Home‎ > ‎Wisdom‎ > ‎St. Bonaventure on Wisdom‎ > ‎Chapter 1‎ > ‎Chapter 2‎ > ‎Chapter 3‎ > ‎Chapter 4‎ > ‎Chapter 5‎ > ‎Chapter 6‎ > ‎

Chapter 7

> ‎Chapter 8‎ > ‎Chapter 9‎ > ‎Chapter 10‎ > ‎Chapter 11‎ > ‎Chapter 12‎ > ‎Chapter 13‎ > ‎Chapter 14‎ > ‎Chapter 15‎ > ‎Chapter 16‎ > ‎Chapter 17‎ > ‎Chapter 18‎ > ‎Chapter 19‎ >   
 
 
 

Secondly, from his own example he gives a reason for exhorting to wisdom

 

I myself also am a mortal man, like all others, and of the race of him that was first made of the earth, and in the womb of my mother I was fashioned to be flesh. Above,[274] he warned rulers to acquire and love wisdom by an argument taken from the danger of their office, but now he argues from his own example. He shows, firstly, how he received wisdom, namely, in the present chapter; secondly, how much he loved it, in chapter eight; thirdly, how devoutly he begged it from God, namely, in chapter nine.

 

He shows, firstly, how he acquired wisdom

 

In the first part, as he comes to the topic, he describes, firstly, the trouble of human weakness, and how this prompted him to acquire wisdom: Wherefore I wished, and understanding was given me, and I called upon God, and the spirit of wisdom came upon me; thirdly, he shows by whom he was taught: God has given to me to speak.

 

Firstly, on the trouble of human weakness

 

In the first part he treats, firstly, of the imperfection of human nature; secondly, of the lowly nature of human conception: in the womb of my mother I was fashioned to be flesh; thirdly, the circumstances of birth: I was nursed in swaddling clothes; fourthly, the work of education: I was nursed in swaddling clothes; fifthly, that all share this trouble: none of the kings had any other beginning of birth.

(Verse 1). I myself also am a mortal man, like all others, and of the race of him that was first made of the earth, and in the womb of my mother I was fashioned to be flesh. I advised you to accept the discipline of wisdom by my words[275]; and you can do this not only by my words but also by my example, because I am also, that is, certainly, a mortal man, like yourselves; I say, I am mortal that is, able to die from the first condition, but having to die because of the first sin; according to Boethius,[276] humans are rational but mortal animals; also Romans 8:10: ‘The body indeed is dead because of sin’, that is, committed to the necessity of dying. Like all others, others in this condition of mortality; 2 Samuel 14:14: ‘We all die and like waters that return no more we fall down into the earth’. And of the race of him, namely of Adam the transgressor, that was first made, namely, from the earth; so Genesis 2:7: ‘The Lord God formed man of the slime of the earth’; also 1 Corinthians 15:47-48: ‘The first man was of the earth, earthly’ and ‘Such as is the earthly, such also are the earthly’. And in the womb of my mother I was fashioned to be flesh. For, according to Augustine in his book Eighty-three Different Questions,[277] for the first six days the seed was like milk; after nine more days the milk changes into blood; after twelve more it takes on the shape of a body; after a further eighteen it is formed into an organic body. And then about the forty fifth or forty sixth day a soul is put in the body. During all the time remaining after the infusion of the soul in the body it is living and growing.

(Verse 2). In the time of ten months I was compacted in blood, of the seed of man, according to the philosophers of nature, as a Gloss[278] says: ‘The seed of a woman is full of blood, the seed of a man is white; from a mixture of these, one acting as passive, the other as active, curdling takes place’; Job 10:10: ‘Have you not milked me as milk and curdled me like cheese?’ However, this curdling takes place in the first part of the ten months while the whole time of the development is nine months.

But contra: Because the normal time for formation is nine months;[279] so 2 Maccabees 7:27: ‘My son, have pity upon me that bore you nine months in my womb’.

I reply: As a Gloss[280] says: ‘some are born in the seventh month, some in the eighth, some in the ninth; but those born in the tenth month are said to be more perfect, healthy and vital’. However, Christ, according to a Gloss,[281] was in the womb of his mother ‘for nine months and six days’; so when it says: ten months, it is understood as synecdoche; ‘for it was from twenty fifth March until twenty fourth of December’.

And the pleasure of a dream[282] concurring, or concurring in the pleasurable act of a husband and wife sleeping together. This pleasure is compared to the pleasure of a dream because it covers reason and quickly passes, like the pleasure of a dream.

(Verse 3). And being born I drew in the common air necessary for breathing; Ecclesiastes 3:19: ‘All things breathe alike’. And fell, from the womb of my mother, upon the earth that is made alike, namely, by God as in Genesis 1:1;[283] this is necessary for life and nourishment. And the first voice which I uttered was crying as all others do, namely, those being born. Augustine[284] says that ‘a child by its crying begins to be a prophet of its fate’; ‘they report, that is, they say, that Zoroaster, king of the Bactrians, was the only child to have laughed when he was born’. Also only John the Baptist, against the law of birth, anticipated his birth with joy and exultation; Luke 1:44: ‘The infant in my womb leaped for joy’.

(Verses 4, 5, 6). I was nursed in a covering, namely, in swaddling clothes; Luke 2:7: ‘She wrapped him in swaddling clothes’. And with great care, 2 Maccabees 7:27: ‘I gave you suck for three years and brought you up to this age’.[285]

For none of the kings had any other beginning of birth, for in what concerns nature there is no difference between kings and subjects, only in what concerns fortune.

For all have one entrance into life, namely, through such a poor temporal birth, as it is said; and the like going out, through such a bitter death as described in Ecclesiastes 12:3ff. Also, one entrance, by a poor birth; and the like going out, by the poorest death; Job 1:21: ‘Naked came I out of my mother’s womb and naked shall I return thither’; Ecclesiastes 5:15: ‘A most deplorable evil; as he came, so shall he return’.

 

He shows, secondly, that by this he is directed to wisdom

 

Wherefore I wished, and understanding was given me, and I called upon God, and the spirit of wisdom came upon me. Here he shows that this has directed him to acquire wisdom; and he treats, firstly, of receiving the desired wisdom; secondly, his judgment on the wisdom received: and understanding was given me, that is, wisdom; thirdly, his love for what he has judged: I loved her above health and beauty; fourthly, the sharing of what he has received and loved: Which I have learned without guile, and communicate without envy, and her riches I hide not.

