TE *DI/A GENE/QLION OU)/TE *(/HRAN GAMH/LION. @&Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 131.$ A)RE/SKEI DE\ AU)TOI=S KAI\ KOINA\S EI)=NAI TA\S GUNAI=KAS DEI=N PARA\ TOI=S SOFOI=S: W(/STE TO\N E)NTUXO/NTA TH=| E)NTU-XOU/SH| XRH=SQAI, KAQA/ FHSI *ZH/NWN E)N TH=| POLITEI/A| KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS E)N TW=| PERI\ *POLITEI/AS>20__PA/NTAS TE PAI=DAS E)PI/SHS STE/RCOMEN PATE/RWN TRO/PON KAI\ H( E)PI\ MOIXEI/A| ZHLOTUPI/A PERIAIREQH/SETAI. @&10Origenes contra Celsum VII 63 Vol. II p. 213, 6 Ko+. [1p. 739 Del.]1.$10 E)KKLI/NOUSI TO\ MOIXEU/EIN OI( TA\ <20TOU= *KITIE/WS *ZH/NWNOS>20 FILOSOFOU=NTES__ DIA\ TO\ [2MH\]2 KOINWNIKO\N KAI\ PARA\ FU/SIN EI)=NAI TW=| LOGIKW=| ZW/W| NOQEU/EIN TH\N U(PO\ TW=N NO/MWN E(TE/RW| PROKATALHFQEI=SAN GUNAI=KA KAI\ FQEI/REIN TO\N A)/L-LOU A)NQRW/POU OI)=KON. @&10Clemens Al. Paedag. II p. 224 Pott.$10 EI) GA\R OU)DE\ TO\N DA/KTULON W(S E)/TUXE SALEU/EIN TW=| SOFW=| O( LO/GOS E)PITRE/PEI, W(S O(MOLOGOU=SIN OI( *STWI+KOI/, PW=S OU)XI\ POLU\ PLE/ON TOU= SUNOUSIASTIKOU= E)PIKRATHTE/ON MORI/OU TOI=S SOFI/AN DIW/KOUSIN; @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 120.$10 DOKEI= DE\ AU)TOI=S KAI\ <20GONE/AS SEBH/SESQAI>20&10 &10[1scil.$10 TOU\S SPOUDAI/OUS]1 KAI\ A)DELFOU\S E)N DEUTE/RA| MOI/RA| META\ TOU\S QEOU/S. FASI\ DE\ KAI\ <20TH\N PRO\S TA\ TE/KNA FILOSTORGI/AN FUSIKH\N EI)=NAI>20 AU)TOI=S KAI\ E)N FAU/LOIS MH\ EI)=NAI. @&10Origenes contra Celsum IV 16 Vol. I p. 285, 23 Ko+. [1p. 511 &10Delarue]1.$10 *EI)SI\ GA\R DIA/FOROI OI(ONEI\ TOU= LO/GOU MORFAI/, KAQW\S E(KA/STW| TW=N EI)S E)PISTH/MHN A)GOME/NWN FAI/NETAI O( LO/GOS, A)NA/LOGON TH=| E(/CEI TOU= EI)SAGOME/NOU, H)\ E)P' O)LI/GON PROKO/PTONTOS H)\ E)PI\ PLEI=ON H)\ KAI\ E)GGU\S H)/DH GINOME/NOU TH=S A)RETH=S H)\ KAI\ E)N A)RETH=| GEGENHME/NOU. @&Quintilianus instit. orat. I 1, 15_16.&3 Quidam litteris insti-&3tuendos qui minores septem annis essent non putaverunt, quod illa pri-&3mum aetas et intellectum disciplinarum capere et laborem pati posset. &3__melius autem qui nullum tempus vacare cura volunt, ut <21Chry-&3sippus>21. nam is, quamvis nutricibus triennium dederit, tamen ab illis &3quoque iam formandam quam optimis institutis mentem infantium iudicat. @1 @&Quintilianus instit. orat. I 1, 4.&3 Ante omnia ne sit vitiosus &3sermo nutricibus, quas, si fieri posset, sapientes <21Chrysippus>21 optavit, &3certe quantum res pateretur optimas eligi voluit. et morum quidem in &3his haud dubie prior ratio est%10 recte tamen etiam loquantur. has pri-&3mum audiet puer, harum verba effingere imitando conabitur& etc. &@Quintilianus instit. orat. I 10, 32.&3 nam et Pythagoran acce-&3pimus concitatos ad vim pudicae domui adferendam iuvenes iussa mu-&3tare in spondium modos tibicina composuisse, et <21Chrysippus>21 etiam &3nutricum illi quae adhibetur infantibus allectationi suum quoddam &3carmen adsignat. @&Quintilianus instit. orat. I 3, 14.&3 Caedi vero discentis, quam-&3libet receptum sit et <21Chrysippus>21 non improbet, minime velim. @&Quintilianus instit. orat. I 11, 17.&3 cum praesertim haec chi-&3ronomia, quae est, ut nomine ipso declaratur, lex gestus, et ab illis tem-&3poribus heroicis orta sit et a summis Graeciae viris atque ipso etiam &3Socrate probata, a Platone quoque in parte civilium posita virtutum, et &3a <21Chrysippo>21 in praeceptis de liberorum educatione compositis non &3omissa. @&Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 129.$ EU)XRHSTEI=N DE\ KAI\ TA\ E)GKU/KLIA MA-QH/MATA FHSI\N O( <20*XRU/SIPPOS.>20 @&Philo de sacrif. Abel et Cain %14 78 Vol. I p. 234, 7 Wendl.$10 W)FE/-LIMON ME\N OU)=N, EI) KAI\ MH\ PRO\S A)RETH=S KTH=SIN TELEI/AS, A)LLA/ TOI PRO\S POLI-TEI/AN, KAI\ TO\ PALAIAI=S KAI\ W)GUGI/OIS E)NTRE/FESQAI DO/CAIS, KAI\ A)RXAI/AN A)KOH\N E)/RGWN KALW=N METADIW/KEIN, A(/PER I(STORIKOI\ KAI\ PA=N TO\ POIHTIKO\N GE/NOS TOI=S TE KAQ' E(AUTOU\S KAI\ TOI=S E)/PEITA MNH/MH| PARADEDW/KASI. @&10Quintilianus instit. orat. I 10, 15. et eius sectae quae aliis &10severissima, aliis asperrima videtur, principes in hac fuere sententia, ut &10existimarent sapientium aliquos nonnullam operam his studiis accommo-&10daturos. @&10Origenes contra celsum III 25 Vol. I p. 221, 3 Ko+. [1p. 461 &10Delarue]1.$10 EI)/PER ME/SON E)STI\N H( <20TW=N SWMA/TWN I)ATRIKH\>20 KAI\ PRA=GMA PI=PTON OU)K EI)S A)STEI/OUS MO/NON A)LLA\ KAI\ FAU/LOUS, ME/SON DE\ KAI\ H( <20PERI\ TW=N MEL-LO/NTWN PRO/GNWSIS>20: OU) GA\R PA/NTWS E)MFAI/NEI TO\ A)STEI=ON O( PROGIGNW/SKWN. @&10Origenes contra Celsum IV 96 Vol. I p. 368, 23 Ko+. [1p. 574 &10Del.$10]1. *XRH\ D' EI)DE/NAI O(/TI <20TO\ TA\ ME/LLONTA PROGIGNW/SKEIN OU) PA/NTWS QEI=O/N E)STI>20: KAQ' AU(TO\ GA\R ME/SON E)STI\ KAI\ PI=PTON EI)S FAU/LOUS KAI\ A)STEI/OUS: KAI\ I)ATROI\ GOU=N A)PO\ I)ATRIKH=S PROGIGNW/SKOUSI/ TINA, KA)\N FAU=LOI TO\ H)=QOS TUGXA/NWSIN, OU(/TW DE\ KAI\ KUBERNH=TAI, KA)\N MOXQHROI\ TUGXA/NWSIN O)/NTES, PRO-GIGNW/SKOUSIN E)PISHMASI/AS KAI\ A)NE/MWN SFODRO/THTAS KAI\ TROPA\S PERI\ TO\ PERI-E/XON E)/K TINOS PEI/RAS KAI\ THRH/SEWS KAI\ OU) DH/POU PARA\ TOU=TO QEI/OUS TIS A)\N AU)TOU\S EI)=NAI FH/SEIE, A)\N TU/XWSI MOXQHROI\ EI)=NAI TO\ H)=QOS. @1 @&10Origenes contra Celsum IV 45 p. 538 Delarue.