@&Galenus hist. philos. 3 [1p. 600, 10 Diels]1.$ TOU= DE\ [1&scil. Chry-&sippi$]1 <20*DIOGE/NHS O( *BABULW/NIOS>20 A)KROATH\S GEGONW\S *)ANTIPA/TROU KAQHGHTH\S GE/GONE. @&Strabo XVI p. 743.$ PA/LAI ME\N OU)=N H( *BABULW\N H)=N MHTRO/PO-LIS TH=S *)ASSURI/AS, NU=N DE\ *SELEU/KEIA H( E)PI\ TW=| *TI/GREI LEGOME/NH. __ W(/SPER DE\ *BABULWNI/AN TH\N XW/RAN KALOU=MEN, OU(/TW KAI\ TOU\S A)/NDRAS TOU\S E)KEI=QEN *BABULWNI/OUS KALOU=MEN, OU)K A)PO\ TH=S PO/LEWS, A)LL' A)PO\ TH=S XW/RAS, A)PO\ DE\ *SELEUKEI/AS H(=TTON, KA)\N E)KEI=QEN W)=SI, KAQA/PER *DIO-GE/NH TO\N *STWI+KO\N FILO/SOFON. @&Diogenes Lae+rtius VI 81.$ TE/TARTOS [1&scil.$ GE/GONE *DIOGE/NHS]1 *STWI+KO/S, GE/NOS *SELEUKEU/S, KALOU/MENOS DE\ *BA-BULW/NIOS DIA\ TH\N GEITONI/AN. @&Index Stoic. Herc. col. XLVIII.$ [1G]1NW/RI[1MOI]1 %5 D' A[1U)TO]1U= GE-GO/NASIN *DIO%5GE/N[1HS]1 *)ARTEMIDW/ROU %5 *SE[1LEUKE]1U\S [1A)P]1O\ *TI/GRIOS O( [1PARALABW\N *ZH/]1NWNOS TH\N %5 [1SXOLH/N]1. @&Lucian. Macrob. 20.$ <20*DIOGE/NHS>20 DE\ O( *SELEUKEU\S A)PO\ *TI/GRIOS, *STWI+KO\S FILO/SOFOS, O)KTW\ KAI\ O)GDOH/KONTA [1&scil.$ E)/TH E)/ZHSEN]1. @&Plutarchus de Stoic. repugn. cp. 2.$ TI/S OU)=N MA=LLON E)N TW=| SXOLASTIKW=| BI/W| TOU/TW| KATEGH/RASEN H)\ *XRU/SIPPOS KAI\ *KLEA/NQHS KAI\ <20*DIOGE/NHS>20 KAI\ *ZH/NWN KAI\ *)ANTI/PATROS; OI(/ GE KAI\ TA\S AU(TW=N KATE/LI-PON PATRI/DAS OU)DE\N E)GKALOU=NTES, A)LL' O(/PWS KAQ' H(SUXI/AN KAI\ E)PI\ ZWSTH=ROS SXOLA/ZONTES KAI\ FILOLOGOU=NTES DIA/GWSIN. @&Cicero Cato maior 23.&3 num postea Zenonem, Cleanthem aut &3eum, quem vos etiam vidistis Romae, <21Diogenem Stoicum>21, coe+git in &3suis studiis obmutescere senectus? an in omnibus his studiorum agitatio &3vitae aequalis fuit? @&Plutarchus de vita Catonis 22.$ H)/DH DE\ AU)TOU= GE/RONTOS GEGO-NO/TOS PRE/SBEIS *)AQH/NHQEN H)=LQON EI)S *(RW/MHN OI( PERI\ *KARNEA/DHN TO\N *)AKADHMAI+KO\N KAI\ <20*DIOGE/NH TO\N *STWI+KO\N>20 FILO/SOFON, KATADI/KHN TINA\ @1 PARAITHSO/MENOI TOU= DH/MOU TW=N *)AQHNAI/WN, H(\N E)RH/MHN W)=FLON *)WRW-PI/WN ME\N DIWCA/NTWN, *SIKUWNI/WN DE\ KATAYHFISAME/NWN, TI/MHMA TALA/N-TWN PENTAKOSI/WN E)/XOUSAN. EU)QU\S OU)=N OI( FILOLOGW/TATOI TW=N NEA-NI/SKWN E)PI\ TOU\S A)/NDRAS I(/ENTO KAI\ SUNH=SAN A)KROW/MENOI KAI\ QAUMA/ZONTES AU)TOU/S. @&Gellius Noct. Att. VI 14, 8.&3 Animadversa eadem tripartita varie-&3tas est in tribus philosophis, quos Athenienses Romam ad senatum lega-&3verant impetratum, uti multam remitteret, quam fecerat is propter Oropi &3vastationem. Ea multa fuerat talentum fere quingentum. Erant isti &3philosophi Carneades ex Academia, <21Diogenes Stoicus>21, Critolaus Peri-&3pateticus. Et in senatum quidem introducti interprete usi sunt C. Acilio &3senatore; sed ante ipsi seorsum quisque ostentandi gratia magno con-&3ventu hominum dissertaverunt. Tum admirationi fuisse aiunt Rutilius &3et <21Polybius>21 philosophorum trium sui cuiusque generis facundiam. &3"1Violenta, inquiunt, et rapida Carneades dicebat, scita et teretia Crito-&3laus, <21modesta Diogenes et sobria>21."2 @&Cicero Acad. Pr. II 137.&3 Legi apud Clitomachum, cum Car-&3neades et <21Stoicus Diogenes>21 ad senatum in Capitolio starent, A. Al-&3binum, qui tum P. Scipione [et] M. Marcello coss. praetor esset, __ &3doctum sane hominem__iocantem dixisse Carneadi%10 "1Ego tibi, Car-&3neades, praetor esse non videor, quia sapiens non sum, nec haec urbs &3nec in ea civitas."2 Tum ille%10 "1Huic Stoico non videris."2 @&Cicero Tusc. disp. IV 5.&3 Quibus [1scil. Laelio et Scipione]1 adu-&3lescentibus <21Stoicum Diogenem>21 et Academicum Carneadem video ad &3senatum ab Atheniensibus missos esse legatos, qui cum rei publicae &3nullam umquam partem attigissent essetque eorum alter Cyrenaeus, &3alter <21Babylonius>21, numquam profecto scholis essent excitati neque ad &3illud munus electi, nisi in quibusdam principibus, temporibus illis, fuis-&3sent studia doctrinae. @&Ind. Stoic. Herc. col. LI.$ _XOU TH=S *TRW|A/DOS *)A%5LECANDREI/AS: *PANAI/%5TIOS *NIKAGO/ROU *(RO/DIOS: %5 *MNH/SARXOS *)ONHSI/MOU %5 *)AQHNAI=OS: *DA/RDA[1NOS]1 %5 *)ANDROMA/XOU *)A[1QHNAI=]1%5OS: *)APOLLO/DW[1ROS *SELEU]1%5KEU\[1S]1 A)PO\ *T[1I/GRIOS: *BO/H]1%5QOS *SIDW/[1NIOS !!!!! @&Diogenes Lae+rt. VII 29.$ *ZHNO/DOTOS O( *STWI+KO/S, *DIOGE/NOUS MA-QHTH/S [1&epigramma fecit in Zenonem Citiensem]1. &@Ps. Scymnus v. 10 @$TW=N *)ATTIKW=N TIS GNHSI/WN TE FILOLO/GWN, @GEGONW\S A)KOUSTH\S *DIOGE/NOUS TOU= *STWI+KOU=, @1 @SUNESXOLAKW\S DE\ POLU\N *)ARISTA/RXW| XRO/NON @SUNETA/CAT' A)PO\ TH=S *TRWI+KH=S A(LW/SEWS @XRONOGRAFI/AN STOIXOU=SAN A)/XRI TOU= NU=N XRO/NOU. @&Ind. Stoic. Herc. col. LII.$ QU%5GATRO\S UI(O/S: E)GE/NETO %5 DE\ [1K]1AI\ *)AREOPAGI/THS %5 OU(=TOS: *)APOLLWNI/DHS %5 *SMURNAI=OS: *XRU/SERM[1OS]1 %5 *)ALE-CANDREU\S TH=S PRO\S %5 *AI)/GUP[1TON]1: *DIONU/SIOS %5 *KURHNAI=OS. OU(=T[1OS DE\]1 %5 KAI\ GEW[1ME/]1TRHS [1H)=N A)/]1%5RISTOS, O( KAI\ A)NT[1I]1G[1RA/YAS]1 %5 *DHMHTRI/W| TW=| [1R(H/]1%5TORI TW= P[1RO\S TOU\S GEWME/TRAS GRA/YANTI%1]1 @&Cicero Acad. Pr. II 98.&3 Cum aliquid huius modi inciderat, &3sic ludere Carneades solebat%10 "1si recte conclusi, teneo; sin vitiose, mi-&3nam <21Diogenes reddet>21."2 Ab eo enim Stoico dialecticam didicerat; haec &3autem merces erat dialecticorum. @&Cicero de fin. II 24.&3 Nec ille qui <21Diogenem>21 Stoicum adu-&3lescens, post autem Panaetium audierat Laelius. @&Cicero de fin. I 6.&3 Quid enim est a Chrysippo praetermissum &3in Stoicis? Legimus tamen <21Diogenem>21, Antipatrum. @&Diog. Lae+rt. VII 39.$ *TRIMERH= FASIN EI)=NAI TO\N KATA\ FILO-SOFI/AN LO/GON: EI)=NAI GA\R AU)TOU= TO\ ME/N TI FUSIKO/N, TO\ DE\ H)QIKO/N, TO\ DE\ LOGIKO/N. OU(/TW DE\ PRW=TOS DIEI=LE *ZH/NWN O( *KITIEU/S: __KAI\ <20*DIOGE/NHS O( *BABULW/NIOS>20. @&Diocles Magnes apud Diog. Lae+rt. VII 55.$ E)/STI DE\ FWNH\ A)H\R PEPLHGME/NOS H)\ TO\ I)/DION AI)SQHTO\N A)KOH=S, W(/S FHSI <20*DIOGE/NHS O( *BA-BULW/NIOS E)N TH=| PERI\ TH=S FWNH=S TE/XNH|>20. [2KAI\]2 ZW/|OU ME/N E)STI FWNH\ A)H\R U(PO\ O(RMH=S PEPLHGME/NOS, A)NQRW/POU DE/ E)STIN E)/NARQROS KAI\ A)PO\ DIANOI/AS E)KPEMPOME/NH, W(S O( <20*DIOGE/NHS>20 FHSI/N, H(/TIS A)PO\ DEKA-TESSA/RWN E)TW=N TELEIOU=TAI. @&Diocles Magnes apud Diog. Lae+rt. VII 55.$ KAI\ SW=MA D' E)STI\N H( FWNH\ KATA\ TOU\S *STWI+KOU/S, W(/S FHSIN *)ARXE/DHMOS__KAI\ <20*DIO-GE/NHS>20 KAI\ *)ANTI/PATROS: PA=N GA\R TO\ POIOU=N SW=MA/ E)STI: POIEI= DE\ H( FWNH\ PROSIOU=SA TOI=S A)KOU/OUSIN A)PO\ TW=N FWNOU/NTWN. @&Simplicius in Aristot. Phys. p. 426, 1 Diels.$ KAI\ OI( A)E/RA DE\ @1 PEPLHGME/NON TH\N FWNH\N A)PODIDO/NTES, W(/SPER <20*DIOGE/NHS O( *BABU-LW/NIOS>20, A(MARTA/NOUSI. SW=MA GA\R OU(/TWS E)/STAI H( FWNH/, EI)/PER E)N GE/NEI TW=| A)E/RI E)STI/, KAI\ TO\ PEPONQO/S, TOUTE/STI TO\N PEPLHGME/NON A)E/RA, A)NTI\ TOU= PA/QOUS, O(/PER E)STI\N H( PLHGH/, A)PODIDO/ASIN. @&Diocles Magnes apud Diog. Lae+rt. VII 56.$ <20*LE/CIS>20 DE/ E)STI KATA\ TOU\S *STWI+KOU/S, W(/S FHSIN O( <20*DIOGE/NHS>20, FWNH\ E)GGRA/MMATOS, OI(=ON "1H(ME/RA"2. @<20LO/GOS>20 DE/ E)STI FWNH\ SHMANTIKH\ A)PO\ DIANOI/AS E)KPEMPOME/NH, [2OI(=ON "1H(ME/RA E)STI/"2]2. @<20DIA/LEKTOS>20 DE/ E)STI LE/CIS KEXARAGME/NH E)QNIKW=S TE KAI\ *(ELLHNI-KW=S: H)\ LE/CIS POTAPH/, TOUTE/STI POIA\ KATA\ DIA/LEKTON, OI(=ON KATA\ ME\N TH\N *)ATQI/DA "1QA/LATTA"2, KATA\ DE\ TH\N *)IA/DA "1H(ME/RH"2. @<20TH=S DE\ LE/CEWS STOIXEI=A/>20 E)STI TA\ EI)KOSITE/SSARA GRA/MMATA. TRI-XW=S DE\ LE/GETAI TO\ GRA/MMA, [2TO/ TE STOIXEI=ON]2 O(/ TE XARAKTH\R TOU= STOI-XEI/OU KAI\ TO\ O)/NOMA, OI(=ON "1A)/LFA"2. @<20FWNH/ENTA>20 DE/ E)STI TW=N STOIXEI/WN E(PTA/: A, E, H, I, O, U, W. @<20A)/FWNA>20 DE\ E(/C: B, G, D, P, K, T. @DIAFE/REI DE\ FWNH\ KAI\ LE/CIS, O(/TI FWNH\ ME\N KAI\ O( H)=XO/S E)STI, LE/CIS DE\ TO\ E)/NARQRON MO/NON. @LE/CIS DE\ LO/GOU DIAFE/REI, O(/TI LO/GOS A)EI\ SHMANTIKO/S E)STI, LE/CIS DE\ KAI\ A)SH/MANTOS, W(S H( "1BLI/TURI"2, LO/GOS DE\ OU)DAMW=S. @DIAFE/REI DE\ KAI\ TO\ LE/GEIN TOU= PROFE/RESQAI: PROFE/RONTAI ME\N GA\R AI( FWNAI/, LE/GETAI DE\ TA\ PRA/GMATA, A(\ DH\ KAI\ LEKTA\ TUGXA/NEI. @&Diocles Magnes apud Diog. Lae+rt. VII 57.$ TOU= DE\ <20LO/GOU E)STI\ ME/RH>20 PE/NTE, W(/S FHSI <20*DIOGE/NHS TE E)N TW=| PERI\ FWNH=S>20 KAI\ *XRU/SIPPOS: O)/NOMA, PROSHGORI/A, R(H=MA, SU/NDESMOS, A)/RQRON. @&Diocles Magnes apud Diog. Lae+rt. VII 58.$ E)/STI DE\ <20PROS-HGORI/A>20 ME/N, KATA\ TO\N <20*DIOGE/NHN>20, ME/ROS LO/GOU SHMAI=NON KOINH\N POIO/THTA, OI(=ON "1A)/NQRWPOS"2 "1I(/PPOS"2. @<20O)/NOMA>20 DE/ E)STI ME/ROS LO/GOU DHLOU=N I)DI/AN POIO/THTA, OI(=ON *DIO-GE/NHS, *SWKRA/THS. @<20R(H=MA>20 DE/ E)STI ME/ROS LO/GOU SHMAI=NON A)SU/NQETON KATHGO/RHMA, W(S O( <20*DIOGE/NHS>20, H)/, W(/S TINES, STOIXEI=ON LO/GOU A)/PTWTON SHMAI=NO/N TI SUN-TAKTO\N PERI/ TINOS H)\ TINW=N, OI(=ON "1GRA/FW"2 "1LE/GW"2. @1 @<20SU/NDESMOS>20 DE/ E)STI ME/ROS LO/GOU A)/PTWTON, SUNDOU=N TA\ ME/RH TOU= LO/GOU. @<20A)/RQRON>20 DE/ E)STI STOIXEI=ON LO/GOU PTWTIKO/N, DIORI/ZON TA\ GE/NH TW=N O)NOMA/TWN KAI\ TOU\S A)RIQMOU/S: OI(=ON "1O(, H(, TO/, OI(, AI(, TA/"2. @&Diocles Magnes apud Diog. Lae+rt. VII 62.$ <20A)MFIBOLI/A>20 DE/ E)STI LE/CIS DU/O H)\ KAI\ PLEI/ONA PRA/GMATA SHMAI/NOUSA LEKTIKW=S KAI\ KU-RI/WS KAI\ KATA\ TO\ AU)TO\ E)/QOS, W(/SQ' A(/MA TINA\ PLEI/ONA E)KDE/CASQAI KATA\ TH\N AU)TH\N LE/CIN, OI(=ON "1AU)LHTRI\S PE/PTWKE"2. DHLOU=TAI GA\R DI' AU)TH=S TO\ ME\N TOIOU=TON "1OI)KI/A TRI\S PE/PTWKE"2, TO\ DE\ TOIOU=TON "1AU)LH/TRIA PE/PTWKE"2. @&Diocles Magnes apud Diog. Lae+rt. VII 59.$ <20A)RETAI\ DE\ LO/-GOU>20 EI)SI\ PE/NTE. E(LLHNISMO/S, SAFH/NEIA, SUNTOMI/A, PRE/PON, KATASKEUH/. @<20E(LLHNISMO\S>20 ME\N OU)=N E)STI FRA/SIS A)DIA/PTWTOS E)N TH=| TEXNIKH=| KAI\ MH\ EI)KAI/A| SUNHQEI/A|. @<20SAFH/NEIA>20 DE/ E)STI LE/CIS GNWRI/MWS PARISTA=SA TO\ NOOU/MENON. @<20SUNTOMI/A>20 DE/ E)STI LE/CIS AU)TA\ TA\ A)NAGKAI=A PERIE/XOUSA PRO\S DH/-LWSIN TOU= PRA/GMATOS. @<20PRE/PON>20 DE/ E)STI LE/CIS OI)KEI/A TW=| PRA/GMATI. @<20KATASKEUH\>20 DE/ E)STI LE/CIS E)KPEFEUGUI=A TO\N I)DIWTISMO/N. @O( <20DE\ BARBARISMO/S>20, E)K TW=N KAKIW=N, LE/CIS E)STI\ PARA\ TO\ E)/QOS TW=N EU)DOKIMOU/NTWN *(ELLH/NWN. @<20SOLOIKISMO\S>20 DE/ E)STI LO/GOS A)KATALLH/LWS SUNTETAGME/NOS. @&Diocles Magnes apud Diog. Lae+rt. VII 60.$ <20GE/NOS DE/ E)STI PLEIO/NWN KAI\ A)NAFAIRE/TWN E)NNOHMA/TWN SU/LLHYIS, OI(=ON "1ZW=|ON"2: TOU=TO GA\R PERIEI/LHFE TA\ KATA\ ME/ROS ZW=|A. @<20E)NNO/HMA>20 DE/ E)STI FA/NTASMA DIANOI/AS, OU)/TE TI\ O)\N OU)/TE POIO/N, W(SANEI\ DE\ TI\ O)\N KAI\ W(SANEI\ POIO/N: OI(=ON GI/NETAI A)NATU/PWMA I(/PPOU KAI\ MH\ PARO/NTOS. @<20EI)=DOS>20 DE/ E)STI TO\ U(PO\ GE/NOUS PERIEXO/MENON, W(S U(PO\ TOU= ZW/|OU O( A)/NQRWPOS PERIE/XETAI. @<20GENIKW/TATON>20 DE/ E)STIN O(\ GE/NOS O)\N GE/NOS OU)K E)/XEI, OI(=ON TO\ O)/N. @<20EI)DIKW/TATON>20 DE/ E)STIN O(\ EI)=DOS O)\N EI)=DOS OU)K E)/XEI, W(/SPER O( *SW-KRA/THS. @1 @<20DIAI/RESIS>20 DE/ E)STI GE/NOUS H( EI)S TA\ PROSEXH= EI)/DH TOMH/, OI(=ON "1TW=N ZW/|WN TA\ ME/N E)STI LOGIKA/, TA\ DE\ A)/LOGA."2 @<20A)NTIDIAI/RESIS>20 DE/ E)STI GE/NOUS EI)S EI)=DOS TOMH\ KATA\ TOU)NANTI/ON, W(S A)\N KATA\ A)PO/FASIN, OI(=ON "1TW=N O)/NTWN TA\ ME/N E)STIN A)GAQA/, TA\ D' OU)K A)GAQA/."2 @<20U(PODIAI/RESIS>20 DE/ E)STI DIAI/RESIS E)PI\ DIAIRE/SEI, OI(=ON "1TW=N O)/NTWN TA\ ME/N E)STIN A)GAQA/, TA\ D' OU)K A)GAQA/: KAI\ TW=N OU)K A)GAQW=N TA\ ME/N E)STI KAKA/, TA\ DE\ A)DIA/FORA."2 @<20MERISMO\S>20 DE/ E)STI GE/NOUS EI)S TO/POUS KATA/TACIS, W(S O( <20*KRI/NIS>20: OI(=ON: "1TW=N A)GAQW=N TA\ ME/N E)STI PERI\ YUXH/N, TA\ DE\ PERI\ SW=MA."2 @&Diocles Magnes apud Diog. Lae+rt. VII 71.$ TW=N D' OU)X A(PLW=N A)CIWMA/TWN <20SUNHMME/NON>20 ME/N E)STIN, W(S O( *XRU/SIPPOS E)N TAI=S DIA-LEKTIKAI=S FHSI KAI\ <20*DIOGE/NHS E)N TH=| DIALEKTIKH=| TE/XNH|>20, TO\ SUN-ESTO\S DIA\ TOU= "1EI)"2 SUNAPTIKOU= SUNDE/SMOU: E)PAGGE/LLETAI DE\ O( SU/N-DESMOS OU(=TOS A)KOLOUQEI=N TO\ DEU/TERON TW=| PRW/TW|, OI(=ON "1EI) H(ME/RA E)STI/, FW=S E)STI."2 @&Philo de incorrupt. mundi 15 p. 248 Bern. p. 25, 3 Cumont.