(Verses 7, 8). Wherefore, that is, urged on from reflecting on the aforementioned misfortunes, I wished, namely, for wisdom. And understanding was given me, that is, wisdom; Proverbs 10:24: ‘To the just their desire shall be given’. And I called, Gloss[286]: ‘on the Lord’; James 1:5: ‘If any of you want wisdom, then ask God for it’. And the spirit of wisdom came upon me while I was asking, according to Psalm 118:131: ‘I opened my mouth’, in prayer, ‘and attracted the spirit’; also Sirach 15:5: ‘In the midst of the church she opened his mouth and filled him with the spirit of wisdom’.[287]

And I preferred her, namely by calculating her value, before kingdoms, that is, the grandeurs of kings, and thrones, that is, the grandeurs of judges; and rightly because Proverbs 8:15 says: ‘By me kings reign’. And I esteemed riches nothing in comparison of her, Proverbs 3:15: ‘She is more precious than all riches’. ‘What does it avail a fool to have riches, seeing the fool cannot buy wisdom?’[288]

(Verse 9). Neither did I compare unto her any precious stone, that is, by price or excellence; Psalm 118:127: ‘I loved your commandments above gold and topaz’; also Job 28:16: ‘It shall not be compared with the dyed colours of India, or with the most precious stone sardonyx or the sapphire’. ‘The topaz of Ethiopia shall not be equal to it’. For all gold in comparison of her, is as a little sand, and silver in respect to her shall be counted as clay, as if to say: and rightly because all gold, that is, all the gold in the world, in comparison of her, is as a little sand, namely, unfertile land; Bernard[289]: ‘What is gold other than red earth?’ A little sand, that is, of slight weight; Job 28:15: ‘The finest gold shall not purchase it’. Shall be counted as clay, that is, of no value; Job 28:15: ‘Neither shall silver be weighed in exchange for it’; Proverbs 3:14: ‘The purchasing of her is better than the merchandise of silver, and her fruit than all the best and purest gold’. Clay is compared to silver because it stains the hands and soul; Habakkuk 2:6: ‘How long does he load himself with thick clay?’

Note, that wisdom is preferred to silver, gold and every earthly treasure, firstly, because of its origin, for earthly treasure is of the earth; Job 28:1: ‘Silver has beginnings of its veins and gold has a place wherein it is melted’, indeed, according to blessed Bernard,[290] it is ‘of the earth’; but wisdom is from heaven as is clear in James 3:17.[291]

Secondly, because of its nature, for earthly treasure is something bodily, while wisdom is spiritual; so Isaiah 11:2: ‘The spirit of the Lord shall rest upon him, the spirit of wisdom etc.’

Thirdly, because of its power [earthly] treasure is limited while wisdom is finite; so further on in this same chapter[292] he says: For she is an infinite treasure to people which they that use become the friends of God.

Fourthly, because of its mode of acting, for [earthly] treasure can do but few things while wisdom can do everything; below in chapter 8:5 he says: What is richer than wisdom, which makes all things?

Fifthly, because of its value, for treasure is valued while wisdom is not; Job 28:16: ‘It shall not be compared with the dyed colours of India or with the most precious stone sardonyx or the sapphire’.

Sixthly, because of its usefulness, for wisdom without wealth is a benefit, but riches without wisdom are of no benefit but do harm; so Ecclesiastes 5:12: ‘Riches kept to the hurt of the owner’.

Seventhly, because of its duration, for, as in Wisdom 6:13: Wisdom is glorious, and never fades away; but riches are destroyed; so James 5:2: ‘Your riches are corrupted’; also James 1:11: ‘The rich shall fade away in their ways’.

Eighthly, because of its movement, for wisdom which is from above lifts upwards, while gold and silver draw one down, namely, to the earth; so Baruch 3:18-19: ‘They that hoard up silver and gold, wherein people trust, are cut off and are gone  down to hell’.

I loved her above health and beauty, and chose to have her instead of light: for her light cannot be put out. Here he shows a love for the wisdom he has valued. Firstly, he shows the extent of his love; secondly, its cause: Now all good things came to me together with her, and innumerable riches through her hands.

(Verse 10). I loved her above health; Gloss[293]: ‘of the body’ namely, interior: Psalm 59:13: ‘For human help is vain’; and beauty, Gloss[294]: ‘Of what concerns the body’, namely, exterior beauty, because, Proverbs 31:30 says: ‘Favour is deceitful and beauty is vain’; I loved her, namely, wisdom, because to the degree that spirit is better than body and should be loved more dearly, to that degree spiritual concerns should be loved better and more than bodily concerns. And I loved it so much that I chose to have her instead of light; I say, compared to bodily lights she is the most beautiful, most delightful and best, according to Augustine;[295] in this way wisdom, in spiritual matters, is the light of the soul; Sirach 51:26: ‘In its wisdom my soul bewailed and it enlightened my ignorance’;[296] and Wisdom 7:29: she is more beautiful than the sun. The text continues: For her light cannot be put out, namely, in itself, as stated in Wisdom 7:29-30: Being compared with the light, she is found before it, for after this comes night.

(Verse 11). Now all good things came to me, namely, of graces totally within me; together with her, that is, with uncreated wisdom, the Son of God; so Romans 8:32: ‘He that spared not even his own Son but delivered him up for us all, how has he not also, with him, given us all things?’ Gloss[297]: ‘Whoever seizes hold on Christ, has also grace and life eternal in the future’. Or: With her, that is with created wisdom because it is the most perfect gift. ‘Solomon experienced this when, on asking for wisdom, the Lord added riches and glory’.[298] And innumerable riches, externally in comparison with others, through her hands, that is her works; add: come to me; Wisdom 10:10: Made him honourable in his labours and accomplished his labours.

(Verse 12). And I rejoiced, filled with joy, in all these, namely, with spiritual gifts; Sirach 4:12: ‘Wisdom protects those who seek after her, and will go before them in the way of justice’. This is the column of fire and the cloud that led Israel by night and day, Exodus 13:21.[299] And I knew not, namely, before having her; Gloss[300]: ‘He understands from a practice of meditation that he has advanced to the point where he now thinks of his former knowledge as ignorance when compared to the latter knowledge’. I say, I knew not that she was the mother of them all, namely, the good things; Sirach 24:24: ‘I am the mother of fair love and of fear and of knowledge and of holy hope’; also Sirach 24:25: ‘In me is all grace of the way and of the truth, in me is all hope of life and of virtue’.