$10 *TH\N TW=N A)GA-QW=N KAI\ KAKW=N KAI\ A)DIAFO/RWN E)ZH/THSAN KAI\ *(/ELLHNES FU/SIN: KAI\ OI( E)PITUG-XA/NONTE/S GE AU)TW=N TA\ ME\N A)GAQA\ KAI\ KAKA\ TI/QENTAI E)N PROAIRE/SEI MO/NH|, PA/NTA DE\ A)DIA/FORA TW=| I)DI/W| LO/GW| FASI\N EI)=NAI TA\ XWRI\S PROAIRE/SEWS E)CETA-ZO/MENA: TH\N DE\ PROAI/RESIN TOU/TOIS XRWME/NHN DEO/NTWS ME\N E)PAINETH\N EI)=NAI, OU) DEO/NTWS DE\ YEKTH/N. EI)=PON OU)=N E)N TW=| PERI\ A)DIAFO/RWN TO/PW|, <20O(/TI TW=| I)DI/W| LO/GW| QUGATRA/SI MI/GNUSQAI A)DIA/FORO/N E)STIN, EI) KAI\ MH\ XRH\ E)N TAI=S KAQESTW/SAIS POLITEI/AIS TO\ TOIOU=TON POIEI=N. *KAI\ U(PO-QE/SEWS XA/RIN, PRO\S PARA/STASIN TOU= A)DIA/FORON EI)=NAI TO\ TOIOU=TON, PAREILH/FASI TO\N SOFO\N META\ TH=S QUGATRO\S MO/NHS KATALELEIMME/-NON, PANTO\S TOU= TW=N A)NQRW/PWN GE/NOUS DIEFQARME/NOU: KAI\ ZH-TOU=SIN, EI) KAQHKO/NTWS O( PATH\R SUNELEU/SETAI TH=| QUGATRI\ U(PE\R TOU= MH\ A)POLE/SQAI KAT' AU)TH\N TH\N U(PO/QESIN TO\ PA=N TW=N A)NQRW/PWN GE/NOS>20. *)=AR' OU)=N PARA\ ME\N *(/ELLHSIN U(GIW=S TAU=TA LE/GETAI KAI\ OU)K EU)KATA-FRO/NHTOS AU)TOI=S AI(/RESIS H( <20TW=N *STWI+KW=N>20 SUNAGOREU/EI&10 etc. @&Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 188.$ <20E)N DE\ TW=| PERI\ POLITEI/AS KAI\ MH-TRA/SI LE/GEI SUNE/RXESQAI KAI\ QUGATRA/SI KAI\ UI(OI=S>20: TA\ D' AU)TA/ FHSI KAI\ E)N TW=| <20PERI\ TW=N MH\ DI' AU(TA\ AI(RETW=N>20 EU)QU\S E)N A)RXH=|. @&Sextus Emp. adv. math. XI 192.$8 O( <20DE\ *XRU/SIPPOS E)N TH=| POLITEI/A|>20 KATA\ LE/CIN FHSI\N OU(/TWS "1<20DOKEI= MOI KAI\ TAU=TA OU(/TWS E)CAGAGEI=N KAQA/PER KAI\ NU=N OU) KAKW=S PARA\ POLLOI=S EI)/QISTAI, W(/STE %2 KAI\ TO\N PATE/RA E)K TH=S QUGATRO\S KAI\ TO\N O(MOMH/TRION E)K TH=S O(MOMHTRI/AS>20."2 @&Pyrrh. Hyp. III 246.$8 TOU/TOIS DE\ [1&Zenonis similibus placitis]1$8 O(MO-GNWMONEI= KAI\ O( *XRU/SIPPOS: E)N GOU=N TH=| POLITEI/A| FHSI\ "1<20DOKEI= DE/ MOI TAU=TA OU(/TW DIECA/GEIN KAQA/PER KAI\ NU=N OU) KAKW=S PARA\ POL-LOI=S EI)/QISTAI, W(/STE KAI\ TH\N MHTE/RA E)K TOU= UI(OU= TEKNOPOIEI=SQAI KAI\ TO\N PATE/RA E)K TH=S QUGATRO\S KAI\ TO\N O(MOMH/TRION E)K TH=S O(MOMHTRI/AS>20."2 @&Eundem librum fortasse Sextus respicit P. H. III 200.$8 KAI\ TI/ QAU-MASTO/N, O(/POU GE KAI\ OI( A)PO\ TH=S KUNIKH=S FILOSOFI/AS KAI\ OI( PERI\ TO\N *KITIE/A *ZH/NWNA KAI\ *KLEA/NQHN KAI\ *XRU/SIPPON A)DIA/FORON TOU=TO EI)=NAI FASI/N. @&Epiphan. adv. haeres. III 39 [1DDG 593, 1]1.$ <20*XRU/SIPPOS O( *SOLEU\S>20 NO/MOUS E)/GRAYEN OU) QEMITOU/S. <20E)/LEGE GA\R DEI=N MI/GNUSQAI TAI=S MHTRA/SI TOU\S PAI=DAS, TOI=S DE\ PATRA/SI TA\S QUGATE/RAS>20. EI)S DE\ TA\ A)/LLA SUNEFW/NHSE *ZH/NWNI TW=| *KITTIEI=: PRO\S TOU/TOIS DE\ E)/LEGE @1 <20KAI\ A)NQRWPOBOREI=N>20: E)/LEGE DE\ TO\ TE/LOS TW=N PA/NTWN TO\ H(DUPAQE\S EI)=NAI. @&Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 188.$ <20E)N DE\ TW=| TRI/TW| PERI\ *DIKAI/OU>20 KATA\ TOU\S XILI/OUS STI/XOUS KAI\ TOU\S A)POQANO/NTAS KATESQI/EIN KELEU/WN. @&Sextus Emp. adv. math. XI 192.$ DEI=GMA DE\ TH=S PRO\S TOU\S KATOIXOME/NOUS AU)TW=N O(SIO/THTOS GE/NOIT' A)\N KAI\ TA\ PERI\ TH=S A)NQRWPO-FAGI/AS PARAGGELLO/MENA: <20OU) GA\R MO/NON A)CIOU=SI TOU\S TETELEUTH-KO/TAS E)SQI/EIN, A)LLA\ KAI\ TA\S AU(TW=N SA/RKAS, EI)/ POTE TU/XOI TI ME/ROS TOU= SW/MATOS A)POKOPE/N>20. *LE/GETAI D' <20E)N TW=| PERI\ *DIKAIO-SU/NHS U(PO\ *XRUSI/PPOU>20 TAUTI/ @"1<20KAI\ A)\N TW=N MELW=N A)POKOPH=| TI ME/ROS PRO\S TH\N TROFH\N XRH/SIMON, MH/TE KATORU/TTEIN AU)TO\ MH/TE A)/LLWS R(I/PTEIN, A)NA-LI/SKEIN DE\ AU)TO/, O(/PWS TW=N H(METE/RWN E(/TERON ME/ROS GE/NHTAI."2 @&10Plutarchus de esu carnium II 3 p. 997 e.$10 SKO/PEI D' H(MA=S PO/TE-ROI BE/LTION E)CHMEROU=SI TW=N FILOSO/FWN, <20OI( KAI\ TE/KNA KAI\ FI/LOUS KAI\ PATE/RAS KAI\ GUNAI=KAS E)SQI/EIN KELEU/ONTES>20 [W(S] A)POQANO/NTAS, H)\ *PUQA-GO/RAS KAI\ *)EMPEDOKLH=S. @&10Theophilus ad Autolycum III cp. 5.$10 *)EPEIDH\ OU)=N POLLA\ A)NE/GNWS TI/ SOI E)/DOCEN TA\ *ZH/NWNOS H)\ TA\ *DIOGE/NOUS KAI\ *KLEA/NQOUS, O(PO/SA PERIE/XOUSIN AI( BI/BLOI AU)TW=N, DIDA/SKOUSAI A)NQRWPOBORI/AS, <20PATE/RAS ME\N U(PO\ I)DI/WN TE/KNWN E(/YESQAI KAI\ BIBRW/SKESQAI, KAI\ EI)/ TIS OU) BOU/LOITO H)\ ME/-LOS TI TH=S MUSERA=S TROFH=S A)POR)R(I/YEIEN, AU)TO\N KATESQI/ESQAI TO\N MH\ FAGO/NTA>20; *PRO\S TOU/TOIS A)QEWTE/RA TIS FWNH\ EU(RI/SKETAI, H( TOU= *DIO-GE/NOUS, DIDA/SKONTOS TA\ TE/KNA TOU\S E(AUTW=N GONEI=S EI)S QUSI/AN A)/GEIN KAI\ TOU/-TOUS KATESQI/EIN. @&10cp. 6 fin.$10 *PRO\S TI/ OU)=N *)EPI/KOUROS KAI\ OI( <20*STWI+KOI\>20 DOGMATI/ZOUSIN A)DELFOKOITI/AS KAI\ A)R)R(ENOBASI/AS E)PITELEI=SQAI, E)C W(=N DIDASKALIW=N MESTA\S [2TA\S]2 BIBLIOQH/KAS PEPOIH/KASIN. @&10Lactant. div. instit. VI 12. Quin etiam non defuerunt, <21qui &10supervacaneam facerent sepulturam>21, nihilque esse dicerent mali, &10iacere inhumatum atque abiectum. Quorum impiam sapientiam cum omne &10humanum genus respuit, tum divinae voces, quae id fieri iubent. Verum &10illi non audent dicere, id non esse faciendum; sed <21si forte non fiat, &10nihil esse incommodi>21. Itaque in ea re non tam praecipientium quam &10consolantium funguntur officio, ut si forte id sapienti eveniat, ne se ob &10hoc miserum putet. @&Sextus Emp. adv. math. XI 194.