$ LE/GETAI DE\ KAI\ <20*DIOGE/NHS>20 H(NI/KA NE/OS H)=N SUNEPIGRAYA/MENOS TW=| DO/GMATI TH=S E)K-PURW/SEWS O)YE\ TH=S H(LIKI/AS E)NDOIA/SAS E)PISXEI=N. @&Ae+tius II 32, 4 [1DG p. 364&14a& 1]1$ [1TO\N ME/GAN E)NIAUTO/N%10]1 *(HRA/-KLEITOS E)K MURI/WN O)KTAKISXILI/WN E)NIAUTW=N H(LIAKW=N. <20*DIOGE/NHS>20 O( *STWI+KO\S E)K PE/NTE KAI\ E(CH/KONTA KAI\ TRIAKOSI/WN E)NIAUTW=N TOSOU/TWN, O(/SOS H)=N O( KAQ' *(HRA/KLEITON E)NIAUTO/S. @&Galenus de Hipp. et Plat. dogm. II 5 p. 201 Mu+.$ KAI\ MH\N O( QAUMAZO/MENOS U(PO\ TW=N *STWI+KW=N LO/GOS O( <20*ZH/NWNOS>20, O(\N KAI\ PRW=TON A(PA/NTWN E)/GRAYEN <20E)N TW=| PERI\ TOU= TH=S YUXH=S H(GEMONIKOU= *DIO-GE/NHS O( *BABULW/NIOS>20, __EI)/SH| D' E)NARGE/STERON, EI) PARAGRA/YAI-MEN AU)TO/N, E)/XEI GA\R W(=DE. "1*FWNH\ DIA\ FA/RUGGOS XWREI=. EI) DE\ H)=N A)PO\ TOU= E)GKEFA/LOU XWROU=SA, OU)K A)\N DIA\ FA/RUGGOS E)XW/REI. O(/QEN DE\ LO/GOS, KAI\ FWNH\ E)KEI=QEN XWREI=. LO/GOS DE\ A)PO\ DIANOI/AS XWREI=, W(/ST' OU)K E)N TW=| E)GKEFA/LW| E)STI\N H( DIA/NOIA."2 TO\N AU)TO\N DH\ TOU=TON LO/GON <20*DIOGE/NHS>20 OU) KATA\ TH\N AU)TH\N E)RWTA=| LE/CIN, A)LL' W(=DE: "1*(/OQEN E)KPE/MPE-TAI H( FWNH/, KAI\ H( E)/NARQROS, OU)KOU=N KAI\ H( SHMAI/NOUSA E)/NARQROS FWNH\ E)KEI=QEN. TOU=TO DE\ O( LO/GOS. KAI\ LO/GOS A)/RA E)KEI=QEN E)KPE/M-PETAI, O(/QEN KAI\ H( FWNH/. H( DE\ FWNH\ OU)K E)K TW=N KATA\ TH\N KEFALH\N @1 TO/PWN E)KPE/MPETAI, A)LLA\ FANERW=S E)K TW=N KA/TWQEN MA=LLON. E)K-FANH\S GOU=N E)STI DIA\ TH=S A)RTHRI/AS DIECIOU=SA. KAI\ O( LO/GOS A)/RA OU)K E)K TH=S KEFALH=S E)KPE/MPETAI, A)LLA\ KA/TWQEN MA=LLON. A)LLA\ MH\N KA)KEI=NO A)LHQE\S TO\ TO\N LO/GON E)K TH=S DIANOI/AS E)KPE/MPESQAI. E)/NIOI GOU=N KAI\ O(RIZO/MENOI AU)TO\N FASI\N EI)=NAI FWNH\N SHMAI/NOUSAN, A)PO\ DIANOI/AS E)K-PEMPOME/NHN: KAI\ A)/LLWS DE\ PIQANO\N U(PO\ TW=N E)NNOIW=N E)NSESHMASME/NON TW=N E)N TH=| DIANOI/A| KAI\ OI(=ON E)KTETUPWME/NON E)KPE/MPESQAI TO\N LO/GON, KAI\ PAREKTEI/NESQAI TW=| XRO/NW| KATA/ TE TO\ DIANOEI=SQAI KAI\ TH\N KATA\ TO\ LE/GEIN E)NE/RGEIAN. KAI\ H( DIA/NOIA A)/RA OU)K E)/STIN E)N TH=| KEFALH=|, A)LL' E)N TOI=S KATWTE/RW TO/POIS, MA/LISTA/ PWS PERI\ TH\N KARDI/AN."2 TOIOU=TOS ME/NTOI KAI\ O( TOU= *DIOGE/NOUS LO/GOS, E)/MPALIN H)\ KATA\ TO\N TOU= *ZH/NWNOS EI)S MH=KOS R(H/SEWN E)KTETAME/NOS, W(/STE E)KEI/NW| ME\N E)LLEI/PEIN TINA\ TW=N A)NAGKAI/WN A)CIWMA/TWN, PLEONA/ZEIN DE\ TOU/TW|. @&Galen de H. et Plat. dogm. II 8 [1`110]1 p. 246 Mu+.$ OU)/KOUN OU)/TE TOU/TWN TW=N LO/GWN I)SXURO\S OU)DEI/S, OU)/Q' O(/TAN O( <20*DIOGE/NHS>20 EI)/PH|: "1O(\ PRW=TON TROFH=S KAI\ PNEU/MATOS A)RU/ETAI, E)N TOU/TW| U(PA/RXEI TO\ H(GE-MONIKO/N, O(\ DE\ PRW=TON TROFH=S KAI\ PNEU/MATOS A)RU/ETAI, H( KARDI/A."2__ @&ibid.$ *KATA\ TO\N AU)TO\N DE\ TRO/PON KAI\ E(AUTOU= TOI=S LO/GOIS E)XRH/-SATO. "1*TO/, FHSI/, KINOU=N TO\N A)/NQRWPON TA\S KATA\ PROAI/RESIN KINH/SEIS YUXIKH\ TI/S E)STIN A)NAQUMI/ASIS, PA=SA DE\ A)NAQUMI/ASIS E)K TH=S TROFH=S A)NA/GETAI, W(/STE TO\ KINOU=N PRW=TON TA\S KATA\ PROAI/RESIN KINH/SEIS KAI\ TO\ TRE/FON H(MA=S A)NA/GKH E(\N KAI\ TAU)TO\N EI)=NAI."2 O(/TAN TAU=TA O( *DIO-GE/NHS GRA/FH|, PERI\ ME\N TOU= TH\N OU)SI/AN EI)=NAI TH=S YUXH=S A)NAQUMI/ASIN, EI)/T' OU)=N E)K TROFH=S EI)/T' E)K PNEU/MATOS, OU)DE\N E)/N GE TW=| PARO/NTI FH/SOMEN A)MFISBHTEI=N, I(/NA MH\ TA\ PA/NTA LUPW=MEN TO\N A)/NDRA& etc. &@paulo post%10$ *KAI\ AU)TO\S E)PILANQANO/MENOS TW=N OI)KEI/WN DOGMA/TWN AI(=MA/ FHSIN EI)=NAI TH\N YUXH/N, W(S *)EMPEDOKLH=S KAI\ *KRITI/AS U(PE/LABON. EI) DE/ GE E(/POITO <20*KLEA/NQEI>20 KAI\ <20*XRUSI/PPW|>20 KAI\ <20*ZH/NWNI>20, TRE/FESQAI ME\N E)C AI(/MATOS FH/SASI TH\N YUXH/N, OU)SI/AN D' AU)TH=S U(PA/RXEIN TO\ PNEU=MA, PW=S E)/TI TAU)TO\N E)/STAI TO\ TRE/FON KAI\ TO\ KINOU=N, EI)/PER TRE/FEI ME\N TO\ AI(=MA, KINEI= DE\ TO\ PNEU=MA; @&Ae+tius I 7, 17 [1DG p. 302&14b& 15$]1. <20*DIOGE/NHS>20 KAI\ *KLEA/NQHS KAI\ *OI)NOPI/DHS TH\N TOU= KO/SMOU YUXH/N [1&scil.$ QEO\N A)PEFH/NANTO]1. @&Sextus adv. math. IX 133.$ *ZH/NWN DE\ KAI\ TOIOU=TON H)RW/TA LO/GON: "1TOU\S QEOU\S EU)LO/GWS A)/N TIS TIMW/|H: TOU\S DE\ MH\ O)/NTAS OU)K A)/N TIS EU)LO/GWS [2TIMW/|H]2: EI)SI\N A)/RA QEOI/"2. W(=| LO/GW| TINE\S PARABA/LLONTES FASI/: "1TOU\S SOFOU\S A)/N TIS EU)LO/GWS TIMW/|H: TOU\S DE\ MH\ O)/NTAS OU)K A)/N TIS EU)LO/GWS TIMW/|H: EI)SI\N A)/RA SOFOI/."2 O(/PER OU)K H)/RESKE <20TOI=S A)PO\ TH=S *STOA=S>20, ME/XRI TOU= NU=N A)NEURE/TOU O)/NTOS TOU= KAT' AU)TOU\S SOFOU=. @1 A)PANTW=N DE\ PRO\S TH\N PARABOLH\N <20*DIOGE/NHS O( *BABULW/NIOS>20 TO\ DEU/-TERO/N FHSI LH=MMA TOU= *ZH/NWNOS LO/GOU TOIOU=TON EI)=NAI TH=| DUNA/MEI "1TOU\S DE\ MH\ PEFUKO/TAS EI)=NAI OU)K A)/N TIS EU)LO/GWS TIMW/|H."2 TOIOU/TOU GA\R LAMBANOME/NOU DH=LON W(S PEFU/KASIN EI)=NAI QEOI/. EI) DE\ TOU=TO, KAI\ EI)SI\N H)/DH. EI) GA\R A(/PAC POTE\ H)=SAN, KAI\ NU=N EI)SI/N, W(/SPER EI) A)/TOMOI H)=SAN, KAI\ NU=N EI)SI/N. A)/FQARTA GA\R KAI\ A)GE/NHTA TA\ TOIAU=TA/ E)STI KATA\ TH\N E)/NNOIAN TW=N SWMA/TWN: DIO\ KAI\ KATA\ A)KO/LOUQON E)PIFORA\N SUNA/CEI O( LO/GOS: OI( DE/ GE SOFOI\ OU)K E)PEI\ PEFU/KASIN EI)=NAI, H)/DH KAI\ EI)SI/N. @&Philodemus de pietate 15 [1DG p. 548&14b& 14]1.$ <20*D[1I]1OGE/NHS D' O( *BABULW/NIOS E)N TW=| PERI\ TH=S *)AQHNA=S T[1O\]1N>20 K[1O/S]1MON GRA/FEI TW=| *D[1II\ T]1O\N AU)TO\N U(PA/R[1XEI]1N H)\ PERIE/XE[1IN TO\]1N *DI/A K[1AQ]1A/PE[1R]1 A)/NQRWP[1ON Y]1UXH/[1N]1: KAI\ TO\[1N H(/LI]1ON M[1E\N]1 *)APO/LL[1W, T]1H\N D[1E\ SE]1-LH/NH[1N *)/AR]1T[1E]1MI[1N: KAI\]1 P[1AI]1D[1ARIW=]1DES EI)=N[1AI]1 QE[1O]1U\S A)[1N]1QRWPOE[1I]1-DEI=S L[1E/GEI]1N KAI\ A)DU/NATON. [1EI)=]1N[1AI/]1 TE TOU= *DIO\S TO\ ME\N EI)S TH\N QA/LATTAN DIATETA[1K]1O\S *POSEIDW=NA, TO\ D' EI)S [1T]1O\N A)E/RA *(/HRAN, KAQA/PER K[1AI\ TO\N *PLA/]1TWNA LE/GEIN, W(/S[1T' E)]1A\N POLLA/KIS "1A)H/R"2 [1L]1E/GH| TIS E)REI=N "1*(/H[1RA"2, TO\]1 D' EI)S TO\[1N]1 A[2I)Q]2E/RA *)AQHNA=N: TOU=TO GA\R LE/[1GE]1SQAI TO\ "1E)K TH=S [1KEFA]1LH=S"2 KAI\ "1*ZEU\S A)/RRHN *ZEU\S QH=LUS"2. TINA\S DE\ TW=N *STWI+KW=N FA/SKEIN, O(/TI TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N E)N TH=| K[1E]1FALH=|: FRO/NHSIN GA\[1R]1 EI)=NAI, DIO\ KAI\ *MH=TIN KALEI=SQAI: *XRU/SIPPON D' E)N TW=| STH/[1Q]1EI TO\ H(GEMONIKO\N [1E]1I)=NAI KA)KEI= TH\[1N *)AQ]1HNA=N GEGONE/NA[1I]1 FRO/NHSIN OU)=SAN, TW=| [1D]1E\ T[1H\]1N FWNH\N E)K TH=S [1K]1EFALH=S E)KKRI/NESQAI [1LE/]1GEIN E)K TH=S [1K]1EFA[1L]1H=S, U(PO\ DE\ *(H[1F]1AI/S[1TOU DI]1O/TI T[1E/]1XNH[1I GI/]1NEQ' H( FRO/NHSIS, KAI\ *)AQHNA=N ME\N O[1I(=]1ON *)AQ[1RH]1NA=N EI)RH=SQAI, [1*TRITW]1NI/DA DE\ KAI\ *TR[1I-TOGE/N]1EIAN DIA\ TO\ TH\N FRO/NHSIN E)K TRIW=N SUNESTHKE/NAI LO/GWN, TW=[1N]1 F[1USIKW=]1N KAI\ TW=[1N H)]1QIKW=[1N K]1AI\ TW=N LOGIKW=N. KAI\ TA\S A)/LLAS D' AU)T[1H=S PROS]1HGOR[1I/]1AS KAI\ TA\ FORH/MATA MA/LA KATAXRU/SWS TH=| FRO-NH/SEI SUNOIKEIOI=. @&Cicero de nat. deor. I 41.&3 quem [1scil. Chrysippum]1 <21Diogenes &3Babylonius>21 consequens in eo libro qui inscribitur "1de Minerva"2, &3partum Iovis ortumque virginis ad physiologiam traducens diiungit a &3fabula. @&Cicero de divin. I 6.&3 Quem [1scil. Chrysippum]1 subsequens &3unum librum <21Babylonius Diogenes>21 edidit, eius auditor [1scil.$ PERI\ MANTIKH=S]1. @&Cicero de divin. II 90.&3 Quibus [1scil. Chaldaeis]1 etiam <21Dio-&3genes Stoicus>21 concedit aliquid, ut praedicere possint dumtaxat, qualis &3quisque natura et ad quam quisque maxume rem aptus futurus sit; &3cetera quae profiteantur, negat ullo modo posse sciri; etenim geminorum @1 &3formas esse similis, vitam atque fortunam plerumque disparem. Procles &3et Eurysthenes, Lacedaemoniorum reges, gemini fratres fuerunt. At ii &3nec totidem annos vixerunt; anno enim Procli vita brevior fuit; mul-&3tumque is fratri rerum gestarum gloria praestitit. 91. At ego id ipsum, &3quod vir optumus <21Diogenes>21 Chaldaeis quasi quadam praevaricatione &3concedit, nego posse intellegi. @&Cicero de divin. I 84.&3 Hac ratione et Chrysippus et <21Diogenes>21 &3et Antipater utitur [1&Chrys. fr. phys. n. 1192 Vol. II p. 342, 27]1 .. &@Diog. Lae+rt VII 84.$ TO\ DE\ H)QIKO\N ME/ROS TH=S FILOSOFI/AS DIAIROU=SIN [1&ipsam partitionem vide III p. 3, 1]1.$ KAI\ OU(/TW D' U(PODIAI-ROU=SIN OI( PERI\ *XRU/SIPPON__KAI\ <20*DIOGE/NHN>20 &etc. &@Arrianus Epict. dissert. II 19, 13.$ "1TW=N O)/NTWN TA\ ME/N E)STIN A)GAQA/, TA\ DE\ KAKA/, TA\ D' A)DIA/FORA. A)GAQA\ ME\N OU)=N AI( A)RETAI\ KAI\ TA\ METE/XONTA AU)TW=N, KAKA\ DE\ KAKI/AI KAI\ TA\ METE/XONTA KAKI/AS, A)DIA/-FORA DE\ TA\ METACU\ TOU/TWN, PLOU=TOS, U(GI/EIA, ZWH/, QA/NATOS, H(DONH/, PO/NOS."2 PO/QEN OI)=DAS; "1*(ELLA/NIKOS LE/GEI E)N TOI=S *AI)GUPTIAKOI=S."2 TI/ GA\R DIAFE/REI TOU=TO EI)PEI=N H)\ O(/TI <20*DIOGE/NHS>20 E)N TH=| H)QIKH=| H)\ *XRU/SIP-POS H)\ *KLEA/NQHS. @&Cicero de finibus III 33.&3 Bonum autem__etiam definitione &3explicatur. Sed eorum definitiones paulum oppido inter se differunt et &3tamen eodem spectant. Ego assentior <21Diogeni>21, qui bonum definierit &3id, quod esset natura absolutum. Id autem sequens illud etiam quod &3prodesset$ [1W)FE/LHMA &3enim sic appellemus]1 motum aut statum esse dixit &3e natura absoluto. @&Cicero de finibus III 49.&3 Divitias autem <21Diogenes>21 censet &3non eam modo vim habere, ut quasi duces sint ad voluptatem et ad &3valetudinem bonam, sed etiam uti ea contineant; non idem facere eas &3in virtute neque in ceteris artibus, ad quas esse dux pecunia potest, con-&3tinere autem non potest; itaque si voluptas aut si bona valetudo sit in &3bonis, divitias quoque in bonis esse ponendas, at si sapientia bonum sit, &3non sequi ut etiam divitias bonum esse dicamus. Neque ab ulla re, &3quae non sit in bonis, id quod sit in bonis contineri potest, ob eamque &3causam, quia cognitiones comprehensionesque rerum, e quibus efficiuntur &3artes, appetitionem movent, cum divitiae non sint in bonis, nulla ars &3divitiis contineri potest. 50. Quod si de artibus concedamus, virtutis &3tamen non sit eadem ratio, propterea quod haec plurimae commentatio-&3nis et exercitationis indigeat, quod idem in artibus non sit, et quod vir- @1&3tus stabilitatem, firmitatem, constantiam totius vitae complectatur, nec &3haec eadem in artibus esse videamus. @&Cicero de finibus III 57.&3 De bona autem fama [1quam enim &3appellant$ EU)DOCI/AN, &3 aptius est bonam famam hoc loco appellare quam &3gloriam]1 Chrysippus quidem et <21Diogenes>21 detracta utilitate ne digitum &3quidem eius causa porrigendum esse dicebant. @&Epiphanius adv. haeres. III 40 [1DG p. 593, 5]1.$ <20*DIOGE/NHS O( *BABULW/NIOS>20 E)/LEGE TA\ SU/MPANTA SUNI/STASQAI E)C H(DONH=S. @&Stobaeus ecl. II 75, 11 W.$ TO\ DE\ TE/LOS O( ME\N *ZH/NWN OU(/TWS A)PE/DWKE "1TO\ O(MOLOGOUME/NWS ZH=N"2 __OI( DE\ META\ TOU=TON PROS-DIARQROU=NTES OU(/TWS E)CE/FERON__<20*DIOGE/NHS>20 DE\ "1EU)LOGISTEI=N E)N TH=| TW=N KATA\ FU/SIN E)KLOGH=| KAI\ A)PEKLOGH=|."2 @&Diog. Lae+rt. VII 88 [1antecessit Zenonis, Cleanthis, Chrysippi &de fine bonorum explicatio]1.$ O( ME\N OU)=N <20*DIOGE/NHS>20 TE/LOS FHSI\ R(H-TW=S TO\ EU)LOGISTEI=N E)N TH=| TW=N KATA\ FU/SIN E)KLOGH=|. @&Clemens Alex. Stromat. II 21 p. 179 Sylb., I p. 497 Pott.$ [2<20*DIOGE/NHS DE\ O( *BABULW/NIOS TO\ TE/LOS>20]2 E)N TW=| EU)LOGISTEI=N [O(\] E)N TH=| TW=N KATA\ FU/SIN E)KLOGH=| KEI=SQAI U(PELA/MBANEN. @&Stobaeus ecl. II 84, 4 W.$ *TH\N DE\ DO/SIN FHSI\N O( <20*DIOGE/NHS>20 KRI/SIN EI)=NAI, E)F' O(/SON KATA\ FU/SIN E)STI\N H)\ E)F' O(/SON XREI/AN TH=| FU/SEI PARE/XETAI. *TO\ DE\ "1DOKIMASTOU="2, OU)X W(S LE/GETAI TA\ PRA/GMATA DOKI-MASTA\ PARALAMBA/NESQAI, A)LL' W(S DOKIMASTH/N FAMEN EI)=NAI TO\N TA\ PRA/GMATA DOKIMA/ZONTA: TH=S OU)=N A)MOIBH=S TO\N TOIOU=TO/N FHSI DOKIMASTH\N EI)=NAI. *KAI\ TAU/TAS ME\N TA\S DU/O A)CI/AS KAQ' A(\S LE/GOME/N TINA TH=| A)CI/A| PROH=XQAI, TRI/THN DE/ FHSIN EI)=NAI, KAQ' H(/N FAMEN A)CI/WMA/ TINA E)/XEIN KAI\ A)CI/AN, H(/PER PERI\ A)DIA/FORA OU) GI/NETAI, A)LLA\ PERI\ MO/NA TA\ SPOU-DAI=A. *XRH=SQAI D' H(MA=S FHSIN E)NI/OTE TW=| O)NO/MATI TH=S A)CI/AS A)NTI\ TOU= E)PIBA/LLONTOS: W(S E)N TW=| TH=S DIKAIOSU/NHS O(/RW| PAREI/LHPTAI, O(/TAN LE/GH-TAI EI)=NAI "1E(/CIS A)PONEMHTIKH\ TOU= KAT' A)CI/AN E(KA/STW|"2. E)/STI GA\R OI(=ON TOU= E)PIBA/LLONTOS E(KA/STW|. @&Stobaeus ecl. II 64, 13 W.