Which I have learned without guile, that is, with all my heart, knowing that ‘the holy spirit of discipline will flee from the deceitful, as above in Wisdom 1:5; also Proverbs 2:4-5: ‘If you shall seek her as money and shall dig for her as for a treasure, then shall you understand the fear of the Lord and shall find the knowledge of God’. And communicate without envy, namely, by not hiding what are useful, as above in Wisdom 6:25: Neither will I go with consuming envy; also Proverbs 5:16: ‘Let your fountains be conveyed abroad’. And her riches I hide not, that is, her beauty by covering her with obscure words; Sirach 4:28: ‘Hide not your wisdom in her beauty’; also Sirach 20:32: ‘Wisdom that is hid, and treasure that is not seen, what profit is there in them both?’

(Verse 14). For there is an infinite treasure, in her, for people, and so there is no limit to how much can be given; so Tullius[301] says, that knowledge is a noble treasure of the soul that is increased as it is shared while a covetous owner is shamed; unless treasure is made public, it disappears. Augustine[302]: ‘Every good thing is not diminished by sharing; if it is possessed and not shared, is not yet possessed as it should be’. Sirach 1:21: ‘She shall fill all her house with her increase, and her storehouses with her treasures’. Which, namely, the treasure of wisdom, they that use, by guiding themselves by her, become the friends of God; so below in Wisdom 7:27: She makes the friends of God and prophets. Being commended for the gift of discipline, that is, of wisdom which they do not get by their own efforts but as given by the Holy Spirit, according to 1 Corinthians 12:11: ‘All these things’, namely, the gifts of grace, ‘one and the same Spirit works, dividing to every one according as the Spirit wills’. Being commended, that is, made commendable to God and people; 2 Corinthians 10:18: ‘For not those who commend themselves, are approved, but those whom God commends’.

 

Thirdly, he shows from whom wisdom is learnt

 

And God has given to me to speak as I would, and to conceive thoughts worthy of those things that are given me: because God is the guide of wisdom, and the director of the wise. Here he shows from whom wisdom is learnt; and he shows, firstly, who taught him; secondly, what kinds of things he was taught: God has given to me to speak; thirdly, by what medium he was taught: The worker of all things taught me.

 

Firstly, who did the teaching

 

(Verse 15). And God has given to me to speak as I would. I have said well: She is an infinite treasure to people which they that use become the friends of God; but I have been used; and, for because;[303] God has given to me to speak, that is, not only to know but also to teach; Isaiah 50:4: ‘The Lord has given me a learned tongue that I should know how to uphold by word him that is weary’. To speak, I say, as I would, that is, with a sure opinion; Proverbs 12:19: ‘The lip of truth shall be steadfast for ever’; Psalm 36:30: ‘The mouths of the just shall meditate wisdom and their tongue shall speak judgment’, that is, a sure opinion. And to conceive thoughts worthy of those things that are given me. Note that there is an arrogant presumption of which Judith 6:15 says: ‘You humble those who presume of themselves and glory in their own strength’. But there is a presumption of confidence in divine power and mercy, of which Judith 6:15 says: ‘You do not forsake those that trust in you’; also Judith 9:17: ‘Hear me a poor wretch, making supplication to you, and presuming on your mercy’. And to conceive thoughts, that is, to carry out with confidence, worthy, that is, works of those things that are given me, that is, strenuous and upright works according to the gifts given to me; ‘to whom more is given, more will be required’.[304] Because God is the guide of wisdom; Gloss[305]: ‘That is, author’; Sirach 1:1: ‘All wisdom is from the Lord God’. Also God gives wisdom; James 1:5: ‘If any of you want wisdom, ask for it from God who gives to all abundantly’. And the director of the wise, that is, the corrector; Revelation 3:19: ‘Such as I love, I rebuke and chastise’, namely, if it should happen that they fall into error. ‘Sometimes the good Homer sleeps’.[306] Also Augustine[307]: I will be able to err, but I will never be a heretic.

(Verse 16). For in God’s hand are both we, and our words, and all wisdom, and the knowledge and skill of works. I have said well that God is the guide and the director of the wise, for we are in God’s hands; Gloss[308]: ‘That is, in God’s power’; both we who have wisdom, Jeremiah 18:6: ‘As clay is in the hand of the potter, so are you in my hand, O house of Israel’; also Proverbs 21:1: ‘As the divisions of waters so the heart of the king is in the hand of the Lord’. And our words, Proverbs 16:1: ‘It is the part of mortals to prepare the soul, and of the Lord to govern the tongue’;[309] Matthew 10:20: ‘For it is not you that speaks but the Spirit of your Father that speaks in you’. And all wisdom which is knowledge of divine matters, and of works, namely, human works, the discipline of knowledge;[310] Isaiah 26:12: ‘You have wrought all our works for us’.

 

Secondly, what kinds of things he was taught

 

For God has given me. Here he shows what and what kinds of things God taught him, and firstly, that God taught him knowledge of temporal causes; secondly, of temporal changes: The beginning, and ending; thirdly, of temporal workings: The natures of living creatures.

(Verse 17). For God who alone teaches hearts, according to the words of Augustine[311]: ‘God who teaches hearts on earth has a chair in heaven’; has given me the true knowledge of the things that are, namely, the existence of things because there can be no knowledge of what does not exist; so the Philosopher[312] says: ‘What does not exist cannot be known’. Also as he says[313]: ‘As anything is in relation to being so is it in relation to truth’. True knowledge, namely, sure knowledge with no mixture of error; 1 Kings 4:29: ‘God gave to Solomon wisdom and understanding exceeding much’. To know the disposition of the whole world, namely, the whole world under the encompassing sky; Sirach 24:8: ‘I alone have compassed the circuit of heaven’; and the virtues of the elements, namely, the qualities, seminal reasons, mixtures or connections, and harmonies of the elements; Proverbs 8:27: ‘When the Lord prepared the heavens, I was present, when with a certain law and compass the Lord enclosed the depths’.