$ <20E)N DE\ TW=| PERI\ TOU= *KAQH/-KONTOS>20 [1&<21Chrysippus>21]1$ PERI\ TH=S TW=N GONE/WN TAFH=S DIECERXO/MENOS R(HTW=S FHSI/N @"1$8<20*)APOGENOME/NWN DE\ TW=N GONE/WN TAFAI=S XRHSTE/ON TAI=S @1 A(PLOUSTA/TAIS, W(S A)\N TOU= SW/MATOS KAQA/PER O)/NUXOS H)\ TRIXW=N OU)DE\N O)/NTOS PRO\S H(MA=S, OU)D' E)PISTROFH=S KAI\ POLUWRI/AS PROS-DEOME/NWN H(MW=N TOIAU/THS TINO/S. DIO\ KAI\ XRHSI/MWN ME\N O)/NTWN TW=N KREW=N TROFH=| XRH/SONTAI AU)TOI=S, KAQA/PER KAI\ TW=N I)DI/WN MERW=N OI(=ON PODO\S A)POKOPE/NTOS E)PE/BALLE XRH=SQAI AU)TW=|, KAI\ TOI=S PARAPLHSI/OIS. A)XREI/WN DE\ O)/NTWN AU)TW=N H)\ KATORU/CANTES TO\ MNH=MA E)POI/SOUSIN, H)\ KATAKAU/SANTES TH\N TE/FRAN A)FH/SOUSIN, H)\ MAKRO/TERON R(I/YANTES OU)DEMI/AN E)PISTROFH\N AU)TW=N POIH/SON-TAI KAQA/PER O)/NUXOS H)\ TRIXW=N>20."2 @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 22 p. 1044f.$ *KAI\ MH\N <20E)N TW=|[1%1]1 TW=N *PROTREPTIKW=N>20 EI)PW\N O(/TI KAI\ TO\ MHTRA/SIN H)\ A)DELFAI=S H)\ QUGATRA/SIN SUGGENE/SQAI KAI\ TO\ FAGEI=N TI KAI\ PROELQEI=N A)PO\ LEXOU=S H)\ QANA/TOU PRO\S I(ERO\N A)LO/GWS DIABE/BLHTAI. KAI\ PRO\S TA\ QHRI/A FHSI\ DEI=N A)POBLE/PEIN, KAI\ TOI=S U(P' E)KEI/NWN GINOME/NOIS TEKMAI/RESQAI TO\ MHDE\N A)/TOPON MHDE\ PARA\ FU/SIN EI)=NAI TW=N TOIOU/TWN: EU)KAI/RWS GA\R PRO\S TAU=TA GI/NESQAI TA\S TW=N A)/LLWN ZW/|WN PARAQE/SEIS, EI)S TO\ MH/TE SUGGINO/MENA MH/TE GENNW=NTA MH/T' E)NAPOQNH/SKONTA E)N TOI=S I(EROI=S MIAI/-NEIN TO\ QEI=ON."2 @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 22 p. 1045a.$ <20*)EN DE\ TW=| PE/MPTW| PA/LIN PERI\ *FU/SEWS>20 LE/GEI "1KALW=S ME\N A)PAGOREU/EIN TO\N *(HSI/ODON, EI)S POTAMOU\S KAI\ KRH/NAS OU)REI=N: E)/TI DE\ MA=LLON A)FEKTE/ON EI)=NAI TOU= PRO\S BWMO\N OU)REI=N H)\ A)FI/DRUMA QEOU=: MH\ GA\R EI)=NAI PRO\S LO/GON, EI) KU/NES KAI\ O)/NOI TOU=TO POIOU=SI KAI\ PAIDA/RIA NH/PIA, MHDEMI/AN E)PISTROFH\N MHD' E)PILOGISMO\N E)/XONTA PERI\ TW=N TOIOU/TWN."2 @&10Sextus Pyrrh. Hypot. III 201.$10 KAI\ <20TOU\S *STWI+KOU\S>20 DE\ O(RW=MEN OU)K A)/TOPON EI)=NAI LE/GONTAS TO\ E(TAI/RA| SUNOIKEI=N H)\ TO\ E)C E(TAI/RAS E)RGASI/AS DIAZH=N. @&10Origenes contra Celsum IV 26 Vol. I p. 295, 29 Ko+. [1p. 520 &10Delarue]1.$10 KAI\ OI( TAI=S XAMAITU/PAIS A)DIAFO/RWS PROSIO/NTES, DIDA/SKONTES DE\ KAI\ <20MH\ PA/NTWS PARA\ TO\ KAQH=KON TOU=TO GI/NESQAI>20. @&10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 130.$10 <20EU)LO/GWS TE/ FASIN E)CA/CEIN E(AUTO\N TOU= BI/OU TO\N SOFO/N>20, KAI\ U(PE\R PATRI/DOS KAI\ U(PE\R FI/LWN, KA)\N E)N SKLHRO-TE/RA| GE/NHTAI A)LGHDO/NI H)\ PHRW/SESIN H)\ NO/SOIS A)NIA/TOIS. @&10Stobaeus ecl. II 110, 9 W.$10 *FASI\ DE/ POTE KAI\ <20TH\N E)CAGWGH\N>20 @1 TH\N E)K TOU= BI/OU <20TOI=S SPOUDAI/OIS KAQHKO/NTWS [2GI/GNESQAI>20]2 KATA\ POL-LOU\S TRO/POUS, TOI=S [2DE\]2 FAU/LOIS MONH\N [2TH\N]2 E)N TW=| ZH=N KAI\ EI) MH\ ME/LLOIEN E)/SESQAI SOFOI/: OU)/TE GA\R TH\N A)RETH\N KATE/XEIN E)N TW=| ZH=N OU)/TE TH\N KAKI/AN E)KBA/LLEIN: TOI=S DE\ KAQH/KOUSI KAI\ TOI=S PARA\ TO\ KAQH=KON [2PARA]2METREI=SQAI TH/N TE ZWH\N KAI\ TO\N QA/NATON. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 18 p. 1042d.$ *)ALL' OU)D' O(/LWS, FASI/N, OI)/ETAI DEI=N <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 OU)/TE MONH\N E)N TW=| BI/W| TOI=S A)GA-QOI=S, OU)/T' E)CAGWGH\N TOI=S KAKOI=S PARAMETREI=N, A)LLA\ TOI=S ME/SOIS KATA\ FU/SIN. *DIO\ KAI\ TOI=S EU)DAIMONOU=SI GI/NETAI/ POTE KAQH=KON E)CA/GEIN E(AUTOU/S, KAI\ ME/NEIN AU)=QIS E)N TW=| ZH=N TOI=S KAKODAIMONOU=SIN. @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 11 p. 1063d.$ *TAU=TA TOI/NUN E)N TH=| *STOA=| NOMOQETEI=TAI, KAI\ POLLOU\S ME\N E)CA/GOUSI TW=N SOFW=N, W(S A)/MEINON EU)DAIMONOU=NTAS PEPAU=SQAI: POLLOU\S DE\ KATE/XOUSI TW=N FAU/LWN, W(S KAQH/KONTOS AU)TOI=S ZH=N KAKODAIMONOU=NTAS. *KAI/TOI O( ME\N SOFO\S O)/LBIOS, MAKA/RIOS, PANEUDAI/MWN, A)SFALH/S, A)KI/NDUNOS, O( DE\ FAU=LOS KAI\ A)NO/H-TOS OI(=OS EI)PEI=N: @*GE/MW KAKW=N DH\ KOU)KE/T' E)/SQ' O(/POU TEQH=|. [1&Eur. Herc. 1245]1$ A)LLA\ KAI\ TOU/TOIS MONH\N OI)/ONTAI KAQH/KOUSAN EI)=NAI, KA)KEI/NOIS E)CAGWGH/N. *EI)KO/TWS DE/, FHSI\ *XRU/SIPPOS: OU) GA\R A)GAQOI=S KAI\ KAKOI=S DEI= PARA-METREI=SQAI TO\N BI/ON, A)LLA\ TOI=S KATA\ FU/SIN KAI\ PARA\ FU/SIN. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 18 p. 1042a.$ <20E)N DE\ TW=| TRI/TW| PERI\ *FU/SEWS>20 U(PEIPW\N O(/TI "1<20LUSITELEI= ZH=N A)/FRONA MA=L-LON H)\ [2MH\]2 BIOU=N, KA)\N MHDE/POTE ME/LLH| FRONH/SEIN>20"2 E)PILE/GEI @"1$8<20*TOIAU=TA GA\R TA)GAQA/ E)STI TOI=S A)NQRW/POIS, W(/STE TRO/PON TINA\ TA\ KAKA\ TW=N A)NA\ ME/SON PROTEREI=N>20."2 @&p. 1042b.$ TW=N D' A)NA\ ME/SON LEGOME/NWN PAR' AU)TOI=S MH/TE KAKW=N O)/NTWN MH/T' A)GAQW=N. @&p. 1042c.$ *BOULO/MENOS OU)=N TAU/THN E)PILEAI/NEIN TH\N A)TOPI/AN, E)PI-LE/GEI PERI\ TW=N KAKW=N: @"1$8<20*)/ESTI D' OU) TAU=TA PROTEROU=NTA, A)LL' O( LO/GOS, MEQ' OU(= BIOU=N E)PIBA/LLEI MA=LLON, KAI\ EI) A)/FRONES E)SO/MEQA>20."2$ @*PRW=TON ME\N OU)=N TA\ KAKA\ KAKI/AN LE/GEI KAI\ TA\ METE/XONTA KAKI/AS, A)/LLO D' OU)DE/N: H( DE\ KAKI/A LOGIKO/N E)STI, MA=LLON DE\ LO/GOS H(MARTHME/NOS& etc. &@Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 14 p. 1039d.