$ *DITTW=S DE/ FHSIN O( <20*DIOGE/NHS>20 LE/GESQAI TA\ DI' AU(TA\ AI(RETA/, [2TA\]2 KAI\ TELIKW=S AI(RETA/, W(S E)/XEI TA\ E)N TH=| PROEIRHME/NH| DIAIRE/SEI KATATETAGME/NA, TA\ DE\ O(/SA E)N AU(TOI=S E)/XEI TH\N AI)TI/AN TOU= AI(RETA\ EI)=NAI, O(/PER PANTI\ A)GAQW=| U(PA/RXEI. @&Cicero de officiis III 50.&3 Sed incidunt, ut supra dixi, saepe @1 &3causae, cum repugnare utilitas honestati videatur, ut animadvertendum &3sit, repugnetne plane an possit cum honestate coniungi. __&`51.&3 In huius &3modi causis aliud <21Diogeni Babylonio>21 videri solet, magno et gravi &3Stoico, aliud Antipatro__Antipatro omnia patefacienda, ut ne quid &3omnino, quod venditor norit, emptor ignoret, <21Diogeni>21 venditorem, qua-&3tenus iure civili constitutum sit, dicere vitia oportere, cetera sine insidiis &3agere et, quoniam vendat, velle quam optume vendere. "1Advexi, exposui, &3vendo meum non pluris quam ceteri, fortasse etiam minoris, cum maior &3est copia. Cui fit iniuria?"2 __&`52.&3 Exoritur Antipatri ratio ex altera &3parte [1cf. Antip. fr.]1. Respondebit <21Diogenes>21 fortasse sic%10"1Aliud est &3celare, aliud tacere; neque ego nunc te celo, si tibi non dico, quae na-&3tura deorum sit, qui sit finis bonorum, quae tibi plus prodessent cognita &3quam tritici vilitas; sed non, quicquid tibi audire utile est, idem mihi &3dicere necesse est."2 "1Immo vero, inquiet ille, necesse est, siquidem me-&3ministi esse inter homines natura coniunctam societatem."2 "1Memini, &3inquiet ille, sed num illa societas talis est, ut nihil suum cuiusque sit? &3Quod si ita est, ne vendundum quidem quicquam est, sed donandum."2 ____&`55.&3 <21Diogenes>21 contra%10 "1Num te emere coe+git, qui ne hortatus &3quidem est? Ille, quod non placebat, proscripsit, tu, quod placebat, emisti. &3Quodsi, qui proscribunt villam bonam beneque aedificatam, non existi-&3mantur fefellisse, etiamsi illa nec bona est nec aedificata ratione, multo &3minus, qui domum non laudarunt. Ubi enim iudicium emptoris est, &3ibi fraus venditoris quae potest esse? Sin autem dictum non omne prae-&3standum est, quod dictum non est, id praestandum putas? Quid vero &3est stultius, quam venditorem eius rei, quam vendat, vitia narrare? quid &3autem tam absurdum, quam si domini iussu ita praeco praedicet%10 Do-&3mum pestilentem vendo."2 @&Seneca de ira III 38, 1.&3 Contumeliam tibi fecit aliquis%10 num-&3quid maiorem quam <21Diogeni>21 philosopho Stoico, cui de ira cum ma-&3xime disserenti adulescens protervus inspuit? Tulit hoc ille leniter et &3sapienter%10 "1non quidem, inquit, irascor, sed dubito tamen, an oporteat &3irasci."2 @&Quintilianus Instit. orat. I 1, 8.&3 de paedagogis hoc amplius, &3ut aut sint eruditi plene____aut se non esse eruditos sciant. ____ &3nec minus error eorum nocet moribus; si quidem Leonides, Alexandri &3paedagogus, ut a <21Babylonio Diogene>21 traditur, quibusdam eum vitiis &3imbuit, quae robustum quoque et iam maximum regem ab illa institu-&3tione puerili sunt persecuta. @&Athenaeus IV 168e.$ <20*DIOGE/NHS D' O( *BABULW/NIOS E)N TOI=S PERI\ *EU)GENEI/AS>20 "1TO\N *FWKI/WNOS UI(O/N, FHSI/, *FW=KON OU)K H)=N O(\S OU)K E)MI/SEI *)AQHNAI/WN. KAI\ O(PO/TE A)PANTH/SEIE/ TIS AU)TW=| E)/LEGEN "3W)= KATAI- @1SXU/NAS TO\ GE/NOS"3. PA/NTA GA\R A)NA/LWSE TA\ PATRW=|A EI)S A)SWTI/AN KAI\ META\ TAU=TA E)KOLA/KEUE TO\N E)PI\ TH=S *MOUNIXI/AS: E)F' W(=| PA/LIN U(PO\ PA/N-TWN E)PER)R(API/ZETO. E)PIDO/SEWN DE/ POTE GINOME/NWN PARELQW\N KAI\ AU)TO\S EI)S TH\N E)KKLHSI/AN E)/FH "3E)PIDI/DWMI KA)GW/"3, KAI\ OI( *)AQHNAI=OI O(MOQUMA-DO\N A)NEBO/HSAN "3EI)S A)KOLASI/AN"3. H)=N D' O( *FW=KOS KAI\ FILOPO/THS. NI-KH/SANTOS GOU=N AU)TOU= I(/PPOIS *PANAQH/NAIA W(S O( PATH\R EI(STI/A TOU\S E(TAI/ROUS, SUNELQO/NTWN EI)S TO\ DEI=PNON LAMPRA\ ME\N H)=N H( PARASKEUH\ KAI\ TOI=S EI)SIOU=SI PROSEFE/RONTO PODONIPTH=RES OI)/NOU DI' A)RWMA/TWN. OU(\S I)DW\N O( PATH\R KALE/SAS TO\N *FW=KON "3OU) PAU/SEIS, E)/FH, TO\N E(TAI=RON DIAFQEI/RONTA/ SOU TH\N NI/KHN"3; @&Athenaeus XII 526c.$ *QEO/POMPOS D' E)N PENTEKAIDEKA/TH| *(ISTO-RIW=N XILI/OUS FHSI\N A)/NDRAS AU)TW=N [1&scil.$ TW=N *KOLOFWNI/WN]1 A(LOURGEI=S FOROU=NTAS STOLA\S A)STUPOLEI=N: O(\ DH\ KAI\ BASILEU=SIN SPA/NION TO/T' H)=N KAI\ PERISPOU/DASTON. I)SOSTA/SIOS GA\R H)=N H( PORFU/RA PRO\S A)/RGURON E)CETAZOME/NH. TOIGAROU=N DIA\ TH\N TOIAU/THN A)GWGH\N E)N TURANNI/DI KAI\ STA/SESI GENO/MENOI AU)TH=| PATRI/DI DIEFQA/RHSAN. TAU)TA\ EI)/RHKEN PERI\ AU)TW=N KAI\ <20*DIOGE/NHS O( *BABULW/NIOS E)N TW=| PRW/TW| TW=N *NO/MWN>20. @&Philodemus de musica p. 5 Kemke.$ KAI\ E)N O)LI/GOIS [1M]1E\N KURI/WN GI/NESQAI TA\S MELE/TAS TW=N [1KA]1TA\ TA\S A)RETA/S. A)NAGKAI=[1ON G]1A\R E)N TOI=S E)LA/TTOSIN KAI\ TOI=S O(MOI/OIS W(/S[1PE]1R STOIXEI[1OU=SQAI: KAI\ TOU=TO SU]1MBAI/NEIN [1DIA\ TH=S MOUSIKH=S. @&Philodemus de musica p. 6 Kemke.$ [1PA/NTWN TA\ ME/LH AU)TH=S TA\ ME\N KALA\ KAI\ SW/FRONA KAI\ A)]1N[1D]1REI=A, T[1A\]1 D[1E\ DEILA\]1 KA[1I\]1 A)KO/-LASTA KAI\ O(/L[1WS]1 A[1I)]1SXRA\ PROSAGOREUO/NTWN, W(S SUNEPIFEROU/SHS TA\S TOIAU/TAS DIAQE/SEIS. OU) GA\R A)\N I)/SWS OU)D' E)FAI/NONTO MH\ OU)=SAI/ GE KA[1T']1 A)LH/QEIAN. OU)D' I)ATRIKW/TERON GOU=N FAI/NESQAI MH\ [1O)/N]1TWN I)ATRI-KW=N, OU)D' I(PPIKW/TERON MH\ [1O)/N]1TWN I(PPIKW=N. @&Philodemus de musica p. 7 ed. Kemke.$ AU)TH\N DE\ KAQ' E(AU-TH\N [1TH\N SU/]1NESIN TOU= TE [1A(]1R[1MONIKOU=]1 KAI\ TOU= R(UQM[1IKOU= O(M]1OLOGW=N EI)=NAI [1PRO\S TH\N PAI]1DEI/AN XRH/SIMON. @&ibidem paulo post%10$ KAI\ TH\N E(/C[1I]1N POI[1H/SEIN A(RM]1ONIKWTA/THN KAI\ [1R(UQMIKW]1TA/THN: E)PIZHTH/[1SANTOS]1 DE/ TINOS, PO/TERON OI)/S[1ETAI/ TIN]1AS @1 A)RETA\S H)\ TI/NAS H( [1MOUSIKH/]1, PROA/GEI *DA/MWNA !!!!!!!! TO\N MOUSIKO\N [1TA\ O(/MOIA]1 SXEDO\N OI)/ESQAI. LE/[1GONTA GA\]1R AU)TO/N, PROSH/KEIN [1A)/|DONT]1A KAI\ KIQARI/ZON[1TA TO\N P]1AI=DA MH\ MO/NON& etc. &@Philodemus de musica p. 8 ed. Kemke.$ [1TO\]1 DE\ KA[1LW=S KAI\]1 XRHSI/MWS KINEI=SQAI/ TE KAI\ H)REMEI=N TW=| SW/MATI TH=S [1GU]1MNASTIKH=S, KAI\ TA\S E)PI\ TOU/TWN TETAGME/NAS AI)SQH/SEIS KRITIKA\S POIEI=N: U(PO\ DE\ TH=S GRAFIKH=S TH\N O)/YIN DIDA/SKESQAI KALW=S KRI/NEIN POLLA\ TW=N O(RATW=N: TH=S DE\ MOUSIKH=S TO\ ME\N A)NAGKAI=ON H)=[1TTON]1 TOU/TWN E)/XEIN [1DOKOU/-SHS]1 &etc. &@Philodemus de musica p. 8 Kemke [1refert <21Diogenis Baby-&lonii>21 de musica opiniones]1.$ TA\ KATA\ TA\S O)[1RGA\S]1 KAI\ TA\ M[1E]1Q' [1H(]1DO-NH=S KAI\ [1LU/]1PHS E)NTUG[1XA/NONTA KOINW=S, E)]1PEIDH\ TW=N OI)KEI/WN D[1IAQE/S]1EWN OU)K E)/CWQEN A)LL' E)[1N H(]1MI=N E)/XOMEN TA\S AI)TI/AS: [1TW=N]1 DE\ KOINW=N EI)=NAI/ TI KAI\ [1TH\N]1 MOUSIKH/N: PA/NTAS GA\R *(/ELLHNA/S TE KAI\ BARBA/ROU[1S AU)]1TH=| XRH=SQAI KAI\ KATA\ [1PA=]1SAN, W(S EI)PEI=N, H(LIKI/AN: [1H)/DH]1 GA\R PRO\ TOU= LOGISMO\N E)/[1XEIN]1 KAI\ SU/NESIN A(/PTESQA[1I TH\N]1 MOUSIKH\N DU/NAMIN [1PAI-DIKH=S]1 H(=STINOS [1OU)=N YUXH=S]1 &etc. &@Philodemus de musica p. 9 Kemke.$ NO/MON QE[2I=]2SIN, PA/[1N-TAS]1 AU)TH=| XRH=S[1QA]1I KAI\ MH[1DE/N]1A [1KAIN]1OTOMEI=N, TH\N DE\ N[1U=N E)PIP]1O-L[1A/]1ZOUSAN DIA/QESIN A)P' [1AU)TH=S]1 A)FESTHKE/NAI. K[1AI\ TOU\S]1 DEIQURAM-BIKOU\S DE\ TRO/P[1O]1US EI)/ TIS SUGKRI/NAI, TO/N TE KATA\ *PI/NDARON KAI\ TO\N KATA\ *FILO/CENON, MEGA/LHN EU(REQH/SESQAI TH\N DIAFORA\N TW=N E)PIFAINO-ME/NWN H)QW=N, TO\N D' AU)TO\N EI)=NAI LO/GON KAI\ PERI\ TW=N A)/LLWN TRO/PWN [1O(POI/]1WN DH/ TINWN.& v. 20$ XRW=MA. @&Philodemus de musica p. 10 Kemke.$ _XRO/NON, KATARCAME/[1NWN]1 TW=N *MANTINE/WN TE KAI\ *LA[1KE]1DAIMONI/WN [1KAI\ *PEL]1LA[1NE/]1WN: PARA\ TOU/TOIS GA\R KA[1I\ PR]1W/TOIS KAI\ MA/LISTA TH\N A)KRIBESTA/THN E)PIME/[1LEIAN]1 GENE/SQAI TW=N TOI[1OU/TWN]1 E)PITHDEUMA/TWN [1KAI\ TH=S]1 A)/LLHS MOUSIKH=S. @&ibidem.$ TOIAU/THS D' OU)=N [1GENOM]1E/NHS A)GWGH=S KAI\ [1SUNA]1QROIZO-ME/NHS POL[1LH=S K]1AI\ GENNAI/AS S?POU[1DH=S OU(/T]1WS W(/STE KAI\ OI)KEI[1WQH=NA]1I/ TE KAI\ A(/YASQAI !!!!EWS TH\N TOIAU/THN [1A)GWGH/]1N, OU)KE/TI KATALEI/PEI XW/RAN TOI=S E)NANTIWQE[2I=]2SIN, OU)X U(PA/RCEIN TO\ PARADECO/MENON [1E(/NE]1KA TW=N E)QW=N TE [1KAI\ QE]1MA/TWN &etc. &@Philodemus de musica p. 11 Kemke.$ SU[1NWMOLOG]1HKE/NAI D' AU)TW=|, TA\ ME\[1N AU)TO]1FUOU=S AI)SQH/SEWS DE[1I=S]1QAI, TA\ D' E)PISTHMONIKH=S, TA\ [1Q]1ERMA\ ME\N KAI\ TA\ [1Y]1UXRA\ T[1H=S AU)]1TOFUOU=S, TO\ D' H(RMOSME/N[1ON]1 KAI\ A)NA/RMOSTON TH=S E)P[1ISTH]1MONIKH=S: [1E(]1TE/RAN DE\ TH=| [1TOI]1AU/TH| SU[1N- @1E]1ZEUGME/NH[1N KA]1I\ PARAKOLOUQOU=SAN W(S [1E)PI\ T]1O\ POLU/, DI' H(=S DEXO/MEQA [1TH\N P]1AREPOME/NHN [H(DON[1H\N] E(K]1A/STW| TW=N AI)SQHTW=N [1H(DON]1H/N TE [1KAI\ LU/]1PHN, OU)=SAN [1OU) PA=SI]1 TH\N AU)TH/N. OU(= GA\R A)\N [1A)NA]1MEIXQW=SIN DU/O AI)SQH/SEIS, [1PERI\]1 ME\N TO\ U(PO[1K]1EI/[1M]1ENON SUM[1F]1WNEI=[1N]1, OI(=ON O(/TI !!HGON H)\ A[1U)ST]1HRO/N, PERI\ DE\ TH\N [1P]1AREP[1OME/N]1HN H(DONH/N [1T]1E KAI\ L[1U/PHN]1 DIAFWNEI=N [1E)N]1A[1RGW=S]1. @&Contra haec disputat Philodemus lib. IV p. 62sq. Kemke%10$ KA)=|TA POI=[1ON]1 TO\ U([1PO\ A)/L]1L[1H]1S DUNA/MEWS PERI\ TH\N AI)/SQHSIN KATALAMBA/-NESQ[1A]1I TA\S POIO/THTAS W(=N A)NTILAMBA/NONTAI, KAI\ TA\S H(D[1ONA\]1S KAI\ O)XLH/SEIS TA\S [1A)]1P' AU)TW=N, TH=S ME\N AU)TOFUOU=S, TH=S D' E)PISTHMONI[1KH=]1S: U(P[1O\ G]1A\R AU)TOFUOU=S KAI\ [1A)L]1O/GOU KREI/NETA[1I DUNA/MEWS H( POI]1O/THS AU)TH\ K[1AQ' AU(TH/N: U(PO\ D' E)P]1ISTHMONI[1KH=S TO\ PRO\S H(MA=S A)P' E)KEI/]1NOU MA=LLON; O[1U) MAXO/MENON T]1OI=S E)NARGE/SIN [1KAI\ DIEYEUSME/N]1ON PRO[1X]1EI-RO/TA[1TA; KA]1TA\ LO/GON D[1E\]1 KAI\ TO\ [1E)PI\ TOU/TW| O(/MOI]1ON, O(/ FHSIN E)NAR[1G]1E\S EI)=NA[1I, EI)/LH]1PTAI: [2AI(]2 PARAP[1LH/]1SIOI GA\[1R]1 AI)SQ[1H/SEIS]1 KATA\ T[1H\]1N DIA/QE[1S]1IN OU)[1X]1 O(/TI ME\N [1AU)S]1THRO\N TO\ U([1POKE]1I/MENON O(MOLOGOU=S[1IN, EI) D']1 O)XLHRW=S H)\ E)PITERPW=S [1E)/X]1EI DIAFWNOU=SIN, A)LLA\ TH\N AU)TH\N POI-OU=NTAI KRI/SIN. KAI\ E)PI\ ME/N GE TOU/TW[1N]1 PARA/ TINAS PRODIAQE/SEIS E)NDE/XETAI PARALLATTOU/SAS SUMBAI/NEIN E)PAISQH/SEIS, E)PI\ DE\ TW=N A)KOW=N OU)D' E)/STIN O(/LWS DIAFORA/ TIS, A)LLA\ PA=SAI TA\S O(MOI/AS TW=N O(M[1OI/]1WN MELW=N A)NTI[1LH/Y]1EIS POIOU=NTAI KAI\ TA\S H(DONA\S PARAPLHSI/OUS A)POLAM-BA/NOUSIN, W(/STE KAI\ TH=S E)NA[1R]1MONI/OU KAI\ TH=S XRWMATIKH=S DIAFE/RONTAI [1O]1U) KATA\ TH\N A)/LOGON E)PA[1I/S]1QHSIN A)LLA\ KATA\ TA\S DO/[1CAS]1, OI( ME/N, W(/SPER OI( TOU/TW| [1P]1ARAPLH/S[1IOI]1, TH\N M[1E\N]1 FA/[1SKO]1NTES EI)=NAI SEMNH\N KA[1I\ GEN]1NAI/AN KAI\ [1A(P]1LH=N KAI\ [1KAQ]1ARA/N, TH\N [1D' A)/]1NANDRON [1KAI\ FO]1RTIKH\N KA[1I\]1 A)NELEU/QERON. OI( DE\_OI( DE\_: TA\ D' A)NA/[1L]1O[1G]1A KAI\ E)PI\ TW=N R(UQMW=N [1K]1A[1I\]1 MELOPOI+W=N: KAI\ [1P]1RO/[1DHLO/N]1 E)STIN W(S H( MOUSIKH/, KA)\N [1H(]1 POLUE[1I]1DESTA/TH KA[1Q' A(/PAN DIAFORA\ A(L]1W=I PROSOU=SA [1AU)]1TH=I, TW=N [1H)]1QW=N E)[1M]1F[1A/]1SEIS OU)DE/POTE [1PO]1IH/SE[1I OU)D' A)/LLWN %5 A)/L-LWS KATA\ TH\N DIA/QESIN TA\S %5 A)KOA\S KINH/SEI]1 A(/TE A)PARA[1L]1LA/KTOU[1S K]1AQESTW/SAS. KAI\ DIA\ TOU=[1TO]1 ZHTW=N MOUSIKO\S TH\N TOIAU/THN SU/NESIN, H(=| DUNH/SETAI DIAGINW/SKEIN, AI( POI=AI TW=N AI)SQH/SEWN PW=S DIATEQH/SON-TAI, TW=N A)NUPA/RKTWN E)PISTH/MHN ZHTEI= KAI\ T[1A\]1 PRO\S TOU=TO KENW=S PARADI/DWSIN. @&Philodemus de musica p. 12 Kemke.