(Verse 18). The beginning, and ending, and midst of the times, namely, the four seasons or parts of the year which are caused by the movement of the sun, according to the four quarters of the zodiac; the alterations of their courses, that is, of the successions of days and nights by which the quality of the atmosphere is changed from brightness to darkness and the reverse; and the reckoning[314] of seasons, that is, of both the solar and lunar months. Some add here: changes of behaviour and divisions of times; changes of behaviour, namely, of human customs, according to the diverse states of people; divisions of times, that is, of the ages of the world and of people.[315]

(Verses 19, 20). The revolution[316] of the year, namely, the whole time caused by the movement of the sun through the zodiac; Genesis 1:14: ‘Let them be for signs and for seasons and for days and years’. And the dispositions, in the quality of the nights, of the stars, namely, as distinct from the sun; in Psalm 135:9: ‘The moon and the stars to rule the night’.

The natures of living creatures, namely, tame animals, and the rage of wild beasts, that is, the movement of savage animals such as the lion and similar animals. Note that he says: The natures of living creatures, and rage of wild beasts with reference to living substances. Then he adds with reference to inanimate things: the force of winds which are twelve, four main and eight collateral winds;[317] these are of great strength as is clear in Job 1:19 and Exodus 14:21 in the drying up of the sea and in many other places. And reasonings of people.

Contra: Only God knew human hearts, so in 1 Corinthians 2:11 we read: ‘For who knows the things of a person but the spirit[318] within the person ‘, as if to say: No one other than God.

It must be said that here he is speaking of conjectural knowledge, not knowledge of certitude. Or it has to be said that by the revelation of Scripture they can be known by human beings, not by nature or by their own efforts. The diversities of shrubbery, namely, of plants, and the virtues of roots, namely, of crops; 1 Kings 4:33: ‘He treated about trees from the cedar that is in Lebanon unto the hyssop that comes out of the wall’.

(Verse 21). And all such things as are hid, or concealed,[319] from its causes, and not foreseen, by people, I have learned; Ecclesiastes 7:26: ‘I have surveyed all things with my mind, to know, and consider, and seek out wisdom’.

 

Thirdly, through what medium he was taught

 

For wisdom, the worker of all things, taught me. Here he shows by what medium he was taught, namely, by uncreated Wisdom begotten from the Father; and for what he had been able, what he knew and wanted to teach, what he had been shown, firstly, by the Holy Spirit who comes from uncreated Wisdom; secondly, by the nature and virtue which is in it: For wisdom is more active than all active things and reaches everywhere by reason of her purity.   

In the first part he touches on the procession of the Holy Spirit from uncreated Wisdom; secondly, the multiple effect of the Spirit in us: holy, manifold etc.; thirdly, the goodness of the nature of wisdom: undefiled; fourthly, its overall sufficiency: having all power.

Its effect touches us, firstly, interiorly, secondly, exteriorly: Modest.[320] He treats of the interior effect[321] in four ways, namely, the correcting of sin, when he says: holy; the multiplying of grace, when he says: manifold; the unity of agreement, when he says: one; the subtlety of understanding, when he says: subtle. He treats of the exterior effect in three ways, namely, modest, when he says: Modest; eloquence, when he says: eloquent; obedience, when he says: active.

(Verse 21). There is shown the worker of all things, of all that is above, in the middle and below; the worker is God as in Hebrews 11:3.[322] Wisdom taught me, that is, I was taught by wisdom; Gloss[323]: ‘Because knowledge of truth is given by it’, because a human being can teach externally, but not internally; so Gregory[324]: ‘Unless one who teaches is an inner person, externally the person works with the tongue of a doctor but into a void’.

(Verse 22). For in her is the spirit of understanding, as if to say: she was well able to teach me; for in her, namely, in wisdom is the spirit of understanding; in her by dwelling in the humanity; Isaiah 11:2: ‘The spirit of the Lord shall rest upon him’; it is in her by the divinity emanating from her. I say, she is the giver of the spirit of understanding; Job 32:8: ‘The inspiration of the Almighty gives understanding’. Holy, Gloss[325]: ‘Making all things holy’; above in Wisdom 1:5: The holy spirit of discipline will flee from the deceitful. Manifold, Gloss[326]: ‘Giving manifold graces’; 1 Corinthians 12:4, 11: ‘And there are diversities of graces, but the same Spirit. But all of these things one and the same Spirit works, dividing to everyone according as the Spirit wills’. One, Gloss[327]: ‘Uniting good people’; Ephesians 4:3: ‘Careful to keep the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace’. Subtle, namely, enabling one to penetrate hidden things; 1 Corinthians 2:10: ‘The Spirit searches all things’, that is, enables all things to be searched, ‘even the deep things of God’.[328] Also subtle, namely, by providing stability or giving clarity of understanding; so it is called ‘the spirit of understanding in Isaiah 11:2. Modest,[329] namely, teaching everything in a kindly way; Philippians 4:5: ‘Let your modesty be known to all people’. Eloquent, namely, by making people eloquent; below in Wisdom 10:21: She made the tongues of infants eloquent. Active, namely, by making people active through obedience; Ezekiel 1:20: ‘Wherever the spirit went, the wheels also were lifted up, and followed it: for the spirit of life was in the wheels’.[330]

Undefiled, sure. Here he describes the goodness of its nature and, firstly, its absolute goodness in itself; secondly, its goodness in comparison to us: loving that which is good; thirdly, its firmness in both: steadfast.

He touches on its absolute goodness in three things, namely, in its purity when he says: undefiled; in truth: sure; in its tranquillity when he says: sweet.

(Verse 22). Therefore, he says undefiled; Gloss[331]: ‘That is, without stain’, and so it cleanses stains in baptism; John 3:5: ‘Unless a person be born again of water and the Holy Spirit, the person cannot enter the kingdom of heaven; also in Titus 3:5: ‘By the washing of regeneration, and renovation of the Holy Spirit’. Sure; Gloss[332]: ‘It neither deceives nor is deceived’; so in John 16:13 it is called: ‘The Spirit of truth’. Sweet, namely, tranquil with no trace of harshness; Gloss[333]: ‘Kind and merciful’; below in Wisdom 12:1: ‘O how good and sweet is your spirit, O Lord, in us!’

Loving that which is good, quick, who nothing hinders, beneficent. Here he shows its goodness in comparison to us, firstly, in a love for good; secondly, in promoting goodness: who nothing hinders;[334] thirdly, in communicating or sharing itself: Gentle; fourthly, in communicating what it has: kind.

He says, therefore, loving good deeds; 1 Corinthians 13:6: ‘Rejoice not in iniquity but rejoice with the truth’; who puts no obstacle to doing good, but rather gives help; Romans 8:26: ‘The Spirit helps our infirmity’; Proverbs 3:27: ‘Do not withhold a person from doing good who is able; if you are able, do good yourself too’.