$ <20*)EN GOU=N TOI=S PERI\ TOU= *PROTRE/PESQAI>20, TOU= *PLA/TWNOS E)PILAMBANO/MENOS LE/GONTOS, O(/TI TW=| MHDE\ MAQO/NTI MHD' E)PISTAME/NW| ZH=N, LUSITELEI= MH\ ZH=N, TAU=T' EI)/RHKE KATA\ LE/CIN: @1 @"1<20*(O GA\R TOIOU=TOS LO/GOS KAI\ E(AUTW=| MA/XETAI KAI\ H(/KISTA/ E)STI PROTREPTIKO/S. *PRW=TON GA\R PARADEIKNU/WN, O(/TI KRA/TISTON H(MI=N E)STI TO\ MH\ ZH=N KAI\ TRO/PON TINA\ A)POQNH/SKEIN A)CIW=N, PRO\S E(/TERA/ TINA MA=LLON H(MA=S PROU)/TREYEN H)\ TO\ FILOSOFEI=N: OU) GA\R E)/STI MH\ ZW=NTA FILOSOFEI=N: OU)DE\ MH\ POLU\N XRO/NON E)PIZH/SANTA KAKW=S KAI\ A)PEI/RWS FRO/NIMON GENE/SQAI."2 KAI\ PROELQW\N DE/ FHSIN O(/TI "1KAI\ TOI=S FAU/LOIS KAQH/KEI ME/NEIN E)N TW=| ZH=N."2 EI)=TA KATA\ LE/CIN: "1*PRW=TON GA\R H( A)RETH\ YILW=S OU)DE/N E)STI PRO\S TO\ ZH=N H(MA=S, OU(/TW D' OU)D' H( KAKI/A OU)DE/N E)STI PRO\S TO\ DEI=N H(MA=S A)PIE/NAI>20."2 @&Plutarchus de comm. not. cp. 11 p. 1064a.$ <20*KAI\ GA\R *(HRA-KLEI/TW|, FASI/, KAI\ *FEREKU/DH| KAQH/KEIN A)/N, EI)/PER H)DU/NANTO, TH\N A)RETH\N A)FEI=NAI KAI\ TH\N FRO/NHSIN, W(/STE PAU/SASQAI FQEI-RIW=NTAS KAI\ U(DRWPIW=NTAS: KAI\ TH=S *KI/RKHS E)GXEOU/SHS DU/O FA/RMAKA, TO\ ME\N POIOU=N A)/FRONAS E)K FRONI/MWN, TO\ DE\ [FRO-NI/MOUS] O)/NOUS E)C [A)FRO/NWN] A)NQRW/PWN, TO/TE DH\ TO\N *)ODUSSE/A PIEI=N TO\ TH=S A)FROSU/NHS MA=LLON, H)\ METABALEI=N EI)S QHRI/OU MORFH\N TO\ EI)=DOS, E)/XONTA TH\N FRO/NHSIN>20 [1KAI\ META\ TH=S FRONH/SEWS DHLONO/TI TH\N EU)DAIMONI/AN]1. <20*KAI\ TAU=TA/ FASIN AU)TH\N U(FHGEI=SQAI KAI\ PARAKELEU/ESQAI TH\N FRO/NHSIN: "1*)/AFES ME KAI\ KATAFRO/-NHSON A)POLLUME/NHS E)MOU= KAI\ DIAFQEIROME/NHS EI)S O)/NOU PRO/-SWPON>20."2 @&10Cicero de finibus III 18, 60. Sed cum ab his [1scil. a princi-&10piis naturalibus]1 omnia proficiscantur officia, non sine causa dicitur, ad &10ea referri omnes nostras cogitationes, in his et <21excessum e vita>21 et in &10vita mansionem. In quo enim plura sunt, quae secundum naturam sunt, &10huius officium est, in vita manere; in quo autem sunt plura contraria &10aut fore videntur, huius officium est, e vita excedere. E quo apparet, &10et <21sapientis esse aliquando officium, excedere e vita>21, cum beatus &10sit, et stulti manere in vita, cum sit miser. 61. Nam bonum illud et &10malum__postea consequitur; prima autem illa naturae, sive secunda &10sive contraria, sub iudicium sapientis et dilectum cadunt, estque illa sub-&10iecta quasi materia sapientiae. Itaque et manendi in vita et migrandi &10ratio omnis iis rebus, quas supra dixi, metienda. Nam neque [2virtutem &10qui habet]2 virtute retinetur in vita, nec iis qui sine virtute sunt, mors @1 &10est oppetenda. Et saepe officium est sapientis desciscere a vita, cum sit &10beatissimus, si id opportune facere possit. Sic enim censent, <21opportuni-&10tatis esse beate vivere>21, quod est convenienter naturae vivere. Itaque &10a sapientia praecipitur, se ipsam, si usus sit, sapiens ut relinquat. Quam &10ob rem cum vitiorum ista vis non sit, ut causam afferant mortis volun-&10tariae, perspicuum est etiam stultorum, qui iidem miseri sint, officium esse &10manere in vita, si sint in maiore parte rerum earum, quas secundum na-&10turam esse dicimus. Et quoniam excedens e vita et manens aeque miser &10est, nec diuturnitas magis ei vitam fugiendam facit, non sine causa dicitur &10iis, qui pluribus naturalibus frui possint, esse in vita manendum. &10@Alexander Aphrod. de anima libri mant. p. 168, 1 Bruns.$10 KA-QO/LOU DE/, EI) H( A)RETH\ AU)TA/RKHS PRO\S TO\ PARASXE/SQAI TO\N BI/ON H(MW=N A)/KRWS EU)DAI/MONA KAI\ MAKA/RION, <20PW=S EU)/LOGOS E)CAGWGH\ TW=| TH\N A)RETH\N E)/XONTI, E)N MAKARI/W| BI/W| O)/NTI>20; W(S GA\R A)/TOPON TO\ LE/GEIN TO\N *DI/A E)QE/LEIN A)PO-QANEI=N, OU(/TWS A)/TOPON KAI\ TO\N E)PI/SHS TOU/TW| MAKARI/WS ZW=NTA E(AUTO\N E)CA/GEIN EU)LO/GWS TOU=DE TOU= BI/OU, TW=N ME\N SWMATIKW=N KAI\ E)KTO\S A)DIAFO/RWN O)/NTWN KAI\ MH/TE POIOU/NTWN TH\N EU)DAIMONI/AN MH/TE A)NAIROU/NTWN, TH=S DE\ A)RETH=S, H(\ MO/NH KAI\ KATASKEUA/ZEI TO\N MAKA/RION BI/ON KAI\ FULA/TTEI BE/BAION PAROU=SA, MHDE/POT' A)\N A)POLEIPOU/SHS TO\N SOFO/N. __<20PW=S GA\R EU)/LOGON TH\N A)RE-TH\N TOU=Q' U(POBA/LLEIN TW=| SOFW=|>20; @&10Clemens Al. Strom. IV 6 p. 576 Pott.$10 AU)TI/KA <20EU)/LOGON E)CA-GWGH\N TW=| SPOUDAI/W| SUGXWROU=SI>20 KAI\ OI( FILO/SOFOI, EI)/ TI TOU= PRA/SSEIN [AU)TO\N] OU(/TW STERH/SEIEN AU)TO/N, W(S MHKE/TI A)POLELEI=FQAI AU)TW=| MHDE\ E)LPI/DA TH=S PRA/CEWS. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de anima libri mant. p. 160, 24 Bruns.$10 EI) PERI\ TH\N TW=N KATA\ FU/SIN KAI\ OI)KEI/WN E)KLOGH\N H( E)NE/RGEIA TH=S A)RETH=S KAI\ PERI\ TH\N A)POIKONOMI/AN KAI\ E)/KKLISIN TW=N TOU/TOIS E)NANTI/WN, DEI= DHLONO/TI PAR-EI=NAI A(\ E)KLE/CETAI. OU) GA\R DH\ A)EI\ TW=| A)NQRW/PW| TAU=TA PA/RESTI: <20DIA\ GOU=N TH\N TOU/TWN E)/NDEIAN O( TH\N A)RETH\N E)/XWN E(AUTO\N E)CA/GEI POTE/>20. OU)DE\ GA\R DIA\ TO\ A)DUNATEI=N E)KLE/GESQAI TAU=TA H( E)CAGWGH/, O(/PER E)/RGON TH=S A)RETH=S, A)LLA\ TW=| MH\ PAREI=NAI A(\ OU)K E)P' AU)TH=|. @&10Alexander Aphrod. de anima libri mant. p. 159, 19 Bruns.$10 O( DE\ TH\N A)RETH\N E)/XWN KATALEI/POI A)/N POTE TO\N BI/ON TO\N META\ A)RETH=S E(KW\N <20DIA\ TH\N E)CAGWGH\N TH\N EU)/LOGON>20. @&10Excerpta philos. Cod. Coislin. 387 Cramer Anecd. Paris Vol. IV &10`403.