$ [1DU/NASQAI GA\R TH\N MOU-SIKH\N A)KEI/NHTON YUXH\N KAI\ H(SUXA/ZOUSAN E)GEI/REIN KAI\ A)/G]1EIN EI)S TOI-AU/THN DIA/Q[1ESIN OI(/]1AN AU)TH=| KINHQH=NAI [1KATA\ FU/]1SIN E)STI\N U(PO\ TH=S @1 PRO[1SHKOU/]1SHS MELWDI/AS: E)PEI\ O[1U) PA/N]1TES O(MOI/WS KINHQH/S[1ONTAI]1 PRO\S TH=S AU)TH=S: H)\ TOU)[1NANTI/]1ON E)C A)TTOU/SHS TE KAI\ [1FERO]1ME/NHS PRO\S [1O(/, T]1I DH\ [1PRA]1U/+NEIN TE KAI\ EI)S H)REM[1I/AN]1 KA]1Q[1IS]1TA/NEIN H)\ METAKE[1INEI=N]1 KAI\ A)POSTRE/FEIN PRO\[1S A)/L]1LHN O(RMH\N A)P' A)/LLH[1S H)\ TH\N]1 U(PA/RXOUSAN A)/GEIN D[1IA/QESIN]1 EI)S AU)/CHSIN H)\ E)LA/TT[1WSIN]1. @&idem lib. IV p. 65 Kemke.$ E)PEIDH/PER OU)DE\N ME/LOS KAQO\ ME/LOS, A)/LOGON U(PA/RXON, YUXH\N OU)/T' E)C A)KEINH/TOU KAI\ H(SUXAZOU/S[1HS]1 E)[1G]1EI/REI KAI\ A)/GEI PRO\S TH\N KAT[1A\ F]1U/SIN E)N H)/[1Q]1EI DIA/QESIN, OU)/T' E)C A)[1T]1TOU/SHS KAI\ FEROME/NHS P[1RO\S O(/T]1I DH/POTE PRA[1U/+]1NEI KAI\ EI)S H)REMI/AN KAQI/STHSIN, OU)D' A)P' A)/LLHS O(RMH=S E)P' A)/LLHN A)POSTRE/F[1EIN]1 OI(=O/N [1T' E)STI\]1N OU)DE\ TH\N U(PA/RXOU[1SA]1N DIA/QESIN EI)S AU)/CHSIN A)/GEIN KAI\ E)LA/TTWSIN. @&Philodemus de musica p. 12 Kemke.$ KAQO/LOU ME\N !!!!!!!!!! PA=SAN MOUSIKH\N !!!!!!!! [1&post duos versus$]1 DE\ EI) MIMHTI[1KO\N !!! &etc. @&idem lib. IV p. 65.$ OU)DE\ GA\R MIMHTIKO\N H( MOUSIKH/, KAQA/PER TINE\S O)NEIR[1W/TT]1OUSIN, OU)D', [1W(S O]1U(=TOS, O(M[1OI]1O/[1T]1H[1TA]1S H)QW=N OU) MIMHTIKA\S ME\[1N E)/X]1EI, PA/NTWS DE\ PA/SA[1S TW=N H)]1QW=N POIO/THTAS E)P[1I-FA]1I/NE[1I]1 TOIAU/TAS E)NAR[1GW=S]1, T[1O\]1 MEGA[1L]1OPREPE\S KAI\ TAPEINO\N KAI\ A)NDRW=DES KAI\ A)/NANDRON KAI\ K[1O/S]1MION KAI\ QRASU/, M[1A=]1LLON H)/PER H( MAGEIRIKH/. [1DI]1O/PER OU)DE\ KAQ' AU(TA\S E)/[1XOUSI]1 DIAFO/RWS OU)DE\ KATA\ TH\N [1A)]1LLH/LAIS MEI=CIN: OU)DE\ TA\S E)NANTI/AS A)LLH/LAIS DIAQE/SEIS, O(/SON E)PI\ TOI=[1S]1 PRO\S A)KOH\N E)PAISQH/MASIN [1DI' A(R]1M[1O]1N[2I]2W=N E)/STIN DHMI-O[1U]1RG[1EI=N]1. A(\ DE\ LE/GEI PRO\S %5 !!!!!!!!!ASQAI KI/NHSIN %17 [1E)N]1 A)/LLW| TO/PW| KATOY[1O/MEQA. @&Philodemus de musica p. 12 Kemke.$ <20E)N DE\ TW=| TRI/TW|>20 MA-KRO/TERA ME\N EI)/RHKE KAI\ MA/LISTA PER[1I\ T]1H=S PRO\S TO\ DAIMO/NION MOUSI-KH=S, OU)K A)PODEIKTIKW=S A)LL' I(STORIKW=S KAI\ E)CHGHTIKW=S, A)RKE/SEI DE\ TH\N SUGKEFALAI/WSIN E)PITEMEI=N. K]1AI\ T[1H\]1N E)/NNOMO/N TE KAI\ S[1P]1OU[1DAZO-M]1E/NHN MOUSIKH\N PRW=[1TA]1 ME/N FHSIN E(/NEKA TH=S PRO\S TO\ QEI=ON SUN-TAXQH=NAI TEIMH=S, E)/PEITA TH=S TW=N E)LEUQE/RWN PAIDEI/AS: O(/TI DE\ PRO\S T[1O\]1 QE[1I=ON]1, KAI\ AU)TA\ SHMAI/NEIN TA\ O)NO/MATA, TO/ TE QEWREI=N [1KAI\ TO\]1N QEATH\N [1KAI\ T]1O\ QE/ATRON. @&Idem lib. IV p. 66.$ PERI\ TOI/NUN TH=S DIA\ T[1W=N MOU]1SIKW=N [1T]1OU= QEI/OU TEI[1MH=S EI)/RH]1TAI ME\N AU)TA/RKWS KAI\ PRO/TERON__ _DIO/PER OU)D[1E\]1 SUNA/GETA[1I]1 TO\ TOI=S KATA\ ME/ROS AU)TH\N XRHSIMEU/EIN, A)LL' EI)/PER A)/RA [1T]1W=[1I]1 DHMOSI/W|: KAI\ TOU/TW| D' OU)/TE PA=N EI)=DOS AU)TH=S OU)/TE O(/SON POTE\ PAR[1ALAM]1BA/NETAI DIAPEPOI[1KILME/N]1O[1N]1, A)[1L]1LA\ [1O(]1PO/[1SON]1 LIT[1O/-TERON]1: KAI\ OU)X U(PO\ PA/NTW[1N A)LL']1 U(PO\ TINW=N *(ELLH/N[1WN KA]1I\ KATA\ E)NI/OUS KAIROU\S KAI\ [1TO/ GE]1 NU=N DIA\ MISQWTW=[1N A)NQR]1W/PW[1N. __ _ @1 A)LLA\ DH\ KAI\ PA/LAI TW=N G' *)OLUM[1PI/WN]1 H( PLEI/STH D[1O/]1SIS OU)[1XI\]1 TW=[1N]1 MELW=N KA[1I\]1 T[1W=]1N K[1R]1OU/SEWN [1H)=N, OU)DE\]1 TOU= QEWRE[1I=]1N [1KAI\ T]1OU= Q[1EATOU=]1 KA[1I\ TO]1U= Q[1EA/T]1RO[1U]1: KAI/[1TOI]1 W)NOMA/SQAI [1F]1H/SEI[1EN]1 A)/N TIS KAI\ A)PO\ TOU= QEI=N TO\ QEWREI=N KAI\ TO\N QEATH\N [1K]1AI\ TO\ QE/ATRO[1N]1: OU) GA\R E)PIKOINWNEI= TO\ QEI=ON AU)TOI=S MA=LLON H)\ TO\ QEI=N: KAI\ TA\ QEA/-MATA SUNA/GESQAI TH=S TIMH=S E(/NEKA PA[1REILH=]1FQAI TW=N QEW=N, A)LL' OU) TH\N MOUSIKH/N, A)KOUSTH/N G' U(PA/RXOUSAN: MA=LLON D' A)PO\ TOU= TAI=S O)/YES[1IN]1 O(RA=N KAI\ TH=| DIANOI/A| PROSHGOREU=SQAI TAU=TA. @&Philodemus de musica p. 67 Kemke.$ E)PEI\ DE\ A)POXRW/NTWS KAI\ PERI\ TOU= DIA\ MOUSIKH=S PAIDEU/ESQAI LE/LEKTAI, <20PERI\ TW=N E)[1G]1KWMI/WN>20 AU)TA\ TAU=T' EI)/PWMEN, O(/TI KAI\ U(PO\ TW=N POIHMA/TWN E)GI/NETO, A)LL' OU)X U(PO\ TW=N KATA\ MOUSIKH\N TH\N NU=N E)CETAZOME/NHN. __ _<20EI)S DE\ TOU\S GA/MOUS>20 KAI\ MA/GEIROI KAI\ DHMIO[1UR]1GOI\ PARALAMBA/NONTAI, KAI\ TA\ POI-H/MAT' E)STI/N, OU)X H( MOUSIKH/, <20TA\ TH\N EI)RHME/NHN U(P' AU)TOU= PARE-XO/MENA XREI/AN E)N TOI=S U(MENAI/[1OI]1S>20: KAI\ BRAXEI=A/ TIS A)PARXH\ TOU= GE/NOUS E)GI/NETO KAI\ PARA\ TISI/N, A)LL' OU)X A(/PASIN, KAI\ TOI=S GAMOU=SIN, OU)[1X]1I\ KAI\ TOI=S A)/L[1L]1OIS, EI) DH\ KAI\ GA/MOS A(PLW=S A)GAQO\N A)\N LE/GOITO. __KAI\ MH\N [1<20TO/]1 GE E)RWTIKO\N PA/QO>20[1S OU)/Q']1 O(/SION A)LL[1A\__ _EI)/]1RH[1T]1AI DE\ KAI\ U(PO\ TOU/TOU TARA[1X]1W=DES U(PA/R[1X]1EIN: <20OU)/Q' A(\ GI/NE[1S]1QAI/ FHSI>20, DIA\ MOUSIKH=S SUN[1T]1ELEI=T' A)LL' U(PO\ TW=N POIHMA/-[1T]1WN, OU)/TE BOHQEI=TAI DIA\ [1M]1OUSIKH=S KAI\ POIHTIKH=S E)/RWS [1A)]1LL' U(PO\ TW=N PLEI/STWN KA[1I\]1 [1T]1OI=S PLEI/STOIS E)KKA/ETAI. KA[1I\ T]1A\ <20GI/NESQAI D' E)N TOI=S E)RWTI[1K]1OI=S U(PO\ TOU/TOU LEGO/MENA>20 PARI/STHSIN E(KA/TE-RON, E)FISTA[1M]1E/NOU DE\ L[1O/G]1O[1U]1 KAI\ PANTA/PASI. KAI\ <20TOU\S Q[1RH/]1NOUS>20 ME/NTOI POI[1H/]1MAT' EI)=NAI SUMBE/[1B]1HKE KAI\ TOI=S O(/LOIS OU)[1D]1E\N I)ATREU/EIN TH=S LU/PHS, A)LL' E)NI/OTE KAI\ E)PI/SXEI[1N]1, TA\ POLLA\ DE\ E)PITEI/NEIN, KAI\ DH\ [1P]1RO\S TOU=TO TW=N [1G]1RAFO/N[1T]1WN A(M[1IL]1LWME/NWN, EU)[1PA/QEI]1AN DE\ KAI\ EU)SXHMOSU/NHN E)K [1T]1OU/[1TWN]1 MH\ PA[1R]1A[1K]1OLOUQ[1E]1I=N, A)[1LL]1A\ T[1OU)]1NAN-TI/ON, EI)S U(PER[1BOLH\]1N E)KKALOUME/NWN, [1MO]1USIKH=S [1H)=QO]1S OU)D' E)PIDEXO-ME/NHS. @&Philodemus de musica p. 14 Kemke.$ NO/MO]1US, TO/N TE PERI\ TA\S PO[1LEMIKA\S]1 E)NERGEI/AS KAI\ TO\N [1PERI\ TA\S]1 GUMNASTIKA\S KAI\ A)[1QLH-TIK]1A\S TO\ ME\N PALAIO\[1N E)PI\ P]1LEI=ON, NU=N D' E)P' E)/LATTO[1N. KOI]1NH=| ME\N GA\R PRO\S TA\S PO[1LEMI]1KA\S TOI=S E)N TH=| SA/LPI[1GGI]1 KAI\ NU=N TO\ POLU\ PLH=QOS [1TW=N *(E]1LLH/NWN XRH=SQAI, TI[1NA\S]1 DE\ KAI\ T[1W=]1I DIA\ TW=N AU)[1L]1W=N: PRO\S DE\ TA\S A)QLH/SEIS [1KAI\]1 TH=| SA/LPIGGI SHMAI/[1NEIN T]1O\N POLEMIKO\N NO/M[1ON, O(/NTI]1N' [1A)\N]1 E)/XWSIN, E)PI\ TO\ [1POLU/: E)N]1 TOI=S DE\ PENTA/QLOIS [1E)S T]1H\N A(/LSIN KAI\ TO\N DI/[1AULO]1N AU)LW=| PEPOIH=SQAI [1KAI\ PR]1O\S TH\[1N]1 XEI- @1RONOMI/AN [1DE\ AU)LEI=SQAI]1 TO\ O(MW/NUMON [1ME/LOS. *)ARGEI/O]1US DE\ KAI\ PRO\S [1TH\N P]1A/LHN [1PROS]1A/GEIN TO\N AU)[1LO/N]1. @&Idem lib. IV p. 69.$ A)L[1L]1A\ MH\N I(KANA\ [1KAI\ P]1ERI\ TH=[1S P]1<20RO\S TO[1U\S]1 POLE/[1MOUS>20 S]1UNER[1G]1I/AS P[1R]1O[1GE/]1GRAPTA[1I: __<20TO\ [1D]1E\ TW=N A)QLHMA/[1T]1WN GE/[1N]1OS>20 OU)/Q' U(PO\ PA/[1NT]1WN E)PA[1SKEI=]1TAI, KOIN[1H\]1N [1D']1 H(MEI=S [1E)PI]1ZHTOU=MEN EU)XRHSTI/AN [1KA]1I\ KAQ' E(/KASTON [1&ex sequenti-&bus nihil de Diogenis sententiis colligi potest]1. &@Philodemus de musica p. 14 Kemke.$ PROSH=XQ[1AI]1 DE\ TH\N MOUSIKH\N KAI\ PR[1O\S T]1A\S XORIKA\S [1O)RXH/]1SEIS TW=N TE GUMNOPAI[1DIK]1W=N KAI\ TW=N E)NO/PLWN TOU/TWN DRAMATIKW=N, TRAGIKH=S KAI\ SATURIKH=S KAI\ KWMIKH=S. TH\N ME\N OU)=N KALLI/[1STHN]1 TOU/TWN TH\N TRAGIKH\N!!!!!!!!! E(K]1ATE/RWN!!!! %5 !!!!!!!!!TH\]1N DE\ SATURIKH/N. @&Idem lib. IV p. 70.$ KAI\ DIO/TI PERIH|RHME/[1N]1HS [1T]1H=S O)RXH/SEWS E)K TW=N DRAMA/TWN OU)DE\N E)/XOMEN E)/LATTON, E)PEIDH/PER O[1U)]1DE\N H)=N E)N OU)DE-MIA=| PRO\S TO\ KALO\N KAI\ GENNAI=ON SUNE/RGHMA. TAI=S DE\ QHLEI/AIS EI) KAI\ TA\ P[1O]1H/MATA KA[1T]1A\ TO\ SUNE/XON E)POH/QH, TOSOU=TON A)[1P]1E/XW TOU= XRH/-SIMO/N TI N[1O]1MI/ZEIN PER[1I]1GI/NESQAI DIA\ MOUSIKH=S PRO\S GENNAIO/THTA K[1A]1I\ SWFROSU/NHN KAI\ EU)TACI/AN, W(/STE KA[1I\]1 LEI/AN E)PISFALE\S PEI/QOMA[1I]1 KAI\ U(/POPTON TO\ D[1I/]1DAG[1M]1A, [1M]1H/ POTE POLLH\N A)FORMH\N DIDW=| PRO\S A)KO-LASI/A[1N]1 KAI\ [1A)T]1ACI/AN [1B]1AKXEU/OUSA[1N]1, W(=N U(POMNH/SW POU PROBAI/NWN. @&Philodemus de musica p. 15 Kemke.$ TA\ MANTEUO/MENA TW=N OI)KEI/WN A)/NWQEN [1E)/XEIN]1 FU/SEI TO\ ME/LOS K[1INHTIKO/]1N TI KAI\ PARASTA-[1TIKO\]1N PRO\S TA\S PRA/CEIS, [1KAI\ M]1EMUQEU=SQAI/ G' *)OR[1FE/A QE/LC]1AI TA\S PE/TRAS, K[1INEI=N DE\ O]1U)K E)KEI/[1N]1AS A)LLA\ [1TOU\S PO]1NOU=NTAS PARI/STA[1SQAI: D]1IO\ KAI\ *PTOLEMAI=ON [1KEL]1EU=SAI TOI=S A)DUNATOU=[1SIN]1 KAQELKU/SA[1I]1 KE/-LEU[1SMA P]1ROSAULEI=N *)ISMHNI/[1AN]1. @&Idem lib. IV p. 70.$ NU=N]1 DE\ [1M]1ETABA\S LE/GW DIO/[1TI TW=N S]1UN-HGME/NWN U(PO\ *DIO[1GE/NO]1U[1S TO\ A)/N]1WQEN [1A)]1EI\ [1TO\]1 ME/LOS E)/XEIN TI KINH-TI[1KO\N KAI\ P]1A[1R]1ASTATIKO\N PR[1O\]1S [1TA\S PRA/]1CEIS, [1E]1I) ME\N U(PO\ TH=[1S PRON]1OI/AS EI)SH=XQAI/ FH[1SI T]1OU/T[1OU]1 XA/[1RI]1N, OU)K E[1U)/]1KA[1IRO/N E)STIN]1 E)CETA/ZEIN, EI) D', W(S TO\ PU=R FU/[1S]1EI KAUSTIKO\N TW=| FU/SIN E)/XEIN KAUSTI-KH\N PR[1O]1SAGO[1REU/]1OMEN, OU(/TW KA[1I\ TO\]1 ME/LOS A)CIOI=, [1N]1A[1I\]1 M[1A\]1 *DI/A M[1E/]1GA YEU/DETA[1I. __ _PRO\S D' OU)=N TH\N U(PO/[1NO]1IAN TH\N OU(/TW KWFH\N [1E)/]1OIKEN E)PESPA/SQAI TO\ TOI=S E)LA[1U/]1NOUSIN E)N TAI=S NAUSI\N KAI\ TOI=S QERI/ZOUSIN PA/LAI KAI\ TO\N OI)=NON E)RGAZOME/NOIS KAI\ POLLOI=S A)/LLOIS TW=N E)PI/PO[1N]1A SUNT[1E]1LOU/N[1T]1WN E)/RGA TW=N O)RGA/NWN TINA\ PARA[1ZE]1U[1G]1-NU/EIN: O(\ KAI\ *PTOLEMAI=O[1N]1 OU(=[1T]1OS GRA/FEI PEPOIHKE/NAI TO[1I=S]1 KAQE/L-KOUSIN. __ _[1K]1A)\[1N]1 TO\N *)ORFE/A [1MH\ D]1IA\ [1T]1H\[1N E)CO]1XH\N TH=S @1 E)M[1M]1EL[1EI/AS U(P]1AK[1OU/]1WMEN MEMUQ[1E]1U=SQ[1AI]1 KA[1I\]1 TOU\[1S L]1I/Q[1O]1US KAI\ [1TA\ DE/ND]1RA Q[1E/L]1GEIN, W(S KAI\ N[1U=N H(MEI=S]1 EI)W/QAMEN U(PE[1R]1BO[1LIKW=S]1 LE/GEIN, A)LLA\ TOI=S TRIHRA[1U/]1LAIS, <20W(/SPER O( *STWI+KO/S>20, A)NA[1LO/G]1WS [1E)]1F[1E]1STW=TA POIW=MEN [1OI)]1KODO/MOIS, DIA\ TAU=TA FH/SOMEN, [1OU) DI]1A\ TA\ TOU/TOU LHRH/[1MA]1TA. @&Philodemus de musica p. 15 ed. Kemke.$ [1OU)]1 MO/NON DE\ TA\S YUXA\S [1DIATIQ]1E/NAI PWS, A)LLA\ KAI\ [1TA\ SW/M]1ATA. PAIDO\S GOU=N A[1U)L]1-OU=NTOS [1K]1AI/ TI ME/LOS MOUSIKO\N [1DIAPERAI/NONTOS]1 TO\ PRO/SW[1PON &etc. &@Idem lib. IV p. 72.$ XA/RIEN D[1E\]1 T[1O\]1 MH\ MO/N[1ON]1 FA/NAI [1T]1A\S YUXA\S DIATIQE/[1N]1AI PWS TO\ ME/LOS [2A)LLA\]2 KAI\ TA\ SW/MATA, KAQA/PER PR[1OS]1-EPITE[1I/]1NONTA__DIO\ KAI\ [1PRO/TERON ME\N]1 E)X[1RH=N]1 TO\ SW=[1M]1A DI[1A-TEQEI]1ME/NON E)PIDEI/CANTA TO\ PA[1RA]1DOC[1O/T]1ERON E)PIFE/REIN "1OU) MO/NON DE\ TO\ SW=MA"2 LE/GONT' "1[1A)L]1LA\ KAI\ TH\N YUXH/N PWS DI[1A]1TI/QHSIN."2 OU) MH\N A)LLA\ QAU/MATOS A)/CION, PW=S E)C OU(= LE/[1G]1EI DEI/KNUTAI TO\ KAI\ TA\ SW/MATA. TO\ GA\R [1P]1RO/SWPON TW=[1I E)]1SXHMATIS[1M]1E/NWI TO\ TW=N A)|D[1O/N]1-TWN E)[1K]1EI/NHSE KAI\ PARE/STHSE PRO\S TH\N E)NE/RGEIAN TH=S W)|DH=S, OU) TO\ ME/LOS E)KI/NH[1S]1EN TO\ SW=MA KAI\ DIE/QHKE/ PWS, EI) MH\ ME/LOS E)[1S]1TI\N O( SXHMATISMO/S. @&Philodemus de musica lib. IV p. 73 Kemke.$ TO\ DE\ TO\N ZW-[1GR]1A/FON E)PITUXEI=N TH=S O([1MO]1IO/THTOS, O(/T' H)=|SEN O( K[1I]1QARW|[1D]1O/S, U(PO\ ME\N TOU= ME/LOUS TH\N E)PITUXI/AN !EL!I POI%5EI=N, A)LLA\ TH=[1S YUX]1H=S AU(/TH E)[1S]1TI\ MA=LLON H)/P[1E]1R H( [1T]1W=[1N K]1AQELKO/NTWN: I)SXU\N GA\R E)MFA[1I/N]1EI PROSEILHFO/TAS, O(/PER E)STI\N SW[1M]1ATIKO/N: W(/ST' E)XRH=N E)NHLL[1A]1XE/NAI KAI\ DIA\ M[1E\]1N TOU= Z[1W]1GRA/FOU TO\ TH\N YUXH\N [1K]1IN[1EI=]1SQA[1I]1 PROSBIBA/ZEIN, DIA\ DE\ TW=[1N]1 KAQELKO/NTWN TO\ KAI\ [1TA\]1 SW/MATA. A)/LLWS D' E)PEZH/THSEN A)/N TIS U([1P]1ERHDE/WS, TI/ TH=S W)|DH=S S[1U]1MBALLOME/NHS O(/MOI[1O]1N E)/GRAYEN, A)[1D]1UNATW=N PRO/TERON: OU) GA\R DH\ KAI\ TEXNIKWTE/ROUS [1GE P]1OIEI=N TO\ [1ME/]1LOS E)[1N]1O/MI[1SE]1N, H)\ MAKA/RIO[1S]1 H)=N [1T]1H=S S[1UN]1E/SEWS. @&Philodemus de musica lib. IV p. 74 Kemke.$ O( D' E)PA/[1G]1EI TOI=S [1Q]1AU/[1M]1ASIN TOU/TOIS A)/LLA TE/RATA, KINHTIKO\N LE/G[1WN]1 MA=[1LL]1ON EI)=NAI TH=S [1L]1OGI[1STI]1KH=S [1DIAN]1OI/AS [1TO\ A)|DO/MENON H)\ TO\ YILO\N PO/H]1MA: KAI\ TO\ MO/NON !!!!!! TO\ TOU= *KRE/COU PO/HMA KAI/PER OU)K O)\N A)NA/RMOSTON POLU\ SEMNO/TERON FAI/NE[1SQAI T]1OU= ME/LO[1U]1S PROSTEQE/NTOS, KAI\ TOU\S U(/MNOUS TOU\S E)N *)EFE/SW[1I KAI\ TOU\]1S U(P[1O\ T]1W=N E)N *LAKEDAI/MON[1I]1 XO-RW=N A)|D[1O]1ME/NOUS MHD[1E\N P]1OH/SEIN PARAPLH/SION A)FAIREQE/NT[1O]1S, A)PO-[1XR]1H=N E)[1NO/M]1ISEN PRO\S A)PO/DEICIN T[1OU=]1 MA=LLON KEINEI=N, OU)QE\N [1U(P]1O-LOGISA/MENOS O(/TI [1R(]1A|DI/WS PRO\S AU)TO\N O( ME\N E)REI= MHDE\ E(\N PRO\S @1 SEMNO/THTA KAI\ LOGISTIKH\N E)/[1MF]1ASIN POI[1EI=]1N TO\ ME/LOS D[1I]1AFORW/TE[1R]1ON, A)LLA\ TE/RYIN A)KOH=S PROSTI[1Q]1E/NAI MO/NON, O( DE\ DIA\ [1TH\]1N [1P]1R[1O]1SUPO-LAMBA[1NOME/N]1HN TIMH\N TW=N QEW=N KAI\ TW=N A)NDRW=N, O[1U)]1 DI[1A\]1 TO\ ME/-LO[1S E)M]1FAI/NESQAI TH\[1N]1 KA[1T]1ALL[1A]1GH/N, O( [1DE\ T]1A/X[1A KAI\]1 TOU=TO [1M]1E\N GI/NESQAI, [1TH\N D]1E\ DIA/[1NO]1IAN TOU= POH/[1MAT]1OS A)|DO[1ME/N]1OU KAI\ PROS-[1KIR]1NA=SQAI!! @&Philodemus de musica lib. IV p. 75 Kemke.