(Verse 23). Gentle, Gloss[335]: ‘Common to all’; Acts 10:34: ‘In every deed I perceive that God is not a respecter of persons’. Or: Gentle, that is, sympathetic of which the sign is what is said in Romans 8:26: ‘The Spirit asks for us with unspeakable groanings’. Or: Gentle: that is, living willingly among people; Proverbs 8:31: ‘My delights were to be with the children of the human race’. Kind, that is, liberal ‘from innate goodness’;[336] above in Wisdom 1:6: The spirit of wisdom is benevolent etc.; also: Kind, by forgiving evils, by giving good things, by guiding to the fatherland; so, in Galatians 5:22, gentleness is said to be a fruit of the Holy Spirit. Steadfast, namely, in itself, according to a text of Boethius[337]: Remaining steadfast etc.; also, giving steadfastness in the gifts promised. Nor is it surprising that he speaks here of steadfast and above in the same chapter[338] of active, because here he is speaking of its diverse effects, of which in Psalm 39:3 we read: ‘He set my feet upon a rock, and directed my steps’. Or: Active in active works, steadfast in contemplatives; or: steadfast in Christ, active[339] in other Saints; John 1:33: ‘Upon whom you shall see the Spirit descending’. Or in this way: steadfast in good; assured, that is, constant in truth; secure, from evil, according to Psalm 90:10: ‘No evil shall come to you’. And just as it is steadfast and assured and secure in itself, so in those in whom it dwells it makes them steadfast in good, assured in truth, secure from evil; Colossians 1:23: ‘In the faith grounded and settled, and immovable from the hope of the gospel’.

Having all power. Here he shows its universal sufficiency, firstly, in goodness; secondly, in wisdom: overseeing all things; thirdly, in power: and containing all spirits.

He says, therefore: Having all power; in Psalm 32:6: ‘All the power of them by the spirit of the Lord’s mouth’.

But contra: Because one does not have faith since faith is an obscure knowledge and an imperfect power.[340]

It must be said that he is speaking of every power, understood not of any but of perfect power.

Overseeing all things; Job 37:3: ‘God beholds above[341] all the heavens, and God’s light is upon the ends of the earth’; also Hebrews 4:13: ‘For all things are naked and open to God’s eyes’. And the One who contains all spirits, namely, angelic spirits, ‘because they go from within God to wherever they are sent’, according to Bede[342] on Luke 1:19: ‘I am Gabriel who stand before God’. The Angels are called spirits because of their substance and nature[343]; intelligible because of their power, or because by their nature they cannot be joined to bodies; Or[344]: Containing, that is, enables one to contain, all spirits, that is, all the gifts of the Holy Spirit, of which Isaiah 11:2 says: ‘The spirit of the Lord shall rest upon him: the spirit of wisdom, and of understanding, the spirit of counsel, and of fortitude, the spirit of knowledge and of godliness’. Pure, namely, from purity of innocence; according to Dionysius,[345] the Angels are ‘pure and clearest mirrors’; and he adds: pure, in contrast to unclean spirits, that is, demons. Subtle, from a keenness of understanding; or: subtle, from wisdom; Gregory[346]: ‘What is it they are not to see who, when looking, see everything?’ Some books[347] have is pure, subtle; pure is the spirit of wisdom because it is without the dregs of matter; subtle, because it is pure form. But the first version is more exact because Rabanus has it both in his text and commentary. Or: the spirit of wisdom is said to be pure because it cleanses from past sins and protects from future sins; or because it purifies from sin in the present and in the future from punishment; undefiled, because it can incur uncleanness neither from itself nor from another; subtle, because it penetrates everything, or because it causes in us a subtlety of affection from the gift of wisdom and of the mind by the gift of understanding or discernment.

For wisdom is more active than all active things and reaches everywhere by reason of her purity. Here he shows that wisdom by its nature and by the power within it can be a medium by which we are taught. And to illustrate this he states, firstly, its activity; secondly, its purity: reaches everywhere by reason of her purity, thirdly, its power: And being but one, she can do all things; fourthly, its beauty: For she is more beautiful than the sun.

(Verse 24). I have said well that there is in her is the spirit of understanding: holy, one, manifold, subtle, eloquent, active, undefiled, sure, sweet, loving that which is good, quick, which nothing hinders, beneficent. For wisdom is more active, in every kind of movement whether it be in substance, in quality, in quantity, or local motion; wisdom is more active, that is, it works more swiftly; Gloss[348]: ‘Nothing is more subtle and active than wisdom for it created, rules and orders all things’; more active, I say, not because it is moved but because it moves all things while remaining still, according to the text of Boethius[349]: ‘Remaining steadfast you give movement to all things’. Also Acts 17:28: ‘For in God we live, and move, and are’.

However, it reaches everywhere by reason of her purity. Here he shows its purity, firstly, from the fact that it comes, or emanates, from the purest source; secondly, because it reflects in itself the brightness of the source: For she is the brightness of eternal light, and the unspotted mirror of God's majesty, and the image of God’s goodness.

I have said that wisdom is more active than all active things; nor only; and for but; but what is more, she reaches everywhere, that is, from the supreme creature to the last creature; Ambrose in Hexaëmeron[350]: ‘Divine wisdom has penetrated even to a shell-fish’.

But contra: Job 28:14: ‘The depth says: It is not in me; and the sea says: It is not with me’.

The reply is that he is speaking there[351] not of creatures but of the vices of creatures. Or it should be said in a better way that God is not in the abyss or in the sea by being contained in it, since God cannot be contained, but is there by presence, according to Psalm 138:8: ‘If I ascend into heaven, you are there, if I descend into hell, you are present’.

By reason of her purity, that is, its distance from every dreg of matter, for, because it is completely immovable, it cannot be enclosed, according to Damascene.[352]

(Verse 25). She is a vapour of the power of God, that is, it emanates from God just as vapour rises from heat; Gloss[353]: ‘That is, for warming the cold of our unfaithfulness’; Sirach 24:21: ‘My dwelling is as the frankincense not cut’. And a certain pure emanation of the glory of the almighty God, that is, emanating from God the Father just as brightness emanates from light, namely, to enlighten the darkness of our mind; Hebrews 1:3: ‘Who being the brightness of God’s glory and the figure of God’s substance’; also Isaiah 62:1: ‘Till the just one comes forth as brightness’. Certain, with no mixture of darkness; 1 John 1:5: ‘God is light and in God there is no darkness’. This process in no way lessens, or separates, the substance of the Father, for the Persons remain distinct, according to Athanasius[354]: ‘Without confusion of Persons or separation of substance’. And because it comes out like light, it cannot be stained; therefore no defiled thing comes into her, namely, neither by a culpable nor natural defilement; comes into her, namely, uncreated wisdom; Gloss[355]: ‘Evil does not come close to the highest good’.