$10 A)LLA\ KAI\ OI( <20*STWI+KOI\>20 FILO/SOFOI_TH\N FILOSOFI/AN U(PE/LABON ME-LE/THN EI)=NAI TOU= FUSIKOU= QANA/TOU: DIO\ KAI\ <20PE/NTE TRO/POUS EU)LO/GOU E)CA-GWGH=S>20 E)/GRAYAN: E)/OIKE GA/R, FHSIN, O( BI/OS MAKRW=| SUMPOSI/W|, E)N W(=| DOKEI= EU)WXEI=SQAI H( YUXH/: KAI\ PAR' O(/SOUS TRO/POUS LU/ETAI TO\ SUMPO/SION, PARA\ TOSOU/TOUS TRO/POUS GI/NONTAI KAI\ EU)/LOGOI E)CAGWGAI/. *LU/ETAI DE\ TO\ SUMPO/SION KATA\ PE/NTE TRO/POUS: H)\ <20DIA\ XREI/AN MEGA/LHN A)/FNW KATALABOU=SAN>20, OI(=ON PAROUSI/AN FI/LOU DIA\ XRO/NOU: U(PO\ XARA=S GA\R A)NI/STANTAI OI( FI/LOI KAI\ LU/ETAI TO\ SUMPO/SION. H)\ <20DIA\ TOU\S E)PEISKWMA/ZONTAS>20 KAI\ AI)SXROR)R(HMONOU=NTAS LU/ETAI O(MOI/WS TO\ SUMPO/SION: H)\ <20DIA\ TO\ NEKRA\ KAI\ NOSW/DH EI)=NAI TA\ @1 PARATIQE/MENA: H)\ DIA\ SPA/NIN>20 E)DESMA/TWN: H)\ <20DIA\ ME/QHN>20 LU/ETAI TO\ SUM-PO/SION. @*KATA\ TOU\S AU)TOU\S OU)=N PE/NTE TRO/POUS GI/NONTAI KAI\ EU)/LOGOI E)CAGWGAI/: <20H)\ DIA\ XREI/AN MEGA/LHN KATALABOU=SAN>20 W(S PROSE/TACEN H( *PUQI/A TINI\ A)POSFA/CAI E(AUTO\N U(PE\R TH=S I)DI/AS PO/LEWS, FQORA=S TH=| PO/LEI E)PIKEIME/NHS_ _<20H)\ DIA\ TOU\S E)PEISKWMA/ZONTAS TURA/NNOUS>20 KAI\ A)NAGKA/ZONTAS H(MA=S H)\ PRA/TTEIN AI)SXRA\ H)\ LE/GEIN TA\ A)PO/R)R(HTA&10 [1sequitur narratiuncula de muliere &10Pythagorea]1$10 <20H)\ DIA\ MAKRA\N NO/SON>20 KWLU/OUSAN E)PI\ POLU\ O)RGA/NW| XRH=SQAI TH\N YUXH\N TW=| SW/MATI, EU)LO/GWS DEI= E)CA/GEIN AU)TH/N: DIO\ KAI\ *PLA/TWN OU)K A)PODE/XETAI TO\ DIAITHTIKO\N TH=S I)ATRIKH=S W(S PAIDAGWGOU=N TA\ NOSH/MATA KAI\ POIOU=N E)GXRONI/ZEIN, A)LL' A)PODE/XETAI TO\ XEIROURGIKO\N KAI\ FARMAKEUTIKO/N, W(=| E)XRH=TO *)ARXIGE/NHS, O( STRATO/PEDON QERAPEU/WN: FHSI\ DE\ KAI\ *SOFOKLH=S @OU) PRO\S I)ATROU= SOFOU= @QRHNEI=N E)PW|DA\S PRO\S STOMW=NTI TRAU/MATI [1&10Ai 582$10]1 H)\ <20DIA\ PENI/AN>20: KAI\ KALW=S FHSIN O( *QE/OGNIS: @XRH\ PENI/HN FEU/GONTA &10etc.$10 H)\ DIA\ LH=RON>20: W(/SPER GA\R E)KEI= H( ME/QH E)/LUE TO\ SUMPO/SION, OU(/TWS KA)NTAU=QA E)/STI TINA\ E)CAGAGEI=N E(AUTO\N DIA\ LH=RON: OU)DE\N GA/R E)STI LH=ROS, EI) MH\ FUSIKH\ ME/QH: KAI\ OU)DE/N E)STI ME/QH, EI) MH\ PROAIRETIKO\S LH=ROS: KAI\ TAU=TA ME\N PERI\ TOU/TOU. @1 @&Scholia in Homeri Iliadem A 129.$ *ZW/I+LOS DE\ O( *)AMFIPOLI/-THS KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 O( *STWI+KO\S SOLOIKI/ZEIN OI)/ONTAI TO\N POIHTH\N A)NTI\ E(NIKOU= PLHQUNTIKW=| XRHSA/MENON R(H/MATI: TO\ GA\R DW=SI FASI\ PLHQUNTI-KO/N: A)GNOOU=SI DE\ &etc. @&10Scholia in Homeri. Iliad.$10 *A&10 405.$10 O(/S R(A PARA\ *KRONI/WNI: O(/TI E)N-TEU=QEN E)PI\ TOU= *)/AREWS LE/GETAI OU)K O)RQW=S&10 [1`1. Il. E&10 906]1$10 *(/OMHROS DE/, W(S *STWI+KO/S, *POSEIDW=NOS AU)TO\N EI)=NAI/ FHSI. @&Scholia in Hom. Iliad.$10 *Q& 441.$ A)MBWMOI=SI: <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 U(F' E(\N PROFE/RETAI, O( ME/NTOI *)ARI/STARXOS DU/O ME/RH LO/GOU &etc. &@Etymol. Magn. s. v.$ A)MBWMOI=SIN: A)NTI\ TOU= PERI\ TOI=S BWMOI=S. <20*XRU/-SIPPOS>20 U(F' E(\N PROFE/REI, O( ME/NTOI *)ARI/STARXOS DU/O ME/RH LO/GOU. @&Scholia ad Hom. Iliad.$ *K& 252.$ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 DE\ W(/SPER EI)/ TIS, FHSI/, PERI\ TRIW=N H(MERW=N DIALEGO/MENOS E)N TH=| TRI/TH| LE/GEI MI/AN A)PO-LEI/PESQAI E)/TI H(ME/RAN, KA)\N MH\ PERI\ O)/RQRON POIH=TAI TOU\S LO/GOUS, OU(/-TWS KAI\ TO\N *)ODUSSE/A EI) KAI\ PLE/ON H)=N PARW|XHKO\S TW=N DU/O MOIRW=N TH\N TRI/THN FA/NAI KATALEI/PESQAI, E)PEIDH\ TRIMEROU=S OU)/SHS TH=S NUKTO\S E(/KASTON ME/ROS E(/N TI LAMBA/NETAI, W(/STE KA)\N E)LLIPE\S H)=| TOU=TO KAI\ MH\ O(LO/KLHRON, A)LL' A)RIQMEI=SQAI/ GE TRI/THN, TW=| TA/CIN TW=N H(MERW=N E)/XEIN TH\N TRI/THN. OU(/TW GA\R KAI\ A)/NQRWPON PARA\ PO/DA GENO/MENON E)/TI TUGXA/NEIN TH=S O(/LHS PROSHGORI/AS. @&Scholia in Hom. Iliad.$ *N. &v. 41.$ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 DE\ O( *STWI+KO\S KAI\ *DIONU/SIOS O( *QRA=|C DASU/NOUSI TO\ "1AU)I/+AXOI"2 I(/N' H)=| CHRO/FWNOI. @&Scholia in Hom. Iliad.$ *O. &v. 241.$ A)MFI\ E(\ GIGNW/SKWN: __ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 DE\ YILOU=N TO\ W(S PERISSEU=ON, KAI/ FHSIN "1A)MFIGNOW=N A)NTI\ TOU= A)NTIBA/LLWN."2 @&Scholia in Hom. Iliad. X 212.$ ME/SSA: <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 R(U=MA GRA/FEI: TH\N GA\R R(OPH\N TOU= ZUGOU= R(U/MHN KALEI=SQAI. @1 @&Scholia in Hom. Odyss.$ *E.& 240.$ PERI/KHLA: <20*)ARI/STARXOS>20 W(/SPER CHRA\ E)KDEXO/MENOS, TA\ PERIKEKAUME/NA U(PO\ H(LI/OU. <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 DE\ DIH/|REI, PERI\ KH=LA, PERISSW=S CHRA/. @&Etymol. Magn. s. v.$ E)PIKUNEI=N [1&p. 361, 13 Gaisf. $]1. KAI\ <20*XRU/-SIPPOS>20 GRA/YEI *KULLH/NIOS *(ERMH=S, E)PEIDH\ H( R(A/BDOS AU)TOU= A)NDRW=N O)/MMATA QE/LGEI__*FAI/AKES DE\ QU/OUSIN AU)TW=| E(SPE/RAS W(S *(/OMHROS "1O(/TE MNHSAI/ATO KOI/TOU"2 OU)X O(/TI O)NEIRO/POMPOS H)=N A)LL' O(/TI U(/PNOU H(DE/OS AI)/TIOS. @1 <20*PERI\ TW=N *DI' AU(TA\ *AI(RETW=N>20 *A @1 @&10Athenaeus Deipnos. VII 285d.$10 *XRU/SIPPOS D' O( FILO/SOFOS E)N TW=| PERI\ TW=N DI' AU(TA\ AI(RETW=N "1TH\N A)FU/HN, FHSI/N, [TH\N] E)N *)AQH/NAIS ME\N DIA\ TH\N DAYI/LEIAN U(PERORW=SI KAI\ PTWXIKO\N EI)=NAI/ FASIN O)/YON, E)N E(TE/RAIS DE\ PO/LESIN U(PERQAUMA/ZOUSI POLU\ XEI/RW GENOME/NHN. EI)=Q' OI( ME/N, FHSI/N, E)NTAU=QA TOU\S A)DRIATIKOU\S O)/RNIQAS TRE/FEIN SPEU/DOUSIN A)XREIOTE/ROUS O)/NTAS, O(/TI TW=N PAR' H(MI=N POLU\ E)LA/TTOUS EI)SI/N: E)KEI=NOI DE\ TA)NANTI/A METAPE/MPONTAI TOU\S E)N-QA/DE."2 {1*PERI\ TW=N MH\ *DI' AU(TA\ *AI(RETW=N}1 @&10Athenaeus Deipnosoph. IV p. 159a.