$ TO\ D' U(PO\ TW=N !!!AI/WN [1TETI]1MH=SQAI TH\N [1MOU]1SIKH\N I)D[1I]1W/TH| ME\N K[1AI\ A)PAIDEU/TW| T]1EKMH/RIO[1N H(G]1EI=SQA[1I TH=S EU)X]1RHSTI/AS SU[1GG]1NWS[1TO/N, PE]1PAIDEUME/[1N]1W| DE\ [1KAI\ M]1A=LLON E)/TI FI[1L]1OSO/F[1W| ME/G']1 A)\N O)/NEIDOS [1EI)/H]1: E)P[1EI\!!!!! K]1AI\ MANTI[1KH/]1, U(PO\ TW=N *STWI+[1KW=N A)CIOUM]1E/N[1H]1 TIM[1H=S, KAI\ M]1U/RIA A)/L[1LA]1 T[1W=N]1 MHDE\N A)[1GA]1QO\N PA[1RA]1SK[1EUA]1ZO/NTWN, [1E)/]1NIA DE\ [1KA]1I\ PAMPO/N[1H]1RA [1PR]1OELH[1LE]1GME/NA KA[1I\ FILO]1SOFI/A| [1M]1H\ TIMW/M[1ENA%1%1 &omitto tres versus.$ TOU)]1NANTI/[1ON D]1E\ W(S PLEI/STH[1S]1 H( [1MO]1USIKH/, ME/XRI TW=N SUMPO[1SI/]1WN PROBAI/NOUSA. TW=| D[1E\]1 KAI\ MAINOME/NOUS A)EI\ TO[1U\]1S POLLOU\S NOMI/ZONT[1I]1 KAI\ PANTELW=S OU)K E)/CESTI E)PI\ TA\[1S]1 KRI/SEIS KATA-FEU/GEIN AU)TW=N, TOI=S DE\ KATAFEU/[1GOUSI]1N OU)DE\N H(=TTON AU)TH\N A)PODOKI-MASTE/ON, TH\N MOUSIKH/N, [1D]1IA\ TH\N [1T]1W=N U(/ST[1ER]1ON [1A)]1ME/L[1EI]1AN. Ȉ@&p. 76,25.$ TO\ GA\R LE[1LE/XQAI A)P]1O\ *MOUS[1W=N]1 MOUSI[1KH/N, AI(=S]1 PA=SA[1N P]1AIDEI/[1AN KAI\ TE/XNA]1S O(/SAS A)[1NA]1FE/ROUSIN [1&post duos versus%10]1$ KAI\ [1P]1A=SIN A)NAGK[1AI/A]1N EI)=NA[1I L]1ABEI=N &etc. &@Philodemus de musica lib. IV p. 76 Kemke.$ POIH]1TW=N TI BARB!!!AI QUMO\N A)M[1BL]1U/NONTA KAI\ "1FWNA\N E)N OI)/NW|"2 KAI\ "1[1G]1LUKU\ TRWGA/LION"2 AU)TH\N EI)=NAI LEGO/NTWN PARA\ TA\ DEI=PNA, TOU=TO ME\N FWNEI=[1N]1 W(S E)[1P]1EGEIR[1O/]1N[1T]1WN TINW=N MELW=N KAI\ TH\N DIA/NOIAN E)NTE[1I]1NO/NTWN PRO\S TH\N O(MEILI/AN KAI\ TH\N A(RMO/TTOUSAN A)NASTROFH/N. @&Philodemus de musica lib. IV p. 77 Kemke.$ TO\ TO[1I/]1NUN U(P[1O\]1 TW=N A)RXAI/WN K[1A]1I\ PRO\S A)GWGH\N PARAL[1A]1M[1B]1A/NESQAI P[1AI/]1DWN EI)S U(POTU/P[1W]1SIN A)RET[1W=N]1 TE/TEUXE LO/G[1O]1U [1H)/DH]1 PLH\N I)/SW[1S]1 TH=[1S E]1U)SE-BEI/AS, PRO\S H(\N [1H(]1DE/W[1S A)\]1N H)KOU/SAMEN [1AU)TOU=]1 TI/[1N]1AS [1U(]1POLH/YEIS SUMBALLOME/N[1H]1 KATA/ GE TO\ MOUSIKO\N [1EI)=]1DOS U(POT[1U]1POI=. TW=| D[1E\ K]1AI\ PRO\S TH\N [1T]1W=N A)NDRW=N, [1W(/]1STE KAI\ TO/TE E)NERGEI=N, PW=S OI( K[1W]1MI[1KOI\]1 MART[1UR]1OU=SI[1N]1 E)[1PI]1ZHTW=[I]. TO\ GA\R MEMOUSW=SQ[1AI]1 MO/NON, [1A)]1PA[1N-DRWQH=]1N[1AI DE\]1 MH\ LOIDO[1ROU=SIN KAI\ T]1W=N [1X]1EIROTON[1I]1W=N A)PEI/R[1GOU]1-SIN: W(=N TO\ ME\N [1E)G]1GEN[1E/SQ]1AI, TO\ DE\ MHDAMW=S PA[1I/D]1WN U(PARXO/NTWN KAI\ N[1E/]1W[1N D]1U/NATAI LE/[1G]1ESQAI K[1URI/WS]1 OU(/TWS: E[1I)]1S GA\R DH\ T[1H\N]1 A)NDR[1A/S]1IN E)[1S]1OM[1E/N]1HN A)[1RET]1H\N PROETUPOU=NT[1O. TI/ G]1A\R DEI= LE/GEIN U(PE\R TOU= TO\N FILO/SOFON W([1S]1 A)CIOPIST[1OT]1E/R[1W]1N E(AUTOU= [1T]1A\S FA/SEIS T[1W=]1N [1B]1WMOLOXWTA/TWN A)[1POD]1EI/CEIS NOMI/ZEIN; [1&post quinque @1 &versus%10$ KA]1TAKEKRI/S[1QAI K]1AI\ PONHROU\S GEGONE/N[1AI]1 TOU\S TO/TE FIL[1O]1-SO/[1F]1OU[1S KAI\ T]1OU\S A)/LLOUS O(/SOUS E)KO/LASAN. @&Philodemus de musica lib. IV p. 78 Kemke.$ U(PERBA/NTES DH\ [1TOIGA]1ROU=N TA\ PE[1RI\]1 TH=[1S S]1WFRO[1SU/]1NHS [1E]1I)RHME/NA KA[1I\]1 TH=S [1A)N-DR]1EI/AS, E)PEIDH\ LO/GOU [1TE/TE]1UXEN, E)PI\ TA\ P[1E]1RI\ TW=N E)[1R]1W/TWN BADI/-Z[1W]1MEN. PR[1W=TON]1 ME\N DH\ TO\ KAKOU= KAI\ [1ME]1GA/LOU TH=S E)RWTIKH=[1S]1 O)RE/C[1EW]1S OU)/SHS, H(/N GE [1D]1H\ NOOU=SI[1N OI( *P]1ANE/LLHNES, A)RETH\N [1E)R]1W-TIKH\N EI)=NAI NOMI/[1ZEI]1N [1KATAG]1E/LASTON OU) MET[1RI/]1WS: E)/P[E]IT' AU)= TO\ DOKEI=N ME/L[1H SU]1NERGEI=N PRO\S [1O)]1RQH\[1N]1 A)N[1AS]1TR[1O]1FH\N E)/RWT[1OS]1, TW=N ME\N [1E)]1M FWNH=S [1K]1EIME/NWN POIO/TH[1T]1I MO/NON, TOU= DE\ LO/[1GW| T]1W=| DIDA/-[1SK]1ONTI TO\ M[1A/T]1AION [1KAI\]1 B[1LA]1BERO\N K[1AI\]1 A)P[1L]1H/R[1W]1T[1ON TOU= E)KRI]1-P?I[1Z]1OM[1E/N]1OU KAI\ P[1AROCUN]1OME/NO[1U]1 ME/[1XR]1I A)NOI/[1AS PA/QOUS SUNERGEI=-SQAI PEFUKO/TOS &deest unus versus%10$ K]1AI\ [1M]1H\ [1B]1LE/PEIN O(/[1SON E)/DW]1KEN A)FORMH=S EI)S [1A)TACI/A]1N KAI\ A)KOLASI/AN: [1&quae secuntur, nondum recte &suppleta sunt]1. @&Philodemus de musica lib. IV col. XIII p. 79 Kemke.$ PRO\S DE\ TOU/TOIS W(S !!!!!!%5DHS ME\[1N EI)]1KO/TWS EI%5PEOS3!!!!!!!!!AN!!!! E)LEUQER[1!!!]1NOM!!!! %5 PERIA/PTEI[1N E)/]1RWTA %5 BOU/LETAI KA[1I\]1 *TIMO/QE[1ON]1%5 E(/[1NE]1KA TW=N @&col. XIV.$ EU)GENW=N PREPW/DH, TA\ D' E(TAIRW=N, OU)K E)/STIN FU/SEI KAI\ MH\ KATA\ DIATA/CEIS KENA/S: OU)D' OU(=TOS U(PODEI/GMA[1T]1A PARE/QHKE TOIOU/-TWN, A)LLA\ DIANOHMA/TWN: MO/N[1O]1N [1DE\]1 FATIKW=S SUMPAR[1E/]1SURE KAI\ TO\ M[1E/]1LOS. OU)DE\ TOU\S NE/OUS TOI=S ME/LESI DIAF[1QE]1I/RONTAS PARE/DEICEN TO\N *)/IBUKON KAI\ TO\N *)ANAKRE/ONTA KAI\ TOU\S O(MOI/OUS, A)LLA\ TOI=S DIANOH/MASI: KAI\ GA\R A(/PER *SAP?%5[1FW\]1 O)NO/MAT' E)/LEGE, TOU/TOIS E)/QRUPTEN, EI)/PER [1A)/]1RA: ME/L[1OS D' A)]1KO/LOUQON O)\N POIO/THTI FWNH=S !!T!!! OU) DU/NAT' E[1I)=]1NAI !!!!!!!! D[1I]1A\ [1ME]1LW=[1N]1 O(MOI/W[1S]1 A)[1L]1L' O)NOMA/TW[1N]1 KAI\ DIANOHM[1A/]1-TWN A)RE/SKESQAI KAI\ TOU\S E)RW[1M]1E/NOU[1S]1, EI) QE/LOUSIN, O(MOLO[1G]1H/SOMEN, TO\N D' *)ARISTOF[1A/]1N[1HN]1 TOU\S A)RXAI/OUS A)POF[1AI/NE]1IN E)NKEKL[1AS]1ME/NH| KAQA/[1PER]1 OI( PALAIOI\ TH=| FWNH=| X[1R]1H=[1SQ]1AI KAI\ TOI=S O)FQALMOI=[1S PRO]1-AGWGEU/EIN E(AUTOU/S, [1OU) TOI=S]1 ME/LESIN: EI) DE\ TOU/TOIS [1E)/LE]1GEN, [1K]1LAI/EIN AU)TW=| PROS[1LE/G]1OMEN: TAU=TA GA\R OU)/T' EI)S A(/ FHSIN W(/[1S]1PER A)DI/STAKTA [1E)/]1XWN, E)KKALEI=Q' O(/SON E)F' AU([1TOI=]1S, OU)/TE PRO\S SUNOUSI/AS [1AI)SXR]1A\S KAI\ A)/NDRAS KAI\ GUNAI=[1KAS]1 KAI\ NE/OUS W(RAI/OUS [1EI)S G]1UNAIKISMO/N: OU)/TE GA\[1R OU(=T]1OS OU)/Q' OI( KWMIKOI\ [1P]1ARE/D[1E]1ICA/N [1T]1I TW=N *)AGA/QWNO[1S]1 KAI\ *DHMOKRI/TOU TOIO[1U=T]1ON, A)LLA\ MO/NON LE/GOUS[1IN]1: OU) [1DE\]1 *NI/KANDROS OU)DE\ K!!!! T]1OU=T[1O]1 PARE/STHSE D[1IA\]1 TW=[1N !!!!! A)LL']1 E)PL[1A/]1NHSEN EI)/PER A)/RA. @1 @&Idem p. 16 Kemke.$ KAI\ PRO\S [1SUNOUSI/AS AI)SXRA\S]1 E)KKALEI=S[1QAI KAI\ A)/NDRAS KAI\ GU]1NAI=KAS KA[1I\ NE/OUS W(RAI/OUS]1 EI)S GUNAIKIS[1MO/N !!!!! *)AGA/QWNOS A(\ KAT[1HGOROU=SIN OI(]1 KWMIKOI\ KA[1I\ !!!!!!!!!! %5 KAI\ *DHMO-KR[1I/TOU. *NI/KAN]1DRON DE\ TO\N !!!!!!!!!! E)]1PIDEI[1K]1NU/ME[1NON!!!!!!!!%5 E)/RGOIS DIDA/C[1ANTA !!!!]1 A)LLA\ KAI\ @&Philodemus de musica lib. IV p. 80 Kemke.$ KAI\ MH\N OU)DE\ PARAMUQEI=SQAI DU/NATAI MOUSIKH\ TA\S E)N E)/RWTI DUSPRACI/AS: LO/GOU GA\R MO/NOU TO\ TOIOU=TON, A)LL' A)NEPIBLH/TOUS POIEI= PERISPW=SA KAQA/PER A)FRO-DEI/S[1I]1A KAI\ ME/QH: POH/MATA D' EI) PROAIREI=TAI, DIDO/SQW KAI\ *FILO/CENON, EI) TOU=T' H)|NI/TTETO, MH\ TELE/WS YEU/DESQAI, KAQA/PER OU)DE\ *ME/NANDRON PO[1N]1HR[1O\N]1 U(PE/KKAUMA POLLO[1I=]1S AU)TH\N LE/GONTA TW=| DIDO/NAI TINA\S A)FORMA/S. @&Idem p. 16.$ A)]1LL' H( M[1OUSIKH\ DU]1NATH/ [1E)STIN PARAMUQEI=SQAI]1 TA\S E)N E)/[1RWTI DUSPRACI/AS. &paulo post Menandri versus videtur afferri. @&Philodemus de musica p. 16 Kemke.$ [1TW=|]1 DE\ TO\ M[1E/LOS SUM]1-BA/LLE[1SQ]1AI PRO\[1S TH\N E)RWTI]1KH\N A)RETH\N [1LE/GEI PROSH]1KO/NTWS KAI\ MI/A[1N TW=N *MOU]1SW=N *)ERATW\ [1W)NOMA/SQAI]1. @&Idem lib. IV p. 81.$ H( ME/NTOI G' *)ERATW\ ZHTW= PW=S TO\ SU[1M]1BALE/-SQA[1I]1 TH\N I)DI/WS [1K]1ALOUME/NHN M[1OUS]1IKH\N PRO\S TH\N E)RWT[1I]1KH\N A)RE-TH\N E)[1R]1RH/QH DHLO[1U=SA]1 M[1A=]1LLON H)\ TH\N POHTIKH\N H)\ BE/LTION E)/[1TI TH\N]1 FI[1LO]1SOFI/AN: [1A(/]1PANTA GA\R DH\ TAI=S [1*M]1OU/SAIS A)NATE/QHTAI: KAI\ T[1O\ !!!!!!!!]1AN U(POBA/LLEIN, A)[1LL' O]1U) [1T]1O\ DIAMA/XESQAI [1PRO\S]1 TO\ PA/QOS. @&Philodemus de musica p. 16 Kemke.$ E)/TI]1 DE\ TOU=T' A)CI[1OI= [&scil.$ TO\ ME/LOS] SUNERGEI=N KAI\]1 PRO\S TH\N SUMPO[1TIKH\N A)RE]1TH/N: TOU= GA\R E)/RW-[1TOS KAI\ KA]1QO/LOU TW=N E)RWT[1IKW=N !!!! &`29.$ OU)]1D' EU(REQH=[1NAI PREPW-DESTE/RAN]1 E)LEUQE/R[1OIS]1 A)/LL[1H]1N A)/NES[1IN]1 KAI\ PAIDEIA\[1N]1 TOU= TO\N ME\N A)=SAI, TO\N DE\ KIQARI/SAI, TO\N DE\ XOREU=SAI. KAI\ GA\R EI) MH/ TIS E)PITH-DEU/OI, TO\N OI)=NON E)[1KK]1ALEI=[1SQA]1I "1POLU/FRONA/ [1PER MA/L' A)EI=SAI]1 KAI\ Q' A(PALO\N [1GELA/SAI KAI/]1T' O)RXH/SASQAI"2 [1&Od. c 464sq.]1.$ TAU=[1TA ME\N]1 POI-EI=N &etc. &@Idem lib. IV p. 81.$ A)LLA\ GA\R E)PEI\ PRO\S E)RWTIKH\N A)RE[1T]1H\N OU) FAI/NEQ' H( MOUSIKH\ SUNERGOU=SA, DH=LON W(S OU)DE\ PRO\S H(/N FHSIN O[1I)]1-KEI/AN AU)TH=S EI)=NAI TH\N SUMPOTIKH\N KAI\ TA\ SUMPO/SIA KOINW=S: E)GW\ D' OU)/T' EI)=NAI TH\N KALOUME/NHN SUMPOTIKH\N A)RETH\N_A)LL' OU)XI\ TH\N U(PO\ TOU/T[1W]1N PLASQHSOME/NHN_A)PO\ FRONH/SEWS H(GOU=MAI, TA/XA D' [1O]1U)DE\ PI/PTOUSAN EI)S FRONI/M[1OUS]1, OU)/[1T]1E SUMPOSI/OIS E)/RWTAS E)NARMO/TT[1E]1IN W(S A)\N TARAXW/DEIS KAI\ A)TERPEI=S KAI\ DIASTATIKOU\S TW=N SUNO/NTWN U(P[1A/]1R-XONTAS. TH\N ME/NT[1OI M]1OUSIKH\N OI)KEI/AN ME\N E[1I)=NA]1I SUMPOSI/WN KA[1I\]1 TA\ PAR' [1*(OM]1H/RW| DEO/NTWS E)P[1I]1SESHMA/NQ?AI DI[O]DOU/S, E)/TI D[1E\]1 KAI\ TO\ @1 DEI=N A)NI/ESQAI KAI\ [1P]1AI/ZEIN E)N AU)TOI=S, OU) DW/SW TO\ M[1H]1DEMI/AN EI)=NA[1I]1 PREPWD[1E]1STE/RAN E)LEUQE/R[1OI]1S A)/NESI[1N KAI\ P]1AIDIA\N TOU= TO\N [1ME\N]1 A)=SAI, TO\[1N]1 DE\ KIQARI/[1S]1AI, T[1O\]1N [1D]1E\ XOREU=SA[1I, TW=N D']1 E)R[1W/TWN POLLW=| A)]1MEI/NOUS E[1I)=]1NAI [1TOU\S K]1ATA\ MOUSIKH\N TH\N E)[1P']1 A)KOUSMA/TWN, OU) TH\N AU)[1L]1W=N. OU)X O(MO[1L]1OGH/SW D' OU)D' E)KKALEI=SQAI TO\[1N]1 OI)=NO[1N]1 E)C A)[1N]1-A/GKHS KAI\ TOU\S FR[1O]1N[1I/]1MOUS A(/PANTA POIEI=N, O(/SA FH[1SI/N__ _ ψ@&col. XVII.$ MH\ SK[1AI]1W=S A)LL' E)MMELW=S A)NAS[1T]1R[1E/]1FESQAI. @&Philodemus de musica lib. IV p. 83 Kemke.$ KA)KEI=NO DE\ XRH-ST[1O]1MAQW=S EI)/RHTAI TO\ SAI/NE[1SQAI]1 ME\N KAI\ TOU\S I)D[1I]1W/TAS U(PO\ TH=S OI)KEIO/THTOS [1&scil.$ TH=S MOUSIKH=S PRO\S TA\ SUMPO/SIA]1, PARALAMBA/NEIN [1G]1E/ TOI KAI\ A)KROA/MAT' EI)S TA\ SUMPO/SI[1A]1, DIAPI/PTEIN DE\ TW=| MH\ TO\N *(/OMHRON KAI\ TO\N *(HSI/ODON KAI\ TOU\S A)/LLOUS P[1O]1HTA\S TW=N ME/TRWN KAI\ MELW=N: BELTI/W GA\R E)/STW TA\ XRW/MENA SUMPO/SIA TOI=S TOU/TWN: MOUSIKH=| DE\ PW=S A)/MEINON XRH=[1T]1AI, POHTA\S A)LL' OU) MOUSIK[1O]1U\S TOU/S GE TW=N ME/TRWN EI)S[1A/]1GONTA; KA)N TW=| LOIPW=| BI/W| TOIGAROU=N E)K TINW=N XRO/NWN, EI) KAI\ MH\ PAR' O(/LON SXEDO/N, W(S OU(=TOS E)/GRAYE, POI[1KI/]1LH[1N]1 DIAGWGH\N U(PO\ [1TW=N M]1OUSIKW=N PARASKEU[1A/Z]1ESQAI PROSDEXO/MENOI, TO\ P[1O]1IKI/LON KAI\ PLEI=ON U(P[1O\ T]1W=N SUMPLEKOME/NWN G[1I/NE]1SQAI FH/SOMEN, OU)X U([1PO\]1 TH=S MOUSIKH=S A[1U)TH=S &etc. &@Philodemus de musica p. 17 Kemke.$ [1YUXA]1GWGI/AN I)DI/A|!!! KA!FAQAI PARA\ TOI=S MELOPOIOI=S, O(/SOI [1XR]1HSI/MWS PEFILOMOUSH/[1K]1ASIN: MH\ GA\R KAKW=S E)PISH[1M]1AI/NESQAI *XAMAILE/ONTA TOIOU=TO/N TI TOU\S KWMI-KOU\S [1AI)]1NI/TTESQAI PERI\ TW=N *G*I*S3%5WN, PROSHGORI/AIS ME\N XRW[1M]1E/NOUS TAI=S TW=N [1P]1RW/TWN KAI/ POTE!!!! %17 EI)S PA/NTAS DE\ TH\N I)DIO/THTA [1T]1OU/TWN. @&Idem lib. IV p. 83.$ !!!NA DE\ DH\ GRA/FOI T[1H\N YUXA]1GWGI/AN I)DI/A| P[1!!!!!!!]1QAI PARA\ TOI=S MEL[1OP]1O[1IOI=]1S KAI\ TUGXA/NEIN E)PISTA/SE[1W]1S U(PO\ *XAMAILE/ONTOS, A(/P[1A]1NTA SX[1E]1DO\N DIANOHMA/[1TW]1N EI)=NAI KAI\ POHTI-K[1H=S XR]1W/MATA [1&scil.$ FH/SOMEN]1. @&Philodemus de musica p. 17 Kemke.$ E)/XEIN DE/ TI KAI\ PRO\S F[1ILI/]1AN [1O]1I)KEI=ON. E)PEIDH\ GA\R PRO\S E)/RW[1TA E)]1DEI/XQH, KA[1I\]1 PRO\S TO\ TE/LOS AU)TOU= [1L]1O/GON AI(REI=N. E)/TI D' E)PEI\ PRO\S [1SUMPO/]1SIA, KAI\ [1P]1R[1O\S]1 TO\ TE/LOS [1AU)TW=N, O(\]1 FAI/NESQA[1I P]1A/LI FILO[1FROSU/]1NHN. EI) DE\ [1PR]1O\S TAU/T[1HN, KAI\]1 PRO\S FILI/AN. A)/LLWS [1DE\ KAI\]1 TH\N [1YUXH\N]1 A)NI/HSIN [1KAI\ A)FILAROI=]1. @&Idem lib. IV p. 84.