(Verse 26). Indeed, no defiled thing comes into her. For she is the brightness of eternal light, namely, the purest light from eternal light, proceeding from the Father; so there is sung[356]: ‘O Christ, you have appeared as light from light’. Eternal light is seen in this light, according to Psalm 35:10: ‘In your light we shall see light’; also John 14:9: ‘The one who sees me, sees the Father also’. She is, therefore, the brightness of eternal light, by her representation of wisdom, and the unspotted mirror of God's majesty by her representation of divine majesty and power, according to John 5:19: ‘What things soever the Father does, these the Son also does in like manner’. I say unspotted because Christ ‘did no sin’.[357] And the image of God’s goodness; Gloss[358]: ‘That is, a total representation of God’s goodness; Colossians 1:15: ‘Who is the image of the invisible God’.

Note, that the image is the Son of God, immaculate in action and potential. According to Dionysius,[359] an Angel is a pure and most bright mirror, but while being immaculate in what it does, it has at least a remote possibility of being stained. The human spirit is a mirror from which a divine image shines out, Genesis 1:26,[360] but stained in both action and potential. Also, every creature is called a mirror because the invisible things represent footprints of God; Romans 1:20: ‘For the invisible things of God from the creation of the world are clearly seen’;[361] 1 Corinthians 3:12: ‘We see now through a glass in a dark manner’. Sacred Scripture is a mirror; James 1:23: ‘They shall be like those who look at the face of their birth in a mirror’.

(Verse 27). And being but one, namely, in essence with the Father, according to John 10:30: ‘I and the Father are one’; she can do all things, that is, she has the same power as the Father; so below in Wisdom 18:15: Your almighty word leapt down from heaven from your royal throne.

But if she can do all things, therefore she is able to deceive and to die, which is wrong.

 It must be said that she can do all things that are not contrary to her goodness, or that a power is able to do, not powerlessness.[362]

And remaining in herself the same, namely, unchanging, according to James 1:17: ‘With whom there is no change, nor shadow of alteration’; she renews all things, namely, temporal things by a continuous generation; Ecclesiastes 1:4: ‘One generation passes away and another generation comes’; and she renews spiritual things by a spiritual regeneration; 2 Corinthians 5:17: ‘If then any be in Christ a new creature, the old things are passed away’; Revelation 21:5: ‘Behold, I make all things new’. And through nations, carnal or rather spiritual, of which John 3:5 says: ‘Unless a person be born again of water and the Holy Spirit, the person cannot enter into the kingdom of God’. Conveys herself into holy souls, that is, into souls clean of sin, by the spiritual coming of grace into the soul; John 14:23: ‘We will come to that person and will make our abode in that person’. Note, she is said to convey herself not by taking a new position or by changing places, but by a new effect; so he adds: So she makes the friends of God, by inflaming the affections, and prophets, by enlightening the mind; John 15:15: ‘I will not now call you servants, for the servant does not know what the lord does. But I have called you friends, because all things whatsoever I have heard of my Father I have made known to you’.

(Verse 28). For God loves none but those who dwell with wisdom, namely, by remaining with God, and who ‘shall meditate day and night on the law of the Lord’, according to a Gloss;[363] Proverbs 8:12: ‘I wisdom dwell in counsel, and am present in learned thoughts’. And if God loves none but those who dwell with wisdom, then ‘blessed is the person who shall continue in wisdom’, Sirach 14:22.

For God loves none but those who dwell with wisdom. – Contra: Below in Wisdom 11:25 he says: You love all things that are, even though not all things dwell with wisdom.

But it has to be said, that there he is speaking of natural love while here he is speaking of gratuitous love.

For she is more beautiful than the sun, and above all the order of the stars: being compared with the light, she is found before it. Here he treats of the beauty of wisdom, preferring it to the beauty of the sun, and he states, firstly, a comparison; secondly, the proof of the comparison: For after this comes night.

(Verse 29). I have said well that God loves none but those who dwell with wisdom, and rightly. For she, namely, wisdom, is more beautiful than the sun, because spiritual beauty excels bodily beauty; above in verse 10 of this chapter: I loved her above health and beauty; than the sun, namely, the material sun because it is the beauty of the Sun of justice of which Malachi 4:2 says: ‘Unto you that fear my name, the Sun of justice shall arise’. And above all the order of the stars, repeating the words: is more beautiful. For she made the stars, Genesis 1:16; and she is constant because she has retained for herself more beauty than that given to the stars; so above in Wisdom 4:1: O how beautiful is the chaste generation with glory, namely, the glory of wisdom. Being compared with the light, namely, both of the sun and of the stars, she is found before it, namely, in eternity, dignity and causality; so Sirach 24:6: ‘I made that in the heaven there should rise light that never fails’;[364] Gloss[365]: ‘Bodily light that now sets, now rises, when compared to spiritual light, is like a sparkle. Christ also far transcends the brightness of the Saints’.

(Verse 30). For after this, namely after bodily light, comes night, according to Genesis 8:22: ‘Night and day shall not cease’; also Isaiah 21:12: ‘The morning comes, also the night’. But night does not follow spiritual light; so there follows: but no evil, spiritual darkness, can overcome wisdom which is spiritual light, according to John Damascene;[366] so John 1:5: ‘The light shines in the darkness’. 

 
 
______________________________________________________________
 
 
FOOTNOTES
 
 

[274]               Wisdom 6:2ff.

[275]               Wisdom 6:27.

[276]               In Porphyr. Dialog. II, De differentiis; IV Comment. Porphyrr. De differentiis and I, De differentiis topic.

[277]               Question 56.

[278]               Namely Ordinaria (on 6:27) from Rabanus: As the Philosophers of nature say, the male seed is white and female seed is full of blood; in the mixing of these over a period of time a body is formed, until when it is living it comes to birth.

[279]               From the codices we have added the words: But contra … months.