$10 OI(=ON O( KALO\S <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 DIAGRA/FEI <20E)N TW=| PERI\ TW=N MH\ DI' AU(TA\ AI(RETW=N>20 LE/GWN W(=DE "1E)PI\ TOSOU=TON TINE\S E)KPI/PTOUSI PRO\S TO\ A)RGU/RION W(/STE I(STORH=SQAI PRO\S TH=| TELEUTH=| TINA\ ME\N KATAPIO/NTA OU)K O)LI/GOUS XRUSOU=S A)POQANEI=N TO\N DE\ E(/TERON R(AYA/MENON EI)/S TINA XITW=NA KAI\ E)NDU/NT' AU)TO\N E)PISKH=YAI TOI=S OI)KEI/OIS QA/YAI OU(/TWS, MH/TE KAU/SANTAS MH/TE QERAPEU/SANTAS."2 {1*PERI\ *DIKAIOSU/NHS}1 @&10Cicero de republ. III 8, 12 et reqeriret et tueretur, alter [1scil. &10Aristoteles]1 autem de ipsa iustitia quattuor implevit sane grandis libros. &10Nam ab <21Chrysippo>21 nihil magnum nec magnificum desideravi, qui suo &10quodam more loquitur, ut omnia verborum momentis, non rerum ponde-&10ribus examinet.$10 @1 {1*EI)SAGWGH\ TH=S PERI\ *)AGAQW=N KAI\ *KAKW=N PRAGMATEI/AS}1 @&10Athenaeus Deipnos. IV p. 159d.$10 <20*XRU/SIPPOS D' E)N TH=| EI)SA-GWGH=| TH=| EI)S TH\N PERI\ A)GAQW=N KAI\ KAKW=N>20 PRAGMATEI/AN NEANI/SKON FHSI/ TINA E)K TH=S *)IWNI/AS SFO/DRA PLOU/SION E)PIDHMH=SAI TAI=S *)AQH/NAIS PORFURI/DA H)MFIESME/NON E)/XOUSAN XRUSA= KRA/SPEDA. PUNQANOME/NOU DE/ TINOS AU)TOU= PODA-PO/S E)STIN A)POKRI/NASQAI O(/TI PLOU/SIOS. @&10Origenes contra Celsum IV 63 Vol. I p. 334, 15 Ko+. [1p. 552 &10Delarue]1. [1Dum refutare studet Celsi opinionem$10 TA\ KAKA\ OU)/TE PLEI/ONA OU)/TE E)LA/TTONA GI/GNESQAI]1 KAI\ A)/LLWS D' E)LE/GXETAI O( TOU= *KE/LSOU PERI\ TW=N KA-KW=N LO/GOS A)PO\ TW=N E)CETASA/NTWN FILOSO/FWN TA\ PERI\ A)GAQW=N KAI\ KAKW=N KAI\ PARASTHSA/NTWN KAI\ A)PO\ TH=S I(STORI/AS O(/TI PRW=TON ME\N E)/CW PO/LEWS KAI\ PRO-SWPEI=A PERIKEI/MENAI AI( E(TAI=RAI E)CEMI/SQOUN E(AUTA\S TOI=S BOULOME/NOIS: EI)=Q' U(/STERON KATAFRONH/SASAI A)PE/QENTO TA\ PROSWPEI=A KAI\ U(PO\ TW=N NO/MWN MH\ E)PITREPO/MENAI EI)SIE/NAI EI)S TA\S PO/LEIS, E)/CW H)=SAN AU)TW=N: PLEI/ONOS DE\ TH=S DIA-STROFH=S GINOME/NHS O(SHME/RAI, E)TO/LMHSAN KAI\ EI)S TA\S PO/LEIS EI)SELQEI=N. *TAU=TA DE\ <20*XRU/SIPPO/S>20 FHSIN <20E)N TH=| PERI\ A)GAQW=N KAI\ KAKW=N EI)SAGWGH=|>20: "1*(/OQEN W(S TW=N KAKW=N PLEIO/NWN KAI\ H(TTO/NWN GINOME/NWN, E)/STI LABEI=N O(/TI OI( KALOU/MENOI A)MFI/BOLOI H)=SA/N POTE PROESTHKO/TES, PA/SXONTES KAI\ DIATIQE/NTES KAI\ TAI=S E)PIQUMI/AIS TW=N EI)SIO/NTWN DOULEU/ONTES, U(/STERON DE\ OI( A)GORANO/MOI TOU/TOUS E)CW=SAN."2 *KAI\ PERI\ MURI/WN D' A)\N TW=N A)PO\ KEXUME/NHS TH=S KAKI/AS E)PEISELQO/NTWN TW=| BI/W| TW=N A)NQRW/PWN E)/STIN EI)PEI=N, O(/TI PRO/TERON OU)K H)=N. *AI( GOU=N A)RXAIO/TATAI I(STORI/AI, KAI/TOI GE MURI/A O(/SA KATHGOROU=SAI TW=N A(MAR-TANO/NTWN A)R)R(HTOPOIOU\S OU)K I)/SASI. @1 {1*)HQIKW=N *ZHTHMA/TWN *I}1 &10Scholia in Eur. Androm. v. 276 Vol. IV p. 152 Dind. Vol. II &10p. 274 Schw.$10 <20*XRU/SIPPOS DE\ E)N *)HQIKW=N DEKA/TW|>20 LOGISA/MENON TO\N *PA/RIN TI/NWN DEI= MA=LLON A)NTE/XESQAI, POLEMIKH=S A)SKH/SEWS H)\ E)RWTIKH=S H)\ BASILEI/AS, NEU=SAI [AU)TO\N] MA=LLON EI)S TA\ E)RWTIKA\ KAI\ OU(/TWS TO\N PERI\ TH=S KRI/SEWS MU=-QON SUNTEQH=NAI. {1*PERI\ TOU= *KALOU= KAI\ TH=S *(HDONH=S PRO\S *)ARISTOKRE/ONTA *I}1 @&10Gellius N. A. XIV 4. Condigne mepercule et condecore Chry-&10sippus in <21librorum, qui inscribuntur>21$10 <20PERI\ KALOU= KAI\ H(DONH=S>20,&10 <21primo, &10os et oculos>21 Iustititiae vultumque eius severis atque venerandis verborum @1 &10coloribus depinxit. Facit quippe imaginem Iustitiae fierique solitam esse &10dicit a pictoribus rhetoribusque antiquioribus ad hunc ferme modum%10 &10"1forma atque filo virginali, aspectu vehementi et formidabili, luminibus &10oculorum acribus, neque humilis neque atrocis, sed reverendae cuiusdam &10tristitiae dignitate."2 Ex imaginis autem istius significatione intellegi vo-&10luit, iudicem, qui Iustitiae antistes est, oportere esse gravem, sanctum, &10severum, incorruptum, inadulabilem contraque improbos nocentesque immi-&10sericordem atque inexorabilem erectumque et arduum ac potentem, vi et &10maiestate aequitatis veritatisque terrificum. Verba ipsa Chrysippi de Iu-&10stitia scripta haec sunt%10$10 @"1*PARQE/NOS DE\ EI)=NAI LE/GETAI KATA\ SU/MBOLON TOU= A)DIA/FQOROS EI)=NAI KAI\ MHDAMW=S E)NDIDO/NAI TOI=S KAKOU/RGOIS, MHDE\ PROSI/ESQAI MH/TE TOU\S E)PIEIKEI=S LO/GOUS MH/TE PARAI/THSIN KAI\ DE/HSIN MH/TE KOLAKEI/AN MH/TE A)/LLO MHDE\N TW=N TOIOU/TWN: OI(=S A)KOLOU/QWS KAI\ SKUQRWPH\ GRA/FETAI KAI\ SUNESTHKO\S E)/XOUSA TO\ PRO/SWPON KAI\ E)/NTONON KAI\ DEDORKO\S BLE/POUSA, W(/STE TOI=S ME\N A)DI/KOIS FO/BON E)MPOIEI=N, TOI=S DE\ DIKAI/OIS QA/RSOS: TOI=S ME\N PROSFILOU=S O)/NTOS TOU= TOIOU/TOU PROSW/POU, TOI=S DE\ E(TE/ROIS PROSA/NTOUS."2&10 &10@Haec verba Chrysippi eo etiam magis ponenda existimavi, ut prompta &10ad considerandum iudicandumque sint, quoniam legentibus ea nobis deli-&10catiores quidam disciplinarum philosophi, Saevitiae imaginem istam esse, &10non Iustitiae, dixerunt. &10@Athenaeus Deipnosoph. XIII p. 565a.