$ PA/LI D[1E\ LE/GOME]1N, E)PEI\ PRO\S TO\N E)/RWTA TH\[1N]1 MOUSIKH\N OU)QE\N A)\N E[1U(/RO]1M[1EN]1 X[1RH]1SIMEU/OUSA[1N, OU)]1DE\ PRO\S FIL[1I/]1AN OI)KE[1I/WS]1 PROSFE/RESQAI @&col. XVIII.$ [1PRO\S]1 SUM[1P]1O/SIA DIDO/NTES E)NARMO/[1T]1TEIN [1A]1U)TH/N, @1 TO\ DE\ MO/NON TE/LO[1S]1 AU)TW=N EI)=NAI FILOFROSU/[1N]1HN OU) TIQE/NTES, A)LLA\ KAI/ TIN' E(/TERA, PRO\S TH\N H(DONH/N, OU) PRO\[1S]1 E)KEI/NHN XRHSIMEU/EIN O(MO-LOGH/SOMEN: W(/ST' OU)DE\ PRO\S [1F]1ILI/AN. __OU)D' A)NEI/HSI DE\ TA[1U=T]1A KAI\ A)FIL[1A]1ROI=, TA\ DE\ SUMPEPLEG[1M]1E/NA AU)TOI=S DIANOH/MA[1TA. __ &p. 85.$ OU) MH\[1N]1 A)L[1L]1A\ [1KA)\N]1 A)NIH=| KAI\ [1I(]1LAROU\S [1POI]1H=|, KAQA/P[1ER]1 A)PO/LAUS[1IS P]1O[1TW=N]1 TE [1KAI\]1 BRWTW=N KA[1I\ PA=SA H(DON]1H/, FILI/AS KAI\ O(MO[1NOI/AS OU)]1K A)\N AI)/TIA [1DID]1O[1I=MEN EI)=NAI]1 O[1U)D]1E\ TAU/TH| MO/N[1ON]1, M[1H\ U(P' A)/]1LLWN KATA\ [1T]1A\S I([1L]1AR[1O/]1TH[1TAS]1 H(MA=S MA/[1LI]1STA GI/NESQ[1A]1I D[1I]1ALUTIKOU/S. @&Philodemus de musica lib. IV p. 85 Kemke.$ *LAK[1ED]1AIMONI/OUS DE\ TOI=S A)DIANOH/TOIS OU) PROSIE/M[1EQ]1A MARTUROU=NTAS, O(/TI KAI\ PU[1Q]1O/-XRHSTON E)/SXON METAP[1E/]1MY[1A]1SQAI *QALH/TAN KAI\ P[1AR]1A[1G]1ENOME/NOU TH=S DIXO[1NOI/]1AS [1E)/L]1HCAN: EI) DH\ MAR[1TURO]1U=S[1IN]1, A)/LLO[1IS]1 MO/NON EI(/P[1ONTO]1 TOI=S PEPLAKO/SI [1T]1A)R[1XAI=A]1 KAI\ MOUSIKOI=S: A)/LLO[1I GA\R]1 A)NTILE/GOU[1S]1IN, [1AU)TO\N DEI/CANTES]1 A)L[1A]1ZONEUO/MENON DI' A)NAQE/MATOS, EI)/PER A)NE/QHKEN OU(/TWS E)PIGRA/YAS, W(S [1O]1U(=TOI LE/GOUSIN. @&Philodemus de musica p. 18 Kemke.$ KAI\ *TE/RPAND[1ROS KATA\ MAN]1TEI=ON !!!! [1E)N TOI=]1S FILITEI/OIS A)/|[1D]1W[1N TH=S TAR]1AXH=S E)/PAUSE TOU\S [1*LAKEDAIMONI/O]1US. @&Idem lib. IV p. 85.$ OU) PEIQO/MEQA [1D']1 OU)DE\ TW=| *TE/RPANDRON K[1A]1TA\ MANTEI/AN KEKLH=SQAI PR[1O\]1S KATA/PAUSIN E)MFULI/OU STA/[1S]1EWS, A)\N KAI\ PA/NU POLLOI\ SUMFWNW=SI PERI\ TOU/TOU TW=N MOUSOLH/PTW[1N]1, OU(=TOS DE\ SXEDO\N MO/NOS [1E)]1N TOI=S FILEITEI/OIS AU)TO\N A)/|DONTA POIH=|. KAI\ DH\ GA\R PRO[1S]1H=KE TOU\S FILOSO/FOUS U(POGRA/YANTAS, TI/NA TRO/PON DU/NATAI PA[1U/]1-EIN A)/LOGA ME/L[1H]1 LOGIKH\N DIAFORA/N, OU(/TW PEI/QEIN KAI\ TA\ *QAL[1H/TOU]1 KAI\ *TERPA/NDROU PEPAUKE/NAI [1TA\S]1 TW=N *LAKW/NWN. @&Philodemus de musica p. 18 Kemke.$ KAI\ PERI\ *STHSIXO/ROU D' E)N ME/SOIS [1H)=|SE/ TI PARA]1KLHTIKO\N KAI\ DIA[1LLA/C]1A[1S]1 DIA\ TOU= ME/LOU[1S EI)S H(SUX]1I/AN AU)TOU\S METE/S[1THSEN. A)/LL]1OU DE/ TINOS E(/NE[1KA OU)DE\ *PIN]1-DA/RW| GEGRA/FQ[1AI "1TO\ KOINO/N]1 TIS A)STW=N E)N E[1U)DI/A| TIQEI/S"2]1 KAI\ TO\ *SOFO[1KLE/OUS E)N TO]1I=S *)EPIGO/NOIS. @&Idem lib. IV p. 87.$ A)LLA\ MH\N KAI\ TO\ ME\N KA[1T]1A\ *STHSI/XORON OU)K A)KRI[1B]1W=[1S]1 I(STO[1REI=]1TAI: T[1O\ D]1E\ *P[1I]1NDA/REION EI) TH=S DIX[1ON]1OI/AS E)/PAUSEN OU)K OI)/DAMEN. __TO\ D' E)K TW=N *)EPIGO/NWN ME/LOS U(PO[1G]1RA/FOMEN OU)K @1 [1A)]1PIQAN[1W]1TE/RAN A)/LLHN [1D]1IA/NO[1IAN: K]1A)\N D[1E\ NO]1W=MEN W(S OU(=TOS, [1A)LL]1A\ META\ TH=S E)PI[1S]1HM[1ASI/AS T]1OU= KWMWDOGRA/F[1OU E)ATE/]1ON E)STI/N. @&Philodemus de musica p. 19 ed. Kemke.$ [1DIAT]1A/TTEI[1N]1 ME/LH TI[1NA/, W(/]1STE MH\ MO/NON KOINW=S [1TAU=TA]1 PRO\S QEW=N TIMH\N [1OI)KE]1I=O/N [1TI]1 E)/XEIN, A)LLA\ KAI\ [1KAT]1A\ TA\S DIAFORA\S TW=N D[1AIMO/NW]1N A)/LLA PRO\S A)/L[1L]1OUS. @&Idem lib. IV p. 88.$ W(/ST' E)F' A(\ GRA/FEI PE[1RI\]1 T[1H=]1S EU)SEBE[1I/]1AS METABA/N[1TE]1S LE/GWMEN, W(S EI) XA/RIN T[1OU= TIM]1A=SQAI TO\ QEI=ON DIA\ [1M]1OU-SIKH=S U(PO\ TW=N POLLW=[1N OI)]1KE[1I/]1AN EI)=NAI TH\N MOUS[1IKH\N]1 TH=S EU)SEBEI/AS OI)HSO/[1MEQA, K]1A[1I\]1 MAGEIRI[1K]1H\N OI)HSO/[1M]1EQ[1A]1__ _[1E)/TI D' A)\N E(/]1POITO [1TOI=S DO/GMASI TOU= FI]1LOSO/[1FOU TO\ MH\ OI)KEI/AN EI)=NAI]1, E)PEI\ DI' AU)TH=S OU)D[1E\]1 EI(=S TIMA=[1T]1AI, DIO/TI <20KATA\ TOU\S *STWI+KOU\S>20 O[1I(]1 POLLOI\ QEOI=S O)/NTES E)XQROI\ KA[1I\]1 A)NO/HTOI TA\S A)LHQE[1I]1NA\S TIMA\[1S]1 T[1W=]1N [1KR]1A-TI/[1ST]1WN OU)D' W)NE[1IR]1OPOLH/KASIN. __ _KAI\ [1T]1O\N *P[1I/]1NDARON OU(/TW NOM[1I/Z]1EIN, O(/T' E)/FH QU/SWN PO[1IEI=S]1QAI DIQU/RAMBON, A)LLA\ DH\ KAI\ TO\[1N]1 TA\ ME/LH DIATA/TTO[1NT]1A TW=N QEW=N E(KA/STW| KWMIKO/N. __ _EI) MH\ *D[1I]1OGE/NHS A)/RA SUNEPEI/QETO KAI\ TW=| TW=N QEW=N E(TE/ROUS E(/TERA ME/LH PROSI/ESQAI KAI\ PRE/PEIN E(KA/STOIS I)/DIA. @&Philodemus de musica p. 19 Kemke.$ [1EU)XRHSTE]1I=N DE\ [1LE/GEI]1 TO\ [1ME/LOS KAI\]1 PRO\S [1SU/NES]1IN. KAI\ GA\R O(/[1ROUS]1 KAI\ DIAIRE/SEIS KAI\ A)[1PODEI/CEIS E)]1N A(RMONIKH=| [1P]1LEI/S[1TAS EI)=NAI]1 KAI\ KAT' A)/LLON !!!!!!!!! !!!!!TINA\ QEWRI/A[1N @&Idem. lib. IV p. 89.$ KAI\ TI/ DEI= TA)=LLA QAUMA/ZEIN AU)TOU=; KAI\ PRO\S S[1U/]1NE[1S]1IN GA\R EU)[1XR]1H[1STE]1I=N [1OI)/ET]1AI TW=| KAI\ O(/ROUS [1KAI\ DIAIR]1E/SEIS KAI\ A)PODEI/C[1EIS POL]1LA\S U(PA/RXEIN E)N A([1RMO]1N[1I]1K[1H=|]1, KA[1Q]1A/PER O(/TI MO/[1NON DIEI=LON H)\ W(/RI]1SA/N TI TOU/TWN, H([1MARTH]1ME/NON A)/LLWS, KAT' AU)[1T]1O\ [1D]1H\ [2TO\]2 DIALEKTIKW=S E)PIT[1UGX]1A/NE[1S]1QAI/ [1T]1I, TW=N PARA\ T[1OI=]1S [1M]1OU-SI[1K]1OI=S OU)K A)SUNE/TW[1S]1 K[1AI\ K]1ATAGELA/S[1T]1WS E)KKEIME/NWN &etc. ____ EI) DE\ TH\N A)PO\ FRONH/SEWS [1&scil.$ SU/NESIN LE/GEI]1 OU)DE\N E)PIDEI/CEI TA\ TW=N MOUSIKW=N PRO\S TAU/THN SUNERGOU=NTA MA=LLON H)\ TA\ TW=N A)/LLWN A)KRI-BW/MATA. @&Philodemus de musica lib. IV p. 90.$ T[1H=]1I DE\ KRITIKH=| LE/GWN [1P]1ARAPLHSI/AN TINA\ QEWRI/AN E)/XEIN TOU\S FILOMOUSOU=NTAS, OU) MO/NON A)GNOEI= KAQO/SON W(S E)M ME/LESI KAI\ R(UQMOI=S PRE/PONTOS KAI\ A)PREPOU=S O)/NTO[1S]1 KAI\ KALOU= KAI\ AI)SXROU= KRITIKH\N AU)TW=N A)PE/LEIPE QEWRI/AN, [1A)]1LLA\ KAI\ KAQO/SON, EI)/ TI TOIOU=TON H)=N, OU)XI\ TOI=S FILOSOFOU=SIN A)PE-DI/DOU TH\N KRI/SIN, KAI\ NH\ TO\N *DI/A KAQO/SON TH\N KRITIKH/N, H(=I TI PARA-PLH/SION E)/X[1E]1IN TH\N MOUSIKH\N E)/FASKE[1N, O]1U)XI\ TOU/TO[1IS]1 A)LLA\ [1TO]1I=S O)NOMAZOME/NOIS KRITIKOI=[1S SUNE]1XW/REI. KAI\ TH=| POIHT[1IKH=|]1 DE\ GRA/FWN A)NA/LOGO[1N EI)=NA]1I KATA/ TE TH\N MI/MHS[1IN K]1AI\ KATA\ TH\N A)/LLHN EU(/R[1E]1SIN, @1 KATA\ ME\N TH\N MI/MH[1S]1IN OU)K A)\N E)PE/DEICEN, K[1AT]1A\ [1DE\]1 TH\N EU(/RESIN OU) ؈TAU/T[1H| M]1A=LLON H)\ TAI=S A)/LLAI[1S TE/X]1NAIS. KATA\ ME/N[1T]1OI TO\ PL[1A/TTES]1QAI KAI\ A)NTAPODIDO/NAI T[1O\ M]1E/LOS E)/STW TI PARAPLH/SI[1ON]1 AU)[1TH=]1S KAI\ TH=| GRAMMATI[1KH=|]1. TI/ GA\R DEI= F[1R]1ONE!!!!!!! @&Ibidem p. 92.$ A(\ ME/NTOI <20*DIOGE/NHS>20 F[1H]1SI\N KA[1TA]1NOH/SANTAS H(MA=S A)NAGEGRAMME/NA PAR' *(HRAKLEI/DH| PERI\ PRE/PONTOS ME/LOUS KAI\ A)PREPOU=S KAI\ A)[1R)R(]1E/NWN KA[1I\]1 MALAKW=N H)QW=N KAI\ KR[1OU/S]1EWN A(RMOTTOUSW=N K[1AI\ A)]1NARMO/STWN TO[1I=S]1 U(P[1O]1KEIME/NOIS PROSW/P[1OI]1S OU) MAKRA\N A)PHRT[1H-ME/]1N[1HN TH=]1S FILOSOF[1I/AS H(GH/]1S[1E]1S[1QA]1I TW=| PRO\S P[1LEI=STA]1 E)PI\ TOU= BI/OU XRHSI[1MEU/EIN]1 TH\N MOUS[1IKH\]1N [1KAI\ TH\N]1 PERI\ AU)TH\N FIL[1OTEX]1NI/AN OI)KEI/WS DIATI[1QE/N]1AI PRO\S PLEI/OUS A)RETA/S, MA=LLON DE\ PRO\S PA/SAS, E)K-QE/NTES H(MEI=S E)N TW=| TRI/TW| TW=N U(POMNHMA/TWN_KAI\ TA\ PAR' [1A)/]1LLOIS DE\ SUGGENW=S EI)RHME/NA_PAREDEI/CAMEN O(/SHS E)STI\N GE/MONTA LHREI/AS. @&Philodemus de musica p. 19 Kemke.$ KATANOH/SANTA/ TI[1NA TW=]1N EI)RHME/NWN, E)N OI(=S [1PERI\ PR]1E/[1P]1ONTOS ME/LOUS KAI\ [1A)PREPO]1U=S KAI\ PERI\ H)QW=N A)R)[1R(]1E/[1NWN KA]1I\ MALAKW=N KAI\ PERI\ [1KROU/SE]1WN A(RMOTTOUSW=N KA[1I\ A)NARM]1O/STWN TOI=S U(POKEIME/[1NOIS PR]1OSW/POIS, A(/PER O(MOLO[1GOUME/]1-NWS OU) MAKRA\N A)PEI=R[1XQAI TOU=]1 FILOSOFEI=N KAI\ PARA_[1&post duos &versus]1$ @[1EI)=]1NAI FANERO\N PRO\S [1PA/NT]1A ME/RH TOU= BI/OU [1XRHSIM]1EU/EIN TH\N MOUSIKH\N [1KAI\ DU/]1NASQAI TH\N PERI\ AU)TH\[1N FI]1LOTEXNI/AN OI)KEI/WS H([1MA=S DI]1ATIQE/NAI PRO\S PLEI/OUS [1A)RE]1TA/S, DOKEI=N [2DE\]2 AU(TW=| KAI\ P[1RO\S PA/]1SAS. @&Philodemus de musica p. 20 Kemke.$ E)C W(=N DE\ PARATI/QET[1AI *DIK]1AIA/RXOU LA/BOI TIS A)\N O(/S[1A BOU/LET]1AI PRO\S TH\N E)NESTHKU[1I=AN]1 U(PO/-QESIN, [1W(S]1 TO\ TOU\S PA[1LA]1IOU\S KAI\ SOFO\N TO\N W)|D[1O\N NO]1MI/ZEIN, W(S EI)=NAI DH=LON [1E)K]1 TOU= PARA\ TH=| *KLUTAIM[1H/STRA| KAT]1ALEIFQE/NTOS: KAI\ !!!!!!G]1NW=NAI/ FASIN O!!!%5!! T]1OU/TWN A)KOU/SH|: DI' OU(= GE %5 !!!FWNEI=-TAI KAI\ PLEI/O%5[1SI !!!!!]1TA[1T]1AI TO\ PRO\[2S]2 TAI=S A)/L[1LAIS DUNA/M]1ESIN TO\ ME/LOS KAI\ [1STA/SEWN K]1AI\ TARAXW=N EI)=[1NAI K]1ATA[1PA]1USTIKO/N, W(S E)PI\ [1TW=N A)NQRW/PW]1N KAI\ TW=N ZW/|[1WN FAI/N]1ESQAI KATAPRAU+NO[1ME/NW]1N: DIO\ KAI\ TO\N *)ARXI/LO[1XON L]1E/GEIN "1KHL[1EI=]1TAI D' O(/TIS [1E)STI\]1N A)OIDAI=S."2 PA[1RA\]1 DE\ *K[1ARSI\N E)]1PEIDA\N E)N TAI=S E)K[1KLHSI/AIS Q]1O/RUBOS GE/NHTAI, TW=N [1GLU-K]1UTA/TWN TINA\S W)|D[1W=N E)CA/]1RXEIN EI)=T' EI)S TOU\S [1A)/LLOUS GI/]1NESQAI KAI\ PE/RAS [1EI)]1S A(/[1PANT]1AS: OU(/TW DE\ KATA[1LU/EIN]1 TO\ PROKEI/MENON: EI)=TA_ @&Philodemus de musica lib. IV p. 105 Kemke.$ A)[1L]1LA\ MH\N [1QE]1O\S ME\N [1O]1U)QEI\S EU(RET[1H\S]1 E)GE/N[1E]1TO TH=S MOUSIKH=[1S OU)]1DE\ P[1AR]1-E/DWKE TOI=S A)NQRW/PO[1IS, A)L]1L' OU(/TW PAR[1ECE/]1MAQON W(S PRO/TERON A)PE-DW/KA[1M]1EN. LO/GON DE\ KAI\ FRO/NH[1SIN]1 KAI\ PAIDEUT[1I]1KA\S E)P[1ISTH/]1MAS @1 OU)DEI\S EU)SEBH\S NO[1MI/ZEI]1 TO\N *(ERMH=N KAI\ TH\N *)A[1Q]1HNA=N KAI\ TA\S *MOU/-SA[1S]1. E[1I)]1 D' O( LO/GOS H(=| LOGISMO\S E)PH/GA[1G]1EN TH\N MOUSIKH/N, OU)K H)/D[1H KAI\]1 X[1RH/]1SIM[1OS]1 DIA\ TO\ KAI\ TA\ [1X]1EI/RISTA. TO\N DE\ LO/GON A)\N A)[1CI]1W=[1S]1I KAI\ FRO/NHS[1IN]1 KAI\ TA\[1S]1 PAID[1EU]1TIKA\S E)[1PISTH/MAS E)N]1APO[1L]1ABEI=N, [1LEGE/TWSAN]1 TA\S A[1I)]1TI/AS. @&Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. I p. 329 Sudh.$ [1DU/]1NAS[1Q]1AI PIQANW=S E)PAINEI=N, H(\N A)\N BOULW/MEQA DI/AITAN, KA[1I\]1 PA/LIN TH\N AU)T[1H\]1N TAU/THN, A)\N H([1MI=]1N DOKH=| YE/GEIN: W(/STE PEI/Q[1EI]1N TO\N LO/[1G]1ON, O(/TI EI)SI\N U(GIEINAI\ AI( U(F' H(MW=N LEGO/MENAI H)\ E)KEI/NWN MA=LLON, TO\N U(GIAI/NEIN BOU-LO/MENON. H( DE\ TOIAU/TH E)RGOLABEI=N ME\N TA\ I)AT[1RI]1KA\ ZHTOU=NTI, [1FH]1SI/N, [1OU)]1K A)\N A)/[1X]1RHSTOS [1EI)/H]1, PRO\S [1DE\]1 TO\ U(GIAI/NEIN [1OU)QE\]1N [1A)\N SUM]1-BA/LL[1OI]1TO. @&Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. I p. 329 Sudh.$ [1EI) DE\ TW=| R(H/-TORI H(/KIS]1TA TW=N KATA\ [1DO/]1CAN A)LHQH= FAI/NET' EI)=NAI PROSH=KON, A)NTI-[1Q]1EI=NAI TA\ KATA\ MATA[1I/]1AN DO/[1C]1AN U(PO/KWFON H)=N OU!H%5TA/ TE MH\ TH\N A)NAF[1O]1RA\N E)PI\ [1T]1A\S E)N[1A]1R[1GEI/]1AS LAMBA/NONTA KAI\ [1TO\ MH]1DE\ TOU/TWN TELE/WS E)[1L]1L[1EI/P]1EIN TOU\S R(H/TORAS. A)LLA\ MH\N E)N TW=| KATASKEUA/ZEIN TO\ PROKE[1I/]1MENON PRO\S OU)QE\N E)/O[1IK]1EN A)PO\ TH=S MOUSIKH=S E)PA/GEIN. OU) GA\R H)=N FAU[1L]1O/TERA TA\ KAT' AU)T[1H\]1N? [1T]1W=N U(PE\R W(=N E)POI/EI T[1OU\S LO-GI]1SMO[1U/]1S, A)LLA\ TAU=TA [1ME\]1N EU)PARAKOL[1O]1U/QH[1TA PA=]1SIN O)/NTA &etc. @&Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. I p. 332 Sudh.$ E(AUTOU\S KAI\ E)!!%5!!!!!M EU)MAQ[1E]1I=S [1O]1U) PEI/[1QOUSIN]1, A)LLA\ PA=SA H( MELE/[1TH E)S]1T[1I\]1N AU)TW=N PRO\S TOU\S [1O)/XLOUS]1 KAI\ TA\ DIKASTH/RIA: [1O(/QE]1N DE\ PRO\S E(AUTO/N TI E)R[1EI=, O]1U)QEI\S E)PIME/LETAI OU)DE\ PRO\S SUNH/QH, PRO\S UI(O/N, PRO\S GU-NAI=KA: KA)\N ME\N DI/KH GE/NHTAI PE/NTE MNW=N, M[1E]1LETW=SIN KAI\ E)NTEI/[1NO]1N-[1TAI]1, O(/PWS PEI/SOUSIN: [1TO\N]1 D[1E/]1 POU DIA\ KENODOCI/[1A]1N EI)S MOXQHRA\S E)PIQ[1UMI/]1AS [1T]1A/LANTON ME/[1LL]1ONT[1A]1 A)NALI/SKEIN KAI\ [1META\ T]1OU/TOU E(AUTO\N PROSA[1P]1OBA/LLEIN, [1H)\ T]1H=S [1G]1UNAI[1KO\S H)\ TOU= UI(]1OU= &etc. @&Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. I p. 333 Sudh.$ W(S O( [1PEI/QWN A)NAME/%5N]1EIN E)N [1*M]1ARAQW=N[1I *LAKEDAI]1MONI/OUS: "1TI/ OU)=N E)PI[1X]1EIREI=S"2; E)RWTH/SANTOS, E)/FH O(/TI "1TA\ STENA\ KAI\ TA\S PARO/DOUS KATALH/[1Y]1ONTAI [1KAI\]1 TA\ O)XURW/MATA E)KPOL[1IOR]1KH/SOUSIN."2 "1*)ELH/LUQAS OU)=N"2 EI)PO/NTOS "1EI)S *MARAQW=NA"2; "1*OU)/K"2 E)/FH. "1*)ALL' A)[1K]1H/KOA[1S]1 E)PIMELW=S PERI\ TOU/-[1TOU]1 T[1OU=]1 T[1O/]1POU"2; TOU= D' A)NANE[1U/S]1A[1N]1T[1OS]1 "1*TI/ OU)=N, EI)=PEN, E)PI-XE[1IR]1EI=S OU)[1D']1 EI)DW/S, EI) EI)SI/N"2; [1T]1OIOU=TOI/ EI)SIN OI( SU/MBOU[1LOI]1 OI( @1 DOKOU=N[1TES]1 EI)=NA[1I]1 DEINOI\ E)N TAI=S [1PO/L]1ESIN KAI\ LE/GOUSIN [1O(MOI/]1WS TOU/TW| &etc. &@Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. I p. 333 Sudh.