[280]               Namely Ordinaria (from Rabanus) on 6:27.

[281]               Ordinaria taken from Rabanus on 6:27 who depends on Question 56 of Augustine’s Eighty-three Different Questions, and Book IV, ch. 5 n. 9 of his De Trinitate.

[282]               Cardinal Hugh of St Cher has this reading in the margin and he also has convenientis (of [sleep] concurring). The literal translation of Bonaventure would be: And with the concurring delight of a dream, while the text with convenientis would mean: with the delight of a dream concurring. The Vulgate has: somni conveniente ([with] the concurring [delight] of sleep) and in some editions the word used is: somnii. Bonaventure has: somni, which refers to a dream.

[283]               ‘In the beginning God created heaven and earth.’

[284]               Ch. 1 n. 1 of his Sermon 167 (alias 24 De verbis Apostoli): [A child] is born and immediately cries; after some days, I am ignorant of the number, it laughs. When it cried at birth, it was a prophet of its fate; tears bear witness to misfortune. It has not yet spoken but already it prophesies. What does it prophesy? Work lies before it etc. And in Book XXI, ch. 14 of his De civitate Dei: ‘Indeed, when [infancy] begins this life not with laughter but with crying, it is prophesying, without knowing how, that it has entered into such evils. Zoroaster was the only one to have laughed at birth, nor did his strange laughter foreshadow any good. He is said to be the founder of the magical arts’ etc. In Book VII, ch. 15 of Pliny’s Natural History: We accept that one person, Zoroaster, laughed on the very day on which he was born. His brain was so agitated that it would repel a hand placed on it, as an indication of future knowledge.    

[285]               The Vulgate reads: ‘I gave you suck three years, and nourished you, and brought you to this age’.

[286]               Glossa interlinearis.

[287]               The Vulgate has: In the midst of the church she shall open his mouth and shall fill him with the spirit of wisdom.

[288]               Proverbs 17:16.

[289]               Sermon 4 n. 1 De adventu Domini: Are not gold and silver the red and white earth, which only a human error makes when regarding them as more precious?

[290]               For the opinion of Bernard see preceding note.

[291]               ‘But the wisdom that is from above.’

[292]               Wisdom 7:14.

[293]               Interlinearis. Rabanus: Health of soul which is the possession of divine wisdom together with works of justice, is to be absolutely preferred to all health of body and every type of bodily concern, for this wisdom is more beautiful than the sun [Wisdom 7:29].

[294]                                                                                                                                                                                 Interlinearis.

[295]                                                                                                                                                                                 Book X, ch. 34 n. 51 of his Confessions: For this light is the queen of colours, pouring through all we see, and wherever I shall have been during the day, it entices me with its varied appearances even when I am doing something else and not paying attention to it. It insinuates itself so strongly, that, were it to be taken away suddenly, it would be longed for with desire and if it is absent for a long time, this saddens the soul. In Book III, ch. 5 n. 17 of his De libero arbitrio he says: Light holds the first place in bodies.

[296]                                                                                                                                                                                 This is the reading of Rabanus who is followed by Cardinal Hugh of St Cher and Lyranus; the Vulgate has: I bewailed my ignorance of her.

[297]                                                                                                                                                                                 Glossa ordinaria from Rabanus.

[298]                                                                                                                                                                                 Glossa ordinaria from Rabanus: Solomon experienced this [1 Kings 3:11-13] when, on asking God for wisdom, he merited to receive with wisdom the dignity of the kingdom, riches and glory.

[299]               ‘And the Lord went before them to show the way by day in a pillar of a cloud, and by night in a pillar of fire.’

[300]               Namely, Ordinaria from Rabanus.

[301]               See ch. 6 of his Oratio pro Archia poeta, where he blames those who increase knowledge only for themselves in such a way ‘that they are not able to draw from their knowledge anything for the common benefit nor bring it forth into view and into the light’. In Book I, ch. 42 of his De officiis he teaches that among the offices which provide greater value, is to be included the teaching of what is honourable. In Book III, ch. 19 of his De finibus he shows that it is natural ‘that we would want to benefit as many as possible, especially by teaching’. -  For: dicit Tullius (Tullius says) the editions have: dicitur (it is said).

[302]               Book I, ch. 1 n. 1 of De doctrina christiana: For everything that is not diminished by being shared, if it is possessed and not shared, is not yet possessed as it ought to be possessed.

[303]               The Douay Rheims Bible translated: autem (however), as: but, while Bonaventure comments that it should be understood as: because.

[304]                                                                                                                                       Luke 12:48: ‘Unto whom much is given, much shall be required, and to whom they have committed much, of them they will demand the more’.

[305]               Interlinearis (Rabanus: The guide of wisdom is God since the omnipotent Father is the author of the incarnation of his only begotten Son etc.).

[306]               Verse 359 of Horace’s Epistola ad Pisones (or De arte poetica).

[307]                                                                                                                                       The quote from Augustine can be derived from Book I, chs 1-4 (especially from ch. 3 n. 5) of his De Trinitate, see Tome IV, p. 313 note  8.

[308]               Namely, Interlinearis.

[309]               In Proverbs 16:1 the Vulgate has: souls.

[310]               Both Cardinal Hugh and Lyranus have this reading, namely: et operum et scientiae disciplina (of works and skill of knowledge); the Vulgate has: et operum scientia et disciplina (knowledge and skill of works).

[311]               This reference can be seen on p. 36 note 1.

[312]               Book I, ch. 2 of Aristotle’s Analytica posteriora.

[313]               Book II, text. 4 (I, brevior, ch. 1) of Aristotle’s Metaphysica.

[314] The Vulgate has: commutationes (changes), while Bonaventure has: consummationem (reckoning); Cardinal Hugh and Lyranus have: consummationes (reckonings) and also in the margin they have an addition noted by Bonaventure a little further on: morum mutationes, divisiones temporum (changes of behaviour, divisions of times).

[315]               See Prologue # 2 of Bonaventure’s Breviloquium, and Collation 16 of his Collations on the Six Days, (Tome V, p.s 203 and 403).

[316]               Vulgate has: cursus (revolutions).

[317]                                                                                                                                                                     Book XIII, ch. 11 n. 9ff. of Isidore’s Etymologiarum libri (PL 82, 480): Four of the winds are principal spirits: the east wind, the south wind, the west wind, and the north wind, each of which has twin spirits of wind. The east wind has on its right side a south-east wind, on its left a south-west wind; the south wind has on its right a south-east wind etc.’ See Book II, n. 4 of Aristotle’s Meteorologia; ibid., Book I, Sum. 4 ch. 1 (ch. 13); Book IV, n. 5 of his Topica; and n. 3 of De mundo

[318]               Vulgate adds: of a person, after the word: spirit.