$10 TOU= CU/RESQAI TO\N PW/-GWNA KAT' *)ALE/CANDRON EU(RHME/NOU, W(/S FHSIN U(MW=N O( <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 E)N <20TW=| TETA/RTW| PERI\ TOU= KALOU= KAI\ TH=S H(DONH=S>20. OU)K A)KAI/RWS DE/, W(S E)MAUTO\N PEI/QW, MEMNH/SOMAI TH=S LE/CEWS: XAI/RW GA\R PA/NU TW=| A)NDRI\ DIA/ TE TH\N POLU-MAQI/AN KAI\ TH\N TOU= H)/QOUS E)PIEI/KEIAN. LE/GEI DE\ OU(/TWS O( FILO/SOFOS "1TO\ CU/RESQAI TO\N PW/GWNA KAT' *)ALE/CANDRON PROH=KTAI, TW=N PROTE/RWN OU) XRWME/NWN AU)TW=|. KAI\ GA\R *TIMO/QEOS O( AU)LHTH\S PW/GWNA ME/GAN E)/XWN HU)/LEI, KAI\ E)N *)AQH/-NAIS DIATHROU=SIN OU) SFO/DRA A)RXAI=ON TO\N PRW=TON PROSKEIRA/MENON PARWNU/MION E)/XEIN *KO/RSHN. DIO\ KAI\ *)/ALECIS E)/FH POU: @A)\N PITTOKOPOU/MENO/N TIN' H)\ CUROU/MENON @O(RA=S, DUOI=N TOU/TWN E)/XEIN DEI= QA/TERON: @H)\ GA\R STRATEU/EIN E)PINOEI=N MOI FAI/NETAI @KAI\ PA/NTA TW=| PW/GWNI DRA=N E)NANTI/A @H)\ PLOUSIAKO\N TOU/TW| TI PROSPI/PTEI KAKO/N. @TI/ GA\R AI( TRI/XES LUPOU=SIN H(MA=S, PRO\S QEW=N, @DI' A(\S A)NH\R E(/KASTOS H(MW=N FAI/NETAI, @EI) MH/ TI TAU/TAIS A)NTIPRA/TTESQ' U(PONOEI=S. *DIOGE/NHS DE\ I)DW/N TINA OU(/TWS E)/XONTA TO\ GE/NEION E)/FHSE, "1MH/ TI E)/XEIS E)GKALEI=N TH=| FU/SEI O(/TI A)/NDRA S' E)POI/HSE KAI\ OU) GUNAI=KA;"2 E(/TERON DE/ TINA E)PI\ I(/PPOU I)DW\N PARAPLHSI/WS E)/XONTA KAI\ MEMURISME/NON KAI\ TOU/TOIS A)KOLOU/QWS H)MFIES-ME/NON, PRO/TERON ME\N E)/FHSE ZHTEI=N TI/ E)STIN O( I(PPO/PORNOS, NU=N DE\ EU(RHKE/NAI. E)N *(RO/DW| DE\ NO/MOU O)/NTOS MH\ CU/RESQAI OU)DE\ O( E)PILHYO/MENOS OU)DEI/S E)STI DIA\ TO\ PA/NTAS CU/RESQAI. E)N *BUZANTI/W| DE\ ZHMI/AS E)PIKEIME/NHS TW=| E)/XONTI KOUREI= CURO\N OU)DE\N H(=TTON PA/NTES XRW=NTAI AU)TW=|."2 KAI\ TAU=TA ME\N O( QAUMA/SIOS EI)/-RHKE <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20. &10Athenaeus Deipnosoph. IV p. 137f.$10 <20*XRU/SIPPO/S T' E)N TETA/R-TW| PERI\ TOU= KALOU= KAI\ TH=S H(DONH=S>20 FHSI\N "1E)N *)AQH/NAIS DE\ I(STOROU=SIN OU) PA/NU A)RXAI/WN DUOI=N GENOME/NWN DEI/PNWN, E)N *LUKEI/W| TE KAI\ *)AKADHMEI/A|, @1 TOU= ME\N EI)S TH\N *)AKADH/MEIAN EI)SENE/GKANTOS O)YOPOIOU= LOPA/DA PRO\S E(TE/RAN TINA\ XREI/AN TO\N KE/RAMON KATA=CAI PA/NTA TOU\S I(EROPOIOU/S, W(S MAKRO/QEN OU)K A)STEI/AS PAREISDU/SEWS GINOME/NHS, DE/ONTOS A)PE/XESQAI TOU/TWN [2TW=N]2 MAKRO/QEN: TO\N D' E)N TW=| *LUKEI/W| KRE/AS TARIXHRO\N EI)S TA/RIXOS DIASKEUA/SANTA MASTIGW-QH=NAI W(S PARASOFIZO/MENON PONHRW=S."2 @&10Athenaeus Deipnosoph. IX p. 373a.$10 KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 D' O( FI-LO/SOFOS <20E)N TW=| PE/MPTW| PERI\ TOU= KALOU= KAI\ TH=S H(DONH=S>20 GRA/FEI OU(/TWS "1KAQA/PER TINE\S TA\S LEUKA\S O)/RNIQAS TW=N MELAINW=N H(DI/OUS EI)=NAI MA=LLON."2 @&10Athenaeus Deipnosoph. VIII 335b.$10 <20*XRU/SIPPON>20 D', A)/NDRES FI/-LOI, TO\N TH=S *STOA=S H(GEMO/NA KATA\ POLLA\ QAUMA/ZWN E)/TI MA=LLON E)PAINW=, TO\N POLUQRU/LHTON E)PI\ TH=| O)YOLOGI/A| *)ARXE/STRATON A)EI/ POTE META\ *FILAINI/DOS KATA-TA/TTONTA, EI)S H(\N A)NAFE/RETAI TO\ PERI\ A)FRODISI/WN A)KO/LASTON SU/GGRAMMA. @&10id. 335a.$10 A)LL' OU)=N O(/ GE QAUMASIW/TATOS <20*XRU/SIPPOS E)N TW=| PE/MPTW| PERI\ TOU= KALOU= KAI\ TH=S H(DONH=S>20 FHSI/ "1KAI\ BIBLI/A TA/ TE *FILAINI/DOS KAI\ TH\N TOU= *)ARXESTRA/TOU *GASTRONOMI/AN KAI\ DUNA/MEIS E)RWTIKA\S KAI\ SUNOUSIASTI-KA/S, O(MOI/WS DE\ KAI\ TA\S QERAPAI/NAS E)MPEI/ROUS TOIW=NDE KINH/SEW/N TE KAI\ SXH-MA/TWN KAI\ PERI\ TH\N TOU/TWN MELE/THN GINOME/NAS."2 KAI\ PA/LIN "1E)KMANQA/NEIN T' AU)TOU\S TA\ TOIAU=TA KAI\ KTA=SQAI TA\ PERI\ TOU/TWN GEGRAMME/NA *FILAINI/DI KAI\ *)ARXESTRA/TW| KAI\ TOI=S TA\ O(/MOIA GRA/YASI."2 <20KA)\N TW=| E(BDO/MW|>20 DE/ FHSI "1KAQA/PER GA\R OU)K E)KMANQA/NEIN TA\ *FILAINI/DOS KAI\ TH\N *)ARXESTRA/TOU *GASTRONOMI/AN E)/STIN W(S FE/RONTA/ TI PRO\S TO\ ZH=N A)/MEINON."2 @&10Athenaeus Deipnos. I p. 4e.$10 *)ARXE/STRATOS O( *SURAKO/SIOS H)\ *GE-LW=|OS E)N TH=| W(S <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 E)PIGRA/FEI *GASTRONOMI/A|, W(S DE\ *LUGKEU\S KAI\ *KALLI/MAXOS *(HDUPAQEI/A|. @&10Athenaeus Deipnosoph. XIV p. 616a.$10 KAI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 D' O( FILO/SOFOS <20E)N PE/MPTW| PERI\ TOU= KALOU= KAI\ TH=S H(DONH=S>20 PERI\ TOU= *PAN-TALE/ONTOS TA/DE GRA/FEI "1O( DE\ PLA/NOS *PANTALE/WN TELEUTA=N ME/LLWN E(KA/TERON TW=N UI(W=N KAT' I)DI/AN E)CHPA/THSE, FH/SAS MO/NW| AU)TW=| LE/GEIN, O(/POU KATORWRU/XOI TO\ XRUSI/ON: W(/STE MA/THN U(/STERON KOINH=| SKA/PTONTAS AI)SQE/SQAI E)CHPATH-ME/NOUS."2 @&10Athenaeus Deipnosoph. XIV p. 616b.$10 OU)K H)PO/REI D' H(MW=N TO\ SUMPO/SION OU)DE\ TW=N FILOSKWPTOU/NTWN. PERI\ DE\ TOIOU/TOU TINO\S PA/LIN O( <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 E)N TW=| AU)TW=|&10 [1scil.$10 <20E)N TW=| PE/MPTW| PERI\ TOU= KALOU= KAI\ TH=S H(DONH=S>20]1 GRA/FEI "1FILOSKW/PTHS ME/LLWN U(PO\ TOU= DHMI/OU SFA/TTESQAI EI)=PE QE/LEIN W(/SPER TO\ KU/KNEION A)/|SAS A)POQANEI=N. E)PITRE/YANTOS D' E)KEI/NOU E)/SKWYEN."2 @&10Athenaei Deipnosoph. epit. lib. I p. 9c.$10 TO\ PARA\ POLLOI=S LASTAU- @1ROKA/KKABON KALOU/MENON BRW=MA, W(/S FHSI <20*XRU/SIPPOS [2E)N TW=| PERI\ KALOU= KAI\ H(DONH=S>20]2 OU(= H( KATASKEUH\ PERIERGOTE/RA. 򠱰@&10Athenaeus Deipnosoph. I p. 5e.$10 *)APO\ TOU/TOU TOU= *FILOCE/NOU KAI\ FILOCE/NEIOI/ TINES PLAKOU=NTES W)NOMA/SQHSAN. PERI\ TOU/TOU <20*XRU/SIPPO/S>20 FHSIN "1E)GW\ KATE/XW TINA\ O)YOFA/GON E)PI\ TOSOU=TON E)KPEPTWKO/TA TOU= MH\ E)N-TRE/PESQAI TOU\S PLHSI/ON E)PI\ TOI=S GINOME/NOIS, W(/STE FANERW=S E)N TOI=S BALA-NEI/OIS TH/N TE XEI=RA SUNEQI/ZEIN PRO\S TA\ QERMA/, KAQIE/NTA EI)S U(/DWR QERMO/N, KAI\ TO\ STO/MA A)NAGARGARIZO/MENON QERMW=|, O(/PWS DHLONO/TI E)N TOI=S QERMOI=S DUSKI/NHTOS H)=|. E)/FASAN GA\R AU)TO\N KAI\ TOU\S O)YOPOIOU=NTAS U(POPOIEI=SQAI, I(/NA QERMO/TATA PARATIQW=SI, KAI\ MO/NOS KATANALI/SKH| AU)TO/S, TW=N LOIPW=N SUNAKO-LOUQEI=N MH\ DUNAME/NWN."2 @&10Athenaeus VIII p. 336a.