$ A(/MA ME\N GA\R E)[1P]1AGGE/[1L]1LONTAI POLITIKOU\S P[1OIH/]1SEIN KAI\ XRHSI/MOUS [1T]1H=I PO/LEI KAI\ TOI=S FI/LOIS, [1A(/]1MA D' A)POLOGOU=NTAI PERI\ TH=S TE/XNHS, W(S OU)K OU)/SHS FAU/LHS, A)LLA\ TW=N [1XR]1WME/NWN AU)T[1H=]1I FAU/LWS: W(/SPER DUNATO\N TOU\S GENOME/NOUS OI(/OUS DEI= [1KAI\]1 TH=| PO/LEI XRHSI/MOUS KAI\ TOI=S FI/LOIS, E)N TAU/THI TH=I DUNA/MEI A)GNW[1MO/]1NWS [1FE/R]1ESQ[1AI &etc. &@p. 334.$ [1EI)]1KH=| D[1E/ TI]1S TW=N P[1ONH]1RW=N E)NI/O[1T' E)N P]1O/LE[1SIN]1 TH=| TE/XNH| XRH=[1T]1AI. GENOME/NOUS ME\N GA\R OI(/O[1US]1 DEI= KAI\ TH=I PO/LEI [1XR]1H-SI/MOU[1S]1 KAI\ TOI=S FI/LOIS, [1OU)]1K E)ND[1E]1XO/MEN[1O]1N A)GN[1W]1MO/NWS XRH=SQAI TOU/T[1OIS]1, OU(\S E)PHNO/RQWSAN, OU)D' A)GNW/MONAS KA[1I\ P]1ONHROU\S KA[1I\ DW]1RODO/KO[1U]1S TIN[1A\S]1 O)/NT[1A]1S KAI\ PO/[1L]1EI K[1AI\ FI/LOIS E]1I)=NAI XRHSI/-M[1OUS]1. @&Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. I p. 337 Sudh.$ KAI\ DIKOLO/GO[1N. PRW=]1TON ME\[1N TO]1I/NUN PROS[1E]1KTE/ON [1H)=]1N, MH/POT' O[1U)]1K [1A)]1FAIRH=I [1TW=N]1 NEWTE/RWN TO\N PO/Q[1O]1N TH=S R(HTORIKH=S A)LL' E)[1P]1ITEI/NHI DIA\ TW=N [1K]1ATH-GORIW=N. KA)\N GA\R E)MF[1A]1NW=[1S]1 A)/LLO TI LE/GW[1SI]1N, QAUMA/[1ZOU]1S?I? TH\N OU(/TW GE P[1RAKT]1IKH\N DU/[1NAM]1IN OI(=ON [1TH\N]1 MEMUQEUME/NHN [1PERI\ T]1O\N *AU)TO/[1L]1UK[1ON KAI\ TOU\]1S O(MOI/OUS. @&Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. I p. 344 Sudh.$ __TOU\]1S DE\ FILOSO/FOUS DUNA[1T]1OU/S, G[2E]2LOI=ON H)=N KEL[1EU/]1EIN AU)TA\ PARIE/NAI GEGRA[1M]1MATEUKO/SI KAI\ KEXOREU[1KO/]1SI KAI\ TETELWNHKO/SI KAI\ TH\N W(/RAN PEPWLHKO/SI: EI) DE\ E)?K?E/?L?EU?S?E MH\ PARAXWREI=N LE/[1G]1EIN, A)LL' A)NT[1IPOIEI=]1-SQAI [1TW=]1N A)POTELESMA/T[1W]1N, A)P[1OR]1W/TERON POIEI= TO\ [1SU]1M[1BAI=NON, OU)]1 FA/SKWN U(PO\ TW=N I)DI[1W]1TW=N PARA!!!!%5!!!SQAI. @&Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. I p. 344 Sudh.$ _EI)=]1NAI TO\ KAT' A)LLH/LW[1N EI)]1RHKE/NAI [1T]1OU\S R(H/TO[1RA]1S, A(\ PARATI/QHSI, KAI\ TOU= PAMPONH/ROUS GEGONE/NAI TOU\S FILOSO/FOUS SH[1ME]1I=O?N H(GH/SETAI TA\ KA[1T']1 A)LLH/LWN PAR' AU)TOI=S GEGRAMME/NA: KAI\ POLU\ MA=LLON O(/SW| TOI=S ME\N OU)K A)PARE/SK[1E]1I TO\ KAI\ YEUDE/S POU [1LE/GEIN &etc. @&Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. I p. 345 Sudh.$ OU)DE\ GA\R TH\N TW=N I)ATRW=N TE/XNHN %5 DEI]1XQH/S[1E]1SQA[1I]1 TH=S U(G[1IEI/A]1S OU)K A)PERGASTI-[1KH\]1N [1O]1U)=SAN, E)PEIDH\ NIKW=N[1TAI]1 U(PO\ TW=N I)DIWTW=N, FA/RMAKON I(STORH-KO/TWN TI NOSH/MATOS A)PALLAKTIKO/N, A)GN[1O]1OU=NTES AU)TOI/. TW=N TE R(H-[1T]1O/RWN OI( DIAFE/RONTES OU) POLLA/KIS U(P' I)DI[1W]1TW=N H(TT[1W=]1N[1TAI]1 TOI=S PRA/GMASIN [1H)\ OU) POL]1LA/KIS A)/GAN, KATA[1LAL]1EI=SQAI DE\ POL[1LA/KI]1S @1 [1POL%5LO]1U=? DE/OUSIN, EI) MH/ PO[1U A)/]1%5FWNOI DIA\ SWMATI[1K]1H\N NO/SON H)\ A)X?AN[1E]1I=[1S U(P]1O/ TINOS PA/[1QO]1US [1GEGEN]1H[1M]1E/NOI. @&Hac Philodemi refutatione probatur Diogenis verba esse, quae &leguntur p.343.$ A)/LLOI DE\ [1MI]1KRW=[1I EU)]1LABE/STERON TH\N PRW/[1THN E)]1PAG-GE/LLONTAI KAI\ O(/MWS TOIAU=TA SUN[1G]1RAFO/MENOI OU) MO/NON KATA\ TA\ PRA/G-MAQ' H(T[1T]1W=NTAI A)LLA\ KAI\ KA[1T]1ALALHQE/NTES POLL[1A/KIS]1 U(P' I)DIWTW=N, OU)[1D]1E\[1N OU(/]1TWS E)STI\N PEI[1S]1TIK[1O\N W(]1S A)LH/[1Q]1EIA KAI\ H( [1PERI\ TW=]1N PRAGMA/TWN [1A)ME]1TA/[1PTW]1TOS E)MPEIR[1I/]1A. @&Ad ultima verba referri videntur, quae Philodemus disputat p. 346%10$ E)MP[1EIRI/A A)META/PTWTO/S]1 E)STI: [1TOU)N]1AN[1TI/]1ON DE\ OU) TW=N R(HTO/RWN, A)LLA\ TH=S <20*DIOGE/NOUS>20 KAI\ TW=N O(MOI/WN E)PAGGELI/AS U(PE\R TOU= R(H/TO[1R]1A KA[1I\]1 MO/NON EI)=NAI TO\N SOFO\N [1A)]1PO[1FA]1TIKO/N. OI( ME\N GA\R %5!!!A/KASI TH\N A)LH/[1Q]1E[1IAN E(]1KA/STOU [1TW=N PO/]1LE[1I SUM]1FERO/NTWN KATA\ [1TH\N I(STO]1RI/AN TH=S!!!&etc. &@Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. I p. 346 Sudh.$ __EI)=NAI *FI/LWNOS, O(\ [1*DHMH/]1TRIOS O( *FALHREU\S E)N [1T]1W=| PERI\ TH=S R(HTORIKH=S E)/TA-[1C]1EN, I)/SWS TA\ PRA/GMAT' A)/LLA. KAT' AU)TOU= DE\ KAI\ TA\ PERI\ QATE/[1RO]1U *FI/LWNOS. E[1I)/]1TE GA\R O( MA=LLON EI)DW\[1S TW=N]1 EI)DO/TWN ME\N !!!!!AQ', H(=[1T]1TON D' E[1I)DO/]1TWN A)FEI/L[1E]1TO TH\N E)RGOLAB[1I/AN TW=|]1 A)NASKE[1UA/S]1AI, !KOI!!!%5SEI TO\N [1O(/LW]1S A)/PEI[1RON]1 SOFO\N TW=N POLITIKW=N O( TH\N A)/KRAN E)SXHKW\[1S]1 R(H/TWR E)MP[1EIRI/]1AN A)[1PO\]1 TW=N !EW!!!!!! [1KAI\]1 DU[1N]1A/-ME[1NOS &etc. &@Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. I p. 347 Sudh.$ __LEIN MA=LLO[1N PLANWM]1E/NWN H)\ MH\ PL[1ANWM]1E/NWN, U(P[1O\]1 <20*DIOGE/NOUS>20 [1DE\ K]1AI\ T[1W=N PA]1RAPLHSI/WN SXEDO\[1N]1 DI%5A\ T?[1W=N]1 LEGOME/NWN [1E)]1CAPATA=SQAI, KAI\ KAT[1AS]1KEUAS[1T]1IKO\N FE/REI TO[1U= M]1H\ PLANA=N TOU\[1S R(]1H/TO[1R]1AS, A)LLA\ TA\ LI!!!!!!TO !! %5 PEI/QEIN KA[1TA\ TO\ PL]1EI=S[1T]1ON: PEI/QEIN !!!! &etc. &@Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. I p. 348 Sudh.$ TOU\S ME[1GA/]1-LOUS [1TW=N]1 PR[1O/TER]1ON R(H[1T]1O/[1RWN KATA\]1 SU/NESIN E)Z?HKE/NAI POLITIKH\N K[1AI\]1 ME[1G]1A/L[1H]1N EU)A[1GWGI/AN T]1AI=S [1P]1O/[1LE]1SIN? [1E)N]1AP?ER?[1GA/SA]1SQ[1A]1I B[1IW]1%5TIKH/N: TOU\[1S]1 N[1U=]1N [1G]1A\R [1&post duos versus%10$]1 OI( DE\ KAI\& etc. &@Col. LIII, 9.$ KAI\ PRO\[1S O)/X]1LON TUG[1XA/N]1O[1U]1SI, [1M]1HQE\N MAQO/NTWN [1P]1OT[1E\ !]1AS1!!!!! %5 DHN, MH/[1T' A)PO\ TH=]1S E)M?P?[1EI]1R?I/AS E)N[1DO/C]1WN GEGONO/-TWN MH/T' A)[1P]1O\ TOU= KALW=S [1E)/XONT]1OS [1PR]1OSERXOME/[1NWN TAI=S]1 A)RXAI=S, A)LL' A)[1PO\%5 !!!!!!!!!!! PE]1RI\ LALH/SEWS @&Col. LIV.$ [1KAI\ TOU/]1TWI P[1ARA]1PLH/SIOI/ TINES OU)[1QE\N MA]1QO/NT]1ES. @1 E)MPEI/RW[1S GA\R E)/]1XEIN [1K]1AI\ A)[1P]1O\ TOU= K[1ALLI/]1STOU PRO[1SE/R]1XES[1QAI TAI=S]1 A)RXAI=S, A)PEI/RG[1ESQAI DE\ MH\]1 TOU\S TELEI/OUS KA[1T' A)RETH\N]1 KAI\ [1T]1A\S PO/L[1EI]1S D?U?[1NATOU\S]1 BR[1AB]1E[1U/]1EIN. A)LLA\ [1TH\N]1 ME\N I(S[1TORI/]1AN. @&Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. I p. 350 Sudh.$ TO\ DE\ TOU\S]1 A)RCA[1M]1E/?[1NO]1U?S? A)[1PO\ TOU=]1 DU/NAS[1QAI SIW]1PA=N, W([1S]1 PARA\ *CENOKRA/TEI, MONWTA/TOUS KAI\ LE/GEIN EI)DE/NAI_TAU)TOU= GA\R E(KA/TERON EI)=NAI_TI/[1NI]1 PRO[1S]1E/XO[1N]1TES, W)= PRO\S QEW=N, PISTEU/SOMEN, EI) MH\ TW=| *CENOKRA/THN OU(/-TWS [1E)]1P' *)ANTIPA/[1T]1ROU KAI\ TW=N SUNE/DRWN DIALEXQH=NA[1I, KAQA/]1P[1ER O(]1 *FALHREU\S [1I(STO/RHKEN E)N T]1W=I [1PERI\ TH=S R(HTORIKH=S]1; @&Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. I p. 350 extr. Sudh.$ K]1AI\ TOU\S E)[1PI]1SHM[1O]1TA/T?OU[1S TW=]1N [1E)M]1P?RA/[1K]1T?[1WN R(]1HTO/[1R]1WN, DI[1A\ TH\]1N E)[1M]1FAI-NOME/NHN E)K TW=N F[1I]1LOSO/FWN SUNER[1G]1I/AN, H)=XQ?[1AI]1 PAR' AU)T[1W=N]1, W(/[1SPER *PE]1RI[1K]1LE/A KAI/ TINAS A)/LLOUS A)/RXON[1TAS KAI\]1 *DH[1MO]1SQE/NHN, KAI\ [1OU)]1-DE\N P?[1LHMELH=]1SAI TOI[1OU=]1TON, OI(=ON [1*SW]1KRA/TE[1I]1 PARABALO/N[1TAS]1 *)ALKI-[1BI]1A/D[1HN]1 T?E KAI\ [1*KR]1ITI/A[1N]1. TH=S [1D']1 AU)TH=S U(/[1LHS]1 T[1H\N TW=N R(H]1TO/-RWN E)/X[1ESQAI]1 &etc. &@Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. I p. 351 Sudh.$ _LAIS TH\[1N]1 %5 A)!!NT!I IIN [1P]1AREIS[1H=G]1EN: TOI=S D' O(/PLOIS OU)[1K E)/O]1IKEN. TA\ ME\[1N]1 GA\R OU)QE\N EU)FUE\S PROSFE/RETAI PRO\S A)PA/THN MEMHXANHME/NON, H( D[1E\]1 TW=N R(H[1TO/R]1WN EI)SAGWGH\ PA/NTA [1T]1A\ QEWRH/MATA PR[1O\]1S TOU=T' E)/XEI TEI/-NO[1NTA]1 KAI\ KATA\ TO\N *(HRA/KLEITON KOPI/DWN E)STI\N A)RXH[1GO/S.]1 @&p. 354 col. LXII.$ TA\ [1ME\N GA\R OU)QE\N E]1U)FUE\S E)/XE[1I PRO\S A)PA/T]1HN MEMHXA[1NH]1ME/N[1ON]1, H( DE\ TW=N R(HTO/RWN [1E]1I)S[1A]1GWGH\ PA/NTA TA\ QEWRH/MATA PRO\S TOU=T' E)/XEI TEI/NONTA KAI\ KATA\ TO\N *(HRA/KLEITON KOPI/DWN A)RXHGO/S: PW=[1S]1 GOU=N E)/ST[1I]1N, XWRI\S TOU= PA/NT' E)PIDEI=CAI TA\ QEWRH/MATA, PRO\S O(\ LE/GEI TEI/NONTA [1MA=LLON H)\]1 MHQE\N A(PLW=S EI)PEI=N; H)\ TI/S A)\[1N T]1O\ P[1R]1O/-TERON TOU=T' A)N[1E/XOIT']1, A)PO\ TOU= R(H[1Q]1HSOME/NOU KA[1I\ L]1EGO[1ME/]1NOU PRO\[1S AU)]1TW=[1N& etc. &@p. 355 col. LXIII.$ TA/XA D' I)/[1SW]1S A)[1FORMH/N]1 TIN' [1OU(/]1TW[1S]1 DI/-DWSIN E)N[1I/]1O?IS PRO\S A)PA/THN TW=N A)KO[1UO/]1NTWN. "1A)LLA\ NH\ *DI/A TOU=[1T]1O TOI=S O(/PLOIS, E)REI= TIS, OU) SUMBE/BHKEN, [1T]1O\ D[1ID]1O/NAI PRO\S A)PA/THN A)FOR-MA/S."2 OU)KOU=N TOU=T' E)XRH=N, E)[1GW\ F]1H/SW, LE/GEIN SUMBEBHKE/NAI TOI=S TH=S R(HTORIKH=S QEWRH/MASIN, MA=LLON DE\ TISI/N, A)LL' OU) TO\ PA/NTA KAI\ TH\N EI)SAGWGH\N EI)S TOU=TO TEI/NEIN. @&Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. I p. 352 Sudh.$ DI[1O\ KIN]1A/DOIS *)ARISTOFA/NHS A[1U)]1TOU\S E[1I)]1KA/[1Z]1EI& etc. &@col. LIX.$ [1TW=N MA/LISTA]1 P[1EPI]1STEUME/NW[1N EU)=]1 I(STORI/A[1N G]1RA/-FEIN, [1OU)K A)G]1ENOU=S TINOS KAI\ A)[1N]1E[1PIGR]1A/FOU PAR[1A]1TIQEI/S. [1OU) M]1O/- @1NON D' *)AL[1E/C]1AN[1DR]1ON H)RE/QIZ[1O]1N, A)LLA\ KAI\ TO\N PATE/R[1A]1. KON!!!! !!!WN KWMW|DOPOIO\N [1TH=]1S EI)S TOU\S R(H/TORAS !!!MNHSQEI\S [1BLA]1SFHMI/AS, O(/QEN, FH[1SI/N, O]1U) KAKW=S MO!OK!U!NHNE!!WNPE!!!!!!RE!!ATO!! DOP!H!UE. @&col. LX.$ E)]1PIRER!!!!!!!!!!!! %5 PROSDO[1K]1W=N T!!!!!!!!!%5 NU=[1N]1 GE DIAM[1AX!!!!!! %5 FILOSO/FWI XARAKTH=RI %5 PIE!EI PRO\S !!!!ORON TO\N FILO/SOFON. OU) MH\N A)LL' E)/TI [1T]1AU=TA PA/NT' E)P[1IME]1LW=S E)PIKO/YOMEN, EI) KA[1I\]1 DI' AU(TOU\S A)NAGKA[1Z]1O/MEQA KAI\ AU)TOI/ P[1W]1S TA\ PARAPLH/SIA P[1A/NT]1A LE/GEIN. TI/S GA\R OU)K A)\N DIETRA/P[1H TO\]1N <20*DIOGE/NOUS>20 [1E)]1PH-[1REAS]1MO/N, MH\ PIQANW/[1TERO]1N PROSFE/RONTA KA[1T' AU)TW=]1N? H)\? O( *P?[1W=L]1O?S%1 EI)SH=K[1TAI P]1ARA\ *PLA/TWN[2I]2 A)__ @&col. LXI.$ TO\ D']1 AU)= FH=SAI TO\ R(HQE\N O(/MOION EI)=NAI TW=I LE/GEIN [1W(S %5 OU)DE\N]1 KWLU/EI TH\N ME/QODON EI)DE/NAI, KAQ' H(\N !PERGA POIOU=SI KAINA\ [1F]1AI/NESQAI KAI\ KAQ' H(\N [1A)P]1OTE/MNOUSI BALLA/NTI[1A]1, MH\ ME/NTOI XRH=SQAI KA[1T']1 A)NQRW/PWN, A)LL' O(/TAN XREI/A GE/NHTAI, TAU)TO/N [1E)]1STIN TW=I MHDE\N E)/[1X]1E?I?N? A)NTEIPEI=N. EI)=NA[1I GA\]1R AU)[1T]1H=I XRH=SQAI [1P]1R?O\[1S !!!!!%5!!N KAI\ P[1R]1O\[1S]1 SO__ @&col.LXIX p. 359.$ TA\ DE\ LEGO/]1M?E?N?[1A %5 KATA\]1 *DHMOS[1QE/]1NOUS KAI\ *LUKOU/RGOU PERI\ TW=N *(A[1R]1PA[1L]1EI/WN YEUDH= PEIRA/SONTAI DEIKNU/EIN, [1O(\N]1 DE\ TW=N MA/LISTA PEPISTEUME/NWN I(STORI[1O]1GRA/FWN GRA/FEIN A(/ FHSIN LE/-GEI[N], KAI\ P[1A/]1NTWS A)SHMO/TATON EI)=NAI DIA[1TE]1NOU=NTAI KAI\ DUSMENH= KAI\ TO\ PE/RAS A)[1N]1AI[1D]1E[1I/AS]1. A)PARN[1H/]1SONTAI D' EI)KO/TWS KAI\ *)ALE/CANDRON AU)TOU\S H)REQ[1IKE/]1NA[1I K]1AI\ TO\N PATE/RA [1POL]1U\ PRO/TERON E)P __ @&Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. I p. 355 Sudh.$ [1KAI\ MH\N]1 PER[1I]1O[1U]1SI/AN KAI\ SW/[1MA]1TOS [1I)S]1XU\N KA[1I\ K]1A/LLO[1S]1 KAI\ [1MU]1RI/' A)/LLA PROFE/REIN [1EI)=]1XEN A)/[1N]1 TIS, A)FORMH\N M[1E/N]1 TISIN EI)S A)DIKI/AN A)[1N]1QRW/-PWN DIDO/NTA, TETIMHME/NA DE\ XA/RIN W)FELI/AS KAI\ PAREXO/MENA POLL[1OI=S, X]1RHSTA\ DE\ LEGO/MENA KAI\ U(PO\ <20*DIOGE/NOUS>20. EI) D' O)/NTWS A(MIL[1LA=]1SQAI DUNATO/S E)STIN O( R(H/TWR KAI\ TH\N SIWP[1H\N]1__ @&col. LXV.$ [1TAU/TH|]1 ME\N DU[1NH/SETAI/ TIS KAI\ TO]1U\S *STWI+KOU/S, [1EI) MH\]1 KA[1I\]1 TOU\S FILOSO/FOUS A(/PANTAS LE/GEIN O(RA=SQAI TOIOU/TOUS KAI\ E)PI-DEIKNU/EIN TINA\S R(H/TORAS OU) TOIOU/TOUS, EI) KAI\ PAID?A[1R]1IWDW=S OU(=T[1OS, PROSDO]1K?H/[1S]1AS U(POPTEUQ[1H/]1SESQA[1I H)\]1 A)PANTHQH/SESQAI, TOU=TO PROSE/-QHK[1EN: "1E)A\]1N MH/ TIS OI)KEI/AS H(/T[1TWN]1 H)=I FU/SE[1WS."2 !!!!!!!TO]1U\S A)POLA?[1U/]1ONTAS E(AUT[1W=N]1 A)N[1QRW/P]1OUS KAI\ LO/GOUS: %5 C!!!!!A!EN!I KAI\ DI_&etc. &@Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. I p. 357 Sudh.