[319]               The Vulgate omits the word: abscondita (concealed); Cardinal Hugh and Lyranus note the double reading as in Bonaventure.

[320]               The word: modestus, is not in the Vulgate.

[321]               We have added the words: firstly, interiorly … interior effect, on the basis of the codices.

[322]               By faith we understand that the world was framed by the word of God.

[323]               Namely, Interlinearis. See Rabanus on this text.

[324]               Book II, homily 30 n. 3 of his Homiliae in Evangelia.

[325]               Glossa ordinaria from Rabanus: As Isaiah shows, all the gifts of the Holy Spirit exist in the humanity of the Saviour, ‘In whom are hid all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge’ [Colossians 3:2], ‘and the fullness of the Godhead’ [ibid. v. 9], to whom ‘the Spirit’ is not given ‘by measure’ [John 3:34].

[326]               Interlinearis from Rabanus.

[327]               Interlinearis from Rabanus.

[328] In n. 5 of Augustine’s Enarratio in Psalmum 52 he explains this text as follows: ‘Not that the Spirit who knows everything searches, but because the Spirit is given to us and makes us search; and what you do with this gift, the Spirit is said to do, because without the Spirit you cannot work etc.’.

[329]               The Vulgate does not have the word: modest, but it is in both Cardinal Hugh and Lyranus.  Book X, n. 169 of Isidore’s Etymologiarm libri has: Modest comes from the words: modus (way or manner) and temperies (moderate), not doing anything either too much or too little.  

[330]               The Vulgate has: Wherever the spirit went, thither as the spirit went the wheels also were lifted up etc.

[331]               Glossa interlinearis from Rabanus.

[332]               Glossa interlinearis from Rabanus.

[333]               Glossa interlinearis from Rabanus.

[334]               The reading: Qui nihil vetat benefacere (who puts no obstacle to doing good), is found in Rabanus who, however, has: nullum (no thing) for: nihil (nothing); it is also in Cardinal Hugh and Lyranus; the Vulgate has: quem nihil vetat, benefaciens (it hinders in no way anyone who is doing good).

[335]               Namely, Interlinearis.

[336]               As stated by a Glossa interlinearis.

[337]               Book III, metr. 9 of his De consolatione philosophiae: Remaining steadfast you give movement to all things.                                                                            

[338]               Chapter 7:22. See Lyranus on this text.

[339]               The words: in active … active, have been added on the basis of the codices.

[340]               This refers to 1 Corinthians 13:9ff.

[341]               Cardinal Hugh and Lyranus in the margin have the reading: Super omnes (Above all), for the text of the Vulgate: Subter omnes (Beneath all).

[342]               Bede concludes from the immensity of God and the enclosing of the Angels: ‘Accordingly, the Angles are sent from before God, because they come to wherever they are sent and move within God’. This is taken from Book II, homily 34 n. 13 of Gregory’s Homiliae in Evangelia. See Tome V, p. 226 note 2.

[343]               Sermon 1 n. 15 of Augustine’s Enarratio in Psalmum 103: The spirits are angels but they are not angels because they are spirits; when they are sent they become Angels. Angel is the name of an office, not of a nature etc.

[344]               The following text in Bonaventure is that of Rabanus: Et qui capiat omnes spiritus intelligibiles, mundos, subtiles (And the one who contains all spirits, intelligible, pure subtle); the Vulgate has: intelligibilis, mundus, subtilis (is intelligible, pure, subtle).

[345]               Chapter 3 #2 of his De caelesti hierarchia. See Tome II, p. 83 note 1.

[346]               Book IV, ch. 33 of his Dialogues: What is it that they do not know who know the one who knows everything? See Book II, ch. 3 n. 3 of his Moralia in Job, quoted in Tome IV, p. 953 note 8.

[347]               Cardinal Hugh and Lyranus have this reading as noted above on p. 166 note 2.

[348]               Namely, Interlinearis from Rabanus. On the kinds of movement or change see ch. De motu in Aristotle’s De praedicamentis, and  Book V, text 7ff. (ch. 1ff.) of his Phsyica. See the Master (Peter Lombard) in Book I, d. VIII, ch. 2 and 6 of his Sentence Commentary; p. I, a. 2 q. 1 ad 11 of ibid.

[349]               Book III, metr. 9 of his De consolatione philosophiae. See above p. 165 note 4.

[350]               Book V, ch. 23 n. 82: Divine grace has penetrated even to a shell-fish.

[351]               Referring to the text of Job just quoted, a text explained in the same way in Book XVIII, ch. 42 n. 67 of Gregory’s Moralia in Job.

[352]               Book I, ch. 13 of his De fide orthodoxa.

[353]               Namely, Interlinearis which substitutes: calefaciens (warming), for: ad calefaciendum (for warming).

[354]               Or, as stated, of Vigilius Tapsensis, in the Creed: Quicumque.

[355]               Namely, Interlinearis from Rabanus. In Tractate 5 n. 15 of his Tractates on the Gospel of John Augustine says: Pure light is received by what has to be illumined, and if it were to pass through uncleanness, it would not be stained.

[356]               On the Feast of the Epiphany, In evangelio, the Antiphon as found in the Liber responsalis (in the works of Gregory, PL 78, 743).

[357]               1 Peter 2:22.

[358]               Namely, Interlinearis.

[359]               See above p. 166 note 6.

[360]               ‘Let us make humankind in our image, according to our likeness.’

[361]               See Book I, d. 3 p. I, q. 2 towards the end of Bonaventure’s Sentence Commentary. See Collation 12 n. 14-16 of his Collationes in hexaëmeron.

[362]               See Book I, d. 42 q. 2 of Bonaventure’s Sentence Commentary.

[363]               Namely, Interlinearis in which Psalm 1:2 is quoted.

[364]               In Sirach 24:6 the Vulgate has: coelis (in the heavens).

[365]               Glossa interlinearis from Rabanus.

[366]               Book II, ch. 4 of his De fide orthodoxa: Good, in fact, is spiritual light just as on the other hand evil is spiritual darkness.

 
 
 
 
Subpages (1): Chapter 8
Comments