$10 [1O( *SARDANA/PALLOS]1 E)F' OU(= TOU= TA/FOU E)PIGEGRA/FQAI FHSI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 TA/DE @&10Athenaeus Deipnosoph. XV p. 686f.$10 KAI\ O( QAUMASIW/TATOS DE\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 TH\N O)NOMASI/AN FHSI\ LABEI=N TA\ MU/RA A)PO\ TOU= META\ POLLOU= MO/-ROU KAI\ PO/NOU MATAI/OU GI/NESQAI. *LAKEDAIMO/NIOI/ TE E)CELAU/NOUSI TH=S *SPA/R-THS TOU\S TA\ MU/RA KATASKEUA/ZONTAS W(S DIAFQEI/RONTAS TOU)/LAION, KAI\ TOU\S TA\ E)/RIA DE\ BA/PTONTAS W(S A)FANI/ZONTAS TH\N LEUKO/THTA TW=N E)RI/WN. *SO/LWN TE O( SOFO\S DIA\ TW=N NO/MWN KEKW/LUKE TOU\S A)/NDRAS MUROPWLEI=N. @&10Athenaeus Deipnosoph. XIV p. 659a.$10 E)KA/LOUN D' OI( PALAIOI\ TO\N ME\N POLITIKO\N MA/GEIRON *MAI/SWNA TO\N D' E)KTO/PION *TE/TTIGA. <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 D' O( FILO/SOFOS TO\N *MAI/SWNA A)PO\ TOU= MASA=SQAI OI)/ETAI KEKLH=SQAI, OI(=ON TO\N A)MAQH= KAI\ PRO\S GASTE/RA NENEUKO/TA, A)GNOW=N O(/TI *MAI/SWN GE/GONE KWMW|DI/AS U(POKRITH\S *MEGAREU\S TO\ GE/NOS, O(\S KAI\ TO\ PROSWPEI=ON EU(=RE TO\ A)P' AU)TOU= KA-LOU/MENON MAI/SWNA, W(S *)ARISTOFA/NHS FHSI\N O( *BUZA/NTIOS E)N TW=| PERI\ PROSW/PWN. @&10Athenaeus Deipnosoph. II p. 67c.$10 KA/LLISTON D' O)/COS EI)=NAI/ FHSI <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 O( FILO/SOFOS TO/ TE *AI)GU/PTION KAI\ TO\ *KNI/DION. @&10Athenaeus Deipnosoph. I p. 8c.$10 *XRU/SIPPOS DE/ FHSIN: A)SU/M-BOLON KW/QWNA MH\ PARALI/MPANE. @1 {1*PERI\ *PAROIMIW=N}1 &10Diog. Lae%28rt. VII 1. [1de Zenone locutus]1$10 O(/TI I)SXNO\S H)=N, U(POMH/-KHS, MELA/GXRWS, O(/QEN TIS AU)TO\N EI)=PEN *AI)GUPTI/AN KLHMATI/DA, KAQA/ FHSI <20*XRU/SIPPOS E)N PRW/TW| *PAROIMIW=N>20. @&10Schol. Pind. Isthm. II 17.$10 *XRH/MATA XRH/MAT' A)NH/R] TOU=TO A)NA-GRA/FETAI ME\N EI)S TA\S PAROIMI/AS U(P' E)NI/WN, A)PO/FQEGMA DE/ E)STIN *)ARISTODH/MOU, KAQA/PER FHSI\ <20*XRU/SIPPOS E)N TW=| PERI\ PAROIMIW=N>20. TOU=TON DE\ TO\N *)ARI-STO/DHMON *PI/NDAROS ME\N OU) TI/QHSIN E)C O)NO/MATOS, W(S DH/LOU O)/NTOS O(/S E)STIN O( TOU=TO EI)PW/N, MO/NON DE\ E)SHMEIW/SATO TH\N PATRI/DA O(/TI *)ARGEI=OS &10etc. &10@Diogenianus Paroemiographus I 62 p. 10.$10 *AI)\C *SKURI/A%10 <20*XRU/-SIPPO/S>20 FHSIN E)PI\ TW=N TA\S XA/RITAS A)NATREPO/NTWN TETA/XQAI TH\N PAROIMI/AN, E)PEIDH\ POLLA/KIS TA\ A)GGEI=A A)NATRE/PEI H( AI)/C. @&10Zenobius V 32.$10 *OU) NUKTIPLOEI=S%10 E)PI\ TW=N MH\ A)KRIBW=S TI POI-OU/NTWN. *(H GA\R NU\C A)KRIBESTE/RA TH=S H(ME/RAS TOI=S PELAGODROMOU=SI, DIA\ TA\S TW=N A)/STRWN SHMEIW/SEIS. <20*(O DE\ *XRU/SIPPOS>20 A)FELW\N TH\N "1OU)"2 A)PO/FASIN "1NUKTIPLOEI=S"2 EI)=PEN. @[&10Plut.] Prov. Alex. I 3 [1Cod. VB._Corp. Par. II p. 321$10]1. *)OPI-SA/MBW[N]: TAU/THN <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 TA/TTEI KATA\ TW=N XEI=RON E)N TOI=S PRA/GMASI PROBAINO/NTWN PARA\ TO\ A)EI\ O)PI/SW BAI/NEIN. *ME/MNHTAI TOU= O)NO/MATOS *SOFOKLH=S. @&10Zenobius Paroemiogr. III 40.$10 *DOI=DUC AU)/CEI%10 E)PI\ TW=N MH\ AU)CA-NOME/NWN FHSI\N O( <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20, A)LLA\ KAI\ [2E)PI\ TW=N]2 MIKRW=N MENO/NTWN EI)/RHTAI H( PAROIMI/A. *(O GA\R DOI=DUC MIKRO/S E)STI KAI\ STROGGU/LOS. @&10Plutarchus vita Arati 1, 1.$10 *PAROIMI/AN TINA\ PALAIA/N, W)= *POLU/-KRATES, DEI/SAS MOI DOKEI= TO\ DU/SFHMON AU)TH=S, O( FILO/SOFOS <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 OU)X O(\N E)/XEI TRO/PON, A)LL' W(S AU)TO\S W)/|ETO BE/LTION EI)=NAI DIATI/QETAI, @TI/S PATE/R' AI)NH/SEI, EI) MH\ EU)DAI/MONES UI(OI/; *DIONUSO/DWROS DE\ O( *TROIZH/NIOS E)LE/GXWN AU)TO\N A)NTEKTI/QHSI TH\N A)LHQINH\N OU(/TWS E)/XOUSAN: @TI/S PATE/R' AI)NH/SEI, EI) MH\ KAKODAI/MONES UI(OI/; &etc. @&10Suidas s. v.$10 *KE/RKWPES&10 [1pr.$10]1_H( DE\ PAROIMI/A "1KERKWPI/ZEIN"2 H(\N O( <20*XRU/SIPPOS>20 A)PO\ TW=N SAINO/NTWN TH=| KE/RKW| ZW/|WN FHSI\ METENHNE/XQAI. {1*PERI\ *POLITEI/AS$}1 @1 @&10Diogenes Lae%28rt. VII 34.$10 O(/TI D' AU)TOU= E)STIN H( *POLITEI/A&10 [1scil. &10Zenonis]1$10 KAI\ *XRU/SIPPOS E)N [1W(/SPER E)N *B]1 <20TW=| PERI\ *POLITEI/AS>20 FHSI/. @1 {1*(UPOGRAFH\ TOU= LO/GOU TOU= [2H)QIKOU=]2 PRO\S *QEO/PORON *A}1 @&10Stob. Eclog. II 116, 11 W.$10 *PERI\ GA\R PA/NTWN TW=N PARADO/CWN DOGMA/TWN E)N POLLOI=S ME\N KAI\ A)/LLOIS O( *XRU/SIPPOS DIELE/XQH: KAI\ GA\R E)N TW=| PERI\ DOGMA/TWN KAI\ E)N TH=| U(POGRAFH=| TOU= LO/GOU KAI\ E)N A)/LLOIS POLLOI=S TW=N KATA\ ME/ROS SUGGRAMMA/TWN. @1 пA)SU/MBOLON KW/QWNA MH\ PARALI/MPANE. ѿKW/QWN D' OU) PARALEIPTO\S A)SU/MBOLOS, A)LLA\ DIWKTO/S. {2#524}2 EU)= EI)DW\S O(/TI QNHTO\S E)/FUS SO\N QUMO\N A)/ECE, ҂TERPO/MENOS MU/QOISI: FAGO/NTI SOI OU)/TIS O)/NHSIS. KAI\ GA\R E)GW\ R(A/KOS EI)MI/, FAGW\N W(S PLEI=STA KAI\ H(SQEI/S. TAU=T' E)/XW O(/SS' E)/MAQON KAI\ E)FRO/NTISA KAI\ META\ TOU/TWN E)/SQL' E)/PAQON: TA\ DE\ LOIPA\ KAI\ H(DE/A PA/NTA LE/LEIPTAI. %2 @1 TH=| O(MOMHTRI/A| [2A)]2DE[LFH=| H)\ A)N-]QRW/POU FAGEI=N K?[] EI OU(/TWS TA\ FHMI?[] TOIS PARAPLH/SIA A?S3[] PAR' A)/LLOIS KAI\ DI[] #6KAI\ TETI/MHTAI: P?R?O?[] AUTA PA/NTA OU(/TWS E?[] PAR' A)/LLHN AI)TI/AN? ![] H)\ PARA\ TH\N EU)QU[] #6DIABOLH/N: KAQA/P?[ER] R?OI ME\N PRO\S TO\ I)XQ?[UOFAGEI=N] DIABE/BLHNTAI K[] #6DE\ PRO\S A)/LLA: E)PI\ P[] TOU/TWN TW=N DIAST[ROFW=N] [E)]GGINOME/NWN KA[] [!]RA DUSSULLOGI/STWS [] [P]ARA\ TW=N POLLW=N A?[] @9 @1