$ _KAQ[1A/PE]1R E)N *LA[1KEDAI/MO]1NI, FA[1NH=N]1AI TOU\S R(H/TORAS H)|[1TI]1A=TO: A)/L[1L]1AI DE\ POLLAI\ @1 SUNTUXI/AI KAI\ [1P]1ONHRI/AI PA/NTH| DIA\ TW=N A)NQRW/PWN. [1E)]1W= GA\R O(/TI KA[1I\]1 A)PO\ FILOSOFI/AS W(RM[1H]1ME/NOU[1S E)/X]1OI [1A)\]1N E)PIDEIKNU/EIN TINA\S AI)-TI/OUS KA[1I\ SU]1NAITI/OUS TW=N EI)RHME/NWN. EU)PORH/SOUSI DE\ KAI\ DHMOKRA-TI/AS E)K TURANNI/DWN PARAFE/REIN [1KAI\]1 FULAKA\S E)K POL[1EMI/WN K]1AI\ SWTHRI/A[1S E)K TW=N MEGI/S]1TWN SUMF[1ORW=N TOU\S]1 R(H/TORA[1S E)CEURHKO/TAS.]1 @&col. LXVII.$ [1O(MO]1I/WS *)A[1QH/]1NH[1SI TO\ GE/NOS E)]1FU/ET[1O TO\]1 TW=N TU-RA/NNWN, O(/POU PLEI/ONES E)GE/NONTO R([1H/]1TORES H)\ SULLH/BDHN KATA\ TH\N A(/PASAN OI)KOUME/NHN, A)LHQE\S EI)=NAI DU/NATAI TO\ MHDEMI/AN P[1O/LIN NH\]1 *DI/A R(H/TORAS E)K DHMOKRATI/AS EI)S TURANNI/DA PERISTH=SAI. SIWPW= GA\R O(/TI KAI\ TA\S [1AI)]1TI/AS A(\S FA!%5!AS U(PE/GRAYE, KOINA\S [1ME\N]1 EI)=NAI KAI\ PANTO\S O)/XLOU SUMB[1H/SE]1TA[1I @&Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. I p. 358 Sudh.$ O( D' *A[1I)SXI/]1-NHS OU)K A)\N E)PET[1EI/M]1A TOI=S *)AQHNAI/OIS O(/[1TI]1 *DHMOSQE/NHN OU)X W(S TOU\S PERITRE/YANTAS TW=N PORQME/WN E)KW/[1L]1U[1ON E)]1PEUQU/NEIN A)NATE[1TR]1AFO/TA TH\N *(ELLA/DA: K[1A]1KW=S <20*DIOGE/NHN>20 E)ROU=SIN LE/[1GEI]1N "1OU) XRH=SQAI TOI=S AU)TOI=S R(H/TORSI TOU\S *)AQHNAI/OUS."2 @&Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. I p. 359 Sudh.$ R(H/T]1O[1RAS DE\ E)KBEBLHKE/]1NAI KAI\ TEQANATWKE/NAI TA\S *)AQH/NAS. EI) D' E)/NIAI KAI\ R(H/TORAS E)KW/LUSAN PROSIE/NAI, MH\ MO/NON SUMBOULEU/EIN, A)LLA\ POLLA\S KAI\ TA\S MEGI/STAS DIATELEI=N AU)TOI=S XRWME/NAS. KAI\ PA/LIN TOU\S R(H/TORAS MH\ PA/N-TAS AU)XOU=NTAS, W(S E)/FH OU(=TOS, E)PITHD[1EU/ONTAS DIA]1TELEI=N TO/LMAN. KAI\ [1GA\R T]1W=N A)/LLWN [1T]1OU\S [1ME\]1N KAKOURG[1EI=N]1, TOU\S [1DE\]1 KAI\ TA)GAQA/ PWS PEI/[1QEI]1N. @&Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. II p. 202 Sudh.$ TW=N ME\N [1G]1A\R PANARE/TWN, OI(/OU FATE\ [1T]1OU\S POLEITIKOU\S U(PA/R[1XEIN %5!EIN [1O]1U)DEI\S OU)-DE\ *FWKI/WN, A)\N A)/RA DO/CH| KALEI=SQ[1AI, O(\N]1 E)/FH DH/MO[1U G]1ENE/SQ?A?I? [1SW-TH=RA]1 %5 DIA\ TW=N E(AUTOU= LO/GWN, [1KATA\]1 <20*DIOGE/NHN>20 [1P]1ANA/RE[1TO/S TIS]1 H)=N. @&Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. II p. 203 Sudh.$ O(/]1TAN MH\ T[1OU=]1 KA[1LOU= XA/RIN PR]1OSE/RXWNTAI T[1W=I]1 POLI[1TEU/]1ESQAI, TEWR%5!!ON!HGO !!!ENOI, KAQA/PER E)N TH=[1I *SKUQ]1W=N E)RHMI/A| DI[1AL]1EGO/MENOS OU(/TWS GRA/-FEI. [1T]1A\ ME\N [1G]1A\R A)/LLA P[1A]1REI/SQW, [1E)]1PEI\ TO/N GE S[1UNAR]1MO/TTONTA LO/GON E)[1CHGH]1SA/MEQA PRO/TERON DI[1O/TI OU)]1 TOU= KALOU= XA/RIN PRO[1SE/R]1-XE[1S]1QAI DEI= T!!!!WN T!! %5 *A*S3*S3*T*O!!NEI [1&post duos versus%10$ O( NO]1OU/-MENOS D' U(PO\ TH=S [1*STO]1A=S OU)/TE GE/GONEN [1OU)/TE E)/STI]1N OU)/T' [1E)/]1STAI POTE/& etc. &@Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. II p. 204 Sudh.$ META\ DE\ TAU=TA LI/AN E)PE[1NH/NEKTAI A)/]1PIST[1ON: "1DH=LOI D' OU) METE/XON]1TES [1TW=N TOIOU/TWN E)PISTH]1MW=N, [1O]1U)/[1TE A)NALI/SKONTES]1 XRO/NO[1N OU)/TE D]1AP[1A/NHN OU)/]1T' A)SX[1O- @1L]1I/AN U(POME/[1NON]1TES E(/NEKA [1T]1W=N TOIOU/TWN OU)D' U(POTA/TTONTES E(AUTOU\S OU)[1DE]1NI\ PW/POTE TW=N TA\ TO[1IAU=]1TA E)PANGELLOME/NWN."2 @&Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. II p. 207 Sudh.$ TO/ TE [1FA/-S]1KEIN D[1IA]1TETELEKE/NA[1I]1 TOU\S R(H/TORAS FAI/NONTA/S TE KAI\ E[1U)]1QU/NONTAS [1KAI\ EU)QU]1NOM[1E/N]1OUS, PIKRI/A| [1KAI\ E)P]1HR?EI/A| E)STI\ XA?R?IZOME/N[1WN]1 A)NQRW/-PWN. TOU\S [1G]1A\R E)PISH/MOUS AU)TW=N EU)QUNKO/TAS ME/N POTE KA[1I\ A]1U)TOU\S U(PESXHKO/T[1AS]1 E[1U)Q]1U/NA[1S]1 KAI\ PARE[1IL]1H/F[1A]1M[1E]1N KAI\ [1O( POL]1ITIKO\S FILEI= BI/OS TA\ T[1OIA]1U=TA P[1A/SXE]1IN TE KAI\ PRA/TTEIN KA!!OG!%5NH-MENO& etc. &@Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. II p. 208 Sudh.$ EI) DE\ MO/NOS <20*DIOG[1E/NH]1S>20 DH=|MON I(STO/RHKE [1PRAG]1MAT[1IKO\]1N ME\N AU)TW=N O[1U)D]1E/N[1A LABO/]1NTA, DIA\ PANTO\S DE\ PR[1O\S X]1A/[1RIN]1 O(MIL[1O]1U=NTAS KAI\ TO/[1GE]1 QEW-RIKO\N D[1IDO/N]1TAS [1H)\ K]1AT' A)/LLON TRO/[1P]1ON [1T]1A\ [1KOINA\]1 DIA[1NE/MON]1TA[1S]1, I)/S[1WS BE/L]1TIO?[1N E)/X]1OM[1EN]1 OI( MHD[1E\]1N I(STO[1RHK]1O/TES T[1W=N P]1ERI\ TOU\S [1R(H/]1T[1ORAS: TO\ M]1E\[1N]1 GA\R E)[1NI/]1OUS TOIOU/TOU[1S GE]1GONE/N[1AI, P]1OLLOU\S DE\ KAI\ PRAGMATIKA\ [1SU]1MBEBOU[1LE]1UKE/NAI KAI\ DI[1A/NO]1I[1AN]1 E)NBRI[1Q]1E-STE/RAN E)/XONT[1A KAI\ M]1ETA\ PAR)R(HSI/AS POLLH=[1S PEPOLIT]1EU=SQAI KAI\ PE-P[1OLEMHKE/N]1AI TOI=S TA\S NEMH/[1SEIS TW=]1N KOINW=N EI)SHGOU[1ME/NOI]1S, KAI\ TA\S I(STORI/AS E)DO[1CA/]1ZOMEN H(MI=N MARTURH/SEIN. @&Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. II p. 209 Sudh.$ A)K[1O]1LOU/QWS DE\ TOU/TOI[1S]1: "1I(KANO/N, [1F]1HSI/N, EI)=NAI DEI= TO\N POLITIKO\N A)/RXEIN TA\S KATA\ PO/LI[1N A)]1RXA/S, R(H/TW[1R]1 D' OU) D[1U/NATAI"2]1 &etc. &@col. VII, 7.$ OU) M[1H\]1N O(/ GE TH=S I)DIWTE/RAS TUN[1XA/]1NWN PROSHGORI/AS POLITIKO\S E)PI\ TO\N [1STRA]1THGEI=N DUN[1A/M]1ENON KAI\ NAUARXEI=N [1E)PI]1DIA-TEI/NEI& etc. &@Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. II p. 210 Sudh.$ E)/TI KATAGE-LA/[1STWS FHSI/N "1TH=S ME\N]1 R(HTOR[1IKH=S A)]1N[1TI]1POIOUME/N[1HS O]1U) [1P]1AN[1TO\]1S TOU= [1P]1OLITIKOU= KAI\ OU)!!NOU, TOU= D' I)DI/[1WS KAI\]1 K[1A]1TA\ P?O/[1LEIS SUM]1-BOULEU/[1EIN& deest unus versus$ TO\N SOF]1O\N [1A)/]1RXEIN [1A(PA/SAS]1 TA\S K[1A]1TA\ PO/L?IN A)[1RXA/S& post tres versus%10$]1 OU) MO/NON [1TH\N!!!!!!!!! %5 !!AN FRO/-NHSIN E)C!!!!!!!%5EN, OU)DE\ MO/NO[1N]1 A)GA[1Q]1O/S E)S[1TIN]1 DIALEKTIKO\S KAI\ GRAMMATIKO\[1S KAI\ PO]1HTH\S KAI\ R(H/TWR KAI\ TE[1LEI/WS MEQO]1DIKO\S O( KALO\S E)PI\ PA/SA[1IS G]1E/GON[1EN]1 TAI=S TE/XN[1AI]1S, [1A)LL]1A\ KAI\ PRO\S TW=I SU[1MFE/-RONTI TW=N P]1O/LEWN: [1OU)DE\ TOI=S OI)KOU=SI T]1A\S *)AQH/NAS [1MO/]1NO[1N H)\ *LAKE]1-DAI/MONA SUM[1PO]1L?[1I]1T?E[1U/EI]1: A)[1FR]1O/NWN GA\R POLIT[1EI/A OU)K E)/S]1TI[1N]1 OU)DE\ NO/MOS: A)LLA\ TW=| %5 E)K [1Q]1EW=N KAI\ SO[1F]1W=N SUSTH/MAT[1I, H(=|]1 KAI\ B?A[1SI- @1L]1E[2U\]2S EI)=N[1AI LE/%5GETAI]1 KAI\ STRATHGO\S K[1AI\ KAT]1A\ [1GH=]1N KAI\ KATA\ QA/LA[1TTAN KA]1I\ TAMI/AS KAI\ PRA/[1KTWR KAI\ T]1A\S A)/LLAS KATA\ TRO/PON [1OI)-KO]1NOMEI=N A)RXA/S, E)PEIDH\ [1TO\N]1 POLITIKO\N E)C A)NA/GKHS DEI= KAI\ TH\N A(PA/N-TWN T[1OU/]1TWN E)/XEIN E)PISTH/MHN."2 @&Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. II p. 214 Sudh.$ T[1OU\S]1 ME\N A)PO[1TE/M]1NESQAI TO\ SUMBOULEUTIKO\N AU)T[1H=S]1 ME/RO[1S]1, TOU\[1S]1 DE\ TO\ DI-KA[1NIKO/N]1, TO[1U\S DE\]1 TO\ KATA\ TA\S A)RXA\[1S]1 E)/MPEIRON, W(S E)PI\ I)ATR[1I]1KH=S E)/XEI [1K]1AI\ ZWGRAFI/[1AS]1 KAI/ TINW[1N A)/LLW]1N [1T]1EXNW=N: KAI\ TOU\S P[1ERI\ *DH]1MO[1SQ]1E/NH[1N]1 KAI\ *DHMA/DHN TO\ SUMBOULEUTIKO\[1N]1 KAI\ DIKAN[1IKO\]1N EI)=DOS E)KPEPONHK[1O/TA]1S EI)KO/[1TW]1S U(P[1O\ T]1W=N [1*)AQ]1HN[1AI/]1WN OU)K E)NP[1I-STEU/ESQ]1AI [1TO\]1 ME/ROS, OU(= T[1H\]1N [1E)MPEIRI/A]1N OU)K E)/SXON. @&Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. II p. 216 Sudh.$ PRO\S]1 TO\ KA-LW=S PRESB[1EU/EIN SU]1NERGE[1I=]1N TH\N R(HTORIKH/N. "1*LAKEDAIMO/NIOI, FHSI/N, KAI/P[1ER]1 E)KPAI/ZONTES AU)TH/N, D[1IA\]1 TH=S TUXOU/SH[1S]1 E)NTE[1U/CEW]1S OI)KONO-M[1OU=]1NTAI P[1A=N O(\ Q]1E/LOUSIN."2 [1PR]1W=TON M[1E\N OU)=N]1 OU) DW/SEI TIS OI)-KONOMEI=[1SQ]1AI PA=[1N]1 O(\ QE/LOUSIN *LAKE[1D]1AI[1M]1ONI/OUS A)PO\ T[1H=]1S TUXOU/SHS [1E)]1NTEU/CEWS, OU)D' E[1I)]1D[1E/N]1AI [1F]1H/SEI KALW=S PRESB[1EU/]1EIN, KAI\ PARA\ TAU/THN TH\N [1AI)T]1I/AN OU)K EI)DE/NAI, DIO/TI [1T]1H=S [1R(]1HTO[1R]1IKH=S OU)K [1E)P]1E-MELH/[1Q]1HSA[1N]1, A)LL' U(PO\ <20*DIOGE/NOUS>20 EI)KH=| [1TA]1U=TA PERIF[1E/RESQAI: KA)\N]1 SUGXWRHQH=| DE\ E)[1PIT]1E[1TEU]1XE/NAI K[1A]1TA\ PRE[1SBEI/AS AU)]1TOU/S, A)LLA\ P[1W=S DE/DEIKTAI G]1EI/NESQA[1I AU)TOU\S OU(/TWS A)]1PEI/ROUS TH=S [1R(HTORIKH=S W(/S]1T' E)[1KP]1A[1I/]1ZEIN [1AU)TH/N& etc. &@Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. II p. 218 Sudh.$ E)]1A/N TE DIA\ TOU=[1TO MH\ FH=|]1 TH\N POLITIKH\N R(H[1TORIK]1H\N EI)=N[1AI]1 PA/NTWS, E)PEIDH/ [1TI]1NES OU)K O)/NTES R(H/TORES KALW=S PR[1E]1SBEU/[1OUSIN]1, TO/[1GE]1 TH\N R(HTORIKH\N OU)K EI)=NAI KAI\ POLITIKH\N [1PW=]1S PROSH=KTAI; @&Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. II p. 218.$ "1N[1H\ *D]1I/' A)LLA\ KAI\ *)AQHNA[1I=O]1I KA[1I/PE]1R O)/NTE[1S]1 FILORH/TORE[1S H)/DH]1 PROSKO/PTOUSI TAI=S P[1ERIO/DOIS]1 KAI\ TOI=S [1T]1E/XNHS [1KAI\ DIDAS]1KALEI/[1OU]1 R(HTORIKOU= P[1RO]1S-BA/LLO[1USI]1N."2 GELOI=ON ME\N TO\ N[1U=]1N LE/GEIN PROSKO/P[1T]1EIN *)AQHNAI/OUS TOU/TOIS.& etc. &@Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. II p. 220 Sudh.$ LE/GEIN, A)[1LL' E]1I)SI\N [1KAI\ FI]1LO/SOFOI, [1OI(=ST]1ISIN E)/QOS E)STI\N FLUAREI=N W(/SPER SOI\ KAI\ *KRITOLA/WI, SAFW=S LE/GONTOS A)/KOUSON: "1H(/ G' E)NPEIRI/A TW=N POLITIKW=N R(HTO/RW[1N]1, TO\ SUNE/XON E)/XOU[1SA]1 KEI/[1ME]1NON E)N EU)KAIRI/AS STO[1XASM]1W=I K?A?I\ DIDA/SKEI POL[1LA/K]1IS ME\N E)[1K]1TEI/NEIN MA[1KR]1OU\S LO/GOUS, POLLA/KIS DE\ BA[1I]1A/ TINA DIALEXQH=NAI, PO[1LL]1A/KIS DE\ MHDE\ DIA=RA[1I]1 TA\ [1XEI/L]1H."2 PARA[1I]1ROU/MENOS OU)=[1N E)K]1 TH=S E)PISTH/M[1HS KAI\]1 T[1H=]1S E)NPEIRI/AS [1TA\]1 @1 MA/LISTA PARA[1DIDO/]1MENA, [1E)]1P?EI\ KAI\ TINE\S A)STOXOU=S[1IN]1, AU)TO\[1S]1 GE-LOI=[1O/]1S E)STIN. @&Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. II p. 220, 25.$ "1A)LL' EI) DU/NAN-TAI SULLU=SA[1I PO/]1LEIS KAI\ SUMMA/X[1OUS POI]1H=SAI, GNWRI/MOUS DIA[1FERO]1-ME/NOUS KAI\ [1G]1UNAI=[1KA]1 PRO\S A)/NDRA [1S]1TASIA/[1ZOUSAN H)\ E)R]1AST[1H\N PW=S OU)X OI(=OI/ TE DIALL]1A/T[1TEIN]1 PRO\S T[1O\N E)RW/]1MEN[1O]1N KAI/ PWS A)!!!%5!!! E[1SQAI]1 FILI/AN; T[1H=S GA\R AU)T]1H=S E)[1STIN]1 E)NPEIRI/[1AS E)/%5NA P]1RO\S E(/NA OI)-KEIW=SAI KA[1I\ PLH/QH]1, KAQA/PER TH=S AU)TH=[1S E)NPEIRI/]1AS MI/AN LU/RAN P[1RO\S E(]1TE/[1R]1AN SU/MFWNON POIH=[1SAI]1 KAI\ POLLA\S PRO\S POLLA/S."2 @&Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. II p. 224 Sudh.$ "1KAI\ MH\N NH\ *DI/A, FHSI/N, EI(=[1S H)\]1 OU)D[1EI\S]1 MNHMONEU/ETAI TOU/TW[1N]1 PEPRESBEUKW\S E)PI\ [1TW=|]1 SUMFE/RONTI TH=S P[1ATRI/DOS."2]1 @&p. 225.$ "1A)LL' OU)[1DE\]1 EI(=S, FHSI/N, I(STO/RH[1T]1AI TOU/TWN POLI/THS A)GA-[1QO\S GENO/MENOS."2]1 @&col. XX.$ POLI/TOU POLITIKO\S !!A%5!!NHTA!DAIOS, EI) DE\ P[1OLITIK]1O/N, OU) MO/NON, FH/S[1W]1, TW=N R(HTO/RWN A)LLA\ KAI\ TW=N T[1A\]1S PO/LEIS KATOIKOU/N-TW[1N OU)]1K O)L[1I/GOI X]1WRI\S FILOSO[1FI/%5AS A)/NDR]1ES [1GEG]1O/NASIN POLI[1TI-KOI/: OI(]1 M?E\?[1N G]1A\R A)/F?[1R]1ONE[1S PA/N]1TES [1EI)]1SI\N A)/QLIOI, XRHST[1O\S]1 D' OU)DE\ EI(=S OU)D[1E\ H(/]1MEROS [1OU)]1DE\ FILO/PA[1TRIS OU)]1DE\ TA\[1S A)/LLA]1S DHMW/-D[1EIS A)RE]1TA\S E)/XW[1N, MH/ TI D]1H\ [1T]1A\S TELE[1I/]1OUS. KAI\ %5 PROSE[1NHN]1EGME/-N[1WN TW=N]1 TOIOU/[1TWN E)K]1 FU/SEW/S [1TINA]1 KAI\ A)GW[1GH=S]1, E)/ST[1AI]1 S[1UN]1-DEDOME/[1NON]1 TO\ X[1WRI\S FILOSO]1FI/AS [1POLITIKOU\S DU/NA%5SQA]1I GENE/SQA[1I TINA/S: W(/S%5TE]1 PW=S POLI[1TIKO\]1S O[1U)K]1 E)/S[1TA]1I R(H/TWR XW[1RI\]1S FIL[1OSO]1FI/AS; @&Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. II p. 226 Sudh.$ "1O(/QE[1N]1 ME\N M[1H\ K]1ALW=S PROST[1H/]1SESQAI TO\N R(H/TORA TH=S PATRI/D[1OS]1, KA)\N E)/XH| TH\N E)NPEIRI/A[1N]1, A)/NEU FILOSOFI/AS LE/GO[1MEN."2]1_*PE[1RI]1KLH=S TOI/NUN, O(\N [1E)/FH]1 A)N[1EK]1TO/TATON GE[1G]1O[1NE/NAI TW=]1N A)/LLWN R(HTO/[1RWN, O(/TI *)ANAC]1A-GO/ROU KAI\ [1A)/LLWN TINW=N]1 H)/KOUSEN, FI[1LOSO/FOIS]1 ME\N I)/SWS PARE/BALE, *STWI+[1K]1OI=S D' O[1U)]1DA[1M]1W=S, A)LLA\ KA[1I\ T]1A\S E)NANTI/AS E)S[1X]1HK[1O/SIN D]1O/CAS U(PE\R TW=N O(/L[1WN]1: MO/NON DE\ [1KA]1TA\ *DIO[1GE/N]1HN>20 H( *STWI+KH\ [1P]1OIEI= PO[1LI/T]1AS A)GA[1QOU/S]1 &etc. @&Philodemus de rhetorica Vol. II p. 228 Sudh.$ [1*ZH/NW]1NOS KAI\ *KLE[1A/NQOUS KAI\ *XR]1USI/PPOU KAI\ TW=N T[1OIOU/]1T[1W]1N A(PA/NTWN. A)LLA\ GA\[1R OU)XI\]1 PROSEDREU/EIN [1XRH\ E)PI\ PLE/ON]1 TOI=S <20*DIOGE/NOUS>20 [1LO/GOIS: KAI\]1 GA\[1R OU)/]1T' A)KRIBE\S O[1U)/TE !!]1%5T!!!!TI [1GR]1A/FWN [1FAI/NE]1T[1AI]1 &etc. @1